Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Counterplan
Aff › No Solvency › No Solvency – Innovation/Growth

Raising the Minimum wage fails:

No behavioral response among firms and workers (will lead to unemployment)

No innovation to offset higher costs (companies will shrink)

Makridis 16 [Christos Makridis; February 5 2016; a Ph.D. Candidate in Macroeconomics and Public Finance at Stanford University; The New Republic; “Raising the Minimum Wage Won’t Reduce Inequality”; ; CP]

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Gender K

A UBI is necessary to address racial and gendered economic inequality – this threatens everyone’s economic security

Bhattacharya, 2019 - of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa, June 19 Issue Brief. Roosevelt Institute, “Exploring Guaranteed Income Through a Racial and Gender Justice Lens.” TA Acc 6/10/23]

Race- and gender-based wealth inequities are two of the greatest failures of the American economy. Economic policy choices and practices put forth by those in power, such as the GI Bill and redlining, created wealth-building opportunities for white men but established barriers for everyone else. Implemented in tandem with the rise of corporate power by which profit is revered over people, these racist policies have resulted in racial and gender economic stratification that have reached epic heights. Today, approximately 160,000 households in America own more wealth than the poorest 90 percent combined— the highest concentration of wealth since 1962 (Igraham 2017). Without bold, visionary action and policies to address these issues, the chasm between those who are economically secure and those who are not—mainly Black, brown, and Native American communities and women—will continue to grow, ultimately threatening our nation’s ability to finally achieve our promise of freedom, dignity, and security for all. A growing group of progressives is committed to tackling racial wealth inequities head on (Newkirk II 2019). Once seen as fringe, “pie in the sky” ideas, a number of seemingly progressive economic policies have entered the public discourse, including a government funded cash benefit program. Often referred to as “guaranteed income,” this big idea is a no-strings-attached direct cash benefit from the government that would provide a basic floor of living regardless of employment status or income by offering people a regular cash payment (Marinescu 2017). With that context, this issue brief will explore to what extent and under what type of design a program that is usually discussed as a way to boost regular incomes could make a dent in racial and gender wealth inequities. Race- and gender-based wealth inequities are two of the greatest failures of the American economy. In the past, bold economic policies—such as those enshrined in President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal—have paved a pathway to economic security for white families and individuals while creating barriers to well-being for people of color and women. Given that history, and the extent to which recent economic rules have reinforced historical inequities, we must ask a key question of any economic policy put forth today: How would this effort rectify historical, racially exclusionary policies and increase access to wealth, economic stability, and freedom for women and people of color?

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Psychoanalysis K

Wealthy white Americans are motivated to believe in racial equality because challenging this threatens their own self image of success.

Kraus et al, 2019 - Sustainability Research Institute at the University of Leeds [Michael, with Ivuoma N. Onyeador, Natalie M. Daumeyer, Julian M. Rucker, Jennifer A. Richeson September 10 Perspectives on Psychological Science, “The Misperception of Racial Economic Inequality” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1745691619863049#tab-contributors KB]

In addition to these and other more structural forces that undermine the accuracy of high-status group members’ perceptions of current racial equality, motivational factors are likely to contribute to these misperceptions. High-income White Americans may be particularly motivated to perceive society as fair and just and thus believe that their elevated societal status is based solely on individual merit rather than the persistence of racial or class-based discrimination (Brandt, 2013; Kraus & Tan, 2015). In essence, a sense that one’s membership in a high-socioeconomic-status group is based in part on the accident of birth, chance, or unfair advantage, rather than one’s own individual merit or hard work, is sufficiently psychologically threatening to motivate some high-income White Americans to deny the extent of relevant forms of societal inequality and, thus, to overestimate current levels of racial economic equality. Indeed, considerable research has revealed positive associations between perceptions of society as fair and higher societal-group status (Brandt, 2013; Malahy, Rubinlicht, & Kaiser, 2009; McCoy & Major, 2007; O’Brien & Major, 2009). For instance, having higher income is associated with a greater belief in the possibility of intergenerational economic mobility, a pattern that is not in line with actual estimates, which suggest that mobility is quite low in American society (Davidai & Gilovich, 2015; Kraus & Tan, 2015). Likewise, the tendency for Whites, relative to other racial groups, to believe that society is fair correlates positively with the likelihood that these same individuals deny their race-based privilege (Phillips & Lowery, 2015). Consistent with this work, White Americans are three times more likely to believe that race relations have improved in America relative to Black respondents (Bialik & Cilluffo, 2017). Overall, then, these analyses suggest that Americans with higher societal-group status (e.g., high-income Whites) tend to endorse narratives of racial progress more strongly than their lower-status counterparts; we argue that this set of beliefs engenders the misperception of racial economic equality. Mediation analyses from our prior research are indicative of this possibility: High-income White Americans were particularly likely to endorse beliefs that society was fair, and this association statistically accounted for their tendency to overestimate Black–White economic equality relative to both Black Americans and low-income Whites (Kraus et al., 2017).

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Psychoanalysis K

Misperceptions of Racial Inequality are Willful Ignorance – Americans faced with contradictory evidence of inequality are in denial because it would challenge their core beliefs about America.

Kraus et al, 2019 - Sustainability Research Institute at the University of Leeds [Michael, with Ivuoma N. Onyeador, Natalie M. Daumeyer, Julian M. Rucker, Jennifer A. Richeson September 10 Perspectives on Psychological Science, “The Misperception of Racial Economic Inequality” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1745691619863049#tab-contributors KB]

Willful Ignorance? A Case for Motivated Social Cognition Motivated reasoning in the context of racial inequality The large, consistent, and significant pattern of misperception we have documented up to this point can be attributed to a host of psychological as well as structural forces that both create racial disparities and then lead average Americans to explain them away. In our discussion thus far, we have alluded to one fundamental aspect of the psychology underlying these misperceptions of equality; namely, the desire to see society as fair, just, and merit-based. These underlying motivations are strong enough, we argue, to lead individuals to pay greater attention to confirming information and considerably less attention to information that suggests society continues to be both unequal and unjust, especially on the basis of race. In essence, we contend that Americans engage in motivated cognition to remain willfully ignorant of racial inequality in general and racial economic inequality in particular, in service of our prevailing narrative of racial progress. The foundations of motivated reasoning are grounded heavily in cognitive dissonance (Jost, Glaser, Kruglanski, & Sulloway, 2003; Kunda, 1990), a core social psychological phenomenon that suggests that when individuals are faced with a conflict between two attitudes or an attitude and a behavior, that state is psychologically and affectively uncomfortable, and people are likely to make the easiest changes of attitude to resolve the conflict (Festinger, 1972; Festinger & Carlsmith, 1959). In the domain of racial inequality, the discomfort comes from the conflict that emerges when a person comes in contact with evidence of racial inequality that runs in stark contrast to the broad narrative of racial progress cultivated in television, film, literature, news, and other media. Whenever dissonance emerges in this context, it is far easier to contextualize, rationalize, and/or minimize such inequalities than it is to change the prevailing progress narrative. Against the threat of potentially shattering this prevailing and persistent narrative of racial progress, we argue, people are motivated to explain away any evidence of stable, persistent racial inequality as noise rather than signal, at best, and as justifiable, at worst. Over time, this dissonance process leads people to selectively bring to mind and attend to high-status rather than low-status Black exemplars when asked to make inferences about racial economic disparities.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Economy DAs

UBI increases productivity through creating a door for better jobs – Empirically proven

Farooqi, 2021 – LA Times columnist [Sana, Mar 21 HPHR “The Case for Universal Basic Income as a Tool for racial Justice” https://hphr.org/30-article-farooqui/ KB]

Critics of UBI claim this policy would be disastrous, namely as an assured cash deposit would disincentivize employment and consequently wreck the economy. Accordingly, UBI would essentially create a lazy and unmotivated society dependent on state-provided handouts.13 Yet, the evidence displays the opposite effect. In a recent small-scale experiment in Stockton, California, 125 residents who made less than the median income of $46,000 a year were given $500 per month for the past two years. Less than 1 percent of the entire amount of disbursed cash was spent on tobacco and alcohol. Rather, recipients used the cash to pay off debts and obtain better-paying fulltime jobs. Enrollees reported that they had lower rates of anxiety, depression, and fatigue; having a sustained source of cash gave them enough financial security to allocate time for better job-hunting, for example.13

This isn’t a novel policy; the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians in North Carolina has been providing all tribe members with a yearly payment of $4000 to $6000 since 1997. Employment statistics remain unaffected, with tribe members continuing to work. However, educational and mental health outcomes have significantly improved, while there is a noted decrease in addiction-related issues and crime.9 On a larger scale, the state of Alaska has guaranteed income to each adult and child since 1982. Rather than harm its economy, Alaska has instead managed to eliminate extreme and cash-based poverty. More Alaskans actually joined the workforce, with some positing the payments allowed workers to afford fixed job costs like transportation or childcare. Additionally, Alaska’s internal economy flourished, as the payments stimulated more spending, enabling businesses to hire more employees and consequently increasing overall employment.14 Again, this isn’t as foreign of an idea as opponents may suggest.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Spending

Corporate and wealth taxes can pay for a UBI

Farooqi, 2021 – LA Times columnist [Sana, Mar 21 HPHR “The Case for Universal Basic Income as a Tool for racial Justice” https://hphr.org/30-article-farooqui/ KB]

That isn’t to say that a UBI policy won’t face an immense uphill battle. The current polarized political climate will be a severe barrier to passage, as are the ongoing culture wars. A national UBI policy – especially one promoted to rectify facets of structural racism – goes against the very mythos of America. As the belief goes, “true” (i.e. white) Americans earn their wealth through hard work alone. This thinking racializes any sort of social safety net or UBI program, dismissing groups who need assistance despite welfare primarily boosting the white middle class.15 More harmfully, the notion rejects the presence of structural racism, powering the cycle of racial inequities. To combat this idea, reframing is necessary. Any UBI measure would have to center around perceived white benefits to muster through. Another major barrier is finding funding sources; such a plan would cost almost three trillion dollars per year or the equivalent of one COVID-19 relief bill. Revenues from corporate taxes or hyper-efficient taxes such as land value, carbon emissions, or vice taxes could cover some of the required money. A suggestion would be to pass complementing wealth taxes, i.e., tax 1-2% of accumulated wealth of those with more than a million dollars in their bank accounts or investment holdings to cover the program. Overall, this intervention is more palatable to policymakers than reparations. It would also enable generational wealth-gathering, versus simply raising the minimum wage for income.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Capitalism K

Our methodology comes from the Black Radical Tradition – addressing racial capitalism solves best because it can address systems resistant to change – focusing only on class politics cannot.

Inwood et al, ’20 - Department of Geography and Rock Ethics Institute, Pennsylvania State University [Joshua F.J. Anna Brand, Elise Quinn, December 19, 2020, Antipode, “Racial Capital, Abolition, and a Geographic Argument for Reparations”, , June 24, 2023, LN]

Conceptual Framework In this section, we trace the broad contours of racial capital and how it shifts understandings of race and economics in fundamental ways. By focusing on how these processes played out over time, we explore how racial difference is a con- stituent logic of capitalism (Robinson 2000) and building through Pulido’s (2016:1) work advance an “intersectional conception of capitalism in which its deeply racialized nature is fully recognized”. We then outline an understanding of reparations within a geographical framework before turning to our analysis of the rise and fall of Lehman Brothers to ground understandings of racial capitalism in specific geographies of accumulation by dispossession and abandonment. Troubling traditional understandings of capital, Robinson argues that ethnic and racial difference predates the development of modern economies. Racism was not just a convenient ordering system for Europeans to categorise non-Europeans, but instead, its “genesis is in the ‘internal’relations of European peoples”themselves (Robinson 2000:2). Capitalism and its attendant identity positions are not a radi- cal departure from feudalism as traditional Marxists would understand it, but instead, capitalism emerged from feudalism and in a context already and every- where infused with racialism (Bledsoe and Wright 2019; Kelley 2017). As a result, capitalism produced a world economic system “dependent on slavery, violence, imperialism and genocide”(Kelley 2017). European society was rife with differ- ence, and these differences grafted onto changes in the political economy as feudalism gave way to mercantilism and colonialism. Thus, it becomes necessary to see race not epiphenomenally or as something outside of capital, but as central to the very making and unfolding of capital relations themselves. Robinson’s perspective is essential for understanding how and in what ways cap- ital unfolds and for tracing its socio-spatial trajectories (Pulido 2017). First, by chal- lenging the idea that racism can be reduced to class, racial capitalism opens space to understand a range of revolutionary movements and moments that Robinson identifies as the “Black Radical Tradition”. De fined as an “African response to an oppression emergent from the immediate determinants of European development in the modern era and framed by orders of human exploitation”(Robinson 2000:73), the Black Radical Tradition sits outside of traditional understandings of revolutionary consciousness or conceptualisation of change as driven by class soli- darities or politics (Pulido 2006). The Black Radical Tradition is outside what many would understand as traditional ways of knowing (Woods 1998) and incorporates a range of practices that open space to understand various resistant traditions.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Capitalism K

Racial capitalism makes reparations necessary – it is the only way to account for geographic exploitation

Inwood et al, ’20 - Department of Geography and Rock Ethics Institute, Pennsylvania State University [Joshua F.J. Anna Brand, Elise Quinn, December 19, 2020, Antipode, “Racial Capital, Abolition, and a Geographic Argument for Reparations”, , June 24, 2023, LN]

Tracing the development of Lehman Brothers from their roots as a dry goods store in Montgomery, Alabama, into a Fortune 500 global financial services com- pany that collapsed in the 2007 financial crisis reveals the contours of US-style racial capitalism. We highlight how race and capital are geographically rooted in the United States. At the heart of our argument is an understanding of the geographic imperative of capital which creates and exploits differences to wrench capital’s profits from the blood, sweat, and toil of racialised bodies. Perhaps most geographically significant, we advance a second, interrelated argument, the geographic case for reparations. By argu- ing the system itself is entirely and wholly wrapped in race in ways that extend and advance practices of exploitation, we understand reparations that do not fundamentally undermine, transform, destabilise or smash the system as doomed to be short-term solutions to long-term structural problems. Affidavits in the Alabama State Archives from 1861 signed by Judge David Camp- bell affirm the ownership of enslaved men to the Montgomery and Eufaula Rail- road Company (MERC).1 The railroad connected Montgomery, Alabama, to the Central Georgia line, opening Alabama’s blackbelt region and its massive cotton plantations to Savannah, Georgia. Located on the Atlantic Ocean, Savannah con- nected cotton production in Alabama with Liverpool and the massive cloth manu- facturing centres in England. MERC was backed with $1.8 million in loan guarantees by Georgia cotton trader John Durr and the Lehman brothers, prominent Montgomery businessmen (Neeley 2010:240). The rail venture cemen- ted the Lehman Durr Company as one of the most important business interests in Alabama and perhaps the South,2 and locates their business interests within the local and global scales of racial capitalism.3 The archival record of MERC is significant for animating the fundamental role that race and the exploitation of difference play in making the broader US political economy (Woods 1998), from its roots in plantationism to its current manifesta- tions. We trace the development of Lehman Brothers from their founding as a dry goods store in Montgomery into a Fortune 500 global financial services company that collapsed in the 2007 financial crisis to illustrate the range of highly profitable financial practices that were derived from Lehman’s origins in the US South during slavery. We reveal the contours of US-style racial capitalism and how the massive extraction of wealth from Black bodies is central to understanding the multiple scales at which capital works. At the heart of our argument is an understanding of “variegated landscapes” of difference (Pulido 2016:7) and the way difference is used to wrench capital’s profits from the blood, sweat, and toil of racialised bodies. Centring a perspective that wrestles with the racialised nature of capital (Pulido 2016:7), we use a critical geographical perspective grounded in racial capitalism to re-tell the development of Lehman Brothers, opening up space to take an American origin story—hardworking, first-generation immigrants turning a small business into a multinational corporation—and expose how that story is intrinsi- cally intertwined with slavery and forms of racial exploitation.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Capitalism K

The negative link is a lie – diverting the discussion from racism to broader class struggles perpetuates false narratives about the roots of oppression and poverty in white supremacy

Coates, 2014 – MacArthur Fellowship Winner. [Ta-Nehisi, June The Atlantic “THE CASE FOR REPARATIONS” https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ KB]

The urge to use the moral force of the black struggle to address broader inequalities originates in both compassion and pragmatism. But it makes for ambiguous policy. Affirmative action’s precise aims, for instance, have always proved elusive. Is it meant to make amends for the crimes heaped upon black people? Not according to the Supreme Court. In its 1978 ruling in Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, the Court rejected “societal discrimination” as “an amorphous concept of injury that may be ageless in its reach into the past.” Is affirmative action meant to increase “diversity”? If so, it only tangentially relates to the specific problems of black people—the problem of what America has taken from them over several centuries. This confusion about affirmative action’s aims, along with our inability to face up to the particular history of white-imposed black disadvantage, dates back to the policy’s origins. “There is no fixed and firm definition of affirmative action,” an appointee in Johnson’s Department of Labor declared. “Affirmative action is anything that you have to do to get results. But this does not necessarily include preferential treatment.” Yet America was built on the preferential treatment of white people—395 years of it. Vaguely endorsing a cuddly, feel-good diversity does very little to redress this. Today, progressives are loath to invoke white supremacy as an explanation for anything. On a practical level, the hesitation comes from the dim view the Supreme Court has taken of the reforms of the 1960s. The Voting Rights Act has been gutted. The Fair Housing Act might well be next. Affirmative action is on its last legs. In substituting a broad class struggle for an anti-racist struggle, progressives hope to assemble a coalition by changing the subject. The politics of racial evasion are seductive. But the record is mixed. Aid to Families With Dependent Children was originally written largely to exclude blacks—yet by the 1990s it was perceived as a giveaway to blacks. The Affordable Care Act makes no mention of race, but this did not keep Rush Limbaugh from denouncing it as reparations. Moreover, the act’s expansion of Medicaid was effectively made optional, meaning that many poor blacks in the former Confederate states do not benefit from it. The Affordable Care Act, like Social Security, will eventually expand its reach to those left out; in the meantime, black people will be injured. Billy Brooks, who assisted the Contract Buyers League, still works in the neighborhood, helping kids escape poverty and violence. (Carlos Javier Ortiz) “All that it would take to sink a new WPA program would be some skillfully packaged footage of black men leaning on shovels smoking cigarettes,” the sociologist Douglas S. Massey writes. “Papering over the issue of race makes for bad social theory, bad research, and bad public policy.” To ignore the fact that one of the oldest republics in the world was erected on a foundation of white supremacy, to pretend that the problems of a dual society are the same as the problems of unregulated capitalism, is to cover the sin of national plunder with the sin of national lying. The lie ignores the fact that reducing American poverty and ending white supremacy are not the same. The lie ignores the fact that closing the “achievement gap” will do nothing to close the “injury gap,” in which black college graduates still suffer higher unemployment rates than white college graduates, and black job applicants without criminal records enjoy roughly the same chance of getting hired as white applicants with criminal records.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Monthly PIC

Monthly UBI payments are key to allow autonomy and planning, because they are regular.

Bhattacharya, 2019 - of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa, June 19 Issue Brief. Roosevelt Institute, “Exploring Guaranteed Income Through a Racial and Gender Justice Lens.” EO]

Monthly Installments Perhaps the most common model of a guaranteed income disbursement is an equal monthly payment given to all families across the board. Beneficiaries would receive a set monthly amount, which is generally talked about in the $500-1000 per month range. Monthly benefits allow families to budget and plan for the cash benefit on a regular basis. Payment is unconditional with no strings attached, meaning it would come regardless of employment status; no conditions would be placed in order to receive the benefit or restrictions placed on its use.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Financial Literacy CP

Financial literacy cannot solve the racial wealth gap without capital to manage.

Ray and Perry 2020 – Senior Fellows at the Brookings Institution [Rashawn Ray and Andre M. Perry, April 15, 2020, Brookings Institution, “Why we need reparations for Black Americans” , June 22, 2023, LN]

Bootstrapping isn’t going to erase racial wealth divides. As economists William “Sandy” Darity and Darrick Hamilton point out in their 2018 report, What We Get Wrong About Closing the Wealth Gap, “Blacks cannot close the racial wealth gap by changing their individual behavior –i.e. by assuming more ‘personal responsibility’ or acquiring the portfolio management insights associated with ‘[financial] literacy.’” In fact, white high school dropouts have more wealth than Black college graduates. Moreover, the racial wealth gap did not result from a lack of labor. Rather, it came from a lack of financial capital.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Financial Literacy CP

Financial literacy is a scam to trap black home owners in predatory loans. Empirically proven

Coates, 2014 – MacArthur Fellowship Winner. [Ta-Nehisi, June The Atlantic “THE CASE FOR REPARATIONS” https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ KB]

Plunder in the past made plunder in the present efficient. The banks of America understood this. In 2005, Wells Fargo promoted a series of Wealth Building Strategies seminars. Dubbing itself “the nation’s leading originator of home loans to ethnic minority customers,” the bank enrolled black public figures in an ostensible effort to educate blacks on building “generational wealth.” But the “wealth building” seminars were a front for wealth theft. In 2010, the Justice Department filed a discrimination suit against Wells Fargo alleging that the bank had shunted blacks into predatory loans regardless of their creditworthiness. This was not magic or coincidence or misfortune. It was racism reifying itself. According to The New York Times, affidavits found loan officers referring to their black customers as “mud people” and to their subprime products as “ghetto loans.”

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Colorblind CP

Universal policies undermine the support for reparative work – race neutral discussions may be less controversial, but they also do not address misperceptions that are the root of a lack of support.

Kraus et al, 2019 - Sustainability Research Institute at the University of Leeds [Michael, with Ivuoma N. Onyeador, Natalie M. Daumeyer, Julian M. Rucker, Jennifer A. Richeson September 10 Perspectives on Psychological Science, “The Misperception of Racial Economic Inequality” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1745691619863049#tab-contributors KB]

Societal Policy Change and Color-Blind Approaches to Messaging on Racial Disparities Color-blind approaches to economic policy Of course, one way to increase the accuracy of people’s perceptions of racial economic equality is to actually increase racial economic equality—that is, reduce inequality. Developing the kind of momentum necessary to garner support for transformative, equity-enhancing, reparative economic policies, however, is no easy task. One essential question is whether political messages aimed at reducing racial inequality are better situated to drum up support for policy change if they do not mention race. As an anecdote, when Senator Cory Booker deployed his plans for a bill that provides federal need-based savings accounts for newborns—also known as “baby bonds”— the initial press coverage did not mention race until the ninth paragraph of the announcement (Lane, 2018), even though the baby-bonds policy is a targeted means by which the racial wealth gap can be reduced (Hamilton & Darity, 2010; Shapiro, 2017). Some work suggests that such a race-neutral approach may be wise. A growing body of research indicates that the perception that some racial differences may be closing—most notably, the relative population share of different groups, voting, and/or political power—can engender status threat among White Americans that, in turn, can negatively affect support for equity-enhancing policies (e.g., Blumer, 1958; Bobo, 1999; Craig & Richeson, 2014; Craig et al., 2018; Major & Kaiser, 2017; Richeson & Sommers, 2016; Wilkins, Hirsch, Kaiser, & Inkles, 2017; Wilkins & Kaiser, 2014). For instance, when affirmative-action policies are framed as race neutral, White perceivers rate those policies more positively than when they are framed as negatively affecting admissions for Whites (Lowery, Unzueta, Knowles, & Goff, 2006). Despite their potential to avoid these types of backlash effects, color-blind discussions of and approaches to economic inequality have a different drawback. As highlighted in the work reviewed here, avoidance of the racial patterns of economic and other forms of inequality is in fact part of the reason there are such powerful, robust, yet inaccurate narratives regarding societal racial progress in the first place (Lowery, Knowles, & Unzueta, 2007; Nelson et al., 2013). Although meaningful engagement with race may initially increase the anxiety and discomfort experienced during cross-race contact (Richeson & Shelton, 2007; Trawalter & Richeson, 2006), it may also reduce the miscommunication that often characterizes these interactions (Dupree & Fiske, 2018) and, moreover, may result in more-accurate perceptions of the current state of racial inequality in the nation (Dixon, Durrheim, & Tredoux, 2007; Saguy et al., 2009). In sum, we suggest that political messages that attempt to reduce misperceptions of racial economic inequality and drum up support for equity-enhancing policies should not necessarily avoid race, but must also take care to address racial inequality in ways that highlight how to foster the very equality that people believe we have already achieved. In other words, it may be possible to harness action toward fostering racial equality by leveraging Americans’ commitment to racial progress while simultaneously making people aware that it has not yet been achieved and will not be achieved without sociopolitical intervention (e.g., Eibach & Purdie-Vaughns, 2011).

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT States CP

Only the federal government can fulfill the obligation of reparations – polls prove that advocates hold the federal government responsible.

Blazina and Cox ‘22 – Formal digital producer and research associate at Pew Research Center [Carrie and Kiana, November 28, Pew Research Center, “Black and White Americans are far apart in their views of reparations for slavery, , June 21, 2023 LN]

Some racial, ethnic and partisan differences over who bears responsibility for reparations, what form they should take In the Center’s 2021 survey, the 30% of Americans who favored reparations were also asked about the institutions and individuals who bear responsibility for repayment. They were presented with four options: the U.S. federal government, businesses and banks that profited from slavery, colleges and universities that benefited from slavery, and descendants of families who engaged in the slave trade. Three-quarters of reparations supporters say the federal government has all or most of the responsibility to repay descendants of enslaved people. A smaller share, though still a majority, say businesses and banks that profited from slavery (65%) have all or most of the responsibility. Fewer say the same about colleges and universities that benefited from slavery (53%) and descendants of families who engaged in the slave trade (44%).

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT States CP

Permutation – the Federal and State governments should adopt the plan. The federal portion improves solvency with oversight and distribution infrastructure.

Farooqi, 2021 – LA Times columnist [Sana, Mar 21 HPHR “The Case for Universal Basic Income as a Tool for racial Justice” https://hphr.org/30-article-farooqui/ KB]

To help rectify the 300+ years of racial and socioeconomic disenfranchisement a universal basic income program must be implemented. This intervention refers to a regular provision of cash to a specified population group within a targeted area. Some form of UBI has been promoted since the 1500s, by advocates as varied as Thomas Paine, Milton Freidman, Mark Zuckerberg, and Elon Musk. More recently, former Democratic presidential nominee contender Andrew Yang built his platform on UBI, inadvertently becoming the most famous proponent for the cause.9 Similar to Yang’s policy, my recommended proposal is a no-strings attached, monthly payment of $1000 regardless of the recipient’s income. This plan would target all residents of the United States ages 18 to 70, with state and federal governments each shouldering half the costs. The age limits are based on the assumption of full social security benefits remaining intact upon reaching age 62, with eight years of buffer in between. The federal government would provide oversight and distribution responsibility. State governments have the option to increase monthly amounts based on cost of living. The funds can be disbursed as live checks, direct deposits based on IRS information, or mailed “debit cards,” similar to those used by SNAP recipients. The latter method is to help reach the 5.4 percent of Americans who are unbanked and mainly low-income people of color.10 The no-strings attached approach would ensure there are no limitations to use and limit exclusions. UBI payments would include currently incarcerated people; if imprisoned folks still have to pay income taxes, then they should be afforded the payments indiscriminately. This would also be untaxed income for everyone, easing some of the middle-class/upper middle-class squeeze – and helping foment cross-class buy-in.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Reparations are a Handout

Opposition to a UBI is entrenched in racist language and ideology

Chambers et al, 2022 – prof of political science at Trinity College [Stefani, with Abby Nick and Maddie Granato, May 3 “The Benefits of Guaranteed Basic Income: Lessons from Advocates” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

A. Advocates warned against opponents’ use of coded racist language A key theme throughout my interviews and research was that much of the opposition to basic income programs is rooted in racial and economic discrimination. Opponents disguise racist intents into common language in debates and discussions. Advocates explained that many opponents see GBI as a free giveaway, offering free income to those too lazy to work. David Grant, head of the Hartford GBI task force, explained the opposition Hartford faced from surrounding majority-white towns: “Our surrounding sister cities and towns have residents that are absolutely against [GBI]. They see it as a free giveaway… And so there are these divides, these cultural divides that exist even in a state like Connecticut… I learned very quickly doing this work just how divided the community is on a program like GBI” The biggest opposition to the basic income program is the shame wrongly associated with giving money. We as a society view these programs as handouts and instead as assistance in rectifying a broken and inequitable system. Madeline Neighly, the Director of Guaranteed Income at the Economic Security Project stated: “I think honestly, the biggest opposition is one of narrative. It is a deeply held, deeply ingrained belief around pulling yourself up by your bootstraps. There are both spoken and undercurrents of gendered racism around who is deserving.” (Neighly) Advocates then explained that this opposition is often racially charged and when advocating for GBI you must be wary of opponents using racist language, Neighly went on to say: “And I think there are very key prime examples that people are much more aware of, like the welfare queen racist trope, but it’s much deeper than that. So there are dog whistles that are used, There are ways in which we’ve all been steeped in that culture, and it’s really hard to challenge that both externally and within ourselves… One should be able to live in dignity because of their existence, not because of their value in the labor market.” When advocating for GBI and UBI programs we must be aware of this underlying bias within conversation and opposition strategies.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Reparations Incalculable

The costs of racial capitalism and slavery are incalculable – this incalcuability is a reason we Need reparations, not a reason to vote against them as they demonstrate the magnitude of the debt and help build space for black bodies to achieve freedom

Inwood et al, ’20 - Department of Geography and Rock Ethics Institute, Pennsylvania State University [Joshua F.J. Anna Brand, Elise Quinn, December 19, 2020, Antipode, “Racial Capital, Abolition, and a Geographic Argument for Reparations”, , June 24, 2023, LN]

The duality between the actual material realities of slavery and the cost owed to the enslaved, coupled with realities that the full cost and weight owed for slav- ery can never be fully calculated, sits at the heart of reparations debates. Put dif- ferently, in the years after the US Civil War, efforts to collect back wages, land redistribution schemes, and efforts to provide access to educational resources were central to debates around reparations. These efforts were grounded in a kind of mathematics of redistribution that sought to make good on centuries of stolen labour and the reality that slavery had left large swaths of African American com- munities devoid of financial capital. Building on the insights of Katherine McKit- trick and Saidiya Hartman, respectively, we argue a limit to this kind of calculation, used to compute, understand and determine a kind of actuarial accrual of wrong that animates much of the historical and contemporary under- standing of reparations for the enslaved. These accountings largely leave untouched the violences inherent in a system built through anti-Black racism. As McKittrick (2014:16) argues, the accounting that stands in for traditional under- standings of reparations is “filled with bodies that can only come into being vis-a- vis racial-sexual violence; the documents and ledgers and logs that narrate the brutalities of this history give birth to new world blackness as they evacuate [or to use Gilmore’s term abandon] life from blackness”. Hartman (2008) argues that the end of slavery did not bring freedom, but instead brought other modes of unfreedom into being, including incarceration, new forms of colonialism, Jim Crowism as well as the continuation of processes that obscure black humanity and central to anti-Black racism. Moreover, we argue the contemporary mathematics of reparations fails to artic- ulate, much less directly address, the continued ways that racial capital is left inscribed in the landscape, and how racial capitalism has been reiterated through processes of abandonment and the creation of variegated landscapes of difference that come to reinforce anti-Black racism and the workings of white subjectivities (Hartman 2008; Sharpe 2010). Sharpe (2010:4) notes that, within contemporary frameworks on race, Black bodies become the knowledge bearers of abandon- ment, whereas white bodies are marked through an “exuberant freedom”. The duality of this dilemma, the latent spatialisations of slavery, which McKittrick (2013) points out in her work on plantation futures, and the layered and ongoing spatial manifestations of racial capitalism, which rest uneasily within and amidst each other in the current political and spatial moment, pose questions for repara- tive geographical approaches that cannot be dealt with enumeratively. As our work on Lehman Brothers documents and as Gilmore notes, racial capitalism is always multi-scaled and multi-dimensional. Therefore the growth of racial capital- ism within the US is tied to much larger global trade processes; the foundation stones of racialised inequity in the US are always and everywhere local and global. Further, the ongoing processes of racial capitalism represented so chillingly in the ongoing violence against Black bodies, the realities of Covid-19, and the concentration of deaths within communities of colour, as well as the continued practices of voter suppression and displacement, amongst other examples, point to the need for reparations to deal with the brutal systems of racism and white supremacy still at work in enumerating, marking and spatialising differences. A geographical case for reparations, therefore, we argue, is both spatial and tempo- ral. It raises questions not only about how to identify the interlocking ways that white supremacy works at different geographical scales and times but most importantly, is focused on strengthening and supporting those knowledge sys- tems and practices that animate Black freedom movements and which are foun- dational to the freedom aspirations of Black peoples within the US.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT No Way to tell Who gets Reparations

It is possible to provide qualifications for reparations – previous legislation proves tracing heritage is possible

Ray and Perry 2020 – Senior Fellows at the Brookings Institution [Rashawn Ray and Andre M. Perry, April 15, 2020, Brookings Institution, “Why we need reparations for Black Americans” , June 22, 2023, LN]

One key question after deciding what a reparations package should include is who should qualify. In short, a Black person who can trace their heritage to people enslaved in U.S. states and territories should be eligible for financial compensation for slavery. Meanwhile, Black people who can show how they were excluded from various policies after emancipation should seek separate damages. For instance, a person like Senator Cory Booker whose parents are descendants of slaves would qualify for slavery reparations whereas Senator Kamala Harris (Jamaican immigrant father and Indian immigrant mother) and President Barack Obama (Kenyan immigrant father and white mother) may seek redress for housing and/or education segregation. Sasha and Malia Obama (whose mother is Michelle Robinson Obama, a descendant of enslaved Africans) would qualify. To determine qualification, birth records can initially be used to determine if a person was classified as Black American. Economist Sandy Darity asserts that people should show a consistent pattern of identification. Census records can then be used to determine if a person has consistently identified as Black American. Finally, DNA testing can be used as a supplement to determine lineage. This is how Senator Booker, who first introduced a reparations bill in the Senate, learned that his lineage stemmed from Sierra Leone.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT Other Groups Deserve Reparations

African Americans are the last group to be denied reparations for a history of brutal racism.

Ray and Perry 2020 – Senior Fellows at the Brookings Institution [Rashawn Ray and Andre M. Perry, April 15, 2020, Brookings Institution, “Why we need reparations for Black Americans” , June 22, 2023, LN]

Reparations—a system of redress for egregious injustices—are not foreign to the United States. Native Americans have received land and billions of dollars for various benefits and programs for being forcibly exiled from their native lands. For Japanese Americans, $1.5 billion was paid to those who were interned during World War II. Additionally, the United States, via the Marshall Plan, helped to ensure that Jews received reparations for the Holocaust, including making various investments over time. In 1952, West Germany agreed to pay 3.45 billion Deutsche Marks to Holocaust survivors. Black Americans are the only group that has not received reparations for state-sanctioned racial discrimination, while slavery afforded some white families the ability to accrue tremendous wealth. And, we must note that American slavery was particularly brutal. About 15 percent of the enslaved shipped from Western Africa died during transport. The enslaved were regularly beaten and lynched for frivolous infractions. Slavery also disrupted families as one in three marriages were split up and one in five children were separated from their parents. The case for reparations can be made on economic, social, and moral grounds. The United States had multiple opportunities to atone for slavery—each a missed chance to make the American Dream a reality—but has yet to undertake significant action.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AT No one today participated in Slavery

Saying that we did not participate in slavery ourselves ignores that we have benefited from the structures of anti-black racism, and if we want the benefits we also are responsible for the harms.

Coates, 2014 – MacArthur Fellowship Winner. [Ta-Nehisi, June The Atlantic “THE CASE FOR REPARATIONS” https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ KB]

One cannot escape the question by hand-waving at the past, disavowing the acts of one’s ancestors, nor by citing a recent date of ancestral immigration. The last slaveholder has been dead for a very long time. The last soldier to endure Valley Forge has been dead much longer. To proudly claim the veteran and disown the slaveholder is patriotism à la carte. A nation outlives its generations. We were not there when Washington crossed the Delaware, but Emanuel Gottlieb Leutze’s rendering has meaning to us. We were not there when Woodrow Wilson took us into World War I, but we are still paying out the pensions. If Thomas Jefferson’s genius matters, then so does his taking of Sally Hemings’s body. If George Washington crossing the Delaware matters, so must his ruthless pursuit of the runagate Oney Judge. Black families making $100,000 typically live in the kinds of neighborhoods inhabited by white families making $30,000. In 1909, President William Howard Taft told the country that “intelligent” white southerners were ready to see blacks as “useful members of the community.” A week later Joseph Gordon, a black man, was lynched outside Greenwood, Mississippi. The high point of the lynching era has passed. But the memories of those robbed of their lives still live on in the lingering effects. Indeed, in America there is a strange and powerful belief that if you stab a black person 10 times, the bleeding stops and the healing begins the moment the assailant drops the knife. We believe white dominance to be a fact of the inert past, a delinquent debt that can be made to disappear if only we don’t look. There has always been another way. “It is in vain to alledge, that our ancestors brought them hither, and not we,” Yale President Timothy Dwight said in 1810. We inherit our ample patrimony with all its incumbrances; and are bound to pay the debts of our ancestors. This debt, particularly, we are bound to discharge: and, when the righteous Judge of the Universe comes to reckon with his servants, he will rigidly exact the payment at our hands. To give them liberty, and stop here, is to entail upon them a curse.