2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS Trade Off Disad Aff Answers › A2 UQ › Non UQ --- IRS Cred Low Now – Budget Cuts
Laura Weiss, 23 [6-5-2023, Laura Weiss, Roll Call, IRS budget battle not over after debt ceiling agreement, 7-2-2023, ] //AshAN
A handshake deal to redirect IRS funding to offset tight spending caps for other domestic programs won’t mark the end of a partisan battle over expanding the tax collecting agency. About $21 billion of an $80 billion tranche of funding that Democrats enacted last year is set to be cut and repurposed as part of the agreement between President Joe Biden and Speaker to suspend the debt limit and cap federal agency spending. But that hasn’t quenched Republicans’ desire to slash more IRS funds, setting up a familiar fight in the annual government funding process. “I think that no doubt there’ll be people trying to alter that annual [IRS] funding and, of course, really this agreement is just the next step toward the appropriation battles,” said Texas Rep. , a senior Democrat on the Ways and Means Committee, which oversees the tax code. Republicans are vowing to continue attempts to chip away at the roughly $59 billion in IRS funding that will remain, if the handshake agreement holds. McCarthy said after the House passed the debt ceiling package last week that “we’re not going to stop until we get the rest of the IRS agents repealed.” Sen. , R-Texas, a member of the tax-writing Finance Committee, described the clawback plans as a “good down payment” toward rescinding the full $80 billion. Next step: Appropriations bills The next opportunity to go after those funds will be the fiscal 2024 appropriations process that’s now set to get underway, after Biden signed the debt ceiling bill into law this weekend. The $80 billion that Democrats enacted last year is a separate, mandatory add-on spread over a decade, but the agency also gets an annual chunk of discretionary funding, most recently $12.3 billion in the omnibus package for the current fiscal year. It will be the first appropriations process since the became law in which Democrats are negotiating with a Republican-controlled House. To attract Senate GOP support in the 50-50 chamber last year — appropriations bills require 60 votes to get past a filibuster — Democrats agreed to a 2 percent IRS budget cut. A Republican who negotiated the debt limit deal on McCarthy’s behalf, North Carolina Rep. , said the plan to repurpose $10 billion each year during the next two years’ appropriations cycles is “a pre-agreement that this is on the table.” But he said the side deal isn’t meant to determine the details of appropriations outcomes. The appropriations process “is still wide-open for appropriators to make their decisions,” McHenry said. “It is not my intention for this agreement to hamper that process. Same thing for the White House.” Another $1.4 billion rescission was written into the debt ceiling package. That shielded the accounts for improving taxpayer services and modernizing IRS systems from cuts, in line with traditional bipartisan backing for that spending. Louisiana Sen. , a Republican member of the Financial Services Appropriations Subcommittee that funds the IRS, said the clawbacks won’t change the conversation around the agency’s annual funding level. He said the IRS has had abysmal customer service and that’s where dollars should be concentrated. For other accounts, like revamping technology systems, Kennedy said the IRS should come up with a plan, citing wasted funding in the past. He also expressed hesitancy about enforcement funds. “Now I think the Biden administration is trying to use the funding increase to target taxpayers. I get that; everybody ought to pay their fair share of taxes,” Kennedy said. “But the record of the IRS in terms of treating people fairly and being transparent in doing so is not good.” Democrats are readying for a fight. Sen. , who chairs the Financial Services subcommittee that oversees IRS funding, said he’ll be pushing to fulfill the White House’s request that the IRS get $14.1 billion in fiscal 2024, a 15 percent boost over this year. The Maryland Democrat said that would protect the agency’s ability to improve customer service, modernize technology and ramp up enforcement against wealthy tax cheats. Rep. , D-Md., said he expects pressure from Republicans to trim IRS resources, particularly to squeeze tax enforcement. Hoyer, the top Democrat on the House Financial Services Appropriations Subcommittee, said he’s discussed the issue with the panel’s Republican chairman, of Arkansas. “He’s under a lot of pressure to cut out all of the $80 billion. That did not happen,” Hoyer said. “And we’re gonna have that fight I’m sure on a continuing basis.” Senate Finance Chair , whose panel has jurisdiction over the tax code, said in a statement after the debt ceiling package cleared Congress that he’d fight any effort to further strip the IRS funding. Funding squeeze It’s not clear exactly how the funding losses could impact IRS plans, although the result may depend on whether annual appropriations cuts further squeeze the agency. Democrats have so far projected confidence that the IRS can still carry out plans to build up customer service, hire more auditors to enforce the tax code and update technology in the near term. IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel has said that even with the $80 billion cash infusion in place, the yearly government funding process could determine the agency’s course in the years to come. If its regular annual budget falls below the fiscal 2022 level plus inflation, the IRS will have to siphon funds from its $80 billion stash to maintain its typical operations, he wrote in an April memo included in the IRS’ strategic operating plan. Doggett said he believes Democrats can stave off deeper budget cuts that impact the IRS’ immediate plans to expand tax enforcement but the partisan divide on the issue will continue to linger over funding debates. “I’m satisfied that we can win the short-term battle, maybe not in the House but ultimately in conference committee, and IRS can do this [work] initially,” he said. “Over the long term, there’ll be a struggle about it.” Even if the IRS proceeds with its existing plans, the agency is expected to collect less tax revenue with fewer funds. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated that clawing back $1.4 billion of IRS funding would end up costing the government $900 million over a decade as revenue losses outweigh the spending cut. A preliminary estimate from CBO found that a repeal of $21.4 billion in total of IRS funding would grow the deficit on net by $19 billion, according to Senate Budget Chairman , D-R.I., who requested the analysis. Lindsey McPherson contributed to this report.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › IL --- Cartels
Monica Cruz Monica Cruz is a freelance reporter from Mexico City and a student at UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism. [“An IRS Regulation Offers a New Weapon Against Mexican Drug Cartels”, Texas Observer, 01-04-2013,. Accessed 07-03-2023.]
Starting next year, the U.S. government might have a more effective way to catch money launderers than leaks from bitter ex-spouses. A new IRS regulation that goes into effect this month could be a powerful tool in trying to stop illegal money from making its way to U.S. bank vaults. Although it was originally designed to fight offshore tax evasion, not combat organized crime, the regulation would force banks to strengthen their “know your customer” policies and shut their doors to money launderers like Fernando Cano. Cano’s case joins a list of recent U.S. money-laundering investigations involving Mexican organized crime. These cases leave no doubt that American banks are the preferred choice for deadly drug cartels like Los Zetas. Founded by former elite Mexican military deserters, Los Zetas is now one of the most dangerous criminal organizations in the Western Hemisphere. The cartel is notorious for its gruesome tactics: bombings of public venues, beheadings and videotaped torture.
Despite its barbaric nature, Los Zetas is principally an enterprise seeking to increase its profits.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › IL --- Cartels
IRS 04-30-2021 [“Sinaloa Cartel Leader Convicted”, IRS,
. Accessed 07-03-2023.]//ahcchs
SAN DIEGO — Sinaloa Cartel leader Ismael Zambada-Imperial, aka "Mayito Gordo," pleaded guilty in federal court today to drug trafficking charges following his extradition to the Southern District of California in December 2019. He also agreed to forfeit $5 million in drug trafficking proceeds. Zambada-Imperial pleaded guilty to all charges in a superseding indictment returned by a federal grand jury in San Diego on July 25, 2014. The indictment also charges his father, the alleged leader of the cartel, Ismael Zambada-García, known as "El Mayo;" as well as another son of El Mayo, Ismael Zambada-Sicairos, known as "Mayito Flaco;" and Ivan Archivaldo Guzmán-Salazar, known as "Chapito," whose father Joaquín "El Chapo" Guzmán Loera was the former leader of the Sinaloa Cartel along with Mayo. Zambada-Imperial was arrested by Mexican authorities in November 2014. Zambada-García, Zambada-Sicairos, and Guzmán-Salazar remain fugitives. In a proceeding today before U.S. District Judge Dana M. Sabraw, Zambada-Imperial accepted responsibility for his role as a leader within the Sinaloa Cartel, acknowledging that he organized the transportation and distribution of thousands of kilograms of controlled substances, including cocaine, heroin, and marijuana for importation from Mexico into the United States. Zambada-Imperial also admitted to directing acts of violence for the purpose of promoting the Sinaloa Cartel's narcotics trafficking activities. A sentencing hearing is scheduled for April 29, 2022 at 2 p.m. before Judge Sabraw. "Zambada-Imperial's guilty plea today sends a message to other drug kingpins operating in Mexico. There is no place to hide because our law enforcement partners will find you and work tirelessly to bring you to justice in the United States," said Acting U.S. Attorney Randy S. Grossman. "Our investigation and prosecution of other high-level Sinaloa Cartel members is continuing and is having a significant impact on the global operations of the cartel." Grossman praised Assistant U.S. Attorney Matthew J. Sutton, DEA agents and all law enforcement partners for their excellent work on this case. "Because of the dedication and determination of the DEA and our law enforcement partners, today we are one step closer towards dismantling the violent Sinaloa Cartel with the guilty plea of a Sinaloa Cartel leader," said DEA Special Agent in Charge John W. Callery. "The DEA remains confident that we will capture the remaining fugitives of this investigation and bring them to justice, along with many additional members of the Sinaloa Cartel. If the public has any information on the whereabouts of these fugitives or information on the Sinaloa cartel, we urge you to contact the DEA at 858-616-4100." The Southern District of California prosecution in this case is part of a multi-year investigation that, in total, has resulted in charges against over 125 people and has had a significant impact on the worldwide operations of the Sinaloa Cartel. This investigation has also offered one of the most comprehensive views to date of the inner workings of one of the world's most prolific, violent and powerful drug cartels. Cartel members and associates were targeted in this massive investigation involving multiple countries, numerous law enforcement agencies around the United States, a number of federal districts and over 250 court-authorized wiretaps in this district alone.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › --xt: Fraud Key
Gordon 3, Professor of Economic Crime Programs Executive Director of the Economic Crime Institute Utica College, et al (Gary, “Identity Fraud: A Critical National and Global Threat,” Economic Crime Initiative, http://www.lexisnexis.com/presscenter/hottopics/ECIReportFINAL.pdf0
Identity theft has been at the forefront as a societal problem for several years. The public has been made aware of the dangers of identity theft, particularly to personal and financial security. Many studies have been completed concerning the size and scope of victimization. The government, credit card and other financial service industries have responded by putting tighter controls in place. On the other hand, the insidious threat of identity fraud has not been similarly acknowledged. Both the public and private sectors must understand and confront the enormity of the identity fraud problem so that it can be solved. Identity fraud, which encompasses identity theft, is the use of false identifiers, false or fraudulent documents, or a stolen identity in the commission of a crime. It often emanates from a breeder document created from fictitious or stolen identifiers. The breeder document, such as a driver’s license or birth certificate, is used to spawn other documents, resulting in the creation of a credible identity which allows a criminal or terrorist access to credit cards, employment, bank accounts, secure facilities, computer systems, and the like. Once a criminal or terrorist has an established identity, he can use it to facilitate a variety of economic crimes, drug trafficking, terrorism, and other crimes. At one time, not that many years ago, a breeder document, such as a driver’s license, meant something; it could be used to establish a person’s identity with little or no question. Now, technology has enabled criminals to produce fraudulent documents, which can be used to procure additional fraudulent documents. Counterfeit documents, such as credit cards, used to be easily detectable; now it is relatively easy to produce a counterfeit hologram that usually passes for the real thing. Counterfeit documents are now readily available to illegal immigrants, drug traffickers, and international terrorists. Technology and the ability of the criminal element to adapt and defeat existing identification methodologies, predicated on breeder documents that are susceptible to counterfeiting, have made it necessary to develop different, more advanced identity authentication systems. Identity fraud is a component of almost every major crime and its presence is felt throughout the world. Therefore, it is absolutely essential that the importance of identity authentication is recognized whenever the potential result of misidentification is the commission or perpetuation of criminal activity. Government and industry leadership is necessary to facilitate the development of policies and technological tools that will assure accurate identity authentication.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › --xt: Fraud Key
Perri 10, J.D., CFE, CPA(Frank, “The Fraud-Terror Link: Terrorists are Committing Fraud to Fund Their Activities,” Fraud Magazine, )
The threat of terrorism has become the principal security concern in the United States since 9/11. Some might perceive that fraud isn’t linked to terrorism because white-collar crime issues are more the province of organized crime, but that perception is misguided. Terrorists derive funding from a variety of criminal activities ranging in scale and sophistication – from low-level crime to organized narcotics smuggling and fraud. CFEs need to know the latest links between fraud and terror. Credit card fraud, wire fraud, mortgage fraud, charitable donation fraud, insurance fraud, identity theft, money laundering, immigration fraud, and tax evasion are just some of the types of fraud commonly used to fund terrorist cells. Such groups will also use shell companies to receive and distribute illicit funds. On the surface, these companies might engage in legitimate activities to establish a positive reputation in the business community. Financing is required not just to fund specific terrorist operations but to meet the broader organizational costs of developing and maintaining a terrorist organization and to create an enabling environment necessary to sustain their activities. The direct costs of mounting individual attacks have been relatively low considering the damage they can yield. “Part of the problem is that it takes so little to finance an operation,” said Gary LaFree, director of the University of Maryland’s National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism. For example, the 2005 London bombings cost about $15,600.3 The 2000 bombing of the USS Cole is estimated to have cost between $5,000 and $10,000.4 Al-Qaida’s entire 9/11 operation cost between $400,000 and $500,000, according to the final report of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States.5 Terrorist groups require significant funds to create and maintain an infrastructure of organizational support, sustain an ideology of terrorism through propaganda, and finance the ostensibly legitimate activities needed to provide a veil of legitimacy for their shell companies.6 However, don’t think that only large operations are needed for terrorists to carry out attacks; small semi-autonomous cells in many countries are often just as capable of conducting disruptive activities without extensive outside financial help – they just conduct smaller-scale frauds.7 Even though the nexus between fraud and terrorism is undisputed, there’s concern at state and local levels that law enforcement professionals lack specialized knowledge on how to detect the fraud-terror link because they’re more apt to investigate and prosecute violent crimes.8 A critical lack of awareness about terrorists’ links to fraud schemes is undermining the fight against terrorism. Fraud analysis must be central, not peripheral, in understanding the patterns of terrorist behavior.9
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- Strong/credible IRS is key to the economy
NBC NEWS May 5, 2023, 9:25 AM CDT ( Flush with cash, the IRS is offering a more accurate picture of when the U.S. will hit debt ceiling)
That big that Congress approved last year to shape up the beleaguered IRS is having an unexpected side benefit. The has helped the agency to catch up on processing new and backlogged tax returns. And that, in turn, has allowed federal bean-counters to give policymakers a more precise picture of when the Treasury could run out of money — the — if the government isn’t able to take on more debt. The nation is stepping uncomfortably close to an unprecedented default that could have catastrophic effects on the global economy because it is bumping up against its legal limit for borrowing. Congress and the White House have been unable to agree on a plan to lift or suspend the borrowing limit. The debt covers the gap between revenues collected by the government and the programs, projects and services it provides. In the meantime, the Treasury is using “extraordinary measures” to keep the U.S. from running out of cash. The X-date arrives when Treasury has exhausted those accounting workarounds. Nina Olson, a former head of the Office of the Taxpayer Advocate, said the latest X-date calculation, provided through IRS data, offers a contrast to how underfunded the agency was in previous years. During the pandemic, the IRS was so backlogged that it was still processing 2020 returns at the start of 2022. “They have a better picture of what receipts will be,” Olson said. IRS and Treasury spokespeople declined to comment. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen informed Congress this week that the U.S. could default on its debt as early as June 1, if lawmakers do not raise or suspend the nation’s borrowing authority. That same day, the Congressional Budget Office reported that it, too, was able to zero in on a more accurate X-date because the IRS is “processing tax returns more rapidly than it did last year.” Tax and policy experts say the up-to-date IRS data is invaluable to understanding the nation’s financial position as the debate over whether to raise the debt ceiling drags on. “That, in combination with less-than-expected receipts through April, means that the Treasury’s extraordinary measures will be exhausted sooner than we previously projected,” CBO Director The X-date is typically not a specific date — it’s a time range. That’s because it reflects not just the money coming into the government, but the cash that goes out. Even if the government has a better sense of tax revenues, it could have to reimburse a state government, pay a contractor or face expenses that make the X-date a moving target. Natasha Sarin, a Yale Law School professor who previously worked as a counselor for Yellen on IRS issues, said the latest tax data reveals the “tremendous uncertainty that exists in determining the precise X-date.” The CBO, Moody’s Analytics and the private Bipartisan Policy Center all try to calculate the time frame for potential default using data on government cash flows and changes in debt. But even their leaders say that no one knows exactly when the X-date could arrive. That depends on the billions of dollars flowing in and out of federal coffers all the time. Mark Zandi, chief economist of Moody’s Analytics, said Thursday at a that he estimates the X-date to fall around June 8. The closer the nation gets to potential default, the more perilous the nation’s financial standing and the more accurate X-date forecasts become, economists say. President Joe Biden has to the White House on Tuesday for talks — signaling the growing fears of a default. Daleep Singh, who served as deputy national security adviser earlier in the Biden administration, said the new tax data gives credibility to Treasury’s most recent assessment of the projected default date. He called the debt ceiling brinkmanship a national security issue, especially as the U.S. government’s relationship becomes more strained with China, as a major creditor holding U.S. debt. “This is a matter affecting our financial stability,” he said. ”If we commit an unforced error, we’re handing a gift to our adversaries.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- Strong/credible IRS is key to the economy
Jacob Bogage August 6, 2022 at 6:00 a.m. EDT(RM)
A newly empowered Internal Revenue Service is one of the keys to the sweeping climate, health care and tax bill Senate Democrats hope to pass this week — with billions of dollars in new funds for the agency so it can collect money for the federal government by going after higher-income tax cheats. The bill, known as the Inflation Reduction Act, would put $80 billion toward beefing up the IRS, in line with liberals’ long-term goals to strengthen tax collection and enforcement on corporations and high-income earners, while relieving low-income taxpayers of cumbersome and frightening audits. Some of the additional revenue would go to pay for the largest-ever U.S. investment in clean energy technology. The idea is that the government could brings[s] in more money by examining corporate and high-income returns than it does by pursuing lower- or middle-income taxpayers who make mistakes on their returns or underpay their taxes by small amounts. The IRS in recent years has grown more dependent on those types of audits because they are relatively inexpensive: They’re automated, and they preserve the agency’s limited personnel resources. But they also mostly fall on taxpayers who can’t afford to fight back by spending hours on the phone with the tax agency or hiring lawyers. The result is that the IRS’s prolific enforcement capabilities — which bring in on average better than $10 in revenue for every $1 spent pursuing audits — are often trained on the most economically vulnerable taxpayers. More than half of the agency’s audits in 2021 were directed at taxpayers with incomes less than $75,000, according to IRS data. More than 4 in 10 of its audits targeted recipients of the earned income tax credit, one of the country’s main anti-poverty measures. Congress and the White House, when led by Republicans, have starved the IRS of resources for so long, experts say, that even with an influx of $80 billion in new funding, the agency’s ability to transform itself is far from assured. Some of its main computers still run on programming language that dates to the 1960s, called COBOL, the IRS has repeatedly told policymakers. The program is so old that college computer science courses rarely teach it anymore, forcing the IRS to spend heavily on training new hires in antiquated systems. The IRS has 60 discrete case management systems that do not communicate with one another. Its staffing levels have dropped by 17 percent since 2010, including a 30 percent decline in enforcement employees, because its budget has flatlined: Adjusted for inflation, its annual appropriation from Congress is down 12 percent over the same span, at $12.6 billion this year. “Part of this is not expecting miraculous rates of return. It’s about stopping the decline,” said Douglas Holtz-Eakin, president of the conservative think tank American Action Forum and a former director of the Congressional Budget Office. Republican lawmakers have bashed the legislation — which would be a signature achievement of President Biden’s first term — by claiming that a reinvigorated IRS would use its new resources to go after middle-class and poor Americans. Lobbyists are rushing to influence the Democrats' climate and health care bill Speaking at a news conference Wednesday, Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.), the head of the Senate Republican Conference, said the proposed spending would “put the IRS on steroids” and in total amounted to about “a million per IRS agent.” “You don’t need that many IRS agents to go after a few people they say are very, very rich,” Barrasso said, adding that it would hit “families, farmers and the small businesses of Americans, that’s who’s going to bear the burden of this legislation.” “This is an agency that only succeeded in answering about one out of every 50 phone calls during the 2021 tax season,” Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) said on the Senate floor Tuesday. “Yet 4 percent of the $80 billion is going to taxpayer services; 57 percent goes to enforcement, so that the IRS can spend more time harassing taxpayers around this country.” But experts say that’s a condition brought about largely by GOP policies, which drove the IRS into more audits of poorer taxpayers by depriving the agency of the resources it would have taken to go after wealthier targets who shelter potentially much higher sums. IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig wrote to lawmakers on Thursday that his agency was committed to upping enforcement “in areas of challenge for the agency — large corporate and global high-net-worth taxpayers.” He added, “These resources are absolutely not about increasing audit scrutiny on small businesses or middle-income Americans.” Rettig was appointed by President Donald Trump in 2018 after a career as a tax attorney in Beverly Hills, Calif. His term expires in November, and the Biden administration has been exploring other possible candidates for the role, people familiar with the matter told The Washington Post last month, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss private talks. Sanders grapples with missed opportunity in Democrats’ economic plan Without question, the proposed funding will help the IRS collect more revenue. An analysis conducted by the Congressional Budget Office, the legislature’s nonpartisan bookkeeper, found the IRS provisions would knock $203 billion off the federal deficit, far more than what Democrats expected when they introduced the bill. Of the $80 billion total allotment to the tax agency, $45.6 billion will go to enforcement, marking a projected return-on-investment of $4.50 in revenue for every dollar spent on enforcement. Experts say that figure — which is much lower than what the IRS typically brings in — has two potential explanations. The first is that it could simply be a conservative estimate; with resources to hire hundreds, if not thousands, of employees, the agency could significantly exceed its revenue projections by both pursuing more tax cheats and by improving taxpayer services to make it easier for Americans to voluntarily comply with the tax code. “If you are able to bring on a cadre of people who are really thinking forward … if they’re able to bring on the technology that allows them to bring on some of the data that they already have, that would have a compliance effect and help them going forward,” said Nina Olson, who served as national taxpayer advocate, the IRS’s internal consumer rights watchdog, from 2001 to 2019. “That would help, and I hope that’s what they’re planning to do.” The second explanation, experts say, is that cracking down on higher-income taxpayers comes with diminishing returns — even if the amount of money involved is potentially far larger. Rich people who file complex returns have access to accountants and lawyers who can fight the IRS’s enforcement mechanisms, or at least draw the process out over years. Even when the IRS is able to collect from those types of taxpayers, it will have expended lots of resources in the process. “That’s not an effective place to go raise revenue,” Holtz-Eakin said, even if having an enforcement presence among the wealthy is important to maintain fairness.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- IRS is key to fight Climate Change
Evergreen Action, 23 (6-22-2023, Evergreen Action, How IRS Could Make or Break Clean Energy, 7-3-2023, ) //shelbor
The fate of hundreds of millions of tons of carbon pollution is hidden in a technical IRS decision coming this summer on the Inflation Reduction Act’s (IRA) clean hydrogen tax credit. If IRS folds to industry pressure, it will increase carbon pollution, undermine the future of a truly clean hydrogen industry in the US, and do enormous damage to the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) critical carbon pollution standards before they can even be finalized. Will death and taxes come for the grid? It’s time for the Biden administration to make sure that IRS does not undercut our race for clean energy. And they need to hear from you. The stakes are high, and polluters would prefer the public get lost in the details. Instead, let’s take a look at the pollution hidden in the fine print—and why it’s not too late to stop it. What is clean hydrogen? As leading advocates from NRDC and Energy Innovation have been pointing out for months, at stake is a lucrative and uncapped tax credit from the Inflation Reduction Act for producing clean hydrogen. Hydrogen is a potent fuel that can be burned without greenhouse gas emissions—and therefore could be used to cut carbon pollution from sources that burn fuel if it is also produced without increasing emissions. However right now, most hydrogen is produced through a dirty refinery process using fossil fuel-heated steam to break apart molecules of fossil gas—a process known as “steam methane reforming.” We don’t need more of that. Blog Post Image - Infographic (Good IRS Guidance) IRS has broad technical and legal authority to ensure that the IRA tax credit only goes toward subsidizing clean hydrogen. In contrast, clean hydrogen comes from using renewable power to split apart water molecules through a process known as electrolysis, using a unit called an electrolyzer—avoiding fossil fuel use altogether. This clean hydrogen can then be used to replace fossil fuels in high-heat industrial processes like steel-making or in power plants. The challenge is that it takes a lot of electricity to produce hydrogen, so the electricity powering this process has to come from clean, carbon-free sources in order for the hydrogen to be truly clean energy. To address this dilemma, the tax credit from the IRA increases as emissions from production decrease to favor production with clean electricity that does not spur emissions increases on the grid. This means more public money from our country’s biggest climate bill is directed to the products that are the best for our climate. So, with a process that is extremely energy intensive and hundreds of billion dollars or more of funding at stake, the consequences of what counts as "clean" hydrogen are astronomical. And IRS is in the process of issuing guidance to answer that question now. Determining what counts as “clean” is trickier than it sounds. Our power grid gets electricity from a mixture of fossil fuel gas, coal plants, and renewable energy sources. When there are surges in demand, the grid meets these needs by triggering production in the cheapest available (or “marginal”) source. This is not generally not the cleanest source, and almost always comes from a methane gas power plant. Blog Post Image - Electrolyzer In order for hydrogen to be truly clean energy, electrolyzers (pictured above) must be powered by carbon-free sources. (© 2021 Sunfire/Flickr CC BY-ND 2.0) That’s a big problem. The potentially hundreds of electrolyzers needed to keep up with the demand for clean hydrogen will require a tremendous amount of electricity. But if this electricity is coming from dirty methane gas, what is allegedly “clean” hydrogen can produce massive carbon pollution each time an electrolyzer switches on, thus undercutting the benefits of the fuel they are making. In fact, the potential demand for power from a growing hydrogen industry, underwritten by what could be a hundred billion dollars in taxpayer money, could actually increase grid emissions by hundreds of millions of tons of carbon dioxide, according to some expert estimates. Three things IRS must consider in its clean hydrogen production credit guidance It would be absurd if IRS misinterpreted the IRA, a climate law, and poured public money into making the climate worse. That’s why advocates, including our colleagues at NRDC and Energy Innovation, and several companies and industry groups are calling for IRS to implement “three pillars” in its guidance to ensure that hydrogen does not undercut our race to clean energy: 1. New clean supply or additionality: Electrolyzers should be powered by new clean energy that is not already on the grid. (Buying credits from existing clean energy doesn’t cut it because that can just shuffle power around the grid without actually decreasing climate pollution—the marginal gas plant just powers another user.) 2. Deliverability: Electrolyzers should use local sources of clean electricity that are physically delivered to them by facilities in their region of the grid. (In short, facilities can’t claim credits from a part of the grid that isn’t reacting to their facility’s demand.) 3. Hourly time-matching: Electrolyzers must run during the same hours as the clean electricity is being generated. (This prevents facilities from buying solar energy credits while running a plant overnight on fossil gas.) If IRS fails to require any one of these three pillars, we’re setting up fake “clean” hydrogen that is actually massively increasing power generation from fossil fuels, sending emissions sky-rocketing. Because power plants are often located in lower-income or minority communities as a result of decades of racist planning, that result would not just be terrible climate news—it’s a civil rights nightmare in stark tension with the President’s environmental justice initiatives. IRS Can't Undercut Our Race for Clean Energy The fate of half a billion tons of carbon pollution is hidden in an IRS decision on the IRA’s hydrogen tax credits. Enter your information and we'll help you submit a public comment to IRS to stop dirty hydrogen from derailing the clean energy transition. Email Address* ZIP Code* SUBMIT A COMMENT These pillars are not new. They are accounting principles that are rapidly becoming a norm, mirroring trends in voluntary clean energy procurement, requirements in the European Union and Colorado’s new hydrogen tax credit, and which can deploy tracking tools already used in major power grids. But it should be no surprise that the dirtier parts of the power industry and some hydrogen developers—who would like the public’s climate money with no strings attached—are filling up IRS docket with claims that it is just too hard to make sure this new industry isn’t just greenwashing. In the face of the potential for creating hundreds of millions of tons of excess climate pollution, with public money that is supposed to reduce climate pollution, some members of the power industry will continue to argue that it’s too expensive to build electrolyzers truly tied to clean energy, the grid is slowly cleaning up anyway, and we should just get started without all these “requirements.” But we have seen this movie before. When the government funds a whole new industry without proper safeguards, it’s easy to turn a “half-measure” into the forever “solution,” raking in public funds and polluting along the way. We’ve seen crop-based biofuels touted as gasoline replacements that turned out to be a climate disaster, fossil gas supposedly acting as a “bridge fuel” from coal power plants but actually spewing heavily-polluting super-pollutant methane—all while gas utilities illegally spend public funds to lobby against electrification and waste gas trucks that were supposed to replace diesel actually pollute more than the trucks they replaced. The Biden administration should know better than spending billions to create another dirty industry spewing malarkey. The power doom loop: How the decision from IRS profoundly impacts carbon pollution Not only can a bad IRS choice spike grid climate pollution on its own, but it can also tank the President’s climate legacy—by badly damaging his critical power plant carbon pollution standards with a spiraling doom loop in which the standards themselves can fail to cut power sector carbon pollution. That’s because those standards (as a result of the limitations placed on the EPA by the Supreme Court’s terrible West Virginia v EPA decision) must be based on technology that power plants can install on site. As such, EPA has proposed standards based on the potential to install either carbon capture technology or to co-fire fossil fuels with hydrogen in power plants. As a result, it matters enormously, what kind of hydrogen those retrofitted and new facilities use. Now, it’s true that the way the standards are set isn’t necessarily how they will be implemented—and advocates should continue to work both to strengthen the standards and to ensure that states opt to replace polluting facilities with renewable energy rather than costly retrofits. But some facilities still may burn hydrogen to comply with EPA’s standards. Blog Post Image - Infographic (Power Doom Loop) Co-firing hyodrgen that is produced with fossil fuel power overall results in increasing carbon emissions. If that happens and IRS fails to make sure that hydrogen is truly clean, we’re in a doom loop: The EPA standards draw increased demand for hydrogen. Hydrogen production raises the demand for power. That power demand is met by fossil fuel plants, which are now more profitable and operate longer, as a result of all that extra demand. The more power they produce, the more their owners need hydrogen—which is produced from a grid that remains dirty and will stay dirty, as a result of the doom loop. And downward we spiral, with dirty hydrogen driving demand for dirty marginal gas plants and prolonging their pollution. EPA knows this. In fact, in their proposed rule (page 76, to be precise), EPA is very clear that only “low-GHG hydrogen” works to break us out of the doom loop. As the agency puts it: “Co-firing hydrogen at combustion turbines when that hydrogen is produced with large amounts of GHG emissions would ultimately result in increasing overall GHG emissions, compared to combusting solely natural gas at the combustion turbine.” In a bit of classic agency deadpan, the proposal explains that spiking climate pollution with a climate pollution control would be an “anomalous result.” That’s quite an “anomaly”: the climate pollution standards would cut between 600 million metric tons to a billion metric tons of CO2, while high-carbon hydrogen could emit hundreds of millions of metric tons—raising climate pollution at comparable scale at which EPA is trying to lower them. Now, these systems are complex, so there’s not an apples-to-apples comparison, but the risk is clear. Depending on how fast the doom loop spins, IRS could slow EPA’s sprint against climate pollution to a crawl or even make it run in place. But EPA would have to struggle mightily to break out of the doom loop on its own. Only IRS can set the standard for what counts as clean hydrogen under the 45V tax credit. Though EPA is proposing to set its own regulatory definitions for its rules, those definitions, even if finalized, would be up against billions of dollars flowing the wrong way from IRS if 45V goes wrong. If IRS folds, EPA will be standing alone against a tide of dirty hydrogen with limited tools at its disposal. In that scenario, we’ll all need to support EPA efforts to limit the damage—but EPA shouldn’t have to start deep in a hole created by another federal agency, and the White House has a chance, now, to make sure IRS is pulling for the team. Power cycle: IRS’ pathway to keep hydrogen clean A better future is possible. IRS has broad technical and legal authority to adopt the “three pillars” in their guidance, ensuring that the IRA tax credit only goes toward subsidizing truly clean hydrogen. And if they do, we could see a world in which the hydrogen industry helps fund a cleaner, greener, power grid. In that world, not only do the ever-fewer power plants burning hydrogen use truly clean fuel, but there will be fewer combustion facilities because more renewable energy will also come online. In that world, clean hydrogen means more renewables; more renewables mean less “marginal” gas power and less coal, and less gas and coal mean ever cleaner hydrogen that can be used where it’s actually needed. That’s a world in which fossil plants retire, consistent with environmental justice and climate needs, and where truly clean hydrogen helps us clean up other hard-to-decarbonize industrial sectors. A virtuous cycle, not a doom loop. Which path will we choose? That comes down to the Biden administration’s IRS and to public pressure. It’s time to see the threat lurking in those tax policy weeds, to make sure IRS supports the EPA rather than blowing up the President’s pollution-cutting legacy, and for the Biden administration to make sure we’re power-cycling forward. It’s not too late; tell President Biden and IRS today to “follow the three pillars and keep hydrogen clean.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- IRS is key to fight Climate Change
Bravender, 22 (10-17-2022, Robin Bravender, E&E News by POLITICO, The surprising new climate agency, 7-3-2023, ) //shelbor
The IRS is a climate agency now. The massive climate and energy law enacted by Democrats in August puts the IRS at the forefront of the effort to incentivize renewable energy across the economy. Of the nearly $370 billion of climate spending in the new law, about $270 billion will be delivered through tax incentives for electric vehicles, energy-efficient buildings, solar power and other “clean” energy technologies. That means the success of the law — and the Biden administration’s ability to achieve its climate goals — will hinge in part on the work of a beleaguered agency that’s sprinting to staff up as it implements the new law. But Republicans are already campaigning against an emboldened IRS, and they’ve pledged that slashing its funding will be a top priority if they take control on Capitol Hill next year. Advertisement “The IRS is at the center of it because the way that you get this cash that the federal government has basically earmarked for all these things is through tax credits and benefits that you get when you file your tax return,” said Lauren Collins, a partner at Vinson & Elkins LLP who specializes in renewable energy. This isn’t totally uncharted territory for the IRS, which has long been central to the government’s efforts to subsidize favored industries and energy types through the tax code, Collins said. What’s different this time is the massive scale of federal investments under the law Democrats have dubbed the Inflation Reduction Act. “It has taken what we’ve always done and just hyped it up, turned the dial up to 11,” Collins said. “Now we have tax benefits for a gazillion different renewable technologies, climate-benefiting programs, green manufacturing, domestic manufacturing, electric vehicles, the list goes on.” The IRS and its parent agency — the Treasury Department — are hustling to put policies in place so businesses and consumers can understand and take advantage of them. “I am proud that the Treasury Department will be at the forefront of implementing our economic and climate plan,” Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said in a September speech at a North Carolina solar company. Senior officials from the Treasury and the White House recently announced an effort to encourage the public to weigh in on their policies as they’re being drafted (Greenwire, Oct. 5). “We’re committed to ensuring that as many eligible taxpayers as possible get credits provided by law, while carefully protecting against fraud and abuse,” Deputy Treasury Secretary Wally Adeyemo told reporters earlier this month. It’s a big new workload at an agency reeling from budget and staffing cuts in recent years. The IRS’s budget in 2021 was 19 percent below what it was in 2010, when adjusted for inflation, according to an analysis by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. The agency’s staff was reduced by about 22 percent during that time. The IRS has struggled to answer phone calls and efficiently process tax returns, according to a June report released by an independent watchdog within the agency. During the 2022 filing season, the IRS received about 73 million telephone calls, the report said. Only one in 10 of those calls reached an IRS employee. Democrats are attempting to revitalize the IRS with an infusion of new cash under the Inflation Reduction Act. The new legislation gives the IRS about $80 billion over the next decade for expenses like enforcement and taxpayer assistance. The cash influx was welcome news for the agency. IRS Commissioner Chuck Rettig said in August that the new law marks a “transformational moment” for the agency, which “has struggled for many years with insufficient resources to fulfill our important mission.” Rettig, a Trump appointee, is nearing the end of his five-year term heading the IRS, and Biden could soon name a replacement, causing a leadership change at the agency that employs about 80,000 staffers. Meanwhile, Republicans have seized on the specter of a beefed-up IRS to campaign against Democrats in this fall’s midterm elections. If they’re successful in winning control of the House or the Senate, they would gain more power to investigate the IRS and its role in implementing the climate law. They would also have more leverage to try to slash the agency’s funding during budget negotiations. House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) warned that the new law “hires an army of 87,000 IRS agents to harass working Americans.” McCarthy also said that if Republicans win the House, their first piece of legislation would be a bill to repeal the $80 billion in new IRS funding. The administration and its allies accuse the GOP of spreading misinformation about its plans to staff up the IRS. Some of the GOP claims are “outlandish and even irresponsible and dangerous,” said Seth Hanlon, a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress who served in the Obama White House National Economic Council. Yellen has promised to use new funding to improve customer service at the IRS. Adeyemo said earlier this month that much of the new money will help to restock personnel lost over recent decades and to replace retiring staffers. A major chunk of the cash, he said, will go toward modernizing outdated technologies. “That will allow us to provide benefits to individuals but also to companies better going forward,” Adeyemo said. “And the first area of focus is going to be on these climate provisions.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- IRS is key to fight Climate Change
Joel Michaels, 22 (10-19-2022, Joel Michaels, American Prospect, Will the Green Transition Build Worker Power? The IRS Will Help Decide., 7-3-2023, ) //shelbor
Democrats’ Inflation Reduction Act, passed in August, is the United States’ biggest-ever investment in fighting climate change. Congress designed this legislation with an expansive vision for what a green economy should look like, funneling resources toward creating well-paying jobs in communities that may be hardest-hit by the transition away from fossil fuels. But congressional intentions don’t implement themselves. The Treasury Department and IRS are about to issue regulations setting rules for the tax credits in the legislation. This technical exercise will have vast consequences for whether federal investments end up in the pockets of workers—or of Wall Street investors. Of the Inflation Reduction Act’s estimated $369 billion in investments in combating climate change, a large majority—at least $270 billion—will take the form of forgone revenue through tax concessions. These include incentives for generating renewable electricity; credits for installing electric-vehicle charging stations, and deductions for building energy-efficient commercial buildings. Because many of these tax credits are “uncapped”—they can be claimed by anyone who is eligible, without limit—many analysts think that these cost estimates by the Congressional Budget Office are dramatic underestimates. Total climate spending under the IRA could be upward of $800 billion, catalyzing $1.7 trillion in private investments in green technologies, according to analysts at the investment bank Credit Suisse. This technical exercise will have vast consequences for whether federal investments end up in the pockets of workers—or of Wall Street investors. Congress attached strings to these tax giveaways so that the forgone revenue enables good-quality jobs. To take full advantage of the incentives, companies must ensure that 10 to 15 percent of construction work is done by apprentices learning new skills, enabling them to find full-time work in that industry. And they must pay all laborers and mechanics minimum prevailing wages set by the Department of Labor—which are soon to be substantially raised through new DOL regulations. If companies don’t meet these high labor standards, they are only eligible for one-fifth of the tax credit or deduction. Congress is also using tax credits to steer money toward U.S. manufacturing, and the communities hard-hit by the energy transition. Firms get extra tax credits if they use materials built in the United States to build green generation facilities. And companies generating renewable energy can reduce their taxes further if they site new power generation on brownfield sites or higher-unemployment areas reliant on extraction and burning of fossil fuels. Collectively, these provisions represent a dramatic new vision for shared growth. The U.S. has always done industrial policy through the tax code. The fuel and R&D tax subsidies of yore, however, had no requirements for recipient companies to pay their workers a living wage. But whether this new vision will be successful is uncertain. Its success rests on how the Treasury and IRS write the regulations implementing Congress’s plan. The agencies want to issue these regulations expeditiously, pointing to guidance issued the same day that the IRA was passed as a model. These rules are urgently needed. But there are three major problems they will need to address. First, the agencies need to tailor eligibility criteria narrowly so that green-energy tax credits don’t subsidize activities that don’t actually reduce emissions. One of the few bipartisan features of the Trump-era tax cuts was a set of tax incentives for investments in low-income “Opportunity Zones.” But the IRS rules for designating such eligible zones were far too lax; the resulting investments were highly concentrated in real estate construction in rich cities. In implementing the IRA tax credits, Treasury has enormous discretion to decide what kinds of electricity generation facilities count as zero-emission. The agencies have stated that they see “effective guardrails and reporting” as key to the implementation of these tax credits—but it is not yet clear what standards they will use to make these necessary determinations. Second, the agencies need to make sure that companies claiming these tax credits actually meet the labor standards in the law. While there are penalties for failing to comply with these provisions, including pay restitution for workers, the IRS is dramatically underfunded, and it has limited capacity to audit companies suspected of cheating. Instead, the IRS needs to collect information at the time of tax filing about whether companies actually pay prevailing wages and hire the required apprentices. Finally, the agencies need to help make these provisions visible to the broader public, rather than just the accountants who prepare companies’ tax returns. Political scientists have highlighted the importance of “policy feedback loops” to successful government programs: Policies that are known and understandable to their beneficiaries are more likely to mobilize coalitions to strengthen those policies. As it stands, workers who benefit from better pay or greater demand for U.S.-made steel as a result of these provisions are far removed from corporate accounting departments. No one could blame them for failing to see this vision for inclusive growth buried deep in the tax code. The first problem is one for government lawyers. But the agencies should enlist workers and communities to address the issues of oversight and public awareness. Regulators should create tools for workers to easily check whether they’re being paid prevailing wages, and to notify the IRS if they are not. They should collaborate with labor unions to build network ties between apprenticeship programs, making sure that a company can’t weasel out of the requirement via an exemption in the law if the company can’t find apprentices to hire on the first try. And they should reach out to local governments and community groups in eligible “energy zones,” getting them to spread the word of the expanded tax credit opportunity, such as by working with local households and businesses to install solar panels on their properties. The Biden administration is eager to get these tax regulations out the door. They’re right to hurry: Many of the tax credits only go into effect 60 days after the rules are issued. But it is just as important to get the details right. The success of the green transition—and the broader democratic vision behind it—depends on it.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- IRS K2 Income Equality
Folley 23. Aris Folley is a congressional reporter for The Hill, where she closely covers the federal budget and the annual appropriations process. She also writes for The Hill’s Business & Economy newsletter. She began working at The Hill in 2018, after several years in journalism, spanning the likes of NBC News, Ebony and The Breakfast Club. She can often be found in the depths of Congress bugging lawmakers with questions … or tracking the latest on whenever Beyoncé is touring next. “CBO: GOP’s IRS bill will add $114B to deficit” . Accessed July 2nd 2023. -TP
The Republican proposal to eliminate billions of dollars in IRS funding will pile more than $100 billion onto federal deficits, according to a new estimate from Congress’s official budget scorekeeper. The bill, which is slated to hit the House floor Monday night as the first legislative act of the new GOP majority, would claw back most of the almost $80 billion in new IRS funding provided under the Democrats’ massive climate, health and tax package, which was signed by President Biden last year. Almost $46 billion of that spending would go toward agency enforcement efforts designed to prevent certain taxpayers — largely corporations and wealthy individuals — from paying less than they owe. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated Monday that the legislation would cut federal spending by $71 billion, but would reduce tax revenue to the tune of almost $186 billion. The net effect would be a $114 billion increase in deficits over the next decade. The numbers were not overlooked by Democrats, who wasted no time hammering Republicans for vowing to rein in deficit spending, then defying that promise in their first act of business. “It’s a giant tax cut for rich tax cheats,” White House chief of staff Ron Klain tweeted on Monday. “Bill #1 from the new House GOP. Adds to the deficit.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- IRS K2 Income Equality
Williamson 1/26/23. Vanessa Williamson is a Senior Fellow in Governance Studies at Brookings, and a Senior Fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. She studies taxation, redistribution, and political participation. “Cutting IRS funding is a gift to America’s wealthiest tax evaders” . Accessed July 2nd 2023. -TP
In their first act of legislative business, the new House Republican majority voted to cut funding for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The vote was a symbolic effort to repeal the $80 billion increase in funding the revenue agency received last year as part of the Inflation Reduction Act. Cutting IRS funding is a terrible idea. A well-funded IRS can distribute emergency aid quickly, serve taxpayers efficiently, and help ensure that millionaires have to follow the tax laws just like everyone else. It’s an essential investment in good government. The IRS has been persistently underfunded for decades, but the years since 2010 have been particularly tough. Tax law expert Chye-Ching Huang notes that the enforcement budget of the IRS dropped by nearly a quarter in less than ten years. In 2017, the IRS employed less than 10,000 revenue agents—the last time that was true was 1953: the Brooklyn Dodgers were in the World Series, the median housing price was about $8,000, and the IRS was handling over 100 million fewer individual income tax returns a year. The IRS is also “overwhelmingly reliant” on antiquated technology, the U.S. Taxpayer Advocate notes, “systems that are at least 25 years old, use obsolete programming languages (e.g., COBOL), or lack vendor support, training, or resources to maintain.” It is worth noting how much the IRS has managed to achieve despite its perpetually inadequate resources. When COVID struck, for example, only the IRS had the capacity to send millions of emergency checks to keep American households afloat. As my Tax Policy Center colleague Howard Gleckman has said, the IRS “did an extraordinary job in getting these checks out in very difficult circumstances.” But the budgetary toll of persistent underfunding is unmistakable. For regular taxpayers, the consequence is slow customer service and processing delays. Some politicians have irresponsibly suggested that every new IRS employee will be a gun-toting enforcement agent. Actually, the IRS desperately needs employees to process refunds and answer tax filers’ phone calls. Out of the 282 million phone calls the IRS received in 2021, only 11% or 32 million were actually answered. Nearly half the new IRS money is going to taxpayer services and modernization, which will make the agency more responsive and efficient for taxpayers. About $45 billion of the $80 billion in new funding is going to enforcement, and that is great news. For the wealthiest and most sophisticated tax filers, a cash-strapped IRS has meant a tax evasion free-for-all. Currently, the tax gap, which is the amount in taxes that are owed but not paid, comes to nearly $7 trillion over a decade. Three fifths of the tax gap is due to underreporting of income by the top 10% of taxpayers, and more than a quarter comes from the top 1%. But the IRS has been left without the resources to hire and support the kind of tax experts who can catch wealthy tax cheats. The lack of staff was highlighted recently when it was revealed that the audit of former president Donald Trump was staffed by exactly one revenue agent. But Trump wasn’t the only one whose taxes were going without thorough examination. Audits of millionaires have dropped 61% in less than a decade. For those making more than $5 million, the audit rate has dropped 87%. At the same time, responding to a push from Congress, the IRS has focused instead on a much cheaper form of audit, targeting recipients of the Earned Income Tax Credit—i.e. low-income, working families. As a result, the EITC recipients are audited at the same rate as the top 1% of earners. As law professor Dorothy Brown explains, the consequence of high levels of EITC audits is a serious racial disparity in tax policing. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has insisted that the new funding not be used to increase audit rates on those earning less than $400,000 a year. So, the new funding will help rebuild the capacity of the IRS to audit the wealthy, making the tax system far fairer. And, of course, closing the tax gap raises revenues—it’s a policy that more than pays for itself. The IRS investments are expected to raise $124 billion. The Republican effort to repeal the IRS’s $80 billion funding increase will not move forward in the Democrat-controlled Senate. But the IRS might yet see its funding decline, if the House Republicans negotiate a cut in the budget fights later this year. If that happens, it is bad news for the millions of American households who pay their taxes honestly, and great news for the country’s richest tax evaders. Funding the IRS will shore up an essential government service, making tax filing easier and tax enforcement fairer.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- IRS K2 Income Equality
Marr 7/12/22. Chuck Marr is the Vice President for Federal Tax Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. From 1999 through 2004, he was Economic Policy Advisor to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle and Senior Advisor for Budget Policy at the National Economic Council from 1997 through 1999 during the second term of President Clinton. Tax policy was a key area of responsibility in both these positions. In addition, earlier in his career he worked on the staffs of the Senate’s Budget and Banking committees. Prior to joining the Center in March of 2009, he was a senior political strategist in the Washington Research Group of Lehman Brothers and Barclays Capital, where he analyzed the impact of public policy on financial markets. He has also taught as an adjunct professor at Georgetown University. “Success of the IRS Rebuilding and Tax Gap Reduction Effort Depends on Sufficient Funding Through Annual Appropriations” . Accessed July 2nd 2023. -TP
Significant IRS funding boosts are necessary after a decade of steep cuts left the agency ill equipped to provide the customer service taxpayers deserve — 7 in 10 taxpayer phone calls went unanswered in 2019 — or to enforce the nation’s tax laws.The agency has fewer auditors who handle the most sophisticated tax returns than it has had since the early 1950s, when the economy was far smaller and less complex. This depletion of the audit staff comes at a time when an estimated $470 billion a year in legally owed taxes goes uncollected, disproportionately from high-income taxpayers.[2] Reports have shown how overmatched IRS staff is in detecting and countering tax evasion schemes of large corporations and the nation’s wealthiest.[3] The audit rates for millionaires and the largest corporations fell roughly 77 percent and 56 percent, respectively, between 2010 and 2017.[4] The Inflation Reduction Act’s funding will help the IRS fill its budget shortfall while offering a degree of certainty that will enable the agency to rebuild its depleted customer service capacity and make long-term investments in its decades-old computer systems, as well as to hire and train new staff who can conduct sophisticated audits of high-income and high-wealth tax evaders, so the agency can do more both to improve customer service and detect tax cheating. But these funds are designed to supplement and not to supplant the agency’s regular budget, which is set each year through the annual appropriations process. The ultimate success of this effort to rebuild the IRS, improve customer service, and reduce the tax gap hinges on what Congress does starting this December, when it is scheduled to set base funding for the IRS in fiscal year 2023. This two-pronged funding approach follows a successful model already in place in a program that targets Medicare and Medicaid fraud, and it recognizes the need for cooperation among congressional tax-writing and appropriations committees. When drafting the Inflation Reduction Act, the tax-writing committees — Senate Finance and House Ways and Means — understood the IRS’ needs stemming from its ten-year budget shortfall and provided funding to help fill that gap. The Senate and House Appropriations committees, meanwhile, need to continue to provide base funding each year in the appropriations process while also continuing their valuable advisory and oversight roles traditional to the annual appropriations process, as Treasury and the IRS submit detailed information required as part of their budget request for the agency. The Biden Administration’s request for base funding of $14.1 billion for 2023, up from the $12.6 billion enacted for the agency in 2022, is an encouraging sign for the success of this effort. It, along with the Inflation Reduction Act funding, would put the IRS budget close to the funding level that would have existed if not for the cuts that began in 2011, allowing the agency to keep up both with inflation and with the expanding scope of its work in an increasingly complex and global economy. The House and Senate appropriations bills each included $13.6 billion for the IRS, enough to keep pace with inflation over the past year. But the Administration’s request would put the IRS in a better position to fix major shortfalls, not just keep them from getting worse. And while some Republican lawmakers have made reckless statements regarding the agency’s rebuilding effort in recent months,[5] there’s also been bipartisan interest in ensuring the IRS can improve its enforcement function. The Trump Administration’s 2020 and 2021 budgets proposed additional funding “for new and continuing investments to expand and strengthen tax enforcement.”[6] And during negotiations over how to pay for proposed infrastructure legislation in 2021, a group of Senate Republicans supported a separate mandatory funding stream for the IRS to boost tax enforcement and reduce the tax gap.[7] In addition, key Republicans have made helpful observations noting the IRS’ inability to answer taxpayer phone calls.[8] The upcoming base funding appropriations deliberations provide the opportunity to address this problem through adequate customer service funding. At issue is whether policymakers will side with honest taxpayers and provide the resources the IRS needs to give taxpayers the customer service they deserve — including making it easier to file a tax return, answering taxpayer questions, and providing timely refunds — while ensuring that wealthy people and large corporations that may be inclined to game the tax system are paying the taxes they legally owe. If policymakers stay committed to the IRS rebuilding plan, the nation will have a fairer, more user-friendly, and responsive tax system, and the agency will be far better equipped to perform a basic function of government: to enforce the tax laws Congress enacts to raise the revenue to pay for our military, for key benefit programs such as Social Security, and for the rest of the federal government’s operations. Severely Depleted IRS Urgently Needs Rebuilding Appropriations for the IRS — referred to in this piece as “base funding” in contrast to the $80 billion of multi-year mandatory funding in the Inflation Reduction Act — were repeatedly cut in real terms over the last decade-plus and remain more than 20 percent below their 2010 level, after adjusting for inflation. As a result, the agency has been forced to cut more than a fifth of its staff.[9]
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › Turns Case --- IRS K2 Income Equality
Alston & Bird 2023. Alston & Bird LLP is an international law firm with over 800 lawyers in 13 offices throughout the United States, Europe, the UK, and Asia. The firm provides legal services to both domestic and international clients who conduct business worldwide. “IRS Prioritizes Enforcement Against High-Wealth Taxpayers in the Inflation Reduction Act Strategic Operating Plan” . Accessed July 2nd 2023.
The Inflation Reduction Act Strategic Operating Plan, released last week by the Internal Revenue Service, envisions a future of increased audits and penalties for family offices, high-wealth individuals, large partnerships, and large corporations. Our Federal Tax and Family Office Teams break down what high-income taxpayers can expect in light of the IRS’s new enforcement resources. $45.6 billion of the IRS’s funding under the Inflation Reduction Act has been earmarked for tax enforcement activities The IRA Strategic Plan explicitly prioritizes taxpayers with complex issues and tax returns High-income taxpayers should plan for more aggressive use of enforcement tools by the IRS Is a new tide of audits rolling in? Since 2021, the Biden Administration has been promising significant increases in funding of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS)—a promise furthered by Congress’s passage of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) in August 2022. Late last week, the IRS released its Inflation Reduction Act Strategic Operating Plan, outlining how the IRS plans to deploy the approximately $80 billion provided to it under the IRA. The Strategic Plan reiterates and expands the IRS’s stated enforcement priorities—namely, increased audit activity for family offices, high-wealth individual taxpayers, large partnerships, and large corporations. Background In August 2022, the enactment of the IRA provided a roughly $80 billion increase in IRS funding over the next 10 years. This followed years of significant backlog and underfunding at the IRS, which has left the IRS struggling to successfully manage processing tax returns and auditing taxpayers. Specifically, there has been a significant decline in audits of individuals in higher income brackets, with an 86% decrease in audit rates from 2010 to 2019 for those earning $5 million or more each year. $45.6 billion of the roughly $80 billion under the IRA has been earmarked for tax enforcement activities, such as hiring more enforcement agents, providing legal support to agents as they develop their cases, and investing in investigative technology to improve the IRS’s audit selection process. In many ways, additional IRS resources are sorely needed. In our experience over the past few years, audits have consisted of generally smaller teams with less experience and more time pressure. Complex issues that require intensive factual background and an individualized analysis have often been harder to resolve, because audit teams and appeals rely more on IRS guidance and templates, with less flexibility. The matters going into the IRS Office of Appeals and litigation often tend to be less developed. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has directed the IRS to use its new enforcement resources from the IRA to focus on “high-end noncompliance,” such as auditing more high-wealth individuals, large corporations, and complex pass-throughs. Yellen further directed the IRS not to increase audits of individuals and small businesses earning $400,000 per year or less. The increased IRA funding, however, is not free from controversy or political strife. Congressional Republicans, now in the majority in the House of Representatives, are determined to strip the IRS of its new funding under the IRA; for example, a bipartisan funding bill passed by Congress in December 2022 reduced the IRS’s annual appropriations by $275 million. The Strategic Plan Following the IRA’s passage, tax practitioners have been questioning how the IRS intends to use its additional enforcement dollars. The Strategic Plan explicitly prioritizes taxpayers with complex issues and tax returns when audit rates are minimal. The IRS has identified the following specific initiatives related to this objective: Expand enforcement for high-income and high-wealth individuals. The IRS will increase enforcement against these individuals and will make the necessary resources available to do so given the size and complex nature of these tax filings. The IRS will focus on hiring and training staff needed to achieve appropriate compliance coverage rates, including in the Independent Office of Appeals to resolve tax controversies and in the Office of Chief Counsel to support compliance and appeals and to litigate when necessary. The IRS will also refine its approaches to high-income and high-wealth enforcement, and it will use data analytics to explore new treatments and interventions to address potential noncompliance and to resolve noncompliance issues. Employ centralized, analytics-driven, risk-based methods in its selection of compliance cases. The IRS will establish a centralized function for compliance planning and strategy, build a unified compliance organization, establish a model for workforce allocation, centralize compliance analytics and models into one platform and develop a process for refining the platform, and improve its Whistleblower Program. Expand enforcement for large corporations and partnerships. The IRS will focus on hiring staff to achieve appropriate compliance coverage rates for large corporations and partnerships. It will also develop new compliance treatments for large partnerships and improve existing tools for auditing them. Expand enforcement in other areas. The IRS will hire staff to achieve appropriate compliance coverage in other needed areas, such as employment taxes, excise taxes, and estate and gift taxes. New enforcement approaches and compliance treatments will also be developed. Pursue enforcement for emerging issues. The IRS will mobilize resources, improve detection, establish response processes, and hire staff to increase enforcement related to high-risk issues such as digital assets transactions, listed transactions, and certain international issues. Promote fairness in enforcement. The IRS will develop procedures to regularly evaluate system fairness, improve enforcement practices to help ensure fairness, and hire staff to reach the goals. Takeaways Undoubtedly, family offices and high-wealth individuals can expect more aggressive and increased use by the IRS of its current enforcement tools, such as audits and penalties. Large partnerships and large corporations operating in multiple jurisdictions can expect similar treatment. These new initiatives build upon tools already in use by the IRS. For example, the IRS’s Criminal Investigative Division (CID) has pioneered the use of data analytics in identifying individuals for investigation and building cases against them, and the CID has been a leader in the exchange of information with international taxing authorities to coordinate enforcement efforts, particularly against high-net-worth individuals. With additional funding, the IRS intends to build upon this experience in the civil arena. Taxpayers under civil audit should expect that IRS examiners will have multiple new sources of information to draw from—with varying degrees of reliability. It is definitely a small world! Further, in focusing on high-wealth individuals, we would expect the IRS to draw upon its experience with the Global High Wealth Industry Group. This group was formed in 2009 as part of the Large Business and International Division of the IRS to address the high-wealth population. (A similar initiative, the High Income High Wealth Strategy, was implemented by the Small Business/Self-Employed Division in 2010 but was ultimately disbanded.) In our experience, in its early years, the Global High Wealth initiative faced challenges in identifying appropriate taxpayers for audit and effectively examining their returns, but all indications are that the IRS has learned from this history. In addition, the IRS is empowering its examiners to impose draconian penalties, which may result in audits becoming even more contentious and difficult to resolve. In April 2022, the IRS removed the requirement of executive approval for the assertion of economic substance penalties under 7701(o) of the Internal Revenue Code. Removing the requirement enables IRS auditors to assert these penalties more frequently, with only managerial approval required. High-income taxpayers of all stripes should plan for increased enforcement by anticipating potential issues and identifying expected areas of dispute. Developing an audit strategy and carefully documenting transactions will help prepare for potential IRS action
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › IL --- Strong IRS Key to Government Credibility/Democracy
Burke, 21 (6-1-2021, Henry Burke, Revolving Door Project, How Revitalizing the IRS Can Help Save Democracy, 7-2-2023, ) //shelbor
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is tasked with ensuring Americans follow tax laws. The IRS not only audits everyday Americans and foreign nationals with US tax liabilities but also maintains the power to investigate wealthy individuals and corporations for tax avoidance or other forms of malfeasance. Despite its crucial role in enforcing federal taxes laws (or, more aptly, because of this role), Republican austerity has systematically dismantled the IRS over the past decade. When accounting for inflation, the IRS has lost over $2 billion in annual funding between 2010 and 2020. The resulting loss of capacity not only has made it easier for the rich to avoid paying their taxes, it has also led to the disproportionate auditing of certain poor Americans. Importantly, however, the loss of capacity coupled with weak leadership has also created an effectively oversight-free environment for tax-exempt organizations and those institutions which apply for tax-exempt status. Rebuilding the IRS must be a priority for the Biden administration not only for the revenue it will generate but because of its role in protecting democracy. The IRS has suffered from a decline in full time staff in recent decades, experiencing a precipitous drop in staffing levels between fiscal year (FY) 2010 and FY 2019 when the agency lost a combined 29,618 full-time employees. Between FY 2018 and FY 2019 the IRS hired a scant net 1,593 employees, bringing the total number of full-time employees (including seasonal staff) to 78,004. This hiring did little to stem the loss of experienced IRS officers and agents, as the agency lost a significant portion over the same period. In the coming years, should trends continue, the IRS is expected to lose even more staff as a large portion of its aging staff nears retirement age. An examination in 2020 discovered that up to 31 percent of IRS employees were eligible to retire by 2024. The loss of these experienced auditors and agents will wreak more havoc than can be understood through pure staffing numbers, particularly on more complex financial audits, as the institution will be drained of experience in addition to staff. Further, the decline in IRS staffing and its diminished investigative capacity has been coupled with leadership intent on abdicating any responsibility to enforce US tax law, at least on those most intent to violate it. Under the leadership of Charles Rettig, the current IRS Commissioner who was appointed by Donald Trump in 2018,, the IRS has reduced its already historically low audits of wealthy Americans while holding the rate of audits on low income households relatively steady. This is no surprise to those with knowledge of Commissioner Rettig, who built his career as a tax lawyer in Beverly Hills by parrying IRS audits of his wealthy clients, helping them dodge US tax law. Despite his clear allegiance to the wealthy and previous statements against the IRS doing its basic due-diligence, Rettig has continued to serve well into the Biden administration. 501(c)(4) Tax Exempt Organizations Campaign finance reform has become a focus for many politicians eager to reverse the influence of Citizens United and other court cases that opened the floodgates for corporations, wealthy individuals, and PACs to effectively buy elections. This effort for reform is popular, too, with 77 percent of Americans supporting new laws to limit outside spending on politician campaigns. But one under-discussed aspect of campaign finance reform is the role the IRS plays in this fight and how the agency could potentially reduce outside expenditures without ever passing new legislation. 501(c)(4) tax exempt organizations are a large source of “dark money,” i.e., anonymous outside campaign expenditures. . These organizations are “social welfare organizations,” distinguished from the other main category of tax-exempt organizations, 501(c)(3)s, by their somewhat higher allowance for political activity. Registered 501(c)(4)s are also not required to disclose their donors so long as political expenditures are not the organizations’ primary activity. While this rule is somewhat difficult to enforce, the IRS has almost completely abdicated its oversight responsibilities regarding tax-exempt organizations in recent years. This tendency toward inaction accelerated following bad-faith conservative outcry regarding purported anti-conservative bias at the agency. Construction of that “scandal” resulted in the ouster of the then-Director for the Exempt Organizations Unit, Lois Lerner, despite the core elements of the alleged bias ultimately being disproven. ProPublica reported in 2019 that despite 2,000 claims of 501(c)(4)’s violating the primary activity rules, not a single one was investigated in the two-year window between 2017 and 2019. In 2017, out of almost 1,500 organizations that filed for 501(c)(4) status, all but three were granted their applications, a staggeringly-low .002 percent rejection rate. With limited resources, the IRS has seemingly decided that the enforcement of existing US tax code regarding these tax-exempt organizations is simply less important than performing hundreds of thousands of audits on poor Earned Income Tax Credit claimants each year. The IRS’s abandonment of its obligations to oversee tax-exempt organizations is a glaring shortcoming in the effort to build a more transparent campaign finance regime. It also is an opportunity for Biden to make an impact upon the campaign finance system without changing current law or facing down the Senate’s archaic procedural rules. By appointing officials intent on reversing the lack of oversight to the IRS Oversight Board and by replacing Trump’s handpicked IRS commissioner, Biden can make a serious impact on dark money spending. Biden also can push Congress to invest in a strong IRS, appropriating more funds to the agency and providing them with the budget necessary to both rebuild staff levels lost over the past decade and hire additional staff to accommodate for the growing tax base and the agency’s steadily growing list of responsibilities. With the midterm elections fast approaching and Democrats’ narrow hold on the Senate majority, the Biden administration should take advantage of laws already on the books to uphold his campaign promise to make American political campaign spending more transparent and guard against the corrupting influence of money in politics.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › IL --- Strong IRS Key to Government Credibility/Democracy
Don Griswold, 23 (2-1-2023, Don Griswold, No Publication, Defend IRS Funding as a High-Return Investment in Democracy, 7-2-2023, ) //shelbor
Policy analysts have warned that last month’s House vote to cut nearly all of the IRS’ transformative new funding wasn’t mere symbolism. We can be confident that the Senate and president won’t go along with gutting the deeply needed $80 billion, decade-long [IRS] investment that the last Congress belatedly enacted as part of the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022. But the annual ritual of budget battles and government shut-down threats will give the House multiple new opportunities and better leverage to achieve its gutting goal. The public must remember why the IRS funding package is essential to our nation’s fiscal resilience and, indeed, to the health of our democracy. In short, it closes the tax gap by targeting wealthy tax dodgers while closing the tax service gap by bringing the IRS into the digital age. Tax Gap and Tax Service Gap Let’s start with the $7 trillion problem. That’s the size of the tax gap—the shortfall between what taxpayers owe and what the IRS collects—over the next decade. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities reports that this shortfall was $574 billion for 2019 alone, and that the annual tax gap will soon reach $1 trillion a year if we continue on the present course. Honest mistakes by middle-class taxpayers make up a tiny fraction of the tax gap; this group has more than a 99% compliance rate. Tax avoidance and evasion (corporate and individual) account for almost all of the gap. And an astounding 20%—$160 billion in 2019—was tax avoidance or evasion by “one percenters,” the wealthiest 1% of Americans. One percenters possess the resources to hire expensive professionals in the tax avoidance industry who can easily outmaneuver the IRS because the agency lacks the resources to audit these complex avoidance strategies. And these Big Four, Big Law, and boutique firms run thriving multibillion-dollar businesses in part because all too many of these one-percenters possess something else—a distinctly un-American eagerness to engage in tax avoidance and evasion. And then there’s the tax service gap. Honest taxpayers can’t get the help they need from the IRS to navigate the tax system. Starved of staff and technology—with software dating to the Kennedy administration—the IRS is capable of answering only 15% of taxpayer phone calls. View of the IRS building in Washington, DC, on Jan. 24, 2023. Photographer: Photo by Stefani Reynolds/AFP via Getty Images IRS Funding and Its Implications Congress has been “financially starving the IRS for over 25 years,” former IRS Commissioner Charles Rossotti says. The agency operates today with almost 20% less than its 2010 funding—fewer auditors than at any time since World War II. It has lost nearly 40% of its sophisticated “Wealth Squad” audit staff who possess specialized expertise to audit complex tax returns of high-income individuals and large corporations—whose avoidance and evasion are responsible for most of that nearly $1 trillion annual tax gap. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen notes that the result is reduced tax fairness—”working families are shouldering a disproportionate burden of investing in our roads, schools, military” and more. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities explains that the underfunded agency’s failure to detect and stop tax avoidance and evasion “is unfair to honest taxpayers and risks undermining the integrity of the tax code.” For these reasons, the last Congress provided that $80 billion over 10 years to modernize and rebuild the IRS’ capacity to live up to its essential mission. Yellen explained that the money will correct the current “two-tiered tax system, where high earners play by different rules than working and middle-class families [and] raise hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue.” Return on Investment The projected return on investment pursuant to the IRS funding package would make any investor salivate. The US Treasury Office of Tax Analysis estimates that the $80 billion will raise an additional $700 billion in tax collections—a large part of the tax gap—and raise another $1.6 trillion in the following decade. Rossotti, a technology expert, predicts that every incremental dollar of enforcement funding will return $15 to $20 over the next decade. That outstanding ROI would have satisfied even the grandfather of conservative trickle-down economics, Adam Smith. His fourth maxim of taxation—“economy in collection”—requires that tax administration not “take out … of the pockets of the people a great deal more than it brings into the public treasury.” Taxation, Tax Collection, and Democracy Despite considerable national disagreement regarding the level of services that ought to be provided by the US government, we can all agree that we must fund our government’s operations by imposing and collecting taxes. As Oliver Wendell Holmes put it, “Taxes are what we pay for civilized society.” Consequently, as Yellen puts it, “the IRS is a foundation of our government and society.” Delving into this truism, the Tax Justice Network has explained that fair and efficient taxation joins citizens together in a “social fiscal contract” that “can build healthy links of accountability and political representation between governments and their citizens.” Yellen, pointing out that the IRS “is one of the very few parts of the federal government that touches nearly every American household,” explains that tax enforcement “is not only a means to raise revenue. It is also a matter of fundamental fairness.” She goes on to stress a critical rationale behind the IRS funding bill: “It is important for honest taxpayers to know that, when they file their taxes accurately with the IRS, other people are doing the same.” The continuing vitality of our nation’s social fiscal contract depends in no small measure on the ability of our federal tax collection agency to provide service and to enforce compliance—with a consistently high level of professionalism and effectiveness that generates widespread agreement that our tax system is fundamentally fair. This requires robust funding for the IRS.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › IL --- Strong IRS Key to Government Credibility/Democracy
Jessie Eisinger and Paul Kiel Eisinger is a senior editor and reporter for propublica. Paul kiel eisinger is and editor and writer focused on business, consumer finance, and tax systems. [jessie esinger and Paul Kiel, “you can’t tax the rich without the IRS”, ProPublica, published 05-03-2019, . Accessed 07-02/2023.] //ahcchs
So, what to do? One 2020 candidate already has a bold proposal to resuscitate the IRS. It’s a plan to pump tens of billions into the agency, enough to fund a second army of agents. That candidate’s name is Donald Trump. Of course, it was Trump’s party that gutted the agency, costing the country, , more than $100 billion in lost revenue. The president’s 2020 budget, however, did propose adding $15 billion over 10 years to the IRS enforcement budget, a move that would add more than the agency’s current budget. The administration estimated this would produce revenue of at least $47 billion. The question arises: Has the administration genuinely had a change of heart? Or is this merely a neat trick to make deficit projections appear smaller? So far, this is all just talk. It is, though, one of the few areas where Trump and Democrats are in substantive agreement. Democrats in the House recently proposed a $400 million IRS budget increase next year. Among the Democratic presidential candidates, Warren does mention the IRS in her wealth tax proposal. but “significant increase in the IRS enforcement budget” and a minimum audit rate for taxpayers subject to her “ultramillionaire” tax. Raising taxes on the rich is a more compelling cause than increasing the operating budget of a bureaucracy most American voters probably hate thinking about. But the boldest tax plan of all starts with salvaging the IRS.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › IL --- Strong IRS Key to Government Credibility/Democracy
Lisa Mascaro [“Trump’s taxes: house oks bill on IRS audits of presidents”, AP news, published 12-22-2023, . Accessed 07/02/2023.] //ahcchs
The Democrat-led measure provides a capstone to a yearslong investigation of Trump’s tenure as the first president in recent history not to disclose his tax returns to the public. The legislation faced staunch opposition from Republicans and has little chance of becoming law in the final days of this Congress. But it is seen as a starting point for future efforts to . “These improved guardrails will provide Americans the assurance they deserve that our tax code applies evenly and fairly to all of us, no matter how powerful,” said Democratic Rep. Richard Neal of Massachusetts, chairman of the that led the effort. The vote was approved 222-201, mostly along party lines. The committee’s top Republican, Rep. Kevin Brady of Texas, said the bill would infringe on taxpayer privacy. He said the “unprecedented action jeopardizes the rights of every American to be protected from political targeting.” The committee’s lengthy investigation revealed this week that the IRS had failed to pursue audits of Trump on a timely basis during his presidency, as required under the tax agency’s protocol. Only when Democrats formally questioned the IRS on April 19, 2019, did the IRS begin its first review, two years into Trump’s tenure. raised stark questions about Trump’s insistence he could not publicly release his tax returns — as other presidents routinely have done to give people a glimpse into their livelihoods — because he said his filings were under ongoing IRS review. The committee’s report also highlighted shortcomings at the IRS, which has been criticized for auditing lower-income people more often than the rich. Later this week, the committee is expected to release Trump’s returns after a protracted legal battle with the former president. The wealthy businessman declined to fully explain his finances during his 2016 campaign and while in the White House. It would be the first formal release of his financial situation from his time in office. “The the purpose of this legislation is to ensure that no American is above the law — even the president of the United States,” said Rep. Dan Kildee, D-Mich., during the debate on the bill. Five Republicans, including Reps. Liz Cheney, R-Wyo., and Adam Kinzinger, R-Ill., joined Democrats in voting for the bill. All of the five Republicans are either retiring or failed to win their reelections. The practice of auditing presidential tax returns grew from the Watergate era, when then-President Richard Nixon was under scrutiny by Congress. In 1977, the IRS created the mandatory audit requirement as part of its operations, but the practice was simply the norm, not the law. When Trump defied traditional presidential practice by refusing to disclose his tax returns it raised questions and spurred the committee’s investigation. The House Ways and Means Committee oversees tax policy, and like all of Congress, is able to provide a check-and-balance on the executive branch. The bill would require an initial IRS report on a president’s tax returns no later than 90 days from the time they were filed. It would require an updated report on the president’s filings in six months. The committee’s report found that the IRS did not have sufficient experts on staff able to probe the complex filings of Trump and his associated companies. The committee’s investigation found “only one mandatory audit was started” of Trump’s tax returns during his presidency “and the program was otherwise dormant, at best.” Scrutiny of the IRS comes as Republicans, who are preparing to take control of the House in the new year after winning the majority in the midterm elections, have pledged to cut funding to the agency as one of their first moves.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Internal Link/Impacts › IL --- Strong IRS Key to Government Credibility/Democracy
Vanessa Williamson, senior fellow brookings urban tax center [vanessa williamson, “Cutting IRS funding is a gift to america’s wealthiest tax evaders”, Brookings Institute, published 01-26-2023,
. Accessed 07/02/2023.] //ahcchs
In their , the new House Republican majority voted to cut funding for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The vote was a symbolic effort to repeal the $80 billion increase in funding the revenue agency received last year as part of the Inflation Reduction Act. Cutting IRS funding is a terrible idea. A well-funded IRS can distribute emergency aid quickly, serve taxpayers efficiently, and help ensure that millionaires have to follow the tax laws just like everyone else. It’s an essential investment in good government. The IRS has been persistently underfunded , but the years since 2010 have been particularly tough. Tax law expert Chye-Ching Huang notes that the enforcement budget of the IRS dropped by in less than ten years. In , the IRS employed less than 10,000 revenue agents—the last time that was true was 1953: the Brooklyn Dodgers were in the World Series, the median housing price was , and the IRS was handling over individual income tax returns a year. The IRS is also “overwhelmingly reliant” on antiquated technology, the , “systems that are at least 25 years old, use obsolete programming languages (e.g., COBOL), or lack vendor support, training, or resources to maintain.” It is worth noting how much the IRS has managed to achieve despite its perpetually inadequate resources. When COVID struck, for example, only the IRS had the capacity to send to keep American households afloat. As my Tax Policy Center colleague Howard Gleckman has said, the IRS “ in getting these checks out in very difficult circumstances.” But the budgetary toll of persistent underfunding is unmistakable. For regular taxpayers, the consequence is . Some politicians have suggested that every new IRS employee will be a gun-toting enforcement agent. Actually, the IRS desperately needs employees to process refunds and answer tax filers’ phone calls. Out of the 282 million phone calls the IRS received in 2021, only 11% or 32 million were actually answered. is going to taxpayer services and modernization, which will . About $45 billion of the $80 billion in new funding is going to enforcement, and that is great news. For the wealthiest and most sophisticated tax filers, a cash-strapped IRS has meant a tax evasion free-for-all. Currently, the tax gap, which is the amount in taxes that are owed but not paid, comes to . is due to underreporting of income by the top 10% of taxpayers, and more than a quarter comes from the top 1%. But the IRS has been left without the resources to hire and support the kind of tax experts who can catch wealthy tax cheats. The lack of staff was highlighted recently when it was revealed that the audit of former president Donald Trump was . But Trump wasn’t the only one whose taxes were going without thorough examination. in less than a decade. For those making more than $5 million, the audit rate has . At the same time, responding to a , the IRS has focused instead on a much cheaper form of audit, targeting recipients of the Earned Income Tax Credit—i.e. low-income, working families. As a result, the EITC recipients are audited at the same rate as the top 1% of earners. As law professor Dorothy Brown explains, the consequence of high levels of EITC audits is a serious . Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has insisted that the new funding . So, the new funding will help rebuild the capacity of the IRS to audit the wealthy, making the tax system far fairer. And, of course, closing the tax gap raises revenues—it’s a policy that more than pays for itself. The IRS investments are expected to raise . The Republican effort to repeal the IRS’s $80 billion funding increase will not move forward in the Democrat-controlled Senate. But the IRS might yet see its funding decline, if the House Republicans negotiate a cut in . If that happens, it is bad news for the millions of American households who pay their taxes honestly, and great news for the country’s richest tax evaders. Funding the IRS will shore up an essential government service, making tax filing easier and tax enforcement fairer.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
IRS TRADEOFF DA › Link › Link --- Distribution is not the same as RE-distribution (1 card only needed)
John Hills [ “Distribution and Redistribution”, Inequality and the State Oxford, 2004 online edn Oxford Academic, 20 Jan. 2005, , accessed 2 July 2023.] //ahcchs
Distribution is a central issue in the appraisal of social and welfare policies. For some, it is the central issue when they make statements such as: ‘without a National Health Service providing free medical care, the poor could not afford treatment’; or ‘the primary aim of social security is preventing poverty’. Over twenty years ago, in his book The Strategy of Equality, Julian Le Grand (1982: 3) reached the striking conclusion that ‘Almost all public expenditure on the social services benefits the better off to a greater extent than the poor’. If so, a large part of social policy had failed in what many would see as one of its main aims. This conclusion was controversial (see Powell 1995, for a discussion of some of the issues, with a response from Le Grand). As we shall see below, the answer to this kind of question depends critically on a particular series of choices in the way in which distribution is analysed. Alternative ways of looking at the problem can give different answers. Whether redistribution is occurring or not can depend on the point of analysis. Under private insurance for, say, burglaries, a large number of people make annual payments (insurance premiums) to an insurance company, but only a small number receive payouts from the company. After the event (ex post) there is redistribution from the (fortunate) many to the (unfortunate) few. But, looking at the position in advance (ex ante), not knowing who is going to be burgled, all pay in a premium equalling their risk of being burgled, multiplied by the size of the payout if this happens (plus the insurance company's costs and profits). In ‘actuarial’ terms there is no redistribution—people have arranged a certain small loss (the premium) rather than the risk of a much larger loss (being burgled without insurance). Similarly, much of the welfare state is insurance against adversity. People ‘pay in’ through tax or National Insurance Contributions, but in return, if they are the ones who become ill or unemployed, the system is there to protect them. It does not make sense just to look at which individual happens to receive an expensive heart bypass operation this year and present him or her as the main ‘gainer’ from the system. All benefit to the extent that they face a risk of needing such an operation. The system is therefore often best appraised in actuarial terms; that is, in terms of the extent someone would expect to benefit on average. Equally, if we look at pension schemes over a single year, some people pay in contributions while others receive pensions. On this snapshot, there is apparently redistribution from the former to the latter. But, with a longer time horizon, today's pensioners may simply get back what they paid in earlier.