Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › 2NC – OV › Violation – OCO’s

The AFF is NOT strengthening systems – they are at most effects topical

1AC Lewis ’15 [read yellow] [James; October; Director and Senior Fellow, Strategic Technologies Program, Center for Strategic and International Studies; "THE ROLE OF OFFENSIVE CYBER OPERATIONS IN NATO’S COLLECTIVE DEFENCE,” Tallin Paper No. 8, A NATO CCDCOE Publication on Strategic Cyber Security, https://www.ccdcoe.org/uploads/2018/10/TP_08_2015_0.pdf]

The central question for NATO’s cyber doctrine is how the lack of an articulated offensive cyber capability affects its ability to deter or defend. Put another way, can any military force credibly claim to have advanced capabilities if it does not include offensive cyber operations in its arsenal? Offensive capabilities, unlike NATO’s current defensive posture, involve deliberate intrusions into opponent networks or systems with the intention of causing disruption, damage or destruction. The question of NATO and offensive cyber capabilities touches on a range of sensitive political issues that militate against any change in policy in the near term.

The US has always been overly secretive about its offensive cyber capabilities, even after a flood of media leaks have made the most sensitive doctrine publicly available. This secrecy has carried over into NATO, and is unhelpful in that it increases the likelihood of opponents miscalculating as they consider the risks of using force or coercion against NATO members or interests. A lack of public discourse on offensive cyber operations undercuts the legitimacy of NATO operations by failing to build public understanding, and leaves NATO open to charges of sinister plots, since denial of offensive capabilities is not credible when two NATO members are world leaders in cyber operations.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › 2NC – OV › Violation – Cohesion – Strengthen Systems

NATO’s cohesion means unity

Mierzwa ’21 [Danuta; 09/30/21; General Tadeusz Kościuszko Military University of Land Forces; and Marek Tomaszycki, General Tadeusz Kościuszko Military University of Land Forces; "Imperial policy of the Russian Federation versus cohesion and coherence of NATO’s new strategic concept," SpringerLink, //smarx, AZG]

NATO’s cohesion means a level of political and ideological unity as well as solidarity between the members of the Pact. It mainly refers to the principles on which the Alliance is based. This is particularly true of the Member States’ commitment to collective defence, threats and challenges facing the Alliance.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › 2NC – OV › Violation – Cohesion – Strengthen Systems

Extensive findings prove that cohesion is about synergy, NOT strengthening systems

Bazin ’17 [Aaron; 09/27/17; Graduate Certificate in Blockchain Strategy from the University of Oxford, PsyD from the University of Rockies; and Dominika Kunertova, PhD in Political Science from Université de Montréal with specialization in Security Studies, Senior Researcher at the Center for Security Studies in fields like security cooperation; "An Alliance Divided? Five Factors That Could Fracture NATO," Army University Press, smarx, AZG]

In making sense of Alliance cohesion in the future, this study first refined the understanding of cohesion itself. The findings indicate that NATO’s cohesion means synergy and the ability of NATO nations to think and act together. That is, to develop shared interests, values, and common standards and rules, and to respond to problems as a united group. Relying on mutual trust, cohesion is “doing what is best for the community” and looking beyond self-interests. Building on the analogy of ties between family members, the participants stated that cohesion is an expression of staying together despite differences, of “something bigger than ourselves.” One participant believed that “without cohesion, the Alliance would implode.”

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › 2NC – OV › Violation – Interoperability

Interoperability refers to how things can be used together

Cambridge Dictionary ’No Date [“Interoperability,” //smarx, AZG]

the degree to which two products, programs, etc. can be used together, or the quality of being able to be used together:

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › 2NC – OV › 2NC – Cybersecurity – Strengthen Systems

Cybersecurity is strengthening the security and resilience of cyberspace

Wallace ’No Date [Matthew; Certification in Cybersecurity: Technology, Application, and Policy from Massachusetts Institute of Technology Professional Education, Professional Member Association of Computing Machinery; “Glossary of Terms,” Internet Salmagundi, smarx, AZG]

CyberSecurity is strengthening the security and resilience of cyberspace:

CyberSecurity at the federal level includes: Combating Cyber Crime, Securing Federal Networks, Protecting Critical Infrastructure, Cyber Incident Response, Cyber Safety, Cybersecurity Governance, Cybersecurity Insurance, Cybersecurity Jobs, Cybersecurity Training & Exercises, Information Sharing, Stakeholder Engagement and Cyber Infrastructure Resilience.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › 1NC---Cybersecurity – Strengthen Systems

‘Cybersecurity’ is defined as strengthening systems

Newton and Hogan ’15 [Elaine; Michael; December 2015; Newton, PhD in Engineering and Public Policy at Carnegie Mellon University; Hogan, Distinguished Graduate of the Infantry Officer Candidate School, electronics engineer at NIST; “Supplemental Information for the Interagency Report on Strategic U.S. Government Engagement in International Standardization to Achieve U.S. Objectives for Cybersecurity,” National Institute of Standards and Technology, U.S. Department of Commerce, //smarx, AZG]

Cybersecurity is defined as the prevention of damage to, unauthorized use of, exploitation of, and—if needed—the restoration of electronic information and communications systems, and the information they contain, in order to strengthen the confidentiality, integrity and availability of these systems.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative

They’re not mutually exclusive

Laura B. West 21, Judge Advocate in the U.S. Army and currently serves as the Deputy Chief of National Security Law at U.S. Cyber Command, “ARTICLE: BEYOND FIGHTING WORDS: RECONCEPTUALIZING INFORMATION WARFARE AND ITS LEGAL BARRIERS,” National Security Law Journal, 8, 162. //chico

This article's focus on a data-centric solution to information warfare by no means suggests neglecting network-centric efforts. On the contrary, cybersecurity and data security need to be viewed as mutually reinforcing mechanisms to solving the information warfare problem. Discussing the needed reform and issues revolving around cybersecurity is, however, outside the scope of this article.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › 2NC › Cybersecurity – Excludes Info Sharing

Information sharing often weakens cybersecurity

Eli Dourado & Andrea O’Sullivan 15, Senior Research Fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University and advisor to the State Department on international telecommunication matters who has served on several U.S. delegations to UN treaty and policy conferences & feature writer at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, “’Information Sharing’: No Panacea for American Cybersecurity Challenges”, 06/22/2015, Mercatus Center at George Mason University, /lg

Information sharing initiatives are not novel. A 1998 presidential order authorized the formation of public-private partnerships to share threat information within critical infrastructure industries. Dozens of such Information Sharing and Analysis Centers (ISACs) have coordinated cyberthreat information flows among public and private entities since that time. Additionally, at least 20 federal offices already carry out missions that prioritize information sharing and public-private cybersecurity coordination. The National Cybersecurity and Communications Center (NCCIC), a DHS cyberthreat coordination center, houses the US Computer Emergency Response Team (US-CERT), which has served as the primary cyberthreat collection, assistance, and notification center since it was founded in 2003. President Obama created the CTIIC in February 2015 to advance information sharing goals along with the NCCIC, the Federal Bureau of Intelligence’s National Cyber Investigative Task Force, DOD’s US Cyber Command, and “other relevant United States Government entities”—which could amount to several dozen offices. Such overlapping roles and unclear lines of communication results in waste, inefficiency, and poorer security outcomes.

Despite the ample resources devoted to this task, the federal government has struggled to effectively collect and share incident information internally and with the private sector. ISACs can cease to operate if members do not actually share valuable information. A DHS Inspector General Report finds that the NCCIC faces large challenges in effectively sharing information among the appropriate parties. As of October 2014, the NCCIC had not even developed a common incident management system to coordinate information sharing—five years after being formed to do so. US-CERT has yet to develop performance metrics to gauge and improve effectiveness, despite serving as the main federal cybersecurity consultant for over a decade. Additionally, private sector threat analysis efforts often outpace US-CERT in breach notification. Indeed, DHS has at times been unable to even adequately share threat information within its own offices. In March 2013, DHS’s own US-CERT issued a warning about Windows XP vulnerabilities to government and private sector partners. But by November of that year, DHS’ Inspector General reported that several DHS computers were still running a vulnerable version of Windows XP, even after other DHS representatives ensured they had stopped running that version.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 1AR---Cybersecurity---Reasonability

SPECIFICALLY in the field of cybersecurity our arguments about substance crowd-out are true.

Robert Dewar 14, Senior Researcher on the Cyber Defense Project at the CSS, 2014, "The "Triptych" of Cyber Security", https://www.academia.edu/9034642/The_Triptych_of_Cyber_Security?email_work_card=thumbnail, 6th International Conference on Cyber Conflict, accessed 7-7-2022 \\SYang

In the field of cyber security, ill-defined concepts and inconsistently applied terminology are further complicating an already complex issue. This causes difficulties for policy-makers, strategists and academics. Using national cyber security strategies to support current literature, this paper undertakes three tasks with the goal of classifying and defining terms to begin the development of a lexicon of cyber security terminology. The first task is to offer for consideration a definition of “active cyber defence” (ACD). This definition is based upon a number of characteristics identified in current academic and policy literature. ACD is defined here as the proactive detection, analysis and mitigation of network security breaches in real-time combined with the use of aggressive countermeasures deployed outside the victim network. Once defined, ACD is contextualised alongside two further approaches to cyber defence and security. These are fortified and resilient cyber defence, predicated upon defensive perimeters and ensuring continuity of services respectively. This contextualisation is postulated in order to provide more clarity to non-active cyber defence measures than is offered by the commonly used term “passive cyber defence”. Finally, it is shown that these three approaches to cyber defence and security are neither mutually exclusive nor applied independently of one another. Rather they operate in a complementary triptych of policy approaches to achieving cyber security.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 1AR---AT: CIA triad

Cybersecurity only requires one tenet of the CIA triad

Christian Calliess & Ansgar Baumgarten 20, Professor for Public and European Law at Freie Universität Berlin, holder of an Ad Personam Jean-Monnet-Chair, and previous Legal Adviser to the European Political Strategy Center (EPSC), advising and working under the authority of its President Jean-Claude Juncker & PhD candidate and scientific assistant for Dr. Calliess at Freie Universität Berlin, “Cybersecurity in the EU The Example of the Financial Sector: A Legal Perspective”, 2020, German Law Journal, Vol. 21, p. 1149 /lg

Alongside space, air, land, and sea, cyber is the fifth dimension. It opens a global virtual world, radically changing societies and shaking classical borders. But a digital world also comes with new types of micro threats on businesses and citizens, and macro threats on public policies and state security, which are asymmetrical, unpredictable, and unaffected by classical state responses. They occur at [*1150] the level of tricksters and range up to state espionage and, potentially, offensive cyber-attacks against states. Cyber is as such a new global world, where there is no dividing line between external and internal security. There is an attacker in one country, aiming for a target in another, causing damage in yet a third. There are as well large-scale attacks targeting and affecting several Member States at once--with the actual attack being carried out in cyberspace, which does not even adhere to one spot, country, or continent, but is a dimension for itself. This raises the question of the adequacy, or inadequacy, of the classical regulatory tools to reply to these challenges.

In this new environment, the EU and its Member States need to anticipate and plan for hitherto unimaginable scenarios in which they would be put if under a severe cyber-attack. This is particularly true for the implementation of the European Commission's EU Digital Single Market agenda. With the financial industry at its very center, a digital single market for the free movement of persons, services, and capital is highly dependent on a reliable and robust IT infrastructure. Comparable to the field of "industry 4.0," innovation in the financial sector--for example, the idea of a "Digital City," a financial platform of Europe that coordinates a network of financial centers in the EU --and the success of new business models depend on trust in a safe digital environment.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 1AR---AT: CIA triad

The CIA triad interp is too vague, unnecessarily broad, and impedes the success of cybersecurity operations

Derek E. Bambauer 15, Professor of Law at the University of Arizona, where he teaches Internet law and intellectual property (covers Internet censorship, cybersecurity, and intellectual property) + was a Research Fellow at the Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard Law School, “Conundrum”, 04/11/2015 revision date (originally published 4/11/2011), Minnesota Law Review, Vol. 96, p. 584 /lg

Conceptualizing cybersecurity challenges policymakers and academics. 32 The current theoretical approaches to cybersecurity, though, have proved to be significantly flawed. They employ definitions that are vague and overbroad; they seek to force cybersecurity's issues into the straitjackets of existing doctrines poorly suited to cybersecurity's problems; and they produce concomitant policy recommendations that not only fail to mitigate, but actually worsen, the Internet's security challenges.

Conventional wisdom on cybersecurity identifies the problem as all-encompassing. 33 Scholars, government officials, and journalists tend to view cybersecurity as the "protection of all things Internet" 34 - an approach that impedes practical progress by failing to set priorities. Government efforts at capturing cybersecurity's scope have been particularly overbroad. [*592] President Barack H. Obama's Cyberspace Policy Review offers a representative definition, where cybersecurity is:

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 1AR---AT: CIA triad

We meet --- __{area of aff found in card}___ is specifically included within the CIA triad

Igor Nai-Fovino et al. 19, Scientific Project Manager with the Joint Research Centre in Ispra, Italy who was a Contractual Researcher with the University of Milano and received Ph.D. in computer security from the Università degli Studi di Milano, “A Proposal for a European Cybersecurity Taxonomy”, 2019, European Comission (executive body of the EU) /lg

Network security is concerned with hardware, software, basic communication protocols, network frame structure, and communication mechanisms factors of the network [SOURCE ISO/IEC TR 29181-5]. Information Security in the network context deals with data integrity, confidentiality, availability and non-repudiation while is sent across the network. A distributed system is a model in which components located on networked computers communicate and coordinate their actions by passing messages. In this context cybersecurity deals with all the aspects of computation, coordination, message integrity, availability and (if required) confidentiality. Message authentication is also in the scope.

Network security (principles, methods, protocols, algorithms and technologies);

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 2AC---C/I – Defend systems & info – AT: CIA triad

Cybersecurity is a state whereby systems and information are defended against damage, unauthorized use, or exploitation --- Kosseff bases this definition on legal documents and policy

Jeff Kossef 16, Assistant Professor of Cybersecurity Law, United States Naval Academy. B.A., M.P.P., University of Michigan; J.D., Georgetown University Law Center, “The Cybersecurity Privilege”, Spring 2016, Ohio State Technology Law Journal, Vol. 12, p. 261 /lg

Cybersecurity is a relatively new concept for courts. Indeed, few U.S. courts have used the term, and none have articulated a common definition for cybersecurity. The Department of Homeland Security's National Initiative for Cybersecurity Careers and Studies (NICCS) offers a fairly comprehensive definition of cybersecurity: "[t]he activity or process, ability or capability, or state whereby information and communications systems and the information contained therein are protected from and/or defended against damage, unauthorized use or modification, or exploitation." That definition, which is based on various documents and policies issued by Department of Homeland Security, National Institutes of Standards and Technology, and the White House, makes clear that cybersecurity includes the protection of both systems and information. This definition also correctly makes clear that cybersecurity is different from privacy, which NICCS defines as the "assurance that the confidentiality of, and access to, certain information about an entity is protected." Although cybersecurity can help to protect individuals' privacy, the terms are not interchangeable. Privacy involves assuring individuals that their personal data is protected, while cybersecurity more broadly encompasses the steps that a company takes to protect its systems and the information that is stored on those systems. If a company does not enact the necessary cybersecurity safeguards, then its consumers' and employees' privacy may be more likely to be at risk. Accordingly, companies are increasingly focusing on cybersecurity.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 2AC---AT: Excludes Property Rights

The property rights interp is too vague, unnecessarily broad, and impedes the success of cybersecurity operations

Derek E. Bambauer 15, Professor of Law at the University of Arizona, where he teaches Internet law and intellectual property (covers Internet censorship, cybersecurity, and intellectual property) + was a Research Fellow at the Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard Law School, “Conundrum”, 04/11/2015 revision date (originally published 4/11/2011), Minnesota Law Review, Vol. 96, p. 584 /lg

Conceptualizing cybersecurity challenges policymakers and academics. 32 The current theoretical approaches to cybersecurity, though, have proved to be significantly flawed. They employ definitions that are vague and overbroad; they seek to force cybersecurity's issues into the straitjackets of existing doctrines poorly suited to cybersecurity's problems; and they produce concomitant policy recommendations that not only fail to mitigate, but actually worsen, the Internet's security challenges.

Conventional wisdom on cybersecurity identifies the problem as all-encompassing. 33 Scholars, government officials, and journalists tend to view cybersecurity as the "protection of all things Internet" 34 - an approach that impedes practical progress by failing to set priorities. Government efforts at capturing cybersecurity's scope have been particularly overbroad. [*592] President Barack H. Obama's Cyberspace Policy Review offers a representative definition, where cybersecurity is:

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 2AC---AT: Defensive Only

Precision DA---contemporary cybersecurity includes offensive techniques.

Bred Medairy 22, 2021 Federal 100 Award Winner, Top 50 Cyber Leader for 2021, 2020 Cyber Executive of the Year by the Northern Virginia Technology Council, and a Finalist for WashingtonExec’s 2020 Cybersecurity Industry Executive of the Year, accessed July 5, 2022, “The future of cybersecurity: the best defense is a good offense”, https://www.boozallen.com/s/insight/blog/future-of-cybersecurity.html \\SYang

In today’s unpredictable environment, filled with rapidly evolving threat actors and emerging technologies, the only way organizations can protect themselves is by unleashing offensive cyber techniques to uncover advanced adversaries on their networks. The most effective approach—Threat hunting—is essential to any organization that wants to stop and prevent attacks in its networks.

“In working with clients on hunt engagements, Booz Allen has found an average dwell time—that is, the time an advanced adversary lies undetected in a victim’s network—of 200-250 days before discovery. ”

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 2AC---C/I---Includes Offensive Operations

C/I---Cybersecurity can be both offensive and defensive---their evidence doesn’t have intent to exclude.

Lily Teplow 21, Content Marketing Manager at Huntress, September 14, 2021, “Should We Be Playing Offense or Defense in Cybersecurity?”, https://www.huntress.com/blog/should-we-be-playing-offense-or-defense-in-cybersecurity \\SYang

Defensive cybersecurity is all about blocking. This could come in the form of both tools and actions. You have your defensive tools that are designed to prevent or mitigate the effects of a cyberattack—such as antivirus software, firewalls, etc. And then you have your defensive actions, which include things like patching software and fixing system vulnerabilities. 

Offensive cybersecurity, on the other hand, is all about tackling and outmaneuvering. The focus here is on seeking out the hackers, and in some cases, attempting to disable or “hack back” to disrupt their operations. Offensive cybersecurity can also help identify vulnerabilities or weaknesses in your defense. It’s a slightly more proactive approach to security and can include practices like penetration testing and threat hunting. 

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 2AC---C/I---Military/Domestic/Econ

“Cybersecurity” means protecting military security, domestic peace and order, or economic stability from cyber threats

National Cybersecurity Bill (Thai) 15, “Memorandum of Principle and Rationale of [Draft] National Cybersecurity Act B.E”, draft was approved by the cabinet on 01/06/2015, translated by the Thai Netizen Network, /lg

“Cybersecurity” means measures and operations that are conceived in order to maintain national Cybersecurity, enabling it to protect, prevent or tackle circumstances of cyber threats which may affect or pose risks to the service or application of computer network, internet, telecommunications network, or the regular service of satellites in ways that affect national security, which includes military security, domestic peace and order, and economic stability.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 2AC---C/I---Includes Cybercrime

Cybersecurity includes network and information security, the fight against cybercrime, and cyber defense

Christian Calliess & Ansgar Baumgarten 20, Professor for Public and European Law at Freie Universität Berlin, holder of an Ad Personam Jean-Monnet-Chair, and previous Legal Adviser to the European Political Strategy Center (EPSC), advising and working under the authority of its President Jean-Claude Juncker & PhD candidate and scientific assistant for Dr. Calliess at Freie Universität Berlin, “Cybersecurity in the EU The Example of the Financial Sector: A Legal Perspective”, 2020, German Law Journal, Vol. 21, p. 1149 /lg

Alongside space, air, land, and sea, cyber is the fifth dimension. It opens a global virtual world, radically changing societies and shaking classical borders. But a digital world also comes with new types of micro threats on businesses and citizens, and macro threats on public policies and state security, which are asymmetrical, unpredictable, and unaffected by classical state responses. They occur at [*1150] the level of tricksters and range up to state espionage and, potentially, offensive cyber-attacks against states. Cyber is as such a new global world, where there is no dividing line between external and internal security. There is an attacker in one country, aiming for a target in another, causing damage in yet a third. There are as well large-scale attacks targeting and affecting several Member States at once--with the actual attack being carried out in cyberspace, which does not even adhere to one spot, country, or continent, but is a dimension for itself. This raises the question of the adequacy, or inadequacy, of the classical regulatory tools to reply to these challenges.

In this new environment, the EU and its Member States need to anticipate and plan for hitherto unimaginable scenarios in which they would be put if under a severe cyber-attack. This is particularly true for the implementation of the European Commission's EU Digital Single Market agenda. With the financial industry at its very center, a digital single market for the free movement of persons, services, and capital is highly dependent on a reliable and robust IT infrastructure. Comparable to the field of "industry 4.0," innovation in the financial sector--for example, the idea of a "Digital City," a financial platform of Europe that coordinates a network of financial centers in the EU --and the success of new business models depend on trust in a safe digital environment.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Cybersecurity › Affirmative › 2AC---C/I---Includes Satellites

Cybersecurity is the prevention of damage to, unauthorized use of, or exploitation of information systems --- includes protection and restoration of satellites

Christopher Hannan 16, lawyer who briefed and argued multiple issues on consolidated appeals in the United States Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals and graduated from the Loyola School of Law, J.D., magna cum laude with Law Excellence Awards in Civil Procedure I, Legal Research & Writing, Civil Law Property II, Maritime Personal Injury, Evidence, Law of the European Union I, Courts in a Federal System and Community Property, “Maritime Cybersecurity Inland and Offshore – Avoiding ‘Paid Spies and Secret Confidential Agents on the Water of the Devil’ and ‘Mere Dead Reckoning of the Error-Abounding Log’”, 12/14/2016, JDSUPRA, https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/maritime-cybersecurity-inland-and-51369/ /lg

The past eighteen to twenty-four months have seen a tectonic shift of focus (as well as a plethora of industry-generated white papers) by virtually every governmental regulatory entity, NGO, and industry group in the maritime world (up to and including the President of the United States) to the amorphous and dynamic issue of maritime “cybersecurity,” a term that covers a large waterfront of potential threats. The United States Coast Guard (USCG) has adopted the following broad definition of “cybersecurity” from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. National Infrastructure Protection Plan, 2013:

Cybersecurity – The prevention of damage to, unauthorized use of, or exploitation of, and, if needed, the restoration of electronic information and communications systems and the information contained therein to ensure confidentiality, integrity, and availability; includes protection and restoration, when needed, of information networks and wireline, wireless, satellite, public safety answering points, and 911 communications systems and control systems.