2022
Michigan
Negative
Rememory
David A. Deptula et.al , Marc R. Devore, Emma Salisbury, Michael Hunzeker 22, 3-16-2022, "6 Things NATO Can Do to Help Ukraine Right Now," Foreign Policy, https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/03/16/nato-ukraine-support-russia-war-help-ideas/
Facilitate civilian cyber activities. Civilian hacking groups, including Anonymous, have already begun independently targeting Russia and Belarus by crashing government websites, leaking classified documents, and hacking state-run media outlets. These grassroot cyberattacks are certainly eye-catching. Yet they are unlikely to fundamentally blunt Russia’s war effort, if only because they are being executed by a loose-knit community of cyber activists that possess high levels of technical skills but lack the contextual knowledge to maximize the damage of their efforts. NATO can help fill this gap by finding ways to “guide from behind” to coordinate what will otherwise amount to a series of disparate and uncoordinated attacks. Russia takes this approach to an extreme by employing private actors as cyber auxiliaries. During their 2007 distributed denial-of-service attacks on Estonia, Russian intelligence agencies provided software and guidance to ordinary citizens or “patriotic hackers” who wanted to punish Estonia for removing a World War II-era statue memorializing the Red Army’s victory over Nazi Germany. NATO should take a different approach. Because many hackers—especially those affiliated with groups like Anonymous—are deeply distrustful of government authority, NATO should not recruit cyber activists to work for U.S. or European government agencies. Instead, NATO should adopt a hands-off approach that maximizes plausible deniability and avoids antagonizing hackers who harbor anti-government sentiments. Rather than hire hackers and direct their operations, NATO can suggest cyber objectives that just so happen to be of particular strategic importance. For example, NATO cyberunits could set up front organizations that identify lesser-known Russian government agencies, Russian companies that produce military components, and organizations that are known fronts for Russian cyber efforts. More controversially, NATO could also facilitate knowledge transfers by finding creative ways to leak bits of code or zero-day exploits that can help hackers engineer attacks on Russian networks. NATO member states should also begin to consider ways to protect hackers operating on their territory from legal liability and prosecution by Russia and its allies.a.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Imperialism
1AC Campbell ’19 — Horace; Professor of African American Studies and Political Science, Syracuse University. He is the author of Global NATO and the Catastrophic Failure in Libya. April 9, 2019; “Global NATO: A 70-Year Alliance of Oppressors in Crisis”; CounterPunch; ; //CYang//-ekh-
While the energies of many are focused on the issues of electoral politics, progressives must remain alert to new false flag operations of NATO. We are in a revolutionary moment and revolutionaries cannot be pessimistic. There are three important tasks: dismantle NATO, fight imperialism, racism, and white supremacy globally and be at the forefront for social justice and solidarity in all parts of the world.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Imperialism
Garcia, 12 [Denise Garcia is an Assistant Professor of Political Science and International Relations at Northeastern University, 2012, accessed on 7-18-2022, Cornell International Affairs Review, "Banning Evil: Cluster Munitions and the Successful Formation of a Global Prohibition Regime", http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/1244/banning-evil-cluster-munitions-and-the-successful-formation-of-a-global-prohibition-regime]/ISEE
Cluster munitions constitute a substantial part of the military arsenals of all major powers. Their development, procurement and stockpile are a central hard component of national security. Yet, in less than two years, cluster munitions were banned by an international treaty negotiated outside the normal channels, the United Nations (UN), and spectacularly, in less than two years. The treaty is the Convention on Cluster Munitions (CCM) signed in Oslo in December 2008, by almost one hundred states, and quickly enforced force (August 2010). Realists would dismiss such cases and say that the politics of national security is impervious to change and influence. A few prominent scholars have demonstrated the role of other actors beyond the state in bringing change to other issues that are close to the national security of states. The case of the powerful convention that banned landmines in 1997 proved to be the first hard case in which an issue of national security was brought to change by the penetrating and coordinated influence of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) worldwide. Differently from landmines, cluster munitions are a highly profitable industry and have a vital place in the military doctrines of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) allies and others. One element that fundamentally differentiates landmines from cluster munitions is economic. The latter are much more costly to produce and the trade is substantially more profitable. A major part of global artillery arsenals is made up of cluster bombs. Eighty per cent of United States (US) artillery ammunition, for instance, consists of such munitions. Russia, China and the US are the biggest producers. Marchers at the May 2008 Dublin Diplomatic Conference on Cluster Munitions that produced the Convention on Cluster Munitions Marchers at the May 2008 Dublin Diplomatic Conference on Cluster Munitions that produced the Convention on Cluster Munitions I argue that the ban on cluster munitions was brought to life by a stout global prohibition regime by a more complex set of arrangements and coalitions than the landmines case and it represents a moral prohibition regime. In the cluster munitions ban case, few states were as progressive as NGOs. The ban was brought to fruition by the exceptional combination of state and non-state activism, a new form of diplomacy for the 21st century, and the commanding moral force of international humanitarian law (IHL) as a robust and compelling previously existing normative structure. Clearly, the Convention that banned cluster bombs went beyond IHL but benefited from this powerful normative framework. Demonstrators at the May 2008 Dublin Diplomatic Conference on Cluster Munitions that produced the Convention on Cluster Munitions Demonstrators at the May 2008 Dublin Diplomatic Conference on Cluster Munitions that produced the Convention on Cluster Munitions The ban of cluster bombs is about military doctrines succumbing to the higher authority of moral and humanitarian concerns. In 1997, the International Campaign to Ban Landmines (ICBL), led by Nobel Peace Laureate chief negotiator Jody Williams, leading civil society worldwide, successfully banned antipersonnel landmines with the Ottawa Treaty. Yet once again, another set of weapons, namely cluster munitions, has gained prominence on the international agenda. Jody Williams, said upon receiving the Nobel Peace Prize: the landmine does not recognize the peace, after the war is over, it keeps on killing. Cluster munitions also present the same indiscriminate elements with the same ‘unnecessary suffering' component to civilian populations. In summer 2006, the world watched in dismay, the brief but devastating war between Israel and Hezbollah when the Israeli army fired as many as four million cluster bombs into Lebanese territory during the short-lived war. Unfortunately, de-mining experts say, up to 1 million cluster bombs failed to explode immediately and continue to threaten civilians. Although the war ended in a month, Lebanese citizens continue to live in fear of leftover munitions; unexploded cluster bomb remnants that remain scattered across the country. Due to anti-personal characteristic of cluster munitions, which often leaves children as victims, advocates for banning the weapons created a united voice. The international outcry for the catastrophic humanitarian consequences of deploying these weapons in densely populated areas, in the summer 2006, helped spark the global movement to ban cluster munitions and to create a global prohibition regime. Some of the other serious precedent situations include during the Cold War, Laos, most prominently. After the end of the Cold War Afghanistan, Iraq, Chechnya, Kosovo, and the EthiopiaEritrea conflict were some of the most notable cases. It is important to notice that the process towards a ban is more than a century old. However the focus of this article will be since the summer 2006. What happened then in Lebanon constituted the shock event that triggered all the action for global prohibition treaty-making. I use primarily the framework of the illuminating theory of global prohibition regimes to start explaining how this has happened. The ban process started with the creation of the "Oslo Process", a track-two diplomacy course of action, i.e. with the government of Norway's call to negotiate a ban on clusters outside the UN in November 2006. The Oslo Process started with 46 states who committed to begin negotiations in February 2007 towards creating an international instrument to ban the use of cluster munitions (Oslo Conference on Cluster Munitions, 2008). Over the following year and a half, several conferences around the world were held to continue to craft the prohibition regime on banning cluster munitions. Three months after Oslo, states met again in Lima in May 2007, and again in Vienna in December. Discussions were held to work towards creating a treaty, with negotiations that spanned from specific definitions of cluster munitions to the extent of the assistance to victims. By February 2008, states met in New Zealand reaching an agreement known as the Wellington Declaration. This was a commitment by states to attend the Dublin conference three months later, setting final negotiations for a treaty to ban cluster munitions. The conference in Dublin lasted 10 days in May 2008 resulting in 107 states that signed and decided upon a final treaty.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Fem IR
Millar et al 21 Dr. Katharine Millar (Assistant Professor of International Relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) and holds a doctoral degree from the University of Oxford, United Kingdom. Her research interests lie in the relationship between gender, sexuality, politics and violence. Her current research examines gender and cybersecurity; gender, race, militarism, and contemporary populism(s)) et al, 2021, " Gender approaches to cybersecurity: design, defence and response," United Nations Institution for Disarmament Research, https://s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/igc-production/5VmjuiWvoa7oVEK1Y2ErHT4HxYMu2lUJ.pdf
3.3 Recommendations » International standards organizations, in cooperation with national standards bodies, should identify, and collect data on, the areas where cybersecurity standards have gender effects. » Based on data collection and analysis, current cybersecurity standards should be revised in a gender-sensitive and gender-responsive manner. » All proposed new cybersecurity standards should be subject to a gender impact assessment to ensure gender sensitivity and gender responsiveness. Practitioners should be given gender and cybersecurity training to support them in conducting these assessments. 25 GENDER APPROACHES TO CYBERSECURITY » International standards organizations and national standards bodies should ensure that all working groups developing cybersecurity standards have gender and intersectional equality experts. » International standards organizations and national standards bodies should ensure diverse gender representation in cybersecurity standardmaking processes, in stakeholder consultations and within standards organizations.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Fem IR
Väyrynen, 2019. Tarja Väyrynen is a professor of Peace and Conflict Research and a director of Tampere Peace Research Institute (TAPRI). Her research interests include conflict resolution and peacebuilding, feminist theory and post-colonial theory. “Mundane peace and the politics of vulnerability: a nonsolid feminist research agenda,” Peacebuilding, 7:2, 146-159, //barn
Choreographies do not happen in a vacuum: they are enacted in the corporeal practices people deploy in the everyday to form and maintain movement within practices of power. For the actors, then, choreographies are always partially pre-given, already planned and presented as fixed lines to be followed – yet the interactional resources of bodies can be used to remould the situation, as my vignettes demonstrate. Looking closer at these everyday techniques of interaction reveals that choreographies are in fact open to surprises and even disturbances, and tend to produce extraordinary acts out of the ordinary.57
Because the everyday is made and remade thorough the changing positions and relations of bodies, choreographies are always situationally enacted in events. As such, choreography allows, in my view, the study of embodied micro-practices of peace. In short, the immediacy of the everyday and its encounters, as well as their relevance for peace, calls for the analysis of events and their corporeal choreographies where acknowledgement and recognition emerge. This ‘corporeal turn’ in peace thinking points research towards events and processes that are marked by their mundaneness and ordinariness – their everydayness – as well as towards embodied data collected from multiple sources.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
DoS CP › 2AC---Links to Tradeoff
Young 20 [Thomas-Durell Young, Senior Lecturer at the Naval Postgraduate School; "The "Politics" of Security Cooperation and Security Assistance"; Office of the Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Army for Defense Exports and Cooperation; Published: 9-10-2020; Accessed: 6-18-2022; https://www.dasadec.army.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/2344014/the-politics-of-security-cooperation-and-security-assistance/; KL]
Since 2006, the previous position of the Department of State, which originally had the lead in funding (and therefore some influence in controlling) these activities, has been eclipsed. While it continues to control funding for its many Title 22 programs, they are largely executed via DSCA and the MILDEPs. Although Congress has recognized that it has, in effect, created the basis for confusion via the two departments’ dual congressionally mandated authorities and authorizations, a political decision to create a clear lead agent for these activities remains missing. One will return to the U.S. Government’s well-used practice of “fudging” when it comes to identifying who’s in charge.
2022
Michigan
Affirmative
Digital Cyclops › 2AC – AT: Antiblackness K
McGlotten 14 [Shaka McGlotten, 02-13-2014, “Black Data,” Traversing Technologies, <<Shaka is a social anthropologist & Professor of Media Studies at the State University of New York>>,
Thurston’s work on race and technology provides a template for my talk today. Here I engage in a Black queer call and response with a few key areas in culture. I use an eclectic group of artifacts: Thurston’s slideshow, an interview with Barack Obama in the wake of the NSA surveillance scandal, the artwork of Zach Blas, and a music video about technology and gentrification. I do this to proffer the heuristic Black data. This heuristic, I suggest, offers some initial political and analytical traction for Black queer studies to more fully engage with the theories, effects, and affects of network cultures. And although there are some significant bodies of literature in science and technology studies, as well as cultural and media studies, that grapple with issues of race, there are only a handful of issues from Black queer studies itself that really address sexuality and new media head on.
So here I use Black data to think through some of the historical and contemporary ways that Black queer people, like other people of African descent and people of color more broadly, are hailed by big data, through which techniques of race and racism reduce our lives to mere numbers. We appear as commodities, revenue streams, statistical deviations, or vectors of risk. Big data also refers to the efforts of states and corporations to capture, predict, and control political and consumer behavior. In my reading, then, Black data is also a response to big data’s call. And I’m going to offer some readings that outline possible political and affective vectors—some ways to refuse the call or perhaps even to hang up.
2022
Michigan
Affirmative
Digital Cyclops › 2AC – AT: Feminist Cyborg K
Haraway & Gane 06 [Dona Haraway & Nicholas Gane, 12-01-2006, “When We have Never Been Human, What Is to Be Done?: Interview with Donna Haraway,”, <<Donna is a Professor in the History of Consciousness Department & Feminist Studies Department at the University of California>>, Theory, Culture & Society]
NG: One thing I find fascinating about the ‘Manifesto’ is its complex mix of feminism and cybernetics. It is stated, for example, that ‘Human beings, like any other component or subsystem, must be localized in a system architecture whose basic modes of operation are probabilistic’ (Haraway, 1991a: 212). This is a radical extension of Claude Shannon and Warren Weaver’s famous Mathematical Theory of Communication (1949), in which information is defined in statistical terms. In an interview conducted in 1999 you said that you were familiar with the work of Norbert Wiener at the point of writing the ‘Manifesto’ (Haraway, 2004: 324), but were Shannon and Weaver also key points of reference? And what of cybernetics more generally – is this a field which continues to influence your work? DH: Yes, Shannon and Weaver were there. I had read them and the Macy conferences were there more generally. My dissertation adviser was Evelyn Hutchinson (1903–91), who was a really wonderful man: a theoretical ecologist, mathematician, biologist, natural historian, studier of Italian medieval manuscripts – a polymath of his generation, English by origin (see Hutchinson, 1979). I fled to his lab from developmental biology and its molecular incarnations because all my cells were dying in the lab – partly! But mainly because I was intellectually unhappy and I finally had to get it that biology for me was a cultural-material practice. I needed to locate biology in its intersection with many other communities of practice, made up of entangled humans and others, living and not. Evelyn Hutchinson’s lab made that possible. In his lab we read things like Simone Weil, Shannon and Weaver, and Virginia Woolf – those were the ‘biology’ texts that we read as part of his lab group. It was not a biology lab group in the narrow sense. It was a ‘what’s interesting the world’ lab group. And a lot of people that came out of Evelyn’s lab – like Robert MacArthur (1930–72) – [were] really important biologists. MacArthur’s colleague-ship with E.O. Wilson on island biogeography (MacArthur and Wilson, 2001 [1967]) is really important. MacArthur was a major cybernetic theorist in animal behaviour and a fabulous ornithologist. 138 Theory, Culture & Society 23(7–8) Downloaded from tcs.sagepub.com at University of Waikato Library on June 8, 2014 Anyway, a lot of people came out of Evelyn’s lab deeply interested in various aspects of cybernetics, including me. But how could you not be interested in that stuff in those years? The quote you just read is not so much what I want to be the case but my sitting down and looking at what seemed to me to be an imperative that knowledge projects these days constitute their objects of attention in the Foucauldian sense – as discourse constitutes it own objects of attention. This is not a relativist position. This is not about things being merely constructed in a relative sense. This is about those objects that we non-optionally are. Our systems are probabilistic information entities. It is not that this is the only thing that we or anyone else is. It is not an exhaustive description but it is a non-optional constitution of objects, of knowledge in operation. It is not about having an implant, it is not about liking it. This is not some kind of blissed-out technobunny joy in information. It is a statement that we had better get it – this is a worlding operation. Never the only worlding operation going on, but one that we had better inhabit as more than a victim. We had better get it that domination is not the only thing going on here. We had better get it that this is a zone where we had better be the movers and the shakers, or we will be just victims. So inhabiting the cyborg is what this manifesto is about. The cyborg is a figuration but it is also an obligatory worlding – that inhabiting it you can’t not get it – that it’s a military project, a late capitalist project in deep collaboration with new forms of imperial war – McNamara’s electronic battlefield is of course a major parent of cyborg worlds – also the Bell telephone company. And much more than that – cyborgs open radical possibilities at the same time. This is like Bruno Latour, but I give more space to the critic in the basement than Bruno Latour. I have more sympathy with critical theory than Bruno does – much more. And I’m much more willing to live with indigestible intellectual and political heritages. I need to hold on to impossible heritages more than I suspect Bruno wants to. Our kinds of creativity take different directions but they’re allied. So yes, Shannon and Weaver are in there big time. Cybernetics is in there in various forms. Gregory Bateson is in there too, and through Bateson’s lineage the second/third order of cybernetic worlds that Katherine Hayles analyses (see Hayles, 1999). I’m sympathetic to certain kinds of cybernetic efforts to think through autopoiesis. Lynn Margulis is also in there with the whole Gaia hypothesis of the world, including her symbiogenesis stuff. I am nonetheless deeply resistant to systems theories of all kinds, including so-called third-order cybernetics and the autopoiesis and structural coupling approaches. I’m not really happy there, but I remember that there is much more than Norbert Wiener in cybernetics. NG: There seems to have been a general resurgence of interest in cybernetics as debates over the ‘posthuman’ have come to the fore (for example in Hayles, 1999). The subtitle of your 1992 essay ‘Ecce Homo, Ain’t (Ar’n’t) Gane & Haraway – Interview with Donna Haraway 139 Downloaded from tcs.sagepub.com at University of Waikato Library on June 8, 2014 I a Woman, and Inappropriate/d Others’ is ‘The Human in a Post-humanist Landscape’ (in Haraway, 2004: 47–61). What do you take this term ‘posthuman’ to mean? Is it a concept that you continue to find useful? DH: I’ve stopped using it. I did use it for a while, including in the ‘Manifesto’. I think it’s a bit impossible not to use it sometimes, but I’m trying not to use it. Kate Hayles writes this smart, wonderful book How We Became Posthuman. She locates herself in that book at the right interface – the place where people meet IT apparatuses, where worlds get reconstructed as information. I am in strong alliance with her insistence in that book, namely getting at the materialities of information. Not letting anyone think for a minute that this is immateriality rather than getting at its specific materialities. That I’m with, that sense of ‘how we became posthumanist’. Still, human/posthuman is much too easily appropriated by the blissed-out, ‘Let’s all be posthumanists and find our next teleological evolutionary stage in some kind of transhumanist technoenhancement.’ Posthumanism is too easily appropriated to those kinds of projects for my taste. Lots of people doing posthumanist thinking, though, don’t do it that way. The reason I go to companion species is to get away from posthumanism.
2022
Michigan
Affirmative
Digital Cyclops › 2AC – AT: Settler Colonialism K
Castro-Gómez 7 [Santiago Castro-Gómez, 04-03-2007, “The Missing Chapter of Empire: Postmodern reorganization of coloniality and post-Fordist capitalism,” <<Santiago is a Colombian philosopher & professor at the Pontificia Universidad Javeriana>>, Cultural Studies Vol. 21, Nos. 2&3 March/May 2007, T&F Online]
The centrality of knowledge in the global economy and in imperialistic politics of development is made more evident when we examine the subject of the environment. Beginning with the Conference in Rio already mentioned, the environment becomes the backbone of sustainable development. It was at the conference where this Conference that The Agreement on Biological Diversity was signed, obligating signatory nations to protect their genetic resources given that now genetic resources were considered part of the ‘common heritage of mankind’. The United Nations’ interest in the conservation and management if this ‘heritage’ is clear: genetic resources have economic value and mean benefits for those businesses that work with the latest technologies in the areas of biotechnology and genetic engineering. In this way, the handling of information and abstract languages what H/N call ‘immaterial production’ is placed at the center of the capitalist, postmodern business.
In effect, the identification, alteration and transference of genetic material by way of knowledge have economic applications in the fields of agriculture and health. In the agricultural sector, biotechnology works by incrementing the production of food by means of the production of transgenic plants that are most resistant to plagues and insects, and less vulnerable to chemical fumigation. In 1999, 90 percent of the soya beans produced in Argentina and 33 percent of the corn produced in the United States originate from transgenic crops, and that percentage is even higher for products like cotton, tomatoes, tobacco, sugar cane, asparagus, strawberries, papaya, kiwi, barley, cucumber and zucchini. The biotechnological transformation of agriculture is a profitable business for the food industry and is controlled by a handful of businesses specialized in biotechnical research. The same occurs in the health sector. The pharmaceutical industry is concentrated in the production of medicines with a biological basis that are used in the treatment of illnesses like cancer, hemophilia, and hepatitis B, not to mention the growing production of generic medication and pharmaceutical drugs. It is estimated that the market for medication derived from pant extracts or biological products generates profits that hover around four hundred thousand million dollars annually, earnings that are concentrated in the hands of a small number of multinational businesses that monopolize ground-breaking research.14
2022
Michigan
Affirmative
Digital Cyclops › 2AC – AT: Settler Colonialism K
Kroker 14 [Arthur Kroker, 2014, “Exits to the Posthuman Future,” <<Professor of Political Science @ the University of Victoria and Director of Pacific Centre for Technology & Culture>>, Polity Press]
Technologies of abandonment: lost dreams of the sustainable “global village” Insurgencies of the periphery: Idle No More, a courageous Indigenous political protest of global significance, takes place in the bitter cold of a Canadian winter.1 Inspired by a hunger strike by an Indigenous woman, Chief Theresa Spence, an Attawapiskat tribal leader, from a community on the shores of James Bay, Idle No More is resistance by the abandoned. Not quiet resistance, but Indigenous collectivities in solidarity, spontaneously organizing as dancing flash mobs moving to the inspiring rhythms of Indigenous drummers in shopping malls, outdoor city squares, blockading busy highways and barricading railway tracks. Day after day, the hunger strike by Chief Spence continues with one simple, but basic, demand: to meet with the Canadian government to negotiate nation-to-nation exploitative land-use policies affecting all the energy sectors that are quickly destroying the land and its Indigenous inhabitants. The government’s official response is the silence of cynical indifference, perhaps based on the political calculation that defeating Indigenous protest will facilitate exploitation of the land. In this case, the themes rise beyond simple politics to the level of Thinking the Future 185 eschatology. As long as Indigenous responsibility for the land and its inhabitants exists, the earth will continue to exist. Disappear Indigenous protest, and the land and its (dissenting) inhabitants may well disappear as well. When McLuhan once said that, in the electronic world, any periphery can quickly become the center of politics, he probably didn’t have in mind a hunger strike undertaken by a single Indigenous woman in a teepee on a small island on the Ottawa River across from the parliament buildings of Canada. Truly one of those insurgencies of the periphery in which great eschatological themes – the future of the land, the very survival of Indigenous peoples, the possible reconciliation of humans with earth, sky, water, and air – achieve such powerful clarity that suddenly the center of politics, Canadian at first, but swiftly by extension any form of politics steered by massive energy projects, gravitates around the profound ethical issues raised by an Indigenous tribal leader who says “no.”
With Idle No More, we are present at the first of the clashes of cosmology that will increasingly dominate the politics and culture of the twenty-first century – a cosmological collision between the system of politics, economy, and information associated with the ruling will to technology and the more profound vision of sustainability emerging from this insurgency of the periphery. If official power can respond only with the silence of indifference, perhaps that is because the masters of the technological universe – political and energy elites – recognize that no mediation is possible in this clash of cosmology, that in the courageous body politics of an Indigenous tribal leader willing to wager her claims to a broader sense of justice on the scales of life and death, that everything is at stake, that there can be no easy reconciliation between these competing life visions because what is really involved here is less a local political protest than a fundamental turning point in the direction of cosmology – technologies of abandonment represented in all their destructive intensity by mass energy projects versus enduring dreams of earth, land, and people mediated by social community and personal responsibility as a common dwelling place. Seemingly everything, today, is environment to the will to technology, not only the natural environment but human nature as well with all that entails for the future of human subjectivity. Transcendental in spirit and driven by a double dialectic of augmentation and incorporation, the will to technology has evolved to a point well in excess of what Nietzsche described as the “will to power” and Heidegger the “will to will.” Perhaps sensing the appearance of an epochal change, that moment when the will to technology began to turn back on itself, the philosopher Hannah Arendt captured the essence of contemporary 186 Crash times when she noted in her last book, Life of the Mind, that the future will be fully enveloped by the metaphysics of the “not-will” – a time of abandonment of all that is not necessary for the self-preservation of the will to technology. In Arendt’s prophetic vision, the historical primacy of conditions for the self-preservation of technique will inevitably result in the nihilism of “not-being,” that moment in which everything that is valued is measured only in its relationship to the self-preservation of the will to technology and, subsequently, everything that is not a condition of self-preservation is abandoned, effectively left behind as surplus remainder. Idle No More, this insurgency of the periphery, this declaration on behalf of a deeper conception of a sustainable environment that speaks to issues of individuals, community, and nature, is a rebellion against this formulation of the will to technology.
2022
Michigan
Affirmative
Digital Cyclops › 2AC – AT: Capitalism K
Wark 19 [Mckenzie Wark, 2019, “Capitalism is Dead: Is this something worse?”, <<Professor of Media & Cultural Studies @ The New School>>, Verso]
A reminder of the thought experiment that threads through these chapters: What if this was no longer capitalism, but something worse? Could we approach this now by describing relations of exploitation and domination in the present, starting with the emerging features, and work back and out and up from that? This chapter plays mostly with the sociological imagination. 1 This is the ability to conceptualize the problem synchronically, as if we could slice through the social formation of the present and look at its anatomy, rather than diachronically, in terms of patterns of development through time (a topic discussed in Chapter 5, a historical fantasia).
Since the sociology we are playing with is vulgar Marxist, our imagination might be drawn initially to some features of the forces of production. It is still the case that extracting useful organic and inorganic matter from the earth is the basis of social existence. And it is still the case that applying vast amounts of energy in the form of fossil fuels and labor to that base matter is still how the endless array of commodities around us come into existence. But both of those processes seem these days to be subordinated to a third form of relation. At the smallest and largest scales, so much of primary production and secondary manufacturing seems to be controlled by rapid flows, extensive archives and complex algorithms whose concrete existence is in a tertiary form—that of information.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
AT: DSCA DA › 2AC---AT: DSCA DA---Russia Already Lost
Jean-Baptiste Jeangene Vilmer, 2-22 (Jean-Baptiste Jeangene Vilmer, Ph.D., director of the Institute for Strategic Research at the French Ministry of the Armed Forces and a nonresident senior fellow at the Europe Center of the Atlantic Council, 2-22-2022, accessed on 5-15-2022, War on the Rocks, “PUTIN LOSES NO MATTER HOW THIS PLAYS OUT, BUT WE MIGHT TOO”, https://warontherocks.com/2022/03/putin-loses-no-matter-how-this-plays-out-but-we-might-too/, HBisevac)
No matter how the war in Ukraine plays out, Putin loses. Even if Russian forces prevail on the ground and in the air, he loses. Even if he takes Kyiv tomorrow, he loses. Russia lacks the forces (and perhaps the will) to occupy Ukraine in the face of a restive civil society and guerrilla movement. And that would be on top of having already reinforced NATO, awakened Europe, isolated his country, ruined its economy, and alienated many Russians, including his “friends.” What happens next depends less on the military outcome of the conflict than on other factors he has already put in motion and that will further affect him. It might seem presumptuous in the first week of a war to predict its outcome and second-order effects for Ukraine, Russia, and the West, but it seems Putin’s defeat is the likely product of five factors: the heavy price of a prospective military victory, the quagmire of an occupation, the strengthening of NATO and European defense, the international isolation of Russia, and the internal contestation which may lead to Putin’s fall. So Putin lost, but it does not mean we win. He knows that he cornered himself and this is precisely where it gets dangerous because he may think that the only way out for him is to escalate.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
AT: DSCA DA › 2AC---AT: DSCA DA---Russia Win Good
Jean-Baptiste Jeangene Vilmer, 2-22 (Jean-Baptiste Jeangene Vilmer, Ph.D., director of the Institute for Strategic Research at the French Ministry of the Armed Forces and a nonresident senior fellow at the Europe Center of the Atlantic Council, 2-22-2022, accessed on 5-15-2022, War on the Rocks, “PUTIN LOSES NO MATTER HOW THIS PLAYS OUT, BUT WE MIGHT TOO”, https://warontherocks.com/2022/03/putin-loses-no-matter-how-this-plays-out-but-we-might-too/, HBisevac)
What this war is destroying is the future of Russia and its people know it. The war in Ukraine is likely to produce immense discontent in Russia, and therefore an immense problem for Putin who, like all dictators, fears first and foremost his own people.
Even before the war, the Russian population was divided on the issue: A poll showed that 50 percent of Russians were supportive of a military intervention. But that was before the all-out attack on Ukraine, the shelling of civilians, the numerous Russian casualties, the international condemnation, the effect of the sanctions, the tumble of the ruble, and the threat of a nuclear war. It is an assumption, but it seems a safe one, that today the opinion of the Russian population has changed, as a number of signs suggest. Since the beginning of the offensive, demonstrations have been organized all over the country. Thousands took to the streets in support of Ukraine, in dozens of cities. Tags “No to the war” appeared everywhere, and the few remaining independent media in the country displayed their opposition to the conflict and their support for the Ukrainian people. Even the political consensus began to crack: Three members of the Russian Parliament, from the Communist Party, who had voted in favor of recognizing the separatist enclaves, are now criticizing the war in Ukraine. The war will be a catalyst for Russian opposition.
2022
Michigan
Evidence
AFFIRMATIVE › AT Arctic War
Jeremy Tasch 20. Professor of Geography & Environmental Planning, Towson University. “Why the Talk of an ‘Artic Cold War’ Is Exaggeration”. Valdai Club. Jul 7 2020. https://valdaiclub.com/a/highlights/why-the-talk-of-an-artic-cold-war-is-exaggeration/
As Russia’s government has promoted a more visible presence in the Arctic—nervously observed by international governments aware of Russia’s increased military presence in its High North—a few related critical points seem often disregarded.
In summer 2007, while both the Mir-1 and Mir-2 submersibles were assisting a planned Russian government expedition to map the seabed, the famous flag-planting performance was funded by Frederik Paulsen, a Swedish pharmaceutical entrepreneur and the event was organized by an Australian-American group of deep-sea exploration enthusiasts. In other words, this feat, which drew the ire of Canada’s Foreign Minister and focused international media attention on a “new Cold War,” was unlikely prearranged either to perform scientific research in support of Russia’s Lomonosov territorial claims nor as a statement of territorial acquisition.
2022
Michigan
Evidence
AFFIRMATIVE › AT Arctic War
Øystein Tunsjø 20, professor and head of the Asia programme at the Norwegian Institute for Defence Studies, Norwegian Defence University College, “The Great Hype: False Visions of Conflict and Opportunity in the Arctic,” Survival, Vol. 62, No. 5, 09-23-2020, https://doi.org/10.1080/00396338.2020.1819649
In recent years there has been an abundance of studies, reports, articles and statements presenting the Arctic as a new frontier for resource extraction and sea lanes of communication.1 These studies claim that the receding Arctic ice provides not just commercial opportunities, but also security challenges that could fuel great-power rivalry and conflict.2 Yet, despite the hype, there is little likelihood of a shipping bonanza or a natural-resource boom in the Arctic.3 This does not mean that climate change is unimportant for the region – we can expect more shipping activity, investment and competition as the ice cap recedes. But it is important to maintain a balanced view of the opportunities and challenges presented by the ‘new Arctic’.4
Equally important, the stakes in a changing Arctic are not high enough to warrant a great-power conflict. As in the past, it remains unlikely that military force will be used to resolve a conflict originating in the Arctic. It is more likely that any potential great-power competition in the High North between Russia and NATO will reflect the more consequential sources of competition and conflict in Eastern or Southern Europe – in other words, that conflict might spill over into the High North from somewhere else.5 Developments in the Arctic appear to have caused some observers to forget that Russia’s recent naval build-up is primarily focused on safeguarding traditional Russian security interests, such as maintaining its sea-based nuclear deterrent and contesting sea lanes of communication in the North Atlantic. Thus, it is a familiar security challenge – Russia’s rivalry with the United States and NATO over the European security order – that has the highest potential for creating conflict in the Arctic.
2022
Michigan
Evidence
AFFIRMATIVE › AT Baltic War
Aleksandr Khramchikhin 18, Deputy Director of the Institute for Political and Military Analysis in Moscow, 1/25/2018, “Rethinking the Danger of Escalation: The Russia-NATO Military Balance”, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, https://carnegieendowment.org/2018/01/25/rethinking-danger-of-escalation-russia-nato-military-balance-pub-75346
In an atmosphere of crisis permeated by mutual recriminations and suspicions, both sides—NATO and Russia—have engaged in a series of military activities along the line of contact. These maneuvers in turn have triggered multiple warnings from both sides of a sharp deterioration in European security, a growing threat of a military confrontation between Russia and NATO, and an urgent need to deescalate the situation in order to avoid a catastrophic war with disastrous consequences for all. An emerging conventional wisdom maintains that the new Cold War in Europe, if allowed to continue unchecked, runs the risk of escalating into a hot war unless steps to reduce tensions are taken swiftly.
But conventional wisdom is often wrong, and so it is this time. The hysteria that has engulfed public commentary throughout Europe about this ostensibly dire military situation on the brink of getting out of hand has little, if any, basis in fact. Both sides in the standoff exaggerate the tensions and the danger of escalation, and the risks of the military moves—their own and their adversary’s—supposedly driving these tensions.
2022
Michigan
Evidence
AFFIRMATIVE › Swindland Bad
Buchanan 22, author of “Nixon’s White House Wars: The Battles That Made and Broke a President and Divided America Forever.” (Pat, “Why would US give a war guarantee — to Finland?,” The Journal,
Nervous about Russian President Vladimir Putin’s intentions, Finland wants America legally and morally bound to fight Russia on its behalf, should Putin invade Finland as he invaded Ukraine. From the Finnish point of view, this is perfectly understandable. But why would the United States consent to go to war with Russia, the largest nuclear power on earth, for violating Finland’s frontiers? Finland is not Alaska; it is not Canada; it is 5,000 miles away. And no one ever asserted during the Cold War, or for the decades since, that Finland was a U.S. vital interest. Why, then, would we consent, in advance, to go to war with Russia over Finland? President Joe Biden said last week that NATO has an “open door” policy and Finland and Sweden are welcome, and he looks forward to their joining. Consider what Biden is actually saying and doing here. He is ceding to Finland, a country of 5.5 million people with an 830-mile border with Putin’s Russia, the right to obligate the United States of America to go to war with Russia, if Russia attacks Finland. What patriot would commit his own country, in perpetuity, to go to war on behalf of another country not his own? Why would America surrender to the Finns our freedom of action in deciding whether or not to fight a nuclear-armed Russia? NATO is not a country club; it is a military alliance Putin regards as an enemy. Every member of that alliance is obliged to treat an attack on any one of its 30 members as an attack on all, and all are obligated to come to the defense of the nation attacked. By welcoming Finland into NATO, Biden is offering Helsinki the kind of war guarantee Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain gave to Poland in the spring of 1939, which led to Britain’s having to declare war on Sept. 3, 1939, two days after Germany invaded Poland. How did that work out for Britain and the empire? In his farewell address, President George Washington warned his countrymen against “permanent alliances.” In conscious echo of our first president, Thomas Jefferson warned against “entangling alliances.” NATO is a military alliance that has been in existence since 1949. While it began with the U.S., Canada and 10 European nations, it ended the Cold War with 16. We have since added 14 more. Six of the nations NATO added since the Cold War — Poland, Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovakia, Bulgaria, Romania — were members of the USSR’s Warsaw Pact. Three of the newest NATO members — Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania — are former republics of the Soviet Union. The last quarter-century of NATO’s encroachment into Russia’s space and onto Russia’s front porch has been a leading cause of the worsening relationship between the world’s two great nuclear powers. The repeated refusal of Biden and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy to rule out NATO membership for Ukraine was a primary cause of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. This does not absolve Putin of culpability in launching the war on Ukraine, but it should tell us that any new members of NATO, in Russia’s “near abroad,” especially a new NATO member with an 830-mile border with Russia from the Baltic to the Arctic, is running a real risk and raising the possibility of war. Indeed, with Russia’s war in Ukraine in stalemate, having failed to achieve its objectives in Kyiv, Kharkov and Odessa, Russian officials have repeatedly raised the prospect of a desperate resort to tactical nuclear weapons to stop the bleeding. “Escalate to de-escalate” is the slogan. Bringing Sweden and Finland into NATO, which has already elicited rage from Moscow and ominous threats, is unlikely to reduce whatever pressure currently exists to escalate to nuclear war.
2022
Michigan
Evidence
AFFIRMATIVE › Swindland Bad
Stephen Collinson 22. Politics Reporter at CNN. "The most striking aspect of Sweden and Finland's application to join NATO." CNN. 5-18-2022. https://www.cnn.com/2022/05/18/europe/sweden-finland-nato-analysis-intl/index.html. accessed 6-21-2022 //ART
The most striking aspect of Sweden and Finland's application to join NATO is how little debate there is about whether it's a wise idea.
The entry of the two Nordic nations would be the most significant geopolitical outcome of the Ukraine war, transforming the strategic security picture in northeastern Europe and adding hundreds of miles of direct NATO borders with Russia.
2022
Michigan
Evidence
AFFIRMATIVE › Swindland Bad
Emma Ashford 22. Senior fellow, Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council. "NATO Should Think Twice Before Accepting Finland and Sweden." Washington Post. 5-30-2022. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/nato-should-think-twice-before-accepting-finland-and-sweden/2022/05/30/b412ee2a-dff7-11ec-ae64-6b23e5155b62_story.html. accessed 6-21-2022 //ART
Yet from the point of view of existing NATO members — and particularly the US — it’s still not necessarily a net win. Finland and Sweden have long focused their militaries on defending their own territories, raising doubts about their value in contributing to a common defense, which is at the heart of NATO’s charter.
And while both nations have pledged to increase their military spending and ability to bolster Europe’s broader defenses, it is also possible that they would not. Instead, they may free-ride on America’s military strength — and its nuclear umbrella — as so many European states have done for years. According to the International Monetary Fund, neither country comes close to meeting the NATO goal of spending 2% of GDP on defense.
2022
Michigan
Evidence
AFFIRMATIVE › ---xt: ME---Impact
Lantier 19, PhD @ Geneva (Alex, “Syrian army, Iran threaten counterattack against Turkish invasion of Syria,” )
The conflicts erupting between the different capitalist regimes in the Middle East pose an imminent threat not only to the population of the region, but to the entire world. Workers can give no support to any of the competing military plans and strategic appetites of these reactionary regimes. With America, Europe, Russia and China all deeply involved in the proxy war in Syria, a large-scale Middle East war could strangle the world oil supply and escalate into war between nuclear-armed powers. The working class is coming face to face with the real possibility of a Third World War.