Disability and the Ideology of Competence As stated, I am not going to analyse the disabling phenomena beyond the sphere of capitalism, but rather to understand them as part of the complex system of ontological maintenance of the capital (Mészáros 2011). One way (not the only way) to do that is to approach, from a materialist perspective, the ideological discourse of competence. It unveils not only what is expected from the working class but also what is to be discarded. Competence is a concept that is in dialectical relation with the concepts of class, exploitation, and individual. Social class, one’s position in the economic and political structure of capitalism, will have a direct impact on the limits imposed on and possibilities opened up to individuals. That is, humans make their history, but they are determined by sociohistorical forces beyond their control (Marx & Engels 1968). Therefore, a materialist reading of disability may largely contribute to deepen and expand the scientific knowledge around the disabling phenomena. Social class, albeit a commonly forgotten category in the analyses of disability, is an essential aspect of it. There are complex divergencies between facing an impairment in the higher classes, in the middle-classes, or in the lower-classes7 (See Erevelles 2011; Cabral 2021; Russel 2019; Santos 2020). Wright (1998) argues that exploitation is a grounding concept when it comes to class analysis because it creates a fissure between the higher classes (the owners of the capital, land, and means of production), who exploit, and the rest who are exploited. The development of capitalist relations, however, engendered new classes, a class that originates from the social and technical divisions of labour (Wayne 2020; Wright 1998). The middle-classes are constituted by those in the working class who perform jobs that require more complex skills in contrast to those who are working in manual jobs - and thus tendentiously share contrasting interests with them. These are also called in sociological works primary and secondary sector jobs, which respectively represent “those with high wages, high skill levels, good working conditions, job security, and ample opportunities for promotion” in contrast to “low wages, low skill levels, poor working conditions, little job security, and few if any possibilities for advancement.” (Barnes 1992b, p. 57). Wayne (2020, p. 5) keenly highlights that The social division of labour is linked to class formation because across the various branches of productive activity designed to meet variable social needs, the same social types in control of those branches have more in common with each other than they do with their immediate workers, who have the least control, least power and lowest remuneration in the production process. The maintenance of class structure and the inducement of competition and individualism in the working-classes is a fundamental trait to the ontological continuation of capitalism. The social division of labour focuses on the formation of an un-critical, individualist, and indebted working-middle class with no sense of unity or class consciousness (Marx & Engels 2008; Mészáros 2008; 2011). The spread of meritocratic values amongst the professional and managerial strata of the working-class gives them a glamorous look and the false impression that they are closer to the top than to the bottom, that they share more with those in power than with those in classes below them (Wayne & Cabral 2021). The relevance of the discussion of class lies in the fact that when we talk about inclusion without questioning capitalism, we are usually referring to the right to enter the labour force and be exploited. Disability in the working-class demands the absence of one of the non-disabled members of the family from the labour market to provide care for the disabled member. This care may also be relegated to a philanthropic special institution - in the latter, allowing all working members of the families to be absorbed by the capital (Russel 2019). It may be argued, however, that the concepts and definitions of what it means “to be able to work” are variable (Stone 1984). Indeed they are, but those are regulated by the State and by the capitalists themselves, and they vary not only influenced directly by pressures of society, but by the demands of the capital (Russel 2019). In other words, it means to say that their jobs and the place they occupy are both part of a regulatory system of the capital, as Russel (2019) argues, and a special kind of charity - in either case their workforce is easily disposable. If we consider here Robert Young’s (2009) analyses of Marx’s concept of use of value, we may indicate that: in the Capital’s commodity structure when those deemed disabled are exchanged, they are exchanged for less. Erevelles (2011, p. 252) argues that “[…] “becoming disabled is also a historical event where disability also has a use value that is deployed simultaneously with race to justify the creation of the enslaved un-gendered body. ” and that the “[…] actual act of impairment that is used both to create and at the same time to justify this construction.” Proof of that have also been the recent changes in the Brazilian legislation regarding the regulations for the mandatory employment of disabled people. Advancements in laws and legal regulations are indeed an important part of the struggles of the working class, but they “are ‘solutions’ which promote conflict between groups of disadvantaged workers, rather than making it a right of every citizen to have a living-wage job and health care” (Russel 2019, p. 77). They are part of what Mészáros (2008; 2011) regards as corrections in the structure of the capital. They play a fundamental role in the ontological conservation of capital when softening the tensions between the owners of the capital and the working class. Barnes (1992) advocated in favour of anti-discrimination legislation as a solution to improve the participation of disabled workers in the labour market, as we all should. No one would deny that even within the limits of the capital one should always fight against discrimination, prejudice, and deprivation of access to better living conditions. Notwithstanding, the market finds its ways to ‘dodge’ the legislation. When it comes to disabled workers that usually happens through what Samuels (2014) calls biocertification. Biocertification is the process companies and industries use to certify that a new employee will follow their not-so-secret internal rules, using medical reports, exams, and tests. By means of biocertification processes individuals are reduced to their biological characteristics and are erased as social subjects, “[b]iocertification materializes the modern belief that only science can reliably determine the truths of identity and generally claims to offer a simple, verifiable, and concrete solution to questions of identity” (Samuels 2014, p. 122). The structure of capital and its relations of material and cultural production, distribution, and exchange convey ideological models of individuals, social relations, and patterns of social behaviour that must be assimilated to guarantee the right to actively participate in everyday life, from the most trivial activities to the most complex forms of social participation. These representations will revolve around the notions of gender, race, age, ethnicity, sexual orientation, and, in the case of the working classes, labour skills. They carry labels of non-deviant and deviant. The archetype of an ideal individual is linked to the project of society: Hence, the oppression that disabled people face is rooted in the economic and social structures of capitalism. And this oppression is structured by racism, sexism, homophobia, ageism, and disablism, which is endemic to all capitalist societies and cannot be explained away as a universal cognitive process. (Oliver 1990, p. 165). Oliver is arguing that the foundations of prejudice are in fact part of the ideological structure of capitalism. It a structure founded on an ideological and hegemonic set of “ideas, values, belief systems, habits and practices that defend and legitimise the interests of groups at the expense of other groups in relationships of inequality” (Wayne 2020, p. 136, author’s highlights). Hence, it is important here to clarify my understanding of five concepts that are usually present in discussions of inequality, prejudice, and disability: oppression, segregation, exploitation, and inclusion/exclusion. It is my understanding that, from a materialist perspective, they are all class-related issues. Oppression derives from the idea that due to one or more deviant characteristics one is deprived from access to some or all material, cultural, and social conditions that would allow them to carry on a fulfilling life or, as Wright (2019) calls it, a flourishing life. Oppression represents an image of someone being crushed, smashed, held (socially) against their own will and despite their own efforts to change. Oppression is a product of ideologies embedded in the social structure of capitalism and it is related to inequality. Segregation revolves around marginalisation. The social process in which those who are unable to follow one or more social expectations are centrifuged, sent to the borders of society. They are not welcomed to participate in everyday life. Segregation comes as an alternative to the idea of social exclusion, as we shall see below. Exploitation, in turn, is the essential concept that sustains capital every day. The act of extracting surplus value out of those who own nothing else but their labour power (Marx 2012). Stripped of all properties and material conditions, workers have no way to sustain life other than by selling their labour power to those who own those material conditions. Modern capitalism, however, has become even more complex than it used to be when Marx’s wrote Das Kapital (Wright 2019). In order to guarantee its own survival, the structure of class conditions was reshaped based on the social and technical divisions of labour. Different class interests will clash between those who own the capital, those in positions that require higher qualification and more sophisticated skills (the modern middle-classes), and the ones performing jobs that are socially characterised as lower jobs (Wayne 2020). A material approach to these concepts understands that the condition of class will determine - imposing starting points, limits, and ends, as Williams (1988) and Wright (2019) define it - their extensions and impacts on an individual’s life. It means to say that one may be segregated but not so much oppressed. So, the extent of the processes of oppression, segregation, and exploitation is class-determined. Going back to Wayne’s definition of ideology, he understands that: there is capitalism itself which has a built-in cultural tendency to decontextualise social phenomena, individualise social phenomena and de-historicise social phenomena. We may also add that capitalism prematurely or falsely universalises capitalist culture and value systems (e.g., the only way to live) (Wayne 2020, p. 137). Therefore, there is a paramount comprehension of capitalist practices when it comes to the analysis of the disabling phenomena. When we look at Marx’s exposition of the sphere of pauperism, we were in fact targeting how this process of decontextualisation, individualisation, and de-historicisation affect those who are considered unable to adapt. Historically and traditionally, capitalist ideologies have treated disability as a personal, individual tragedy, which is brought out of context and history, in an attempt to exempt society from any obligations it might have. Against this, Russel (2019, p. 51) argues that: Our institutions (particularly medical and social welfare institutions) have historically held disablement to be an individual problem, not the result of economic or social forces. They have equated disability with physiological, anatomical, or mental “defects” and hegemonically held these conditions responsible for the disabled person’s lack of full participation in the economic life of our society. This approach presumed a biological inferiority of disabled persons. Their deviation from social models of adaptation to everyday life and productivity in the cycle of the capital, established by social standards of normality, promotes processes of social marginalisation, from institutionalising policies of discrimination to deprivation of social participation (Barnes 2012; Bueno 2001; Ferreira 1994; Vygotski 2004). It is in and from everyday life that the concepts, values, and norms that represent, regulate and organise a concrete social formation are executed (Heller 2016). Daily life is the expression of the real life of the subjects that are part of it, it is the immediate unity of action and thought and expression of concepts, values and norms formed from the hegemonic ideology conveyed and foisted upon individuals (Chauí 2016; Heller 2016). Everyday life is ordinary thinking, common sense, and the expression of uncritical thinking. It is the embodiment of men's life, and it is from it that they express their truth, build their beliefs, and guide their lives (Heller 2016). Everyday thought, the common sense, is based on experience in the complex ideological network that maintains the socio-metabolic functioning of capital and aims at the “orientation towards stability and relatively quiet social reproduction” (Mészáros 2004, p. 486- 487). The process of stigmatisation in the case of disabled people permeates the complex social construction of everyday life. The distancing of adaptation to the patterns of normality established in everyday life crystallises the stigma and removes from the person with an impairment the condition of ‘human’ and projects it socially as the ‘non-human’ – as Marx’s pointed out a spectre to political economy. The representation of the stigma occurs by a reduction of the subject to only one of its characteristics - usually that which is downgraded or socially overvalued (Goffman 1963). The possible overcoming of these conditions, or even the performance of more basic daily actions, can raise the stigmatised subject to the condition of superhuman, keeping them still in a non-human status. A stigmatised person may, however, reformulate the rules when they reach a position a social prestige. They are taken to the level of representation of their group and will be considered the example of self-determination, meritocracy, and success (Goffman 1963; McNamee & Miller 2009; Wayne & Cabral 2021). Leonard Kriegel (1987) scrutinised the images of representation of disabled characters reproduced in literature and narrowed them down to four categories, namely: Demonic cripple, Charity cripple, Realistic cripple, and Survivor Cripple. I will not discuss all of these categories, but the last one may be useful here to illustrate my previous arguments. The Survivor Cripple “[…] is the man who endures and, in his endurance, discovers survival as a cause in itself […]. His endurance is attractive, both to himself and to the audience, for it is constructed around his understanding of the limitations it has imposed on him.” (KRIEGEL, 1987, p. 38). The survivor cripple is the counterpart of the disabled person as pitiable and pathetic, as an object of pity, it is the representation of meritocratic values - the one who fights against all odds and thrives. The bridge between class conditions and the idea of a (disabled) survivor relies on capitalist meritocracy that seems to be reproduced in the image of the survivor, both in the lower and in the middle classes. The image of the disabled person has been used as a motivational strategy, to trigger feelings of determination, and has been associated with struggle and the power to overcome difficulties, usually followed by the question “What is your excuse?”. This may be perceived in the real-life based cinematic representations of disability, as they may imprint more credibility and cause a greater effect on the audiences. The Survivor Cripple makes the impairment a tragedy and overcoming it the objective or the solution to the problem. The use of disability in motivational campaigns and films projects the disabled person as an object of ridicule and as their own worst and only enemy – “if they wanted, they could.” – and cement meritocratic values – “if they did, what’s your excuse?”. As examples, I could mention the biographical films based on the lives of Christy Brown (Sheridan 2008), Gabriela Brimmer (Mandoki 1987), and Stephen Hawking (Marsh 2014). The decades after 1990 have been marked by various events and political and social reviews on the role and place of disabled people in society (Jannuzzi 2004). However, the system of justification and ideological reproduction of stereotypes in the categorisation of the socially conceived human body, the labour body and mind, as perfect permeates concrete social relationships in everyday life and triggers processes of stigmatisation of the deviants (Samuels 2014; Stone 1984). Stigma is thus very much in constant relation with the ideologies that are working through culture – as I have demonstrated with some examples in the previous paragraph. Competence, structured by bourgeois ideological pillars, conveyed by the media, and absorbed by the cultural industry, sells signs and images of youth, health and happiness (Chauí 2016). It is a powerful method of manipulation that “inoculate[s] individuals with the bourgeois appetite for personal success” (Freire 1970, p. 147). The social process of constructing the discourse of the competent produces its dialectical counterpart, the incompetent. The social and ideological role of the competent, valued by the social power of science, as an unquestionable source of knowledge, underlies and justifies the domination and economic exploitation of one class, considered superior in material and cultural capital, over the other, expropriated from the whole (Chauí 2016; Samuels 2014). The analysis of perfection, based on a neoliberal ideology, established mainly after the 1980s (Harvey 2011), subjugates disability in the working class mainly to spaces of pauperism, marginalisation and segregation and is marked by the sociopolitical order and the power of science. The ideological projection of the perfection of productivity, sociability, independence, meritocracy characterises in the opposite pole the lack and the insufficiency, emphasising the defect and erasing individuals beyond their disability and making the construction of their social relations unfeasible (Barnes 2012; Heller 2016; Soldatic & Meekosha 2012a; 2012b; Vygotski 1993). The naturalising element of capital is propagated and foisted upon individuals that reproduce the social structure through complex ideological systems of conservation, keeping individuals locked in the relationships of everyday life. Everyday life is, therefore, the life of every social subject, without being able to be totally out of it or completely trapped by it. It is in everyday life that the dominant metabolic ideological processes are emptied and reified as absolute and natural truths (Heller 2016; Mészáros 2004; 2016). Mészáros (2005, p. 401) argues that the dominant ideology of capitalism is “[…] sustained by the practical evidence of the established material structures within which people have to reproduce the material and cultural conditions of their existence and ‘feel at home as a fish in water’”. Most of the population is conditioned by the ideological standards set by the ruling class. Its ideological structure is: a logical, systematic, and coherent set of representations (ideas and values) and norms or rules (of conduct) that indicate and prescribe to the members of a society what they should think and how they should think about it, what they should value and how they should value it, what they should feel and how they should feel it, what they should do and how they should do it. (Chauí 2016, p. 53). The dominating force of ideology lies in pacification, naturalisation of the hegemonic social organisation and unity of interests, although they are conflicting (Mészáros 2008; Wayne 2020; Zizek 2012). Ideology, in its hegemonic sense, structures life lived and represents “a sense of reality for most people in the society, a sense of absolute because experienced reality beyond which it is very difficult for most members of the society to move, in most areas of their lives” (Williams 1980, p. 38). It is in the everyday life that the ideological patterns of normality are executed. Heller (2016, p. 37) indicates that [t]he maturation of man means, in any society, that the individual acquires all the essential skills for the daily life of the society (social layer) in question. It is an adult who is able to live his daily life for himself. Ideological patterns of normality are socially and historically established attributes and characteristics that are reproduced as natural and ordinary and that categorise subjects as normal and abnormal deviant. They establish the norms that define what it means to be a socially desired human (Amaral 1995; Everlles 2011; Heller 2011). Stigma disqualifies the individual due to a singular characteristic that deviates from the ideological norms and standards imposed and determines the limits of their social participation. Lastly, I would like to go back to inclusion. Inclusion is part of the ideological process of self-correctness and self-preservation of the bourgeois society. It is an attempt to lessen the weight of structural injustices, inequalities, segregations/exclusions that are part of the ontological foundations of the capital. Marx’s thought elucidates how contradictory the concept is: when analysing the production of relative surplus-value, that within the capitalist system all methods for raising the social productivity of labour are put into effect at the cost of the individual worker; that all means for the development of production undergo a dialectical inversion so that they become means of domination and exploitation of the producers. (Marx 1990, p. 799). Some lines below, he famously concludes that: Accumulation of wealth at one pole is, therefore, at the same time accumulation of misery, the torment of labour, slavery, ignorance, brutalization and moral degradation at the opposite pole, i.e., on the side of the class that produces its own product as capital. (Marx 1990, p. 799). Inclusion, therefore, is the movement of opening opportunities to share material and cultural capital with (some of) those who were deprived from access to them. It does so without questioning or challenging the very essence of the society that created deprivation in the first place. Inclusion and exclusion are part of the same dialects. One is the dialectical inversion of the other. The need to include only exists because of a society that engenders exclusion. Thus, as I suggested, exclusion might not be a real thing, in immediate cultural and material access perhaps it does, but not as part of the structure of the system itself, i.e., the individual is not excluded from the system, they are a product of it. Inclusion and exclusion were uncritically adopted by all postmodern studies of identity, and inclusion became a motto to be fought for - as Wayne suggested (2020, p. 39), “change without real change”. In other words, these changes are constrained within the limits of capitalism and do not represent a threat to the structure of the system. Notwithstanding its core contradictions, it is something we shall all fight for. If within the limits and contradictions of the capital this is the only possibility - or the closest possibility - some individuals will have to access a flourishing life - meaning access to education, health, cultural expressions, housing, food - then until the whole system changes, perhaps it is what one should fight for. In the case of disabled people, it applies even to the access or opportunity of access to be exploited – as cruel as this may sound; that is what the “inclusion for disabled people” is in fact fighting for. In that sense, “[b]asic changes must be made in the economic, social, and political structure in order to advance economic solutions that reach beyond capitalism’s instability. The reserve army, itself, must be made a disposable concept” (Russel 2019, p. 77). Despite the limitations of what Wayne calls (following Gramsci) passive revolution – “the paradox of massive change within the social relations of capitalism: change without real change” (Wayne 2020 p. 39, author's highlights) -, these seem to represent a possibility to improve the lives of those who are now in need, not only focusing on disabled people, but also on other forms of discrimination as well. My favourite and paramount argument in that regard is that Every reasonable and reasoned action proposed in an attempt to accelerate the social and political inclusion of the poor in the process of economic development in order to bring equality to social development is historically welcomed. As much within the scope of the State and its public policies as within civil society. It would be equally wicked to deny the diversity of the aspirations and intervention actions in the problematic reality. (Martins 2012, p. 1). Nonetheless, we should not be satisfied with them, for they do not interrupt the flow and the logics of the capital.