2023
GDI
Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Solvency*** › #3 Extension – Tax turn
Greenstein, Quals, 2021
[Robert, June 13, 2019, center of budget and policy priorities. Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It, , 6/24/23, PE]
There are over 300 million Americans today. Suppose UBI provided everyone with $10,000 a year. That would cost more than $3 trillion a year — and $30 trillion to $40 trillion over ten years.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Solvency*** › #2 Extension – No studies
Hilary W. Hoynes, Richard & Rhoda Goldman School of Public Policy, and Jesse Rothstein Goldman School of Public Policy and Department of Economics, ‘19, February, “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME IN THE US AND ADVANCED COUNTRIES,” Working Paper 25538, https://gspp.berkeley.edu/assets/uploads/research/pdf/w25538.pdf
UBIs meeting the definition we laid out above – large enough to live on, without phase-out or other eligibility restrictions – have never been implemented in a rich country on a large scale or even in a pilot experiment. What we know about the likely effects of a UBI comes from analyses of policies that are similar in some way to UBIs, though different in others, and from the broader labor supply literature.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Solvency*** › #1 Extension – inadequate or unaffordable
Harris, Oxford Brookes University 23’
Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562
While much of the academic literature on UBI remains theoretical and rooted in normative political philosophy (see Van Parijs, 1991, inter alia), there have been several, highly analysed, UBI experiments (Torry, 2016). These trials can be divided into three groups – microsimulations, Global North trials, and trials in the Global South. Microsimulations have typically provided a larger amount of money for a longer period of time to a smaller cohort (see Martinelli, 2017: 16–17; Torry, 2016). These microsimulations have been split into two kinds based on whether the UBI is designed to replace or supplement/partially supplement existing state benefits, as discussed above (see Martinelli, 2017: 1). Typically, trials that replace socially provided large-scale provision (i.e. state healthcare) with individualised and marketised provision (i.e. private healthcare) have proved unsustainable (Martinelli, 2017: 1). To fund (often expensive) private healthcare for a large number of people would require considerably higher levels of UBI to be in place than has been accessible for the UBI trials to date. This poses a fundamental problem of the practicability of the actual implementation of UBI more broadly relative to more traditional alternatives, such as universal basic services. In keeping with Martinelli’s (2017) broader conclusions, microsimulations have broadly shown that an ‘affordable UBI is inadequate, and an adequate UBI is unaffordable’ (p. 43). To unpack this statement: to fund people through UBI at a level where they can have access to private services is prohibitive because it costs too much. This chimes with the social democratic claim that universal basic services are simply more efficient than private service provision. While microsimulations have provided interesting data, the most discussed pilots have been more large scale.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Solvency*** › 1NC Solvency frontline
Robert Greenstein ’19, June 13, “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It,” CENTER ON BUDGET AND POLICY PRIORITIES, https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it
Some UBI proponents may argue that by ending current programs, we’d reap large administrative savings that we could convert into UBI payments. But that’s mistaken. For the major means-tested programs — SNAP, Medicaid, the EITC, housing vouchers, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), and school meals — administrative costs consume only 1 to 9 percent of program resources, as a CBPP analysis explains.[1] Their funding goes overwhelmingly to boost the incomes and purchasing power of low-income families.
Moreover, as the Roosevelt Institute’s Mike Konczal has noted, eliminating Medicaid, SNAP, the EITC, housing vouchers, and the like would still leave you far short of what’s needed to finance a meaningful UBI.[2] Would we also end Pell Grants that help low-income students afford college? Would we terminate support for children in foster care, for mental health services, and for job training?
2023
GDI
Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Solvency*** › 1NC Solvency frontline
Cowan, Policy and Politics Media Commentator, 17 [Simon, November 2017, The Centre for Independent Studies, “Ubi – Universal Basic Income is an Unbelievably Bad Idea”, , accessed 6/25/2023, S.P.]
However all these experiments share a single flaw, which causes them to systematically underestimate the disincentive impact of a UBI. None of the experiments address how a UBI would be funded. This means that none of the participants in the trial communities have to pay extra tax, so none of the taxation disincentive effects inherent in a UBI are included. Given the likely enormous cost of implementing a UBI, substantial additional taxation would be required. As Samuel Hammond puts it “Taxes and transfers are two sides of the same coin … to propose a lump sum transfer like UBI without an explicit discussion of how it’s financed only tells half the story.”70 He goes on to conclude “universal transfer programs like a Basic Income cannot be analysed outside of the tax system that pays for it.”71 Once the cost of a universal style UBI is calculated, it becomes clear just how important it is to factor this in.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Solvency*** › 1NC Solvency frontline
Greenwell, Journalist for Washington post, 2022
[Megan, 10/24/22, The Washington Post, “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/, 6/27/23, PE]
Among many poverty scholars and activists, conditional cash transfers are seen as a step in the right direction, but only a small one. To maximize the impact on poor people’s lives, they say, money must be a right, not a reward, because that’s the only way to empower people to make their own choices. “There are positive outcomes from conditional cash, there are positive outcomes from unconditional cash,” Kline says. “But I think for me, making it conditional misses a really fundamental value around trust, dignity, agency, freedom.” The word “dignity” comes up a lot among guaranteed-income advocates. Research shows that the vast majority of people don’t “waste” cash on vices like drugs and alcohol, but rather use even small amounts to improve their life circumstances dramatically. In a 2019 working paper, Nobel Prize-winning development economist Abhijit Banerjee and two co-authors concluded that the distribution of unconditional cash in low-income countries had positive effects on “income, assets, savings, borrowing, total expenditure, food expenditure, dietary diversity, school attendance, test scores, cognitive development, use of health facilities, labor force participation, child labor migration, domestic violence, women’s empowerment, marriage, fertility, and use of contraception, among others.” Banerjee is part of the research team studying the world’s largest basic-income program, which is midway through a 12-year run across 300 rural villages in Kenya. For about 5,000 people, that means an extra $22 a month for more than a decade. Thus far, the researchers have found, participants have been less likely to get sick or go hungry, and more likely to start a business. In the United States, which has the world’s largest gross domestic product, the basic-income calculus is different than in places like Kenya, where a significant minority of people live on less than a dollar a day. But America has its own unique factors, like that inequality rate and a history of racist policies that have left a disproportionate number of people of color at the bottom of the income scale. Indeed, Tubbs and his counterparts frame basic income as something akin to reparations — a way to alleviate harm done to marginalized people by decades of biased and ineffective policy. The SEED recipients were struggling to survive because society had let them down, Tubbs argues, and the conventional methods of helping them were paternalistic and inadequate. In Baltimore, where more than 1 in 5 residents live below the federal poverty line, a new guaranteed-income pilot gives $1,000 a month to 200 recipients, all of them parents in high-crime neighborhoods. “We’re like the birthplace of racial redlining, right?” Scott says. “You’re not going to erase inequality, inequity that was caused by policy, without creating policy to do the opposite.” The notion of guaranteed income as a government-backed corrective for decades of racist policies has spread to dozens of cities, many led by young, Black mayors. Scott, 38, consults regularly with St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones, 50, whose city launched a guaranteed-income pilot in December 2021. St. Paul, Minn., Mayor Melvin Carter, 43, serves as co-chair of Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, and is a mentor to Tubbs, 32. According to Tubbs, guaranteed-income programs in Columbia, S.C.; Shreveport, La.; and Atlanta were the result of a Black mayors’ group text shortly after George Floyd’s murder in which he evangelized for King’s approach to solving urban poverty, before sending everyone a copy of “Where Do We Go From Here.” It’s no coincidence that these are the people plotting the future of guaranteed income in America, Scott argues. Many of them grew up in families that would have benefited from guaranteed-income programs. “We’re the first group of elected folks who actually lived through all of the s---,” he said, looking up from his phone for a rare moment during a 30-minute interview at Baltimore City Hall and drawing out the vowel sound in “lived.” “We lived through crack and heroin. We lived through zero tolerance. So all the stuff that folks are now talking about, we understand it in a way that no one else will.”
2023
GDI
Affirmative
NEG › ***NEG – Solvency*** › 1NC Solvency frontline
Simon Szreter, Professor of History and Public Policy at Cambridge University, ’22, July 11, “How Seriously Should we Take Universal Basic Income?” https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1467-923X.13169
The core idea for a UBI is simple and attractive: an unconditional monthly payment given to every citizen—forever—to free them to make choices unconstrained by poverty. However, to translate this good intention into practice encounters what has been called a policy trilemma. UBI schemes are either ‘inadequate, giving rise to unacceptable income losses among the poor; [or]… unaffordable, necessitating excessive and unsustainable tax increases; or … compromise the very principles underlying Basic Income’.2
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Coercion
Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’
[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pgs. 16, Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]
A second justice-oriented case for a UBI can be made based on the notion that it serves as compensation for valuable activities that are not compensated by the market. A functioning society relies on many crucial activities—including care work, looking after the elderly, and bearing children—that are not compensated in the form of wages. While some of these forms of work can be outsourced to the market or to state institutions, most of them still take place within the household and are carried out predominantly by women. A second category of valuable activities that are not compensated by the market includes various forms of community involvement and political activism. Communities wouldn’t work as atomistic assemblies of individuals who engage solely in income-generating market activities. And no democracy could exist without dedicated individuals foregoing market income in order to attempt to right social wrongs through endless hours of committed activism. Third, society benefits from many forms of artistic, musical, or literary production that are not commercially rewarded.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Coercion
Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’
[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pgs. 15, Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]
One justice-oriented case for a UBI can be made based on the notion of individual liberty. We are all entangled in a web of social connections and dependencies, which are often enriching and beneficial. But there are also many ways in which these dependencies can lead to problematic constraints on individual liberty. Such dependencies are often driven by economic outside options: If someone risks having no income if they were to leave a relationship, they are compelled to stay. Consider domestic partnerships in which one partner depends on the other for their material sustenance, shelter, and food, and thus cannot leave. Such a situation might sustain emotional and physical abuse, even forced prostitution in some cases. Consider also employment relationships in which an employee cannot quit, perhaps because unemployment would imply poverty and homelessness for his or her children. The lack of an alternative option for this employee allows the employer to engage in all kinds of exploitative and abusive behavior—both within and beyond the boundaries of the law— from low wages and long hours to sexual harassment. Consider lastly a welfare recipient who is dependent upon a caseworker’s judgment on whether he or she fulfilled various conditions, in order to continue receiving a basic level of material sustenance. Based on the interpersonal power this situation confers to them, caseworkers might engage in various forms of humiliation or discrimination.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Coercion
Painter, RSA Policy and Strategy Director, Thoung, Economist, 15
[Anthony, Chris, December 2015, RSA, "Creative citizen, creative state: the principled and pragmatic case for a Universal Basic Income.", , accessed 6/26/2023, S.P.]
The distributional changes outlined provide one answer to any challenges of distributional fairness that may arise from transferring to a Basic Income system. Basic Income already has significant moral and philosophical virtues in that it underpins freedom and security. However, in the context of an often abrasive moral discussion about welfare (‘benefit scroungers’ etc) how does Basic Income fare? The answer is ‘well’.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Feminism K’s
Schulz, Lawyer, 17
[Patricia Schulz, former head of Swiss Federal Office for Gender Equality, current lawyer, “Universal basic income in a feminist perspective and gender analysis” https://socialprotection-humanrights.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/UBI-Feminist-Analysis.pdf-grh]
A feminist perspective and a gender analysis – avoiding conflation of gender and women – can usefully contribute to the discussion on the universal basic income (UBI). Indeed, it helps analyse the concrete situation of women and of men, by looking into power relationships between them and structural discrimination based on sex, including multiple/ intersectional discriminations.1 These contribute to making women and those they care for vulnerable to poverty with its various deprivations. Advocates of the UBI could thus reinforce their strong arguments based on social justice, equality, dignity, freedom from want if they argued (more) systematically also from a gender equality perspective.2 The UBI, if unconditional and at a level covering basic needs, would help tackle the structural inequalities inherited from the past, due to the sexual divide between the public and private sphere. Although the normative framework has improved in many countries of the North and South, and women’s education is now higher than men’s in a number of countries, in average, women still face de facto unequal chances of political, economic and social participation. Their educational efforts are not rewarded the same: the higher their education, the greater the gender pay gap – one of the most depressing statistics one can consider. A recent study on the discrimination experienced by women due to pregnancy and maternity in the United Kingdom shows how deeply discrimination is embedded in society and how it prevents an equal access to the world of work and equal chances in this world, even after decades of efforts, legal and practical, in one of the most advanced economies, to implement gender equality in this field
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC social justice K’s
Thomas Straubhaar, University of Hamburg, ’17. “On the Economics of a Universal Basic Income,” INTERECONOMICS, Volume 52, 2017 · Number 2 · pp. 74–80, https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2017/number/2/article/on-the-economics-of-a-universal-basic-income.html
The UBI follows the principle that economic efficiency and social justice are not opposites. They can be harmoniously combined and, moreover, they complement one another. “The unconditional basic income unites the social with the liberal: it is liberal because it is unconditional, and social because it is for everyone. It is equal for everyone – and at the same time allows everyone to be different.”23
Like the social market economy, the UBI consistently separates the allocation of income and the distribution of income. It frees the labour market from social-political redistribution tasks. But it also corrects the distribution effects of the labour market. It takes something away from the better-off to give it to those who earn little or nothing.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Capitalism K
Levin-Waldman, Professor of Public Policy at Metropolitan College, ’18 [Oren, 04-23-2018, tadfonline.com, “The Inevitability of a Universal Basic Income”] 06-29-2023, RM
Critics of the minimum wage often claim that a minimum wage will result in the substitution of technology for labor, especially in the low-wage labor market. This is not a new idea. George Stigler (Citation1946) long ago observed that either a minimum wage would result in lower employment as employers would lay off workers or hire fewer workers in the future, or it would result in greater productivity. Either employers would find it worth their while to invest in their workers’ human capital so that by becoming more productive, greater efficiency would be achieved, or they would substitute technology for workers. Although Stiglitz presented this as an either/or proposition, the very nature of the global economy suggests that both could occur simultaneously. If higher wages will lead to a substitution of technology and perhaps the full automation of the low-wage and low-skilled economy, then a minimum wage intended to boost otherwise declining wages only hastens the process. But if this result is inevitable because of the march of technology, will there not be a need for a policy that will support millions of workers who will be displaced?
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Capitalism K
Sculos, Florida International University, Political Science Professor, 18
[Bryant W. Sculos, 2018, Creative Commons, “Socialism and Universal Basic Income,” , 6/27/2023, EJ]
The idea that an expansive UBI program could not be a direct challenge to capitalism is frankly laughable. There are two main reasons why a subsistence UBI (or higher) could be a challenge to capitalism, but it is important to note that in the very short-term there is the chance of some increase in stability brought to the capitalist system by the Keynesian effects of the policy, if enacted in even a single globally-crucial economy like the US, the EU, or even China or India. 5 This stability would be short-lived and could lead to progress towards socialism, for the reasons that follow.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Capitalism K
Yun et al. 19
Jinhyo Joseph Yun- principal researcher at DGIST and a Professor of SOItmC, KyungBae Park- Research Professor, Seoul National University, Sung Duck Hahm- Dean and Naun Professor of Political Science and Law at University of Seoul, and Dongwook Kim- Lecturer in International Relations in the School of Politics and International Relations at the Australian National University. Basic Income with High Open Innovation Dynamics: The Way to the Entrepreneurial State. J. Open Innov. Technol. Mark. Complex. 2019, 5(3), 41; . . Accessd 5.24.23. AR.
2.2. Philosophical Foundation of Basic Income
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC K’s
Miller, Former Wall Street Journal staff reporter, 19
[John W. Miller, October 2 2019, America: The Jesuit Review, “Universal basic income is having a moment. Can advocates convince a skeptical public?” , 6/25/2023, EJ]
The time is ripe for U.B.I., Mr. Van Parijs said, because the toxic combination of growing inequality, automation and a “more acute awareness of the ecological limits to growth” demands bold policy proposals that reinforce human freedom, justice and dignity.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC PICs
Boso , Professor of Sociology And Environmental Studies, 2006 Et al.
(Alex Boso, Professor of Sociology And Environmental Studies, Irkus Larrinaga, Advocacy Technician at The Spanish Comission for Refugee Aid, Mihaela Vancea, Lecturer Professor in the Department of Research Methods and Diagnostic, “Basic Income for Immigrants Too”, https://basicincome.org/bien/pdf/IrkusFinalVersionFullPaper.pdf”-grh)
Having considered all these arguments, we believe that excluding immigrants from the right to receive a Basic Income cannot be justified by any known criterion. From the human rights perspective (and as the Universal Declaration makes clear), it is completely unacceptable to deny the right to existence to anybody, especially the most vulnerable populations. In present-day circumstances, the right to existence can only be offered through proposals, which, like Basic Income, guarantee at least the minimal material support so that the recipients not only stay alive but can participate as full citizens in the societies in which they live. Independently of the institution(s) that are chosen for distributing a Basic Income, the possible negative effects are not nearly as evident as many critics have suggested. On the contrary, empirical evidence strongly suggests that, in general, this proposal would be more desirable than damaging in social (not to mention ethical) terms.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC PICs
Hilary W. Hoynes, Richard & Rhoda Goldman School of Public Policy, and Jesse Rothstein Goldman School of Public Policy and Department of Economics, ‘19, February, “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME IN THE US AND ADVANCED COUNTRIES,” Working Paper 25538, https://gspp.berkeley.edu/assets/uploads/research/pdf/w25538.pdf
There may be political value in the universal aspect of a UBI, as a way of maintaining widespread support for the program (e.g. as with universal programs such as social security and Medicare) and as a way of signaling social inclusion and that everyone is valued (Lowrey 2018). If this argument has merit, it has implications for program design and the taxes needed to pay for it. A tax on non-UBI income effectively becomes a program phase-out. But separating out the program, and maintaining universality, from the taxes needed to pay for it, may be advantageous even if irrelevant from an accounting perspective.
Another implication of universality, related to potential impacts on social inclusion, is a lack of stigma for UBI recipients. In highly means tested and eligibility-restricted programs, participation reveals information that many consider private, and thus may be stigmatized. This reduces program take-up and the potential reach and benefits of programs (Currie 2006), though may also help target the programs, maximizing impact by reaching those who stand to benefit the most. Take-up rates in AFDC were quite low (about 50%) with stigma cited as one of the reasons (Moffitt 1983). Interestingly, the EITC has fairly high take-up rates (80% or more, see Scholz 1994, Plueger 2009), and ethnographic research has found low stigma with recipients viewing the credit as “my work bonus” rather than a handout (Halpern-Meekin, Edin, Tach and Sykes 2015). How much this derives from the “in work” nature of the credit (G=0) or its high P relative to other U.S. means-tested programs is not known. The UBI could lead to similar results given a universal structure.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP
Cooper, national correspondent at TheWeek.com, ‘20 [Ryan, 05-19-2020, the week, “The wrong way to fight poverty”] 06-27-2023, RM
Here's how the EITC works. If you make a small amount of labor income during the year, it will add to that income depending on the characteristics of your household and how much money you make. For a family with two children in 2018, for instance, it added 40 cents to every dollar earned (or "phased in") up to $14,290 in income, providing a maximum credit of $5,716. But if that family made more than $18,600, the credit would be reduced (or "phased out") with each additional dollar of income, so that if they made more than $45,802, they got nothing. If you are single, or have one child, or three children, the thresholds are different in each case. That's all very complicated, but the basic idea is fairly simple. The government adds to poor people's labor income up to a plateau, then slowly backs off the assistance again for people making more money. If you plot the EITC on a chart, it shows a series of trapezoids for each household category, which is why many have taken to using that shape as a name for this style of policy. Democrats are smitten with trapezoids. The EITC itself was seriously boosted during the Clinton administration. During her presidential campaign, Hillary Clinton proposed making the Child Tax Credit into an EITC-style trapezoid. Rep. Ro Khanna and Senator Sherrod Brown proposed a major expansion of the EITC in 2017. Senator Kamala Harris' (D-Calif.) LIFT Act is also essentially a beefed-up EITC. Joe Biden's campaign platform would allow single workers over 65 (who are currently excluded) to claim the credit.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP
Edwards & Rugy, family chair and scholar CATO Institute, ‘15 [Chris & Veronique, 10-14-2015, CATO Institute, “Earned Income Tax Credit: Small Benefits, Large Costs”] 06-27-2023, RM
The EITC is a huge program. In 2015 it will provide an estimated $69 billion in benefits to 28 million recipients. The EITC is the largest federal cash transfer program for low-income households. Benefits are available to household with earnings from employment. While the EITC is administered through the tax code, it is primarily a spending program. The EITC is "refundable," meaning that individuals who pay no income taxes are nonetheless eligible to receive a payment from the U.S. Treasury. Of the $69 billion in benefits this year, about 88%, or $60 billion, is spending. Articles by liberal and conservative pundits regarding the EITC often make it seem as if there are few downsides to the program. The EITC is aimed at reducing poverty and encouraging work. Alas, there is no free lunch with subsidy programs. The EITC has a high error and fraud rate, and for most recipients it creates a disincentive to increase earnings. Also, the refundable part of the EITC imposes a $60 billion cost on other taxpayers, reducing their incentives to work, invest, and pursue other productive activities. We conclude that the costs of the EITC are likely higher than the benefits. As such, the program should be cut, not expanded. Policymakers could better aid low-income workers by removing government barriers to investment, job creation, and entrepreneurship.