Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Counterplan
Aff Answers › Perm Do CP

A negative income tax is a basic income and it’s the best.

Bowman 14

Sam Bowman, 5-23-2014, "The Negative Income Tax and Basic Income are pretty much the same thing — Adam Smith Institute," Adam Smith Institute, Associate Professor of ,  &  Co-PI, Alignment Research Group, ML² Group & CILVR Lab (on research leave Summer 2022–Summer 2024) New York University PhD 2016, Stanford NLP Group & Stanford Linguistics

I’ve been talking about the Negative Income Tax lately, and equating it with the idea of a Basic Income. I think most of the policies’ respective advocates would deny that they’re the same policy. In this post I’m going to outline why that’s incorrect and I’m happy to say that they’re basically the same thing. For the uninitiated, a Negative Income Tax is a form of welfare that replaces most existing welfare schemes with a single payment that supplements the income of the unemployed and low-paid. The payment is withdrawn as your earnings increase, ideally at a gradual enough rate that increasing your earnings (and hence reducing leisure time) is always worthwhile.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
Aff Answers › Perm Do CP

NIT is the same as basic income

Widerquist et. al 2005

(Karl Widerquist, an economist at Georgetown University, is a co-founder of the U.S. Basic Income Guarantee Network. He is also the co-chair of the  and co-founded Basic Income News in 2011. "A Retrospective On The Negative Income Tax Experiments: Looking Back At The Most Innovative Field Studies In Social Policy". 7-10. AH)

The United States government conducted four negative income tax (NIT) experiments between 1968 and l 980. NIT is a form of basic income guarantee (BIG) that was popular in the 1960s and 1970s. It differs from basic income in that it gives money only to those with low incomes. However, both are basic income guarantees in the sense that they guarantee everyone a minimum income. Although the differences between the two policies are important, they have enough similarities so that what was learned from the NIT experiments can help us understand the consequences of either BTG plan.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Affirmative › No scale up

Psychoanalysis can’t be scaled up to explain society or politics – they can’t explain our impacts and definitely can’t solve

Sharpe 10 – Lecturer, Philosophy and Psychoanalytic Studies, and Goucher, Senior Lecturer, Literary and Psychoanalytic Studies at Deakin University Matthew and Geoff, Žižek and Politics: An Introduction, p. 182-185

Can we bring some order to this host of criticisms? It is remarkable that, for all the criticisms of Žižek’s political Romanticism, no one has argued that the ultra- extremism of Žižek’s political position might reflect his untenable attempt to shape his model for political action on the curative final moment in clinical psychoanalysis. The differences between these two realms, listed in Figure 5.1, are nearly too many and too great to restate – which has perhaps caused the theoretical oversight. The key thing is this. Lacan’s notion of traversing the fantasy involves the radical transformation of people’s subjective structure: a refounding of their most elementary beliefs about themselves, the world, and sexual difference. This is undertaken in the security of the clinic, on the basis of the analysands’ voluntary desire to overcome their inhibitions, symptoms and anxieties. As a clinical and existential process, it has its own independent importance and authenticity. The analysands, in transforming their subjective world, change the way they regard the objective, shared social reality outside the clinic. But they do not transform the world. The political relevance of the clinic can only be (a) as a supporting moment in ideology critique or (b) as a fully- fl edged model of politics, provided that the political subject and its social object are ultimately identical. Option (b), Žižek’s option, rests on the idea, not only of a subject who becomes who he is only through his (mis) recognition of the objective sociopolitical order, but whose ‘traversal of the fantasy’ is immediately identical with his transformation of the socio- political system or Other. Hence, according to Žižek, we can analyse the institutional embodiments of this Other using psychoanalytic categories. In Chapter 4, we saw Žižek’s resulting elision of the distinction between the (subjective) Ego Ideal and the (objective) Symbolic Order. This leads him to analyse our entire culture as a single subject–object, whose perverse (or perhaps even psychotic) structure is expressed in every manifestation of contemporary life. Žižek’s decisive political- theoretic errors, one substantive and the other methodological, are different (see Figure 5.1) The substantive problem is to equate any political change worth the name with the total change of the subject–object that is, today, global capitalism. This is a type of change that can only mean equating politics with violent regime change, and ultimately embracing dictatorial government, as Žižek now frankly avows (IDLC 412–19). We have seen that the ultra- political form of Žižek’s criticism of everyone else, the theoretical Left and the wider politics, is that no one is sufficiently radical for him – even, we will discover, Chairman Mao. We now see that this is because Žižek’s model of politics proper is modelled on a pre- critical analogy with the total transformation of a subject’s entire subjective structure, at the end of the talking cure. For what could the concrete consequences of this governing analogy be? We have seen that Žižek equates the individual fantasy with the collective identity of an entire people. The social fantasy, he says, structures the regime’s ‘inherent transgressions’: at once subjects’ habitual ways of living the letter of the law, and the regime’s myths of origin and of identity. If political action is modelled on the Lacanian cure, it must involve the complete ‘traversal’ – in Hegel’s terms, the abstract versus the determinate negation – of all these lived myths, practices and habits. Politics must involve the periodic founding of entire new subject–objects. Providing the model for this set of ideas, the fi rst Žižekian political subject was Schelling’s divided God, who gave birth to the entire Symbolic Order before the beginning of time (IDLC 153; OB 144–8). But can the political theorist reasonably hope or expect that subjects will simply give up on all their inherited ways, myths and beliefs, all in one world- creating moment? And can they be legitimately asked or expected to, on the basis of a set of ideals whose legitimacy they will only retrospectively see, after they have acceded to the Great Leap Forward? And if they do not – for Žižek laments that today subjects are politically disengaged in unprecedented ways – what means can the theorist and his allies use to move them to do so?

2023 Michigan Kritik
Affirmative › Psycho not scientific

Psychoanalysis does not function like a scientific method, recent evidence proves that psychoanalysis does not give any coherent response to any criticism.

Paris 17 (Joel Paris obtained his psychiatric training at McGill. His current research interests include a project carrying out a controlled study of the outcome of stepped care treatment for BPD. HE is a Professor, Department of Psychiatry, McGill University. He is also a Research Associate, Department of Psychiatry, Jewish General Hospital, and an Associate Psychiatrist at the McGill University Health Center. “Is Psychoanalysis Still Relevant to Psychiatry?” 1/31/17 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0706743717692306) //Sajad

Psychoanalysis claimed to be a science but did not function like one. It failed to operationalize its hypotheses, to test them with empirical methods, or to remove constructs that failed to gain scientific support.1 In this way, the intellectual world of psychoanalysis more closely resembles the humanities. Today, with few psychiatrists or clinical psychologists entering psychoanalytic training, the door has been opened to practitioners with backgrounds in other disciplines, including the humanities. This trend is related to a hermeneutic mode of thought,50 which focuses on meaningful interpretations of phenomena, rather than on empirical testing of hypotheses and observations. Since the time of Freud, the typical psychoanalytic paper has consisted of speculations backed up with illustrations, similar to the methods of literary theory and criticism. One model currently popular in the humanities is “critical theory.”51 This postmodernist approach uses Marxist concepts to explain phenomena ranging from literature to politics. It proposes that truth is entirely relative and often governed by hidden social forces. In its most radical form, in the work of Michel Foucault,52 critical theory and postmodernism take an antiscience position, denying the existence of objective truth and viewing scientific findings as ways of defending the “hegemony” of those in power. Some humanist scholars have adopted the ideas of Jacques Lacan, a French psychoanalyst who created his own movement and whose eccentric clinical practice resembled that of a cult leader.53 Moreover, recruitment of professionals and academics with no training in science could lead to an increasing isolation of the discipline. While only a few contemporary psychoanalysts have embraced postmodernism, the humanities have made use of psychoanalytical concepts for their own purposes as a way of understanding literature and history. Conclusions In 2009, the British Journal of Psychiatry published a debate about whether the journal should accept psychoanalytic case reports.54 The debate pitted a biologist, Lewis Wolpert, against a psychoanalyst-researcher, Peter Fonagy. Wolpert argued that psychoanalytic case reports should be excluded because they are in no way scientific. Fonagy, while conceding some of his opponent’s points, defended analysis by pointing out that research is possible and is now beginning to be conducted. But while Fonagy himself is committed to empiricism, he represents a very small minority in a field that lacks that commitment. Unfortunately, the modern revisions of psychoanalysis do not offer a coherent response to critics. It is difficult to see how any of the current responses to criticism can save psychoanalysis from a continued and lingering decline. Analysis has separated itself from psychiatry and psychology by teaching its method in stand-alone institutes. The field may only survive if it is prepared to dismantle its structure as a separate discipline and rejoin academia and clinical science. Whatever its limitations, psychoanalysis left an important legacy to psychiatry. It taught a generation of psychiatrists how to understand life histories and to listen attentively to what patients say. In an era dominated by neuroscience, diagnostic checklists, and psychopharmacology, we need to find a way to retain psychotherapy, whose basic concepts can be traced back to the work of Freud, as part of psychiatry.55

The “Lack” is a lie—critics are silenced and threatened

2023 Michigan Kritik
Affirmative › Psycho not scientific

Nonfasifiability, lack of prediction, lack of rules and regulations, being impossible to test all ensure psychoanalysis will inevitably fail, and reinforces the idea that psychoanalysis is illegit.

Beystehner 98 (Kristen M. Beystehner graduated from University of Georgia School of Law, and Northwestern University, BA, with honors "Psychoanalysis: Freud's revolutionary approach to human personality." 1998 http://www.personalityresearch.org/papers/beystehner.) //Sajad

Finally, many people feel that a major flaw of psychoanalysis is that, according to Farrell (1981), "it appears to encourage analytic and psychodynamic practitioners to overlook the place and great importance of ordinary common sense" (p. 216). Because psychoanalysis deals chiefly with unconscious motives and repressed emotions, common sense no longer seems to be applicable. Farrell (1981) and other critics believe that it is increasingly important for analysts to be aware of common sense and the role that it can, should, and does play in psychoanalysis (p. 216). Criticisms of the Principles of Psychoanalysis

Storr (1981) insists, "Only a few fundamentalist psychoanalysts of an old-fashioned kind think that Freud was a scientist or that psychoanalysis was or could be a scientific enterprise," and that, "...to understand persons cannot be a scientific enterprise" (p. 260). Although many psychoanalysts themselves would undoubtedly consider psychoanalysis to be a science, many critics would disagree.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Affirmative › Psycho not scientific

Psychoanalysis is a pseudoscience with no scientific backing -- turns the K

Zepf 18 (Siegfried Zepf, MD, is a Training analyst (DPG, DGPT) and the former director of the Institute of Psychoanalysis, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatic Medicine, University of Saarland Germany. He is the author of numerous publications on epistemological, psychosomatic, socio-psychological, and psychoanalytical topics. “Psychoanalysis Today—A Pseudoscience? A Critique of the Arbitrary Nature of Psychoanalytic Theories and Practice” 2/26/18 https://doi.org/10.1521/pdps.2018.46.1.115) //Sajad

Neuroses are the outcome of unfavorable and socially determined measures, corresponding to a given historical milieu and necessary in this milieu ... The contradictions of a society are reflected in its education, and later in the neuroses of the educated individuals. (p. 586)

This indicates that the essential conditions of neurotic disturbances are not situated in individuals but inherent in the social system they grow up and live in. If this holds true, then by neglecting that societal critique the crucial etiological conditions of neurotic diseases remain a blind spot in the field of clinical vision.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › at: aff args › At: psycho not scientific

Psychoanalysis is not built upon pure theorization, there is scientific evidence backing it up.

Solms 18 (Mark Solms is a South African psychoanalyst and neuropsychologist, who is known for his discovery of the brain mechanisms of dreaming and his use of psychoanalytic methods in contemporary neuroscience., 2-15-18, "The scientific standing of psychoanalysis," PubMed Central (PMC), https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6020924/)//JzLim

This paper summarizes the core scientific claims of psychoanalysis and rebuts the prejudice that it is not ‘evidence-based’. I address the following questions. (A) How does the emotional mind work, in health and disease? (B) Therefore, what does psychoanalytic treatment aim to achieve? (C) How effective is it?

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › at: aff args › at: psycho is racist

While psychoanalysis in the past could be perceived as racist, the new wave of theorists are putting inclusion and anti racist ideals at the forefront

Warren 22- (Micaiah Warren is a psychology professor at DePaul University 9-13-2022, "How to Decolonize Psychoanalysis," Depth Counseling - Counseling Therapists Chicago, IL, https://depthcounseling.org/blog/warren-how-to-decolonize-psychoanalysis)//JzLim

Psychoanalysis and psychology as a whole have transformed, becoming more inclusive than they have ever been. This means that new minds, with new ideas, originating from a multitude of backgrounds are entering the field with the intention of improving the well-being of different individuals. We must keep in mind, however, that while psychology in general and psychoanalysis in particular have come such a long way, there is still plenty of work to be done, or…undone. Psychoanalysis was constructed by professionals existing in a world that was and continues to be discriminatory, prejudiced, and exclusionary of people who exist in outgroups or belong to different identities. Consequently, we must grow to understand that the ideologies of psychoanalysis have also been affected by those same injustices. Throughout history, we have seen the efforts of oppressors to exploit the needs and desires of oppressed people, hindering them from making gains across different fields. Additionally, albeit intentionally or unintentionally, we have seen their efforts to limit the availability of services in communities where they are needed most. These issues have been named time and time again, and while they have received growing attention, these problems persist. Psychoanalysis has historically catered to the needs of specific groups of people. In order for psychoanalysis to develop into a more inclusive model of therapy, it will need to become more accessible to people of color, broaden its scholarly focus beyond dominant culture norms/expectations, and adopt a mission of anti-racism.

Psychoanalysis is defined by the American Psychoanalytic Association as a theory of mind intended to “embrace complexity and understand below the surface.” The purpose of psychoanalysis as a treatment is to bring to light influential aspects of experience that are functioning outside of the patient’s awareness or consciousness. (AAPA, 2022). There is still so much that can be uncovered using this model of therapy. One particularly useful concept is the idea of transference. This phenomenon, which lies at the core of psychoanalytic theory, refers to the transfer of wishes, needs and anxieties from childhood onto people in the adult present, including the therapist. We can use the concept of transference to explore questions of how early socialization around issues of race and privilege shape our unconscious prejudices and lead us to react in the ways that we do in our present lives.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Framework › Fw – race aff

Psychoanalysis comes first- ethical research and understanding racial fantasy’s constructed obstacles are prerequisites to understanding the truths to fight racism and inequalities

McGowan et al 21 — Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont; Sheldon George, Professor and Chair of the Department of Literature & Writing at Simmons University; and Derek Hook, Associate Professor at Duquesne University, Lacan and Race--Racism, Identity, and Psychoanalytic Theory, Routledge, 2021, pp. 19-22) // skohli

Fantasy doesn’t just make the impossible possible. It does so, ironically, by placing a barrier between the subject and its object. The fantasy object is possible only insofar as something blocks the subject’s access to it. By prohibiting the impossible object, fantasy creates the illusion that the object is attainable but for the prohibition. This barrier enables the subject to avoid encountering the disappointment of actually obtaining the object and thus plays the pivotal role in the fantasy. As the fantasy stages it, if the subject were to attain this object, it would achieve an enjoyment without any restriction. As a result, the fantasy must place an obstacle in the way of the object. The obstacle, not the object, is the crucial ingredient.

The fundamental task of fantasy is to transform an impossible satisfaction that no one could attain into a prohibited satisfaction that becomes un- attainable due to the fantasized obstacle that prevents the subject from having its object. There is no such thing as complete satisfaction. But complete satisfaction comes to appear possible through the erection of an obstacle to it.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Framework › Fw – policy – DA’s

Superegotisticality DA: The affirmative’s outlook on life and law is manifested in the superego, which ruins quality of life as it fuels the death drive and eats them from the inside out

McGowan 13—Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont, Enjoying what we don’t have, EBSCO PUBLISHING, 2013, pp. 143-147) // skohli

In his account of the superego, Lacan picks up on Freud’s claim that the superego draws its energy from the reservoir of the id. The proximity of these two psychic registers in Freud’s schema leads Lacan to dissociate the superego from prohibition and to align it with an imperative to enjoy. In his Seminar XVIII Lacan claims: “The order of the superego . . . originates precisely . . . in this call for pure enjoyment, that is also to say for non-castration.”29 Even when the superego bombards the subject with imperatives that appear in the guise of prohibitions, Lacan insists that these imperatives actually command enjoyment.

The superego, as Lacan understands it, constantly reminds the subject of its failure to enjoy, and it promulgates an ideal of the ultimate enjoyment as a measuring stick against which the subject can contrast its own failures.30 No subject can obey the demands of the superego because the ideal it provides remains ever out of reach. The closer that the subject approaches to it through obedience, the faster it recedes. The superego enjoins an enjoyment that it never allows the subject to find.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Framework › Fw – policy – DA’s

Racial Fantasia DA: The aff is a self-perpetuating fantasy; in failing to challenge the racial fantasy that underwrites their problems, they just cause them to continue

McGowan et al 21 — Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont; Sheldon George, Professor and Chair of the Department of Literature & Writing at Simmons University; and Derek Hook, Associate Professor at Duquesne University, Lacan and Race--Racism, Identity, and Psychoanalytic Theory, Routledge, 2021, pp. 25-26) // skohli

The persistence of racism depends on an intractable underlying fantasy. Racism endures because the fantasy endures, not because we have failed to come up with the proper legal remedy or the most enlightened educational methods. The racist fantasy remains the same while the legal and social structure changes. Even proposals like slave reparations, which seem like a radical remedy to racism, do not threaten the fantasy and actually risk strengthening it by solidifying the image of the racial other who illegitimately enjoys in the stead of the nonracial subject. The fight against racism must target the enjoyment that racism provides by disrupting the racist fantasy structure. As long as the fantasy endures, racism will remain insoluble. Responding to racism requires first understanding how the fantasy relates to desire and enjoyment.

Both desire and enjoyment are transitive, but they are transitive in fundamentally different ways. To put it briefly: our desire is the desire of the Other, but our enjoyment is the enjoyment of the other. We learn how to desire through our interpretation of what the Other or Symbolic authority desires. We discover our mode of enjoyment through an identification not with the social authority but with the figure of social ostracism—the other. Enjoyment takes its clue from the social exile rather than the social authority, from an other rather than the Other. The way that enjoyment is transitive causes it to appear as intransitive because it models itself on what doesn’t fit within the social order. This is why some theorists claim that enjoyment has nothing to do with the other.17 This contrasting relationship to otherness informs how desire and enjoyment touch on racism. The racist fantasy brings together how we desire and how we enjoy in a specific calculus. It is an attempt to use the racial other’s enjoyment as the solution to the problem of the Other’s desire.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt -- race

Thus we advocate for the process of anti-racism. Vote neg to deconstruct the racial fantasy of the other and rewire our pathways of enjoyment.

McGowan et al 21 — Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont; Sheldon George, Professor and Chair of the Department of Literature & Writing at Simmons University; and Derek Hook, Associate Professor at Duquesne University, Lacan and Race--Racism, Identity, and Psychoanalytic Theory, Routledge, 2021, pp. 29-32) // skohli

Although no one saves lynching picture postcards today, the racist fantasy that led to such a practice has not, unfortunately, undergone any change whatsoever. The public acceptance of racism has diminished, but the un- conscious power of the racist fantasy has not. One of the leading indicators of the continued profound racism of American society is the association of blackness with enjoyment, which has not abated since the time of lynchings.

The outsized role that black popular musicians and black athletes have testifies to the structuring power of a fundamental racist fantasy that privileges black enjoyment. Although American society’s racist structures largely keep black individuals out of top business and political positions, top positions in entertainment and sports are available because these positions, unlike the leadership of a massive company, fit into the prevailing racist fantasy.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt – recognition of death drive

The recognition of the death drive produces a positive politics of enjoyment

McGowan 13—Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont, Enjoying what we don’t have, EBSCO PUBLISHING, 2013, pp. 281-286) // skohli

Because of its transcendental status, the missing signifier is the stumbling block that the attempt to lift repression continually comes up against. But psychoanalytic thought offers us a unique vision of this signifier as nothing but an internal torsion within the signifying structure. This internal tor- sion serves as the basis for politics insofar as it permanently dislodges the structure’s mastery from within. The obstacle to lifting repression is in fact the basis for our political activity, but we must recognize it as such. This is the psychoanalytic conception of politics.30 By identifying with the absent signifier, we do not insist on subverting the system but on adhering to the truth of the signifying system and forcing that truth to manifest itself.

There is no path leading from the death drive to utopia. The death drive undermines every attempt to construct a utopia; it is the enemy of the good society. It is thus not surprising that political thought from Plato onward has largely ignored this psychic force of repetition and negation. But this does not mean that psychoanalytic thought concerning the death drive has only a negative value for political theorizing. It is possible to conceive of a positive politics of the death drive.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Impacts › ! -- death anxiety -- t/case

Death is impossible to imagine, represent, and anticipate, and because of this the affirmative ‘s inability to represent their death only causes more anxiety. Death should allow resolution, yet the affirmative believes they can escape it through perfectionism which only leads to unconscious hatred and conflict.

Encyclopedia 20- International Dictionary, 29 Jun. 2023, "Death and Psychoanalysis," Encylopedia.com, https://www.encyclopedia.com/psychology/dictionaries-thesauruses-pictures-and-press-releases/death-and-psychoanalysis//JzLim

 Our own death cannot be represented, which is obvious since it would require a self-observing consciousness that disappears with death and therefore cannot perceive the death. Any anticipation of our own death as nothingness is therefore impossible. For Freud, this philosophical evidence was reflected in his remarks that "our unconscious . . . does not believe in its own death; it behaves as if it were immortal" (1915b, p. 296) and "it is indeed impossible to imagine our own death; and whenever we attempt to do so we can perceive that we are in fact still present as spectators" (1915b, p. 289). These two propositions should not be confused. The second is a logical statement, since in the absence of existence there is no consciousness, while the first refers to the make-up of the unconscious system and especially the fact that it ignores time and its passage, and more radically, negation.

The inability to represent one's own death does not imply that we fail to suffer about the certainty of death. Anxiety about death occupies a central place in our lives, and ultimately it is this that superego anxiety and castration anxiety refer to. Moreover, death is represented in dreams and symbols. Departures and muteness, or the ability to hide from others are oneiric representations of death. Among the typical dream types Freud mentions in The Interpretation of Dreams (1900a) is the dream of the death of loved ones.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Impacts › ! -- death anxiety -- t/case

*** Labeling death as a certain suffering only feeds into the ‘perfectionist’ rhetoric of the aff. Only by truly examining what we know to be certain can we escape this unhealthy anxiety of death

Piven 09- 10-1-2009, (Jerry Piven teaches at New School University and New York University, where his courses focus on the psychology of religion.)"Razinsky’s “Freud, Psychoanalysis, and Death” – Ernest Becker Foundation," https://ernestbecker.org/razinskys-freud-psychoanalysis-and-death//JzLIM

Razinsky begins by delineating the psychoanalytic rationales for rejecting the import of death anxiety. As others have also explicated in considerable detail (Piven, 2004) Freud reduced the fear of death to castration anxiety or guilt, maintained that death could not be represented in the unconscious, and asserted that the psyche could not fathom death since one was always present as a spectator when envisioning one’s own mortality. Space doesn’t permit elaboration of Freud’s complex and contradictory arguments here, as he also argued that the dread of death impels religious beliefs and fantasies of life beyond the grave. Razinsky’s primary innovation in his own book is the detailed analysis of some of the post-Freudians like Klein, Lacan, and Yalom. Razinsky is also at his most provocative (and often beautifully analytical) when dissecting the arguments that reject the importance of the fear of death, and further asseverating that such theoretical refutations are themselves psychologically motivated.

This is also where Razinsky is most precarious, however, since it is immensely difficult to ascertain what the psychological motives for a theory may be. Just because we may believe that death anxiety is profoundly momentous doesn’t ipso facto prove that anyone who rejects such ideas must be in denial (no matter how likely it seems). And where psychoanalysis may indeed suffer all manner of frailties, if nothing else it exposes the utter intricacy of the mind, in its irrationality, conflict, and flights of fantasy. So it seems ironic and perplexing that Razinsky is immersed in a subject so palpably elusive, that itself informs us of the ubiquity of the irrational, while also seeming so certain what the psychological motives for theoretical rejection must be. And further, again despite such awareness of our propensities for irrationality and illusion, throughout the book he uses a language that decisively and apodictically declares others’ ideas to be categorically right, wrong, or failures.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Impacts › ! -- Self-suffering

The 1AC’s view of the world through suffering and its belief in the power that rests above self-influence leads to endless loss of life and self-harm.

McGowan 4—Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont, The End of Dissatisfaction?. EBSCO PUBLISHING, 2004, pp. 4-7) // skohli

Though Marxism has certainly fallen on hard times today, this funda-mental thesis of Marxism has not. Cuba Gooding’s mantra in the film Jerry Maguire—“Show me the money!”—has become the automatic explanation of all varieties of behavior. Why does Alex Rodriguez decide to play baseball for the Texas Rangers? Why does Monica Lewinsky appear in an interview with Barbara Walters to tell her story? If Alex Rodriguez mentions the passion for the game he found in the Ranger franchise or Lewinsky mentions her need to tell her side of things, we respond with a wink or a cynical aside. In the spirit of Marx, we know that self-interest (i.e., money) is always the chief motivation. But if Marx errs, his error does not lie, as his critics often allege, in underestimating “innate human selfishness.” Instead, his error—and, again, it is the common error today—lies in the other direction, in underestimating the capacity of subjects to act against their self-interest.

Psychoanalysis, however, calls into question the idea that we primarily act on behalf of our own interest. It allows us to see another power operating beneath the apparent predominance of self-interest. Of course, the common-sensical understanding of psychoanalysis is exactly the opposite of this, con-tending that psychoanalysis reduces everything to self-interest. This is often the basis for the most scathing criticisms leveled at Freud himself and at psychoanalysis as a whole. For instance, John Farrell claims that under the spell of psychoanalysis “every appearance of good must be exposed as unconscious hypocrisy, every commitment to public interests and to social institutions must be recognized for what it is—a disguise for narcissistic gratification or a painful instinctual concession.”10 Farrell, like so many critics of psychoanaly-sis, sees Freud as a prophet of human selfishness. But this attack on psycho-analysis—perhaps the most popular of all attacks—completely misunder-stands what is at stake in psychoanalytic interpretation. Rather than uncovering narcissistic self-interest behind a benevolent act, Freud uncovers the abandonment of self-interest that is at stake behind a seemingly self-inter¬ested act. In Seminar V, Lacan points out that Freud discovers the self-destructiveness of desire, that “what we find at the foundation of the analytic exploration of desire is masochism.”11 Anyone can point out why human subjects act self-interestedly—and many thinkers before Freud (Hobbes, Machiavelli, etc.) did so—but it is the province of psychoanalysis to explain why they are able to act against their self-interest, to transcend their narcissism. Because of this ability to act against our interest, Freud claims that “the normal man is not only far more immoral than he believes but also far more moral than he knows.”12 It is on this point that Freud directly questions Marx: for Marx, there is only self-interest; for Freud, there is something more, and this some¬thing more is enjoyment—the jouissance factor.13

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Impacts › ! -- Endless Violence

The affirmative’s focus on life leads to infinite theoretical violence and extensive material suffering through their “defense” against death

McGowan 13—Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont, Enjoying what we don’t have, EBSCO PUBLISHING, 2013, pp. 227-229) // skohli

The further the project of modernity moves in the direction of life, the more forcefully the specter of fundamentalism will make its presence felt. The exclusive focus on life has the effect of producing eruptions of death. As the life-affirming logic of science and capitalism structures all societies to an increasing extent, the space for the creation of value disappears. Modernity attempts to construct a symbolic space where there is no place for death and the limit that death represents. As opposed to the closed world of traditional society, modernity opens up an infinite universe.14 But this infinite universe is established through the repression of finitude. Explosions of fundamentalist violence represent the return of what modernity’s symbolic structure cannot accommodate. As Lacan puts it in his seminar on psychosis, “Whatever is refused in the symbolic order, in the sense of Verwerfung, reappears in the real.”15 Fundamentalist violence is blowback not simply in response to imperialist aggression, as the leftist common sense would have it. This violence marks the return of what modernity necessarily forecloses.

Historically, the opposition between those who privilege life and those who privilege death has coincided with the opposition between the forces of emancipation and those of conservatism. The emancipatory project works to liberate life from the restrictions that the oppressive and hierarchical social order places on it, while conservatism tries to sustain a life-denying order because it views order as the source of all value. Conservative thinkers defend their abridgement of life’s possibilities in the name of order and civilization. Without the restrictions that we place on life, according to this line of thought, we would lose everything valuable.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Links › Link – race aff – k

Their approach to tackling racism fails. Only psychoanalyzing the wrongs of racism truly solves their problems. The affirmative’s investment in “solving racism and inequality” and “reorienting the way we look at race” just cover up the true myths of race

McGowan et al 21 — Todd McGowan, Professor of English at the University of Vermont; Sheldon George, Professor and Chair of the Department of Literature & Writing at Simmons University; and Derek Hook, Associate Professor at Duquesne University, Lacan and Race--Racism, Identity, and Psychoanalytic Theory, Routledge, 2021, pp. 19-22) // skohli

The contemporary proliferation of racism in spite of our knowledge about its wrongs suggests that we have an unconscious investment in racism that continues and multiplies. Armed with education and a belief in racism’s fundamental immorality, people today should have no problem leaving racist ideas and practices behind. But education and morality are not enough. They are powerless in the face of an unconscious investment, which provides the foundation for racism’s continuing appeal for those who indulge in it. The unconscious investment is the central pillar of racism’s intransigence. Unless one takes the unconscious as the starting point for making sense of racism’s appeal, the mystery of the enduring power of racism is almost impossible to decipher. Today, there is a proliferation of historical accounts of all the various manifestations of racism. These accounts make clear the extent of the problem, but they do not help us to resolve it because they never attack racism at the point where it has a hold over us. The struggle against racism requires an engagement with the unconscious, but deciphering the unconscious appeal of racism places us on the difficult terrain of psychoanalytic interpretation.1

When we look at the terminology deployed in the contemporary combat against racism, one might mistakenly assume that the combatants have already taken the unconscious into account. The predominance of the term unconscious bias specifically names this aspect of the psyche. But this apparent nod to psycho- analytic thought is ultimately misleading. Although the term unconscious bias has become a regular part of the anti-racist lexicon, the analysis of the unconscious has not. In fact, the proponents of the term often take pains to distinguish their thought from Freud’s. In Blindspot, their leading work on unconscious bias, Mahzarin Banaji and Anthony Greenwald assure us that “an understanding of the unconscious workings of the mind has changed greatly in the century since Freud’s pathbreaking observations.”2 According to Banaji and Greenwald, Freud’s un- scientific conception of the unconscious has given way to a scientifically verifiable one: we have now collectively moved beyond Freud’s failure to be scientific enough.3 But in the process of this shift, what has been lost is Freud’s insistence on the radical otherness of the unconscious in relation to consciousness.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Links › Link – race aff – k

The 1AC’s views on the economy redeeming impoverished peoples requires that they also subscribe to a charitable cannibalism façade- they construct their own problems to solve and make them feel better about themselves. They cover up the roots of racism through tackling “racialized class consciousness”

Meyerson 97 Gregory Meyerson is a professor at UNC Greenboro, "Marxism, Psychoanalysis, and Labor Competition", 1997, University of British Columbia, pp. 12-14 // skohli

Copyright © 1997 by Gregory Meyerson and Cultural Logic, ISSN 1097-3087 // skohli

Marxists who are economic determinists, who analyze white working-class racism via the labor competition hypothesis or what Saxton calls "the direct economic argument," must deny the graphic particularities of racism, must as a corollary view class consciousness as purified of racialization or gendering. This leads naturally enough to the charge of ahistoricism and hyperrationalism leveled by discourse theorists focusing on how class formation always already takes place in discourse. The ahistoricism of the notion of class interest relied on by economic determinists carries with it the assumption that workers transparently know their interests, which are in turn defined in narrow, economic, calculating, utilitarian terms. Thus, Marxism as economic determinism presupposes a historical, rationalist Lockean man, and Marxism thus falls prey to the bourgeois ideology it claimed to deconstruct. The flipside of the deracialized version of working-class consciousness is that the ruling class is itself seen in essentially non-racial terms. First, it knows (transparently) its economic interest and then, second, it utilizes racism to legitimate a pre-existing non-racial class consciousness.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Links › Link -- Economics

The aff’s acts of financial redistribution only further proves their attempt to create a perfect market through the desire to achieve maximal efficiency. To escape this desire and obsession they must realize that a perfect market does not exist and is theoretically and empirically impossible. Continuing down the path of perfecting a market without realizing that it is impossible only leads to complacency through incorrect, biased conclusions

Schroeder 98, (Jeanne L. Schroeder is a professor at Cardozo School of Law, Yeshiva U, “The End of the Market: A Psychoanalysis of Law and Economics, Harvard Law Review” Dec 1998, p. 483-558, JSTOR//JzLim

Mainstream economics is driven by a number of closely related ideals that I call, collectively, the "perfect market." Achieving the effi- ciency'03 of the perfect market is the object of the economist's desire. In this sense, the perfect market is the ideal or end to which an actual markets are the means. According to one school of law and economics, 1'04 efficiency would be achieved if the ideal perfect market were implemented. We should, therefor modify our legal and political institutions in order to make the act we can or, if that is impossible, to replicate the results of the perfect market as nearly as possible.105

Given the centrality of the ideal of the stream economics, one would expect that economic literature delineating its characteristics. Yet there is remarkable silence among law and economics advocates on the issue. I started this project largely because over the years I had heard numerous critics of law and economics assert that the concept of perfect markets was surprisingly poorly worked out, considering its importance. As a student of economics, I would reply, "That's nonsense. Every introductory economics textbook contains a discussion of the perfect market." Indeed, I thought I remembered reading such discussions, albeit twenty-plus years ago when I was a college student. "Show me," my interlocutors would challenge. In an attempt to prove them wrong, I searched for such a discussion. To my surprise, the only discussions I could find were generally sketchy and conclusory. This Commentary contains the results of my search for a coherent analysis of the perfect market. The surprising silence of the literature led me to try to understand not only the underlying logic of the concept of the perfect market so imperfectly described in the literature, but also the reason economists and lawyers (including myself) fail to attempt such an analysis and then repress this failure.