Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Econ Comp k2 beat China

US engaged in competition with China- only a focus on maintaining competitive edge ensures continued hegemony

Martijn Rasser and Megan Lamberth in 2021

Former Senior Fellow and Director, Technology and National Security Program and Former Associate Fellow, Technology and National Security Program; Taking the Helm

A National Technology Strategy to Meet the China Challenge; Center for a New American Security; https://www.cnas.org/publications/reports/taking-the-helm-a-national-technology-strategy-to-meet-the-china-challenge

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Econ Comp k2 beat China

US competitiveness is the backbone of its competition with China- economic, political, and military power all rely on it

Martijn Rasser and Megan Lamberth in 2021

Former Senior Fellow and Director, Technology and National Security Program and Former Associate Fellow, Technology and National Security Program; Taking the Helm

A National Technology Strategy to Meet the China Challenge; Center for a New American Security; https://www.cnas.org/publications/reports/taking-the-helm-a-national-technology-strategy-to-meet-the-china-challenge

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Econ Comp k2 beat China

Shifting the government’s attention to economy is key- China’s growing economically and challenges Western hegemonic superiority

Jaeger 22, Markus Jaeger, Dr. Markus Jaeger is a research fellow at DGAP and an adjunct professor at Columbia University. Prior to joining DGAP, Jaeger was a director at Deutsche Bank Research in New York, where he was responsible for the analysis of US economic and financial markets. Previously, he held a variety of research and advisory roles with Deutsche Bank in London and New York, covering global economics and emerging markets as well as country risk and geopolitics.“The Economics of Great Power Competition,” DCAP, May 02, 2022, sim

The United States and its allies are status quo powers; China and Russia are revisionist powers. Russia wants to change the status quo in Eastern Europe, China in East Asia. Despite the Ukraine war, China continues to present a greater long-term challenge to the status quo than Russia. China is rising economically, while Russia is experiencing stagnation and relative decline. Whether Russo-Chinese cooperation intensifies or not, China’s rise has important implications for American strategy, transatlantic relations, and German and European defense policy. The United States is strongly committed to defending the status quo in Asia as well as in Europe, and it has good reasons for doing so. Preventing the rise of a hegemonic power on either side of the Eurasian landmass has been a strategic interest for more than a century. The United States fought two world wars and committed to an extensive forward military presence and extensive security guarantees during the Cold War to prevent Europe and East Asia from falling under German, Japanese, or Soviet hegemony. Whether or not a Sino-Russian geopolitical bloc emerges, both China and Russia are set on a collision course with the United States and its allies. Economically, the US-led alliances are well-positioned to engage in long-term geopolitical competition, provided the United States manages to maintain alliance cohesion. But to remain competitive, America will need to shift attention and resources to Asia – Russian revisionist policies notwithstanding. This will force its European allies to take on greater responsibility for defending the status quo in Europe. Germany has a pivotal role to play here. As the economically and financially most powerful country in Europe, it will have little choice but to contribute to strengthening European security. Unlike smaller countries, it cannot free-ride on the security provided by its European allies. Germany also has at its disposal greater economic, financial, and technological resources than its European partners. The main challenge will be to convert economic resources into military power and enhanced security in an efficient and effective way. Economic might is the foundation of political and military power. It is also a prerequisite for engaging in successful long-term geopolitical competition. Paul Kennedy and Robert Gilpin have famously argued that shifting economic fortunes underpin the rise and fall of great powers. The economically stronger or ascendant power, or alliance of powers, emerges victorious, often but not always in the wake of a ‘hegemonic war.’ Anecdotal evidence suggests that more forceful military mobilization or more innovative military tactics may confer a temporary advantage, but rarely translate into strategic victory. How do the US-led alliances on the one hand and China and Russia on the other hand compare in terms of economic power? At present, the aggregate economic resources of the United States and its allies outstrip the combined resources of China and Russia. But the current and prospective ‘balance of economic resources’ is much more favorable for the status quo powers in Europe than in Asia. The economies of European NATO members are five times larger than Russia’s, and even prior to the imposition of the war-related sanctions, the Russian economy was already stagnating. Its long-term growth outlook is weak, given its demographics, dependence on natural resource exports, and uncompetitive domestic markets. Russia will be lucky if its growth rate matches that of low-growth major European economies like France and Germany, especially if the substantial one-off drop due to sanctions is taken into account. In Asia, however, the aggregate economic size of the US-led alliances exceeds China’s by a far smaller margin. The Chinese economy is also growing much faster. Under reasonable assumptions, it will be twice as large as the US economy by the middle of this century. It will then exceed the combined economic size of the United States and its regional allies. These are baseline projections, and it is worth noting that significant risks attach to China’s future growth trajectory, much more than to the outlook of the mature, lower-growth advanced economies of the United States and allies. Chinese growth has averaged nearly ten percent a year since its economic opening in the late 1970s. More recently, trend growth has dropped closer to six percent and is set to decline further. China’s official 2022 target is five and a half percent. By comparison, the present US growth potential is estimated to be around two percent or less. China certainly has sufficient savings to finance capital accumulation. But this is of little use if not enough profitable investment opportunities can be identified. Doubling down on infrastructure investment will only lead to excess debt accumulation and raises the risk of a financial and economic crisis. Rapidly deteriorating demographics, a declining catch-up growth potential, and the so-called middle-income trap represent considerable risks to China’s economic outlook. So-called economic rebalancing to make growth more sustainable is proving challenging. Nevertheless, in all reasonable scenarios, Chinese economic growth will exceed American growth. The Chinese economy will therefore continue to pull ahead of the American economy. This will allow China to increase defense expenditure far more rapidly than the United States and its allies, while keeping it stable as a share of GDP and thereby limiting the resource drain on the economy. China’s increasing economic might will force the United States to mobilize and allocate greater resources to Asia. With Chinese capabilities focused on Asia, the United States – which deploys its military assets globally – will face an increasingly difficult strategic challenge. As a result, America’s European allies will need to take greater responsibility for European defense.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Green Infra K2 Competitiveness

Green Jobs are key to econ competitiveness – they represent the bulk of economic advancement and job growth

Marcacci 22 Silvio Marcacci - is Energy Innovation's Senior Director of Communications, leading media relations as well as communications outreach and message strategy across all of the firm's policy programs. “Clean Energy Jobs Are Booming, Making Up For Rising Fossil Fuel Unemployment,” Forbes, Jun 29, 2022 ///Mgal

Memo to job-seekers: The United States’ clean energy industry is hiring, faster than the overall national economy, and it’s paying above-average wages. The 2022 U.S. Energy and Employment Report (USEER), released by the U.S. Department of Energy, details dramatic growth across every major clean energy occupation – especially in the electric vehicle industry. Meanwhile most of the fossil fuel industry continued losing jobs, even as the economy roared back from its COVID-induced downturn. Overall energy sector jobs rose 4% in 2021, adding more than 300,000 jobs to reach more than 7.8 million total energy-related jobs. U.S. energy sector job growth outpaced overall U.S. jobs growth, which rose 2.8% in 2021. Nearly 3.1 million of the total energy sector jobs are in net-zero aligned industries, composing 41% of total energy jobs. Net-zero aligned jobs are related to renewable energy, grid technologies, transmission and distribution, energy storage, nuclear energy, biofuels, energy efficiency, and electric vehicles. “Amidst the unique challenges of a nation coming out of a global pandemic, America’s energy sector stands out with considerable job growth across nearly all industries,” said U.S. Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm. “Jobs critical to our clean energy transition are on the rise and poised for continued expansion.” Clean energy technologies—like wind turbines, solar panels, and electric vehicles—offer a bright spot for the U.S. manufacturing sector if the federal government continues implementing emissions reduction policies, and particularly if the U.S. Senate passes proposed reconciliation legislation. Adding jobs in these industries will boost our economic competitiveness in a 21st century global clean energy economy while fighting climate change. Clean energy, electrified vehicles lead job growth USEER covers all jobs in the professional operations, construction, utility operations, and production associated with energy infrastructure and use – including motor vehicle manufacturing. Energy sector jobs were one of the fastest-growing sectors of the U.S. economy before the COVID pandemic, which cost it nearly 840,000 jobs. But rebounding energy sector job growth is not evenly distributed. While the electric power generation sector grew 2.9% led by solar and wind energy, coal and nuclear jobs both declined. Fuel sector jobs – particularly in extraction – tumbled 3.1% with the petroleum sector shedding 31,600 jobs for the largest total job losses of any sector, and the coal fuel sector losing 7,100 jobs for the largest percentage loss of any sector at 11.8%. Motor vehicle and component parts manufacturing was the standout sector in 2021, adding 228,000 jobs, a 9.8% annual gain. Hybrid electric, battery electric, plug-in hybrid, and hydrogen fuel cell manufacturing comprised 65,000 of the sector’s total job growth. These jobs in carbon-reducing vehicle manufacturing grew a collective 25% in 2021, and were the only subcategory of energy jobs that did not decrease in 2020 due to COVID. Clean energy jobs offer higher wages than the national average, and are widely available to workers without four-year degrees, meaning most Americans can access them. Brookings Institution research finds landing a clean energy job can equal an 8%-19% income increase, and 45% of all workers in clean energy production only have a high school diploma, while earning higher wages than similarly educated peers in other industries. Wind turbine technician and solar photovoltaic installers are forecast by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics to be two of the top five fastest-growing occupations through 2030. Wind turbine technician jobs are expected to grow 68% and pay more than $56,000 per year, while solar installer jobs are expected to grow 52% and pay nearly $48,000 per year. Energy sector jobs also enjoy higher union representation than the overall economy, with 10% of the energy workforce represented by a union or covered under a project labor agreement compared to 6% within the private sector. States with strong climate policies see high job growth USEER also reports state-level job growth, and the states that set clear clean energy policy and investments are reaping rewards. Michigan added 35,500 new energy jobs, pacing the country, totaling more than 390,000 jobs. This growth was powered by motor vehicle jobs, spurred by the U.S. auto industry’s strategic investments in electric vehicles. Michigan Governor Whitmer established an economywide net zero by 2050 goal in 2020, just the fourth nationwide, heavily focused on transitioning from coal power to renewable energy with dramatic electric vehicle infrastructure investments. California ranked third in total new energy jobs, adding nearly 30,000 new positions. This growth was fueled by about 11,000 new jobs in carbon-reducing motor vehicle manufacturing. Jobs in the state’s electric vehicle industry pay an average of more than $91,000, well above California’s average annual wage of $60,400. This growth has been fueled by the state’s ambitious zero-emission vehicle target of all new car sales being zero-emission by 2035. Expanding federal climate policies could create millions of new jobs That relationship between clear policy to reduce emissions through a clean energy transition is backed up at the national level, and could be supercharged by enacting federal policies to hit net-zero targets. G7 Leaders Convene For Summit At Schloss Elmau GARMISCH-PARTENKIRCHEN, GERMANY - JUNE 26: U.S. President Joe Biden speaks at the "Global ... [+]GETTY IMAGES While the Biden administration has gone further on this front than any other administration in history, truly transforming our economy and creating millions of new jobs depends on the U.S. Senate passing proposed reconciliation legislation. As the clean energy industry expands, strong labor standards and prevailing wage guarantees can ensure new jobs are equitable, while investing in fossil fuel-dependent communities can help workers transition to stable careers. Energy Innovation modeling of the U.S. Nationally Determined Contribution to the Paris Agreement on Climate Change, which would push nationwide emissions to near net zero through a combination of economywide policies, would create more than 3.2 million new jobs by 2030 and nearly 5 million new jobs by 2050 while increasing annual GDP 2.4% in 2050. Modeling of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) which was signed into law by President Biden, and reconciliation legislation which is still under consideration by the U.S. Senate, showed the combined bills would create up to 638,000 new jobs in 2030. These jobs would be concentrated in manufacturing, construction, and job creation. USEER notes the IIJA’s impacts have not yet been felt, but predicts the more than $63 billion in energy sector funding would help expand clean technology deployment and transition fossil fuel-dependent communities and workers. Still, policies and investments contained in the reconciliation legislation would contribute the largest share of these long-term jobs, underlining how important passage in the U.S. Senate would be to U.S. economic growth. Modeling also shows that transitioning to all electric vehicle sales, which the reconciliation legislation could help jump start, would be a job engine. Research shows that pushing to reach 100% all-electric new car and truck sales by 2035 across the U.S. would support more than 2 million jobs in 2035. Federal and state governments have shown that setting clear policies like emissions reduction goals, clean energy deployment targets, stable tax incentives, clean energy infrastructure investments, and workforce transition will fight climate change while creating jobs and strengthening the economy. Expanding clean energy can keep our economy growing – if policymakers invest in our future by enacting smart climate policies.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Green Infra K2 Competitiveness

Green Infrastructure key to US competitiveness

Johannes Urpelainen, Chetan Hebbale, 4-12-2022, "The US should treat climate policy as economic policy," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-us-should-treat-climate-policy-as-economic-policy/

The United States and China jointly account for more than 40 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions, putting these two nations at the center of efforts to address the climate crisis. Yet cooperation on climate policy between Washington and Beijing has stalled in recent years, reflecting a broader deterioration in the U.S.-China relationship. After decades of increasing dependence on imports from China, the pandemic highlighted the vulnerability of global supply chains to external shocks and strengthened calls for national self-sufficiency both in China and the United States. The stakes and opportunities of such a move are nowhere higher than in clean energy sectors, where China currently dominates global manufacturing. China makes roughly two-thirds of the world’s solar panels, nearly half of global wind turbines, and three quarters of lithium-ion batteries needed for electric vehicles and on-grid energy storage. To date, the U.S. federal government has not done enough to improve the competitive position of domestic clean energy sectors, which could provide an alternative to the current reliance on China. In the absence of policies to support these industries domestically, tariffs—the main U.S. government response to China’s rise—have made clean energy technologies more expensive but have not drastically improved the competitive position of American firms. Other economies have taken a different approach. Partly in response to China’s dominance in clean technology industries, European policymaking now treats climate change as an economic imperative, as governments seek to expand shares for domestic firms in growing global clean energy technologies markets and hope to meet a growing share of domestic demand with home-grown technologies. From offshore wind turbines to hydrogen and battery technologies, Europe has combined economic and climate objectives in strategic initiatives to support the growth of domestic clean energy industries. For instance, the EU established the European Battery Alliance to reduce dependence on China for the highest value components in electric vehicle manufacturing. Its goal is to position domestic firms along the entire battery supply chain for economic and security reasons, with the alliance taking on a coordinating function to bring the required industrial actors together. The EU’s push to self-sufficiency in the use of clean energy technologies has taken on new urgency since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, as the continent seeks to reduce its dependence on imports of Russian fossil fuels. The United States needs to treat climate policy as economic policy or risk falling behind other economies that have made clean energy industries a domestic priority. Not just since the beginning of the Ukraine crisis, the Biden administration has looked for ways to boost the domestic production of clean energy technologies. Yet the use of tools such as the Defense Production Act alone won’t be sufficient to secure the domestic production of clean energy technologies that are needed more than ever for energy security and to protect the United States from a volatile global price environment. To strengthen the competitive position of domestic clean energy sectors, the United States should (i) improve financing for domestic clean technology industries through the creation of a national lending institution, (ii) create a stable domestic market environment for low-carbon technologies to reduce investment uncertainty, and (iii) renew investments in vocational training to create a workforce ready to tackle the clean energy challenge. Without a clear strategy to support the growth of domestic clean energy sectors, calls for greater economic separation from China will likely jeopardize climate goals while ceding economic gains to nations with more comprehensive green growth strategies.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Carbon Reduction Solves Econ

Econ impacts are devastating but carbon reduction solves

NIES 19 (National Institute for Environmental Studies. “Potentially large economic impacts of climate change can be avoided by human actions,” Science Daily . September 25 2019 ) @ehatt

A study estimates global-scale, multi-sectoral economic impacts of climate change, and suggests that a plausible range of decisions and actions by humans can determine the scale of the economic impacts, even if the uncertainty in the climate response to increased greenhouse gas concentration is considered. These actions include reductions of greenhouse gas emissions and improvement of socioeconomic conditions. This study highlights the importance of societal changes and the current generation's responsibility for the future. People are less motivated to take actions if its outcome is uncertain, and this could be true for climate-related issues. The uncertainty in climate response to the increase in greenhouse gas concentration, which is often believed to be substantially large, makes it difficult to believe the benefit of reducing emissions or the effectiveness of making society more resilient to climate-related hazards. This could be one of the reasons for inaction even though urgent action is called for. A new study published in Nature Climate Change, conducted by a Japanese research team (consisting of researchers at Ibaraki University, Kyoto University, National Agriculture and Food Research Organization, National Institute for Environmental Studies, Ritsumeikan University, Shibaura Institute of Technology, The University of Tokyo, and University of Tsukuba), might change such views. The study estimates economic impacts of climate change and suggests that humankind's decisions and actions can overwhelm the uncertainty in climate response in terms of reducing the impact of climate change. Estimation of the economic impacts of climate change is itself extremely challenging because it can affect society in many ways. Collaboration between researchers in a diverse range of fields enabled the research team to conduct a global-scale assessment covering the economic impacts associated with climate change for nine impact sectors: the economic impacts arising from changes in agricultural productivity, undernourishment, heat-related excess mortality, cooling/heating demand, occupational health costs, capacity of hydroelectric power generation, capacity of thermal power generation, fluvial flooding, and coastal inundation. Describing the novelty and significance of the study, Dr. Hijioka, the research managing director of Center for Climate Change Adaptation, National Institute for Environmental Studies states, "This is very special research, with no equivalent in the world." The estimated value of the aggregated economic impacts had a large divergence depending on three assumptions: socioeconomic conditions, amount of greenhouse gas emissions, and climate responses to the increased greenhouse gas concentration. Under the most pessimistic combination of assumptions, the estimated economic impact will be equivalent to 8.6% of the global total GDP at the end of the 21st century, while it will be limited to around or less than 1% if the 2-degree target, which was adopted in the Paris Agreement, is achieved and societal resilience to climate-related hazards improves. More importantly, the results also indicated that the contribution of the uncertainty in the climate response to the divergence -- or variance -- of the estimates was minor compared to the contribution of the differences in the anthropogenically directed societal pathways (i.e., greenhouse gas emissions and socioeconomic developments). "This means that humankind has the potential to determine the scale of the economic impacts of climate change," explains Dr. Takakura, a researcher at National Institute for Environmental Studies. According to the results of this study, the future is uncertain mainly because how we behave is uncertain, rather than because how the climate behaves is uncertain in terms of the economic impacts of climate change. "In other words, we can choose the future by taking or not taking actions,and have responsibility for the outcome," he added.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Climate Leadership Openings Now

We have a historic opportunity for the US to reassert itself over China through the GND but failure means loosing the green energy race – we need bold action

Robinson 19 Eugene Robinson - writes a twice-a-week column on politics and culture and hosts a weekly online chat with readers. In a three-decade career at The Washington Post, Robinson has been city hall reporter, city editor, foreign correspondent in Buenos Aires and London, foreign editor, and assistant managing editor in charge of the paper’s Style section. “ Yes, the Green New Deal is audacious. But we have no choice but to think big.” The Washington Post, February 18, 2019, ///Mgal

Who’s afraid of the Green New Deal? I’m not. It’s ambitious, aspirational, improbable, impractical — almost as audacious as putting a man on the moon. We used to be able to think big. Let’s do it again. Sign up for a weekly roundup of thought-provoking ideas and debates Since the 14-page resolution was introduced in Congress this month by Sen. Edward J. Markey (D-Mass.) and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), critics have been falling over themselves to denounce the Green New Deal’s policies as prohibitively expensive, totally unworkable or somehow Venezuelan. If those opponents would stop shouting long enough to actually read the document, they’d see that it’s not a compendium of concrete policies at all, but rather a set of goals. And they are the right goals. The Green New Deal seeks to outline a national project for our time — not just a response to a grave environmental threat, but a framework for enhanced growth, opportunity and fairness. More powerful hurricanes are one of many signs of climate change, and those who deny it are complicit in the destruction, meteorologist Eric Holthaus says. (Video: Gillian Brockell, Kate Woodsome, Adriana Usero/The Washington Post) The laudable aim is to play offense, not defense, in the fight to limit climate change. We are going to have to wage that battle one way or another. Why not do it on our terms, before Miami slips underwater and the yet-unburned parts of California go up in flames? The best historical analogy is not the New Deal but World War II, when mobilization of the nation’s vast productive capacity not only defeated Germany and Japan but also generated unprecedented domestic economic growth, hugely expanding the middle class. Once again, the planet faces a dire threat. Once again, the United States can help lead the world to victory. It’s a massive overreach, critics of the Green New Deal say. But any effort to address climate change that is commensurate with the scale of the problem is going to look like an overreach. Worldwide emissions of carbon dioxide and other heat-trapping gases — the cause of global warming — are beginning to level off, but they need to start falling, and fast, if we are to spare our grandchildren and great-grandchildren an ecological nightmare. Can we really shift entirely to clean energy sources within 10 years, as the resolution pledges? Well, certainly not if we don’t try. In 1961, when President John F. Kennedy announced the goal of sending an American to the moon and back by the end of the decade, NASA scientists had only a vague idea how to do such a thing. They figured it out, and succeeded in 1969. Breakthroughs will be needed, for example, in solar energy technology and battery storage. Why should China — now the world’s biggest producer of solar panels — be allowed to make these innovations and reap the resulting economic benefits? Why not the United States? It’s too expensive, naysayers complain. They point to a clause in the resolution that calls for “upgrading all existing buildings in the United States” to make them more energy-efficient. That sounds absurd — until you remember the massive blackout drills that took place across the country during World War II. People participated. It was their patriotic duty. Windows, roofs, doors, appliances — all have to be replaced every once in a while, and all can be made less wasteful of energy. And as for goals such as making sure every American has “high-quality health care” and “affordable, safe and adequate housing,” well, those have been Democratic Party positions for a very long time. Acting alone would be pointless, skeptics say. Indeed, China is now by far the world’s biggest carbon emitter, with the United States second and India a fast-rising third. What would be the point of going to great effort to reduce U.S. emissions while others just burn more coal? Think about it, though. We are, after all, the second-biggest emitter, which means that any substantial reduction would indeed have measurable impact. Also, officials in China and India, unlike those in the Trump administration, understand and accept the conclusions of climate scientists. China may be adding coal-fired power plants, but it is also making massive investments in clean energy. Do you really want Beijing to lead the way into the future? Shouldn’t it be Washington? That’s a rationale for the Green New Deal that the Make America Great Again crowd should embrace. If you believe in American, you believe that the United exceptionalism States has a duty to lead at moments of crisis. This is such a moment. Look at the big picture. Unless you deny the science of climate change, you have to believe that we need to take bold action. Stop all the nitpicking. Enough with the posturing. Let’s talk about what to do.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › Climate Leadership Openings Now

Criticisms of China provides the opportunity for U.S. climate leadership

Scott Moore, Erin Sikorsky, 11-15-2021, "The U.S. Can Steal China’s Climate Leadership Crown," Foreign Policy, -- MG

For decades, China was a leader in international climate negotiations. But that changed at the latest United Nations climate change conference in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt. At the November 2022 summit, known as COP27, China became the target of criticism for failing to do enough to address climate change. The disapproval came not just from other big greenhouse gas emitters but also from other developing countries: Gaston Browne, the prime minister of Antigua and Barbuda and chair of the influential Alliance of Small Island States, called China a “major polluter” that could no longer expect a “free pass” on contributing to climate finance. This shift underscores an inconvenient truth for Beijing: Given its status as the world’s largest emitter and second-largest economy, China’s climate commitments increasingly look insufficient, and even its former allies in climate negotiations want Beijing to do more. This creates major geopolitical vulnerabilities for China—and opportunities for the United States and its allies. In short, Beijing’s leadership loss on climate is Washington’s gain. China has played an essential role in climate talks since the 1990s. Beijing took part in the original negotiations that led to the main global climate agreement, the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, which then-Premier Li Peng signed in 1992. As China became the world’s largest emitter of greenhouse gasses in the early 2000s, it began to play a more prominent role in international climate policy, underscored by a 2014 U.S.-China joint announcement in which Beijing, for the first time, promised to take steps to reduce its emissions alongside similar steps pledged by Washington. In 2020, when the United States had stepped back from its climate commitments under the Trump administration, Chinese President Xi Jinping pledged to reach net-zero emissions by 2060. Despite this increasingly prominent role, the bedrock of China’s climate policy has remained the principle of “common but differentiated responsibilities”—the idea that while all countries should do their part to fight climate change, wealthy industrialized nations that contributed the bulk of emissions over time should bear most of the effort and expense. This principle helps hold together the Group of 77, or G-77, a caucus of developing countries at the United Nations. Beijing has long been influential in the G-77—so much so that it is technically called the Group of 77 and China—and has coordinated its role in U.N.-sponsored climate negotiations largely through the coalition. Yet it has become increasingly difficult for China to draw a clear line between itself and the industrialized nations it argues should bear the brunt of costs in responding to climate change. When the Paris Agreement was signed in 2015, China was able to secure its status as a developing country in the world’s climate regime. But every year since then, China has been the world’s largest emitter. Though China was responsible for about 12 percent of cumulative global emissions since the start of the Industrial Revolution to 2017—compared to 25 percent for the United States and 22 percent for the European Union and United Kingdom—China now emits about a third of the world’s greenhouse gasses each year, well ahead of any other economy. Analysis suggests China could surpass the United States’ cumulative emissions around 2050.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › China Leads Renewables Now

China ahead now – US dependencies could be easily exploited

Johannes Urpelainen, Chetan Hebbale, 4-12-2022, "The US should treat climate policy as economic policy," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-us-should-treat-climate-policy-as-economic-policy/

Historically, governments have often prioritized economic growth over climate policy, particularly during periods of economic hardship. Yet the view that emissions reductions and good economic policy are irreconcilable is increasingly outdated. In 2021, global markets for renewable energy and electric vehicles soared to USD $366 and USD $273 billion, respectively; global investment in the clean transition topped USD $755 billion. Global clean energy markets are now roughly equivalent to the GDP of Switzerland and roughly three times the size they were ten years ago. In light of rapidly growing markets for clean energy technologies, policymakers around the world have begun to promise new jobs, industries, and sources of prosperity in the transition to a zero-carbon economy. In addition to creating service-sector jobs in the installation and maintenance of clean energy technologies and infrastructure for the electrification of the transportation sector, policymakers have argued that climate policy will lead firms to invest in technological innovation and ultimately co-locate manufacturing to commercialize and produce clean energy technologies domestically. Among policy options to address climate change, those that pursued the dual objective of achieving emissions reductions while creating new sources of economic growth have been easier to implement politically. Such economic benefits have also helped justify growing public investments in the clean energy transition. Yet economic co-benefits from climate policy have not been achieved everywhere. Although governments worldwide have connected climate policymaking to the broader premise of “green growth,” not all economies have successfully built large industrial sectors in support of decarbonization. One reason green sources of economic growth have proven elusive has been the political opposition of industries invested in fossil fuels. Clean energy sectors—wind, solar, storage, and electric vehicles, among others—continue to compete with an existing fossil fuel-based energy system. Utility companies, car manufacturers, and traditional energy providers have mounted political opposition to the clean energy transition. In many cases, such opposition has undermined policies to create markets for clean energy technologies and prevented state support for firms seeking to develop zero-carbon alternatives. This is true even if in many parts of the world new energy technologies are now cheaper than those they are seeking to replace. Other governments have begun to strategically position their domestic economies to benefit from rapidly growing investment in clean energy. Nowhere is this more the case than in China, which has rapidly established itself as the dominant manufacturer in industries central to addressing greenhouse gas emissions. Over the past two decades, China has increased its share of global solar photovoltaic production from less than 1 percent to over 60 percent of the world’s solar panels. For 15 of the past 17 years, China has added more production capacity for crystalline solar cells than any other country in the world. China is also one of the world’s largest producers of and market for electric vehicles. It now commands roughly 75 percent of global production capacity for non-consumer batteries, which are the highest value component in electric vehicles and critical for on-grid electricity storage. China dominates most individual steps in the supply chain, including in the mining and production of Nickel, Cobalt, and Lithium, in the manufacturing of cathodes and anodes, and lithium-ion cell manufacturing. In 2020, China accounted for 58 percent of global production capacity for wind turbine nacelles, primarily for its large and growing domestic market. In addition to producing components for domestic turbine assembly, China produces gearboxes and generators that are used by turbine manufacturers around the world. China’s dominance in the production of low-carbon energy technologies has national security implications in the United States and elsewhere. Without investments in alternative supply chains from raw materials to final assembly, meeting global climate goals could mean trading dependence on Russian fossil fuels for reliance on China for electric vehicle batteries and renewable energy products. As the Ukraine crisis has demonstrated, such interdependencies are easily weaponized. China’s rise to dominance in clean energy industries was not accidental, but the result of strategic and aggressive government support for R&D and manufacturing. No other economy has devoted a similar level of resources to the expansion of production capacity and manufacturing R&D in clean energy sectors central to reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › China Leads Renewables Now

Right now, the US lacks a competitive edge against China

Johannes Urpelainen, Chetan Hebbale, 4-12-2022, "The US should treat climate policy as economic policy," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-us-should-treat-climate-policy-as-economic-policy/

The problem with U.S. policies for low-carbon industries As China began to dominate global supply chains for clean energy technologies, the U.S. responded with a series of trade barriers against Chinese imports. Initially targeting Chinese wind turbine towers, tariffs were expanded to Chinese solar panels under the Obama administration. Tariffs were renewed in 2018 under the Trump administration, again targeting Chinese solar cells despite vocal opposition from the domestic solar industry which feared the impact of rising prices in the large U.S. solar installation and maintenance industry. Despite these trade barriers, manufacturing did not “come back” to the United States as both Democratic and Republican administrations had argued. Tariffs instead led to relocation of production capacity to other Asian economies, including to Vietnam and Malaysia, but they did not forge a reorganization of the solar industry in the United States or promote the expansion of domestic manufacturing capacity. China continues to account for roughly two-thirds of global production capacity in the solar sector, and most U.S. panels are imported. More recently, the Biden administration launched a broad investigation into gaps in domestic supply chains from both economic and security perspectives in the context of China’s dominance in key industrial sectors. But the administration has thus far continued to primarily rely on tariffs implemented under previous administrations as its main tool to improve the competitiveness of domestic firms. The Strategic Competition Act, which seeks authorization to assist U.S. companies with supply chain diversification away from China, proposes new investments in domestic infrastructure to compete with China and emphasizes the need to build alliances to counteract China’s growing international influence. The bill remains stalled in Congress. The Infrastructure and Investment Jobs Act, which passed in November 2021 with bipartisan support, includes investments in the domestic grid and electric vehicle (EV)-related infrastructure, but does not directly address the competitiveness of domestic clean energy technology firms. Proposals such as the use of the Defense Production Act to accelerate domestic mining could increase the availability of raw materials needed for low-carbon technologies but do little to address underlying structural problems of U.S. clean tech manufacturing. Meanwhile, the March 2022 launch of an investigation into possible tariff evasion by Chinese companies—and the prospect of new tariffs on Asian solar panels—has prompted protest by the U.S. solar industry which fears higher prices.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Competitiveness/Leadership › China Leads Renewables Now

China’s investments in clean energy place it far ahead of the United States in all climate sectors.

Theodore Chia, October 26, 2022, (“How China is Winning the Race for Clean Energy Technology”, ) #GayFrog

For the past two decades, a clean energy revolution has been quietly taking place across the globe. More recently, a heated global race has begun with China at the head of the pack. Judging from the emissions data, you wouldn’t think China is ahead. China’s carbon emissions have yet to peak, while the United States and the European Union have drastically lowered their carbon emissions over the last decade. The UK is now at 44% below its 1990 levels and plans to reduce annual carbon emissions to 70% below 1990 levels by 2045. Having peaked its carbon emissions in 2007, the United States has reduced its carbon emissions to 2% above its 1990 levels. China plans to peak its emissions by 2030. But recent investments in fossil fuel have cast doubt on that scenario. At the same time, however, China has been making massive investments in energy transition. “China saw an economic opportunity in low-carbon industries,” according to Kelly Sims Gallagher, Director at the Tufts University Center for International Environment and Resource Policy, “and they formed industrial policy.” While Europe was an early mover in clean energy, China has harnessed its competitive advantage in policy consistency and lower-cost capital to lead the market in solar, wind, and EV technology exports. With the passage of the CHIPS, Infrastructure, and Inflation reduction bills in 2022, the United States has finally significantly accelerated clean energy investment. But is it too late for the Americans to catch up? At a recent Critical Issues Confronting China talk hosted by the Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies, Gallagher gave an update on the current state of the global race for Leadership in low-carbon tech and provided her outlook on the future of clean energy. Five key takeaways: China’s clean energy innovation was driven by economic opportunism By 2009, China had made strong political commitments to renewable energy development and there was a noted government acceptance of climate science. But it was rather recognition of the immense economic potential in the green energy innovation that drove China past its tipping point. In 2009, China was already on track to pass the US as the world’s largest market for wind turbines and had begun pitting state owned power companies against each other to see which could build solar plants fastest. According to Gallagher, China initially made forays into clean energy technology as a means for export, but was able to adroitly set up a domestic market when conditions for outward investment and trade turned sour. Today, China is a veritable green power. It leads the world in renewable energy production figures and is the world’s largest producer of wind and solar energy, as well as the largest domestic and outbound investor in renewable energy. A fear of China drove the U.S. to act on clean energy Nothing exemplifies the return of Great Power politics more than the race for clean energy. Where decades of activism and warnings from scientists had failed to push significant policy change, fear of falling behind China has created a bipartisan effort to invest in clean energy transition. Together, the CHIPS and Science Act, Infrastructure Deal, and Inflation Reduction Act have brought close to half a trillion dollars in fiscal incentives and investments into the growth of clean energy and low-carbon technologies in the US. However, while the bills will boost research and development, they bring in limited regulation. Gallagher pointed out that according to the Department of Energy’s own estimates, the U.S. is “not competitive” in most clean energy sectors. It is still too early to tell if the massive influx of capital will be enough for the U.S. to win the clean energy race. “It’s a little daunting for the U.S.,” Gallagher said. Speaking of China’s dominance in the supply chains for low-carbon technologies, she added, “China is a planning economy, and that has really paid off.” While China maintains an advantage in the race, the U.S. still has some areas where it might have a slight edge. China seems to have an all-round lead on the U.S. in terms of trade balance, R&D investment, and patenting. On the investment front, China had surpassed the U.S. by the late 2000s and Europe by 2012 to be the world leader in low carbon technology investment, pumping in annually at least US$100 billion into innovation by 2014. As of 2018, Chinese investment in clean energy technology was almost double that of the U.S. (The scenario changes when accounting for nuclear investments by the U.S.) At the same time, China’s State-Owned Enterprises are still making massive investments in fossil fuels that entrench the high-carbon economy and signal a bumpy energy transition for China in the coming future. Still, China’s clean energy leadership is signaled not just by its robust investment, trade, and patent figures but rather the number of clean energy jobs. Arguing that a competitive economy is shown through job creation, Gallagher noted that China has created many jobs in the clean energy sector. A case study in solar energy: Nowhere is China’s leading position clearer than in the solar energy sector. China has an estimated 2.7 million people employed in the solar energy sector, making up more than half of the world’s 4.3 million solar jobs. How did China do it? Initially China’s solar industry began in the 1990s to supply Germany’s high demand. The Chinese government provided tax incentives and credits to lure in investors and scoured the globe for supplies of machinery and polysilicon. This vertically integrated supply chain in China created a mammoth solar manufacturing industry that produced more solar panels for less. When western countries imposed tariffs (charging dumping), the Chinese government was able to quickly develop a domestic market. In contrast, the U.S. outsourced its solar production to China. In 2014, the U.S. had a dozen factories producing Photovoltaic wafers and ingots. Today, none exist. According to Gallagher, the disassembling of clean energy infrastructure is making it difficult for the U.S. to claw its way back. The outlook for the U.S. is grim Gallagher concluded that U.S. competitiveness in low carbon technology had completely eroded and that Chinese dominance in the clean energy supply chain will not soon go away. China’s carefully operated state machinery, political commitment, and industrial backing will let it keep its advantage in the clean energy race for the years to come. Gallagher characterized China’s recent investments in fossil fuels as a response to a temporary response to global energy instability. But the direction and momentum of China’s industrial policy will continue China on the path of clean energy dominance. There is one bright spot of hope for the U.S. however: U.S. climate-related spending is due to take off in the next 5 years and will focus on the next step of the clean energy transition: electricity and energy systems integration opportunities (Liu et al., 2015; Samad et al., 2010).

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Integrated Approach Key

Addressing the energy-poverty nexus is key to solve structural inequality- climate policy exacerbates inequality by unevenly distributing resources and exacerbating health risks to marginalized communities

Saurabh Biswas et al in 2022

Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Authors and Affiliations Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Saurabh Biswas; School for the Future of Innovation in Society, Arizona State University, Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Ending the Energy-Poverty Nexus: An Ethical Imperative for Just Transitions; Science and Engineering Ethics volume 28, Article number: 36 (2022)

To illustrate our approach to just transitions, we examine in this paper what we consider to be one of the most important existing facets of the problem of energy injustice and inequality: the energy-poverty nexus (Biswas, 2020; Biswas et al., 2020). Consistent with our overall argument above, we suggest in the rest of this article that the energy transition offers a unique opportunity to reduce the contribution of energy systems to enduring poverty and inequality and, ideally, to leverage new energy system designs to foster improved economic security and wellbeing in low-income households and communities. We define the energy-poverty nexus as an ensemble of complex, negative feedbacks in socio-energy systems (Miller et al., 2015) that, over time, reinforce and exacerbate poverty and make conditions worse off for individuals, households, or communities. Our definition of the energy-poverty nexus incorporates but extends beyond the idea of energy poverty. Energy poverty typically refers to a lack of access to the energy or fuel resources necessary to create a good life (González-Eguino, 2015; Jenkins et al., 2016). This lack of access may arise from a variety of causes (Sovacool, 2012). In developing countries, for example, it may stem from the absence of technological access to modern energy services, such as reliable and sufficient electricity or clean cooking technology, although affordability is also often a problem (Pauchari et al., 2004). In wealthy countries, it generally results from the lack of ability to pay for energy or a high energy burden in which households pay a large proportion of income for energy (Bouzarovski et al., 2012; Lewis et al., 2020). In both developing and wealthy countries, considerable research has begun to illuminate that the concept of energy poverty, as traditionally defined, underestimates the complexity of the problems facing communities vis-à-vis energy (Lewis et al, 2020). Many marginalized communities not only face difficulties accessing and affording energy, but they also pay higher costs and higher fractions of their income for energy and confront a suite of complex and intertwined forms of energy insecurity. Elements of this insecurity include: poor quality energy equipment and infrastructures, with little financial capacity to improve them; more substantial and longer duration disruptions of energy systems after disasters, e.g., as occurred for rural and remote communities in Puerto Rico after Hurricanes Irma and Maria (Castro-Sitiriche, 2018); debilitating trade-offs between energy and food and nutrition, health, education, and employment (Caniglia et al., 2016); disproportionate environmental and health burdens and risks from energy systems; and unjust governance processes that more frequently site pollution-generating facilities in or nearby to low-income communities, communities of color, and indigenous communities (Bullard, 2008; Sze, 2006). Thus, the organization of socio-energy systems reinforces and reinscribes poverty and inequality in communities that lack the economic or political resources or power to change how these systems work. Social and economic insecurities thus perpetuate and exacerbate energy insecurities that, in turn, further undermine social and economic wellbeing and capabilities, creating a cycle of value destruction, structural injustice, and unequal opportunities (Liu et al., 2015; Samad et al., 2010).

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Integrated Approach Key

Only an integrated approach assures a just transition by ensuring the costs and benefits of change are equally distributed

Boyle et al in 21

Alaina D. Boyle, Graham Leggat, Larissa Morikawa, Yanni Pappas, Jennie C. Stephens; Green New Deal proposals: Comparing emerging transformational climate policies at multiple scales; Energy Research & Social Science Volume 81, November 2021, 102259;

The “just” part of a just transition focuses on increased equity, or fair and repaired access to opportunity, which is a prevailing social goal of the GND framework. In H.R. 109, equity is described as “stopping current, preventing future, and repairing historic oppression of… frontline and vulnerable communities” [30]. Beyond the climate change impacts of fossil fuels, many already disadvantaged communities in the US and internationally have lived and worked on the toxic front lines of energy production and distribution, bearing the environmental and health damages that accompany proximity to these sites, despite often paying more for energy [31]. Globally, the communities that are most vulnerable to climate change have emitted the fewest GHG emissions [32]. Although technological change is crucial to remediating these harms and decarbonizing the energy system, social innovation is an essential part of reducing risks of the worsening climate crisis. The climate justice movement and energy justice scholarship highlight that all toooften policies focused narrowly on decarbonization actually result in widening economic inequities and racial injustices because the incentives and benefits are disproportionately distributed to privileged households and communities [33], [34], [35]. There is a mounting need to restructure not only how energy is produced and distributed, but also how energy investments are distributed among marginalized and underinvested-in communities. Because the causes and experience of climate change are deeply interwoven with health, power, financial, and social disparities, it is increasingly apparent that integrating climate action with efforts to address inequities is necessary in the US and across the world. As people’s lives and livelihoods become more precarious with each new disaster [2], [31], [36], an integrated approach to addressing vulnerabilities of all kinds is increasingly important.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Integrated Approach Key

Framing is key – decision makers must evaluate climate issues as symptoms of the larger destructive system of capital- failure ensures continued inequality and future crises

Jennie C. Stephens in 2022

School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);

Climate justice leader and human rights attorney Colette Pichon Battle calls on all of us to reframe our understanding of the problem [10]. “Climate change is not the problem; climate change is the most horrible symptom of an economic system that has been built for a few to extract every precious ounce of value out of this planet and its people, from our natural resources to the fruits of our human labor. This system has created the crisis.” [10]. This perspective is shared by multiple scholars who have critiqued how climate experts and sustainability transition researchers have failed to engage in any significant critiques of capitalism and the financialization of society. [20, 46]. Until more climate experts and key climate decision-makers with power and influence over climate policy are able to reframe their own understanding of the crisis, and move beyond climate isolationism, societal responses will continue to be inadequate and both climate risks and social injustices will continue to worsen. Without this essential reframing, well-intentioned climate decision-makers will continue to inadvertently perpetuate inequities and exacerbate disparities in health, wealth, and opportunity.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Solves Inequality/Climate

A Green New Deal would hold a dual purpose in solving both income inequality and climate – preparing workers for the clean transition is essential.

Joseph W. Kane, Mark Muro, and Adie Tomer, 1-25-2019, "The Green New Deal promises jobs, but workers need to be ready to fill them," Brookings, #GayFrog 

Against a background of scary reports, hurricanes, and fire, a “Green New Deal” is emerging to address global warming head-on, generating a ton of buzz in Washington. The Green New Deal raises more questions than it answers at the moment, but nevertheless, one vision it holds is exciting and solid—the notion that the transition to a cleaner economy can be expected to bring jobs for all kinds of workers. Past Brookings research has shown that the clean economy encompasses a vast array of industries (and jobs) directly involved in producing goods and providing services with an environmental benefit. Think about all the workers who oversee renewable energy facilities, manufacture energy-efficient appliances, construct green buildings, and so on. While the clean economy has no standard definition or measurement, there is a sizable workforce nationally that figures to grow in importance as the market for cleaner designs, technologies, and other advanced industries expands—and there are policies in Washington and elsewhere that can help accelerate this transition. So Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) is right to call out the possibilities. Admittedly, the Green New Deal is more of a rallying cry than a substantive policy platform at this point. Similar ideas on combating climate change and promoting more job growth have been floated for nearly a decade, and progressive leaders like “AOC” are still light on details when it comes to identifying and paying for any related workforce development efforts. Meanwhile, even as other Democratic leaders voice support for the Green New Deal, they are split on how to exactly incorporate it in their agenda. For instance, Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) has focused on addressing climate change and creating jobs as part of a separate infrastructure push. But the fact remains that jobs are a central element in the shift toward a cleaner economy, and the Green New Deal’s emphasis on this point serves as another reminder of that. The bigger question moving forward, though, is what types of jobs will be part of this transition? Up until now, much of the focus among researchers and policymakers has been on counting the number of workers currently employed in the clean economy. As just one example, the Department of Energy has counted 6.4 million workers engaged in closely related activities in its latest “U.S. Energy and Employment” report in 2017. Yet, these studies hint at an even larger opportunity facing the country, namely all the current and future workers implicated in the transition to a cleaner economy. If efforts like the Green New Deal are to truly expand economic opportunity for more workers, they must not only identify who is going to carry out all these activities, but must also better target future training efforts. Identifying the major occupations involved in this transition is crucial in order to see where individual workers stand and ultimately equip them with the skills to support long-term career pathways. In other words, the conversation cannot simply start and end with the types and numbers of industries involved in the clean economy, but it should examine all the various engineers, technicians, and other workers who are directly responsible for driving this clean transition. These workers, after all, are involved in a range of specialized activities—from clean energy production, to energy efficiency, to environmental management—and tend to require particular types of applied learning and on-the-job training, similar to other skilled trade positions found throughout the infrastructure supersector. Along the way, they can also earn competitive wages and gain highly valuable (and transferrable) skills. To help enable that, in any event, forthcoming research from Brookings Metro will delve deeper into these clean economy occupations, while examining their ability to support more inclusive growth for all types of workers. As momentum builds for national efforts like the Green New Deal—to say nothing of all the efforts being led by states and localities—it’s key that policymakers and practitioners design workforce development efforts in light of the specific training needs for workers in the transition to a cleaner economy. This new work will aim to fill that information gap and seek to address barriers in education, training, and the broader workplace that may be preventing workers from growing their careers in this space. So stay tuned—concerns over climate and economic inequality are only increasing, and preparing workers for a cleaner future is essential. 

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Solves Inequality/Climate

A Green JG Lowers energy consumption, poverty, and mortality It would cost very little too – Economic models prove

Godin 12 Antoine Godin - Senior Social Economic Research at the Levy institute at Bard College, “Guaranteed Green Jobs: Sustainable Full Employment,” Levy Economics Institute, May 2012, ///Mgal

Literature on cost-benefit analysis of green buildings is wide. Some authors focus only on domestic houses (Clinch and Healy 2001, Hens and Verdonck 2001, Levine et al. 2007, POST 2005), while others focus on public buildings (Kats et al. 2005, Kats 2006, Lee et al. 2000). Generally, various benefits are cited: energy and water savings, improved health and decreased mortality, enhanced student learning, increased productivity, job creation—all leading to clear economic and social profits. 17 We will only consider energy savings both in dwellings and public buildings. 5.1 Adding the ELR into the Model Introducing a green-job employer-of-last-resort (ELR) into the economy does not change the model much. Table 5 is the social account matrix. The only difference from the previous model is that now unemployed workers do not receive an unemployment subsidy, but are employed by the state for a minimum wage. The balance sheet does not change and is not reproduced here. There are no substantial modifications. First of all, as already stated, wage earners’ income is now composed of private sector earnings and ELR wage instead of the dole. Second, works done under ELR have an effect both on governmental and household energy consumption. Equation (20) shows that we relax the hypothesis of constant government spending, as public energy consumption decreases proportionally to the size of ELR (measured by u, the private unemployment rate). Equation (21) indicates that wage earners’ propensity to consume energy ( ) also diminishes proportionally to the ELR size. (20) (21) 5.2 Green-Job ELR vs. Baseline The first set of simulations18 analyses the structural effect on the economy of a green-job ELR scheme (hereafter GJ). The GJ starts in period 25. The policy consists of an expected increase of total government spending of 10 percent, an increase that is devoted to the wage paid to ELR workers. 19 Furthermore, ELR changes the consumption patterns of both wage earners and the public sector following (20) and (21). It is important to note that since these two equations constantly modify the parameters, no steady state can be reached. The economy is constantly changing according to the new preferences of wage earners as well as to the new government spending. Figures 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, and 14 show the results obtained through these simulations. In all graphs, the blue line represents the green-job ELR results, while the red line represents the baseline ones. All the results are relative changes from steady state values. Obviously, unemployment disappears as soon as ELR is put into action. However, not all workers are employed in the private sector. The analysis is conducted on how private unemployment (i.e., all workers not employed in the private sector; that is, ELR workers) varies. Figure 8 shows that private unemployment decreases directly by almost 15 percent. Then, due to the structural change that green jobs imply, private unemployment keeps decreasing rather steeply, at first, then more gently. This result of decreasing unemployment depends on whether the energy sector is more or less labor intensive than the consumption good industry. It is also interesting to note that the predicted 10 percent increase in government spending is not reached at all. Private unemployment decreases drastically due to the increase in aggregate consumption from both household sectors, lowering the cost of ELR. Both households sectors see an increase in their income after the green-job program is enacted. This leads to an increase in their wealth, resulting in an increase in desired bond holding. This implies an increase in the public debt level. Furthermore, GDP increases also, due to an increase in consumption and investments. The increase in public debt is nonetheless larger than the increase in GDP, leading to an increased level of debt to GDP of about 0.4 percent. The 6 percent increase in government expenditure observed at the beginning of the program is lowered as private unemployment keeps decreasing, removing workers out of ELR and as public energy consumption decreases. The structural change in the economy can be observed through employment in widget and energy production sectors. In the short run, the increase in income by both wage earners and capitalists increases energy consumption. In the long run, the reduction in energy consumption by both the public sector and wage earners leads to a reduction in energy consumption. This leads to a reduction in employment in the energy industry. However, the reduction in energy employment is countered by an increase in the widget sector. 20 Three conclusions can be drawn from this analysis. First, an ELR is a direct way to remove all involuntary unemployment and address poverty issues. Second, a green-job ELR implies structural changes in the economy, aiming at lower energy consumption. Regarding the 20 As noted before, the total reduction or increase in employment depends on whether the energy industry is more or less labor intensive than the widget one. 21 structural change, the present model does not include synergy effects that a green-job public sector might imply. It is obvious that imitative firms would appear on the market as soon as new green technologies would be used in the green-job program. Finally, aggregate ELR cost has to be lowered by the reduction in unemployment due to the spur in aggregate demand that higher income implies. In our simulation, a predicted 10 percent increase in government spending leads to an ex-post increase of only 4 percent. Furthermore, poor people usually receive benefits, which could be removed for ELR workers, further lowering the cost of ELR.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › GND Solves Climate Inequality

Green new deal is key to systemic change- it recognizes the futility of small technocratic fixes and uses an integrative approach that shows the connection between socioeconomic structures and climate change

Boyle et al in 21

Alaina D. Boyle, Graham Leggat, Larissa Morikawa, Yanni Pappas, Jennie C. Stephens; Green New Deal proposals: Comparing emerging transformational climate policies at multiple scales; Energy Research & Social Science Volume 81, November 2021, 102259;

Policy proposals applying a GND framework are part of a new approach to climate policy that is distinct from both previously proposed traditional cost-based climate policies and business as usual (BAU), which assumes continued reliance on fossil fuels (Fig. 1). Throughout this paper we refer to GND proposals or GND-like policies as a new type of integrated climate policy that applies the GND framework including some policy proposals that do not explicitly use the words Green New Deal. Traditional cost-based climate policies, including carbon taxes and cap-and-trade policies, have dominated public policy discourse around climate change. Traditional policies focus on market-based approaches and are based on the economic assumption that climate change is an externality that can be addressed by internalizing costs [19]. These policies, which result from a “climate isolationist” technocratic framing of climate change as a discrete and isolated problem in need of a technological solution, tend to focus narrowly on greenhouse gas emissions reductions [20]. Although market-based policies have contributed to some renewable energy gains and reductions in GHG emissions, market-based policies alone increasingly appear to be insufficient to achieve the systemic transformation needed to both drastically reduce GHG emissions and build the resilience needed to minimize climate-based catastrophes and the resulting human and economic losses [1], [3], [21], [22], [23], [24]. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) developed Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) projecting climate change in response to different climate policy approaches [25]. In these pathways, BAU represents the future without additional climate policy; a continuation of a predominately fossil-fuel based energy system. This system perpetuates structural inequity of climate impacts and resource access, leading to climate displacement and increased morbidity and mortality for the most vulnerable [2], [26]. Without any ambitious new climate policies, either GND-like policies or cost-based climate policies, a future still dominated by fossil fuel use, continued economic precarity and inequities, and devastating climate disruptions can be expected (Fig. 1). Although the IPCC’s RCPs project the future through 2100, the figure reflects that GND policies propose nearer-term targets through 2050. The GND framework differs from other types of climate policies because it is based on large-scale investments designed to increase community resilience to climate disruptions as well as reduce emissions. The goals of GND proposals are not just based on short-term, cost-effective shifts to decarbonize the economy; they also include long-term social and economic outcomes related to jobs, health, and social equity. While most prior proposed climate policies assume emissions reductions targets will be met by incentivizing technological development or economic mechanisms including carbon taxes, GND proposals contextualize emissions reductions as a benefit within an economic re-orientation away from fossil fuels, linking investments in renewable infrastructure and employment while addressing social inequities [27]. GND proponents argue that the environmental damage of fossil fuel reliance and social inequities are inextricably linked, so policies addressing these problems will not be effective unless they are simultaneously addressing both [28]. The GND framework can be characterized as a component of a just transition that incorporates consideration for the employment effects of the economic shift to renewable energy and the longstanding harms to frontline communities from fossil fuel energy pollution [4]. To address this complex set of issues, GND proposals typically feature multiple sections to contextualize and describe environmental, economic, and social goals, including clean energy, equity, health, and emissions reductions. As a multi-sectoral economy-wide approach to climate, GND policies include investments in climate mitigation, adaptation, and resilience. This integrated approach offers an opportunity for broader transformational social change and offers opportunities for addressing climate justice and economic justice with decarbonization [20]. Given the scale of the climate challenges ahead, GND policies recognize that the scale of climate action needed is beyond incremental adjustments that recombine the existing elements of socio-economic structures [1], [29]. These policies acknowledge that systemic transformation requires social innovation to create economic decoupling from carbon consumption, where increased economic activity does not directly contribute to increased carbon consumption [29]. While some scholars and activists suggest degrowth – which focuses on reducing economic activity to meet physical ecological boundaries – is critical for the societal transformation that is needed, the decoupling included in GND proposals assumes continued resource consumption but in ways that do not contribute to GHG emissions. Some scholars argue that a GND featuring decoupling, rather than degrowth, is necessary to meet rising standards of living and expand job opportunities not only in the Global North, but worldwide [27].

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › GND Solves Climate Inequality

The green new deal enacts structural changes on the economy that address inequality as a root cause of climate change

Julia Robertson Hathaway in 2020

Department of Communication, George Mason University; Climate Change, the Intersectional Imperative, and the Opportunity of the Green New Deal; ENVIRONMENTAL COMMUNICATION 2020, VOL. 14, NO. 1, 13–22

How individuals and communities experience climate change is influenced by multiple factors. An intersectional approach includes “the complex, irreducible, varied, and variable effects which ensue when multiple axes of differentiation – economic, political, cultural, psychic, subjective and experiential – intersect in historically specific contexts” (Brah & Phoenix, 2004, p. 76). Gender, combined with ethnicity, age, and socio-economic background, determine to a large extent people’s resilience in the face of climate change (Harris, 2010). When viewed through an intersectional lens, climate vulnerability is the product of these multifaceted factors and processes interacting within systems of power (Osborne, 2015). A growing literature has examined how climate change relates to equity (e.g. Djoudi et al., 2016; Patterson et al., 2018; Sonja & Harald, 2018; Spencer, Perkins, & Erickson, 2018) and intersectionality (e.g. Kaijser & Kronsell, 2014; Thompson-Hall, Carr, & Pascual, 2016) – even in the context of the climate change scientific community (Gay-Antaki & Liverman, 2018). Intersectionality is explicitly oriented towards transformation, building coalitions among different groups, working towards social justice (Hankivsky, 2014), and enabling critical questions about norms and the power structures that shape them in the context of climate change (Kaijser & Kronsell, 2014). If well-communicated, an intersectional approach can provide a powerful basis for intervention on climate change (Kaijser & Kronsell, 2014; Pulido, 2017). When introduced in January of 2019 as joint House and Senate resolutions, the GND represented an unprecedented departure from past policy approaches to climate change. The nonbinding resolutions signified the vast diversity of lived experiences and the ways in which they intersect, as well as the inextricable links between climate change, poverty, inequality, and economic injustice. As Rhiana Gunn-Wright, policy director for New Consensus and an architect of the GND, explained in an interview: To take an intersectional approach seeks to make visible and address the various privileges and oppressions that we all have in order to build an activist movement that is more just, inclusive and coherent … We each carry different identities; each could be dominant, oppressed or a combination of both. Our identities intersect and overlap. When we don’t take into account this overlapping, people marginalized by the intersection of power structures are forgotten and not understood. As a result, it becomes impossible for them to ask for justice as our society cannot grasp their issue (Pod Save America, 2019). In outlining a package of policies addressing including health care, green jobs, transportation, and housing, the GND positions equity as central to addressing climate change (Gunn-Wright & Hockett, 2019). In so doing, the GND establishes a new stance regarding how these interrelated issues should be reflected in political and institutional processes and norms. The challenge was met with derision and vilification (e.g. Carney, 2019; Cillizza, 2019; McConnell, 2019).

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › GND Solves Climate Inequality

Green new deal represents an intersectional approach to climate that recognizes systemic inequality as its root cause- this is key to initiating change on the scale needed to stop disaster

Julia Robertson Hathaway in 2020

Department of Communication, George Mason University; Climate Change, the Intersectional Imperative, and the Opportunity of the Green New Deal; ENVIRONMENTAL COMMUNICATION 2020, VOL. 14, NO. 1, 13–22

In this essay, I argue that communicators must understand and convey the relevance of intersectionality if we are to avoid climate disaster. I begin by summarizing the literature focused on gender and climate change to present one important example of the type of analysis required to begin to communicate effectively about systemic inequities and climate change. I explore how climate change impacts women differentially; the extent to which women are underrepresented in decision making fora; and the potential for women to improve our efforts to mitigate and adapt. I then discuss the ways in which gender, sexuality, race, and class are linked in ways that have been neglected by climate change communicators. I focus on the Green New Deal (GND, 2019) as an example of an intersectional policy proposal. The GND reflects a marked departure from other federal legislation in that it recognizes the inequities of systemic power relations as root causes of climate change, and their redress as the only promising way forward. I contrast the GND with other policy approaches to climate change that view and understand climate change responses through the lens of technology and science. Third, I describe the discourse surrounding the GND during the first quarter of 2019. Finally, I argue that in order for the GND to serve as a viable proposal and platform for public deliberation, communicators and advocates must draw on climate communication research to effectively enact its theory of change.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › GND Solves Climate Inequality

GND policies strengthen marginalized communities and eliminate disparities created by a fossil fuel economy- the cost of inaction far outweighs the cost of the plan

Boyle et al in 21

Alaina D. Boyle, Graham Leggat, Larissa Morikawa, Yanni Pappas, Jennie C. Stephens; Green New Deal proposals: Comparing emerging transformational climate policies at multiple scales; Energy Research & Social Science Volume 81, November 2021, 102259;

Beyond the international health crisis, increased societal attention on systemic inequality and racial violence in 2020 followed multiple highly visible murders of Black people by police in the US [59]. This heightened awareness extends attention to broader issues of environmental injustice: the unequal harmful health effects of fossil fuel energy and climate change due to the legacies of marginalization in housing, land use planning, and zoning place communities of color and low-income communities in the path of pollution, often from fossil fuel sources [30]. Current disparities in economic and health outcomes are thus inextricably linked to the fossil fuel economy, a fact acknowledged and incorporated in many of the GND proposals. GND policies highlight the importance of addressing local environmental pollution to protect the health of under-invested communities beyond the focus of reducing GHG emissions in more traditional climate policies. GND proposals also support the development of a clean energy, resilience, and adaptation workforce as an opportunity to improve equity and address climate change while providing career opportunities, as an opportunity to build back better or bounce forward [6], [55]. Creating good jobs by investing in green infrastructure builds social resilience and economic security, especially in vulnerable and frontline communities as identified in H.R. 109 [9]. With respect to the finding that women and women of color in particular, are more at risk for losing or leaving their jobs during the pandemic, GND proposals can foster equity across the board by encouraging investment in people and infrastructure instead of further entrenching infrastructure that maintains or deepens economic, social, and health inequalities [60]. These policy proposals claim that investing in climate action is not only a worthwhile endeavor for social justice or job creation potential. They also explain that the projected economic, environmental, and human morbidity and mortality costs of climate change are staggering in comparison to the costs of investment in climate action (see Fig. 5) [7], [61]. These proposals are based on the understanding that the projected costs of inequality in the US alone reach up to $1.5 trillion USD [62]. Although opponents to the federal GND have estimated costs up to $93 trillion USD, the environmental costs of climate inaction due to temperature rise could, within 70 years, have been estimated to reach as high as 14% of GDP per capita, which in 2019 would be $3 trillion, per year [61]. It is not news that climate action, even investment in deeply ambitious action, yields a positive return on investment [63].