Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—Generic—2NC

The allure of money is what causes endless desire for growth and more—it reinforces capitalism and makes it infinitely regressive.

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

In Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics, we have to be continuously and mindfully examining our motivations as well as our social arrangements and make clear the distinction between the motivations that stem from greed and those that stem from in impulse for creative self-development, of which healthy entrepreneurship and business enterprise building can be a part. The corporation is at the center of a vast network of powerful commercial, financial, government, media, and monetary institutions— a corporate hegemony. Within that hegemony, the largest Fortune 500 corporations and leviathan bank holding companies are the dominant institutions by virtue of concentration of wealth and revenue. From the holistic view, therefore, the corporation is viewed not as a business model, but as an institution. Moreover, it is not just an institution existing in isolation, but is part of a system of institutions that play a dominant role in contemporary culture. This culture is shaping the intentions, values, and motivations of a large segment of the American population, with little regard or attention being paid to whether we are contributing to our wellbeing.

Captured by the allure of ever-rising wealth accumulation, people pour trillions into pension funds, hedge funds, mutual funds, etc., because of the promise that these investments are going to continuously appreciate in value and will provide for us in our retirement or pay for our children’s education. When these funds began racking up double digit returns, dreams of becoming millionaires spread, everyone wanted more. Institutional investors including pension funds with defined benefits sought higher and higher returns wherever they could find them. Bond returns were too low, and the allure of risky ventures became irresistible. A kind of institutionalized gambling addiction was created. Like all addictions, this is fraught with delusion. Parents used to say to their children that money doesn’t grow on trees implying that you have to work for it. That has changed and money now is always expected to grow at an extraordinarily fast rate in investment funds stretching out into an infinite horizon of financial wealth.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—Generic—2NC

Wealth redistribution entrenches the fascination with money and material consumption—limiting ourselves by only realizing basic needs solves

Loy 01, David Robert Loy is an American scholar, author and authorized teacher in the Sanbo Zen lineage of Japanese Zen Buddhism. ResearchGate, , March 2001 //$$G

By redefining these moral qualities as “noble wealth,” Buddhism draws attention to the fact that the single-minded pursuit of material wealth will not make human beings happy or even rich. A world in which envy (issa) and miserliness (macchariya) predominate cannot be considered one in which poverty has been eliminated. This follows from the second noble truth of the Buddha: the cause of dukkha is tanha “craving”. When human beings gain an intense acquisitive drive for some object, that object becomes a cause of suffering. Such objects are compared to the flame of a torch carried against the wind, or to a burning pit of embers: they involve much anxiety but very little satisfaction — an obvious truth repressed by immediately turning our attention to another craved object. For Buddhism such a proliferation of wants is the basic cause of unnecessary ill-being. This implies that poverty can never be overcome by proliferating more and more desires which are to be satisfied by consuming more and more goods and services. In some places this may result in the elimination of material poverty for many or most, yet at the cost of promoting a different kind of poverty that is even more harmful. In short, there is a fundamental and inescapable poverty “built into” a consumer society. For that reason, development projects which seek to end poverty by “developing” a society into an economy focused on consumption are grasping the snake by the wrong end. From a Buddhist point of view we should not be surprised that such efforts in social engineering end up creating more problems than they solve. This is not a criticism of wealth itself: as in the Bible, not money but love of money is the source of evil. However, wealth must be acquired by righteous means, through one’s own efforts without using immoral or exploitative methods. Economic activity involving injury to human or nonhuman life, or undermining the moral ideals of a society, however beneficial that may be according to purely economic criteria, is unacceptable from a Buddhist perspective. Is this image of our human nature and its potential too idealistic? I don’t think so: in fact, this approach reflects better than economic theory the attitudes of most societies not already conditioned by advertising into believing that happiness is something you purchase. According to my favorite definition, by the Vietnamese teacher Thich Nhat Hanh, Buddhism is “a clever way to enjoy your life.” Confusing the quality of one’s life with a quantitative “standard of living” is, in contrast, a stupid way. Many of the Third World peoples we have been so eager to “develop” seem to be more aware of the difference than we are. The first World Bank definition of poverty was based upon the crude criterion of average national income. Since then the Bank has become more sensitive to differences of income among sectors within a country, and now even within families. For economics, however, lack of income remains the basic criterion of ill-being, perhaps because some such numerical measurement is necessary to satisfy the economist’s craving for statistical assessment. Gross National Product is a lot easier to gauge than General Well-Being. As a result, development agencies have been slow to realize what many anthropologists have long since understood: in traditional societies, especially rural communities, income is not the primary criterion of well-being; it is sometimes not even a major one. One of the things we found in the village which surprised us was people’s idea of well-being and how that related to having money. We talked to a family, asking them to rank everybody in the village from the richest to the poorest and asking them why they would rank somebody as being less well off, and someone as poor. And we found that in the analysis money meant very little to the people. The person who was ranked as poorest in the village was a man who was probably the only person who was receiving a salary. (Delia Paul on a rural household in Zambia, quoted in Chambers, 179) When a master builder in a Bulgarian community was invited to rank people according to wealth, he “spontaneously enlarged the list of wellbeing criteria emphasizing the importance of children’s education, good health and a good humoured nature.... Interestingly, the less well-off group included the most wealthy person in the village — an unhappy, bad tempered fellow put at the bottom of the pile along with the drunks and the sick.” (quoted in Chambers, 179). From his study of the literature Robert Chambers concludes: “Income, the reductionist criterion of normal economists, has never, in my experience or in the evidence I have been able to review, been given explicit primacy” (178). To assume that we in the “developed” world know something about worldly well-being which such peoples do not is a form of intellectual imperialism that looks increasingly dubious. De-emphasizing income is something difficult for us to understand, since money is after all the “pure means” that enables us to buy anything. . . . or is it? Our obsession with economic growth seems natural to us because we have forgotten the historicity of the “needs” we now take for granted. That includes the need for a monetary income in Western societies now thoroughly monetarized and commodified, where anything can be converted into anything else through a common medium of exchange. Since our needs (or rather our wants) are now taken for granted as defining our common humanity as much as universal human rights do, we are encouraged to forget what for Buddhism is an essential human attribute if we are to be happy: the need for selflimitation. The fundamental human problem is not the technological and economic issue of meeting all our material needs — something psychologically as well as environmentally impossible — but the psychological and spiritual need to understand the nature of our own minds. For this reason any formulation of “needs” is as much a value judgement as it is a determination of fact. This is something Buddhism and other religions emphasize but economics does not acknowledge. Economics cannot avoid reducing the good to the amount because it factors all desires into its basic equation of scarcity, which derives from comparing limited means with potentially unlimited wants. Without having been seduced by the utopian dream of a technological cornucopia, however, it would never occur to most “poor” people to become fixated on fantasies about all the things they might have. For them, their ends are an expression of the means available to them. Insofar as they do this, we are imposing our own value judgements when we insist on seeing them as poor, or as living in a state of scarcity (again, except for the destitute unable to satisfy basic requisites for survival). It is presumptuous to assume that they must be unhappy, and that the only way to become happy is to start on the treadmill of a lifestyle dependent on the market and increasingly preoccupied with consumption. All this is expressed better with a Tibetan Buddhist analogy. The world is full of thorns and sharp stones (and now broken glass as well). What should we do about this? We can try to pave over the entire earth; or we can wear shoes. “Paving the whole planet” is a good metaphor for how our collective technological and economic project is attempting to make us happy. It will not be satisfied even when all the earth’s resources are transformed into products to be consumed. The other solution is for our minds to learn how to make and wear shoes, so that our collective ends become an expression of the renewable means that the biosphere provides. Why do we assume that “income/consumption poverty” is the same as ill-being? That brings us to the heart of the matter. For us, material well-being has become increasingly important because of our loss of faith in any other possibility of fulfilment — for example, in heaven with God, or the secular heaven of socialism, or even (due to despair about the ecological crisis) the future progress of humankind. Increasing our “standard of living” has become so compulsive for us because it serves as a substitute for traditional religious values — or, more precisely, because it has actually become a kind of secular religion for us. If so, our efforts to economically “develop” Third World peoples, who have their own spiritual traditions, may be viewed as a contemporary form of religious imperialism, a new mission to convert the heathen. . . . Despite their benighted violence, do “Third World terrorists” understand this aspect of globalization better than we do?

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—UBI—2NC

A UBI built into the capitalist system is merely a band-aid towards our current problems—it entrenches the fascination with more money—only after a mindset shift towards consumption can we truly redistribute wealth

Ng 20, Dr. Ernest C. H. Ng is adjunct assistant professor at the Centre of Buddhist Studies, University of Hong Kong, where he teaches undergraduate and postgraduate courses on Buddhism and economics. Dr. Ng is a fellow at the European SPES Institute and author of Introduction to Buddhist Economics. “A Buddhist Perspective: Is Universal Basic Income Genuinely Caring, Compassionate, and Wise?”, Berkely Center For Religion, Peace, and World Affairs, . ,$$G

Universal basic income (UBI), as a universal and unconditional periodic cash payment directly to individuals, has recently become a topic of interest among politicians, scholars, and religious leaders. It aims to serve as a neatly designed policy tool to address widening income disparities. Even though further studies are required, some  supports that UBI-style programs alleviate poverty, improve health and education outcomes, and do not hinder labor market participation. These programs have drawn more interest and debate during the COVID-19 pandemic, as they are temporarily accepted to serve as band-aid and short-term responses to the unprecedented economic dislocation. The pandemic may push the circumstances to extremes: Even some self-righteous defenders of the free market are willing to concede that if rescue packages are required to bail out failing corporations, many others may need help too! When people are restricted from working to protect public health, not because they are not motivated, previous concerns over moral hazards may also seem unwarranted.

The pandemic may also force us to rethink what humans really “need” instead of “want” to be happy. Necessary medicine to maintain good health, proper food and nutrition, safe shelter, and sufficient protective clothing are the  in Buddhist teachings. In , the Buddha waited for a poor peasant to be properly rested and fed before commencing his teachings. Those without these four basic needs would be . Nonetheless, Buddhist notions of wealth are not only material. The Buddha does not deny material wealth like silver and gold, but these forms of wealth can be taken away (by fire, water, kings, thieves, and displeasing heirs). They are also unreliable because they can deepen our greed, hatred, and delusion. Instead, the Buddha taught about the cultivations of wealth in terms of moral virtues, namely (1) faith; (2) virtuous behavior; (3) learning; (4) generosity; (5) wisdom; (6) moral shame; and (7) moral dread (Anguttara Nikaya [AN] 7.6 and ). These seven kinds of wealth are truly worthy because they cannot be taken away, and they lead to the cessation of suffering. The Buddha taught that those without moral temperaments are truly indebted and poor (). 

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › 1NC—Capitalism Critique › 1NC—Top Level

The alt is to adopt a consumption focused mindset on economics—focusing on others instead of our own self interest stops the capitalist drive for accumulation and endless consumption. The endless consumption is intertwined with our lives—realizing this is enough to restructure our lives and the global economy.

Brown 17, Clair Brown is an American economist who is Professor of Economics and Director of the Center for Work, Technology, and Society at the University of California, Berkeley. Brown is a past Director of the Institute of Industrial Relations at UC Berkeley. Clair has published research on many aspects of how economies function, including the standard of living, wage determination, inequality, sustainability, high-tech industries, and development engineering. Her books include American Standards of Living: 1919-1988 and Buddhist Economics: An enlightened approach to the dismal science (Bloomsbury Press, 2017) "How “Buddhist Economics” Can Make Us Happier – Lions Roar," Lions Roar, , April 27, 2017 //$$G

Economics affects how we live and how happy we are. Yet most people ignore economics, even though it has a powerful impact on our lives and our future. Take our two biggest worldwide challenges: global warming and income inequality. United Nations climate scientists warn that time is running out if we are to avoid destroying our planet and our way of life. Income inequality rivals that of the Gilded Age, with economists predicting that inequality will continue to grow, along with political turmoil.

Both of these challenges are profoundly influenced by economics. Overcoming them will require a complete rethinking of our economic system, our lives, and what matters to us. We must learn to live in harmony with nature and with one another.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › 1NC—Capitalism Critique › 1NC—Top Level

Capitalist accumulation is unsustainable, causes extinction and planetary immiseration.

Robinson, 23—Distinguished Professor of Sociology, Global and International Studies, and Latin American Studies at the University of California at Santa Barbara (William, “The Violent Crackup of the Post-WWII International Order: Notes on the Geopolitical Crisis and Global Capital,” Journal of World-Systems Research, Vol. 29, No. 1, dml)

Some scholars have framed the crisis of global capitalism in terms of a declining U.S. hegemony and the rise of a Chinese competitor. But no new nation-state power can supply the political authority necessary to stabilize the now-inextricably integrated global economy. The crisis of hegemony in the international system takes place within this single, integrated global economy. No one state, no matter how powerful, can control the process of global accumulation. This disjuncture between a globalized economy and a nation-state-based system of political authority generates enormous geopolitical tensions. The end of Western domination of world capitalism is upon us as the center of gravity of the global economy shifts to China. But China will not become a new hegemon. Rather, we are moving towards political multipolarity at a time of acute crisis in global capitalism—prolonged economic turbulence and political decay.

The breakdown of the political organization of world capitalism is not the cause but the consequence of contradictions internal to a globally integrated system of capital accumulation. Escalating geopolitical conflict is pushing us towards global conflagration. Wars provide enormous outlet for surplus accumulated capital. Historically they have pulled the capitalist system out of accumulation crisis while they serve to deflect attention from political tensions and problems of legitimacy. The most urgent task at this time is to prevent World War III. The more we understand the changing nature of this beast that is global capitalism, the better we are situated to work out strategies of resistance and transformation. The task before us is ever more urgent in the face of the threat of nuclear holocaust, the collapse of the biosphere, and ever more acute inequality, immiseration, and social disintegration around the world.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › Russia-Collapse---Impact---2NC

Nuclear war bad- with exact numbers, risk of NW increasing

ICAN, 9-18-2019, "New Study on US-Russia nuclear war: 91.5 million casualties in first few hours," ICAN, https://www.icanw.org/new_study_on_us_russia_nuclear_war

34.1 million people could die, and another 57.4 million could be injured, within the first few hours of the start of a nuclear war between Russia and the United States triggered by one low-yield nuclear weapon, according to a new simulation by researcher’s at Princeton‘s Science and Global Security programme.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › Russia-Collapse---Impact---2NC

Nuclear war with Russia and NK likely

Lauren Sukin, 5-4-2023, nonresident scholar in the Nuclear Policy Program and an assistant professor of international relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE)"Rattling the Nuclear Saber: What Russia’s Nuclear Threats Really Mean," Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, https://carnegieendowment.org/2023/05/04/rattling-nuclear-saber-what-russia-s-nuclear-threats-really-mean-pub-89689

On March 23, Deputy Chairman of the Security Council of the Russian Federation Dmitry Medvedev warned that the  is drawing “closer.” This threat, however oblique, is one of several that Russian officials have  that imply the threat of nuclear use against Ukraine and the NATO states supporting Kyiv. Moscow has spouted this dangerous rhetoric since the start of the Russo-Ukrainian war in early 2022, making threats that are loud, frequent, and extreme.

Some commentators have suggested that Russian nuclear threats . Moscow may hope its threats convince NATO states and Ukraine to accept Russia’s territorial gains; Russia may even intend to use threats to deter NATO states and Ukraine from fighting harder. But threatening to use nuclear weapons doesn’t necessarily mean Russia plans to use them. To this camp of thinkers, that the threats emanating from Moscow have become increasingly commonplace makes them seem even less grave. After all, if bellicose threats are a normal part of politics, doesn’t that suggest they are mere bluffs?

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › Russia-Collapse---Impact---2NC

Global economy RELIANT on Russian oil exports- Russian oil industry collapse would go GLOBAL

IEA 22 – International Energy Agency (April 2023, “Energy Fact Sheet: Why does Russian oil and gas matter? – Analysis,” IEA, 3-21-2022, Available Online: https://www.iea.org/articles/energy-fact-sheet-why-does-russian-oil-and-gas-matter, Accessed: 7-12-2023)//DD- ILake-EN

Russia is a major player in global energy markets. It is one of the world’s top three crude producers, vying for the top spot with Saudi Arabia and the United States. Russia relies heavily on revenues from oil and natural gas, which in 2021 made up 45% of Russia’s federal budget.

In 2021, Russian crude and condensate output reached 10.5 million barrels per day (bpd), making up 14% of the world’s total supply. Russia has oil and gas production facilities throughout the country, but the bulk of its fields are concentrated in western and eastern Siberia. In 2021 Russia exported an estimated 4.7 million bpd of crude, to countries around the world. China is the largest importer of Russian crude (1.6 million bpd) , but Russia exports a significant volume to buyers in Europe (2.4 million bpd).

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › Russia-Collapse---Impact---2NC

Russian state collapse causes nuc prolif – spurs terrorism, organized crime, and civil war.

Dmitri Alperovitch and Sergey Radchenko, 8-29-2022. DMITRI ALPEROVITCH is Chairman of Silverado Policy Accelerator, host of the podcast Geopolitics Decanted, and Co-Founder and former Chief Technology Officer of the cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike. SERGEY RADCHENKO is Wilson E. Schmidt Distinguished Professor at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies and the author of Unwanted Visionaries: The Soviet Failure in Asia at the End of the Cold War. "Another Russia Is Possible," Foreign Affairs, //ecam

Another outcome that the United States should want to avoid is the outright implosion of Russia. The United States should continue to punish Putin for the war in Ukraine, but it must not lose sight of the fact that destabilizing Russia—or even breaking Russia apart, as some commentators have called for—is not in its interest. During the tail end of the Cold War, President George H. W. Bush worried about the Soviet collapse, not because the Soviet Union was worth preserving, but because the breakup of a major nuclear power risked unleashing loose nuclear weapons and fissile material, spurring nuclear proliferation among successor states, and prompting the emergence of new terrorist and organized crime networks. Four decades later, these risks remain. Russia’s collapse could lead to a bloody civil conflict that might destabilize Eurasia for years to come.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › Russia-Diversion---Impact---2NC

Russia will retaliate – Bad economy is a threat to Putin’s rule

Ash ‘22 – (Timothy, Professional economist for 30 years and a soverign strategist at Bluebay Asset Management in London, “Will an EU oil price cap limit Russian aggression?” Chatham House, December 5, 2022, https://www.chathamhouse.org/2022/12/will-eu-oil-price-cap-limit-russian-aggression)//DDD

Russia has threatened to retaliate by stopping oil sales to any countries participating in the oil price cap. This is likely a bluff as Russia’s own export volumes and total revenues would be hit at a time when foreign exchange reserves have been under sharp downward pressure – falling by more than $100 billion per year to date despite a rising current account surplus.

There are also technical issues for Russia in halting the supply of oil as its storage capacity is finite. Similarly, stopping production at oil wells could cause long-term damage to the country’s production potential.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › Saudi-Collapse---Impact---2NC

Saudi state collapse causes ME civil war, terror prolif, and global econ decline

Theodore Karasik and Joseph Cozza, 8-10-2016.Theodore Karasik is a Senior Advisor to Gulf State Analytics, a geo-strategic consultancy based in Washington, DC. Joseph Cozza is a Visiting Assistant Professor at Rice University in the department of political science "What If Saudi Arabia Collapses? – LobeLog," //ecam

The collapse of the Saudi state would have grave implications for the region and the world. As illustrated by Libya, Syria, and Yemen, state collapse creates a vacuum for radical jihadist groups to claim new territory. Currently, al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) is pushing against the Saudi border with Yemen and the Islamic State (ISIS or IS) in Iraq and Syria poses a constant threat to the kingdom’s north. Thus, civil war, instability, and high levels of sectarian tension would likely be fertile ground for these groups to grow and expand their control, threaten the holy sites, and perpetuate regional instability. Washington’s national security establishment has expressed concerns about turmoil escalating in Saudi Arabia if MBS’s reform agenda fails to achieve its objectives. Some see the kingdom at a crossroads and fear that the kingdom’s collapse would benefit the Islamic State. Regarding MBS possibly becoming the next king, one anonymous Saudi expert told NBC News, “It’s him or it’s ISIS.”

The July 4 attacks in three Saudi cities (Medina, Jeddah, and Qatif) underscored the significance of the militant Salafist-Jihadist threat not only to the country’s security but also Al Saud’s prestige and Islamic legitimacy as the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques. The intended attack by IS adherents on the Prophet’s Mosque during the end of Ramadan signals the Islamic State’s intent to usurp the Al Saud much as the apocalyptic leader Juhayman al-Otaybi did when he seized the Grand Mosque in 1979. “This attack has made it very clear that ISIS does not seem to believe in any moral red lines whatsoever,” said Fahad Nazer, a leading expert on Saudi Arabia. “Even al-Qaeda, which is certainly brutal in its own right, has never targeted Muslims in their houses of worship. ISIS has done that repeatedly.”

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › ME Diversionary War---Impact---2NC

Saudi Arabia is geared to diversionary war – campaigns throughout the middle east proves.

Barbara Kelemen 18[July, 5, 2018 Barbara Kelemen is a graduate candidate at the LSE-PKU Double Degree Program in International Affairs. “Saudi Arabia from Within: Diversionary Policy of Iranian Containment?” NPAT]

One of the important aspects of the diversionary theory of war is the significance it places on domestic issues when explaining a country’s foreign policy. It claims that leaders, confronted with domestic opposition over economic, societal and political issues, might try to divert the population’s attention from domestic matters to the international arena by means of war or conflict, which enables them to survive politically while simultaneously maintain stability at home. This ‘scapegoat’ hypothesis focuses on examining belligerent foreign policy from the perspective of leaders whom are trying to solidify their domestic political power. Saudi Arabia is currently experiencing the biggest social and economic transformation in past decades, pioneered through MBS’s ‘Vision 2030’. Reasons for this initiative, as much as diversification being an economic priority since the 1970s, are simply summarised as structural challenges caused by the unsustainable rentier nature of the Saudi economy. This not only requires a plethora of economic changes, but also changes in societal rules, predominantly associated with Islam. While popular backlash, such as that experienced during the 1979 Iranian Revolution is highly unlikely, changes in society and policy might lead to certain degrees of destabilisation. In fact, the history of vigorous opposition from Saudi conservative circles on hot topics like women’s rights is quite extensive. Thus, one of the biggest challenges for the current Saudi leadership will be to mitigate any kind of instability caused by any of Saudi Arabia’s three societal groups: clerics, citizens, and the royal family. This means that if MBS wants to keep Saudi Arabia stable while transforming it as per ‘Vision 2030’, the country needs to be domestically strong and united. A lot has been written on the sectarian nature of the current conflicts in the Middle East and sectarianisation as a tool for governments to paralyse strong opposition. While Saudi Arabia’s role during the Arab Spring has been often discussed in relations to sectarian conflict between Sunni Kingdom and Shia Republic, its current behaviour is often misrepresented as driven purely by Shia–Sunni animus. The Kingdom, which has embarked on the aggressive policy of Iranian containment through proxies in the region, seems to be more interested in different aspect of the conflict. The unifying principle behind its policy of targeting different groups is the group in question’s sympathy towards Iran, which often correlates with sectarian preference. Nonetheless, sympathy towards Iran is rather divorced from the sectarian profiling of ‘Sunni vs Shia’. Saudi Arabia and Iran are currently fighting via proxies on two fronts, Yemen and Syria, while standing on opposite ends vis-à-vis the Qatar diplomatic rift. Despite this having roots in the 2011 Arab Spring, it is only since 2016 that the Kingdom has cut its ties with Iran, taking a more assertive containment stance and stepping up its rhetoric. After international isolation and under an arms embargo from both the US and the UN (since 2006), Iran has been lacking a major security guarantor, a role the US has played in the case of Saudi Arabia. In order to make up for this vulnerability, Iran focuses on asymmetric military capabilities – extending its network of partners and engaging via proxies through what it calls the ‘axis of resistance’ (Iran, Syria, Hezbollah and Hamas). Iranian fighting through the axis of resistance, which diverts fighting to other countries, is strategically important, given its outdated conventional military capabilities. The war in Yemen has caused serious financial pressure on the Kingdom, given the costs of bombing, ground incursions, and billions of dollars in humanitarian aid given to Yemen. In fact it pushed Saudi Arabia to allocate more than 25 percent of its total budget on military spending, ultimately impacting on its foreign reserves. The rising cost of the intervention, accompanied by falling oil prices, forced it to sell $1.2 billion of holdings in European equities. At the same time, Saudi Arabia has declared its increasing willingness to send troops to Syria. This begs the question as to why Saudi Arabia would invest such a high number of resources in multiple conflicts in the region, while simultaneously undergoing deep shifts and reforms at home. (The ambitious project Vision 2030 requires at least $4 trillion of investment according to McKinsey.) While there are legitimate reasons for Saudi concerns over Iranian activities in the region, Saudi Arabia’s current foreign policy does not seem proportionate to the threat, hinting at a hidden agenda of interventionism and aggression. Saudi Arabia is deliberately exacerbating tensions with Iran, while Iran has tried to ease them by proposing dialogue with the Kingdom. This strategy reflects Saudi Arabia’s ongoing social and domestic political reforms. Saudi Arabia is thus trying to reassert its leadership in the region, while uniting its population in the fight against the common enemy – Iran. By evoking the possibility of Saudi annihilation, the leadership engages in hostile rhetoric that evokes fear domestically, while temporarily distracting it from the domestic reforms that are disrupting traditional cultural principles. Whether Saudi Arabia’s foreign policy will indeed escalate into diversionary war is yet to be seen.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › ME Dependence---Internal---2NC

Middle East relies on oil for jobs and infrastructure

ICE 18 [Institution of Civil Engineers (ICE), 2018, "Oil development in the Middle East," https://www.ice.org.uk/what-is-civil-engineering/what-do-civil-engineers-do/oil-development-in-the-middle-east; Accessed 7-11-23; AO]

The growing demand for oil meant many Middle Eastern countries could now pay for a more effective infrastructure. Hundreds of engineering projects in the 1950s and 1960s transformed the lives of entire populations as a result. The results were similar to those achieved by Victorian engineers in Britain in the 19th century. Engineers – many of them British – built transport, water and sewer systems. Cities grew and health and life expectancy in the region improved. Kuwait, Iran, Iraq and Saudi Arabia were among the first countries to benefit. Many early schemes aimed to improve water supplies. Projects included major dams, irrigation systems and desalination plants on coastal sites. Despite political upheavals, revolutions and wars in the region over the years, engineers have continued to design and build infrastructure projects throughout the Middle East. "The Middle East was transformed… by the boom in infrastructure projects made possible through the discovery [of] oil.” GWILYM ROBERTS Former ICE President. From His Paper On The Middle Eastern Infrastructure Boom 1945-1995. November 2009 Oil development in the Middle East Hussam Uddin Ahmad is a geotechnical engineer for Jacobs in Dubai. He talks us through his involvement with the oil infrastructure network in the Middle East, which has some of the largest oil reserves in the world. Did you know … The 3 largest oil producers in the Middle East are Iran, Iraq and Saudi Arabia. Kuwait, Oman, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates are next in the region’s oil league table – experts describe them as having ‘midsize potential.’ Bahrain, Pakistan, Syria and Yemen have a combined output of around 1m barrels a day. Observers say Syria’s output peaked in 1995. Egypt, Jordan and Lebanon have small or no oil reserves. Egypt ‘only’ produces around 600,000 barrels a day. Because of its large population, this translates into roughly $220 a head. Most of Egypt’s oil is used domestically. In 2011, its exports were worth about $32 per head of the population compared to an average figure of $1,605 per head for the whole of the Middle East. Difference that oil has made Development of infrastructure in the Middle East has allowed those countries with reserves – such as Kuwait and Saudi Arabia - to exploit their oil fields. As an example, by 2002 the 3 main Middle East producers - Iran, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia – were jointly producing an average of 13m barrels of oil a day. This was about 17% of global supply. Oil sales have created immense wealth and boosted the economy in countries such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq, and Kuwait. Millions of people in these and other parts of the Middle East have homes, jobs and education as a direct result of oil. The downside has seen illegal funding of terrorism in Syria, Iraq, and Yemen using money made from oil sales. How the work was done The Kuwait Oil Company (KOC) began production in 1946 – making the state the first country in the region to use oil revenues for significant infrastructure projects. Schemes designed and built for KOC included a deep water port as well as the Gulf’s first municipal power and desalination plants. Saudi Arabia has seen the greatest transformation as a result of its enormous oil wealth. The 1950s saw Aramco – a US/Saudi joint venture company – construct the Tapline, a major pipeline to the Mediterranean. Other schemes included irrigation systems which made the country self-sufficient in the production of wheat.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › ME Dependence---Internal---2NC

Oil key to middle east stability – drivers behind welfare programs

Kevin Butler ’19 has a BS in Government and Politics, with a focus in the Arabic language and Middle Eastern politics. He worked alongside several foreign militaries, state departments, and Ministries of Defense. “How Falling Oil Prices Will Affect the Middle East” 9/18/19 //ecam

Ever since the discovery of oil in the Middle East in the mid-20th century, the region has relied heavily on rentier government systems to secure their stability.[xxvii] However, this system has always precariously depended on the value of a single natural resource in order to prevent total collapse. While rentier systems are prone to economic swings, unemployment is another major concern. Oil extraction and exportation requires such little personnel employment that a massive percentage of Gulf nations need to provide for their citizens via an extensive welfare system. These welfare systems in turn are only made possible through the profits generated from oil. A long-term shortage of profits means governments will no longer be able to placate their citizens with money, and unemployment will start to emerge as a major concern. Given this foundation, falling oil value could threaten to unravel the social contract between Middle Eastern citizenry and their governments. Doing so will likely lead to a major increase[decrease] in political stability, which in turn could lead to major crises throughout the region. If Middle Eastern countries wish to see a way out of this trajectory, they should look to the example set by the UAE for economic diversification by investing in new industries. However, major economic reforms are only possible if governments reform politically in conjunction. Corruption and political turmoil turn away foreign investors, and thus, any chance at joining the global economy.[xxviii] The Middle East can wade through this incoming crisis, but major economic and political reforms are necessary first. Failure to do so could create extreme large-scale problems in the Middle East, perpetuating the cycle of poor development in the region.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › ME Dependence---Internal---2NC

Middle East oil key to stabilize energy markets – and energy prices high now

Middle East Oil Review ’22 “Middle East oil and gas vital for oil market stability – GlobalData” 3/10/22 //ecam

The mere prospect of oil and gas sales from the world’s third-biggest oil producer and second-biggest producer of natural gas being removed from the international market saw oil prices surge to nearly US$138 a barrel on March 7 - their highest mark since 2008, and some 45% higher than at the start of the crisis, and they remain volatile.

High energy prices will be maintained for as long as the conflict continues and Moscow is sanctioned, and for as long as Europe is dependent on Russian energy. In the short term, the surge in oil prices delivers a financial windfall to Middle East oil producers, who will use the money to accelerate post-pandemic stimulus infrastructure in 2022.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › ME Dependence---Internal---2NC

MENA econ growth is key to sufficient living standards and progress – reliance on oil high now.

Martin Philipp Heger and Lukas Vashold 7-22-2021, "Decoupling economic growth from emissions in the Middle East and North Africa," Brookings, //ecam

Economic growth plays a critical role in raising living standards and enabling human progress. However, growth needs to decouple from negative environmental consequences, as these, in turn, degrade the very foundations of human development. One example of a negative environmental consequence is airborne emissions that lead to climate change and air pollution. To meet any emissions reduction target, the minimum requirement is that economic growth decouples from emissions growth. Hence, at best, emissions would be reduced from year to year, at a steady pace, even if the economy grows—a process called absolute decoupling. At second-best, the growth rate of the economy would outpace the growth rate of emissions—a process called relative economic decoupling.

No decoupling of emissions from economic growth in MENA

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › ME Dependence---Internal---2NC

Middle eastern economies highly dependent on oil

Alterman ’21 is a senior vice president, holds the Zbigniew Brzezinski Chair in Global Security and Geostrategy, and is director of the Middle East Program at CSIS. Prior to joining CSIS in 2002, he served as a member of the Policy Planning Staff at the U.S. Department of State and as a special assistant to the assistant secretary of state for Near Eastern affairs. He often teaches Middle Eastern studies at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies and the George Washington University. “A New Revolution in the Middle East” 8/9/21 . //ecam

No region of the world is more immersed in the consequences of global climate change than the Middle East. The region accounts for about 30 percent of global oil production, and oil revenues drive government revenues in the region—either because the countries produce oil, or because the countries produce a labor force that works in oil-exporting countries and sends money home. Because of oil revenues, Middle Eastern governments can afford to employ large percentages of their own populations, and they do. As the world turns away from oil as an energy source, the economics of the Middle East will change profoundly.

At the same time, the Middle East is subject to the consequences of climate change. The region is already desperately water poor—nine of the ten most water-poor countries are in the Middle East. Drought is pushing farmers off their land, the region’s many coastal cities are threatened by sea level rise, and rising summer temperatures increasingly combine with humidity to put human survival at risk.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › AT: Renewables Inevitable

Transition to renewables coming now – but it’ll be rough and takes ages

David R. Baker 11-29-2022, is an energy and cleantech reporter at Bloomberg. MA in journalism from Columbia. BA in English from Amherst. "Analysis," Washington Post, //ecam

The world is changing its entire system for producing and using energy, and it’s a bumpy ride. The “energy transition” now underway will replace the very base of the global economy — fossil fuels — with clean power sources that don’t warm the climate, such as solar and wind. It’s a delicate, decades-long switch that’s sometimes compared to rebuilding an airplane midflight. And while the transition has created investment and jobs worldwide, it has delivered shocks as well. European electricity prices jump, for example, when winds slack off. California flirts with blackouts in heat waves because old, gas-burning power plants are shutting down faster than renewable energy sources can replace them. And some industries, like airlines, can’t run on electricity, for now. While the new energy system could one day be more reliable than the old, there’s a variety of reasons why the transition is proving so difficult, and will take so long to complete. These are some of them.

Renewables are intermittent

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › AT: Renewables Inevitable

Transition takes a quarter century

Daniel Yergin, 12-1-2022, is a leading authority on energy, geopolitics, and the global economy, bestselling author, and winner of the Pulitzer Prize. Energy Writer of the Year for his intellectual approach. "Bumps in the Energy Transition," IMF, //ecam

The current climate-driven energy transition is meant to be achieved quickly—in little more than a quarter century. And it is meant to be transformative. Coal is to disappear, and the European Union anticipates that hydrogen will provide 20 to 25 percent of its total energy by 2050. While it is the focus of increasingly intense activity and ambition, hydrogen provides less than 2 percent today.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Oil › AT: Renewables Inevitable

Transition to renewables take ages

Vaclav Smil, 1-1-2014, is a a Czech-Canadian scientist and policy analyst. He is distinguished professor emeritus in the Faculty of Environment at the University of Manitoba in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. "A Global Transition to Renewable Energy Will Take Many Decades," Scientific American, // ecam

A mere three sequences do not dictate the tempo of future global energy transitions. And a real breakthrough in safe and inexpensive nuclear power or a truly cheap way to efficiently store massive amounts of energy generated by wind and solar could hasten another change. But the similar pacing of three global transitions over two centuries is remarkable, particularly because the fuels required very different production techniques, distribution channels and machinery to convert them into usable power—whether diesel engines for trains or furnaces for homes. Worldwide the enormous investment and infrastructure needed for any new energy source to capture a large share of the market require two to three generations: 50 to 75 years.

A Challenging Switch to Renewables