Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Counterplan
Neg---Counterplans › CP Theory › AT: PICs Bad

Narrow focus good—engaging small parts of the plan spurs adaptation and innovation that solves their offense, it’s net better cause it creates in depth debates instead of stale disad and case—you should reward specificity, not punish it --- this is the best internal link to education

Branson 2007 (Josh, NDT winner who became a policy analyst for major think-tanks, edebate, http://www.ndtceda.com/pipermail/edebate/2007-May/071122.html, 5/31)

B) How to make debate more like the technical policy world? Narrower debates. PICs are vital to this (sorry, Duck). Thinking back on my 8 years in debate, the topic about which I can best converse with experts about is the design of emissions trading schemes. That was because the literature was deep and the prevalence of upstream/downstream/auctioned/timetable PICs narrowed the debates and forced a real in-depth discussion. I just don’t think we get that in a ton of debates, because most PICs are either wanky rhetoric PICs (and yes I was an extreme culprit) or something even worse like Consultation. Thinking back on it, I don’t think that the legal topic was worded particularly poorly, I just think that our strategic norms of judging/debating create a lot of problems in generating the type of education a lot of us want. But one of the most striking thing for me about last year’s topic was that I learned more from Repko’s post about his day at the Supreme Court than I did from all the debates I judged combined. In any event, how to create the types of narrow debates that will general real sustainable expertise on topics is tough.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Neg---Counterplans › CP Theory › AT: Covert CPs Bad

Lit base checks – covert policies are frequently used and are “controversial.”

Brunet-Jailly 05 [Emmanuel Brunet-Jailly is a Canadian politics and public policy scholar at the University of Victoria, British Columbia, Canada, where he is Associate Professor, co-director of the Local Government Institute, and director of the European Studies Program, 2005, http://dspace.library.uvic.ca/bitstream/handle/1828/781/uram_2005.pdf] Eric

Covert action is a policy tool used by the United States government. It is secretive and highly controversial in that it attempts to actively change the course of events in other nations. Much covert action undertaken by the US government has taken place within the developing world - governments have been overthrown, elections influenced, media distorted, and the lives of millions of individuals affected by covert activities secretly organized and executed by US officials in Washington, DC and Langley, Virginia - headquarters of the Central Intelligence Agency

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Neg---Counterplans › CP Theory › Debating EU Good

It has been THE alternative to NATO for decades – this is a core debate.

Kastrati 14 [Bilbil Kastrati is a Security Researcher of international security, 2014, “Similarities and Differences between NATO and the EU Enlargement,” https://www.readcube.com/articles/10.21113/iir.v4i2.45] Eric

After the end of the Cold War the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and the European Union (EU) enlargement were two main political processes in the European continent. Both organizations since their inception, promoted the idea of integrated Europe without borders, which meant creating a Europe without divisions and bringing back all Central Eastern European (CEE) countries into the European family where they belong. However, after half a century of isolation in the totalitarian communist system the CEE countries (CEEC) had to undertake fundamental institutional, political, economic, military and other reforms in order to join NATO and the EU. In order to ease the process of accession, both organizations set certain criteria for membership for the CEECs. While NATO’s requirements for membership were more general and flexible, the EU’s requirements, on the other hand, were non-negotiable and closely enforced.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Neg---Counterplans › CP Theory › Debating Russia Good

Develops critical thinking and checks ethnocentrism -- net benefit alone fails

Hulme 11 – Ph.D. Candidate (Michael, March 23, “Education for Global Citizenship in America”, http://libres.uncg.edu/ir/uncg/f/Hulme_uncg_0154D_10611.pdf)

The richness and diversity of sources reinforces the need for their critical evaluation. This is more than understanding that all „data‟ are more or less partial, in the senses of being both biased and incomplete: a compounding factor is the extent to which interpretation may be influenced, possibly unintentionally, by the mediating influence of one‟s own (possibly ethnocentric, certainly partial) view of the world. Even where ethnocentrism is not a factor, interactions with others might nevertheless be perceived as ethnocentric, especially in the minds of those whose understanding of the US and Americans have already been adversely prejudiced, in the same way as some Americans have internalized prejudices against others. This points to a greater need to develop the willingness to try to see the world through the eyes of others – and conversely to help others to see the world through American eyes (though without imparting any sense of superiority). Developing this skill, and generally developing awareness and understanding of others‟ perspectives, might additionally inform students‟ perceptions of bias in domestic media, domestic political representations, and other domestic sources. It should also provide insights into the extent to which media channels reinforce the prejudices of their respective audiences, no matter how ‘false’ those prejudices might be, effectively stifling critical thinking.

An example of a particular lesson here is to compare and deconstruct the various stories presented about a particular event or phenomenon in another country, whether contemporary or historical. These various presentations might include historical records, news media coverage, „official‟ statements, and stories shared by individuals with whom relationships have been established on the one hand, and the domestic equivalents on the other.87 Comparisons of this sort may well provide significant insights into how others (even those essentially friendly to the US) view the US and Americans, and why they do so. This in turn might lead to some understanding of others‟ behavior, which would otherwise remain opaque. Some of the findings set out in Chapter IV constitute cases in point, two example being on the one side you say we want to assist you, but on the other side you are pointing fingers at us. So which way do you want to be, a devil or an angel?

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Neg---Counterplans › CP Theory › Debating Russia Good

Ethnocentrism—scholars that isolate the US role are suspect

McFaul 9 (Michael, Democracy Badass @ Stanford, http://iis-db.stanford.edu/res/2278/Evaluating_International_Influences_-_Transitions_-_Concept_Paper.pdf)

A second shortcoming stems from the fact that the existing analyses on international democracy promotion focuses on the democracy promotion efforts (the “supply side”) of individual countries, notably the United States. 15 In reality, it is never the case that the United States alone - or any other external actor for that matter - plays an independent causal role in the development of democratization in another country. The unique American contribution to democratic development in a given country can only be isolated if all other external variables are included in the analysis. There was a time when the United States government was the only major actor in the world promoting democracy, but that time has passed. As noted above, today, the European Union, individual European governments and their democracy-promoting foundations and NGOs, the United Nations, NATO, the World Bank, and hundreds if not thousands of transnational networks and private foundations also contribute to the democracy promotion business. Simply focusing on the American contribution to a case of democratization (or the lack thereof) is methodologically suspect and therefore empirically flawed. There is some analysis on the role of Western European governments and supranational European institutions (particularly the European Union) in promoting democracy abroad, 16 but American and European insights are rarely integrated, and few studies are prepared to look at a range of international actors and processes. 17 Consequently there has been little systematic thinking about the spectrum of forces shaping the international “democratic environment,” not to mention the interaction of the external environment with domestic processes.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Neg---Counterplans › CP Theory › Debating Russia Good

Debating about Russia as an actor creates more critical thinking and solves interpersonal violence

Earle 86 [Professor of Psychology, The Ohio State University. International Relations and the Psychology of Control: Alternative Control Strategies and Their Consequences. Political Psychology, Vol. 7, No. 2 (Jun.,1986), pp. 369-375. https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/3791131.pdf]

Research into the psychology of control has revealed that control needs are key elements of individual psychological functioning. This paper argues that a “need for control’’ framework is also useful for understanding actions and ideologies at the national and international levels. It critically analyzes prevalent strategies for exerting control in this domain and proposes alternative strategies which permit greater fulfillment of control needs. These alternatives emerge from an examination of potential similarities between satisfaction of control needs within the separate but parallel domains of international relations and interpersonal relations.

Political psychology has the potential to translate issues of international relations into the terms of human interpersonal encounter. In my view, such a translation enhances our ability to think creatively about the current world situation.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › misc › at- nato obsolete

NATO is needed as much now as during the cold war

Andreas Kluth, 6-30-2022, "Rumors of NATO’s Brain Death Were Greatly Exaggerated," Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-06-30/nato-turkey-s-nod-to-finland-and-sweden-create-a-baltic-lake-to-buttress-east, accessed 7-3-2022//cpd

Far from comatose, NATO is today more vital and vigorous than it’s been since the height of the Cold War. It remains the greatest guarantor of security in the West and the entire free world. It is without doubt the most successful alliance in history.

When Macron was speaking off the cuff in 2019 — a time so recent in years and yet so distant in events — the allies had a lot to worry about. One concern was a US president, Donald Trump, who disdained America’s partners and cast doubt on NATO’s theretofore sacrosanct mutual-defense clause, and thereby its power to deter aggression.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › misc › bbb uq updates

Manchin is agreeing to a path forward!!

Sahil Kapur, 6-29-2022, "Senate Democrats see 'major progress' on Biden agenda bill, hope for July vote," NBC News, https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/senate-democrats-see-major-progress-biden-agenda-bill-hope-july-vote-rcna36041, accessed 7-3-2022//cpd

WASHINGTON — Senate Democrats are close to a deal to lower prescription drug costs as part of a larger party-line package to advance a number of President Joe Biden's economic priorities, three sources familiar with the negotiations said.

Democrats plan to submit a "finalized agreement" on allowing Medicare to negotiate prices with pharmaceutical companies to a key Senate official "in the coming days" to see whether it complies with the chamber's strict budget rules, one of the sources said.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › misc › bbb uq updates

Manchin is on board for BBB- Sinema is key

Joseph Zeballos-Roig, 7-2-2022, "Senate Democrats are edging closer to a deal with Manchin to resurrect Biden's economic agenda. They'll face Sinema next.," Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/senate-democrats-sinema-deal-biden-economic-agenda-bbb-millionaire-tax-2022-7, accessed 7-3-2022//cpd

Senate Democrats are inching closer to a deal with Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia to resurrect swaths of President Joe Biden's stalled economic agenda once known as Build Back Better. That has positioned the party to advance over GOP opposition a measure that would slash prescription drug prices, one of their chief priorities stretching back years.

However, if Democrats led by Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer have any hope of securing other initiatives like an extension of enhanced Affordable Care Act subsidies, their attention must soon shift to another centrist with outsized influence over the party's agenda: Sen. Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › misc › bbb uq updates

reconciliation fails- McConnell is giving ultimatums!

Steve Benen 07-01-2022, "Mitch McConnell’s new hostage threat is brazen (even for him)," MSNBC, https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/mitch-mcconnells-new-hostage-threat-brazen-even-rcna36294, accessed 7-3-2022//cpd

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell has never been timid about launching legislative hostage strategies. Indeed, for the Kentucky Republican, the word isn’t even especially inflammatory: McConnell has literally referenced “hostages“ when describing his tactics.

That said, the Senate GOP leader’s newest threat is brazen, even by McConnell’s standards. Roll Call reported:

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › nato cohesion high now

The Madrid summit proves cohesion against Russia is at an all time high

Lindsay Maizland, 06-30-2022, "NATO Countries Signal Resolve at Summit: What Does It Mean for Russia?," Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/in-brief/nato-countries-signal-resolve-summit-what-does-it-mean-russia, accessed 7-4-2022//cpd

Russia’s strategic position has deteriorated substantially as a consequence of President Vladimir Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine. NATO is more unified in opposition to Russia than it has been for years, NATO has more forces along its borders than ever since the end of the Cold War, and Finland and Sweden are set to join the alliance. Talking to the press along with U.S. President Joe Biden, NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg noted the irony: Putin wanted less NATO on his borders, but because of his actions, he’s getting more.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy appears on a television screen as he delivers a statement at the start of the NATO summit in Madrid.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › nato cohesion high now

NATO cohesion against Russia and China is strong now

Steven Erlanger, 6-29-2022, "A More Muscular NATO Emerges as West Confronts Russia and China," https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/29/world/europe/nato-expansion-ukraine-war.html, accessed 7-4-2022//cpd

MADRID — Faced with a newly aggressive Russia, NATO leaders on Wednesday outlined a muscular new vision that names Moscow as the military alliance’s primary adversary but also, for the first time, declares China to be a strategic “challenge.”

It was a fundamental shift for an alliance that was born in the Cold War but came to view a post-Soviet Russia as a potential ally, and did not focus on China at all.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › yes escalation

Russia will attack!

Paul Steidleer, 6-21-2022, "Political Games Empower Russian Cyberattacks – InsideSources," InsideSources, Paul Steidler is a senior fellow with the Lexington Institute, a public policy think tank in Arlington, Virginia. He wrote this for InsideSources.com.https://insidesources.com/political-games-empower-russian-cyberattacks/, accessed 7-8-2022//cpd

The United States faces an alarming and growing threat of cyberattacks from Russia. Some in Congress would compound these dangers by enacting legislation that would force America’s leading tech companies to allow access to their software, hardware and operating systems to customers and competitors in the U.S. and overseas.

The Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Agency (CISA) has been blunt about Russia.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › yes escalation

Despite current lack of escalation, experts predict a major destabilizing attack soon

Kyle Alspach, 6-29-2022, "Security experts brace for possible Russian cyberattacks," Protocol, https://www.protocol.com/enterprise/russia-cyberattacks-ukraine-putin-us, accessed 7-6-2022//cpd

In the four months since its invasion of Ukraine, Russia hasn't intensified its usual pattern of cyberattacks against the U.S. and Western Europe in response to sanctions and Ukrainian military aid, as many expected. But that doesn't mean the risk of escalation with the West is gone, numerous experts told Protocol.

In other words, don't lower your shields just yet.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › no escalation

800 cyberattacks in Ukraine since the war started proves there’s no threshold for escalation

Sergiu Gatlan, 6-30-2022, "Ukraine targeted by almost 800 cyberattacks since the war started," BleepingComputer, https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/ukraine-targeted-by-almost-800-cyberattacks-since-the-war-started/, accessed 7-6-2022//cpd

Ukrainian government and private sector organizations have been the target of 796 cyberattacks since the start of the war on February 24, 2022, when Russia invaded Ukraine.

According to Ukraine's cybersecurity defense and security agency SSSCIP (short for State Service of Special Communications and Information Protection), the country's networks have been under a constant barrage of hacking attempts since the war started.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › no escalation

Status quo solves- the updated strategic concept outlines shored up defenses against cyberattacks from Russia and China [ALT- also assumes interoperability, likely applicable against ai logistics]

NATO 6-29-22, 29 June 2022 NATO 2022 STRATEGIC CONCEPT Adopted by Heads of State and Government at the NATO Summit in Madrid, https://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/2022/6/pdf/290622-strategic-concept.pdf//cpd

We will continue to enhance the collective readiness, responsiveness, deployability, integration and interoperability of our forces. We will individually and collectively deliver the full range of forces, capabilities, plans, resources, assets and infrastructure needed for deterrence and defence, including for high-intensity, multi-domain warfighting against nuclear-armed peer-competitors. We will ensure a robust, resilient and integrated command structure, increase the alignment of national and NATO defence plans and strengthen and modernise the NATO force structure. We will strengthen training and exercising, adapt and streamline our decision-making processes, enhance our planning and improve the effectiveness of our crisis response system.

23. Maritime security is key to our peace and prosperity. We will strengthen our posture and situational awareness to deter and defend against all threats in the maritime domain, uphold freedom of navigation, secure maritime trade routes and protect our main lines of communications.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › no escalation

Status quo solves, the CISA is developing capabilities to defend against Russian cyberattacks now

Dave Muoiomar 3-25-22, "Amid warnings of potential Russian cyberattacks, new Senate bill directs CISA, HHS to shore up digital defenses," Fierce Healthcare, https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/health-tech/cybersecurity-healthcare-senate-bill-bipartisan-cisa-hhs-cassidy-rosen-new-bipartisan, accessed 7-6-2022//cpd

A bipartisan bill introduced Wednesday in the Senate aims to shore up the healthcare industry’s cyber defenses shortly after White House warnings of potential Russian cyberattacks.

The so-called Healthcare Cybersecurity Act would direct the Department of Homeland Security’s Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to work side by side on bolstering cybersecurity readiness among healthcare and public health organizations, according to statements from its co-sponsors.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › no escalation

No Russian escalation, Putin is focusing on getting more weapons to Ukraine [ALT: No Russian escalation, they can’t even supply the war in Ukraine]

Isabel Van Brugen, 7-1-2022, "Russia admits it's running out of weapons in Ukraine war," Newsweek, https://www.newsweek.com/russia-putin-admits-running-out-weapons-ukraine-war-invasion-state-duma-law-1720957, accessed 7-3-2022//cpd

For the first time, Russia has admitted that it is running out of weapons in the Ukraine war, after President Vladimir Putin's government created a draft federal law that would allow the country to quickly repair weapons and military equipment.

On Thursday evening, the Kremlin submitted a bill to the State Duma on "special economic measures" for "counterterrorist and other operations" outside of Russia.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › russia war › no escalation

Russia doesn’t have the capabilities for escalation, they’ve tried and failed :(

David E. Sanger and Julian E. Barnes, 6-22-2022, "Many Russian Cyberattacks Failed in First Months of Ukraine War, Stud…," https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/22/us/politics/russia-ukraine-cyberattacks.html, accessed 7-8-2022//cpd

WASHINGTON — A new examination of how Russia used its cybercapabilities in the first months of the war in Ukraine contains a number of surprises: Moscow conducted more cyberattacks than was realized at the time to bolster its invasion, but more than two-thirds of them failed, echoing its poor performance on the physical battlefield.

However, the study, published by Microsoft on Wednesday, suggested that the government of President Vladimir V. Putin was succeeding more than many expected with its disinformation campaign to establish a narrative of the war favorable to Russia, including making the case that the United States was secretly producing biological weapons inside Ukraine.

2022 Michigan Evidence
general topic updates › finland and sweden › finland and sweden- baltics

Finland and sweden’s admission fortifies russian deterrence in the baltics

Francesca chambers and michael collins, 6-29-2022, "finland's, sweden's push to join nato 'a kick in the gut' for putin," archive.ph, https://archive.ph/gd2qm, accessed 7-3-2022//cpd

The breakthrough in the top-level diplomatic talks between Finland, Sweden and Turkey came shortly after President Joe Biden and other NATO leaders arrived in Spain for a three-day summit that will determine the course of the alliance for years.

Finland’s and Sweden’s entry into the alliance will vastly expand its reach.