Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › Spending Internal Link

New spending requires budget offsets – Farm Bill cuts risk derailing compromise due to heightened expectations

Coppess, University of Illinois Agricultural & Consumer Economics professor, 6-15-23

[Jonathan, 6-15-23, Farm Doc Daily Illinois, “Farm Bill 2023: Trying To Reason With Expectations For Farm Policy”, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]

The challenges presented by relatively higher crop prices are not unusual for farm bill reauthorizations, most notably in the efforts for the 1973, 1996, and 2014 Farm Bills. For 2023’s debate, however, the challenges are magnified by elevated expectations created by payment experiences since 2018. As indicated in Figure 2, farmers have received record levels of payments in recent years particularly from ad hoc and supplemental assistance programs not authorized in a farm bill. These ad hoc and supplemental payments have extended assistance to a much more extensive population of farmers than do traditional farm payment programs, including payments to livestock and specialty crop producers. Figure 4 provides an example, illustrating a categorical breakdown of the total payments from MFP 2019, CFAP 1 and CFAP 2 as reported by USDA (USDA, farmers.gov: ; ; ). In total, these three programs have paid more than $45.7 billion to farmers.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › Spending Internal Link

McCarthy signaling concessions to the Republican right to get a bipartisan Farm Bill through – the plan’s spending would trigger fight, crushing cooperation and scuttling passage this year, wrecking the ag industry

Hill, POLITICO food and agriculture policy reporter, 6-15-23

[Meredith Lee, 6-15-23, Politico, “Far-Right Republicans Threaten To Derail Another House Party”, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]

The recent far-right rebellion that brought the House floor to a halt is a bad omen for another rapidly approaching legislative fight: the 2023 farm bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › Spending Internal Link

Spending in other areas can trade-off with the crucial Farm Bill

Munch, American Farm Bureau economist, 6-21-23

[Daniel, 6-21-23, Ohio’s Country Journal, “Farm Bill Math”, , 7-3-23, accessed EH]

The Congressional Budget Office’s (CBO) most recent Baseline for Farm Programs, released in May, identifies expected outlays for farm program spending, assuming existing programs continue without changes, and indicates program spending available to Congress as crafting of the 2023 farm bill kicks into high gear. CBO releases these projections on expected spending for farm programs for the 10-year baseline — the current budget year plus 10 years — up to three times a year.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › Spending Internal Link

Spending limits make food assistance a tension point – risking collapsing the Farm Bill

Guebert, Farm and Dairy, 6-29-23

[Alan Guebert, 6-29-23, Farm and Dairy “‘Appeasing hardliners’ all but promises farm bill failure,” , 7-3-2023, EJ]

Now everyone is stuck as moderate Republicans try to remove a monkey wrench thrown into the already-creaky gears of a deeply divided government by a handful of hard-right House Republican monkeywrenchers.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › Spending Internal Link

The coming negotiations will determine if funding is increased or decreased

Salant, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-3-23

[Johnathan D., 6-3-23, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, “A Pa. congressman is in the middle of the action as Congress debates the farm bill,” , accessed 7-3-2024, EJ]

Under existing programs, the farm bill is expected to cost $1.5 trillion over 10 years, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. Of that total, $1.2 trillion is for nutrition programs such as food stamps.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › Bipartisanship Internal Link

Bipartisan cooperation is key – spending fights risk delay

Heider, RFD TV Journalist, 6-21-23

[Alex Heider, 21 June 2023, RFD TV, “The clock is ticking for an on-time Farm Bill,” , accessed 7-3-2023, EJ]

The September expiration for the current Farm Bill is fast approaching, and there has been little progress toward finalizing a new one. House Ag Committee Chair ‘GT’ Thompson says there are only three options.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › Bipartisanship Internal Link

Bipartisanship key to passing the Farm Bill

Salant, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Journalist, 7-3-23

[Johnathan D., 7-3-23, Post-Gazette, “A Pa. congressman is in the middle of the action as Congress debates the farm bill,” , accessed 7-3-2024, EJ]

"The chairman says the bill is only going to get done if it's a bipartisan bill,” Mr. Eidshaug said. “Having someone who is committed to working in a bipartisan way tells you something. It's the only path to victory."

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › AT – NDAA – Senate Will Kill It

McCarthy will expose his members to hard votes, killing the House NDAA and increasing the Senate NDAA’s Chances

Perano, Daily Beast, 7-14-23

[Ursula, 7-14-2023, Daily Beast "Kevin McCarthy Cedes Speakership to the Far Right Once Again,", , Accessed 7/14/23, S.A.M]

Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC), who has been pushing her party to find a “middle ground” on abortion, told reporters on Thursday that she was aghast at the abortion amendment.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › AT – Amendments Derail the Farm Bill

Test run incoming – Ag Committee will look for ways to fend amendments that derail farm bill.

Downs, Politico, 6-26-23

[Garrett, 06-26-2023, POLITICO, "A farm bill test run," , Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M ]

FARM BILL TEST RUN: The farm bill will get a test run when the Senate votes on its newly approved Ag-FDA appropriations bill, Sen. John Hoeven (R-N.D.) told reporters last week.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Narrow Window of Time

Window is narrow to get the Farm Bill Done

KMALand, 6-25-23

[KMALand, 6-25-23, “Passing A Farm Bill In 2023 Is A Steep Challenge”, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]

Senator Deb Fischer, a member of the Senate Ag Committee, admits that passing a Farm Bill in 2023 is a steep challenge.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › AT – No Focus Now

Congress focusing on the Farm Bill now

Salant, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-3-23

[Johnathan D., 6-3-23, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, “A Pa. congressman is in the middle of the action as Congress debates the farm bill,” , accessed 7-3-2024, EJ]

The Senate received 681 forms from groups or law firms saying they were lobbying on the farm bill during the first three months of 2023. During the same period a year earlier, 201 entities filed lobbying disclosure forms mentioning the farm bill. Likewise, 55 new entities registered to lobby on the issue during the first three months of the year, a 62% increase over 2022.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

The farm bill will pass now – logrolling will gain majority support

Edwards, Cato Institute Kilts Family Chair fiscal studies, 7-12-23

[Chris, 7-12-23, Cato Institute, “Farm Bill Palooza”, , accessed 7-12-23, EH]

Congress will consider a new farm bill this year, which will likely be a logrolling extravaganza costing $1.5 trillion or more over the coming decade. Just as Lollapalooza had a diverse lineup of bands, the farm bill will include a diverse lineup of subsidies for farms, food programs, energy, rural programs, forestry, trade, environmental activities, and many other things. Hemp production used to be illegal but now gets  in the farm bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

Farm Bill will pass now

Salant, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-3-23

[Johnathan D., 6-3-23, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, “A Pa. congressman is in the middle of the action as Congress debates the farm bill,” , accessed 7-3-2024, EJ]

Adding to the interest is that few pieces of legislation are expected to pass with Republicans controlling the House and Democrats in the majority in the Senate. The farm bill is an exception.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

Farm Bill passage likely now

RFD TV, 6/22/23

[6/22/23, RFD TV, “There is optimism for an on-time Farm Bill now that these hurdles are done, according to Rep Lucas,” , accessed 7/12/2023, EJ]

There is some growing optimism that this year’s Farm Bill will be passed on time.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

Farm bill will pass – McCarthy promising bipartisan Farm Bil now

Brasher and Wicks, Agri-Pulse editors, 6/21/2023

[Phillip, Noah, Agri-Pulse, “GOP hardliners' anger could delay, imperil new farm bill”, , Accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]

One longtime GOP lobbyist and Capitol Hill veteran says conservative demands could make it difficult, if not impossible, for McCarthy to put a bipartisan farm bill on the House floor. If he does do that, he risks being ousted as speaker, said the lobbyist, who asked not to be identified.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

Farm Bill likely to pass now – high priority

Dorenkamp, Brownfield Ag News, 7-5-23

(Mark, 7-5-23, 1430wcmy, " House Majority Whip: “massive failure” if new farm bill isn’t done on time, https://1430wcmy.com/2023/07/05/house-majority-whip-massive-failure-if-new-farm-bill-isnt-done-on-time/, Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M)

Pressure is mounting on lawmakers to pass a new farm bill before the current bill expires.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

The farm bill will pass but the window is closing

Hart Brownfield anchor/reporter 7/10/23

[Carah, 7/10/2023, Brownfield news “TIME AND MONEY BOTH SHORT IN THE FARM BILL,” , accessed 7/12/2023, eo]

The president of the American Farm Bureau Federation says he is optimistic the new farm bill will be completed by the end of the year.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

Farm bill will pass now, but not guaranteed

Coppess, University Of Illinois Department Of Agricultural And Consumer Economics professor, 6-15-23

[Jonathan, 6-15-23, Farm Doc Daily Illinois, “Farm Bill 2023: Trying To Reason With Expectations For Farm Policy”, , accessed 7-3-23, EH]

The debt limit barrier to a farm bill has been removed, which may increase the odds that Congress can reauthorize a farm bill this year but certainly doesn’t guarantee it. A collision between expectations for farm program payments and the rules governing a farm bill budget could be among the most significant barriers remaining. This article reviews some of what may be driving expectations for farm program payments and the challenges that result.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Uniqueness › Farm Bill Will Pass Now

Farm Bill likely to pass – coalition-building now

Knight, The Community Word, 7-8-23

[Bill Knight, 7-8-23, Community Word "Bill Knight: Can bipartisanship outdo ‘Cavity Caucus’ and Big Ag for next Farm Bill?,", , accessed 7-11-23, S.A.M]

It’s not hoping against hope to see possibilities for reasonable people in Congress to put country above party and again work together to compromise and construct a new, five-year Farm Bill, which is being drafted this summer.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › 1NC – Farm Bill 1NC Shell › Farm Bill 1NC Shell

2. Food insecurity escalates every hotspot to go nuclear causing extinction

Castellaw, Founder and CEO of Farmspace Systems LLC founder & CEO, 17

[John, Lieutenant General, former President of the non-profit Crockett Policy Institute, Agri-Pulse, “Opinion: Food Security Strategy Is Essential to Our National Security,” , accessed 7-16-23]

The United States faces many threats to our National Security. These threats include continuing wars with extremist elements such as ISIS and potential wars with rogue state North Korea or regional nuclear power Iran. The heated economic and diplomatic competition with Russia and a surging China could spiral out of control. Concurrently, we face threats to our future security posed by growing civil strife, famine, and refugee and migration challenges which create incubators for extremist and anti-American government factions. Our response cannot be one dimensional but instead must be a nuanced and comprehensive National Security Strategy combining all elements of National Power including a Food Security Strategy.