Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Counterplan
Fism DA › Links › Enforcement

Enforcement of plan undermines federalism

Ross, Office of Water at the EPA, assistant administrator, et al 21 [Dave, Misha Tseytlin, or Houston Shaner, 3-5-21, JD Supra, “Don’t Forget the States as You Grapple with Federal Regulation," https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/don-t-forget-the-states-as-you-grapple-5333302/, Accessed: 6-29-2021, /MB]

Historically, federal enforcement displaces state enforcement, either because the federal government demands primacy or because states defer to the federal lead and reallocate their enforcement and compliance assistance resources to other priorities. Many states for that second reason may not mind a more active federal role. Others, however, prefer to manage enforcement within their borders under their delegated federal authorities or under other state programs. One concern for those states is that heavy-handed federal involvement and elongated negotiations may alter state relationships with the regulated community, or with the federal government. More active federal enforcement also tends to increase federal audits and oversight of state programs, creating further opportunity to erode the federal-state relationship.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Fism DA › Links › Cooperative Federalism Link

That spills over to broader environmental management

Zollitsch, Senior Policy Analyst, PhD, 2019 [Brenda, May/June 2019, ASWM, “Cooperative Federalism: Finding the Right Balance between Federal and State Roles in Implementing the Clean Water Act”, , MB]

Cooperative federalism relies on states maintaining the authority to control their own resources in partnership with enforcement and financial support from federal government. There are concerns about how current actions by EPA and their lack of formal consultation with states may impact the delicate balance of cooperative federalism. Water managers across the nation argue that any reduction in state authority through changes in §401 timelines and other controls are of great concern. They argue, instead, that there are many examples of successful cooperative federalism. While it does not work in all cases and in many cases could be improved, the base foundations of cooperative federalism are critical to successful environmental management and relationships that protect the interests of all three levels of government.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Fism DA › 1NC shell

Internal link – Preventing federalism conflicts is crucial for broader environmental policy and responding to climate change - the link alone turns case

Weted, Department of Public Administration and Policy and American University, doctoral student 21 [Carley, 5-7-21, Medium, Does Environmental Policy “Need” the Federal Government?," https://medium.com/3streams/does-environmental-policy-need-the-federal-government-21abcd8fe970, Accessed: 6-24-2021, /MB]

The best option, it seems, is to maintain existing allocations of authority and attempt incremental reform. The federal-state partnership is not as cooperative as it used to be. It’s actually sometimes disruptive — but finding a more even-keeled balance is critical for the future of environmental protection. The success of our system depends on a working relationship between the federal government and state environmental agencies.

When not functioning, a problem arises for the quality of environmental policy and big, looming issues like climate change and water pollution. What there is a need for within environmental policy is partnerships. Yes, the federal government is important — and so are states. There has to be some collaboration. That’s how our government was designed to function and how it works best, if it’s done right. There needs to be some flexibility, some innovation and a lot of power-sharing.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Fism DA › 1NC shell

Federal fiscal policy makes the states too dependent on the federal government – undermines federalism

Edwards, Cato, state tax and budget issues top expert, 22

(Chris, 2022, CATO Institute, “Fiscal Federalism”, , Accessed 7-3-23, ED)

Under the U.S. Constitution, the federal government was assigned specific, limited powers, and most government functions were left to the states. To emphasize the limits on federal power, the nation’s Founders added the Tenth Amendment: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” The amendment embodies federalism, the idea that federal and state governments have separate policy areas and that federal activities are “few and defined,” as James Madison noted in Federalist no. 45.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › AT: L2NB › Avoid Econ/Inflation DA

State Fiscal Redistribution don’t affect economic growth – neighbor effects prove that the FR in one state would help the economy of the other states

Chernick, Hunter College, Professor of Economics, 10

(Howard, 2010, SAGE, “Redistribution at the State and Local Level: Consequences for Economic Growth”, DOI: 10.1177/1091142110375694, Accessed 7-9-23, ED)

Neighbor effects. Although own progressivity does not affect growth, row 2 of table 3 indicates that neighbor state progressivity (NEIGH TAX PROG) has a significant positive effect, particularly over the five-year period. When I decompose the neighbor progressivity ratio into separate tax burdens NBURD1 and NBURD5 (rows 3 and 4 of table 4), the per capita growth models (columns 1 and 2), NBURD5 is positive and significant, while NBURD1 is negative but insignificant. Based on the point estimate of 0.18 in column 1, a percentage point increase in NBURD5 raises the five-year annual rate of state growth in per capita income by 0.18, or slightly less than 10 percent of the 2.3 percent average. From the 0.379 coefficient in column 7, a percentage point increase in NBURD5 increases own-state aggregate income growth by about 10 percent, relative to mean growth of 3.6 percent per year.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › AT: L2NB › Avoids PTX DA

Prior action means states get credit – also means the perm is a sequencing question

Ferraiolo 8 – Professor of Political Science at James Madison University (Kathleen Ferraolo, “State Policy Innovation and the Federalism Implications of Direct Democracy,” Publius)//BB

Ballot Initiatives that Respond to Federal Inaction There were a number of policy issues that appeared on multiple state ballots during the past several election cycles. Voters have cast their ballots on topics ranging from same-sex marriage and gambling to education, energy, election reform, and taxes. Eminent domain, the minimum wage, abortion, government finances, and animal rights were other subjects that occupied voters’ attention. This study focuses on four issue areas, most of which were considered in multiple states and targeted federal policy either by responding to perceived inaction or by challenging federal law. The Minimum Wage Until the newly elected Democratic Congress tackled the issue in early 2007, the federal government had not enacted a minimum wage increase since 1997, when it was raised to five dollars and fifteen cents an hour. Not content to wait for the federal government to act on what they perceived to be an important issue, in 2006 voters in six states (Nevada, Arizona, Ohio, Colorado, Missouri, and Montana) ratified initiatives to increase the minimum wage and index it to inflation, in some cases overwhelmingly. Eleven state legislatures approved raises in 2006 as well. The average ‘‘yes’’ vote for the 2006 ballot measures was 66 percent, and the average margin of victory was thirty-one points. In 2004, voters in Florida and Nevada overwhelmingly supported minimum wage ballot measures. In total, the National Conference of State Legislatures (2007b) reports that thirty states and the District of Columbia have adopted state minimum wages that are higher than the federal minimum wage. Clearly, despite inaction at the federal level there is much support for raising the minimum wage among both state voters and elected officials, including Democratic and some Republican governors and legislators. The ballot presence of hot-button issues such as same-sex marriage and the minimum wage has led scholars to investigate the mobilizing effects of these issues (Abramowitz 2004; Smith 2006; Nicholson 2005) and to uncover evidence of initiatives’ educative and electoral spillover effects. Smith and Tolbert, among the first to study the educative effects of direct democracy, found that initiative use is associated with increases in voter turnout, civic engagement, political interest, and political knowledge (Tolbert and Smith 2006; Smith and Tolbert 2004). Smith and Tolbert (2001), Kousser and McCubbins (2005), and others document the spillover effects of ballot initiatives on broader electoral and political processes such as citizens’ voting behavior in candidate elections and political party and interest group strategies. Smith (2006) notes that political officials (such as Arnold Schwarzenegger) and party operatives have skillfully used the initiative process to advance their policy agendas, threaten the legislature into action, and frame candidate elections. Smith, DeSantis, and Kassel (2006) find a positive correlation between support for anti-same-sex marriage measures and the vote for George W. Bush in Ohio and Michigan in 2004. Kousser and McCubbins (2005) describe how Democratic party activists in Colorado helped sponsor a successful 2004 initiative to increase mass transit funding that contributed to high voter turnout and Democratic victories in an election when Republican candidates dominated in many other states. In a wide-ranging study, Nicholson (2005) finds that ballot measures have agenda-setting, priming, and electoral spillover effects, altering the weight voters assign to various issues, the standards by which they evaluate candidates for congressional and gubernatorial offices, and the strategies of political candidates and parties. No longer the exclusive domain of citizens or interest groups, political party organizations, candidates, and elected officials now use initiative elections for many purposes: To increase voter registration and turnout, advance their political agendas and ideologies, circumvent contribution and expenditure limits in candidate races, selectively mobilize support for their own candidates, prime vote choice for issues on which they believe they have an advantage, or drive a wedge in opponent coalitions (Smith 2005, 2006; Kousser and McCubbins 2005; Smith and Tolbert 2001). As candidates and parties seek initiative success for policy or ideological reasons, they also force their opponents to drain their resources in attempting to defeat initiatives that run counter to their own policy and political goals. The minimum wage ballot measures that experienced overwhelming success in 2004 and 2006 were part of a concerted effort by progressive activists to mobilize sympathetic voters and sway candidate elections. Support for Florida’s 2004 minimum wage initiative by the Association of Community Organization for Reform Now (ACORN) led to the adoption of the measure as well as a successful voter registration drive. The group appeared to achieve its goals of ‘‘‘driving heightened Democratic turnout, passing the initiative, and building permanent political capacity for future gains’’’ (quoted in Kousser and McCubbins 2005, 973). In 2004 progressive activists in Nevada and Florida, with the approval of the Democratic National Committee, used focus groups and pre-election surveys to pretest the language of a variety of minimum wage proposals. They selected those they believed would mobilize low-income voters who would also support Democratic candidates, including presidential nominee John Kerry (Smith 2006). In 2006, the belief that minimum wage ballot initiatives could mobilize Democratic-leaning voters was an attractive possibility for labor unions (particularly the AFL-CIO, which launched its ‘‘America Needs a Raise’’ campaign that year) and other progressive groups such as ACORN interested in unseating the Republican congressional leadership (Broder 2006; Andrews 2006). The objectives of minimum wage sponsors, then, were manifold, including bringing about both state and federal policy change, boosting voter registration and turnout, and influencing candidate elections. Even before they appeared on state ballots and in Congress, proposals to increase the minimum wage received high levels of support in public opinion polls (Roper Center 2007, 55). Democrats in Congress are certainly more sympathetic to a minimum wage increase than are most Republicans, and it is not surprising that they would choose to address the issue as one of their signature initiatives in the 110th Congress in early 2007. Still, the evidence presented here suggests that supporters of raising the minimum wage were able to simultaneously achieve three objectives: Advocates took independent state-level action to address a policy issue of public concern; they had a hand in helping to bring about an electoral majority in Congress more favorable to increasing the minimum wage; and their efforts led to increased turnout (if not Democratic victories) in at least some of the states where the measures appeared. As predicted, the success of minimum wage initiatives in multiple states during the 2004–2006 election cycle ultimately resulted in intergovernmental policy consensus. Impatient with the pace of federal efforts to raise the minimum wage, state lawmakers and voters used the legislative process and direct democracy institutions to address the issue, ultimately producing a divergence in policy not only between states and the federal government but across states as well. The newly elected Democratic Congress resolved this federal–state policy diversity (if not state-to-state diversity; many states set their minimum wage rates higher than the federal level) by acting to raise the minimum wage for the first time in ten years. However, some evidence suggests that state voters and policymakers, and not federal lawmakers, receive most of the credit for policy innovations that originate at the state level. The House of Representatives passed a bill to raise the minimum wage during the second week of the congressional session, but in an early February 2007 poll fewer than one in five respondents gave the House credit for this accomplishment (Roper Center 2007, 131); 84 percent of survey respondents favored a minimum wage increase in 2006, but in March 2007 a mere 2 percent of respondents cited the issue when asked what was the most important thing Congress had done in its first few months (Roper Center 2007, 090). While Congress received little credit for its support for a minimum wage increase, the initiatives’ overwhelming success and the Democratic takeover of Congress in 2007 brought state and federal policy more in line with public opinion, enhancing the opinion-policy connection particularly at the state level and fostering vertical policy consensus and diffusion.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › AT: Perms › PDCP

Not states

OED 89 (Oxford English Dictionary, 2ed. XIX, p. 795)

b. Of or pertaining to the political unity so constituted, as distinguished from the separate states composing it.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › AT: Perms › PDCP

Federal refers to the national government. It’s distinct from state law.

Dictionary of Government and Politics ’98 (Ed. P.H. Collin, p. 116)

federal [‘federal] adjective (a) referring to a system of government in which a group of states are linked together in a federation; a federal constitution = constitution (such as that in Germany) which provides for a series of semi-autonomous states joined together in a national federation (b) referring especially to the federal government of the United States; federal court or federal laws = court or laws of the USA, as opposed to state courts or state laws.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › AT: Perms › PDCP

National government, not states or localities

Black’s Law 99 (Dictionary, Seventh Edition, p.703)

A national government that exercises some degree of control over smaller political units that have surrendered some degree of power in exchange for the right to participate in national political matters

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › AT: Perms › PDB

States can fund – The 1996 welfare reform provided states with lower costs to institute benefits

Marton, University of Kentucky, Assistant Professor, and Wildasin, University of Kentucky, Endowed Chair in Public Finance, 06

(James, and David E., 4-25-06, Journal of Urban Economics, “State government cash and in-kind benefits: Intergovernmental fiscal transfers and cross-program substitution”, doi: 10.1016/j.jue.2006.04.006, Accessed 7-12-23, ED)

US states provide both cash and health insurance benefits for the poor, partially financed by fiscal transfers from the Federal government. The 1996 welfare reform drastically reduces Federal support for cash transfers at the margin, lowering the relative price to states of providing benefits to the poor through Medicaid. This paper analyzes the comparative-statics response of state governments to such changes in intergovernmental transfers, showing (in central cases) that they can contribute not only to reductions in state expenditures on cash benefits but to increases in expenditures on Medicaid, whether or not beneficiary populations are mobile among states.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solves Aff Areas › 2NC Progressive Tax

States work best at implementing income tax – exhibits substantial altruism, creates a better balance, and innovates the system

Miron, Harvard University, senior economic lecturer, 11

(Jeffrey A., Winter 2011, National Affairs, “Rethinking Redistribution”, , Accessed 7-8-23, ED)

Indeed, the negative income-tax system as a whole might well work best at the state level — that is, if it replaced both federal and state redistribution efforts with 50 state-level negative income-tax systems. Advocates of redistribution fear that state-level negative income taxes would start a "race to the bottom," in which states slash benefits to avoid attracting poor populations. But in fact, numerous examples — including minimum-wage laws, TANF and Medicaid provision, and pre-1935 state-level Social Security programs — show that states can exhibit substantial altruism, so that state-level anti-poverty efforts would not be miserly. Concern over in-migration might nevertheless counter political pressures in favor of excessive expansion, yielding a better balance than a federal system could attain. And state experimentation would no doubt produce some innovations and improvements that a federal system would fail to discover. Of course, a transition from our current system to a negative income tax might be easier if it first involved a transition to one federal negative income tax. In an ideal world, however, such a system would eventually be turned over to the states.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solves Aff Areas › 2NC UBI

States programs solve UBI better – A state guaranteed income program is more efficient than a federal UBI because the ability to share information across programs

Downey, Legal Impact Network at the Shiver Center, Staff Attorney, et al., 22

(Nolan, Jeremy Rosen, Shiver Center staff, Marie Claire Tran-Leung, Shiver Center staff, Michelle Nicolet, Shiver Center staff, Emily Coffey, Shiver Center staff, Marcus Samuel, Shiver Center staff, Dina Kostrow, Shiver Center staff, Gabriela Camargo Martins, Economic Security Project staff, Michael Conti, Economic Security Project staff, Andrea Diaz, Economic Security Project staff, Pedro Morillas, Economic Security Project staff, Madeline Neighly, Economic Security Project staff, April 2022, Shiver Center on Poverty Law, and Economic Security Project, “States Lead the Way in Reimagining the Social Safety Net”, , Accessed 7-2-23, ED)

Building a New Program

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solves Aff Areas › 2NC UBI

States can fund a UBI – States can give dividends from a public fund to fund the UBI program

Downey, Legal Impact Network at the Shiver Center, Staff Attorney, et al., 22

(Nolan, Jeremy Rosen, Shiver Center staff, Marie Claire Tran-Leung, Shiver Center staff, Michelle Nicolet, Shiver Center staff, Emily Coffey, Shiver Center staff, Marcus Samuel, Shiver Center staff, Dina Kostrow, Shiver Center staff, Gabriela Camargo Martins, Economic Security Project staff, Michael Conti, Economic Security Project staff, Andrea Diaz, Economic Security Project staff, Pedro Morillas, Economic Security Project staff, Madeline Neighly, Economic Security Project staff, April 2022, Shiver Center on Poverty Law, and Economic Security Project, “States Lead the Way in Reimagining the Social Safety Net”, , Accessed 7-2-23, ED)

Dividend from an Invested Public Fund

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solves Aff Areas › 2NC UBI

States Solve UBI – Disappointing Federal UBI efforts open the door for states to implement their own UBI programs

Downey, Legal Impact Network at the Shiver Center, Staff Attorney, et al., 22

(Nolan, Jeremy Rosen, Shiver Center staff, Marie Claire Tran-Leung, Shiver Center staff, Michelle Nicolet, Shiver Center staff, Emily Coffey, Shiver Center staff, Marcus Samuel, Shiver Center staff, Dina Kostrow, Shiver Center staff, Gabriela Camargo Martins, Economic Security Project staff, Michael Conti, Economic Security Project staff, Andrea Diaz, Economic Security Project staff, Pedro Morillas, Economic Security Project staff, Madeline Neighly, Economic Security Project staff, April 2022, Shiver Center on Poverty Law, and Economic Security Project, “States Lead the Way in Reimagining the Social Safety Net”, , Accessed 7-2-23, ED)

Why Should

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Tech dev + innovation

Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf has already calling for more investment in helping grow technological efforts

GT Editorial Staff, Media and research public-sector innovation for state and local government., ‘22

[GT Editorial Staff , 03/26/2022, Government Techonology, “State of the States 2022: How Much Tech Is on the Table?,” https://www.govtech.com/state-of-the-states-2022-how-much-tech-is-on-the-table, Accessed 07/12/2023, BS]

Pennsylvania State of the State Address, Address date: Feb. 8, 2022, Stars: 1, To sum it up: In his final budget address, Gov. Tom Wolf recounted efforts during his tenure to dig out Pennsylvania from a fiscal hole while also looking ahead. Though he barely made direct mention of technology, his speech did touch upon areas where the state can improve its technological innovation and investments., For starters, he told listeners that the state needs to essentially honor its traditional economic strengths and keep developing new sources of revenue and jobs. “We’re strong in manufacturing, in natural resources, in human capital,” Wolf said. “We’ve seen explosive growth in traditional industries like tourism and agriculture, and in cutting-edge industries like robotics, life sciences, and petrochemicals.”Wolf called upon state lawmakers to make sure they keep putting money into areas that will further help the state grow its technological efforts. He noted existing investments in secondary and higher education STEM education, as well as career and technical programs.Like other governors this year, Wolf also went beyond education and urged a focus on other areas where the state can use technology to both increase economic benefits and protect the environment. He called for more investment in clean energy and infrastructure programs — along with more attention to fighting the opioid crisis and raising the minimum wage — so that the state will not be left behind over the next generation.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Tech dev + innovation

Arkansas is already gearing towards tech innovation

GT Editorial Staff, Media and research public-sector innovation for state and local government., ‘22

[GT Editorial Staff , 03/26/2022, Government Techonology, “State of the States 2022: How Much Tech Is on the Table?,” https://www.govtech.com/state-of-the-states-2022-how-much-tech-is-on-the-table, Accessed 07/12/2023, BS]

Arkansas State of the State Address, Address date: Feb. 14, 2022, Stars: 1, To sum it up: In his Feb. 14 State of the State address, Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson noted the state has made significant strides in terms of economic development, as communities across the country struggle to recover from a recession brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic. He said the state has signed 556 incentive agreements with employers like EnviroTech to bring over 25,000 new jobs to the state, adding that “81,000 more people are employed now” compared to when he took office in 2015. Touching more on the state’s current job market and workforce training goals, Hutchinson noted the progress made by state policymakers to establish computer science courses in the state’s public schools in order to prepare graduates for an increasingly digitized job market. As of last year, the state reported it had increased computer science enrollment by more than 800 percent since the launch of its Computer Science Imitative in 2015. Hutchinson said the state is now “leading in computer science education” due in part to the state program, among other efforts geared toward “technology innovation."

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Tech dev + innovation

Governors have been talking about specifics on getting the growth of the tech / support for the growth in those industry’s

GT Editorial Staff, Media and research public-sector innovation for state and local government., ‘22

[GT Editorial Staff , 03/26/2022, Government Techonology, “State of the States 2022: How Much Tech Is on the Table?,” https://www.govtech.com/state-of-the-states-2022-how-much-tech-is-on-the-table, Accessed 07/12/2023, BS]

Thirty-six states will hold elections for governor this fall, which makes 2022 an interesting year for State of the State addresses. Government Technology writers and editors review these speeches annually to see what they foretell for technology — an interesting exercise in a “normal” year. But in a year where more than two-thirds of governors will be voted up or down, politics often took center stage.If governors have positive economic news to report, the State of the State address is a great place to share it. Budget surpluses and low unemployment rates — equal or almost equal to pre-pandemic levels — were touted by many governors, with many getting specific about their work to support the growth of industry and therefore job numbers within their borders. Manufacturing, technology and clean energy business development is especially coveted, based on these speeches.As expected, many leaders got specific about the central nature of broadband expansion to their plans for their states to flourish. Interestingly, though, fewer seemed to feel it necessary to justify these investments — perhaps signaling broad acceptance by Americans of the essential nature of connectivity. Another interesting twist for 2022 was that more governors are pointing to robust connectivity as an integral part of their economic development strategies: Ubiquitous connectivity makes states more competitive in luring both new businesses and new workers. Gov. Polis in Colorado, Gov. Holcomb in Indiana and Gov. Ige in Hawaii, as of this writing, were explicit about plans to boost connectivity to ensure remote workers could thrive in their states.Also on this year’s agenda is continuing to expand access to telehealth, which many governors now see as a critical part of a more accessible health-care system, especially to residents in areas with limited access to doctors and medical facilities. Many policies around the use of telemedicine were relaxed to observe COVID-19 protocols, exposing its benefits to whole new populations.And speaking of the pandemic, it is less of a central theme in speeches this year, though there were scattered mentions of the need for in-person learning as well as celebrations of vaccine victories in states with successful programs. West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice’s COVID-19 diagnosis forced him to cancel his planned in-person speech, vowing a rain check when he is able. Known for an aggressive vaccine rollout, the state is the first in the country to seek approval for at-risk West Virginians to get a fourth dose of the vaccine.

2023 GDI Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › AT: States Have No Power

State have control of labor laws and rights of employees then fed

Arnold Law Firm, attorney that practice law in Califronia , ‘22

[Arnold, October 14, 2022, JUSTICE4YOU , “WHAT HAPPENS WHEN STATE AND FEDERAL LABOR LAWS DIFFER?”, https://www.justice4you.com/blog/state-vs-federal-labor-laws.html, Accessed 07/08/2023, BS]

Due to the Supremacy Clause in Article VI of the Constitution, federal law can supersede state laws. However, the tenth amendment of the Constitution also gives some power back to the states to govern themselves. This means that there is often a balancing act between how state and federal laws interact with each other. When it comes to labor laws, states often have more authority to expand the rights of employers or employees.In California, there are several labor laws that expand on the rights of employees already set forth by federal law. This then raises an important question about which law shall be enforced if there is an employment dispute.Below, our Sacramento wage and hour lawyers discuss the differing laws and when each can be enforced.