Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › GND Solves Climate Inequality

The Green new deal is key to creating systemic economic changes that address inequity and transition the US to renewable energy- now is key

Boyle et al in 21

Alaina D. Boyle, Graham Leggat, Larissa Morikawa, Yanni Pappas, Jennie C. Stephens; Green New Deal proposals: Comparing emerging transformational climate policies at multiple scales; Energy Research & Social Science Volume 81, November 2021, 102259;

As wildfires, hurricanes, droughts, floods, extreme temperatures, and other climate disruptions worsen around the world, it is increasingly recognized that systemic change facilitated by transformational policy is required to prevent the human and economic losses currently projected [1], [2]. Widespread recognition of the deep interconnections among climate change, social equity, and economic activity has led to a growing transformation-focused climate justice movement that advocates for equity and social justice to be at the core of all climate policy [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7]. Moving away from proposed climate policies that exacerbate and perpetuate economic disparities, a new set of policies are rapidly emerging that focus on a just transition, where communities that will be most affected by the shift away from fossil fuels to a renewable-based low-carbon society are empowered and supported. These policies explicitly address the social and economic structures that have enabled the worsening climate crisis, and prioritize protecting vulnerable populations both locally and internationally [8]. Among the most prominent and influential of these new proposed policies is the US Green New Deal (GND) Resolution (H.R. 109 Recognizing the duty of the Federal Government to create a Green New Deal), which was proposed in 2018 and introduced in the U.S. Congress in February 2019 [9]. In 14 pages, the 2019 GND resolution describes large-scale national goals across sectors for greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and pollution reductions, employment, infrastructure, housing, health and equity. The breadth and ambition of the proposal, which calls for 10 years of intensive investment and mobilization, is justified with references to recent climate science reports that call for urgent action. The resolution is based on the assertion that climate change is a direct threat to the United States, exacerbating environmental, economic, and social instabilities, and that the Federal Government, therefore, has both a responsibility and an opportunity to make large public investments to accelerate the transition to a green, healthy economy through job training, job creation, infrastructure, healthcare, and housing. By explicitly invoking the New Deal from the 1940s, the GND recalls the example of large-scale U.S. Federal investment in public mobilization to alleviate unemployment, develop physical infrastructure, and enact public works [10]. Despite the widely perceived success of the New Deal in stimulating positive outcomes for American society, the proposed GND (H.R. 109) has been met with vigorous opposition, and the economic and political feasibility of the proposed policy vision has been hotly debated [11]. Public opinion of the GND, which was developed and proposed by liberal Democrats, has polarized primarily along party lines as the Republican Party has opposed both large public investments and climate action, although there has also been some pushback by centrist Democrats. Given the partisan associations of the major media outlets in the US, soon after the GND was first proposed, many Republicans harshly critiqued it in part due to what Gustafson et al. (2019) call the “Fox News effect”, where more critical coverage by the outlet caused a sharp decline in support for the policy among conservative Republicans [8]. Despite the rigorous, partisan political debates about the federal GND resolution, other new proposals asserting the need for integrated multi-sectoral coordination and investment at other levels of government, including state, municipal, regional, and tribal, have been rapidly emerging. While ambitious climate policies that address justice have been implemented in other countries, H.R. 109 was the first to explicitly connect unprecedented investment in social, economic, and climate goals to a just transition for local communities and more equitable climate outcomes relative to GHG emissions globally [12]. Building on the ambition and inspiration of the US national-level proposal, these GND-type policies have been proposed to spur major public investment in multiple interconnected aspects of the transition toward a renewable-based society including the environment, labor, and infrastructure across multiple levels of government, from US cities to the EU. A broad range of communities, advocates, and organizations have leveraged the GND framework to advocate for their priorities including Indigenous rights, racial equity, and labor rights. Although some proposals using the GND framework include specific economic and policy mechanisms, the initial federal GND proposal of 2019 focuses on broad goals and leaves the specifics of policy design and implementation to be developed. Emerging research on the feasibility of the national GND is growing, including studies integrating economic, political, and systemic transition framework lenses [3], [13], [14], [15], [16]. Most of this work was published prior to the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, before the unprecedented federal investment in the US workforce through the CARES (Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security) Act that followed, and before the need for massive public investments in the United States was so much more acute and widespread. In a time where cities and regions across the world face immense increases in unemployment rates and the depths of social inequalities revealed and exacerbated by COVID-19, pandemic recovery offers a new mechanism to provide public investments to simultaneously achieve multiple goals including creating jobs, addressing a legacy of injustices, and accelerating a transition toward renewable energy. In both the United States and Europe, the GND framework has been explicitly recognized as a crucial framework for confronting the climate crisis as part of pandemic recovery. Not all climate policies that apply a GND-type framework, however, use the language of the GND to connect explicitly to the original GND proposal. The Biden administration, for example, appears to be taking a “quiet” approach to climate policy; avoiding linking their climate policies to the GND in an attempt to avoid the kind of polarizing media coverage and political opposition that has hindered H.R. 109 since its introduction [8], [17]. In contrast to the Biden/Harris administration being careful not to explicitly associate its ambitious climate plans as embracing the proposed GND, the European Commission integrates the 2019 European Green Deal with COVID-19 recovery in NextGenerationEU [18].

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › GND Solves Climate Inequality

A Green New Deal Federal Jobs Guarantee solves for climate and income inequality – it is the best means of solving both these impacts.

Jeremy Brecher, March 18, 2019, (“The Green New Deal: A Strategy for a More Equal United States”, ) #GayFrog

The Green New Deal often gets portrayed as simply a program for climate protection. But the Green New Deal — as proposed in a new congressional resolution from Representative Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Ed Markey — stands just as boldly as a strategy to counter America’s grotesque and growing inequality. The resolution they’ve introduced calls for “a new national, social, industrial, and economic mobilization on a scale not seen since World War II and the New Deal era.” Such a mobilization, notes their resolution, provides “a historic opportunity to create millions of good, high-wage jobs, virtually eliminate poverty in the United States, provide unprecedented levels of prosperity and economic security for all U.S. persons, and counteract systemic injustices.” The Green New Deal resolution outlines a vision of what we need to do to address the dual crises of climate change and runaway inequality. What policies and programs could help us realize that vision? My recent Labor Network for Sustainability discussion paper — Eighteen Strategies for a Green New Deal: How to Make Climate Mobilization Work — lays out a comprehensive strategic framework that draws on the experience of the original New Deal and the homefront mobilization for World War II. This framework envisions a Green New Deal active on a variety of fronts. The Green New Deal will use the powers of government to rectify past and present injustices. Green New Deal jobs protecting the climate will be available to those individuals and groups who’ve been denied equal access to good jobs, with job recruitment programs that include strong racial, gender, age, and locational affirmative action to counter our current employment inequalities. Green New Deal programs will also require standards for local hiring and minority business enterprises and provide job ladders within and across employers so those who currently face only dead-end jobs won’t face only dead-end jobs in the climate-protection economy. Green New Deal projects will remedy the concentration of pollution in marginalized and low-income communities and counter the deprivation of transportation, education, health, and other facilities in poor neighborhoods. The Green New Deal will ensure full employment. The original New Deal used the tools of what came to be known as macroeconomic or Keynesian economic policy to steer the economy as a whole. That New Deal employed budget deficits and other fiscal policies as well as low interest rates and other monetary policies to fight unemployment. Neoliberalism today has abandoned Keynesian full-employment policies and steered the United States into the deepest economic crisis since the Great Depression, followed by an aftermath of ongoing income polarization and the impoverishment of millions of working people. The Green New Deal’s full-employment macroeconomic policies will reduce fears about climate protection’s impact on prosperity and also give working people a greater stake in the transition. The Green New Deal will guarantee jobs for all. To counter the insecurity of working class life in general and the specific fear that climate protection may lead to job loss, climate protection policies will incorporate the principle of a job for everyone who wants one. A Green New Deal government, if its other policies haven’t led to full employment, would serve as the employer of last resort for all who want to work, putting them into jobs in climate protection and other socially needed activities. Funding provided through this federal jobs guarantee — a commitment somewhat like the New Deal’s Works Progress Administration — will help nonprofits, local governments, and other agencies serving the public employ anyone who wants a job at a wage roughly comparable to the demands of the Fight for $15 campaign. The jobs guarantee will not exclude any individual or group of people who want to work and make whatever special provisions may be necessary to employ veterans, at-risk youth, ex-convicts, people with disabilities, and other people with special needs who face barriers to employment. These jobs will also pay an estimated $15 per hour plus benefits, including health insurance. By guaranteeing every person who wishes to work a public-option job with a wage twice the current federal minimum wage plus benefits, the Green New Deal will establish a standard that all employers will have to meet, ensuring that no working person will live in poverty. And the Green New Deal will also provide the education, training, and apprenticeship opportunities to help make this new economy a reality. The Green New Deal will ensure worker rights and good union jobs. Pay and benefit standards will offer working families a decent life and future. The Green New Deal will support “high road” employers, prevailing wage provisions like those required by the Davis-Bacon Act, and project labor agreements negotiated between unions and employers to ensure that climate protection jobs elevate rather than depress wages and working conditions. The Green New Deal — like the original New Deal — will establish a new framework that protects workers’ fundamental constitutional and human rights. The industrial mobilization during World War II reinforced the rights of workers to express themselves freely, bargain collectively, and organize for concerted action on the job. So will the Green New Deal. The Green New Deal will tax the rich. The Green New Deal offers us an opportunity for correcting our extreme inequality. We can tax the rich to help pay for climate protection. The Green New Deal will put to productive user the trillions of dollars that American banks, corporations, and investors have lying unused in their bank accounts — much of it from government giveaways billed as “economic stimulus.” And the Green New Deal will draw on the enormous resources of the fossil fuel industry. These resources should go to pay for the damage the industry has done to our Earth and every one of its people. The Green New Deal will use the trillions in tax breaks and subsidies given away to America’s wealthy and the corporations they run — and the wealth of the fossil fuel industry itself — to ensure that the transition to climate safety leaves ordinary Americans far better off.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Climate Justice Key

Climate justice is key- it’s a structural access point for addressing inequality more broadly

Hollis, ’21 (Adrienne Hollis is an environmental Justice advocate and has been working in the environmental/environmental justice arena for more than 20 years. She has a Juris Doctorate which she uses to focus on Environmental Law and Justice. and a PhD. in Biomedical Sciences with a focus on Nutritional Biochemistry from Meharry Medical College in Nashville Tennessee. As such, she is also an environmental toxicologist.) https://www.carbonbrief.org/experts-why-does-climate-justice-matter/

I think of climate justice as an important part of a larger issue, environmental justice, which I envision as a huge umbrella with many spokes. Each spoke is an interrelated issue – climate justice, racial justice, immigration justice, criminal justice, gender justice, etc. These issues matter – climate justice matters – because our environment is not just where we live, pray, play, work and learn, it is also who we are, how we are treated and why. People are not affected by these issues equally, whether through intent or indifference. Climate justice matters because we are in an era of racial and social reckoning and ensuring that justice and equity are incorporated into our actions. Climate justice focuses on correcting decades of structural racism which affect communities of colour, poor communities, rural communities and non-English speaking communities more than any other. Remember, long before our brothers and sisters of colour screamed that they could not breathe at the hands of the justice system, they (we) were choking on environmental pollution resulting from racist practices. Climate justice matters because it forces people to work with and protect communities bearing the brunt of devastating hurricanes and accompanying flooding, disproportionate exposures to toxic substances, chronic flooding, premature deaths, chronic illnesses and more. Through it, we can begin to address a multitude of issues such as infrastructure (including housing quality and affordability, transportation, roads), economic apartheid, food apartheid, mental and physical health, climate gentrification and others. You cannot address climate justice without addressing these issues. That is why it matters.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Climate Justice Key

The round should be evaluated through a lens of climate justice- only a recognition of the relationship between socio-economic inequality and climate can ensure the holistic approach key to solve

Jennie C. Stephens in 2022

School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);

Moving beyond the lens of climate isolationism, climate justice provides a more productive, complex, and holistic framework within which to assess and prioritize responses to the climate crisis [58, 70]. Climate justice requires recognizing that: (1) many policies, processes, and practices of wealthy elite institutions and individuals are the drivers of climate change, (2) the impacts of climate disruptions and the capacity to adapt are distributed unequally among and within local and global communities; and (3) equitable climate adaptation and strengthening climate resilience requires new transformative investments, innovations, and actions to rectify the disproportionate burdens on those who are most vulnerable to ongoing and future climate impacts [27]. Decision-making within a climate justice frame involves striving for transformative systemic changes that integrate technological and social innovation while prioritizing equity and social, racial, and economic justice. Just as Ibram X Kendi explains in his book “How to be an Antiracist” (2019) that there is no such thing as neutrality when it comes to considering systemic racism [37], there is no policy that is neutral on climate justice. Policies and decisions at every level are either perpetuating climate injustices if they are not intentionally and explicitly trying to reduce climate injustices. Given the racial and economic injustices associated with fossil fuel reliance [28] and fossil fuel combustion [47], a societal transformation toward a renewable-based society needs to be prioritized. The case for keeping fossil fuels in the ground can be made from a climate isolationism lens, however, the case becomes so much more compelling and practical when the social justice opportunities are also explicitly called out [41]. To move beyond climate isolationism toward climate justice, climate decision-making has to focus more explicitly on power dynamics and social innovations to redistribute power to people and communities who are most vulnerable. Climate decision-making needs to explicitly consider how policies, practices, and priorities either reinforce or disrupt the systems that are currently concentrating wealth and power. For less powerful groups to gain a foothold in decision-making processes, renewed attention to the multiple ways that social, economic, and political power shape social change must be acknowledged [34]. Feminist theory offers expertise in the study of power [11], so embracing a feminist lens is one valuable approach to moving away from climate isolationism toward climate justice. The social science literature on sociotechnical transitions has been critiqued for minimizing the role of power [6], and a recent contribution by Avelino [7] identifies seven specific ways to consider power in decision-making, processes of change, and innovation: (1) power over versus power to, (2) centered versus diffused, (3) consensual versus conflictual, (4) constraining versus enabling, (5) quantity versus quality, (6) empowerment versus disempowerment, and (7) power in relation to knowledge [7]. As jurisdictions around the world grapple with the interconnected crises of housing and food insecurity, climate disruptions, and economic precarity, narrow efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions or control the global average temperature are likely to cause more harm than good. New ways of strategically integrating climate action into other social policies, in the way that the Biden/Harris administration integrated their climate agenda into pandemic recovery and inflation reduction investments, provides an empirical example of the practical valuable potential of moving away from climate isolationism [52].

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Renewables Solve Climate Inequality

A just transition away from fossil fuels is the key site for ending environmental injustice- the scale of change requires opens space for structural reforms

Saurabh Biswas et al in 2022

Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Authors and Affiliations Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Saurabh Biswas; School for the Future of Innovation in Society, Arizona State University, Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Ending the Energy-Poverty Nexus: An Ethical Imperative for Just Transitions; Science and Engineering Ethics volume 28, Article number: 36 (2022)

The current transformation of energy systems from carbon-based to carbon-neutral fuels and technologies offers a once-in-a-century opportunity to not simply redesign of socio-energy systems to address climate change but to also redesign them in ways that reconfigure the relationships between energy and poverty. At stake in clean energy transitions are the vast majority of the world’s energy resources, the supply chains and systems that transform those resources into usable energy, the industries and organizations that control energy resources and operate energy systems, and the use of that energy to power societies and economies worldwide. Worldwide, electric utilities and the oil, coal, and gas industries all face existential risks as several transitions unfold, and many parts of the global financial sector are confronting the consequences of massive intertwining of monetary and energy systems. Aspects of these systems and industries may well survive. However, as is illustrated by the above example of Puerto Rico’s bottom-up energy initiatives, renewable energy resources, technologies, and imaginaries also contain at least the potential to nucleate vastly different designs, organization, and governance of socio-energy systems. Solar energy, in particular, can be configured into radically different socio-technological forms, including, e.g., solar-powered devices, like lanterns, lights, and libraries (Linzy & Hosman, 2018); rooftop and solar home systems; community-scale solar; and utility-scale power plants. As such, it offers an especially fertile ground for rethinking the human relationship to energy (Miller et al., 2018). What would it take to leverage this opportunity to redesign socio-energy systems so that they are generative of more equitable conditions in terms of environmental sustainability, long-term economic thriving, and community health and self-determination, in order to interrupt and end the energy-poverty nexus? In our view, it will take new strategies for identifying, analyzing, and reversing the negative feedback loops that link energy insecurity with economic, social, human, and political insecurity and, instead, leveraging the design of energy systems to grow wellbeing and thriving for communities. Key to this are three innovations, each of which derives from the ideas discussed in this article. The first, which directly addresses the challenges of equity among the inhabitants of socio-energy systems, including but not limited to energy users, is to leverage a user-centered perspective on energy to ensure that the ability of people and communities to create value through engagements with energy systems is equitably distributed across all communities and, for all, outweighs the costs, burdens, and risks that energy systems impose. This is our definition of generative. The system is generative of benefits that outweigh costs, burdens, and risks. For all communities, in other words, energy systems should be generative of improved conditions over time, not extractive and destructive to community cohesion: net benefits should flow in rather than just out. The second, which addresses positionality amidst energy infrastructures, is to disperse energy ownership more equitably and much more broadly. Major aspects of the energy-poverty nexus flow from the concentration of ownership over resources, assets, systems, and opportunities and the resulting concentration of wealth and power. Key to this will be the future of ownership over the billions of solar panels required to power the global economy in a post-carbon future and the sunlight they capture. Solar panels are literally the next oil. But energy ownership will also be at stake in a wide array of other facets of the future of energy and transportation, as it has been historically in debates over, e.g., public versus private power and state versus private ownership of oil. Finally, the third innovation is to grow local capacity to engage in and ideally control energy governance. Understanding the full ramifications of energy development, with regard to both existing centralized, carbon-based energy systems and future alternatives, “requires ethnographic attention to the moral commitments, people, and practices that constitute and defend it” (Smith, 2014, p. 36), an exercise that is made significantly easier when people positioned within energy systems have greater power to effectively govern their own energy affairs. This may be the most difficult innovation of all, as it requires finding ways to balance local decision-making with the demands for high-levels energy security and/or to decentralize socio-energy systems to reduce the costs of systems failures (although decentralization, too, comes with its own challenges in terms of achieving universal energy rights and responsibilities, as existing electricity systems illustrate). There is a pressing and immediate need to rethink what our energy systems should be generating beyond accessibility and affordability. Our research demonstrates that the energy-poverty nexus poses deep challenges at the intersection of energy systems and community life. Only by unpacking how the energy-poverty nexus works in each community and designing alternative arrangements that are more generative of local value creation, ownership, and control can the energy-poverty nexus be ended. The specific dynamics of the energy-poverty nexus vary quite significantly from place to place, even as the general analysis holds that energy insecurities and economic insecurities tend to reinforce one another in strong feedback dynamics. Thus, while solutions must be tailored to the particular situations of any given community, the broad framework holds of redesigning energy systems so that they work to enhance human capabilities and empower value creation that outweighs their costs and risks. Energy production and access are often posited as a solution to poverty. Yet many of the consequences of energy system design and operation play a persistent role of in exacerbating and perpetuating poverty, both in a financial sense and, more broadly, in terms of human capabilities. As societies seek to transform energy systems to mitigate climate change, now is the time to focus on how to ensure that the energy systems of the latter half of the twenty-first century and beyond do not continue to replicate those same inequalities and injustices. A major accomplishment of a just transition to a new global energy future should be to design and implement carbon-neutral energy systems that also act to help the worst-off communities determine their own energy futures, alleviate poverty, and grow capabilities by disentangling and ending the energy-poverty nexus.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Ethical Obligation

We have an ethical obligation to address structural inequality in energy systems

Saurabh Biswas et al in 2022

Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Authors and Affiliations Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Saurabh Biswas; School for the Future of Innovation in Society, Arizona State University, Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Ending the Energy-Poverty Nexus: An Ethical Imperative for Just Transitions; Science and Engineering Ethics volume 28, Article number: 36 (2022)

Pulling these ideas together, we approach the energy-poverty nexus in terms of configurations of socio-energy systems that deepen, reinforce, and exacerbate a variety of factors that either reduce the income of communities, undermine their capabilities to improve their wellbeing and livelihoods, or both (Drehobl & Ross, 2016; Gómez-Barris, 2017; Moore, 2013). We term such configurations extractive. In pursuing a just transition, we believe that societies have an ethical obligation to redress the forms of injustice reflected in the energy-poverty nexus. At a minimum, the obligation is to design future socio-energy systems that no longer exacerbate poverty. Ideally, the obligation would be to design socio-energy systems that are generative: i.e., that support low-income communities over time in their quest to escape poverty and achieve higher quality of life. The latter is what we mean by the phrase to end the energy-poverty nexus. Many facets of socio-energy system design contribute to the energy-poverty nexus. Here we describe three major categories of design elements that work together to create and exacerbate negative feedbacks between energy insecurity and economic insecurity. In the first, equity among energy users, we examine the commitment of socio-energy systems to the principle of equity and the ways in which that commitment too often falls short, reinforcing inequalities and thus undermining the ability of low-income communities to use energy to alleviate or escape poverty. In the second, positionality within energy supply chains, we highlight the structural organization and design of energy systems and the ways in which that structural design distributes risks, harms, benefits, and opportunities within energy systems. Finally, in the third category, capacity in energy systems governance, we focus on the political design of energy systems and the ways in which governance institutions distribute capacity, empowerment, and self-determination.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Ethical Obligation

We have an ethical obligation to uphold climate justice; disproportionately affects already marginalized communities.

Madani ’21

(Professor Kaveh Madani is an environmental scientist, educator, and activist, working at the interface of science, policy, and society. He is the Director of the United Nations University Institute for Water, Environment and Health (UNU-INWEH), known as the UN Think Tank on Water. He has previously served as the Deputy Vice President of Iran in his position as the Deputy Head of Iran’s Department of Environment, the Vice President of the UN Environment Assembly Bureau, and the Chief of Iran’s Department of Environment’s International Affairs and Conventions Center. He is a Research Professor at the City University of New York’s Remote Sensing Earth Systems Institute (CUNY CREST). Professor Madani is known internationally for his work on integrating game theory into water resources management models as well as his role in raising public awareness about water and environmental problems in his home country, Iran. He joined the United Nations University in 2021 as the Head of the Nexus Research Programme at UNU-FLORES where he founded UNU's Resource Nexus AID (Analytics, Informatics and Data) Program.) https://www.carbonbrief.org/experts-why-does-climate-justice-matter/

Climate justice matters because the scope of the climate change problem is not only limited to nature. This problem has a human dimension and when humans are involved, justice matters. Obviously, we will not bear the climate change impacts fairly and equally. The marginalised, low income, Indigenous, minority and disadvantaged communities will be disproportionately impacted by global warming. They also have a much more limited capacity to mitigate climate change and cope with its consequences, compared to the wealthier groups. This means that climate change is going to increase the already significant inequalities around the world. The discussions about climate justice are mostly focused on the disproportionate human “impacts” of climate change. But we must also worry about important inequalities in the levels of contribution to the “causes” of climate change. Justice principles call for taking historical responsibility for causing the problem into account. The wealthy nations’ resource-exhaustive, un-green economies together with their unsustainable and consumptive lifestyles created this problem. They have the ethical responsibility as well as the required capacity to take immediate climate action and help the poor nations. The people of the global south deserve the same quality of life as the people in the global north, but this remains unachievable for them unless there is a transfer of knowledge, technology and wealth from the advanced economies. We must also care about the temporal and spatial dimensions of climate justice. Its temporal dimension necessitates paying attention to intergenerational climate justice and underlines the need for protecting the environmental rights of our children by taking climate action. The spatial dimension of climate justice reminds us about the heterogenous climate change impacts across space and geographic coordinates, calling for different levels of mitigation and adaptation efforts around the globe. We have “unequal” responsibilities and levels of access to the necessary resources to secure an “equal” world under climate change.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Ethical Obligation

Climate is an apriori ethical issue—evaluate the round through the lens of impacts on the global biosphere and an ethics of responsibility – any other ethical framework falls into anthropocentrism by denying subjectivity to nonhuman life and future generations

Farah and Giudice 23 (Paolo Davide Farah and Alessio Lo Giudice. “Climate Justice in the Anthropocene and Its Relationship with Science and Technology: The Importance of Ethics of Responsibility,” Connecticut Law Review. June 2023. https://scholarship.law.pitt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1567&context=fac_articles *edited for gendered language) @ehatt

WARNING: possibly a massive reproductive futurity link—be prepared to defend future generations lol

In Jonas’s reading, the Western ethical tradition, 173 founded on a synchronic and anthropocentric conception, appears inadequate to face the moral dilemmas produced by the technological civilization of the second modernity. It is precisely the technological focus of contemporary human beings that requires a change of perspective. First of all, this reversal of paradigm passes from a conception of duty no longer limited in an anthropocentric sense. Following Jonas’s lead, it is more than reasonable, in the context in which we live, to ask whether or not human beings have a duty to take care of the biosphere and protect biodiversity. The question of duty is one that is rationally based on the de facto domination, unprecedented compared to the past, of humans over the environment. But the recognition of the existence of a moral claim on the part of the biosphere does not presuppose a questionable representation of the anthropomorphization of the natural environment. In reality, it is equivalent to the adoption of a point of view placing, at the center, rational subjects as integral parts of the environment to be preserved. From a natural science and geographical perspective, nature and the environment are more rational than, or at least as rational as, human beings. Non-humans and humans have always had similar self-preservation instincts and a fundamental tendency to behave in a manner that avoids injury and maximizes chances of survival.174 As from the Anthropocene epoch, it seems that a fracture has happened. The majority of humans have gradually moved from the countryside and now live in modern and industrialized cities or locations far from nature.175 In most cases, they do not need to fight to provide food, water, and/or shelter to their families, and they do not have an immediate perception of how nature and biodiversity are more and more affected by industrialization, the related means of production, global commercialization, and their overgrowing needs connected to both consumerism and market demands. Consequently, because of their lack of awareness of the impending risk and their distance from nature, human beings did not immediately realize the need to reverse their actions, which are endangering the environment, because their self-preservation instinct was not triggered by the external factors that are more visible in nature. Nature follows rules that are certainly rational and include rational subjects in the paradigm, but with very different categories and perspectives than human equivalents. Anthropocentrism is a structural trait of ethical reasoning, despite Jonas’s claim to neutralize it. But it can take on a moderate connotation if the very concept of the environment is understood as the synthesis and coexistence of nature and culture, as a biosphere and biodiversity and human presence. On the other hand, the representation of the Anthropocene epoch surely leads to such a conception of the environment. If so, environmental rights176 lose any ideological characterization to assume a rational foundation from an ethical point of view. If this is the case, as Jonas maintains, “[i]t would mean to seek not only the human good but also the good of things extrahuman, that is, to extend the recognition of ‘ends in themselves’ beyond the sphere of [humans]man and make the human good include the care for them.” 177 The synchronic foundation of traditional ethics should, therefore, be questioned. The rights of future generations should coincide and be positively combined with environmental law in a diachronic and therefore trans-temporal perspective. Thus, a new moral imperative, adapted to such a change of perspective, would be: “Act so that the effects of your action are compatible with the permanence of genuine human life.” 178 This is an imperative based on the level of historical rationality, starting from the awareness of the potential of contemporary technology that is able to produce structurally and incessantly long-term effects. How technology is integrated into the biosphere will have consequences that affect the complex environment provided by humans. This new imperative is one that, on a strictly ethical level, is justified considering that, before respecting the freedom of others to do anything that does not violate freedom, we must allow those other people in a trans-temporal sense to exist as moral subjects. The principle of the responsibility of humans toward future generations, which bases the rights of each generation on the basis of the duties of the present generation, is philosophically justified by the first purpose of humanity, which is to continue to exist. This principle feeds on fear, in the sense of apprehension for the vulnerability of those who do not yet exist (on the model of the ethics of parental responsibility). This fear should lead to prudent public action to intervene, as a precaution, as enshrined, for example, in Principle 15 of the Rio Declaration, which states: “In order to protect the environment, the precautionary approach shall be widely applied by States according to their capabilities. Where there are threats of serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific certainty shall be not used as a reason for postponing cost-effective measures to prevent environmental degradation.”179 Principle 15 can be deduced from Jonas’s imperative, which is aimed mainly at public policy and not directly at the behavior of private individuals. Again, Jonas’s ethics of responsibility differs from Kant’s view. The coherence invoked by Jonas’s imperative and the principle of responsibility is, in fact, one that should be between the ultimate effects of our actions and the permanence of human activity in the future. For this reason, the causal order of reference is not provided by private behavior but by political choices of a collective nature. The universalization that this imperative implies is not hypothetical, as in the Kantian case of the logical projection of the subject with respect to the representation/imagination of all the others. Instead, it is a universalization that is measured on the basis of the practical success calculated over the time horizon of the future. Therefore, the ethics of responsibility feeds on the cognitive contribution provided by predictive science. It is on the basis of this contribution, in fact, that its success is measured. All this returns us to the background from which we started. It brings us to the framework of the global world and the awareness of the need to remedy the political failure of globalization. Jonas’s ethics of responsibility acquires, in fact, full meaning only in a global perspective and calls into question the establishment of effective political structures of governance of globalization capable of affecting an emblematically global phenomenon such as climate change.180 But the ethics of responsibility also makes it possible to pull the threads of reflection on the relationship between science, technology, and the Anthropocene. Responsibility toward future generations is justified because of technical domination, as the result of a self-perpetuating process, and the evidence of the Anthropocene as an environmental and anthropic result of this domain. In other words, the principle of responsibility is supported by the very fact of a technically manipulated environment that risks calling into question the conditions for the permanence of human life. At the same time, in light of the relationship between technology and the Anthropocene, it is clear that the ethics of responsibility represents a rational foundation for the conception of climate justice. If taken seriously, the environmental ethics here, sketched and reworked from a starting point of Jonas’s reflections, stands in contrast with the techno-economic model that dominated the second modernity. As Jonas wrote: The object’s self-owned futurity is the truest futural aspect of the responsibility, 181 which thus makes itself the guardian of the very source of that irksome unpredictability in the fruits of its labors. Its highest fulfillment, which it must be able to dare, is its abdication before the right of the never-anticipated which emerges as the outcome of its care. Its highest duty, therefore, is to see that responsibility itself is not stifled, whether from its source within or from constraints without. In the light of such self-transcending width, it becomes apparent that responsibility as such is nothing else but the moral complement to the ontological constitution of our temporality. 182 Unlike the perspective provided by ecological modernization, the ethics of responsibility makes it possible to theoretically institute collective choices that can lead to rethinking models of development, production processes, and lifestyles. Climate justice, as an aspiration not only for a fair distribution of the costs of climate change but also of political responsibilities, can bring about a reversal of the trend in public institutional choices. This reversal can occur only if it identifies, as the basis of its proposal, the protection of vulnerability183 understood in a radical sense by embodying within its theoretical framework future generations and their rights. From this perspective and focus, rationally based on the ethical and not the ideological level, it is factually consequential and politically sustainable to expand the protected subjects to include the most vulnerable groups in the present time. But to achieve this result, it is necessary that a global and universal projection of the aspirations of climate justice occurs. Further, this projection must coincide with the rights of the future generations and therefore of the preservation of a healthy environment in which they will live. There is no gap between present vulnerability and future vulnerability; they are two faces of the same coin. By protecting the latter, justice is done for the former in the name of the continuity of the species (and bearing in mind the hope of eternity and the wishes of infinity well above us), which allows us to belong to humanity beyond our historical time.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Ethical Obligation

Policymakers have an ethical obligation to frame climate policy to reduce inequality and focus on structural injustice

Saurabh Biswas et al in 2022

Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Authors and Affiliations Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Saurabh Biswas; School for the Future of Innovation in Society, Arizona State University, Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Ending the Energy-Poverty Nexus: An Ethical Imperative for Just Transitions; Science and Engineering Ethics volume 28, Article number: 36 (2022)

Arguments for a just transition are integral to debates about climate change and the drive to create a carbon-neutral future. Decarbonizing the energy sector involves disruptive changes to both energy technologies and broader societies and economies (Miller et al., 2013, 2015). In the past, energy transitions have wrought major shifts in industries, regulations, workforces, and markets (Jones, 2014), as well as the forms and geographies of resource extraction (Pasqualetti, 2011). As a result, profound ethical questions arise about the meaning and impact of energy transitions for diverse groups of people within and across societies (Jasanoff, 2011, 2018; Miller, 2014; Sovacool et al., 2017). Proponents of a just transition insist, therefore, that the design and navigation of future energy transitions acknowledge and mitigate the resulting disruptions in people’s lives, livelihoods, health, and environments. As the Just Transition Alliance (2020) put it, for example: “Just Transition” is a principle, a process and a practice. The principle of just transition is that a healthy economy and a clean environment can and should co-exist. The process for achieving this vision should be a fair one that should not cost workers or community residents their health, environment, jobs, or economic assets. Any losses should be fairly compensated. And the practice of just transition means that the people who are most affected by pollution—the frontline workers and the fenceline communities—should be in the leadership of crafting policy solutions. This definition encompasses both an ethical and a justice-oriented stance. Energy ethics and justice are overlapping fields. Both raise questions about the normative dimensions of energy transitions. Energy ethics is concerned with the social principles, values, and norms that govern energy transitions. Energy justice uses distributive, recognition, and procedural frameworks familiar from environmental justice movements to interrogate and challenge patterns of inequitable distributions of benefits and burdens in an energy transition, focusing especially on historically marginalized populations and communities (Bethem et al., 2020; Bickerstaff, 2017; Biswas et al., 2021; Heffron & McCauley, 2017; Jenkins et al., 2018; McCauley et al., 2019; Jetten et al., 2020; Sovacool & Dworkin, 2015). Questions of distributive justice interrogate how the benefits and burdens of energy systems and transitions are distributed across groups. Recognition justice “refers to the acknowledgement of, and respect for, the complex circumstances and vulnerabilities of individuals and social groups in patterns of cultural value” (Lewis et al., 2020, p 425–426). Procedural and participatory justice focus on how decisions get made, the differential abilities of and opportunities for groups to contribute to and shape decision-making, and the institutional barriers that limit or constrain their participation. Two broad approaches rooted in ethics and justice currently frame discussions of just energy transitions, and are present in the Just Transition Alliance quote above. The first can be described as internal to the transition and emphasizes the anticipation, assessment, and redressing of harms created by the transition itself and the inclusion in transition governance of groups or communities potentially harmed by its disruptions. This approach tends to focus on current coal, oil, or gas workers whose employment is threatened (Pai et al., 2020; Pai & Carr-Wilson, 2018, 2019); communities that may lose tax revenues or businesses due to the decline of these industries or confront environmental risks from legacy infrastructures stranded by the transition (Roemer & Haggerty, 2021); or communities confronting challenges due to the siting of new energy infrastructures, such as lithium mines, solar and wind farms, or natural gas wells (Barandiaran, 2015; Kinchy, 2017; Mulvaney, 2019). In this paper, we focus on a second approach to ethics and justice in energy transitions, which is systemic or societal in scope. This approach complements attention to the proximate dynamics and impacts of the transition itself with a focus on the distant societal and economic outcomes the transition brings into being and how they compare to conditions prior to the transition. It poses the question: do the transformative social, economic, and technological changes wrought by energy transitions create more just societies and economies, or do they instead reinforce or recreate long-standing injustices and inequalities? The present reality is that carbon-based energy systems systematically help create and foster a wide range of structural inequalities and injustices across markets and societies (Sovacool, 2016). We propose, therefore, that those leading energy transitions have an ethical obligation to redress these existing inequalities and injustices, in addition to proactively addressing any potential additional harms created by the transition process, thus contributing to more just, equitable, and fair societies and markets. This can be accomplished by using ethical and justice principles and practices to inform the (re)design of energy systems and the work of carrying out energy transitions by institutions in the energy sector and with regulatory or governance authority over energy, as well as by civil society organizations and communities working with them. Ultimately, we argue, just transitions to carbon-neutral energy systems should promote the creation of alternative socio-energy arrangements that intentionally create and improve positive social, political, economic and environmental conditions and outcomes for the world’s lowest income and least well-off communities, rather than continue to diminish them.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Inequality- War

Growing economic inequality drives diversionary nationalism and makes war inevitable.

Frederick Solt 11. Ph.D. in Political Science from University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, currently Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Iowa, Assistant Professor, Departments of Political Science and Sociology, Southern Illinois at the time of publication. “Diversionary Nationalism: Economic Inequality and the Formation of National Pride.” The Journal of Politics, Vol. 73, No. 3, pgs. 821-830, July 2011.

One of the oldest theories of nationalism is that states instill the nationalist myth in their citizens to divert their attention from great economic inequality and so forestall pervasive unrest. Because the very concept of nationalism obscures the extent of inequality and is a potent tool for delegitimizing calls for redistribution, it is a perfect diversion, and states should be expected to engage in more nationalist mythmaking when inequality increases. The evidence presented by this study supports this theory: across the countries and over time, where economic inequality is greater, nationalist sentiments are substantially more widespread. This result adds considerably to our understanding of nationalism. To date, many scholars have focused on the international environment as the principal source of threats that prompt states to generate nationalism; the importance of the domestic threat posed by economic inequality has been largely overlooked. However, at least in recent years, domestic inequality is a far more important stimulus for the generation of nationalist sentiments than the international context. Given that nuclear weapons—either their own or their allies’—rather than the mass army now serve as the primary defense of many countries against being overrun by their enemies, perhaps this is not surprising: nationalism-inspired mass mobilization is simply no longer as necessary for protection as it once was (see Mearsheimer 1990, 21; Posen 1993, 122–24). Another important implication of the analyses presented above is that growing economic inequality may increase ethnic conflict. States may foment national pride to stem discontent with increasing inequality, but this pride can also lead to more hostility towards immigrants and minorities. Though pride in the nation is distinct from chauvinism and outgroup hostility, it is nevertheless closely related to these phenomena, and recent experimental research has shown that members of majority groups who express high levels of national pride can be nudged into intolerant and xenophobic responses quite easily (Li and Brewer 2004). This finding suggests that, by leading to the creation of more national pride, higher levels of inequality produce environments favorable to those who would inflame ethnic animosities. Another and perhaps even more worrisome implication regards the likelihood of war. Nationalism is frequently suggested as a cause of war, and more national pride has been found to result in a much greater demand for national security even at the expense of civil liberties (Davis and Silver 2004, 36–37) as well as preferences for “a more militaristic foreign affairs posture and a more interventionist role in world politics” (Conover and Feldman 1987, 3). To the extent that these preferences influence policymaking, the growth in economic inequality over the last quarter century should be expected to lead to more aggressive foreign policies and more international conflict. If economic inequality prompts states to generate diversionary nationalism as the results presented above suggest, then rising inequality could make for a more dangerous world. The results of this work also contribute to our still limited knowledge of the relationship between economic inequality and democratic politics. In particular, it helps explain the fact that, contrary to median-voter models of redistribution (e.g., Meltzer and Richard 1981), democracies with higher levels of inequality do not consistently respond with more redistribution (e.g., Bénabou 1996). Rather than allowing redistribution to be decided through the democratic process suggested by such models, this work suggests that states often respond to higher levels of inequality with more nationalism. Nationalism then works to divert attention from inequality, so many citizens neither realize the extent of inequality nor demand redistributive policies. By prompting states to promote nationalism, greater economic inequality removes the issue of redistribution from debate and therefore narrows the scope of democratic politics.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Inequality- Slow Growth

Slow growth goes nuclear – breaks down global cooperation

Landay 17 (Jonathan – Reuters National Security Correspondent, 1/9/17, “U.S. intelligence study warns of growing conflict risk”, )

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The risk of conflicts between and within nations will increase over the next five years to levels not seen since the Cold War as global growth slows, the post-World War Two order erodes and anti-globalization fuels nationalism, said a U.S. intelligence report released on Monday. “These trends will converge at an unprecedented pace to make governing and cooperation harder and to change the nature of power – fundamentally altering the global landscape,” said “Global Trends: Paradox of Progress,” the sixth in a series of quadrennial studies by the U.S. National Intelligence Council. The findings, published less than two weeks before U.S. President-elect Donald Trump takes office on Jan. 20, outlined factors shaping a “dark and difficult near future,” including a more assertive Russia and China, regional conflicts, terrorism, rising income inequality, climate change and sluggish economic growth. Global Trends reports deliberately avoid analyzing U.S. policies or choices, but the latest study underscored the complex difficulties Trump must address in order to fulfill his vows to improve relations with Russia, level the economic playing field with China, return jobs to the United States and defeat terrorism. The National Intelligence Council comprises the senior U.S. regional and subject-matter intelligence analysts. It oversees the drafting of National Intelligence Estimates, which often synthesize work by all 17 intelligence agencies and are the most comprehensive analytic products of U.S intelligence. The study, which included interviews with academic experts as well as financial and political leaders worldwide, examined political, social, economic and technological trends that the authors project will shape the world from the present to 2035, and their potential impact. ‘INWARD-LOOKING WEST’ It said the threat of terrorism would grow in coming decades as small groups and individuals harnessed “new technologies, ideas and relationships.” Uncertainty about the United States, coupled with an “inward-looking West” and the weakening of international human rights and conflict prevention standards, will encourage China and Russia to challenge American influence, the study added. Those challenges “will stay below the threshold of hot war but bring profound risks of miscalculation,” the study warned. “Overconfidence that material strength can manage escalation will increase the risks of interstate conflict to levels not seen since the Cold War.” While “hot war” may be avoided, differences in values and interests among states and drives for regional dominance “are leading to a spheres of influence world,” it said, The latest Global Trends, the subject of a Washington conference, added that the situation also offered opportunities to governments, societies, groups and individuals to make choices that could bring “more hopeful, secure futures.” “As the paradox of progress implies, the same trends generating near-term risks also can create opportunities for better outcomes over the long term,” the study said. THE HOME FRONT The report also said that while globalization and technological advances had “enriched the richest” and raised billions from poverty, they had also “hollowed out” Western middle classes and ignited backlashes against globalization. Those trends have been compounded by the largest migrant flows in seven decades, which are stoking “nativist, anti-elite impulses.” “Slow growth plus technology-induced disruptions in job markets will threaten poverty reduction and drive tensions within countries in the years to come, fueling the very nationalism that contributes to tension between counties,” it said. The trends shaping the future include contractions in the working-age populations of wealthy countries and expansions in the same group in poorer nations, especially in Africa and South Asia, increasing economic, employment, urbanization and welfare pressures, the study said. The world will also continue to experience weak near-term growth as governments, institutions and businesses struggle to overcome fallout from the Great Recession, the study said. “Major economies will confront shrinking workforces and diminishing productivity gains while recovering from the 2008-09 financial crisis with high debt, weak demand, and doubts about globalization,” said the study. “China will attempt to shift to a consumer-driven economy from its longstanding export and investment focus. Lower growth will threaten poverty reduction in developing counties.” Governance will become more difficult as issues, including global climate change, environmental degradation and health threats demand collective action, the study added, while such cooperation becomes harder.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Inequality- Slow Growth

Inequality hollows out economics resilience and locks in slow growth---shocks are inevitable, only worker stability makes recovery possible.

Kate Bahn 21. Washington Center for Equitable Growth Testimony before the Joint Economic Committee, "Kate Bahn testimony before the Joint Economic Committee on monopsony, workers, and corporate power". Equitable Growth. 7-14-2021. https://equitablegrowth.org/kate-bahn-testimony-before-the-joint-economic-committee-on-monopsony-workers-and-corporate-power/

Thank you Chair Beyer, Ranking Member Lee, and members of the Joint Economic Committee for inviting me to testify today. My name is Kate Bahn and I am the Director of Labor Market Policy and the interim Chief Economist at the Washington Center for Equitable Growth. We seek to advance evidence-backed ideas and policies that promote strong, stable and broad-based growth. Core to this mission is understanding the ways in which inequality has distorted, subverted and obstructed economic growth in recent decades. Mounting evidence, which I will review today, demonstrates how the rising concentration of corporate power has increased economic inequality and made the U.S. economy less efficient. Reversing the trends that have led to a “second gilded age” is critical to encouraging a resilient economic recovery following the pandemic-induced economic crisis of 2020 and encouraging a healthy, competitive economy for the future. Introduction The United States boasts one of the wealthiest economies in the world, but decades of increasing income inequality, job polarization, and stagnant wages for most Americans has plagued our labor market and demonstrated that a rising tide does not lift all boats. Furthermore, economic evidence demonstrates how inequality results in an inefficient allocation of talent and resources while increasing corporate concentration that enriches the few while holding back the entire economy from its potential. Understanding the causes and consequences of the concentration of corporate power will guide policymaking in order to ensure that the economic recovery in the next phase of the pandemic will be broadly shared and ensure a more resilient economy. “Monopsony” is a key economic concept to understand in this discussion. Monopsony is the labor market equivalent of the better-known phenomenon of “monopoly,” but instead of having only one producer of a good or service, there is effectively only one buyer of a good or service, such as only one employer hiring people’s labor in a company town. Like in monopoly, this phenomenon is not limited to when a firm is strictly the only buyer of labor. Today I will explain the circumstances and effects of employers having significant monopsony power over the market and over workers. When employers have outsized power in employment relationships, they are able to set wages for their workers, rather than wages being determined by competitive market forces. Given this monopsony power, employers undercut workers. This means paying them less than the value they contribute to production. One recent survey of all the economic research on monopsony finds that, on average across studies, employers have the power to keep wages over one-third less than they would be in a perfectly competitive market. Put another way, in a theoretical competitive market, if an employer cut wages then all workers would quit. But in reality, these estimates are the equivalent of a firm cutting wages by 5 percent yet only losing 10 percent to 20 percent of their workers, thus growing their profits without significantly impacting their business. It is not only important for workers to earn a fair share so they can support themselves and their families, but also critical to ensure that our economy rebuilds to be stronger and more resilient. Prior to the current public health crisis and resulting recession, earnings inequality had been growing since at least the 1980s while the labor share of national income has been declining in same period. This is cause for concern as recent evidence suggests that the labor share of income has a positive impact on GDP growth in the long-run. The unprecedented economic shock caused by the coronavirus pandemic revealed how economic inequality leads to a fragile economy, where those with the least are hit the hardest, amplifying recessions since lower-income workers typically spend more of their income in the economy. But the crisis also demonstrated how economic policy targeted toward workers and families can provide a foundation for growth. This is because workers are the economy, and pushing back against the concentration corporate power by providing resources to workers is the foundation for strong, stable and broadly shared growth. The Causes of Monopsony The concept of monopsony was initially developed by the early 20th century economist Joan Robinson, who examined how lack of competition led to unfair and inefficient economic outcomes. The prototypical example of monopsony is a company town, where there is one very dominant employer and workers have no choice but to accept low wages since they have no outside options. This is the most extreme case, but it is important to note that firms have monopsony power in any circumstance where workers aren’t moving between jobs seamlessly in search of the highest wages they can get. Firms can use monopsony power to lower workers’ wages any time workers: Have few potential employers Face job mobility constraints Can only gather imperfect information about employers and jobs Have divergent preferences for job attributes Lack the ability to bargain over those offers I will go through each of these factors in turn and demonstrate how labor markets are unique compared to other markets in dealing with competitive forces. While concentrated labor markets are not the norm, they are pervasive across the United States, especially within certain sectors or locations. When markets are very concentrated, employers can give workers smaller yearly raises or make working conditions worse, knowing that their workers have nowhere to go to find a better job with better pay. (See Figure 1.) A study published in the journal Labour Economics by economists Jose Azar, Ioana Marinescu, and Marshall Steinbaum finds that 60 percent of U.S. local labor markets are highly concentrated as defined by U.S. antitrust authorities’ 2010 horizontal merger guidelines. This accounts for 20 percent of employment in the United States. Research by economists Gregor Schubert, Anna Stansbury, and Bledi Tsaka goes further by estimating workers’ outside options, or the likelihood a worker is able to change into a different occupation or industry. This study finds that even with a more expansive definition of job opportunities more than 10 percent of the U.S. workforce is in local labor markets where pay is being suppressed by employer concentration by at least 2 percent, and a significant proportion of these workers facing few outside options are facing pay suppression of 5 percent or more. As study co-author Anna Stansbury noted, “for a typical full-time workers making $50,000 a year, a 2 percent pay reduction is equivalent to losing $1,000 per year and a 5 percent pay reduction is equivalent to losing $2,500 per year.” Certain sectors are now very concentrated, such as the healthcare industry. In a paper by the economists Elena Prager and Matt Schmitt, they find that hospital mergers led to negative wage growth among skilled workers such as nurses or pharmacy workers. Consolidation and outsized employer power, alongside other phenomenon such as the fissuring of the workplace, may have broader impacts on the structure of the U.S. labor market when it affects the overall structure of the labor market, including the hollowing out of middle class jobs that have historically been a pathway for upward mobility.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › !- Inequality OW/RC

Inequality outweighs war and is the root cause of negative disads

Lee, MD/MDV Yale, 16

(Bandy X, Medicine&Law@Yale, Causes and cures VII: Structural violence Aggression and Violent Behavior Volume 28, May–June 2016, Pages 109-114)

Behavioral violence, in measurements by the tolls of street violence or war, is more noticeable, even though the “tranquil” waters of structural violence may contain much more violence. American violence scholar James Gilligan (1999) compared structural violence to the most deadly military conflicts: estimating 49 million military and civilian deaths from World War II, or about 8 million per year from 1939 to 1945, or even a hypothetical nuclear exchange between the United States and the former Soviet Union at 232 million, could not even begin to compare with structural violence, which continues year after year, during times of peace as well as of war. In other words, every fifteen years, on average, as many people die because of relative poverty as would in a nuclear war that caused 232 million deaths. This is, in effect, the equivalent of an ongoing, unending, in fact accelerating thermonuclear war or genocide, perpetrated on the weak and poor every year of every decade, throughout the world. He also described structural violence as increased rates of disabilities and deaths among the people who occupy the bottom class. He noted that the suffering of people from lower classes are the product of people above who have collective bargaining power making choices that determine the allocation of resources. Unlike behavioral violence, its lethal effects operate continuously rather than sporadically; it can occur independently of any intention to kill anyone (for example, it can be a byproduct of wishing to maximize one's wealth and power); and it is usually invisible, in the sense that deaths from structural violence may appear to have other causes, natural or violent. More recent figures bear out these conclusions even more startlingly, as we will see in the next section. Gilligan (2001) also articulated how, through the mechanisms of shame, humiliation, and inferiority, the disparities in classes are the most potent cause of behavioral violence, such as suicide, homicide, warfare, or capital punishment (Bloom, 2001). American anthropologist Paul Farmer (2003) also developed the concept of structural violence by first defining structure as a pattern of collective social actions within institutional practices, law, economic policies, and other habitual elements. These structures can materially manifest through facilities such as roads, server systems, hospitals, and schools. He described violence as suffering resulting from social arrangements that put individuals in harm's way. Since the exertion of structural violence is systematic—that is, indirect—by everyone who belongs to a certain social order, no one is at fault, at the same time as everyone of that order is at fault. Cumulative historical forces and processes work together to constrain individual agency inversely, if not always neatly, with the ability to resist marginalization and oppression, and deny them the benefits of social progress.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Holistic Approach Needed

Only a holistic approach that centers climate justice can make the systemic changes needed to solve

Jennie C. Stephens in 2022

School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);

To advance climate justice, humanity must move beyond climate isolationism and leverage the interconnectedness of the climate crisis with other social injustices for transformation. The broader social changes that are needed require massive public investments in social innovation centered on social justice to complement continued investment in technological innovation. Climate scholars and activists need to expand their focus beyond decarbonization and greenhouse gas emission reductions and link all efforts with the social, economic, financial, and political change required to end fossil fuel reliance and disrupt and redistribute the power of corporate interests. Transformation requires persistent, consistent focus on four things: (1) explicitly revealing problematic power structures that are perpetuated by status quo policies, practices, and priorities at multiple scales; (2) resisting fossil fuel interests and the perpetuation of fossil fuel reliance at every opportunity; (3) prioritizing and centering social justice, economic justice, and the redistribution of political power to enable massive public investments in people and communities; and (4) linking climate and energy policy directly to all other policies including housing policy, transportation policy, economic policy, fiscal policy, health policy, food policy, education policy, and criminal justice reform. Taking back power from corporate interests, billionaires and other polluter elites require coordinated, collective action occurring at every scale—from the local to the global. Now that we are in an era where “all politics is climate politics” [4], new forms of interconnected and holistic public investments are essential to reduce the current and future suffering around the world.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Technocratic Approach Bad

Framing in terms of systemic change is key- technocratic solutions lead to incremental reforms that fail to address social inequality

Jennie C. Stephens in 2022

School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);

As the climate crisis worsens and continues to reveal stark injustices and inhumane inequities in society, the evidence suggests that our decision-making and policy processes have resulted in ineffective and inadequate responses in both climate mitigation [73] and climate adaptation [39]. The systemic, transformative changes that are needed to end fossil fuel reliance and to invest in supporting the most vulnerable people and communities have not yet been prioritized. A key contributor to the insufficient actions taken so far toward a more just and sustainable future is the fact that climate decision-making has been all-too-often constrained within a narrow technocratic lens which I call “climate isolationism” [63, 64]. I have coined this term to characterize the common framing of climate change as an isolated, discrete, scientific problem in need of technological solutions. Decision-makers working within a lens of climate isolationism often focus in a quantitative way on carbon reductions, greenhouse gas emissions, and temperature changes while inadvertently ignoring the societal complexities and social injustices associated with these quantitative measures [30]. This narrow technocratic lens is prevalent in decision-making around both climate mitigation and climate adaptation. When climate isolationism is applied to climate mitigation, decarbonization is usually the goal [26], carbon accounting is the primary metric, and incentives and costs of a variety of different mitigating technologies are often projected and compared [5]. When climate isolationism is applied to climate adaptation, a disproportionate focus on investing in technical infrastructure (i.e., sea walls and drought-resistant crops) often detracts attention and investment from social innovation and social changes that could enhance climate resilience [59]. This paper reviews the inadequacy and dangers of climate isolationism, explores why climate justice provides an alternative more effective framing, and calls for more intentional consideration of power and power dynamics in climate decision-making to shift from climate isolationism to climate justice. This review is based on a US-based perspective with potential for global application.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Technocratic Approach Bad

The technocratic framing of climate perpetuates inequality by excluding marginalized communities and limiting technological solutions that fail to change social structures

Jennie C. Stephens in 2022

School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);

Climate isolationism is dangerous because it is exclusive and ineffective in advancing the transformative social change that is needed to reduce the suffering of climate change. A review of the literature on public perception of low carbon technologies reveals that the narrowness of climate isolationism results in limited opportunities for people to connect and that interest and awareness about these technologies are constrained [55]. The technocratic focus limits public discourse because it excludes people for whom these abstract, scientific terms, or the technological details may not be meaningful and it makes the challenge seem distant and unapproachable [63]. Not only does the very technical way of discussing climate change resonate with only a small subgroup of society, it also often projects the need for sacrifice and hardship rather than highlighting benefits and opportunities [54]. Climate isolationism is also exclusive because many proposed technological “solutions” are also expensive and perceived as options that are only accessible to the rich. Driving a Tesla electric vehicle, for example, is not an option for most people, so the focus on this technological innovation results in many people feeling disempowered and disengaged [68]. This disempowerment is compounded by science and engineering fields that continue to be dominated by white men [78]. Despite efforts to diversify science and engineering, persistent racial, gendered, and economic injustices of our economy and our educational systems perpetuate exclusive access to science and engineering [74]. Participating in science continues to be a selective activity only accessible to a privileged few [40]. The lack of diversity within the fields of science and engineering limits the scope of inquiry and constrains the types of connections that are made among science, technology, and society [63]. As we move to incorporate innovative responses that promote social justice to climate change beyond technological justifications for energy transformation, there is a need to include other kinds of expertise, experiences, and perspectives. When the climate crisis is framed as a scientific problem with a possible technological fix, the systemic societal and economic problems, including the concentration of wealth and power among those profiting from maintaining fossil fuel reliance, are all-too-often ignored [63]. The prevalence of climate isolationism has encouraged too many leaders to be blind to the important opportunities for improving people’s lives and strengthening communities as we transition away from a society reliant on fossil fuels [62]. The narrow technocratic approach of climate isolationism has not only been ineffective in mobilizing transformative change but it has also resulted in climate and energy programs and policies that exacerbate inequities and perpetuate injustice [32]. Because the social dimensions of climate and energy have not been adequately considered, we have ended up with policies that further exclude and disadvantage low-income communities, women, and communities of color [57]. The quantitative technocratic tendency of climate isolationism reinforces a dubious technological optimism [9], which has led to growing interest and funding for technological fixes to the climate crisis [67]. While technology is an essential part of a transition toward a more just, equitable, and climate-stable future, investments in science and technology have not yet been balanced with investments in social science, social infrastructure, social innovations, and social justice. This lack of investment in social infrastructure and social innovations has weakened our social ties and reduced our societal resilience [2]. For decades, strategic governmental responses to the climate crisis have been focused almost exclusively on investments in science and technology [61], while very little has been invested in social innovation. Some examples of social innovations include cooperative ownership of businesses, non-extractive finance like zero-interest, negative interest, or low-interest loans, and community-based initiatives to support the provisioning of local and regionally appropriate energy, food, and other essentials.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Climate Exacerbates inequality

Warming exacerbates inequality.

Guivarch et al. ‘21 [CÉLine is a researcher at the Centre International de Recherche sur l’Environnement et le Développement in Nogent-sur-Marne, France. NICOLAS TACONET is a researcher at the Centre International de Recherche sur l’Environnement et le Développement in Nogent-sur-Marne, France. AURÉLIE MÉJEAN is a researcher at the Centre International de Recherche sur l’Environnement et le Développement in Nogent-sur-Marne, France. “Linking Climate and Inequality;” 9-2-2021, IMF, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2021/09/climate-change-and-inequality-guivarch-mejean-taconet; JFan]

While the effects of climate change are global, and their projected impacts concern every area in the world, a wide scientific literature suggests that climate risks disproportionately affect the poorest countries and people, who are more exposed and more vulnerable to their impacts.

In the poorest economies, a large part of the population depends directly on activities that may be the most affected by climate change, notably, the agricultural, forestry, and fisheries sectors. People with the lowest incomes are the most likely to depend for their survival on resources provided by nature. Rising temperatures are exacerbating preexisting disparities in access to clean water and affordable food. Most of the time, the poorest populations do not benefit from insurance mechanisms or have access to basic health services, making them particularly vulnerable to any shock hitting their assets and income streams.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Inequality/Climate Justice › Inequality rising now

Wealth Inequality Rising Now

Rick Baum ’23 -- teaches Political Science at City College of San Francisco. He is a member of AFT 2121.

"The U.S. has Made Great Progress at Increasing Economic Inequality," CounterPunch.org, https://www.counterpunch.org/2023/06/09/the-u-s-has-made-great-progress-at-increasing-economic-inequality/

One of the more impressive accomplishments of the United States in recent decades is how it has achieved greater economic inequality in line with what Marx expected from a capitalist economy. There are periods of setbacks—in which economic inequality is reduced–followed by improvements resulting in even higher levels of inequality. Advancing economic inequality has been a bipartisan undertaking. The actions of both the Democrats and Republicans in power have increased economic inequality as their leaders, together, champion the interests of the rich and powerful at the expense of the middle and working classes. Additionally, despite the growth in the diversity of the ruling class, economic inequality has continued to widen. Examples of progress towards greater economic inequality that results in unmet needs and misery for many is made apparent in media stories such as a recent one in the Guardian with “I can’t afford groceries’: why one-third of US college students don’t have enough to eat.” Wealth Inequality Wealth is the value of what one owns minus one’s debts. Many people owe more than all of what they own is worth. They have negative wealth. Then there are those at the top who have played a major role in our country’s success at achieving such high levels of economic inequality. They include our “generous” good friends, the “job creators,” Musk, Bezos and Gates, the wealth of each is more than $100 billion. The Federal Reserve Board, the banker’s bank, has been providing on the distribution of wealth in the U.S. going back to 1989. The share of the nation’s wealth held by the wealthiest has grown tremendously. In 1989, the wealthiest one-tenth of one percent held 8.7% of the nation’s wealth rising to 12.6% as of the end of 2022. The Fed’s data show that in 1989, the wealth of the .1% was 2.26 times greater than the poorest 50%. At the end of 2022, the value of their holdings, $17.6 trillion, was more than four times greater than the wealth, $4.16 trillion, of the poorest 50% of the U.S. population. The table below, using the Fed figures from 1989 to 2022, shows the growth in wealth inequality. Highlighted are the highest percent of the holding of the entire nation’s wealth by the wealthiest 1% reached during the terms of presidents in a particular quarter going back to Bush, and the first quarter of the survey. [table omitted] During each administration since 1989, the share of the nation’s wealth held by the wealthiest 1% has had its declines, but the trajectory has been up. It reached a new record during the presidencies of everyone except Trump, who came close and whose tax cut bill helped pave the way for a new record. To restore the share of the wealth of the wealthiest 1% back to where it stood in 1989 would require the immediate confiscation of over $12 trillion of their $43.45 trillion as of the end of 2022. Senator Elizabeth Warren, probably considered one of the more “progressive” members of the Senate, has put forward a that would raise “$3.75 trillion in revenue over a ten-year period.” In the last ten years, the nominal wealth of the 1% increased over $23 trillion from $19.81 trillion to $43.45 trillion, more than six times the anticipated revenue raised by Warren’s tax proposal which, at best, would likely make a tiny dent into what she describes as “an extreme concentration of wealth.”

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Climate › At: Budget

Past mobilization proves the GND is feasible/within our grasp

Johnson 19

(Brad, Climate activist/author, , 3-3)

To match a WWII-level mobilization today, US federal spending would reach somewhere between $30 trillion to $80 trillion a year. The nation’s mobilization for World War II saw federal spending grow from 10 percent of GDP (which represented a doubling from pre-Great Depression spending) to over 40 percent by 1945, vastly higher than federal outlays since. Source: FRED Economic Data, Federal Spending as Percent of GDP. One of the most common attacks against any kind of federal investment in the health of its citizenry is the specter of “soaring deficits.” Again, if we look to the highly successful example of the New Deal and World War II, we can see that we have little to worry about. (There’s also the point that budgetary deficits are meaningless when the alternative to spending is extinction.) The federal deficit reached 25 percent of GDP at the peak of the WWII-spending boom, vastly higher than today’s deficits. Source: FRED Economic Data, Federal Surplus as Percent of GDP. Note: As total US GDP grew dramatically thanks to the war mobilization, US federal spending increased not four-fold from 1940 to 1945 but seven-fold. The spending ramp-up from the start of the Great Depression to the peak of WWII mobilization is much more dramatic — a twenty-fold increase. That previously unprecedented spending is better understood as investment — the US economy tripled in size from 1929 to 1959. As economic analyst Kimberly Amadeo summarizes, “the New Deal worked.” Remarkably, the US’ historically high percentage of federal spending during World War II would put it at the low end of present-day spending in Europe: Source: OECD Data, general government spending. Following World War II, federal government spending has remained stable at about 20 percent of GDP. (The 2009 stimulus very briefly increased spending to 25 percent of GDP.) The US federal budget is currently about $4 trillion a year. If the federal government increased investment by seven to twenty times — paralleling the ramp-up that got the world out of the Great Depression, beat the Nazis, and made the United States the undisputed superpower of the free world — we would see an annual federal budget of about $30 trillion to $80 trillion a year. We can end global warming pollution and build a just, green economy in ten years with a budget of $50 trillion a year.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
Case Extensions › Climate › At Climate Change Inevitable

Even if climate change is inevitable, carbon reductions can limit the scope and rate avoiding the most severe impacts

Science Daily 9-25-19 https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/09/190925100415.htm

A study estimates global-scale, multi-sectoral economic impacts of climate change, and suggests that a plausible range of decisions and actions by humans can determine the scale of the economic impacts, even if the uncertainty in the climate response to increased greenhouse gas concentration is considered. These actions include reductions of greenhouse gas emissions and improvement of socioeconomic conditions. This study highlights the importance of societal changes and the current generation's responsibility for the future. People are less motivated to take actions if its outcome is uncertain, and this could be true for climate-related issues. The uncertainty in climate response to the increase in greenhouse gas concentration, which is often believed to be substantially large, makes it difficult to believe the benefit of reducing emissions or the effectiveness of making society more resilient to climate-related hazards. This could be one of the reasons for inaction even though urgent action is called for. A new study published in Nature Climate Change, conducted by a Japanese research team (consisting of researchers at Ibaraki University, Kyoto University, National Agriculture and Food Research Organization, National Institute for Environmental Studies, Ritsumeikan University, Shibaura Institute of Technology, The University of Tokyo, and University of Tsukuba), might change such views. The study estimates economic impacts of climate change and suggests that humankind's decisions and actions can overwhelm the uncertainty in climate response in terms of reducing the impact of climate change. Estimation of the economic impacts of climate change is itself extremely challenging because it can affect society in many ways. Collaboration between researchers in a diverse range of fields enabled the research team to conduct a global-scale assessment covering the economic impacts associated with climate change for nine impact sectors: the economic impacts arising from changes in agricultural productivity, undernourishment, heat-related excess mortality, cooling/heating demand, occupational health costs, capacity of hydroelectric power generation, capacity of thermal power generation, fluvial flooding, and coastal inundation. Describing the novelty and significance of the study, Dr. Hijioka, the research managing director of Center for Climate Change Adaptation, National Institute for Environmental Studies states, "This is very special research, with no equivalent in the world." The estimated value of the aggregated economic impacts had a large divergence depending on three assumptions: socioeconomic conditions, amount of greenhouse gas emissions, and climate responses to the increased greenhouse gas concentration. Under the most pessimistic combination of assumptions, the estimated economic impact will be equivalent to 8.6% of the global total GDP at the end of the 21st century, while it will be limited to around or less than 1% if the 2-degree target, which was adopted in the Paris Agreement, is achieved and societal resilience to climate-related hazards improves. More importantly, the results also indicated that the contribution of the uncertainty in the climate response to the divergence -- or variance -- of the estimates was minor compared to the contribution of the differences in the anthropogenically directed societal pathways (i.e., greenhouse gas emissions and socioeconomic developments). "This means that humankind has the potential to determine the scale of the economic impacts of climate change," explains Dr. Takakura, a researcher at National Institute for Environmental Studies.