2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage
Carlock, et.al, 2018 GREG CARLOCK Contributing Author EMILY MANGAN Executive Producer SEAN MCELWEE CO-FOUNDER OF Data for Progress September 2018 Policy Report by Data for Progress A GREEN NEW DEAL A PROGRESSIVE VISION for ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY and ECONOMIC STABILITY https://www.dataforprogress.org/green-new-deal-report
A Green New Deal can have a multiplier effect—every dollar of government spending generates more than a dollar in local economic growth. A Green New Deal will produce immense demand for new goods and services that the private sector can provide. This includes clean energy technology, energy efficient goods and appliance installation services, zero-emission vehicles and charging infrastructure, building construction and retrofits, environmental remediation and restoration, agriculture, forestry, tourism, and recreation—to name some. A Green New Deal creates signals that encourages private capital to move into these new and expanding markets, and new businesses will generate demand for more workers. This also means reinstating the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Green Jobs Initiative for accurate tracking of green job growth.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage
Stiglitz, 2021 Testimony of Joseph E. Stiglitz Before the U.S. Senate Committee on the Budget “The Cost of Inaction on Climate Change” April 15, 2021 https://www.congress.gov/event/117th-congress/house-event/114471?s=1&r=4
Too often, critics of taking action point to the job losses. Change is costly. But change provides opportunity. I am also firmly convinced that the opportunities afforded by addressing climate change are enormous. The number of jobs that will be lost in the old fossil fuel industries are dwarfed by those that will be created in the new industries. The value created in the new industries will also dwarf the value of the stranded assets in the fossil fuel and related sectors. As just two examples: the number of installers of solar panels already is a multiple of the number of coal miners; the auto company with the highest valuation today is Tesla. The current focus on changing to a green economy is already stimulating enormous innovation, innovation that holds out the promise of significant increases in standards of living. The price of renewable energy has been plummeting, and in many areas outcompetes fossil fuels. The drive for a greener society is stimulating the design of new buildings and new ways of doing agriculture, which turn out actually to save resources, particularly if we value them appropriately. Our country especially has much to gain, because innovation is a key comparative advantage. If we are ahead of the game—rather than a laggard—we will develop technology that will be in demand around the world. If we are behind the game, we will pay a high price. It is almost inevitable that other countries will demand cross-border adjustments that will put our companies at a disadvantage. Government has an important role in enabling, facilitating, and encouraging the transition to a green economy. One might say we are in good luck: The deficiencies in public investment over the past decades has made it imperative that we undertake such investments now; and we can make those investments “green” investments. The investments themselves will create an enormous number of jobs, stimulating the economy and banishing to the past discussions of secular stagnation that have abounded for the past two decades. They will also crowd-in private investment. Basic research and technology investments by government, for instance, provide the foundations for investments by the private sector. We saw that in the case of the internet; we saw that in the case of the vaccines that were produced with such rapidity in response to Covid-19. And we will see it with these green investments as well.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage
UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs, 2023 The World Economic Situation and Prospects as of mid-2023 updates the World Economic Situation and Prospects 2023 released on 25 January 2023. The report is prepared by the Global Economic Monitoring Branch in the Economic Analysis and Policy Division of the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4011461
The world economy is facing severe headwinds amid weak growth prospects, elevated inflation and heightened uncertainties. A confluence of factors – legacy effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, the lingering war in Ukraine, the ever-worsening impact of climate change and rapidly shifting macroeconomic conditions – are clouding the economic outlook, even as the global picture shows slight signs of improvement. Persistently high inflation has prompted the most aggressive interest rate hikes in decades, causing financial conditions to tighten sharply and exacerbating debt vulnerabilities. While economic prospects remain subdued, the slowdown in global growth in 2023 is likely to be less severe than previously expected, mainly due to resilient household spending in developed economies and recovery in China. Global growth is now projected to slow from 3.1 per cent in 2022 to 2.3 per cent in 2023, an upward revision by 0.4 percentage points from the January forecast. Global inflation is projected to decline from 7.5 per cent in 2022 to 5.2 per cent in 2023, mainly due to lower food and energy prices and softening global demand. Amid easing inflationary pressures, the global economy is expected to pick up some momentum in 2024, but at 2.5 per cent, growth is projected to remain well below the longer-term (2000-2019) average of 3.1 per cent. Against a backdrop of multiple interconnected crises and heightened macroeconomic uncertainties, monetary and fiscal policy challenges have further intensified. The recent banking sector turmoil in the United States and Europe has illustrated fragilities in the financial system, complicating the trade-off for central banks between fighting inflation and preserving financial stability. After a decade of loose monetary policy with low interest rates and quantitative easing in developed countries, which encouraged excessive leverage in the financial sector and generated negative global spillovers, the prospect of high interest rates and quantitative tightening now poses a massive challenge for developing countries. Lack of access to affordable finance limits the ability of many governments to invest in education, health, sustainable infrastructure and the energy transition, while threatening to push a growing number of countries into debt default.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Phil Torres, Scholar at the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, 5-20-2016, "Biodiversity Loss: An Existential Risk Comparable to Climate Change," Future of Life Institute, https://futureoflife.org/2016/05/20/biodiversity-loss/
Catastrophic consequences for civilization. The consequences of this rapid pruning of the evolutionary tree of life extend beyond the obvious. There could be surprising effects of biodiversity loss that scientists are unable to fully anticipate in advance. For example, prior research has shown that localized ecosystems can undergo abrupt and irreversible shifts when they reach a tipping point. According to a 2012 paper published in Nature, there are reasons for thinking that we may be approaching a tipping point of this sort in the global ecosystem, beyond which the consequences could be catastrophic for civilization. As the authors write, a planetary-scale transition could precipitate “substantial losses of ecosystem services required to sustain the human population.” An ecosystem service is any ecological process that benefits humanity, such as food production and crop pollination. If the global ecosystem were to cross a tipping point and substantial ecosystem services were lost, the results could be “widespread social unrest, economic instability, and loss of human life.” According to Missouri Botanical Garden ecologist Adam Smith, one of the paper’s co-authors, this could occur in a matter of decades—far more quickly than most of the expected consequences of climate change, yet equally destructive. Biodiversity loss is a “threat multiplier” that, by pushing societies to the brink of collapse, will exacerbate existing conflicts and introduce entirely new struggles between state and non-state actors. Indeed, it could even fuel the rise of terrorism. (After all, climate change has been linked to the emergence of ISIS in Syria, and multiple high-ranking US officials, such as former US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel and CIA director John Brennan, have affirmed that climate change and terrorism are connected.) The reality is that we are entering the sixth mass extinction in the 3.8-billion-year history of life on Earth, and the impact of this event could be felt by civilization “in as little as three human lifetimes,” as the aforementioned 2012 Nature paper notes. Furthermore, the widespread decline of biological populations could plausibly initiate a dramatic transformation of the global ecosystem on an even faster timescale: perhaps a single human lifetime. The unavoidable conclusion is that biodiversity loss constitutes an existential threat in its own right. As such, it ought to be considered alongside climate change and nuclear weapons as one of the most significant contemporary risks to human prosperity and survival.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Sarah Gibbins “The world’s wetlands are slipping away. This vibrant sanctuary underscores the stakes.” February 02, 2021 https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/world-wetlands-are-slipping-away-agusan-marsh-underscores-stakes
The Agusan Marsh represents everything wetlands can offer—storm protection, food security, biodiversity, carbon storage—but also the large challenges they face. Upstream pollution, climate change, and habitat destruction threaten the sanctity of this ecosystem. Pollutants from mining operations and palm oil plantations compromise water quality, and critical, carbon-rich peatlands are being drained and burned to make room for more palm oil, rice, and corn. Fifty years ago today, on February 2, 1971, representatives of 18 nations meeting in Ramsar, Iran, adopted the Convention on Wetlands, also called the Ramsar Convention, a treaty aimed at conserving wetlands around the world. Today, 171 countries have signed the treaty. But since 1971, more than 35 percent of the world’s wetlands have been drained for urban development or agriculture, polluted, paved over, or lost to sea level rise. February 2 remains a day devoted to calling attention to the plight of wetlands, and this year, World Wetlands Day is highlighting them as a critical source of freshwater at a time when that commodity is becoming ever more scarce. What are wetlands and what do they do? Wetlands comprise a diverse array of ecosystems that are either flooded permanently or seasonally. They’re often along the coast, in the form of grassy marshes or mangrove forests, but can also be further inland, like forested swamps or peat bogs where water collects and saturates the ground. They’re often fed by rivers and tributaries and contain lakes. In Agusan, freshwater marshes are surrounded by forested swamps, peatland, rivers, and 59 lakes. “I think they’ve suffered for a long time from the perception as muddy, buggy areas that didn’t have a lot of value,” says Jennifer Howard, Senior Director of Conservation International’s Blue Carbon Program. “We’ve shown recently you’re very hard pressed to find an ecosystem that’s more productive, that has all the environmental and climate benefits rolled into one.” It’s estimated that nearly a billion people depend on wetlands for a living in some way—be it farming, fishing, tourism, or transportation—and around 40 percent of the world’s species breed in wetlands or use them as nurseries. Wetlands are also an important source of “green” infrastructure. Like a levee that shield a town from a hurricane, coastal wetlands lessen the damage from powerful storms, helping to control flooding by blocking incoming storm surges, while reducing the impact from wind. One recent study found that one lost hectare (about 2.5 acres) of coastal wetland increased the cost of damage from major storms by $33,000 on average. While forests are often described as the “lungs of the Earth” because they’re important sources of oxygen, wetlands are described as the kidneys because they filter upstream pollutants.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Stevens 2012 - public relations consultant with the Communication Station (Bonnie, “An era of mega fires,” Arizona Daily Sun, America’s News)
Covington says mega fires are symptoms of an unhealthy forest caused by a century of actions -- mostly fire suppression, and overgrazing during the late 1800s -- that have changed the structure and function of ponderosa pine and dry mixed conifer forests. "We need to stop being surprised by the types of fires we're having," said Summerfelt, wildland fire management officer for the city of Flagstaff. "My first fire was on the North Kaibab and it was considered huge. It was 20 acres. A 20-acre fire now means nothing. So in those three-and-a-half decades in my career, I've been able to watch fire change in size and intensity to levels today that even a decade ago would have been unthinkable. And we're not done breaking records." Covington says Arizona is set up for three more enormous crown fires across the Mogollon Rim that burn through the tops of old growth trees and can ignite spot fires as far as 3 miles ahead of the blaze. "There's the Payson to Winslow corridor, the Sedona to Flagstaff corridor and the Prescott corridor. If we don't get out in front of these and do restoration treatments, it's just going to be a matter of time before we have three more major landscapes burn up." As we approach the 10th anniversary of the Rodeo-Chediski Fire, scientists, firefighters and natural resource managers are examining today's forest conditions and reviewing lessons learned from the state's two largest fires. To compare, both fires were started by people on warm, dry, windy days. "With the Wallow Fire, we knew we were in extreme conditions. We had fuel everywhere and our probability of ignition for any fire that hit the ground was 100 percent. With 62 mph wind gusts, it was blowing so hard it was tough to walk," said Zornes. Former Forest Service ranger and firefighter Jim Paxon, now Arizona Game and Fish Department spokesperson, describes the 468,000-acre Rodeo-Chediski Fire as a plume-dominated fire. "It was pretty much fuels related, fed by the millions of excess trees in our overcrowded forests. It had extremely high energy. When I started fighting fire in the late'60s we didn't have these big columns of plumes that would build up, collapse in an explosion on the ground and create hurricane winds. This didn't happen until the '90s." As a result, 49 percent of the area in the Rodeo-Chediski Fire was considered severely burned. For the 538,000-acre Wallow Fire, that figure is 28 percent. "It could take a couple hundred years for these forests to return back to what they were," said Alpine District Ranger Rick Davalos. "Some of the severely burned area includes older growth trees." ERI researchers say crown fires that kill old growth trees also destroy critical wildlife habitat. "The Mexican spotted owl is the biggest concern we have as an endangered species that we're trying to help out," Paxon said. "The Forest Service is under extreme pressure not to do any cutting around the nesting sites. So between the two fires we lost 20 percent of the Mexican spotted owl nests that exist in the world." In addition, heat from the Wallow Fire baked streams and killed aquatic life. Then floods, from monsoon rains after the fire, moved silt into rivers and lakes making matters worse. "The problem with these fires is they remove so much of the vegetation they can create hydrophobic soils. The water won't penetrate the soil. It runs across the surface so all that ash and sediment ends up in streams and rivers. In the Wallow Fire it ruined the habitat for the re-introduced Apache trout," Covington said. "So, whether you look at fish or you look at birds or you look at mammals, the impact of these mega fires over the long haul is very negative."
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Terrapass, 2022 How Reforestation Can Make Earth a Healthier Place to Live January 26, 2022 https://terrapass.com/blog/how-reforestation-can-make-earth-a-healthier-place-to-live/
Reforestation is the process of replenishing forest land that has been depleted of its trees. is an effective form of carbon offsetting; that is why it is so important to replenish and protect forest land. Forests can lose trees in a number of ways. Natural disturbances like wildfires are a common threat to forests. Plus, human practices like logging for timber, clearing land for agricultural reasons, and urbanization cause deforestation. Whether deforestation has occurred due to human activity or a natural cause, it is important to restore the condition of forests. Forests play a key role in Earth’s natural , acting as one of the ecosystems that absorb carbon from the atmosphere. These carbon-absorbing ecosystems are called and include forests, the ocean, and soil. Each year, forests alone absorb one-third of carbon dioxide emitted from burning fossil fuels. As more deforestation occurs, less carbon dioxide is absorbed from the atmosphere. What’s more, the land sector is responsible for 25% of global that contribute to climate change. The activity of forest degradation is responsible for half of these emissions. The very process of deforestation causes a substantial amount of carbon emissions, while simultaneously destroying one of Earth’s abilities for natural regeneration. Deforestation is a serious issue amid the climate crisis. Luckily, forest restoration is a great climate change solution, and conducted at a university in Switzerland, it is our best bet when it comes to countering increasing global temperatures and carbon dioxide levels.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Root, Tik., 9-16-2021, https://www.proquest.com/docview/2573201993/fulltext/9FE1C9219EFC4E79PQ/3?accountid=13921, "9 questions about the Civilian Climate Corps, answered," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-21-2023)
What would the Civilian Climate Corps look like? The corps would be a federally funded initiative aimed at employing tens of thousands of young people to fight climate change. In his executive order, Biden laid out a litany of objectives for the corps. "The initiative shall aim to conserve and restore public lands and waters, bolster community resilience, increase reforestation, increase carbon sequestration in the agricultural sector, protect biodiversity, improve access to recreation, and address the changing climate," it reads. Projects could range from wetland restoration in Florida's Everglades to building parks or installing solar panels in urban areas. Corps members would be paid, with Democrats pushing for a $15-an-hour minimum wage, health-care benefits and — under some proposals — an educational stipend.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Podesta and Ogden 7 – *President of the Center for American Progress and Senior National Security Analyst at the Center for American Progress (John and Peter, The Security Implications of Climate Change, The Washington Quarterly 31.1, Winter 2007)
Consequently, even though the IPCC projects that temperature increases at higher latitudes will be approximately twice the global average, it will be the developing nations in the earth's low latitudinal bands, as well as sub-Saharan African countries, that will be most adversely affected by climate change. In the developing world, even a relatively small climatic shift can trigger or exacerbate food shortages, water scarcity, destructive weather events, the spread of disease, human migration, and natural resource competition. These crises are all the more dangerous because they are interwoven and self-perpetuating: water shortages can lead to food shortages, which can lead to conflict over remaining resources, which can drive human migration, which can create new food shortages in new regions. Once underway, this chain reaction becomes increasingly difficult to stop. It is therefore critical that policymakers do all they can to prevent the domino of the first major climate change consequence, whether it be food scarcity or the outbreak of disease, from toppling. The most threatening first dominos, where they are situated, and their cascading geopolitical implications are identified in this essay.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Aronoff, et.al., 2019 A Planet to Win: Why We Need a Green New Deal Kate Aronoff, Alyssa Battisoni, Daniel Aldana Cohen, and Thea Riofrancos 2019 google books
For the United States to get to net zero emissions in its power sector by the mid-2030s, the country needs to build out new clean energy at least ten times faster than in recent years. Along with public investments in ecosystem restoration, green infrastructure, and conservation work, these measures would require an enormous amount of labor—and thus create millions of high-quality green jobs. There’s simply no precedent for the private sector mobilizing that broadly and quickly. With state support, green capitalists have developed cheap and effective clean energy technologies. But while solar companies can gradually outcompete coal, they can’t legislate coal out of existence or transform the electricity grid and broader energy system.
Under a radical Green New Deal, the public sector would direct investment and coordinate production, much as it did during World War II. Can government bureaucracies handle such complex work? They could seventy-five years ago working with legal pads and chalkboards. In the 1940s, improvised public agencies, the army, and government subsidized businesses ramped up the production of killing machinery with unbelievable speed. The public backed industry built the world’s largest factory in under a year near Ypsilanti, Michigan; it went on to produce a B-24 bomber every hour. Overnight, car seat factories switched to parachute production and Cadillac assembly lines started churning out tanks. We wish we had a different analogy for that scale of public action than World War II. But the point remains: we can build—and push—a public sector capable of stewarding a rapid and just transition. Its often forgotten, moreover, that state capacity was built up in the decade prior by the New Deal. Neoliberals have spent four decades chipping away at these administrative capacities, weakening regulations and many federal agencies to empower big business. Rebuilding and reinvigorating public institutions is one of the most important tasks we face today.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Ann Pettifor 2020 The Case for the Green New Deal. google books.
For humanity to survive on a liveable planet there is an urgency to what we must, and can, do. We are facing extinction. The earth’s complex life support systems of atmosphere, oceans, land surface and life forms are at the point of breakdown, according to the world’s top scientists. As George Monbiot has warned, ‘only one of the many life support systems on which we depend—soils, aquifers, rainfall, ice, the pattern of wind and currents, pollinators, biological abundance and diversity—need fail for everything to slide. The UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) issued a clear and trenchant call for action in 2018. We need to cut annual global emissions by half in the next twelve years and hit net zero carbon by the middle of the century. According to Jason Hickel in Foreign Policy magazine, it would be difficult to overstate how dramatic this trajectory is. It requires nothing less than a total and rapid reversal of our present direction as a civilization. The challenge is staggering in its scale, and the stakes are even more so. As the co-chair of an IPCC working group put it, ‘the next few years are probably the most important in our history’. After decades of delay, this is our last chance to get it right. For the UK and US, as well as other OECD countries, averting climate breakdown means cutting CO2 emissions by 80 percent by 2030 and reaching a zero carbon economy by 2040. This will allow OECD emission cuts to be equitably shared with non-OECD countries’ emission cuts (as in the 1992 UN Convention on Climate Change’s ‘common but differentiated responsibilities’ (CBDR), in which OECD nations have to cut first and hardest).
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
A Green New Deal Makes Economic And Environmental Sense April 25, 2021 Updated April 25, 2021 at 6:33 pm https://www.bcheights.com/2021/04/25/a-green-new-deal-makes-economic-and-environmental-sense/
Last Tuesday, U.S. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Massachusetts’ own U.S. Senator Ed Markey took the their signature bill, the Green New Deal. With new Democratic control of both houses of Congress and the White House, it appears as though the most sweeping piece of climate legislation in history may have another chance at being passed. If so, it will transform the national economic and environmental landscape. It is well past time for the Democratic Party to uniformly rally around the Green New Deal and work to change the course of climate injustice in America.
As it stands today, climate change is undoubtedly one of the most pressing issues facing the world. There are surrounding the prospects for maintaining an inhabitable world—storms and major weather events are worsening, the sea level is rising, and humans have already warmed the globe by about one degree Celsius. It is also important to note that the effects of the climate and environmental crises are not uniformly felt across all social groups. Declining air and water quality is far more likely to impact racial minorities, especially those who live in urban areas. In the United States, one out of every six Black children due to poor air quality, and they are than white children to contract lead poisoning because they live in close proximity to toxic waste. On a more global scale, the majority of those who will be displaced by rising sea levels, unstable weather events, and plummeting food supplies will be , mostly in the global south. It is evident that this situation is fundamentally unfair and unsustainable. The question is, what can we do about this moral and environmental crisis?
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Green & Healy, 2022 Fergus Green1, * and Noel Healy2 1Department of Political Science, University College London, London, UK 2Geography and Sustainability Department, Salem State University, Salem, MA, USA How inequality fuels climate change: The climate case for a Green New Deal
Policy proposals for mitigating climate change have predominantly emerged from a carbon-centric policy paradigm: a reductionist approach that focuses on reducing greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs). Amid growing concerns about the normative credentials and political viability of this agenda, proponents of more radically transformative approaches have begun to coalesce around a Green New Deal (GND) policy paradigm.1–4 For GND proponents, excessive GHGs are densely intertwined with socioeconomic inequalities—such as income and wealth inequality, poverty, extreme wealth concentration, unequal political influence, and social hierarchies based on race and gender— which must be tackled simultaneously if deep decarbonization is to succeed. In Box 1, below, we contrast more fully the key features of the carbon-centric and GND policy paradigms. In the US, where the GND agenda is most politically advanced, GND proposals have provoked predictable resistance from conservative elites and carbon-intensive capital interests.12,13 More interestingly, they have attracted criticism from advocates of decarbonization who endorse the carbon-centric paradigm (see Table S1). Essentially, these criticisms reflect a view that socioeconomic inequalities are not significant drivers of climate change and that tackling them together would be unjustified and/or politically counterproductive. The following quote from distinguished climate scientist Michael Mann, writing in Nature, is illustrative: ‘‘Saddling a climate movement with a laundry list of other worthy social programmes risks alienating needed supporters (say, independents and moderate conservatives) who are apprehensive about a broader agenda of progressive social change.’’1 Here, we aim to provide a systematic response to critiques of this kind. We show that socioeconomic inequalities causally contribute to climate change. We then argue that a more systemic approach to climate mitigation, exemplified by the GND policy paradigm, better addresses these inequality-related drivers and is more likely to be politically effective than carboncentric policy alone. We synthesize the theory and evidence linking climate change to socioeconomic inequalities. The numerous channels through which climate change exacerbates socioeconomic inequalities are well established and widely understood in the climate policy community,15 so we do not discuss these here. Less well known, and therefore the focus of our synthesis, are the channels through which causation flows in the opposite direction: from existing socioeconomic inequalities to climate change. We use ‘‘socioeconomic inequalities’’ as an umbrella term, intending that it be understood to encompass both interpersonal inequalities per se and absolute forms of disadvantage (e.g., financial insecurity) and advantage (e.g., extreme wealth). However, when analyzing causal mechanisms linking socioeconomic inequalities to climate change, we identify the particular explanatory variable relevant to each.We identify 10 such mechanisms, which we discuss under five themes: consumption patterns, production decisions, the obstruction of climate change mitigation policies by elites, households’ fears about the economic and social effects of climate mitigation policies, and the erosion of the social bonds that underpin collective political action—in short, consumption, production, obstruction, trepidation, and non-cooperation. This evidence suggests that integrating certain carbon-centric policies into a wider program of social, economic, and democratic reforms would achieve decarbonization more effectively than carbon-centric policies alone. In the second half of the paper, we draw on this evidence to evaluate the case for GNDs as a means of climate action. We argue first that GNDs make for good policy. On the basis of our review of 29 GND-style proposals from around the world in 2019–2021, we show that common policy components of GNDs do indeed tackle the mechanisms by which inequalities fuel climate change, making them more effective than carbon-centric policies alone. We then argue that GNDs make for good politics: the political strategy associated with GNDs is likely to be more effective than the political strategies associated with carbon-centric policies.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff › 1AC --- MSDI › 1AC ---Warming Advantage
Fiona Harvey 5-17-2023. (Fiona Harvey Environment editor, . "World likely to breach 1.5C climate threshold by 2027, scientists warn." Guardian. Web. accessed 6-7-2023 < https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/may/17/global-heating-climate-crisis-record-temperatures-wmo-research >.)MSUCB
The world is almost certain to experience new record temperatures in the next five years, and temperatures are likely to rise by more than 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, scientists have warned. The breaching of the crucial 1.5C threshold, which scientists have warned could have dire consequences, should be only temporary, according to research from the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO). However, it would represent a marked acceleration of human impacts on the global climate system, and send the world into “uncharted territory”, the UN agency warned. Countries have pledged, under the 2015 Paris climate agreement, to try to hold global temperatures to no higher than 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, after scientific advice that heating beyond that level would unleash a cascade of increasingly catastrophic and potentially irreversible impacts. Prof Petteri Taalas, the secretary general of the WMO, said: “This report does not mean that we will permanently exceed the 1.5C specified in the Paris agreement, which refers to long-term warming over many years. However, WMO is sounding the alarm that we will breach the 1.5C level on a temporary basis with increasing frequency.” Global average surface temperatures have never before breached the 1.5C threshold. The highest average in previous years was 1.28C above pre-industrial levels. The report, published on Wednesday, found there was a 66% likelihood of exceeding the 1.5C threshold in at least one year between 2023 and 2027. New record temperatures have been set in many areas around the world in the heatwaves of the past year, but those highs may only be the beginning, according to the report, as climate breakdown and the impact of a developing El Niño weather system combine to create heatwaves across the globe. El Niño is part of an oscillating weather system that develops in the Pacific. For the past three years, the world has been in the opposing phase, known as La Niña, which has had a dampening effect on temperature increases around the world. As La Niña ends and a new El Niño develops, there is a 98% likelihood that at least one of the next five years will be the hottest on record, the scientists found. Taalas warned of the effects. “A warming El Niño is expected to develop in the coming months and this will combine with human-induced climate change to push global temperatures into uncharted territory. This will have far-reaching repercussions for health, food security, water management and the environment,” he said. “We need to be prepared.” The Arctic is heating much faster than the rest of the world, and this appears to be having an impact on global weather systems, including the jet stream, which has disrupted weather across the northern hemisphere in recent years. There is likely to be less rainfall this year in the Amazon, Central America, Australia and Indonesia, the report found. This is particularly bad news for the Amazon, where scientists have grown increasingly concerned that a vicious cycle of heating and deforestation could tip the region from rainforest into savannah-like conditions. Over the next five years, there is likely to be above-average rainfall in northern Europe, Alaska and northern Siberia, and the Sahel, according to the report. For each year from 2023 to 2027, the global near-surface temperature is predicted to be between 1.1C and 1.8C above the pre-industrial average, taken from the years 1850 to 1900. The world has warmed considerably in recent years. In 2015, when the Paris agreement was signed, requiring countries to hold global temperature increases to no more than 2C above pre-industrial levels while “pursuing efforts” to hold them to 1.5C, it was forecast that the chance of temporarily exceeding the 1.5C threshold within the following five years was zero. This November, governments will meet for the Cop28 UN climate summit, where they will assess progress towards meeting the goals of the Paris agreement. Known as the “global stocktake”, this assessment is likely to show that the world is far off track to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by the 43% this decade that is required to have a good chance of limiting temperature rises to 1.5C.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Disadvantages › 2AC --- AT: Federalism
Mousseau 16 – Michael, Political Science Professor at the University of Central Florida. “Grasping the scientific evidence: The contractualist peace supersedes the democratic peace”, Conflict Management and Peace Science, pg. 1-18, , 01-28-2016
A weighty controversy has enveloped the study of international conflict: whether the democratic peace, the observed dearth of militarized conflict between democratic nations, may be spurious and accounted for by institutionalized market ‘‘contractualist’’ economy. I have offered theory and evidence that economic norms, specifically contractualist economy, appear to account for both the explanans (democracy) and the explanandum (peace) in the democratic peace research program (Mousseau, 2009, 2012a, 2013; see also Mousseau et al., 2013a, b). Five studies have responded with several arguments for why we should continue to believe that democracy causes peace (Dafoe, 2011; Dafoe and Russett, 2013; Dafoe et al., 2013; Ray, 2013; Russett, 2010).
Resolution of this controversy is fundamental to the study and practice of international relations. The observation of democratic peace is ‘‘the closest thing we have to an empirical law’’ in the study of global politics (Levy, 1988: 662), and carries the profound implication that the spread of democracy will end war. New economic norms theory, on the other hand, yields the contrary implication that universal democracy will not end war. Instead, it is market-oriented development that creates a culture of contracting, and this culture legitimates democracy within nations and causes peace among them. The policy implications could hardly be more divergent: to end war (and support democracy), the contractualist democracies should promote the economies of nations at risk (Krieger and Meierrieks, 2015; Meierrieks, 2012; Mousseau, 2000, 2009, 2012a, 2013; Nieman, 2015).
2023
SDI
Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Disadvantages › 2AC --- AT: Federalism
Hannah Loeffler 12-1-2022. (. "Does a universal basic income affect voter turnout? Evidence from Alaska." Cambridge Core. Web. accessed 6-15-2023 < https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/political-science-research-and-methods/article/does-a-universal-basic-income-affect-voter-turnout-evidence-from-alaska/11D46D5315AEB1C6D01D88D4DB1A8647 >.)MSUCB
This paper analyzes the link between a UBI and aggregate turnout. I hypothesize the Alaskan Permanent Fund Dividend as a case of a UBI—celebrated by some to be the only UBI in the world—to have a positive effect on turnout. I employ a DiD estimation strategy to compare the pre- to post-treatment change in turnout for the state of Alaska—where the dividend program is introduced in 1982—relative to the development in all other US states. This paper provides compelling evidence that a UBI increases turnout among an entire electorate persisting over an almost 20-year period—in spite of the dividend payments staying below USD 2,000 and varying considerably.
Among several possible explanations, I analogously to Clinton and Sances (Reference Clinton and Sances2018) argue that two mechanisms are able to account for the lasting increase in turnout, both occurring simultaneously (Pierson, Reference Pierson1993; Schlozman et al., Reference Schlozman, Brady and Verba2018). On the one hand the additional income increases resources for every Alaskan through the dividend, resources that are necessary in order to navigate the voting process. Analyzing the marginal effect of the dividend on voting at different values of educational attainment showed that especially Alaskans with a lower socioeconomic background reflected a strong and significant turnout effect, corroborating findings on the “diminishing marginal utility of income” (Pacheco and Plutzer, Reference Pacheco and Plutzer2008; Ojeda, Reference Ojeda2018, 814). On the other hand, owing to the fact that turnout increased on average as well as the size of the dividend payments may well be expected to have a smaller effect on more affluent Alaskans, it cannot be the increase in resources alone affecting turnout. Rather, an interpretive effect seems to be in place that is grounded on the unconditional nature of the payments. This interpretive effect may emerge, as the role an administration plays in the lives of citizens changes where everyone becomes a program beneficiary. Beyond presenting suggestive evidence I however cannot determine how the discussed mechanisms of interpretive and resource effects interplay.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Counterplan › 2AC --- AT: States
UEA ’75 [United States Embassy in Argentina; cites 1975; Embassy of the U.S. Government; Information Resource Center, “U.S. Government,” https://ar.usembassy.gov/education-culture/irc/u-s-government/]
While often categorized as a democracy, the United States is more accurately defined as a constitutional federal republic. What does this mean? “Constitutional” refers to the fact that government in the United States is based on a Constitution which is the supreme law of the United States. The Constitution not only provides the framework for how the federal and state governments are structured, but also places significant limits on their powers. “Federal” means that there is both a national government and governments of the 50 states. A “republic” is a form of government in which the people hold power, but elect representatives to exercise that power.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Kritik › 2AC --- AT: Cap
Rogelio Luque-Lora 21, MSci in History and Philosophy of Science from the University of Cambridge, M.A. in Natural Sciences from the University of Cambridge, “Engaging imaginaries, rejecting utopias: The case for technological progress and political realism to sustain material wellbeing,” Political Geography, Vol. 86, 02-21-2021, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2021.102358
Gómez-Baggethun is right to suspect that the modern myth of progress has theological origins. In fact, it is largely a product of the Christian conception of human history as an inherently meaningful story that has salvation as its end point. Without the belief that there is a teleological coherence to the history of humanity, and that salvation (whether the Christian version of the Kingdom of God on Earth, or the humanist faith in an emancipated and harmonious future) is an earthly event that lies ahead of the present, the idea of progress is groundless. In cultures that are not historically steeped in Western monotheism, the belief that humanity is inexorably marching toward a better state of affairs is largely absent (Gray, 2007, pp. 29–39). Where Gómez-Baggethun's reading of progress misses the mark is in limiting its scope to technology. The central tenet of modern belief in progress is that ethics and politics advance in line with the growth of knowledge, so that as scientific and technological understandings accrue, so too do humans increasingly learn to arrange their societies in rational and ethical ways (Gray, 2002).
Contrary to Gómez-Baggethun's assertions, technological progress is a fact. Throughout their history, humans have increasingly learnt to manipulate the environment around them to serve their interests. The reason for this is that scientific knowledge grows cumulatively: past discoveries are not necessarily lost with the advent of new knowledge, but rather can be built upon or thrown into question by these new understandings. In contrast, any historical ‘gains’ in politics and ethics (placed between inverted commas to reflect that such evaluations will depend on the particular values of each generation) are easily undone by regime and cultural changes. It is progress in ethics and politics, not in technology, that is a myth.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Kritik › 2AC --- AT: Cap
Aschenbrenner ’20 [Leopold; September 6; Research Fellow in Economics at the Forethought Foundation and Global Priorities Institute at the University of Oxford, B.A. from Columbia University; Global Priorities Institute, “Existential risk and growth,” no. 6]
Secondly, note that this existential risk Kuznets curve appears in the transition dynamics of the optimal allocation. Considering that existential risk mitigation is a global public good, it is unlikely resources are allocated to safety optimally in the real world. As such, this should not be taken to be a prediction of what a particular country with a particular set of institutions will do with regard to existential risk.
Nevertheless, there are a number of reasons why we might still be interested in the transition dynamics under the (impatient) optimal allocation. For one, since there are very long timescales involved here, it is very hard to know (and thus model) what government and societal institutions will evolve to deal with existential risk. However, the ideal these institutions will likely aim at is the optimal allocation. The optimal allocation might thus be a rough proxy for the real-world allocation.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Economy › 2AC --- AT: No Econ Impact
Mann ’14 (Eric Mann is a special agent with a United States federal agency, with significant domestic and international counterintelligence and counter-terrorism experience. Worked as a special assistant for a U.S. Senator and served as a presidential appointee for the U.S. Congress. He is currently responsible for an internal security and vulnerability assessment program. Bachelors @ University of South Carolina, Graduate degree in Homeland Security @ Georgetown. “AUSTERITY, ECONOMIC DECLINE, AND FINANCIAL WEAPONS OF WAR: A NEW PARADIGM FOR GLOBAL SECURITY,” May 2014, )
The conclusions reached in this thesis demonstrate how economic considerations within states can figure prominently into the calculus for future conflicts. The findings also suggest that security issues with economic or financial underpinnings will transcend classical determinants of war and conflict, and change the manner by which rival states engage in hostile acts toward one another. The research shows that security concerns emanating from economic uncertainty and the inherent vulnerabilities within global financial markets will present new challenges for national security, and provide developing states new asymmetric options for balancing against stronger states.¶ The security areas, identified in the proceeding chapters, are likely to mature into global security threats in the immediate future. As the case study on South Korea suggest, the overlapping security issues associated with economic decline and reduced military spending by the United States will affect allied confidence in America’s security guarantees. The study shows that this outcome could cause regional instability or realignments of strategic partnerships in the Asia-pacific region with ramifications for U.S. national security. Rival states and non-state groups may also become emboldened to challenge America’s status in the unipolar international system.¶ The potential risks associated with stolen or loose WMD, resulting from poor security, can also pose a threat to U.S. national security. The case study on Pakistan, Syria and North Korea show how financial constraints affect weapons security making weapons vulnerable to theft, and how financial factors can influence WMD proliferation by contributing to the motivating factors behind a trusted insider’s decision to sell weapons technology. The inherent vulnerabilities within the global financial markets will provide terrorists’ organizations and other non-state groups, who object to the current international system or distribution of power, with opportunities to disrupt global finance and perhaps weaken America’s status. A more ominous threat originates from states intent on increasing diversification of foreign currency holdings, establishing alternatives to the dollar for international trade, or engaging financial warfare against the United States.