2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › AT: Europe Moving to Alternative Fuels
Brower, et. al, 6-22-23 [Derek Brower in New York and David Sheppard and Shotaro Tani, 6/22/23, Financial Times, “Germany locks in more US natural gas as it shuns Russian supply,” https://www.ft.com/content/ecdadbf1-1939-4952-b2cc-c84fb1cbe6d6 6/26/23, JR]
Germany has signed another long-term deal to import more US liquefied natural gas, as Berlin moves to replace Russian energy in its economy amid Moscow’s war in Ukraine.
SEFE, or Securing Energy For Europe — the company born out of Berlin’s effective nationalisation of the German operations of Russia’s state-owned Gazprom — will purchase 2.25mn tonnes a year of the super-chilled gas from Venture Global LNG, an American developer of export terminals along the Gulf of Mexico.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – U.S. Supplies Europe with Natural Gas
Cooban, 23 – Global Markets Writer for CNN (Anna Cooban, March 28, 2023, US has replaced Russia as Europe’s top crude oil supplier, https://www.cnn.com/2023/03/28/energy/eu-us-oil-imports-overtake-russia/index.html, BDP)
The United States is now the biggest supplier of crude oil to the European Union.
In December, 18% of the bloc’s crude imports came from America, EU data office Eurostat said Tuesday.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – U.S. Supplies Europe with Natural Gas
Chicaiza, 22 [ Melissa, 27 December, Energy in Depth, “Year in Review: U.S. Oil and Natural Gas Industry Hits Record Production to Meet Rising Global Demand in 2022.” Energy in Depth, 27 Dec. 2022, www.energyindepth.org/year-in-review-u-s-oil-and-natural-gas-industry-hits-record-production-to-meet-rising-global-demand-in-2022/, Accessed on 23 June 2023, NP]
With a war in Europe, economies recovering from COVID-19, and an ongoing global energy crisis, the U.S. oil and natural gas industry met the moment in 2022, increasing production to record highs to meet the demand of American consumers and businesses, as well as our allies abroad.
As 2022 comes to an end, here are a few highlights from this year:
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – U.S. Supplies Europe with Natural Gas
Chicaiza, 22 [ Melissa, 27 December, Energy in Depth, “Year in Review: U.S. Oil and Natural Gas Industry Hits Record Production to Meet Rising Global Demand in 2022.” Energy in Depth, 27 Dec. 2022, www.energyindepth.org/year-in-review-u-s-oil-and-natural-gas-industry-hits-record-production-to-meet-rising-global-demand-in-2022/, Accessed on 23 June 2023, NP]
Oil and Natural Gas Industry Continues Commitments to Reduce Emissions
Bottom Line: By delivering energy security to Europe at its time of greatest need, the American oil and natural gas industry once again demonstrated that it is a vital pillar of the world’s energy system. It continued setting production records this year despite the slowdowns brought on by the pandemic and other external pressures experienced over the previous two years, and is doing it cleaner than ever. Once again, 2022 proved that oil and gas is and will remain a reliable and secure energy source for many years ahead.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – U.S. Supplies Europe with Natural Gas
Cahill, 6-5-23 – Senior fellow with the Energy Security and Climate Change Program at CSIS (Ben, “Europe Wants Cleaner Gas. Can the United States Provide It?” https://www.csis.org/analysis/europe-wants-cleaner-gas-can-united-states-provide-it, NK)
These regulatory efforts align with international engagement on greenhouse gas reductions. At the 27th 2022 UN Climate Change Conference (COP27), a joint declaration between energy importers and exporters committed to reduce methane, carbon dioxide, and other emissions from the oil and gas value chain. In April, the U.S.-EU Energy Council extended these goals, aiming to “develop an internationally aligned approach for transparent measurement, monitoring, reporting, and verification for methane and carbon dioxide emissions across the fossil energy value chain.” The Department of Energy and the State Department have now pulled together a working group on these issues involving some 20 countries.
It is still early days for these efforts, and the underlying challenges are not easy to solve. One example is methane measurement, reporting, and verification (MRV) standards. At present, companies looking for ways to improve emissions accounting must make sense of industry protocols, a global reporting framework called the Oil and Gas Methane Partnership (OGMP 2.0), voluntary gas certification schemes and emissions registries, and frameworks for LNG cargo emissions accounting. Each has merit but none has universal approval, although the European Union’s proposed methane legislation strongly supports OGMP 2.0. Even if one gold standard were to emerge, policymakers are underestimating the difficulty of integrating methane measurement data from various sources such as satellites and aerial surveys. Some segments of the LNG value chain such as shipping could prove especially challenging.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – U.S. Supplies Europe with Natural Gas
Lefebvre 2023 – Covered the Energy Industry for the past Decade [Ben Lefebvre, March 28, 2023, “How American Energy helped Europe best Putin”, https://www.politico.com/news/2023/02/23/american-energy-europe-putin-00083750 AA]
The Russian troops who poured into Ukraine a year ago had a seemingly powerful weapon to keep Kyiv’s would-be allies cowed — Moscow’s dominance of Europe’s oil and gas supplies.
A year later, that strategy has backfired.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – More LNG Terminals Now
Humpert ’23 [Malte, 4/17/23, High North News, “Biden Administration Renews Green Light for Alaska LNG Project” https://www.highnorthnews.com/en/biden-administration-renews-green-light-alaska-lng-project 6/23/23, JR]
As part of an ongoing global push to produce and export more liquified natural gas (LNG), the US government renewed its approval of the proposed Alaska LNG facility.
The project, overseen by the Alaska Gasline Development Corporation, pitches the construction of a 1,300km pipeline from Alaska’s North Slope to deliver natural gas to a future liquefaction terminal on the Kenai peninsula.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – More LNG Terminals Now
Disavino 6-23-23 (Scott, “US LNG project approvals on track for record new volumes,” https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-lng-project-approvals-track-record-new-volumes-2023-06-23/, NK)
NEW YORK, June 23 (Reuters) - U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) developers are on track to approve three export projects capable of processing 5.1 billion cubic feet per day (bcfd) of gas in the first half of the year, a record volume for new LNG projects in any year.
The U.S. became the world's largest LNG producer by installed capacity in 2022 driven by the boom in LNG plant construction and a decade of surging shale gas discoveries. U.S. LNG exports are poised to reach 12.1 bcfd this year and 12.7 bcfd next year.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Natural Gas Affordable and Available
U.S. Energy Information Administration, 4-27-2023 [U.S. Energy Information Administration, 27 April, U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Natural gas explained Where our natural gas comes from” https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/natural-gas/where-our-natural-gas-comes-from.php Accessed on 20 June 2023, NP]
The United States now produces nearly all of the natural gas that it uses
U.S. dry natural gas production in 2022 was about 35.81 trillion cubic feet (Tcf), an average of about 98.11 billion cubic feet per day and the highest annual amount recorded. Most of the production increases since 2005 are the result of horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing techniques, notably in shale, sandstone, carbonate, and other tight geologic formations. Natural gas is produced from onshore and offshore natural gas and oil wells and from coalbeds. In 2022, U.S. dry natural gas production was about 10.8% greater than total U.S. natural gas consumption. Although most of U.S. the natural gas consumption is met with domestic production, the United States imports some natural gas to help supply domestic demand.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Natural Gas Affordable and Available
Corne, 2023 --- Employee of US Energy Information Administration (Matthew Corne, 4/27/23, US Energy Information Administration, U.S. natural gas production and LNG exports will likely grow through 2050 in AEO2023, https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=56320, 6/20/23, BDP)
Data source: U.S. Energy Information Administration, Annual Energy Outlook 2023 (AEO2023)
In our Annual Energy Outlook 2023 (AEO2023) Reference case, we project U.S. natural gas production to increase 15% and liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports to increase 152% between 2022 and 2050. We expect natural gas production to rise to 42.1 trillion cubic feet (Tcf) by 2050. Production growth is largely driven by U.S. LNG exports, which we expect to rise to 10 Tcf by 2050. Natural gas production growth on the Gulf Coast and in the Southwest reflects increased activity in the Haynesville Formation and Permian Basin, which are close to infrastructure connecting natural gas supply to growing LNG export facilities.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Natural Gas Affordable and Available
Hyerczyk 5-25-23 – Senior Market Analyst (James, “Natural Gas Forecast: Prices Face Downward Pressure Amid Ample Supply, Milder Weather”, https://www.fxempire.com/forecasts/article/natural-gas-forecast-prices-face-downward-pressure-amid-ample-supply-milder-weather-1349407, FX Empire, NK)
The Natural Gas Supply Association (NGSA) stated that ample storage levels, milder weather, and increased production will likely lead to downward pressure on US natural gas prices this summer. Despite reaching record levels of customer demand, with an average of 97 billion cubic feet per day (bcfd), prices at the Henry Hub are expected to average below last year’s $7.10 per million British thermal units (mmBtu) from April through October.
Higher Production, Storage Impact Prices
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Natural Gas Affordable and Available
Blankley 6-24-23 (Bethany, “Texas oil and gas industry reaches another record in May” https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/texas-oil-and-gas-industry-reaches-another-record-in-may, Washington Examiner, NK)
(The Center Square) – As Texas continued to lead the U.S. in job growth last month, the Texas upstream oil and natural gas industry added 6,900 jobs in May, the highest job growth reported in a single month in the 33 years the Texas Workforce Commission has reported the data.
The record jobs added in May brought the total upstream oil and natural gas job count in Texas to over 200,000 employed in the industry for the first time in over three years. Last month’s more than 206,000 upstream jobs was an increase of 22,700, or 12.4%, from May 2022, according to the data
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness – Natural Gas Affordable and Available
AT: renewables thumper --- natural gas biggest source of power despite existing renewable increases
Graeber 6-8-23 (Daniel “Renewables gaining ground, but gas dominates the U.S. energy grid” https://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2023/06/08/eia-renewables-natural-gas-electric-power/7301686235769/)
June 8 (UPI) -- Considerable gains in renewable energy are apparent in the energy sector, though natural gas remains the single largest source of power, the U.S. government said.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness / Link
McCormick ’23 [Myles, 4/17/23, Financial Times, “Rising costs and competition threaten US boom in LNG projects,” https://www.ft.com/content/e7f3681f-3f0a-40de-ab65-65f62c7d6acb 6/24/23, JR]
Intense competition between developers and escalating costs are complicating efforts to bring new liquefied natural gas projects online in the US, even as the fallout from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine creates huge appetite for American fuel exports.
A new wave of multibillion-dollar LNG projects on the US coast of the Gulf of Mexico has gathered pace over the past year as the energy upheaval triggered by the war prompts a global dash to secure fossil fuels from vast Texas shale fields.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › Uniqueness › 2nc Uniqueness / Link
U.S. Energy Information Administration, 3-3-2022 [U.S. Energy Information Administration, 27 April, U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Annual Energy Outlook 2022” https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/narrative/production/sub-topic-01.php Accessed on 23 June, NP]
We project U.S. consumption and production of petroleum and other liquids to grow through 2050. Domestic consumption and production levels of petroleum and other liquids remain relatively close to one another through most of the projection period in the Reference case. Consumption increases by 15%, and production increases by 17% from 2021 to 2050. However, consumption and production of specific petroleum products vary. We also project consumption and production of natural gas to grow through 2050. During the projection period, natural gas production grows by almost 24%, approximately twice as fast as consumption. Much of this growth in natural gas production is exported as liquefied natural gas (LNG). By 2050, we project that approximately 25% more natural gas will be produced than consumed in the United States. Together, these Reference case trends highlight the continued growth in demand for U.S. natural gas and petroleum products.
NATURAL GAS EXPORTS INCREASE WITH PRODUCTION, DRIVEN BY GLOBAL DEMAND AND CONTINUED CONSTRUCTION OF NEW LNG EXPORT FACILITIES
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › 1nc DA Natural Gas
Bollfrass '22 - Senior Researcher at the Center for Security Studies of ETH Zurich [August-September 2022, Alexander and Stephen Herzog; "The War in Ukraine and Global Nuclear Order;" Survival Global Politics and Strategy Volume 64, 2022 - Issue 4, p. 7-32]
The odds of nuclear use have increased in recent months, but this is not the first time that has happened. It is more relevant that Russia’s behaviour has brought nearly invisible constructs into public view, exposing the scaffolding of a European security environment based on nuclear deterrence and the targeting of cities. While these revelations will certainly shape government and public views on nuclear issues, it is premature to ascribe to them the erosion of the nuclear taboo. At the same time, complacency regarding the dangers of nuclear weapons in a world where they are used as shields to enable infringements of national sovereignty and grievous war crimes against civilians is simply foolhardy. Open debates on the value of nuclear deterrence versus disarmament as tools of security are long overdue. How they will be resolved is uncertain. In the meantime, Washington will need to seize the moment to continue reassuring its allies of the ironclad nature of its nuclear guarantees. In turn, the governments of US allies and partners should encourage honest discussions with their populations about nuclear protection to attenuate the effects of Russian scaremongering.
* * *
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
DA – Natural Gas – MNDI HPA › 1nc DA Natural Gas
Jones, 6/22/2023 - International Banker [Alexander, 22 June 2023, International Banker, “Why Natural-Gas Prices Have Crashed” internationalbanker.com/brokerage/why-natural-gas-prices-have-crashed/ Accessed 25 June 2023, NP]
In the United States, meanwhile, booming natural-gas production has been cited as one of the main factors responsible for the price decline. Already the world’s largest natural-gas producer, the US is now pumping out vast quantities of natural gas, with the country’s biggest shale field—the Permian Basin of Texas and New Mexico—producing record-high gas volumes for every month this year thus far, according to the U.S. EIA. Much of this supply uptick has come in concert with the rise in crude-oil production off the back of higher oil prices. “About a third of US gas production is associated gas—produced from oil wells,” Jacques Rousseau, a managing director at research firm ClearView Energy Partners, told Reuters in early April. “This production is unlikely to decline given current oil prices.” As such, the amount of gas sitting in storage in the US is around one-fifth higher than is normal for this time of year.
One also cannot ignore the outsized impact LNG (liquefied natural gas) is now having on the natural-gas market, with a wave of new export terminals coming online over the next few years likely to weigh heavily on prices. Indeed, with gas supplies from Russia to Europe being severely curtailed, something of a supply frenzy has emerged as LNG exporters step in to replace this shortfall. The US, for one, is set to expand its export capacity significantly, with several LNG projects on the US Gulf of Mexico coast that use Texas shale gas expected to launch soon.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
Bonus › Carbon Border Taxes => Inequality
Western countries ignore inability developing countries have to keep up with incredible expenses of avoiding fossil fuels
Ghosh 23--- Professor of Economics, University of Massachusetts (Jayati, “The High Cost of Carbon Pricing” https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/carbon-border-taxes-protectionist-and-harm-developing-countries-by-jayati-ghosh-2023-03, NK)
Amid the growing enthusiasm for carbon border taxes, Western policymakers have largely ignored the negative impact on the world’s poorest countries. For carbon-pricing policies to succeed, developed countries must show their commitment to shared prosperity by enabling knowledge-sharing and fostering equitable climate finance.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
Affirmative Answers › 2ac AT: Asia / Taiwan Impact
Menon, 23 – director of the grand strategy program at Defense Priorities, a professor emeritus at the City College of New York’s Colin Powell School for Civic and Global Leadership, and a senior research fellow at Columbia University’s Saltzman Institute of War and Peace Studies [Rajan and Daniel De Petris; 3/16/23; "What the United States Does in Ukraine Won’t Matter in Taiwan;" https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/03/16/usa-china-ukraine-taiwan-credibility-resolve/]
The o ne constant element in this slew of surprises has been the familiar claim that U.S. credibility is on the line and will rise or fall depending on the war’s result and that Ukraine must therefore be provided the weaponry it needs to prevail.
The logic underlying this assertion can be summarized as follows: If the United States does not stand firm against an adversary like Russia, some other rival, somewhere else, even one located far afield, will be emboldened to test the limits of America’s resolve. In short, every region is connected and every decision the United States makes will have global ramifications.
2023
MNDI
Disadvantage
Affirmative Answers › --- XT: No Escalation
Berdishevsky '23 [Shachar; 1/14/23; "Russia's Vladimir Putin afraid of coup, will retire in 2023 - report;" https://www.jpost.com/international/article-728496]
A source who was close to Putin once claimed that "the president will nominate his chosen heir already this year, instead of risking his downfall," the British Daily Mail reported on Friday. This comes after the Russian president's popularity is reportedly in a freefall because of repeated military failures in the war in Ukraine.
According to his former ally, Putin will want to transfer the power to his chosen successor and retire to his palace near the black sea, rather than risk a coup against him, similar to what happened to Qaddafi and other dictators.