2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, ]
The freedom not to be employed runs counter to the direction of much recent public policy and political rhetoric (especially in Anglo-American countries, though the policies are international), and this makes stakeholding more palatable than basic income in the current political climate. The effect of such policies and rhetoric is to draw even tighter the long-standing link between employment and citizenship, at the very time when a reassessment has been made possible by changing circumstances. The institution of employment is a barrier to democratic freedom and citizenship in two ways. First, economic enterprises have an undemocratic structure, a point that I shall not pursue here.23 Second, as feminist scholars have demonstrated, the relationship between the institutions of marriage, employment, and citizenship has meant that the standing of wives as citizens has always been, and remains, problematic. The Anglo-American social insurance system was constructed on the assumption that wives not only were their husbands’economic dependents but lesser citizens whose entitlement to benefits depended on their private status, not on their citizenship. Male “breadwinners,” who made a contribution from their earnings to “insure” that they received benefits in the event of unemployment or sickness, and in their old age, were the primary citizens. Their employment was treated as the contribution that a citizen could make to the well-being of the community. Ackerman and Alstott acknowledge this in their criticism of “workplace justice,”24 and their recognition that unconditional retirement pensions would be particularly important for the many older women whose benefits still largely derive from their husbands’ employment record.25 That is to say, only paid employment has been seen as “work,” as involving the tasks that are the mark of a productive citizen and contributor to the polity. Other contributions, notably all the work required to reproduce and maintain a healthy population and care for infants, the elderly, the sick, and infirm—the caring tasks, most of which are not paid for and are undertaken by women—have been seen as irrelevant to citizenship.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Flanigan, 2018 - prof of leadership studies and law at the University of Richmond [Jessica, Jan 25, Slate “The Feminist Case for a Universal Basic Income” TA]
2. Women Could Make Unfettered Decisions About How to Structure Their Families and Lives Child care is extraordinarily expensive, and women, especially single moms, end up shouldering an enormous burden for this cost. Some parents who would prefer to work are unable to because they cannot afford quality child care for their kids. Women are more likely to leave the workforce for this reason than men. A UBI for mothers and children would enable women who want to work to pay for child care. In addition, a UBI (including child benefits) would formally recognize and reward socially valuable labor that people currently perform outside of the paid economy, such as caregiving for children, disabled people, and elderly relatives. The UBI could amount to “wages for housework,” something feminists in the 1970s pushed for. Furthermore, because a UBI aims to pay all individuals and not households, it allows people to make decisions about marriage and cohabitation based their intrinsic desires, not based on tax policies such as the “marriage penalty” that working couples currently face or means-tested welfare programs that withhold benefits from women when their household income increases after marriage.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
Another indication why gender roles are at the disadvantage of women is that people who are not doing a substantial part of household work, or bear no respon-sibility for it, tend to underestimate this work. The results of a project in Iceland and occasional evidence from the media suggest that men taking parental leave or becoming househusband are surprised to see how demanding household work is, and start valuing the work much more once they (had to) do it for a while by themselves. Sticking to traditional gender roles will probably imply that house-hold work will continue to be underestimated by men who don't do a substantial part of it. Second, one has to recognise the importance of gender differences in power, or as Nussbaum (1999a, 286-287) calls them, gender hierarchies. In general, we can define gender differences in power as a general tendency in society that men have more power than women. As men occupy most of the powerful or influential jobs (politicians, bankers, religious leaders, publishers, investors, directors, profes-sors, media makers, ... ), they can claim more resources, influence public policy, determine public agenda setting and set social norms. Those men are typically also better integrated in networks of other men who can provide them with infor-mation, jobs and rare and cheap services and goods. Women are more likely to have less command over money, resources, (influential) jobs, networks of powerful people, etcetera. Women are also much more likely to bear either the day-to-day responsibility or at least the final responsibility for dependents. Some examples, like the earlier mentioned division of labour in heterosexual couples, give some indication how these gender power differences have some small seeds from the very. beginning of life, and are confirmed and intensified in an accumulating way through life. Gender roles and the gender division of labour are two of those fac-tors2 that help men gain their power, and prevent women from getting an equal distribution of power.3 Some authors, like Mill (1869) and Okin (1989; 1995) also discuss the role that the unequal division of labour within families has on public justice. They argue that families have to form the moral characters of children, and prepare them to be just democratic citizens. However, "families in which females are unequal to males serve those goals badly; for they raise males who are used to a feudal hierarchy within the household and who will therefore have a difficult time tolerating political equality outside the household. A more equal division of power between males and females, by contrast, better serves these larger human interests." (Nussbaum 1999a, 272) Research on the division of labour in lesbian couples is very revealing on how gender roles influence the division of labour. Empirical research shows that lesbian couples are far more egalitarian than heterosexual couples (Dunne 1998a; 1998b). This can be explained because the division of labour in those couples is less guided by gender roles. Moreover, in the public sphere the male gender role of fully committed employees is not expected from those women, so that both mothers can combine paid work with family commitments.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? AC]
To receive the federal block grant TANF established, states are required to mandate work participation rates.64 This is based on the idea that welfare undermines individual responsibility and recipients’ work ethic.65 Ending welfare, however, means ending poor, unmarried mothers’ ability to caregive.66 Unmarried women specifically are disadvantaged because PRWORA requires just one parent to engage in work activities. This makes interfamilial child care nearly impossible for unmarried women whom it forces to leave their homes to work. PRWORA fails to accommodate the needs of these women. This makes wage-earning and caregiving incompatible for many women, ensuring that successfully combining these aspects of life remains a privilege for women who are married or can afford to hire caregivers. Meanwhile, PRWORA forces married mothers into dependence on male wages and pressures them to sacrifice wage-earning because formal employment structures do not accommodate family needs.67 Work requirements also treat mothers as providers of goods, services, and care for any other children and families besides their own.68 Policies that force women to accept even low-paying and menial work send the message that, if a caregiver is unmarried, her labor is more valuable anywhere other than her own home and with her own children. Women of color disproportionately fulfill these caregiving roles and do so in White families. This perpetuates the devaluation of Black women’s intimate lives and domestic responsibilities. These requirements therefore harm White and Black women in different ways, and they harm poor women regardless of race. They reveal U.S. society’s disregard for the importance of caregiving labor and our readiness to force poor women into inadequate jobs even if it means that they and their families are worse off.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Warren and Cady, 1994 - Chair of the Philosophy Department at Macalester College and Professor of Philosophy at Hamline [Karen and Duane, “Feminism and Peace: Seeing Connections”, p16http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdfplus/3810167.pdf]
Operationalized, the evidence of patriarchy as a dysfunctional system is found in the behaviors to which it gives rise, (c), and the unmanageability, (d), which results. For example, in the United States, current estimates are that one out of every three or four women will be raped by someone she knows; globally, rape, sexual harassment, spouse-beating, and sado-masochistic pornography are examples of behaviors practiced, sanctioned, or tolerated within patriarchy. In the realm of environmentally destructive behaviors, strip-mining, factory farming, and pollution of the air, water, and soil are instances of behaviors maintained and sanctioned within patriarchy. They, too, rest on the faulty beliefs that it is okay to "rape the earth," that it is "man's God-given right" to have dominion (that is, domination) over the earth, that nature has only instrumental value, that environmental destruction is the acceptable price we pay for "progress."And the presumption of warism, that war is a natural, righteous, and ordinary way to impose dominion on a people or nation, goes hand in hand with patriarchy and leads to dysfunctional behaviors of nations and ultimately to international unmanageability. Much of the current" unmanageability" of contemporary life in patriarchal societies, (d), is then viewed as a consequence of a patriarchal preoccupation with activities, events, and experiences that reflect historically male-gender identified beliefs, values, attitudes, and assumptions. Included among these real-life consequences are precisely those concerns with nuclear proliferation, war, environmental destruction, and violence toward women, which many feminists see as the logica[is the]outgrowth of patriarchal thinking. In fact, it is often only through observing these dysfunctional behaviors-the symptoms of dysfunctionality that one can truly see that and how patriarchy serves to maintain and perpetuate them. When patriarchy is understood as a dysfunctional system, this "unmanageability" can be seen for what it is-as a predictable and thus logical consequence of patriarchy.'1 The theme that global environmental crises, war, and violence generally are predictable and logical consequences of sexism and patriarchal culture is pervasive in ecofeminist literature (see Russell 1989, 2). Ecofeminist Charlene Spretnak, for instance, argues that "militarism and warfare are continual features of a patriarchal society because they reflect and instill patriarchal values and fulfill needs of such a system. Acknowledging the context of patriarchal conceptualizations that feed militarism is a first step toward reducing their impact and preserving life on Earth" (Spretnak 1989, 54). Stated in terms of the foregoing model of patriarchy as a dysfunctional social system, the claims by Spretnak and other feminists take on a clearer meaning: Patriarchal conceptual frameworks legitimate impaired thinking (about women, national and regional conflict, the environment) which is manifested in behaviors which, if continued, will make life on earth difficult, if not impossible. It is a stark message, but it is plausible. Its plausibility lies in understanding the conceptual roots of various woman-nature-peace connections in regional, national, and global contexts.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
When designing a policy platform to address gender and racial wealth inequity, key considerations include: shifting harmful narratives that impede us from seeing everyone as deserving; addressing current wealth extraction policies as well as historic impediments to building wealth for women and people of color; tackling wealth concentration and corporate power; and healing generations of trauma caused by economic instability. Below, we outline design elements that can help us create a society where everyone has the ability and wherewithal to live with dignity, freedom of choice, and security. Enacting Tiered Disbursement According to Historic Disadvantage A guaranteed income policy proposal that is grounded in racial and gender justice must include a racial and gender equity approach that accounts for the rules, institutions, and norms that have ensured that certain groups reap a greater share of all that America offers while others have been intentionally left out. Without a strategic race and gender equity approach, a guaranteed income will not address and undo the underlying structures of racial and gender exclusion and discrimination that cause people of color and women to be overrepresented among the jobless and low-wage workers in the first place. It is for these reasons that a tiered guaranteed income model that gives stipends based on historic disadvantage and current wealth status is the most promising way forward. Such a model allows for people of color and women-headed households to receive a larger benefit in order to make up for barriers placed on them by policies of our past and present.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
Most of this research is gender blind in the sense that it does not tackle the question whether a basic income would differently affect men and women. However, a thorough gender analysis could be interesting for two reasons: there is a public interest to know more about this issue and currently there are opposite claims being made about the expected gender effects. Proponents of a basic income argue that unpaid work would get some recognition (Miller 1986; Walter 1989; Withorn 1990), that the autonomy of poor women (McKayfVanEvery 1995) or all women (Walter 1989) would increase, that it would help to achieve greater gender equality in the labour market by improving women’s bargaining position and by encouraging men to work part-time, thus allowing them to share more in domestic work (Standing 1992) and that it would be possible to choose for unpaid labour (Miller 1986; Walter 1989). Parker (1993) claims that a basic income holds more advantages for women than the current British social security system, not because a basic income favours women, but because the British social security system benefits men more. However, according to Parker a basic income is not enough to change the current situation, and equal opportunities and equal wages remain important. These positive evaluations stand in contrast with the belief among some fem-inists that a basic income will turn out to be some kind of housewives wage or hush money, sending women back home and tempering emancipation. According to Orloff (1990), a basic income is not a good strategy to reach gender equality and justice. She claims that the unequal division of household responsibilities is crucial in the explanation of the disadvantageous position of women in society and that other elements of social policy, which alter the structure of both paid and unpaid work, can be much more effective to reach gender justice. Although there are very few academic articles arguing for this point of view, it has often been raised by the audiences of academic or public debates on basic income. Some feminist pamphlets and articles in popular magazines also strongly oppose a basic income. However, it is important to stress that this belief is not shared py all feminists-there are also feminist advocates of a basic income. Authors on basic income proposals are not alone in neglecting the gender di-mension and its moral problems. Feminist philosophers and feminist theorists haven’t raised this question either. As Nussbaum (1999a, 278; 1999b, 38) argues, feminist philosophy has increasingly turned away from the material side of life, towards theories of verbal and symbolic politics. Similarly, Barrett (1992) de-scribes the “shift from things to words” in feminist theory. Recent handbooks in feminist theory, like Kemp and Squires (1997), hardly make any reference to economic subjects or material inequality, but instead focus on topics like the body, representation, sexuality, and race and ethnicity. In this article, I want to make a first step towards a better understanding of the moral questions and problems of gender justice that can arise with the implementation of a basic income. In her recent book on gender inequality and injustice against lesbians and gays, Nussbaum (1999a) has repeatedly argued that real-life political issues, especially those where deep disagreement exists, can only be solved if we approach them rationally and lay out the arguments to feed the civil public debate. In an attempt to take this route, I will use insights from social and economic research on basic income to introduce the gender-related normative questions into the philosophical discussion. Hence, this article will address the question whether a basic income does justice to women in the context of West-European welfare states. The article is structured as follows. The next section provides a descriptive gender analysis of a basic income. Section 3 analyses some of the normative arguments. Section 4 spells out the genuine moral issues underlying the tension between gender justice and basic income. The last section concludes. 2. A Descriptive Gender Analysis If we introduce a basic income, which effects relevant for a gender analysis can we expect? A basic income causes two kinds of effects: first order effects (visible, important and easily recognisable effects, taking place in the short run) and second order effects (less material effects, less visible, and with some effects only in the long run.) I will discuss three first order effects (2.1-2.3): changes in labour supply, changes in incomes, and changes in well-being derived from a change in (profes-sional) activities. I will also discuss six second order effects (2.4-2.9): a revaluation of unpaid work, psychological effects on housewives, a change in the bargaining position and power in the household, non-pecuniary advantages of paid labour, the decrease of human capital, and spill-over effects due to statistical discrimination.1
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Gendered UBI
Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, TA]
Thus feminists might be expected strongly to support the introduction of a basic income.34 Yet this is not the case. Some feminists are critical of the idea because they fear a basic income would reinforce the existing sexual division of labor and women’s lesser citizenship. They argue that the provision of an income without having to engage in paid employment would, in light of women’s position in the labor market combined with lingering beliefs about the proper place and tasks of women and men, give women an even greater incentive to undertake more unpaid caring work in the household, and, conversely, men would have another incentive to freeride. A basic income, that is, would reinforce existing limitations on women’s freedom.35 This objection illustrates the importance of the reasons advanced for supporting a basic income. The probability of feminist fears being borne out is higher, for example, when the argument is made that to avoid weakening the “incentive to work” a basic income should be below subsistence level. This “incentive” is promoted with men and paid employment in mind. A basic income at this level provides no incentive for wives to “work” (i.e., enter paid employment); rather, it would encourage them to do more unpaid caring work. Again, to support basic income on the grounds that it would improve the living standards of the poorest sectors of the population does not promote consideration of the structural connections between marriage, employment, and citizenship, and the private and public sexual division of labor. Without the debates about basic income being informed by feminist arguments, and a concern for democratization (and genuine democratization necessarily includes women’s freedom and standing as citizens), the discussion will revolve around ways of tinkering with the existing system rather than encouraging thinking about how it might be made more democratic. Putting democratization at the center requires attention to institutional structures, especially the institutions of marriage and employment. For instance, Ackerman and Alstott remark in The Stakeholder Society that the “case for stakeholding does not ultimately rest on its effects on employment, marriage, or crime. It rests on each American’s claim to respect as a free and equal citizen.”36 However (leaving crime aside), the respect accorded to women and men as free and equal citizens has a great deal to do with the institutions of marriage and employment. It is not possible to understand women’s lesser citizenship, as Ackerman and Alstott show in their discussion of social security, without understanding the relationship between their position as wives and men’s position as workers.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
2.6 Bargaining Position and Power in the Household In principle, all family members gain by the formation of a household, but the share of those gains that different individuals get can differ considerably from one arrangement to another. Therefore, households can best be seen as "co-operative conflicts" (Sen 1990). How the gains from the co-operation are divided depends, among other things, on the bargaining position of the individuals. There is evidence on the existence of links between money and power in the household. Power is then conceptualised by the ability to take (part in) decisions. It appears that the partner with the highest income is more dominant in decision-making, and women with paid employment have on average more power than women working unpaid at home (Pahl1989). Ott (1995) shows that specialisation in unpaid labour weakens the bargaining position of housewives. Her empirical tests confirmed that education and non-labour income increase the power of housewives in the household. The higher the income of the husband, the less power the wife has. Although these studies are limited in number and most of them are small-scale and thus difficult to generalise from, there is growing evidence that personal income increases power. This implies that the introduction of a basic income will increase the bargaining power of housewives, but that for women working on the labour market, everything depends on the effects of the labour supply and total net income change.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Adams, 2016 – Michigan State Department of Psychology [Adrienne. “Measuring the Effects of Domestic Violence on Women’s Financial Well- Being.” University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Financial Security, 25 Feb. 2016, cfs.wisc.edu/2011/05/01/adams2011/. AC]
Thus, subjective measures of financial well-being may be just as important as objective measures for understanding women’s relationships, their help-seeking behaviors, and their financial decisions. For example, research has shown that women’s beliefs about their ability to provide for their families independent of an abuser affect their decisions to remain in or return to abusive relationships (Anderson & Saunders, 2003). Two dimensions of subjective financial wellbeing particularly relevant in the context of DV are financial strain and financial self-efficacy. First, financial strain is defined as “the perceived adequacy of financial resources, financial concerns and worries, and expectations regarding one’s future economic situation” (Voydanoff, 1983). Perceived adequacy of financial resources has been assessed through questions including “how difficult is it for you to live on your total household income right now,” and “how do you feel about the income you have, or the amount of money you get” (Tolman, et al., 2001)? It is also important to assess DV survivors’ perceptions about the adequacy of their independent financial resources. This has been assessed by asking questions such as “how important is the money that your partner brings in to you and your family? By important I mean how hard would it be for you and your family to get by without it?” The Financial Distress and Relationship Decisions subscale of the DV-FI contains one item that assesses the influence of financial strain on a woman’s relationship decisions: “concerns or worries about my financial future affected my decisions about staying or leaving my partner” (Weaver, et al., 2009).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Flanigan, 2018 - prof of leadership studies and law at the University of Richmond [Jessica, Jan 25, Slate “The Feminist Case for a Universal Basic Income” TA]
And because a basic income would make the decision to work more voluntary, women would no longer choose to remain in toxic jobs solely because they can’t afford not to. In this way, a UBI could address gender-based mistreatment in workplaces. By freeing women of their economic dependence on employers, a UBI would also improve women’s bargaining positions, enabling them to negotiate for more flexible hours or better conditions. But a UBI would not discourage work to an extent that would undermine the economy. People would still need to work to afford most consumer goods and luxuries. And unlike minimum wage requirements, touted by Fight for $15 activists, a UBI neither raises the cost of employing low-income workers relative to other workers nor disproportionately burdens employers to provide a decent standard of living for people in their communities. With an even starting ground, the opportunities to move beyond the lowest-paying work could be more readily available to marginalized workers who’ve been left out for too long. 2. Women Could Make Unfettered Decisions About How to Structure Their Families and Lives Child care is extraordinarily expensive, and women, especially single moms, end up shouldering an enormous burden for this cost. Some parents who would prefer to work are unable to because they cannot afford quality child care for their kids. Women are more likely to leave the workforce for this reason than men. A UBI for mothers and children would enable women who want to work to pay for child care. In addition, a UBI (including child benefits) would formally recognize and reward socially valuable labor that people currently perform outside of the paid economy, such as caregiving for children, disabled people, and elderly relatives. The UBI could amount to “wages for housework,” something feminists in the 1970s pushed for. Furthermore, because a UBI aims to pay all individuals and not households, it allows people to make decisions about marriage and cohabitation based their intrinsic desires, not based on tax policies such as the “marriage penalty” that working couples currently face or means-tested welfare programs that withhold benefits from women when their household income increases after marriage. A further benefit for families? With an added, guaranteed boost to their income, women in abusive relationships would have the financial security to leave, even if they lack qualifications or credentials that would enable them to support themselves and their families. UBI would do more than almost any other economic policy imaginable to make women less susceptible to abuse both in the workplace and at home.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]
What could universal basic income mean for gender equality? Feminist perspectives vary on the significance of UBI for gender equality. The feminist case for UBI Feminists supporters argue that an individual income such as UBI could help guarantee women’s economic autonomy in the face of ongoing discrimination in employment and increase their bargaining power in (and beyond) families and communities. UBI would remove the exclusionary pitfalls and stigma attached to means-tested schemes, as well as avoid the paternalistic and sometimes coercive implementation practices documented for some conditional cash transfers. It may also avoid the ‘unemployment traps’ sometimes experienced by welfare recipients who risk losing their benefits should they increase their labor force participation— with particular detriment to single parents and people with disabilities. A secure and reliable income on an individual rather than household level could be especially important for those seeking to leave violent partners or unhappy relationships, by cushioning the financial shocks of partnership dissolution that tend to leave women and transgender and gender-diverse people worse-off than men. Research on cash transfers also suggests that a regular inflow of cash can in some cases mitigate intimate partner violence, including by improving emotional and mental wellbeing through reduced economic stress. In the context of employment, UBI may provide the necessary safety net to exit exploitative working conditions or buffer income instability for those unable to access waged work. Employment discrimination can make it especially difficult for transgender and gender-diverse people to access safe and secure employment. For example, in the European Union alone at least nine member States do not protect against discrimination in employment on grounds of gender identity. Some feminist proponents of UBI also celebrate its potential to reshape patriarchal gender norms around paid work and unpaid care, since no person is relegated to being a masculinized ‘breadwinner’ or feminized ‘caretaker’ in order to have income security. If combined with the provision of affordable quality care services, UBI could potentially encourage a more equitable distribution of care among genders. Indeed, some argue that UBI could lead to higher valuation of a range of non-commodified activities, including voluntary, emotional/affective and creative pursuits. Given that UBI is paid to individuals regardless of kinship relations, it could also support a range of diverse family forms, including cohabiting and extended families and ‘families of choice’ formed by many LGBTIQ people. Whether and to what extent these positive effects materialize will depend to a large degree on specific design features, including whether the UBI’s benefit level allows for maintaining an adequate standard of living. What can we learn from existing UBI schemes? No national-level UBI scheme meeting the criteria defined above has been carried out, and the implications of a long-term scheme at that level are largely unknown.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Lee, 2016 – consultant on public health approaches to violence prevention for the World Health Organization [Bandy X, May-June, Aggression and Violent Behavior “Causes and cures VII: Structural Violence” SP]
He therefore believed that we could easily avoid structural violence if people became conscious of the limitations social structures imposed on them (Beyer, 2008). Liberation theologists have made their own contribution to shaping the concept, starting in the 1950's and 1960's with the Catholic Church in Latin America, principally as a moral reaction to the poverty and the social injustice in the region (Gutiérrez, 1973). Canadian peace researchers Gernot Kohler and Norman Alcock (1976) devised ways to quantify the excess deaths that social, political, and economic inequalities cause, through two measures. In the first, they used Sweden as a model, for it had come closest to eliminating structural violence, with the greatest equities in living standard and the highest life expectancy among nations. They asked: how many deaths would we avoid, if all countries enjoyed the same living conditions as Sweden? The second measure they used was “the egalitarian model,” one that postulates complete and equal redistribution of the available global wealth. They asked: how many deaths would we avoid, if we equally distributed the available global wealth around the world? When the authors compared life expectancies everywhere else in the world with Sweden, they found that 18 million deaths a year could be attributed to “structural violence,” or the socioeconomic inequalities that exist globally. Considering life expectancy to be a function of relative socioeconomic position (Galtung and Høivik, 1971), when they plotted gross national product (GNP) per capita for each nation on earth, they were able to show that the life expectancy for nations with a GNP per capita at world average was 68.3 years for the year 1965. One remarkable aspect of the egalitarian life expectancy is its magnitude, the authors note, which is about forty years higher than the lowest life expectancy in 1965 (27 years for Guinea) and only six years less than the highest life expectancy (74.7 years for Sweden). In other words, under conditions of complete global equality, rich countries would lose only minor amounts of life expectancy, whereas poor ones would gain tremendously. British social epidemiologists Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett (2009) make similar observations, concluding that egalitarian societies do better overall, with only minor compromises from “the wealthy.” Behavioral violence, in measurements by the tolls of street violence or war, is more noticeable, even though the “tranquil” waters of structural violence may contain much more violence. American violence scholar James Gilligan (1999) compared structural violence to the most deadly military conflicts: estimating 49 million military and civilian deaths from World War II, or about 8 million per year from 1939 to 1945, or even a hypothetical nuclear exchange between the United States and the former Soviet Union at 232 million, could not even begin to compare with structural violence, which continues year after year, during times of peace as well as of war. In other words, every fifteen years, on average, as many people die because of relative poverty as would in a nuclear war that caused 232 million deaths. This is, in effect, the equivalent of an ongoing, unending, in fact accelerating thermonuclear war or genocide, perpetrated on the weak and poor every year of every decade, throughout the world. He also described structural violence as increased rates of disabilities and deaths among the people who occupy the bottom class. He noted that the suffering of people from lower classes are the product of people above who have collective bargaining power making choices that determine the allocation of resources. Unlike behavioral violence, its lethal effects operate continuously rather than sporadically; it can occur independently of any intention to kill anyone (for example, it can be a byproduct of wishing to maximize one's wealth and power); and it is usually invisible, in the sense that deaths from structural violence may appear to have other causes, natural or violent. More recent figures bear out these conclusions even more startlingly, as we will see in the next section. Gilligan (2001) also articulated how, through the mechanisms of shame, humiliation, and inferiority, the disparities in classes are the most potent cause of behavioral violence, such as suicide, homicide, warfare, or capital punishment (Bloom, 2001). American anthropologist Paul Farmer (2003) also developed the concept of structural violence by first defining structure as a pattern of collective social actions within institutional practices, law, economic policies, and other habitual elements. These structures can materially manifest through facilities such as roads, server systems, hospitals, and schools. He described violence as suffering resulting from social arrangements that put individuals in harm's way. Since the exertion of structural violence is systematic—that is, indirect—by everyone who belongs to a certain social order, no one is at fault, at the same time as everyone of that order is at fault. Cumulative historical forces and processes work together to constrain individual agency inversely, if not always neatly, with the ability to resist marginalization and oppression, and deny them the benefits of social progress.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Winter 1999 - psychology professor at Whitman College [Deborah DuNann Winter, D. D., & Leighton, D. C. (2001). Structural violence. In D. J. Christie, R. V. Wagner, & D. D. Winter (Eds.), Peace, conflict, and violence: Peace psychology in the 21st century sites.saumag.edu/danaleighton/wp-content/uploads/.../SVintro-2.pdf TA]
Direct violence is horrific, but its brutality usually gets our attention: we notice it, and often respond to it. Structural violence, however, is almost always invisible, embedded in ubiquitous social structures, normalized by stable institutions and regular experience. Structural violence occurs whenever people are disadvantaged by political, legal, economic, or cultural traditions. Because they are longstanding, structural inequities usually seem ordinary—the way things are and always have been. But structural violence produces suffering and death as often as direct violence does, though the damage is slower, more subtle, more common, and more difficult to repair. The chapters in this section teach us about some important but invisible forms of structural violence, and alert us to the powerful cultural mechanisms that create and maintain them over generations. Johan Galtung originally framed the term “structural violence” to mean any constraint on human potential caused by economic and political structures (1969). Unequal access to resources, to political power, to education, to health care, or to legal standing, are forms of structural violence. When inner-city children have inadequate schools while others do not, when gays and lesbians are fired for their sexual orientation, when laborers toil in inhumane conditions, when people of color endure environmental toxins in their neighborhoods, structural violence exists. Unfortunately, even those who are victims of structural violence often do not see the systematic ways in which their plight is choreographed by unequal and unfair distribution of society’s resources. Such is the insidiousness of structural violence. Structural violence is problematic in and of itself, but it is also dangerous because it frequently leads to direct violence. The chronically oppressed are often, for logical reasons, those who resort to direct violence. Organized armed conflict in various parts of the world is easily traced to structured inequalities. Northern Ireland, for example, has been marked by economic disparities between Northern Irish Catholics—who have higher unemployment rates and less formal education—and Protestants (Cairns & Darby, 1998). In Sri Lanka, youth unemployment and underemployment exacerbates ethnic conflict (Rogers, Spencer, & Uyangoda, 1998). In Rwanda, huge disparities in both income and social status between the Hutu and Tutsis eventually led to ethnic massacres. While structural violence often leads to direct violence, the reverse is also true, as brutality terrorizes bystanders, who then become unwilling or unable to confront social injustice. Increasingly, civilians pay enormous costs of war, not only through death, but through devastation of neighborhoods and ecosystems. Ruling elites rarely suffer from armed conflict as much as civilian populations do, who endure decades of poverty and disease in war-torn societies. Recognizing the operation of structural violence forces us to ask questions about how and why we tolerate it, questions that often have painful answers. The first chapter in this section, “Social Injustice,” by Susan Opotow, argues that our normal perceptual/cognitive processes lead us to care about people inside our scope of justice, but rarely care about those people outside. Injustice that would be instantaneously confronted if it occurred to someone we love or know is barely noticed if it occurs to strangers or those who are invisible or irrelevant to us. We do not seem to be able to open our minds and our hearts to everyone; moral exclusion is a product of our normal cognitive processes. But Opotow argues convincingly that we can reduce its nefarious effects by becoming aware of our distorted perceptions. Inclusionary thinking can be fostered by relationships, communication, and appreciation of diversity.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Story, 2017 – writer for Basic Income.org [Rae, Breaking the Vicious Circle: Basic Income and Sexual Exploitation March 18, TA]
I had an abusive boyfriend once. He lured me in with promises of provision and vindication. But he was a perfidious son of a gun, because the initial half of his Janus face was insidiously torn aside, to reveal his deft capacity for creating insecurity, isolation and intellectual dissonance. My boyfriend, my great, devastating, intoxicating love, was prostitution. Yes, like any other lover of an abuser, I was hooked in by his exaggerated claims of support and potential for actualisation — “I will empower you! I will make you free!” — smoke screening an undercurrent of exploitative tendencies. For me, for others, by the time we understand this, we have become trapped. Some people may wince at my comparing prostitution to abuse. I have been usefully informed, on a number of occasions, that it is a simply a job as any other. That it is not sexual exploitation, because women choose to enter into it freely. But even if that were so, what if the same women can’t manage to leave when they decide they have had enough? How many times, after that point, must they be utilised for sex effectively against their true will, before it becomes a violation? Being trapped in prostitution, relationship violence and cycles of survival sex can indeed be crushing to a person’s sense of capacity and the “outside” world can look increasingly hostile and difficult to negotiate. Coercive control, which often operates in these situations, is manipulative and extremely sophisticated. It tells you that you are not capable of surviving — let alone thriving — in any other way, just as it depletes you. It is like living with a blade at your throat, but being told it is for your own protection. What does all this have to do with Universal Basic Income (UBI)? Because as with all of the most effective manipulations, it contains a kernel of truth. If a woman is told by her abuser or her pimp — or by the propaganda of living in prostitution — that she could not survive without them, that voice is solidified by the material experience of structural inequality that poor women suffer. The crossroads between class and sex-based oppression is, indeed, best exemplified by a woman having to make a daily decision between sexual or domestic abuse, and poverty. So if our toxic situation has been the source of our “income” — in exchange for domestic, reproductive or sexual labour — what do we do if we want to leave? Refuge recommends that women escaping abusive or exploitative situations should seek out emergency accommodation from friends or family, but often abuse victims have been systematically disenfranchised from such social support and, as with high numbers of women in prostitution, have come through the care system, many didn’t have it in the first place. Women’s refuges are suffering from closures and on average 155 women are turned away each day, according to Women’s Aid. Shockingly, women escaping domestic violence are not automatically considered in priority need for social housing. That is even before you even get to prostitutes; an even less likely group to be considered a “worthy” cause. Indeed, our current welfare system is based on nebulous arbitrations of “need” and “worthiness,” which are often further gunned through the dubious prism of abstract bureaucracy. The Conservative government has seemingly decided that it cannot trust the word of doctors in assessing someone’s capacity for work and so subject often extremely vulnerable people to further “assessments.” Women who have been in prostitution or domestic violence often suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and other psychological fragilities. For them these processes can be intimidating, due to the fear of being judged, blamed and dismissed as “undeserving.” This is even before we even get to the trials of unemployment benefit, not available to anyone whose partner works more than 24 hours per week — not much good if said partner has a predilection for controlling every aspect of your life. And if you’re under 35 and have no children you cannot suddenly decide to no longer submit to unwanted sex with men you don’t know, because you are not eligible for housing benefit contributions for your apartment. Or because you cannot find another job, due to your lack of experience or your anxiety, or both. Yes, I’ve seen many a woman make her Great Escape from abuse only to find her road blocked at every turn. Back she goes, to her hard fisted boyfriend or her brothel pimp — now more vulnerable and more convinced of the absolutenesses of her “destiny.” What is the first thing a woman escaping violence needs? To not have to “explain herself” to society — to beg even — to get the ticket out of her situation. Because asking such people to make the case for their right to freedom from abuse is an extension of that abuse. She has already had to try to explain to her “lover” why he should allow her to sleep safe that night, or to her pimp why she cannot work because her vagina has become torn and bruised. The idea behind UBI is that every member of society gets a basic monthly amount, irrespective of their social circumstances or their assumed worthiness. I am not going to make a more general case for UBI, as those arguments can be found elsewhere. However, it has instigated the twitching of my feminist ear because as a policy it has, under the right conditions, the potential to give victims of domestic violence and sexual exploitation a slightly easier out. In the 1970s there were a lot of debates about whether or not women should receive wages for housework, but many feminists felt that this would crystallise the idea that domesticity was women’s work. UBI on the other hand is a basic economic sustenance that is paid to a woman by virtue of her humanity, not her femininity, which is in any case a social imposition demanding of her submissive agreeableness. Of course UBI is not the full answer to the question of women’s exploitation. But because it does not require women to be the perfect victims, it is at least starting to ask the right questions.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Mazurana and McKay, 2001 - Research Director of Gender, Youth, and Community at Tufts Univ. and contributor to The Irish Times [Dyan and Susan “Women, Girls, and Structural Violence: A Global Analysis”, TA]*** from backfile
The male bias inherent in (patriarchal) democracy has led to forms of patriarchal structural violence that relegate “women’s issues” to the “private” realm where they become “private matters” that the state does not address. This bias is perhaps nowhere clearer than in the issue of domestic violence, where male bias greatly impairs the ability of police, judges, and lawmakers from recognizing the violent behavior in the family. “The view that ‘as a family matter’ battery is less important, is based on men’s, not women’s perceptions” (Murray & O’Regan, 1991, p. 45). The multiple forms of domestic violence that women suffer have profound physical and psychological effects (Herman, 1992; Kelly, 1993), prompting international calls for domestic violence to be recognized as a form of torture (Copelon, 1994). Governmental support of patriarchal structural violence through its inattention to “private” matters is apparent throughout the world. Until 1991, the murder of a wife in Brazil was legal—it was considered an honor killing and was done to preserve the family’s honor because of a woman’s transgression. In many areas of the world, men are free to rape their wives with no threat of legal repercussions (Mertus, 1995). Other examples of government-sponsored patriarchal structural violence include laws and systems that condone particular forms of violence against women, deny women control over their bodies, provide no assistance with child care and maternity leave, make no attempt to remedy child support defaults, and fail to provide unemployment protection to women who work within the “private” realm in domestic service or farm work (Waring, 1988; Murray & O’Regan, 1991). Because governments rarely address patriarchal structural violence or fight for women’s rights, progress for women is largely made by women working for the recognition and enforcement of women’s rights. As a result, in countries such as Australia, Brazil, Britain, Columbia, India, Sri Lanka, and the United States, violence against women in the home has been identified and some forms of it criminalized (Fineman & Mykitiuk, 1994).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Adams, 2016 – Michigan State Department of Psychology [Adrienne. “Measuring the Effects of Domestic Violence on Women’s Financial Well- Being.” University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Financial Security, 25 Feb. 2016, cfs.wisc.edu/2011/05/01/adams2011/. AC]
Introduction Women with abusive partners often face tremendous threats to their financial well-being and barriers to realizing their personal financial capability. Abusers use physical, psychological, and economic tactics to isolate, control, exploit, and terrorize their partners. For many women, these actions have devastating consequences. The purpose of this research brief is to summarize current thinking about how to assess the impact of domestic violence (DV) on women’s financial well-being. I begin by discussing the measurement of abusers’ economically abusive actions and then briefly describe approaches for measuring the impact of abuse on three dimensions of women’s financial lives: 1) economic self-sufficiency through employment; 2) financial stability; and 3) subjective financial well-being. Finally, I conclude with a brief discussion of implications for practice and policy. Economic Abuse Economic abuse, defined as controlling a woman’s ability to acquire, use, and maintain economic resources, is as common in battering relationships as physical and psychological abuse. In fact, in one study of 103 DV survivors, all of the women reported being psychologically abused by their partners, 98% had been physically assaulted, and all but one (99%) had experienced economic abuse (Adams, et al., 2008). Understanding the impact of DV on financial well-being requires an assessment of the abuser’s past and current actions to hurt his partner financially. Recently, three standardized instruments have been developed to assess the nature and extent of economic abuse in women’s relationships: (1) The Work/School Abuse Scale (W/SAS; Riger, Ahrens, & Blinkenstaff, 2001) measures a specific component of economic abuse—interfering with women’s education and employment. The W/SAS is comprised of 12 questions that assess the frequency of a batterer’s use of interference and restraint tactics to keep women from working or going to school, make them miss work or school, get them fired, or make them quit work or school. (2)The Scale of Economic Abuse (SEA; Adams, et al., 2008) is an instrument with 28 questions that assess two dimensions of economic abuse: control and exploitation. Questions pertaining to economic control assess abusers’ efforts to dictate women’s access to and use of money (e.g., interfering with employment, or deciding when and how money is spent), while the exploitation questions assess how an abuser takes advantage of his partner financially (e.g., refuses to work, steals from her, builds debt in her name). (3) The economic abuse subscale of the Domestic Violence-Related Financial Issues Scale (DV-FI; Weaver, et al., 2009) consists of five questions that assess the impact of abuse on women’s credit ratings, education, employment, access to money, and debt. 2 Center for Financial Security Economic Self-Sufficiency through Employment Economic self-sufficiency can be defined as having the income necessary to meet basic needs (e.g., food, housing, child care, health care, transportation, taxes) without relying on public or private/informal assistance.1 Achieving selfsufficiency requires earning a steady living wage, which can be a significant challenge for DV survivors. Batterers may forbid their partners from having a job or engage in disruptive behaviors in an attempt to sabotage their employment (Adams, et. al. 2008). The result is often lost hours, lost work days, and lost jobs (Swanberg, Macke, & Logan, 2006; Wettersten, et al., 2004). Further, batterers’ interference can contribute to an inconsistent employment record or weakened job skills, which can compromise a woman’s future employability and earning potential (Tolman, Danziger, & Rosen, 2001). A great deal of research has examined the effects of DV on women’s employment. Early on, researchers focused on employment status (employed vs. not employed) as the central employment outcome; however, it quickly became evident that at any point in time a woman with an abusive partner is as likely to have a job as any other woman (Browne, Salomon, & Bassuk, 1999; Lloyd & Taluc, 1999; Tolman & Rosen, 2001).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Adams, 2016 – Michigan State Department of Psychology [Adrienne. “Measuring the Effects of Domestic Violence on Women’s Financial Well- Being.” University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Financial Security, 25 Feb. 2016, cfs.wisc.edu/2011/05/01/adams2011/. AC]
Instead, what distinguished women with abusive partners from their non-abused counterparts were their higher levels of job instability (Browne, Salomon, & Bassuk, 1999; Tolman & Wang, 2005). To date, job stability has been measured in several ways. One method is to examine how DV affects the amount of time a woman spends employed. For example, research has shown that DV is linked to working fewer weeks and months in a given period, as well as with working fewer hours annually (Staggs & Riger, 2005; Tolman & Wang, 2005). A second approach to measuring job stability requires not only taking into account the amount of time a woman spends working, but also examining job loss (Adams, et al., in press). It is important to consider job loss as a dimension of job stability because cycling between many jobs likely affects women’s economic well-being differently than having one sustained job. For example, working nine months out of the year at one job likely relates to different economic outcomes than working for a total of nine months at four or five different jobs. Thus, considering job loss as a dimension of job stability more fully captures the complex ways that DV may affect women’s employment. Related to job instability, DV can also compromise women’s ability to gain selfsufficiency through employment by negatively affecting their employability and earning potential. Factors related to employability that are important in the context of DV are human capital and work-supporting resources. Three commonly used measures of human capital are education, job skills, and work history (Staggs & Riger, 2005; Tolman & Wang, 2005). Education can be assessed by asking about the number of years of formal schooling or the highest level of education completed; job skills are often measured using Holtzer’s (1996) 9-item index of entry-level job skills; and work history has been captured through the number of months or years a woman has worked for pay in a given timeframe. The critical work-supporting resource issues for women with abusive partners are reliable transportation and child care (Browne, et al., 1999; Brush, 2000; Meisel, Chandler, & Rienzi, 2003; Riger, Staggs, & Schewe, 2004; Sable, et al., 1999; Swanberg, et al., 2006; Tolman, et al., 2001).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Stanley, 2020 - Special Advisor to the Harvard Law School Gender Violence Program [Maclen "Why the Increase in Domestic Violence During COVID-19?" Psychology Today, 9 May, EO]
Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, instances of IPV were already extremely high. According to the CDC, 1 in 3 women in the United States have experienced IPV. The risks to victims are serious, with CDC data linking IPV to an increased risk of death. Unfortunately, one of the most striking findings to come out of research on IPV in the wake of disasters is that, in addition to the rate of abuse increasing, the severity of abuse can increase as well. With gun sales surging, many researchers are concerned that we will see an uptick in domestic homicides when the dust finally settles. It is also important to note that the various factors discussed above are all reciprocal in nature. Stress begets alcohol abuse and job loss just as much as job loss begets alcohol abuse and stress. The factors underlying IPV are fluid, interrelated, and numerous, which makes IPV that much more difficult to extinguish. Today, the COVID-19 pandemic has elicited a perfect storm for IPV by provoking some of the most common factors associated with its occurrence.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC – Domestic Violence UBI
Niess-May, 2019 - Executive Director of SafeHouse Center [Barbara, October 22nd, The Intersection of Domestic Violence and Poverty, https://www.safehousecenter.org/the-intersection-of-domestic-violence-and-poverty/#:~:text=Poverty%20is%20a%20primary%20driver,a%20survivor%20of%20domestic%20violence. EP]
What is Domestic Violence? Domestic violence is a crime that is under-reported and misunderstood. Domestic violence is a PATTERN of coercive behavior used by people to control their intimate partners. It encompasses abusive tactics including but not limited to threats and the commission of physical and sexual violence; economic, emotional and psychological abuse and the abuser using any privilege they may have to maintain power and control. But, it is our experience at SafeHouse Center that the vast majority of those who are surviving domestic violence are women. Michigan has epidemic levels of domestic violence. In the last year almost 30,000 (unduplicated) incidences were reported to 911. Nationwide, domestic violence accounted for 21% of all violent crime. And while research indicates approximately 25% of women will experience this, only 2.5 to 15% will report. There are many myths about domestic violence. Many assume it is caused by stress, substance use or that it only happens among the low to no income. That is not true. The fact is assailants learned the abusive behavior. Their behavior is learned from our society and/or in the home. Domestic violence is caused by the choice of the perpetrator to use the pattern of power and abuse to control the survivor. Survivors never have a part in the abuse that is caused by the perpetrator. Being low income does not cause domestic violence, yet, income levels are part of the predeterminants of what will happen to the survivor and their children. Intersection of Domestic Violence and Poverty We do know that poverty disproportionately affects women and single mothers. What many do not know is how the intersection of poverty and domestic violence can 1) exacerbate the impact of the abuse, 2) cause an exceptional loss of resources for the survivor and 3) lessen positive outcomes for a survivor. In short, being poor further entraps the survivor in the abuse, and often lengthens any process she may go through to escape—as well lengthens entrapment in poverty. The intersection of poverty and domestic violence further endangers survivors, their children and our communities as a whole. Outcomes for women of color and immigrants are even more grave because safety net systems often ignore their unique needs. And programs like SafeHouse Center see a disproportionate amount of survivors from these populations.