Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Inflation DA › 2AC – UBI Doesn’t Hurt Inflation

With regulation from an independent institution, UBI rates can be set to target inflation.

Rasoolinejad’ 21 [Mohammad Rasoolinejad; November 24, 2021; Postdoctoral Research Fellow in Computational Social Science at Kellogg School of Management with focus on network action especially in the financial markets and complex socio-economic systems.; “Universal Basic Income: The Last Bullet in the Darkness”; https://www.researchgate.net/publication/336551387_Universal_Basic_Income_The_Last_Bullet_in_the_Darkness]

UBI has failed in many cases solely due to an uncontrolled money supply to the middle class, which produced hyperinflation. The catch here is that UBI should not be controlled by the executive branch of government. In the case of democracy, it is quite logical to assume each candidate will promise higher UBI rates to gain more votes. This will produce a vicious cycle ending with hyperinflation. UBI should be under the control of an independent entity, such as the Federal Reserve in the United States. That entity will control the money supply and amount of UBI based on projections of inflation. UBI will be an extra tool of the Federal Reserve which can directly target inflation and wealth disparity. As an example assume the target inflation to be two percent and country’s inflation rate sustainably runs below the target. Eq. 2 gives an estimation for the UBI rate to be paid to achieve the target inflation. After running the program for certain amount of time (for example three months), the inflation rate shall be reassessed. If running below or above the target range, the rate can be readjusted accordingly. UBI rate eventually goes to zero if the inflation rate sustainably runs above the target range. UBI works best in a deflationary environment, not in an inflationary one. It is best suited for developed countries with deflationary or low inflation environment. In such countries, not only inflation to be avoided, but the central banks are pushing to raise inflation to a healthy level. For developing countries often with higher inflation rates, UBI can cause disastrous effects. Some have suggested that UBI can be implemented for the currency inflation [11, 12]. The UBI is not good to compensate for inflation, as it is itself an inducer of inflation. In this case, more inflation would cause increase in UBI rates, which makes the inflation problem worse. Also, the amount one loses due to inflation is proportional to his/her cash holding, so people with more cash should receive more basic income, which does not seem rational.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Inflation DA › 2AC – UBI Doesn’t Hurt Inflation

A UBI is not inflationary; it redistributes and controls hyperinflation.

Reed et al.’ 23[Howard Reed, Elliott Johnson, Matthew Johnson, and Graham Stark; April 9, 2023; Senior Research Fellows and Professor of Politics at Northumbria University.; “Universal Basic Income does not cause inflation”; https://www.newsroom.co.nz/universal-basic-income-does-not-cause-inflation]

There is little evidence to support this view. UBI is no more or less inflationary than anything else that raises incomes – its impact would depend on whether the economy is at full employment, whether taxes are raised to pay for the scheme and various other factors. Where hyperinflation has occurred, it has been because essential goods are scarce, raising their value overall, and debt has been held in foreign currencies and paid in currencies declining in value by virtue of countries’ domestic production being disrupted or declining. Our current levels of inflation are caused by similar pressures as those in the 1970s: war leading to an increase in the cost of fossil fuels. If the logic behind objecting to a UBI on the basis of inflation were correct, then there ought to be absolutely no attempt to introduce new jobs or increase wages, as both increase purchasing power. If inflation is our sole concern, governments ought to slash wages and massively increase taxes. The point is that nobody wants either of those options because, even if they did reduce inflation, people would not want to have their wages reduced. UBI is a redistributive economic policy that can be funded by taxing those resources that contribute little to society: wealth and passive income from shares as well as income at the very top end of society. The resources of the rich are generally off-shored and contribute little to a country’s financial wellbeing. Analysis of the distributive impacts of UBI in the UK suggest its introduction would shift resources to those people and areas that need the investment most. That may increase the cost of housing and other goods in parts of countries that have been left behind, but this is a central means of enhancing community wealth and ‘Levelling Up’. It is also a means of developing entrepreneurship and production within areas that have been deindustrialised. This support for production is, again, an essential means of supporting a bulwark against hyperinflation. Given that we live in market societies, the fear this will lead to unchecked inflation is counterintuitive, as competition is supported by rising purchasing power and serves to check price increases. The alternative is simply to leave all but the metropolitan centres to wither away and to be dependent on the whims of finance. As our recent RSA report indicated, if governments are committed to resolving our age of crisis, they need to do as their predecessors did after World War Two: invest in transformative policies with expensive up-front costs to achieve the most significant social outcomes. Nothing is more expensive than undoing climate change, dealing with pandemics and repairing the damage of social decay. In that context, there is evidence a UBI is economically feasible and voters regard UBI as a necessary means of promoting social security.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP (Climate NB) › A2 Tipping Points

Ecological tipping points are “scientific garbage” and lack data---effects are slow and localized

Brook et al. 18 — Barry W. Brook, ARC Australian Laureate Professor and Chair of Environmental Sustainability at the University of Tasmania in the Faculty of Science, Engineering & Technology, Erle C. Ellis, Ph.D., Cornell University, 1990 Professor, Geography & Environmental Systems University of Maryland, and Jessie C. Buettel, “What Is the Evidence for Planetary Tipping Points?” In Effective Conservation Science: Data Not Dogma, Chapter 8, Oxford University Press (2018). http://ecotope.org/people/ellis/papers/brook_2018.pdf

*The Nine Planetary Boundaries Brook Et Al. Refer Too Are, “Land-Use Change, Rate of Biodiversity Loss, Phosphorus Cycle, Global Freshwater Use, Ocean Acidification, Climate Change, Stratospheric Ozone Depletion, Atmospheric Aerosol Loading, Chemical Pollution, Terrestrial Net Primary Production, and Biodiversity Intactness”

As living standards, technological capacities,

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP (Climate NB) › A2 Ocean Acidification

No ocean acidification impact and CO2 increases ocean bio-d

Goklany, 15—independent scholar and author, member of the US delegation that established the IPCC and helped develop its First Assessment Report, he subsequently served as a US delegate to the IPCC, and an IPCC reviewer, he is a member of the GWPF’s Academic Advisory Council (Indur, “CARBON DIOXIDE: The good news”, http://www.thegwpf.org/content/uploads/2015/10/benefits1.pdf, dml)

Increasing carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere clearly increase the growth rate of land plants, other things being equal. Is the same true for marine photosynthesisers such as algae, phytoplankton and symbiotic zooxanthellae in corals? Carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater and there is good evidence that this causes enhanced growth rates in many taxa. This is despite the fact that dissolved carbon dioxide forms bicarbonate ions, which slightly decrease the pH of the water, leading to what is often inaccurately called ‘ocean acidification’. There is no likelihood of the ocean’s average pH getting anywhere near as low as 7 because of elevated carbon dioxide concentrations during the next three centuries. Ocean pH currently averages about 8 and is forecast to fall by 0.2 pH units or so during the present century. This change is considerably smaller than the difference in pH between different parts of the ocean, different days in the same part of the ocean, and even different times of day in coral reef lagoons. An examination of upper-ocean pH for a wide variety of ecosystems ranging from polar to tropical, open-ocean to coastal, kelp forest to coral reefs, indicates that variations in month-long pH spanned a range of 0.024 –1.430 pH units, and found that many organisms ‘are already experiencing pH regimes that are not predicted until 2100.’93 In other words, the projected change in pH is much smaller than the noise in its natural variation. So it is highly speculative that this small long-term trend will bring problems for marine life that are greater than the benefits of extra carbon dioxide for photosynthetic marine organisms and hence the whole marine biosphere.

Here follow some examples of studies finding positive or neutral impacts of lower pH on different groups of marine photosynthesisers:

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP (Climate NB) › Too Late

No climate change solvency—requires impossible international coordination

Falkner & Buzan 22

Robert, Associate Professor of International Relations and Research Director of the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment at the London School of Economics and Political Science, UK; Barry, Professor Emeritus at the London School of Economics and Political Science, UK, and a Senior Fellow at LSE IDEAS. “Introduction.” Great Powers, Climate Change, and Global Environmental Responsibilities. Pg 3. LJS

Climate change is one of the most pressing global challenges of the twenty-first century. To avert catastrophic global warming, international society needs to take urgent, and internationally coordinated, action. Although virtually all nations are united in their desire to tackle the man-made causes of global warming, they have yet to reverse the long-term trend of rising greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The Covid-19 pandemic provided temporary relief in that it led to a drop in global emissions by up to 7% in 2020 (UNEP, 2020), but the post-pandemic economic recovery seems likely to return the world to a path of rising emissions again. As yet, states’ climate policy intentions and emission pledges have proved to be inadequate. Climate change is a truly global problem, requiring all nations to undertake mitigation and adaptation measures. At the same time, the responsibility for causing the problem is unequally distributed, as is the capacity to respond to the climate threat in an effective manner. Two-thirds of current global emissions originate from just 10 major economies, and by and large it is the same countries that also have the economic and technological clout to develop and finance the required global solutions. Climate change and international power inequality are thus closely entwined. Indeed, if the major emitters were to act decisively and in a coordinated manner, the chances of averting a climate catastrophe would be much improved. By the same token, even if only some of them fail or refuse to act responsibly, the world faces a bleak future. The International Relations (IR) literature on global environmental politics (GEP) has tended to acknowledge, implicitly at least, the important role that a few select major powers play, either as international leaders that set an example for others and shape international environmental agendas, or as veto players that block progress in multilateral environmental negotiations (Kelemen and Vogel, 2010; Liefferink and Wurzel, 2017; Eckersley, 2020). GEP scholarship has also highlighted the inherent inequalities that structure the environmental policy area, both within societies and between them, and especially with regard to unequal levels of economic development and consumption levels (Roberts and Parks, 2007; Ciplet, Roberts, and Khan, 2015). However, questions of power asymmetry in international environmental politics, the nature of states’ environmental power, what counts as a great power in the environmental field, and whether great environmental power comes with special responsibilities have not attracted the kind of systematic attention in GEP that they deserve. This book seeks to fill that gap. By connecting the IR literature on great powers and great power responsibility with GEP scholarship, it develops a new analytical perspective on international power inequality and the role of environmental great powers in GEP, with a special focus on international climate politics. The contributions to this volume develop and apply a conceptual framework for the study of environmental great powers and their special international responsibilities. They examine how individual great powers have responded to the global climate challenge and whether they have accepted a special responsibility for stabilizing the global climate. And they place emerging discourses on great power responsibility in the context of wider debates about international environmental leadership and climate change securitization. Great Powers and the Global Climate Challenge The urgency of the climate change problem is now well understood. Man-made global warming, which is caused by GHG emissions from the burning of fossil fuels (coal, oil, gas) and land use changes (e.g. deforestation), has already led to a 1°C increase of average global temperatures since pre-industrial times. If current net emission trends continue unabated, the world is likely to face a global warming trend of between 3°C and 5°C by the end of the twenty-first century. The ecological consequences of such runaway global warming would be catastrophic. If left unchecked, climate change is expected to result in the melting of glaciers and rising sea levels, more extreme weather patterns, heat waves and wild fires even in arctic lands, the destruction of biologically diverse ecosystems, and changes in the amount, frequency, and intensity of precipitation. Some of these changes are already occurring (disappearance of glaciers, coral bleaching, wildfires) while others will only kick in at a later stage. The challenge for humanity is that the longer global warming is allowed to carry on, the stronger future ecological stresses will be and the sooner we may reach ecological tipping points that lock in large-scale and irreversible environmental damage (Lenton et al., 2019; Dalby, 2020). International society has recognized the threat that global warming poses to human well-being and prosperity. What is unclear, however, is whether the UN’s multilateral climate regime can quickly enough come up with an effective response. The 197 countries that negotiated the 2015 Paris Agreement to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) agreed to keep global warming to well below 2°C. In order to stay within this temperature target, they will need to bring GHG emissions under control, first by reaching a global emissions peak as soon as possible and then by bringing them down to reach a balance between GHG emissions and sinks (so-called net zero) by the second half of this century. All of this is to be achieved through a system of voluntary climate mitigation pledges that are to be reviewed internationally. The key question is whether the Paris Agreement’s framework for ratcheting up national climate ambitions can set the world on the path towards deep decarbonization, and within a timeframe that keeps global warming below 2°C (Falkner, 2016b). The past record of multilateral efforts is far from encouraging. Issue complexity, institutional inertia, and diverging national interests have turned climate change into a ‘wicked’ global problem that seems to exceed the problem-solving capacity of environmental multilateralism (Levin et al., 2012; Keohane and Victor, 2016).

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP (Climate NB) › Too Late

Climate extinction is inevitable—we already hit the tipping point and nothing can solve

Berardelli 21 (Jeff Berardelli is a meteorologist and climate specialist with a masters in Climate & Society fom Columbia University. “Climate tipping points may have been reached already, experts say,” CBS News. April 26 2021. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/climate-change-tipping-points-amazon-rainforest-antarctic-ice-gulf-stream/ )@ehatt

Through decades of research, and now lived experience, it has become clear that the impacts of climate change will have drastic and far-reaching consequences on our planet. And while some of those consequences are predictable — like more extreme weather, sea-level rise and loss of biodiversity — the pace at which these unfold and their eventual severity hinge on what happens with key linchpins in the climate system, called tipping points. A tipping point is a threshold or point of no return in the climate system that once passed can no longer be reversed. Passing a tipping point does not necessarily mean immediate, drastic consequences, but it does mean those consequences become unavoidable, and over time the impacts may be dramatic. In a 2019 paper, Professor Timothy Lenton, a global leader on the subject, identified nine climate tipping points, from melting permafrost in the Arctic to the loss of tropical coral reefs. Here we will focus on what he deems the three most critical tipping points: the Amazon rainforest, the West Antarctic ice sheet and the Gulf Stream system. Lenton highlights these three because the West Antarctic ice sheet may have already passed a tipping point; the Amazon because it is a crucial crucible of biodiversity and for its warehouse of carbon; and the Gulf Stream system because of its potential for profound changes with connected ramifications all around the planet. CBS News spoke to Lenton and several other scientists about the state of climate tipping points. While they have different areas of expertise, ranging from oceans to atmosphere to biosphere, their message was unanimous: Changes are happening faster than what was expected and the chance of hitting tipping points in the climate system, which just a decade ago appeared remote and far off, now seems much more likely and more immediate. "This is why I have been raising the alarm," Lenton said. "In just a decade the risk level has gone up markedly — that should be triggering urgent action." The Amazon rainforest For 55 million years the Amazon rainforest has weathered all of nature's ups and downs, but just one century of human negligence — a geological blink of an eye — threatens to be the nail in the coffin for this ancient forest. The Amazon is huge — almost the size of the contiguous United States. Home to an estimated 3 million species, about 10% of the Earth's known biodiversity, and half of the planet's remaining rainforest, the Amazon is among the most diverse places on Earth. But many experts believe the Amazon may have already entered tipping point territory. Having studied the Amazon for 56 years and visited hundreds of times, Dr. Thomas Lovejoy is one of those experts. "We are really right at that tipping point. We see the signs in longer dry seasons, hotter dry seasons, tree species that prefer drier conditions gaining dominance over those that prefer wet conditions," explains Lovejoy, a professor at George Mason University and founder of the Amazon Biodiversity Center. "So we know that it's right there at the tipping point right now." When Lovejoy started studying the Amazon in the 1960s, 10 million people lived there and the forest was 97% intact. Now there are 30 million people living there and deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon is at 20% — the critical level at which scientists believe the Amazon starts to tip towards the point of no return, where it no longer survives as a lush wet rainforest and transitions into an arid savanna. Lovejoy says this transition from rainforest to savanna could happen as fast as a mortgage cycle. "I would say it's a matter of something that happens on the timescale of decades like 10, 20, 30 years, not centuries. So, a lot of the people alive today would actually get to see that negative consequence." rainforest-to-savanna-in-20-years.png Some experts believe most of the Amazon rainforest could transition to drier savanna in just a few decades if we keep deforesting and warming. CBS NEWS Lenton is less sure. "I wish I knew how close we are to a tipping point," he said. But he agrees the signs are pointing in that direction. "We have work submitted showing early warning signs that the whole forest is losing resilience. I'd say that for the drier southeast side of the Amazon it is already under serious risk of fire-amplified loss." A rainforest is only a rainforest because it is a rain-making machine — generating 50% of its own rainfall. That phenomenon is made possible as the leaves that make up the canopy of trees exhale moisture upward (a process called evapotranspiration), condensing in the cooler air above and forming a river of clouds that rains the moisture back down. "Just by watching what happens after a rainfall in the Amazon and afterwards you see plumes of moisture coming up out of the canopy of the forest and that all moves westward to become rainfall once again, " explains Lovejoy. amazon-cbsnews.png A river of clouds forms over the Amazon as water vapor evaporates from the canopy of trees and condenses above. CBS NEWS But as the trees disappear and the forest becomes fractured, so does the moisture. Lovejoy says this destruction is due to fires and deforestation from small landowners grabbing land and to large corporations engaged in industrial agriculture, mainly growing soybeans and supporting livestock. In 2020, fires reached their highest number in a decade in the Brazilian Amazon and deforestation in the Amazon surged to its highest point in 12 years. Critics blame Brazil's President Jair Bolsonaro for looking the other way on enforcement of environmental regulations and even encouraging agriculture and mining activities, which undermine the health of the forest. Since the 1980s, NASA has observed a significant increase in something called the vapor pressure deficit (VPD) over the Amazon rainforest. The VPD is the difference, or gap, between the amount of moisture in the air and the amount it can hold. That gap is widening, which represents a drop in relative humidity, due to an increase in greenhouse warming from human-caused climate change and aerosols from biomass burning. amazon-vapor-pressure-def.png NASA measures more vapor pressure deficit increasing in the Amazon Basin over recent decades which means the atmosphere trend is toward a lower relative humidity. Overall it is an indicator of drying. NASA When the atmosphere is less humid, it has room for more moisture and it becomes more thirsty, pulling that moisture out of the ground and making the vegetation drier. This leads to more drought and is very similar to what is happening in California, which is making wildfires worse. Over the past century temperatures in the Amazon have risen by over 2 degrees Fahrenheit and in the past 50 years the dry season has expanded by a month. Lovejoy says the impacts of a transition of the Amazon rainforest to a more arid savanna would be devastating both locally and globally. Locally, the 30 million people who live there, many of them Indigenous, depend on the reliable rainfall produced by the rainforest. Significant loss of rain means an escalation of drought that may be devastating to agriculture. A drier Amazon would also mean a significant loss in biodiversity — the extinction of unique creatures which only exist in that one region. Globally, the Amazon rainforest is a tremendous repository for the planet's carbon, but if it becomes a savanna much of that carbon will be unleashed, magnifying climate change, "It does matter in a very, very big way in terms of the global carbon cycle and climate change," says Lovejoy. He estimates the forest contains a staggering 100 billion tons of carbon in its lush vegetation and soils — equivalent to about three times the amount of greenhouse gases emitted from the burning of fossil fuels each year. If the Amazon crosses the tipping point, "It not only absorbs a lot less, but all the forest that is being replaced by grassland, all that carbon ends up in the atmosphere," Lovejoy warns. Lovejoy says there is still hope we could stop this from happening, but the task is urgent. He says the nations which make up this unique ecosystem must cooperate and immediately work to reforest the Amazon. "There is a very urgent priority to move to a point where we are actually collectively managing the Amazon as a sustainable system," he said. West Antarctic ice sheet Of all the threats posed by climate change, sea level rise is arguably the biggest. That's because with billions of people living along the world's coastlines, rapid sea-level rise will force massive disruption. Given the immense amount of heat already absorbed in the ocean system due to human-caused climate change, there's no doubt several feet — and likely much more — of sea level rise is already locked in, but the question is how fast will it happen? The latest research finds that global warming thresholds that would trigger tipping points on both the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets are not that far away. The authors of a 2018 study find that these tipping points will likely occur between 1.5 and 2 degrees Celsius of global warming above pre-industrial levels — the level at which the Paris Climate Agreement aims to halt warming. The Earth has already warmed by 1.2 degrees, and 1.5 degrees of warming may be less than 15 years away. Because of the complexity of ice sheet dynamics, it is hard to know exactly when a tipping point will be reached, but Lenton warns we may already be there: "It is plausible we are already past a tipping point." With ice more than a mile thick and a size almost double the contiguous United States, the Antarctic landmass holds enough ice to raise sea levels by 200 feet. For decades it was assumed the frigid Antarctic ice sheet was fairly stable, so most glacier headlines were focused on the other massive ice sheet in Greenland. But in just the past few years, researchers have become alarmed at several areas in Antarctica which are showing signs of instability due to a warming climate and shifting ocean and atmosphere currents. The most pressing concern appears to be in West Antarctica — namely the Pine Island and Thwaites Glaciers. A paper published this past fall uncovered the rapid development over just the past decade of damage areas on the ice shelves of these two glaciers causing structural weakening which the authors say "preconditions these ice shelves for disintegration." pine-island-thwaites-nasa.jpg In West Antarctica, the Pine Island Glacier and Thwaites Glacier are becoming more unstable, shedding more ice to the sea, indicated in red. NASA Ice shelves are giant walls of ice floating on the oceans that act as dams on the edge of the glaciers, holding the land ice (ice sheets) behind them in place. If the ice shelves break apart, it's like pulling the cork out of a wine bottle: the ice behind it flows freely into the sea, raising sea levels. collapse.png Warm water undercut the ice shelf, breaking up the ice, allowing the ice sheet sheet behind it to become unstable and flow into the sea. CBS NEWS What makes the situation at Pine Island Glacier, and especially Thwaites Glacier, so precarious is that the ice shelves float far out over the sea. Warm water, about 2 degrees Celsius above the historical average, is now undercutting the marine ice. That is destabilizing the base of the ice shelf where it is propped up on land (called the grounding line) and accelerating its retreat. If and when the base of the glacier lifts off the ocean floor, it will no longer be supported by land and thus will become floating ice. Just like adding ice cubes to a glass, this raises the water level. Because Thwaites, also known as the Doomsday Glacier, is below sea-level, that means much more ice is vulnerable to warming seas. grounding-line-blue.jpg Pine Island and Thwaites Glaciers have significant ice shelves which float on the sea. Lately, warmer water is getting underneath, breaking up the ice shelf and eating away at the grounding line. As that happens, more of the ice floats off the sea bed and then adds to sea level rise. Since the backside of the glacier is below sea level, as the grounding line retreats, an increasingly thicker portion of the ice floats, adding even more to sea level rise. CREDIT: NATIONAL SNOW AND ICE DATA CENTER NSIDC, NASA A study published last month found early warning indicators of the onset of marine ice sheet instability, and thus the authors were able to identify distinct tipping points on Thwaites and Pine Island, but they did not give a timeline. If Thwaites Glacier collapses, sea levels would rise by 1.5 feet. If that collapse destabilized its neighbor Pine Island, sea level would rise 4 feet. And if the whole West Antarctic ice sheet collapsed, 10 feet of sea level rise would follow. While most scientists agree this is likely to unfold over centuries, not decades, increasingly ice experts are warning that higher-end estimates of sea-level rise are becoming more likely. In 2017, NOAA projected sea levels could rise 5 to 8 feet by 2100. Lenton agrees that if we are indeed in the midst of, or near, a tipping point, "It opens up the possibility that we could get greater than 1 meter (and perhaps up to 2 meters) of sea-level rise from all sources this century which would already have huge impacts." This kind of sea-level rise, over such a short time span, would threaten or displace hundreds of millions of people who live near rising waters, and the ramifications would ripple through much of human civilization "On the longer term it could mean a commitment has already been made to multi-meter sea level rise that will pose major challenges to future generations," warns Lenton. The fact that sea levels will rise dramatically is not a matter of scientific controversy and is all but assured. About 125,000 years ago, before the last Ice Age, sea level was likely at least 20 feet higher than it is today. At that time global temperatures were just a couple of degrees warmer than today. Three million years ago sea levels were 75 feet higher than today in a climate that was 4 degrees Fahrenheit warmer than now. So, over centuries and millennia, these types of sea-level rise are not just possible, they are probable. Even if humans were able to stop warming in the next few decades, temperatures equivalent to that last interglacial will likely be equaled. That's why experts say at least 20 feet of sea-level rise is inevitable. The critical question is will it happen gradually over many centuries, or will coastal regions be swallowed up in just decades? Oceanographer John Englander, author of the new book "Moving to Higher Ground," says this is a tough question to answer because sudden geophysical events, like the collapse of glaciers, are not accurately predictable — much like an earthquake, mudslide or avalanche. That's why Englander says we must look to history as a guide for what is possible. Since the last Ice Age, sea-level rise has not been linear and predictable. To the contrary, Englander explains, it has occurred in fits and starts, at times stable and at other times rising abruptly. "11,000 years ago, the last time that sea-level rise was rising quickly, it rose at about 15 feet per century. That's amazing, more than a foot a decade of sea level rise," Englander warns. "Now, there was more ice on the planet back then, but we are warming a lot faster now. So, in terms of looking for real-world historical rates, we could be looking at a foot a decade." sea-level-rise-since-lgm.jpg Since the last Ice Age peaked about 20,000 years ago, sea level has risen hundreds of feet. But sea-level rise is not linear; it can happen abruptly. 11,000 years ago sea level rose as much as 15 feet in one century. For our future, this is evidence sea level can rise fast again. JOHN ENGLANDER Right now, sea levels are rising at nowhere near those rates, only at about 2 inches per decade, but rates are doubling every decade. To help illustrate the power of doubling, in his book Englander uses the analogy of how long it would take to fill a soccer stadium with water if you started with a single drop of water and doubled it every minute. The answer is shocking: only 47 minutes! Englander says the point is that small changes in sea-level rise today will mount quickly over the decades, and if tipping points are crossed, society should be prepared for abrupt changes. That's why he says it would be wise for nations to invest in preparation now and not wait for the inevitable water to come. The Gulf Stream system Lenton described a potential tipping point in the Gulf Stream system as "profound." That's because the Atlantic Ocean circulation is a linchpin in Earth's climate system. It is the driving force behind the Global Ocean Conveyor Belt (pictured below) and transports 20% of the excess heat which accumulates at the Equator towards the Northern Hemisphere polar regions. This is how Earth attempts to balance out unequal heating from the sun, and the flux of heat is a big factor controlling weather patterns. What concerns scientists is that this current is slowing down. In fact, a new study found it is moving the slowest it has in at least 1,600 years and may decrease speed by up to 45% by 2100, possibly tipping the circulation into collapse. ocean-conveyor.png WMO Before we go any further, it is worth mentioning that the Gulf Stream system is a newly popularized nickname for the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC for short). One look at that name and it's clear why the Gulf Stream system may be preferable. But in that AMOC name there are some clues as to why this current system is so important. "Meridional" means transport in a north-to-south or south-to-north direction. And "overturning" implies that the current moves vertically as well. So this current is the engine that propels ocean heat to the ends of the Earth. gulf-stream-current-2.jpg CBS NEWS Being that it takes any one water parcel around 1,000 years to complete a full journey, anything we do today lingers in the system for a great many generations. We have already done a lot. Each year ocean heat content hits a new record high because 93% of the excess heat trapped by greenhouse gases is stored in the ocean. That's equivalent to 5 Hiroshima atomic bombs worth of heat per second. This is a big reason why ice melt has already locked in 20 feet or more of future sea-level rise. But this ice melt poses another problem, because everything is connected. Accelerated meltwater from Greenland ice is rushing into the North Atlantic. That combined with heavier rainfall is likely responsible for a slowdown of the AMOC by 15% since 1950. Here's how it works. In the North Atlantic, east of Greenland, water is cold, salty and dense. Therefore it sinks. That vertical movement of the AMOC is the driving force, the momentum which keeps the whole system moving. But the water is changing in this region. That's because, according to NASA, a warmer climate is melting ice at 6 times the rate of the 1990s. That is pumping a layer of fresh water — which is not as heavy — into the North Atlantic, resulting in a decreased ability to sink, slowing down the overturning. gulf-stream-current-5-new.jpg CBS NEWS Michael Mann, a distinguished professor of atmospheric science at Penn State, authored the 2015 paper which found the 15% slowdown in the AMOC, which he calls "unprecedented" in recent history. "The Greenland ice sheet appears to be disintegrating decades ahead of schedule and so that fresh water, as that ice melts, runs off into the North Atlantic earlier than we expected it to," Mann explains. Mann says some of the evidence for the impact this is having in the North Atlantic is right there in plain sight. While the vast majority of Earth is warming, a big "cold blob" near Greenland sticks out like a sore thumb — as seen in the maps below. earth-warming-compare-ed-hawkins.jpg Top: Areas that have warmed since 1950 are shaded in red. Notice the blue hole south of Greenland, evidence of the slowing of the AMOC. Bottom: Shows temperature changes relative to other regions. The red is the fastest warming areas. The blue are the areas warming less fast, or even cooling. Particularly apparent is the cold blob south of Greenland. DR. ED HAWKINS Mann says this colder region is a "fingerprint" for the slowdown of the AMOC. It's a result of a decrease in heat transfer northbound due to the slowing of the Gulf Stream. And Mann warns this is all happening much faster than projected. "The observations tell us we are about 50 years, or more, ahead of where the climate models say we should be at this point," he said. The mounting evidence, and the speed at which changes are taking place, lead Mann to believe that a collapse of the current is possible. "It's hard to rule out the scenario of a full on collapse sometime in the next few decades. We have continued to be surprised by how fast some of these processes appear to be playing out." Lenton agrees and says while he may not be alive to see it, the next generation could be. "A collapse this century can't be ruled out (so within my kids lifetimes)," he said. Given the major amount of heat displaced by the AMOC, if the current slows dramatically or stops, weather patterns would be thrown off-kilter in the Northern Hemisphere and extreme weather would escalate. In addition, Mann says it would have a direct effect on the Atlantic Ocean, pushing sea level up by a foot along the U.S. Eastern Seaboard and impacting fish stocks in the North Atlantic. Lenton believes the impacts would be profound. "Western Europe would have to try and adapt to a completely different climate. Major monsoons could shift, in a bad way, e.g. in India and West Africa." To put it simply, Lenton says, "It would change the world." While some of these tipping points are now only decades away, or perhaps even upon us, scientists say we can still avert worse disaster if we act now. This argument is bolstered by new research from the University of Exeter which shows the disastrous consequences of climate "tipping points" could be averted if global warming was reversed quickly enough — concluding that thresholds could be "temporarily exceeded" without prompting permanent shifts. We may still pass some of these tipping points, but the less we warm the Earth, the slower the impacts will unfold, and the more time our children and grandchildren will have to adapt to the changes.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP (Climate NB) › UBS Increase CC

UBS increases climate change

Vogt-Schilb 22 --- Adrien Vogt-Schilb, Inter-American Development Bank, Providencia, Chile. 11/10/2022 (“Solving poverty need not cost the Earth”. Nature Sustainability. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-022-00999-1#auth-Adrien-Vogt_Schilb. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.)

Rammelt and colleagues go on to elucidate that, given current technology and lifestyles, universal access to basic services would gravely exacerbate climate change but only marginally affect the other environmental indicators they consider. Greenhouse gas emissions would increase anywhere from 15% to 26%, depending on whether the low or high thresholds are used; while pressure on water and land ecosystems would rise more modestly, between 2% and 4%. For context, the authors show that these numbers correspond to the environmental footprint of the those in the top 1–4% of the income distribution.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP › 2AC PDB

UBI and UBS lift those out of poverty and secure regular income for all

Gordon 2020 [ Isky Gordon, Professor, “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME & UNIVERSAL BASIC SERVICES: HOW CAN WE BRING THEM TOGETHER?” Rethinking Poverty, Oct 1, 2020, ]

The goals of UBI and UBS are to improve the conditions of people’s daily lives – the circumstances in which people are born, grow, live, work, and age – as well as to tackle the inequitable distribution of power, money, and resources. The aim of this article is to begin a discussion between the proponents of UBI and UBS to identify common ground and to join forces to confront the failed neoliberal financial and social policies of the last few decades. Three crises, financial of 2008, Brexit and Covid-19 have created a unique situation where big change is possible. Climate emergency must be at the forefront of all future policies made to improve people’s lives, including development and support for a new Green Deal. UBI will give money to individuals on an unconditional basis while with UBS individuals will need to claim money, both guarantee an income. Both envisage that certain benefits (e.g. housing and disability) would remain. Both aim to lift the poorest out of poverty, and to provide a level of security. This freedom will allow self-development and open new choices and opportunities. How to achieve these goals is where contentions appear. Both approaches demand a high level of state resources, so what to prioritise raises big questions. Deciding level of income and eligibility, are critical questions for both approaches; predicting the effect (and unintended consequences) on, for example, employment, consumerism, individual and collective responsibility, concerns both approaches. UBI and UBS have different underlying philosophical approaches, UBI is based on universality and the individual. UBS has its basis on an improved social wage. Referred to by many as Basic Income (BI). This policy focuses narrowly on monetary income. UBI is universal, every citizen automatically receiving a basic income, distribution is easy, and bureaucracy reduced to some degree. The role of the state, outside provision of the money, is not stated explicitly. The negative aspects of UBI include promoting individualism as well as reinforcing the current value system: consumerism and money. It is noteworthy that Google’s Foundation is a major funder of GiveDirectly’s UBI pilot while and Silicon Valley Company Y-Combinator is funding a $60 million experiment in UBI, one recognises how UBI supports neoliberal philosophy. UBI does not address the climate emergency directly. UBS policy is for provision of comprehensive public services according to need not ability to pay, combined with a guaranteed minimum income for all. UBS is based on shared needs, collective responsibility and sustainable development and its proponents consider it part of a Green New Deal. UBS calls for a customised approach to each area of need, with emphasis on devolved and democratic control, active engagement of residents and service users, enforceable rights of access to services, phasing out for-profit provision. The state will have five key roles: ensure equality of access for all, to raise, distribute and invest funds, to set and enforce standards, to provide directly where appropriate, and to support and coordinate a range of service providers across sectors. I have assumed that the principle of universality remains for both UBI and BI. Both UBI and UBS support the principle of a guaranteed secure regular income for all. Under UBI money payments are intended to be unconditional, automatic and universal. UBS focuses primarily on enhancing the ‘virtual’ income derived from services which has a substantial value. This ‘virtual’ income is coupled with a guaranteed minimum income which people claim when their income falls below an agreed level of sufficiency. The cost of providing a sufficient income for all on the one hand and comprehensive services for all on the other is huge. As resources will be limited, some compromises are being sought. For example, some supporters of UBI are currently talking about BI for selected groups only, and UBS supporters are considering a range of ways in which the costs of services can be covered without compromising quality or accessibility for all. A major issue between UBI and UBS is the universality of UBI, because this requires far more resources than the Minimum Income Guaranteed proposed by UBS. Expanding in-kind benefits to all is highly redistributive because these services are worth so much more to low-income families, thus providing security and stability. Currently most people are obliged to pay for rent, transport, adult social care, child care, further education and other services. Both UBI and UBS aim for the creation of new jobs and training. Improving and extending services can help create secure employment at all skills levels. UBI can supplement low and intermittent wages. Will both UBI and UBS be equally successful in developments such as housing with universal access according to need, sustainable energy, a connected transport system reliable and affordable to all, universal free digital communication? The current crises in care for the elderly, disabled and children as well as in healthcare show that reconstruction is essential and the same is true for education. What’s needed here is a principled framework to guide policy and practice.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP › 2AC PDB

The perm solves – UBI and UBS can work together

Buchs 22 (Milena Buchs, Professor of Sustainable Welfare at the Sustainability Research Institute, University of Leeds, United Kingdom, “Sustainable welfare: would a mix of universal basic income and universal basic services help?” United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization Policy Lab, 2-2-2022, https://en.unesco.org/inclusivepolicylab/analytics/sustainable-welfare-would-mix-universal-basic-income-and-universal-basic-services-help)

Given the right contexts, UBI and UBS can complement each other in supporting sustainable welfare. UBS are well suited to cater for needs where risk pooling and redistribution of resources is required (e.g., health and social care; public transport) or where goods and services are relatively uniform, like water, electricity or internet access. However, markets will still be required in a sustainable society to cater for needs where personal preferences and circumstances play a more important role, for instance for food or clothing. A partial UBI to support needs satisfaction in these areas, combined with market regulations that ensure environmentally friendly and socially just production, can make an important contribution here. Combining UBS and UBI could be achieved by expanding universal service provision to directly cater for people’s needs while also introducing an unconditional universal income for everyone to address needs for which market provisioning is likely to remain important. As argued above, UBI could be paid at a lower level in this context to avoid financial competition between the two schemes (Büchs, 2021).

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP › UBS No S

UBS is not universal and result in stigmitization

Painter 17 --- Anthony Painter is Chief Research & Impact Officer (CRIO). Anthony leads the RSA’s Research and Impact team, overseeing our research, policy, publications and practical innovation. Anthony is an award winning policy and social innovator. He leads the RSA’s social change work covering economic security, future of work, education, lifelong learning, local democracy and regenerative futures. He has been a leading voice, writer and presenter on the RSA’s platforms for almost a decade. 10/16/2017 (“Universal Basic Services or Universal Basic Income?” https://www.thersa.org/blog/2017/10/universal-basic-services-or-universal-basic-income. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.)

A new and welcome voice in the debate came from UCL’s Institute for Global Prosperity last week. As an alternative approach to UBI, their proposal is for universal basic services including access to mobile and internet, housing, food, and transport at a cost of 2% or so of GDP per annum. Would this be a better way to go than the politically challenging route of UBI?

On the face of it, it is attractive. The politics of giving people services rather than cash seems easier. The NHS is founded in just this way. The report finds that the maximum value of this approach is £126 per week. The same money distributed as a UBI would deliver just £12.47 a week. Slam dunk right? Not so fast.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP › UBS No S

Providing free food and housing as part of UBS program is near impossible – too difficult to know who needs it.

Standing 19 (Guy, professorial research associate at SOAS University of London, technical adviser to the basic income pilot, “Why ‘Universal Basic Services’ is no alternative to Basic Income,” Open Democracy, 6/6/2019, https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/why-universal-basic-services-is-no-alternative-to-basic-income/)

For a start, what is being proposed is not ‘universal’ in any accepted use of the word. For instance, the provision of ‘free food’ under the UBS banner is deceptive. According to the UBS scheme, the state would provide "one-third of the meals for the 2.2 million households deemed to experience food insecurity each year". That is not universal. It is targeted. Identifying those suffering from food insecurity would necessarily imply means-testing or some complex test of ‘food insecurity’. As with all targeted schemes, many of those eligible would not be reached, while those receiving the free food would, as a result, face an even greater poverty trap and accompanying precarity trap than exist in the British welfare state today. The Department for Work and Pensions itself estimates that going from means-tested benefits into the sort of low-paid job claimants could obtain results in only a 20% increase in net income – a poverty trap of 80%. If they also lost ‘free food’, the net gain would be even less.

The proposal would also generate a new moral hazard. Someone deemed food insecure, and thus entitled to free meals, would have a disincentive to become food secure, unless the free food on offer was lousy (which could hardly be a policy objective, even though it is likely to be a policy outcome). That moral hazard would be accompanied by an equally perverse immoral hazard, since some people would have an incentive to become food insecure deliberately in order to claim free meals.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › UBS CP › UBS No S

UBS isn’t actually universal and incentivizes people to stay food and housing insecure to receive benefits

Standing 19 (Guy Standing, professorial research associate at SOAS University of London, " Why ‘Universal Basic Services’ is no alternative to Basic Income," openDemocracy, 6-6-2019, https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/why-universal-basic-services-is-no-alternative-to-basic-income/)

The proposal would also generate a new moral hazard. Someone deemed food insecure, and thus entitled to free meals, would have a disincentive to become food secure, unless the free food on offer was lousy (which could hardly be a policy objective, even though it is likely to be a policy outcome). That moral hazard would be accompanied by an equally perverse immoral hazard, since some people would have an incentive to become food insecure deliberately in order to claim free meals. Providing ‘the poor’ with free food would extend the charity state and institutionalise the obnoxious system of ‘food banks’, which have mushroomed in the austerity era. The mass provision of free food would also risk more waste of food. However well-intentioned the charity state might be, people receiving free goods tend to value them less and treat them with less care than if they pay for them. In practice, the choice of what food to make free would be arbitrary, based on paternalistic views of what is good for ‘the poor’ and what is not. Those countries that have implemented highly subsidised food have not had great success with it. And there is the likely effect of stigmatisation of food support claimants, as has been the case in the USA with food stamps. Many are so ashamed to show their poverty that they forego their entitlement. The next UBS on the advocates’ list is free basic housing. That would not be a ‘universal’ service either, since it would be ‘offered on a needs basis’. All the problems related to targeted provision of free food would apply here too. How would ‘need’ be determined without a means test? What would happen if people no longer ‘needed’ the basic housing – would they be evicted? Incentives to become ‘in need’ to qualify for free housing would be enormous, unless the ‘basic’ housing was so unattractive as to weed out all but the truly desperate, increasing their marginalisation in new ‘sink estates’. Perhaps unsurprisingly, in the latest advocacy of UBS, ‘universal’ free food and free housing are not mentioned at all, while free childcare and adult social care make an appearance instead. So, in this manifestation, two of the most basic of needs – food and shelter – are effectively regarded as not basic. And as free childcare and adult social care were not costed by the original report proposing universal basic services, £42 billion is likely to be a considerable underestimate. With the added services, UBS would surely be a good deal more expensive than its proponents claim. The latest report on UBS cites an estimate of £33 billion (1.8 per cent of GDP) for the gross cost of providing free childcare, with workers providing it paid the minimum wage. The cost is then finessed down to a lowly £1.7 billion by assuming employment gains, higher tax receipts and reduced income support payments. But in a sleight of hand, in asserting that UBS would cost much less than basic income, UBS proponents cite only what they claim would be the gross cost of a basic income, not a net cost. Yet the difference between gross and net costs could be expected to be even larger in the case of basic income since, apart from savings in benefit expenditure, the basic income would effectively be clawed back from those on higher incomes through the tax system.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Cap K › 2AC – L/T UBI stops Capitalism

UBI is a part of a series of Marxist reforms that will solve ecological disaster and increase productivity.

Duffy 19 [Simon Duffy, Simon has a doctorate in moral philosophy and writes on the welfare state, citizenship, social justice and inclusion. Key publications include Unlocking the Imagination (1996), Keys to Citizenship (2003) Women at the Centre (2011) A Fair Income (2011) Peer Power (2012) and The Unmaking of Man (2013).  The Marxist Case for Basic Income ,May 7, 2019 MP]

What makes Mason’s Marxism different to these competing aristocratic, rational and revolutionary forms is his commitment to cooperation (which he calls peer to peer exchange) and his view that emerging technological change has put us on the cusp of a deeper social and economic changes that can move us beyond capitalism. Mason stresses the emergence of networks, cooperative systems, free public goods and the possibility of abundance as the real basis for replacing capitalism. His challenge is that the current economic system is stuck in a form of late capitalism, which is failing, and that future reform requires a complex transition away from neoliberalism and towards a postcapitalist world of high productivity and networked cooperation. Hence basic income is only one element of a reformed system; Mason proposes a series of economic reforms, and in particular taking complete control over energy production, in order to rapidly move the planet onto a sustainable path to a world where we are able to enjoy increasing amounts of free time. In a sense Mason is trying to combine two different traditions on the Left. On the one hand, mutualism, which is not really a Marxist tradition, but which values equality, cooperation and community as the natural forms of social justice. On the other hand there is the historical-materialist Marxist tradition which is strongly committed to the idea that social developments are underpinned by the form of productive life that sustain itself, but which will then evolve around the emergence of new technologies. Mason is arguing that mutualism is the essence of postcapitalism, but that it can only really emerge and thrive if we manage the complex transition away from the current system towards a new model which will require radically different systems of democratic control, financing and management. There is so much going on in Mason’s book that it is impossible to make any simple judgements about it. It is an exciting vision of the future, and also an education in the fractured world of Marxist theory. Even if you are not a convinced Marxist it is hard to resist his analysis of the global economic, political and environment crisis we face today. It is exciting and encouraging to see that basic income, while no panacea, may not only help us move our world away from ecological disaster, but could also help create the productivity gains that will be essential to move the whole human population out of poverty and into a world of equal citizenship. Certainly, as UBI Lab Sheffield itself demonstrates, there are very many of us who are willing to use our free time, despite the costs of our precarity, to advance social justice and to seek a shift in power towards citizens and to our local communities. So we are ourselves living proof of the existence of networked individuals who are willing to come together to think and act, not because we are being paid, but because we think the work is important.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Cap K › 2AC – L/T UBI stops Capitalism

UBI is in fact, a struggle against a Capitalist society. UBI will lead to reform

Sculos, 18 [Bryant W. Sculos, Born and raised on Cape Cod, Massachusetts, I earned a Bachelor of Arts dually at the Maxwell School and College of Arts and Sciences of Syracuse University in Political Philosophy and History (with a minor in Global Political Economy) in May of 2011. I began my graduate work at FIU in the Fall of 2011. My research interests are driven by a deep respect for dialectical thinking and practically-oriented theorizing, and broadly include normative political theory, Critical Theory (including the IR variants), and global ethics—specifically cosmopolitanism. My dissertation uses Theodor Adorno and Erich Fromm to offer an immanent critique of various theories of cosmopolitanism and post-Marxism. I have taught Modern and Contemporary Political Theory and Political Ideologies. My work has been published in New Politics, the Marx & Philosophy Review of Books, and Class, Race, and Corporate Power. Class, Race, and Corporate Power. Florida International University, 2018

(3) The idea that an expansive UBI program could not be a direct challenge to capitalism is frankly laughable. There are two main reasons why a subsistence UBI (or higher) could be a challenge to capitalism, but it is important to note that in the very short-term there is the chance of some increase in stability brought to the capitalist system by the Keynesian effects of the policy, if enacted in even a single globally-crucial economy like the US, the EU, or even China or India. 5 This stability would be short-lived and could lead to progress towards socialism, for the reasons that follow. 4 In his book Raising the Floor: How a Universal Basic Income Can Renew Our Economy and Rebuild the American Dream, Stern attributes this insight to Timothy Roscoe Carter (PublicAffiars, 2016: pg. 188). 5 This is especially important when it comes to speculating about the costs of implementing a UBI program in various countries. The cost would be extraordinarily high, but that is only a death sentence for UBI if one assumes relatively similar growth rates as we have today (between roughly 1% and 4% depending on the specific economy or measure). Increased growth combined with a dedicated tax on higher income earners, inheritance, luxury properties (e.g., second and third homes, cars, and/or boats), and investment incomes would likely be enough to pay for a substantial UBI with little negative impact on anyone. Now, relying on the potential for consumer-driven growth is a dangerous proposition for the Left to accept given the planetary harms already done due to the growth-fetishizing economic logic of capitalism. However, if short-term consumer growth, driven by UBI, was channeled through green technologies and processes alongside a corollary demand that existing production be progressively reorganized to meet different consumer demands than the manipulated desires that are produced by capitalism in the same way that the physical products are, it is possible that further ecological damage would be sufficiently mitigated (especially when compared with existing trends). A low-carbon economy is also more likely to be achieved than the zero-carbon economy we need, but it seems reasonable to assume that progress towards a low-carbon economy would make eventually achieving a zero-carbon economy more likely. This is not a speculation or qualification that is rooted in optimism though. The planet and its various inhabitants—especially those already excessively harmed by the existing order—are already between a rock and hard (warm, wet) place. No amount of wishful thinking can change that. Low-carbon consumer growth could create an increase in the tax base large enough to sustain a UBI for a few decades, and it will be in those decades that the broader struggle against capitalism will be waged. It is also important to note that the typical alternative to UBI heralded by the Left is a combination of full employment and a shorter work week (see Daniel Zamora’s “The Case Against a Basic Income,” in Jacobin [Dec. 28, 2017] for a recent iteration of this false alternative). If one is primarily concerned about the ecological impact of a growth economy, full employment and a shorter work week fail to offer any necessarily more feasible path towards a The first reason builds on the points made under the previous section: a subsistence UBI that did not replace existing, or was implemented alongside expanded, social welfare programs would require a mass movement in order to be achieved. It would also take workers in enormous numbers out of the realm of necessity and closer to the realm of freedom (as described by Marx). With a subsistence UBI, workers would no longer be forced to work at low-paying, degrading, unsafe, or mindless jobs. These jobs would then likely become the first sites of full automation. If systematically-compelled wage-labor is the sine qua non of the capitalist mode of production, then a subsistence-or-above UBI would be a direct challenge to the foundation of capitalism. Secondly, a thick UBI could change how people think about their value in society. By declaring, not with mere rhetoric, but with serious policy, that all people, regardless of status, effort, place of birth, gender, race, sexuality, or any other category, are worthy of the dignity of the means to support themselves, society has a powerful opportunity to evolve in a more just and democratic direction. It wouldn’t necessarily be a smooth transition, but it would certainly provide the basis for a practicable transition from capitalism to an egalitarian democratic postcapitalism (i.e., socialism). These two points are in direct opposition to the position articulated by Daniel Zamora in Jacobin. 6 Zamora argues that UBI reinforces the market ideology by simply allowing more people to participate in consumption. What Zamora misses (though this is basically true of most socialist critics of UBI) is the progressive decommodification of work and life in general that UBI can contribute to. If I don’t have to work or don’t want to work under undemocratic or unsafe conditions, I wouldn’t have to. Yes, labor would still be commodified to some degree— but not universally or necessarily. In the same way that we could imagine a world where basic necessities are not commodified but luxury goods could be. With an expansive UBI, I wouldn’t be required to sell my labor to survive. And while there would certainly still be a market for consumer goods at this stage, buying goods in the market is not the defining trait of capitalism. With an expansive UBI, the connection between structurally-coerced labor and one’s ability to live a (decent) life—the foundational relationship of the capitalist mode of production—would be progressively severed.7 Imagine the creative “work” people could participate in of their own accord if they didn’t have to “get a job” to survive.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Turn Answers › AT: Immigration Turn

A UBI would push past racial exclusions – historically proven. The risk of exclusion does not eliminate the need to adopt a UBI

Warren, 2017 – Fellow at the Roosevelt Institute [Dorian, May 3, Boston Review, “Reparations and Basic Income Basic income could function as reparations.” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

Rogers is spot on to warn us that basic income could be “designed to serve white nationalist ends.” We know this from our own historical experience. Seemingly “universal” social policies, from the New Deal to the Great Society, have had intended and unintended consequences of maintaining or exacerbating existing racial and gender inequalities. Many supposedly “universal” policies ultimately were not. But Rogers’s rightful skepticism and warning about a white nationalist basic income comes down to a question of political power. President Franklin D. Roosevelt compromised on his New Deal programs because southern Democrats insisted on it. The race-based occupational exclusions of agricultural and domestic workers were ultimately included in Social Security, the National Labor Relations Act, and the Fair Labor Standards Act to appease political elites protecting the southern Jim Crow racial and economic regime over the protests of racial justice organizations. Black workers were excluded as a result of this previous iteration of white nationalism and populism. But advocates for a truly universal social policy did not give up, eventually winning racial inclusion in Social Security but not the other two major New Deal policies. Similarly we should not limit our political imaginations about the promise of a basic income because of the very perilous questions around race, immigration, and exclusion. Quite the opposite. We should imagine a robust basic income that advances racial and gender justice while simultaneously addressing the ills of twenty-first-century capitalism.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Turn Answers › AT: Immigration Turn

A UBI includes undocumented migrants and non-residents

Standing 2019 - research associate at the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London [Guy, 6 June 2019, “Why ‘Universal Basic Services’ is no alternative to Basic Income” Acc 3/23/23 TA]

So much for the limitations of what is actually proposed under UBS. But the proponents go further in provocatively presenting UBS as preferable to ‘UBI’ (Universal Basic Income). Before considering this claim, I want to make it clear that sensible advocates of basic income do not or should not use the word ‘universal’, because in practice some people would not be entitled to it – non-resident citizens and short-term or undocumented migrants. Presumably something similar would apply with UBS. That pragmatic matter aside, services and basic income have different objectives and justifications. Therefore, different criteria should be used to assess their desirability.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Turn Answers › AT: Costs

Turn – Revenue will increase after a UBI is established by 100-200 billion annually.

Cheng & Maass 20 --- Alex Cheng & Andreas Maass. Writers for Berkeley Economic Review 2/25/2020 (“Unboxing Universal Basic Income”. Berkeley Economic Review. https://econreview.berkeley.edu/unboxing-universal-basic-income/. Date Accessed: 6-22-2023.)

Another consideration against UBI is how the state will pay for the $4.3 trillion program. Yang’s proposal for funding the Freedom Dividend includes the reduction of some current welfare programs and a Value Added Tax (VAT). Essentially, Yang argues that a monthly income of $1,000 would be more beneficial to many welfare recipients than the United States’ current programs. Thus, he would offer those on welfare the opportunity to choose between their current welfare programs and UBI, predicting that the vast majority will elect for the cash influx. This shift is projected to save nearly $500  in revenue for the government. The second arm of this funding plan is a VAT, which has been  in more than 140 countries worldwide, including every other economically advanced nation, and is projected to generate between $100 and $200 billion for the US in annual revenue. Essentially, the VAT taxes the value that each member of a product’s supply chain adds to the final cost of the product. As a result, the VAT is deemed a highly effective method of redistributing wealth, as it taxes corporations at every step of their involvement in a product. Finally, the economic growth that the UBI is predicted to foster will lead to a general increase in sales tax revenue and income tax revenue for the federal government. This tax revenue will be the final piece in UBI funding and account for . Putting these funds together, the money is in the budget for this type of federal expenditure, but it definitely puts a significant stress on other welfare programs and would likely lead to the eradication of many of them.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Solvency › S – Mental Health

CP alleviates worries that people with mental health issues face

Peterson, 20 – Mental Health Nurse

[Ashley L. Peterson, “Benefits of Universal Basic Income for People with Mental Illness,” Mental Health @ Home, 11-23-2020, https://mentalhealthathome.org/2020/11/23/universal-basic-income-mental-illness/, accessed 6-23-2023]

Support for UBI from a mental health perspective comes from multiple perspectives, ranging from the , Canada’s major mental health non-profit organization, to the anti-psychiatry-leaning site Mad in America. UBI may help to prevent mental illness to some extent by influencing the . The stress associated with poverty is an important risk factor for mental illness, and guaranteeing people an income to meet basic needs would allow people to shift from a focus on surviving to finding ways to meet higher-level needs in Maslow’s . For people with mental illness who are able to work, having the safety net of UBI could be important if illness necessitated a period of time off since many workers don’t have much (if any) paid sick time. I used to work at a well-paying unionized job with pretty good sick-time benefits, but when I was hospitalized, I ran out of sick time and had to take unpaid leave. UBI could also alleviate some of the worries about what might happen if the illness progresses to the point that working just isn’t possible. Applying for disability benefits can be a stressful process, particularly if an appeal is needed. process definitely has certainly had a negative impact on my mental health. Luckily, my application was approved, but my total monthly benefit is less than the average monthly benefit in the city where I live. If I hadn’t paid off the mortgage on my home while I was still working, I would have to a) move out of my city to somewhere that rent is cheaper, and b) rely on food banks to eat. Work on a limited basis For some people with mental illness, regular employment might be out of reach, but working on a casual basis could allow them to remain in the workforce longer. UBI could make that feasible from a financial perspective.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Solvency › S – Mental Health

A UBI program can decrease the underpinnings of some mental health issues by ensuring basic needs are met.

Smith, 20 – Professor in Health History

[Matthew Smith, “Universal basic income could improve the nation's mental health,” Conversation, 4-27-2020, https://theconversation.com/universal-basic-income-could-improve-the-nations-mental-health-123816, accessed 6-23-2023]

Many are talking about (UBI) these days. Giving everyone a guaranteed income could be the solution to many economic woes. But one factor that hasn’t been mentioned much in discussions of UBI is how it might improve our mental health. in the mid-20th century showed that mental illness was often caused by , and . Responding to such findings, the US Joint Commission on Child Mental Health published in 1969. The report was the work of 500 child mental health experts. One of its chief recommendations to prevent mental illness was to provide all Americans with a “guaranteed minimum income”, or UBI. Crisis in Child Mental Health was distributed widely to politicians, policymakers and physicians. But its message about UBI wasn’t heeded. Could it be revisited today? Poverty One of the main arguments for UBI is that it would . Recent research has linked the of poverty with in the brain, leading some to suggest that could be the solution. But what about eliminating poverty altogether? UBI could be set at a level to ensure that everyone’s basic needs are met. This would reduce much of the stress faced by the working poor or families on benefits. Today, these families are often forced to use or go into debt to pay for necessities. The working poor often have to rely on food banks. Andy Rain/EPA People today are also vulnerable to changes in the benefits system that may make them ineligible for benefits. The introduction of the in 2013, for instance, was . The consequences of these rule changes were also highlighted in . Since UBI is universal, there is no means testing. It would increase in line with inflation to ensure that people were kept out of poverty. Other measures could also be introduced alongside UBI to prevent inflation. Governments could create schemes to provide better access to affordable fresh local food. Providing free public transportation in cities would also mitigate against people’s expenses increasing too much. Rent controls would help curb inflation, too. Getting rid of means testing would also free up those running the benefits system. Benefits workers are typically gatekeepers – as is powerfully portrayed in I, Daniel Blake. Their time is spent screening out the ineligible, not helping those who need it. I have personal experience that is comparable to this situation. During the late 1990s, I worked for a charity as a youth counsellor and career advisor in Edmonton, Canada. Although those were my job titles, I spent precious little time counselling or providing career advice to young people who were not in school or work. What I actually did was determine whether my clients met the criteria for government funding to go back to school. The complexity of the application process and the numerous rules recipients had to follow to keep their funding prevented me from doing much else. My time would have been much better spent helping these young people overcome the numerous barriers they faced. Many had psychological problems, had been victims of abuse, had criminal records and addictions. These problems tended to be ignored until they flared up and jeopardised the client’s funding status. One of the reasons we persist in this gatekeeping approach is that the benefits systems in the UK, Canada and elsewhere retain the Victorian idea that there are . This idea inspired the (1834), which introduced the workhouse system depicted in . It persists in television programmes, such as Channel 4’s . Benefits workers should instead be redeployed to help people deal with difficult, intractable problems, including mental illness and addictions. They could also provide people with career guidance and counselling. Such work would serve to improve mental health, not worsen it. UBI would also help people, usually women and children, to . Domestic abuse occurs more often in poorer households, where financial means to escape. makes it for women to leave abusive situations. Similarly, UBI might prevent believed to lead to mental illness and other problems later in life. experiencing violence or abuse, or having parents with mental health, substance abuse and legal problems. Behind these problems are often poverty, inequality and social isolation. Inequality Inequality also encompasses a lack of opportunity, class bias, disenfranchisement, low self-worth and often racism. It results in hopelessness that can trigger depression, anxiety, addictions and other health problems. Inequality has featured in recent studies on . This includes Pickett and Wilkinson’s and . Pickett and Wilkinson show that rates of mental illness are highest in . Although mental illness is diagnosed , the authors also found that socioeconomic inequalities lead to higher rates of drug abuse, obesity, infant mortality, teenage pregnancy and other social and health problems. Put simply, . UBI can erode inequality in many ways. Unlike benefits, UBI is provided to all, regardless of class or income. There would be no stigma or shame associated with receiving it. UBI would also help with social mobility. It would facilitate further education, entrepreneurial activity, artistic endeavours and career changes. People intent on leaving unrewarding jobs could rely on it while they found something more meaningful. Above all, UBI would prevent some of the hopelessness and shame associated with deprivation. It would help to prevent so-called , which include suicide, chronic liver disease and drug and alcohol poisoning. Social exclusion Social psychiatry showed that social isolation is bad for mental health. This was regardless of whether a person lived in or . The link between UBI and social inclusion might be more subtle than that for poverty and inequality. But that doesn’t make it less important. The COVID-19 crisis highlights how important social connections are for our . We all need to love and to be loved. Alone time can be great, but being lonely can make life seem bleak and purposeless. UBI could give people the means to focus more on engaging with their communities, rather than simply earning an income. This would include carers, parents and volunteers. A UBI provides proof to such workers that their labour is valued and appreciated. UBI would shift our focus from economic growth, which doesn’t benefit everyone, to social and emotional growth, which would. It would allow people to reassess what matters most to them and give them a platform to live more meaningful lives. To explore it further, I would suggest two ways forward. First, those should explicitly measure mental health outcomes. often emerge out of such pilots, but they should be automatically assessed from the outset. of improved mental health could well outweigh the cost of implementing UBI. Second, mental health professionals and charities should advocate more strongly for socially progressive policies to prevent mental illness. UBI is one possibility, but there are others as well. Mental illness is caused by many factors. Many of these, such as childhood sexual abuse or other forms of trauma, are very difficult to prevent. The illnesses that emerge out of these experiences are also hard to treat. UBI could ease the burden of mental illness faced by health services. It could allow researchers and mental health professionals more time to deal with more intractable cases.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC › Solvency › S – Racial Inequality

Evidence proves – implementation of a UBI program would address racial inequities like unemployment and debt.

Farooqui 21 (Sana K., MPH student and Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Fellow at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. She received a bachelor’s degree in government and politics and a Master’s in Public Policy from the University of Maryland, College Park; “The Case for Universal Basic Income as a Tool for Racial Justice,” HPHR, 6/7/2021, https://hphr.org/30-article-farooqui/)

To help rectify the 300+ years of racial and socioeconomic disenfranchisement, a universal basic income program must be implemented. This intervention refers to a regular provision of cash to a specified population group within a targeted area. Some form of UBI has been promoted since the 1500s, by advocates as varied as Thomas Paine, Milton Freidman, Mark Zuckerberg, and Elon Musk. More recently, former Democratic presidential nominee contender Andrew Yang built his platform on UBI, inadvertently becoming the most famous proponent for the cause.9 Similar to Yang’s policy, my recommended proposal is a no-strings attached, monthly payment of $1000 regardless of the recipient’s income. This plan would target all residents of the United States ages 18 to 70, with state and federal governments each shouldering half the costs. The age limits are based on the assumption of full social security benefits remaining intact upon reaching age 62, with eight years of buffer in between. The federal government would provide oversight and distribution responsibility. State governments have the option to increase monthly amounts based on cost of living. The funds can be disbursed as live checks, direct deposits based on IRS information, or mailed “debit cards,” similar to those used by SNAP recipients. The latter method is to help reach the 5.4 percent of Americans who are unbanked and mainly low-income people of color.10 The no-strings attached approach would ensure there are no limitations to use and limit exclusions. UBI payments would include currently incarcerated people; if imprisoned folks still have to pay income taxes, then they should be afforded the payments indiscriminately. This would also be untaxed income for everyone, easing some of the middle-class/upper middle-class squeeze – and helping foment cross-class buy-in. Guaranteeing a steady cash flow will help Black and brown Americans engage in wealth accumulation without the traditional barriers of property- or stock-market based methods. In a more roundabout manner, UBI could assist Americans in formally entering the financial economy, another source of wealth generation. More directly, UBI payments can prevent a descent into poverty, a sobering reality as almost 40 percent of Americans are only one paycheck away from being homeless.11 A regular source of income could prevent entrapment by predatory loans and ease debt burden; Black students in particular hold $25,000 more in student loans than white counterparts.12 Likewise, UBI implementation would have more social and psychological effects as well, including a potential reduction in crime and increased trust in U.S. social institutions. The policy may alleviate stress and anxiety, which can ease the effects of weathering in Black Americans. A guaranteed cash stream can also reduce barriers to healthcare access by promoting utilization, preventing future wealth losses in the form of medical debt. Critics of UBI claim this policy would be disastrous, namely as an assured cash deposit would disincentivize employment and consequently wreck the economy. Accordingly, UBI would essentially create a lazy and unmotivated society dependent on state-provided handouts.13 Yet, the evidence displays the opposite effect. In a recent small-scale experiment in Stockton, California, 125 residents who made less than the median income of $46,000 a year were given $500 per month for the past two years. Less than 1 percent of the entire amount of disbursed cash was spent on tobacco and alcohol. Rather, recipients used the cash to pay off debts and obtain better-paying fulltime jobs. Enrollees reported that they had lower rates of anxiety, depression, and fatigue; having a sustained source of cash gave them enough financial security to allocate time for better job-hunting, for example.13