2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › No Econ !
Stephen Walt 20. Robert and Renée Belfer professor of international relations at Harvard University. “Will a Global Depression Trigger Another World War?”, May 13th,
On balance, however, I do not think that even the extraordinary economic conditions we are witnessing today are going to have much impact on the likelihood of war. Why? First of all, if depressions were a powerful cause of war, there would be a lot more of the latter. To take one example, the United States has suffered 40 or more recessions since the country was founded, yet it has fought perhaps 20 interstate wars, most of them unrelated to the state of the economy. To paraphrase the economist Paul Samuelson’s famous quip about the stock market, if recessions were a powerful cause of war, they would have predicted “nine out of the last five (or fewer).”
Second, states do not start wars unless they believe they will win a quick and relatively cheap victory. As John Mearsheimer showed in his classic book Conventional Deterrence, national leaders avoid war when they are convinced it will be long, bloody, costly, and uncertain. To choose war, political leaders have to convince themselves they can either win a quick, cheap, and decisive victory or achieve some limited objective at low cost. Europe went to war in 1914 with each side believing it would win a rapid and easy victory, and Nazi Germany developed the strategy of blitzkrieg in order to subdue its foes as quickly and cheaply as possible. Iraq attacked Iran in 1980 because Saddam believed the Islamic Republic was in disarray and would be easy to defeat, and George W. Bush invaded Iraq in 2003 convinced the war would be short, successful, and pay for itself.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › No Econ !
BROMBERG 22- the financial editor. Michael received a Bachelor of Arts degree in literature from the University of Wisconsin-Madison and a master's degree in linguistics from the Universidad de Antioquia in Medellin, Colombia. He is currently pursuing a PhD from Tulane University.; November 17, 2022; Do Recessions Have a Silver Lining?; https://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/lessons-recessions-depressions.asp#:~:text=Recessions%20have%20plenty%20of%20negative,a%20recession%20can%20benefit%20homebuyers.
From worries about job security to the sinking feeling caused by shrinking balances in your retirement accounts, there are plenty of negative consequences of a recession. However, an economic downturn is not the end of the world. In fact, recessions are an inevitable and necessary part of the economic cycle. History has shown that, when it comes to the financial markets, what goes down eventually comes back up, although the road to recovery may be a bumpy one. And while it may seem counterintuitive, recessions aren't all bad news. From the chance to earn higher yields on your savings account to the potential for bargains and low-cost dividends in the stock market, the clouds that settle over the economy during a recession do in fact have a few silver linings. KEY TAKEAWAYS Recessions have plenty of negative consequences, but they can provide a necessary reset for the markets. Higher interest rates that often coincide with the early stages of a recession provide an advantage to savers, while lower interest rates moving out of a recession can benefit homebuyers. Investors may be able to find bargains on assets that have decreased in price during a recession. Correcting Market Imbalances A recession resulting from an economic imbalance may rectify it, clearing the way for a return to growth. For example, the 1981-1982 recession, which was triggered by Federal Reserve interest rate increases in response to high inflation, helped to lower the inflation rate from 11% in June 1979 to 5% by October 1982, and the U.S. economy grew for the next eight years. Similarly, a recession can end the misallocation of investment capital, whether fueled by a housing bubble or a dot-com one. Although the process can be painful for many investors, recessions may be instrumental in bringing the markets back down to earth, setting the stage for an eventual recovery and renewing the foundations for economic growth. Incentivizing Savings The early phases of an economic downturn often coincide with increases in interest rates as the Federal Reserve pulls the levels of monetary policy in an attempt to combat inflation. For example, in 2022, the Fed engaged in a series of 75-basis-point interest rate hikes, lifting the federal funds rate to a range of 3.75% to 4% at its meeting on Nov. 2. While rate hikes may have a cooling effect on the economy, there is a bright side, as the higher rates translate to higher yields on deposits in savings accounts. While other assets may be subject to heightened levels of risk as the economy tumbles, savings accounts benefit from the higher interest rates during the early stages of a recession, providing stable returns. Savings vehicles like certificates of deposit (CDs) and money market accounts may offer even higher rates than traditional accounts, and online accounts often have the best terms, so it's important to shop around before stashing your cash. The advantages of higher savings account rates make this stage of the economic cycle a perfect time to focus on beefing up your emergency fund. This way, if you lose your job or suffer another economic setback during the recession, you will have a cushion of cash on hand to pull through the difficult time. What's more, you can use the cash you accumulate in your savings account to allocate to other investments as the economy begins to recover. If the higher rates aren't enough, depositing your money in a savings account can help you rest easier during a recession because the funds are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). Bringing Bargains to the Market Recessions can be a stressful time for investors. To put it simply, it can be quite distressing to watch your portfolio shed value as the economy takes a dive. This is especially true for retirees or those nearing retirement who don't have the luxury of time to recover from investment losses. However unsettling it may be to see all that red ink on your account statement, it's important to avoid overreacting and selling your assets at their recession-induced lows. In fact, if you have the patience and are able to adopt a long-term perspective, a recession can be a good time to hunt for bargains and purchase undervalued assets. In addition to identifying stocks of resilient companies that may have suffered overblown declines, investors who continue to buy through a recession stand to benefit from lowering the average cost paid for their assets. For example, if a stock you own has lost value during a recession but you remain bullish on the company's outlook, you could buy additional shares at the reduced price. This will bring down the overall cost per share that you paid for your position, making it easier for you to break even and setting you up for extra gains when the stock recovers. Declining stock prices during a recession also have the potential to benefit investors seeking income from dividends. As the price of a stock decreases, its dividend yield increases, generating higher returns for shareholders. However, the perks of increased dividend yield come to fruition only if the company maintains its dividend, despite the recession's potential negative impacts on its business. While such due diligence is important any time you are researching a dividend-paying stock, it is particularly critical during a recession to seek companies with a history of stable payouts and the capacity to weather the current downturn. Purchasing shares of index funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can be one way to mitigate the risk of investing during a recession. If you invest in individual stocks, there is a chance that the company you choose may post outsized losses or even fail to survive the downturn. On the other hand, pooled index funds and ETFs offer built-in diversification that enhances your chances for weathering the recession. Foreshadowing Lower Interest Rates In contrast with the interest rate hikes that often accompany the beginning of a recession, the later stages of an economic downturn frequently see policymakers lower rates in a bid to jumpstart the sputtering economy. While vehicles like savings accounts lose much of the appeal they generated earlier in the downturn, there are other advantages to the prospects of lower rates on the horizon. For instance, a lower fed funds rate translates to lower mortgage rates. The favorable borrowing environment during the later stages of a recession could provide an excellent opportunity for homebuyers. What Is a Recession? A recession is a substantial, broad-based decline reflected in numerous indicators of economic performance and typically lasting longer than a few months. Can I Benefit From a Recession? By their nature, recessions have far-reaching consequences, with negative effects spanning multiple areas of the financial markets. Although it is impractical to expect to reap a financial reward from a struggling economy, recessions have a few silver linings. Heightened interest rates at the beginning of a recession may allow you to earn more on your savings deposits, while lower rates moving out of the recession may provide opportunities to secure a favorable mortgage loan. You may also be able to buy assets at a discounted price after they have depreciated in value. How Do I Manage My Portfolio During a Recession? If you have a longer investment horizon that will give your assets time to recover from any losses during the recession, you may benefit from maintaining your existing asset allocation, remaining invested in the markets and poised to gain from an eventual recovery. However, there are ways that you can reduce your portfolio's risk in response to an economic downturn. Riskier assets like stocks and high-yield bonds tend to lose value in a recession, while assets that are seen as more stable like gold and U.S. Treasuries tend to appreciate. Within the stock market, shares of large companies with solid cash flows and dividends tend to outperform in downturns. The Bottom Line Recessions are a natural, unavoidable stage of the economic cycle that invariably brings hardship to individuals who lose their jobs or businesses. Economic downturns can also be a difficult time for investors, especially people nearing retirement who can't afford losses in their portfolios. However, for those with the flexibility to adopt a long-term perspective, recessions have a few silver linings. It's difficult if not impossible to time the bottom of the market, but depressed asset prices during a recession could offer buying opportunities for investors. Shifts in interest rates throughout the course of an economic downturn also provide certain advantages—higher rates aimed at fighting inflation benefit savings deposits, while lower interest rates implemented to spur a recovery make it cheaper to take out a loan. Although they don't make up for the economic pain experienced during a recession, these bright spots could be helpful in weathering the storm and positioning for an eventual recovery.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › No Econ !
Walt 20 [Stephen M. Walt is the Robert and Renée Belfer professor of international relations at Harvard University. “Will a Global Depression Trigger Another World War?”, May 13th, https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/05/13/coronavirus-pandemic-depression-economy-world-war/]
On balance, however, I do not think that even the extraordinary economic conditions we are witnessing today are going to have much impact on the likelihood of war. Why? First of all, if depressions were a powerful cause of war, there would be a lot more of the latter. To take one example, the United States has suffered 40 or more recessions since the country was founded, yet it has fought perhaps 20 interstate wars, most of them unrelated to the state of the economy. To paraphrase the economist Paul Samuelson’s famous quip about the stock market, if recessions were a powerful cause of war, they would have predicted “nine out of the last five (or fewer).” Second, states do not start wars unless they believe they will win a quick and relatively cheap victory. As John Mearsheimer showed in his classic book Conventional Deterrence, national leaders avoid war when they are convinced it will be long, bloody, costly, and uncertain. To choose war, political leaders have to convince themselves they can either win a quick, cheap, and decisive victory or achieve some limited objective at low cost. Europe went to war in 1914 with each side believing it would win a rapid and easy victory, and Nazi Germany developed the strategy of blitzkrieg in order to subdue its foes as quickly and cheaply as possible. Iraq attacked Iran in 1980 because Saddam believed the Islamic Republic was in disarray and would be easy to defeat, and George W. Bush invaded Iraq in 2003 convinced the war would be short, successful, and pay for itself. The fact that each of these leaders miscalculated badly does not alter the main point: No matter what a country’s economic condition might be, its leaders will not go to war unless they think they can do so quickly, cheaply, and with a reasonable probability of success. Third, and most important, the primary motivation for most wars is the desire for security, not economic gain. For this reason, the odds of war increase when states believe the long-term balance of power may be shifting against them, when they are convinced that adversaries are unalterably hostile and cannot be accommodated, and when they are confident they can reverse the unfavorable trends and establish a secure position if they act now. The historian A.J.P. Taylor once observed that “every war between Great Powers [between 1848 and 1918] … started as a preventive war, not as a war of conquest,” and that remains true of most wars fought since then. The bottom line: Economic conditions (i.e., a depression) may affect the broader political environment in which decisions for war or peace are made, but they are only one factor among many and rarely the most significant. Even if the COVID-19 pandemic has large, lasting, and negative effects on the world economy—as seems quite likely—it is not likely to affect the probability of war very much, especially in the short term.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Budget
Hoffman 22 (Alex Hoffman, under the advisement of Matthew Johnson. Undergraduate Honors Thesis Sanford School of Public Policy. “Securing the Right to Work: The History and Future of Job Guarantees.” Duke University. 12/9/22.)
Many critics charge proponents of job guarantees with minimizing the true costs of their proposals. Earlier proponents of job guarantees calculated the total cost of the program simply by multiplying the total number of underemployed workers by the minimum wage (Minsky, 1986; Gordon, 1997; Wray, 1998). Both recent proposals (Paul, et al., 2018; Tcherneva, 2018) predict a budget the size of $543 billion, or 2.5% of GDP; and $514 billion to $749 billion, or 2.2% to 3.3% of GDP, respectively. Neither of these totals is precise. Both proposals underestimate the cost of their respective programs by assuming zero administrative costs including paying for the salaries of federal, state, and local officials implementing the program. At the same time, investments in the job guarantee may reduce federal spending on other social programs and increase tax revenues. The number of people requesting unemployment benefits would likely decline as the job guarantee expands and previously unemployed workers gain jobs. Similarly, increased incomes for poor 17 Americans would decrease enrollment in programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). Additionally, both Paul et al. and Tcherneva briefly allude to the fact that a job guarantee would increase tax revenues across the country by improving infrastructure and developing human capital through job training programs and soft skill development. Neither proposal attempts to quantify the potential cost savings of spending reductions and increased revenue, but both suggest the true cost of their programs would be lower than the price tag they provide. Regardless of the specific numbers, both proposals acknowledge that an annual budget ranging in the hundreds of billions of dollars is a nontrivial sum to fund, even through a combination of deficit spending and taxes that both plans propose.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Budget
Earle 18
Peter C. Earle, 'Federal Jobs Guarantee' Idea Is Costly, Misguided, And Increasingly Popular With Democrats, Investors,
Several think tanks — including the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), Levy Economics Institute (LEI), PolicyLink, and the Center for American Progress — have proposed job guarantee plans. While there are minor differences between them, each essentially contemplates a massive, government-run program to provide work (at a predetermined wage) and benefits to enrollees on demand. Currently, individuals in the job market "sell" their labor to firms as much as firms "purchase" labor. Mutually, this transaction — employment — arises because both the employee and employer benefit; value is recognized reciprocally. With a federal jobs guarantee program, the government is inserted between the employee and the employer; the value proposition is limited at best. Centralized plans such as these forgo the most fundamental elements of markets — information, competition, and incentives — in favor of rote bureaucratic reckoning. Simply finding work for tens of millions of job guarantee enrollees would be a formidable task; finding productive, impactful work catering to an individual's skills, in a given locality and in a timely manner, would be staggeringly difficult — if possible at all. The costs, too, are daunting. Both the CBPP and LEI reports project costs ranging from $450 billion to more than $600 billion, which put the proposed programs in the same league with the Pentagon in terms of discretionary spending. And while it is true that the cost of any of the federal jobs guarantee programs would be offset by savings in current unemployment insurance and poverty mitigation programs, neither of the estimates include costs of designing, staffing, and managing the proposed agency. In terms of potential enrollees, estimates start at roughly 10 million. According to LEI's high-end estimate of 17.5 million enrollees, the program would have more employees than the combined head count of the U.S. Department of Defense, the Chinese People's Liberation Army, Walmart, McDonalds, the U.K.'s National Health Service, the China National Petroleum Corporation, the State Grid Corporation of China, the Indian Railways, and the Indian Armed forces. A government organization of that size — 17.5 million job guaranteed individuals, with an untold number of administrators, managers, and other employees to attend to them nationwide — would become the largest public or private organization in history. It would also be the largest experiment in organizational efficiency in history, with the livelihoods of millions of newly government-dependent citizens hanging in the balance. Another issue is the wage, which several plans recommend should be (or average) $15 per hour. With the increasing focus on "living wages," it will not be long before program directors discover that $15 per hour goes far further in Alabama than Hawaii, and the tendency will be to equalize cost-of-living disparities up, further increasing already massive costs.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Budget
Bhandari 19; Ryan Bhandari- Former Senior Policy Advisor, Economic Program; March 25, 2019; What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?; ; [TMS—GK]
#2: The cost is enormous. A federal jobs guarantee will cost at least hundreds of billions of dollars per year and much more during a recession when the employment rolls for the government would naturally increase. Here are the cost estimates from both plans based on people participating in the jobs guarantee: [graph omitted] With annual federal outlays at roughly $4.5 trillion, we’re talking about anywhere from a 10-20% increase in spending to pay for the jobs guarantee. As for how to pay for it, advocates are split on whether it should be paid for at all. Paul et al. provide a few possible tax increases but don’t devote much attention to the matter. Stephanie Kelton says, “What the models show is you can do this without creating an inflation problem and therefore why would you pay for it with tax increases of one kind or another?”2Even though the cost of the program could be partially offset through decreasing social assistance costs, it’s still very uncertain how and when these savings would materialize. What we’re left with is a new program taking up funding that could be used instead for things like increased childcare, training support, expanded health care coverage, and more.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Small Businesses !
Mitha 21 (Farooq Mitha, director of the Defense Department's Office of Small Business Programs. He obtained his law degree from the University of Florida Levin College of Law and holds a B.S. degree in Interdisciplinary Health Sciences from the University of South Florida. “Why Small Businesses Are Essential to U.S. National Security.” DOD. 10/14/21. https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/2810965/why-small-businesses-are-essential-to-us-national-security/)
Small businesses are the engines of the U.S. economy, the heartbeat of communities, and the sources of U.S. global economic strength. This is often heard from the nation's leaders, but what is not often heard is the importance of small businesses to national security. Since the middle of the 20th century, the Defense Department has relied on contributions from small businesses to make significant advances in defense capabilities. These contracts with small businesses enable citizens to benefit from technological advances in their everyday lives. Companies most people know, such as Qualcomm and Symantec, and technologies, such as GPS and modern-day LASIK surgery, were developed from defense or other federal agency contracts. In fact, even Moderna's mRNA technology, which was used in its COVID-19 vaccine, was funded with a grant from the Defense Advanced Research Project Agency to research mRNA therapeutics in 2013. Federal law requires government agencies to award a minimum of 23% of all contracts annually to small businesses, and DOD awards its proportional share. Last year, DOD's awards to small companies amounted to more than $80 billion, with 45% of those dollars going to disadvantaged and women-owned businesses, and those are just prime contracts. While there are tens of thousands of small businesses with DOD prime contracts, there are almost an equal number of small businesses supporting the defense mission as sub-tier suppliers to large companies that produce major platforms and systems for DOD. These companies are innovators developing cutting-edge technologies; manufacturers producing critical parts and components; and service providers that bring some of the nation's best talent to the workforce. However, over the past decade, there have been some alarming trends. The number of small-business suppliers in the federal marketplace — specifically in the defense marketplace — has declined. If this decline continues at the current pace, the nation is at risk of losing key domestic capabilities. Further, small businesses continue to struggle with bureaucratic red tape, including competing in an environment where larger businesses are generally favored. Small businesses face disproportionate barriers to entering that marketplace.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Small Businesses !
Rowinski 22 (Martin Rowinski is the CEO of Boardsi, a corporate board recruitment company, and an investor and author. “How Small Businesses Drive The American Economy.” Forbes. 3/25/22. https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesbusinesscouncil/2022/03/25/how-small-businesses-drive-the-american-economy/?sh=4b064d8d4169)
Just as enough tiny droplets of water slowly fill a bucket, the growth of small businesses fills the U.S. economy. Big corporations might get a lot of attention when it comes to creating jobs, but small businesses employ more people and are more resilient when times get tough. Before coming up with something innovative that propelled them into growth, all big businesses once started out small. Not only are small businesses driving the U.S. economy, but they also keep the American dream alive. According to the U.S. Small Business Association (SBA), small businesses of 500 employees or fewer make up 99.9% of all U.S. businesses and 99.7% of firms with paid employees. Of the new jobs created between 1995 and 2020, small businesses accounted for 62%—12.7 million compared to 7.9 million by large enterprises. A 2019 SBA report found that small businesses accounted for 44% of U.S. economic activity. Without small businesses, the American economy and workforce would be a pretty wild landscape to imagine. Not only do small businesses provide more jobs, they also bring careers and opportunities. Successful small businesses put money back into their local community through paychecks and taxes, which can support the creation of new small businesses and improve local public services. No matter how small it starts—one, two, five, 10 employees—within that town, the city or the county, your small business creates new economies where once there was nothing. Small businesses are also better able to focus more energy on their customers and their needs, which can make them more adaptable to change in times of economic uncertainty. A global health crisis may have rocked the economy, but the formation of new U.S. businesses intending to hire employees rose to historic peaks in 2021, with nearly 1.4 million applications by September and over 400,000 more than at the same point in 2019. When tough times for big businesses lead to layoffs, small businesses become an opportunity. Small Businesses Help All Businesses To become big, all businesses once started out small. In 1978, when the track-and-field coach and his former student who founded Blue Ribbon Sports by making running shoes with a waffle iron changed their company name to Nike, they never imagined it would become the massive multinational corporation that it is today. The two high school friends and devoted computer tinkerers who ended up founding their own software company in 1975 under the name Microsoft could never have expected how large their once small business venture would soon become. Small businesses grow because they draw innovation, attracting talent that brings inventions or new solutions to old ways of doing business that larger corporations have less flexibility to incorporate. This is why big companies today want to acquire small businesses, for their innovators. Apple and Google may be known for their innovation, but they also buy up small startups with innovative new technology to boost this development. Big businesses and even big government projects depend on small businesses as subcontractors, vendors and customers. Federal bills focusing on new jobs to come out of a recession talk a lot about building bridges and freeways, but less about the small businesses across the country that bid for these contracts and carry them out. No matter where you find significant economic development, small businesses are behind it.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Small Businesses !
Duplain 23 (Rachel Duplain - experienced content, marketing, and business professional at Podium, the premiere marketing and communications platform for local businesses. “Small Business, Big Impact: Why Small Businesses are Essential to Our Economy.” Podium. 3/3/23. https://www.podium.com/article/why-small-businesses-are-essential/)
So, how important are small businesses to the economy? 3 Reasons Small Businesses are Essential to Our Economy Small businesses are the lifeblood of the U.S. economy as they create new opportunities. That’s new opportunities for jobs, new opportunities for innovation, and new opportunities to serve niche communities. Operating with agility and the ability to adapt quickly, small businesses have an important role to play in society. 1. Small Businesses Drive Economic Growth With the recent onset of a recession as a stark reminder of how important a growing economy is, small businesses play an essential role in keeping things running smoothly as they are responsible for 44% of U.S. economic activity. This economic success doesn’t only benefit business owners but also leads to team expansion and new roles. In fact, 62% of the new jobs created between 1995 and 2020 were created by small businesses—more than large enterprises! That’s a staggering impact that benefits the people in the local community. As well as supporting the local community with the creation of jobs, small businesses often source their supplies from the local community, boosting the local economy once again. This is an easily traceable and low carbon footprint supply chain that larger businesses that operate on mass just can’t compete with. Speaking of large enterprises, small businesses keep them on their toes. While well-known brands tend to have better brand awareness, recognition, and trust, small businesses are still strong competition. They have a unique perspective that drives innovation and are more personable, enabling them to build strong relationships with customers. Due to small businesses innovating, large enterprises have to innovate too if they want to maintain their market share. This produces better options for the target market all around. 2. Small Businesses Offer a Diverse Range of Products and Services By nature, large enterprises operate on a large scale. So, they won’t implement changes unless it is appealing to a broad customer base and viable across area-wide, state-wide, nationwide, or even international locations. They are often limited to being generalists meaning they can’t appeal to the locals in the same way small businesses can. That’s a major pitfall as about 50% of customers have switched to a competitor that was more relevant and met their needs better. Small businesses can leverage the power of niching by focusing on meeting the needs of, marketing to attract, and nurturing their relationship with a specific target audience. That could be a local community with specific needs that brand names aren’t meeting. Or they could leverage globalization and digital transformation by appealing to a niche market that doesn’t have large numbers locally but does on a wider scale and will interact with the business online. A niche market that has grown in demand recently is eco-conscious shoppers. Big supermarkets tend to be slow in the uptake of new innovations like sustainable products. But by looking online these consumers can find plenty of options for making their home more eco-friendly such as Bee’s Wrap, which offers sustainable food storage options to cut down on plastic usage. Specificity is profitable. You only have to look at the rise of personalized marketing, enabled by the technological development of data-driven segmentation, as evidence of this. In the age of information that can lead to marketing overwhelm, direct marketing that speaks to a certain niche cuts through the noise. By adding diversity to the products and services on the market, small businesses give consumers the power of choice. 3. Small Businesses are Resilient and Adaptive Small businesses can use their small scale to their advantage. They can adapt to changes in the market, come up with an action plan for overcoming economic downturns, and meet new demands with speed and efficiency that isn’t possible in a large enterprise. This agility was put to the test during the Covid-19 pandemic. While 9.1 million jobs were lost in the first two quarters of 2020, small businesses created 5.5 million jobs in the following four quarters, recovering 60% of jobs lost. That’s quite the bounce back, and it shows how well small businesses can adapt to new circumstances and return to serving their customers. For example, Battery Watering Technologies only had 50 employees at the onset of the pandemic. They were able to keep all of them working by using the equipment they had to operate in the battery sector to start making face shields which they sold through an e-commerce website. It was a massive success that led to sales of 6,000 face shields a day. Such adaptability leads to a high level of resilience. It’s not just once-in-a-lifetime pandemics that resilience protects the business against, but the fast pace of technological developments as well. To keep up with innovation and continue to meet customer expectations, digital transformation is a commitment all businesses need to make and small businesses have the advantage of implementing developments much faster.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Small Businesses
Misra 18 (Tanvi Misra - staff writer for CityLab covering urban demographics, inequality, and culture. “WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT GAVE CITIZENS GUARANTEED EMPLOYMENT?” Pacific Standard. 12/19/18. https://psmag.com/economics/the-impacts-of-a-federal-jobs-guarantee)
But what would be the effect of a national jobs guarantee? A new analysis out of the Brookings Institution's Hamilton Project takes a stab at the answer. It finds that if such a plan offers $15 an hour, it could affect up to 44 million already-employed workers, a maximum of 5.9 million unemployed workers, as well as a portion of the tens of millions of working-age people currently outside the labor force. Although such a "sweeping" program would cost a lot of money—hundreds of billions a year—it could improve employment rates by 2 to 4 percent, depending on how it's received, the report finds. "A full national job guarantee at a relatively high wage would be a radical transformation of today's labor market," says Jay Shambaugh, director of the Hamilton Project at Brookings. "So it it would not just be something affecting today's unemployed, it would be affecting a much wider swath of today's labor market." What jumps out in the report is the incredible uncertainty. A federal jobs program could have dramatic effects not just for unemployed individuals but across the U.S. economy—for better and for worse. Much of the impact of this proposal depends on how exactly it is implemented and how it is seen by workers and private companies. Take the unemployed population, for example, which is the target group of a national jobs guarantee. At 5.9 million, it will likely make up a small share of the total population of workers attracted by a job guarantee. But even then, not all unemployed people will be champing at the bit to sign up. The ones who were at the mid- to high-range of the income spectrum before they lost their jobs may want to keep looking for a comparable opportunity, instead of downgrading to a $15 government job. Those who are in very long spells of unemployment, however, may not have a choice. How employed workers react to such a program depends, in large part, on the kind of economic ripples a federal jobs guarantee creates. Currently, 27.9 million full-time workers earn below $15 in the country, and would clearly benefit from switching over to a government job. So would 15.9 million part-time workers. But one potential impact of a jobs guarantee, often hailed by proponents, is that it may compel private companies to raise their wages so they can compete for workers. If that happens, many workers may stay put at their now-higher-paying jobs, lowering the overall dependency on the government jobs program. It's also possible, however, that this upward pressure on wages could adversely affect some smaller private employers, meaning they won't be able to afford workers and might even close up shop, leading to job losses in some cases.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Small Businesses
Earle 18
Peter C. Earle, 'Federal Jobs Guarantee' Idea Is Costly, Misguided, And Increasingly Popular With Democrats, Investors,
Two other factors: both the CBPP and LEI plans fail to account for the potential disruption to existing businesses — mostly small businesses, the engine of economic growth in the United States — which will inevitably occur when workers earning less than $15 per hour leave their private sector jobs for higher-paying employment with job guarantee placement. At present, more than 40 million Americans earn less than the proposed guarantee wage of $15 per hour, which could trigger a major shift of the U.S. workforce away from private employment, on to public rolls. It would also effectively force small businesses to compete directly against the federal government on the labor market.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Small Businesses
Bourne 19 [Ryan Bourne, Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics at Cato, “Bernie Sanders Wants to End At‐Will Employment, and That’s a Truly Bad Idea That Would Increase Unemployment”, CATO Institute, December 8, 2019, .]
Firms could compensate for the risk burden just‐cause laws impose by reducing the wages offered to risky hires, negating the unemployment effect. But these results suggest wages aren’t fully flexible. What’s more, Senator Sanders wants a $15 federal minimum wage and the rollout of collective bargaining nationwide, making US wages less flexible still. The combined effect of his plan to reshape the labor market would therefore be doubly damaging for the job prospects of low‐skilled, inexperienced workers. , the impact of less labor market flexibility is clear. In part because of the flexibility of the US labor market, the unemployment rate has now fallen to an incredibly low 3.5%. By contrast, Sweden, Finland, and Denmark — which have variants of the just‐cause laws Bernie Sanders proposes — have higher unemployment rates of 6.8%, 7.3%, and 4.8% respectively. Other European countries with much more broadly inflexible labor markets, such as France, Spain, and Italy, have much higher levels of unemployment still. The experience of the past decade suggests that although flexible labor markets can be volatile in the short term — US unemployment jumped above European levels in 2009 — they near consistently deliver lower structural unemployment over time. Sanders’ agenda doesn’t just risk unemployment, though. A just‐cause law would likely weaken productivity and hence wages too. Silicon Valley’s success has been credited with an ability to hire and fire workers quickly according to a company’s needs. Making it difficult to hire and fire leads to workers in jobs to which they are not best suited, or else convinces employers to explore needlessly costly mechanization, reducing their efficiency. Our labor‐market outcomes are not perfect. Many workers want more hours, more security, or higher pay. But Sanders’ idea to abolish at‐will employment goes too far and will hurt the job prospects of inexperienced workers significantly.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Generic
Ozimek 18 Adam Ozimek economist at Moody's Analytics, where I cover labor markets and other aspects of the U.S. economy. The views expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not represent the views of my employer, Moody’s Analytics, its parent company (Moody’s Corporation) or its affiliates “Yes, The Jobs Guarantee Is Absurd” Apr 24, 2018,03:08pm EDT ///Mgal
I gather from my last post that people want me to say more about why a jobs guarantee program is absurd. I've written about this before (here, here, and here), and my main point in that post was really just to be clear about how ridiculous I thought the program was. But if readers want more they can have it. The jobs guarantees that are being proposed out there have two purposes: end involuntary unemployment and ending low wages. This is really important because some defenders of jobs guarantees simply focusing on their role in providing jobs for people who truly struggle to find work even in a healthy labor market, and for those who lose them for cyclical reasons. But the jobs guarantee proposals in both rhetoric and policy details are clear: these polices are meant to guarantee everyone a good job. In the CBPP proposal the authors list as one of the 3 main recommendations of their report "The elimination of poverty wages through the pay structure of the NIEC". Their goal is to create a floor in the labor market below which private employers will not go: "Since the job guarantee places a floor in the labor market, employers will likely have to offer compensation packages at least as desirable as those offered under the NIEC" In case there is any confusion, the authors don't mince words, warning readers that "Make no mistake, this is a policy to transform the U.S. labor market". And they're right! They recommend a minimum wage of $24,600 which they translate to a minimum hourly wage of $11.83. At a first pass, private employers simply won't be able to offer less than this if they want to hire anyone. But they also argue for inclusion of health benefits, and since this is a guaranteed job you presumably can't easily be fired from, it also includes the best job security you can get. What's more, that's just the minimum wage in this program, and they expect the average worker will make $32,500, which translates to a minimum hourly wage of $15,60. And that's just the average, not the peak! Despite these generous benefits, they estimate this program will only require hiring about 10 million workers, all of whom are currently unemployed. While they admit "the job guarantee may result in the displacement of some workers currently employed in the private sector, especially at the low end of the labor market", they minimize this risk by pointing to the minimum wage literature. As such, their cost estimates don't assume any crowd out of private employers. Does that sound reasonable to you? They believe their program will prompt tens of millions of employers to raise wages, but this won't cause any disemployment or crowd out at private employers. By their own estimate, their program "may result in a comparable change within the labor market" as a $15 minimum wage, which affects 41 million workers. To believe there would be no crowd out despite this massive change requires the assumption every low wage worker in this country has productivity high enough to justify a good paying job, but employers aren't paying it now. Usually, liberal commentators are quick to tell us how bad low wage jobs are in the U.S. not just by pay but by working conditions. Wage theft, unpredictable hours, abusive bosses, tenuous employment at will, lack of opportunities for advancement are all allegedly widespread features of the low-skilled labor market. Are we to believe that workers will not abandon these jobs in droves for guaranteed government employment with benefits, or that employers will change overnight? I think these criticisms of working conditions are often overblown, but at the very least you can certainly easily be fired from a private sector job and turnover is quite high, making a guaranteed job clearly nicer in that important regard. And yes, many low-skilled jobs are far from pleasant. The idea employers would and could universally raise wages, offer full benefits, and upgrade job quality to prevent crowd out strikes me as absurd. For many advocates I think this risk isn't worth worrying about because it's not much of a risk to them. If the job guarantee ends up with 20, 30, or 40 million instead of the 10 million they expect than that's not really a problem because massively expanding the size of government isn't really a big deal. But it would be. The first problem is you lose the output those workers were producing. In that sense, their production is nationalized quite like when the government takes over an industry, except in this case they are taking over the labor instead of the capital. What's more, when employers of low skilled workers go out of business this will also harm the high skilled workers they employ. The second problem is what this will do to the size of government. Righ now there are about 21 million federal, state, and local government workers in the U.S. By the authors' calculations, the 10 million more jobs would increase government employment by a whopping 50%. If only 10 million private sector jobs are crowded out it would double the size of government. We are going to put to work 50% to 100% more government workers than we already do, and we should expect that the bill will approximately double as well. This brings me to the issue of what all of these people will do. It's alleged that there is a ton of work for government workers to do that isn't being done. Here is my challenge to the people who claim this: first have all the police officers, teachers, and other public sector workers who are allowed to retire at age 55 do this work instead of retiring. If the work is too strenuous for a 55 to 65 year old, then I'm going to question how realistic it is to guarantee that literally anyone can do it. If you say is impossible given political constraints from the power of government employees, then perhaps this is a reason to worry about drastically expanding the scope of government employment. When it comes to what work these people will do, read Matt Bruenig's criticisms of the alleged work that people in this program will do. Matt deserves praise for doing what I argued that more liberals should be doing: criticizing the absurdity of this program instead of trying to hold up a very watered down version of it that doesn't actually do what advocates and now politicians are actually proposing. It's not crazy for the government to want to improve job quality widely. It is crazy to say you are going to do that by the government directly offering everyone a good job. Tweak the program all you want, trying to make every job a good job via this mechanism is going to per se be a radical and massive undertaking and a bad idea. Policies should focus on subsidizing private employment of low-skilled workers and the government spending money on boosting wages directly. Honestly the idea is so bad I find the fact that we have to actually debate it far more interesting than actually debating it. It's a bad sign about the state of ideas on the left today.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Generic
Bourne 21’
Ryan Bourne occupies the R. Evan Scharf Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics at Cato and is an author, “Democrats Will Break the US Labor Market, Not Fix It”, Cato Institution, March 19 2021
These successes were a testament to America’s freedom‐driven labour laws and modest safety net, on the one hand, and tax cut‐driven macroeconomic policies on the other. The latter boosted demand for workers and encouraged investment in them. Yet the healthier the labor market got, the more Democrats dreamed of transforming it. Bizarrely, talk even filtered out in the presidential primaries about a “jobs guarantee” policy — a federal government “make work” scheme at $15 per hour — at a time when most economists thought the country near “full employment”. Mercifully, Biden isn’t going there. But he’s appointed economists who desire a much higher minimum wage, clampdowns on independent contractors and fresh mandates on businesses. In flexible labor markets, unemployment spikes when shocks such as pandemics hit, and that experience last year is being used as a precursor for policies to provide more “security”. The trade‐off evident in much of Europe — permanently higher unemployment — goes unmentioned. While US pandemic unemployment peaked at 14.8pc last year, it has already fallen to 6.2pc, lower than the average EU rate even before Covid‐19 hit. Democrats, though, would jeopardize the policy environment that delivered low unemployment and rising wages. x the near‐term, their stimulus extends generous supplemental unemployment benefits of $300 per week to laid off workers until September 2021. That will deter individuals from taking up new roles as the economy reopens. In the longer term, the party intends to part‐finance its agenda by raising the corporate tax rate back up from 21pc to 28pc, a large proportion of which will be ultimately borne by workers through lower wages owing to less investment. In Congress, Democrats are pushing a $15 per hour national minimum wage phased in by 2025, despite estimates it will reduce employment by 1.4m people. An aggressive first rise from $7.25 to $9.50 would occur this year, despite the fact that 60pc of jobs that pay the current federal minimum wage are in leisure and hospitality, industries crushed by forced closures, reluctant consumers and social distancing. The party’s proposed Pro Act, passed already by the House of Representatives, would redefine a lot of working adults who currently operate as independent contractors as “employees” through application of a strict “ABC test” for contractor status. This test would put a wide range of freelance and gig economy work at risk by making the business models of the companies offering them unviable, despite these roles offering flexibilities that the contractors say they enjoy. The party’s Act would also effectively preclude against current state “right‐to‐work” laws, which, in over half of the country, prevent unions forcing workers to pay dues in order to maintain their employment. Indeed, Biden is pushing a range of pro‐trade union legislation that would make collective bargaining easier and has described himself as “the strongest labour president you have ever had”. This embrace of an old‐school continental insider‐outsider labor market model doesn’t stop with employment legislation. An aggressive government‐led green agenda, new “Buy American” provisions, and a range of other mercantilist tariffs, means Biden’s administration intends to be much more activist on “job creation” too. We would thus see the US government playing a far more intrusive role on both the supply and demand side of the labour market. One could understand the urgency for a revolution in labour interventions if the US had suffered from high unemployment or falling wages for years. But the pre‐pandemic world shows that the US has a very low natural rate of unemployment under existing policies, meaning the key to avoiding high unemployment is avoiding macroeconomic mistakes. The party’s intent on the retrograde Europeanisation of US labour laws is therefore quite baffling. Biden should listen again to Lance’s message: If it ain’t broke, Joe, don’t try to fix it.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Turn- Crowd Out- Generic
Bourne 19 [Ryan Bourne, Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics at Cato, “Bernie Sanders Wants to End At‐Will Employment, and That’s a Truly Bad Idea That Would Increase Unemployment”, CATO Institute, December 8, 2019, .]
Despite US labor‐market flexibility delivering much lower unemployment than more heavily regulated countries, Sanders thinks it’s time to move toward more onerous employment laws. Getting rid of at‐will employment would not only make it much more difficult for inexperienced, young, and risky hires to find work, but it would also reduce wages and living standards. Democratic presidential candidates continue to demand risky and radical plans to overhaul the way Americans work. Sanders’ goal is laudable but the idea is misguided Doing away with at‐will employment means eliminating the presumption that employers should be able to fire workers at any time or for any reason, just as workers are free to walk away from a job if they choose. Federal protections against termination already exist for discrimination against protected classes. And many states have additional safeguards for workers, such as laws that prevent companies from firing workers if it would breach implied promises to the employee or is a way to punish the employee for complying with public policies. Yet Sanders’ plan goes much further. He wants a national “just cause” law, where the government would dictate what constitutes a fair layoff for personal or economic reasons, with the threat of court action and fines for employers found guilty of “unjust” dismissals. His stated desire is laudable: improving job security for workers. But security isn’t free. Making it costlier or riskier to fire people also makes it riskier to hire them. Abolishing at‐will employment entirely could make firms less likely to take on workers who are young and inexperienced, particularly when their performance is difficult to observe. The risk of such a law, then, is higher unemployment and weaker labor productivity.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Labor Power High Now
Corvey et al 23 (J.J. McCorvey, Sara Ruberg and Brian Cheung. “Covid transformed the U.S. labor market, and it isn’t done yet.” NBC News. 5/11/23. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/economy/covid-pandemic-emergency-workforce-jobs-recession-rcna83412)
After a three-year national health emergency, over 1.1 million Covid deaths, a wave of retirements and high inflation, the U.S. labor force is smaller and tighter than before the pandemic. For workers, that means continued leverage to secure pay gains and better conditions even as the economy cools. The labor market rebounded sharply from the blow dealt by Covid-19 as it swept the country in early 2020, thanks to aggressive federal relief measures and widespread vaccine rollouts. But the health crisis transformed the economy in ways that have persisted throughout the recovery, and analysts expect its ripple effects to linger despite a hiring slowdown and simmering recession fears. When the world shut down in March 2020, low-wage workers in hospitality and other service roles saw some of the steepest job losses amid the sharpest drop in employment post-WWII, according to a National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) study in March. While some parts of the economy have rebounded beyond pre-pandemic metrics, employers in many industries are still contending with staffing challenges. “Spending is back, demand for labor is back, but we have a smaller labor force,” said Wendy Edelberg, director of the Hamilton Project and a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. “That is one of the reasons why the labor market feels tight and why firms have been reporting left, right and center that they’re having a hard time finding workers.” The U.S. population is 1.4 million people shy of pre-pandemic projections based on its growth rate before Covid hit, according to an April Brookings analysis of federal data. About 900,000 of those “missing” people would have been expected to be working. Edelberg attributed roughly 650,000 of those absences to deaths (Covid-related or otherwise) and the remaining 250,000 to immigration policies during the pandemic — particularly Title 42, a Trump administration measure that expired Thursday night along with the federal public health emergency. Many of the nation’s workers continue to suffer from health effects incurred during the pandemic. A January report by the New York State Insurer’s Fund, the state’s largest workers’ compensation carrier, found that during the first two years of the pandemic, 71% of patients with “long Covid” symptoms required ongoing medical treatment or didn’t return to work for six months or longer. A report from the management consulting firm McKinsey & Co., also from January, estimated that the economy lost 315 million to more than 1 billion working days among U.S. employees because of Covid last year alone, equivalent to 1.3 million to 4.3 million people’s leaving the workforce. “At the high end, that’s about double the average number of sick days taken by US workers in the decade before the pandemic,” the researchers wrote. A key reason the labor market remains so tight is that the pandemic collided with an already aging U.S. population. Some older workers bowed out of the workforce earlier than planned as employers slashed jobs and furloughed staff. As the subsequent recovery kicked off a hiring spree, many recent retirees came back off the sidelines, but others stayed put. A recent study by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York flagged a 2.1 million worker “participation gap,” which it largely attributed to the aging of the massive baby boomer population and a surge in retirements. While job growth is finally cooling down and layoffs have been piling up for months, many employers remain hungry to hire. Government data showed 9.6 million job openings in March, coming down from last year’s levels but still much higher than the roughly 7 million openings posted before the pandemic — in what was already a hot market at the time. Last month the U.S. added 253,000 roles, continuing a lengthy run of job gains that have been a boon to workers, with many taking part in the so-called Great Resignation to seek out better opportunities and work-life balance, or even entirely new careers during the economic recovery. Others have reaped rewards by sticking around, as bosses add incentives to retain staffers. We’ve had this huge imbalance between demand for employees and supply of employees for the last couple of years,” said Paige Ouimet, a finance professor at the Kenan-Flagler Business School at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. “It’s slowly starting to shift,” she said, “but it is still a different situation in terms of the bargaining power that employees have relative to their employers.” An NBER study from March found that wage gains among the lowest-paid workers have substantially slowed the growth of income inequality. Arindrajit Dube, a study co-author and economist at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, said the scale of low earners’ pay gains was striking — rising 6% from January 2020 to September 2022. “Wage growth at the bottom is really making the labor market more equal,” Dube said. Lower-wage workers have been pulling in more income “because they’ve been able to leave, because they’ve been able to find better jobs,” he said. The trend has fanned a pandemic-era surge in labor organizing efforts, including at name brands such as Starbucks and Amazon, as workers test their leverage. There are also signs that the tight competition for workers is increasing labor participation among certain groups. According to Brookings, women ages 25-54 boosted their labor force participation by 1.5 percentage points since 2019, and Black people aged 25-64 did so by 1.7 percentage points over the same period. Some demographics, however, are seeing the opposite trend. “White men of all ages and older white women are participating less” in the workforce, the Brookings researchers wrote. Labor force participation among white men ages 20 and older stood at 70.1% in April, down from 71% in March 2020. The 23% labor force participation rate among people with disabilities is up from 20.7% in 2019, according to federal employment data. The uptick reflects the many disabled workers who have entered the workforce during the job boom — as well as the increase in people working with long Covid. Remote and flexible work arrangements have made many jobs more accessible to those with disabilities. Government data showed 27.5% of private employers allowing full- or part-time telework as of last fall, the latest data available. “I’m very confident that the ability to work remotely will continue to affect who works and who doesn’t,” said Edelberg of Brookings. “Those effects are not fully settled down in the data. That’s with us for a long time.”
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Labor Power High Now
Wallace 22 ( - senior writer for CNN Business covering the economy. “America’s workers gained power during Covid. A volatile economy will put that to the test.” CNN Business. 6/14/22. https://edition.cnn.com/2022/06/14/economy/labor-union-momentum-economy/index.html)
The pandemic shone a spotlight on the vast disparities in benefits and rights among America’s workforce and helped fuel a movement to unionize more workers. And with today’s tight labor market, workers continue to have the upper hand — there are almost two job openings for every unemployed person — creating an environment that’s even more favorable to labor union activity. In the last year, unions have been formed at big corporations such as Starbucks, Amazon, and Alphabet; union election petitions filed with the National Labor Relations Board from October 2021 through March 2022 were up 57% from the same period a year before; and a September Gallup poll found that 68% of Americans surveyed were in favor of labor unions – the highest level of approval since 1965. But as the war in Ukraine, record gas prices and spiraling inflation continue to put pressure on the US economy, what remains to be seen is whether the newly robust labor movement could weather higher unemployment and an eventual economic downturn. The extraordinary conditions that created this more pro-worker market won’t last forever, said Heidi Shierholz, president of the Economic Policy Institute and former chief economist for the US Department of Labor under President Barack Obama. “To the extent that has contributed to this increase in workers organizing … that will abate,” she said. “But how much momentum will have been established before that time, it’s not going to be zero.” “This daily drumbeat of seeing workers win when they’re trying to organize, that’s not going to be quickly unlearned,” she added. In April, workers at an Amazon warehouse in Staten Island were the first to vote to successfully unionize in the company’s history; what began as a slow drip of unionizing Starbucks stores now totals more than 100 locations; employees at Apple stores in Georgia and New York and, just last week, a Massachusetts Trader Joe’s, are trying to do the same, citing concerns related to health and safety, pay, benefits, hours and working conditions. Noel Bennett is a shift supervisor at a Starbucks in Santa Cruz, California, that voted to unionize last month. For workers at her store, it came down to a simple desire: To have their voices heard. “I think, especially due to the pandemic and seeing how corporations might not really think about the worker and workers’ experiences, I think that’s what really made partners at Starbucks realize that what’s happening could be better, and that unionization can be that thing that allows us to have a voice and to obtain the ability to live in this economy,” she told CNN Business. The latest batch of unionization efforts are still likely heavily influenced by pandemic-related issues and demands placed on workers, but the current economic state is layering in other factors, said Ileen DeVault, professor of labor history at Cornell University’s School of Industrial and Labor Relations. “I think many of these efforts at unionization are still concerned about workers’ treatment in the workplace, whether that’s health and safety issues or hours of work or expectations about how much work is going to be accomplished,” she said. “I do think that inflation and, in particular, the ridiculous rise in gas prices is also really on workers’ minds.” But the current economy also benefits workers, DeVault said, adding that it’s easier to risk one’s job when there are plenty of other positions available. Also contributing to a potentially favorable environment are actions taken by the Biden Administration, which has explicitly promoted pro-union measures, including creating the White House Task Force on Worker Organizing and Empowerment, which in February released nearly 70 recommendations for action; tapping former union leaders and lawyers to fill key roles such as Secretary of Labor and general counsel for the National Labor Relations Board; and backing the Protecting the Right to Organize Act of 2019, which is stalled in the Senate after passing the House of Representatives last year.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Inequality Stable/Decreasing
Popli 22 (Nik Popli – Reporter at TIME. “Income Inequality in America Hasn’t Risen in a Decade. It May Not Feel Like It.” TIME. 10/5/22. https://time.com/6220111/income-inequality-us-2/)
The U.S. may have the highest level of income inequality of the G7 nations, but new research suggests that disparity has actually stabilized over the last decade, thanks to rapid growth in wages for the lowest-paying jobs. It just may take a while for the average American to feel it. A pair of researchers from Harvard and MIT examined data from the period between 1980 and 2020, and found that income inequality peaked in 2012 and then began to stabilize even though many of the drivers of rising inequality—such as a decline in union membership—have persisted. “After decades of rising inequality, overall earnings inequality stopped growing, and possibly declined, since 2012,” according to the research paper, titled Rapid wage growth at the bottom has offset rising U.S. inequality. That could be good news for the fight against inequality, but the gains are hardly permanent and could be wiped away if the economy spirals. “It’s got me feeling very cautiously optimistic,” says Clem Aeppli, a Harvard PhD student and co-author of the research article, which was published on Monday in the competitive PNAS journal. “Optimism in the sense that maybe the increase in inequality we’ve observed since the 1980s is not inevitable.” But Aeppli says he is also “incredibly cautious…because the stabilization in inequality seems so reliant on these very fragile market conditions.” Tracing income inequality can be especially messy, but the researchers say they pulled together multiple measures of earnings—from household and business surveys to Bureau of Labor Statistics data—which they say all told a similar story: Income inequality is declining as growth for low-wage workers outpaces middle- and high-wage workers. “It’s unexpected good news for those of us who have been studying inequality trends for a while,” says Nathan Wilmers, an associate professor at MIT Sloan and co-author of the research paper. Separate data from the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta shows that as of August, the bottom quartile of U.S. earners saw a 7% increase in wages over the last year, while those in the top quartile saw wages increase 4%. According to Wendy Edelberg, a senior fellow in economic studies at the Brookings Institution and director of The Hamilton Project, wage gains have been greatest for the leisure and hospitality sector and the retail trade sector, while workers in other industries have not seen the same benefits. “We’ve seen big declines in real wages for every sector except those two,” she says, partly because of pandemic and inflationary pressures. “And they happen to be pretty low wage sectors.” While the research suggests individual income inequality is shrinking, figures from the Census Bureau present a less optimistic picture for American households, which are facing current inflation levels of 8.3%, putting pressure on living costs. The Census Bureau’s 2021 American Community Survey, released Oct. 4, found that household income inequality was “significantly” higher than its 2019 estimate (based on a calculation of the Gini index, a summary measure of income inequality used across the world). Contrary to the two scholars’ findings about individual income, the Census Bureau found that household income inequality increased over the last year for the first time since 2011 due to declines in real income—which takes inflation into account—at the bottom of the income distribution. The scholars attribute this difference to changes in the Bureau’s data collection and processing methods. “That report is looking at household income inequality rather than inequality in individual earnings,” Aeppli says. “It’s a different unit of analysis and different quantity. And even when we correct for that difference, we still observed that household income inequality seems to be stabilizing in the last decade—it just isn’t as pronounced.” Research in related fields seems to support the scholars’ findings. As earnings grow for low-wage workers, the number of Americans living below the poverty line has also decreased, says Chris Wimer, director of the Center on Poverty and Social Policy at Columbia University. A number of policies designed to offset the impact of rising prices have contributed, including employment expansions, stimulus payments and the child tax credit of 2021. “But some of those policies are going away,” Wimer says, “so families coping with inflation no longer have the same policy support.” However, the Harvard and MIT study suggests that policy measures have had less of an impact than market dynamics. It argues that a tight labor market is what’s driving these changes in inequality rather than other factors like minimum wage legislation, labor action or a shortage of workers. The early months of the pandemic put frontline workers dealing with the public face-to-face at the most risk, and saw workers resigning in droves, particularly in the food services and retail industries. Their analysis found that raising minimum wages to $15 an hour would, perhaps unsurprisingly, increase earnings at the bottom, though most cities did not increase minimum wages in 2021. However, labor shortages meant that some employers were offering higher wages in order to get staff in these roles.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › Inequality Stable/Decreasing
Semuels 23 (ALANA SEMUELS - Economic correspondent at TIME. She is a four-time nominee for the Gerald Loeb Award for Distinguished Business and Financial Journalism, and has won awards from the Society of Business Editors and Writers and the Los Angeles Press Club. “American Inequality is (Finally) Lessening.” TIME. 3/31/23. )
If 2022 was the year the U.S. economy came roaring back like a lion, 2023 is more of a lamb. Modest job growth, consistent inflation, falling home prices, slowing GDP growth—meh. February was another month of meh, the government reported Friday, with personal incomes increasing 0.3% in February after growing 0.6% in January. In addition, consumer spending grew 0.2% in February. But there’s some pretty good news that doesn’t readily appear in the steady stream of government data released each week. After decades in which the gap between the richest and poorest Americans grew by leaps and bounds, the strange rebound from the pandemic has led to something different: a slow reduction in inequality across the economy. Incomes of people in the bottom half of income distribution grew by 4.5% in the last calendar year, much faster than the 1.2% average income growth of all Americans, according to Realtime Inequality, a tool launched by economists at the University of California, Berkeley to show a more holistic picture of how the U.S. economy is faring, as compared to GDP. While lower-income households struggled following the Great Recession, taking more than eight years to reach pre-crisis income levels, they have done much better in the pandemic’s aftermath. Between February 2020 and September 2022, average income for the lowest-earning 50% of Americans increased by more than 10%, faster than all groups of population except for the top 1%, according to a paper by the Realtime Inequality economists, Thomas Blanchet, Emmanuel Saez, and Gabriel Zucman. This reduction in inequality breaks from a long-running trend in which the rich were getting richer and the poor were stagnating. Since 1980, the top 10% of earners have seen income grow 144%, while the bottom half of earners saw just 20% growth in income. “What we’re witnessing since the late 2010s—significant growth rates for low-wage workers—is a notable break from the trend that has prevailed since the 1980s,” Zucman says, in an email. The biggest factor driving this reduction in inequality is a tight labor market that has pushed up wages for workers whose pay had previously been stagnating. The monthly unemployment rate hovered around 4% in both 2018 and 2019 as well as in 2022 (the massive layoffs at the beginning of the pandemic spiked unemployment in 2020 leading into 2021); this year it hit a decades-long low at 3.4% in January. Economists expect the government to report an unemployment rate of 3.6% when it releases March data on April 7.
2023
CNDI
Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Job Loss Coming- AI
Gaskell 22 (Adi Gaskell - Journalist. “AI Creates Job Disruption But Not Job Destruction.” Forbes. 1/18/22. https://www.forbes.com/sites/adigaskell/2022/01/18/ai-creates-job-disruption-but-not-job-destruction/?sh=593d8d4c3b3e)
A common concern surrounding automation in recent years is that it will result in widescale job losses as the work previously done by people is taken over by technology. Of course, the reality doesn't really support this narrative, and indeed, companies that invest in technology often end up employing more people as a result of the improvement in their fortunes heralded by the investment. The leadership team of the fintech company Kashat highlight the reality of investing in technology. They reveal that microfinance has traditionally been highly labor intensive, with many of the skills the same as those used in the sector for years. With the introduction of AI, new skills have been introduced into the underwriting process in order to serve at scale, while enabling employees to further expand their skillset and become even more valuable in the future. The impact of this distinction is clearly visible in the growth rates across the sector, with those more tech-enabled firms growing far faster, and therefore employing more people, than their more traditional peers. A cursory glance at the news coverage around automation doesn't suggest that the fears around its job destructing capabilities is going to go away any time soon, so it feels like all additional data brought to the table has merit, even if it does largely repeat that which has gone before. Research from the University of Warwick fits this bill and argues that just a quarter of the firms that have introduced some form of AI-based technology over the past few years have suffered any form of net job loss. Indeed, the number who said jobs have been lost was roughly the same as the number who said that investing in AI had resulted in more jobs being created (the remaining half said it had no impact). “Advances in AI have reignited debates about the impact of technology on the future of work, raising concerns about massive job losses," the researchers say. "However, current evidence supporting this is beset by methodological limitations and there is very little analysis of what actually happens in organisations introducing AI-enabled technologies." “Discussions about AI’s potential impact on jobs have tended to focus on potential job loses as AI is increasingly capable of automating complex tasks," the researchers say. "And while there does seem to be some evidence of that, our research shows that AI is as likely to lead to net job creation in companies introducing AI as it is to lead to net destruction. Indeed, the introduction of AI was found to be 28.4% more likely to create jobs than similar investments in other technologies, while it was also 26% more likely to result in job destruction. Disruption rather than destruction What appears clear from the research is that AI and associated technologies do indeed disrupt the labor market, with some jobs going and others emerging, but across the board there are more jobs created than lost. “While we can’t say for sure how many jobs will be created or destroyed from the research, it is likely that the automation of some tasks may mean fewer people are needed to perform some jobs but that increased productivity may reduce costs stimulating sales and demand for workers overall," the researchers explain. "This of course is likely to depend upon the specific AI-technology used and what employers hope to achieve by using it." The researchers go on to suggest that there have been clear moves towards a greater investment in digital technologies during the Covid pandemic, and that this trend is likely to continue for some time. Despite this investment, however, there have been well documented skills shortages in many sectors. A period of change It's a level of disruption that is echoed by a report from MIT's Task Force on the Work of the Future, which was created to examine the changes being seen in the labor market. The report reminds us that over 60% of the jobs of today did not exist a generation ago, with technology not so much driving a destruction of work but rather an evolution in the kind of work we do. The inevitability of this was underlined by research from Columbia Business School, which found that investing in AI, whether in terms of technology or skills, boosted revenue by around 15%, while also allowing firms to expand their product range and the markets they sell into. This revenue growth then encourages firms to make further investments, and so the cycle continues. The issue, therefore, is not so much to protect jobs but rather to help people develop the skills needed to perform the jobs of today and tomorrow, while also striving to ensure that those jobs are high quality.