Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Labor Market

A UBI helps counter women’s exclusion from the workplace.

Flanigan, 2018 - prof of leadership studies and law at the University of Richmond [Jessica, Jan 25, Slate “The Feminist Case for a Universal Basic Income” TA]

Globally, women are more likely to live in extreme poverty than men. In the United States, women as a group are poorer than men due to the economic burdens associated with caregiving and the segregation of women into “pink-collar” industries that typically pay less than male-dominated industries. One of the main benefits of implementing a UBI in the U.S. and elsewhere is that giving people cash is a relatively direct and effective way to fight poverty. The basic income is also a matter of economic justice for women as a whole. While capitalism has been beneficial to women on balance, the current system reflects historical patterns of female exclusion from labor markets and policies that denied property rights to women. For example, throughout the 19th century and into the 20th century, married women lacked legal protections for their property rights under the legal doctrine of coverture. And until the 1980s, husbands retained unilateral control over marital property in some jurisdictions. As I have argued elsewhere, a UBI would make capitalism more just by compensating those who live with the legacy of historical and enduring economic injustices.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Gender Poverty Gap

A basic income is key to ending the patriarchy because reducing women’s poverty promotes democratic engagement.

Pateman, 2018 – Prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Aug 15, Feminist Current “Why feminists need to take up a basic income in their fight for women’s liberation: An interview with Carole Pateman” Interviewed by Jacqueline Gullion, https://www.feministcurrent.com/2018/08/15/feminists-need-take-basic-income-fight-womens-liberation-interview-carole-pateman/ Acc 3/23/23 TA]

JG: Can you describe how you came to understand basic income as in the interests of the advancement of women and a more democratic society? CP: One of the first things that attracted me to basic income is that, if the income was set at a sufficient level, it would not just relieve poverty, but it would be the end of poverty. For women it is actually very important because women’s income tends to be less than men’s. I mean if you think about a few decades ago [in the global North], it was not seen as altogether seemly for married women to be employed. They were reliant on their husband’s income, and his generosity (or not) for their own standard of living. Now, women’s wages still tend to be less than men’s, so we still don’t have a situation where women and men have equally high standards of living. With something like a basic income, women could be assured of a reasonable standard of living in the same way men are. Finally, we’d really start talking about equal citizenship. JG: That certainly supports the argument of why it would be better for individuals to be entitled to the basic income rather than a household to have a set amount. CP: You know what happens historically when money goes to the household? Men tend to spend it on things other than the necessities of life for their wives and children. One good thing about family allowances in Britain is that they were always paid to the mother, so there was a really good chance that the children benefited. JG: Could you say a bit more about the ways in which a basic income enables women (or anyone) to participate fully as a citizen in a democracy? CP: A certain level of subsistence is required if you’re going to have the time and energy and possibility of getting the knowledge required to participate fully in your society. If all your time and energy goes toward trying to make enough money to keep body and soul together, or to providing for a family, then you are going to have to make pretty heroic efforts to actually participate. If you are actually interested in having a democratic citizenry — that is where citizens have the opportunity, in some way or another, to govern themselves and not just be governed by others — then there has to be a material basis for it.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Gender Poverty Gap

A UBI would address structural discrimination against women by addressing the gender wealth gap – women are disproportionately poor.

Schulz 2017 - Board of Directors of the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development [Patricia, Jan 31, Global Social Policy “Universal basic income in a feminist perspective and gender analysis” UP]

A feminist perspective and a gender analysis – avoiding conflation of gender and women – can usefully contribute to the discussion on the universal basic income (UBI). Indeed, it helps analyze the concrete situation of women and of men, by looking into power relationships between them and structural discrimination based on sex, including multiple/intersectional discriminations. These contribute to making women and those they care for vulnerable to poverty with its various deprivations. Advocates of the UBI could thus reinforce their strong arguments based on social justice, equality, dignity, freedom from want if they argued (more) systematically also from a gender equality perspective. 2 The UBI, if unconditional and at a level covering basic needs, would help tackle the structural inequalities inherited from the past, due to the sexual divide between the public and private sphere. Although the normative framework has improved in many countries of the North and South, and women’s education is now higher than men’s in a number of countries, in average, women still face de facto unequal chances of political, economic and social participation. Their educational efforts are not rewarded the same: the higher their education, the greater the gender pay gap – one of the most depressing statistics one can consider. A recent study on the discrimination experienced by women due to pregnancy and maternity in the United Kingdom shows how deeply discrimination is embedded in society and how it prevents an equal access to the world of work and equal chances in this world, even after decades of efforts, legal and practical, in one of the most advanced economies, to implement gender equality in this field

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Gender Poverty Gap

A UBI is a key issue for women because they are more vulnerable to market failures and extreme poverty – COVID proves.

Goldblatt, 2021 - Professor of Law, University of the Witwatersrand [Beth “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights” Acc 1/28/23 TA]

Basic income has been a prominent policy proposal from a range of quarters in the context of uncertainty over the future of work and the problem of growing economic inequality. More recently it is being considered in some countries as a possible response to the economic fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic. A basic income is an unconditional, tax-financed, government payment provided to every member of society. It has recently been articulated by the UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, Philip Alston, as a human rights issue. It has also been the subject of long-standing debate amongst feminists about its likely benefit for women and gender equality. This article explores the intersections between basic income, gender and human rights. It provides some background to the discussion of a basic income within human rights and within feminism before considering how a human rights lens informed by gender might deepen the debate on basic income and contribute to the development of social policies that address gendered poverty and inequality. It also gives some thought to the value of a human rights framing of basic income for the feminist project. Keywords: Basic income, gender, feminism, human rights 1. Introduction The idea of a basic income, ‘paid by a political community to all its members on an individual basis, without means test or work requirement’,1 is a fiercely debated policy option. The idea has a long history and has generated a rich academic literature covering basic income’s philosophical premises, feasibility and likely impact.2 There is also a prominent movement across the world on basic income with many vocal supporters.3 The idea is being floated at the highest levels and in a wide range of forums. In 2018, the UN Secretary General in a speech to the General Assembly said governments may need to consider a basic income in responding to the changing nature of work as a result of technological innovation.4 Former US president Barack Obama in his 2019 Nelson Mandela lecture also called for discussion of a basic income in response to technological change, globalisation, challenges to work, and even the problems facing democracies.5 At a time of global uncertainty a basic income is being proposed by diverse voices across the political spectrum, including technology and business leaders such as Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk and Richard Branson.6 The COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns and their severe consequences for economies, employment and livelihoods have turned the basic income debate into a live policy issue in some countries. The economic downturn, described as a ‘pink collar recession’, is having a particularly harsh impact on women.7 This is because women are in industries and roles hardest hit by job cuts, loss of access to child care, and because women were already the most precarious workers. Lack of state support due to a decade of austerity cuts in many countries following the 2008 financial crisis have left vulnerable workers and carers with little to fall back on. As the UN Secretary-General has noted: Across the globe, women earn less, save less, hold less secure jobs, are more likely to be employed in the informal sector. They have less access to social protections and are the majority of single-parent households. Their capacity to absorb economic shocks is therefore less than that of men. 8

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Gender Poverty Gap

A UBI helps women escape poverty – they disproportionately have low paying jobs.

Webster, 2019 - Head of research at Royal Society of Arts [Hannah March 8th Why Basic Income is a women’s issue, Royal Society of Arts, , EP]

Basic Income and the role of women in the labour market There are wider arguments to be made to support Basic Income, regardless of the failures of the current system. Analysis by the Resolution Foundation last year found that women were more likely to be in the lowest paid jobs than men, and that they were less likely to be able to progress out of low pay. Universal payments would support these women to keep their heads above water. And, looking inside the home, the ONS estimate that women carry out 10 hours more work in the home per week than men. Again, a Basic Income could act as an antidote to this, empowering and affording them the means to pursue their own interests.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Stigmatization

An Unconditional UBI would liberate women from their vulnerability and stigmatization – it would restore the unbalanced power relationships

Schulz 2017 - Board of Directors of the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development [Patricia, Jan 31, Global Social Policy “Universal basic income in a feminist perspective and gender analysis” UP]

As women, especially heads of households, are exposed to a far higher degree than men to poverty, they also are more exposed to the stigmatization and marginalization provoked by poverty. An unconditional UBI would contribute to freeing them from this vulnerability and would respect their dignity. It could also help balance unequal power relationships with (male) relatives and/or partners. A UBI would help social security systems to keep up with the challenges they face: increase of inequality and persistence of gender inequality, recurring economic and financial crises, technological change and globalization and their effects on jobs (number and quality) and social protection, demographic evolution and migration patterns. It would also contribute to strengthening the social fabric, needed for the future of democracies. If they do not rapidly handle these challenges, and the fears created by them, democratic systems could lose their legitimacy with citizens no longer considering them capable to ensure a fair enough re-distribution of the fruits of increased productivity. Female citizens have a particular stake in the introduction of a UBI to maintain systems that respect their human rights and freedoms as, generally, authoritarian governments have quite restrictive views of women’s rights and gender equality. Many developing countries have established programmes for universal social protection, and some have shown that it is possible even in poor countries. ‘Where there is a will, there is a way’ remains as true today as at the time the first social laws were adopted. GSP Forum 91 But it remains a huge political challenge to overcome the resistance against delinking social protection and remunerated work, even when the latter tends to become more and more uncertain. The international legal framework on human rights can certainly be used to advocate for the introduction of a UBI, also in a gendered perspective, to all persons, at a level that covers their basic needs, with no conditionalities. International Labour Organization (ILO) Recommendation 202 of 2012 on social protection floors and the Sustainable Development Goals8 (SDGs) adopted in September 2015 by all member countries of the United Nations are important elements of soft law and/or political commitments9 completing the international human rights framework offered by articles 9, 11 and 12 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights as well as articles 11, 12, 13 and 14 of the Convention on the Elimination of All forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) and of course the Universal Declaration on Human Rights articles 3, 22, 23 and 25. Social protection and care are mentioned in three of the SDGs: ending poverty (no. 1), reducing inequality (no. 2) and reaching gender equality (no. 5). In addition, Goal 17 on governance could also be used. It remains to be seen whether the SDGs give the necessary impetus for States to implement the human rights norms that most of them have ratified but that many violate or ignore far too often. A UBI would be the continuation of the previous efforts to ensure that every person has a right to basic economic security, everywhere on the planet, women as well as men. A UBI would thus be part of an emancipatory politics for all, linking economic security to all other human rights including gender equality, and ensuring every person the dignity and personal calm of having enough to provide for their basic needs. It would be of historical significance that human beings not born rich could benefit from this security and that those unable to be in the labour market, formal or informal (or only in reduced fashion), would also benefit from it. Again, in view of the present level of gender inequality in certain parts of the world, women and their dependents have a lot to gain from such a change. The UBI would be the logical evolution of all previous social security measures. It can be transformative, as is hoped for with the Agenda 2013 on the SDGs. We cannot afford to miss this opportunity

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Welfare Queen

A Basic Income would liberate women because it eliminates the gendered Discourse of welfare policy.

Pateman 2004 - Professor of Government at the University of Sydney [ Carole Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income Politics and Society, Vol. 32 No. 1, March 89-105 TA]

Little attention has been paid in recent academic debates to the democratic significance of a stake or a basic income. Participants have tended to focus on such questions as social justice, relief of poverty, equality of opportunity, or promotion of flexible labor markets, rather than democracy. I do not want to downplay the importance of these questions, or suggest that they are irrelevant to democracy, but they involve different concerns and arguments than explicit attention to democratization. Academic discussion today is too often conducted in a series of separate compartments, each with its own frame of reference. In political theory, for instance, discussion of social justice has usually been undertaken by one set of theorists and democratic theory by others, with the two discussions seldom inter- secting. The terms of the debate about stakeholding have tended to be confined within the framework provided by republicanism, libertarianism, utilitarianism, and liberalism. And, rather oddly in ostensibly “political” theory (though in keeping with the times), political argument is being displaced by neo-classical economic concepts and theories. The narrowness of the debate is exacerbated by the striking absence of the arguments and insights provided by feminist scholars. Some feminists are opposed to a basic income but their arguments are absent too. Many years of scholarship about marriage, employment, and citizenship are virtually ignored in debates about basic income and stakeholding, and women’s freedom (self government) and its implications for a democratic social transformation have hardly been mentioned. Now that the nostrums of neo-classical economics enshrined in national and international policy making have begun to look a little tattered, the way is being opened for some new ideas. The idea of a basic income is not, strictly speaking, new; advocates usually trace it back to Tom Paine, and I have mentioned one of its earlier incarnations as a state bonus. But it is now being more widely discussed, and current circumstances (as I shall discuss below) offer a much more favorable environment than in years past. A basic income offers not just an alternative to highly bureaucratized public provision, and to the less eligibility doctrines that have been resurrected in recent years, but an opportunity to move out of the very well-worn ruts of current discussions of welfare policy. As Brian Barry has stated, “Basic income is not just another idea for rejigging the existing system.” Rather, it has the potential to lead to “a different way of relating individual and society.”4 Or, at least, it has that potential if it is argued for in terms of democratization and women’s freedom.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Breadwinner Model

A UBI empowers gender minorities by dispelling gendered and family stereotypes

Williams, 2021 - Research and Data Section, UN Women [Loui, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal Basic Income: Potential And Limitations From A Gender Perspective” TA]

Some feminist proponents of UBI also celebrate its potential to reshape patriarchal gender norms around paid work and unpaid care, since no person is relegated to being a masculinized ‘breadwinner’ or feminized ‘caretaker’ in order to have income security. If combined with the provision of affordable quality care services, UBI could potentially encourage a more equitable distribution of care among genders.19 Indeed, some argue that UBI could lead to higher valuation of a range of non-commodified activities, including voluntary, emotional/affective and creative pursuits.20 Given that UBI is paid to individuals regardless of kinship relations, it could also support a range of diverse family forms, including cohabiting and extended families and ‘families of choice’ formed by many LGBTIQ people.21 Whether and to what extent these positive effects materialize will depend to a large degree on specific design features, including whether the UBI’s benefit level allows for maintaining an adequate standard of living.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Breadwinner Model

A basic income empowers women – it gives autonomy over financial decision making, valuing care work benefits women’s mental health, and it dispels the male breadwinner model by giving men the opportunity to enter caregiving.

Cantillon and McLean, 2016 - Glasgow Caledonian University and UC Berkeley [Sara and Caitlin, Sept 3, The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare, Basic Income Guarantee: The Gender Impact within Households," Available at: TA]

There is a large theoretical literature and accumulating empirical evidence to suggest that in addition to, or even regardless of, material welfare gains, independent income provides a source of economic autonomy which, in turn, impacts bargaining and power relations with the household. Differences between men and women in terms of their roles in household decision-making (particularly regarding income and large expenditures) have been linked to their differences in terms of income, status, education, and ethnicity (Cantillon & Nolan, 1998, 2001; Nyman & Reinikainen, 2007; Rake & Jayatilka, 2002). An important distinction has also been made between high-level decisions on the allocation of resources to each area (food, clothing, household bills, holidays, etc.) and instrumental decisions regarding the management of the budget within each of these areas (Pahl, 1989). Several studies suggest that the woman usually engages in the management of household resources, while the overall allocative control and decisionmaking power rests with the man (Lauer & Yodanis, 2011). Differences in control over household finances are therefore important in their own right, as an indicator of power, and for the role they may play in producing and explaining differences in living standards. Differences in management are also important insofar as they reflect respective roles in decision- making and identify who carries the burden of responsibility for stretching scarce resources. Several UK studies, using both small scale surveys and large nationally representative samples (Rake & Jayatilaka, 2002; Vogler, 1998; Vogler & Pahl, 1994), have explored different systems for managing household resources and their implications for the living standards of individual members. Rottman (1994), Cantillon, Gannon, and Nolan (2004) and Watson, Maître, & and Whelan (2013) used Irish data to examine this issue and also identified a number of distinct approaches to managing resources. The studies produced similar results: while joint financial decision-making is common among couples, in a significant proportion of couples the husband retains control in terms of major decisions, while the wife has the responsibility of managing resources on a week-to-week basis. Further, the responsibility for making resources stretch when money is tight falls disproportionately on women. A third possible effect is that, irrespective of any material benefit or even increased control over financial resources, a BIG could have a positive psychological impact on women's sense of self and well-being. Some of those studying BIG have pointed out that this could be a result of increased recognition or valuation of unremunerated work, in the sense that activities outside the paid labor market are formally recognised as worthwhile (Robeyns, 2001). Alternatively, it could arise in terms of measures of psychological health and well-being where independent income provides a greater sense of control, as empirical studies within the intra-household literature have demonstrated (Cantillon & Moran, 2016; Kan & Laurie 2010; Walters, McDonough, & Strohschein, 2002). The fourth effect relates to the issue of inequalities in leisure time and participation in unpaid work. There is now a vast literature documenting disparities in time use between men and women which has specifically highlighted the greater participation of women in unpaid domestic and care work and the inequality of leisure time which results from this (Bianchi, Sayer, Milkie, & Robinson, 2012; Latshaw, 2011). BIG advocates have argued that unconditional cash benefits can raise the status of work outside the labor market, as well as reduce economic pressure to create space for such activity. For example, McKay (2005) and Zelleke (2011) argue that a BIG does not prioritize labor market participation at the expense of productive activity outside the labor market and therefore does not penalize individuals for engaging in it. There is a tendency to assume that this would lead to continued gender specialization; however, an unconditional, steady cash payment could theoretically reduce pressure on men as breadwinners by providing a measure of financial security outside labor market income, allowing space for men to reduce their participation in the labor market and potentially to take on a greater share of traditionally feminine tasks (Bambrick, 2006). This could be heightened or strengthened via the psychological effect: e.g., greater societal value placed on these activities could shape men's willingness to engage in such work.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Breadwinner Model

A basic income increases women’s bargaining power in the family because it makes them less dependent on the male as the “breadwinner”

Zelleke 2011 - prof of political science at The New School [Almaz, January Policy and Politics, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” TA]

None of these changes would guarantee on their own that men would scale back time spent in paid employment, or that if they did they would increase their time spent in care work. But they would decrease the costs to men of doing so, and would increase their opportunities to break out of the gendered distribution that confines men to paid employment-centric models of contributory citizenship just as women are constrained in other ways (Roebyns, 2000, 2001). An unconditional basic income and the reduction of the dependency of the caregiving partner on the employed partner for income, benefits and status should encourage both men and women to combine both roles either simultaneously or in turn. Finally, while an unconditional basic income and the associated institutional changes a feminist theory of distributive justice implies would increase the bargaining power of women vis-à-vis men over determining the distribution of labour within any particular family, the gains for women in traditional male–female partnerships are not accomplished at the expense of the exclusion of single parents from any benefits or the exploitation of the low-income women who carry the burden of care work when more affluent women work in paid employment.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Breadwinner Model

A feminist framework requires a universal basic income – it problematizes the breadwinner model and prevents the punishment of women who go against the model.

Zelleke 2011 - prof of political science at The New School [Almaz, January Policy and Politics, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” TA]

Conclusion Feminist political theory has in many ways moved on from critiques of theories of justice, by moving beyond the focus on questions of economic inequality to questioning the value or legitimacy of such comprehensive theories altogether. While much recent work has indeed extended feminism’s critical project into important new areas, it is crucial that our attention not shift entirely before the insights gained in the realm of economic inequality are institutionalised in policy. The Scandinavian version of the universal breadwinner model of citizenship – a generous welfare state with policies designed to induce men to take caregiving leaves from paid employment – offers one model of a gender-egalitarian society, but one that continues the prioritisation of the male-dominated public sphere of paid employment over the sphere of care. The feminist version of the liberal egalitarian tradition that has as its foundation a universal, unconditional basic income at a level to meet basic needs, on the other hand prioritises the emerging norm of combined care work and paid employment throughout adulthood. The latter attempts not so much to mould individual behaviour to a socially dominant norm, but to allow for the emergence of alternative norms of behaviour beyond the dominant universal breadwinner norm. By socialising the cost of supporting care – not only among fathers, but also among all those whose high earnings suggest protection from the burdens of care – a basic income promotes reciprocity not only within families but also between those with care responsibilities and those without. Finally, by providing an unconditional floor of income to low-skilled workers, basic income provides bargaining power for those who might prefer to stay home and take care of their own children or parents over working as low-paid caregivers for higher-paid women and men, or for women and men of all classes to demand workplaces more accommodating of universal care responsibilities. A universal, unconditional basic income does not promise a gender-symmetrical society – an unreachable goal anyway, until men can bear and breastfeed babies. But it may lead to a society in which remaining, and perhaps essential gender differences do not penalise women (or men) who choose not to pursue androcentric ideals of citizenship by relegating them to poverty, dependence on their spouses or employers, and second-class citizenship.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Welfare Queen

The “Welfare Queen” label reinforces racism, sexism, poverty and other forms of social injustice.

Sparks et al, 2003 - prof at Bryn Mawr College Graduate School of Social Work and Social Research [Holloway with Joe Soss, and Richard Fording, Race and the Politics of Welfare Reform, P. 175-177]

One particularly powerful way that discourses enter public sphere discussions is through stereotypes, or what Patricia Hill Collins has theorized as “controlling images” (2000, chap. 4; see also Lubiano 1992). Controlling images, Collins suggests, are socially constructed images “designed to make racism, sexism, poverty, and other forms of social injustice appear to be natural, normal, and inevitable parts of everyday life” (2000, 69). The examples Collins discusses—mammies, matriarchs, welfare queens, and hoochies—objectify and subordinate black women. These images serve as a kind of shorthand for interpreting, shaping, stigmatizing—and thereby controlling—the actions of marginalized groups. For example, Collins notes that single black women who work outside the home to support their families are called “matriarchs,” and instead of being praised as good providers are blamed for driving their men away and for not being home to supervise their children adequately. Single black women who do stay home to supervise their children are stigmatized as “welfare queens” and are viewed as lazy rather than as good parents. In both cases, the controlling image constructs the woman as the problem, which draws attention away from structural reasons for poverty, and from the gender, race, and class discrimination that hinders the ability of black women to support and care for themselves and their families in the first place (2000, 72–84).6 Controlling images and stereotypes are used in turn to reinforce larger, overarching narratives about social and political issues. For example, as I discuss in the next section, controlling images of welfare recipients as loafers and drug addicts have supported a narrative that portrays poverty as the result of individuals’ bad decision-making and learned “dependency.” This narrative in turn supports policy programs that sanction participants for failures of “personal responsibility.” If a controlling image is widely taken as true, then opponents will have more difficulty challenging either the discourse or the policy prescription that has been constructed to solve the “problem” posed by the stereotyped group (Naples 1997). For democratic theorists concerned about citizen participation, attending to the discourses and controlling images used in the context of public sphere discussions clearly augments approaches that attend to more obvious practices of exclusion. The power to construct potent con- trolling images and discourses about other citizens, if unchallenged, not only shapes the way those citizens’ speech is heard, but also affects whether they even try to speak in the first place. Such power can thus significantly affect who participates and how in public sphere discussions. While some advantaged citizens have an easy time both with gaining access to political discussions and being heard as authoritative once there, others face nearly insurmountable challenges on both fronts. The result is a public sphere in which some citizens have a far more powerful voice than they should.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms - Breadwinner Model

The Breadwinner model reinforces patriarchy – social norms interact to stereotype women as dependent on their husbands and to devalue women’s domestic work

Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, TA]

The freedom not to be employed runs counter to the direction of much recent public policy and political rhetoric (especially in Anglo-American countries, though the policies are international), and this makes stakeholding more palatable than basic income in the current political climate. The effect of such policies and rhetoric is to draw even tighter the long-standing link between employment and citizenship, at the very time when a reassessment has been made possible by changing circumstances. The institution of employment is a barrier to democratic freedom and citizenship in two ways. First, economic enterprises have an undemocratic structure, a point that I shall not pursue here.23 Second, as feminist scholars have demonstrated, the relationship between the institutions of marriage, employment, and citizenship has meant that the standing of wives as citizens has always been, and remains, problematic. The Anglo-American social insurance system was constructed on the assumption that wives not only were their husbands’economic dependents but lesser citizens whose entitlement to benefits depended on their private status, not on their citizenship. Male “breadwinners,” who made a contribution from their earnings to “insure” that they received benefits in the event of unemployment or sickness, and in their old age, were the primary citizens. Their employment was treated as the contribution that a citizen could make to the well-being of the community. Ackerman and Alstott acknowledge this in their criticism of “workplace justice,”24 and their recognition that unconditional retirement pensions would be particularly important for the many older women whose benefits still largely derive from their husbands’ employment record.25 That is to say, only paid employment has been seen as “work,” as involving the tasks that are the mark of a productive citizen and contributor to the polity. Other contributions, notably all the work required to reproduce and maintain a healthy population and care for infants, the elderly, the sick, and infirm—the caring tasks, most of which are not paid for and are undertaken by women—have been seen as irrelevant to citizenship.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms - Breadwinner Model

Welfare policies must move away from a focus on the family to promote women’s autonomy – otherwise they reinforce women’s subordinate role in the family.

Mckay and Vanevery, 2002 – prof of economics at Glascow Univ. and Independent Writer [Ailsa and Jo “Social Politics, Gender, Gender, Family, and Income Maintenance: A Feminist Case for Citizens Basic Income,” Summer TA]

In liberal democracies a woman's relationship to the state is mediated by her husband, who is seen to contribute directly to society through his paid work. Despite recognition at the level of discourse of women's "vital unpaid service" to the nation, this service is still treated as if it were but a personal one to her husband. A new model of citizenship needs to explicitly recognize the importance of the "sexual contract." In addition, it must recognize the social changes in personal relationships and intimate/sexual lives. Janet Finch (1989) points out that historical evidence shows that when the state's notion of family obligation is out of line with individual ideas of appropriateness, policies can have the opposite effect to that intended. Both Finch (1989) and Weston (1991) emphasize that individuals tend to see family as a last resort for assistance. This is in direct contrast to the state's assumptions, enshrined in social security policies, that the (nuclear) family should be a first resort. Several authors have proposed concepts that attempt to account for this. Julia O'Connor's insistence on the importance of personal autonomy, as "insulation from personal and public dependence," seems to us a promising direction (O'Connor 1993, 515). Lister's concept of "defamilialization" performs a similar role (1994; see also the discussion in Lister 1995, 29-30). In our opinion, welfare policies need to be disengaged from a particular model of the family— worker-citizen + wife-mother + children—if women are to achieve personal autonomy and a direct relationship to the state. The implications of family change and sexual citizenship for policy are that policies should be based on personal autonomy and enable a variety of supportive relationships. This involves a radical rethinking of the relationship between family and citizenship, a relationship with significant implications for the construction of gender. In an apparently paradoxical fashion, the best way to support families may be to treat people as individuals in social security policies. The privileging of marriage (even if broadened to include cohabiting heterosexual couples and even lesbian or gay couples) is part and parcel of constituting women as "second-class" citizens. Equal citizenship rights involve recognizing the dependence of the "social contract" on the "sexual contract" and devising new ways of organizing the various types of work that need to be done. As Judith Stacey has argued: "The family" is not "here to stay." Nor should we wish it were. On the contrary, I believe that all democratic people, whatever their kinship preferences, should work to hasten its demise. An ideological concept that imposes mythical homogeneity on the diverse means by which people organize their intimate relationships, "the family" distorts and devalues this rich variety of kinship stories.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Care Work

A basic income improves equality for mothers who stay home because it recognizes their unpaid work.

Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1  AC]

2.3 Effects on the Choice of Labour and Job The last first-order effect of a basic income is the higher direct well-being that individuals can gain when they can choose the job they like better but which is worse paid, or when they can choose for unpaid care labour instead of market labour. Which second order effects can we expect? First, we might expect that a basic income will lead Many young mothers want to withdraw (temporarily) from the labour market to raise their children themselves. If these women have the choice between a badly paid job, or the possibility to stay at home, the second option is for many of them much more attractive.

2.4 A Revaluation of Unpaid Work. to a revaluation of unpaid work. In Western societies there is a societal tendency to undervalue unpaid work, especially household work and care labour. European societies value the job one has often as the most important source of status and integration into society. A basic income will in an indirect way contribute to a financial revaluation of unpaid work, which might also help to increase the respect people show for this kind of work.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Care Work

A basic income solves gender inequality by compensating housewives for work done in the home.

Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1  AC]

It is not sure, however, whether a housewife’s wage would not create other injustices amongst women. It would have to be financed by general tax revenues. A working wife doing household chores after work and in weekends, would hence have to pay taxes for women who do the same household chores in a ‘paid’ fashion. Empirical studies have shown that on average women active on the labour market work significantly more than housewives, and a few hours more than their husbands (de Hart 1995, 41-42; Steil 1997). With a housewife’s wage, working women would then face a triple disincentive: working outside the house increases their workburden, they are extra taxed to pay for the housewife’s wage, and they do not receive any allowance for the household work they perform. I would argue that a basic income will resolve part of these problems. House-wives would get an allowance, and would not feel treated unjustly especially with regard to the improper but necessary use of the unemployment benefits. Neither would they feel treated unjustly with regard to persons taking career interruption who receive an allowance for this. For unemployed women, a basic income has the advantage that everyone receives it unconditionally. In several West-European countries, the fact that the unemployment benefits are conditional on the will-ingness to work and on an unemployment duration that does not substantially exceed the average duration, results in especially women being denied benefits (Schokkaert/Van der Linden/Van Parijs 1997)

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Care Work

A basic income would empower gender equality because it would recognize the value of care giving and women are disproportionately in poverty

Hermann, 2021 - MA Candidate in International Affairs at Hertie School [Katrin, Sept 28, Path for Europe, “Reimagining Care: Feminist degrowth and UBI” Acc 1/16/23 TA]

The story of Iceland is meant to emphasize the vital contribution that women make to our societies, not only in the labour market, but also through the invisible labour that they perform at home and in care facilities. Long before the pandemic, the crisis of care was acknowledged by many feminists to be a structural problem that reveals just how interdependent our society is, especially in terms of the work that is being done to care for others. It must also be said that migrant women and women of colour bear an even greater burden, as much of the care work previously performed by white women has now been outsourced to them. The ongoing pandemic has further exposed the burdens borne by underpaid care workers, the limits of dual earner households and the lack of investment in care infrastructure.[1] Within the European Union, proposals to reconceptualize the care economy have been put forth by the European Women’s Lobby and other organizations, who have praised the European Commission’s new Gender Equality Strategy 2020-2025 for including this issue and consider this an important starting point to eventually develop a Care Deal for Europe. However, more ambitious policies are needed in order to remove the burden of unpaid and underpaid care work from women’s shoulders and distribute it equally. Due to the demographic shift that will occur as the EU’s population ages, considerable demand will be placed on the care sector, making the need for changes within this system all the more pressing. Rethinking the care sector has long been a topic for feminist economists within and outside of Europe – they stress the need to challenge our traditional understanding of work, production, and how the current growth paradigm systematically devalues the care sector. This has led to the emergence of a relatively new feminist degrowth approach, which puts care work and the reproductive economy at its centre, recognizing and strengthening its importance and the need for transformative policies that acknowledge it accordingly. The main issue with the EU’s current proposal is that they do not necessarily target the unequal gender relations that persist within and without the care economy and how they can be broken down. In the words of renowned economist Kate Raworth “The great mistake of economics is thinking of the economy as separate from the society of which it is part and the environment in which it is embedded.” Inequalities within the Care Economy Care work most often operates outside the traditional economic sphere, i.e. being relegated to the domestic sphere, where its importance is diminished and rendered valueless. This work is often seen as intrinsically different from other forms of labour due to the interpersonal and emotional relations between subjects and the inherent vulnerability that can exist between those receiving care and those providing it, which again is regarded as a ‘feminized’ task. According to EIGE, the care economy can be defined as “part of human activity, both material and social, that is concerned with the process of caring for the present and future labour force, and the human population as a whole, including the domestic provisioning of food, clothing and shelter.” As mentioned, feminist economists were the first to argue for the recognition of the essential nature of this ‘unproductive’ care work, which includes not only domestic work, but also child and elderly care.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Care Work

A UBI would empower women by democratizing social institutions to secure equality and recognize gendered work roles.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? EO]

Other authors who write about UBI focus on poverty. Brian Barry, for instance, argues for a “pragmatic and principled” approach to UBI, meaning that he focuses on the ends that UBI might achieve.6 Pragmatists like Barry would not oppose, for instance, eligibility requirements for UBI. In contrast, authors who argue for a right to UBI on the basis of equal democratic citizenship believe that making this right conditional negates is purpose. The rights-oriented authors most relevant to this paper are those who advocate for UBI to secure women’s equality. Carole Pateman argues that basic income facilitates democratization, or the creation of a more democratic society in which all citizens enjoy full standing, democratic rights, and individual freedom. UBI would help democratize the U.S. by breaking the link between marriage, income, employment, and citizenship. Pateman focuses on these institutions because they shape and limit women’s citizenship and thereby empower women to exercise their citizenship rights.7 Breaking the link between them will enable individual autonomy and participation in democratic society.8 Just as universal “suffrage is the emblem of equal citizenship [...] a basic income is the emblem of full standing as a citizen, of citizenship that is of equal worth.”9

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Care Work

A UBI breaks down existing gender roles because it recognizes that reproductive labor in the home is as valuable as the male wage worker

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? ] EP

Some claim that we value certain types of labor less because they are worth less based on merit. The importance of reproductive labor undermines this claim. Few things are more important than birthing and “raising children, tending to the disabled and the sick, aiding the elderly, and giving succor to the dying: few things are of more societal importance.” Still, this labor goes unpaid, or is paid with low wages and few benefits, unrecognized, and unaccounted for even though unpaid “care workers provide the infrastructure that lets formal labor exist.” There is no productive labor without reproductive labor. But we also dismiss women’s productive labor. Women disproportionately enter lower-paid and female-dominated occupations, but they are directly influenced by societal norms, discrimination, and other forces which influence their decisions to enter these fields. To solve these problems, we need a policy that does not try to fit women into the mold of the male wage worker. Existing policies simply “add women and stir” when they try to be inclusive, treating them as “subjects without changing the tools of analysis.” If we are to undermine oppressive hierarchies of race and gender, we cannot maintain structures which devalue or erase some forms of labor because they do not fit with the dominant groups’ interpretations, experiences, and life patterns. Unlike potential reforms which try to incorporate women into existing systems of labor, UBI offers an alternative route that acknowledges that all people contribute to society through some form of participation. UBI would compensate women for their unpaid labor and reject the notion that those who perform it do not contribute to society. It would also recognize the value of and thereby bolster the wages of women of color who are most often paid caregivers, as well as compensate women for their “second shift.”

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Care Work

Family patriarchy subordinate women - women’s activities are excluded from the idea of work - conceptions of work center on the production of commodities for the market ignoring the nature of household work

Mckay, 2001 – prof of economics at Glascow Univ. [Ailsa, “Rethinking Work And Income Maintenance Policy: Promoting Gender Equality Through A Citizens ’ Basic Income,” Feminist Economics, 3/1/01, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-923X.2004.00611.x/abstract, TA]

Conceptually work is usually distinguished from leisure. The implication is that the cost of time spent engaging in activities clearly defined as work can be measured by the associated sacrifice of leisure time. This is not to say that all of those activities we deem enjoyable are categorized as “leisure” and activities involving pain, toil, or a sacrifice of enjoyment as “work.” Work may be something we enjoy, but it is distinct from leisure in that it is not done solely for its own sake but must also be purposeful. Any activity that displays “the characteristic of using up time and energy for an extrinsic purpose” can be defined as work, in that desirable end results are created through a process that involves an opportunity cost of lost leisure time (Susan Himmelweit 1995: 3). These end results are not only produced for the enjoyment or satisfaction of the individual carrying out the activity, but also have a use-value that can be shared by others. It is therefore the productive, purposeful aspect of any activity that defines it as work. For André Gorz (1994: 53), conceptualizing work in this way is a feature of modern industrial capitalism: So long as commodity production remained marginal and the great majority of needs were covered by domestic production and the village economy, the notion of “work” as such . . . could not take hold. People “produced”, “constructed” and “prepared” things; they “laboured”, “toiled”, “drudged” and “attended to” a wide variety of specific “occupations” which had no common measure between them within the framework of the domestic community. And responsibility for the various activities was assumed by the husband, the wife, the children or the older members of the family according to an immutable division of labour. These activities were gendered . . . and thus there was no common denominator between them. They were not interchangeable, and could not be compared and evaluated in terms of a single yardstick. The term “work” referred not to a creative or productive act but to the activity in so far as it entailed pain, annoyance and fatigue. The dominance of commodity production and consumption over subsistence production brought about by the development of capitalist modes of production results in the depersonalization of work activities. This leads Gorz to assert that the modern notion of work refers to: the name of an activity fundamentally different from the activities of subsistence, reproduction, maintenance and care performed within the household. This is not so much because “work” is a paid activity, but because it is done in the public domain and appears there as a measurable, exchangeable and interchangeable performance; as a performance which possesses a use-value for others, not simply for the members of the household community carrying it out; for others in general, without distinction or restriction, not for a particular, private person. (Ibid.: 53) This socialization of productive activities means that the worker becomes separable from the resulting output. Producing goods and services for exchange in the public domain renders irrelevant the direct relationship between the person carrying out the task and their economic output. Activities are interchangeable between workers, and outputs become measurable in terms of their use-value to others. In modern terms the concept of work is associated with any impersonal activity that results in output that can be measured and presented as a commodity, or service, for sale or exchange in an impersonal public marketplace. Many of the activities frequently performed by women are “invisible,” in the sense that there is either no tangible output, or the actual nature, and therefore value, of the output is not transparent. Consequently these activities do not meet the conventional criteria that would allow them to be labeled ‘“work.” Although much progress has been made in valuing domestic work to illustrate the signifi cance of women’s productive contribution to the economy (see, for example, the Human Development Report 1995) little has been done to quantify “provisioning” functions within the family. That is, the label domestic work is generally assigned to a range of “physical” tasks, considered essential ingredients in the effi cient functioning of the household economy. Such tasks can either be undertaken by a person(s) employed for that specifi c purpose or can be performed by an individual member of the household who receives no formal remuneration for doing so. The latter I refer to as “internalized unpaid domestic work,” which serves to draw the distinction between work done by the “hired help” and work done by wives and mothers themselves. As noted above, attempts at recognizing the value of internalized unpaid domestic work have at least got under way. However, in addition to internalized unpaid domestic work, many nonphysical exchanges or services performed in the household contribute positively to individual welfare, which prove even more difficult to quantify. Examples of “provisioning functions within the family” include the transfer of knowledge or skills, providing a safe and loving environment, expressing and acting from concern for the health and emotional needs of other family members, and organizing the distribution and allocation of resources within the family unit. Many of these activities are essential for human survival, particularly those concerned with the care of children ( Julie Nelson 1993: 32). Nonmaterial sources of human satisfaction influence intra-family power structures and directly affect the economic position of women. That they remain in the periphery of the economics discipline is possibly because quantifying them would be a technically difficult thing to do. However, it more likely stems from the fact that such activities are not viewed as “important” simply because they are performed by women; Humans are born of women, nurtured and cared for as dependent children, socialized into family and community groups, and are perpetually dependent on nourishment and shelter to sustain their lives. These aspects of human life, whose neglect is often justified by the argument that they are unimportant or intellectually uninteresting or merely “natural”, are, not just coincidentally, the areas of life thought of as “women’s work”. (Nelson 1996: 31)