2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › Alt Causes › Alt Cause---Algorithms
Paul Barret et. al 21 P.B Deputy Director and Senior Research Scholar - NYU Stern Center for Business and Human Rights, J.H Associate Research Scientist and Adjunct Instructor - NYU Tandon School of Engineering Founder and Editor - Tech Policy Press, G.S Grant Sims Research Fellow - NYU Stern Center for Business and Human Rights, “How tech platforms fuel U.S. political polarization and what government can do about it,” BROOKINGS, //chico
As both members of Congress and federal law enforcement agencies investigate the origins and execution of the January 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol, the role social media played in the mayhem is emerging as a crucial issue.
The House Select Committee probing the mob attack has asked a wide range of social media and telecommunications companies to preserve records related to several hundred people, including members of Congress, who could be relevant to the investigation. Beyond these specific requests, the Committee has signaled a broader interest in how false claims about the 2020 election spread on platforms like Facebook and Twitter, including how algorithms might contribute to the promotion of disinformation and extremism. Meanwhile, federal prosecutors pursuing more than 600 criminal cases are relying on evidence gathered from social media accounts used to organize the attempt by Trump supporters to stop Congress from certifying President Joe Biden’s victory.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › Alt Causes › Alt Cause---Global Disinfo
David L. Sloss 2022, He is a professor at Santa Clara University School of Law, received his JD from Stanford University, MPP from Harvard University Kennedy School of Government, and BA from Hampshire College. He worked as a litigation associate at Wilson, Sonsini, Goodrich & Rosati in Palo Alto and clerked for Senior Judge Joseph T. Sneed, U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, San Francisco. He also worked for the U.S. Arms Control and Disarmament Agency for nine years before he attended law school., “Tyrants on Twitter”, pg 76// SK
We saw in the last two chapters that Russia is actively using social media to interfere with democratic elections in the United States and western Europe. China’s approach to information operations differs from Russia’s in several respects. First, China’s ambitions are global: it aims to reshape the global information environment to align with its authoritarian values. Second, social media is a fairly small element of China’s global information strategy: China is utilizing a broad range of communication tools to achieve its goals. Third, whereas Russia’s agenda is primarily negative— to undermine Western democracies— China has a much more positive agenda. Ultimately, China seeks to transform the liberal international order created by the United States and its allies after World War II so that international norms and institutions align more closely with China’s authoritarian governance model. The Chinese term huayuquan is translated as “discourse power.” Discourse power is the “national capability to infl uence global values, governance, and even day- to- day discussions on the world stage.”1 One commentator notes: “The Chinese Communist Party’s quest to dominate thought and narrative has always been central to its pursuit of power. To this end, every supreme party leader since Mao has reaffirmed the strategic and national security importance of the party’s control of media, culture, and narrative.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › Alt Causes › Alt Cause---Domestic Disinfo
Ritu Gill et al. 2022, Ritu Gill is Ritu Gill is an Intelligence Analyst with 13 years of experience working with Canadian law enforcement, 12 of those years were with the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), Dr. Rebecca Goolsby currently serves as a program officer for the Office of Naval Research and the lead on NATO Research Technology Group, HFM-293 “Digital and Social Media Assessment For Effective Communication And Cyber Diplomacy”, “COVID-19 Disinformation: A Multi-National, Whole of Society Perspective”, pg.48//SK
Social media is characterized as a powerful online interaction and information exchange medium. However, it has given rise to new forms of deviant behav- iors such as spreading fake news, rumors, misinformation, disinformation, and conducting propaganda and influence campaigns. Due to afforded anonymity and perceived diminished personal risk of connecting and acting online, deviant groups are becoming increasingly common. Online deviant groups have grown in parallel with online social networks, whether it is black hat hackers using Twitter to recruit and arm attackers, announce operational details, coordinate cyber-attacks (Calabresi, 2017), and post instructional or recruitment videos on YouTube targeting certain demographics; or state/non-state actors’ and extremist groups’ (such as ISIS) savvy use of social communication platforms to conduct phishing operations, such as viral retweeting of messages containing harmful URLs leading to malware (Al-khateeb et al., 2016). These campaigns use a variety of tactics, techniques, and strategies to further their agenda. Some of these campaigns exploit deep-rooted biases along racial, ethnic and political lines (leveraging pandemic disparity), to erode trust in scientific and democratic institutions (invoking vaccination fears), to stoke anger, anxiety, and chaos, and ultimately polarize an already divided society. People increasingly obtain their news from social media rather than from mainstream media (Barthel & Mitchell, 2017), and with the world adjusting to the current pandemic and officials struggling with the misinfodemic, it is important now, more than ever, to closely monitor social media platforms to identify misinformation and disinformation campaigns and stem their impact on society.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › Alt Causes › Alt Cause---Domestic Disinfo
Samia Benaissa Pedriza 2021, She has a PhD in Journalism at the Complutense University of Madrid and Is a researcher on communication and international law, “Sources, Channels and Strategies of Disinformation in the 2020 US Election: Social Networks, Traditional Media and Political Candidates”, Vol. 2 Iss. 4//SK
In relation to the sources of disinformation, it is usual that the amount of fake news grow exponentially during electoral seasons (Waisbord 2018). As Shin et al. (2016) recall, during the 2012 US election, false information was widely disseminated via Twitter, especially among politically polarized voters. The 2016 US election was also another clear example of misinformation derived from social media, but in that case, it was also largely orchestrated by foreign powers that managed to unwantedly influence the electoral campaign (Hall Jamieson 2018). However, in the 2020 election, the sources of disinformation that most attracted the attention of fact-checkers were those represented by users of social networks, the candidates themselves and traditional media. Therefore, in this case, no foreign power following a planned and sustained over time disinformation strategy was involved, according to the concept of “organized disinformation” used in international relations (Volkoff 1986). In the 2020 election, the only messages analyzed by international fact-checkers that came from an institutional source were those issued by the White House itself.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Polarization IL › 1NC---AT: Polarization IL
Markus Pausch 21, political scientist and professor at the University of Salzburg, 10/10/21, “The future of polarisation in Europe: relative cosmopolitanism and democracy,” mh
The political polarisation that we observe in recent years, is linked to various factors of political equality [11], including representation, participation, transparency, but is also a dialectical relationship between contradictory needs for freedom and belonging, to which cosmopolitanism and communitarianism correspond at the political level. A balance between these needs requires a non-dogmatic relative cosmopolitanism that is based on real life experiences and competences of democracy, dialogue and citizenship education.
Basis characteristics of polarisation
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Democracy IL › AT: LIO IL
John J. Mearsheimer 19, R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago. “Bound to Fail: The Rise and Fall of the Liberal International Order,” International Security (2019) 43 (4): 7–50. //chico
By 2019, it was clear that the liberal international order was in deep trouble. The tectonic plates that underpin it are shifting, and little can be done to repair and rescue it. Indeed, that order was destined to fail from the start, as it contained the seeds of its own destruction.
The fall of the liberal international order horrifies the Western elites who built it and who have benefited from it in many ways.1 These elites fervently believe that this order was and remains an important force for promoting peace and prosperity around the globe. Many of them blame President Donald Trump for its demise. After all, he expressed contempt for the liberal order when campaigning for president in 2016; and since taking office, he has pursued policies that seem designed to tear it down.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Democracy IL › 1NC---AT: Democracy Internal---Squo Solves
Chris Zappone 22, an inaugural member of the National Security College’s Futures Hub in 2017. His focus has been on hybrid warfare, propaganda, cyber competition. He is Digital Foreign Editor at The Age and Sydney Morning Herald, where he was among the first in the media to report on the Kremlin’s efforts to interfere in the 2016 US election. He has presented on related subjects at SXSW in the US and testified to Parliament on the political risk of social media manipulation, March 2022, "‘It’s a clear pattern’: Why declassifying secrets is good for democracy," The Sydney Morning Herald, https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/it-s-a-clear-pattern-why-declassifying-secrets-is-good-for-democracy-20220304-p5a1nw.html //AShah
The Biden administration’s decision on Thursday to tell the public that Vladimir Putin was likely to use chemical weapons in Ukraine shows the extent to which the US strategy to battle Russia’s disinformation has evolved.
Once upon a time, such intelligence would have only been shared with the top echelons of allied countries. But in the evolving East-West confrontation, declassifying secrets is proving good for democracy.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Democracy IL › 1NC---AT: Democracy Internal
Kevin Riehle 21, Associate Professor at the University of Mississippi Center for Intelligence and Security Studies, January 2021, “Winners and losers in Russia’s information war,” Intelligence & National Security, Vol. 36, Issue 7, pp. 1057-1064, https://doi.org/10.1080/02684527.2021.1877405, RMax
It might be soothing to claim that Russia is the root of our problems, and Russia certainly has no desire to help us solve those problems. Jankowicz even seems to imply that maintaining vigilance against Russian influence activities will help in ‘repairing the cracks that allowed them in the first place.’40 However, such sentiments hide the true origin of Russia’s influence: our internal divisiveness. The success of Russian influence activities can only serve as an indicator of how far we have to go to heal our own societies. Nevertheless, Russia’s actions have placed it back on the table as an adversary, just as its Soviet predecessor was, which is not in Russia’s best interests. That is evidenced by the very existence of these two books: without Russia’s actions, Kent and Jankowicz would never have written them. However, Russia’s strategy of division and deception is a losing one. Russia is not capable of destroying a democratic society; the society can only do that to itself. Democratic societies survived the Soviet-era information onslaught and will survive the current one if they can reduce internal anger and divisiveness, while Russia offers nothing constructive to the world. In her claim to be describing How to Lose the Information War, Jankowicz is in fact showing how Russia is doing just that.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › AT: Truth Decay/Public Trust IL
Gabrielle Lim 20, researcher at Harvard Kennedy School’s Shorenstein Center and a fellow with Citizen Lab. “The Risks of Exaggerating Foreign Influence Operations and Disinformation,” Centre for International Governance Innovation (CGI), //chico
As a first step, the US Foreign Agents Registration Act, which risks being abused for political reasons, should be reformed, as Nick Robinson argues in Foreign Policy. Second, increasing transparency around campaign funding and online ad spending would also be helpful, specifically around “dark money” — where the identities of the donors are concealed. And lastly, states need to do the hard work of governance. In many ways the prevalence of false and misleading content is symptomatic of deeper issues. As Johan Farkas and Jannick Schou demonstrate in their book, Post-Truth, Fake News and Democracy, the decline in democracy has been ongoing for decades and is not because of social media: “There is a series of deep-seated problems facing liberal democracies, but the rise of fake news and alternative facts is not the biggest of our problems.” Instead of looking overseas for scapegoats, we should be looking at why trust in our own institutions and authorities has fallen, why civil discourse has devolved and how to better address the many social divisions that drive our receptivity for dubious content.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › AT: Polarization IL
Levi Boxell 17, L.B Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Matthew Gentzkow Department of Economics Stanford University, Jesse M. Shapiro Economics Department @ Brown University, “IS THE INTERNET CAUSING POLITICAL POLARIZATION? EVIDENCE FROM DEMOGRAPHICS,” NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES, //chico
Our findings are difficult to square with a straightforward account linking the recent rise of polarization to the internet. This is especially true for accounts in which social media plays a central role. Unless cross-group spillovers are very large or the effects of digital media vary greatly across groups, some other forces must explain the large increase in polarization among the groups least likely to use the internet. None of this is to say that the rise of digital technologies is not important. They may well account for some recent polarization, and whatever role they may have played in the past is likely to grow in coming years.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › AT: CDC/Public Health IL
Mario H. Lopez 21, Opinion Contributor for THE HILL, “Moderna’s missteps undermine US vaccine diplomacy,” THE HILL, //chico
This isn’t just problematic for the company. It hurts America’s standing on the world’s stage at a time when we need to project strength and stability. Instead of riding high on the historic wave of innovation unleashed by the U.S. pharmaceutical industry, the Biden administration is publicly admonishing Moderna for failing to increase its global vaccine supply.
Consider the events that have unfolded since December 2020 when Moderna became the second company to obtain FDA authorization for its vaccine. Despite receiving $2.5 billion from American taxpayers, Moderna has opted not to follow the lead of other COVID vaccine manufacturers who have offered their product at a reduced rate. The company’s president flatly stated, “We will not sell it at cost.”
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › AT: CDC/Public Health IL
Jeneen Interlandi 21, staff writer at the New York Times, “Covid Proved the C.D.C. Is Broken. Can It Be Fixed?,” The New York Times Magazine, //chico
For most of the last seven decades, the C.D.C. has stood as the world’s premier public-health institution — so much so that counterpart agencies in other countries are often called C.D.C.s, even when the abbreviation means nothing in their native languages. The agency invented disease surveillance as we know it, helped lead the (successful) quest to eradicate smallpox, initiated the (ongoing) fight against H.I.V. and beat back Ebola — more than once. Its heroics have been the stuff of novels and movies and harrowing nonfiction best sellers. Americans took for granted that the C.D.C. would be engaged and quick in a crisis; that it was well funded and equipped with modern technology; that it had, or could quickly get, comprehensive data on diseases of concern; and that it knew how to translate that data into sound guidance in a crisis. Wasn’t that, at least partly, how bird flu, swine flu and a thousand other nameless plagues were prevented from decimating the American masses?
The agency may be just one cog in the nation’s public-health apparatus, but it is a crucial one. In an ideal world, its edicts would hold sway not only over schools but also nursing homes, prisons and meatpacking plants. It would guide elected officials and private institutions alike through not just global pandemics but all manner of public-health threats: food-borne pathogen outbreaks, the opioid crisis, gun violence. In an ideal world, its efforts would succeed, more often than not, at keeping people safe and helping them stay healthy. This is the C.D.C. we need. But as the last year has made clear, it is not the C.D.C. we have.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 2NC---AT: Info Ecosystem IL
William H. Dutton 2017, Professor of Media and Information Policy, Michigan State University, May 2017, “Fake news, echo chambers and filter bubbles: Underresearched and overhyped”, SK
In the early years of the internet, it was revolutionary to have a world of information just a click away from anyone, anywhere, anytime. Many hoped this inherently democratic technology could lead to better-informed citizens more easily participating in debate, elections and public discourse.
Today, though, many observers are concerned that search algorithms and social media are undermining the quality of online information people see. They worry that bad information may be weakening democracy in the digital age.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 2NC---AT: Info Ecosystem IL
Joseph Bernstein 21 is a senior reporter at BuzzFeed News and a 2021 Nieman Fellow. “Bad News: Selling the story of disinformation,” Harper’s Magazine, //chico
The media narrative of sinister digital mind control has obscured a body of research that is skeptical about the effects of political advertising and disinformation. A 2019 examination of thousands of Facebook users by political scientists at Princeton and NYU found that “sharing articles from fake news domains was a rare activity”—more than 90 percent of users had never shared any. A 2017 Stanford and NYU study concluded that if one fake news article were about as persuasive as one TV campaign ad, the fake news in our database would have changed vote shares by an amount on the order of hundredths of a percentage point. This is much smaller than Trump’s margin of victory in the pivotal states on which the outcome depended.
Not that these studies should be taken as definitive proof of anything. Despite its prominence in the media, the study of disinformation is still in the process of answering definitional questions and hasn’t begun to reckon with some basic epistemological issues.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 2NC---AT: Info Ecosystem IL
Mathew Ingram 19, CJR’s chief digital writer. “Researchers say fears about ‘fake news’ are exaggerated,” Columbia Journalism Review (CJR), //chico
Nyhan and his fellow researchers, however, including Princeton political scientist Andrew Guess, say their study looked at the actual behavior of a large sample of users who consented to have their online activity tracked and recorded in real time, and then followed up with interviews about their perceptions of the content. Not only was the amount of actual fake news they encountered incredibly tiny, Guess told CJR this past fall, but the idea that this would influence their behavior is also a bit of a stretch (something Nyhan wrote about for The New York Times last year). “It’s predominantly people who are inclined to believe the conclusions that are being made in this content, not so much swaying them to believe something,” Guess said. “In other words, it’s more or less just confirmation bias.”
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 2NC---AT: Info Ecosystem IL
Bryan Robinson 2020, He is a Professor Emeritus at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, authored 40 nonfiction books, and was featured on 20/20, Good Morning America, ABC’s World News Tonight, NBC Nightly News, NBC Universal, The CBS Early Show, CNBC’s The Big Idea and NPR's Marketplace, October 2020, “A New Study Shows Fake News May Benefit Your Memory”, Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/bryanrobinson/2020/10/17/a-new-study-shows-fake-news-may--benefit-your-memory/?sh=27d81e9c2687//SK
During the workday, we are flooded with emails, texts, and other social media. And with the advent of photo shopping and political leaders who don’t divulge the truth, it’s often difficult to know what to believe anymore. Hence, the term fake news has caused many people to become skeptical about what they read or see on television news feeds—even the authentic news. But a new study says we shouldn’t throw out the baby with the bathwater. Not all news is fake, and even if a story turns out to be fake news, there’s value in it, according to a study in the journal Psychological Science. Thinking back on a time you encountered false information or “fake news” may prime your brain to better recall truthful memories. People who receive reminders of past misinformation may form new factual memories with greater fidelity. Past research highlights one insidious side of fake news: The more you encounter the same misinformation—for instance, that world governments are covering up the existence of Bigfoot and flying saucers—the more familiar and potentially believable that false information becomes. New research, however, has found that reminders of past misinformation can help protect against remembering misinformation as true while improving recollection of real-world events and information. Researcher Christopher Wahlheim at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro and his research team conducted two experiments with 96 participants, who read factual statements and misinformation statements taken from news websites and then read statements that corrected the misinformation. Reminders of past misinformation appeared before some corrections but not others. Study participants then tried to recall facts, indicated their belief in those recalls and indicated whether they remembered corrections and misinformation. The researchers examined whether reminders of misinformation could improve memory for and beliefs in corrections. Study results showed that misinformation reminders increased the participants' recall of facts and belief accuracy. The researchers interpreted the results to indicate that misinformation reminders raise awareness of discrepancies and promote memory updating. These results may be pertinent to individuals who confront misinformation frequently. "Reminding people of previous encounters with fake news can improve memory and beliefs for facts that correct misinformation," said Wahlheim. "This suggests that pointing out conflicting information could improve the comprehension of truth in some situations." These findings demonstrate that misinformation reminders can diminish the negative effects of fake-news exposure in the short term. According to Walheim, "It suggests that there may be benefits to learning how someone was being misleading. This knowledge may inform strategies that people use to counteract high exposure to misinformation spread for political gain.”
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 2NC---AT: Info Ecosystem IL
Matthew Ingram 2019, He is CJR’s chief digital writer. Previously, he was a senior writer with Fortune magazine. He has written about the intersection between media and technology since the earliest days of the commercial internet. His writing has been published in the Washington Post and the Financial Times as well as by Reuters and Bloomberg., Febuary 2019, “Researchers say fears about ‘fake news’ are exaggerated”, SK
IT’S SO WIDELY ACCEPTED that it’s verging on conventional wisdom: misinformation, or “fake news,” spread primarily by Facebook to hundreds of millions of people (and created by Russian agents), helped distort the political landscape before and during the 2016 US presidential election, and this resulted in Donald Trump becoming president. But is it really that cut and dried? Not according to Brendan Nyhan, a political scientist and professor of public policy at the University of Michigan. He and several colleagues have been researching this question since the election, and have come to a very different conclusion. Fears about the spread and influence of fake news have been over-hyped, Nyhan says, and many of the initial conclusions about the scope of the problem and its effect on US politics were exaggerated or just plain wrong.
Nyhan says his data shows so-called “fake news” reached only a tiny proportion of the population before and during the 2016 election. In most cases, misinformation from a range of fake news sites made up just 2 percent or less of the average person’s online news consumption, and even among the group of older conservatives who were most likely to consume fake news, it only made up about 8 percent. Not only that, but the University of Michigan researcher says a new paper he and his colleagues recently published shows the reach of fake news actually fell significantly between the 2016 election and the midterm elections last year, which suggests Facebook has cracked down on the problem. Nyhan also says “no credible evidence exists that exposure to fake news changed the outcome of the 2016 election.”
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 2NC---AT: Info Ecosystem IL
Mathew Ingram 19, CJR’s chief digital writer. “Researchers say fears about ‘fake news’ are exaggerated,” Columbia Journalism Review (CJR), //chico
IT’S SO WIDELY ACCEPTED that it’s verging on conventional wisdom: misinformation, or “fake news,” spread primarily by Facebook to hundreds of millions of people (and created by Russian agents), helped distort the political landscape before and during the 2016 US presidential election, and this resulted in Donald Trump becoming president. But is it really that cut and dried? Not according to Brendan Nyhan, a political scientist and professor of public policy at the University of Michigan. He and several colleagues have been researching this question since the election, and have come to a very different conclusion. Fears about the spread and influence of fake news have been over-hyped, Nyhan says, and many of the initial conclusions about the scope of the problem and its effect on US politics were exaggerated or just plain wrong.
Nyhan says his data shows so-called “fake news” reached only a tiny proportion of the population before and during the 2016 election. In most cases, misinformation from a range of fake news sites made up just 2 percent or less of the average person’s online news consumption, and even among the group of older conservatives who were most likely to consume fake news, it only made up about 8 percent. Not only that, but the University of Michigan researcher says a new paper he and his colleagues recently published shows the reach of fake news actually fell significantly between the 2016 election and the midterm elections last year, which suggests Facebook has cracked down on the problem. Nyhan also says “no credible evidence exists that exposure to fake news changed the outcome of the 2016 election.”
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 1NC---AT: Info Ecosystem IL
Gabrielle Lim 20, researcher at Harvard Kennedy School’s Shorenstein Center and a fellow with Citizen Lab. “The Risks of Exaggerating Foreign Influence Operations and Disinformation,” Centre for International Governance Innovation (CGI), //chico
In recent years, concerns over foreign interference from “bad actors” have increased, and in the wake of the 2016 US presidential election, governments around the world, social media companies and civil society alike have been on the lookout for such attempts to degrade the integrity of our elections or, more vaguely, to “sow discord.” From pseudonymous trolls and botnets to outrage-inducing, hyper-partisan content, it seems that week after week, there is news that online accounts are pushing narratives in the interest of Russia, Iran or China. The Global Engagement Center (GEC), a division of the US State Department, for example, has alleged that Russia is operating an “ecosystem” of humans and bots to amplify conspiracy theories related to COVID-19 in a bid to “sow discord and undermine U.S. institutions and alliances.” Senator Elizabeth Warren even released a detailed plan to fight disinformation as part of her presidential campaign, citing “foreign actors” as the main threat. Scholars and journalists are also on the hunt. Indeed, plenty of ink has been spilled on the ills of “weaponized social media” and the next generation of “active measures.”
However, despite all the fears of mass-targeted influence operations from foreign adversaries, it remains unclear whether they have much impact at all.
2022
Michigan
Negative
ADV---Information Ecosystem › AT: Info Ecosystem ILs › 1NC---Squo Solves
Ondrej Filipec 2019, Ph.D. is Assistant Professor at the Department of Politics and Social Sciences, Faculty of Law, Palacký University in Olomouc, “Towards a Disinformation Resilient Society? The Experience of the Czech Republic” vol. 11 no. 11 pg 16//SK
On the other hand, the gap is slowly being filled by NGOs and individuals who provide textbooks (often on a commercial basis), and materials and information on how to teach media education. Lecturers and universities provide assistance or volunteers (initiative Zvolsi.info) and the NGO People in Need organizes the Week of Media Education. Some webs contribute to the field with the fact checking of political speeches (Demagog.cz), and are aimed at debunking political disinformation (Manipulatori.cz) or hoaxes (Hoax.cz). In recent years, there have also been valuable books written by experts on disinformation and propaganda, which are not fully academic but have a popular style in order to reach a larger audience. In this way, the role of civil society and active individuals play an important role in the fight against disinformation and propaganda as they help to reveal and debunk the disinformation and contribute to media literacy at least within the selected segments. Moreover, approximat crely since 2018 there are ‘Czech Elves’ present on the social networks who fight ‘Russian Trolls’. As pointed out by Elven anonymous speakers: ‘we know that they are dividing our society and that support of extremes is intentional, backed by foreign interests. Activities are made by variously motivated enemies of our values ... we are not indifferent to the division of our society, that is why we want to defend our state and fight against Russian propaganda’ (Aktulne.cz 2018). However, the Czech environment is different from that of the Baltic States where people are more aware of Russian influence. For example while Elves in Latvia have approximately a five year long tradition and Elves are counted in hundreds, in the Czech Republic society is divided and there are just dozens of Elves (Aktualne.cz 2018). It is too early to evaluate the presence of Czech Elves on the internet as the real effects remain hidden. The presence has been notified also by its critics who consider Elves as the agents on the side of the censors as they help to fight disinformation.