Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- at- permutation

3. Pragmatism DA – the perm keeps its foot in the door of neoliberalism as a pragmatic move in the face of neoliberal subject formation – that’s a fatalistic move that captures the alt

Reed 18

(Patricia Reed obtained her BFA from Concordia University, Montreal, and an MA in communications from the European Graduate School, Switzerland. She has been a grant recipient from the Canada Council of the Arts, Akademie Schloss Solitude, Stuttgart (Germany); CCA Kitakyushu (Japan); Foundation and Centre for Contemporary Art Prague, (Czech Rep.); The Banff Centre for the Arts (Canada); and the CCA Ujazdowski, Warsaw (Poland). She was Canada Council Artist in Residence at the Cité des Arts in Paris, 2016. “Optimist Realism: Finance and the Politicization of Anticipation” MoneyLab Reader 2: Overcoming the Hype, 18 January 2018, )

Petrified Futurity Capitalist Realism indexes not only our economic condition, but more pervasively, the 'atmosphere' of political resignation which denies the possibility for any other socio-economic structural scenario. This 'atmosphere' permeates both conscious and unconscious life, including the arena of cultural production (music, art, film, etc.) where instead of seeing boundless innovation (a capitalist premise), we seem caught in retroparalysis: loops of re-makes and pop-cultural revivalism,5 where substantial technological development devolves into trivial consumer gadgetry.' Within such an atmosphere, mental distress and illness has also proliferated as a debilitating symp- tom of the behavioral imperatives this naturalization entails. This is in the way one is compelled to 'govern from within' to adapt to the world successfully in full, entrepre- neurial self-reliance. Such naturalization is internalized as the only system compat- ible with 'innate' humanness, where this picture of 'innateness' is both self-referential and self-reinforcing, coercing the human into a narrow mold wherein the incentive of accumulation through competition is isomorphic with our 'intrinsic' selfishness and self-interest (those very social biases buttressing neoclassical economics, upon which neoliberalism is built). In this framing, capitalism is upheld as the only system com- mensurate with the 'nature' of the human; to suggest otherwise is to fall prey to folly, almost as nonsensical as fighting the fact of gravity on earth. The diagnosis Fisher puts forth, quite pointedly, is that Capitalist Realism petrifies politics because it stifles our imaginative and perspectival horizons. The axiom then gets extrapolated: if futurity is always a political project and politics is dead-locked, our future, as such, has become cancelled - a point to which we will return.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- climate change

Financialization of capital is at the root of the fossil fuel economy – makes climate change inevitable

Foster 19

John Foster, Prof of Sociology at the Univ of Oregon, “Capitalism Has Failed – What Next?” Monthly Review, 02/01/19, .

A characteristic of this new era of financialized accumulation is that it is progressively removed from the realities of production and use value, heightening the conflict between exchange value (the value form) and use value (the natural form) within the overall production and accumulation process.71 The result is “a social and ecological planetary emergency.”72 This is most evident in the rapid destruction of the natural environment. Fossil fuels are entered as financial assets on the books of corporations, even when they exist only in the form of reserves buried in the ground. In this way, they are integral to the entire financialized accumulation process of monopoly capitalism. Trillions of dollars of Wall Street assets are thus tied up in fossil capital.73 This has made it doubly difficult to shift away from the extraction and use of fossil fuels to more sustainable alternatives, such as solar and wind power. No one owns the sun’s rays or the wind. Hence, there is less of a vested interest in these forms of energy. In today’s capitalism, more than ever before, current and potential future profits dictate all, at the expense of people and the planet. The human population stands by, seemingly helpless, watching the destruction of the climate and the loss of innumerable species, all imposed by the ostensibly overwhelming force of market society.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- climate change

Capitalism necessitates mass environmental destruction – the entire planet is the sacrifice zone for the demands of growth

Monbiot 19 [George, investigative journalist and environmental activist, recipient of the SEAL Environmental Journalism Award, attempted citizen’s arrest of John Bolton, “Dare to declare capitalism dead – before it takes us all down with it,” The Guardian, 04/25/19, ]

For most of my adult life I’ve railed against “corporate capitalism”, “consumer capitalism” and “crony capitalism”. It took me a long time to see that the problem is not the adjective but the noun. While some people have rejected capitalism gladly and swiftly, I’ve done so slowly and reluctantly. Part of the reason was that I could see no clear alternative: unlike some anti-capitalists, I have never been an enthusiast for state communism. I was also inhibited by its religious status. To say “capitalism is failing” in the 21st century is like saying “God is dead” in the 19th: it is secular blasphemy. It requires a degree of self-confidence I did not possess. But as I’ve grown older, I’ve come to recognise two things. First, that it is the system, rather than any variant of the system, that drives us inexorably towards disaster. Second, that you do not have to produce a definitive alternative to say that capitalism is failing. The statement stands in its own right. But it also demands another, and different, effort to develop a new system. Capitalism’s failures arise from two of its defining elements. The first is perpetual growth. Economic growth is the aggregate effect of the quest to accumulate capital and extract profit. Capitalism collapses without growth, yet perpetual growth on a finite planet leads inexorably to environmental calamity. Those who defend capitalism argue that, as consumption switches from goods to services, economic growth can be decoupled from the use of material resources. Last week a paper in the journal New Political Economy, by Jason Hickel and Giorgos Kallis, examined this premise. They found that while some relative decoupling took place in the 20th century (material resource consumption grew, but not as quickly as economic growth), in the 21st century there has been a recoupling: rising resource consumption has so far matched or exceeded the rate of economic growth. The absolute decoupling needed to avert environmental catastrophe (a reduction in material resource use) has never been achieved, and appears impossible while economic growth continues. Green growth is an illusion. A system based on perpetual growth cannot function without peripheries and externalities. There must always be an extraction zone – from which materials are taken without full payment – and a disposal zone, where costs are dumped in the form of waste and pollution. As the scale of economic activity increases until capitalism affects everything, from the atmosphere to the deep ocean floor, the entire planet becomes a sacrifice zone: we all inhabit the periphery of the profit-making machine. This drives us towards cataclysm on such a scale that most people have no means of imagining it. The threatened collapse of our life-support systems is bigger by far than war, famine, pestilence or economic crisis, though it is likely to incorporate all four. Societies can recover from these apocalyptic events, but not from the loss of soil, an abundant biosphere and a habitable climate. The second defining element is the bizarre assumption that a person is entitled to as great a share of the world’s natural wealth as their money can buy. This seizure of common goods causes three further dislocations. First, the scramble for exclusive control of non-reproducible assets, which implies either violence or legislative truncations of other people’s rights. Second, the immiseration of other people by an economy based on looting across both space and time. Third, the translation of economic power into political power, as control over essential resources leads to control over the social relations that surround them. In the New York Times on Sunday, the Nobel economist Joseph Stiglitz sought to distinguish between good capitalism, which he called “wealth creation”, and bad capitalism, which he called “wealth grabbing” (extracting rent). I understand his distinction. But from the environmental point of view, wealth creation is wealth grabbing. Economic growth, intrinsically linked to the increasing use of material resources, means seizing natural wealth from both living systems and future generations. To point to such problems is to invite a barrage of accusations, many of which are based on this premise: capitalism has rescued hundreds of millions of people from poverty – now you want to impoverish them again. It is true that capitalism, and the economic growth it drives, has radically improved the prosperity of vast numbers of people, while simultaneously destroying the prosperity of many others: those whose land, labour and resources were seized to fuel growth elsewhere. Much of the wealth of the rich nations was – and is – built on slavery and colonial expropriation.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- climate change

Climate change is inevitable within capitalism – only class struggle aimed at a revolutionary reconstitution of the system of production has a chance of staving off the worst impacts and organizing around the most vulnerable

Foster & Clark 22 [John Bellamy, Prof of Sociology at the Univ of Oregon, Brett, Prof of Sociology and Sustainability Studies at the University of Utah, “Socialism and Ecological Survival: An Introduction,” Monthly Review, 07/01/22, ]

Capitalism has brought the world to the edge of the abyss. We are rapidly approaching a planetary tipping point in the form of a climate Armageddon, threatening to make the earth unlivable for the human species, as well as innumerable other species. Such an absolute catastrophe for civilization and the human species as a whole is still avoidable with a revolutionary-scale reconstitution of the current system of production, consumption, and energy usage, though the time in which to act is rapidly running out.2 Nevertheless, while it is still possible to avoid irreversible climate change through a massive transformation in the mode of production, it is no longer feasible to circumvent accelerating environmental disasters in the present century on a scale never seen before in human history, endangering the lives and living conditions of billions of people. Humanity, therefore, is facing issues of ecological survival on two levels: (1) a still reversible but rapidly worsening Earth System crisis, threatening to undermine civilization as a whole and make the planet uninhabitable for the human species, and (2) accelerating extreme weather and other ecological disasters associated with climate change that are now unavoidable in the coming decades, affecting localities and regions throughout the globe. Social mobilization and radical social change are required if devastating near-term costs to people and communities, falling especially on the most vulnerable, are to be prevented. Six decades after the threat of accelerated global warming was first raised by scientists, the situation has only gotten worse. In August 2021, UN secretary general António Guterres declared that it is “Code Red for Humanity.”3 His warning coincided with the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) release of the Physical Science Basis report of Working Group I of its Sixth Assessment Report (AR6). In this report, five primary scenarios were provided with respect to climate mitigation. Among the most significant findings was that even in the best-case scenario (SSP1-1.9), requiring at this point nothing less than a rapidly escalating transformation of the entire global system of production and consumption, the world will surpass a 1.5°C increase in global average temperature after 2040, and will not get below that temperature again until the very end of this century.4 The second scenario (SSP1-2.6) points to an increase in global average temperature at the end of the century of 1.8°C (still well below the guardrail of 2°C). The threat of irreversible planetary catastrophe is represented by the next three IPCC scenarios. The fifth scenario (SSP5-8.5) points to an increase in the global average temperature of 4.4°C (best estimate)—spelling the collapse of civilization and absolute disaster for the human species. To avoid such a prospect, given the direction in which the world is now headed, it is necessary to reverse “business as usual,” transcending the prevailing logic of an “unsustainable” capitalist system.5 At the same time, the IPCC report makes it clear that it is no longer conceivable to prevent accelerating climate disasters this century, even in the best-case scenario, in which an irrevocable planetary tipping point would be avoided. The decades immediately ahead will therefore see the proliferation of extreme weather events that will compound one another: heavy precipitation, megastorms, floods, heatwaves, droughts, wildfires, and failing monsoons. Sea-level rise will continue throughout this century and beyond, regardless of the actions taken by humanity—though the rate of sea-level rise can still be affected by the world’s actions. Massive global crop failures are to be expected.6 Climate refugees will be in the hundreds of millions.7 All of this is further complicated by the fact that climate change is not the only planetary boundary that capitalism is currently crossing or threatening to transgress. Others include: the loss of biological diversity (marking the sixth extinction), ocean acidification, disruption of the nitrogen and phosphorus cycles, loss of ground cover (including forests), loss of freshwater resources, chemical pollution, and radioactive contamination.8 Up to now, the ecological, including ecosocialist, strategy with respect to climate change has focused almost entirely on mitigation, aimed at stopping greenhouse gas emissions, particularly carbon emissions, before it is too late. Yet, this general approach has all too often been rooted in a type of reformist environmentalism that does not seriously challenge the parameters of the present system, allowing the ecological crisis to deepen and expand. Mitigation—but today necessarily of a far more revolutionary character—still has to play the leading role in any global climate strategy, since it is essential for the continuation of civilization and survival of the human species (and most of the known species on Earth). However, it is now also necessary, given the inevitable degradation of the earth this century, to mobilize immediately for survival at the level of communities, regions, nations, and whole peoples. The harsh reality is that during the next few decades, which according to even the IPCC’s most optimistic scenario will involve breaching the 1.5°C threshold—at least for a time—humanity will inevitably see the proliferation of environmental catastrophes at all levels and throughout the planet. This requires that populations organize, plan, and create spaces of ecological sustainability and substantive equality designed to protect what Karl Marx called “the chain of human generations.”9 Self-mobilization of populations in order to protect lives, communities, and local and national environments, while carrying out revolutionary changes at all levels of existence as part of completely reorganizing production, consumption, and energy usage, now constitutes the pathway to ecological survival. Yet, this new strategic moment, in which mitigation has to be accompanied by environmental disaster management aimed at protecting populations in the community in the present as well as future, has not yet been fully mapped. A broad revolutionary ecological and socialist strategy has to be articulated that transcends the dominant liberal refrains of individual “adaptation” and “resilience,” which largely deny the realities of class, race, gender, and imperialism—along with the metabolic rift between capitalism and the environment.10 The only meaningful, radical approach to these unprecedented challenges and multiple levels of catastrophe is that of socialism as a pathway to ecological survival. It is now widely understood within natural science that the Holocene Epoch in the geological history of the earth of the last twelve millennia has ended and that the planet entered into the Anthropocene Epoch around 1950.11 The Anthropocene Epoch is defined as the geological epoch in which anthropogenic, rather than non-anthropogenic factors (as in the entire prior history of the earth), now largely determine the rate of Earth System change. In what might be called the Capitalinian Age, the first geological age of the Anthropocene, the world is characterized by an Anthropocene crisis associated with “anthropogenic rifts” in the biogeochemical cycles of the planet, brought on by the Great Acceleration of the human impact on the planet under mature monopoly capitalism.12 What is needed in these circumstances is the creation of a novel mode of production ushering in a new geological age of the Anthropocene (since the Anthropocene itself is now a permanent feature of geological history, as long as human civilization continues). In a previous analysis, we dubbed this potential future geological age of the Anthropocene the Communian Age, standing for community, communal, and the commons. The advent of the Communian Age would mark the historical development of a new, higher, more sustainable human relation to the earth, one which could only come about through ecological, collective, and socialist action. This transition to the second age of the Anthropocene, transcending the present Capitalinian, must begin as soon as possible to protect lives, coordinate environmental disaster management strategies, and undercut the momentum associated with the accelerating trends of ecological disaster.13 Such revolutionary, socialist transformations constitute the necessary foundation for survival, moving forward in this century.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- disease

Capitalism makes massive pandemics inevitable through numerous new vectors for disease spread

Friedman 21 [Samuel R.; 11-4-21; Department of Population Health, NYU Grossman School of Medicine, “Environmental change and infectious diseases in the Mediterranean region and the world: an interpretive dialectical analysis” ]

A review of infectious disease epidemics over the last generation shows that many of them began due to socioeconomic processes tied to capitalist growth. HIV first emerged in in the Congo River Basin in the early 1900s after colonial conquests led to the extension of agricultural markets and labor systems. It then diffused along trade routes that were used to bring products to market or labor to and from the new agricultural enterprises (Faria et al. 2014; Gray et al. 2009; Tebit and Arts 2011; Timberg and Halperin 2013). The spread of HIV was accelerated by underfunded medical systems that imperial governments established to limit the spread of sexually transmitted and other diseases, which led to iatrogenic sharing of syringes and consequent HIV transmission (the extent of which has been subject to considerable controversy) (Gisselquist et al. 2004; Hoelscher et al. 1994; Kiwanuka et al. 2004; Pépin 2012; Reid 2009). Capitalist growth-oriented activities destroy the habitats of many animals, often leading them and the pathogens they carry into close contact with people. In addition, investors find it profitable to capture and sell a wide variety of “exotic” animals as food or as pets, bringing animal vectors and their (potential) disease agents into contact with each other and with people. Corporations find it profitable to raise common meat sources such as pigs and chickens in factory farms where they are jammed together. All of these processes allow viruses or other agents to jump from species to species, and to mutate into virulent forms. Modern transportation routes, maintained in large part to facilitate business travel, rapidly spread emerging diseases across geographic regions. In recent decades, these dynamics have led to outbreaks of Ebola, SARS, new virulent strains of influenza, and SARS-CoV-2 (Davis 2005, 2020; Johnson et al. 2020; United Nations Environment Programme and International Livestock Research Institute 2020; Wallace 2016; Wallace et al. 2020; Weiss and McMichael 2004). As described in a recent United Nations publication, there are seven human-mediated “drivers of the emergence of zoonotic diseases: (1) increasing human demand for animal protein; (2) unsustainable agricultural intensification; (3) increased use and exploitation of wildlife; (4) unsustainable utilization of natural resources accelerated by urbanization, land use change and extractive industries; (5) increased travel and transportation; (6) changes in food supply; and (7) climate change” (United Nations Environment Programme and International Livestock Research Institute 2020). Each of these seven drivers is a result of capital’s need for growth, as described in the preceding paragraph. Detailed examination of public health and other responses to the HIV/AIDS epidemic shows that individualistic belief systems tied to capitalist neoliberalism limited what was done to primarily behavioral (as opposed to social or structural) interventions (Anon 1995; Auerbach et al. 2011; Chan 2015; Decoteau 2013; Friedman et al. 1992; Kippax and Stephenson 2016; Nguyen 2010). Since the discovery of effective antiretroviral therapies, the interests of pharmaceutical firms in maximizing profits have limited the application of antiretroviral therapies in “treatment as prevention” strategies (Chan 2015; Kippax and Stephenson 2016). International and philanthropic efforts to implement treatment as prevention using antiretroviral therapy have increased access to this therapy, but these efforts remain insufficient and may be seriously impeded by the severe economic downturn and fiscal crises that began in 2019 and are being greatly enhanced by the COVID-19 crisis (Fauci and Lane 2020; Kates et al. 2018). Responses to the COVID-19 pandemic have likewise been shaped by the need for capitalism for growth and profits—although the pandemic has indeed created a profitability and growth crisis that has been reflected in different countries by different policies in terms of how and when they have shut and reopened various public services and industries, how they have attempted to sustain the livelihoods of those who cannot work (and therefore “effective demand”) and thus sales volumes, and governmental and individual reactions to the use of face masks. It is clear that, in spite of strong tendencies among scientists to cooperate and make information widely available in the face of the pandemic, the need for pharmaceutical companies and governments to prevail in competition has created barriers to this. Capitalism and environmental crises In a closely related pattern, the capitalist need for continuous growth has driven the production of greenhouse gases and the pollution of the oceans, the atmosphere, and much of the land. This has been detailed in the many reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), and much additional literature (Dunlap and Brulle 2015; Foster 2013a, b; IPCC 2014; Levy and Patz 2015; Masson-Delmotte et al. 2019; Moore 2015; Schwartzman and Schwartzman 2019). In its report Global Warming of 1.5°, the IPCC reports that the Mediterranean area will probably suffer from a particularly strong increase in temperatures and a particularly severe decrease in rainfall and periods of extreme drought, with concomitant decreases in food production in the area (Masson-Delmotte et al. 2019). These pose the threat of increased social conflict and war. Considerable evidence already suggests that both the Arab Spring uprisings of 2011 and the Syrian Civil War and international involvement therein are rooted in early manifestations of these processes (Kelley et al. 2015; Werrell and Femia 2013). Civil wars and wars among nations have well-known tendencies to create conditions for epidemics of infectious diseases such as cholera, sexually transmitted infections, and vector-borne infections. In addition, there are likely to be changing and complicated effects of the mixture of drought and rising sea levels (Reisen 2015; Rose and Wu 2015). Rising sea levels may create new mosquito-breeding swamps or other pools of stagnant water, increasing rates of malaria. Drought will probably lead to migrations of vector-bearing fauna, and higher temperatures are likely to increase the frequency of vectors feeding on human blood. Nonetheless, there are a wide variety of arthropods and other vectors (carrying different pathogens), some of which may become more prevalent and some of which may become less prevalent due to the drought. It is thus difficult to predict which specific vector-borne diseases will become major problems, and additional research on this is clearly needed. We can be reasonably sure, however, that high levels of urbanization and internal and international migration will tend to magnify the outbreaks that do occur.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- nuclear war

Capitalism ensures global destruction – numerous paths to nuclear war and extinction

Foster 19 [John, Prof of Sociology at the Univ of Oregon, “Capitalism Has Failed – What Next?” Monthly Review, 02/01/19, ]

War, engineered by the United States and other major powers at the apex of the system, has become perpetual in strategic oil regions such as the Middle East, and threatens to escalate into a global thermonuclear exchange. During the Obama administration, the United States was engaged in wars/bombings in seven different countries—Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Yemen, Somalia, and Pakistan.28 Torture and assassinations have been reinstituted by Washington as acceptable instruments of war against those now innumerable individuals, group networks, and whole societies that are branded as terrorist. A new Cold War and nuclear arms race is in the making between the United States and Russia, while Washington is seeking to place road blocks to the continued rise of China. The Trump administration has created a new space force as a separate branch of the military in an attempt to ensure U.S. dominance in the militarization of space. Sounding the alarm on the increasing dangers of a nuclear war and of climate destabilization, the distinguished Bulletin of Atomic Scientists moved its doomsday clock in 2018 to two minutes to midnight, the closest since 1953, when it marked the advent of thermonuclear weapons.29 Increasingly severe economic sanctions are being imposed by the United States on countries like Venezuela and Nicaragua, despite their democratic elections—or because of them. Trade and currency wars are being actively promoted by core states, while racist barriers against immigration continue to be erected in Europe and the United States as some 60 million refugees and internally displaced peoples flee devastated environments. Migrant populations worldwide have risen to 250 million, with those residing in high-income countries constituting more than 14 percent of the populations of those countries, up from less than 10 percent in 2000. Meanwhile, ruling circles and wealthy countries seek to wall off islands of power and privilege from the mass of humanity, who are to be left to their fate.30 More than three-quarters of a billion people, over 10 percent of the world population, are chronically malnourished.31 Food stress in the United States keeps climbing, leading to the rapid growth of cheap dollar stores selling poor quality and toxic food. Around forty million Americans, representing one out of eight households, including nearly thirteen million children, are food insecure.32 Subsistence farmers are being pushed off their lands by agribusiness, private capital, and sovereign wealth funds in a global depeasantization process that constitutes the greatest movement of people in history.33 Urban overcrowding and poverty across much of the globe is so severe that one can now reasonably refer to a “planet of slums.”34 Meanwhile, the world housing market is estimated to be worth up to $163 trillion (as compared to the value of gold mined over all recorded history, estimated at $7.5 trillion).35 The Anthropocene epoch, first ushered in by the Great Acceleration of the world economy immediately after the Second World War, has generated enormous rifts in planetary boundaries, extending from climate change to ocean acidification, to the sixth extinction, to disruption of the global nitrogen and phosphorus cycles, to the loss of freshwater, to the disappearance of forests, to widespread toxic-chemical and radioactive pollution.36 It is now estimated that 60 percent of the world’s wildlife vertebrate population (including mammals, reptiles, amphibians, birds, and fish) have been wiped out since 1970, while the worldwide abundance of invertebrates has declined by 45 percent in recent decades.37 What climatologist James Hansen calls the “species exterminations” resulting from accelerating climate change and rapidly shifting climate zones are only compounding this general process of biodiversity loss. Biologists expect that half of all species will be facing extinction by the end of the century.38 If present climate-change trends continue, the “global carbon budget” associated with a 2°C increase in average global temperature will be broken in sixteen years (while a 1.5°C increase in global average temperature—staying beneath which is the key to long-term stabilization of the climate—will be reached in a decade). Earth System scientists warn that the world is now perilously close to a Hothouse Earth, in which catastrophic climate change will be locked in and irreversible.39 The ecological, social, and economic costs to humanity of continuing to increase carbon emissions by 2.0 percent a year as in recent decades (rising in 2018 by 2.7 percent—3.4 percent in the United States), and failing to meet the minimal 3.0 percent annual reductions in emissions currently needed to avoid a catastrophic destabilization of the earth’s energy balance, are simply incalculable.40 Nevertheless, major energy corporations continue to lie about climate change, promoting and bankrolling climate denialism—while admitting the truth in their internal documents. These corporations are working to accelerate the extraction and production of fossil fuels, including the dirtiest, most greenhouse gas-generating varieties, reaping enormous profits in the process. The melting of the Arctic ice from global warming is seen by capital as a new El Dorado, opening up massive additional oil and gas reserves to be exploited without regard to the consequences for the earth’s climate. In response to scientific reports on climate change, Exxon Mobil declared that it intends to extract and sell all of the fossil-fuel reserves at its disposal.41 Energy corporations continue to intervene in climate negotiations to ensure that any agreements to limit carbon emissions are defanged. Capitalist countries across the board are putting the accumulation of wealth for a few above combatting climate destabilization, threatening the very future of humanity. Capitalism is best understood as a competitive class-based mode of production and exchange geared to the accumulation of capital through the exploitation of workers’ labor power and the private appropriation of surplus value (value generated beyond the costs of the workers’ own reproduction). The mode of economic accounting intrinsic to capitalism designates as a value-generating good or service anything that passes through the market and therefore produces income. It follows that the greater part of the social and environmental costs of production outside the market are excluded in this form of valuation and are treated as mere negative “externalities,” unrelated to the capitalist economy itself—whether in terms of the shortening and degradation of human life or the destruction of the natural environment. As environmental economist K. William Kapp stated, “capitalism must be regarded as an economy of unpaid costs.”42 We have now reached a point in the twenty-first century in which the externalities of this irrational system, such as the costs of war, the depletion of natural resources, the waste of human lives, and the disruption of the planetary environment, now far exceed any future economic benefits that capitalism offers to society as a whole. The accumulation of capital and the amassing of wealth are increasingly occurring at the expense of an irrevocable rift in the social and environmental conditions governing human life on earth.43

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- structural violence

Capitalism generates global apartheid of extreme exploitation and neofascist militarism

Robinson 16 [William, distinguished professor of sociology, global studies and Latin American studies at UC Santa Barbara, “Sadistic Capitalism: Six Urgent Matters for Humanity in Global Crisis,” truthout, 04/12/16, ]

3) The sheer magnitude of the means of violence is unprecedented, as is the concentrated control over the means of global communications and the production and circulation of knowledge, symbols and images. We have seen the spread of frightening new systems of social control and repression that have brought us into the panoptical surveillance society and the age of thought control. This real-life Orwellian world is in a sense more perturbing than that described by George Orwell in his iconic novel 1984. In that fictional world, people were compelled to give their obedience to the state (“Big Brother”) in exchange for a quiet existence with guarantees of employment, housing and other social necessities. Now, however, the corporate and political powers that be force obedience even as the means of survival are denied to the vast majority. Global apartheid involves the creation of “green zones” that are cordoned off in each locale around the world where elites are insulated through new systems of spatial reorganization, social control and policing. “Green zone” refers to the nearly impenetrable area in central Baghdad that US occupation forces established in the wake of the 2003 invasion of Iraq. The command center of the occupation and select Iraqi elite inside that green zone were protected from the violence and chaos that engulfed the country. Urban areas around the world are now green zoned through gentrification, gated communities, surveillance systems, and state and private violence. Inside the world’s green zones, privileged strata avail themselves of privatized social services, consumption and entertainment. They can work and communicate through internet and satellite sealed off under the protection of armies of soldiers, police and private security forces. Green zoning takes on distinct forms in each locality. In Palestine, I witnessed such zoning in the form of Israeli military checkpoints, Jewish settler-only roads and the apartheid wall. In Mexico City, the most exclusive residential areas in the upscale Santa Fe District are accessible only by helicopter and private gated roads. In Johannesburg, a surreal drive through the exclusive Sandton City area reveals rows of mansions that appear as military compounds, with private armed towers and electrical and barbed-wire fences. In Cairo, I toured satellite cities ringing the impoverished center and inner suburbs where the country’s elite could live out their aspirations and fantasies. They sport gated residential complexes with spotless green lawns, private leisure and shopping centers and English-language international schools under the protection of military checkpoints and private security police. In other cities, green zoning is subtler but no less effective. In Los Angeles, where I live, the freeway system now has an express lane reserved for those that can pay an exorbitant toll. On this lane, the privileged speed by, while the rest remain one lane over, stuck in the city’s notorious bumper-to-bumper traffic — or even worse, in notoriously underfunded and underdeveloped public transportation, where it may take half a day to get to and from work. There is no barrier separating this express lane from the others. However, a near-invisible closed surveillance system monitors every movement. If a vehicle without authorization shifts into the exclusive lane, it is instantly recorded by this surveillance system and a heavy fine is imposed on the driver, under threat of impoundment, while freeway police patrols are ubiquitous. Outside of the global green zones, warfare and police containment have become normalized and sanitized for those not directly at the receiving end of armed aggression. “Militainment” — portraying and even glamorizing war and violence as entertaining spectacles through Hollywood films and television police shows, computer games and corporate “news” channels — may be the epitome of sadistic capitalism. It desensitizes, bringing about complacency and indifference. In between the green zones and outright warfare are prison industrial complexes, immigrant and refugee repression and control systems, the criminalization of outcast communities and capitalist schooling. The omnipresent media and cultural apparatuses of the corporate economy, in particular, aim to colonize the mind — to undermine the ability to think critically and outside the dominant worldview. A neofascist culture emerges through militarism, extreme masculinization, racism and racist mobilizations against scapegoats. 4) We are reaching limits to the extensive expansion of capitalism. Capitalism is like riding a bicycle: When you stop pedaling the bicycle, you fall over. If the capitalist system stops expanding outward, it enters crisis and faces collapse. In each earlier structural crisis, the system went through a new round of extensive expansion — from waves of colonial conquest in earlier centuries, to the integration in the late 20th and early 21st centuries of the former socialist countries, China, India and other areas that had been marginally outside the system. There are no longer any new territories to integrate into world capitalism. Meanwhile, the privatization of education, health care, utilities, basic services and public land are turning those spaces in global society that were outside of capital’s control into “spaces of capital.” Even poverty has been turned into a commodity. What is there left to commodify? Where can the system now expand? With the limits to expansion comes a turn toward militarized accumulation — making wars of endless destruction and reconstruction and expanding the militarization of social and political institutions so as to continue to generate new opportunities for accumulation in the face of stagnation. 5) There is the rise of a vast surplus population inhabiting a “planet of slums,” alienated from the productive economy, thrown into the margins and subject to these sophisticated systems of social control and destruction. Global capitalism has no direct use for surplus humanity. But indirectly, it holds wages down everywhere and makes new systems of 21st century slavery possible. These systems include prison labor, the forced recruitment of miners at gunpoint by warlords contracted by global corporations to dig up valuable minerals in the Congo, sweatshops and exploited immigrant communities (including the rising tide of immigrant female caregivers for affluent populations). Furthermore, the global working class is experiencing accelerated “precariatization.” The “new precariat” refers to the proletariat that faces capital under today’s unstable and precarious labor relations — informalization, casualization, part-time, temp, immigrant and contract labor. As communities are uprooted everywhere, there is a rising reserve army of immigrant labor. The global working class is becoming divided into citizen and immigrant workers. The latter are particularly attractive to transnational capital, as the lack of citizenship rights makes them particularly vulnerable, and therefore, exploitable. The challenge for dominant groups is how to contain the real and potential rebellion of surplus humanity, the immigrant workforce and the precariat. How can they contain the explosive contradictions of this system? The 21st century megacities become the battlegrounds between mass resistance movements and the new systems of mass repression. Some populations in these cities (and also in abandoned countryside) are at risk of genocide, such as those in Gaza, zones in Somalia and Congo, and swaths of Iraq and Syria.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- economic inequality

Growing economic inequality undermines growth

Baker & Salop 15

Jonathan Baker- Prof of Law at American Univ Washington College of Law. Steven Salop- Prof of Economics and Law at Georgetown Univ Law Center, “Antitrust, Competition Policy, and Inequality,” Georgetown Law Journal Online 104, https://tinyurl.com/hvpvetn2, p.8-10

Inequality also can reduce economic growth. The economic literature has reached a “tentative consensus” that inequality “tends to reduce the pace and durability of growth.”35 Even a small reduction in the long-term rate of growth makes a substantial difference to economic well-being from one generation to the next. 36 Inequality can slow economic growth for several reasons. Workers in families experiencing financial hardship may find it difficult to invest in education and training because they lack the necessary savings and because financial market imperfections limit their ability to borrow against their future prospects.37 Their incentives to change jobs, learn new skills, or start new businesses also can be reduced. Poverty makes it harder for students to learn, and a majority of the students in public schools today are from low-income families. 38 Moreover, the disproportionate influence on public policy by those at the very top can lead to insufficient provision of public goods that would disproportionately benefit others, even when those programs foster overall economic growth. These same factors also can contribute to creating a vicious cycle of widening inequality. We are not claiming that concerns about inequality are ignored in our society. Social insurance programs provide benefits to people who are unemployed, poor, retired and disabled. Government programs support public goods such as health care, education, job training, and housing. While certain redistributive policies may impede growth,39 redistribution has generally not done so in practice. 40 Instead, these programs have been found to encourage economic growth, even when they are funded in ways that redistribute resources away from those at the top.41 Despite these benefits from redistribution, existing programs do not appear to have offset the growing inequality in our economy.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- economic inequality

Massive wealth gap rooted in financialization of the economy

Foster et al 21

John, Prof of Sociology at the Univ of Oregon, “The Contagion of Capital,” Monthly Review, 01/01/21,

The U.S. economy and society at the start of 2021 is more polarized than it has been at any point since the Civil War. The wealthy are awash in a flood of riches, marked by a booming stock market, while the underlying population exists in a state of relative, and in some cases even absolute, misery and decline. The result is two national economies as perceived, respectively, by the top and the bottom of society: one of prosperity, the other of precariousness. At the level of production, economic stagnation is diminishing the life expectations of the vast majority. At the same time, financialization is accelerating the consolidation of wealth by a very few. Although the current crisis of production associated with the COVID-19 pandemic has sharpened these disparities, the overall problem is much longer and more deep-seated, a manifestation of the inner contradictions of monopoly-finance capital. Comprehending the basic parameters of today’s financialized capitalist system is the key to understanding the contemporary contagion of capital, a corrupting and corrosive cash nexus that is spreading to all corners of the U.S. economy, the globe, and every aspect of human existence.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- laundry list

Capitalism is unsustainable and plunging the world into a global civil war – ramping up tensions with Russia and China to distract from crises accelerates the tendency to over-accumulate, causing extinction through nuclear war, climate change, super-viruses, the rise of fascism, and rampant inequality.

Robinson, 21

William I. Robinson, prof. sociology and global studies @ UCSB: "What are the real reasons behind the New Cold War?" ROAR Magazine, published 5-6-21, https://roarmag.org/essays/new-cold-war-crisis-capitalism/?fbclid=IwAR2RzXn0SMlPSiLfXcXNtTcDIybQa6GxH_eodUmyEww2i59lh5qHpZpcwhk

The US is launching a New Cold War against Russia and China in an attempt to deflect our attention from the escalating crisis of global capitalism.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Impacts › 2nc- !- laundry list

Capitalism controls all the impacts

Foster 19 [John, Prof of Sociology at the Univ of Oregon, “Capitalism Has Failed – What Next?” Monthly Review, 02/01/19, , accessed 08/22/21, JCR]

Less than two decades into the twenty-first century, it is evident that capitalism has failed as a social system. The world is mired in economic stagnation, financialization, and the most extreme inequality in human history, accompanied by mass unemployment and underemployment, precariousness, poverty, hunger, wasted output and lives, and what at this point can only be called a planetary ecological “death spiral.”1 The digital revolution, the greatest technological advance of our time, has rapidly mutated from a promise of free communication and liberated production into new means of surveillance, control, and displacement of the working population. The institutions of liberal democracy are at the point of collapse, while fascism, the rear guard of the capitalist system, is again on the march, along with patriarchy, racism, imperialism, and war. To say that capitalism is a failed system is not, of course, to suggest that its breakdown and disintegration is imminent.2 It does, however, mean that it has passed from being a historically necessary and creative system at its inception to being a historically unnecessary and destructive one in the present century. Today, more than ever, the world is faced with the epochal choice between “the revolutionary reconstitution of society at large and the common ruin of the contending classes.”3 Indications of this failure of capitalism are everywhere. Stagnation of investment punctuated by bubbles of financial expansion, which then inevitably burst, now characterizes the so-called free market.4 Soaring inequality in income and wealth has its counterpart in the declining material circumstances of a majority of the population. Real wages for most workers in the United States have barely budged in forty years despite steadily rising productivity.5 Work intensity has increased, while work and safety protections on the job have been systematically jettisoned. Unemployment data has become more and more meaningless due to a new institutionalized underemployment in the form of contract labor in the gig economy.6 Unions have been reduced to mere shadows of their former glory as capitalism has asserted totalitarian control over workplaces. With the demise of Soviet-type societies, social democracy in Europe has perished in the new atmosphere of “liberated capitalism.”7 The capture of the surplus value produced by overexploited populations in the poorest regions of the world, via the global labor arbitrage instituted by multinational corporations, is leading to an unprecedented amassing of financial wealth at the center of the world economy and relative poverty in the periphery.8 Around $21 trillion of offshore funds are currently lodged in tax havens on islands mostly in the Caribbean, constituting “the fortified refuge of Big Finance.”9 Technologically driven monopolies resulting from the global-communications revolution, together with the rise to dominance of Wall Street-based financial capital geared to speculative asset creation, have further contributed to the riches of today’s “1 percent.” Forty-two billionaires now enjoy as much wealth as half the world’s population, while the three richest men in the United States—Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates, and Warren Buffett—have more wealth than half the U.S. population.10 In every region of the world, inequality has increased sharply in recent decades.11 The gap in per capita income and wealth between the richest and poorest nations, which has been the dominant trend for centuries, is rapidly widening once again.12 More than 60 percent of the world’s employed population, some two billion people, now work in the impoverished informal sector, forming a massive global proletariat. The global reserve army of labor is some 70 percent larger than the active labor army of formally employed workers.13 Adequate health care, housing, education, and clean water and air are increasingly out of reach for large sections of the population, even in wealthy countries in North America and Europe, while transportation is becoming more difficult in the United States and many other countries due to irrationally high levels of dependency on the automobile and disinvestment in public transportation. Urban structures are more and more characterized by gentrification and segregation, with cities becoming the playthings of the well-to-do while marginalized populations are shunted aside. About half a million people, most of them children, are homeless on any given night in the United States.14 New York City is experiencing a major rat infestation, attributed to warming temperatures, mirroring trends around the world.15 In the United States and other high-income countries, life expectancy is in decline, with a remarkable resurgence of Victorian illnesses related to poverty and exploitation. In Britain, gout, scarlet fever, whooping cough, and even scurvy are now resurgent, along with tuberculosis. With inadequate enforcement of work health and safety regulations, black lung disease has returned with a vengeance in U.S. coal country.16 Overuse of antibiotics, particularly by capitalist agribusiness, is leading to an antibiotic-resistance crisis, with the dangerous growth of superbugs generating increasing numbers of deaths, which by mid–century could surpass annual cancer deaths, prompting the World Health Organization to declare a “global health emergency.”17 These dire conditions, arising from the workings of the system, are consistent with what Frederick Engels, in the Condition of the Working Class in England, called “social murder.”18 At the instigation of giant corporations, philanthrocapitalist foundations, and neoliberal governments, public education has been restructured around corporate-designed testing based on the implementation of robotic common-core standards. This is generating massive databases on the student population, much of which are now being surreptitiously marketed and sold.19 The corporatization and privatization of education is feeding the progressive subordination of children’s needs to the cash nexus of the commodity market. We are thus seeing a dramatic return of Thomas Gradgrind’s and Mr. M’Choakumchild’s crass utilitarian philosophy dramatized in Charles Dickens’s Hard Times: “Facts are alone wanted in life” and “You are never to fancy.”20 Having been reduced to intellectual dungeons, many of the poorest, most racially segregated schools in the United States are mere pipelines for prisons or the military.21 More than two million people in the United States are behind bars, a higher rate of incarceration than any other country in the world, constituting a new Jim Crow. The total population in prison is nearly equal to the number of people in Houston, Texas, the fourth largest U.S. city. African Americans and Latinos make up 56 percent of those incarcerated, while constituting only about 32 percent of the U.S. population. Nearly 50 percent of American adults, and a much higher percentage among African Americans and Native Americans, have an immediate family member who has spent or is currently spending time behind bars. Both black men and Native American men in the United States are nearly three times, Hispanic men nearly two times, more likely to die of police shootings than white men.22 Racial divides are now widening across the entire planet. Violence against women and the expropriation of their unpaid labor, as well as the higher level of exploitation of their paid labor, are integral to the way in which power is organized in capitalist society—and how it seeks to divide rather than unify the population. More than a third of women worldwide have experienced physical/sexual violence. Women’s bodies, in particular, are objectified, reified, and commodified as part of the normal workings of monopoly-capitalist marketing.23 The mass media-propaganda system, part of the larger corporate matrix, is now merging into a social media-based propaganda system that is more porous and seemingly anarchic, but more universal and more than ever favoring money and power. Utilizing modern marketing and surveillance techniques, which now dominate all digital interactions, vested interests are able to tailor their messages, largely unchecked, to individuals and their social networks, creating concerns about “fake news” on all sides.24 Numerous business entities promising technological manipulation of voters in countries across the world have now surfaced, auctioning off their services to the highest bidders.25 The elimination of net neutrality in the United States means further concentration, centralization, and control over the entire Internet by monopolistic service providers. Elections are increasingly prey to unregulated “dark money” emanating from the coffers of corporations and the billionaire class. Although presenting itself as the world’s leading democracy, the United States, as Paul Baran and Paul Sweezy stated in Monopoly Capital in 1966, “is democratic in form and plutocratic in content.”26 In the Trump administration, following a long-established tradition, 72 percent of those appointed to the cabinet have come from the higher corporate echelons, while others have been drawn from the military.27 War, engineered by the United States and other major powers at the apex of the system, has become perpetual in strategic oil regions such as the Middle East, and threatens to escalate into a global thermonuclear exchange. During the Obama administration, the United States was engaged in wars/bombings in seven different countries—Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Yemen, Somalia, and Pakistan.28 Torture and assassinations have been reinstituted by Washington as acceptable instruments of war against those now innumerable individuals, group networks, and whole societies that are branded as terrorist. A new Cold War and nuclear arms race is in the making between the United States and Russia, while Washington is seeking to place road blocks to the continued rise of China. The Trump administration has created a new space force as a separate branch of the military in an attempt to ensure U.S. dominance in the militarization of space. Sounding the alarm on the increasing dangers of a nuclear war and of climate destabilization, the distinguished Bulletin of Atomic Scientists moved its doomsday clock in 2018 to two minutes to midnight, the closest since 1953, when it marked the advent of thermonuclear weapons.29 Increasingly severe economic sanctions are being imposed by the United States on countries like Venezuela and Nicaragua, despite their democratic elections—or because of them. Trade and currency wars are being actively promoted by core states, while racist barriers against immigration continue to be erected in Europe and the United States as some 60 million refugees and internally displaced peoples flee devastated environments. Migrant populations worldwide have risen to 250 million, with those residing in high-income countries constituting more than 14 percent of the populations of those countries, up from less than 10 percent in 2000. Meanwhile, ruling circles and wealthy countries seek to wall off islands of power and privilege from the mass of humanity, who are to be left to their fate.30 More than three-quarters of a billion people, over 10 percent of the world population, are chronically malnourished.31 Food stress in the United States keeps climbing, leading to the rapid growth of cheap dollar stores selling poor quality and toxic food. Around forty million Americans, representing one out of eight households, including nearly thirteen million children, are food insecure.32 Subsistence farmers are being pushed off their lands by agribusiness, private capital, and sovereign wealth funds in a global depeasantization process that constitutes the greatest movement of people in history.33 Urban overcrowding and poverty across much of the globe is so severe that one can now reasonably refer to a “planet of slums.”34 Meanwhile, the world housing market is estimated to be worth up to $163 trillion (as compared to the value of gold mined over all recorded history, estimated at $7.5 trillion).35 The Anthropocene epoch, first ushered in by the Great Acceleration of the world economy immediately after the Second World War, has generated enormous rifts in planetary boundaries, extending from climate change to ocean acidification, to the sixth extinction, to disruption of the global nitrogen and phosphorus cycles, to the loss of freshwater, to the disappearance of forests, to widespread toxic-chemical and radioactive pollution.36 It is now estimated that 60 percent of the world’s wildlife vertebrate population (including mammals, reptiles, amphibians, birds, and fish) have been wiped out since 1970, while the worldwide abundance of invertebrates has declined by 45 percent in recent decades.37 What climatologist James Hansen calls the “species exterminations” resulting from accelerating climate change and rapidly shifting climate zones are only compounding this general process of biodiversity loss. Biologists expect that half of all species will be facing extinction by the end of the century.38 If present climate-change trends continue, the “global carbon budget” associated with a 2°C increase in average global temperature will be broken in sixteen years (while a 1.5°C increase in global average temperature—staying beneath which is the key to long-term stabilization of the climate—will be reached in a decade). Earth System scientists warn that the world is now perilously close to a Hothouse Earth, in which catastrophic climate change will be locked in and irreversible.39 The ecological, social, and economic costs to humanity of continuing to increase carbon emissions by 2.0 percent a year as in recent decades (rising in 2018 by 2.7 percent—3.4 percent in the United States), and failing to meet the minimal 3.0 percent annual reductions in emissions currently needed to avoid a catastrophic destabilization of the earth’s energy balance, are simply incalculable.40 Nevertheless, major energy corporations continue to lie about climate change, promoting and bankrolling climate denialism—while admitting the truth in their internal documents. These corporations are working to accelerate the extraction and production of fossil fuels, including the dirtiest, most greenhouse gas-generating varieties, reaping enormous profits in the process. The melting of the Arctic ice from global warming is seen by capital as a new El Dorado, opening up massive additional oil and gas reserves to be exploited without regard to the consequences for the earth’s climate. In response to scientific reports on climate change, Exxon Mobil declared that it intends to extract and sell all of the fossil-fuel reserves at its disposal.41 Energy corporations continue to intervene in climate negotiations to ensure that any agreements to limit carbon emissions are defanged. Capitalist countries across the board are putting the accumulation of wealth for a few above combatting climate destabilization, threatening the very future of humanity. Capitalism is best understood as a competitive class-based mode of production and exchange geared to the accumulation of capital through the exploitation of workers’ labor power and the private appropriation of surplus value (value generated beyond the costs of the workers’ own reproduction). The mode of economic accounting intrinsic to capitalism designates as a value-generating good or service anything that passes through the market and therefore produces income. It follows that the greater part of the social and environmental costs of production outside the market are excluded in this form of valuation and are treated as mere negative “externalities,” unrelated to the capitalist economy itself—whether in terms of the shortening and degradation of human life or the destruction of the natural environment. As environmental economist K. William Kapp stated, “capitalism must be regarded as an economy of unpaid costs.”42 We have now reached a point in the twenty-first century in which the externalities of this irrational system, such as the costs of war, the depletion of natural resources, the waste of human lives, and the disruption of the planetary environment, now far exceed any future economic benefits that capitalism offers to society as a whole. The accumulation of capital and the amassing of wealth are increasingly occurring at the expense of an irrevocable rift in the social and environmental conditions governing human life on earth.43

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › FW › 2nc- fw at- policy key

Only question is if our assumptions are desirable. Policy frameworks make slavery and extinction certain.

Falk, Professor Emeritus of International Law at Princeton University, 21

Richard is a Professor Emeritus of International Law at Princeton University and Fellow of the Orfalea Center of Global Studies at the University of California, Santa Barbara, “Global Solidarity: Toward a Politics of Impossibility,” Opening Essay for a GTI Forum, , TZ)

We must start by rejecting conventional foreclosures of the imagination. We cannot accept that politics is “the art of the possible” if the “possible” remains circumscribed by the play of current forces of stasis, confining the idea of change to policy shifts at the margin or—at the most ambitious—elite-driven national revolutions. The structures of state and market remain essentially untouched and continue to run the show. As long as these constraints are not removed, the Great Transition will be stymied. The first challenge is to find effective ways to subvert and transform these primordial structures. Meeting this challenge starts with liberating the mind from ingrained conventions that solidify the ideological biases of modernity. If we carefully consider our own lives, we are likely to appreciate how many epochal public happenings had been previously deemed “impossible,” or only seemed possible after the fact. A potent illustration of the tyranny of a status quo bias is Winston Churchill’s derisive attitude toward Gandhi during the early stages of the rise of Indian nationalism. Dismissive of any threat to Indian colonial rule, Churchill described Gandhi as a “malignant subversive fanatic” and “a seditious Middle Temple lawyer, now posing as a fakir of a type well known in the East, striding half-naked up the steps of the Viceregal palace.” The great British war leader displayed his attachment to a Western understanding of power that had little insight into historical circumstances vulnerable to anti-colonial nationalism. Similar patterns of the seemingly impossible happening are evident in contemporary history, such as the peaceful ending of the Cold War followed by the collapse of the Soviet Union; the American defeat in the Vietnam War despite overwhelming military superiority; China’s half-century rise from mass impoverishment and backwardness to prime geopolitical challenger, including threatening Western mastery of innovative technology such as AI, G5 connectivity, robotics, and genetic engineering; and the abandonment of apartheid by South Africa in the face of nonviolent resistance from within and anti-apartheid solidarity from without. What these examples demonstrate is that our understanding of the scope of the possible has been artificially circumscribed in ways that protect the interests of various elites in the maintenance of the status quo, making it seem reckless and futile to mount structural challenges however justified they may be morally or bio-politically. Such foreclosures of imagined futures have been key to the protection of institutions like slavery, discrimination, and warfare but often remain limited in scope to specific locales or policy areas. The uniqueness of the Anthropocene is to restrict the possible to unsustainable and dysfunctional structures and modes of behavior, while bringing to a head the question of finding more viable ways of organizing life on the planet and living together in a manner that protects future generations. Such foreclosures of the imagination inflict damage both by shortening our temporal vision and by constraining our understanding of useful knowledge. Despite what science and rationality tell us about the future, our leaders—and, indeed, most of us—give scant practical attention to what is needed to preserve and improve the life prospects for future generations. Given the scope and depth of the challenges, responsible anthropocentrism in the twenty-first century should incorporate a sense of urgency to temporal axes of concern. We now need a “politics of the impossible,” a necessary utopianism that stands as an avowal of the attainability of the Great Transition. We must begin by interrogating the semantics of the possible as a cultural, political, economic, and ideological construct binding humanity to a system that is increasingly bio-politically self-destructive for the species and its natural habitat. Closely connected to this foreclosure of our temporal vision has been a scientifically conditioned epistemology asserting the limits of useful knowledge. Within the most influential epistemic communities, an Enlightenment ideology prevails that sets boundaries limiting productive intellectual inquiry. The positive legacies of the Enlightenment in grounding knowledge on scientifically verified evidence rather than cultural superstitions and religiously guided prejudice and dogma are real and important, but there have been costs as well. Notably, a bias against subjectivity discourages normative inquiry and advocacy, which is dismissed as “non-scientific.” The noted Confucian scholar Tu Wei-Ming has powerfully criticized the impact of what he calls “instrumental rationalism” on the capacity of Western civilization to embrace the value of empathy, which he views as integral to human dignity and humane governance. We need a moral epistemology to achieve responsible anthropocentrism, exploring right and wrong, and distinguishing between desirable and diminished futures, not as matters of opinion, but as the underpinnings of “normative knowledge.” Universities, split into specialized disciplines and privileging work within the Enlightenment paradigm, are largely oblivious to the need for a holistic understanding of the complexities and solidarities with which we must grapple in order for humanity to extricate itself from present structures that divide and fragment the human experience, strangling possibilities. It may be helpful to distinguish “the feasible,” “the necessary,” and “the desirable” to further illuminate “the pursuit of the impossible.” In short, “the feasible” from the perspective of the status quo seems incapable, under the best of circumstances, of achieving “the necessary” and “the desirable.” We will need to pursue “the desirable” to mobilize the capabilities needed to engage effectively in realizing “the necessary.” If existing conditions continue, the bio-political destiny of the human species seems destined for dark times. In the past, before the Nuclear Age, we could ignore the future and address the material, security, and spiritual needs of bounded communities, and success or failure had no ramifications for larger systems. Now we must find ways to attend to the whole, or the parts will perish and likely destroy one another in the process. St. Francis found some fitting words for such an emancipatory path: “Start by doing what is necessary, then what is possible, and suddenly you are doing the impossible.”

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › FW › 2nc- fw at- policy key

Focus on policy agenda influence ignores the concrete material praxis needed for broad social transformation

Wigger 18 [Angela, Assoc Prof in Global Political Economy at Radboud Univ, “From dissent to resistance: Locating patterns of horizontalist self-management crisis responses in Spain,” Comparative European Politics 16.1, p.34-5, JCR]

A historical materialist approach gives ontological primacy to historically specific socio-economic realities constituted by the social relations of production and the collective class agency emanating from it. It allows for systematically analysing clusters of class action in a historical context of broader ideational and material structures of power and counterpower. As an emancipatory project, changing the social relations of production is considered the groundwork for a wider social transformation. Analyses in the historical materialist tradition however often suffer from an elitist bias by focusing overwhelmingly on the role and internal fractionation of capital (Wigger and Horn, 2014). Social struggles consequently tend to be reduced to top-down institutional arrangements securing domination within the state apparatus, while dissent, disruption, protest and resistance outside the remit of the state institutional realm, such as demonstrations, strikes, square occupations, as well as more concrete material economic practices, remain analytically and theoretically marginalized (Huke et al, 2015). Emerging forms of resistance are consequently often perceived as limited or as reactive only (Featherstone, 2015). Social movement literatures in contrast clearly give primacy to bottom-up political struggles but often suffer from a similar state-centric bias by focusing predominantly on political demands by social movements vis-a-vis the established state institutional arena, and henceforth, their successes in influencing the policy agenda (McAdam et al, 2001; Tarrow, 2012; Della Porta, 2013). Tarrow (2011: 9), for example, conceptualizes social movements as ‘collective challenges, based on common purposes and social solidarities, in sustained interaction with elites, opponents, and authorities’. Such a state-centric institutional reductionism is problematic insofar as it tends to ignore forms of concrete material radical praxis that takes place outside the realm of state institutional pressure politics of political parties, trade unions, interest groups, advocacy networks or NGOs and that challenges the very status quo of how the (re-)production of everyday life through work is organized. As a result, the traditional social movement literature has paid little attention to forms of resistance in the form of alternative social relations of (re-)production and the redistribution of material resources. Collective action is moreover frequently portrayed as classless. Certainly, not all forms of collective action are necessarily rooted in class or class awareness; yet, such agency may nonetheless have ‘conjuncturally determined’ class relevance (Jessop, 2002: 32).

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › FW › 2nc- fw at- extinction first

“Extinction first” framing justifies genocide. Prioritize ethics.

Torres, PhD candidate in philosophy at Leibniz Universität Hannover, 21

Emile P. Torres, Aeon, Against longtermism, . October 19,2021. DOA: 06/19/23. AR.

This way of seeing the world, of assessing the badness of AIDS and the Holocaust, implies that future disasters of the same (non-existential) scope and intensity should also be categorised as ‘mere ripples’. If they don’t pose a direct existential risk, then we ought not to worry much about them, however tragic they might be to individuals. As Bostrom wrote in 2003, ‘priority number one, two, three and four should … be to reduce existential risk.’ He reiterated this several years later in arguing that we mustn’t ‘fritter … away’ our finite resources on ‘feel-good projects of suboptimal efficacy’ such as alleviating global poverty and reducing animal suffering, since neither threatens our longterm potential, and our longterm potential is what really matters.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › 1nc – shell - redistribution

The alternative is to affirm the Party – only the Party can provide effective accountability mechanisms to correct unproductive tendencies, educate and mobilize marginalized communities, and connect local struggles to a movement for international liberation

Alyson Escalante 18, a Marxist-Leninist, Materialist Feminist and Anti-Imperialist activist. (“PARTY ORGANIZING IN THE 21ST CENTURY” September 21st, 2018 )

I would argue that within the base building movement, there is a move towards party organizing, but this trend has not always been explicitly theorized or forwarded within the movement. My goal in this essay is to argue that base building and dual power strategy can be best forwarded through party organizing, and that party organizing can allow this emerging movement to solidify into a powerful revolutionary socialist tendency in the United States. One of the crucial insights of the base building movement is that the current state of the left in the United States is one in which revolution is not currently possible. There exists very little popular support for socialist politics. A century of anticommunist propaganda has been extremely effective in convincing even the most oppressed and marginalized that communism has nothing to offer them. The base building emphasis on dual power responds directly to this insight. By building institutions which can meet people’s needs, we are able to concretely demonstrate that communists can offer the oppressed relief from the horrific conditions of capitalism. Base building strategy recognizes that actually doing the work to serve the people does infinitely more to create a socialist base of popular support than electing democratic socialist candidates or holding endless political education classes can ever hope to do. Dual power is about proving that we have something to offer the oppressed. The question, of course, remains: once we have built a base of popular support, what do we do next? If it turns out that establishing socialist institutions to meet people’s needs does in fact create sympathy towards the cause of communism, how can we mobilize that base? Put simply: in order to mobilize the base which base builders hope to create, we need to have already done the work of building a communist party. It is not enough to simply meet peoples needs. Rather, we must build the institutions of dual power in the name of communism. We must refuse covert front organizing and instead have a public face as a communist party. When we build tenants unions, serve the people programs, and other dual power projects, we must make it clear that we are organizing as communists, unified around a party, and are not content simply with establishing endless dual power organizations. We must be clear that our strategy is revolutionary and in order to make this clear we must adopt party organizing. By “party organizing” I mean an organizational strategy which adopts the party model. Such organizing focuses on building a party whose membership is formally unified around a party line determined by democratic centralist decision making. The party model creates internal methods for holding party members accountable, unifying party member action around democratically determined goals, and for educating party members in communist theory and praxis. A communist organization utilizing the party model works to build dual power institutions while simultaneously educating the communities they hope to serve. Organizations which adopt the party model focus on propagandizing around the need for revolutionary socialism. They function as the forefront of political organizing, empowering local communities to theorize their liberation through communist theory while organizing communities to literally fight for their liberation. A party is not simply a group of individuals doing work together, but is a formal organization unified in its fight against capitalism. Party organizing has much to offer the base building movement. By working in a unified party, base builders can ensure that local struggles are tied to and informed by a unified national and international strategy. While the most horrific manifestations of capitalism take on particular and unique form at the local level, we need to remember that our struggle is against a material base which functions not only at the national but at the international level. The formal structures provided by a democratic centralist party model allow individual locals to have a voice in open debate, but also allow for a unified strategy to emerge from democratic consensus. Furthermore, party organizing allows for local organizations and individual organizers to be held accountable for their actions. It allows criticism to function not as one independent group criticizing another independent group, but rather as comrades with a formal organizational unity working together to sharpen each others strategies and to help correct chauvinist ideas and actions. In the context of the socialist movement within the United States, such accountability is crucial. As a movement which operates within a settler colonial society, imperialist and colonial ideal frequently infect leftist organizing. Creating formal unity and party procedure for dealing with and correcting these ideas allows us to address these consistent problems within American socialist organizing. Having a formal party which unifies the various dual power projects being undertaken at the local level also allows for base builders to not simply meet peoples needs, but to pull them into the membership of the party as organizers themselves. The party model creates a means for sustained growth to occur by unifying organizers in a manner that allows for skills, strategies, and ideas to be shared with newer organizers. It also allows community members who have been served by dual power projects to take an active role in organizing by becoming party members and participating in the continued growth of base building strategy. It ensures that there are formal processes for educating communities in communist theory and praxis, and also enables them to act and organize in accordance with their own local conditions. We also must recognize that the current state of the base building movement precludes the possibility of such a national unified party in the present moment. Since base building strategy is being undertaken in a number of already established organizations, it is not likely that base builders would abandon these organizations in favor of founding a unified party. Additionally, it would not be strategic to immediately undertake such complete unification because it would mean abandoning the organizational contexts in which concrete gains are already being made and in which growth is currently occurring. What is important for base builders to focus on in the current moment is building dual power on a local level alongside building a national movement. This means aspiring towards the possibility of a unified party, while pursuing continued local growth. The movement within the Marxist Center network towards some form of unification is positive step in the right direction. The independent party emphasis within the Refoundation caucus should also be recognized as a positive approach. It is important for base builders to continue to explore the possibility of unification, and to maintain unification through a party model as a long term goal. In the meantime, individual base building organizations ought to adopt party models for their local organizing. Local organizations ought to be building dual power alongside recruitment into their organizations, education of community members in communist theory and praxis, and the establishment of armed and militant party cadres capable of defending dual power institutions from state terror. Dual power institutions must be unified openly and transparently around these organizations in order for them to operate as more than “red charities.” Serving the people means meeting their material needs while also educating and propagandizing. It means radicalizing, recruiting, and organizing. The party model remains the most useful method for achieving these ends. The use of the party model by local organizations allows base builders to gain popular support, and most importantly, to mobilize their base of popular support towards revolutionary ends, not simply towards the construction of a parallel economy which exists as an end in and of itself. It is my hope that we will see future unification of the various local base building organizations into a national party, but in the meantime we must push for party organizing at the local level. If local organizations adopt party organizing, it ought to become clear that a unified national party will have to be the long term goal of the base building movement. Many of the already existing organizations within the base building movement already operate according to these principles. I do not mean to suggest otherwise. Rather, my hope is to suggest that we ought to be explicit about the need for party organizing and emphasize the relationship between dual power and the party model. Doing so will make it clear that the base building movement is not pursuing a cooperative economy alongside capitalism, but is pursuing a revolutionary socialist strategy capable of fighting capitalism. The long term details of base building and dual power organizing will arise organically in response to the conditions the movement finds itself operating within. I hope that I have put forward a useful contribution to the discussion about base building organizing, and have demonstrated the need for party organizing in order to ensure that the base building tendency maintains a revolutionary orientation. The finer details of revolutionary strategy will be worked out over time and are not a good subject for public discussion. I strongly believe party organizing offers the best path for ensuring that such strategy will succeed. My goal here is not to dictate the only possible path forward but to open a conversation about how the base building movement will organize as it transitions from a loose network of individual organizations into a unified socialist tendency. These discussions and debates will be crucial to ensuring that this rapidly growing movement can succeed.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › 1nc – shell - redistribution

The crisis of capitalism is inevitable and existential – at best the Aff delays a reckoning by suppressing class struggle and facilitating a new round of productive expansion that magnifies the risk

Robinson 22 [William, Distinguished professor of sociology, global studies and Latin American studies at UC Santa Barbara, Can Global Capitalism Endure? Epub]

Who can deny that global capitalism is in deep crisis? The global economy is mired in prolonged stagnation. Civil strife and social upheaval are tearing up political systems and, in some cases, leading to the collapse of states. The planetary ecosystem is breaking down. Millions are fleeing, displaced by climate change, transnational corporate land grabs, wars and political persecution. Hunger and disease are on the rise in many countries. The worldwide social fabric is in decay. The coronavirus contagion exposed governments, unable to cope with the fallout from the health emergency, as callous instruments of wealth and corruption. It is clear that the crisis is far more encompassing than its economic dimension alone; it is civilizational and existential. Yet the varied dimensions of this crisis of humanity have a common denominator: a socioeconomic system that relentlessly pursues private profit at all costs. The ruling groups appear clueless as to how to resolve the mounting crisis beyond ramping up a global police state to contain mounting unrest. This should come as no surprise. The political elites are beholden to the system of global capitalism that by its very nature places the endless accumulation of capital above all else. I have been writing about global capitalist crisis since the turn of the century from the perspective of my theory of global capitalism as a qualitatively new stage in the ongoing and open-ended evolution of world capitalism, characterized above all by the rise of truly transnational capital and the integration of every country into a globally-integrated productive, financial and service system. The work before you is an attempt to provide a concise summary of this theory and to further advance the analysis of the crisis originally laid out in my 2014 book, Global Capitalism and the Crisis of Humanity. My aim is to present a “big picture” snapshot in a shorter work and from the vantage point of global capitalism theory that takes into account some elements of global capitalism that have come further into focus in recent years, especially the ever-deeper financialization and digitalization of the global economy and society. As the title indicates, it is not clear how far into the future global capitalism can endure. A collapse of world civilization cannot be ruled out. To the contrary, the current course of events is leading to just that. Indeed, there are plenty of historical cases of societal collapse, with the distinction this time that what we understand as society is now irreversibly global. These days it is not particularly controversial to observe that capitalism has outlived whatever usefulness it may once have had. But just because the system is now archaic does not mean that it cannot hang on well into the future. The survival of global capitalism beyond the present crisis requires a substantial restructuring involving a measure of transnational regulation of the global economy and a redistribution of wealth downward. Even at that, though, a new period of economic reactivation and prosperity will not bring to an end the threat to our survival. For that, we must do away with a system whose drive to accumulate capital puts it at war with the mass of humanity and with nature. Only an ecosocialism can ultimately lift us from the threat. There is a vast literature on capitalist crisis and a rich history of debate among political economists, Marxists and non-Marxists alike. The theme of capitalist breakdown is recurrent in the social sciences, going back to the writings of Karl Marx in the second half of the nineteenth century and to the Polish-German socialist, Rosa Luxemburg, among others writing in the early twentieth century. The famed Austrian economist, Joseph Schumpeter, not a Marxist himself, titled one of the chapters in his celebrated 1942 study, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, “Can Capitalism Survive?” (He feared it could not).16 The January 1, 1975 issue of Time magazine, published in the midst of the previous major crisis of world capitalism blared the same question on its front cover.17 In that decade and subsequent to it, Marxists have reexamined the classical literature and hotly debated the nature of crises.18 In particular, Marxist economists debate whether capitalism can expand indefinitely, and if capitalist crises are caused by a fall in the rate of profit or by what is known as overproduction and underconsumption. I indicate my position with respect to this debate in the first section of this work. However, I am as much or more concerned here, as elsewhere, with a sociological study that takes up the social, political, ideological and cultural dimensions of the crisis as I am with its specifically economic dimension. The entire edifice of a global capitalism in crisis rests on an intensification of exploitation and of control over the exploited, which is what makes all economics political and a matter of social and class struggle. The 2008 Great Recession triggered a veritable tsunami of mass rebellion around the world not seen in decades. Far from letting up, worldwide protest escalated throughout the coronavirus contagion. As humanity descends into global civil war, the ruling groups have utilized the pandemic to launch all-out class warfare aimed at an exponential increase in profit-making opportunities and at ramping up the social control of restive masses.19 All systems are in a perpetual state of motion, transformation, and eventual demise, whether through collapse or supersession. The challenge for radical political economy of the type I aspire to here is to capture the motion of structural change and to identify possible trajectories and outcomes that are always contingent on politics and class struggle. And the challenge for radical intellectuals is to contribute through theory and analysis to exposing the contradictions of the prevailing system as input into the burning struggles of our day. As I attempt to take up these challenges, several caveats apply. Our explorations of the world are always an open-ended process of clarification and revision. The account here is necessarily a simplification, as are all synopses of complex reality that attempt to present a “big picture” in such broad brushstrokes. Moreover, I have set out to both analyze the present and to speculate as to what the future may hold. This is an exploratory work with some of its arguments tentative in nature. As such, conclusions are preliminary. Indeed, I conclude with a set of open-ended questions whose answers I do not provide because I do not have them. In the introduction of his magnus opus, Capital, Karl Marx famously cautioned that “there is no royal road to science, and only those who do not dread the fatiguing climb of its steep paths have a chance of gaining its luminous summits.” There are a few dense passages in the present work that I have tried, with a limited degree of success, to make intelligible to an audience not versed in political economy. I recommend Hadas Their’s A People’s Guide to Capitalism to those readers who seek an eminently readable introduction to the political economy of capitalism.20 In recent years there have been dozens, perhaps hundreds, of studies on the crisis that began with the 2008 global financial meltdown that build on over a century of literature from a Marxist perspective on capitalist crisis. Among those the reader may find useful is Michael Roberts’ The Long Depression.21 I have strived here to find a balance in which this short work is accessible to a general readership concerned with the urgent political affairs of our day yet also satisfying to scholars of global political economy. Both sets of readers will have to decide if I have achieved this goal. If the history of capitalism is one of never-ending transformation, crises often mark before-and-after turning points. The period from 2008, when the global financial system collapsed, into the third decade of the twenty-first century has been one long protracted crisis that, far from being resolved, became aggravated by the coronavirus pandemic. This crisis is as much economic, or structural, as it is political, or one of state legitimacy and capitalist hegemony.22 It is also existential because of the danger of ecological collapse as well as the renewed threat of nuclear war, to which we must add the risk of future pandemics that may involve much deadlier microbes than coronaviruses. It is an organic crisis insofar as it is not static: it comes from deep within the contradictions of capitalist development and its multiple dimensions presuppose one another. Can global capitalism endure? Indeed, will humanity survive? These are, to be sure, two distinct questions. It is entirely possible that the system itself endures even as a majority of humanity faces desperate struggles for survival that lead many to perish in the coming years and decades. Crises are endemic to capitalism. The entire 500-plus year history of world capitalism is marked by successive crises that have at their height shaken the system to its core. Each major crisis has involved predictions that the system would collapse in on itself in the face of intractable contradictions. Yet capitalism has repeatedly proved to be more resilient and adaptable than its doomsday forecasters. As we shall explore in this short work, the system has been undergoing a new round of restructuring and transformation since the financial collapse of 2008, based on a much more advanced digitalization of the entire global economy and society. The coronavirus contagion has turbo-charged these transformations and also allowed the ruling groups to ramp up their surveillance and control of restive populations.23 The agents of global capitalism are now attempting to purchase a new lease on life for the system through this digital restructuring and through reforms that some among the global elite are advocating in the face of mass pressures from below. If some regulatory or redistributive reform actually comes to pass, restructuring may—depending on the play of social and class forces—unleash a new round of productive expansion that attenuates the crisis. In the long run, however, it is difficult to see how global capitalism can continue to reproduce itself without a much more profound overhaul than is currently on the horizon, if not the outright overthrow of the system. In the history of capitalism there have been periodic crises of two types, cyclical and structural. Cyclical crises, sometimes called the business cycle, occur about once a decade and show up as recessions. There were recessions in the early 1980s, the early 1990s, and at the turn of the twenty-first century. World capitalism has experienced over the past two centuries several episodes of structural crisis, or what I call restructuring crises, so-called because the resolution of such crises requires a major restructuring of the system. Here “resolution” means displacement in time and space through restructuring that paves the way for a new burst of sustained accumulation and outward expansion after a period of stagnation and malaise. Eventually the underlying contradictions of the system build up and erupt into new crises, often triggered by a precipitating event, such as the bursting of a speculative bubble or a political watershed moment. The first Great Depression from the 1870s into the 1890s led to the great wave of late nineteenth century imperialism, the rise of powerful national corporations, and ultimately to the First World War and the Bolshevik Revolution. The Great Depression in the 1930s sparked intense worldwide class struggles and political upheavals, bringing in their wake fascism, the Second World War, and eventually the consolidation of a new model of redistributive or regulated capitalism. Known as the New Deal in the United States and elsewhere as social democracy, what we can call more technically Fordist-Keynesian capitalism established the basis for the post-WWII boom, the so-called golden age of capitalism. Fordism refers to the system of standardized mass production and mass consumption introduced originally by Henry Ford. Keynesianism refers to the economic doctrine of John Maynard Keynes, who had broken with the assumptions of classical economic theory that the natural state of the economy was an equilibrium so long as market forces were allowed to operate unimpeded. Instead, he argued, the state had to intervene to regulate the market and generate aggregate demand through credit and employment creation, progressive taxation, and government spending on public works and social programs. The two combined—Fordism and Keynesianism—involved regulation and redistribution in what came to be considered a “class compromise,” mediated by the state, between the working classes and capital.24 Structural crisis hit again in the 1970s, characterized this time by “stagflation,” or the combination of stagnation and inflation. The Fordist-Keynesian “class compromise” was imposed on capital through decades of intense worldwide class and social struggles and the devastation of two world wars. But eventually, redistribution and regulation cut into capitalist power. As stagnation set in, the working and popular classes in each nation-state resisted the effort by capitalists and governments to place the burden of the crisis on their shoulders.25 As class struggle intensified, capitalists and bureaucratic elites from around the world strove to beat back the power of organized labor, radical social movements, and Third World liberation struggles. Capitalists turned to leveraging globalization as a strategy to undercut the power that working and popular classes could exercise within the state; to break free of state constraints to its freedom to accumulate. At its core, globalization is class warfare from above: capital’s drive to revert the global correlation of class and social forces to its advantage. As capital went global, a transnational capitalist class (TCC) emerged in the late twentieth century, forged out of the transnational integration of the leading sectors among national capitalist classes, and consisting of the owners and managers of the giant transnational corporations and financial conglomerates that now drive the global economy.26 Globalization allowed this TCC and its political and bureaucratic agents in states and international agencies to dismantle diverse forms of redistributive or social democratic capitalism and to restore the class power of capital by reorganizing the worldwide circuits of accumulation. This restructuring process has involved above all the rise of a globally integrated production, financial and service system into which every country has been integrated. Global trade as a share of global output jumped from 30 percent in 1970 to 60 percent in the early 2010s.27 But this trade was less in finished goods than in the movement of intermediate goods through numerous nodes in global supply and production chains—a functional integration in which intermediate goods accounted for nearly 60 percent of all trade by the 2010s.28 Hence, unlike the situation in earlier structural crises, in this age of global capitalism the world economy is now inextricably integrated and functions as a single unit in real time. The global fragmentation and decentralization of production and finance around the world brought about by globalization has been marked by the inverse centralization of command and control in a handful of ever more powerful transnational corporations and financial conglomerates at the command of the TCC. As we shall see momentarily, the current crisis is set apart from all earlier ones insofar as it is internal to global capitalism as a whole. National withdrawal from the global economy is entirely out of the question, as are “national” solutions to the global crisis. Liberation from the nation-state may have enhanced the structural power of capital over working and popular classes struggling within the bounds of the nation-state. But at the same time, globalization has ended up exacerbating the underlying contradictions of capitalism. Moreover, it has made it more difficult for states to impose any modicum of regulation on the global market that could help ameliorate the crisis and restabilize the system.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › 1nc – shell - redistribution

Redistribution is a smokescreen used to subdue proletariat demands as the bourgeoise loses mere pocket money

Internationalist Communist Tendency 21

Internationalist Communist Tendency. Libcom. Wealth Tax: Expropriation of the Rich or Capitalist Smokescreen?. . January 16, 2021. DOA: 06/18/23. AR.

A spectre is haunting Europe: the ‘Wealth Tax’ (known in Italy as the Patrimonial). This joke sums up what has now become a stock demand of so many of the "left", both inside and, above all, outside parliament and not just in Italy. By definition, a wealth tax is a form of taxation aimed at the rich, particularly the very rich, via a progressive rate that increases with the level of inherited wealth itself. For many this would be a measure of social justice: a means to redistribute some of the wealth that is presently concentrated in the hands of a few to the most economically disadvantaged sectors of the population. This is especially important in the present period, dominated as it is by the dramatic effects of the pandemic. In any case, its parliamentary supporters argue, this would by no means amount to a subversive manoeuvre to expropriate the bourgeoisie. It would simply mean implementing a provision in the constitution, by which citizens must contribute to public well-being in proportion to their economic circumstances.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Impact Answers › Impact Uniqueness Answer

Non-unique and/or empirically false – COLA and pandemic benefit should trigger the impact scenario

Bowman, Motley Fool Contributor 22

[Jeremy, 10/05/22, The Motley Fool, “Could the 2023 Social Security COLA Make Inflation Even Worse?” https://www.fool.com/retirement/2022/10/05/why-the-2023-social-secuirty-cola-inflation-higher/, accessed 6/24/23, MR]

By contrast, the impact of next year's Social Security COLA should be less considerable. Since the average Social Security recipient got $1,657 a month this year, the estimated 8.9% increase coming next year would translate into an extra $147 a month, on average, for the 70.3 million Americans collecting Social Security. Compared to the COLAs of around 2% that have been more typical, that represents an additional $114 a month Social Security recipients will get. Over the course of the year, that equals an incremental $96.1 billion being injected into the economy. In total, the COLA will pump $124 billion into the economy.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Social Security Link Answers › No Unique Social Security Link

No unique link – COVID benefits overwhelm the link to Social Security benefit expansion

Bowman, Motley Fool Contributor, 22

[Jeremy, 10/05/22, The Motley Fool, “Could the 2023 Social Security COLA Make Inflation Even Worse?” https://www.fool.com/retirement/2022/10/05/why-the-2023-social-secuirty-cola-inflation-higher/, 6/24/23, MR]

By contrast, the impact of next year's Social Security COLA should be less considerable. Since the average Social Security recipient got $1,657 a month this year, the estimated 8.9% increase coming next year would translate into an extra $147 a month, on average, for the 70.3 million Americans collecting Social Security. Compared to the COLAs of around 2% that have been more typical, that represents an additional $114 a month Social Security recipients will get. Over the course of the year, that equals an incremental $96.1 billion being injected into the economy. In total, the COLA will pump $124 billion into the economy.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff › Job Guarantee Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Prevents Poverty

Jobs guarantee solves a lack of income and poverty

Mitchell, University of Newcastle Centre of Full Employment and Equity Director and Economics Professor, 17

[William, 5/31/2017, William Mitchell, “A Basic Income Guarantee does not reduce poverty,” https://billmitchell.org/blog/?p=36105, accessed 6/27/23, EP]

Poverty arises for a number of reasons but a lack of income has to be a central characteristic of someone who is poor. And notwithstanding the increasing tendency for people who work full-time to be found earning wages that place them below the poverty line, the major reason for people having a lack of income is unemployment. That typically makes poverty a systemic event rather than an individual failure because mass unemployment is easy to understand – it occurs when the system fails to produce enough jobs to meet the desires for work by the available labour force. Then, to understand why the system fails in that way, we know that once the spending and saving decisions of the non-government sector are made, if there is still a spending shortfall in the economy, which generates the mass unemployment, then it has to be because the net spending position of the national government is short. That is, either the fiscal surplus is too large or (usually) the deficit is too small. In that sense, the introduction of a Job Guarantee would eliminate poverty arising from unemployment and the working poor because the Government could condition the minimum wage by where it set the Job Guarantee wage. If it truly desired to end poverty among those in employment then it would set the Job Guarantee accordingly. Others argue that a more direct way of dealing with poverty and lack of income is to just provide the income via a Basic Income Guarantee (BIG). The BIG idea has captured the progressive side of politics and many on the Right. It is another one of those sneaky neo-liberal ideas that look good on the surface but are rotten not far below. Supporters of BIG are really absolving currency-issuing governments of their responsibility to use their fiscal capacities to ensure there are sufficient jobs created – whether in the non-government or government sector. They are thus going along with the neo-liberal attack on the right to work. Moreover, closer analysis reveals that the introduction of the BIG would not, under current institutional arrangements reduce poverty at all.