Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---EMP D › 2AC---No Delivery

No EMP delivery mechanism

Butt, 2010, Yousaf Butt is a staff scientist at the Center for Astrophysics at Harvard University, where he worked on NASA’s orbiting Chandra X-ray Observatory project from 1999–2004. He was a research fellow at the Union of Concerned Scientists’ Global Security Program from 2005–2007. He holds BSc degrees in physics and in mechanical engineering from MIT and a PhD in experimental nuclear astrophysics from Yale University. “The EMP threat: fact, fiction, and response (part 2),”

What appears to be of particular concern to the EMP commission is the scepter of terrorist groups or so-called “rogue” nations carrying out such an attack. As outlined by Dr. Pry, one of the commissioners, before a 2005 Senate Subcommittee on Terrorism, Technology and Homeland Security, “[a] nuclear missile concealed in the hold of a freighter would give Iran, or terrorists, the capability to perform an EMP attack against the United States homeland, without developing an ICBM, and with some prospect of remaining anonymous. Iran’s Shahab-3 medium-range missile… is a mobile missile, and small enough to be transported in the hold of a freighter.” However, as mentioned above, such missiles have a payload capacity of approximately 1,000 kilograms corresponding to a crude U-based warhead of ~1 kiloton yield [22]—if, and when, the Iranians eventually develop nuclear weapons. Even the North Koreans, who are much further along in their weapons program, have had great difficulty reaching even a ~5 kiloton yield from their Pu-based devices in carefully orchestrated ground-tests, and their 2009 test was likely a fizzle. Thus, it is not at all a simple matter, even for countries with considerable resources and focused decades-long effort, to build such weapons, let alone pair them to reliable delivery systems. As carefully argued by John Mueller in his new book, Atomic Obsession, it is virtually impossible for a terrorist cell to obtain the raw materials needed for a nuclear device and assemble it correctly themselves [Ref 22, p. 172–198]. Even a “crude” U-type device is not all that “crude” and requires the concerted effort of skilled scientists and engineers. Any weapon produced by a terrorist cell would likely be a one of a kind and would have to remain untested. For a terrorist group to then mate this weapon to a ballistic missile and successfully carry out an EMP strike beggars belief. As John Pike, director of GlobalSecurity.org has said, “It is just very difficult to imagine how terrorists are going to be able to lay hands on a nuclear-tipped missile, and launch it and reprogram it in such a way that it would be a high-altitude burst like that.”

2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---Offense › 2AC---Economy Turn

Economic collapse causes nuclear war---loose nukes and terrorists.

Mann ’14 [Eric; 2014; special agent with a United States federal agency, a special assistant for a U.S. Senator and served as a presidential appointee for the U.S. Congress, Graduate Degree in Homeland Security at Georgetown; “Austerity, Economic Decline, and Financial Weapons of War: A New Paradigm for Global Security,” https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2/37262/MANN-THESIS-2014.pdf]

The conclusions reached in this thesis demonstrate how economic considerations within states can figure prominently into the calculus for future conflicts. The findings also suggest that security issues with economic or financial underpinnings will transcend classical determinants of war and conflict, and change the manner by which rival states engage in hostile acts toward one another. The research shows that security concerns emanating from economic uncertainty and the inherent vulnerabilities within global financial markets will present new challenges for national security, and provide developing states new asymmetric options for balancing against stronger states.

The security areas, identified in the proceeding chapters, are likely to mature into global security threats in the immediate future. As the case study on South Korea suggest, the overlapping security issues associated with economic decline and reduced military spending by the United States will affect allied confidence in America’s security guarantees. The study shows that this outcome could cause regional instability or realignments of strategic partnerships in the Asia-pacific region with ramifications for U.S. national security. Rival states and non-state groups may also become emboldened to challenge America’s status in the unipolar international system.

2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---Offense › 2AC---Economy Turn

Even a small EMP weapon destroys the economy

Radasky 10, awarded Lord Kelvin Medal by the IEC for his electrical expertise, July, Dr. William Radasky served on the EMP Commission staff and was awarded the Lord Kelvin Medal by the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) for his contributions to developing standards for the protection of electronic equipment from high power electromagnetic threats, including HEMP. He is also an EMP Fellow, an IEEE Fellow, and has published over 400 reports, papers and articles dealing with high power EM transients. Dr. Peter Vincent Pry served on the staffs of the EMP Commission, the House Armed Services Committee, the Central Intelligence Agency, and currently is Director of the United States Nuclear Strategy Forum and President of EMPact America. “Rebuttal to “The EMP threat: fact, fiction, and response,”

EMP from a 1-kiloton weapon, though “weak” in comparison to a megaton-range EMP, could still have catastrophic consequences for the critical infrastructures that sustain the U.S. economy and society. This is so because the US electrical power grid, which supports all the other critical infrastructures, is extremely fragile and vulnerable to any EMP attack. Modern microelectronics are over one million times more vulnerable to EMP than electronic systems of the 1960s, and could be damaged or destroyed by the EMP from a low-yield nuclear weapon detonated high enough to cover, for example, the eastern United States. Safety relays and SCADAs (System Control And Data Acquisition) control everything, including the current flowing into big transformers that are indispensable to the power grid, and that currently would require years to be repaired or replaced.4 Dr. Butt himself provides anecdotal evidence illustrating the shocking fragility of the electric power grid, citing the August 2003 Northeast Blackout and the cascading failures that resulted when a high voltage power line was assaulted by a tree branch: The outage affected the Northeast US and parts of Canada and more than 200 power plants, including several nuclear plants, were shut down as a result of the electricity cutoff. Other effects included loss of water pressure, possible sewage contamination, gridlock, various other transportation problems (because of secondary effects on railways, airlines, and gas stations), and disruption of oil refineries’ operations. Phone service was stressed due to high call volume and several radio and television stations went off the air. It is estimated that the one-day blackout cost $7–10 billion in spoiled food, lost production, overtime wages, and other related expenses inflicted on more than one-seventh of the US population. All of this from a tree branch. It is not an isolated incident. The EMP Commission found many large-scale blackouts of the power grid that were started by a seemingly trivial local problem.4 A low-yield nuclear weapon detonated to place an EMP field over the entire eastern portion of the United States would certainly place more stress on the electric grid than a single tree branch, and multiply the above effects manifold by causing many local failures, that could cascade into a national catastrophe.

2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---Offense › 2AC---Nuclear War Causes Extinction

Err aff---nuclear war is under-researched and secondary effects ensure extinction

Seth Baum 15, Executive Director of the Global Catastrophic Risk Institute (gcrinstitute.org), a nonprofit think tank that he co-founded in 2011. His research focuses on risk, ethics, and policy questions for major risks to human civilization including nuclear war, global warming, and emerging technologies. Dr. Baum received a Ph.D. in geography from Pennsylvania State University with a dissertation on climate change policy. He then completed a post-doctoral fellowship with the Columbia University Center for Research on Environmental Decisions. His research has appeared in many journals including Ecological Economics, Science and Engineering Ethics, Science and Global Security, and Sustainability. He is currently co-editor of a special issue of the journal Futures titled “Confronting future catastrophic threats to humanity.”, “The Risk of Nuclear Winter”, FAS, May 29 2015,

Since the early 1980s, the world has known that a large nuclear war could cause severe global environmental effects, including dramatic cooling of surface temperatures, declines in precipitation, and increased ultraviolet radiation. The term nuclear winter was coined specifically to refer to cooling that result in winter-like temperatures occurring year-round. Regardless of whether such temperatures are reached, there would be severe consequences for humanity. But how severe would those consequences be? And what should the world be doing about it? To the first question, the short answer is nobody knows. The total human impacts of nuclear winter are both uncertain and under-studied. In light of the uncertainty, a risk perspective is warranted that considers the breadth of possible impacts, weighted by their probability. More research on the impacts would be very helpful, but we can meanwhile make some general conclusions. That is enough to start answering the second question, what we should do. In regards to what we should do, nuclear winter has some interesting and important policy implications. Today, nuclear winter is not a hot topic but this was not always the case: it was international headline news in the 1980s. There were conferences, Congressional hearings, voluminous scientific research, television specials, and more. The story is expertly captured by Lawrence Badash in his book A Nuclear Winter’s Tale.1)Much of the 1980s attention to nuclear winter was driven by the enthusiastic efforts of Carl Sagan, then at the height of his popularity. But underlying it all was the fear of nuclear war, stoked by some of the tensest moments of the Cold War. When the Cold War ended, so too did attention to nuclear winter. That started to change in 2007, with a new line of nuclear winter research2) that uses advanced climate models developed for the study of global warming. Relative to the 1980s research, the new research found that the smoke from nuclear firestorms would travel higher up in the atmosphere, causing nuclear winter to last longer. This research also found dangerous effects from smaller nuclear wars, such as an India-Pakistan nuclear war detonating “only” 100 total nuclear weapons. Two groups—one in the United States3) and one in Switzerland4)—have found similar results using different climate models, lending further support to the validity of the research. Some new research has also examined the human impacts of nuclear winter. Researchers simulated agricultural crop growth in the aftermath of a 100-weapon India-Pakistan nuclear war.5)The results are startling- the scenario could cause agriculture productivity to decline by around 10 to 40 percent for several years after the war. The studies looked at major staple crops in China and the United States, two of the largest food producers. Other countries and other crops would likely face similar declines. Following such crop declines, severe global famine could ensue. One study estimated the total extent of the famine by comparing crop declines to global malnourishment data.6) When food becomes scarce, the poor and malnourished are typically hit the hardest. This study estimated two billion people at risk of starvation. And this is from the 100-weapon India-Pakistan nuclear war scenario. Larger nuclear wars would have more severe impacts. This is where the recent research stops. To the best of my knowledge there are no recent studies examining the secondary effects of famines, such as disease outbreaks and violent conflicts. There are no recent studies examining the human impacts of ultraviolet radiation. That would include an increased medical burden in skin cancer and other diseases. It would also include further loss of agriculture ecosystem services as the ultraviolet radiation harms plants and animals. At this time, we can only make educated guesses about what these impacts would be, informed in part by what research was published 30 years ago. When analyzing the risk of nuclear winter, one question is of paramount importance: Would there be permanent harm to human civilization? Humanity could have a very bright future ahead; to dim that future is the worst thing nuclear winter could do. It is vastly worse than a few billion deaths from starvation. Not that a few billion deaths is trivial—obviously it isn’t—but it is tiny compared to the loss of future generations. Carl Sagan was one of the first people to recognize this point in a commentary he wrote on nuclear winter for Foreign Affairs.7) Sagan believed nuclear winter could cause human extinction, in which case all members of future generations would be lost. He argued that this made nuclear winter vastly more important than the direct effects of nuclear war, which could, in his words, “kill ‘only’ hundreds of millions of people.” Sagan was however, right that human extinction would cause permanent harm to human civilization. It is debatable whether nuclear winter could cause human extinction. Alan Robock, a leader of the recent nuclear winter research, believes it is unlikely. He writes: “Especially in Australia and New Zealand, humans would have a better chance to survive.”8) This is hardly a cheerful statement, and it leaves open the chance of human extinction. I think that’s the best way of looking at it. Given all the uncertainty and the limited available research, it is impossible to rule out the possibility of human extinction. I don’t have a good answer for how likely it is. But the possibility should not be dismissed. Even if some humans survive, there could still be permanent harm to human civilization. Small patches of survivors would be extremely vulnerable to subsequent disasters. They also could not keep up the massively complex civilization we enjoy today. It would be a long and uncertain rebuilding process and survivors might never get civilization back to where it is now. More importantly, they might never get civilization to where we now stand poised to take it in the future. Our potentially bright future could be forever dimmed.9) Nuclear winter is a very large and serious risk. But that on its own doesn’t mean much—just another thing to worry about. What’s really important are the implications of nuclear winter for public policy and private action.

war between India and Pakistan would pose an existential threat to both countries. A larger nuclear war would threaten humanity itself. These realities make bolt-from-blue strikes much less likely and in turn, reduce the imperative for pre-emptive strikes.

2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---Offense › 2AC---Nuclear War Causes Extinction

Ozone independently causes extinction

Greenpeace 95 – Environmental Organization (“Full of Holes: Montreal Protocol and the Continuing Destruction of the Ozone Layer -- A Greenpeace Report with contributions from Ozone Action, http://archive.greenpeace.org/ozone/holes/holebg.html)

When chemists Sherwood Rowland and Mario Molina first postulated a link between chlorofluorocarbons and ozone layer depletion in 1974, the news was greeted with scepticism, but taken seriously nonetheless. The vast majority of credible scientists have since confirmed this hypothesis. The ozone layer around the Earth shields us all from harmful ultraviolet radiation from the sun. Without the ozone layer, life on earth would not exist. Exposure to increased levels of ultraviolet radiation can cause cataracts, skin cancer, and immune system suppression in humans as well as innumerable effects on other living systems. This is why Rowland's and Molina's theory was taken so seriously, so quickly - the stakes are literally the continuation of life on earth.

2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---Offense › 2AC---Nuclear War Causes Extinction

Even a small nuclear war causes extinction and destroys the ozone

Starr 14 [Steven Starr, the Senior Scientist for Physicians for Social Responsibility and Director of the Clinical Laboratory Science Program at the University of Missouri. Starr has published in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists and the Strategic Arms Reduction (STAR) website of the Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, June 11, 2014, “There Can be No Winners in a Nuclear War”, Truth Out, ]

Nuclear war has no winner. Beginning in 2006, several of the world’s leading climatologists (at Rutgers, UCLA, John Hopkins University, and the University of Colorado-Boulder) published a series of studies that evaluated the long-term environmental consequences of a nuclear war, including baseline scenarios fought with merely 1% of the explosive power in the US and/or Russian launch-ready nuclear arsenals. They concluded that the consequences of even a “small” nuclear war would include catastrophic disruptions of global climate and massive destruction of Earth’s protective ozone layer. These and more recent studies predict that global agriculture would be so negatively affected by such a war, a global famine would result, which would cause up to 2 billion people to starve to death. These peer-reviewed studies – which were analyzed by the best scientists in the world and found to be without error – also predict that a war fought with less than half of US or Russian strategic nuclear weapons would destroy the human race. In other words, a US-Russian nuclear war would create such extreme long-term damage to the global environment that it would leave the Earth uninhabitable for humans and most animal forms of life. A recent article in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, “Self-assured destruction: The climate impacts of nuclear war,” begins by stating: “A nuclear war between Russia and the United States, even after the arsenal reductions planned under New START, could produce a nuclear winter. Hence, an attack by either side could be suicidal, resulting in self-assured destruction.” In 2009, I wrote “Catastrophic Climatic Consequences of Nuclear Conflicts” for the International Commission on Nuclear Non-proliferation and Disarmament. The article summarizes the findings of these studies. It explains that nuclear firestorms would produce millions of tons of smoke, which would rise above cloud level and form a global stratospheric smoke layer that would rapidly encircle the Earth. The smoke layer would remain for at least a decade, and it would act to destroy the protective ozone layer (vastly increasing the UV-B reaching Earth) as well as block warming sunlight, thus creating Ice Age weather conditions that would last 10 years or longer. Following a US-Russian nuclear war, temperatures in the central US and Eurasia would fall below freezing every day for one to three years; the intense cold would completely eliminate growing seasons for a decade or longer. No crops could be grown, leading to a famine that would kill most humans and large animal populations. Electromagnetic pulse from high-altitude nuclear detonations would destroy the integrated circuits in all modern electronic devices, including those in commercial nuclear power plants. Every nuclear reactor would almost instantly meltdown; every nuclear spent fuel pool (which contain many times more radioactivity than found in the reactors) would boil off, releasing vast amounts of long-lived radioactivity. The fallout would make most of the US and Europe uninhabitable. Of course, the survivors of the nuclear war would be starving to death anyway. Once nuclear weapons were introduced into a US-Russian conflict, there would be little chance that a nuclear holocaust could be avoided. Theories of “limited nuclear war” and “nuclear de-escalation” are unrealistic. In 2002 the Bush administration modified US strategic doctrine from a retaliatory role to permit preemptive nuclear attack; in 2010, the Obama administration made only incremental and miniscule changes to this doctrine, leaving it essentially unchanged. Furthermore, Counterforce doctrine – used by both the US and Russian military – emphasizes the need for preemptive strikes once nuclear war begins. Both sides would be under immense pressure to launch a preemptive nuclear first-strike once military hostilities had commenced, especially if nuclear weapons had already been used on the battlefield. Both the US and Russia each have 400 to 500 launch-ready ballistic missiles armed with a total of at least 1800 strategic nuclear warheads, which can be launched with only a few minutes warning. Both the US and Russian Presidents are accompanied 24/7 by military officers carrying a “nuclear briefcase,” which allows them to transmit the permission order to launch in a matter of seconds. Yet top political leaders and policymakers of both the US and Russia seem to be unaware that their launch-ready nuclear weapons represent a self-destruct mechanism for the human race. For example, in 2010, I was able to publicly question the chief negotiators of the New START treaty, Russian Ambassador Anatoly Antonov and (then) US Assistant Secretary of State Rose Gottemoeller, during their joint briefing at the UN (during the Non-Proliferation Treaty Review Conference). I asked them if they were familiar with the recent peer-reviewed studies that predicted the detonation of less than 1% of the explosive power contained in the operational and deployed US and Russian nuclear forces would cause catastrophic changes in the global climate, and that a nuclear war fought with their strategic nuclear weapons would kill most people on Earth. They both answered “no.” More recently, on April 20, 2014, I asked the same question and received the same answer from the US officials sent to brief representatives of the NGOS at the Non-Proliferation Treaty Preparatory Committee meeting at the UN. None of the US officials at the briefing were aware of the studies. Those present included top officials of the National Security Council. It is frightening that President Obama and his administration appear unaware that the world’s leading scientists have for years predicted that a nuclear war fought with the US and/or Russian strategic nuclear arsenal means the end of human history. Do they not know of the existential threat these arsenals pose to the human race . . . or do they choose to remain silent because this fact doesn’t fit into their official narratives? We hear only about terrorist threats that could destroy a city with an atomic bomb, while the threat of human extinction from nuclear war is never mentioned – even when the US and Russia are each running huge nuclear war games in preparation for a US-Russian war. Even more frightening is the fact that the neocons running US foreign policy believe that the US has “nuclear primacy” over Russia; that is, the US could successfully launch a nuclear sneak attack against Russian (and Chinese) nuclear forces and completely destroy them. This theory was articulated in 2006 in “The Rise of U.S. Nuclear Primacy,” which was published in Foreign Affairs by the Council on Foreign Relations. By concluding that the Russians and Chinese would be unable to retaliate, or if some small part of their forces remained, would not risk a second US attack by retaliating, the article invites nuclear war. Colonel Valery Yarynich (who was in charge of security of the Soviet/Russian nuclear command and control systems for 7 years) asked me to help him write a rebuttal, which was titled “Nuclear Primacy is a Fallacy.” Colonel Yarynich, who was on the Soviet General Staff and did war planning for the USSR, concluded that the “Primacy” article used faulty methodology and erroneous assumptions, thus invalidating its conclusions. My contribution lay in my knowledge of the recently published (in 2006) studies, which predicted even a “successful” nuclear first-strike, which destroyed 100% of the opposing side’s nuclear weapons, would cause the citizens of the side that “won” the nuclear war to perish from nuclear famine, just as would the rest of humanity.

2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---Offense › 2AC---Grid Impact

Grid collapse causes meltdowns---Extinction

Nadesan ’14 [Majia; September 13; professor of communication at ASU, their interdisciplinary research examines the ethical implications of societal governing logics and risk-management strategies; “The Nuclear Energy Paradigm Collides with Earth Changes and Technospheric Breakdown,” The Millenium Report, themillenniumreport.com/2014/09/will-fukushima-become-an-extinction-level-event]

As Technospheric Breakdown Accelerates, Nuclear Power Generation Mishaps will Increase and Intensify

There is really no way around this eventuality. As all the nuclear power plants age, they will succumb to the micro-stresses which inevitably occur in such an ever-deteriorating environment. Most people are unaware of the true depth and breadth of technospheric breakdown since it is a concept rarely taken up by academia or the media. The following excerpts provide a wider perspective of this unavoidable byproduct of the Industrial Revolution.

2022 Michigan Evidence
AFF › 2AC---Offense › 2AC---Grid Impact

Grid collapse causes extinction

Weiss ’19 [Matthew and Martin; May 29; National Sales Director at United Medical Instruments, UMI and Research assistant at the American Jewish University; Neurosurgeon at UCLA-Olive View Medical Center; Energy, Sustainability, and Society, “An assessment of threats to the American power grid,” vol. 9]

In testimony before a Congressional Committee, it has been asserted that a prolonged collapse of this nation’s electrical grid—through starvation, disease, and societal collapse—could result in the death of up to 90% of the American population [1].

There is no published model disclosing how these numbers were arrived at, nor are we able to validate a primary source for this claim. Testimony given by the Chairman of the Congressional EMP Commission, while expressing similar concerns, gave no estimate of the deaths that would accrue from a prolonged nationwide grid collapse [2].

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Warming D › 2NC---SV Add-on

Allowing warming to continue perpetuates racist inequalities

J. Andrew Hoerner 8, Director of the Sustainable Economics Program at Redefining Progress, and Nia Robinson, Director of the Environmental Justice and Climate Change Initiative, “A Climate of Change: African Americans, Global Warming, and a Just Climate Policy for the U.S.”, Environmental Justice and Climate Change Initiative Report, June

Everywhere we turn, the issues and impacts of climate change confront us. One of the most serious environmental threats facing the world today, climate change has moved from the minds of scientists and offices of environmentalists to the mainstream. Though the media is dominated by images of polar bears, melting glaciers, flooded lands, and arid desserts, there is a human face to this story as well. Climate change is not only an issue of the environment; it is also an issue of justice and human rights, one that dangerously intersects race and class. All over the world people of color, Indigenous Peoples and low-income communities bear disproportionate burdens from climate change itself, from ill-designed policies to prevent it, and from side effects of the energy systems that cause it. A Climate of Change explores the impacts of climate change on African Americans, from health to economics to community, and considers what policies would most harm or benefit African Americans—and the nation as a whole. African Americans are thirteen percent of the U.S. population and on average emit nearly twenty percent less greenhouse gases than non-Hispanic whites per capita. Though far less responsible for climate change, African Americans are significantly more vulnerable to its effects than non- Hispanic whites. Health, housing, economic well-being, culture, and social stability are harmed from such manifestations of climate change as storms, floods, and climate variability. African Americans are also more vulnerable to higher energy bills, unemployment, recessions caused by global energy price shocks, and a greater economic burden from military operations designed to protect the flow of oil to the U.S.

Climate Justice: The Time Is Now

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Warming D › 2NC---Warming Impact

Err Aff on impact calculus---you’re cognitively biased against climate impacts because you haven’t experienced them, AND they’re in the far future.

Dr. Adam Briggle 21, Ph.D. in environmental studies, Colorado Boulder, associate professor and the director of graduate studies in the philosophy department at the University of North Texas, “The Unnatural Growth of the Natural,” Chapter 2 in Thinking Through Climate Change, pp 14-17, doi:10.1007/978-3-030-53587-2, pacc

The scale of the Anthropocene and the speed of the Great Acceleration pose a fundamental dilemma spotted by the German philosopher Gunther Anders early in the atomic age. For nearly all of history, our abilities to imagine (vorstellen) outstripped our abilities to produce (her-stellen). We could dream big, but we lacked the energy to build big. Now, things are inverted. Our productive powers exceed our imaginative ones. We are making a world that we cannot comprehend. The scholar Timothy Morton (2013) puts this in terms of 'hyperobjects,' phenomena that are so massively distributed across time and space as to confound our usual way of making sense of things.

Climate change is the prime example. It is there in the flood or the wildfire, but it is also not there. We can neither escape it nor keep our attention trained on it. Despite billions of dollars of scientific research, we have still never experienced or felt the climate. What we experience is weather, and it's always changing, so what's the big deal? That might explain why fossil fuels remain at around 80% of the world's energy mix—the same as it was back in 1987 (Harder 2019). The global economy hasn't decarbonized any faster during the era of climate science than it did in the two decades prior to all that knowledge (Pielke 2019).

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Warming D › 2NC---Warming Impact

Climate change trigger feedback loops causing quick extinction. Prefer peer-reviewed climate models.

Dr. Peter Kareiva 18, ecology and applied mathematics PhD from Cornell University, director of the Institute of the Environment and Sustainability at UCLA, Pritzker Distinguished Professor in Environment & Sustainability at UCLA, September 2018, "Existential risk due to ecosystem collapse: Nature strikes back," Futures, a peer-reviewed journal, Vol 102, , pacc

Climate change has a long history of disrupting civilizations and sometimes precipitating the collapse of cultures or mass emigrations (McMichael, 2017). For example, the 12th century drought in the North American Southwest is held responsible for the collapse of the Anasazi pueblo culture. More recently, the infamous potato famine of 1846-1849 and the large migration of Irish to the US can be traced to a combination of factors, one of which was climate. Specifically, 1846 was an unusually warm and moist year in Ireland, providing the climatic conditions favorable to the fungus that caused the potato blight. As is so often the case, poor government had a role as well—as the British government forbade the import of grains from outside Britain (imports that could have helped to redress the ravaged potato yields).

Climate change intersects with freshwater resources because it is expected to exacerbate drought and water scarcity, as well as flooding. Climate change can even impair water quality because it is associated with heavy rains that overwhelm sewage treatment facilities, or because it results in higher concentrations of pollutants in groundwater as a result of enhanced evaporation and reduced groundwater recharge. Ample clean water is not a luxury - it is essential for human survival. Consequently, cities, regions and nations that lack clean freshwater are vulnerable to social disruption and disease.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Nano D › 2NC---AT: Squo Solves

Nano regulation is impossible

Stephen J. Ridge 18, Master of Arts in Security Studies from the Naval Postgraduate School, Assistant Senior Watch Officer, U.S. Department of Homeland Security, National Operations Center, “A REGULATORY FRAMEWORK FOR NANOTECHNOLOGY”, Thesis, March, p. 2-4

There are many roadblocks to developing suitable nanotechnology regulation. One major roadblock for nanotechnology regulation stems from the lack of consensus on the definition of nanotechnology. It is difficult to construct an architectural framework for nanotechnology regulation when many leaders within the field cannot agree on what the term even means. According to Andrew Maynard, Professor in the School for the Future of Innovation in Society at Arizona State University and co-chair of the World Economic Forum Global Agenda Council on Nanotechnology, “a sensible definition [for nanotechnology] has proved hard, if not impossible, to arrive at.”3 A brief perusal of nanotechnology stakeholders reveals a myriad of definitions upon which their interaction with the technology is based. For instance, nanotechnology is defined by the U.S. National Nanotechnology Initiative as the understanding and control of matter at dimensions between approximately 1 and 100 nanometers where unique phenomena enable novel applications. Encompassing nanoscale science, engineering, and technology, nanotechnology involves imaging, measuring, modeling, and manipulating matter at this length scale.4 In 2010, the European Commission released this definition for public comment: “a material that consists of particles with one or more external dimensions in the size range 1 nm-100 nm for more than 1 percent of their number;” and/or “has internal or surface structures in one or more dimensions in the size range 1 nm-100 nm;” and/or “has a greater than 60 m2/ cm3, excluding materials consisting of particles with a size lower than 1 nm, excluding materials consisting of particles with a size lower than 1 nm.”5 In the 2003 law 21st Century Nanotechnology Research and Development Act, the U.S. Congress defines “nanotechnology” as “the science and technology that will enable one to understand, measure, manipulate, and manufacture at the atomic, molecular, and supramolecular levels, aimed at creating materials, devices, and systems with fundamentally new molecular organization, properties, and functions.”6 The inaugural issue of Nature Nanotechnology in 2006 asked a wide array of researchers, industrialists, and scientists what nanotechnology means to them. Unsurprisingly, the 13 different individuals queried yielded 13 different responses. This lack of a commonly agreed upon nanotechnology lexicon makes regulation difficult. Another roadblock arises because nanotechnology is still an emerging technology. When establishing regulation, the regulating entity and those empowering the regulation assume that the regulating entity has the knowledge of what “good behavior” in an industry should be.7 This assumption is somewhat flawed because predicting the way a new technology will be developed and adopted is very difficult. Therefore, predicting what “good behavior” in an industry will look like is also very difficult.8 This challenge of regulation does not mean regulation should be ignored until the technology is mature, but rather that it is necessary to implement a regulatory framework that can both address problems as they arise and attempt to prevent future problems by exercising foresight into what the near-term and long-term technological developments may be. Next, the properties of engineered nanomaterials make categorization of these materials difficult under current regulatory definitions. For example, according to the National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI), at the nanoscale, a particle’s properties such as “melting point, fluorescence, electrical conductivity, magnetic permeability, and chemical reactivity change as a function size of the size of the particle.”9 Additionally, according to the NNI “nanoscale materials have far larger surface areas than similar masses of largerscale materials. As surface area per mass of a material increases, a greater amount of the material can come into contact with surrounding materials, thus affecting reactivity.”10 These physical properties provide much of the basis for why the technology has the potential to be revolutionary. However, according to Beaudrie, Kandlikar, and Satterfield, “not enough is known about the relationship between nanomaterial physicochemical characteristics and behavior to anticipate risks. The result is a serious lack of predictive analytical capacity to anticipate harmful implications.”11 Also problematic is that nanotechnology research and development encompass many different fields of science and across several sectors of society. These sectors include: energy, electronics, defense/homeland security, chemicals, communications/information technology, manufacturing, government, food and agriculture, pharmaceutical/health companies, transportation, education, and commerce/economics. This broad range of potential application blurs the lines of regulatory responsibility across different regulatory agencies. Also, each of these sectors contains stakeholders who have differing concerns and interests in the technology and are often competing with one another for the funding of research and development.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Nano D › 2NC---AT: Squo Solves

No checks or countermeasures to Nano

Dr. Olle Häggström 16 (Professor of Mathematical Statistics at Chalmers University of Technology and Associated Researcher at the Institute for Future Studies, Member of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, PhD in Mathematical Statistics and MSc in Electrical Engineering, Here Be Dragons: Science, Technology and the Future of Humanity, p. 136-138, smarx, MLC)

The comparison to biology is apt, but it is not clear how convincing his idea is that it would take “some maniac” to initiate grey goo “for this very purpose.”313 Can we state with certainty that it cannot happen by mistake? It is true that self-replication will require “clever design,” but we can expect non-maniac nanotechnology engineers to attempt that, as it seems to be the most promising way to produce nanobots in the huge quantities we will need for a variety of applications. Such construction will presumably be done with a degree of precaution so as to avoid the self-replication going overboard as in the grey goo scenario, but such precautions could fail. At this point, the grey goo skeptic could point again to biology, and the fact that life has existed on our planet for billions of years without turning into grey (or green) goo, as an argument for why self-replication is unlikely to spontaneously produce such a catastrophe. While this argument has some force, it is far from conclusive, as the newly formed nanobots may, in the abstract space of possible living organisms, be located quite far from all biological life, and have very different physical and chemical properties. It is hardly absurd to think that this might give the nanobots a robust reproductive power unmatched by anything that the evolution of biological life has discovered. At the very least, this issue deserves further study. A possible middle ground could be that, on one hand, it is possible to proceed with nanobot technology without risking a grey goo scenario, provided that we respect certain safety protocols, whereas, on the other hand, grey goo would be a real danger without these precautions. Phoenix and Drexler (2004) have a number of suggestions for how nanobots can be made to self-replicate in controlled and safe fashion. A key insight is that the self-replication ability of an agent (be it a biological organism or a robot) is always contingent on its environment. Even a set of blacksmith’s tools can, in the right environment (one that provides suitable input of skills and muscle power), produce a duplicate set, and can thus be described as self-replicating. What is always needed for self-replication capability is the raw material and energy needed to produce the replicates.314 Hence, we could avoid grey goo if we construct the self-replicating machines to contain elements not available in the natural environment. But we may not even have to go that far. Phoenix and Drexler point out that a general-purpose molecular assembler will typically not be a general purpose molecular disassembler. It will, most likely, be far easier to construct an APM machine that requires its raw material to be delivered in the form of a limited range of simple chemicals (such as acetylene or acetone), rather than having the ability to extract molecular fragments and atoms from arbitrary chemical compounds. Suppose that we regulate the technology so as to make a specific list of sufficient safety precautions obligatory. With a risk such as grey goo, where the consequences of a single mishap could be global and even put an end to humanity, it is clearly not sufficient that most practitioners of the technology adhere to the regulation, or that almost all of them do: anything short of obedience to regulation from all practitioners would be unsatisfactory. Can this be ensured? This is not clear. Kurzweil (2006) advocates another safety layer, in the form of nanobots specifically designed to fight grey-goo-like outbreaks. Without defenses, the available biomass could be destroyed by gray goo very rapidly. Clearly, we will need a nanotechnology immune system in place before these scenarios become a possibility. . . . Eric Drexler, Robert Freitas, Ralph Merkle, Mike Treder, Chris Phoenix, and others have pointed out that future nanotech manufacturing devices can be created with safeguards that would prevent the accidental creation of self-replicating nanodevices. However, this observation, although important, does not eliminate the threat of gray goo as I pointed out above. There are other reasons (beyond manufacturing) that self-replicating nanobots will need to be created. The nanotechnology immune system mentioned above, for example, will ultimately require self-replication; otherwise it would be unable to defend us against the development of increasingly sophisticated types of goo. It is also likely to find extensive military applications. Moreover, a determined adversary or terrorist can defeat safeguards against unwanted self-replication; hence, the need for defense. The suggestion of setting up this kind of defense system against grey goo – which Kurzweil elsewhere calls “police nanobots” and “blue goo”315 – goes back to Drexler (1986). It makes me very uneasy. Joy (2000) points out that the system.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Nano D › 2NC---AT: Impossible

Nano’s feasible and likely

Dennis Pamlin 15, Executive Project Manager of the Global Risks Global Challenges Foundation, and Stuart Armstrong, James Martin Research Fellow at the Future of Humanity Institute of the Oxford Martin School at University of Oxford, Global Challenges Foundation, February,

Nanotechnology is best described as a general capacity, rather than a specific tool. In relation to infinite impacts this is a challenge, as there are many ways that nanotechnology can be used that could result in infinite impacts, but also many others where it can help reduce infinite impacts. Different possible sequences from today’s situation to precise atomic manufacturing are well documented and the probability that none of the possible paths would deliver results is very small. What specific sequence and with what results is however very uncertain. Compared with many other global challenges nanotechnology could result in many different risks - and opportunities, from an accelerated ability to manufacture (new) weapons623 to the creation of new materials and substances. These are certainly orders of magnitude more likely, far likelier than any probability of the “grey goo” that has resulted in significant misunderstanding. The data availability is difficult to estimate as there are very different kinds of data, and also an obvious lack of data, as nanotechnology is in its very early days. There are some estimates from experts, but the uncertainty is significant. A relative probability estimate is a possible ffrst step, comparing nanotechnology solutions with existing systems where the probability is better known. Admiral David E. Jeremiah, for example, said at the 1995 Foresight Conference on Molecular Technology: “Military applications of molecular manufacturing have even greater potential than nuclear weapons to radically change the balance of power.” 624 A systems forecasting approach could probably provide better estimates and help develop complementary measures that would support the positive parts of nanotechnology while reducing the negative.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Nano D › 2NC---Nano Outweighs

Nanoscale risks are unique and outweigh nukes---math supports probability

(Duncan H. Forgan 19. Associate Lecturer at the Centre for Exoplanet Science at the University of St Andrews, Scotland, founding member of the UK Search for Extra-terrestrial Intelligence (SETI) research network and leads UK research efforts into the search. 04/30/2019. “14.3 Estimates of Existential Risk from Nanoscale Manipulation.” Solving Fermi’s Paradox, Cambridge University Press.)/LRCH Jrhee *graph omitted bc it wouldn’t copy

The nature of the nanoscale risk is quite different from the risks posed by (say) nuclear weapons. The nuclear arsenals of the Earth remain under the control of a very small number of individuals. As genetic engineering and nanotechnology mature as fields of research, the ability to manipulate the nanoscale becomes available to an increasing number of individuals. Any one of these individuals could accidentally (or purposefully) trigger a catastrophic event that destroys a civilisation. If there are E individuals with access to potentially destructive technology, and the probability that an individual destroys civilisation in any given year is P, then we can define the probability that the civilisation exists after time t and can communicate, C, as a set of independent Bernoulli trials, i.e., P(C|t, E, P) = (1 − P)Et . (14.1) Therefore, we can compute the number of civilisations existing between t = 0, t0 as N(t0) = B t0 0 P(C|t , E, P)dt (14.2) where we have assumed a constant birth rate B. This can be easily integrated to show (Sotos, 2017): N(t0) = B St0 − 1 ln S , S = (1 − P)E (14.3) At large t, this tends to the steady-state solution N(t) → B E P (14.4) i.e., there is an inverse relationship between the number of individuals in a given civilisation, and the number of civilisations remaining (Figure 14.1). The generality of this solution to Fermi’s Paradox – that the democracy of technology is the cause of its downfall – is particularly powerful. All we have assumed is that technology can be destructive, and that it eventually becomes accessible to a large enough number of individuals that the product E P becomes sufficiently large. The number of communicating civilisations as a function of time, given E individuals causing self-destruction with a probability of P per individual per year. The civilisation birth rate B is fixed at one per year. This is a sufficiently general solution that we may consider it to be hard – our definition of intelligence hinges on technology, and almost all advanced technology has a destructive use. We can already use the Great Silence to rule out the upper curves in Figure 14.1, which would yield civilisation counts that would be visible on Earth (see also section 19.2). This suggests that if this is the solution to Fermi’s Paradox, then roughly E P > 10−3.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Nano D › 2NC---Nano Impact

Alien lives should be valued as equal to humans---anything else is arbitrary and a logic of devaluation that is at the root of violence

Joe Packer 7, then MA in Communication from Wake Forest University, now PhD in Communication from the University of Pittsburgh and Professor of Communication at Central Michigan University, Alien Life in Search of Acknowledgment, p. 62-63

Once we hold alien interests as equal to our own we can begin to revaluate areas previously believed to hold no relevance to life beyond this planet. A diverse group of scholars including Richard Posner, Senior Lecturer in Law at the University of Chicago, Nick Bostrom, philosophy professor at Oxford University, John Leslie philosophy professor at Guelph University and Martin Rees, Britain’s Astronomer Royal, have written on the emerging technologies that threaten life beyond the planet Earth. Particle accelerators labs are colliding matter together, reaching energies that have not been seen since the Big Bang. These experiments threaten a phase transition that would create a bubble of altered space that would expand at the speed of light killing all life in its path. Nanotechnology and other machines may soon reach the ability to self replicate. A mistake in design or programming could unleash an endless quantity of machines converting all matter in the universe into copies of themselves. Despite detailing the potential of these technologies to destroy the entire universe, Posner, Bostrom, Leslie, and Ree’s only mention of alien life in their works is in reference to the threat aliens post to humanity. The rhetorical construction of otherness only in terms of the threats it poses, but never in terms of the threat one poses to it, has been at the center of humanity’s history of genocide, colonization, and environmental destruction. Although humanity certainly has its own interests in reducing the threat of these technologies evaluating them without taking into account the danger they pose to alien life is neither appropriate nor just. It is not appropriate because framing the issue only in terms of human interests will result in priorities designed to minimize the risks and maximize the benefits to humanity, not all life. Even if humanity dealt with the threats effectively without referencing their obligation to aliens, Posner, Bostrom, Leslie, and Ree’s rhetoric would not be “just,” because it arbitrarily declares other life forms unworthy of consideration. A framework of acknowledgement would allow humanity to address the risks of these new technologies, while being cognizant of humanity’s obligations to other life within the universe. Applying the lens of acknowledgment to the issue of existential threats moves the problem from one of self destruction to universal genocide. This may be the most dramatic example of how refusing to extend acknowledgment to potential alien life can mask humanity’s obligations to life beyond this planet.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: Nano D › 2NC---Nano Impact

Even a small chance of Universe destruction outweighs certain human extinction. Earth is cosmically insignificant.

Dr. Nick Hughes 18, Postdoctoral Research Fellow at University College Dublin, PhD in Philosophy from University of St Andrews & University of Olso, and Dr. Guy Kahane, Professor of Philosophy at the University of Oxford, D. Phil. in Philosophy from Oxford University, “Our Cosmic Insignificance”, 7-6,

Humanity occupies a very small place in an unfathomably vast Universe. Travelling at the speed of light – 671 million miles per hour – it would take us 100,000 years to cross the Milky Way. But we still wouldn’t have gone very far. Our modest Milky Way galaxy contains 100–400 billion stars. This isn’t very much: according to the latest calculations, the observable universe contains around 300 sextillion stars. By recent estimates, our Milky Way galaxy is just one of 2 trillion galaxies in the observable Universe, and the region of space that they occupy spans at least 90 billion light-years. If you imagine Earth shrunk down to the size of a single grain of sand, and you imagine the size of that grain of sand relative to the entirety of the Sahara Desert, you are still nowhere near to comprehending how infinitesimally small a position we occupy in space. The American astronomer Carl Sagan put the point vividly in 1994 when discussing the famous ‘Pale Blue Dot’ photograph taken by Voyager 1. Our planet, he said, is nothing more than ‘a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam’. Stephen Hawking delivers the news more bluntly. We are, he says, “just a chemical scum on a moderate-sized planet, orbiting round a very average star in the outer suburb of one among a hundred billion galaxies.” And that’s just the spatial dimension. The observable Universe has existed for around 13.8 billion years. If we shrink that span of time down to a single year, with the Big Bang occurring at midnight on 1 January, the first Homo sapiens made an appearance at 22:24 on 31 December. It’s now 23:59:59, as it has been for the past 438 years, and at the rate we’re going it’s entirely possible that we’ll be gone before midnight strikes again. The Universe, on the other hand, might well continue existing forever, for all we know. Sagan could have added, then, that our time on this mote of dust will amount to nothing more than a blip. In the grand scheme of things we are very, very small. For Sagan, the Pale Blue Dot underscores our responsibility to treat one another with kindness and compassion. But reflection on the vastness of the Universe and our physical and temporal smallness within it often takes on an altogether darker hue. If the Universe is so large, and we are so small and so fleeting, doesn’t it follow that we are utterly insignificant and inconsequential? This thought can be a spur to nihilism. If we are so insignificant, if our existence is so trivial, how could anything we do or are – our successes and failures, our anxiety and sadness and joy, all our busy ambition and toil and endeavour, all that makes up the material of our lives – how could any of that possibly matter? To think of one’s place in the cosmos, as the American philosopher Susan Wolf puts it in ‘The Meanings of Lives’ (2007), is ‘to recognise the possibility of a perspective … from which one’s life is merely gratuitous’. The sense that we are somehow insignificant seems to be widely felt. The American author John Updike expressed it in 1985 when he wrote of modern science that: We shrink from what it has to tell us of our perilous and insignificant place in the cosmos … our century’s revelations of unthinkable largeness and unimaginable smallness, of abysmal stretches of geological time when we were nothing, of supernumerary galaxies … of a kind of mad mathematical violence at the heart of the matter have scorched us deeper than we know. In a similar vein, the French philosopher Blaise Pascal wrote in Pensées (1669): When I consider the short duration of my life, swallowed up in an eternity before and after, the little space I fill engulfed in the infinite immensity of spaces whereof I know nothing, and which know nothing of me, I am terrified. The eternal silence of these infinite spaces frightens me. Commenting on this passage in Between Man and Man (1947), the Austrian-Israeli philosopher Martin Buber said that Pascal had experienced the ‘uncanniness of the heavens’, and thereby came to know ‘man’s limitation, his inadequacy, the casualness of his existence’. In the film Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life (1983), John Cleese and Eric Idle conspire to persuade a character, played by Terry Gilliam, to give up her liver for donation. Understandably reluctant, she is eventually won over by a song that sharply details just how comically inconsequential she is in the cosmic frame. Even the relatively upbeat Sagan wasn’t, in fact, immune to the pessimistic point of view. As well as viewing it as a lesson in the need for collective goodwill, he also argued that the Pale Blue Dot challenges ‘our posturings, our imagined self-importance, and the delusion that we have some privileged position in the Universe’. When we reflect on the vastness of the universe, our humdrum cosmic location, and the inevitable future demise of humanity, our lives can seem utterly insignificant. As we complacently go about our little Earthly affairs, we barely notice the black backdrop of the night sky. Even when we do, we usually see the starry skies as no more than a pleasant twinkling decoration. This sense of cosmic insignificance is not uncommon; one of Joseph Conrad’s characters describes one of those dewy, clear, starry nights, oppressing our spirit, crushing our pride, by the brilliant evidence of the awful loneliness, of the hopeless obscure insignificance of our globe lost in the splendid revelation of a glittering, soulless universe. I hate such skies. The young Bertrand Russell, a close friend of Conrad, bitterly referred to the Earth as “the petty planet on which our bodies impotently craw.” Russell wrote that: Brief and powerless is Man’s life; on him and all his race the slow, sure doom falls pitiless and dark. Blind to good and evil, reckless of destruction, omnipotent matter rolls on its relentless way…This is why Russell thought that, in the absence of God, we must build our lives on “a foundation of unyielding despair.” When we consider ourselves as a mere dot in a vast universe, when we consider ourselves in light of everything there is, nothing human seems to matter. Even the worst human tragedy may seem to deserve no cosmic concern. After all, we are fighting for attention with an incredibly vast totality. How could this tiny speck of dust deserve even a fraction of attention, from that universal point of view? This is the image that is evoked when, for example, Simon Blackburn writes that “to a witness with the whole of space and time in its view, nothing on the human scale will have meaning”. Such quotations could be easily multiplied—we find similar remarks, for example, in John Donne, Voltaire, Schopenhauer, Byron, Tolstoy, Chesterton, Camus, and, in recent philosophy, in Thomas Nagel, Harry Frankfurt, and Ronald Dworkin. The bigger the picture we survey, the smaller the part of any point within it, and the less attention it can get… When we try to imagine a viewpoint encompassing the entire universe, humanity and its concerns seem to get completely swallowed up in the void. Over the centuries, many have thought it absurd to think that we are the only ones. For example, Anaxagoras, Epicurus, Lucretius, and, later, Giordano Bruno, Huygens and Kepler were all confident that the universe is teeming with life. Kant was willing to bet everything he had on the existence of intelligent life on other planets. And we now know that there is a vast multitude of Earth-like planets even in our own little galaxy. The experience of cosmic insignificance is often blamed on the rise of modern science, and the decline of religious belief. Many think that things started to take a turn for the worse with Copernicus. Nietzsche, for example, laments ‘the nihilistic consequences of contemporary science’, and adds that Since Copernicus it seems that man has found himself on a descending slope—he always rolls further and further away from his point of departure toward… —where is that? Towards nothingness? Freud later wrote about a series of harsh blows to our self-esteem delivered by science. The first blow was delivered by Copernicus, when we learned, as Freud puts it, that “our earth was not the centre of the universe but only a tiny fragment of a cosmic system of scarcely imaginable vastness…” It is still common to refer, in a disappointed tone, to the discovery that we aren’t at the centre of God’s creation, as we had long thought, but located, as Carl Sagan puts it, “in some forgotten corner”. We live, Sagan writes, “on a mote of dust circling a humdrum star in the remotest corner of an obscure galaxy.”

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: AI D › 2NC---AT: Shermer

Shermer defense is pure silliness.

Dr. Olle Häggström 17, professor of mathematical statistics, PhD from the Chalmers University of Technology, research specialist in AI, 9/17/2017, “Michael Shermer fails in his attempt to argue that AI is not an existential threat,” http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2017/09/michael-shermer-fails-in-his-attempt-to.html?m=1, cc

Why Artificial Intelligence is Not an Existential Threat is an aticle by leading science writer Michael Shermer1 in the recent issue 2/2017 of his journal Skeptic (mostly behind paywall). How I wish he had a good case for the claim contained in the title! But alas, the arguments he provides are weak, bordering on pure silliness. Shermer is certainly not the first high-profile figure to react to the theory of AI (artificial intelligence) existential risk, as developed by Eliezer Yudkowsky, Nick Bostrom and others, with an intuitive feeling that it cannot possibly be right, and the (slightly megalomaniacal) sense of being able to refute the theory, single-handedly and with very moderate intellectual effort. Previous such attempts, by Steven Pinker and by John Searle, were exposed as mistaken in my book Here Be Dragons, and the purpose of the present blog post is to do the analogous thing to Shermer's arguments.

The first half of Shermer's article is a not-very-deep-but-reasonably-competent summary of some of the main ideas of why an AI breakthrough might be an existential risk to humanity. He cites the leading thinkers of the field: Eliezer Yudkowsky, Nick Bostrom and Stuart Russell, along with famous endorsements from Elon Musk, Stephen Hawking, Bill Gates and Sam Harris.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: AI D › 2NC---Indict

AFF cards are profit politicized skepticism---err NEG.

Seth D. Baum 18, executive director of the Global Catastrophic Risk Institute and PhD in geography from Penn State, 8/22/2018, “Superintelligence Skepticism as a Political Tool,” Information, 9(9), , cc

The purpose of this paper is to explore the potential for skepticism about artificial superintelligence to be used for political ends. Artificial superintelligence (for brevity, henceforth just superintelligence) refers to AI that is much smarter than humans. Current AI is not superintelligent, but the prospect of superintelligence is a topic of much discussion in scholarly and public spheres. Some believe that superintelligence could someday be built, and that, if it is built, it would have massive and potentially catastrophic consequences. Others are skeptical of these beliefs. While much of the existing skepticism appears to be honest intellectual debate, there is potential for it to be politicized for other purposes.

In simple terms (to be refined below), politicized skepticism can be defined as public articulation of skepticism that is intended to achieve some outcome other than an improved understanding of the topic at hand. Politicized skepticism can be contrasted with intellectual skepticism, which seeks an improved understanding. Intellectual skepticism is essential to scholarly inquiry; politicized skepticism is not. The distinction between the two is not always clear; statements of skepticism may have both intellectual and political motivations. The two concepts can nonetheless be useful for understanding debates over issues such as superintelligence.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: AI D › 2NC---AI Impact

b. On probability---dwarfs the risks from nuke war, climate change, AND pandemics COMBINED.

Toby Ord 20, senior research fellow in philosophy at Oxford University and world-renowned risk-assessment expert who has advised WHO, the World Bank, the WEF, and the US National Intelligence Council, 3/3/2020, The Precipice: Existential Risk and the Future of Humanity, pp. 194-196, cc

The numbers represent my overall degrees of belief that each of the catastrophes will befall us this century. This means they aren’t simply an encapsulation of the information and argumentation in the chapters on the risks. Instead, they rely on an accumulation of knowledge and judgment on each risk that goes beyond what can be distilled into a few pages. They are not in any way a final word, but are a concise summary of all I know about the risk landscape.

Existential catastrophe via: Asteroid or comet impact Chance within next 100 years: ∼ 1 in 1,000,000