Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Internal Link › IL Turn --- IRS Targets the poor first

IRS has insufficient resources to audit the rich

Paul Kiel IRS: Sorry, but It’s Just Easier and Cheaper to Audit the Poor 10-2-2019  Accessed July 2nd, 2023 -AM

The IRS audits the working poor . Now, in response to questions from a U.S. senator, the IRS has acknowledged that’s true but professes it can’t change anything unless it is given more money. ProPublica on lower-income families in April. Lawmakers confronted IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig about the emphasis, , and , asked Rettig for a plan to fix the imbalance. Rettig readily agreed. Last month, but it said the IRS has no plan and won’t have one until Congress agrees to restore the funding it slashed from the agency over the past nine years — something lawmakers have shown little inclination to do. On the one hand, the IRS said, auditing poor taxpayers is a lot easier: The agency uses relatively low-level employees to audit returns for low-income taxpayers who claim the earned income tax credit. The audits — of which there were about 380,000 last year, accounting for 39% of the total the IRS conducted — are done by mail and don’t take too much staff time, either. They are “the most efficient use of available IRS examination resources,” Rettig’s report says. On the other hand, auditing the rich is hard. It takes senior auditors hours upon hours to complete an exam. What’s more, the letter says, “the rate of attrition is significantly higher among these more experienced examiners.” As a result, the budget cuts have hit this part of the IRS particularly hard.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › No Link --- IRS won’t be defunded by the GOP

Republicans allows big corporations skip their taxes while making it harder for the ordinary citizen

Kevin Freking 1/09/23 reporter at AP “House GOP kicks of majority with vote to slash IRS funding” RAY-SOLORIO

WASHINGTON (AP) —  began their tenure in the majority Monday by passing a bill that would rescind nearly $71 billion that Congress had provided the IRS, fulfilling a campaign promise even though the legislation is unlikely to advance further. Democrats had beefed up the IRS over the next decade to help offset the cost of top health and environmental priorities they passed last year and to replenish an agency struggling to provide basic services to taxpayers and ensure fairness in tax compliance. The money is on top of what Congress provides the IRS annually through the appropriations process and immediately became a magnet for GOP campaign ads in the fall claiming that the boost would lead to an army of IRS agents harassing hard-working Americans. The bill to rescind the money passed the House on a party-line vote of 221-210. The Democratic-controlled Senate has vowed to ignore it. Shortly before the vote, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office projected that rescinding the extra IRS funding would increase deficits over the coming decade by more than $114 billion. That created an awkward moment for Republicans, who have been saying that addressing deficits would be one of their top concerns in the majority. It offered an early example of how the GOP’s bold promises on the campaign trail could get tangled in the messy reality of governing. Still, the CBO’s projection didn’t appear to dampen Republican support. Rep. Jeff Duncan, R-S.C., said the extra IRS funding Democrats provided last year was for one purpose. “To go after small businesses, hard-working Americans to try to raise money for reckless spending, reckless spending that has caused $31 trillion in debt in this nation,” Duncan said. Duncan and other GOP lawmakers routinely say the extra funding will be used to hire 87,000 new agents to target Americans, but that’s . The number is based on a Treasury Department plan saying that many IRS employees would be hired over the next decade if it got the money. But those employees will not all be hired at the same time, they will not all be auditors and many will be replacing some 50,000 employees who are expected to quit or retire in coming years. “This debate about IRS lends itself to be the most dishonest, demagogic rhetoric that I have seen in the Congress at any point in time,” said Rep. Steny Hoyer, D-Md. Charles Rettig, the former commissioner of the IRS, said in a final message to the agency in November that the additional money would help in many areas, not just beefing up tax enforcement. He said the investments would make it “even less likely for honest taxpayers to hear from the IRS or receive an audit letter.” Additional funding for the agency has been politically controversial since 2013, when the IRS under the Obama administration was found to have used inappropriate criteria to review tea party groups and other organizations applying for tax-exempt status. In the ensuing years, the IRS was mostly on the losing end of congressional funding fights, even as a subsequent 2017 report found that both conservative and liberal groups were chosen for scrutiny. In April, Rettig told lawmakers the agency’s budget has decreased by more than 15% over the past decade when accounting for inflation and said the number of full-time employees — 79,000 in the last fiscal year — was close to 1974 levels. But Rep. Nicole Malliotakis, R-N.Y., and other Republicans weren’t buying the argument that the funding would be focused on auditing the wealthy. “This is meant to nickel-and-dime, audit and harass America’s small businesses and families, who they know cannot afford the legal fees to fight this army,” Malliotakis said. Sen. Ron Wyden, the Democratic chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, said a decade of Republican-led budget cuts gutted the IRS. “The only way that House Republicans could make it any more obvious that they’re doing a favor for wealthy tax cheats is by coming out and saying it in exactly those words,” Wyden said. “This bill is going nowhere in the Senate.” And the White House said President Joe Biden would veto the bill if it gets to his desk, saying that the wealthiest 1% of Americans hide about 20% of their income so they don’t have to pay taxes on it, shifting more of the tax burden to the middle class. “With their first economic legislation of the new Congress, House Republicans are making clear that their top economic priority is to allow the rich and multibillion-dollar corporations to skip out on their taxes, while making life harder for ordinary, middle-class families that pay the taxes they owe,” the White House said.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › No Link --- IRS won’t be defunded by the GOP

IRS will see funding form the republican party

Ewan Palmer 1/10/23 A reporter newsweek “Wealthy tax cheats set to benefit from republicans’ defunding of IRS” https://www.newsweek.com/how-republicans-plan-defund-irs-1772375 RAY-SOLORIO

Now that Kevin McCarthy has finally been elected House speaker, and a new congressional term sworn in, the GOP has already voted on one of its key promises made during last year's midterm elections: to target the Internal Revenue Service. In a 221 to 210 vote along party lines on Monday, House Republicans voted through the Family and Small Business Taxpayer Protection Act [H.R. 23] which aims to rescind $80 billion funding introduced in the Inflation Reduction Act. Following years of the IRS demanding more funding from Congress, it was a Democrat-controlled House that finally granted its wish and provided the agency a funding boost over the next 10 years as part of the long-fought-for inflation bill which was passed in July .It's this funding that the GOP has vowed to target, warning that the money will be used to hire 87,000 new agents who will go after low and middle class families with audits. In a speech after he was eventually elected House speaker, McCarthy vowed: "When we come back, our very first bill will repeal the funding for 87,000 IRS agents. We believe government should be to help you, not go after you. "After the bill passed on Monday, McCarthy banged the gavel and stated "promises made," prompting cheers and applause from the House Republicans. Experts told Newsweek that defunding the IRS would make it easier for the wealthy and big corporations to evade taxes.GETTY/NEWSWEEK The vow to target the IRS funding had also been made by a number of other prominent Republicans. In August, Texas Senator Ted Cruz sought to remove an amendment from the bill which would scrap the funding for a "new army of IRS agents" who are poised not to "audit billionaires or giant corporations" but instead "created to audit you. “Stephen Miller, a former top White House aide to Donald Trump, also tweeted in October 2022 in response to a tweet from President Joe Biden noting how every Democrat voted for the Inflation Reduction Act, with the claim: "Yes, every Democrat voted to hire 87K new IRS agents to audit the middle class—instead of hiring Border Patrol agents to defend the middle class. “A number of Republican midterm election candidates even ran campaign ads that quoted the 87,000 figure and the claim that it means more chances that low and middle-income families will be subjected to audits. However, Democrats and other groups have said that the GOP's claims are misleading, and that the 87,000 figure is not going to be used to recruit an army of new auditing agents .Instead, it will contain other agency workers as well as bring in much needed new software to help with filing and customer service. Experts said the new hires will also be replacing the tens of thousands employees who are expected to quit or retire over the upcoming years. Democrats have also argued that the new IRS funding is needed to target the rich and corporations for not paying their full taxes, rather than go after average American citizens, who will remain unlikely to be audited. "Defunding the IRS is an attack on tax enforcement and the fairness of our entire tax system," Amy Hanauer, executive director of the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), told Newsweek. "It would make it easier for wealthy Americans and profitable corporations to evade taxes, eroding the integrity of our tax code while reducing the revenue lawmakers have available to invest in the American people," she said. The ITEP also argued that the recent criticism of the IRS and its failure to audit Trump during his first two years of presidency, as revealed in the release of his tax returns, is proof that it desperately needs new funding and reform. One major hurdle for the Republican Party and its plans to target IRS funding is the likelihood of any attempt to rescind the money succeeding. Despite the GOP-controlled House voting to pass the Family and Small Business Taxpayer Protection Act on Monday, it will almost certainly fail to clear the Democrat-controlled Senate. Biden could also use his veto powers to block any attempts for the GOP to dissect his Inflation Reduction Act, which he considers one of the biggest accomplishments of his presidency so far. Tony Reardon, national president of the National Treasury Employees Union, said that the GOP plans to target the new IRS funding is "short-sighted and destructive" as well as being a "stunt" which is destined to fail. "But that doesn't make it any less startling that new House leaders are willing to mislead the American people about how the money is going to be spent," Reardon told Newsweek. "As the fact-checkers have been reporting for months, the IRS is not adding 87,000 new agents to audit regular Americans. "In fact, the agency stands to lose 52,000 current employees over the next five years to regular retirement and attrition, and the Treasury Department has ordered that initial hiring be focused on reinforcing the depleted corps of customer service representatives who answer the phones or meet with taxpayers every day." Reardon said that the Treasury has also "made clear" that the new IRS funding will not be used to increase audits of small businesses or households earning less than $400,000 a year. "The American people will see clearly from this debate that the only people who benefit from an underfunded and understaffed IRS are the wealthy and anyone who wants to cheat the system," Reardon said. On Monday, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated that the Family and Small Business Taxpayer Protection Act would raise the deficit by around $114 billion. The Biden administration condemned the "reckless" bill passed by the House Republicans while stating the deficit increase the bill is estimated to bring in will be caused by "enabling wealthy tax cheats" to engage in additional tax fraud and avoidance. The Office of Management and Budget said in a statement after the vote: "Far from protecting middle-class families or small businesses, H.R. 23 protects wealthy tax cheats at the expense of honest middle-class taxpayer. "With their first economic legislation of the new Congress, House Republicans are making clear that their top economic priority is to allow the rich and multi-billion dollar corporations to skip out on their taxes, while making life harder for ordinary, middle-class families that pay the taxes they owe." It is not just the IRS that the GOP wants to target now they have control of the House. The party also promised to use subpoena powers to go after what they refer to as the "weaponization" of the federal government by the Biden administration. Elsewhere in his speech after being elected House speaker, McCarthy promised the GOP will set up committees to "hold the swamp accountable, from the withdrawal of Afghanistan, to the origins of COVID and to the weaponization of the FBI." "Let me be very clear. We will use the power of the purse and the power of the subpoena to get the job done," McCarthy said. The party is also said to be planning on launching a new special subcommittee to investigate the FBI and Department of Justice's criminal probes into Trump, reportedly headed by expected new chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, Jim Jordan.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › Link Turn --- Progressive taxes increase IRS Credibility

Many people prefer progressive taxes

CHRISTOPHER HOY and CHIARA BRONCHI, 11-9-22 (Chiara Bronchi is the Practice Manager for the Fiscal Policy and Sustainable Growth Global Unit of the World Bank Group. Christopher Hoy is a Young Professional in the Poverty and Equity Global Practice at the World Bank. “Why does the progressivity of taxes matter?”) https://blogs.worldbank.org/governance/why-does-progressivity-taxes-matter

Tax reforms that reduce progressivity, which are intended to improve the fiscal position of a country, could undermine tax compliance to a point where the net impact on revenue is negative.

Countries around the world are struggling with shrinking fiscal space; debt levels are close to record highs, interest payments are increasing rapidly due to high inflation, and the global economic outlook is very uncertain. As governments consider the role of taxation to respond to this environment, we outline in this blog three reasons why maintaining or increasing the progressivity of the tax system is important. These reasons are drawn from insights gained from the most recent round of the World Values Survey, the latest World Bank Poverty and Shared Prosperity Report and a new World Bank working paper. 1. Most people prefer progressive taxes. Progressive tax and transfer systems are broadly supported by the general population. This is illustrated in the most recent World Values Survey, which covers a representative sample of populations in over 40 low and middle-income countries. Respondents were asked, on a scale of 0-10, how supportive they were of governments taxing the rich and subsidizing the poor, which is a simple way of characterizing a progressive tax and transfer system. The figure below shows that, across a diverse range of countries, most were supportive of progressivity, with average scores ranging from 5 to 8. Furthermore, in many countries, richer respondents were more likely to agree than disagree that the tax and transfer system should be progressive. These insights would suggest that policy makers should feel confident that they have popular support for tax reforms that increase progressivity.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › Link Turn --- Progressive taxes increase IRS Credibility

IRS progressive taxes reduce income inequality

IRS No Date “The Whys of Taxes” (https://apps.irs.gov/app/understandingTaxes/student/whys_thm03_les03.jsp)

A progressive tax takes a larger percentage of income from high-income groups than from low-income groups and is based on the concept of ability to pay. A progressive tax system might, for example, tax low-income taxpayers at 10 percent, middle-income taxpayers at 15 percent and high-income taxpayers at 30 percent. The U.S. federal income tax is based on the progressive tax system.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › Link Turn --- Progressive taxes increase IRS Credibility

Progressive taxes and cash transfers reduce income inequality – multiple countries prove

Joumard, Pisu and Bloch, 2012 “Tackling income inequality. The role of taxes and transfers” () Cut by NR

Taxes and transfers are key policy levers to influence distributional outcomes. Information based on household surveys suggests that OECD-wide, taxes and cash transfers reduced the market income dispersion – as measured by the concentration coefficient – by about 25% and relative poverty by about 55% in the late 2000s (Pisu, 2012).3 Their redistributive impact tends to be high in the Nordic countries (Iceland being an exception) and eastern European countries (Figure 1). It is low in Iceland, Korea and Switzerland, all characterised by little market income dispersion, and in Chile. The data suggest that there is a positive link between the redistributive impact of taxes and transfers and the level of market income inequality. Focusing on the working age population yields the same pattern. Cash transfers reduce income dispersion more than taxes (Figure 2).5 The United States, however, is an outlier with virtually the same redistribution achieved through taxes as cash transfers. It relies heavily on the tax code to provide support to lowincome groups – the Earned Income Tax Credit is one of the largest US social programmes – while other countries rely more on cash transfers.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › No Link --- Redistribution does not require taxation

Fiscal Redistribution is defined as either taxation, social transfers, or investment in social services.

Naren Prasad (Contact Author) 10-10-2008. ( Naren Prasad (Contact Author). "Policies for Redistribution: The Use of Taxes and Social Transfers." No Publication. Web. 10-10-2008. accessed 7-2-2023. <  >. mtrue - mrh)

First redistribution can take place through taxation. Different taxes have different impacts of distribution. Generally, personal income taxes and property taxes are progressive (increasing equality), corporate taxes are U-shaped (regressive for small and large companies and progressive for medium-sized companies), and indirect taxes are regressive. Together reliance on different taxes combine to define the extent of progressivity in the overall tax system. Typically, the overall tax system in poor countries is regressive (Gemmell and Morrissey 2005). Great care needs to be taken when using the tax instrument for redistribution purposes. It is crucial that taxes should not distort incentives to work, invest and create wealth. Any recourse to tax reform to reduce income inequalities should therefore take into account the possible impact on economic growth and employment. Second, redistribution can also take place through social transfers, including social assistance benefits and social insurance programmes. The former typically target the needy and can therefore be expected to have a strong redistributive effect. In developing countries, however, social insurance programmes (such as pensions and unemployment insurance) may be regressive rather than progressive; and this tendency is exacerbated by the fact that such programmes tend to exclude workers in the informal economy, who disproportionately comprise the poor. Third and finally, investment in education, health and other social services can also exert a redistributive effect (see box 1). While taxes and social transfers have an immediate effect on income distribution, public provision of social services tends to have a more long-term impact. Government programmes in primary education or health care and infrastructure investment in areas such as water and sanitation may help alleviate the deep-rooted aspects of inequality by creating opportunities (or what Amartya Sen calls capabilities).

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › No Link --- Redistribution does not require taxation

Fiscal Redistribution can be cash benefits as well as spending on education and health.

Nora Lustig May 2018. (Nora Lustig. "." No Publication. Web. May 2018. accessed 7-2-2023. <  >. mtrue - mrh)

Two key indicators of a government’s (or society’s) commitment to equalizing opportunities and reducing poverty and social exclusion are the share of total income devoted to social spending and how equalizing and pro-poor this spending is.3 Typically, redistributive social spending includes cash benefits4 and benefits in kind such as spending on education and health.5 As shown in Enami, Lustig, and Aranda (2018) and Enami (2018), the redistributive potential of a country does indeed depend on the size and composition of government spending and how it is financed, as well as the progressivity of all the taxes and government spending combined.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › No Link --- Redistribution does not require taxation

Fiscal Redistribution occurs in three forms: anti-poverty programs, taxation, an policies that tilt economic outcomes.

Jeffrey A. Miron 2011. ( Jeffrey A. Miron. "Rethinking Redistribution." No Publication. Web. 2011. accessed 7-2-2023. <  >. mtrue - mrh)

Whether one agrees with it or not, this popular understanding of redistribution's purpose yields some useful criteria for assessing the degree to which our redistribution programs are actually succeeding. The aims of helping the poor and minimizing harm to everyone else, in other words, offer some specific ends against which our means of redistribution can be tested.

By and large, those means take three forms. First, there are direct anti-poverty programs, like Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (what we commonly think of as welfare), food stamps, Medicaid, and the Earned Income Tax Credit. Second, there is progressive taxation, which transfers wealth from richer to poorer Americans across the income distribution. And third, there are policies that tilt economic outcomes in specific markets to benefit people with lower incomes (minimum-wage laws are a classic example).

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 Link › No Link --- Redistribution does not require taxation

Deficit Spending is not a form of fiscal redistribution which means the IRS is not involved

LAURENCE J. KOTLIKOFF 8-1-1988. ( View All. "The Deficit Is Not a Well-Defined Measure of Fiscal Policy." Science. Web. 8-1-1988. accessed 7-2-2023. <  >. mtrue - mrh)

Notwithstanding its widespread use, the government's deficit is not a well-defined measure of fiscal policy from the perspective of neoclassical economics; the equations of neoclassical models do not define the deficit. Rather than being a fundamental economic concept, the deficit is an arbitrary cash flow accounting construct with no necessary relation to the true stance of fiscal policy. Although the deficit is supposed to indicate how the burden of paying for the government's consumption is spread across different generations, actual changes in the measured deficit in the United States have had little if any relation to changes in the burden imposed by the government on different generations. The deficit's lack of definition is illustrated with a simple model, and the potential for misreading fiscal policy is discussed with U.S. fiscal policy in the 1980s as an example. In this article, creation of present value generational accounts are called for that would properly measure the intergenerational stance of fiscal policy.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Non-UQ --- IRS Low Now – Debt ceiling cuts

Due to staffing shortages the IRS is failling

Colin Martin, 4-27-2020, "Staff shortage sparks 'hardest year ever' for IRS," No Publication,

The Internal Revenue Service has had their "hardest year ever" due to staff shortages, as they now have less than 80,000 workers, according to Because of that, plus issues due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the IRS is still working on processing more than 3 million tax returns from 2021. The IRS said in a report to Congress at the beginning of the month that they know only 20% of callers are getting through to speak to live IRS agents during this busy part of the year. They added that last year, only 11% of callers were able to successfully talk to a live IRS agent on the phone. "On average our hold times can range anywhere between 30 and 40 minutes," IRS Chief Taxpayer Experience Officer Corbin McFarlane told CBS News. The IRS is significantly behind in tax returns IRS, 6-30-2023, "IRS Operations: Status of Mission-Critical Functions," No Publication, https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-operations-status-of-mission-critical-functions As of June 24, 2023, we had 3 million unprocessed individual returns. These include tax year 2022 returns, 2021 returns that need review or correction and late filed prior year returns. Of these, 1.7 million returns require error correction or other special handling, and 1.3 million are paper returns waiting to be reviewed and processed. This work does not typically require us to correspond with taxpayers, but it does require special handling by an IRS employee, so in these instances it is taking the IRS more than 21 days to issue any related refund.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Non-UQ --- IRS Low Now – Debt ceiling cuts

In order to help to debt ceiling the IRS is experiencing a 26% budget cut with Republicans advocating for increased cuts

Laura Weiss, 6-5-2023, "IRS budget battle not over after debt ceiling agreement," Roll Call, CPKP

A handshake deal to redirect IRS funding to offset tight spending caps for other domestic programs won’t mark the end of a partisan battle over expanding the tax collecting agency. About $21 billion of an $80 billion tranche of funding that Democrats enacted last year is set to be cut and repurposed as part of the agreement between President Joe Biden and Speaker Kevin McCarthy to suspend the debt limit and cap federal agency spending. But that hasn’t quenched Republicans’ desire to slash more IRS funds, setting up a familiar fight in the annual government funding process. “I think that no doubt there’ll be people trying to alter that annual [IRS] funding and, of course, really this agreement is just the next step toward the appropriation battles,” said Texas Rep. Lloyd Doggett, a senior Democrat on the Ways and Means Committee, which oversees the tax code. [Crisis averted as Senate sends debt limit package to Biden] Republicans are vowing to continue attempts to chip away at the roughly $59 billion in IRS funding that will remain, if the handshake agreement holds. McCarthy said after the House passed the debt ceiling package last week that “we’re not going to stop until we get the rest of the IRS agents repealed.” Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, a member of the tax-writing Finance Committee, described the clawback plans as a “good down payment” toward rescinding the full $80 billion. Next step: Appropriations bills The next opportunity to go after those funds will be the fiscal 2024 appropriations process that’s now set to get underway, after Biden signed the debt ceiling bill into law this weekend. The $80 billion that Democrats enacted last year is a separate, mandatory add-on spread over a decade, but the agency also gets an annual chunk of discretionary funding, most recently $12.3 billion in the omnibus package for the current fiscal year. It will be the first appropriations process since the $80 billion cash infusion became law in which Democrats are negotiating with a Republican-controlled House. To attract Senate GOP support in the 50-50 chamber last year — appropriations bills require 60 votes to get past a filibuster — Democrats agreed to a 2 percent IRS budget cut.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Thumper --- Hiring/Modernization will take years

IRS in desperate need of staff, modernized tech, and management practices which isn’t coming anytime soon

Howard Gleckman Senior Fellow Tax policy center [“TaxVox: Individual Taxes”, Tax Policy Center Urban Institute and Brookings Institution, 04-19-2023, . Accessed 07-03-2023.]//ahcchs

As usual, the politicians are missing the point: Success or failure of the won’t be measured by how many new staff it hires. Rather it will depend largely on the agency’s ability to hire the right people, upgrade and modernize its technology, and change its hidebound culture, management, and business practices. At TPC ‘s annual , a broad range of experts, including Deputy Treasury Secretary Wally Adeyemo, former IRS Commissioner Charles Rossotti, former IRS Taxpayer Advocate Nina Olson, former senior Treasury official Natasha Sarin, and others broadly agreed: It will take much more than just increasing the IRS headcount to improve taxpayer experience and reduce non-compliance. That’s not to say the IRS doesn’t need more staff. It does. Desperately. But the agency never will solve its many problems just by hiring more humans. Staff, But More Its need for updated technology is Rossotti, who started and ran a business systems company before leading the IRS, believes the agency can make progress by installing new systems even before it completely replaces its decades-old core taxpayer database. The agency also needs a cultural makeover. Much of its middle management is highly resistant to change, its rank-and-file staff morale is low, and its union/management relations are poor. Olson said the IRS needs to think of itself primarily as an agency that supports taxpayers rather than mostly an enforcer of the law. These days, the IRS talks about “customer service.” Taxpayers, of course, are not customers. But more importantly, much of what the agency does sends very different signals, from its incomprehensible notices to taxpayers to its continued self-harm by effectively forcing many filers to communicate by paper.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Thumper --- Hiring/Modernization will take years

IRS can’t update key tech needed for efficiency and modernization

Natalie Alms staff reporter at Nextogv/FCW, graduate of Wake Forest University [“A 60-year-old IRS IT system won’t finish modernization until 2030”, FWC, 10-20-2021, . Accessed 07-03-2023.]//ahcchs

The IRS completed most of its planned IT modernization activities for the last two fiscal years on schedule and within cost, but one of its efforts, intended as a replacement for a 60-year-old system, is now on track to replace core functions only—and it may not be complete until 2030. That's according to a Government Accountability Office report, which reviewed five IRS IT investments and found that they met most performance goals for FY 2019 and 2020. The 60-year-old system slated for replacement is called the Individual Master File. It's the key source for individual tax data, and a modernized system would provide the infrastructure needed for real time digital taxpayer interactions, rapid access to data and agile response to legislative changes, according to the GAO report. MORE ON IRS MODERNIZATION (March 29, 2021) (Aug. 24, 2020) (July 02, 2019) The program intended to modernize it, called Customer Account Data Engine 2, has seen many delays and cost changes since the IRS first started developing it in 2009, according to the GAO. A key milestone for replacing selected functions, for example, has been pushed back by nine years, from 2014 to 2023. The CADE 2 program actually had lower reported costs than anticipated for 2020 and met most performance goals for the last two years, but GAO called its long term performance and outlook "troubling." The modernized system isn't scheduled to be finished until 2030. Development costs are now about four times higher than originally planned, and CADE 2 is also now expected to replace only core components of the old program, as opposed to the entire system. The current system is one of the oldest in the federal government, said the GAO, with software written in legacy computer languages including COBOL that are no longer part of core computer science curricula. The specialized workers needed to support legacy IRS systems are expensive and increasingly difficult to find.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Thumper --- Hiring/Modernization will take years

IRS is overwhelmed, understaffed, and vastly technologically behind – and future progress is lacking

Samuel Hammond and David Koggan sam hammond is the director of poverty and welfare policy at the Niskanen Center in Washington. david koggan is a student at Carnegie Mellon University and recent Niskanen Center policy intern. [“Saving the IRS”, Milken Institute Review, published 01-24-2022, . Accessed 07/03/2023.] //ahcchs

If taxes are the “,” as the Supreme Court has often reaffirmed, then the IRS is the heart that keeps the federal government’s blood pumping. Virtually every public function relies on the revenue collected by the IRS, including our capacity to underwrite a growing public debt without runaway inflation. But, stretching the metaphor a bit further, the 68-year-old agency’s risk of cardiac arrest is clearly growing. Decades of workforce and budget cuts have left the IRS short of personnel and money: was 19 percent lower in 2021 than in 2010, giving the agency roughly the same inflation-adjusted budget it had 30 years ago. This, despite needing to process over twice the number of business tax returns annually, all while administering an increasingly complex tax code that saddles the agency with growing responsibilities in social welfare and regulatory policy that the agency was never designed to handle. And with nearly to retire, the agency’s staffing crisis is set to grow much worse. This mismatch of responsibilities and resources is not helped by the IRS’s floppy-disc technical infrastructure. The backend of the IRS is the all-important Individual Master File. Used to store and process tax submissions, the IMF is programmed in impenetrable assembly code that literally dates from the Kennedy administration. Translating the code into Java, a comparatively modern programming language, has been a long-term goal of the IRS — but one which has faced repeated and often . And while the agency is formally committed to a broad-based modernization initiative, progress reports have been lacking. As this is being written, the Biden administration is pressing for a considerable increase in the IRS’s enforcement budget. But with lawmakers delegating more and more responsibility to the IRS, it will take more than a boost to its enforcement muscle to bring the agency into the 21st century. The agency was last restructured in 1998 — when we still feared the new millennium might cause a computer-induced apocalypse. Technology has advanced by leaps and bounds in the decades since, but in dealing with the nation’s tax and transfer system has in some ways regressed. This is partly because the IRS is drowning in mission creep, as Congress has found it convenient to expand the agency’s tasks far beyond the business of collecting taxes. Want to know the rules for government programs ranging from opportunity zones to a ? Ask the IRS, although it may take a few years to get back to you. Administering complex tax expenditures and social programs has stretched the agency thin. One way or another, the agency’s bloated mission needs to be devolved, with sufficient resources appropriated to give it a chance to do its core job well. However, achieving these reforms will be impossible without first fixing the broken funding and oversight mechanisms that have long exposed the IRS to politicization.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Thumper --- Tax code EXTREAMELY complex now

The IRS is highly ineffective now due to complex tax codes

Clive Crook 22, 8-19-2022, "Want a Better IRS? Simplify the Tax Code," Bloomberg, 

In a word, yes: The IRS struggles to administer the system because US taxes are insanely complicated. In this respect, the purportedly bold innovation on funding for the agency is partly a tribute to the status quo. The enormous increase in spending is combined with another new batch of complexities. Highlights include incentives for climate-related investments and assorted other good things, and a minimum corporate tax that requires eligible companies to calculate what they owe not one way but two, then pay the larger sum.

Changes like these serve legitimate purposes, but they are partly self-defeating. With one hand you incentivize decisions that serve the public interest; with the other, you cancel them out by closing “loopholes.” On top of which, every further complication is an opportunity for tax avoidance, an added compliance burden on taxpayers and the IRS alike, and a transfer of income from producers of socially valuable goods and services to accountants and lawyers eager for their share of the resulting deadweight loss.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Thumper --- Tax code EXTREAMELY complex now

Tax Code is complex and stunts economic growth

Thomas Hoppe 20, 9-7-2020, "The Tax Complexity Index – A Survey-Based Country Measure of Tax Code and Framework Complexity," Taylor & Francis, 

Recent evidence indicates that tax complexity has increased significantly in the past years (Bornemann et al., ; Devereux, , ; Hoppe et al., ; Hoppe et al., ). This increase can be attributed to at least two factors. The first factor is the introduction and adaption of tax measures to ensure a level playing field for firms and to close tax loopholes, leading to extraordinary costs and uncertainty. The second factor is the implementation of tax incentives and mechanisms to attract investments and resolve uncertainties, thereby lowering costs and providing opportunities for tax planning. Nonetheless, concerns have emerged that tax systems have become too complex (Ingraham & Karlinsky, , United States; Tran-Nam & Karlinsky, , Australia; Deloitte, , China; Whiting et al., , UK) and that the negative consequences of tax complexity may dominate the positive consequences (Müller & Voget, ). In particular, tax complexity is expected to jeopardize economic prosperity (Collier et al., ) and to encourage undesired tax planning or tax avoidance (Budak & James, ). The negative impact of tax complexity is also addressed by the tax certainty reports of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (IMF & OECD, , , ), which conclude that more clarity and less complexity are needed to support economic growth.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Thumper --- Tax code EXTREAMELY complex now

Tax code EXTREMELY complex now

Burman and Gale, 2001, Leonard E. Burman, director of the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, and William G. Gale, senior fellow in Economic Studies at Brookings Institution, A Golden Opportunity to Simplify the Tax System: Options for Reforming a Complex Tax Code. April 3, 2001 Brookings institution.  /cmm

Most of the debate about President Bush’s tax proposals and Democratic alternatives has focused on the highly contentious issues of size and fairness. The effects on tax complexity have been largely ignored, despite widespread consensus that taxes are too complicated. With both parties interested in tax cuts of some kind, this is a prime opportunity to simplify the tax system. In this brief, we discuss why taxes are complicated, examine how the Bush administration’s and the Democrats’ proposals would affect tax complexity, and present options for simpler taxes.

POLICY BRIEF #77

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Non UQ --- IRS Cred Low Now – Budget Cuts

IRS lacks resources to function properly

Bruce Riedel, 23 [1-26-2023, Bruce Riedel, Brookings, Cutting IRS funding is a gift to America’s wealthiest tax evaders, 7-3-2023, ] //AshAN

In their , the new House Republican majority voted to cut funding for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The vote was a symbolic effort to repeal the $80 billion increase in funding the revenue agency received last year as part of the Inflation Reduction Act. Cutting IRS funding is a terrible idea. A well-funded IRS can distribute emergency aid quickly, serve taxpayers efficiently, and help ensure that millionaires have to follow the tax laws just like everyone else. It’s an essential investment in good government. The IRS has been persistently underfunded , but the years since 2010 have been particularly tough. Tax law expert Chye-Ching Huang notes that the enforcement budget of the IRS dropped by  in less than ten years. In , the IRS employed less than 10,000 revenue agents—the last time that was true was 1953: the Brooklyn Dodgers were in the World Series, the median housing price was , and the IRS was handling over   individual income tax returns a year. The IRS is also “overwhelmingly reliant” on antiquated technology, the , “systems that are at least 25 years old, use obsolete programming languages (e.g., COBOL), or lack vendor support, training, or resources to maintain.” It is worth noting how much the IRS has managed to achieve despite its perpetually inadequate resources. When COVID struck, for example, only the IRS had the capacity to send  to keep American households afloat. As my Tax Policy Center colleague Howard Gleckman has said, the IRS “ in getting these checks out in very difficult circumstances.” But the budgetary toll of persistent underfunding is unmistakable. For regular taxpayers, the consequence is . Some politicians have  suggested that every new IRS employee will be a gun-toting enforcement agent. Actually, the IRS desperately needs employees to process refunds and answer tax filers’ phone calls. Out of the 282 million phone calls the IRS received in 2021, only 11% or 32 million were actually answered.  is going to taxpayer services and modernization, which will . About $45 billion of the $80 billion in new funding is going to enforcement, and that is great news. For the wealthiest and most sophisticated tax filers, a cash-strapped IRS has meant a tax evasion free-for-all. Currently, the tax gap, which is the amount in taxes that are owed but not paid, comes to .  is due to underreporting of income by the top 10% of taxpayers, and more than a quarter comes from the top 1%. But the IRS has been left without the resources to hire and support the kind of tax experts who can catch wealthy tax cheats. The lack of staff was highlighted recently when it was revealed that the audit of former president Donald Trump was . But Trump wasn’t the only one whose taxes were going without thorough examination.  in less than a decade. For those making more than $5 million, the audit rate has . At the same time, responding to a , the IRS has focused instead on a much cheaper form of audit, targeting recipients of the Earned Income Tax Credit—i.e. low-income, working families. As a result, the EITC recipients are audited at the same rate as the top 1% of earners. As law professor Dorothy Brown explains, the consequence of high levels of EITC audits is a serious . Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has insisted that the new funding . So, the new funding will help rebuild the capacity of the IRS to audit the wealthy, making the tax system far fairer. And, of course, closing the tax gap raises revenues—it’s a policy that more than pays for itself. The IRS investments are expected to raise . The Republican effort to repeal the IRS’s $80 billion funding increase will not move forward in the Democrat-controlled Senate. But the IRS might yet see its funding decline, if the House Republicans negotiate a cut in . If that happens, it is bad news for the millions of American households who pay their taxes honestly, and great news for the country’s richest tax evaders. Funding the IRS will shore up an essential government service, making tax filing easier and tax enforcement fairer.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Non UQ --- IRS Cred Low Now – Budget Cuts

Staff and budget shortages prevent IRS from functioning at full capacity

William R. Stromsem, 22 [6-24-2022, TXCPA Federal Tax Policy Blog, Are Declining IRS Audit Rates Providing a Credible Audit Deterrent? 7-3-2023, ] //AshAN

The average audit rate for all individual income tax returns has declined to 0.25% according to a  to the House Ways and Means Oversight Committee. This is a continuing downward trend from 0.9% in 2010. The IRS attributes this decline to staff and budget shortages. Things do not look much brighter for the future, with 15% of the IRS’ auditors expected to retire in the next three years. Audit rates decreased the most for taxpayers with incomes of $200,000+ because those audits require more time and expertise for the more complex issues. Also, there were fewer field and office audits because of the pandemic. Almost all audits were more-automated, less-intrusive correspondence audits. With such a low audit potential, the unspoken question is how low can it get before it loses credibility to the extent that otherwise honest taxpayers are tempted to take questionable positions on returns in the hope of not being singled out for an audit? For CPAs, the issue is whether their attention to compliance detail will be appreciated as much by taxpayers who are tempted to play the audit lottery.