Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Expand › Expand = Benefits and Eligibility

Expansion is broad, but includes increasing benefits and eligibility

Smith 18 – [Brenton Smith, "Social Security benefits too low? It’s mostly your own fault," MarketWatch, 10-28-2018, ] /jsam

While the concept of more benefits is always appealing to voters, there is little consensus on the meaning of the phrase “Expand Social Security.” In 2016, then-candidate Hillary Clinton believed it meant helping spouses and widows. Sanders’ proposal would provide significant support for future retirees, but would give current retirees virtually nothing. Larson, on the other hand, has proposed helping current retirees, somewhat at the expense of future retirees. (Republicans, meanwhile, have their own ideas for using Social Security to cover maternity leave or to pay student loans.)

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Expand › Pre-existing

Expand means pre-existing

Portland 18 – [Portland, Oregon, Exhibit A: Findings of Fact Report,” 8/22/2018, ] /jsam

“Encourage” is defined in the Comprehensive Plan as “promote or foster using some combination of voluntary approaches, regulations, or incentives.” The MDP amendments promote or the evolving needs of Portland households by preserving a small but important part of the affordable housing inventory. The MDP amendments include both regulatory and incentive-based approaches to encourage the housing type. The MDPs amendments resolve nonconforming situations, increase density, and expand the ability to transfer unused density in ways that can support the continued operations of these parks, which can lead to park owners and home owners to reinvest and improve living conditions in these parks, which will support the continuing availability of manufactured and mobile homes as a lower-cost market-rate housing choice throughout Portland. Furthermore, the Comprehensive Plan includes a definition of “expand.” “Expand” means to “make something that already exists more extensive.” The MDP amendments “expand” MDPs by creating a new zone that applies to existing parks and allowing for more density—and ultimately the expansion of this housing type. Council interprets “expand housing choices in all neighborhoods” to mean increase housing choices throughout the City as a whole. Council does not interpret this to mean that every single zone must allow for all housing types but rather Council interprets this policy to ensure that the city-wide there is a variety of housing types and within neighborhoods. “Neighborhoods” are defined to include broad areas of the city that typically include residential, commercial, and mixed-use areas. Neighborhood is not limited to the specific MDP but rather the MDP exists as a part of the larger area. Within the neighborhood MDPs serve to promote one housing type and ensure that within the neighborhood as a whole there are housing choices.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Expand › Pre-existing

‘Expand’ means to make something more extensive, as opposed to new uses.

Portland ’22 [City of Portland; July 2022; Fossil Fuel Terminal Zoning Amendments, “Exhibit A: Findings of Fact Report,” https://www.portland.gov/sites/default/files/council-documents/2022/exhibit_a_findings_amended.pdf]

168.Finding: The verb “expand”, which is defined in the 2035 Comprehensive Plan, means to make something that already exists more extensive. The verb “improve”, which is defined in the 2035 Comprehensive Plan, means to make the current situation better. The City Council interprets this policy to apply to the city as whole and not to individual businesses or sectors of business. The City Council finds that this policy provides direction to support business growth that makes economic opportunity available to a more diverse and growing community. The City Council finds that an important factor in improving economic equity is to provide access to job opportunities across a wide range of wage scales, especially middle wage jobs such as those found in Portland’s industrial districts.

The FFTZ amendments do not include map changes, nor do they allow for new incompatible land uses, therefore, these changes maintain Portland’s employment land supply to create opportunities for a growing economy in the industrial districts that are important to economic equity.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Expand › 1NC- Expand = Pre Existing

Interpretation- expanding means building on pre-existing programs, not creating new ones

Holm ’2 [Edward G. Holm and Jeffrey G. Gancher; May 9, 2002; Prosecuting Attorney from Thurston County; Deputy Prosecuting Attorney from Thurston County; Westlaw, “Supplemental Brief of Petitioner Thurston County” in Thurston County v. Western Washington Growth Management Hearings Board, 2002 WL 32859639]

Respondents have argued that the 4 inch sewer line is an *2 extension of sewer and not a replacement. This assertion ignores the plain meaning of RCW 36.70A.110(4) which includes the phrase,“... it is not appropriate that urban governmental services be extended to or expanded in rural areas...” RCW 36.70A.110(4). The term “extend” applies to placing/constructing new urban services in the rural area while the term “expand” applies to existing services in the rural area. This is the plain meaning of the phrase as used in RCW 36.70A.110(4).

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › At: Requires Taxes

Job training and educational elements of the program meet any definition of ‘direct’ fiscal redistribution

Larson ’21 [Sven; February 20; Ph.D., Economics writer with the European Conservative; “The American Welfare State Today,” in Democracy or Socialism, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-65643-0_5]

European programs are in general more redistributive in nature. However, it matters less to what degree a program is redistributive, than the fact that it is redistributive in the first place. Once the architecture of economic redistribution is there, the quantity of redistribution is more of a technical legislative matter than a principled one. Again, as the three rules of entitlement expansion prescribe, it is easier to expand an already existing program for economic redistribution than it is to create one.

Welfare-State Consensus

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › FJG Requires Taxes

Fiscal redistribution excludes job guarantees funded via deficit-spending or from cutting other programs

Harvey ‘6 [Phillip; 2006; Associate Professor of Law and Economics at Rutgers School of Law – Camden, PhD in economics from the New School for Social Research, and JD from Yale; Int. J. Environment, Workplace and Employment, “Funding a Job Guarantee,” Vol. 2, No. 1]

5 The redistributive cost of a job guarantee programme Most social welfare benefits redistribute real income, and although opponents of social welfare initiatives rarely focus on this fact, there is little doubt that it contributes to opposition to social welfare spending in market societies. For this reason it is important for discussions of the cost of social welfare initiatives to consider not only the question of how the proposed benefit could be funded but also how much redistribution of income that funding mechanism would entail. Viewed from this perspective, the appropriate question to ask is not where the funds necessary to pay for a JG programme would come from but how much income redistribution would be required to achieve the programme's social welfare goals. The implications of both my own and the Post Keynesian analysis of JG programme funding is that such a programme could be established in developed market economies without any additional redistribution of income. The Post Keynesian analysis supports this conclusion provided the JG initiative is funded with additional deficit spending since in that case the programme's real cost would be totally covered by the programme's contribution to increased aggregate demand and, hence, to increased aggregate real income. Neither present nor future tax payers would suffer any reduction in their real income to pay for the programme. My own analysis supports the same conclusion even if the JG programme is funded without engaging in additional deficit spending, because of the savings in existing government expenditures the programme would permit and the additional government revenue it could generate. This does not mean that any interest-based opposition to the JG idea would be irrational. As explained above, a JG programme would strengthen the bargaining power of wage earners by reducing the in terrorem effect of unemployment. This would likely tilt the wage/profit tradeoff more in favor of wage-earners over the long run, and in this way, a JG programme probably would cause some redistribution of income over time, even if the funding mechanism used to pay for the programme had no such effect in the short-run. This long-term redistributive effect would be likely to fuel employer opposition to the idea even if they were satisfied that a JG programme could be funded without any additional redistribution in the short run, but it would be hard for employers to mobilise opposition to the JG idea among tax payers in general if the idea could be promoted without relying on additional income redistribution to pay for it.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › FJG = Targeted Jobs

A Federal Jobs Guarantee can target jobs – contextual evidence says it can be infrastructure.

Pavlina R. Tcherneva, 2023 (The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability, )

The proposal herein is to design the Job Guarantee as a “National Care Act” that would help fill many social and environmental needs gaps. With input from community groups, localities and municipalities could begin to develop public service employment opportunities in the following three areas: 1) care for the environment; 2) care for the community; and 3) care for the people. A green Job Guarantee that targets environmental and social concerns could create many different kinds of public service employment for years to come, both in large- and small-scale projects, including physical and social infrastructure. A 21st century Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) would help address acute climate-related problems in every community and would aim to prevent, mitigate, and withstand the impact of intensifying hurricanes, tornadoes, fires, and floods. The Job Guarantee would include, monitoring, rehabilitation, and public investment programs. It could tackle soil erosion and flood control, administer environmental surveys, launch species monitoring, park maintenance and renewal programs, remove invasive species, support sustainable agriculture practices, and work to eliminate food and public health deserts in the United States. It could launch mass rural and urban reforestation projects, local fisheries, community supported agriculture (CSA) farms, community and rooftop gardens, community beekeeping projects, fire and other disaster prevention measures, weatherization of homes, and composting. In addition to the environmental challenges, communities experience social and economic problems connected to urban blight and poverty. Since communities are best rebuilt from within, the Job Guarantee could employ existing best practices from the solidarity economy to address them. Projects could include vacant property cleanup, reclamation of materials, and restoration of public spaces. They could build school gardens, playgrounds, urban farms, co-working spaces, solar arrays, tool lending libraries, alongside training and credentialing programs. They can help run restoration of historical sites, community theaters, carpooling programs, recycling, reuse, and water-collection initiatives, food waste programs, oral histories projects, and more.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › FJG = No Consensus

No consensus on the term

Bruenig ’18 [Matt; March 22; founder of the People’s Policy Project, a think tank specializing in income distribution, taxation, and welfare, former attorney at the National Labor Relations Board, JD from Boston Law School; People’s Policy Project, “Some Notes on Federal Job Guarantee Proposals,” https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2018/03/22/some-notes-on-federal-job-guarantee-proposals]

Discussion around the idea of a job guarantee has picked up of late (CBPP, The Nation, Sanders Institute I, II). As with any idea that attracts a sizable number of adherents, the term “job guarantee” means lots of different things to a lot of different people, which makes it a difficult thing to talk about in a comprehensive way. But with that limitation recognized, I thought it might be worthwhile to share some notes about the recent burst.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › FJG = Universal

The term guarantee means it’s a right that can’t be qualified with a specific skill-set or industry – it’s an unconditional offer of a job.

L. Randall Wray 20, professor of Economics at Bard College and Senior Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, “Job Guarantee,” The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Palgrave Macmillan UK, 2020, pp. 1–9 Springer Link, doi:10.1057/978-1-349-95121-5_3080-1

‘Job Guarantee’ (JG) has become the favoured term applied to a variety of approaches that seek to ensure what can be described as true full employment. While often used as a synonym for ‘Employer of Last Resort’ (ELR), these terms evoke quite different framing. Employer of Last Resort implies that there is an entity that stands by to provide jobs to those who otherwise have failed to secure them. The term Job Guarantee implies a right to a job, although it does not indicate how that right will be secured. However, if we are to include the right to a job as similar to other recognized rights (right to life, right to free speech, right to vote, right to marriage), this would seem to imply that it is government that is to provide the guarantee. Many proponents of the JG do emphasize the human rights angle, interpreting the UN Charter on Human Rights as explicitly guaranteeing the right to access to a job (See Harvey 1989, 1993, 1999; Burgess and Mitchell 1998). Unfortunately, each term carries a negative connotation: ‘last resort’ can be seen as derogatory—the potential workers cannot find anything better; ‘guarantee’ implies that potential workers must be employed no matter what. Together, these associations fuel suspicion that work done is of low quality and otherwise without merit. There have been some efforts to rebrand the proposal as Public Service Employment (PSE) to emphasize the positive potential of such jobs (Wray 1999).

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › FJG = Universal

Job guarantee is defined as a government program to employ any willing worker.

International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, 30 Jun. 2023 (“Job Guarantee”, International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, Encyclopedia.com. <https://www.encyclopedia.com>.)

A job-guarantee program is one in which government promises to make a job available to any qualifying individual who is ready and willing to work. Qualifications required of participants could specify age range (e.g., teens), gender, family status (e.g., heads of households), family income (e.g., below poverty line), educational attainment (e.g., high school dropouts), residency (e.g., rural), and so on. The most general program—sometimes called an employer of last resort (ELR) program—would provide a universal job guarantee by which government promises to provide a job to anyone legally entitled to work.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › GND = Extra T

Green new deal contains multiple programs beyond a jobs guarantee- ag reform, rights to nature, and diplomacy are just a few

DEBORAH D'SOUZA in 2022

Deborah D'Souza is the former news editor at Investopedia. She also writes articles that bring together information from across different financial fields; Understanding the Green New Deal & What's in the Climate Proposal; https://www.investopedia.com/the-green-new-deal-explained-4588463

The main goal of the plan is to bring U.S. greenhouse gas emissions down to net zero and meet 100% of power demand in the country through clean, renewable, and zero-emission energy sources by 2030. The Green New Deal also calls for the creation of millions of jobs to provide a job guarantee to all Americans, along with access to nature, clean air and water, healthy food, a sustainable environment, and community resiliency. These goals are to be accomplished through the following actions on the part of the federal government: Providing investments and leveraging funding to help communities affected by climate change Repairing and upgrading existing infrastructure to withstand extreme weather and ensuring all bills related to infrastructure in Congress address climate change Investing in renewable power sources Investing in manufacturing and industry to spur growth in the use of clean energy Building or upgrading to energy-efficient, distributed, and smart power grids that provide affordable electricity Upgrading all existing buildings and building new ones so that they achieve maximum energy efficiency, water efficiency, safety, affordability, comfort, and durability. Supporting family farming, investing in sustainable farming, and building a more sustainable and equitable food system Investing in transportation systems, namely zero-emission vehicle infrastructure and manufacturing, public transit, and high-speed rail Restoring ecosystems through land preservation, afforestation, and science-based projects Cleaning up existing hazardous waste and abandoned sites Identifying unknown sources of pollution and emissions Working with the international community on solutions and helping them achieve Green New Deals 13

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › GND = Extra T

Green new deal contains multiple components beyond a jobs guarantee

DEBORAH D'SOUZA in 2022

Deborah D'Souza is the former news editor at Investopedia. She also writes articles that bring together information from across different financial fields; Understanding the Green New Deal & What's in the Climate Proposal; https://www.investopedia.com/the-green-new-deal-explained-4588463

While politicians have known about climate change and the idea of a Green New Deal for years, this is the most detailed plan presented to the American people to transform the economy, even though it is extremely vague and acts as a set of principles and goals rather than of specific policies. The text of the resolution details how climate change affects the economy, the environment, and national security, and outlines goals and projects for a 10-year national mobilization. 11 The plan emphasizes environmental and social justice. It acknowledges how historically oppressed groups (indigenous peoples, people of color, the poor, and migrants) are more likely to be affected by climate change and asks that they be included and consulted. Its progressive spirit is reflected in calls for the protection of workers’ rights, community ownership, universal healthcare, and a job guarantee. 12

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › GND = Extra T

Jobs guarantee is just one component of the GND

Deirdre Shelly March 5, 2021

What is A Federal Jobs Guarantee?; https://www.sunrisemovement.org/theory-of-change/what-is-a-federal-jobs-guarantee/

Why is a job guarantee a critical component of the Green New Deal? ?

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › No Spec- Infrastructure Extensions

Requires “essential parts”

David S. Becker ‘14, Partner in the Litigation and Intellectual Property Practice Groups at Freeborn & Peters, LLP, J.D. from DePaul University College of Law, & John C. Hammerle, Associate in the Litigation Practice Group

at Freeborn & Peters, LLP, J.D. from DePaul University College of Law, “The Trouble With “Substantial Completion” in Construction Projects”, Committee News, Winter 2014, https://freeborn.com/assets/the_trouble_with_substantial_completion_in_construction_projects-aba_winter_2014_newsletter.pdf

3 See, e.g., Kinetic Builder’s, Inc. v. Peters, 226 F.3d 1307, 1315 (Fed. Cir. 2000); Ocean Winds Corp. v. Lane, 556 S.E.2d 377, 379 (S.C. 2001) (citing statutory definition of substantial completion as “that degree of completion of a project, improvement, or a specified area or portion thereof . . . upon attainment of which the owner can use the same for the purpose for which it was intended”) (internal citations and emphasis omitted); Daugherty v. Bruce Realty & Dev., Inc., 892 S.W.2d 332, 335 (Mo. Ct. App. 1995) (“a building is substantially complete . . . when it has reached the state of its construction so that it can be put to the use for which it was intended, even though comparatively minor items remain to be furnished or performed to conform to the plans and specifications of the completed building”); E.R. Stone v. City of Arcola, 181 Ill. App. 3d 513, 526 (Ill. App. Ct. 1989) (acknowledging that a project is “substantially complete” at a given date where “it could be used for the purpose for which it was intended on that date”). See also Sorenson v. Dager, 601 N.W.2d 564, 570 (Neb. Ct. App. 1999) (*fix this parenthetical); Evans & Assocs. v. Dyer, 246 Ill. App. 3d 231, 239 (Ill. App. Ct. 1993) (“Substantial performance . . . . means performance in all the essential elements necessary to the accomplishment of the purpose of the contract. ‘Substantial’ means in substance; in the main; essential, including material or essential parts.”)..

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › No Spec- Infrastructure Extensions

‘Substantial’ means totality of circumstances

US First Circuit Court of Appeals ’98

In Re Richard Lamanna, Debtor.first Usa, et al., Appellees, v. Richard Lamanna, AppellantUnited States Court of Appeals, First Circuit. - 153 F.3d 1Heard July 27, 1998.Decided Aug. 25, 1998

Decision Affirmed. The court joins other circuits in adopting the "totality of the circumstances" test as the measure of substantial abuse under the Bankruptcy Code. This is a flexible standard adopted by Congress to allow bankruptcy courts to consider the factors involved in each case and to prevent abuse of Chapter 7 filings. When there is evidence that the consumer can pay their debts, there is likely to be found substantial abuse.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › No Spec- Infrastructure Extensions

Jobs guarantee is distinct from an infrastructure rebuild.

PHILIP HARVEY in 2021

Professor of law and economics at Rutgers Law School.; Infrastructure Investment vs. Job Guarantee; National Jobs For All Network; https://njfac.org/index.php/2021/09/05/infrastructure-investment-vs-job-guarantee/

What is the difference between job guarantee and infrastructure investment? And to what extent would infrastructure investment and a J.G. program serve the aims of the other? The goals of a job guarantee (J.G.) and the infrastructure spending legislation like the American Jobs Plan (AJP) proposed by the Biden Administration or the bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (H.R.) currently under debate in the U.S. Congress are different. -> The purpose of J.G. legislation is to close the economy’s job gap through direct job creation and to administer the job creation program to ensure all job seekers access to proper employment providing fair and adequate wages along with safe and healthful working conditions. -> The purpose of infrastructure investment legislation is to develop and maintain society’s physical and social infrastructure, usually by contracting with private business firms, to perform the work and often stimulate economic growth and create jobs.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › No Spec- Infrastructure Extensions

Infrastructure violates – it’s distinct from a job guarantee and wouldn’t be universal.

Pavlina R. Tcherneva in 2023

Ph.D., an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy, “The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability,” Working Paper Series Open Society University Network Economic Democracy Initiative. https://edi.bard.edu/research/notes/the-job-guarantee-mmts-proposal-for-full-employment-and-price-stability

Large-scale job creation programs are often mistaken for large-scale infrastructure projects. And while it is vital to invest in a nation’s infrastructure as a matter of national priority, such infrastructure investment should not be scheduled around fluctuations of the business cycle. Building schools should be done on as-needed basis, not as an anticyclical policy. Similarly, it would be irrational to build bridges only when the economy is in a recession or, conversely, to discontinue a high-speed rail project on the grounds that the economy is growing. In addition, infrastructure jobs are often high-skill and predominantly male, thus not always suitable for all jobseekers. Large scale infrastructure is not a particularly reliable method for addressing the spatial aspects of unemployment. Jobseekers may live in communities that do not need levees or fire prevention efforts, but may experience multiple other deprivations such as poor access to healthy food or childcare care.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › 1NC- GND- Extra T

Violation- Green new deal is extra topical- jobs guarantee is just one component of a much larger set of mandates

PAVLINA TCHERNEVA in 2019

WHY THE GREEN NEW DEAL INCLUDES A JOBS GUARANTEE; RNN; https://therealnews.com/why-the-green-new-deal-includes-a-jobs-guarantee

PAVLINA TCHERNEVA: Well, I think it’s useful to think of the Green New Deal as a mass mobilization effort. So here we are really talking about an urgent, very bold, very ambitious program that restructures the economy to make fossil fuels a thing of the past and transition to clean energy. The goal here, of course, is to stabilize carbon emissions and to limit warming within the decade. So we’re going to be talking about a wide range of jobs that will be in the energy sector, in the agriculture sector, in the infrastructure sector, to address problems of fallout from climate change, like the fires that we’re watching in California, like the destruction that we see from hurricanes and tornadoes and floods. So we really are talking about a comprehensive program. But I think it’s useful analytically to distinguish the millions of jobs that will be created through the green investment from specifically the Job Guarantee. The Job Guarantee has a unique purpose within this program, and that is the following, that it is essentially the backstop, it is essentially the safety net. It is a program that says if you have lost your fossil fuel job, so to speak, and you have not yet been incorporated into the green sector, we will ensure that transition for you, we will provide the safety net and employment opportunities in the interim in this transition, which for some people will be disruptive, and most likely for the most vulnerable it will be disruptive. DHARNA NOOR: And the New Deal, FDR’s New Deal of the 1930s, included protections for organizing with the National Labor Relations Act, the Wagner Act. The Green Deal resolution specifies that the jobs created under this Jobs Guarantee would be unionized. How could the policy protect workers’ right to organize? PAVLINA TCHERNEVA: Well, I think that’s a very important aspect of the Green New Deal. So here we’re talking about inclusive policies. We’re talking about policies that will address climate change, but will directly target job creation in the most vulnerable communities that experience the floods and the problems with the absence of clean water and pollution and hazardous site areas. And so, we’re talking about not only creating jobs, but really creating jobs in some of the most distressed communities. And those communities also have been the ones that have been lacking decent, good jobs for decades. And we have seen not just the deindustrialization of some of these areas, but also the assault on labor rights, for decades. So here, the Green New Deal is turning the tide and saying look, if we’re going to be creating jobs, and this will be an “all hands on deck” kind of policy, we have to make sure that people are not going to be working in poverty wage jobs. They will be working in decent jobs. So part of that will include a number of labor protections and putting people into union jobs. I think prevailing wages will be one aspect of the Green New Deal. But other people who may not be able to find those employment opportunities, perhaps the most vulnerable amongst us, with the least amount of skill or education who could still contribute to the program, will be absorbed in the Job Guarantee, that we’ll find them employment befitting their skill level. And this is not explicitly stated in the Green New Deal, but the Job Guarantee itself can be unionized. But I want to stress something else. The Job Guarantee, by its nature, formalizes the labor market in ways in which we have not seen from public policy in the past. Imagine a world in which we have a Job Guarantee as a public option for jobs, as a policy that guarantees a basic economic right, that says no one, even the most vulnerable among us, will fall below a certain wage level. And so, we will provide jobs and a base wage with some basic benefits. That has a transformative effect on the entire labor market on the entire spectrum of jobs, because that becomes the standard. And then private employers and public and nonprofit employers will have to meet the standard. DHARNA NOOR: So I do want to talk about that a little bit more. What role, exactly, should the private sector play in this? Because, of course, so much of the American economy is in the private sector, so it seems that in order to create jobs that are in the public sector, you would need to rely in some way on the private sector. Because currently, there is not the ability for the public sector to create things like wind farms or solar panels. PAVLINA TCHERNEVA: That’s right. And so, that’s why I tend to think of these two programs as symbiotic, The Green Deal and the Job Guarantee as symbiotic, but somewhat different in their intent and in their macroeconomic effects. The Green New Deal is, as I said, all hands on deck. We’re going to need all level of skill, knowhow, a technique of production, innovation, et cetera. And that investment, large scale mobilization, will no doubt have to be led by the public sector. But as a practical matter, it will be some sort of partnership through private firms that already perhaps are employing green technologies and that we need to scale up, and that can be mobilized to help with the transition. So it is important for the public sector to take that initiative because the private sector so far has not had the incentive to do so and has really made very few strides towards the transition to a green economy, and we really need a very rapid response. So that’s number one. The second is the Job Guarantee component. And that Job Guarantee component, as I said, is a public option. It’s a transitional jobs program that allows people to find employment opportunities if they have been displaced from hurricanes, find opportunities if they have been laid off, maybe because of recessions, maybe because of restructuring, and then transition out of that program either in these large scale mobilization green efforts, or elsewhere in the economy. So the Job Guarantee has this very specific function of providing a transitional employment opportunity that is decent, that is well-paid, and that allows people to transition in the appropriate places elsewhere in this new economy, green economy. And so, we also need the public sector to lead the way there, because unemployment is not something that the private sector resolves on its own. And if you’re going to have structural change, you just need to have a backstop, something to capture people in the transition.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › 1NC – No Spec

A ‘federal jobs guarantee’ is wholistic and includes multiple jobs.

Bhandari ’19 [Ryan Bhandari; March 25, 2019; Senior Policy Advisor at Thirdway’s Economic Program; Thirdway, “What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?” https://www.thirdway.org/memo/what-is-the-federal-jobs-guarantee-and-what-are-people-saying-about-it]

What is the federal jobs guarantee? A federal jobs guarantee is as simple as it sounds on the surface: everyone in the country will be guaranteed a job by the US government should they desire one. There are two versions right now gaining attention. One plan is written by academics Mark Paul, Sandy Darity, and Darrick Hamilton. The other was written by Pavlina Tcherneva. In general, these plans promise:

Guaranteed jobs in infrastructure repair, ecological restoration, caregiving, and community development projects.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › Jobs Guarantee › 1NC – No Spec

‘Substantial’ means all and without qualification.

Lorne Slotnick 15, Chair of the Arbitration Board, Labour Arbitration Awards has issued the following decision: IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BETWEEN: St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton -and- Canadian Union of Public Employees Local 786, Labour Arbitration Awards: St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton v Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 786, 2015 CanLII 18978 (ON LA), 2015

The union points to the definition of “similar” in the online Oxford English Dictionary as “having a marked resemblance or likeness; of a like nature or kind,” and in Black’s Law Dictionary as “nearly corresponding; resembling in many respects; somewhat like; having a general likeness, although allowing for some degree of difference.” In addition, “substantially” is defined in the Oxford English Dictionary as “in all essential characters or features; in essentials, to all intents and purposes, in the main,” and in Black’s [Law Dictionary] as “essentially; without material qualification; in the main; in substance; materially; in a substantial manner.” The fact that the collective agreement uses both words together must mean that the two shift rotations have to be essentially corresponding or resembling each other in all essential respects for the conditions to be met, the union argues.