2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › Uniqueness – BioPharma collapsing now
Deloitte pharma study: Drop-off in returns on R&D investments – sharp decline in peak sales per asset Zurich/Geneva, 23 January 2023 https://www2.deloitte.com/ch/en/pages/press-releases/articles/deloitte-pharma-study-drop-off-in-returns-on-r-and-d-investments-sharp-decline-in-peak-sales-per-asset.html
The projected return on investment of the global pharmaceutical industry was down significantly from last year. This was revealed by Deloitte’s annual analysis of 20 of the world’s leading pharmaceutical companies. The average expected return on investment for research and development fell from 6.8 per cent in 2021 to just 1.2 per cent in 2022. The study also showed that forecast peak sales per asset declined by a quarter to around $389 million. The development process for new drugs must therefore be transformed and could be made much more efficient with digital technologies. In addition, Switzerland as a pharma location urgently needs clarity over its relationships with Europe, as well as a roadmap for digitising the health care system. Since 2010, the has been measuring the that the biggest life sciences and biotech companies can expect from assets in late-stage development. For each study, Deloitte analyses a cohort of the top global pharmaceutical companies by R&D spend. The 20 companies in the latest study include the two Swiss giants Novartis and Roche. The complete study , including informative graphs, can be found on the website.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › Uniqueness – BioPharma collapsing now
The Pharma Letter, April 20 2023 Top 20 big pharma saw 3.4% market cap decline in Q1https://www.thepharmaletter.com/article/top-20-big-pharma-saw-3-4-market-cap-decline-in-q1
The world’s top 20 biopharma companies reported a drop in their combined market capitalization by 3.4% from $3.61 trillion at the end of 2022, to $3.49 trillion after the first three months of 2023. GlobalData, the data and analytics company, has crunched the numbers and analyzed the findings, which it attributes to the challenging current macroeconomic environment of high inflation and increasing capital costs. A decrease in market capitalization was indicated for 12 of the top 20 players from the end of one quarter to the next, GlobalData found. The other eight did experience growth, with Germany’s Bayer (BAYN: DE) reporting the healthiest rise at more than 23%, followed by Danish drugmaker Novo Nordisk (NOV: N), which saw an 18% jump.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › Uniqueness – BioPharma collapsing now
Michael Erman and Patrick Wingrove February 6, 2023 2:25 PM CSTUpdated 5 months ago Drug companies face COVID cliff in 2023 as sales set to plummet https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/drug-companies-face-covid-cliff-2023-sales-set-plummet-2023-02-06/
NEW YORK, Feb 6 (Reuters) - Pharmaceutical companies that made billions from the pandemic over the past two years selling vaccines and treatments are now up against a steep COVID cliff and investor pressure to spend their windfalls wisely. Western drugmakers including Pfizer Inc , BioNTech SE , Moderna Inc , Gilead Sciences Inc , AstraZeneca Plc and Merck & Co are estimated to have brought in about $100 billion in revenue from . Company and analyst estimates suggest those sales could fall by nearly two-thirds this year due to built up product inventories around the world including in the countries that pay the most. Population immunity from high rates of vaccination and previous infections means that demand for treatments could dip as well. These companies are used to steep revenue drops known as patent cliffs that occur when their exclusivities on big-selling drugs expire and generic rivals move in, but they strategize for those swings for years. "When you think about traditional drug and vaccine development and longevity of sales, it's usually much more spread out," Morningstar analyst Damien Conover said. "This is very, very concentrated." The sudden inflow of revenue should prod companies to strike deals and link up with new partners, he said. BMO Capital Markets analyst Evan Seigerman said companies should use the quick cash for transformative deals. "Pfizer did these $10 billion deals to build their portfolio and I think they need to do something bigger and more impactful," he said, referring to the $5.4 billion of Global Blood Therapeutics and $11.6 billion of migraine drugmaker Biohaven Pharmaceutical.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Cap K
BENJAMIN Y. FONG and CHRISTIE OFFENBACHER Medicare for All Is a Strategy 11.06.2019 https://jacobin.com/2019/11/medicare-for-all-strategy-priority-single-payer-bernie-sanders
Once in place, a Medicare for All system will be all the evidence we need to convince millions of people in America that democratic socialist politics is not only possible but also materially beneficial. If you think Medicare for All is , just wait until it actually exists. This is not to say there will not be problems: if the rollout of the Obamacare exchanges was any indication, there will likely be many technical problems involved in the creation of a new government program. In addition, it is certainly possible that the excellent bills currently in the House and Senate (H.R. 1384 and S. 1129) will be watered down in certain ways, perhaps by eliminating the costly coverage of long-term care or introducing some cost-sharing measures. And though our enemies are unlikely to have the political will to undermine and underfund the new system at the moment of its creation — since too many players will have a stake in its success — every socialized program can be slowly whittled down to dysfunction by conservatives over time, as illustrated in . (It should be noted, though, that the NHS is still very popular with the British public.) In all these ways, Medicare for All might not be everything we want it to be. But here’s the thing: given the truly epic irrationality of the current health-care system, even a less than ideal single-payer system is likely to be a massive political success. This is one of the specific under which we must understand Medicare for All to “make history”: no other industrialized country’s economy is being bled dry by health-care costs in the same way as the United States’, and even an imperfect Medicare for All, by attacking the root of the problem (for-profit health insurance), is going to be remarkably successful for a remarkably high percentage of people. If single-payer health care was met with mass approval in other countries in the postwar period, for an American today, it’ll be like stumbling upon an oasis in the desert.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Cap K
BENJAMIN Y. FONG and CHRISTIE OFFENBACHER Medicare for All Is a Strategy 11.06.2019 https://jacobin.com/2019/11/medicare-for-all-strategy-priority-single-payer-bernie-sanders
We won’t rehearse the familiar points about Medicare for All: it’s good, it’s needed, it’s what the people want — the hard way. But Medicare for All is more than just a matter of fixing our broken health-care system. And it’s more than just a good policy. It’s the perfect fight to pick with our ruling class — one that can unlock the power of a mass, working-class movement in the United States. We don’t believe this because we think health care is somehow naturally more important than other issues. On moral grounds, it’s hard to find an injustice more tragic than migrant detention camps, and we could be convinced that any number of causes are more morally urgent than Medicare for All. On scientific grounds, the imminent threat of climate disaster is surely the most pressing issue, not just for the Left but for humanity as a whole. But on political grounds, if we want to take the nascent left renaissance in America and turn it into a durable, working-class movement in the 2020s — a precondition for addressing more morally and more scientifically urgent issues of the day — the fight for Medicare for All must be at the very top of the Left’s priorities. Despite modest growth in the wake of Bernie Sanders’s 2016 primary run, in terms of its political power and, not uncoincidentally, in relative isolation from the working-class people, institutions, and culture it would need to win real power and influence on the national political stage. Forget our ambivalence about class centrality: what really matters right now is our lack of class rootedness. The central question at present must be: How do we anchor our politics in the lives of working people and institutions? The unmoored left does not get to decide what issues should be prioritized based on its own determination of moral or objective exigency. Rather, we must construct our strategy on the basis of a political analysis of the contemporary situation, considering first and foremost what will attract millions of people to the American left in a concrete and material way. And for that, we believe that there is no better fight than the one for Medicare for All.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Cap K
BENJAMIN Y. FONG and CHRISTIE OFFENBACHER Medicare for All Is a Strategy 11.06.2019 https://jacobin.com/2019/11/medicare-for-all-strategy-priority-single-payer-bernie-sanders
As far as “non-reformist” or “transformative” reforms go, Medicare for All is the closest the American left has to a sure thing. We’ve seen it work elsewhere, and the historical brokenness of the American health-care system perversely assures its success and subsequent popularity. Compare this, for a moment, with another transformative demand that has captured the attention of the Left: the Green New Deal. Though Medicare for All and the Green New Deal are often mentioned in the same breath as key planks of a democratic socialist platform, they are in fact quite different in several key respects. While the Green New Deal is a relatively new and expansive set of related policy proposals (sometimes including Medicare for All) and thus far mostly aspirational, Medicare for All is a specific policy that exists in the form of excellent pieces of comprehensive legislation, including a House bill that is now cosponsored by a majority of Democratic representatives (more on this in a moment). But more important for our present purpose, the Green New Deal, as opposed to Medicare for All, is going to require massive state experimentation, including investing in some programs that could well be huge flops. This is perfectly fine — in fact, it’s what the state — and some failures must be expected. After all, humans have never averted anthropogenic climate disaster before. Climate scientists know what we need to do in terms of decarbonization, but no one can know ahead of time the exact blend of policies and programs that will get us there. Heterodox economists sometimes think that once we reimagine the state, it can just do the dynamic and “entrepreneurial” things they want it to. But they forget that state experimentation must be supported, or at least tolerated, by the electorate. Where are we going to get the political will to accomplish something as far-ranging and experimental as the Green New Deal? It bears repeating: people will be won to left policies if we can show that they make their lives noticeably better. A dramatic win like Medicare for All would establish the trust and durable support — support reinforced on a daily basis in concrete, material ways — of millions of people, which would give us the credibility to move forward with riskier but nonetheless extremely urgent and necessary reforms. In other words, the surest path to a Green New Deal runs through Medicare for All. To be clear, Medicare for All will not by itself lead to an efflorescence of political participation; in fact, as a program that operates most efficiently when centralized on the largest scale possible, Medicare for All does not, by definition, offer opportunities for local community building and engagement. But we are not currently suffering from a lack of opportunities for political participation. What we are suffering from is a broader political malaise, where most people remain unconvinced that “politics” signifies anything more than tawdry posturing in an arena distant from their everyday lives. Medicare for All will change their minds, and not in the abstract: it will demonstrate that politics can be about me, my family, and my friends, but without being a zero-sum game. It will open the door to a broader transformation of society and keep that door propped open with near daily reminders of why democratic socialist politics is in the direct self-interest of the vast majority of people.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- States CP
Seth Giertz and Mehmet Tosun December 2012. Seth Giertz: Associate Professor in the Department of Economics at the University of Nebraska Lincoln. Mehmet Tosun: Professor at the University of Nevada, Reno. “Migration elasticities, fiscal federalism, and the ability of states to redistribute income.” National Tax Journal https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1084&context=econfacpub
For several decades, the dominant view among economists was that the ability of state governments to redistribute income is limited, and thus redistribution should be left primarily to the federal government. This view was well articulated by Richard Musgrave (1971, p. 7): “Policies to adjust the distribution of income among individuals must be conducted on a nationwide basis … Regional measures are self-defeating, as the rich will leave and the poor will move to the more egalitarian-minded jurisdictions. Progressive income taxation at the upper as well as transfers at the lower end of the scale — if substantial in scope — must be uniform within the entire area over which there is a high degree of capital and labor mobility, which means they have to be a function of the national government” (Musgrave, 1971, p.7).
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- States CP
Anshu Siripurapu & Jonathan Masters, March 19, 2021. Anshu Siripurapu: works in economics, energy, and geopolitics, helps edit the Daily News Brief, and holds a BA in political economy from University of Southern California. Jonathan Masters: BA in political science from Emory, MA in social theory from the New School. “How COVID-19 Is Harming State and City Budgets.” March 19, 2021. https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/how-covid-19-harming-state-and-city-budgets
States ended the 2020 fiscal year in better shape than was initially forecast because of hundreds of billions of dollars in federal aid and the unusual nature of the pandemic recession. Low-wage earners in the service industries, who pay less in taxes, were devastated by job losses, while the stock market boomed and high-wage workers were relatively unscathed. But states were still projected to see huge shortfalls in the years ahead, even before the surge of COVID-19 cases in late 2020. The situation varies significantly across states, depending on the structure of their economies and their prepandemic fiscal health: for example, California has seen record revenues, fueled by the stock market and income gains among its wealthiest residents. But the majority of states have seen tax revenues shrink, according to an analysis by the Washington Post; five states, including Alaska and Florida, suffered double-digit percentage declines. Tax revenues have fallen sharply as states faced record unemployment claims and rising public health costs. Though the economy is slowly adding jobs, nearly ten million of them have been lost since the pandemic began, with restaurants and hotels among the hardest-hit businesses. As people lose jobs, more qualify for Medicaid, the costs for which are shared by states and the federal government. Moreover, in the first quarter of 2020, state pension funding levels fell to their lowest point in three decades, as the pandemic caused the value of pension fund assets to plummet. Though the stock market later recovered, there are still concerns about its performance, as well as the effect of low interest rates from bonds on pension funds.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- States CP
Studebaker ’17 (Benjamin Studebaker – PhD candidate in Politics and International Studies @ the University of Cambridge, MA @ the University of Chicago, “Why Single Payer Works Better at the National Level than the State Level,” 2 June 2017, https://benjaminstudebaker.com/2017/06/02/why-single-payer-works-better-at-the-national-level-than-the-state-level/)
A federal single payer program covers the entire healthcare sector, so it’s a true monopoly. What goes wrong when a single state tries to do single payer? Well, a single US state has problems in both these areas. Many individual US states have balanced budget amendments, preventing them from borrowing large amounts of money to facilitate a gradual transition. Even the ones that don’t have balanced budget amendments would struggle to get access to the kind of credit available to the federal government. And crucially, individual US states cannot exercise a true monopoly on demand. If one state tries to slash healthcare spending significantly, its best doctors can simply run to neighboring states, producing doctor shortages and reducing quality of care. This makes individual states afraid to use the cost-cutting leverage which single payer gives them. If they don’t use the cost-cutting leverage and don’t borrow money, they have to raise taxes high enough to cover healthcare spending which will support a national spending figure of 17% of GDP. This means that they end up raising much more tax revenue than the Europeans do to continue propping up a healthcare sector which is too big to fail. This prevents citizens from getting the healthcare relief we promise them–their premiums disappear, but their taxes rise too much for them to get the full benefits of single payer. In the long-run, people are unlikely to continue to support that kind of system, and when they give up on it the right will attempt to use the failure as evidence in national debates about single payer, even though the policy is much more workable at the federal level. There is no other rich democracy American doctors can emigrate to which will pay them the extraordinarily bloated wages they receive in the United States. For the feds, it’s simply a question of whether they prefer to borrow a lot of money facilitating a gradual transition or to profoundly disrupt the healthcare sector to save Americans huge amounts of money very quickly. In sum, the hardest thing about single payer is the fact that it’s replacing a system that has accustomed millions of people who work in the healthcare sector to unrealistic and unsustainable levels of compensation. If we cut their pay to reduce costs and give them somewhere to run, they’ll run. If we cut their pay very quickly, we’ll produce a significant increase in unemployment and disrupt many people’s lives. If we cut their pay gradually, we need to be able to borrow money in the short-term to avoid raising taxes too much. The federal government has the resources and the potential market power to get these things done. The states don’t. It’s hard to wrap our heads around just how wasteful our healthcare system is. It’s a problem that is far too big for any one state to handle. We need the feds–without them, we risk handing the right undeserved propaganda coups, enabling the private system to go on flushing our hard earned money down the drain.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- States CP
MAR. 9, 2022, AT 6:00 AM More States Are Proposing Single-Payer Health Care. Why Aren’t They Succeeding? https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/more-states-are-proposing-single-payer-health-care-why-arent-they-succeeding/
Health care policy researchers Erin C. Fuse Brown and Elizabeth McCuskey introduced in state legislatures across the country from 2010 to 2019, finding a sharp uptick in bills introduced since 2017. During each of those three years, at least 10 single-payer proposals were introduced, according to Brown and McCuskey’s research, for the first time since 2013. In total, state legislators proposed more single-payer bills from 2017 to 2019 than in the previous seven years combined. And for 2021, we’ve identified 10 single-payer bills that legislators introduced across the country, from liberal states like and to more conservative ones including and . What do all these proposals have in common? They’ve all universally failed. In fact, Vermont, the only state that managed to pass single-payer health care in 2011, ended up . It makes sense why single-payer advocates have tried to take these fights to the states. States have traditionally been seen as the “,” and some advocates of single-payer health care have argued that liberal states to advance single-payer health care. But as I’ll explain, passing single-payer health care at the state level is next to impossible, as states are particularly limited in how they can allocate federal and private health care funds. There is, however, evidence that Americans may have an appetite for a public option, or government-run health insurance that people can opt into at the state level. (Colorado, Nevada and Washington) have already passed a public option. It’s not single-payer health care reform, but it’s possible that we might see more states adopt their own public-option reforms. One big reason single-payer proposals haven’t caught on at the state level is because finding a reliable way to pay for such a program is challenging. Single-payer advocates originally envisioned a federal proposal that would cover all Americans under of a preexisting program — that is, Medicare, but now for all. Doing this state-by-state would require each state to divert federal funds used for Medicare, Medicaid and Affordable Care Act exchanges to be used for their own single-payer plans. And that’s tricky because the Department of Health and Human Services has wide discretion to approve or deny states’ requests, which makes any proposal highly dependent on the national political climate. This isn’t just a theoretical debate either: Trump’s administrator for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Seema Verma said in 2018 that she would , while Biden’s Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra . Almost all single-payer proposals depend on these waivers and states don’t often have fallback plans for if this federal funding gets denied. Employer-sponsored health insurance plans, which , are another hurdle for states trying to pass single-payer health care. Federal law employer-provided health insurance, so states can’t just stop employers from offering their own health care benefits. The exact scope of this law has been , but suffice it to say that it’s successfully put the kibosh on many statewide health care reforms. Single-payer health insurance is particularly tricky as there’s no way to get everyone onto the plan without first changing how private insurance works. States have tried to address this through measures like increasing payroll taxes or restricting providers’ ability to accept reimbursement from private insurance plans. But the more elaborate these mechanisms get, the more complicated it becomes to implement — and the more people that could slip through the cracks. Finally, another big financial barrier is that state governments to increase budgetary spending. That means tax increases, which come with their own political challenges, are often necessary for states to secure the funding they need.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Politics
Robert Schwaninger Aug. 29, 2022 Medicare for all is gaining approval https://www.thetelegraph.com/opinion/article/Medicare-for-all-is-gaining-approval-17400887.php
The Democratic effort to establish Medicare for all is gaining greater approval each year, while 26 million Americans still do not have health insurance. Families that rely on Social Security are barely getting by, but Republicans want to lower benefits. And many elderly cannot afford assisted living in states with Republican legislators that refuse to expand Medicaid. Meanwhile, the Biden Administration is making available hearing aids without a prescription, lowering the cost and making these overpriced devices available to millions more Americans of every age.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Politics
Eric Levitz, features writer for Intelligencer who covers politics and economics AUG. 24, 2018 The Left Has Sold Americans on Single Payer. But Can It Get Them to Pay for Installation? https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/08/new-poll-majority-of-gop-voters-support-medicare-for-all.html
The American people want big government to get its hands on their health care. Over the past two years, polls have consistently found to cutting federal health-care spending and A majority of Republican voters believe that Paul Ryan should leave and alone — while Uncle Sam should “.” The ideological debate over whether every American is entitled to basic medical care, regardless of their ability to pay for it, is over. The Affordable Care Act succeeded in — while the law’s failure to arrest the has fueled public demand for further government intervention to secure that right. On Thursday, released a poll that shows (what I believe to be) an unprecedented level of support for Medicare for All, the American left’s brand-name for a single-payer, national health-insurance plan. The survey found a whopping 70 percent support for the proposal, with 84.5 percent of Democrats — and 51 percent of Republicans — voicing their approval. Bottom of Form For the moment, this poll is an outlier (Medicare for All tends to poll well, but not this well). And there’s reason to think that the aberrantly high level of support it shows for socialized health insurance is a reflection of how nondescript the wording of Reuters’ question was; voters were asked whether they would support “a policy of Medicare for All,” but were not provided with any concrete definition of what that policy would entail. By contrast, from the Kaiser Family Foundation asked voters “Do you favor or oppose having a national health plan, or Medicare for All, in which all Americans would get their insurance from a single government plan?” and found “only” 59 percent of respondents expressing support. Meanwhile, when Kaiser defined Medicare for All as a national health-insurance plan that is “open to anyone who wants it but people who currently have other coverage could keep what they have,” 75 percent of respondents endorsed the proposal — including 64 percent of Republican voters.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC ---Politics
Jonathan Oberlander BOOK REVIEW| JUNE 01 2023 Medicare for All—Running Down a Dream J Health Polit Policy Law (2023) 48 (3): 435–450. https://doi.org/10.1215/03616878-10358752 https://read.dukeupress.edu/jhppl/article/48/3/435/320433/Medicare-for-All-Running-Down-a-Dream
In the 2020 Democratic presidential primary, Sanders again ran on a Medicare for All platform. This time he was not alone, as Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) proposed her own Medicare for All plan. So too did Senator (and soon-to-be Vice President) Kamala Harris (D-CA), whose conception of Medicare for All maintained, in contrast to other plans, a substantial role for private insurance. Sanders again lost the Democratic presidential nomination to Joe Biden, who supported more modest reform approaches. Yet the substantial media attention to Medicare for All and its endorsement by establishment politicians appeared to mark a shift in US health politics. The idea of replacing America's health insurance maze with one federal government plan enjoyed more prominence in 2020 than at any point since the early 1970s. After decades of presuming that health reform had to preserve private insurance, a growing number of politicians were now embracing the idea of sidelining private coverage in favor of a vastly expanded government role.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC --- Federalism
Erin Ryan 11, Associate Professor, William & Mary Law School, J.D. Harvard Law School, M.A. Wesleyan University, B.A. Harvard University, “Negotiating Federalism,” Boston College Law Review, 52(1), 2011, https://www.bc.edu/content/dam/files/schools/law/bclawreview/pdf/52_1/01_ryan.pdf
Opponents of Congress’s 2010 Medicaid expansion decried the move as a “gross federal overreach,”1 invoking familiar tropes about the bitter contest between state and federal authority in contexts of jurisdictional overlap. But state and federal regulators in the trenches of health care law know that the truth is more nuanced—that the Medicaid program really represents a site of extensive negotiation between state and federal actors about the specifics of each state plan, set within purposefully broad federal boundaries.2 Those who opposed the 2009 Stimulus Bill on federalism grounds3 similarly discounted the substantial role of state actors in negotiating the terms of the federal law.4 And those who challenged the Clean Water Act’s stormwater regulations on federalism grounds missed the pivotal role state and municipal actors played in negotiating the terms of the rule—which itself became a forum for ongoing negotiation between state and federal regulators about how each municipality would ultimately comply.5 Such instances of intergovernmental bargaining offer a means of understanding the relationship between state and federal power that differs from the stylized model of zero-sum federalism dominating political discourse, which emphasizes winner-takes-all jurisdictional competition.6 Contemporary judicial doctrine presents a similarly wooden view of sovereign antagonism within American federalism.7 But countless real-world examples show that the boundary between state and federal authority is actually negotiated on scales large and small, and on a continual basis. Working in a dizzying array of regulatory contexts, state and federal actors negotiate over both the allocation of policymaking authority and the substantive terms of the mandates policymaking will impose. Bargaining takes place both in realms plagued by legal uncertainty about whose jurisdiction trumps, and in realms unsettled by uncertainty over whose decision should trump, regardless of legal supremacy. Reconceptualizing the relationship between state and federal power as one heavily mediated by negotiation demonstrates how federalism practice departs from the rhetoric, and offers hope for moving beyond the paralyzing [misleading] features of the zero-sum discourse. This Article explores the role of state-federal bargaining in areas of concurrent regulatory jurisdiction, where both state and federal actors hold legitimate regulatory interests or obligations.8 Even as jurists remain mired in debate over how to resolve regulatory competition, regulators working in contested contexts have learned to confront this uncertainty simply by negotiating through it. Working directly or indirectly with counterparts across state-federal lines, regulators reach consensus about sharing or dividing contested authority (and how to implement it) in order to move forward with needed governance. When they do so in processes consistent with the principles of fair bargaining and federalism, they are negotiating the answer to federalism’s most critical question in a manner that vindicates constitutional goals. Indeed, they are interpreting federalism. In the face of persistent uncertainty about the boundaries between state and federal reach, the Article demonstrates how government actors move forward by substituting procedural consensus for substantive clarity about the central federalism inquiry—who gets to decide?—in individual regulatory contexts. Procedural consistency with fair bargaining and federalism principles yields instances in which the very process of intergovernmental bargaining proves more able to preserve constitutional values than judicial or legislative decisions alone. Recognizing how intergovernmental bargaining supplements these more conventionally understood means of allocating authority provides a new lens for understanding the uniquely collaborative process of American governance. Using the negotiation theorist’s definition, the Article broadly understands bargaining as “an iterative process of joint decision-making,”9 encompassing conventional political haggling (as over the terms of the Stimulus Bill), formalized methods of collaborative policymaking (as in the Medicaid partnership), and even more remote signaling processes by which state and federal actors share responsibility for public decision making over time (as they have over medical marijuana enforcement). I use the word “substantive” to refer to the substance of a legal rule or negotiated outcome, and “procedural” to refer to the process by which that rule or outcome was reached. Because “state-federal intergovernmental bargaining” is a mouthful, I use the term “federalism bargaining” to refer collectively to the forums in which state and federal actors engage in these processes of joint decision making, focusing on the vertical federalism relationship within each given array of state and federal participants.10 Given the foundational role that negotiated federalism plays in the American system of dual sovereignty, academics would be wise to better understand it: where and how it happens, what works well and what does not, and what legal constraints should apply. Most importantly, we should understand how procedural tools within negotiated governance can assist the navigation of difficult federalism terrain that other means of interpretation have failed to clarify. Incorporating general bargaining principles of mutual consent and the procedural application of core federalism values, negotiated governance opens possibilities for filling interpretive gaps in the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence or congressional legislation. This Article thus moves beyond the historic debate about the unilateral roles of the Court, Congress, and the Executive in protecting federalism11 and provides the first recognition that bilateral federalism bargaining is itself a means of interpreting the Constitution. When the procedural criteria are met, intergovernmental bargaining enables a partnership of state and federal actors to interpret constitutional directives bilaterally, through negotiated exchange across the state-federal divide. Part I situates the inquiry within the iconic federalism discourse about which branch can best safeguard American federalism: Congress, through political safeguards; the Court, by judicially enforceable constraints; or the Executive, through administrative process.12 Views have vacillated over whether Congress or the Supreme Court should be the final arbiter of compliance with federalism directives, and more recent scholarship addresses the positive and negative contributions of administrative agencies.13 These arguments, however, focus exclusively on unilateral branch activity, eliding the important ways that public actors work bilaterally across state-federal lines to safeguard federalism by negotiating the terms of governance with important federalism implications.14 Federalism scholars have neglected the significance of negotiated federalism, which presents on a continuum from the obvious to the subtle, because it has never before been surveyed. To remedy this gap, Part II offers the first theoretical framework for cataloguing this uncharted landscape in a taxonomy of the opportunities for state-federal bargaining available within various constitutional and statutory frameworks.15 Highlighting categories of conventional bargaining, negotiations to reallocate authority, and joint policymaking bargaining, the taxonomy reviews familiar forms of negotiation used in lawmaking (such as the Stimulus), negotiations over various kinds of law enforcement (such as immigration or pollution), negotiations under the federal spending power (such as the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001), and negotiations for exceptions under otherwise applicable laws (such as the Endangered Species Act).16 It then considers the more interesting, less obvious forms of negotiated policymaking, including negotiated federal rulemaking with state stakeholders (as was used to regulate stormwater pollution), federal statutes that share policy design with states (such as Medicaid), staggered programs of iterative shared policymaking (as used to regulate auto emissions), and intersystemic signaling negotiations, by which independently operating state and federal actors trade influence over the direction of evolving interjurisdictional policies (as reflected in medical marijuana enforcement).17 The taxonomy demonstrates how federalism bargaining permeates American governance, from familiar examples under the spending power to the subtler forms that have previously escaped scholarly notice as forms of negotiation at all. In fleshing out these details, one normative purpose of the piece is simply to call attention to how much federalism-sensitive governance is already negotiated, belying the zero-sum discourse. This should not be surprising, given the negotiation features built into the very structure of American government. The bicameral nature of the legislature, the presidential veto, and even the subtle invitation to iterative policymaking afforded by judicial review—prompting Congress to try again to meet constitutional muster, or signaling the concerns future legislators must heed18—all speak to the way American governance is, by design, an iterative process of joint decision making. Indeed, the interest group representation model of democratic governance itself anticipates how lawmaking will reflect the results of bargaining between competing interest groups.19 But even beyond these features of the American system (and in contrast to the more privately bargained-for governance advocated by the New Governance movement),20 it is striking how much federalism-implicating governance is accomplished bilaterally, whether by conventional or dialogic processes. Examples are especially prevalent in environmental law, where jurisdictional overlap is particularly acute and where the federalism discourse is most driven to extremes.21
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Inflation
Robert H. Frank 7-7-2017. (Robert H. Frank is an economics professor at the Johnson Graduate School of Management at Cornell University. Follow him on Twitter at @econnaturalist., Robert H. Frank. "Why Single-Payer Health Care Saves Money." The New York Times Company. Web. 7-7-2017. accessed 9-7-2017. < https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/07/07/upshot/why-single-payer-health-care-saves-money.html?_r=0 >. Phops)
Total costs are lower under single-payer systems for several reasons. One is that administrative costs average only about 2 percent of total expenses under a single-payer program like Medicare, less than one-sixth the corresponding percentage for many private insurers. Single-payer systems also spend virtually nothing on competitive advertising, which can account for more than 15 percent of total expenses for private insurers. The most important source of cost savings under single-payer is that large government entities are able to negotiate much more favorable terms with service providers. In 2012, for example, the average cost of coronary bypass surgery was more than $73,000 in the United States but less than $23,000 in France. Despite this evidence, respected commentators continue to cite costs as a reason to doubt that single-payer can succeed in the United States. A recent Washington Post editorial, for example, ominously predicted that budget realities would dampen enthusiasm for single-payer, noting that the per capita expenditures under existing single-payer programs in the United States were much higher than those in other countries. But this comparison is misleading. In most other countries, single-payer covers the whole population, most of which has only minimal health needs. In contrast, single-payer components of the United States system disproportionately cover population subgroups with the heaviest medical needs: older people (Medicare), the poor and disabled (Medicaid) and returned service personnel (Department of Veterans Affairs). In short, the evidence is clear that single-payer delivers quality care at significantly lower cost than the current American hybrid system. It thus makes no sense to reject single-payer on the grounds that it would require higher tax revenues. That’s true, of course, but it’s an irrelevant objection.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Inflation
ELIZABETH NAPOLITANO UPDATED ON: APRIL 17, 2023 / 11:51 AM / MONEYWATCH Health care now tops inflation among Americans' concerns, survey shows moneywatch .
Inflation is no longer Americans' No. 1 concern. Nowadays, it's the price of health care that's making Americans sweat. Health care costs are the top concern among middle-income American households for the first time since 2021, outpacing inflation, according to a national survey from financial service provider Primerica. While more than half of survey respondents said that they remain pessimistic about the economy as a whole, 20% expressed being "slightly more optimistic" about their personal finances compared with just 15% of respondents in the previous quarter. "As the nation heads further into 2023, middle-income Americans are showing increasing confidence in their personal finances while remaining realistic about the current economic climate," Primerica CEO Glenn J. Williams said in a press release. Primerica's "Middle-Income Financial Security Monitor" collects data from American households with annual incomes between $30,000 and $100,000 on a quarterly basis. The national poll, conducted by research firm Change Research, surveyed 1,471 respondents about their households' financial health between March 6 and 10.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Business Confidence
Cathy Schoen February 2, 2016 [Senior Scholar in Residence at the New York Academy of Medicine. She is the former executive director of the Commonwealth Fund Council of Economic Advisors and former senior vice president for Policy, Research, and Evaluation at The Commonwealth Fund, as well as the former research director of the Fund’s Commission on a High Performance Health System.] “The Affordable Care Act and the U.S. Economy” The Commonwealth Fund http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/files/publications/fund-report/2016/feb/1860_schoen_aca_and_us_economy_v2.pdf?la=en
Although the number of people working full-time has risen well above pre-recession levels, there has been little improvement in average weekly pay or income for working families. Average wages in the private sector have barely kept up with inflation over the past five years. More recently, inflation-adjusted pay has picked up—with a one-year gain of 2.1 percent through October 2015—but this likely reflects lower energy costs for consumers (Exhibit 9).7 With no significant increases in wages for the majority of the nation’s workforce, particularly middle- and low-wage employees, there has been little or no improvement in median incomes since 2010.8,9 This represents a continuation of a longer-term pattern that began well before the recession. By 2007, before the recession hit, median income adjusted for inflation was below the level in 1999.10 Even in relatively tight labor markets, median incomes have for two decades failed to keep up with inflation. The gains from economic growth have instead accrued mainly to the top 5 percent of the income distribution.11 By 2015, a spreading movement to increase the minimum wage has started to raise the wage floor in labor markets. Reflecting this and perceived mounting upward pressures on wages, the CBO, among other forecasters, predicts that wages will pick up in future years as employers compete for new workers.12 HEALTH CARE COSTS: SLOWDOWN IN GROWTH EXTENDS TO A FIFTH YEAR A key goal of the Affordable Care Act is to slow growth in the costs of health care while enhancing access and health outcomes. With abundant evidence of waste and inefficiency throughout the U.S. health system, the ACA’s framers looked to incentivize providers and payers to achieve better health outcomes at lower cost.13 Lower cost inflation would reduce the federal government’s costs for Medicare and the insurance expansion, make private insurance more affordable, and free up private and public resources for other needs. Critics worried, however, that ACA’s tools for addressing cost were relatively weak and that setting standards for health insurance benefits might increase the cost of coverage. Contrary to critics’ fears, the slowdown in health care spending that began during the recession, before passage of the ACA, has continued well into the economic recovery. As illustrated by Exhibit 10, growth in national health expenditures slowed to the rate of overall economic growth for four years, from 2009–10 through 2013–14. This represents a break from the pattern seen when the economy has emerged from past recessions. Indeed, the slower pace of private as well as Medicare spending through 2014 has led to multiple revisions of the CBO’s federal budget projections. As employers have spent more on jobs and less on health benefits than initially forecast, and as Medicare and insurance expansion costs have come in lower than expected, the CBO has revised upward its federal revenue projections and lowered its projections of federal health care spending. This in turn has led to downward revisions of projected federal deficits (March 2015 and August 2015). Of special significance is the reduction in Medicare spending per beneficiary, which is now below the rate of inflation. According to the CBO’s most recently revised projection, Medicare spending by 2020 will be $186 billion below the level projected in January 2010, for a 10-year cumulative savings of $1 trillion (Exhibit 11). And because actual Medicare costs through 2014 came in well below 2013 projections, the CBO also recently revised downward its 10-year federal spending projection for 2015–2025.14 Spending for privately insured enrollees in marketplace plans also has slowed markedly, although growth rates per person have continued to exceed Medicare’s (Exhibit 12). This slower-than-expected growth has led the CBO in each of the past two years to lower its estimates of the federal cost of providing insurance subsidies. The slowdown has also benefited employers. Because of lower insurance cost growth in 2013 and 2014, the CBO in March 2015 revised its January 2015 10-year estimate of federal budget deficits downward by $431 billion. The agency explained that the revisions reflected increased revenues expected from taxable wage and salary growth—as employers spent less on health benefits and shifted a portion of employee compensation to salaries—as well as the decreased cost of federal marketplace subsidies.15 In August 2015, the CBO revised its 10-year deficit projection downward by another $200 billion, largely based on positive economic news.16 IMPACT OF PROVIDER PAYMENT REFORMS AND NEW INCENTIVES Analysis of the decline in health care spending growth indicates it has been driven partly by changes in the way health care is being delivered and paid for. Although it remains unclear how much of this phenomenon can be attributed to the Affordable Care Act, it seems clear that payment and delivery system changes set in motion by the ACA have made a significant contribution to lower cost growth as well as improvements in care. Among the ACA reforms that appear to be contributing to recent trends are: • A tightening of Medicare’s hospital “productivity adjustment,” which lowered the prices paid by the program. • Adjustments to Medicare’s annual updates of provider payment rates. • Lower payment rates for private Medicare Advantage plans. • Strong incentives to reduce hospital readmission rates and infections. • New payment methods for holding health care providers and systems more accountable for the quality and cost of care they provide. The ACA’s reforms targeting Medicare, including a tightening of payments to hospitals and lower excess payments to private plans participating in Medicare, have directly contributed to lower program spending. Other reforms created incentives for providers to redesign their care delivery systems. Providing evidence that tighter payment rates are not the only factor in Medicare’s lower rate of spending are the significant reductions in hospitalizations for conditions that can be treated with timely primary care and lower hospital readmisson rates. For Medicare beneficiaries, such “ambulatory care–sensitive” admissions have fallen 25 percent since 2010, continuing a decline that began prior to the ACA (Exhibit 13). Meanwhile, rates of hospital readmission within 30 days have fallen from more than 19 percent to 17 percent, after years of failing to improve.17 Tighter payments along with incentives have together contributed to the remarkable Medicare spending slowdown. Indeed, in 2012 and 2013, there was essentially no increase in spending per beneficiary (Exhibit 12). Early participants in a Medicare accountable care organization (ACO) program known as the Pioneer ACOs achieved $385 million savings for Medicare over the first two years (2012–13) relative to fee-for-servicebased medical groups, according to published analyses.18 To lower hospital readmissions for patients discharged to postacute care settings, incentives provided to ACOs, along with other targeted incentives, have led hospitals in communities around the country to select nursing homes that have a track record of lower infection rates and higher quality.19 Readmissions for medical conditions that could have been avoided with appropriate care drive up health costs and put elderly patients at risk.20 Emphasis on Primary Care Other ACA payment provisions create incentives to strengthen primary care, particularly for people with chronic illnesses and complex conditions.21 The goal is improved management of health conditions and complex prescription drug regimens, as well as prevention of complications that lead to hospital and nursing home stays. For example, Medicare and Medicaid, along with many private insurers, are promoting “patient-centered medical homes” and the use of care teams, with expanded roles for nurses and nurse aides. With these and other changes to medical care practice, the bulk of new jobs in health care delivery since 2010 has been in ambulatory care settings, not in hospitals—a reflection of longer-term shifts in care delivery22 as well as recent coverage and payment reforms (Exhibit 14). To the extent that physicians and hospitals continue to respond to the new incentives, potentially entire communities could benefit from the availability of more timely, more coordinated care and reduced acute care spending. Many state Medicaid programs are following suit and adopting similar payment and delivery system changes. With Medicaid and Medicare accounting for nearly 40 percent of total national health care spending and 43 percent of hospital spending, their policies have the potential to leverage further health system change across the country.23 Change in the Private Sector In the private sector, payers have embraced many of the same reforms the ACA has instituted in Medicare, including bundled or episode-based payments, ACOs, and enhanced payment for primary care medical homes. (The ACA, in fact, specifically encourages the private sector to join in Medicare’s payment initiatives.) Notably, private hospital use also has been in decline, a trend that has helped to moderate increases in health insurance costs.24 Indeed, studies show that reforms in the public and private health care markets have had positive spillover effects—in both directions.25,26 Also of note is the ACA’s “minimum loss ratio” requirement, which caps the portion of insurance premiums that can allocated for administrative costs and profits. The rule has yielded more than $5 billion in benefits to consumers from 2011 through 2013, either through the rebates paid by insurance companies or through reduced spending on overhead.27 In sum, the moderation in health costs growth through 2014 has benefited federal, state, and local governments, private employers, and workers and their families. Yet, as discussed later in this paper, the slowdown is unlikely to continue without further action to address the market forces that drive costs higher. POTENTIAL IMPACT OF LOWER COST GROWTH ON LABOR MARKETS AND WORKFORCE PRODUCTIVITY
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Business Confidence
Derek Thompson, 3-5-2017, "Have Americans Given Up?," Atlantic, https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/03/did-american-complacency-lead-to-trump/518586/
Americans have fallen in love with the idea of their entrepreneurial spirit. Silicon Valley seems to have replaced New York City as the country’s metropolitan mascot of dynamism. Innovation is the unofficial buzzword of corporate America, and news organizations heap praise on the zillionaire startup heroes of the Millennial generation. But this is a mirage, according to the economist and popular writer Tyler Cowen, whose new book is The Complacent Class: The Self-Defeating Quest for the American Dream. In fact, the nation's dynamism is in the dumps. Americans move less than they used to. They start fewer companies. Caught in the hypnotic undertow of TV and video games, they are less likely to go outside. Even the federal government itself has transformed from an investment vehicle, which once spent a large share of its money on infrastructure and research, to an insurance conglomerate, which spends more than half its money on health care and Social Security. A nation of risk-takers has become a nation of risk-mitigation experts. So, what happened? Cowen’s thought-provoking book emphasizes several causes, including geographic immobility, housing prices, and monopolization. First, Americans move much less than they used to, and economic mobility has declined along with geographic mobility. The share of Americans moving between states fell by more than half since 1970, from 3.5 percent per year to 1.4 percent. Moreover, as recently as the middle of the 20th century, Americans used to move toward productivity and jobs. In the 1920s, “the creation of a single automobile plant … boosted Michigan’s population by creating more than 100,000 workers,” Tim Noah wrote. But today, the most popular destinations for movers aren’t productive cities, but rather cheap sunny suburbs. This has to do with the second cause. High housing costs in the most productive metro areas have turned places like Silicon Valley and Manhattan into playgrounds for plutocrats. Tighter land-use regulations in rich metros pushed up housing values, as the Harvard economists Peter Ganong and Daniel Shoag have written. That means that lower-income families, who would benefit from living near these bustling job centers, can’t afford to move there. As a result, rich young college graduates have clustered in a handful of cities while the rest of American movers are going to sunbelt suburbs with cheap housing. Moving toward affordability has replaced moving to opportunity. Third, the growth of large companies has clearly sapped some of the dynamism from the U.S. economy. As I've reported, the decline in entrepreneurship has coincided with the rise of new monopolies—across retail, healthcare, and tech—that make it harder to start a new successful firm in these industries. Starting in the late 1970s, antitrust regulators stopped cracking down on large companies as long as they provided cheap products for consumers. Since 1978, the share of U.S. firms that are startups has fallen by 50 percent. At an event this week at Politics & Prose, a bookstore in Washington, D.C., I asked Cowen whether he regarded Trump as the outcome of American complacency or as a kind of vaccine that would cure Americans of their indolence. He sided with the former, explaining that he had long thought that a constitutional crisis or a figure like Trump becoming president might happen in the distant future. He also said that in many ways, Trump is the perfect manifestation of a country that has lost interest in new ideas. “Make America Great Again” is an appeal to nostalgia, a promise to bring back the economics and culture of the 1950s, not to do anything new. Cowen’s book performs the trick of all successful idea-driven non-fiction. It provides an open invitation for the reader to think deeply, even when deep thinking leads to some disagreement. At Politics & Prose, Cowen and I discussed a thesis common to his book and mine. Today’s algorithmic media, like Facebook, Pandora, and dating apps, specializes in offering users content that is “optimally new”—familiar, yet surprising. Cowen argues that these technologies wall off anything that is too novel, which feeds complacency. It’s a fair point. But dating apps also increase the supply of potentially discoverable partners, which leads to more dating. I wonder: Does waiting until your late 20s to settle down with a partner signal complacency, or the opposite? Elite complacency is a complicated idea, too. Cowen is right that American elites have clearly sorted themselves into like-minded, high-income communities that pass rules against new housing construction, which isolates them from the rest of the country. But they are also restless strivers. Americans work longer hours than almost any similarly rich country in the world, and rich Americans work more than they did 30 years ago. As their leisure time has declined, affluent couples spend significantly more money on their children than they used to, providing for an expensive portfolio of tutoring, music lessons, and summer camps. You might say that this obsession with status—not only obtaining it in one generation, but also devoting one’s life to protect it for the next generation—is the perfect example of Cowen’s thesis that American parents are obsessed with mitigating risk and avoiding change. But children of the elite are more likely to move multiple times between cities, live in multicultural metros, start companies, and experiment with different jobs. How complacent can a class be if it’s producing tens of thousands of anxious, restless maximizers? The sign of a good book is that it helps readers see the world through a useful lens. Cowen’s book is a full of “huh, I hadn’t thought about it like that” moments, even on topics that I’ve spent years thinking about. For example, in the last few years, many people, like myself, have argued that the American Dream is dying in America, while it seems to be flourishing more in Canada and northern Europe. But Cowen argues persuasively that many international comparisons fail to account for the fact that lots of people are achieving the American Dream—they just weren’t born in America. “When there is mobility in the American labor market, it comes disproportionately from Mexicans and Mexican Americans,” he writes. “Denmark hasn’t elevated nearly as many immigrants, in either absolute or percentage terms, as America.” In other words, America didn’t completely lose the dream. Rather, the only dreamers left are immigrants. A good economy—and, perhaps, a good society—requires a measure of both security and restlessness; a safety net and an entrepreneurial streak. Clearly, government spending has shifted in the last half century from investments to insurance. But I think that’s okay, because a large and dependable welfare state is not only a moral necessity, but also a potential boon to innovation. For example, several studies have shown that many U.S. workers don’t start new companies because they’re afraid of losing their employer-sponsored health insurance. A single-payer system might increase overall entrepreneurial activity. As I read Cowen’s book, I thought of an acrobat show. No circus performer wants to leap between swings without a net to catch them as they fall. The trick is to design for safety without designing for complacency.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Business Confidence
• March 5, 2020 Josh Bivens joined the Economic Policy Institute in 2002 and is currently EPI’s director of research. His primary areas of research include macroeconomics, social insurance, and globalization. Fundamental health reform like ‘Medicare for All’ would help the labor marketJob loss claims are misleading, and substantial boosts to job quality are often overlooked • https://www.epi.org/publication/medicare-for-all-would-help-the-labor-market/
Despite policymakers’ frequent claims that they seek to support small businesses in the U.S. economy, the United States has a notably small share of small-business employment relative to our rich country peers. In 2018, for example, the U.S. was dead-last among the members of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) in its share of self-employment, at just 6.3% of employment. Countries that are frequently portrayed in U.S. business reporting as being choked by regulation—like Spain, France, and Germany—have far higher shares of self-employment, at 16.0%, 11.7%, and 9.9%, respectively (OECD 2020). Besides a low share of self-employment, the U.S. also had significantly lower shares of overall employment in small businesses, across nearly all industrial sectors. The latest OECD data show that the U.S. share of employment in enterprises with fewer than 50 employees is lower than in any other country except for Russia (OECD 2018, Figure 7). In an earlier overview of trends in employment by firm size, Schmitt and Lane (2009) highlight how health care policy plays two key roles in potentially explaining cross-country trends. First, because health care is nearly universally provided in other rich countries, workers choosing to start their own businesses in those countries do not face a cost confronting would-be entrepreneurs in the U.S.: the loss of ESI. Second, small businesses in the U.S. are at a distinct disadvantage in recruiting employees because the cost of providing health care coverage is significantly higher for small companies.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Answers To: › 2AC – Business Confidence
ERIC LEENSON & DAN GEIGER OCT. 17, 2017 1 PM PT Commentary: Why business should demand single-payer health care https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/opinion/commentary/sd-utbg-healthcare-single-payer-business-20171017-story.html
As compelling as the financial figures are, other compelling benefits for small businesses deserve attention. Freeing businesses from the burden and expense of managing and paying for their employees’ health care will unleash them to invest in innovation, their employees and building their businesses. Small businesses could compete more effectively for employees drawn to larger employers because of health benefits. Would-be entrepreneurs would not have to hesitate about leaving their jobs to start a business for fear of losing health coverage. An article in Fortune magazine noted that small- and medium-sized businesses spend inordinate amounts of time, energy and resources trying to navigate an incredibly complex system to secure cost-effective coverage for employees. Employers often spend weeks every year negotiating with private insurance companies, filling out reams of paperwork and switching carriers to get the best deal. There’s also the stress of administering the plan, which creates risks and liabilities for the business. For example, failing to add a newly eligible plan participant such as a new employee, an employee’s spouse, adopted child or new baby can cause serious issues. Mistakes made in benefit plans can lead to costly lawsuits or to regulatory fines. The process of purchasing and maintaining complex and expensive employee health benefits can sometimes push small businesses to opt out of providing employee coverage. These decisions not only impact the business owners, but also their own families who lose access to attractive group health plans with lower premiums and deductibles like those available in the individual and family insurance market, as well as state exchanges like Covered California.