Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › Progressive income tax – inflation DA

Progressive income tax funding reduces the link to inflation

Stephen Nuñez ’20, January 17, “UBI & the City,” PHENOMENAL WORLD, https://www.phenomenalworld.org/analysis/universal-basic-income-the-city/

Skeptics of guaranteed income tend to worry about the policy’s inflationary effects; absent rent regulation, for instance, one might expect housing costs to rise in proportion to the increase in disposable income generated by the policy. In a new working paper supported by JFI, “Universal Basic Income and the City (2019),” Khalil Esmkhani, Jack Favilukis and Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh explore the effects of a UBI implemented at the city-level in New York City (the updated version of the paper, released in 2021, can be found here). The paper finds that, when financed through a progressive income tax, a UBI increases general welfare and—perhaps most notably—does not lead to housing market inflation. Their research sheds new light on the possible inflationary effects of basic income policies, and also suggests that the financing of a guaranteed income has significant implications for the policy’s outcomes. While the results are tentative, the paper already represents a major advance in the study cash transfer policy. In this post, I present an overview of the macroeconomic literature on basic income before turning back to the authors’ model, its findings, and a path for future work.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › Progressive income tax – T

UBI funded by progressive income tax topically redistributes

Jason Leman ’18, September 27, “WHY SHOULD A UBI PILOT BE TAXING?” https://www.ubilabnetwork.org/blog/should-a-ubi-pilot-be-taxing

So we need to have a good idea of how we will fund a UBI and whether it is additional to, or a development of, the current welfare state. To underline how the detail matters, let’s consider the third scenario, where a progressive income tax funds a UBI. This is the model on the right of Figures 1 and 2. This scheme costs around half that of the scheme where the tax and benefits system were left untouched. We adjust the UBI given to people in the pilot according to what benefits they receive and the additional taxes they would pay under a more progressive income tax. In fact, at some income level people will become net losers, as they are required to pay more tax under the proposed UBI scheme than they do currently. Quite where the tipping point would be depends on the detail: what level of taxation is required, whether the UBI would be maintained if tax revenue fell, and whether it would only be funded through income tax. There are wider issues that it would be hard to model and where there is conflicting evidence, such as likely tax avoidance and resistance to increasing income tax. A pilot would not be able to answer all these questions, not least because most people would not voluntarily pay more taxes under a pilot scheme. However, transparency about funding would allow for a conversation to be had as part of a pilot.

I favour Universal Basic Income as a means of redistributing income, profits and wealth. I would argue that a mix of funding would be best, to help rebalance the economy alongside rebalancing individual income. This may involve closing tax loopholes, raising taxes on profits or transactions, alongside a more progressive income tax model. The UK currently has a regressive tax system because of the high levels of indirect taxes that hit the poor. Yet, changing the tax system isn’t a simple option. Many tax reliefs have the intention of creating socially beneficial outcomes. Increasing indirect taxes or corporation tax significantly would impact on producers and consumers in multiple ways. Any pilot needs to include at least an outline modelling of the impact of these tax changes and have a coherent argument driving them.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › Progressive income tax – T

UBI meets “substantial redistribution” if it is funded by progressive income taxation

Rema Hanna and Benjamin A. Olken ’18, August, “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOMES VS. TARGETED TRANSFERS: ANTI-POVERTY PROGRAMS IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES,” NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES, https://nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w24939/w24939.pdf

Given these challenges, some have begun to advocate for “universal basic income” programs, which dispense with trying to identify the poor and instead provide transfers to everyone. A universal basic income program is comparatively straightforward to implement – each individual receives a fixed transfer, regardless of income – so the main challenge is to ensure that each person receives the transfer only once. Although universal basic income programs distribute the same value of transfer to everyone, including the very rich, if they are financed through proportional or progressive taxation, they can still result in a substantial redistribution to the poor.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Competitiveness***

Basic income will begin a transformation of our economy – resultant innovation will go beyond our imagination

Rutger Bregman, historian’ 16. M.A., UCLA, journalist, and Dutch historian, UTOPIA FOR REALISTS: THE CASE FOR A UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME, OPEN BORDERS, AND A 15-HOUR WORKWEEK, translated by Elizabeth Manton, The Correspondent, 2016, epub

What makes all this especially shocking is that it’s happening in a capitalist system, a system founded on capitalist values like efficiency and productivity. While politicians endlessly stress the need to downsize government, they remain largely silent as the number of bullshit jobs goes right on growing. This results in scenarios where, on the one hand, governments cut back on useful jobs in sectors like healthcare, education, and infrastructure – resulting in unemployment – while on the other investing millions in the unemployment industry of training and surveillance whose effectiveness has long been disproven.

The modern marketplace is equally uninterested in usefulness, quality, and innovation. All that really matters is profit. Sometimes that leads to marvelous contributions, sometimes not. From telemarketers to tax consultants, there’s a rock-solid rationale for creating one bullshit job after another: You can net a fortune without ever producing a thing.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Competitiveness***

Russia and China are revisionist---maintaining military tech dominance is critical to avert great power war.

Trotti 20

Christian Trotti- assistant director of Forward Defense at the Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security. Matthew Kroenig- PhD, Berkeley, Professor of Government at the Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University. Nuclear Modernization in the 21st Century, “Modernization as a Promoter of International Security,” DOI: 10.4324/9780429435829. February 17 2020. AR.

The modernization programs of the United States and its democratic allies at the core of the international system tend to promote international security. On the other hand, the nuclear modernization programs of revisionist autocratic powers intent on challenging the international system tend to threaten global peace and stability. Thus, not all modernization programs are created equal. It is ultimately the underlying geopolitical conditions, and not solely the capabilities themselves, which determine the extent to which modernization programs promote or diminish international security. Since 1945, the United States has been the leader of a rules-based international order that has brought the world unprecedented levels of peace, prosperity, and freedom.3 U.S. nuclear weapons have provided the security backbone of that order by deterring major power conflict in Europe and Asia.4 Additionally, U.S. extended nuclear security guarantees have protected the entire free world and dissuaded many capable states from developing independent nuclear capabilities. The modernization of U.S. nuclear weapons will therefore continue to reinforce these major sources of geopolitical peace and stability. Alternatively, Russia, China, and North Korea are opposed to major elements of the existing international system and seek in varying ways to disrupt or displace it. Given their revisionist geopolitical objectives, nuclear modernization in these countries tends to threaten international peace and stability. Geopolitical intentions guide nuclear strategy, which in turn informs modernization programs. It is therefore essential to account for a state’s position within the international system when evaluating the likely effects of nuclear modernization on international stability. The rest of this essay proceeds in four parts. First, it explains why U.S. nuclear weapons serve as unique guarantor of international security in the postwar world order. Second, it argues that the United States must modernize its aging nuclear capabilities in order to sustain its longstanding role in promoting global security. Third, it addresses the ways in which revisionist powers seek to use their nuclear modernization programs for destabilizing ends. Fourth, it briefly considers the role of other nations’ nuclear forces, including: Britain, France, India, Israel, and Pakistan. Finally, it concludes with implications for scholarship and for policy. The U.S.-led, rules-based international order Following the end of World War II, the United States and its victorious allies built the international system in which we reside today.5 Like past hegemons, the United States ordered an international system to suit its interests. Unlike past hegemons, however, Washington did not seek to rule through formal empire. Rather, it sought to reproduce a variant of its rules-based domestic political system for the global system. This rules-based international order possesses multiple components. First, Washington and its allies established a wide range of international institutions, such as the United Nations, the World Bank, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), and the Treaty on the Nonproliferation of Nuclear Weapons, to encourage multilateral solutions to a wide variety of challenges. Second, it sought to correct the protectionism of the interwar years by creating an open economic system defined by the free flow of trade and capital across borders. Third, the United States and its democratic allies have promoted freedom, human rights, and good governance abroad. Lastly, Washington employed its unmatched military might to provide the underlying stability and security which has allowed the overall system to function. While the system is imperfect and the United States has sometimes disobeyed the rules it helped to write, the rules-based order has nevertheless produced remarkable results. Humanity has been blessed by the absence of great power war for over seventy years. Global standards of living are much higher today than seven decades ago.6 And by the mid-2000s, more people were living under democratic governments than at any time in world history.7 As the world’s most powerful state and the architect of this system, the United States advanced and defended this order through a variety of economic, diplomatic, and military means. An underappreciated but central pillar of this rules-based order, however, has been the U.S. nuclear arsenal. U.S. nuclear weapons have provided the backbone for the underlying security element of the global system. U.S. nuclear weapons and great power peace U.S. nuclear weapons contribute to global stability by deterring great power war. U.S. nuclear weapons have deterred revisionist autocratic powers, such as the Soviet Union during the Cold War and Russia, China, and North Korea today, from attacking U.S. allies in Europe and Asia. Scholars have long appreciated the role of nuclear weapons in deterring war and contributing to the long period of great power peace. Indeed, much social science scholarship credits the nuclear revolution with transforming international politics and making large-scale war among the major powers unthinkable.8 What much of this literature ignores, however, is the unique role played by American nuclear weapons. Unlike other nuclear powers that seek to deter attacks on themselves only, the United States aims to deter attacks against the entire free world.9 The United States extends deterrence to over thirty formal treaty allies, including twenty-eight members of NATO, South Korea, Japan, Australia, and arguably others. The U.S. policy of extended deterrence provides geopolitical stability in Europe and Asia, the two most important geostrategic regions on the planet and the home of all the major nuclear powers. As a status quo power and leader of the international system, the United States has had little interest in or incentive to use military force to revise the territorial status quo in Europe or Asia. Following the end of World War II, for example, the United States’ immediate goal was in setting up independent governments in defeated countries, allowing free elections, and returning home.10 The Soviet Union, on the other hand, had an explicit goal of spreading Marxist revolutions to other nations in Europe and around the world. It established puppet states under Moscow’s control in the territories it occupied in Eastern Europe. It employed military force, in Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968, in order to force these states to remain in the Soviet camp. The Soviet Union also attempted to use military coercion in a failed bid to wrest control of Berlin from the West in a series of crises during the late 1950s and 1960s. In Asia, Moscow gave the green light to North Korea to invade its Southern neighbor and initiate the Korean War.11 These are only the major examples of Soviet militarized revisionism during the Cold War. In the face of this threat from the Red Army, the United States remained in Europe at the behest of its allies to deter Russian invasion. In order to counter the Soviet Union’s conventional superiority in Europe, the United States and NATO relied heavily on nuclear deterrence.12 U.S. nuclear weapons and the requisite resolve to defend allies were critical to forcing Moscow’s submission in the Berlin Crises and to deterring war in Europe. In addition, the United States became more deeply involved in Asia, intervening militarily in Korea and in the Taiwan Straits to prevent communist forces from invading or threatening their neighbors.13 In sum, during the Cold War in Europe and Asia, the Soviet Union’s foreign policy was largely oriented toward revising the status quo, while the United States generally employed force, including nuclear deterrence, in order to uphold it. Similarly today, Russia, China, and North Korea express their displeasure with the territorial status quo in their respective regions.14 Russian President Vladimir Putin refers to the collapse of the Soviet Union as “the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the 21st century” and longs to re-establish a “greater-Russia.”15 He has been clear about his interest in re-establishing a sphere of influence in Eastern Europe and he has already invaded two of his neighbors, Georgia and Ukraine. China has also declared a long-term intention to redraw the map of Asia to incorporate Taiwan and it has begun taking contested territory in the South China Sea through military coercion and gray-zone tactics. North Korea has engaged in repeated bouts of aggression against South Korea and Seoul’s American ally over the decades. It initiated the Korean War and seized the U.S.S. Pueblo during the Cold War. In recent years, Pyongyang has sunk a South Korean warship and shelled a South Korean island. U.S. democratic allies in Europe and Asia consistently call upon the United States to maintain a robust nuclear strategy and posture in order to deter possible aggression from these autocratic and revisionist powers. For example, when U.S. President Obama considered the adoption of a nuclear No First Use Policy at the end of his term, U.S. allies resisted.16 Largely in response to allied demands, the United States agreed to keep the nuclear option on the table to deter conventional aggression. It has also developed nuclear capabilities, including the supplemental, low-yield capabilities called for in the 2018 U.S. Nuclear Posture Review, with the explicit goal of extending deterrence and reassuring allies.17 Therefore, it is true that nuclear weapons have deterred great power war for over seventy years, but it is important to consider whose potential aggression has been deterred. If nuclear weapons were to be un-invented or nuclear deterrence to fail, any ensuing aggression would most likely be conducted, not by the United States, but by Moscow, Beijing, or Pyongyang against their regional neighbors. It is specifically U.S. nuclear weapons that are the most important element for keeping the peace in Europe and Asia. U.S. nuclear weapons and nonproliferation The United States has also contributed to the security of the rules-based international system by halting the spread of the world’s most dangerous weapons. Once again, in this domain, U.S. nuclear weapons have been central to these efforts. As the most powerful state in the international system and the leader of the rules-based order, the United States possesses a strong interest in preventing other nations from acquiring nuclear weapons.18 Washington played a unique role in establishing the major institutions of the nuclear nonproliferation regime, including the Treaty on the Nonproliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT).19 Some theorists, like Kenneth Waltz, argue that horizontal proliferation yields greater systemic stability and that Washington could benefit from slow and selective nuclear proliferation, but there are many risks to the spread of nuclear weapons, especially for the world system’s leader.20 Accordingly, this “proliferation optimism” argument has never found favor in the corridors of power.21 To support its goal of preventing the spread of nuclear weapons to allied states, the United States has provided these states with extended deterrence. Washington struck a bargain with allies: refrain from building your own nuclear weapons and we will protect you with U.S. nuclear weapons. As stated above, the United States currently extends its nuclear umbrella to over thirty formal treaty allies and arguably others. Without these efforts at extending deterrence to assure allies, it is likely that at least several other U.S. allies would possess independent nuclear capabilities today. U.S. assurance efforts were essential to eliminating nuclear weapons ambitions in West Germany in the early days of the Cold War, and South Korea and Taiwan in the 1970s.22 Studies employing statistical analysis have shown that, “States receiving security guarantees from nuclear-armed superpower allies are only 22 percent as likely to explore nuclear weapons as those who do not, 13 percent as likely to pursue them, and 15 percent as likely to acquire them in a given year, conditional on their not having done so previously.”23 To make this extended deterrent guarantee more credible, Washington sometimes goes so far as to deploy U.S. nuclear weapons on the territory of its allies. This forward-deployed American nuclear power has been referred to as a wedding ring to its allies, providing a visible symbol of America’s security commitment.24 An empirical study on the link between forward-deployed nuclear weapons and nonproliferation found that forward-deployed nuclear weapons have a perfect track record in preventing nuclear proliferation. Never has a country with U.S. nuclear weapons on its soil developed independent nuclear capabilities.25 To be sure, U.S. attempts at nonproliferation have occasionally failed. In the early stages of the Cold War, U.S. allies Britain and France chose to build independent nuclear arsenals, despite Washington’s preferences to the contrary. Still, the small number of nuclear-armed states today is a fantastic achievement relative to pessimistic proliferation expectations of the mid-twentieth century. And it is very likely that there would be many more nuclear powers in the world today without U.S. efforts at extended deterrence and assurance. U.S. nuclear security guarantees remain critical in the current security environment to stop the spread of nuclear weapons. With newfound questions about America’s commitment to the security of its allies, there are renewed discussions in Berlin about whether Germany should consider building its own nuclear weapons.26 A majority of the public in South Korea support Seoul going nuclear under uncertain conditions.27 And analysts predict that a weakening of the U.S. nuclear umbrella could lead to proliferation among U.S. allies, including Japan, Poland, and perhaps other states.28 In contrast, other nuclear-armed powers have played a less central role in preventing the spread of nuclear weapons. Indeed, these revisionist and autocratic states have occasionally gone so far as to use their nuclear capabilities to intentionally export the bomb to other states, fueling the spread of nuclear weapons.29 For example, the Soviet Union aided China in developing a nuclear program from 1958 to 1960 to increase the power of the communist bloc relative to the United States. Russia considered exporting a uranium enrichment plant to Iran in 1995 before Washington intervened and pressured them to cancel the transaction. China aided Pakistan due to mutual rivalry with India. Beijing also transferred sensitive nuclear technology to Iran, Algeria, and other countries as well. While Pakistani scientist Abdul Qadeer Khan created a proliferation network which enabled North Korea, Iran, and Libya to acquire sensitive nuclear technology as part of constructing an alliance of “strategic defiance” against the United States and its allies.30 In recent years, Pyongyang has become a nuclear exporter, helping Syria to build a heavy-water reactor before it was destroyed in an Israeli air strike in 2007. All of these countries remain at risk of exporting sensitive nuclear technology in the future, intentionally fueling proliferation in a bid to advance their revisionist aims. Some have argued that by possessing a robust nuclear arsenal, the United States instigates the spread of nuclear weapons to additional countries, but this is incorrect. They aver that the continued maintenance of an American nuclear arsenal sets a dangerous precedent, undermines the NPT, and encourages other countries to build nuclear weapons. These arguments are plausible at a superficial level, but closer investigation reveals that they are unfounded.31 States build nuclear weapons for a wide range of security, economic, and normative reasons, but aping the behavior of the United States is not among them. Moreover, there is no correlation between the size of the U.S. nuclear arsenal and the probability that other states explore, pursue, or acquire nuclear weapons.32 In sum, U.S. nuclear weapons also contribute to the security of the rules-based system by reinforcing the nonproliferation regime and preventing the spread of nuclear weapons. The imperative of U.S. nuclear modernization United States’ nuclear weapons have provided for international security and stability for the past three-quarters of a century, but, if they are to continue to play that role in the future, then they must be modernized. The U.S. strategic nuclear forces consist of a triad of delivery vehicles: 1) submarine-launched ballistic missiles (SLBMs) deployed on ballistic missile submarines (SSBNs); 2) intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs); and 3) strategic bombers (including the B-2 and B-52) carrying gravity bombs and airlaunched cruise missiles (ALCMs). These capabilities are aging, however, and must be updated. The OHIO-class SSBNs entered service in the 1980s and 1990s and were originally designed for a 30-year service life. Their service life has already been drawn out to 42 years and further extension is impossible.33 There are only so many times a submarine can withstand the intense pressures of submerging and resurfacing, and relying on these old boats puts the life of the crew at risk. For the land-based leg, the Minuteman III ICBMs were first deployed in 1970, and they were meant to have a 10-year service life. This service life has been extended multiple times, but the United States cannot continue to rely on this capability beyond 2030.34 Turning to the air leg of the triad, U.S. ALCMs are now 25 years past their expected design life.35 The United States also needs to ensure that its stealth bombers can continue to penetrate current and future enemy air defense systems. Beyond the delivery systems, the underlying nuclear command, control, and communications (NC3) system is also three decades old and is vulnerable to new space and cyber threats.36 Lastly, the warheads themselves are aging, as many were built in 1976, 1978, 1980, and 1988. These warheads require life extension programs for continued survival.37 In sum, U.S. nuclear weapons were built at the end of the Cold War in the 1970s and 1980s. If you drive a car, it is likely that it was not built in the 1970s or 1980s. And, if it was, then it is not likely very reliable. As long as the United States possesses a nuclear deterrent, it must ensure that it is safe, effective, and reliable. This can only be achieved with modernized capabilities.38 In 2010, then-U.S. President Barack Obama laid out a plan to modernize America’s aging nuclear arsenal over the next thirty years. He called for modernizing each leg of the nuclear triad. In 2031, the new Columbia-class SSBN will begin to replace the Ohio fleet, while the Department of Defense will research a potential replacement to the D5 SLBM.39 The Department of Defense has also launched the Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent (GBSD) program to modernize 450 ICBM launch facilities and field 400 new ICBMs to replace the Minuteman III, beginning in 2029.40 Meanwhile, in order to improve the survivability of the air-based leg in the face of sophisticated enemy air defenses, the U.S. will replace the B-2A with the new B-21 Raider stealth bomber in the mid-2020s. It is also replacing the ALCM with the long-range standoff (LRSO) weapon, and it is modernizing the B61 gravity bomb.41 Simultaneously, the Department of Defense is planning NC3 advancements for improved command and control, as well as coordination with the Department of Energy to extend the service life of the warheads.42 President Trump decided to continue with Obama’s modernization plans in his Nuclear Posture Review, released in 2018.43 In addition, the Trump administration called for capability “supplements” to deal with the threat of Russian nuclear “de-escalation” strikes.44 These low-yield nuclear weapons include installing a low-yield warhead on a small number of SLBMs and the resurrection of a nuclear sea-launched cruise missile. These modernization plans have strong bipartisan support with senior defense officials on both sides of the aisle attesting to the need for these capabilities.45 Nevertheless, some analysts have questioned the desirability and feasibility of U.S. nuclear modernization.46 Some have argued that U.S. nuclear modernization is too expensive. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that the cost of nuclear modernization over the next thirty years will come to over $1 trillion. Critics argue that this is unaffordable and this money could be better spent on other priorities. While $1 trillion is certainly a large number, to put it in perspective, it comes to roughly 5–7% of the U.S. defense budget. Is 5% too much to spend on nuclear weapons? Several recent U.S. secretaries of defense have claimed that nuclear deterrence is the most important mission of the U.S. Department of Defense. So, put another way, is 5% too much to spend on the organization’s highest priority mission? Reasonable people can disagree, but to many this seems to be a good value. Indeed, nuclear weapons have traditionally been prized because they are more economical than conventional weapons.47 As Obama’s Secretary of Defense Ash Carter pithily put it, “nuclear weapons don’t actually cost that much.”48 Other critics of U.S. modernization plans charge that building a new generation of nuclear weapons will fuel an arms race with Russia and China.49 But this is incorrect. Russia and China are already modernizing their forces, and this is occurring irrespective of decisions made in Washington. Indeed, Russia is finishing a modernization cycle and is building new, exotic nuclear weapons, such as a nuclear submarine drone, that have never been contemplated in Washington. When Secretary Carter was asked if U.S. nuclear modernization was stimulating an arms race, he replied, “we know they aren’t having that effect, because the evidence is to the contrary.”50 Moreover, U.S. modernization may actually dissuade arms races, as potential rivals realize they have little hope of achieving nuclear parity with or superiority over the technologically-sophisticated United States. Finally, some claim that U.S. nuclear modernization plans are inconsistent with its commitments under the NPT to work toward eventual nuclear disarmament. According to this argument, U.S. modernization will cause nuclear proliferation, but this is also incorrect.51 President Obama took good faith steps toward reducing reliance on nuclear weapons, but, as he did so, Russia, China, and North Korea went in the opposite direction, expanding and modernizing their arsenals. Disarmament advocates often harangue Washington, London, and Paris because they know these democracies will listen to their complaints, but they are barking up the wrong tree. If they want to make progress on disarmament, the real obstacle is Moscow, Beijing, and Pyongyang. If other nations up nuclear weapons, Washington would almost certainly join them. So long as these other nations have nuclear weapons, however, the United States needs to possess a robust nuclear deterrent. Moreover, as argued above, doing so reinforces global nonproliferation, by giving U.S. allies the incentive to forego independent nuclear arsenals. Meanwhile, the United States continues to make progress toward nuclear disarmament in other ways with new initiatives to “create the conditions” for future disarmament.52 In sum, U.S. nuclear modernization is necessary for the continued effectiveness of the U.S. nuclear deterrent. Moreover, such measures are affordable and consistent with America’s longstanding disarmament goals. The threat posed by Russian, Chinese, and North Korean nuclear modernization Not all modernization programs are created equal. The effect of a state’s nuclear modernization on international security depends upon that state’s objectives and strategy, in accordance with its broader geopolitical disposition. Russia, China, and North Korea are revisionist states dissatisfied with the prevailing status quo. Their broader strategies seek to disrupt or displace the U.S.-led order, and thus their defense capabilities, including nuclear weapons, are oriented toward these destabilizing objectives. Nuclear modernization programs in Moscow, Beijing, and Pyongyang, therefore, tend to undermine international security and stability. Russia Russia seeks to disrupt the rules-based international order.53 Under President Putin, Russia has sought to reassert itself as a global great power and to ensure that any major international security issue cannot be decided without Russia at the table. In addition, it seeks to carve out a sphere of influence in Eastern Europe at the expense of the security and sovereignty of its neighbors. It views the spread of the U.S. alliance system and of democratic forms of government as a fundamental threat to the existence of its regime.54 Consequently, it seeks to exploit Western vulnerabilities in order to divide democratic nations within themselves and against each other. To achieve these objectives, Russia employs a “hybrid” or “new-generation warfare” military strategy that combines activities across the full spectrum of conflict, from information operations at the low end to nuclear coercion at the high end.55 The nuclear component of this broader grand strategy is designed to deter NATO from intervening in Russia’s sphere of influence, to coerce neighboring states, and to divide NATO allies against each other.56 In recent years, Russia has increased reliance on nuclear weapons in its strategy.57 Russian leaders have made explicit nuclear threats and have postured and exercised nuclear forces in ways we have not seen since the Cold War. During the Russian invasion of Ukraine, for example, Russian President Vladimir Putin said that “Russia is one of the leading nuclear powers,” and that “it is best not to mess with us.”58 He also put nuclear weapons on alert and moved them into Kaliningrad and Crimea. The message was clear: if the West interferes with Russia’s attempts to use force against its neighbors, the result could be nuclear catastrophe. The most dangerous component of Russian nuclear strategy is the so-called “escalate-to-de-escalate” doctrine.59 This is simply the idea, widely acknowledged by Russian experts, that Russia will rely on nuclear weapons, including limited nuclear strikes, to offset the conventional superiority of the United States and NATO. This strategy sounds reasonable enough if it were only a defensive strategy to defend the Russian homeland from invasion. The concern is that, like in Ukraine, it will be used as a nuclear backstop to bolster future conventional aggression. Russia could invade a NATO member and then use threats of early nuclear escalation to deter a unified NATO response. Short of invasion, it can continue to use the threat for quotidian nuclear coercion of NATO members over foreign policy decisions of which it disapproves, such as regional states hosting NATO military capabilities. To support this strategy, Russia is modernizing its nuclear arsenal. It is currently finishing a modernization cycle of its strategic nuclear forces. The Kremlin is building a new generation of non-strategic nuclear weapons, expanding its asymmetric advantages over NATO in this space, and giving credibility to its “escalate-to-de-escalate” approach.60 Finally, it is developing exotic nuclear weapons, including nuclear-armed hypersonic glide vehicles, nuclear-powered nuclear cruise missiles, and nuclear-armed submarine drones.61 The latter is designed as a system of pure terror to hold at risk Western port cities with the threat of a stealthy, large-yield, and highly radioactive strategic attack. These weapons contribute to Russia’s strategic goals of weakening and terrorizing the free world and, as such, they undermine global security and stability. China While Russia is the more dangerous near-term threat, China is the greater threat to the global order over the long term. Russia can only disrupt the rules-based order, but China may seek to displace it. China endeavors to gradually replace the United States as the global hegemon by 2049.62 The effort begins regionally in Asia where Beijing seeks to expel the United States as a regional power and establish itself as the region’s hegemon. Globally, China is expanding its political and economic influence in every region of the world through its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and Made in China 2025 plans.63 Its state-led capitalist approach seeks to prey on the rules-based economic order at the expense of open market democracies. It is also consciously or unconsciously exporting this state-led capitalist model and seeking to make the world safe for autocracy. Therefore, the rise of China is a profound threat to the rules-based order. China supports this strategy with an ambitious military modernization program. In East Asia, its anti-access/area denial (A2/AD) approach seeks to undermine U.S. power projection capabilities and enable China to pursue territorial claims in the East and South China Seas, while providing coercive leverage vis-à-vis other regional actors.64 In recent years, the balance of power in Asia has shifted and many question the ability of the United States to defend longstanding allies.65 China is also expanding its global military footprint with overseas bases and military exercises in other world regions. China is also building nuclear forces designed to contribute to these revisionist aims. While China claims to desire only a “lean and effective” deterrent, it has gradually expanded and modernized its forces in recent years.66 Beijing is clearly attempting to develop a greater ability to hold the U.S. homeland at risk, to increase U.S. vulnerability to a large-scale nuclear exchange, and to deter U.S. military action, including in defense of its allies. In the past decade alone, the number of Chinese strategic nuclear weapons that could reach the continental United States has more than doubled. And U.S. intelligence has recently estimated publicly that China’s nuclear arsenal will at least double again in the coming decade.67 In addition to its strategic forces, China possesses a large stockpile of medium- and intermediate-range missiles that are capable of delivering nuclear weapons.68 These capabilities contribute to China’s A2/AD strategy and could be used to blunt U.S. and allied military forces in their attempts to defend against possible Chinese aggression. While China espouses a formal nuclear No First Use Policy, Chinese experts acknowledge that there is a narrow range of contingencies, such as a major war with the United States in East Asia, in which China might very well use nuclear weapons first. In the future, China may leverage its substantial resources to sprint to nuclear parity, potentially igniting an arms race with the United States and undermining U.S. extended deterrence and assurance in Asia. North Korea Relative to the Russian and Chinese great powers above, the rogue North Korean regime is not as threatening to the very fabric of the current international order. Still, North Korea’s nuclear program is a challenge to the rules-based order. Pyongyang has flagrantly violated the nonproliferation regime and its weapons threaten the security of the free world. Scholars debate North Korean goals. Some argue that North Korea only wants to defend its brutal totalitarian regime from external intervention; others maintain that Pyongyang is pursing the more aggressive and revisionist goal of eventually reuniting the Korean peninsula under its own rule.69 Regardless, North Korean behavior threatens almost every aspect of the rules-based order. It has repeatedly engaged in armed aggression against its neighbors from initiating the Korean War in the 1950s to sinking a South Korean warship in the 2010s. It cheats on global economic rules engaging in currency counterfeiting and black market smuggling activities. It also conducts massive human rights abuses at home. North Korea’s military strategy seeks to retain the capability to deter external invasion and, if necessary, to fight a full-scale war on the Korean Peninsula. North Korean nuclear capabilities contribute to these goals. It is publicly estimated that North Korea has the ability to deliver close-range, short-range, and medium-range missiles to U.S. allies and bases in Asia, while possessing enough fissile material to build between 30 and 60 nuclear warheads.70 In addition, it is on the verge of developing an ICBM capability to hold the U.S. homeland at risk with the threat of nuclear war.71 While some hope that the international community may be able to negotiate the denuclearization of North Korea, it seems more likely that North Korea will remain a nuclear power for the foreseeable future. If North Korea’s nuclear modernization continues, it will possess a more reliable means of threatening nuclear war against the United States and its allies at the core of the rules-based order. North Korean nuclear weapons may also act as a shield to external intervention, deterring the United States and incentivizing Pyongyang’s aggression against South Korea or Japan. North Korea’s nuclear weapons may also weaken U.S. extended nuclear deterrence and assurance, possibly persuading Tokyo and Seoul to reconsider their nuclear options. More broadly, North Korean possession of nuclear weapons undermines the NPT. North Korea may decide to once again export dangerous nuclear or missile technology. Pyongyang’s nuclear possession may create a dangerous precedent as other nonnuclear nations hope to follow the same path of cheating on the NPT, building nuclear weapons, and ultimately being welcomed as de facto members of the nuclear club. In sum, Russia, China, and North Korea are autocratic, revisionist challengers to the rules-based international order. As such, their nuclear programs threaten core pillars of the system of global stability and security that has reigned for the past several decades. In short, Russian, Chinese, and North Korean nuclear modernization programs undermine global stability and security.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Inequality*** › Inequality impact – Secular stagnation

Secular stagnation causes extinction.

Oppenheimer 21

(Michael Oppenheimer- Clinical Professor in Center for Global Affairs @ New York University; Palgrave MacMillian, “The Turbulent Future of International Relations,” in The Future of Global Affairs: Managing Discontinuity, Disruption and Destruction, Ch. 2.

Four structural forces will shape the future of International Relations: globalization (but without liberal rules, institutions, and leadership)1; multipolarity (the end of American hegemony and wider distribution of power among states and non-states2); the strengthening of distinctive, national and subnational identities, as persistent cultural differences are accentuated by the disruptive effects of Western style globalization (what Samuel Huntington called the “non-westernization of IR”3); and secular economic stagnation, a product of longer term global decline in birth rates combined with aging populations.4 These structural forces do not determine everything. Environmental events, global health challenges, internal political developments, policy mistakes, technology breakthroughs or failures, will intersect with structure to define our future. But these four structural forces will impact the way states behave, in the capacity of great powers to manage their differences, and to act collectively to settle, rather than exploit, the inevitable shocks of the next decade.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Inequality*** › Inequality impact – Secular stagnation

Mass inequality locks in secular stagnation

Banerjee and Bivens ‘22

(Asha Banerjee and Josh Bivens. Asha was a policy analyst at the Center for Law and Social Policy and is now an economic analyst at the EPI; Master of Philosophy (MPhil), Economic and Social History, University of Oxford. Josh has a Ph.D., Economics, economic author, and director of research at EPI. Economic Policy Institute. Will secular stagnation return? The stakes for current economic debates and fiscal policy. . August 4, 2022. Accessed 01/06/2023. AR)

Drawing on a recent paper by Banerjee and Bivens (2022), this policy memo makes the following points:

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Disability

Disabled people benefit more from UBI compared to other welfare systems

Duffy, Elder-Woodward, Centre for Welfare Reform, Scottish Independent Living Coalition, 2019 [Simon, Jim, January 1 2019, Social Alternatives, “Basic Income Plus: Is UBI consistent with the goals of the Independent Living Movement?,” https://individualisedliving.com.au/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2020/12/basic-income-and-independent-living.pdf, June 26 2023, JC]

The most obvious benefit of UBI for disabled people is that it reduces poverty and is also associated with a wide range of wider benefits including: better mental and physical health, reduced domestic violence, increased IQ and better educational outcomes (Standing 2017; Torry 2015). All disabled people would benefit from these changes, but given that they are more likely to be in poverty than other groups, then they would tend to benefit more than most from these improvements (Elwan 1999).

The second benefit of UBI for disabled people is that it would eliminate a chronic insecurity built into most welfare systems. For instance, many systems of income security, like the Employment Support Allowance (ESA) in the UK, are organised so that the whole of your income is dependent on proving the negative impact of your impairment on your ability to work. This assessment process is inherently negative and stressful (Saffer et al. 2018). But this stress is made even worse by the fact that if you feel you have been wrongly assessed and you try to challenge their assessment then you will not be put onto a lower benefit. Instead you will be treated as if you are entitled to nothing until your challenge reaches the tribunal. There is also an in-built delay, often of several months, while the benefit agency ‘reconsiders’ your claim before a case can go to tribunal. To receive any income you must borrow from friends and relatives during the wait, or beg for food from the growing number of charitable ‘foodbanks’ (Garthwaite 2016).

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Racism

Universal Plus Basic Income- Including an additional amount for black Americans in UBI addresses and makes progress against historical racial disadvantages

Warren, Roosevelt Institute Fellow, 17

(Dorian T. Warren, Fellow at the Roosevelt Institute and Board Chair of the Center for Community Change, “Reparations and Basic Income”, https://www.bostonreview.net/forum_response/dorian-t-warren-reparations-and-basic-income/)

Second, even an equal income could disproportionately benefit black Americans. White Americans earn more overall, so a greater percentage of their basic income would be taxed back. More importantly today’s wealthiest Americans benefit either directly from African Americans’ disadvantaged position in our political economy, or indirectly as a result of the cumulative benefits to our nation from centuries of exploiting black bodies. Black Americans either helped build the co-owned wealth of our nation (our infrastructure and banking, legal, and patent systems) or were denied access to our share of it (land, sky, and other natural resources). Even if African Americans receive an income equal to whites, tapping wealth hoarded by racist means and distributing it universally effectively amounts to targeted redistribution.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Racism

Racism is the root cause of war – they can’t win a unique DA

Ghiglieri 99 (Michael Patrick, Biological Anthropoligst and Former Combat Soldier—PhD in Biology from UC-Davis, The Dark Side of Man, p. 212-221)

Most colonial powers practiced genocide to some degree. The extremes were Britain’s complete annihilation of the Tasmanians, Spain’s complete annihilation of the Arawak Indians across the Caribbean, and the near extermination by the Dutch of the !Kung San Bushmen in South Africa (see Chapter 6). Amazingly, into the 1950s, there still existed bounty hunters in northern Australia whose job it was to shoot Aborigines. But it was America that amassed a history of xenophobia and genocide that impressed even Adolf Hitler. Estimates vary greatly, but between 5 million and 40 million Indians lived in North America before 1492. If 40 million, 150 years later nearly 90 percent of those Native Americans were gone, mostly due to diseases brought by the white invaders. After 1650, white Americans resorted to more aggressive genocide. Aside from the dozens of major anti-Indian wars sponsored by the U.S. government (remember General Phil Sheridan’s “The only good Indian I ever saw was dead”?), American citizens in general, especially males, often went out of their way to slaughter Indians. Innocent Indians. Indian women and children asleep at night in their tipis. Even Indians under flags of truce. Sociologist David T. Courtwright explains: The weapons and tactics employed against Indians bespeak Anglo-Americans’ indiscriminate hatred and contempt: poisoned meat and drink, smallpox-infected blankets, booby-trapped bodies, cannon charged with slugs, dogs unleashed on captives, and the execution of the wounded, women, and children. California Indians found “naked or wild” were gunned down without pretense or hesitation while Indian women with children were dispatched with no more compunction than stray dogs. Some white men in California, wrote a disgusted French missionary, Father Edmond Venisse, “kill Indians just to try their pistols.” In South America, the same thing happened between Portuguese colonists and indigenous people. One estimate holds that 11 million Indians lived in what is now Brazil (which encompasses ore land that America’s lower forty-eight states) in the year 1500. Today only about 300,000 survive. As Portuguese colonists arrived, millions of Indians died due to war, slavery, starvation, and disease. North American xenophobia has not been restricted just to hating the original owners of the continent. Whites in America have been lethally prejudiced against other races as well. (Today in U.S. prisons, black, Hispanics, and whites still instantly self-segregate, organize, and begin vying for control of whatever they can control.) Racism is rampant. Courtwright describes, for example, atrocities that whites committed against the Chinese during California’s gold rush: As with the Indians, to whom whites often compared the Chinese, the way such killings were carried out revealed a deep, almost feral hatred. Chinese men were scalped, mutilated, burned, branded, decapitated, dismembered, and hanged from gutter spouts. One Chinese miner’s penis and testicles were cut off and then toasted in a nearby saloon as a “trophy of the hunt.” <Card Continues> To me, The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich is the most chilling book of all time because it reveals, step by step, how one twisted xenophobic male dictator galvanized totalitarian support within a nation whose citizens obeyed him based on his ethnocentric rhetoric of racist destiny. Shirer’s book clearly reveals that Hitler’s sole purpose was to conquer by territorial war and transform through genocide a huge region of the world into an enslaved reproductive machine for the gene pool of his master race. And if not for a few fatal mistakes, he would have pulled this off. Hitler epitomized the biological logic of ethnocentrism run amok. But Nazi Germany also teaches us that when governments decide that the rights of the state exceed those of the individual, this is the result. Hitler’s genocide will happen again. As mentioned above, it already has. As Carl von Clausewitz noted (see page 211), racist hate fuels nearly all international wars. The knight in shining armor who (to “rescue” France, England, and Russia) slayed the twin dragons of World War II, Japan and Germany, was the United States. During the war, 12 percent of all Americans donned uniforms, at a cost of 39.1 percent of the U.S. gross national product. There is no question that the United States was committed, but how pure was this knight? In War Without Mercy, historian John W. Dower documents the blatant, deliberately racist attitudes of both the Japanese and Americans during World War II that shaped genocidal military and political policies. The Japanese, Dower notes, believed that they were the world’s leading race (Shido minzoku), based on “filial piety and loyalty as expressed under the influence of the divinely descended Japanese imperial line” and on their racial “purity.” They held all other races, Asians and Westerners alike, as so inferior and barbaric that they forbade interbreeding with them. “Intermarriage,” they insisted, “would destroy the psychic solidarity of the Yamato race.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Poverty extensions

UBI solves employee abuse and exploitation

Matt Bruenig, researcher on poverty and welfare systems at the thinktank Demos, September 30, 2015, “Tired of capitalism? There could be a better way.” The Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/in-theory/wp/2015/09/30/tired-of-capitalism-lets-try-basicincome/?tid=a_inl&utm_term=.99f30faa44e0 (accessed 7/17/17)

Labor protection in the form of safety laws, collective bargaining and prohibitions against harassment and discrimination have helped cut down on many of the worst employer abuses. But no amount of labor regulation can ever undo the fact that workers are confronted daily with the choice between obeying a supervisor or losing all their income. The only way to break the coercion at the core of the employment relationship is to give people the genuine ability to say no to their employers. And the only way to make that feasible is to guarantee that working-age adults, at least, have some way to support themselves whether they work or not. Even as capitalism makes some workers’ lives miserable, those who can’t work are in even worse shape. Even after counting some or all public welfare benefits, the U.S. poverty rate in 2013 was anywhere from 15 percent to 18 percent. Most of this poverty is endured by vulnerable populations that markets discard as useless. According to my own calculations of the 2014 Annual Social and Economic Supplement, more than 80 percent of the officially poor are either children, elderly, disabled, students, caretakers or the involuntarily unemployed. Because they cannot work or they have a diminished ability to work, these groups often receive little to no direct income from the market and suffer a high risk of poverty as a result. The United States’ relatively small welfare state kept 39 million people out of poverty in 2013, cut the overall poverty rate by 38 percent since 1967 and radically reduced the poverty rate of the elderly by as much as 72 percent since 1960. Globally, the countries with the highest levels of welfare spending — Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden — are also those that have the lowest levels of economic hardship. But even in these countries, poverty is not zero percent and small numbers of people still register an occasional inability to acquire basic needs such as food and housing. Supplementing the existing welfare state with a basic income would, if successful, ensure that nobody falls completely through the cracks of the social welfare system and thereby finds himself or herself destitute.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Mental health

Global North UBI pilots have shown improvements in participants’ mental and physical health and decreased incidents of gender-based violence.

Harris, Oxford Brookes University 23’

Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562

In the Global North, three large pilots stand out: in Canada (Bennett, 2017), in the Netherlands (Groot and Verlaat, 2016) and in Finland (Kela, 2016). While these have produced important results, each falls short of the ‘ideal-typical’ UBI model discussed above. Typically, such projects are only focussed on low earners (this was the case in all three). As detailed above, ‘true’ UBI would be universal, meaning that all adult residents would be eligible, regardless of their level of income. Also, these pilots are limited by the timescale of the project. This is methodologically problematic, it is challenging to abstract meaningful conclusions about how someone would behave if they had access to a UBI for life, on the basis of how they live in the knowledge that they have UBI for just three years, for example. However, that said, supporters of UBI herald these experiments as a success, noting improvements in the participants mental and physical health and decreased incidents of gender-based violence (Bregman, 2018: 37)

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Mental health

UBI proven Good for mental health

Drexel University, 21

[February 21, Drexel University Center for Hunger-Free Communities, “Universal Basic Income: Key to Reducing Food Insecurity and Improving Health, , 6/25/2023, EJ]

UBI pilots show improved outcomes in health and quality of life in several social determinants of health, including better educational outcomes, fewer instances of psychological distress, and improved child health outcomes.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Human rights

Universal Basic Income is key to upholding human rights

Daniel Raventós, lecturer in Economics at the University of Barcelona, and Julie Wark, advisory board member of the international political review Sin Permiso, January 8, 2016, “Basic Income, Basic Issues,” Counter Punch,

Of all the political mechanisms that have been debated in recent years, the most rational and perhaps the only one that would seem capable of providing a sound foundation for universal human rights is basic income. In its different theoretical forms and experiments today it is usually presented instrumentally. For example, the right sees it as a way of dismantling state institutions, and the left as a policy for tackling poverty or robotisation of the workforce. If considered normatively it is much more than that. It is a guarantee of the three great human rights principles, as classical democratic republicanism taught long ago. People can’t be free unless their material existence is guaranteed socially and politically. Indeed, both democratic and oligarchic republicanism shared this conception of freedom. The difference was: whose freedom? For oligarchic republicanism it was confined to adult male property owners, while democratic republicanism championed freedom for every member of the community. All arbitrary interference infringes on individual freedom but some forms are normatively more relevant than others in social policy because they are intimately linked with the basic mechanisms governing the dynamics of human societies. Swindling and lying, for example, affect the lives of individuals and can be used to support the economic status quo but society is not structured by falsehood. It is founded on property (which may then rely on a whole zoo of porkies, red herrings, cock and bull to shore it up). Enter the rich and the poor. Not in the statistical sense (which has its own illustrative merit) but the Aristotelian sense of materially independent people and the rest. The inequalities which limit or deny the freedom of some members of society are the result of several factors, most notably political economy. Any political economy favours some sectors and handicaps others. In the present-day world most of the population can easily be dispossessed by policies like “austerity” and, to quote Jeremy Corbyn, “Austerity is a political choice not an economic necessity.” In that case we can be sure that the choosers won’t be the losers. Since so many lose, a universal counter-measure would seem to be needed and a basic income would be an important component – but only a component – of a political economy and political system that would make the “choice” of tackling social problems. And “social” problems are much broader than people tend to think. Naomi Klein is very clear about the environmental connection as well: “That’s why I talk about basic income as well, that there has to be a stronger social safety net because when people don’t have options, they’re going to make bad choices.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Homelessness extensions

UBI helps homeless people not only get more dignity but climb out of their low status—human experience shows

Konish , reporter for CNBC, 21’

[Lorie, 8-21-2021, CNBC, “How one universal basic income experiment is helping the homeless get off the streets,” https://www.cnbc.com/2021/08/21/how-one-universal-basic-income-experiment-is-helping-the-homeless.html, 6/26,DG]

During the Covid-19 pandemic, Miracle Messages expanded its programs to take its help even further. It started matching unhoused individuals with members of the community to help build relationships. Then, it raised money to pilot a universal basic income project for the homeless. Universal basic income has become a buzz term, especially during the Covid-19 pandemic. Former Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang made the concept popular when he pledged to give Americans $1,000 per month with no strings attached. Now, UBI experiments are popping up in cities across the U.S. Moreover, federal programs tied to Covid-19 like stimulus checks and monthly child tax credit payments have been compared to guaranteed income. This new program, dubbed Miracle Money, is the first of its kind to target the homeless in the U.S. One program in Vancouver, Canada, called the New Leaf Project has also tested the concept. Miracle Money began fundraising in December 2020, and ultimately raised around $50,000 through individual donors. Then, in February, the program began distributing payments of $500 per month to 14 unhoused individuals in the local area. The participants were selected from nominations within the community. A temporary sanctioned tent encampment for the homeless across from the City Hall in San Francisco on May 28, 2020. The program was designed so that the $500 monthly income would not interfere with other government benefits the participants may receive. All of the participants had to set up bank accounts in order to receive the money. They also were paired with a “buddy” from the community, with whom they would keep in touch. Financial coaches were also available upon request to help them navigate their new resources. Notably, there were no requirements as to how they used the money. The initial results of that pilot were “astonishing,” Adler said, with more than 35% of the participants able to use that monthly income to secure permanent housing. “I wasn’t anticipating anyone getting housed. That was not even a thing we were measuring at first,” Adler said. One of those participants who was able to turn his living circumstances — and life — around is Ray, 49. (Ray requested his last name be withheld for privacy reasons). His connection with the program began when someone knocked on the door of the temporary housing where he was staying. The question they asked was simple, he said: “Do you want to have a friend to talk to every now and then?” Ray, left, and Jennifer Roy were paired together as part of the Miracle Friends program. Today, Ray calls it a "lifesaving experience." After saying yes, Ray was connected to Jennifer Roy, a Marin County resident and Miracle Friend volunteer who developed a friendship with him and ultimately nominated him to participate in the UBI pilot. Ray became homeless after he suffered heart failure, which he blames partly on overwork due to the stress and travel his sales job required. Participating in the program was a “lifesaving experience,” he said. He was able to fully reconnect with his 18-year-old daughter after regaining the sense that he could help provide for her. “Miracle Friends gave me the one thing that I really didn’t have being unhoused and that was the confidence that I could be part of somebody’s life,” he said. One thing we should be doing is trusting the ingenuity and resourcefulness of some of the individuals who are experiencing homelessness. Ray also found work, first at a Covid-19 testing site, and then at a vaccination center as the pandemic wore on. “Just to get up every morning and have a purpose was amazing,” he said. Today, after watching his daughter graduate from high school and prepare to move away to college, he has made a move of his own. Ray has relocated to Kansas and paid for the first six months of rent in an apartment he shares with a friend. Having money set aside has also given him the opportunity to focus on his health. But the social support he gained the program through the relationship with Roy and others was even more valuable, he said. “Being unhoused, one thing that’s easy to do is go on with life by yourself and not pay any mind to anyone, or not even reach out to people when you really need to, you’re accustomed to being alone,” Ray said. “It wasn’t a roof over my head — I needed to not feel homeless anymore.” “Ray has realized I can’t do this alone,” Roy said. “I don’t want to do this alone. It’s really about community.” While Ray has received more help than he ever anticipated, she said, he’s also realized how much he has to give back as a result of those relationships he has formed. Both say they anticipate being lifelong friends, despite the geographic distance between them. In addition to securing housing, program participants have found success in other ways, such as by acquiring service dogs or buying appliances they need.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Homelessness extensions

Universal Basic Income succeeds in underprivileged countries – Public financial support is proved to work better in this sector

Battistoni, Magazine Editor, 17

(Alyssa Battistoni, PhD candidate in political science at Yale University and an editor at Jacobin magazine, “The False Promise of Universal Basic Income” https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/false-promise-universal-basic-income-andy-stern-ruger-bregman-grh)

Ongoing expropriation and proletarianization have left billions worldwide in a condition of what historian Michael Denning calls “wageless life,” rendered surplus to capital’s needs and struggling to scrape by in a system that starts “not with the offer of work, but with the imperative to earn a living.” And so while basic income sounds like a program for rich countries—a luxury made possible by a certain level of prosperity—it may be even more promising in places where it seems most unaffordable. In recent years UBI pilot programs have rolled out in Namibia, Kenya, and Uganda, mostly funded by NGOs; more generally, cash transfer programs, which aim to diminish poverty by giving poor people money—though often with specific criteria or restrictions—are the latest fad in development. Elsewhere, public support provides more in the way of livelihoods than do private wages: the anthropologist James Ferguson notes that more South Africans receive income from government welfare programs, whether child allowances or disability aid, than from waged labor. Basic income, Ferguson argues, may be the way to achieve social welfare in countries where the prospect of job creation on a scale adequate to the population is little more than a fantasy.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Happiness

Happiness is a d-rule

Lee Archie and John G. Archie, 2003, Chapter 10, Introduction to Ethical Studies: An Open Source Reader, https://philosophy.lander.edu/ethics/ethicsbook.pdf

It is right then for a man to consider the things which produce happiness, since, if happiness is present, we have everything, and when it is absent, we do everything with a view to possess it. Now, what I have constantly recommended to you, these things I would have you do and practice, considering them to be the elements of living well.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Happiness

UBI solves happiness

Sofia Tereshchenko, politologist and journalist, ‘23, March 2, “THE GLOBAL IMPORTANCE OF UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME (UBI) MANIFESTATION,” date accessed: 6-22-2023 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4368245#:~:text=The%20importance%20of%20UBI%20lies,greater%20social%20and%20economic%20stability.

The world is in danger of a global crisis that will cause the decline of wealth, and lead to a significant decrease of well-being and happiness. The solution features a new “monarchy” or government. This system includes: a system of multiple governing levels, the goal of emancipating the individual, the use of technology to create a world without work.

The world economy is one example that has experienced the negative effects of globalization and income inequality. The current model for economic wealth distribution does not seem sustainable as it does not provide for the needs of all people. The solution for this is to create a system with an equal distribution of power and resources, and in which individuals are emancipated from work such that they can be provided through technology.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Exploitation extension

UBI gives workers power – pressures employers away from exploitative practices

Sculos, PoliSci Professor @ Florida International University, 18

[Bryant W. Sculos, 2018, Creative Commons, “Socialism and Universal Basic Income,” , 6/27/2023, EJ]

Second, it is simply not true that UBI is irrelevant to workers and the workplace—again provided we are discussing a thick version of UBI. There are two key reasons why UBI would help workers in the workplace. First, if workers did not rely entirely on their wage for their subsistence, they would likely be able to take more aggressive positions in collective bargaining (Andy Stern, former president of the SEIU, has referred to UBI as a “national strike fund”). 4 A subsistence UBI would decrease the opportunity-costs of hardline negotiating for higher wages, better benefits, fewer hours, and better working conditions. Workers, in such a position, could also demand greater democratic rights within the workplace. This is not to suggest that wages would cease to be a site of contention. On the contrary, by providing a stronger foundation from which to negotiate wages and benefits, there would be an opportunity for an increase in labor struggles. The second way that UBI would aid workers in the workplace is more speculative. If a subsistence UBI were to be achieved, there is almost no way of imagining this taking place without massive organized support from workers. It would need to be collective demand that itself would require organizing and mobilizing workers, alongside the unemployed and homeless, and even stay-at-home moms and dads. The kind of social solidarity that such a radical policy position like a subsistence-level UBI would require would undoubtedly have important consequences for the organization of the workplace.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Structural Violence Advantage**** › Dignity extensions

UBI affirms undocumented citizens even if it doesn’t solve

Simon Szreter, Professor of History and Public Policy at Cambridge University, ’22, July 11, “How Seriously Should we Take Universal Basic Income?” https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1467-923X.13169

To be fair, until the beginning of the 1980s, advocates of a guaranteed income for all were heirs to over half a century of contracting inequality, at least within most Western liberal advanced nations. This was, of course, in conformity with the Kuznets curve prediction first announced in 1955, and at the time considered by many (although not Kuznets himself) to have the status of an absolute law.6 This meant that a new, radical policy to promote human rights by abolishing absolute poverty everywhere as quickly as possible—'basic needs’ as it was termed in international development discourse—could be viewed as an unalloyed good, since inequality was apparently reducing over the longer term, anyway. It is certainly the case that in countries with masses of undocumented, unregistered poor, a policy which mandates governments to transfer at least some modest resources to each individual is valuable for the elementary recognition of their identity status as citizens, which the transfer requires, even if it does precious little to redress their structural inequality.7