Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-case*** › Link – Elections

Election link--UBI Not popular

Gilberstadt 20’

[Hannah, 8-19-2020, Pew Research Center, “More Americans oppose than favor the government providing a universal basic income for all adult citizens,” https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2020/08/19/more-americans-oppose-than-favor-the-government-providing-a-universal-basic-income-for-all-adult-citizens/, 6-26,DG]

A narrow majority of U.S. adults (54%) say they would oppose the federal government providing a guaranteed income – sometimes called a universal basic income (UBI) – of about $1,000 per month for all adult citizens, whether or not they work; 45% favor the proposal.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-case*** › Link – Politics

Basic income will require fights to pass

Robert Greenstein ’19, June 13, “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It,” CENTER ON BUDGET AND POLICY PRIORITIES, https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it

While some UBI proponents argue that continued pressure on the middle class will make UBI politically feasible, I’m skeptical. Economic pressure on the middle class will not alter UBI’s daunting financing challenges. In fact, more such pressure will likelier increase middle-class resistance to the massive tax increases required to secure UBI without increasing poverty. And we shouldn’t think that we can just get the resources solely or primarily by hitting people at the top. Will we really tax the top 1 percent or top several percent enough to finance most or all of UBI — on top of the higher taxes we’ll want the same group to pay to shoulder a substantial share of the burden of restoring Social Security solvency, repairing the infrastructure, and meeting other critical needs? Increased pressure on the middle class is more likely to put UBI farther out of reach, unless it’s financed heavily — as UBI supporters on the right favor — by shifting income and resources away from the poor.

To be sure, there is a possible exception: a carbon tax that returns its proceeds to the public via a universal payment. For a carbon tax to have any chance of enactment in the not-too-distant future, however, it almost certainly will have to allocate a substantial part of its proceeds to uses that are necessary to get the votes to enact it in the first place, such as relief for coal-producing states or regions. There’s also a powerful case for using some of the proceeds to greatly expand and accelerate research into alternative energy technologies; a carbon tax likely won’t be sufficient by itself to arrest global warming.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-case*** › Link – Politics

Political backing for UBI won’t sustain

Hilary W. Hoynes, Richard & Rhoda Goldman School of Public Policy, and Jesse Rothstein Goldman School of Public Policy and Department of Economics, ‘19, February, “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME IN THE US AND ADVANCED COUNTRIES,” Working Paper 25538, https://gspp.berkeley.edu/assets/uploads/research/pdf/w25538.pdf

It is not clear whether negative effects on labor supply are a drawback. At least some UBI advocates support a UBI because it would eliminate the need to work for some low-skill workers who are expected to be displaced by technological change or who are otherwise occupied in unpaid care work. In that case, reductions in work are a desired impact, not an unintended consequence. But there may not be political will to sustain large transfers to those who choose not to work.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #3 Extension – Workforce turn

Turns their economy advantage – workforce key to growth

The Economic Lowdown, 12

[The Economic Lowdown, Sep 4 2012, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, “The Labor Market - The Economic Lowdown Podcast Series,” ., 6/26/2023, EJ]

Employers demand labor because workers are an important part of the production process. Workers use tools and equipment to turn inputs into output. Without workers, employers couldn't produce goods and services and earn profits. When graphed, the demand for labor looks much like the demand for other goods and services-it has a downward slope. This indicates that a greater quantity of labor is demanded at lower prices than at higher prices. That is, in the labor market, employers are willing to buy more hours of labor at lower wages than at a higher wages.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #3 Extension – Workforce turn

UBI causes massive labor exit

Alan Thomas , June 4, 2020, Berkeley: Walter de Gruyter GmbH, "Full Employment, Unconditional Basic Income and the Keynesian Critique of Rentier Capitalism,"  Pages 18-21 DOA - 6/24/23 DD

There is a specific, macro-economic concern about Van Parijs’s UBI that Minsky explicitly discusses – under his usual description of it as a “negative income tax”. His concern is that this policy is self-stultifying because of its effect on inflation: the purchasing power of the worst off is boosted, only then to be undermined. I think, in Rawlsian terms, we can describe it as one aspect of a conception of justice proving to be unstable – unable to reproduce itself over time. I have already described Minsky’s general argument that tax and transfer schemes, absent an independent commitment to full employment, are of their nature inflationary. Those who produce are taxed and that income is moved to those who do not produce goods or services for consumption. This latter group spend a higher proportion of the transferred resources than those from whom it is transferred. Minsky believed that this inherently inflationary transfer was exacerbated by a UBI via its impact on labour market participation rates. It is true that some people who are currently involuntarily unemployed would, if in receipt of an UBI, be drawn on to the labour market, namely, those currently caught up in benefits traps. But Minsky’s concern is that a significant number of those currently on the labour market will withdraw from it. As Minsky notes, many of the currently poor cannot attach much value to leisure as leisure activities are themselves costly. Not only would a person currently in poverty be even poorer if they reduced their market participation, the leisure would be inadequate compensation given their lack of resources that would allow them to enjoy it. Under a UBI, however, the incentive to introduce more leisure into the economy is accompanied with a financial incentive to make use of it. Those conditions together are likely to produce substantial exit from the labour market. It follows that, at the macro-level, one the one hand, spending power is transferred to those more likely to make use of it. This is an attractive and deliberate upshot of a UBI. However, another macro-effect will be that fewer people will participate in the labour market, so that wages will have to be increased by employers to “bid up” the value of labour. Only this increased remuneration will attract those who could otherwise live on an UBI. As a result, employers will increase wages and push that cost through to prices. Minsky argued that the resulting inflationary increase will largely cancel out the value of a UBI to the worst off, making the policy (from a Rawlsian perspective) self-stultifying. Even those drawn on to the labour market by being freed from benefits traps will see their gains eroded by price inflation. The real point of contrast is between the self-stultifying way in which an UBI leads to inflation that negates most of its good effects for the worst off, and a Rawlsian proposal widely to disperse capital, to ensure fair access to it, and to aim at reasonable equity in its distribution. You can either take SELR to be a policy contained already in this general description – if you include human capital as capital – or as complementary to it (Thomas, 2017, p. 403, fn. 41, 2020b). Rentier Capitalism 19 The final issue to be addressed is the comparative one: if this paper claims that the policy of SELR achieves our egalitarian goals in a stable why, while an UBI does not, what guarantees that the former policy is not inflationary in the same way? Minsky believes that the transition from slack to tight full employment will be inflationary for a time, but: The high wage worker and other affluent citizens have been subsidized, by way of low product prices, by the poor … tight full employment … will lead to cost-push inflation. (Minsky 2013a, p. 10).

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #3 Extension – Workforce turn

UBI hurts the workforce – their arguments for solving inequality and worker conditions GRANT that many employees will credibly threaten to quit

Dan Schawbel, New York Times best-selling author and managing partner of Workplace Intelligence, ’20, January 1, “How Universal Basic Income Would Impact the Future of Work and Careers,” https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-universal-basic-income-would-impact-future-work-careers-schawbel

The reason why there is almost a complete split between American's on UBI is that there are benefits and drawbacks to the government program. The biggest benefits of the UBI social safety net include mental health improvements, bringing people out of poverty, addressing income inequality, promoting social inclusion, reducing homelessness, and stimulating entrepreneurship. As I spoke about earlier with Yang, UBI allows workers to make better employment decisions because it gives them the financial backing to quit a toxic manager, pursue a new career, or start a business. It's easier to follow your passion when there's money to lean on because many ideas fail. In this way, UBI would put pressure on employers to treat their workers better because they would lose leverage and have a harder time competing for talent when talent has more freedom through financial safety.

Although UBI poses some tremendous life-altering and society-improving benefits, there are several drawbacks that should be considered when evaluating it. These include potentially encouraging laziness, discouraging part-time work, higher taxes, and welfare for people like criminals.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #3 Extension – Workforce turn

UBI decreases labor participation – turns growth

Eri Noguchi MSW, MPA, PhD, and Chief Operating Officer of the Association to Benefit Children, ’18, august 16, “A Universal Basic Income (UBI) may affect the labor market. So what?,” ROOSEVELT HOUSE, http://www.roosevelthouse.hunter.cuny.edu/?forum-post=universal-basic-income-ubi-may-affect-labor-market

Arguments surrounding a Universal Basic Income (UBI) often center around its predicted impact on the labor market—whether the introduction of a universal basic income will cause workers to quit their jobs, which in turn will lead to a tight labor market, runaway inflation as demand outpaces supply, and a stagnant economy. It seems plausible that a UBI could result in a tighter labor market, though it would depend in large part on how big the size of the UBI grant is and the specific labor market sector. It seems unlikely, for instance, that workers earning six-digit salaries would quit their jobs en masse once they were paid a guaranteed annual income of $12,000. Let us grant that a UBI would, in fact, result in a tighter labor market. This brief expose asks the question: so what?

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #2 Extension – Econ resilient

U.S. economy is resilient – even if slowdown happens, it won’t crash

Rainey, Emory University Master of Arts (M.A.) for Sociology, 6-29-23 [Michael, 6-29-23, The Fiscal Times, “US Economy – and Biden – Get a Surprise Boost,” https://www.thefiscaltimes.com/newsletter/20230629-US-Economy-and-Biden-Get-Surprise-Boost, date accessed 6-29, DG]

Revised figures from the Commerce Department show that the U.S. economy grew at a 2% annualized rate in the first three months of 2023, a significant increase from the initial estimate of 1.1%, though still a downshift from the 2.6% annualized growth rate recorded in the final quarter of 2022. The third and final revision highlights “the surprising resilience of the country’s economic recovery, which has remained steady despite high inflation, rapidly rising interest rates and persistent predictions of a recession from many forecasters on Wall Street,” wrote Ben Casselman of The New York Times. Speaking to reporters at an event in Washington, National Economic Council Director Lael Brainard said the numbers weaken the case for a recession, at least in the near term. “It’s hard not to conclude that the economy is resilient and chugging along and doing pretty well,” the former vice chair of the Federal Reserve said. “We want to see stable growth, we want to see sustainable growth, but the resilience has really been notable.” Gregory Daco, chief economist at EY-Parthenon, said the report provides more support for the argument that the economy can slow down without crashing. “This is the immaculate soft-landing with below potential growth & easing inflation,” he tweeted. In a separate report, initial jobless claims fell by 26,000 to 239,000 on a weekly basis, beating expectations and easing worries that the labor market was signaling a recession ahead. “Over the past couple of weeks the initial unemployment claims data had spiked, perhaps sending a worrying (albeit noisy) signal of a slowdown,” said University of Michigan economist Justin Wolfers. “Today's good news: That spike has reversed. Maybe it was noise rather than signal.” Taken together, the economic reports could boost President Joe Biden’s campaign to convince Americans that “Bidenomics” is a success. “This is going to be a tailwind for the economy,” said Joseph Brusuelas, chief economist at the consulting firm RSM, per Politico. “This is the stuff that’s going to increase productivity and bring down inflation” and “reflects the underlying resilience of the overall economy and the rock-solid foundation of U.S. households.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #2 Extension – Econ resilient

Doomsayers keep pushing back the crash deadline – the truth is we are seeing resilience

Peter Kasperowicz June 30, 2023, “Yellen brushes off recession fears: Economy ‘more resilient’ than many predicted,” FOX BUSINESS, https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/yellen-brushes-off-recession-fears-economy-more-resilient

"For a year now, we have heard our fair share of predictions about an imminent U.S. recession – with forecasters projecting one by the end of 2022, then by the start of 2023, then by the middle of this year," Yellen said in her prepared remarks. "But our economy has proven more resilient than many had thought," she added. "I continue to believe that there is a path to reducing inflation while maintaining a healthy labor market. Without downplaying the significant risks ahead, the evidence that we’ve seen so far suggests that we are on that path."

Yellen’s predictive powers have been sharply criticized. Last year, she was forced to admit she was wrong after saying for months that rising inflation that started when President Biden took office would be "transitory" and short-lived. "I think I was wrong then about the path that inflation would take," she said in a CNN interview. "As I mentioned, there have been unanticipated and large shocks to the economy that have boosted energy and food prices and supply bottlenecks that have affected our economy badly that I didn't at the time fully understand." On her latest prediction that the U.S. economy would dodge a recession, Yellen said she’s spoken with business executives who feel the same way and said both consumer spending and business investment remain at healthy levels.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #2 Extension – Econ resilient

U.S. economy is fundamentally resilient

Max Zahn June 28, 2023. “US economy 'quite resilient,' Fed Chair Jerome Powell says,” ABCNEWS, https://abcnews.go.com/Business/us-economy-resilient-fed-chair-jerome-powell/story?id=100437185

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell on Wednesday voiced an optimistic message about the U.S. economy and downplayed the threat of a recession. "The U.S. economy has actually been quite resilient," Powell said in Sentra, Portugal, at a conference organized by the European Central Bank. While acknowledging that a recession is "certainly possible," he said such an outcome is "not the most likely case." "The economy is resilient and still growing, albeit at a modest pace," he added. The remarks arrived two weeks after the Federal Reserve paused its aggressive series of interest rate hikes, ending a string of 10 consecutive rate increases that stretched back 15 months. The Federal Reserve has aimed to roll back price increases by slowing down the economy and slashing consumer demand. The approach, however, risks tipping the economy into a recession. Inflation has fallen significantly from a peak last summer but remains at a level double the Federal Reserve's target of 2%. Data released in recent months suggests that the policy approach has succeeded in slowing economic activity while averting a downturn. U.S. gross domestic product grew by a sluggish 1.1% annualized rate over the three months ending in March, according to government data.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #1 Extension – Econ UQ

Economy going strong—Americans are happy about the economy

Wallace, senior writer of economics, 6-27-2023

[Alicia, 6-27-2023, CNN, “Americans are feeling far more confident about the economy,” https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/27/economy/us-consumer-confidence-june/index.html, accessed 6-29, DG]

Americans are feeling fairly bullish about the US economy: A key measurement of consumer confidence just jumped to its highest level since January 2022. The Conference Board’s Consumer Confidence Index was 109.7 in June, rising from 102.5 the month before, according to a report released Tuesday. The latest survey from the business research and membership organization continued to show that consumers retained a far sunnier outlook about the present than what could come in the months ahead. Both the present situations index and the expectations index rose from May; however, the latter remains at a level that flashes a recession warning signal, the Conference Board noted. “If packed-full restaurants and airports were not enough to convince you that consumers are feeling good at the moment, look at the present situation index, which notched its best monthly gain since December 2022,” Wells Fargo economists wrote in a note issued Tuesday. “In level terms, only two months have been higher for the present situation index in the past three years: those being June and July 2021.” The labor market, which has softened somewhat but remains historically tight and strong, continues to give a boost to confidence. The share of consumers who viewed jobs as “plentiful” increased to 46.8% from 43.3%. “Greater confidence was most evident among consumers under age 35, and consumers earning incomes over $35,000,” Dana Peterson, chief economic at the Conference Board, said in a statement. “Nonetheless, the expectations gauge continued to signal consumers anticipating a recession at some point over the next 6 to 12 months.” Some of those recession fears are fading, it seems: Tuesday’s report also showed a decline in the number of consumers who are expecting a recession. In June, 69.3% of consumers said a recession is “somewhat” or “very likely.” That’s down from 73.2% in May. Consumers indicated their plans to purchase homes and cars have slowed, and they’re pulling back more on vacation plans, including travel domestically. “This is an important indicator of desires to spend on services ahead, which may be a signal that post-pandemic ‘revenge spending’ on travel may have peaked and is likely to slow over the rest of this year,” Peterson said.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #1 Extension – Econ UQ

Economy is booming—far from collapse

Casselman, 22’

[Ben, 4-5-2022, Ny Times, “The U.S. Economy Is Booming. So Why Are Economists Worrying About a Recession ,”https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/05/business/economy/recession-economy.html, accessed 6-29, DG]

Employers are adding hundreds of thousands of jobs a month, and would hire even more people if they could find them. Consumers are spending, businesses are investing, and wages are rising at their fastest pace in decades. So naturally, economists are warning of a possible recession. Rapid inflation, soaring oil prices and global instability have led forecasters to sharply lower their estimates of economic growth this year, and to raise their probabilities of an outright contraction. Investors share that concern: The bond market last week flashed a warning signal that has often — though not always — foreshadowed a downturn. Such predictions may seem confusing when the economy, by many measures, is booming. The United States has regained more than 90 percent of the jobs lost in the early weeks of the pandemic, and employers are continuing to hire at a breakneck pace, adding 431,000 jobs in March alone. The unemployment rate has fallen to 3.6 percent, barely above the prepandemic level, which was itself a half-century low. But to the doomsayers, the recovery’s remarkable strength carries the seeds of its own destruction. Demand — for cars, for homes, for restaurant meals and for the workers to provide them — has outstripped supply, leading to the fastest inflation in 40 years. Policymakers at the Federal Reserve argue they can cool off the economy and bring down inflation without driving up unemployment and causing a recession. But many economists are skeptical that the Fed can engineer such a “soft landing,” especially in a moment of such extreme global uncertainty. “It’s like trying to land during an earthquake,” said Tara Sinclair, a professor of economics at George Washington University. William Dudley, a former president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, called a recession “virtually inevitable.” He is among the economists arguing that if the Fed had begun raising interest rates last year, it might have been able to rein in inflation merely by tapping the brakes on the economy. Now, they say, the economy is growing so rapidly — and prices are rising so quickly — that the only way for the Fed to get control is to slam on the brakes and cause a recession. Still, a majority of forecasters say a recession remains unlikely in the next year. High oil prices, rising interest rates and waning government aid will all drag down growth this year, said Aneta Markowska, chief economist for Jefferies, an investment bank. But corporate profits are strong, households have trillions in savings, and debt loads are low — all of which should provide a cushion against any slowdown. “It’s easy to construct a very negative narrative, but when you actually look at the magnitude of all those impacts, I don’t think they’re significant enough to push us into a recession in the next 12 months,” she said. Recessions, almost by definition, involve job losses and unemployment; right now, companies are doing practically anything they can to retain workers. “I just don’t see what would cause businesses to do a complete 180 and go from ‘We need to hire all these people and we can’t find them’ to ‘We have to lay people off,’” Ms. Markowska said. Economists, however, are notoriously terrible at predicting recessions. So it makes sense to focus instead on where the recovery is right now, and on the forces that are threatening to knock it off course. The latest signs suggest maybe not. Despite much higher borrowing costs, thanks to the Federal Reserve’s aggressive streak of interest rate hikes, consumers keep spending, and employers keep hiring. Gas prices have dropped, and grocery prices have leveled off, giving Americans more spending power.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #1 Extension – Econ UQ

Economy is going strong—people who say otherwise are incorrect

Brooks, professor at Yale University, 6-29-2023

[David, and is a member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 6-29-2023, New York Times, “Why Biden Isn’t Getting the Credit He Deserves,” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/29/opinion/biden-economy-inflation-plan.html, date accessed, 6-29, DG]

The misery index is a crude but effective way to measure the health of the economy. You add up the inflation rate and the unemployment rate. If you’re a president running for re-election, you want that number to be as low as possible. When Ronald Reagan won re-election, it was about 11.4, when George W. Bush did so it was 9, for Barack Obama it was 9.5, and today, as Joe Biden runs for re-election, it’s only 7.7. Biden should be cruising to an easy re-election victory. And that misery index number doesn’t even begin to capture the strength of the American economy right now. There are a zillion positive indicators right now, as the folks in the administration will be quick to tell you. The economy has created 13 million jobs since Biden’s Inauguration Day. According to the Conference Board, a business research firm, Americans’ job satisfaction is at its highest level in 36 years. Household net worth is surging. We learned Thursday that the U.S. economy grew at an annualized 2 percent rate in the first quarter of this year, well above the economists’ expectations of around 1.4 percent. The best part of it is that the new prosperity is helping those who have long been left behind. In the four years of Donald Trump’s administration, spending on manufacturing facilities grew by 5 percent. During the first two years of Biden’s administration, such investment more than doubled and about 800,000 manufacturing jobs were created. This is not just coincidence. It’s a direct outcome of Biden policies: the Inflation Reduction Act, with its green technology provisions, the infrastructure bill, the CHIPS Act. Biden’s stimulative spending did boost the inflation rate, but inflation is now lower than in many other developed nations and our economy is stronger. So Americans should be celebrating. But they are not. According to an NBC News survey conducted this month, at least 74 percent of Americans say the country is on the wrong track. The Gallup economic confidence index over the past year has been starkly negative; people haven’t felt this bad about the economy since the throes of the global financial crisis in 2008 and 2009. The University of Michigan’s Consumer Sentiment Index is also tremendously downbeat. Joe Biden’s approval numbers have been stuck around a perilously low 43 percent for a year. As the maestro political analyst Charlie Cook noted in 2020, on average, presidents tend to lose their re-election bids when about 70 percent of Americans think the country is on the wrong track, and they tend to win when fewer than half of Americans think that. Why are Americans feeling so bad about an economy that’s so good? Partly, it’s inflation. Things have stabilized recently as inflation has dropped, but for a while there, real wages really were falling. Prices on things like gas and food are now significantly higher than they were three years ago. Editors’ Picks Is Originality Even a Worthy Ambition Anymore? In ‘The Bear,’ Molly Gordon Is More Than the Girl Next Door Can You Mix Booze and Exercise? The Biden folks are hoping that as inflation continues to decline and as they get the word out, Americans will begin to feel better about things. But it’s not that simple. Part of it is the media. A recent study found that over the past couple of decades headlines have grown starkly more negative, conveying anger and fear. That’s bound to spread bad vibes through the populace. But the main problem is national psychology. Americans’ satisfaction with their personal lives is nearly four times as higher as their satisfaction with the state of the nation. That’s likely because during the Trump era we have suffered a collective moral injury, a collective loss of confidence, a loss of faith in ourselves as a nation. America has suffered two recent periods of national demoralization. In the 1970s, during Vietnam and Watergate, Americans lost faith in their institutions. During the Trump era, Americans also lost faith in one another. Those who supported Trump were converted to the gospel of American Carnage, the idea that elite Americans seek to destroy other Americans, that we are on the precipice of disaster. Those who opposed Trump were appalled that their countrymen could support him, disgusted by his rampant immorality, alarmed that their democracy was suddenly in peril. The anthropologist Raoul Naroll argued that every society has a “moral net,” a cultural infrastructure that exists, mostly unconsciously, in the minds of its members. America’s is in tatters. This manifests a loss of national self-esteem. People begin to assume national incompetence. Fearful and anxiety-ridden people are quick to perceive the negative aspects of any situation, hypersensitive to threat, prone to pessimism. You can’t argue people out of that psychological and moral state with statistics and fact sheets. Biden is going to have to serve as a national guide, not just an administrator. He has to get outside the protective walls that have been built around him and make himself the center of the nation’s attention, not Trump. He’ll have to come up with a 21st-century national story that gives people a sense of coherence and belonging — that we are marching in a clear direction toward some concrete set of goals. Good jobs numbers alone don’t heal a brutalized national psyche, and that’s our main problem right now.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #1 Extension – Econ UQ

US economy continues to improve

Mutikani, reporter for Reuters, 6-27-2023

[Lucia, 6-27-2023, Reuters, “US consumer confidence races to 17-month high; housing market regaining strength,” https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-core-capital-goods-orders-unexpectedly-rise-may-2023-06-27/, date accessed 6-29, DG]

U.S. consumer confidence increased in June to the highest level in nearly 1-1/2 years amid renewed labor market optimism, while business spending appeared to hold up in May, indicating the economy remained on solid footing despite fears of a recession. Hopes that the economy could avoid a downturn in the near-term were also bolstered by other reports on Tuesday signaling a housing market revival was likely underway, with new home sales racing to a 15-month high in May and monthly house prices rising again in April.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › #1 Extension – Econ UQ

No risk of recession – several indicators pointing to healthy growth

Hardy, Reporter, Jun 08, 2023

[Adam,Jun 08, 2023, EVERYDAY MONEY, “The Chances of a 2023 Recession Are Changing Quickly,” ., accessed June 29 2023, JC]

If you asked any financial expert over the past couple of months about how the U.S. economy was doing, you almost certainly heard them ominously predict that we’re heading for a recession in 2023. But now, they're starting to sound a lot more optimistic. One prime example: Goldman Sachs slashed the probability that the U.S. will enter a recession in the next year to 25%. That's down from a 35% forecast in the spring following the . The investment banking firm lowered the chances of the U.S. sliding into a recession largely because the banking industry has stabilized since March, and a U.S. debt default — which but nonetheless had the ability to decimate the economy — was averted by . Another clear indicator that a recession isn’t likely? Another "gangbusters" job report for May, as University of Michigan Economics Professor Justin Wolfers said in a released Wednesday. The U.S. added 339,000 jobs in the month of May, its 29th consecutive month of job growth.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › 1NC Economy frontline

3. A UBI undermines growth – huge expense – decreases labor force participation and GDP

Minogue, Economic Fellow, 2018

[Rachel ,5/24/18, Third Way, “Five Problems with Universal Basic Income,” https://www.thirdway.org/memo/five-problems-with-universal-basic-income, 6/29/23, PE]

Causes for Concern With either approach, UBI is based on assumptions about the future economy that run counter to many economic realities. As a result, it creates a series of problems for the modern US economy that need to be examined. Those problems fall into five categories: Jobs aren’t disappearing; rather, the nature of work is changing. A shrinking labor force would harm economic growth. UBI is very expensive, requiring substantial tax increases or spending cuts. Many of the most disadvantaged would likely be left more vulnerable. The idea has been scarcely tested. Jobs are changing Many of the most ardent UBI supporters believe the policy is an answer to a world where work is vanishing. This is a popular view in Silicon Valley, where many predict widespread technological unemployment is just around the corner.4 But there is almost no evidence that work is ending. Instead, work is changing. The US economy employs more people today than ever, with 37 million jobs added since the introduction of Microsoft Windows in 1993 and 190,000 new jobs created per month over the last year on average.5 As Baby Boomers retire, the US working-age population will grow more slowly than the economy as a whole. For that reason, the US is just as likely to experience a shortage of labor to fill growing jobs as it is to have a labor market oversaturated with workers.6 Many professions are rising in demand today, including those in health care, advanced manufacturing, skilled construction, education, technology, hospitality, and business management. At this very moment, there are 6 million job openings across the country, more than half of which are middle-class jobs or better.7 While we may see a net gain in jobs over the coming years, disruption will still be rampant. These jobs will be in different locations, require different skills, and offer different benefits. That’s why we need policies that help workers adjust to these new realities—not surrender. Reinventing postsecondary education to create more options outside of a four-year college degree, as well as redesigning worker pay and benefits, would do far more for the next generation of workers. Economic growth would suffer With a foundational, albeit limited, income under UBI, some Americans may choose to work part-time instead of full-time. Others may leave the labor force for years when they would have otherwise worked. Eduardo Porter writes that, as almost one quarter of US households make less than $25,000 a year, a $10,000 check each for two parents could change their decisions on how to balance work, child care, and other obligations, resulting in less full-time participation in the labor force.8 If people transition away from full-time work, the US economy would suffer. Macroeconomic theory holds that economic growth is dependent on three factors: increases in capital, advances in technology, and growth of the labor force. UBI has the potential to directly decrease the growth of the US economy, namely GDP growth, through reductions to labor force participation. With GDP shrinking, tax revenues would fall. This would in turn mean fewer resources to help the disadvantaged or to invest in the future, resulting in lower overall prosperity. UBI is incredibly expensive The numbers speak for themselves: UBI is either very expensive or very stingy. The progressive version of UBI is expensive to the point of impossibility, while the conservative version is penny-pinching and punitive. Looking first at the former, consider an annual grant of $12,000 for all American adults aged 18 to 64, like Stern proposes. Stern estimates his plan would cost between $1.75 trillion and $2.5 trillion. The high end of this range seems realistic. Almost two-thirds of the population, or 200 million people, would receive a monthly UBI check for $1,000, with a cost of approximately $2.4 trillion every year, or one-eighth of GDP.9 Social Security beneficiaries currently receiving less than $1,000 a month would also get a supplement, adding an estimated $52 billion a year.10 By comparison, our entire existing social safety net costs $2.6 trillion. That includes Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Unemployment Insurance, and veterans’ benefits.11

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › 1NC Economy frontline

2. U.S. economy is resilient – can’t and won’t collapse

Amadeo, Former President of World Money Watch, ‘22

[Kimberly, 3-30-2022, The Balance, “Top 10 Reasons the U.S. Economy Won't Collapse,” , accessed 6-29, DG]

Have you come across those websites that urge you to prepare for the coming U.S. economic collapse? They start by saying that the debt is unsustainable, the dollar is in a bubble, or that the Federal Reserve is printing dollars. The coronavirus pandemic is one reason why some worry about an economic collapse heading into 2022. All these assertions are true, but they’re nothing to panic over. The doomsayers say that "if" a specific event occurs, "then" the economy will collapse, such as, "If China sells its dollar holdings..." or "If the United States defaults on its debt..." But they don’t tell you that these events are not at all likely. They suggest that you buy gold coins or their survival book to prepare for the event "just in case." Key Takeaways The economy is based on confidence. Fortunately, consumers and investors see the U.S. economy as reliable. U.S. debt has reached dangerous levels, but investors remain confident that it will be repaid. Globalization has made international markets more intertwined. Foreign countries have no incentive to cash in their debt quickly because it would affect their economies as well. Why the U.S. Economy Won't Fail It doesn't mean the U.S. economy will fail even if it enters a deep recession or even a depression. There are 10 good reasons why it won't collapse. Unemployment Is Declining The unemployment rate peaked at 14.8% in April 2020, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). This doesn't come close to economists' direst projections during the early days of the pandemic, but it's still the highest unemployment rate since the Great Depression.12 Fortunately, many of those people are returning to work as employers figure out how to keep their workers safe, and as the vaccine rollout continues. The Stock Market Is Recovering The market hit new highs, then it crashed in 2020. The highs were a reflection of underlying investor confidence. The lows were a result of uncertainty caused by the pandemic. The market has recovered as uncertainty has continued to dissipate over time.3 The Economy Is Not on the Verge of Collapse The U.S. national debt limit was set at $28.4 trillion in August 2021. Government spending in response to the pandemic drove that figure higher.4 Congress acted in December 2021 to increase the debt ceiling by another $2.5 trillion, to almost $31.4 trillion.5 The debt-to-gross domestic product ratio is in the danger zone, but it's not enough to cause a collapse.6 First, the United States prints its money. It's in control of its currency. Lenders feel safe that the U.S. government will pay them back. In fact, the United States could run a much higher debt-to-GDP ratio and still not face economic collapse. Note Japan is another strong economy that controls its currency. It's had a debt-to-GDP ratio above 200% for years. Its economy is sluggish but in no danger of collapse. The U.S. Won't Default on Its Debt Most members of Congress realize that a debt default would destroy America's credibility in the financial markets. The tea party Republicans in Congress were a minority who threatened to default during the 2011 debt ceiling crisis and in 2013. China and Japan Have No Incentive to Create a Collapse The United States is the largest market for China and Japan.7 Their economies will also fail if the U.S. economy fails. China is not selling all of its dollar holdings, despite what doomsayers may claim. The U.S. debt to China has remained above $1 trillion since 2013.8 The Dollar Would Decline Instead of Collapse The dollar fell by 58% between 2002 and 2008. A euro could only buy $0.90 on Jan. 3, 2002. It was worth $1.42 by Dec. 29, 2008. The dollar's value falls as the euro's value strengthens. That was a huge drop in the dollar's value, but it was far from a collapse.9 The Dollar Won't Be Replaced The doomsayers point to gold, the euro, or Bitcoin as replacements for the dollar as the world's global currency. China's shows that it would like the yuan to become a more widely traded currency.10 None of these other alternatives has enough circulation to replace the dollar.11 Bitcoin has become the currency of choice for the underground economy.12 Low Fed Funds Rate Won't Cause Hyperinflation The real cause of hyperinflation has been debt repayments to fund wars. The Fed's programs created a liquidity trap. People, businesses, and banks hoarded cash instead of spending or lending it. Consumer Confidence Hit a 19-Year High in 2018 Consumer spending drives about 70% of the economy.13 Confidence has been hit hard by the pandemic, but its strength will return.14 The Great Depression Was the Worst And as bad as the Great Depression was, it wasn't a collapse. What All This Means to You Do two things before you run out to buy gold or stock up on canned goods. First, read the articles linked in the 10 points above. They will give you the facts that the naysayers ignore. Or read "How the U.S. Economy Works." Second, see what a real economic collapse looks like. Companies pulled out trillions of dollars from money market accounts in September 2018. It would have created a severe cash crunch had it continued. The nation's trucking industry would have ground to a halt. Gas stations would have gone dry. Grocery stores' shelves would have gone empty. But shortages didn’t happen because the Federal Reserve prevented the collapse. It guaranteed money market accounts and that restored confidence. Even the Great Depression wasn't a collapse, but it was close. GDP fell by half.15 Global trade dropped by two-thirds.16 Unemployment was 25%.2 The Fed raised the fed funds rate to protect the gold standard. Congress cut back on the New Deal too soon. That brought back the depression in 1937. It didn't end until Congress started spending again to build up the military for World War II. We aren't headed for an economic collapse or even a second Great Depression. The coronavirus pandemic caused a severe recession lasting several months, but a depression lasts for years.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Economy*** › 1NC Economy frontline

1. US economy going strong—far from economic collapse

Cox 6-29-2023

[Jeff, 6-29-2023, CNBC, “First-quarter economic growth was actually 2%, up from 1.3% first reported in major GDP revision,” https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/29/first-quarter-economic-growth-was-actually-2percent-up-from-1point3percent-first-reported-in-major-gdp-revision.html”, accessed 6-29, DG]

The U.S. economy showed much stronger-than-expected growth in the first quarter than previously thought, according to a big upward revision Thursday from the Commerce Department. Gross domestic product increased at a 2% annualized pace for the January-through-March period, up from the previous estimate of 1.3% and ahead of the 1.4% Dow Jones consensus forecast. This was the third and final estimate for Q1 GDP. The growth rate was 2.6% in the fourth quarter. The upward revision helps undercut widespread expectations that the U.S. is heading toward a recession. A separate economic report released Thursday showed layoffs running well below expectations, indicating that labor market strength has held up even in the face of the Federal Reserve’s 10 interest rate hikes totaling 5 percentage points. According to a summary from the department’s Bureau of Economic Analysis, the change came in large part because both consumer expenditures and exports were stronger than previously thought. Consumer spending, as gauged by personal consumption expenditures, rose 4.2%, the highest quarterly pace since the second quarter of 2021. At the same time, exports rose 7.8% after falling 3.7% in the fourth quarter of 2022. An 8.7% boost in the Social Security cost-of-living adjustment likely boosted the consumer spending numbers, said Scott Hoyt, senior director at Moody’s Analytics. “Overall, however, the economy remains admirably resilient, and odds of a recession beginning this year are receding.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Inequality*** › #3 Extension – Populism impact defense

Populism remains high in Europe and will increase by the end of 2023 without escalating conflict

Wintour and Elgot 1-5-2023 (Patrick Wintour and Jessica Elgot Wed 4 Jan 2023 19.01 EST, article ameneded on 1-5-23, accessed 3-31-23, the guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/05/number-of-populist-world-leaders-at-20-year-low)-TL

The report, however, warns strongly against premature claims of populism’s defeat, pointing out that in 2022 populists were part of election-winning coalitions in Italy, Israel and Sweden. Marine Le Pen was defeated by the French president, Emmanuel Macron, but her party did well in the legislative elections. In the UK, the Conservative party is likely to face a challenge from the populist rightwing party Reform UK, which has vowed to put up candidates against all parties rather than continue with Ukip’s 2019 pact not to stand against Boris Johnson’s Conservatives. While Richard Tice’s party is unlikely to win a seat in the next election, it is polling at about 8% of votes, and the bulk of these would come from disgruntled Conservative voters. It could have greater success if Nigel Farage, who led Ukip and the Brexit party to much wider prominence, becomes more involved. The institute argues that anti-populist mainstream parties may have to recognise they need a different anti-populist playbook when they are in power from the one used by mainstream parties when the populists are in power. It says mainstream parties should have a clear, substantive policy agenda of their own and not focus on negative campaigning against populist challengers, since populist challengers will always argue that their core issues are under-addressed by mainstream politics. The report says mainstream parties must realise voters are increasingly tired of rhetorical excess that ignores the problems a country faces. The report’s author, Brett Meyer, said it showed a trend towards progressive centrism in a number of countries. “Centrists continued to roll back the frontiers of populism in 2022, with the number of populists in power down to a 20-year low,” he said. “This is in large part down to the success of progressive centrism over populism across the Americas as progressive centre-left leaders replaced the old, populist left. Populism also suffered a significant blow in the US midterms.” But the fate of populism may turn this year on elections in Poland and Turkey, where Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s government is in grave jeopardy. “By the end of 2022, Turkey had the deepest negative interest rates in the world when adjusted for inflation and the lira was the worst performer in emerging markets relative to the dollar,” the report said, warning that the Turkish president was willing to talk up conflicts with Greece or the Kurds to excite nationalist support.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Inequality*** › #3 Extension – Populism impact defense

There is no universal response to populism---anything but case-by-case response fails

Philip Manow 21, Professor of Comparative Political Economy at the University of Bremen, 12/15/21, “The political economy of populism in Europe”, https://www.chathamhouse.org/sites/default/files/2021-12/2021-12-15-political-economy-populism-europe-manow.pdf/mh

Beyond illuminating the driving forces of the populist backlash in Europe, the above typology helps us understand how policymakers could respond to it. During the past five years, centrist policymakers have increasingly focused on how to ‘defeat’ populism, which they have tended to see in simplistic terms. But the heterogeneity of populism, as discussed in this paper, means there is no one solution that can be applied everywhere – even in Europe. Rather, in each country’s case an effective solution will necessarily reflect the type of political economy involved.

This has particular implications for EU-level policymaking. Both trade and migration policy have become highly Europeanized, usually in ways that have removed barriers to the movement of goods, services and people across borders. This trend has often exacerbated the social and economic pressures that inspire different populist forces, while removing the opportunity for national policymakers to deal with these pressures. This means that any solutions will by definition need to involve EU institutions. Yet the heterogeneity of populism means that any one-size-fits-all policies emanating from Brussels could reinforce, rather than solve, the conflicts discussed in this paper.