Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?

Bataille is a fascist who views war as an aesthetic---reading his cards justifies mass violence---reject it

Wolin 96 [Richard Wolin, 1996, “Left Fascism: Georges Bataille and the German Ideology,” The Inheritance of the German Right, Constellations, Volume 2, Issue 3,

Moreover, the cultural attitudes of both Spengler and Bataille are linked by an aesthetics of violence that is highly characteristic of the “front generation.” In a key passage in The Decline of the West, Spengler, depicting the “life-world” of blood and instinct that had been repressed by the Faustian spirit of modernity, observes: “War is the primary politics of everything that lives and so much so that in the depths battle and life are one, and being and will-to-battle expire together.”2’ Similarly, for Junger, “War is an intoxication beyond all bonds. It is a frenzy without cautions and limits, comparable only to the forces of nature.”29 Bataille (the meaning of his name in French should be recalled), too, is convinced, that “conflict is life. Man’s value depends upon his aggressive strength. A living man regards death as the fulfillment of life; he does not see it as a misfortune. . , , I MYSELF AM WAR.”30 As Jay observes in this connection: “on a deeper level, the war [World War I] seems to have exercised a certain positive fascination [on Bataille]. For it is striking that many of Bataille’s obsessive themes would betray an affinity for the experiences of degradation, pollution, violence and communal bonding that were characteristic of life in the trenches. In the worldview of both Bataille and that of German young conservatives, war plays an essential, positive role. It serves as a means of dissolving the principium individuationis: the principle of bourgeois subjectivity, on which the homogeneous order of society - a world of loneliness and fragmentation - depends. For, according to Bataille, “the general movement of life is . . . accomplished beyond the demands of individual^."^^ It is in precisely this spirit that he celebrates the nonutilitarian nature of “combat” or “war” as a type of aestheticist end in itself: “Glory . . . expresses a movement of senseless frenzy, of measureless expenditure of energy, which the fervor of combat presupposes. Combat is glorious in that it is always beyond calculation at some moment.”33 For the same reasons, Bataille eulogizes those premodern “warmer societies in which pure, uncalculated violence and ostentatious forms of combat held sway.” For under such conditions, war was not made subservient to the vulgar ends of enterprise and accumulation, as is the case for modern-day imperialism, but served as a glorious end in itself. Yet, in the early 1930s, it was precisely this aestheticist celebration of “violence for violence’s sake,” or “war for war’s sake,” that Benjamin viewed as the essence of modern fascism. As he remarks in a well known passage : “Fiat ars - pereat mundus,” says fascism, and, as Marinetti admits, expects war to supply the artistic gratification of a sense perception that has been changed by technology. . . . Mankind, which in Homer’s time was an object of contemplation for the Olympian gods, now is one for itself. Its selfalienation has reached such a degree that it can experience its own destruction as an aesthetic pleasure of the first order. This is the situation of politics which fascism is rendering aesthetic.~

2022 Michigan Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---Link---AT: Death?

Bifo’s theory is wrong – collapse has been empirically disproven

Malcolm Harris 11, Senior Managing Editor and Columnist for The New Inquiry, Writer and Editor for Sharable, “I Sure Hope Bifo Doesn’t Count Vibrators as Tools of Estrangement”, Destructural, 2-20, \\iris

I just finished Franco Berardi’s The Soul at Work, and though there’s a lot to agree with in there, the conclusion left me feeling argumentative. In reviving Baudrillard’s critique of the politics of desire, Berardi argues that horizontalism and affirmation – two cornerstones of Deleuze and Guatarri’s schizo thought – have been irredeemably co-opted by capital. Our social pathology is no longer Freudian repression, but overabundance of affirmation, of injunctions to consume and desire that produce panic and depression. When our very affective expressions have been colonized, the multitude is nothing but a robotic swarm:

“The multitude can speak hundreds of thousands of languages, but the language that enables it to function as an integrated whole is that of the economic automatisms embodied in technology. Seized in a game of mirrors of indeterminacy and precariousness, the multitude manifests its dark side and follows automatisms that turn its wealth into misery, its power into anguish and its creativity into dependency.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---AT: Cybernetics K---T/L

Data is good for policymaking

Reiter 15 [Dan Reiter, 08-27-2015, “Scholars Help Policymakers Know Their Tools," War On The Rocks, \\iris

A third critique is that much of this academic work on foreign policy tools is unusable by policymakers because it is too quantitative and technically complex. Here, echoing a point made by Erik Voeten, there is a danger in not appreciating the importance of rigorous research design, including sophisticated quantitative techniques, for crafting effective policy. Sophisticated research design is not the enemy of effective policy, it is critically necessary for it. Certainly, the current academic focus on building research designs that permit causal inference speaks exactly to what policymakers care about the most: if implementing a certain policy will cause the desired outcome.

Or, put differently, bad research designs make for bad public policy. A classic example is school busing. In the 1960s and early 1970s, some cities adopted voluntary integration programs for public schools, in which families could volunteer to bus their children to schools in neighborhoods with different racial majorities. Policymakers used the favorable results for the voluntary programs to make the improper inference that mandatory busing policies would also work. The result was bad public policy and violence in the streets.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---AT: Cybernetics K---T/L

Cybernetic information capitalism is inevitable

Zuboff 19 [Shoshana Zuboff, 2019, “Surveillance Capitalism and the Challenge of Collective Action,” New Labor Forum,

The Challenge to Collective Action How do they get away with it? Dozens of surveys conducted since 2008 attest to substantial majorities in the United States, the European Union, and around the world that reject the premises and practices of surveillance capitalism, yet it persists, succeeds, grows, and dominates, remaining largely uncontested by either existing or new forms of collective action.28 In other work I have detailed sixteen conditions that enabled this new logic of accumulation to root and flourish.29 Here I want to underscore two of these conditions: The first is the absence of organic reciprocities between surveillance capitalist firms and their populations. This absence produces the second condition, in which dependency replaces reciprocity as the fulcrum of this commercial project. A first answer to the question “How do they get away with it?” concerns a novel structural feature of this market form that diverges sharply from the history of market democracy. For all the failings, injustice, and violence of earlier forms of modern capitalism, the necessity of organic reciprocities with its populations has been a mark of endurance and adaptability. Symbolized in the twentieth century by Ford’s five-dollar day, these reciprocities reach back to Adam Smith’s original insights into the productive social relations of capitalism, in which firms rely on people as employees and customers. Smith argued that price increases had to be balanced with wage increases “so that the laborer may still be able to purchase that quantity of those necessary articles which the state of the demand for labor … requires that he should have.”30 By the 1980s, globalization and neoliberal ideology, operationalized in the shareholder-value movement, went a long way toward destroying these centuries-old reciprocities between capitalism and its communities. Surveillance capitalism completes the job. Instrumentarianism is a market project that converges with the digital to achieve its own unique brand of social domination. First, surveillance capitalists no longer rely on people as consumers. Instead, the axis of supply and demand orients the surveillance capitalist firm to businesses intent on anticipating the behavior of populations, groups, and individuals. The result is that populations are conceptualized as undifferentiated “users,” who are merely the sources of raw material for a digital-age production process aimed at a new business customer. Where individual consumers continue to exist in surveillance capitalist operations—purchasing smart appliances, digital assistants, dolls that spy, or behavior-based insurance policies, just to name a few examples—social relations are no longer founded on mutual exchange. In these and many other 12 New Labor Forum 00(0) instances, products and services are merely hosts for surveillance capitalism’s data extraction operations. For example, the concept of the “smart home” has become emblematic of this new asymmetry. By 2018 the global smart home market was valued at $36 billion USD and expected to reach $151 billion by 2023.31 The numbers betray an earthquake beneath their surface. Consider just one smart home device: the Nest thermostat owned by Alphabet, the Google holding company, and merged with Google in 2018.32 The Nest thermostat collects data about its usage and environment. It uses motion sensors and computation to “learn” the behaviors of a home’s inhabitants. Nest’s apps can also gather data from other connected products such as cars, ovens, fitness trackers, beds.33 Such systems can, for example, trigger lights if an anomalous motion is detected, signaling video and audio recording, and even sending notifications to homeowners or others. As a result of the merger with Google, the thermostat, like other Nest products, will be built with Google’s artificial intelligence capabilities, including its personal digital “Assistant.”34 The thermostat and its brethren devices create immense new stores of knowledge and therefore new power—but for whom? Wi-Fi-enabled and -networked, the thermostat’s intricate personalized data stores are uploaded to Google’s servers. Each thermostat comes with a “Privacy Policy,” a “Terms of Service Agreement,” and an “End-User Licensing Agreement.” These reveal oppressive privacy and security consequences in which sensitive household and personal information are shared with other smart devices, unnamed personnel, and third parties for the purposes of predictive analyses and sales to other unspecified parties. Nest takes little responsibility for the security of the information it collects and none for how the other companies in its ecosystem will put those data to use.35 A detailed analysis of Nest’s policies by two University of London scholars concluded that were one to enter into the Nest ecosystem of connected devices and apps, each with its own equally burdensome and audacious terms, the purchase of a single home thermostat entails the need to review nearly a thousand so-called contracts.36 Should the customer refuse to agree to Nest’s stipulations, the Terms of Service indicate that the functionality and security of the thermostat will be deeply compromised, no longer supported by the necessary updates meant to ensure its reliability and safety. The consequences can range from frozen pipes to failed smoke alarms to an easily hacked internal home system.37 The absence of consumer reciprocities is complemented by the absence of employment reciprocities. By historical standards the large surveillance capitalists employ relatively few people compared to their unprecedented computational resources. This pattern, in which a small, highly educated workforce leverages the power of a massive capital-intensive knowledge-production infrastructure, is called “hyperscale.”38 The historical discontinuity of the hyperscale business operation becomes apparent by comparing seven decades of General Motors (GM) employment levels and market capitalization to recent post-IPO (initial public offering) data from Google and Facebook. (I have confined the comparison here to Google and Facebook because both were pure surveillance capitalist firms even before their public offerings.) Nest takes little responsibility for the security of the information it collects and none for how the other companies in its ecosystem will put those data to use. From the time they went public to 2016, Google and Facebook steadily climbed to the heights of market capitalization, with Google reaching $532 billion by the end of 2016 and Facebook at $332 billion, without Google ever employing more than 75,000 people or Facebook more than 18,000. General Motors took four decades to reach its highest market capitalization of $225.15 billion in 1965, when it employed 735,000 women and men.39 Most startling is that GM employed more people during the height of the Great Depression than either Google or Facebook employs at their heights of market capitalization. Zuboff 13 The GM pattern is the iconic story of the United States in the twentieth century, before globalization, neoliberalism, the shareholdervalue movement, and plutocracy unraveled the public corporation and the institutions of what historian Karl Polanyi called “the double movement,” a network of “measures and policies … integrated into powerful institutions designed to check the action of the market relative to labor, land, and money.”40 Polanyi’s studies led him to conclude that the operations of a self-regulating market are profoundly destructive when allowed to run free of such countervailing laws and policies. It was the institutions of the double movement that tamed GM’s employment policies with fair labor practices, unionization, and collective bargaining, emblematic of stable reciprocities during the pre-globalization decades of the twentieth century. The societal result was predictable. In the 1950s, for example, 80 percent of adults said that “big business” was a good thing for the country, 66 percent believed that business required little or no change, and 60 percent agreed, “the profits of large companies help make things better for everyone who buys their products or services.”41 [A]…survey in 2015 found 91 percent of respondents disagreeing that the collection of personal information “without my knowing” is a fair tradeoff for a price discount. Although some critics blamed GM’s institutional reciprocities for its failure to adapt to global competition in the late 1980s, leading eventually to its bankruptcy in 2009, analyses have shown that chronic managerial complacency and doomed financial strategies bore the greatest share of responsibility for the firm’s legendary decline, a conclusion that is fortified by the successes of the German automobile industry in the twenty-first century, where strong labor institutions formally share decision-making authority.42 Nearly seventy years later and in the absence of democratic checks on the power of surveillance capitalists, the picture is very different. For example, a major 2009 survey found that when Americans are informed of the ways that companies gather data for targeted online ads, 73 to 86 percent rejected such advertising.43 Another substantial survey in 2015 found 91 percent of respondents disagreeing that the collection of personal information “without my knowing” is a fair tradeoff for a price discount. Fifty-five percent disagreed that it was a fair exchange for improved services.44 In 2016 PEW Research reported only 9 percent of respondents as very confident in trusting social media sites with their data and 14 percent very confident about trusting companies with personal data. More than 60 percent wanted to do more to protect their privacy and believed there should be more regulation to protect privacy.45 Hyperscale firms have become emblematic of modern digital capitalism, and as capitalist inventions they present significant social and economic challenges, including their impact on employment and wages, industry concentration, and monopoly.46 In 2017 there were 24 hyperscale firms operating 320 data centers with anywhere between thousands and millions of servers (Google and Facebook are among the largest). One hundred more data centers are expected to be online by late 2018. Microsoft invested $20 billion in 2017, and in 2018 Facebook announced plans to invest $20 billion in a new hyperscale data center in Atlanta. According to one industry report, hyperscale firms are also building the world’s networks, especially subsea cables, which means that “a large portion of the global internet traffic is now running through private networks owned or operated by hyperscalers.” In 2016 Facebook and Google teamed up to build a new subsea cable between the United States and Hong Kong, described as the highest-capacity transpacific route to date.47 The surveillance capitalists who operate at hyperscale or outsource to hyperscale operations dramatically diminish any reliance on their societies as sources of employees, and the few for whom they do compete are largely drawn from the most-rarified strata of data science. The absence of organic reciprocities with people as sources of either consumers or employees is a matter of exceptional importance in light of the historical relationship 14 New Labor Forum 00(0) between market capitalism and democracy. In fact, the origins of democracy in both Britain and America have been traced to these very reciprocities. Even a brief glance at these histories can help us grasp the degree to which surveillance capitalism diverges from capitalism’s past, a divergence in which an extreme structural independence from people lays the foundation for surveillance capitalism’s unique approach to knowledge that we have called “radical indifference.” In Britain, the rise of volume production and its wage-earning labor force in the nineteenth century contributed not only to workers’ economic power but also to a growing sense of labor’s political power and legitimacy. This produced a new sense of interdependence between ordinary people and elites. Economists Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson show that the rise of democracy in nineteenth-century Britain was inextricably bound to industrial capitalism’s dependency on the “the masses” and their contribution to the prosperity made possible by the new organization of production.48 Acemoglu and Robinson conclude that the “dynamic positive feedback” between “inclusive economic institutions” (i.e., institutions defined by reciprocities) and political institutions was critical to Britain’s substantial and non-violent democratic reforms. Inclusive economic institutions, they argue, “level the playing field,” especially when it comes to the fight for power, making it more difficult for elites to “crush the masses” rather than accede to their demands. Reciprocities in economics produced and sustained reciprocities in politics. “Clamping down on popular demands,” they write, “and undertaking a coup against inclusive political institutions would … destroy … [economic] gains, and the elites opposing greater democratization and greater inclusiveness might find themselves among those losing their fortunes from this destruction.”49 The spread of democracy also depended on the reciprocities of consumption, and the American Revolution is the outstanding example of this dynamic. Historian T.H. Breen argues in his path-breaking book, The Marketplace of Revolution, that it was the violation of these reciprocities that set the American Revolution into motion, uniting disparate provincial strangers into a radical new patriotic force. Breen explains that American colonists had come to depend on the “empire of goods” imported from England, and that this dependency instilled the sense of a reciprocal social contract: “For ordinary people, the palpable experience of participating in an expanding Anglo-American consumer market” intensified their sense of a “genuine partnership” with England. Eventually, the British Parliament famously misjudged the rights and obligation of this partnership, imposing a series of taxes that turned imported goods such as cloth and tea into “symbols of imperial oppression.” Breen describes the unprecedented inventiveness of a political movement originating in the shared experience of consumption, the outrage at the violation of essential producer–consumer interdependencies, and the determination to make “goods speak to power.” The translation of consumer expectations into democratic revolution occurred in three waves, beginning in 1765, when the Stamp Act triggered popular protests, riots, and organized resistance finally expressed in the “nonimportation movement.” (Today we would call it a consumer boycott.) As Breen tells it, the details of the Act were less important than the colonists’ realization that England did not perceive them as political or economic equals bound in mutually beneficial reciprocities. “By compromising the Americans’ ability to purchase the goods they desired,” he writes, “Parliament had revealed an intention to treat the colonists like secondclass subjects,” levying a heavy price “on the pursuit of material happiness.” In the absence of the organic reciprocities between producers, customers, and employees that bind populations in a shared fate, “user” dependency is the fulcrum of the surveillance capitalist project. Surveillance capitalism spread across the internet just as digital communications became the salient means of social participation. A 2010 BBC poll found that 79 percent of people in twenty-six countries considered internet access to be a fundamental human right.50 Six years later in 2016, the United Nations Human Rights Council would adopt specific language on the importance of internet access.51 In the United States, many people call the emergency services number, 911, on those rare occasions when Facebook is Zuboff 15 down.52 Most people find it difficult to withdraw from these utilities, and many ponder if it is even possible.53 The result has been an involuntary merger of personal necessity and economic extraction, as the same channels that we rely on for daily logistics, social interaction, work, education, health care, access to products and services, and much more, now double as supply chain operations for surveillance capitalism’s surplus flows. The result is that effective social participation leads through the means of behavioral modification, eroding the choice mechanisms that once adhered to the private realm––exit, voice, and loyalty. There can be no exit from processes that are intentionally designed to bypass individual awareness and on which we must depend for effective daily life. Users lack reliable channels for voice. Loyalty is an empty suit, as participation is better explained in terms of necessity, dependency, helplessness, resignation, the foreclosure of alternatives, and enforced ignorance.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---AT: Cybernetics K---T/L

Cybernetics isn’t conclusive---war machine isn’t a direct result of cybernetics

Hagmann 17 [Jonas Hagmann, 2017, “Security in the Society of Control: The Politics and Practices of Securing Urban Spaces,” International Political Sociology (2017)]

Fourth and finally, the control society is associated with implicit and potential political projects and/or drivers. There is a widespread understanding that the perfection of control is fueled by neoliberal politics, the privatization of services, technological advances, and alarmist threat discourses—fear of terrorism especially (Munro 2002; Coaffee, O’Hare and Hawkesworth 2009). These elements stimulate an expansion of security dispositives that is uncontrolled and organized at the same time. Security instruments are seen growing horizontally in rhizomatic ways and with little strategic coherence (Rose 2000, 321–322), yet the advent of the control system is nonetheless deemed systematic and thus top-down overall (Coleman and Agnew 2007).2 And indeed, capitalism is recurrently identified as the one authority that, albeit rarely subjected to popular approval, orchestrates the control society and its apparatuses of security, which is why they are often associated with an implicit neoliberal agenda (Reid 2014).3 This political agenda is not the only one possible, of course, and following diagnoses of security dispositives encroaching on democratic politics, it is also not deemed desirable. That is to say that the comprehensiveness, exclusionary practices, totalizing aspirations, and implicit neoliberal inspirations of current security dispositives motivate scholars to critically engage the new control ensembles. Indeed, calls to problematize, resist, or even reject the new control systems abound in the literature (Lacy 2008). And although the components of such strategies or tactics are rarely specified in the scholarly literature (as opposed to activist writings elsewhere; see The Invisible Committee 2009), it is clear from the literature that followed the Postscript that new security dispositives should be met with resistant activities of some sort (Newman 2009; Deseriis 2011; Lundborg 2016). Taken together, it seems no exaggeration to state that with these analytical components, the Deleuzian control thesis advances an impressively rich, integrative, and topical research agenda. Even if the postulation of a neat paradigm shift from “discipline” to “control” seems overstated (Poster 2009)4—the control thesis directs attention to evolving varieties of functionally diverse security actors, the continuing recomposition of material and immaterial security assemblages, the multiple and evolving linkages between security and democratic politics writ large, and novel deterritorialization processes, as well as normative dimensions inherent in 2 It goes without saying that the postulation of a rhizomatic, yet systematic, expansion of security dispositives makes it difficult to identify the precise drivers of the latter process. Deseriis (2011) considers this challenge, to whose clarification Deleuzian scholarship contributed little, to reflect a deeper ambivalence in Marxist theorizing, namely the core question of whether capitalism organizes itself (a rhizomatic perspective set out in Marx’s Grundrisse) or whether it is orchestrated by a “capitalist general” (a systemic reading suggested in Das Kapital). 3 Seemingly, it is also the globalized nature of capitalism that motivates Deleuzian scholars to conclude a global control system—thus confusing characteristics of a driver of control with the nature of security dispositives’ own operation. 4 Since some “Deleuzian elements” had been anticipated or called for by Foucault already, such as the necessity to overcome institution-centric analyses of societal steering (Foucault 2004, 116-118, on the “crisis of disciplinary societies”; also Foucault 1978). Overall, and with the exception of Deleuze’s more explicit concerns with digitalism, privatization, and society’s ability to influence security dispositives perhaps, it thus seems useful to conceive of “control” more as an intensification and spatial expansion of the security arrangements set out by Foucault. Control is not a fundamental rejection of discipline, even if it is defined in relation to the latter. contemporary security management. Doing so, the Deleuzian framework advances a fairly integrative “critical” perspective on the interrelations between security dispositives, democratic politics, and emancipatory practices—indeed, more holistic maybe than the division of academic labor between Foucaultian/Bourdieuan, Arendtian, and Marxist approaches to security research (“Paris, Copenhagen, Aberystwyth”) allows. As important, the control framework allows a variety of highly current empirical observations to be engaged: Deleuzian control studies can address concerns about societies becoming governed ever more intimately in the name of security and about security dispositives becoming more intrusive and ubiquitous (Valverde 2010). It can situate the evolution of such logics and dispositives in broader contemporary processes such as technological innovation (evolving “infrastructural powers”), globalization (the reconfiguration of enclosures and borders), and urbanization (the intensification of the Foucaultian problem of population, or “coexistence”)5; and it can examine these through interscalar lenses (Delaney and Leitner 1997; Brenner 1999), addressing the variegated ways in which international security narratives become localized and local security dispositives transnationalized. Seen this way, the control thesis empowers highly topical and comprehensive accounts of the interplay between security ensembles, democratic politics, and normative choices and allows decidedly empirical “genealogies of governmentality” (Bevir 2010; Joseph 2010) across clinical levels of analysis. This said, a look at the contributions made thus far suggests that the control oriented literature has, in its applications to security, not exploited this potential very systematically. While the literature has offered sophisticated case studies and played a pioneering role in popularizing the control framework in the first place, some of its analyses appear surprisingly incomplete and little differentiated, if not outright overdrawn. Whether security dispositives indeed came to draw so strongly on private agents, for instance, clearly deserves further enquiry (Coleman and Agnew 2007), and so does their alleged reliance on digital instruments and pronounced flexibility (Blomley 2007; Bonelli and Ragazzi 2014; Meiches 2015). Whether the new security ensembles might reformulate democratic politics (Loader and Walker 2007), as opposed to closing it down, has not been answered conclusively, seemingly because the authoritarian penchant of security is considered wellproven among control scholars. The purported presence of global control warrants further analysis—not only because of the mere grandiosity of this statement but also given the literature’s strong reliance on insights from the United Kingdom and North America (e.g., Newman 2009; Vlcek 2010; Hallsworth and Lea 2011), that is, its narrow empirical base. The postulated linearity of the described shifts is counterintuitive, considering the genealogical method and ethos on which Deleuzian work draws, and the emphasis on terrorism as the most immediate justification for new control arrangements points to an exceedingly rapid reduction of security affairs to 9/11 discourses. Whether resistant practices are still to come, finally, is also a point to explore further, for most security studies applications of Deleuze’s control argument derive such need from the technical intrusiveness of new security instruments, not from an empirically verified absence of opposition to control ensembles (Merlingen 2006).Considering these limitations, it is important to challenge the Deleuzian control literature for its selectivity, its merits notwithstanding (Valverde 2010). Instead of providing holistic and contextualized accounts of contemporary security management and its variation across time and space, as its analytical set-up would permit (Goldstein 2010), its empirical contributions still emphasize some actors, instruments, and processes and ignore others. Today, such partial engagement with evolving security assemblages is little conducive to fostering a grounded understanding.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K Answers › Cybernetics K › 2AC---AT: Cybernetics K---T/L

Algorithmic subjects cannot replicate humanity — rather, orienting policies around them solves.

Rouvroy et al. 13, Doctor of Laws of the European University Institute, Research Associate at the Belgian National Fund for Scientific Research, Senior Researched at the Research Centre Information, Law and Society, Law Faculty, University of Namur, Thomas Berns, Translated by Elizabeth Libbrecht, Algorithmic Governmentality And Prospects Of Emancipation, Réseaux Volume 177, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 163 to 196, https://doi.org/10.3917/res.177.0163

Increasingly, “power” grasps the subjects of algorithmic governmentality no longer through their physical body, nor through their moral conscience – the traditional holds of power in its legal discursive form [13]

[13]

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Random › 2NC --- FW

Centering the question of antiblackness in educational spaces is necessary to disrupt the antiblack logics of the nation state that pathologize black youth as lacking intellectualism

Justin A. Coles 2021 “It’s really geniuses that live in the hood”: Black urban youth curricular un/makings and centering Blackness in slavery’s afterlife, Curriculum Inquiry, DOI: 10.1080/03626784.2020.1856622]//sheima

In regards to antiblackness, learning was rooted in the specific idea that Black people lacked intellectualism (Anderson, 1988; Ladson-Billings, 2006; Ruelas, 2017; Williams, 2009). However, many scholars have documented the ways Black people were more than capable of, and possessed a fierce desire for, learning (Anderson, 1988; Cornelius, 1991; Gundaker, 2007; Payne & Strickland, 2008; Span, 2009; Williams, 2009). The deficit theory of Black anti-intellectualism was used because whites owning enslaved persons understood that Black learning would subvert slavery’s structure. In particular, whites held the belief that “learning will spoil the nigger for work” (Anderson, 1988, p. 6 J. A. COLES 20). While some enslaved Blacks were granted access to literacy to aid in basic tasks to help run the property, such as helping with accounts and supplies, this was not the reality for most (Gundaker, 2007). ¶ Socially constructed and stereotypical imaginings of Black people as “less able to think abstractly,” were used by whites to argue that Blacks were naturally fit for slavery (Plous & Williams, 1995, p. 796). As Ruelas (2017) explained, “slave masters were intent on keeping their slaves illiterate.” Due to the ways antiblackness positioned Black people as less than, the majority of those enslaved were excluded from all educational experience. Indeed, the enslaved “were not allowed books, pen, ink, nor paper, to improve their minds” (Williams, 2009, p. 9). The mind of the slave was deemed a non-factor, which facilitated the ways they were reduced solely to their ability to labor (Spivey, 1978) and to fuel and sustain capitalism (Smith, 2012).¶ After emancipation, many white northern missionaries, full of zeal, went to the US South to educate Blacks (Anderson, 1988; Bush, 2004; Jones, 1992; Williams, 2009). However, this enthusiasm diminished as they “began to realize that they had failed to understand the full effects of generations of slavery” (Newby & Tyack, 1971, p. 195). Bullock (1967, p. 93) revealed that educators “decided to sell the idea of Negro education to white Southerners by sacrificing the principle of racial equality …the best way to assure the sale was to emphasize its value to the purchaser” (as cited in Newby & Tyack, 1971, p. 196). History reveals that the living and learning experiences of Black youth are rooted in the full effects of chattel slavery and sustained through sacrificing racial equality; making curriculum for Black children one of the US’ earliest projects in interest convergence or when “the interest of blacks in achieving racial equality will be accommodated only when it converges with the interests of whites” (Bell, 1980, p. 523).¶ Centering Blackness as Critique of Antiblackness Today, Black youth are still not fully benefitting from educational experiences (Baszile, 2019; Caldera, 2020; Coles & Powell, 2020; Lozenski, 2017; Ohito, 2016), because antiblackness continues to manifest in present-day curriculum (Brown & Brown, 2020). This becomes clear when we understand that “the telos of educational praxis for most schools can only come into being through the logics of the imperialist, (settler) colonialist state” (Snaza, 2019, p. 13). In our nation, where the legacy of slavery and antiBlack racism is the paradigmatic signifier of white settler supremacy (Day, 2015), curriculum can be understood as anti-Black by design. ¶ Regardless of a student’s Black ethnicity, how they dress, or their buy-in to myths of Black exceptionalism, Black youth have “no permanent shield against the injuries of racism,” or “the enduring impact of anti-Blackness in everyday life” (Wallace, 2018, p. 278). Distinctly, the schooling of Black people in the US has served as a site of racial animus and miseducation throughout history and continues to serve as a site of Black suffering (Dumas, 2014). While antiblackness robs Black youth of affirming curricular spaces, schools are also robbed of the dynamic knowledges of Black children, Black genius. Ladson-Billings’ (1995) concept of culturally relevant pedagogy and subsequent asset based concepts like culturally sustaining pedagogy (Paris & Alim, 2014) are in fact fueled by the idea that the lives of Black and other minoritized youth can inform the ways schools become better, more humanizing social institutions.¶ Here, I am reminded of Gaztambide-Fernandez and Murad’s (2011) curriculum imperative of browning curriculum and pedagogy or examining “race, nation, and their intersections with multiple forms of oppression within curriculum studies” (p. 15). Through browning, we can “force the hidden hand of the racism that lurks at every turn of the curriculum studies discourse” (Tuck & Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2013, pp. 83–84), revealing “the ways in which colonial heteropatriarchal White supremacy continues to pervade curriculum studies” (Gaztambide-Fernandez & Murad, 2011, p. 15). Brown and Au (2014) extended curricular browning, charging the field to “give specific and detailed theoretical attention to issues of ‘race’ and curriculum that address the material, historical, and discursive processes of ‘race’ and racism” (p. 381). However, for this to manifest, educators need to critically evaluate what Dyson (2015) labeled as ideologically charged institutional discourse, which categorizes Black students as inherently less than, resulting in ongoing Black curricular exclusion. ¶ If we consider the ways US curriculum sustains antiblackness by resting in ahistorical narratives that marginalize “the myriad ways that Black people lived in and shaped U.S. life” (Brown & Brown, 2020, p. 76), it can be deduced that Black people suffer at the hands of curriculum by having their Blackness devalued. Centering Blackness in curriculum is necessary to facilitate the disruption of learning designed through the anti-Black logics of the nation-state. The need for a centering of Blackness in curriculum that leverages critiques of antiblackness, becomes evident when we understand that “thus far there has been little theorizing in education on the specificity of antiBlack racism” or what Dumas (2016b) contends “is the broader terrain of anti- blackness” (p. 12). While antiblackness will always find a home within curriculum, I contend that through a direct centering of Blackness, curriculum workers can be more attentive in efforts to co-construct curricular spaces that position Black youth life-worlds as essential. ¶

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › AFF › 2AC --- Alt Fails Mindset

Alt can’t change society’s worldview and only marginalizes material experiences

Vehmas & Watson 13 (Simo Vehmas & Nick Watson, “Moral wrongs, disadvantages, and disability: a critique of critical disability studies”, p. 648-649)

Further, deconstructing differences will not in and of itself produce respect and equality between all people with various characteristics. Neither will it result in a social order free from a sense of difference. It is simply unrealistic to assume that a society could exist were people would not see some other people as different, and their lives or characteristics as representing a deviation from some norm considered important regarding good human life. This is because some of the individual characteristics that define disabled people are, sometimes with good reason, undesirable, even in a utopia where all differences would have been queered. Disability is not the same as many other group identities and we need to explore both morally and socially disability and difference rather than simply use difference as a concept through which to critique the disability identity. There are no rational reasons to consider homosexuality or gender undesirable characteristics whatever the social context, but there are many impairments that can reasonably be seen as undesirable (Shakespeare 2006). Motor neuron disease, depression or spinal cord injury are the kinds of conditions that we would prefer not to have, and this is not merely because of the cultural representations attached to them but because these conditions are the kinds of predicaments that cause suffering irrespective of one’s cultural environment. In acknowledging that impairments can include an undesirable dimension does not imply devaluing people with impairments nor their positive group identity (Shakespeare and Watson 2010). As long as people are genuinely free to decide for themselves and feel about themselves however they wish to feel, we are pretty close to relational justice, free from hierarchical evils. Imposing on people ableist or disablist assumptions is certainly wrong, but so would be the denial of the personal experiences of fearing the loss of one’s physical and mental capacities, or the fear of dying (Carel 2008). To explain the psychological anguish related to conditions such as motor neurone disease or depression merely in terms of internalized oppression and ableism would be insensitive, disrespectful and simply nonsensical.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › AFF › 2AC --- War Turns alt

War turns—distinctly bad for people with disabilities

Maria Berghs and Nawaf Kabbara 16 (November 8, 2016, “Chapter 17 Disabled People in Conflicts and Wars” , Disability in the Global South by Disability in the Global South The Critical Handbook, Editors: Shaun Grech, Karen Soldatic , https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-319-42488-0 )// RB

The long-term consequences of protracted confl ict on disabled people and the creation of impairment need more research. This calls for a longitudinal or life-course approach (Priestley 2007 ) to see how identities, single and multiple impairment(s), health and social care needs differ as the age of populations and their environments change. A life-course approach can also explore how the concept of disability is changing intergenerationally, whether passed on biologically (e.g. HIV/AIDS) and socially (e.g. stigma), or through ascription of a new kinship identity (e.g. amputee) (Berghs 2012 ). Yet, research, funding and planning to understand the long-term effects of confl ict on disability is rarely available (Wehbi 2011a ). Inhorn and Kobeissi ( 2006 ) usefully note how there are six long-term effects of confl ict on civilians: physical, mental, reproductive/demographic, social structural, infrastructural, and environmental. We briefl y discuss each of these in turn in an effort to illustrate what is missing from current debates in relation to disability.

Physical We know very little about civilian deaths and creation of impairment despite the fact that poorly resourced health systems contribute to death, illness and impairment (Banatvala and Zwi 2000 ; WHO 2011 ). With the focus on public health, the effects of malnutrition, communicable and non-communicable diseases, unsanitary conditions and lack of access to water are given substantial attention post-confl ict. For example, Miles and Medi ( 1994 ) found that while confl ict in Mozambique had resulted in impairment among children, most actually gained indirect impairments due to a mix of effects created by the long-term consequences of the confl ict, such as malnutrition. Insurance provision, necessary implementation of user fees for services and a lack of (paid) professionals, medication, assistive devices, prosthetics and rehabilitation programmes affect impairment, too. Growing privatisation under neo-liberalism is also a threat to access to health and social care services (Berghs 2013 ). Likewise, the impact of landmines, chemicals and circulation of (small) arms can last for generations and will need long-term planning of services. Long-term effects of confl ict and links to impairment need to be identifi ed so that services can be planned and implemented adequately .

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › AFF › 2AC --- State Good

State action can be good for people with disabilities – ADA proves

Mckeever 20 (Amy Mckeever, JULY 30, 2020, "How the Americans with Disabilities Act transformed a country," History, ) //RB

More than 2,000 disability rights advocates gathered on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, D.C., on a hot summer day. It was July 26, 1990, and they’d come together to witness one of the most momentous civil rights victories in decades: President George H.W. Bush signing the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) into law.

During the signing ceremony—days after the Fourth of July—Bush admitted that the United States hadn’t always lived up to its founding principles of freedom and equality. “[T]ragically, for too many Americans, the blessings of liberty have been limited or even denied,” he said. “Today’s legislation brings us closer to that day when no Americans will ever again be deprived of their basic guarantee of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › AFF › 2AC --- Reform

Disability must be politicized---this is the only way to secure collective rights---the retreat from politics reifies ableist tropes of charity politics and naively tries to wish problems away

Ruckelshaus 17, (Jay Ruckelshaus is a Rhodes Scholar and graduate student in political theory at the University of Oxford, and the founder and president of Ramp Less Traveled, a nonprofit organization that helps students with spinal cord injuries pursue higher education, The Non-Politics of Disability, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/18/opinion/denouncing-trump-wont-help-disability-rights.html)

Disability rights enjoy a seemingly ironclad moral consensus, an ostensible unanimity that is striking given America’s entrenched polarization and the antagonism surrounding other identity movements. Many are wary of L.G.B.T. rights or the Black Lives Matter movement, but it seems beyond the pale — almost cruel — to oppose disability rights. Nobody wants to be anti-disability. Initially, this harmony would seem helpful. Free from partisan discord, advancements for the approximately 57 million Americans with disabilities should be easier to achieve, borne aloft by the wings of certain progress. Why, then, do rampant unemployment and educational disparities endure, and why does success remain the exception? I think part of the reason is the insulation of our pro-disabled political consensus. Its logic is rooted not in any deep belief in the equal worth of citizens with disabilities, but rather in a general aversion to disability. This is related to the charity impulse that has always surrounded disability — and has constrained liberation efforts by assuming that inequities are unfortunate but natural realities to be mitigated through compassion, rather than politically structured injustices. There is also a profound lack of disabled people in the public sphere, meaning any substantive discussion that does occur is extremely rare. I suspect many people I talk to about disability maintain an implicit hope that, if they nod as vigorously as possible, the issue will simply go away. In this way, support for disability rights is similar to the act of expressing perfunctory thanks to military veterans. It temporarily absolves us of the responsibility to address the heart of the matter. Moreover, the apparent moral consensus may be mostly superficial. In trying to enact accessibility, disability advocates encounter increasing resistance as the effort and costs involved in proposals come closer to being realized. (Consider the neighborhood store that decides it’s just too costly to install a ramp, or the community lecture that excludes deaf attendees by refusing to hire a sign-language interpreter.) Instead of facilitating change, false unity actually restrains change. It stifles the more substantive conversations true progress requires. And our inability to speak honestly — and contentiously — about disability shows how the politics of disability is in this sense non-political. We are the worse for it. In addition to greater participation in the public sphere, true progress for citizens with disabilities will require a willingness to confront the issues head-on, even when — especially when — citizens disagree on competing solutions. We must politicize disability — not in the cable-news, grandstanding kind of way, but in the term’s more formal sense. The work of the Belgian political theorist Chantal Mouffe can help illuminate what’s at stake. Mouffe begins with the premise that human relations are inherently antagonistic: Political change always requires controversial transfers in power or prestige, and it is an illusion to imagine politics without confrontation. Per this “agonistic” conception of democracy, a healthy political order is one that prefers vigorous, good-faith argumentation to complacent consensus. Until we publicly recognize real disagreements surrounding disability and accessibility, Mouffe would insist, we are doomed to a vacuous, empty debate that is neither political nor productive. Recall the Kovaleski incident. I’m not suggesting that the abhorrence of Mr. Trump’s actions is open to legitimate questioning. But in their forcefully reassuring comments and messages, my friends prevented any serious discussion of disability at the level where reasonable disagreement does exist. Where will the money come from to fund disability employment schemes? How do we even define “disability”? Despite — and, I would argue, partly because of — the broad condemnation of Mr. Trump for his insensitivity, there was no substantive public discussion of such issues. You may be thinking, haven’t we had enough politics lately? Maybe it’s a blessing that disability isn’t as political as it might be; it avoids the drama and messiness that now seem to define our common life. Avoiding politics might be possible if disability were an exclusively private affair. But it is fundamentally a public concern, affecting everyone directly or indirectly and revealing our obligations to one another as members of a democratic society. Issues of accessibility can be fully addressed only through public institutions and collective effort. For the disability community, there is no answer but politics.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › AFF › 2AC --- Reform

Abstract critique keeps us from forefronting political reform

Ruckelshaus 17 (Jay, Rhodes Scholar and graduate student in political theory at the University of Oxford, and the founder and president of Ramp Less Traveled, a nonprofit organization that helps students with spinal cord injuries pursue higher education, "The Non-Politics of Disability”, 1/18/17, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/18/opinion/denouncing-trump-wont-help-disability-rights.html)

Disability rights enjoy a seemingly ironclad moral consensus, an ostensible unanimity that is striking given America’s entrenched polarization and the antagonism surrounding other identity movements. Many are wary of L.G.B.T. rights or the Black Lives Matter movement, but it seems beyond the pale — almost cruel — to oppose disability rights. Nobody wants to be anti-disability. Initially, this harmony would seem helpful. Free from partisan discord, advancements for the approximately 57 million Americans with disabilities should be easier to achieve, borne aloft by the wings of certain progress. Why, then, do rampant unemployment and educational disparities endure, and why does success remain the exception? I think part of the reason is the insulation of our pro-disabled political consensus. Its logic is rooted not in any deep belief in the equal worth of citizens with disabilities, but rather in a general aversion to disability. This is related to the charity impulse that has always surrounded disability — and has constrained liberation efforts by assuming that inequities are unfortunate but natural realities to be mitigated through compassion, rather than politically structured injustices. There is also a profound lack of disabled people in the public sphere, meaning any substantive discussion that does occur is extremely rare. I suspect many people I talk to about disability maintain an implicit hope that, if they nod as vigorously as possible, the issue will simply go away. In this way, support for disability rights is similar to the act of expressing perfunctory thanks to military veterans. It temporarily absolves us of the responsibility to address the heart of the matter. Moreover, the apparent moral consensus may be mostly superficial. In trying to enact accessibility, disability advocates encounter increasing resistance as the effort and costs involved in proposals come closer to being realized. (Consider the neighborhood store that decides it’s just too costly to install a ramp, or the community lecture that excludes deaf attendees by refusing to hire a sign-language interpreter.) Instead of facilitating change, false unity actually restrains change. It stifles the more substantive conversations true progress requires. And our inability to speak honestly — and contentiously — about disability shows how the politics of disability is in this sense non-political. We are the worse for it. In addition to greater participation in the public sphere, true progress for citizens with disabilities will require a willingness to confront the issues head-on, even when — especially when — citizens disagree on competing solutions. We must politicize disability — not in the cable-news, grandstanding kind of way, but in the term’s more formal sense. The work of the Belgian political theorist Chantal Mouffe can help illuminate what’s at stake. Mouffe begins with the premise that human relations are inherently antagonistic: Political change always requires controversial transfers in power or prestige, and it is an illusion to imagine politics without confrontation. Per this “agonistic” conception of democracy, a healthy political order is one that prefers vigorous, good-faith argumentation to complacent consensus. Until we publicly recognize real disagreements surrounding disability and accessibility, Mouffe would insist, we are doomed to a vacuous, empty debate that is neither political nor productive. Recall the Kovaleski incident. I’m not suggesting that the abhorrence of Mr. Trump’s actions is open to legitimate questioning. But in their forcefully reassuring comments and messages, my friends prevented any serious discussion of disability at the level where reasonable disagreement does exist. Where will the money come from to fund disability employment schemes? How do we even define “disability”? Despite — and, I would argue, partly because of — the broad condemnation of Mr. Trump for his insensitivity, there was no substantive public discussion of such issues. You may be thinking, haven’t we had enough politics lately? Maybe it’s a blessing that disability isn’t as political as it might be; it avoids the drama and messiness that now seem to define our common life. Avoiding politics might be possible if disability were an exclusively private affair. But it is fundamentally a public concern, affecting everyone directly or indirectly and revealing our obligations to one another as members of a democratic society. Issues of accessibility can be fully addressed only through public institutions and collective effort. For the disability community, there is no answer but politics. But politics need not be repulsive. That’s the beauty of Mouffe’s agonism: By legitimating clashing arguments and welcoming them into the political fold, unproductive antagonism becomes constructive, and compromises emerge.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › AFF › 2AC --- Liberalism

Even if political liberalism currently excludes the disabled, discussing questions of implementation can revise it

Badano 13 (Gabriele – PhD candidate at the Centre for Philosophy, Justice and Health at University College London – “Political liberalism and the justice claims of the disabled: a reconciliation,” Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, April 2013, http://www.tandfonline.com/eprint/tHKkbrxhGYIWAxTcJrAW/full#.UxyV-PldX-4)

I argue that any proposal abandoning the language of political justice would not seem to do enough for those individuals with disabilities who fall outside the basic idea of persons as depicted by Rawls. In fact, the intuitions supporting the idea that concepts like rights and opportunities are indispensable are very strong.11 Let us go back to the examples of individuals falling outside Rawls’s idea of persons because their disabilities prevent them from being a net benefit to social cooperation. They are individuals who need multiple carers to work, or whose disabilities prevent them from providing a benefit to social cooperation that is large enough. To put the point more sharply, it is worth noticing that the disabilities in question are compatible with being in full possession of one’s logical and moral powers. Now, should we accept that those individuals ought to be given no rights or opportunities? An affirmative answer would strike us as implausible, and for a good reason. In a liberal society, having one’s rights, opportunities and basic distributive entitlements acknowledged is one and the same as being recognized as an equal. And what is missing from Rawls’s political liberalism is precisely the idea that falling below a threshold of full cooperation should not be enough to prevent the disabled from being regarded as persons on an equal footing with anyone else. In sum, Rawls’s political liberalism is not amenable to any extension that, keeping the basic ideas of society and persons intact, is able to include a concern with the status of individuals with disabilities. In addition, the proposal that the interests of the disabled are not for public reason to protect is not satisfactory. Consequently, a substantial revision is the only way to reconcile political liberalism with our intuitions concerning what is due to the disabled. 5. Revising political liberalism I: beyond Hartley’s contractualism The aim of this section and the next is to propose a substantial revision of Rawls’s theory that accommodates the justice claims of the disabled while upholding the project of political liberalism. A question that needs to be answered at this point is: why should we uphold the project of political liberalism, rather than endorsing a different model that more neatly fits with our intuitions concerning what is due to the disabled? First, the general project of political liberalism is compelling. Rawls’s political liberalism aims to identify a common ground of political ideas that can work as the basis on which the most important political decisions should be made. This project is of the greatest importance because, if successful, it creates legitimacy by building institutions on the basis of concepts that are acceptable to each reasonable individual. Moreover, it promotes stability in societies that are characterized by deep pluralism. Second, despite Rawls’s failure to take the interests of the disabled into consideration, political liberalism is well suited to support the justice claims of individuals with disabilities. This is because the idea that the disabled are citizens who deserve our respect is part of the common culture of our societies. In other words, there is an overlapping consensus on the idea that rights, opportunities and distributive shares must be granted to individuals who are not fully cooperating members of society, including those who fall below full moral powers. It is widely believed that those with physical disabilities should have the same rights as their fellow citizens, live in a social environment that does not excessively limit their opportunities and receive benefits that help meet their special needs. Besides, although the state or third parties are given exceptional rights to interfere with the autonomy of individuals with severe cognitive disabilities, it is widely recognized that the mentally disabled are citizens whose basic interests must be protected by the law.12 In the public space, any proposal that individuals who are not fully cooperating members of society should have their basic interests neglected would be widely received with outrage. Such proposal would be said to fit a fascist society, not a decent one. Among other legal documents, the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UN General Assembly, A/61/611) can be taken as the epitome of this widespread attitude. Adopted in 2006, the Convention requires that all individuals with disabilities should share in the enjoyment of equal fundamental rights.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Answers › 2NC --- You’re not disabled

Disidentification with disability and crip allow the mintrotain subject to refuse either fully conform or fully resist to dominate structurces

Schalk 13 (Sami Schalk, Department of Gender Studies, Indiana University, Vol. 33 No. 2 (2013): Self-reflection as scholarly praxis ,Disability Studies Quarterly (DSQ), “Coming to Claim Crip: Disidentification with/in Disability Studies” https://dsq-sds.org/article/view/3705/3240 ) // RB

As a young gender, race, and disability studies scholar, my entry into and relationship with/in this last field of study is not the story many expect when I tell them that I do disability studies. Unlike many people in the field, I am not (yet) a person with a disability and I am not (yet) the parent, guardian, sibling, or partner of a person with a disability. Ten to 15 years ago, being a nondisabled 1 disability studies researcher 2 with no immediate, personal experience with disability would have been relatively unusual. However, due to the growth of disability studies as an academic field since the 1990s, more people are encountering disability theory in the course of their academic careers whether or not they identify as or have a personal relationship with a person with a disability. Although I do not identify as a person with a disability, I nonetheless have come to identify with the term "crip" as elucidated by feminist and queer crip/disability theorists such as Carrie Sandahl, Robert McRuer, and Alison Kafer. As a fat, black, queer woman, my experiences have led me to have particular personal and political connections to the term "crip" and a disidentified relationship with disability studies. In what follows, I argue that disidentification can be used by minoritarian subjects to disidentify with other minoritarian subjects, communities, and/or representations and that this kind of disidentifying process among/across/between minoritarian subjects can allow for coalitional theory and political solidarity.

By coalitional theory, I mean theories which are inclusive of multiple minority groups without being limited to only those people who occupy multiply minoritized positions. Regarding political solidarity, I follow Chandra Talpade Mohanty who defines solidarity as follows:

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Answers › 2NC --- Tech good for disabled

Modern technology is unpredictable and we cannot rely on it to “solve” disability

Schalk 18 (Sami Schalk, Associate Professor in the Department of Gender & Women's Studies at the University of Wisconsin – Madison, (2018) Bodyminds Reimagined: (Dis)ability, Race, and Gender in Black Women's Speculative Fiction 105-108 http://library.lol/main/2C8F7A1D8C5F5DC42089719EDD904C24)

Through the origins of hyperempathy, Butler demonstrates how modern technology can have unpredictable effects, particularly technologies applied to human bodyminds. Such a speculative fictional representation is not far from impossible given the incredible rate of prescription drug consumption in contemporary American culture and our increasing interest in genetic testing, selection, and manipulation of embryos. The representation of hyperempathy suggests, in its critical dystopian form, that we cannot know in advance what our widespread cultural use of pharmaceutical treatments, genetic alterations, and other disability-preventing/curing technologies might have on our bodyminds in the long run, let alone on the bodyminds of future generations. Butler’s papers reveal that she planned to extend this theme in the unfinished third book in the series, often referred to as Parable of the Trickster. Drafts, notes, and outlines for this text show Butler was exploring the idea of having an Earthseed community travel to start a new colony on a planet in another solar system. When the community members arrive, people begin to experience different forms of disablement, which vary from draft to draft, including blindness, epilepsy, paralysis, and hallucinations. The idea that she continued to experiment with, based on these 106 Chapter Three drafts, outlines, and notes, was that either the technology used to keep the Earthseed community members alive on the trip, or the toxins in the air of the new habitable planet, caused these changes, and the community must learn to live with their altered bodyminds.12 Butler’s engagement with the effects of technology in the future is not simply limited to (dis)ability, but also has important material intersections with issues of race, gender, and class. When imagining a disability-free future perpetuated by technological advances that will supposedly prevent congenital disability and “fix” or “cure” all acquired disabilities, it is important to ask, who will have access to these advanced medical technologies and who will not? On whose bodyminds will new and experimental drugs and devices be tested? Who will perform the labor to extract raw materials for and construct these new technologies? Who will benefit the most and who will be barred from participation? If the history of medical experimentation such as the Tuskegee experiments or the work of Dr. Marion Sims tells us anything, people of color, women, working-class people, and people in poverty will benefit the least from technological advances and will be most at risk for harm in the development, production, and consumption of new technologies.13 In the Parable series, Butler emphasizes that technology is neither inherently liberatory nor destructive. In a journal entry dated April 23, 1999, Butler writes about this directly, stating, “Technology isn’t good or bad. It’s part of who we are, part of what we do. It’s how we us[e] it is [w]hat matters, of course” (Octavia E. Butler Papers, “oeb 1069”). Technology does not have inherent value; rather, it is how we as a culture use, misuse, and make available technologies that produces technological enhancements and/or harm. Further, the line between enhancement and harm is not always clear—nor are the two mutually exclusive. Enhancement for whom and harm to whom? What kind of enhancement and how much? What kind of harm and how much? As Butler writes, “Consequences may be beneficial or harmful. They may be too slight to matter or they may be worth the risk because the potential benefits are great, but the consequences are always there” (“A Few Rules for Predicting the Future” 166). Technology, the Parable series asserts in the face of the ideal of a technologically created, disability-free future, is an ambivalent cultural tool which is subject to both use and abuse, availability and unavailability, and a variety of unintended consequences. Hyperempathy is used as a primary example of this position on technology. As a result, Butler encourages readers to un- Bodyminds of the Future 107 derstand that one’s critical position in relation to technology need not be either purely celebratory or, in Melzer’s words, “paranoid rejection” (“And How Many Souls Do You Have?’” 177). Instead, we can evaluate particular technologies within specific contexts of creation and use. We can do so in solidarity with people with disabilities, people of color, the working class, the poor, and others who are more likely to participate in the creation and testing of such technologies while being less likely to be the beneficiaries of the results of such developments. Butler’s published and unpublished writings argue that technology guarantees neither a disability-free future nor any other supposedly desired outcome since we cannot predict its longterm effects, especially when it comes to biomedical technology. In particular, the Parable series demonstrates how marginalized groups, especially people of color and the poor, are less likely to have access to healing/curing technologies and are much more likely to be the targets of destructive technologies of violence and war. The suggestion that we cannot know in advance what our impulse toward a technologically created, disability-free future might lead to may seem problematically foreboding because it potentially suggests that the problem of disability-prevention technologies is that they might simply create more disability. However, the second way that the representation of hyperempathy resists our cultural idealization of a technologically created, disabilityfree future is through the representation of disability-related pleasure. Butler’s creation of hyperempathy insists on pleasure as an inherent aspect of the experience of this disability, a type of pleasure that nonsharers can never experience. For example, Lauren states that when having sex, “I get the guy’s good feeling and my own” (Parable of the Sower 12). During her early travels with her friends Harry and Zahra, Lauren also shares their pleasure when they have sex near her during their watch, writing, “I got caught up in their lovemaking. I couldn’t escape their sensation” (200). Later, when she meets Bankole, Lauren again discusses sharing pleasure in sex, explaining, “Best of all, he took a lot of uncomplicated pleasure in my body, and I got to share it with him. It isn’t often that I can enjoy the good side of my hyperempathy. I let the sensation take over, intense and wild” (266). While these moments of Lauren’s shared pleasure are few in comparison to the many representations of shared pain, they are incredibly important to Butler’s representation of disability in the future. The representation of disability-related pleasure in the Parable series shifts the ableist ways in which our culture typically understands disabled bodyminds as both nonsexual and as always more difficult and limiting than nondisabled bodyminds. Importantly, Butler does this without making Lauren come across as magical or as the perpetually overcoming, superpowered supercrip.14

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Answers › 2NC --- Progress

Neoliberal notions of progress reconstitute themselves as Black debility becomes the antagonist of white racial progress.

Knadler 19 - ( Stephen Knadler; Stephen Knadler is an associate professor of English at Spelman College, where he teaches US literature and cultural studies. He has been published in American Literature, American Literary History, American Quarterly, Minnesota Review, and Modern Fiction Studies.; Originally published: August 6, 2019; “Vitality politics : health, debility, and the limits of black emancipation”; http://link.umsl.edu/portal/Vitality-politics--health-debility-and-the/n6SXiAQq3ac) Dōgen

In my original plan for this book, I had intended to say much more about the legacy of vitality politics in Michelle Obama’s “Let’s Move” antiobesity campaign, and to unpack its continued practice in Flint, Michigan’s lead-poisoned water crisis. While I was completing this book and meditating on the afterlife of these historical intersections of slow violence, Black debility, and fugitive justice, however, the 2016 presidential election occurred, and all seemed changed, changed utterly. I began to suspect that concluding with these stories of historical recurrence may not fully address the questions we need to ask about the long history of antiblackness and African American debility: what are the stories worth telling in our current twenty-first-century cultural moment and, as importantly, what are the questions we need to ask in telling these stories to intervene and to imagine alternative social, economic, and political possibilities? During and now after the 2016 election, as it has been frequently noted, the United States witnessed a resurgence of white nationalism (or at least its unabashed expression) and intensified antiblackness. But what interested me was how the material-semiotic sign of Black debility functioned as a key relationality within a less overt conservative white racism, which reconstituted white citizenship for a supposedly postrace multicultural America. However, this time questions of Black debility had a different valence. Although, as in an earlier post-Reconstruction period, Black debility was once again being invoked as part of a white backlash against racial progress, it had morphed. No longer was white America defining itself against a strategically constituted or permitted Black debility: it was both reappropriating this positionality as a sign of its own victimization while reauthenticating a decontextualized maiming of Black lives as a comparative sign of their inherent and implacable “noncompliant” debility. We can see this story of white America’s “rehabilitation” and the utility of Black debility most clearly in the current narratives about the opioid crisis that has caused political commentators on the right and the left to question white America’s decline and possible future, and also Black America’s intractability. In the remainder of this epilogue I will, therefore, offer a discursive reading of what I call “the gentrification of the drug crisis” narrative in public debates about white America’s needed rehabilitation in the face of the opioid crisis in order to trace out some final thoughts about Black America’s structurally necessary debility in U.S. citizenship-making stories. Then, as a way of demonstrating how this narrative has entrenched itself in Hollywood’s popular overcoming narratives, I will offer a brief analysis of the 2015 film Southpaw that, even though seemingly offering a typical sentimentalized story about cross-racial friendship in the boxing world, reveals the new logic of a white identity politics that, like the drug crisis itself, gentrifies a Black positionality and displaces its devaluation of Black life in order to circulate a dominant narrative about America’s “great (white) hope.” Specifically, in the 2015 film Southpaw, which stars Jake Gyllenhaal and is directed by the African American Antoine Fuqua, we see how the main character, Billy Hope, referred to as the boxing world’s “great white hope,” discloses how a liberal white antiracist narrative of America’s comeback story and contemporary prison reform still depend on the drug-addicted pain and suffering of an inherently different Black debility. During the 2016 presidential campaign there was a lot of talk about America’s—or at least white rural and suburban America’s—drug epidemic. As the candidates noted, citing the most recent available statistics, 37,000 Americans died of drug overdoses in 2013, but what captured headlines, as Vice News noted, was the fact that drug overdoses “killed white people more than anyone else,”14 or, as the New York Times reported on February, 2, 2016, “Addiction [Now] Has a White Face.”15 A study published in JAMA Psychiatry in July 2014 reported that nearly 90 percent of recent heroin users were white, and about 75 percent of these new users came from rural or suburban areas, many in states that are GOP strongholds.16 While campaigning in key primary states such as Iowa and New Hampshire, as a consequence, traditionally conservative law and order Republican candidates broke silences and confessed their own family histories with drug abuse. Jeb Bush shared his daughter’s struggle with addiction and the felony charges she had faced for “illegally possessing prescription drugs”;17 Carly Fiorina admitted her daughter’s struggle with alcohol and opiate addiction before her death from an overdose; and Ted Cruz disclosed his older half-sister Miriam’s similar overdose death, explaining, “[t]hese tragedies are happening in human lives all over this country—it’s the human journey” (emphasis added). Although not sharing personal family histories, Ohio governor John Kasich also addressed what he called (repeating the language of news stories in the New York Times as well as on NPR) the “gentrification of the drug crisis.” In 2014 Governor Kasich had passed in Ohio the first legislation to make naloxone available without a prescription because, at the time, the state had the second highest number of overdose deaths. I want for a moment to quote Governor Kasich’s comments before a Drug Addiction Forum in New Hampshire because they point out the troubling racialization, structuring antiblack debility and emergent white identity politics within various survivalist narratives about America’s drug epidemic and the push toward more humane responses, replacing incarceration with treatment. Speaking to a largely white audience in New Hampshire, a state still 96 percent white, according to the government census data, Kasich noted, “This disease knows no bounds, knows no income, knows no neighborhood; it’s everywhere. . . . And sometimes I wonder how African Americans must have felt when drugs were awash in their community and nobody watched. Now it’s in our communities, and now all of a sudden, we’ve got forums, and God bless us, but think about the struggles that other people had".19 As Kasich’s comments attest, drug addiction should be reframed as a colorblind disease, and five months later, in July 2016, Congress passed a landmark piece of legislation referred to as the Opioid Bill, or more officially as the Comprehensive Addiction and Recovery Act (CARA), that shifted low-level drug violations from the criminal justice system to treatment programs. The promotion of such a public health response represented a significant reframing and overturning of the nation’s response to addiction during the Reagan era “war on drugs,” and we should not minimize the importance of this shift toward rehabilitation. But such a therapeutic rethinking of policy also depends on a new race transcending and seemingly more civilized disability (or addiction) narrative that taps into a structuring antiblackness to rehumanize innocent white users, just as Black debility had functioned to legitimate white labor privileges and enfranchisement during the post-Reconstruction period. This “gentrification of the drug crisis narrative,” as we might call it, discloses not just a racist disparity between an earlier zero tolerance of Black crack users in the 1980s and 90s and a contemporary public health response to sympathetic white heroin users. It also offers insights more generally into an emergent dynamic of a Black debility within an unmarked white identity politics that often comes to stand in for contemporary liberal antiracist multicultural discourse. To begin to unpack how antiblackness structures the white identity politics of this seemingly more civilized “gentrification of the drug crisis” narrative, we need only look at the legacy of a long history of antiblackness and health that I have tried to recover throughout the previous chapters. As I have argued throughout this book, drawing on the work of Black Studies scholars such as Jared Sexton, Frank Wilderson, and Alexander Weheliye, antiblackness encompasses more than racial bias, discrimination, white privilege, and even violence. Antiblackness refers to a foundational structuring differentiation that continues to govern Black lives in the afterlife of slavery. Not only, thus, have white supremacists invoked antiblackness as a self-identifying racial difference, but U.S. liberal notions of personhood, citizenship, and agency have also depended on figurations of antiblackness, or of Black disposability and worthlessness and indifference to Black suffering and pain as a structuring force. In his comments before the Drug Addiction Forum, Kasich, on one hand, calls for empathy, but he also invokes the larger shaping logic of a post–civil rights white liberal identity politics (one that goes unmarked as “color-blind” amid the alarm over a more clearly vocal white supremacism): this white identity politics depends on, to borrow the language of the drug epidemic narratives, a white gentrification and appropriation of a Black positionality in the call for a universalizing empathy.20 As Kasich’s comments before the drug forum’s white audience note, whites are the new Blacks, for whites now share the suffering and pain historically associated with an abstracted Black experience, and as a consequence, the United Stated can now move beyond identity politics to embrace, as Ted Cruz indicated, a universal “human story.” But this supposed postrace, postidentity politics is its own white identity politics, one that although seemingly antiracist (built as it is around a common pain of addiction), obscures the structuring position of a differential Black debility.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Answers › 2NC --- Governance

Narratives of vitality and health create the preconditions necessary for the growth of bio-political governance and the intentional debilitation of Black flesh.

Knadler 19 - ( Stephen Knadler; Stephen Knadler is an associate professor of English at Spelman College, where he teaches US literature and cultural studies. He has been published in American Literature, American Literary History, American Quarterly, Minnesota Review, and Modern Fiction Studies.; Originally published: August 6, 2019; “Vitality politics : health, debility, and the limits of black emancipation”; http://link.umsl.edu/portal/Vitality-politics--health-debility-and-the/n6SXiAQq3ac) Dōgen *Modified for harsh language

In Booker T. Washington’s famous 1895 Atlanta Cotton States and International Exhibition Address, he identifies that a post-Reconstruction backlash depended on the biopolitical production of a lived experience of Black health precarity and tactical debilitation. In this “compromise” speech, Washington repeatedly asserts, as most commentators note, the important role that African Americans ought to play as the laboring race in the industrial development of a New South.48 But Washington’s selling of African Americans as the “most patient, faithful, law-abiding, and unresentful” workforce that mill owners and manufacturers might hire is accompanied by an appeal as well to postemancipation myths about a disabled African American race and, in turn, to the region’s fears about biosecurity.49 As part of his “pragmatism,” it is frequently noted, Washington targets—and appeases—white self-interest, but Washington also taps into white (as well as Black) fears and anxieties about African American productive vitality. After assuring white southerners that African Americans do not seek social equality—willing to remain separate as fingers, but work as one hand in “all things essential to mutual progress”— Washington adds a thinly veiled threat that most in the audience would have hardly failed to detect: the “nearly sixteen millions of hands will aid you in pulling your load upward,” Washington warns, or, switching suddenly from the synecdoche of “hands” to the first person, as if to call attention to his own embodied presence, “we shall prove a veritable body of death, stagnating, depressing, retarding [slowing down] every effort to advance the body politic” (222). In his language that African Americans excluded from participation in the New Southern economy will “retard” “[slow down]” and not advance the “body politic,” and indeed they will putrefy as a “veritable body of death,” Washington invokes a highly contentious and statistically driven public debate prompted by African America post–Civil War health inequalities: since emancipation, it was widely publicized, African Americans were a diseased, debilitated, and even, as Washington notes here, dying race in the absence of their masters’ care and protection (see chapters 1 and 2).50 But what does it mean, we need to ask, that Washington frames African American progress—the question of African American citizenship— around an opposition between Black capacity and debility? What does it mean that commentators have erased this line in their remembering of Washington’s speech and in the repeated criticism of his failure to demand immediate civil or political rights, or both? Washington’s compromise speech talks back, as we will see in chapter 1, to postemancipation debates over the contagious, disabled, and dying African American by reframing and placing these health disparities in the larger context of a post Reconstruction vitality politics. In his promotion of Black labor in the New Southern economy Washington pinpoints that postemancipation antiblackness revolved around not just the denial of rights—to work, to public access, to opportunity—but that antiblackness in the afterlife of slavery functions through the creating of cycles of debilitation and recovery that keep African Americans always on the edge of health and, thus, as the surplus laborers in racial capitalism. As Washington implies in his address, conserving the “wages of whiteness” (to borrow David Roediger’s famous phrase) means neglecting and debilitating black bodies and minds to naturalize their comparative inadequacy.51 In tracing out the diverse techniques grouped under the idea of biopower, or the way politics intervenes into the vital characteristics of biological and mental life, Michel Foucault distinguished between two general technologies: although much of Foucault’s early work focused on the production of individual discipline or the individual’s internalizing of the surveillance, control, and norms implemented in the factory, the schoolhouse, the asylum, and the prison, Foucault’s later work focused on a biopolitics that operated on the level of populations.52 As part of this biopolitics in mass, social scientists, public health officials, reformers, politicians, and race activists sought to track, survey, and regulate various demographics’ births, life expectancy, mortality, and general level of health. As Washington’s often redacted appeal to the debilitated Black body reveals, as part of the post-Reconstruction racial reordering, biopolitics broadened and shifted from tactics of direct exclusion to a dialectical regime of imposed Black debility followed by surveillance, recovery, and assistance toward optimized capacity, or what post-Reconstruction commentators called vitality, according to the demands of an industrial labor market.53 As part of U.S. national fantasies of liberal meritocracy, all citizens had to learn to monitor, assess, and “conserve” their vital resources for their personal success as well as the conservation of the race. However, a post Reconstruction politics of Black debility worked through an environmentally produced corporeal and mental enervation to render freedmen and women as a contrasting disposable population of decapacitated life incapable of achieving the aspirational promises of self-perfectibility, opportunity, economic productivity, material success, and mobility. As a result, “New Negroes [Blacks]” in racial uplift’s politics of respectability were not simply “policed” according to the norms of middle-class propriety.54 They were debilitated, and, as a result, the post-Reconstruction period saw a shift toward data gathering and actuarial assessments by insurance companies and public health officials that broke down the African American “citizen-patient” into an assemblage of risks, statistics, and biomedical predictions that created new networked forms of surveillance and control. Race leaders’ rehabilitative program and their invocation of a language of recovery and cure, however, sought to regulate particularly the behavior of Black women and the poor. I want to end this initial brief historical contextualization of early twentieth-century vitality politics by looking at National Negro [Black] Health Week, and, especially, one health week bulletin from 1927.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Framework › 2NC --- Promise DA

Promise DA – Their model invests in the false promise of policymaking that sees its engagement as the conclusion of their project. Only DisCrit creates a place where white supremacy “can’t hide”.

Johnson 21 -  works for a Washington, DC-based international NGO focused on global worker rights. He resides in Johannesburg, South Africa. His work has been published in the Small Wars Journal, International Policy Digest, E-International Relations, the Journal of Black Studies, the Journal of Pan-African Studies, and Sahara Reporters. He earned his Ph.D. from Temple University, an MSc from the University of Birmingham, an M.A. from the  University at Albany, SUNY, and a B.A. from Elizabeth City State University. (Christopher Keith Johnson, “Using Disability Critical Race Theory in American Special Education Classrooms”, E-International Relations, 2 December 2021, ) || PZ

Definitions DisCrit builds upon the legal activism embedded within Critical Legal Studies (CLS), CRT, and DS. Its voice is as inclusive as CRT’s, with change agents approaching its strictly theoretical elements in an expansive and interdisciplinary manner. It interrogates and engages history, sexuality, gender, the whole person (body and mind), organizational development, conflict resolution, family studies, and personal and community agency. DisCrit places the disabled child in the center as a subject rather than an object of their liberation. The last element places it squarely within an African-centered approach to change that predates even CRT in the 1970s. One of CRTs founders, Kimberley Crenshaw, declares that it “is not a noun, but a verb. It cannot be confined to a static and narrow definition but is considered to be an evolving and malleable practice” (George, 2021). DisCrit is inspired and driven by the spirit of its theoretical predecessor. Raush et al. (2019) capture the definition of DisCrit as a theory and the possibilities of its application in practice: Consider the marginalization that Children of Color with dis/abilities and their families experience due to the intersection of power and privilege around race and dis/ability[…] the DisCrit framework can be used to understand how a difference in power (e.g., between administrators/teachers/schools and families) can lead to the exclusion of very young children with dis/abilities and other social identities and their families […] (Raush et al., 2019 p. 45). In America, it is dangerous to praise an unfinished project. The passage of a law, the change of a policy, and the adoption of an inclusive curriculum are often seen as the conclusion of engagement rather than its start. What DisCrit does is challenge/interrogate well-meaning law/theory/policy to agitate for action and function as a reminder of the centuries of broken promises America has made to its most vulnerable citizens and residents. With DisCrit, there is no sacred space for white supremacy to hide. Furthermore, there is no faith in a system that has proven repeatedly that it is willing to view the codification of best wishes as satisfactory for a population that should be grateful even to be acknowledged. Disability Law, Policy and Implementation Those resistant to further reform of special education in American classrooms point to the existence of disability law and well-meaning child-focused policy as positive proof that America has changed for the better in its treatment of all children with special needs. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), if applied equitably, would bring America closer to its stated aim of inclusion and protection for students with disabilities (ADA National Network, 2018). Further, the policy created by the Division for Early Childhood and the National Association for Education of Young Children, on the surface, acknowledge there are a multiplicity of innovative ways to educate children in the American classroom. However, applying the most positive standards will be limited without an interrogation of race and white supremacy. If the default from which all changes occur is whiteness, then what of those who are not white? If whiteness is the standard, then the beneficiary of these gifts would need to be white or white adjacent to be worthy of receiving anything meaningful from the system. With this in mind, education of special needs children of African descent would first be an exercise in diminishing their blackness to make them deserving of the assistance on offer. DisCrit is forced to involve itself in pushing against the othering of Black students and questioning the utility of an exercise in whitening black spaces through pacification and policing of Black bodies—students, parents, administrators, teachers—any Black body.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Framework › 2NC --- Ivory tower

Theory is a prerequisite to genuine emancipation- their ideas of activism and change miss other forms of resistance against hegemonic power.

Annamma et al 2012 (Annamma, Subini Ancy ; Connor, David ; Ferri, Beth. “Dis/Ability Critical Race Studies (DisCrit): Theorizing at the Intersections of Race and Dis/Ability.” Race, Ethnicity and Education, vol. 16, no. 1, pg 17-18, 30 Oct 2012, United Kingdom: Routledge, pp. 1–31, doi:10.1080/13613324.2012.730511.) //RB

DisCrit supports activism and promotes diverse forms of resistance. Many Critical Race Theorists call for activism that links academic work to the community. This avoids sterile ideas being handed down from the ivory tower without practical application as well as ‘studying the natives’ wherein people who know nothing about the community suggest ways to fix it based on deficit perspectives (Dixson and Rousseau 2005; Stovall 2006). DisCrit acknowledges the need for activism and the reasons behind it, but recognizes that some of the activities traditionally thought of as activism (e.g. marches, sit-ins, and some forms of civil disobedience) may be based on ableist norms, which may not be accessible for those with corporeal differences. Those with admirable equity-based goals can inadvertently maintain and perpetuate inequity for other groups. In other words, to suggest that activism cannot occur from behind a desk may be missing a larger point about what it means to resist forms of domination. If theory can be violent, that is if theory can erase large portions of the population by ignoring their needs and realities, we also believe that theory can be emancipatory, offering oppressed groups a language of critique and resistance (Leonardo 2004). DisCrit supports diverse expressions of resistance that are linked to and informed by the community, whether that be academic or theoretical, pedagogical, or activist.

To summarize, each of the tenets we put forth shares the desire to reject forces, practices, and institutions that attempt to construct dis/ability based on differences from normative cultural standards. We reject attempts at the containment of people of color with dis/abilities due to their perceived divergence from normative cultural standards. Instead, we encourage society to become more encompassing of diversity and perceived difference, at the same time we question the very norms that create difference. Becoming more encompassing includes removing the policing and enforcement of normality, dissolving barriers that actively dis/able people, and focusing instead on learning from those that have historically been uniquely positioned as having what Baker (2002) terms ‘outlaw ontologies’ (663). As Matsuda (1987) plainly states, ‘Those who have experienced discrimination speak with a special voice to which we should listen’ (63).

2022 Michigan Kritik
K --- Disability --- K Lab › Framework › 2NC --- Erasure DA

Erasure DA- debates about public policy and biotechnology never consider ableist struggles.

Wolbring 08 (Dr. Gregor Wolbring is a tenured Professor at the University of Calgary's Cumming School of Medicine, The Politics of Ableism, , 6/3/08)

The concept of ableism is everywhere and yet it is invisible within the context of science and technology policy and governance discourse. Upon searching the public domain search engine Google, Google scholar and three academic clusters of databases (Ovid Cluster of Databases, Academic Search Premier and Cambridge Scientific Databases) to ascertain the visibility of ableism within the science and technology policy academic discourse, one finds (Tables 1 and 2): ‘Ableism’ results in very few hits if combined with the terms ‘science and technology studies’, ‘policy studies’, ‘nanotechnology’, ‘biotechnology’, inequality and inequity. ‘Ableism’receives a few hits if combined with the terms ‘science and technology studies’, ‘policy studies’, ‘nanotechnology’, ‘biotechnology’, synthetic biology, inequality and inequity than if racism or sexism are combined with these terms. Ableism is invisible within the policy studies, the science and technology studies, and the nanotechnology and biotechnology discourse