2023
GDI
Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves CC
Suchnabel, economist, and European Central Bank Executive Board member,2023
[Isabel Schnabel, economist and member of the Executive Board of the European Central Bank, 10 January 2023, European Central Bank, “Monetary policy tightening and the green transition”, DOA 7-3-23 DD]
Over the past year, we have moved forcefully to contain inflation by first stopping net asset purchases and then by raising our key policy rates by a cumulative two and a half percentage points. We have also announced that the Eurosystem will no longer reinvest all of the principal payments from maturing securities in the asset purchase programme (APP).
2023
GDI
Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Avoids Fism DA
Ross Veolia North America Chief Sustainability Officer, et al 21 [Dave“, March 5, 2021, Troutman Pepper, Don’t Forget the States as You Grapple with Federal Regulation," JD Supra, https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/don-t-forget-the-states-as-you-grapple-5333302/, Accessed: 7-12-23, /MB]
Historically, federal enforcement displaces state enforcement, either because the federal government demands primacy or because states defer to the federal lead and reallocate their enforcement and compliance assistance resources to other priorities. Many states for that second reason may not mind a more active federal role. Others, however, prefer to manage enforcement within their borders under their delegated federal authorities or under other state programs. One concern for those states is that heavy-handed federal involvement and elongated negotiations may alter state relationships with the regulated community, or with the federal government. More active federal enforcement also tends to increase federal audits and oversight of state programs, creating further opportunity to erode the federal-state relationship.
At base, the regulated community and the environment are better served by efficient government focused on compliance assistance and preventative measures, with targeted enforcement used to level the regulatory playing field across industry sector groups.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Monetary Policy True
[Troy Segal, Bankrate Senior Editor,June 07, 2023,Investopedia,“Monetary Policy vs. Fiscal Policy: What's the Difference?” ,https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/100314/whats-difference-between-monetary-policy-and-fiscal-policy.asp DOA 7-8-23 DD]
While the overall goal of monetary and fiscal policy is generally the same—to influence the economy—there are inherent differences between the two.
Among the key differences between monetary and fiscal policy is the party responsible for carrying them out. Monetary policy is carried out by a nation's central bank, such as the Fed in the U.S., the Bank of Canada (BOC), and the Bank of England. Fiscal policy, on the other hand, is the sole responsibility of a country's government.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Monetary Policy True
[Anne, ,March 18, 2019,Bizfluent ,“Examples of Monetary Policy” , , DOA 7-8-23 DD/CC]
In the U.S., the Federal Reserve maintains control over our money supply, issuing currency as needed and making decisions that support the stability of our economy. These policies and decisions are called monetary policy and they ensure that unemployment levels are low, the gross domestic product (GDP) maintains stability, prices remain stable, foreign exchange rates are relatively predictable and select sectors are growing properly. The actions of the Federal Reserve are intended to create the kind of stability that empowers our nation to thrive and prevents crashes that result in bank runs and other economically disastrous dynamics.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
2NC › NB OV
[Keith Miller, Montgomery County Revenue Authority-CEO,2023, Future of Working,“11 Advantages and Disadvantages of Monetary Policy”, DOA 7-8-23 DD]
A monetary policy is a process undertaken by the government, central bank or currency board to control the availability and supply of money, as well as the amount of bank reserves and loan interest rates. Its other goals are said to include maintaining balance in exchange rates, addressing unemployment problems and most importantly stabilizing the economy. In the US, the Federal Reserve System is the agency executing monetary policy, which can either be contractionary or expansionary, with the former aiming to slow down the supply and even limit it to prevent the devaluation of assets and slow down inflation and the latter increasing the supply of money by lowering loan interest rates to encourage businesses to expand and cut down unemployment rates during recession. Basically, the agency decides how much interest rates would be imposed on banks in terms of borrowing, where banks would also be the ones to determine how high these rates will they be asking from the borrowers.
During elections, the controversial issue of monetary policy is ironically avoided by hopeful candidates, who would talk about other matters except for this subject. Why, it would seem that this topic has its own set of complicated and vague perks and setbacks, with the importance for people to understand what it really is and what its implications in our daily lives. To have a well-informed opinion on this subject, let us take a look at its advantages and disadvantages.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
2NC › NB OV
Adam Hayes, Economic Sociologist ,April 14, 2022,Investopedia, “Fiscal Policy vs. Monetary Policy: Pros Cons” https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/050615/fiscal-vs-monetary-policy-pros-cons.asp, DOA 7-8-23 DD/CC]
Raising taxes can be unpopular and politically dangerous to implement.
The effect of fiscal stimulus is muted when the money put into the economy through tax savings or government spending is spent on imports, sending that money abroad instead of keeping it in the local economy.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Monetary Policy CP › 1NC › Shell
Monetary policy solves for inflation, lowers unemployment, minimizes economic inequality, and works more efficiently than the fiscal policy
Tax Policy Center 20 (May 2020, Tax Policy Center, , accessed 7-2-2023 CC)
Monetary policy—adjustments to interest rates and the money supply—can play an important role in combatting economic slowdowns. Such adjustments can be made quickly, and monetary authorities devote considerable resources to monitoring and analyzing the economy. Monetary policy can offset a downturn because lower interest rates reduce consumers’ cost of borrowing to buy big-ticket items such as cars or houses. For firms, monetary policy can also reduce the cost of investment. For that reason, lower interest rates can increase spending by both households and firms, boosting the economy.
The Federal Reserve can adjust monetary policy more quickly than the president and Congress can adjust fiscal policy. Because most contractions in economic activity last for only a few quarters, a prompt policy response is crucial. Yet fiscal policy in practice responds slowly to changes in economic conditions: it takes time first to enact a stimulus bill and then to implement it, and time for the spending increases or tax reductions to reach consumers’ pockets. As a result, the effect of fiscal stimulus on household and business spending may come too late.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Impacts › Rate Hikes Risk Economic Instability
[Steven, Carlos, & Franz Ulrich, 6-7-23, AEI, “Financial Spillovers Of Rising U.S. Interest Rates”, , accessed 7-15-23, EH]
The rapid rise in interest rates in the United States poses a significant challenge to emerging market and
developing economies (EMDEs). As the Federal Reserve has pivoted toward a more hawkish stance to rein in inflation, a substantial part of the sharp increases in U.S. interest rates since early 2022 has been driven by shocks that capture changes in perceptions of the Fed’s reaction function. These reaction shocks are associated with especially adverse financial market effects in EMDEs, including a higher likelihood of experiencing a financial crisis. Their effects also appear to be more pronounced in EMDEs with greater economic vulnerabilities. These findings suggest that major central banks can alleviate adverse spillovers through proper communication that clarifies their reaction functions. They also highlight that EMDEs need to adjust macroeconomic and financial policies to mitigate the negative impact of rising global and U.S. interest rates.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Impacts › Rapid Inflation Impact
Smialek, New York Times Federal Reserve reporter, 7-12-23
[Jeanna, 7-12-23, The New York Times, “Inflation Cools Sharply in June, Good News for Consumers and the Fed,” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/12/business/economy/inflation-economy-fed-rates.html#:~:text=Inflation%20Cools%20Sharply-,Inflation%20Cools%20Sharply%20in%20June%2C%20Good%20News%20for%20Consumers%20and,off%20a%20“soft%20landing.”, accessed 7-15-23, DG]
What is inflation? Inflation is a loss of purchasing power over time, meaning your dollar will not go as far tomorrow as it did today. It is typically expressed as the annual change in prices for everyday goods and services such as food, furniture, apparel, transportation and toys.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Internal Links › AT – No Interest Rate Impact
Guida, POLITICO Economic Reporter, 6-30-23
[Victoria, 6/30/23, POLITICO, “Inflation is dropping. But it’s no time for a victory lap,” , Accessed 7/8/2023, J.D., also AS]
THE FED’S ASSIGNMENT — The Federal Reserve just got its latest report card.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Internal Links › Market Internal Link
US Bank Wealth Management, 23
[US Bank Wealth Management, 1/4/23, US Bank, “The continued impact of COVID-19 on financial markets” https://www.usbank.com/investing/financial-perspectives/market-news/how-does-the-covid-vaccine-affect-the-economy.html, 7/15/23, MR]
While the stock market enjoyed a solid recovery in 2021 as most of the world started to reopen, optimism started to slide in 2022 due to , the , U.S. political tensions and the global impact of China’s pandemic response. Wall Street experienced its worst year since 2008’s Great Recession. The S&P 500 index fell 19.4%, and the Down Jones Industrial Average fell 8.9%. Tech stocks were some of the worst performers, down between 22% and 66%.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Internal Links › Spending Drives Monetary Policy
Mason, New Finance CEO, 7-7-23
[John M, 7/7/23, Seeking Alpha, “Federal Reserve Watch: Higher Interest Rates” , 7/15/23, MR]
Right now, the Congressional Budget Office estimates that $24.6 trillion in new government debt will be generated in the next 10 years to pile on top of the existing $31.4 trillion of debt that now exists.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Links › Link – Employment Increases Inflation
[Jeffrey, 6-23-23, RealClear Markets, “What’s Monetary About Interest Rates?”, , accessed 7-15-23, EH]
In October 2018, St. Louis Fed President James Bullard claimed his organization had killed the work of ancient economist AW Phillips. It was the latter who has had his name, voluntary or not, attached to the eponymous curve at the center of this and seemingly every modern Economics mystery. And a big one was brewing in ’18.
The unemployment rate was falling and by official accounts the economy was doing better than well. Sliding those views into the Phillips Curve, policymakers at the Fed worried inflation was at risk of heating up. After all, at heart the curve posits a relationship between employment and price changes.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Uniqueness › AT – Labor Market Hot Now
Irvine, Politico Playbook producer, 23
[Bethany, 7-7-23, Politico Playbook PM, “Playbook PM: What the June job numbers mean”, , Accessed 7-15-23 DD]
While last month’s jobs report pleasantly defied expectations from economists, this month’s numbers from the Labor Department came in slightly lower than expected — indicating a job market that, while healthy, may be cooling off.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Uniqueness › AT – Uniqueness (Inflation Declining) Overwhelms the Link
Folley & Lane, The Hill Business and Economy reporters, 7-11-23
[Aris & Sylvan, 7-11-23, The Hill, “Inflation falls to lowest level in two years”, , accessed 7-15-23, RM]
Prices are still rising, but at the slowest annual rate in two years and barely moving higher on a monthly basis, according to data released Wednesday by the Labor Department.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Uniqueness › AT – Uniqueness (Inflation Declining) Overwhelms the Link
Smialek, New York Times Federal Reserve reporter, 6/21/23
(Jeanna, 6/21/23, New York Times, “Is the Inflation Battle Won? Not Yet.” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/21/business/economy/us-inflation-fed.html Accessed:7/15/23-grh)
The Fed has spent the past 15 months locked in an aggressive war against inflation, raising interest rates above 5 percent in an attempt to get price increases back down to a more normal pace. Last week its officials announced that they were skipping a rate increase in June, giving themselves more time to see how the already enacted changes are playing out across the economy.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Uniqueness › AT – Uniqueness (Inflation Declining) Overwhelms the Link
Smialek, New York Times Federal Reserve reporter, 7/12/23
[Jeanna, 7/12/23, New York Times, “Inflation Cools Sharply in June, Good News for Consumers and the Fed,” , accessed 7/15/23, eo]
Fed officials are likely to avoid declaring victory just yet. Policymakers are still trying to assess whether the moderation is likely to be quick and complete. They do not want to allow price increases to linger at slightly elevated levels for too long, because if they do, consumers and businesses could adjust their behavior in ways that make more rapid inflation a permanent feature of the economy.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Uniqueness › Framing/AT – Inflation High
Cassidy, The New Yorker staff writer, 6-17-23
[John, 6-17-23, The New Yorker, “Why Isn’t Joe Biden Getting More Credit For A Big Drop In Inflation?”, , accessed 7-15-23, EH]
What a difference a year makes. Last June, the inflation rate hit a four-decade high of 9.1 per cent, a development that dominated the news for weeks. At the time, the Federal Reserve was sharply raising interest rates to tackle climbing prices, and many economists were for this year. Barely able to contain their glee, Republicans were rattling on about “Bidenflation,” even though some of the main factors driving the rise in prices had little or nothing to do with the President (the and the , to name two).
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Uniqueness › AT – Fed Will Raise Rates
Halaschak, Washington Examiner, 7/16/23
Zachary, 7-16-2023, Washington Examiner, "Days of Fed’s historic tightening cycle may be numbered, thanks to inflation news," , Accessed 7/16/23, S.A.M
The Federal Reserve might be close to the end of its tightening cycle after more than a year of at times aggressive rate revisions, as signs indicate that inflation is coming down.
2023
GDI
Evidence
NEG – Inflation Updates › Uniqueness › AT – Fed Will Raise Rates
Guilford, Wall Street Journal Economics Reporter, & Timiraos, Wall Street Journal Chief Economic Correspondent, 7-12-23
[Gwynn & Nick, 7/12/23, The Wall Street Journal, “Inflation Eased to 3% in June, Slowest Pace in More Than Two Years,” , Accessed 7/15/23, EP]
Inflation cooled last month to its slowest pace in more than two years, giving Americans relief from a painful period of rising prices and boosting the chances that the Federal Reserve will stop raising interest rates after an expected increase this month.