Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Limits Extension

High schoolers can’t handle the entire Social Security Act.

Falk ’87 [Kenneth J. Falk; 1987; Assistant Director of Litigation at the Legal Services Organization of Indiana, JD at Columbia University; Indiana Law Review, “Recent Developments under the Social Security Act,” vol. 20, no. 1]

The Social Security Act1 has been described by the United States Supreme Court as "among the most intricate ever drafted by Congress,"2 and the Court has stated that the Act is "almost unintelligible to the uninitiated." 3 To most persons, Social Security means only a government benefit program for retired or disabled persons. But the Social Security Act provides the legislative basis for such diverse programs as Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC), Medicaid, and child welfare programs, as well as child support collection programs. The Code sections are further explained and detailed in numerous volumes of the Code of Federal Regulations. And each state has added further glosses to the Act with state administrative rules and regulations.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Limits Extension

‘Social Security’ includes only elderly and disability benefits, which are a distinct subset of ‘benefits received under the Social Security Act.’ Massive limits explosion to all social insurance programs otherwise.

Faris ’16 [Robert J. Faris and Randall L. Dunn; January 16, 2016; Federal Bankruptcy Judges, writing over the dissent of Meredith A. Jury, which disagrees with the interpretation of ‘benefits received under the Social Security Act’ rather than ‘Social Security’; Westlaw, “In re Adinolfi,” 543 B.R. 612]

Judicial decisions, even those that are not binding on this Panel, are an excellent source of interpretive guidance. There are no decisions addressing whether the SSA exclusion covers Adoption Assistance payments. Several courts have considered a related issue: whether unemployment insurance payments are “benefits received under the Social Security Act.” Most of those courts have held that unemployment compensation is not excluded. See, e.g., In re Gentry, 463 B.R. 526 (Bankr.D.Colo.2011). A minority of courts have held that the exclusion applies. See, e.g., In re Munger, 370 B.R. at 23–26.

1. Construction of the individual words

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › SSA Violation

Not the same – distinct systems

Social Security Administration 23, U.S. government agency that administers social programs, January 2023, “Understanding the Benefits”, ssa.gov, //IM

In 2023, when you work, about 85 cents of every Social Security tax dollar you pay goes to a trust fund that pays monthly benefits to current retirees and their families and to surviving spouses and children of workers who have died. About 15 cents goes to a trust fund that pays benefits to people with disabilities and their families.4 From these trust funds, we also pay the costs of managing our programs. We’re one of the most efficient agencies in the federal government, and we’re working to make it better every day. Of each Social Security tax dollar you pay, we spend less than 1 penny to manage the program. The entire amount of Medicare taxes you pay goes to a trust fund that pays some costs of hospital and related care for all Medicare beneficiaries. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, not Social Security, manages Medicare.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › SSA Violation

Social Security and Medicare are distinct – are different structures, programs, and have administration mechanisms.

Thomas H. Stanton 03, former President of the Association for Federal Enterprise Risk Management and chaired Executive Organization and Management, 9/1/2003, “The Administration of Medicare: A Neglected Issue ”, scholarlycommons, https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1256&context=wlulr //IM

Many of Medicare's administrative shortcomings result from a significant disparity between its responsibilities and resources, both in personnel and dollars. At the inception of the Medicare program, providers expressed apprehension about governmental intervention into health care.4 As a result, the government created a different structure for administering Medicare than for administering Social Security. The Social Security Administration (SSA), with an in-house staff of 63,000,' processes Social Security payments directly to over forty-five million beneficiaries according to a schedule of benefits that is easy to administer. 6 By contrast, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), formerly the Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA),7 currently has an in-house staff of fewer than 5,000. CMS, however, must administer a much more complex set of payments for Medicare services for almost as many beneficiaries through numerous third parties that together employ another 22,500 people.8

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Excludes SSI

Supplemental Security Income is not Social Security

Kindness 23 – [Investopedia Team, reviewed by David Kindness, fact checked by Yarilet Perez, "Social Security Administration (SSA): What It Is and How It Works," Investopedia, 5-8-2023, ] /jsam

The SSA administers the Social Security program. Social Security is a vital part of the retirement income planning strategy of many Americans, particularly as savings rates remain low: 4.6% as of February 2023. Almost 67 million Americans, including retired workers, disabled workers, and survivors, received Social Security benefits at the end of 2023, according to the SSA. Social Security is one of the largest government programs in the world. The benefits are funded with payroll taxes paid by employers, employees, and the self-employed. The tax revenue goes into two Social Security trust funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund for retirees and the Disability Insurance Trust Fund (DI) for disability beneficiaries, which also make the benefit payments. Supplemental Security Income (SSI) is distinct from Social Security. It isn't funded by payroll taxes. It aids the disabled, blind, and elderly who have limited income and resources.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Includes Medicare

Social Security includes retirement benefits, disability benefits, medicare, survivors benefits, and social security income

Social Security Administration, no date – [Social Security Administration, no date, “Benefits,” ] /jsam

Retirement Whether you need help deciding when to retire or are ready to start the next chapter in your life, we have the tools you need to get started. No need to visit an office — estimate your benefits, apply for retirement, and check your application status online. Disability If the unexpected happens, Social Security may be able to help. We pay disability benefits to those who can’t work because they have a medical condition that’s expected to last at least one year or result in death. Find out how Social Security can help you and how you can manage your benefits. Medicare Medicare is our country’s health insurance program for people 65 or older. Certain people younger than age 65 can qualify for Medicare too, including those with disabilities and those who have permanent kidney failure. Social Security works with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to ensure the public receives the assistance they need. Survivors If you lose a loved one, we are there to help you get through the difficult time. We pay survivors benefits to widows, widowers, and to the dependents of eligible workers. Find out more about how we help protect you and your family. Supplemental Security Income We are with those who need a helping hand. The Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program provides support to disabled adults and children who have limited income and resources, as well as people age 65 and older who are not disabled but have limited income and resources.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Includes Medicare

Social Security includes health care access

Frans Pennings 18, Professor of Labour Law and Social Security Law, Utrecht University, the Netherlands and Martin Seeleib-Kaiser, Professor of Comparative Public Policy, Institute of Political Science, Eberhard Karls University of Tübingen, Germany, “Social Security,” Routledge Handbook of the Welfare State, edited by Bent Greve, 2nd ed., Routledge, 06/28/2018, pp. 355–365 DOI.org (Crossref), doi:10.4324/9781315207049-32

The definition of social security Earlier in the chapter, social security was defined as income protection regulated in statutory schemes for the compensation of the loss of income due to materialisation of contingencies closely related to the physical situation of the persons concerned, the loss of work by workers and basic provisions to protect persons from want. This definition attempts to cover the provisions described above. The contingencies covered are traditionally the following: old age, survivors, disability, industrial accidents, unemployment, sickness, and maternity. In the definition it is attempted to characterise these schemes: they are linked with the physical situation of the person which means that he cannot work anymore (sickness, disability, old age) or a personal situation that has led to a loss of income (death of breadwinner). Unemployment is not related to the physical position, but is often the result of economic development. This definition does not mean that there is also an obligation to give protection in all situations which fall within this definition. For instance, self-employed persons are hardly ever protected against loss of income due to economic developments. However, if a scheme meets the definition, it is considered part of social security. Family allowances and healthcare schemes were also considered as falling within the definition. Family allowances were considered necessary, since the incomes of low-paid workers were otherwise insufficient to bear all the costs of living. Healthcare is considered necessary to ensure that everybody has access to healthcare provisions. More generally, even though not addressed by an insurance scheme, meeting the needs of the poor is also part of social security. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (2007), which gives an interpretation of the right to social security laid down in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, follows narrowly the contingencies mentioned in the previous paragraph and is not able either to give one single definition. Instead, it needs a three-tier definition to include all the schemes: the right to social security encompasses the right to access and maintain benefits, whether in cash or in kind, without discrimination in order to secure protection, inter alia, from (1) lack of work-related income caused by sickness, disability, maternity, employment injury, unemployment, old age or death of a family member; (2) unaffordable access to healthcare; and (3) insufficient family support, particularly for children and adult dependants. The following sections will discuss criticism of this definition and approach, for instance, in view of the so-called new risks (e.g. the risk of divorce or the ‘risk’ of having to care for another person such as an aged parent). Another point of criticism is that the enumeration is the result of developments across, in particular, European countries. In other continents other risks occur, such as the high impact of AIDS/HIV, tsunamis or draught (Becker et al., 2013). However, so far this has not led to a new definition of social security. The definition is sometimes adapted to fit with the actual question to be answered or research to be done, for instance, if used to describe developments in government expenditure or to compare budgets of countries. However, in discussions on the definition it is important to realise that the term ‘social security’ also has a normative dimension. For this purpose delineation is useful or even necessary. We will discuss this in the next section. The normative dimension of social security Social security as a norm is laid down, in particular, in national constitutions and international instruments. For example, Article 22 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of the United Nations provides that ‘Everyone, as a member of society, has the right to social security’ and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights recognises ‘the right of everyone to social security, including social insurance’ (Article 9). Although no enforceable rights can be derived from these provisions, member states are given the obligation to elaborate this right (see also Riedel, 2007) and therefore the provisions have indeed a legal meaning. In order to be able to interpret the obligations following from the said instruments, it is necessary to limit the scope of social security to the protection for well-defined risks. Otherwise it is impossible to criticise a state for not fulfilling its obligations. Contingencies in respect of which many states have already shown that they are willing to accept their responsibility for protection are very useful for the interpretation of the term ‘social security’ in international instruments, as mentioned in the previous paragraph. Contingencies for which there is a widespread accepted responsibility are basically related to physical reasons for not being able to work and economic reasons affecting the dependent working populations (including poverty). An example is, in particular, ILO Convention 102, the Social Security (Minimum Standards) Convention in 1952, which addresses the same contingencies as mentioned above. See also below and Dijkhoff (2011). In addition, in other international contexts the term ‘social security’ is used and here a broad interpretation could also lead to unacceptable results for states, so it has to be narrowed down for this purpose. For instance, Article 48 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) requires that the European Parliament and the Council adopt such measures in the field of social security as are necessary to provide freedom of movement for workers. Examples of such measures are the export of benefits. If, for instance, the term ‘social security’ Frans Pennings 360 is interpreted as also including housing benefits or study grants, these would have to be exported. This would be unacceptable for the EU member states. Regulation 883/2004 elaborating Article 48 solves this problem by giving a limitative list of benefits, corresponding with the benefits mentioned above (see also Pennings, 2015). We may conclude that for the purpose of defining the extent of obligations of states and/or international bodies following from international instruments, it is necessary that the scope of social security is limited. The list of risks mentioned above is generally accepted for this purpose. For other purposes the term ‘social security’ may have another meaning. Basically, for the purpose of interpreting international standards, the definition of social security is rather narrow, focused on traditional risks. Criticism on narrowness of the definition: ‘new risks’ The definition given earlier in this chapter is sometimes criticised for being limited to so-called old risks, in particular those relevant to workers (see contributions in EJSS Special Issue, 2005). It is also argued that new risks have to be taken into account: for instance, the loss of income in case of divorce or the need to care for children or relatives, in particular if they become seriously ill. While it is not the definition of social security which is being criticised as such, it is argued that state responsibility should extend to adopt a new risk under the definition. The state should also adopt compensation schemes for loss of income in case of such a new risk. In this discussion it is important to point out that the provisions recognised so far as social security (the ‘old’ risks) fulfil the requirement that their materialisation is not due to the initiative of the claimant. More precisely, it is possible to define precisely when a person is eligible or not, for example, between voluntary and involuntary unemployment. This criterion is closely linked with the insurance character of a large part of the schemes, but is also more generally still relevant, since the sustainability (financing) and legitimacy of the system depend very much on the possibility to control access and use. If one can claim ‘at will’ the system cannot survive. Therefore this principle that the materialisation of the contingency must not depend on personal choices is essential for distinguishing schemes as social security schemes. The distinction between old and new risks on grounds of the possibility to influence one’s own risk is not an absolute one. For instance, unemployed people can to a certain extent influence the duration of their unemployment depending on their willingness and attempts to accept and find work. Also in case of illness there can be large variations in the work which persons are still willing to do. Family benefits are only paid after a couple has taken the initiative to produce a child. If we compare this with a new risk, namely the obligation to care for a seriously ill child, this does not leave much choice, in some situations, to quit or reduce work. The problem is, however, that for the old risks the legal conditions for benefit eligibility can be much more sharply defined and supervised than in the case of the new risks. This makes it more difficult to control access to compensation for such new risks. For instance, in the example of the ill child, it can still be disputed whether the partner, or other family members, of a professional organisation is asked to provide the care. And in case of care for other family members, friends or relatives the question also arises if the person concerned has to undertake the task of caring or whether somebody else can be asked. Comparable discussions arise in case of divorce insurance. The new risks make supervision difficult and would require a thorough investigation of the private situation of the claimant. Study grants and housing benefits also provide for income compensation and could therefore be considered a form of social security. However, also for these risks the problem is that there is Social security 361 a choice for claimants to influence their materialisation; moreover, there can be different views on whether these risks should be collectively borne than in the case of the traditional risks. This does not mean, of course, that states cannot make arrangements for such contingencies, but they fall outside the concept of social security generally used. Is the concept too Europe-centred? Another criticism on the social security definition is that it is too Europe-centred. Indeed, the history of European schemes was highly influential on the types of risks to be covered and the ways protection is ensured. Critics argue that in particular in developing countries their economies are still at a stage that is very far from being able to establish the ‘Western-type’ protection schemes against, for instance, unemployment and disability, in particular because of their large informal economies. Moreover, they argue that the most important risks which affect the lives of their people, such as drought, earthquakes and tsunamis, HIV/aids and large movements of refugees and other migrants, are not taken into account. Although these are very valuable criticisms, at this stage of the discussion it is not yet possible to define more generally the measures to be taken to respond to these contingencies and to know what their long-term impact is. Therefore it is premature to incorporate such contingencies into the definition of social security. Further research on these issues is necessary (see Becker et al., 2013). The conclusion from the above is that although the contents of the concept of social security are not fixed forever, the present definition is useful to elaborate obligations of states to ensure income protection of their citizens. Types of schemes that can serve to realise social security In the previous section I discussed the types of contingencies falling within the social security concept. The second question is which types of schemes can serve to realise social security. As we saw above, social insurance schemes were established to make workers less dependent on poor relief provisions. A first question is therefore whether the successor of poor relief, social assistance, is part of social security. This is particularly relevant in view of the question of how states can fulfil their obligation to provide for social security. In my view social assistance is part of the social security system. This does not mean that (international) obligations to provide social security can always be fulfilled by social assistance only. For instance, ILO Convention 121 does not allow means-tested benefits as a way to provide income compensation for the victims of industrial accidents. The view that social assistance belongs to social security is based on the fact that currently most, if not all, social assistance schemes do not essentially differ from other types of schemes, except from the fact that income of claimants is taken into account for benefit eligibility (means- test). Claimants have, however, a legally enforceable right to income if the conditions are satisfied; also their legal position is often well defined. Moreover, means-testing is nowadays not limited to social assistance and the distinction between the traditional schemes and social assistance is declining. Insurance-type schemes sometimes have means-tested elements, for instance, for supplements to the benefit for dependants, or because of the nature of the benefit (e.g. in case of survivor benefits). Therefore there is no good reason to exclude social assistance from the concept of social security. Second, the question is whether social security is strictly limited to public schemes. As discussed at the start of this chapter, acknowledgement of state responsibility for income protection Frans Pennings 362 was at the root of social security, thus stressing the importance of public responsibility. Of course, income protection can also be organised by other parties, including employers, family members, mutual funds and private funds. This raises the question whether such provisions are also to be counted as social security. This question has become more relevant now that in many countries the role of the state is being reduced and some public tasks are privatised, including parts of social security. There is nothing against including such forms in the concept of social security, for instance, for calculating expenditure on social issues or income redistribution. However, in view of the normative dimension the issue is different, since again the question has to be answered whether the state has fulfilled its obligations. Because of the impact upon the legal position of the persons concerned, it still makes a very important difference as to who is responsible for income redistribution. The normative dimension requires that the term ‘social security’ is limited to those forms of income protection that are defined by statutory law giving the core obligations to be fulfilled. Within this context private parties can also be given the task of providing an income. For instance, if the employer has a statutory obligation to continue to pay wages to ill employees, this obligation and payment may be considered as social security. If, however, the employer pays the employee money on the basis of an individual or collective employment contract, this is outside the scope of social security. Income protection can be organised in various ways. The current forms may be characterised as follows. Social insurance, where the insured receive benefits or services in exchange for contributions. There are two main schemes: employee insurance schemes, limited to workers and certain assimilated categories; and residence schemes, covering all residents. The schemes are designed for specific contingencies and define the level and duration of benefit. In case of a low benefit and/or limited duration, recourse has to be made to schemes to supplement these schemes, which are often means-tested (i.e. they are paid only if a person has less than a certain amount of income). Employees’ insurance schemes are often administered by organisations of social partners, but this is not always necessarily the case. Public bodies may also have this task. Residence schemes are administered by public bodies. In some systems statutory law allows or obliges private parties (including employers) to take over part of the income protection (previously or still currently) organised by social insurance. This was discussed above. Universal benefits. These differ from the residence schemes mentioned above, as the latter schemes are based on insurance and are thus contributory. Universal schemes are non-contributory benefits without a means-test for all residents. Examples are family allowances or public pensions. Strictly speaking, social assistance schemes can also be universal; however, because of their very important characteristic of being means-tested, social assistance benefits are often put in a separate category. Minimum benefits. These provide for a minimum income for particular groups with a low income (e.g. for disabled persons or the elderly) and are paid from taxes. The difference with public assistance is mainly that these benefits generally do not have a means-test on the capital. Social assistance (means-tested benefits). These benefits are paid to guarantee the subsistence level as defined in the country in question. For this purpose the income and capital of the person (and often also other family members) are taken into account. Social security may also be realised in the form of services (e.g. by means of delivering special services). Healthcare schemes often provide care in the form of services rather than in cash.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Excludes Medicare

Social Security is distinct from medicare

Norris 21 – [Louise Norris, "Are Social Security and Medicare the same thing?," medicareresources.org, 8-26-2021, ] /jsam

Social Security, which was enacted in 1935, is a government-run income benefit for retirees who have worked – and paid Social Security taxes – for at least ten years. Social Security also provides spousal and survivor benefits, and people under 65 are eligible for benefits if they’re disabled. (Social Security’s official name is “Old Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance” or OASDI.)

Medicare, enacted in 1965, is also a government-run program for older Americans, designed to provide health insurance coverage for anyone 65 or older who has worked – and paid Medicare taxes – for at least ten years. (You can purchase Medicare coverage if the work history is less than ten years, and coverage can also be obtained based on a spouse’s work history). Medicare also provides health insurance benefits to younger people who are disabled, or who have kidney failure or ALS.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Excludes Medicare

Medicare is not social security – SS handles medicare enrollment

AARP 22 – [Aarp, "How Do Social Security and Medicare Work Together?," AARP, 12-21-2022, ] /jsam

Social Security and Medicare are distinct programs serving older and disabled Americans, but they have an important commonality: Social Security handles enrollment for Medicare Part A (hospital insurance) and Part B (medical insurance). In this role, the Social Security Administration (SSA) works with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to inform older Americans about their Medicare sign-up options, process their applications and collect premiums.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Excludes Medicare

Social Security is retirement, disability, and survivors benefits- it excludes Medicare

Darlynda Bogle, Assistant Deputy Commissioner in 2021

Medicare, A Simple Explanation; https://blog.ssa.gov/medicare-a-simple-explanation/#:~:text=While%20Social%20Security%20offers%20retirement,receiving%20Social%20Security%20disability%20benefits.

Social Security and Medicare are both programs that are household names, but do you know the true difference? Both programs help safeguard millions of Americans as well as improve the quality of life for their family and friends. While Social Security offers retirement, disability, and survivors benefits, Medicare provides health insurance. Medicare is our country’s health insurance program for people age 65 or older and younger people receiving Social Security disability benefits. The program helps with the cost of health care, but it doesn’t cover all medical expenses or the cost of most long-term care.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Retirement/Disability/Survivor Benefits

‘Social security’ is OASDI.

CFR ’86 [Code of Federal Regulations; effective Dec. 31, 1986; Title 5: Administrative Personnel, Chapter I: Office of Personnel Management, Subchapter B. Civil Service Regulations, Part 841: Federal Employees Retirement System—General Administration, Subpart E: Employee Deductions and Government Contributions, “Section 841.502 Definitions,” 5 C.F.R. § 841.502]

Social security means old age, survivors and disability insurance under section 3101(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Retirement/Disability/Survivor Benefits

SS benefits limited to retirement, disability, dependents, and survivors

Laurence in 2023

Laurence, Bethany K. “Social Security Benefits: Retirement, Disability, Dependents, and Survivors (OASDI).” Www.Nolo.Com, 13 Feb. 2023, www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/social-security-benefits-retirement-disability-29989.html.

Four basic types of Social Security benefits are paid based on the record of your earnings: retirement, disability, dependents, and survivors benefits. These benefits all fall under the OASDI program. OASDI stands for Old Age, Survivors and Disability Insurance (OASDI). Types of Social Security Benefits Many people think of retirement benefits when they think of Social Security (SS) benefits. But the Social Security Administration (SSA) actually offers four types of benefits to those who have paid into the Social Security trust fund over a number of years, or to their family members. Social Security Retirement Benefits Workers who have worked in "covered employment" for a sufficient number of years are eligible for retirement benefits when they retire. Usually, you must work a total of at least ten years, either at a nongovernmental job, where you pay FICA taxes, or for yourself, paying self-employment taxes. You may choose to begin receiving retirement benefits at any time after you reach age 62. But Social Security offers incentives to wait until your "full retirement age," which is between 66 and 67, depending on the year of your birth. Find out if you qualify for SSDI benefits. Pre-qualify in 60 seconds for up to $3,627 per month and 12 months back pay. Please answer a few questions to help us determine your eligibility. How old are you? Select An Answer If you begin claiming benefits before you reach full retirement age, Social Security will reduce the amount of your benefits by a certain percentage. As a further incentive to keep working, the amount of your benefits will be slightly, but permanently, increased for each year you wait until age 70 to put in your claim. But sometimes it doesn't make sense to delay collecting your benefits (see When to Claim Social Security Benefits?). Also, no matter how long you wait to begin collecting benefits, the amount you receive will be only a portion of what you were earning. Social Security Disability Benefits If you haven't reached full retirement age but you've worked enough to meet the requirements (usually five to ten years, depending on your age), you could be eligible for benefits from the Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) program. To receive benefits, you must have a physical or mental impairment that prevents you from working full-time for at least a year. If Social Security considers you disabled under its medical guidelines, you can receive benefits roughly equal to what your full retirement benefits would be. Social Security Dependents Benefits If you're the spouse of a retired or disabled worker who qualifies for Social Security retirement or disability benefits, you may be entitled to benefits based on the worker's earnings record. This is true whether or not you actually depend on your spouse for your support. Spousal benefits are available for those who reach age 62 or are taking care of the worker's child age 16 or under. (Read about spousal dependents benefits.) Minor children, and older children who became disabled before age 22, can also collect dependent benefits based on the worker's earnings record. (Read about child dependents benefits.) Social Security Survivors Benefits If you're the surviving spouse of a worker who qualified for Social Security retirement or disability benefits, you and your minor or disabled children can be entitled to benefits based on your deceased spouse's earnings record. As a widow or widower, you can begin to collect benefits once you reach age 60, or age 50 if you have a disability that prevents you from working. Survivors benefits are also available to minor children and older children who became disabled before age 22. For more information, read our article on survivors benefits.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Retirement/Disability/Survivor Benefits

Social security refers to retirement or disability benefits funded through SS payroll taxes

Kindness 23 – [Investopedia Team, reviewed by David Kindness, fact checked by Yarilet Perez, "Social Security Administration (SSA): What It Is and How It Works," Investopedia, 5-8-2023, ] /jsam

The benefits are funded with payroll taxes paid by employers, employees, and the self-employed. The tax revenue goes into two Social Security trust funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund for retirees and the Disability Insurance Trust Fund (DI) for disability beneficiaries, which also make the benefit payments.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Retirement/Disability/Survivor Benefits

Social security refers to benefits for the disabled, retired, or survivors

Kindness 23 – [Investopedia Team, reviewed by David Kindness, fact checked by Yarilet Perez, "Social Security Administration (SSA): What It Is and How It Works," Investopedia, 5-8-2023, ] /jsam

The Social Security Administration (SSA) is a U.S. government agency that administers social programs covering disability, retirement, and survivors' benefits, among other services. It's also responsible for issuing Social Security numbers and managing the program’s finances and trust fund. The SSA administers the Social Security program. Social Security is a vital part of the retirement income planning strategy of many Americans, particularly as savings rates remain low: 4.6% as of February 2023. Almost 67 million Americans, including retired workers, disabled workers, and survivors, received Social Security benefits at the end of 2023, according to the SSA. Social Security is one of the largest government programs in the world. The benefits are funded with payroll taxes paid by employers, employees, and the self-employed. The tax revenue goes into two Social Security trust funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund for retirees and the Disability Insurance Trust Fund (DI) for disability beneficiaries, which also make the benefit payments.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Retirement/Disability/Survivor Benefits

Social Security is retirement, disability, or survivors’ benefits

Wilkinson 21 – [The Wilkinson Wealth Management Team, “The 3 Components of Social Security,” 03/09/2021, .] /jsam

But the Social Security program itself also has three important components: retirement, disability benefits, and survivors' benefits.[1] Learn more about these three components and the benefits each one can provide. Social Security Retirement Benefits As of 2020, around 88 percent of all adult workers are insured under the Social Security retirement program—in other words, they've worked enough "quarters" to qualify for Social Security benefits at full retirement age (FRA).2 FRA is age 67 for those born 1960 and later, age 66 for those born between 1943 and 1954, and between 66 and 67 for those born from 1955 to 1959.3 Some people elect to draw their benefits early (at age 62) or wait until age 70 when their benefit maxes out.[2] The amount of your Social Security benefits will depend on a few factors: · How old you are when you first begin drawing Social Security benefits; · How much you earned during your career; and · How many years you worked during your career. The higher your income, the longer you worked, and the later you claim your benefits, the higher your total benefit amount will be.[3] Social Security Disability Benefits Another component of the Social Security program is Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) and Supplemental Security Income (SSI). SSDI is designed for workers who have paid enough into the system to qualify for Social Security retirement, while SSI is for those who have never been able to work or who haven't worked enough quarters to qualify for SSDI or Social Security retirement.[4] Unlike SSDI, SSI is means-tested; those who have more than $2,000 in "countable assets" (or more than $3,000 for a couple) won't be able to receive these benefits.4 But like Social Security retirement, SSDI is available to anyone who has paid into the Social Security program and then becomes disabled.[5] Social Security Survivors' Benefits Finally, the Social Security program has a mechanism to provide ongoing benefits to children whose parent or parents passed away before they could begin collecting Social Security retirement benefits, as well as a surviving spouse caring for those children.[6] These survivor benefits are based on the amount the worker would have received had they retired early, and will continue to be paid until after the youngest child graduates high school (or two months after they turn 19, whichever comes first).5

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Retirement/Disability/Survivor Benefits

Social Security limited to retirement, disability, and survivors benefits

Cornell, no date – [Cornell Law School, "Social Security," LII / Legal Information Institute, no date, ] /jsam

In the United States, the Social Security Program was created in 1935 (42 U.S.C. 401 et seq.) to provide old age, survivors, and disability insurance benefits to workers and their families. Unlike welfare, social security benefits are paid to an individual or his or her [their] family at least in part on the basis of that person's employment record and prior contributions to the system. The program is administered by the Social Security Administration (SSA). Since the establishment of the Medicare program in 1965, it and Social Security have been closely linked. While the original act used "Social Security" in a broader sense, including federally funded welfare programs and unemployment compensation within its scope, and the Medicare legislature took the form of amendments to that act, current usage associates the phrase with old age, survivors, and disability insurance. The Federal Old Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance (OASDI) program pays out monthly benefits to retired people, to families whose wage earner has died, and to workers unemployed due to sickness or accident. Workers qualify for its protection by having been employed for a minimum amount of time and by having made contributions to the program. Once an individual has qualified for protection, certain other family members are, as well. Financial need is not a requirement but continuing to earn substantial sums is inconsistent with eligibility for certain benefits (disability insurance) and can reduce the benefit amount with others (including retirement or survivors benefits).

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Health and Unemployment Protection

Social Security Expansion must extend social security’s solvency, cost of living adjustments, include progressive taxation, and restore previous cuts made to the program.

Van Hollen ET;AL, 22 (June 09, 2022, Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) joined Senators Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) alongside Senators Cory Booker (D-N.J.), Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), Alex Padilla (D-Calif.), and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), “Social Security Expansion Act Fact Shee”, https://www.vanhollen.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Social-Security-Expansion-Act-one-pager.pdf)

The Social Security Expansion Act would: Extend the solvency of Social Security for 75 years by requiring the wealthiest American households to pay their fair share of taxes. Today, because of the earnings cap on Social Security taxes, a CEO making $20 million a year pays the same amount of money into Social Security as someone who makes $147,000 a year. This legislation would lift this cap and subject all income above $250,000 to the Social Security payroll tax. Under this bill, over 93 percent of households would not see their taxes go up by one penny. Expand Social Security benefits across-the-board for current and new beneficiaries. Under this bill, Social Security benefits for current and existing recipients would be increased by $200 a month. Increase Cost-Of-Living-Adjustments (COLAs). This bill would more accurately measure the spending patterns for seniors by adopting the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly (CPI-E). Older Americans, by and large, are not going out on spending sprees buying big screen TVs, laptops, or the latest high-tech gadgets. Rather, they spend a disproportionate amount of their income on health care and prescription drugs and that would be reflected in the formula for calculating COLAs under this legislation. Require millionaires and billionaires pay their fair share into Social Security. Currently, workers have 12.4 percent taken out of each paycheck and contributed to the Trust Fund, half paid by the employer and half by the worker. This bill would require the wealthy pay the same 12.4 percent on their investment and business income, by increasing the net investment income tax by 12.4 percent and applying it to certain business income not already covered by payroll taxes. Improve the Special Minimum Benefit for Social Security recipients. This bill will help low-income workers stay out of poverty by updating the Special Minimum Benefit to make it increase and indexing the benefit level so that it is equal to 125 percent of the poverty line or about $17,000 for a single worker who had worked their full career. Restore student benefits up to age 22 for children of disabled or deceased workers, if the child is a full-time student in a college or vocational school. This legislation restores student benefits to help educate children of deceased or disabled parents that were eliminated in 1983. Combine the Disability Insurance Trust Fund with the Old Age and Survivors Trust fund to help senior citizens and persons with disabilities.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › Health and Unemployment Protection

Social Security means a system of contribution-based health, unemployment protection, and social benefits

ILO – ["Facts on Social Security," International Labour Organization, no date, ] /jsam

Social security protection is clearly defined in ILO conventions and UN instruments as a basic human right – albeit one that a small proportion of the people on our planet actually enjoy. Broadly defined as a system of contribution-based health, pension and unemployment protection, along with tax-financed social benefits, social security has become a universal challenge in a globalizing world.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Social Security › 1NC- No Medicare

2. ‘Expanding’ refers to an existing programs, not creating new ones.

Holm ’2 [Edward G. Holm and Jeffrey G. Gancher; May 9, 2002; Prosecuting Attorney from Thurston County; Deputy Prosecuting Attorney from Thurston County; Westlaw, “Supplemental Brief of Petitioner Thurston County” in Thurston County v. Western Washington Growth Management Hearings Board, 2002 WL 32859639]

Respondents have argued that the 4 inch sewer line is an *2 extension of sewer and not a replacement. This assertion ignores the plain meaning of RCW 36.70A.110(4) which includes the phrase,“... it is not appropriate that urban governmental services be extended to or expanded in rural areas...” RCW 36.70A.110(4). The term “extend” applies to placing/constructing new urban services in the rural area while the term “expand” applies to existing services in the rural area. This is the plain meaning of the phrase as used in RCW 36.70A.110(4).

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Expand › Expand = Benefits and Eligibility

Expanding social security means increasing benefit levels

Smith, no date – [Leah Smith, "Expanding Social Security: A Strategy to Strengthen Retirement Security for Vulnerable Populations and Future Generations," Center for Global Policy Solutions, ] /jsam

There are many ways to improve and expand Social Security so that the program can better protect financially vulnerable workers and their families. The program was created so that the nation could guarantee a basic standard of living to its people. The United States can afford to fund its priorities and should make the expansion of this program a priority so it can fulfill the role it was created to play, especially for the most vulnerable. Most recommendations below are excerpted from Plan for a New Future: The Impact of Social Security Reform on People of Color, a report of the Commission to Modernize Social Security.31 The Commission is composed of experts representing African American, Asian American and Pacific Islander, Latino, and Native American communities, and was convened in 2011 by Global Policy Solutions and the Insight Center for Community Economic Development. Increasing the Special Minimum Benefit to 125 percent of the poverty threshold would protect the most financially vulnerable workers. The special minimum benefit would be increased for workers who have paid into Social Security for at least 30 years and claim benefits at the full retirement age. This increase is crucial because these workers are less likely to have private retirement accounts or discretionary income. Providing a dependent care credit would help workers who spend part of their lives caring for children and disabled or elderly dependents. The time these workers spend out of the workforce can result in lower benefits, which decreases their economic security. A dependent care credit for up to five years could be set at one-half of the average wage. Creating a structural-unemployment credit, similar to the dependent-care credit, would help those individuals affected by stagnating wages, structural unemployment and underemployment. These workers are typically forced to leave the labor force through no fault of their own and face a disadvantage due to the Social Security retirement formula. Like the dependent-care credit, this credit would last up to five years and could be set at one-half of the average wage. Reinstating the student benefit is critical to the economic security of children with parents who are retired, deceased, or disabled. Social Security provides these children benefits until age 19 if they are still in school, or age 18 otherwise. Before 1981, the benefits supported children of workers until age 22 if they were in college or vocational school. When the benefit could last until age 22, it was shown to be particularly helpful to children of low-income and racial and ethnic minority families.32 Increasing benefits by a uniform amount equal to 5 percent of the average benefit is another way to expand benefits to protect workers, especially those who are near retirement and do not have the time to replace savings lost in the recent recession. Increasing revenue has also been proposed as a method for reforming Social Security. One option is to eliminate the cap on payroll contributions and count the earnings towards benefits with a flatter formula. The cap is indexed to keep up with the growth of average worker earnings, but it has not kept up with the rapid growth of earnings at the top.33 A new formula could replace a smaller part of the earnings above the old cap so that Social Security would not have to pay very high benefits to the top earners.34 Other options involve including all new state and local workers in the Social Security system and slowly raising the payroll tax by 1/20th of 1 percent per year for 20 years.