Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Fiscal (policy actions)

Timing size duration and composition key – stimulus should be reversed when conditions improve

Mark Horton, 6-28-2019, "Fiscal Policy: Taking and Giving Away," IMF, , accessed 6/15/23, mw

The exact response ultimately depends on the fiscal space a government has available for new spending initiatives or tax cuts—that is, its access to additional financing at a reasonable cost or its ability to reorder its existing expenditures. Some governments were not in a position to respond with stimulus, because their potential creditors believed additional spending and borrowing would put too much pressure on inflation, foreign exchange reserves, or the exchange rate—or delay recovery by taking too many resources from the local private sector (also known as crowding out). Creditors may also have doubted some governments’ ability to spend wisely, to reverse stimulus once put in place, or to address long-standing concerns with underlying structural weaknesses in public finances (such as chronically low tax revenues due to a poor tax structure or evasion, weak control over the finances of local governments or state-owned enterprises, or rising health costs and aging populations). For other governments, more severe financing constraints have necessitated spending cuts as revenues decline (stabilizers functioning). In countries with high inflation or external current account deficits, fiscal stimulus is likely to be ineffective, and even undesirable.

The size, timing, composition, and duration of stimulus matter. Policymakers generally aim to tailor the size of stimulus measures to their estimates of the size of the output gap—the difference between expected output and what output would be if the economy were functioning at full capacity. A measure of the effectiveness of the stimulus—or, more precisely, how it affects the growth of output (also known as the multiplier)—is also needed. Multipliers tend to be larger if there is less leakage (for example, only a small part of the stimulus is saved or spent on imports), monetary conditions are accommodative (interest rates do not rise as a consequence of the fiscal expansion and thereby counter its effects), and the country’s fiscal position after the stimulus is viewed as sustainable. Multipliers can be small or even negative if the expansion raises concerns about sustainability in the period immediately ahead or in the longer term, in which case the private sector would likely counteract government intervention by increasing savings or even moving money offshore, rather than investing or consuming. Multipliers also tend to be higher for spending measures than for tax cuts or transfers and lower for small, open economies (in both cases, because of the extent of leakages). As for composition, governments face a trade-off in deciding between targeting stimulus to the poor, where the likelihood of full spending and a strong economic effect is higher; funding capital investments, which may create jobs and help bolster longer-term growth; or providing tax cuts that may encourage firms to take on more workers or buy new capital equipment. In practice, governments have taken a “balanced” approach with measures in all of these areas.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

(TVA option) yes eligibility criteria, yes financing instrument to distribute profits from a government owned asset

Congressional Research Service, April 3, 2018, “Universal Basic Income Proposals for the United States,” Congressional Research Service, , accessed 6/12/23, mw

Conceptually, a universal basic income (UBI) program provides a modest cash income at regular intervals (e.g., each month or year) to all individuals meeting minimal eligibility criteria. A UBI can serve as a social insurance program, a method for distributing income generated by a government-owned asset (e.g., the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend), or both. Other terms for a UBI are a “basic income guarantee” or “unconditional basic income.” Whereas some countries—like Finland and Canada—have experimented with UBIs, for the United States, UBI discussions are largely notional: the United States does not have a country-wide UBI, and UBI proposals have not been introduced in the 115th Congress. Specific UBI policy proposals for the United States, however, have been offered by members of the social policy community, business world, and the technology industry (e.g., the company Y Combinator has announced plans to conduct a basic income experiment in California). Defining Features Key defining characteristics of UBI proposals are the following: Universality of Benefit. The UBI benefit is provided to all persons subject to minimal criteria such as citizenship, adulthood, and non-incarceration. Unconditional Benefit Receipt and Usage. Beyond meeting minimal eligibility criteria, UBI proposals do not generally condition benefit receipt on particular attributes, behaviors, or outcomes; means-tests and work requirements are not common features of UBI proposals. Likewise, few proposals place restrictions on UBI recipients’ use of the cash benefit. “Basic” Benefit or Profit-Sharing Dividend. Where a UBI is proposed as a social insurance program, the proposed benefit amount is generally selected to be large enough to cover basic living expenses. Two recent proposals, for example, place the disposable UBI benefit between $10,000 and $12,000 per year (Table 1), which is near the official poverty threshold for a single person under age 65 years with no children ($12,752 in 2017). Where a UBI is used to distribute income generated by a government-owned asset, the dividend amount varies from year-to-year based on the performance of the financing instrument (e.g., the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend). Financing Proposed UBI financial mechanisms depend on the underlying objectives for the program. Some UBI proponents view the benefit as a replacement for some or all existing social transfers, such as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and housing assistance, other targeted federal spending (e.g., agricultural subsidies), and the tax expenditures such as the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC). These proposals suggest that a UBI could be financed in large part by forgone costs of such programs. Some have suggested, however, that new taxes may be needed to cover full UBI program costs. Others view a UBI as a mechanism for distributing income generated from a state-owned resource. For example, the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend provides an annual payment to eligible Alaskan residents generated from an investment fund seeded by Alaskan oil sales; the annual dividend was $1,100 in 2017. Some Native American tribes similarly distribute a share of profits generated from tribeowned casinos to tribe members.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

Goal of UBI is everyone have rights to meet basic needs

Evan Mceldowney, 3-5-2021, "What is A Federal Jobs Guarantee?," Sunrise Movement, , accessed 5/25/23, mw

How is the job guarantee different from universal basic income, and why isn’t Sunrise campaigning around that?

Universal Basic Income, or UBI, calls for giving everyone a fixed and usually monthly payment that they can spend however they want or need. The proposed amount can vary from $1,000 per month, like Andrew Yang called for to much larger amounts. Like the job guarantee, the goal of UBI is to make sure every person in this country should have rights to meet their basic needs regardless of race, class, age, or education.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

At least $500 – no controls on what its used for

Public Health Madison and Dane County, June 28, 2022 “Why Universal Basic Income Could Change the Public’s Health (and how to apply for it in Madison), Public Health Madison and Dane County” , accessed 6/21/21, mw

Depending on the program, the amount of cash given each month might be different but is generally at least $500. Some implementations of UBI aim to benefit everyone, no matter what their household income is; other programs give benefits to those only below a certain household income. But the main thread is that people aren’t constrained with how they can use their benefits, allowing them to spend the money on whatever is most important to their household—whether that’s rent, car payments, phone payments, food, clothing, or whatever else people need.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

Ubi is only to people who aren’t working

Maitreesh Ghatak and François Maniquet, 2019, “Universal Basic Income: Some Theoretical Aspects,” Annual Review of Economics, 11(1), 895–928. doi:10.1146/annurev-economics-080218-030220, accessed 6/16/23, mw

In general, though, basic income typically refers to the income of individuals who do not work, and it is an income guarantee in the sense that individuals would automatically get this income in case they stop working.16 It is funded by taxes paid by working individuals. It is universal when all individuals who do not work receive the same amount, independently of whether they do not work because of their low wage or because of their low willingness to work. This is the topic of Section 4.2.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

UBS is services provided through public institutions – vouchers aren’t UBI

Milena Büchs, 2021, “Sustainable welfare: How do universal basic income and universal basic services compare?” Elsevier, , accessed 6/12/23, mw

While discussions about public services and universal provision have a long history, the specific concept of UBS was only proposed recently in a report by the Institute of Global Prosperity (2017). Fundamental to the UBS proposal is that services that satisfy people's basic needs, including health and social care, education, and basic levels of housing, food, mobility and information, should be provided to everyone through public or collective institutions according to need, regardless of ability to pay and free at the point of use (Coote and Percy, 2020; Gough, 2019; Institute for Global Prosperity, 2017). Here, I will use a broad definition of UBS that includes universal basic infrastructures (such as roads and electricity grids) and universal vouchers (e.g. for home energy or public transport) (Bohnenberger, 2020; Foundational Economy Collective et al., 2018) because services, infrastructures and vouchers can be seen as complementary mechanisms for providing goods and services that satisfy needs. The universality of UBS mainly refers to the right to access services if need arises. The actual provision of UBS often requires some form of M. Büchs Ecological Economics 189 (2021) 107152 4 needs assessment, for instance for health and social care. However, some goods and services could, in principle, also be allocated on an equal per capita basis such as internet access or even water and electricity. Equal per capita allocation removes needs testing and stigma, but bears the risk of over-providing for large households (which typically have lower per capita consumption due to economies of scale), and underproviding for people with additional needs, for instance due to old age or disability. This could be addressed by making the allocation tradable which maintains distributional outcomes of per capita schemes while achieving a more targeted allocation of the actual good or service in question. Which provision mechanism is more suitable for which type of need, and how levels of need would be determined, are highly complex questions that would need to be decided in democratic processes.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

Ubi is not UBS – unconditional, generous, yes robin hood tax, not a supplement (no negative income tax)

Ubs = universal basic services

Milena Büchs, 2021, “Sustainable welfare: How do universal basic income and universal basic services compare?” Elsevier, , accessed 6/12/23, mw

Core to most definitions of UBI is the payment of an unconditional, regular income by the state to every resident in a country (Standing, 2004; Van Parijs and Vanderborght, 2017). Unconditionality means that payments do not depend on levels of other income sources or wealth, willingness to work, or domestic living arrangements. Therefore, UBI is not a supplementary form of income support, minimum income guarantee, or a negative income tax, all of which would be withdrawn as soon as an individual receives income from other sources. The definition of UBI does not specify a set level of income, but supporters commonly argue that a UBI should be sufficiently generous to reduce poverty and increase people's ‘real freedoms’ (Raventos, ´ 2007; Van Parijs and Vanderborght, 2017: 10–11). Some proposals consider a ‘partial’ UBI at a lower level of income (Van Parijs and Vanderborght, 2017: 165–9), and I will argue below that a partial UBI could complement UBS. Most proposals emphasise that UBI would need to be financed by replacing existing income support schemes and through progressive taxes. In this paper, I assume a progressive system of financing UBI which would result in a net redistribution from richer to poorer people. An analysis of the financial viability of UBI (and UBS) goes beyond the scope of the paper. Financial viability will critically depend on societies' willingness to redistribute and target resources towards UBI and UBS schemes which could become fundamental for establishing sustainable welfare systems.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

WM – “Even if” ubi includes conditions, its universal insofar as once conditions are met you are not removed

Rebecca Hasdell, July 2020, “WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME A CROSS-SYNTHESIS OF REVIEWS,” Stanford Basic Income Lab, , accessed 6/12/23, mw

The studies that are used in review reports to project the impact of a UBI vary. Indeed, studies that analyze pilots, policies, and programs with quite different features have been used to arrive at conclusions about what could happen if everyone in a community or region received cash. For this report, all pilots, policies, and programs referenced in included reviews were classified according to the definitional features presented in the introduction of this report. Programs, policies, experiments, and pilots fit into five broad categories (Table 3). A full list of programs covered by the reviews in these categories is included in Appendix 1: ■ cash transfers, conditional and unconditional ■ social insurance ■ in-work benefits ■ dividend payments from resource sector or other revenues ■ cash from non-work sources, such as private remittances or lottery winnings The broad categorizations include different combinations of the core, definitional features of a UBI: universality, unconditionality, in-cash, to individuals, and at a level that meets basic needs (Figure 1). Some pilots, policies, and programs that are included in the reviews synthesized for this report track more closely to the definitional features than others. For this reason, we break down interpretations of universality and unconditionality that explain some of the variability in studies that are included in reviews. Universality is the idea that every person is covered under a given scheme. Universality, though, has multiple interpretations; it can refer to programs where every person is paid or programs where every person is guaranteed to be covered based on demographic characteristics such as age or the average income in the area where they live. In the case where there are criteria for initial eligibility, a defining feature of UBI is continuing eligibility despite changes to income or other characteristics. Conditionality refers to requirements that are imposed to receive benefits. Conditions can refer to service requirements (attending a health clinic or attending school) and to work requirements. Service conditionalities are often used as an exclusion criteria by reviews, however some programs that require recipients to hold or seek employment in the formal economy are commonly used to draw conclusions about the impact of cash. Examples include social assistance programs with work requirements and income-based tax credits. Programs that do not meet any of the meanings of the definitional features may be included when reforms are introduced that allow researchers to evaluate changes in outcomes, as has been the case with the welfare assistance program Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) in the United States. Only a handful of the interventions covered by this review are truly unconditional and universal. In an exhaustive review, Gentilini and colleagues21 identify only a small number of schemes that reach everyone within a geographic region without meansbased or demographic targeting, and regardless of work history. These included national schemes in Mongolia and Iran, dividend transfers in Alaska and the Eastern Band of the Cherokee Nation, a one-off transfer to all citizens in Kuwait, and pilots financed by private contributions and the non-governmental organizations in Kenya and Namibia, and by the national government in India. Several of these programs are either short-term, or not set to a level that would meet basic needs.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

UBI is very broad – two traits – unconditional and universal are guiding principles

Maura Francese and Delphine Prady, 12-1-2018, "What Is Universal Basic Income? – IMF Finance & Development Magazine," IMF, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2018/12/what-is-universal-basic-income-basicsUniversal basic income is an income support mechanism typically intended to reach all (or a very large portion of the population) with no (or minimal) conditions, accessed 6/12/23, mw

Discussions around universal basic income can be heated, both in a scholarly context and in public discourse, and there is no established common understanding. Very different income-support programs are often labeled "universal basic income," even when they have little in common or do not aim at the same goal. Many ongoing and prospective experiments with universal basic income around the world refer to very different interventions. Examples include cash transfers to a selected group of unemployed people for a short time in Finland, to adults for 12 years in Kenya, and to randomly chosen households in California. This diversity reflects the absence of a unified definition and assessment methodology in both the literature and policy discourse. Back to Basics Chart Programs typically grouped under the universal basic income umbrella have a mix of key features (see chart). Does it replace or complement other social protection programs? Is the recipient an individual or a household? How is the pool of beneficiaries defined? What is the timing of the payment? Are there conditions attached? Depending on how these key features are chosen and combined, scholars have proposed various forms of universal basic income (see chart). Thomas Paine’s (1797) "ground-rent" resembles a categorical capital grant (for example, a one-time endowment to a specific group of people) aimed at fighting the transmission of poverty from one generation to the next. Milton Friedman (1968) saw the "negative income tax" as a way to replace the entire American welfare state to overcome administrative inefficiencies. Philippe Van Parijs (1992) advocates a regular, universal, unconditional, and generous cash transfer. Anthony Atkinson’s (1996) "participation income" complements existing social programs and the minimum wage and is conditioned on a form of "social" participation— contributing to society through employment, education, childcare, or other activities. Across this broad spectrum, however, two common traits characterize and differentiate universal basic income-type programs from others: Universality —or very large—coverage of individuals in society Unconditionality —or very broadly conditioned provision—as is the case of Atkinson’s "participation income" Proponents and opponents of universal basic income have highlighted several aspects, and arguments in its favor mirror those opposed. Some advocates point out that it does a better job of reaching the poor than means-tested programs—that is, programs that determine individual or family eligibility for government assistance based on an income or asset test. Many factors can keep means-tested programs from reaching the intended recipients—for example, administrative capacity, high information and administrative costs, poor performance of targeting mechanisms, and social stigma.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › UBI

Replaces structure – basic income with little to no restrictions

Center for Hunger Free Communities, 2021, "Universal Basic Income," https://drexel.edu/hunger-free-center/research/briefs-and-reports/universal-basic-income/UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME, accessed 6/12/23, mw

Universal basic income (UBI), or basic income guarantee, is a government program that aims to address economic inequality and provide economic security through monthly direct cash transfers to every member of a community with no means testing. It creates a basic income floor for everyone, regardless of income and employment status. UBI allows recipients to spend funds however they choose, unlike other benefit programs. UBI differs from other guaranteed income proposals in that every adult in the community receives a monthly payment, regardless of their income. Guaranteed income programs that target only specific populations are problematic as they require citizens to prove they are deserving of basic income support. The concept of UBI has existed since the 1800s when American economist Henry George argued for a “citizen’s dividend” in the form of a single land tax. Milton Friedman described it as a negative income tax. Martin Luther King, Jr. and the Black Panther Party for Self Defense also called for a guaranteed income in the 1960s. In the early 1970s, UBI was part of George McGovern’s presidential campaign and was seriously considered by President Richard Nixon. Many communities offer various forms of guaranteed income and UBI to fill gaps caused by unemployment or underemployment. These benefits are reviewed on a quarterly basis to ensure recipients are receiving the appropriate amount and are responsive to inflation and cost of living increases.UBI provides a sustainable path forward to transition families off SNAP benefits. Implementing UBI can be slow and would replace the current systems over the course of time. Many progressive proponents argue for a UBI+ approach, which would not immediately replace any existing security-enhancing government programs but instead supplement the existing welfare infrastructure.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

TVA – eliminate caps, increase minimum benefits, care + unemployment credits

Leah Smith, 2019, "Expanding Social Security: A Strategy to Strengthen Retirement Security for Vulnerable Populations and Future Generations," Center for Global Policy Solutions, , accessed 6/3/23/ mw

Increasing the Special Minimum Benefit to 125 percent of the poverty threshold would protect the most financially vulnerable workers. The special minimum benefit would be increased for workers who have paid into Social Security for at least 30 years and claim benefits at the full retirement age. This increase is crucial because these workers are less likely to have Average retirement savingsprivate retirement accounts or discretionary income.

Providing a dependent care credit would help workers who spend part of their lives caring for children and disabled or elderly dependents. The time these workers spend out of the workforce can result in lower benefits, which decreases their economic security. A dependent care credit for up to five years could be set at one-half of the average wage.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

TVA – Social Security Expansion Act

Paul Mulholland, 2-17-2023, "Social Security Expansion Act Would Guarantee Solvency for 75 Years," PLANADVISER, , accessed 6/3/23, mw

The Social Security Expansion Act, introduced earlier this week by Senators Bernie Sanders, I-Vermont, and Elizabeth Warren, D-Massachusetts, aims to make Social Security solvent through the end of the 21st century, while also enhancing benefits. The bill would create a tax of 12.4% on investment income for individuals making $200,000 or more and married couples making $250,000 or more, matching the combined employee and employer payroll rates. The bill would also make all income greater than $250,000 subject to the full Social Security payroll tax rate; currently, income greater than $160,200 is not subject to the full payroll tax rate. Under the bill, income between $160,200 and $250,000 would not be taxed differently at first, but the $160,200 threshold would be allowed to rise normally until it reaches $250,000, projected to happen in 2035. At that point, all income would be subject to the full payroll rate. Additionally, any income greater than $250,000 would not be counted for benefit calculation purposes. Since the bill would raise taxes, it must be formally introduced first in the House of Representatives. Sponsored in the House by Representatives Jan Schakowsky, D-Illinois, the bill was referred to the House Committee on Ways and Means on Tuesday. The bill has 26 co-sponsors in the House, as of today, all of whom are Democrats. Republicans control the House, and the Committee on Ways and Means is chaired by Representative Jason Smith, R-Missouri. A statement from Sanders’ office said the bill would make Social Security solvent for at least the next 75 years, based on a study conducted by Stephen Goss, the chief actuary at the Social Security Administration. Goss’ report explained that the bill would change the cost-of-living index used to calculate Social Security benefit increases from the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W) to the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly (CPI-E). The report estimated that the cost-of-living adjustment would increase by “0.2 percentage points per year on average” as a result. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the CPI-E is a statistic which weighs inflation to account for the spending patterns of those aged 62 and older, such as their higher proportional spending on healthcare. The Bureau warned that this statistic has certain limitations, such as a smaller sample population, and currently has no official usage. According to a factsheet for the bill, it would also increase the Special Minimum Benefit to 125% of the poverty line, “or over $18,000 for a single worker who had worked their full career.” The bill would also increase the first income-percentage “bend point” from 90% to 95%. This means that, going forward, 95% of the first $1,115 in monthly wages (for 2023, indexed to inflation) would count toward Social Security benefits, up from 90%. This has the effect of frontloading benefit increases such that low-income workers benefit proportionally more from them. Sanders’ office estimates that the annual Social Security benefit would increase on average by $2,400 a year.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

(TVA – Expand via increase tax and benefits, Eliminate earnings cap, Create an extra tier) Three principles of expansion – Be enough to live on, Universality, new revenues not cuts

Jessie Rothstein, October 16, 2016, "Expand Social Security," Equitable Growth, , accessed 6/3/23, mw

Policymakers should therefore pursue a major expansion of Social Security. There are a number of attractive ways to do this. I articulate three principles that should guide such an expansion, then describe three options that would satisfy the following principles: Social Security benefits should be enough for retirees to live on, on their own The features that have made the program such a success to date, including its universality and its dedicated, untouchable financing stream, should be preserved The existing program’s long-term financing shortfall should be closed via new revenues rather than benefit cuts, with the pain of this offset by real, visible benefits in the form of higher payments to retirees The following three policy options are consistent with these principles Three policy changes to expand Social Security EXPAND THE PROGRAM VIA PROPORTIONATE INCREASES TO TAX RATES AND TO ALL RECIPIENTS’ BENEFITS A modest increase in the payroll tax rate of less than one percentage point—from 6.2 percent to 7.2 percent, respecting the current taxable earnings cap—on both workers and employers would finance a 15 percent benefit increase for all current and future retirees as well as survivors and disabled workers. This could (and should) be scaled to provide larger increases—for example, a 2 percentage point increase in the tax rate would finance a 30 percent increase. If disabled workers’ benefits were excluded from the expansion, the benefit increase would be larger, 18 percent per percentage point on the tax rate. ELIMINATE THE CURRENT TAXABLE EARNINGS CAP, AND SPLIT THE REVENUES AMONG INCREASING BENEFITS FOR THOSE WHO PAY HIGHER TAXES, CLOSING THE FINANCING GAP, AND INCREASING BENEFITS FOR THE LOWEST EARNERS Earnings above $118,500 per year are exempt from Social Security taxes, specifically the Federal Insurance Contributions Act, or FICA, taxes. Only 6 percent of workers earn more than this amount, but the share of wages above the threshold has grown as these income earners have pulled away from the rest of the workforce.19 Eliminating the cap, without increasing benefits, would yield more than enough revenues to close the 75-year projected finance shortfall for Social Security and Social Security Disability Insurance.20 More consistent with the principles above would be to use some of the revenues to increase benefits for high earners in order to preserve the program’s universality while imposing a reasonable cap on the size of the individual benefit. Another portion should go toward increasing benefits for lower-earning recipients. This would help promote retirement security and would create a constituency to support the cap elimination. The remainder could still make a substantial down-payment toward eliminating the financing gap. If earnings were subject to taxes without a cap but non-wage income remained exempt, many high earners might reclassify their earnings as capital gains or business income. To prevent evasion while being consistent with the overall structure of the program, the FICA tax might be applied to all personal income above the taxable earnings cap, regardless of whether that income comes as earnings or in another form. This would raise dramatically more money, more than enough to close the entire financing gap and support larger benefit increases for low-income retirees. While a few very high-income individuals would face sharply increased tax bills under this proposal, dedicating the revenues to the Social Security trust fund, just as FICA taxes are today, would promote the tax increase’s political viability and protect it from attack. CREATE AN OPTIONAL EXTRA TIER OF SOCIAL SECURITY, INTO WHICH WORKERS COULD CONTRIBUTE IN ORDER TO PURCHASE EXTRA BENEFITS WHEN THEY RETIRE Some higher-income workers may want more retirement consumption than even an expanded Social Security benefit can support. As discussed above, pervasive market failures make private retirement saving very inefficient. The government can solve this problem by allowing savers to use the existing Social Security infrastructure, with its built-in mechanisms, to pool and share risks at much lower “load” than any private savings vehicle. Pricing of optional add-on benefits would need to account for a modest degree of adverse selection, as those with longer life expectancies would be somewhat more likely to participate. It would also be more expensive to administer than the current system, though likely much less so than existing private annuity products given the existing infrastructure to track contributions and benefit eligibility. But even with pricing that accounts for these extra costs—set to ensure that the new tier of optional add-on benefits is entirely self-financing—this would be a very attractive option relative to the private annuity market. Participants would contribute throughout their careers, with no need to make investment decisions, pay fees, or face market risk. In return, they or their survivors would receive higher benefits when they retired, became disabled, or died. Other proposed changes that are similarly consistent with the principles enumerated above are also worthy of consideration. It is noteworthy, however, that recent discussions have moved away from the ideas of pre-funding Social Security benefits and investing trust funds in equities. These do nothing to address the above principles, and only expose the program (and the retirees it supports) to political and market risk.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

socials security income is means tested – no tax contributions

KATHLEEN ROMIG AND SAM WASHINGTON May, 5-4-2022, "Policymakers Should Expand and Simplify Supplemental Security Income," Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, , accessed 6/3/2023, mw

SSI provides monthly cash assistance to older or disabled people with little income and few assets. It supplements the incomes of those who aren’t eligible for Social Security or whose benefits are very low. SSI is administered by SSA, but it’s distinct from the Social Security retirement program because it is means-tested and funded by general revenue, not payroll tax contributions. In March 2022, about one-third of SSI recipients also received Social Security retirement, survivors, or disability benefits.[5] SSI uses the same medical criteria as SSDI to determine eligibility for disability benefits but different financial criteria.

In March 2022, 7.6 million people received SSI benefits, including 1 million children with disabilities. (See Figure 1.) Because beneficiaries typically have no other source of income, more than half receive SSI’s maximum benefit, which is $841 per month for an individual and $1,261 for a couple in 2022.[6] SSI reduces these benefit amounts for recipients with other sources of income (such as earnings, Social Security benefits, or child support) or in-kind support, such as help with groceries they receive from family or friends. Such reductions dropped the average SSI monthly benefit to $625 in March 2022.[7] Almost all states supplement the federal SSI benefit for at least some recipients. For instance, those supplements often help cover the care of those who live in congregate settings, such as assisted living.[8] In most states, SSI recipients are automatically eligible for Medicaid.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

3 types of people are explicitly excluded from Social Security – the aff must affect these excluded groups or expand who is eligible to receive benefits.

Social Security Administration No Date. (Social Security Administration . "OASDI" Social Security Administration. Web. No Date. accessed 6-28-2023. < https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/progdesc/sspus/oasdi.pdf >. Phops)

The majority of workers excluded from coverage are in three major categories: (1) Federal civilian employees hired before January 1, 1984, (2) agricultural workers and domestic workers whose earnings do not meet certain minimum requirements, and (3) persons with very low net earnings from self-employment (generally less than $400 per year). The remaining few groups excluded from coverage are very small. An example is certain nonresident, nonimmigrant aliens temporarily admitted into the United States to study, teach, or conduct research. Certain family employment is also excluded (such as employment of children under age 18 by their parents). Ministers and members of religious orders who have not taken a vow of poverty and Christian Science practitioners have their professional services covered automatically as self-employment unless within a limited period they elect not to be covered on the grounds of conscience or religious principle. Religious orders whose members have taken a vow of poverty may make an irrevocable election to cover their members as employees. Employees of State and local governments are covered under voluntary agreements between the States and the Commissioner of Social Security. Each State decides whether it will negotiate an agreement and, subject to special conditions that apply to retirement system members, what groups of eligible employees will be covered. At present, more than 75% of State and local employees are covered. Special rules of coverage apply to railroad workers and members of the uniformed services. Railroad workers have their own Federal insurance system that is closely coordinated with the Social Security program. If they have less than 10 years of railroad service, their railroad credits are transferred to the Social Security program. Under certain circumstances, members of the uniformed services may be given noncontributory wage credits in addition to the credits they receive for basic pay. The Social Security Trust Funds are reimbursed from Federal general revenues to finance noncontributory wage credits.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

Social Security means the OASDI

Social Security Administration No Date. (Social Security Administration . "OASDI" Social Security Administration. Web. No Date. accessed 6-28-2023. < https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/progdesc/sspus/oasdi.pdf >. Phops)

The OASDI program—which for most Americans means Social Security—is the largest income-maintenance program in the United States. Based on social insurance principles, the program provides monthly benefits designed to replace, in part, the loss of income due to retirement, disability, or death. Coverage is nearly universal: About 96% of the jobs in the United States are covered. Workers finance the program through a payroll tax that is levied under the Federal Insurance and Self-Employment Contribution Acts (FICA and SECA). The revenues are deposited in two trust funds (the Federal Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund and the Federal Disability Insurance Trust Fund), which pay benefits and the operating expenses of the program. Benefit payments totaled over $343.2 billion in fiscal year 1996.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

Social Security is a term of art that describes guaranteed income and health care – it is defined and bounded by United Nations Doctrine

International Labour Organization No Date ( International Labour Organization . " Facts on Social Security." No Publication. Web. No Date. accessed 6-28-2023. < https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---dgreports/---dcomm/documents/publication/wcms_067588.pdf >. Phops)

Social security is the protection that a society provides to individuals and households to ensure access to health care and to guarantee income security, particularly in cases of old age, unemployment, sickness, invalidity, work injury, maternity or loss of a breadwinner. Social security protection is clearly defined in ILO conventions and UN instruments as a basic human right – albeit one that a small proportion of the people on our planet actually enjoy. Broadly defined as a system of contribution based health, pension and unemployment protection, along with tax-financed social benefits, social security has become a universal challenge in a globalizing world.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Social security

Social Security is a proper noun that refers to the program within the Social Security Act

Capitalize My Title 10-3-2020. ( Capitalize My Title. "Is "Social Security" Capitalized?." . Web. 10-3-2020. accessed 6-28-2023. &lt; https://capitalizemytitle.com/ufaqs/is-social-security-capitalized/ &gt;. Phops)

Is “Social Security” Capitalized? To find out when the context calls for upper case letters to be used, let’s consider some capitalization rules in English writing that apply to this scenario. First of all, it is quite obvious to most, that each new sentence should begin with a capital, The same rule applies to proper nouns, such as personal and organization names. They also should always be written starting with an upper case letter. Considering these rules it’s simple to see, that if starting a sentence with the phrase “social security”, the “s” in “social” should always be capitalized. What about the word “security” then? All depends on the context. If the phrase is used to describe a certain government program (even in the middle of a sentence), like the Social Security Act, with “Social Security” being the name of said program, then both the “s” letters should be upper case, as it is, in this context, a proper noun. However, if talking about social security nets in general, this is no longer a formal program name. Since no longer a name, or no longer a proper noun, it is in this context correct, to write the phrase with lower case letters. So yes, the phrase “Social Security” should be capitalized.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Federal Jobs Guarantee

TVA – Community job banks

Pavlina R. Tcherneva, April 2018, “The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” Levy Economics Institute, , accessed 5/25/23, mw

3. Preparedness Response: Community Jobs Banks The proposal here is to design the program as a comprehensive preparedness response. A period of planning will be required to design community job banks—these will warehouse the “on-theshelf” jobs that can be supplied to the jobless on short notice. For this purpose, the planning period will include soliciting and identifying project-executing organizations that would serve as providers for those job opportunities. Designing the JG as a preparedness response can be modeled after the Center for Disease Control’s (CDC) Strategic National Stockpile (SNS)—the nation’s largest stockpile of essential pharmaceuticals and medical supplies in case of emergencies. The SNS is designed as a supplement to local preparedness efforts. As the CDC website explains: “When state, local, tribal, and territorial responders request federal assistance to support their response efforts, the stockpile ensures that medicine and supplies get to those who need them most during an emergency. Organized for scalable response to a variety of public health threats, the repository contains enough supplies to respond to multiple large-scale emergencies, simultaneously.” To be able to respond adequately to public health threats, the government maintains warehouses throughout the United States that can distribute vaccines, medication, and other supplies to the local areas in the event of emergencies. Similarly the JG can be designed as a detailed local preparedness response to joblessness, using some of the existing institutional infrastructure (more below). The job guarantee will maintain a repository of jobs and places of work—via the Community Jobs Banks—that can quickly accommodate new entrants into the program and let them go without disruption should they find alternative employment. The ability to absorb or shed employees is not a unique challenge for the JG. Indeed every labor market segment within the private, nonprofit, or public sectors deals with new entrants and job leavers on an ongoing basis. Furthermore, the creation of jobs relatively quickly need not be a tall task either. Experience has shown that large-scale employment programs can be up and running in a matter of a few months (e.g., the New Deal programs in the United States and Argentina’s Plan Jefes). Such programs, however, have often been implemented as emergency measures. If the JG is designed as a preparedness response, a lengthier period of assessment, design, and planning is needed for its long-run success. Once such a program is in place, finding work for any additional entrants is a much easier task by comparison. A fair amount of experimentation may be needed initially, as well as continual evaluation to improve program performance over the long run.

2023 SDI Topicality
MSDI – Topicality › Topic Terms › Federal Jobs Guarantee

underemployment is core concern of FJG

Pavlina R. Tcherneva, April 2018, “The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” Levy Economics Institute, , accessed 5/25/23, mw

For the purposes of this paper full employment is defined as a situation where any person of

legal working age who wants to work is able to obtain employment at a living wage and decent