Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Space Spending

The House is critical of space spending projects

Insinna 19 [Valerie Insinna was Defense News' air warfare reporter. Beforehand, she worked the Navy and congressional beats for Defense Daily, which followed almost three years as a staff writer for National Defense Magazine. Prior to that, she worked as an editorial assistant for the Tokyo Shimbun’s Washington bureau. https://www.defensenews.com/space/2019/05/14/house-appropriators-put-some-pressure-on-the-space-development-agency-in-fy20-funding-proposal/]//LP

Houston, the Pentagon’s new space acquisition agency may have a problem. In its proposed funding bill for fiscal 2020, House defense appropriators are seeking to cut off funding for the Space Development Agency until the Defense Department meets several conditions. While the legislation still has a long way to go before it becomes law, it could spell trouble for the newly established SDA — especially if Senate lawmakers raise similar objections. Acting Defense Secretary Patrick Shanahan signed off on the SDA in March. The agency is supposed to be a fast acquisition arm for emerging space capabilities that may not have a validated requirement, and its first task is to field a layer of low-Earth orbit satellites capable of transferring data among the military’s terrestrial and space assets. However, critics have contended that SDA’s purpose has not been defined clearly enough, a position that House defense appropriators seem to find valid. The bill stipulates that no funding can be spent on the organization until the Defense Department submits a detailed plan to establish the SDA, what projects it will take on over the next three years and how much funding will be required for those efforts. It also wants information about how SDA and the Air Force will collaborate on a holistic space architecture, and the process both organizations will use to guide prototyping efforts into fully fledged programs. Lawmakers also want to know where the SDA will be based and how many personnel will staff it — a prospect that could bring local jobs, a boon to any member of Congress — as well as a plan to transfer SDA from the Defense Department to the Air Force or Space Force by the end of FY22. The bill echoes concerns raised by Air Force Secretary Heather Wilson, who has vocally opposed the creation of SDA. In February, she told reporters that she didn’t understand why a new space acquisition agency was needed, given the establishment of the Space Rapid Capabilities Office and the Air Force’s own work to make the Space and Missile Systems Center more efficient. Even as Shanahan pressed forward with the establishment of SDA, naming Fred Kennedy as head of the organization, Wilson continued to speak out against it. “Let me be clear: The United States Air Force is funding the development of low-Earth orbit systems and commercially based systems for some of our missions,” Wilson told the audience at the Space Symposium in April. “But launching hundreds of cheap satellites into theater as a substitute for the complex architectures where we provide key capabilities to the war fighter will result in failure on America’s worst day if relied upon alone.” While the House appropriations bill can be seen as a modest victory for Wilson, it may be a Pyrrhic one: It also orders that funding the Air Force’s next generation of missile warning satellites be cut by half until the Defense Department meets its requirement to supply more information about SDA. The service’s next-generation Overhead Persistent Infrared program has been touted by the Air Force for its rapid approach. In fact, the service is seeking $632 million in FY19 because the program is moving so quickly that it has met milestones quicker than expected and needs more money to continue prototyping the sensor payload, its acquisition executive Will Roper said in April. House appropriators’ desire to put limits on the next-gen OPIR could stem from worries about whether that constellation may be too similar to one of the systems that the Space Development Agency intends to field. After fielding the initial “transfer layer” of low-Earth orbit satellites meant to augment the department’s data transfer capabilities, the SDA plans to launch a “tracking layer” of missile warning satellites, SDA head Kennedy said last month. Kennedy also suggested that the next-gen OPIR could be changed or reduced in scope if the tracking layer was successful. “Rather than wait to 2025” to get the next-gen OPIR in orbit, “what I’m arguing is that we try to put up some form of capability in 2022 and show that we can do it. We may not have perfect global coverage, but we’ll have some level of coverage — at least regionally — addressing most of that threat,” he said.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Space Spending

The House and Senate Appropriations committees hate space spending

Erwin 19 [Sandra Erwin writes about military space programs, policy, technology and the industry that supports this sector. She has covered the military, the Pentagon, Congress and the defense industry for nearly two decades as editor of NDIA’s National Defense Magazine and Pentagon correspondent for Real Clear Defense. https://spacenews.com/house-appropriators-do-not-approve-space-force-request-call-on-dod-to-study-alternatives/]//LP

The House Appropriations Committee says it will not support DoD’s $72.4 million request to establish a Space Force headquarters, and wants the Pentagon to study alternative options. The committee is scheduled to mark up the defense bill on Tuesday. The draft report accompanying the committee’s proposed fiscal year 2020 defense spending bill notes that the decision to not back the $72 million request should not be read as a complete rejection of the idea of establishing a Space Force. “The Committee recommendation does not fully fund the request to establish the proposed Space Force,” says the draft report obtained by SpaceNews. “The Committee makes this decision without prejudice and includes funds for the Department to examine and refine alternative organizational options that will streamline the management and decision-making process and minimize overhead cost and bureaucracy.” The House and Senate Armed Services Committees are reviewing the administration’s Space Force legislative proposal and considering whether to authorize the new service in the 2020 National Defense Authorization Act. Appropriators are not policy makers. Only the HASC and SASC can authorize DoD to establish a new military service. But it’s up to the House and Senate Appropriations Committees to fund the new branch and decide how much. Defense officials have said they estimate the Space Force will cost no more than $2 billion over five years but have not provided detailed analysis to back that up, according to congressional officials. The Senate Armed Services Committee has done due diligence and directed the Congressional Budget Office to analyze the future costs of the Space Force, U.S. Space Command and the Space Development Agency. The CBO in a report laid out a number of scenarios. On the Space Force, it projects costs significantly higher than $2 billion over five years. The Pentagon has challenged those estimates. DoD has proposed legislation to establish the Space Force as a separate service within the Department of the Air Force, with an Undersecretary for Space and a Chief of Staff for Space. “While the Committee appreciates the intent of the proposal, the plan leaves many unanswered questions and lacks important details and supporting analysis to justify the proposed size, scope, cost, roles, and authorities for the new military service.” Appropriators say in the draft report that they support DoD efforts to advance the military’s space capabilities but are not convinced that requires setting up a new military branch. “The Committee is very concerned with the rapid advances potential adversaries are making to develop capabilities that threaten United States space assets on orbit,” the report says. The committee “understands that this is an urgent problem that will require the Department to reorient its strategies, organizational constructs, and program priorities to meet the reality of these threats.” However, the report notes that it is “fully within the Department’s current authority to make space a higher priority without creating a new military service and is not persuaded that the specific plan proposed justifies the additional overhead cost and disruption across the Department.” The HAC’s defense subcommittee last week agreed to give DoD $15 million to further study how a space service could be organized. Space policy analyst Marcia Smith noted that the House Appropriations defense bill is moving faster than HASC action on the NDAA, which is creating “a bit of confusion regarding the status of the Space Force debate.” The defense subcommittee could have approved the $72.4 million request contingent upon the passage of authorization legislation, but it did not, Smith wrote. “Their action is viewed as lukewarm support for the idea, at best.” Other space-related provisions National security space launch — The House Appropriations Committee in the draft report commends the Air Force for its launch procurement strategy to increase competition and eliminating its reliance on Russian rocket engines. “The national security space launch program is going through a critical transition as it phases out legacy launch systems and considers a variety of new and upgraded rockets to meet the full slate of national security mission requirements,” the report says. The committee also said it is concerned with the “significant level of technical and programmatic risk this transition entails, including risk of a potential gap if any of the new, unproven rockets develop problems or experience setbacks.” Appropriators agreed to fully fund the Air Force’s request for the National Security Space Launch program and “urges the Secretary of the Air Force to proceed expeditiously with its strategy in order to minimize the risk of a gap in assured access to space.” Satellite communications — The draft report calls for a restructuring the military’s satellite communications programs. “The current military satellite communications architecture comprises independently designed, purpose-built spacecraft; ground systems; and user terminals intended to meet differing mission requirements for strategic, wideband, and narrowband communications,” says the report. In fiscal year 2019, the Secretaries of the Army, Navy, and Air Force were tasked with developing an integrated architecture and acquisition strategy for wideband and narrowband communications and were directed to consider both government and commercial systems, user terminals, and network capabilities. The committee encourages the Secretaries of the Navy and the Air Force to consider transferring responsibility for future narrowband satellite communications systems from the Navy to the Air Force to help create an integrated communications architecture. Missile warning satellites — Appropriators question the strategy for the Next Generation Overhead Persistent Infrared (OPIR) program. The 2020 budget seeks nearly $1.4 billion, an increase of $752 million above the 2019 enacted level. The committee cut DoD’s request by $201 million. It agrees with DoD that there is an “urgent need to field a more resilient capability against growing space threats.” But in the report they raise flags about the “rapid budget growth and the Air Force strategy of relying on significant reprogramming requests to keep the program on schedule.” The committee questions whether the use of fast-prototyping authorities given to DoD under Section 804 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2016 is appropriate for this program. The committee also asked DoD to provide a long-term strategy for missile defense and hypersonic defense. The committee “views the current Next Generation Overhead Persistent Infrared Block O program as an important interim step to a currently undefined, but much needed, future comprehensive OPIR architecture,” the report said. It included a legislative provision requiring the Space Development Agency and the Air Force to lay out a plan to develop a “unified and integrated space architecture.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Space Force

Space Force policy causes congressional division

KHEEL 18 [Rebecca Kheel is a congressional reporter for Military.com. She previously worked as a defense reporter for The Hill, covering all things defense from the view at the Capitol, including negotiations over annual defense authorization and appropriations bills, fights about the foreign policy crisis of the day and more. https://thehill.com/policy/defense/415935-divided-congress-to-clash-over-space-force-nuclear-arsenal/]//LP

Space Force The Trump administration has said it wants the establishment of a “Space Force” included in next year’s defense policy bill. That position has contributed to increasingly diverging opinions between House and Senate lawmakers. Republicans in the Senate — who were initially skeptical of creating a separate branch of the military for space — have appeared more open to the idea since Trump got involved. Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman James Inhofe (R-Okla.), a Trump ally who will keep the gavel in the next Congress, has said he has an open mind but is awaiting more cost details. The Senate may lose one of its most vocal Space Force critics, albeit on the Democratic side. Sen. Bill Nelson (D-Fla.), who led the chamber’s opposition to a similar plan from the House last year, is fighting for his political life in a reelection race that appears headed toward a recount. Meanwhile, Democrats in the House have grown more entrenched in their opposition to Space Force ever since Trump injected himself into the debate. Smith, who supported the House’s space corps plan last year, came out against Space Force in September. He said that while he believes the military needs to do a better job of prioritizing its presence in space, a separate branch is not the most cost-effective way to do so. Space Force still has some key Democratic support in the House. Rep. Jim Cooper (D-Tenn.), who worked alongside Rep. Mike Rogers (R-Ala.) to lead the chamber’s space corps push, said in September that he hopes Trump’s involvement doesn’t “ruin the debate” about it. Smith has said this year’s defense budget of $716 billion is “too high,” and in a Thursday letter announcing his run for chairman he vowed to target “inefficiency and waste” at the Pentagon. The Washington Democrat has argued that lawmakers need to start making tough choices about spending and taxing as rising deficits have been compounded by the GOP’s 2017 tax-cut law. Defense hawks and the Pentagon pushed for the $716 billion to help address what they characterized as an urgent readiness crisis. Few Democrats argue that the military is not facing readiness issues, but Smith has said the military needs to be “smart” about how it spends its money. He has cited the Navy’s 355-ship goal, saying the focus on a number is flawed logic because “capability matters.” Senate Republicans argue that defense cuts would reverse any readiness progress that’s been achieved. They say the budget needs to continue the growth trend from the past two years in order to fully emerge from the readiness hole. Asked by The Hill in October about the potential House-Senate split and the looming return of budget caps, Inhofe expressed confidence that the defense budget would at least stay flat. “We have to catch up,” Inhofe said. “We have to keep that up, or all that we have done in catching up in those last two fiscal years will go out the window. So that’s not just going to happen.” But in this case, Democrats may actually have an ally in Trump, who recently ordered his administration to propose a $700 billion defense budget for fiscal year 2020 — a $16 billion cut from this year and $33 billion less than the initial plan for 2020.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Space Force

Democrats hate space spending – especially when it involves the Space Force

Zhang 21 [Sharon Zhang is a freelance writer who covers climate change and race. She has a bachelor's and master's degree in environmental studies from the University of Southern California. https://truthout.org/articles/democrats-file-bill-to-abolish-flagrantly-wasteful-trump-formed-space-force/]//LP

On Wednesday, California Democratic Rep. Jared Huffman filed a bill to abolish the U.S. Space Force, which he describes as “flagrantly” wasteful. The Space Force was established by former President Donald Trump in 2019. Though it is the smallest branch of the Armed Forces, it’s been widely slammed by progressives for having 16,000 personnel and costing billions of dollars a year. Huffman’s No Militarization of Space Act would axe the Space Force completely. “The long-standing neutrality of space has fostered a competitive, non-militarized age of exploration every nation and generation has valued since the first days of space travel. But since its creation under the former Trump administration, the Space Force has threatened longstanding peace and flagrantly wasted billions of taxpayer dollars,” Huffman said in a statement. “Our mission must be to support the American people, not spend billions on the militarization of space,” Huffman continued, saying that money going toward the Space Force would be better spent fighting the climate crisis, COVID-19 and inequality in the U.S. Representatives Rashida Tlaib (D-Michigan), Mark Pocan (D-Wisconsin), Jesús “Chuy” García (D-Illinois) and Maxine Waters (D-California) joined Huffman in introducing the bill. Before President Joe Biden was inaugurated, progressive lawmakers wrote a letter to the incoming administration asking officials to eliminate the Space Force, criticizing its formation for being unnecessary and for further militarizing the U.S, which is already immersed in a culture of endless war. “Maybe, just maybe, we should make sure our people are not dying because they lack health insurance before we start spending billions to militarize outer space,” wrote Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont) in 2018. The Space Force is tasked with gathering military intelligence from space and monitoring and transmitting GPS signals from satellites — but although the force has now been in existence for over a year, its function is not exactly clear as yet. In 2018, retired astronaut Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Arizona) pointed out that the U.S. already had an arm of the military serving the same purpose as the Space Force: the Air Force Space Command, which was reorganized and reformed into its own branch. A press release on the Huffman bill says that the formation of a separate Space Force “creat[ed] bureaucratic confusion and further waste.” The branch received $15.4 billion in funding for the fiscal year 2021, though it was taken from the Air Force budget. The bill directs the Space Force to be reabsorbed into the Air Force. Critics worry that the Space Force’s existence as its own separate entity will eventually lead to further funding for the Defense Department. “Militarizing space is an unconscionable waste of billions of tax dollars, and it risks extending the worst mistakes of history to the final frontier by inviting conflict and escalation,” said Sean Vitka, senior policy counsel for Demand Progress. “Americans don’t want more wasteful military spending, which means Congress should pass the No Militarization of Space Act before the Space Force budget inevitably skyrockets.” Political experts have speculated that it is unlikely Biden will support getting rid of the military branch, which has bipartisan approval. Meanwhile, Congress this week is set to authorize the largest budget the Pentagon has ever seen.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Space Force

New space initiatives cause massive infighting between parties

Roeder 21 [Tom Roeder is a Space Foundation senior data analyst and editor whose work appears in The Space Report, which is considered the authoritative guide to global space activity. Before joining the foundation in 2021, Roeder worked for nearly three decades as a newspaper reporter and editor for publications including The Gazette in Colorado Springs, where he ended his tenure as city editor. Roeder’s reporting, mainly focused on defense, space and politics, has taken him all over the globe from street fighting in Baghdad to street markets in Seoul.https://gazette.com/military/space-force-abolished-house-bill-would-do-just-that/article_7589e9f6-1bd5-11ec-9112-0f98af62e60b.html]//LP

A group of House Democrats introduced a bill Wednesday to abolish the nation’s newest armed service, eliminating the Space Force and giving the Air Force its responsibilities. Backed by five members of the House Progressive Caucus, which is composed of Democrats on the party’s left wing, the “No Militarization of Space Act” was introduced as congress debates its annual Pentagon policy bill. “It’s time we turn our attention back to where it belongs: addressing urgent domestic and international priorities like battling COVID-19, climate change and growing economic inequality,” said the measure's author, U.S. Rep. Jared Huffman, a Democrat from the wealthy San Rafael suburb of California’s Bay Area. “Our mission must be to support the American people, not spend billions on the militarization of space.” The move, trumpeted in a news release, comes amid increasingly rancorous budget negotiations between Democrats and Republicans in the Senate. Republicans have threatened to thwart Democratic efforts to raise the government's debt limit and tie up a Democrat-backed spending plan that's required to avert a shutdown of federal agencies on Oct. 1. Colorado Springs Republican U.S. Rep. Doug Lamborn bristled at the introduction of the bill to kill the Space Force, which came after it was rejected as an amendment to a wider Pentagon measure. “This is an frivolous bill that has no hope of passing," Lamborn said in an email. "The creation of the Space Force was a bipartisan effort from the beginning. This reorganization of our national security space enterprise resulted from the belated recognition of space as a warfighting domain and the increasing threat to critical space assets posed by our near-peer competitors." House Armed Services Committee votes to postpone Space Command’s move from Colorado Springs The measure would have to gain traction to pass the House, where the Space Force has had support from both sides of the aisle. Even if the House backed it, the measure would face almost certain defeat in the Senate, where Democrats hold control by the narrowest of margins and the space service has had bipartisan backing. The bill to kill Space Force is co-sponsored by U.S. Reps. Maxine Waters, D-Calif.; Rashida Tlaib, D-Mich.; Marc Pocan, D-Wisc.; and Chuy Garcia, D-Ill. The Space Force, approaching its second birthday, was created amid rising tensions in orbit between America, Russia and China. Pushed by President Donald Trump, the new service was intended to give space troops a seat in high level discussions of U.S. war plans while giving missions in orbit more prominence in budget discussions. Analysis: After Afghanistan, it's time to talk about troops, draft | Tom Roeder With four Space Force installation, Colorado is home to bulk of the new service's troops and its key capabilities. At Colorado bases, Space Force troops, dubbed guardians in Pentagon lingo, operate almost all of the Pentagon's spacecraft, including the Global Positioning System and missile warning satellites. This week at an Air Force Association conference, the Space Force's top general said the service is working to prevent war from reaching orbit rather than fighting battles beyond Earth's atmosphere. “I am convinced that if we can protect our critical capabilities and deny an aggressor benefit, or impose a cost they cannot bear, we may prevent war for extending to other domains,” Raymond told the conference. The new service, which falls under the Department of the Air Force, will eventually include an estimated 1,300 troops. Unlike the Air Force, Navy and Army, the Space Force doesn't include troops in supporting roles. The service relies on the Air Force for jobs including cooks, cops, lawyers and medics. In a departure from the partisan battles common on Capitol Hill in recent months, Lamborn said most lawmakers from both parties have backed the the new service. "Most Democrats don’t want to abolish the Space Force, as the Biden administration has endorsed our newest service, and congressional Democrats on the Rules Committee rejected this bill as an amendment to the Nation Defense Authorization Act," Lamborn said. "I continue to be a strong supporter of the U.S. Space Force." Lamborn, though, may agree that the Pentagon is spending too much on one aspect of its space enterprise. The congressman has argued that President Donald Trump's decision to uproot U.S. Space Command from Colorado Springs in favor of Alabama could waste billions of dollars. A Lamborn, amendment backed by House members, to the Pentagon policy bill would block funding of the move until investigations of the decision by the Government Accountability Office and the Pentagon's inspector general are completed.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Space Agreements

Multilateral agreements over space are politically deadlocked – 50 years of empirics prove secrecy and sovereignty concerns mean the plan drains pc

Goguichvili et al. 21 [Sophie Goguichvill is a Program Associate at the Wilson Center https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/global-legal-landscape-space-who-writes-rules-final-frontier]//LP

In an age where space is evolving and developing more rapidly than intergovernmental organizations can keep up, it is abundantly clear that the current global space governance framework—a product of the Cold War—is no longer adequate. In its current state, the global space governance framework excludes many space activities and allows actors to operate under wide-ranging and often conflicting interpretations of existing agreements. While there have been many attempts to improve the governance framework, progress in this area has stagnated, in large part due to diplomatic impasses between international actors and has negatively impacted the sustainable development of space. Of the five international agreements previously mentioned, the Outer Space Treaty (1967), Rescue Agreement (1968), the Liability Convention (1972), and the Registration Conventions (1974) require substantial clarification in order to apply many of their principles to new space activities and issues, such as satellite servicing, space traffic management, tourism, or space debris mitigation. The Moon Treaty (1979) has too few signatories to be effective altogether. Although countries have attempted to improve or complement these agreements over the years, no new multilateral agreements have been produced since the 1970s. In their place, non-binding norms have emerged in large part due to the ease by which they can be created and set into effect, however effective or ineffective they may be. Often slow to action, limited in authority, and bogged down by political deadlock, international bodies like COPUOS—and more indirectly, UNOOSA—which were established to advance global space governance, are failing to further their mission. While this has not dissuaded spacefaring nations from proposing new multilateral policies addressing evolving uses of space through international fora, important technological advancements—such as the rapid advancement of the commercial space sector—are often overlooked. This raises concerns, namely because private entities are not bound by the Outer Space Treaty or any of the other agreements. Another obstacle of note is that different States have different priorities when it comes to transparency and confidence building measures (TCBMs) and often, competing economic and military interests tend to stall those efforts. Satellite over California/Earth in spacePlay Video Seeking Strategic Advantage: How Geopolitical Competition and Cooperation are Playing Out in Space As our dependency on space grows, what are the implications for the world’s critical infrastructure? Do risks to space capabilities threaten global economic development and international security? Former NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine and experts from Aerospace Corporation discuss the future of governance in space in this event hosted at the Wilson Center. WATCH While easier to agree upon in the short-term, passive support from various states and private actors on nonbinding agreements—such as the UNGA principles as well as the Code of Conduct for Outer Space Activities—will not hold in the long-run. One thing is clear: multilateral efforts have not proven completely effective, and more is needed to provide order as new space interests are pursued. In response to recent failures to advance international agreements, the development of national space policies is on the rise. Take the U.S., for example, whose concerted government-wide efforts to refocus its attention on space led to the creation of a new National Space Policy, as well as a series of Space Policy Directives, which outline and provide rules of the road for American space activities in the wake of pressing international challenges. These documents cover our human space exploration program (SPD-1); commercial space regulations (SPD-2); national space traffic management (SPD-3); the creation of the Space Force (SPD-4); cybersecurity in space (SPD-5); and space nuclear power and propulsion (SPD-6). With the addition of the U.S.-led Artemis Accords, these documents taken together are a means to establishing modern customary international law and norms of behavior beyond the Cold War-era provisions of the foundational U.N. space treaties. The growth of the commercial space sector has proven to be the single development related to space since the groundwork of international space governance was laid in the 1960s and 1970s. This has by and large contributed to commercial interests receiving greater prioritization as new national policies are developed. Although prioritized less than national security (i.e., military) or civil (i.e., science and exploration) space policy, commercial space has begun to emerge as a third component in national space policy strategies. The preference to develop domestic policies over international agreements reflects both the emerging value of commercial space and the stagnation of international space governance. The U.S. and Russia stand apart from other nations, as they have the most robust set of national laws and regulatory organizations designed with international space commitments in mind. But among the 28 nations with domestic space policies, there is little policy convergence. States’ decisions to develop unilateral space policies with little concern for international cooperation is creating more limitations than benefits. Failing to cooperate only aggravates existing policy confusion, stalling the development of commercial space activities. Prominent examples include satellite servicing operations and space traffic management, both of which hold significant economic value but cannot be fully developed without improved cooperation due to their need for shared norms and best practices, much in the same way civil aviation could not function effectively if states did not agree on norms and best practices for air traffic control or flight safety. As a global commons, if the goal is to take advantage fully of the economic value of near-Earth space, then unilateral national policies cannot replace international agreements. Current trends suggest that the number of space actors and their interests will increase over the coming years. Consequently, competition over the utilization of space will likely expand and intensify with more actors pursuing their interests and disagreements becoming more common. Current international space governance will not be able to handle the changing nature of space development. New governance, structured differently, is needed. Next Steps for Responsible Space Governance Space has unquestionably undergone some significant changes since the turn of the century and therefore, so has its threat landscape. Although space was once seen as a peaceful sanctuary for scientific purposes, it has become the new playing arena for great power competition between the U.S., Russia, and China. Besides the superpowers, there are now a greater number of nations and non-state actors partaking in space activities and the role of commercial actors in space is becoming more considerable by the day. Although the privatization of space has so-far proven to be primarily a Western phenomenon, nations around the world are beginning to adopt the public-private partnership model and will continue to follow suit. As such, since an increasingly democratized and more accessible space will inevitably bring with it more man-made threats and challenges to space sustainability, the current system of space governance will need to be strengthened to effectively deal with near-future challenges. The process of developing new rules of the road in space has been complicated by the rapid proliferation of space technology among novel actors. Throughout the Cold War era, when technology was in the hands of few states, reaching consensus on treaties was much easier due to a shared interest by the permanent members of the U.N. Security Council to control the spread of technology. Today, the same technologies that were in the hands of a select few are in the hands of dozens of countries. As such, there is less incentive to collaborate on amending or updating Cold War era provisions, which has led to gridlock in the international bodies originally established to advance global space governance. In the absence of multilateral consensus on managing space activities through intergovernmental organizations (IGOs), namely the U.N., and specialized international fora stemming from the U.N. (i.e. UNOOSA, UNCOPUOS, and the CD), non-state actors have played an increasingly influential role in the development of space law. Currently, the international space law regime gives legal authority to regulate and manage space activities to nation states, not international bodies, through Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty. International bodies—such as UNCOPUOS—play a critical role in establishing standards and facilitating coordination, but the licensing and enforcement of those standards is at the national level. Non-state actors' successful contributions to global space governance are directly correlated to the broader trend of a strained multilateral order where international norms, standards, and voluntary (or non-binding) agreements are preferred over legally binding treaties. The declining ability of IGOs to create widely accepted treaties and agreements that effectively manage space activities consequently means that non-space faring nations are losing what little access they already had to shaping space governance. Hence, it is no surprise that successful governance through the paragon of space law—legally binding and verifiable measures—has become impossible to achieve in the current international political climate. States today have shifted their attention to creating norms through voluntary, non-legal measures with the goal of achieving mutual understanding and reducing suspicion, competition, rivalry between states bypassing international legal bodies altogether. For space governance to continue being successful, states must think through modern challenges creatively and collaboratively—in the long-run, strictly bilateral agreements, national policies, and passive support on non-binding agreements will not be sufficient. It is important to note that ineffective and outdated multilateral treaties and agreements are not obstacles unique to global space governance alone, but rather, global governance and multilateralism more broadly.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L OCOs – AT StratCon Thumps

The plan costs pc – Strategic Concept proves – member states intentionally avoided defining OCOs – no consensus means the plan triggers a fight

Jensen 2022

Mikkel, Mikkel Storm, Institute for Strategy and War Studies, Royal Danish Defence College, Copenhagen, Denmark, “Five good reasons for NATO’s pragmatic approach to offensive cyberspace operations,” May 30, 2022 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14702436.2022.2080661

Unclassified information on the internal negotiations in NATO on OCOCs and the CyOC is not available, but it has probably been difficult to find common ground between the 29 members NATO had at the time. The elaborate wording used by the alliance to discuss the topic could indicate that OCOs were a controversial topic. While Denmark in 2018 pledged willing to provide “cyber weapons” and “offensive cyber effects” to NATO (Danish Ministry of Defence 2018), NATO has avoided these terms. Instead NATO have compromised on the rather ungainly term “sovereign cyber effects, provided voluntarily by Allies,” or SCEPVA (Goździewicz 2019).

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Disinformation

Republicans like disinformation – they retaliate to any attempts to curb it

Feinberg 22 [https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/disinformation-board-dhs-republican-anger-b2073419.html]//LP

A longstanding Department of Homeland Security effort to combat foreign disinformation has touched off outrage amount Republicans who say the department is assembling an Orwellian “ministry of truth,” but experts and former GOP insiders say the sturm-und-drang over the DHS program shows how much the Trump-era iteration of the Party of Lincoln has come to depend on lying as a political strategy and therefore fears not being able to count on their lies going unchallenged. Last week, Fox News reporters began pressing White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki about a news item, first reported by Politico, which stated that DHS was standing up a “disinformation governance board” to counter foreign disinformation and misinformation “related to homeland security,” led by ex-Wilson Center fellow Nina Jankowicz. Ms Jankowicz, who holds a master’s degree in Russian, Eurasian, and East European Studies from Georgetown University's School of Foreign Service, is a well-known expert who has studied the nexus between democracy and technology and how disinformation can undermine democracies, with a particular specialisation in Central and Eastern Europe. But the appointment of Ms Jankowicz to helm DHS’s anti-disinformation efforts touched off a a geyser of grievance among Republican officeholders and their conservative media allies, citing public statements she’d made describing the October 2020 New York Post reporting on a laptop thought to have belonged to Hunter Biden as a “Trump campaign product” and other statements perceived to be at odds with conservative media narratives regarding Mr Biden and Mr Trump. Though a 2 May fact sheet released by DHS laid out the department’s aims, including a focus on “disinformation that threatens the security of the American people, including disinformation spread by foreign states such as Russia, China, and Iran, or other adversaries such as transnational criminal organizations and human smuggling organizations,” Republicans were animated by the false belief that the Biden administration was establishing some manner of universal arbiter of what is true and what is not for political purposes. At a Wednesday hearing before the Senate Homeland Security and Government Affairs Committee, Senator Rand Paul appeared to believe the DHS board would be retroactively fact-checking news outlets, and asked Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas if the board would have deemed the infamous dossier on Donald Trump compiled by a former MI6 agent, Christopher Steele, to be “Russian disinformation”. After Mr Mayorkas explained the board’s function, to ensure "guardrails, definitions,” and “standards" meant to safeguard civil rights, privacy, and free speech, Mr Paul resumed his complaints. "Here's the problem: We can't even agree what disinformation is. You can't even agree that it was disinformation that the Russians fed information to the Steele dossier," Mr Paul noted. "If you can't agree to that, how are we ever going to come to an agreement on what is disinformation so you can police it on social media?" The Kentucky senator said the “greatest propagator of disinformation” in world history has been the US government, and accused Mr Mayorkas of having “no idea what disinformation is”. "You think the American people are so stupid they need you to tell them what the truth is? You can't even admit what the truth is with the Steele dossier. I don't trust government to figure out what the truth is," he said. And on Thursday, more than 170 Republican members of the House of Representatives signed on to a belligerent letter to Mr Mayorkas calling the board “problematic” and suggesting that “an organization charged with securing the homeland engaging in anything that could have an impact on speech” raises ethical concerns because, in their estimation, it “could be utilized as a political tool under the guise of security”. The Republican representatives added that the DHS efforts to combat disinformation would take away from the department’s “primary mission sets,” including securing the US border. But Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, a senior policy counsel at the American Immigration Council, said combatting disinformation is a necessary aspect of the department’s core border security mission. Mr Reichlin-Melnick said human traffickers and smuggling operations have long preyed upon vulnerable people looking to come to the US through a variety of disinformation streams, including social media and traditional media advertising. “This is a bipartisan issue that has been something that the Trump administration struggled with, the Obama administration struggled with, and now the Biden administration is struggling with. Many people arrive at the southern border with false ideas about what US border policy looks like. That's because — not surprisingly — people who are fleeing their home countries are not going on to Google and checking for relevant US laws and policy before they leave,” he said. “People often receive their information about US border policy through WhatsApp groups, through Facebook memes, and through TikToks and other forms of social media that is often incorrect — there is also disinformation that is pushed out by migrant smugglers who are trying to drum up demand for people to pay to leave their home countries and come to the United States”. He said a significant number of families who arrived at the US-Mexico border during 2018 and 2019 — at the height of the Trump administration’s “zero tolerance” policy that separated parents from their children upon arrival — “sincerely believed” then-president Donald Trump had “passed a law allowing any migrant families arriving at the border to be admitted into the United States”. “Of course, the idea that President Trump was a pro-migrant president is absurd on its face, but many people arrived to the border truly, honestly, believing that because they have been told so by smugglers,” he said. Yet the real-world consequences of foreign disinformation don’t seem to be an operative concern for many in conservative media. According to Media Matters for America — a liberal group which monitors conservative news outlets including Fox News – Fox mentioned the DHS plan more in more than 100 weekday segments over the last nine days, with prime time hosts such as Tucker Carlson describing the effort in bizarre terms such as calling it Mr Biden’s “Ministry of Truth”. Kayla Gogarty, a researcher with Media Matters, said GOP and conservative media outrage over Ms Jankowicz and the DHS board is part of a familiar pattern in which Fox programming and Republican politicians stoke anger over some “shiny object”. “It's a lot of that same fearmongering and misinformation that we see coming out of the right,” she explained. It's this one big ecosystem, with Fox News, pushing it out to their large swath of audiences”. Michael Steele, the former Maryland Lieutenant Governor and Republican National Committee chairman, told The Independent members of the Trump-era iteration of his party tend to show “a particular sensitivity about disinformation” because they themselves traffic in what he called “some of the most profoundly corrosive disinformation there is”. “When you hear someone like Ron Johnson talking about how we should be afraid for our liberty and our values? Yeah, we've been listening to you for the last few years and we are concerned — that's why this was created,” he said. Republicans in both the House and Senate have already vowed to block DHS from spending any funds on combatting disinformation if they take control of Congress next year. But Mr Steele said there’s a better way for members of his party to short-circuit the need for DHS to do anything about disinformation. “If you want it to go away, you don't need to cut the budget, you don't need to defund it — just stop lying,” he said. “It’s amazing to me, but this is how they twist the narrative, and they wrap it in the flag and liberty and values. And they're crapping on all of that”.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Disinformation

Republicans are actively working to stop programs like the Plan

Shabad 22 [Rebecca Shabad is a politics reporter for NBC News based in Washington https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/republican-lawmakers-push-bill-dismantle-new-dhs-disinformation-board-rcna28354]//LP

House Republican leaders are calling on Congress to pass legislation that would shut down a new Department of Homeland Security working group tasked with combatting disinformation and block federal funds from being used for similar activities. The Biden administration has come under fire since Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas recently announced the creation of the group, called the Disinformation Governance Board, because opponents argue its purpose is vague. In response to the backlash, DHS released a fact sheet last week about the group's goals, which it said are to protect "Americans' freedom of speech, civil rights, civil liberties, and privacy" in the department's disinformation work. Mayorkas said at a Senate hearing about his department's budget request last week that DHS has worked over the last decade to prevent disinformation from threatening the nation but that he thought there weren't enough safeguards to ensure that its work doesn't infringe on fundamental rights. "And so we put together a working group to ensure that the guide, guardrails, are in place, that we have clear definitions, that we have good policies and practices in place, to protect the very rights that also are our responsibility not to infringe upon," he said. House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., said Wednesday that the group, which he dubbed President Joe Biden's "ministry of truth," was an "un-American abuse of power," and he accused Democrats of aiming to use the group to "manipulate the facts and discredit the truth when it's inconvenient for their narrative." "It’s a scheme conjured up by Washington Democrats to grant themselves the authority to control free speech," McCarthy said at a news conference calling for the group's termination. "They fear Americans' having unfettered access to information because it will challenge the power that they want to have over people’s lives." McCarthy and other key GOP lawmakers claimed that the administration wants to exploit the office and manipulate information. They also accused the group's executive director, Nina Jankowicz, of previously spreading misinformation. Jankowicz was a disinformation fellow at the Wilson Center, a public policy think tank, where she studied the intersection of democracy and technology in Central and Eastern Europe. When her appointment was announced late last month, she tweeted that she would help shape the government's "counter-disinformation efforts" and said "a HUGE focus of our work, and indeed, one of the key reasons the Board was established, is to maintain the Dept’s commitment to protecting free speech, privacy, civil rights, & civil liberties." Rep. Lauren Boebert, R-Colo., who introduced the measure to dismantle the group, said Wednesday that "free speech is under attack here in America" and that it is part of the administration's efforts "to try to silence dissenting voices." "Misinformation has become a rallying cry for the left to discredit facts that are inconvenient to their liberal agenda," she said. "The Russia collusion hoax, Hunter Biden’s laptop, the Covid lab leak theory were all labeled misinformation by big tech until the truth finally prevailed." Boebert's bill has no chance of coming up for a vote in House, where Democrats have a majority. But Republicans could try to influence spending decisions, including discussions about defunding the group, in debate on the next government spending package. Separately, 20 state attorneys general sent a letter to Mayorkas last week threatening to take legal action against DHS over the board if it isn't disbanded. The GOP group wrote that “the existence of the Disinformation Governance Board will inevitably have a chilling effect on free speech” and that “the resulting damage to our political system and our culture will be incalculable.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L Disinformation

Republicans view anti-disinformation initiatives as censorship

Curi 22 [Maria Cristina Curi will be joining Bloomberg Law next week, reporting on cybersecurity and telecom, including the FCC. Curi was a trade reporter at Inside U.S. Trade, a subscription-fee-based daily online news service from Inside Washington Publishers. Before that, she was an intern at Politico. Curi has also interned at The Iowa Center for Public Affairs Journalism-IowaWatch.org and American Public Media Group. She was also a Politico Journalism Institute participant. https://about.bgov.com/news/republicans-call-disinformation-board-dangerous-censorship/]//LP

Republican lawmakers are blasting a new Department of Homeland Security disinformation board as the latest Democratic effort to censor opposing views. Ahead of the November midterm election, the Biden administration and Democratic lawmakers are looking to tackle disinformation — deliberately deceptive messaging — on issues including the pandemic, the 2020 election, and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas told a House panel Wednesday that the governance board would counter the threat of misinformation and disinformation for elections and homeland security. Misinformation covers any falsehood portrayed as true. “We are addressing all aspects of election security, given, of course, the midterm elections that are upon us, and the fundamental integrity of our democratic processes that is at stake,” Mayorkas told the House Homeland Security Committee. Republican lawmakers call the board an attack on conservative views and the First Amendment. “It can only be assumed that the sole purpose of this new Disinformation Governance Board will be to marshal the power of the federal government to censor conservative and dissenting speech,” Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) said in a statement. “This is dangerous and un-American. The board should be immediately dissolved.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link › L NATO – Domestic Focus t/o

Biden has to remain focused on domestic issues – American’s are no longer interested in defeating Russia

Doyle 7-2-22 - White House reporter for the Washington Examiner (Katherine, The Washington Examiner, “Public wants Biden to prioritize inflation over Russia: Poll”, July 1, 2022, )//RG

President Joe Biden vowed on Thursday that the United States would continue to back Ukraine for “as long as it takes” to stop Russia’s war, but the public is showing signs that its appetite for assistance has limits. Speaking at the close of the NATO meeting in Madrid, Biden said Americans should expect to pay record-high gas prices until Russia is defeated in Ukraine. “As long as it takes,” Biden said, "so that Russia cannot in fact defeat Ukraine and move beyond Ukraine.” “This is a critical, critical position for the world," he added. Over the course of six days of international summit meetings, the U.S. committed its largest military expansion in Europe since the end of the Cold War, and trans-Atlantic alliance members agreed to add two new formerly neutral Nordic countries to their ranks. But returning home to Washington, Biden confronts a stark political reality. Soaring inflation and gas prices are weighing on families wary of more intervention in overseas conflicts and want the president to focus on domestic issues over defeating Russia, according to a new poll shared first with the Washington Examiner. Conducted by YouGov for Concerned Veterans for America from June 23-29, the survey found that 38% of people believe Biden should prioritize the inflation crisis, compared to 8% who want the president to ensure Russia’s defeat in Ukraine. Forty-four percent are unhappy with Biden’s handling of the war.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › U › AT No PC

Biden has the PC with Dems – his constructive engagement and bipartisan overtures are boosting is ability to maintain dem unity

Yglesias 6/19

Matthew Yglesias is a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion. A co-founder of and former columnist for Vox, he writes the Slow Boring blog and newsletter, “Biden Is Delivering on His Bipartisan Promise” June 19, 2022 dmr

For all his many political struggles, President Joe Biden is quietly delivering on one of the central — and most implausible — promises of his campaign: restoring a sense of normalcy and bipartisanship to the legislative process. The latest example is an apparent bipartisan deal on gun regulation, which finally puts vague Republican rhetoric on school security and mental health into action while also embracing modest Democratic proposals on such matters as background checks and red-flag laws. The bill will probably not dramatically alter the level of gun violence in the US. But it should do some good, and re-establishes the idea that Congress can act in response to dramatic events. Before the gun deal, of course, Biden worked with Congress to deliver the kind of bipartisan infrastructure legislation that both his predecessors only talked about. There have also been many more obscure bills, ranging from legislation changing the regulation of ocean shipping to a major overhaul of the US Postal Service. Bipartisan science funding legislation has been languishing for months now, but that’s due to boring House-Senate disagreements that are being worked out by a conference committee — a process so old-school it had become basically forgotten in Washington. Progress is also being made on bipartisan bills about such thorny issues as Chinese investment in US companies and antitrust scrutiny of big technology companies. Much of this work is happening through a process I like to call the Secret Congress: Members quietly working together while allowing the political press to focus on Hunter Biden’s laptop, which books are in which school libraries, the latest Marjorie Taylor Greene tweet or any of the million other controversies that engage the body politic. The Secret Congress dynamic, of course, is one reason why it’s difficult for Biden to secure credit for delivering on this promise. During Barack Obama’s presidency, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell was open about the fact that he was reluctant for Republicans to engage constructively on any topic lest the passage of bills come to reflect positively on an incumbent president he hoped to defeat. Biden has a much lower public profile than his recent predecessors. And while his team has been constructively engaged on all these issues, it’s been a quiet form of engagement that aims to be helpful without hogging the spotlight or preventing the members themselves from owning the process. Conservative firebrands found plenty of (real and fake) controversies with which to fill the air and maintain a sense of combat even as they collaborated on policy. Meanwhile, quite apart from Biden’s efforts, there is the fact that Donald Trump’s presidency helped break down the doors of ideological dogmatism on the right. Republicans don’t talk about it much these days, but the Trump administration’s willingness — led by Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin — to work with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer on the CARES Act is the only reason the 2020 elections didn’t turn into a party-destroying landslide. A free-market approach that devastated consumer spending power and led to liquidated many businesses would have ruined the economy, ruined Trump’s political standing, and driven the GOP into the ground. Trump lack of ideological purity, and Democrats’ willingness to bargain in good faith, saved the economy and the Republican Party — and perhaps opened the doors to further rounds of creativity. Alas, Biden has not had nearly such good fortune with his economic management. The multiple inflationary shocks — first a fiscal stimulus that spent too much too quickly, then a central bank that was probably too slow to react, then a war in Ukraine that’s ravaged the supply side of the global economy — have wrecked Biden’s public standing. When a president is unpopular due to bad economic news, the public doesn’t give him credit for anything. And columnists of all stripes are wont to criticize an unpopular leader. But the fact remains that important elements of Biden’s agenda have succeeded, notably including a Russia policy that has secured strong bipartisan and even international support despite the economic cost. The cloak of unpopularity, meanwhile, makes it even easier for bipartisanship to continue. In his current state, Biden is not politically threatening to Republicans, so they have no reason to avoid collaborating on bills they happen to like. A new proposal from Republican senators Mitt Romney, Richard Burr and Steve Daines to consolidate and simplify various family support programs in a way that would cut poverty and reduce marriage penalties has earned some cautious praise from Democratic Senator Michael Bennet and could be the basis for more bipartisan work. At the end of the day, life as a legislator is more fun if you get to legislate. Sheer exhaustion with the tedium of obstruction has helped make Biden’s approach work.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › U › Will Pass – Industry Pressure

Industry pressure generates momentum – negotiators are aiming for this month

Meyer 7/1 [Theodoric Meyer is a national political reporter for The Washington Post and a co-author of the Early 202 newsletter. He joined The Post in 2021 from Politico, where he covered Washington's lobbying industry and the early months of the Biden administration. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/07/01/marjorie-dannenfelser-what-next-abortion-battles/]//LP

“Sen. McConnell is so beholden to PhRMA that he’s willing to help China, hurt American manufacturing, and screw over Americans with outrageously high Rx prices,” Justin Goodman, a Schumer spokesman, said in a tweet. USICA and a slimmed-down reconciliation bill are both Democratic priorities before the midterm elections. The trade measure received the support of 91 senators last year but was dropped from the competition bill this week because senators could not reach agreement with House Republicans and Democrats, two sources familiar with the negotiations who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe private negotiations tell The Early. The House's preferred trade provisions are expected to fall out as well, sources said. Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi have been working to speed up negotiations so they could hold a vote on a compromise bill in July as manufacturing industry pressure weighed on the negotiations. The microchip bill received the support of 18 Republican senators last year, and the car and technology industries are pressuring lawmakers to act quickly. Intel announced last week that it would put on hold a $20 billion microchip-manufacturing plant in Ohio unless Congress could reach an agreement.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › U › Will Pass – TOA

It will pass this month – aggressive behind the scenes negotiations

Ambrose 6/29 [Mitch manages AIP's science policy newsletters and resources. He previously was a fellow at the Science and Technology Policy Institute and worked for the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee. He received a B.S. in physics from the University of Minnesota. https://www.aip.org/fyi/2022/congress-searches-compromise-landmark-innovation-bill]//LP

Negotiations to reconcile the House’s America COMPETES Act of 2022 with the Senate’s U.S. Innovation and Competition Act (USICA) are in the final stretch, with Democratic leaders pushing to pass a compromise bill by the time Congress departs for its usual August break. The urgency stems from the dwindling time remaining to reach a deal before the November election diverts lawmakers’ attention and the current legislative session expires at the end of the year. The bills reflect broad bipartisan interest in improving U.S. capabilities in research and technology development relative to China and other competitor nations, and each includes $52 billion in direct funding for semiconductor R&D and manufacturing. However, the bills sharply diverge over matters such as how to shape a multiagency R&D push, how to build up regional R&D capacity, whether to expedite visas for technically skilled foreign citizens, and how to protect U.S.-funded research from exploitation by rival governments. Lawmakers also attached a host of provisions unrelated to science policy to each bill, opening up debates over far-flung matters such as trade and environmental policy. Any final bill will require the support of at least 10 Republican senators to avoid a filibuster, which gives the Senate additional leverage in the negotiations. Negotiators have been working behind closed doors since the 107-member conference committee tasked with reconciling the legislation held its first meeting in May. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) said earlier this month that they are “narrowing” the scope of the legislation in hope of reaching compromise, without indicating what they have dropped. She and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), a key proponent of the legislation, met with their Republican counterparts last week to discuss prospects for a final deal. “We expressed our belief that there is no reason that we should not pass this bill through Congress in July,” Pelosi and Schumer said in a statement. “Democrats have already made accommodations in the name of reaching an agreement, which we are optimistic can happen soon.” However, some Republicans reportedly prefer to revisit the legislation next year since they may gain control of Congress after the midterm elections. Nevertheless, any final bill would still require support from both parties and the Biden administration. The semiconductor funding has put lawmakers under particular pressure to complete the bill, with some leaders in the industry warning a delay could lead them to invest in other countries that have already moved ahead with incentives. President Biden has also made the case for quick action on the legislation, arguing it has measures that will help reduce supply chain disruptions that contribute to inflation. “Pass the damn bill and send it to me,” Biden said in May. “It’s going to help bring down prices, bring home jobs, and power America’s manufacturing comeback.” Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger testified at a March hearing on the case for semiconductor industry subsidies. (Image credit – Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee) The semiconductor money would fund programs authorized in the CHIPS for America Act, which Congress passed in early 2021. Of the total, $39 billion is for manufacturing incentives and most of the remainder is for R&D initiatives, with almost all the money channeled through the Commerce Department. Backers of the CHIPS Act have also advocated for Congress to create a tax credit specific to the semiconductor industry, but lawmakers appear to have abandoned the idea of attaching it to the compromise legislation to avoid complicating negotiations. The top Republican for tax policy in the House, Rep. Kevin Brady (R-TX), argued at the conference kickoff meeting that the legislation should not include tax provisions, especially any that favor a specific industry. Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX), a lead advocate of the semiconductor tax credit, told FYI that he and Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA) attempted to include it in the original legislation. “We were told [the credit] wasn't going to be feasible in the Senate when we passed the CHIPS Act, and so we opted for the emergency spending. But I still think in the long term it’s going to take a reliable source of support, and that probably means an investment tax credit, not just spending,” he said. Budget targets for science agencies up in the air While the semiconductor funding is among the most consequential aspects of the bills, their R&D policy sections would also set ambitious targets for ramping up selected federal science agency budgets. Actually meeting those targets would still require Congress to supply the funding through the annual appropriations process. Nearly three years ago, Schumer first floated a proposal to create a massive new directorate at the National Science Foundation to drive progress in vanguard technologies such as artificial intelligence and quantum computing, and he teamed up with Sen. Todd Young (R-IN) to advance the idea legislatively. Senators substantially revised the proposal as it progressed through the chamber, paring back its spending goals for NSF, carving out large roles for the Department of Energy and Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, and attaching a broad policy update for NASA. The bill the Senate ultimately passed, USICA, recommends Congress ramp up NSF’s annual budget from its current level of $8.8 billion to $21.3 billion over five years, with the technology directorate’s annual budget growing to $9.3 billion. It also recommends DOE and DARPA each receive about $17 billion above their base budget over the same period for complementary R&D on the technology areas funded by the new NSF directorate. Meanwhile, the House Science Committee disagreed with the Senate focus on technology development and advanced a distinct vision for the NSF directorate oriented around applying science to “societal challenges” such as climate change, social inequality, and cybersecurity. The committee also proposed Congress channel extra funds into existing programs across NSF, the DOE Office of Science, and the National Institute of Standards and Technology. And in a further break with the Senate, it opted not to loop NASA into the legislation. The committee ultimately produced bipartisan legislation that recommends Congress ramp up NSF’s annual budget to nearly $18 billion over five years, with the new directorate growing only to $3.4 billion. Over the same period it also recommends increasing the Office of Science budget from $7.5 billion to $11.1 billion and the NIST budget from about $1 billion to almost $1.8 billion. The committee has argued its proposals reflect a deeper understanding of the agencies’ strengths and have broader support from science organizations than the approach taken by USICA. But critics counter that the point of the Senate legislation is to prioritize select technologies, and Young has said he plans to stand firm on his vision for the NSF directorate. The House ultimately made the committee’s legislation a central plank of the COMPETES Act, which it passed in February on a party-line vote, with Republicans primarily objecting to provisions not arising from the Science Committee. Some senators have embraced aspects of the House’s vision, with leaders of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee introducing legislation for the DOE Office of Science that hews closely to the Science Committee proposals. However, it is unclear whether their proposals would displace the funding recommendations for DOE in USICA or add to them, or how much support they have among senators.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › U › Will Pass – TOA

His push means it passes

Galston 6/14

Wiliam, Wallstreet Journal, “How Good Bills Die in Committee” June 14, 2022

Noting that the Senate bill already represents a true bipartisan compromise, Mr. Young argues that it would be unreasonable to expect the final agreement to split the difference between the House and Senate versions. Instead, it should be much closer to the Senate bill. Mr. Schumer understands this, he said, as do Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo and the White House, but apparently Mrs. Pelosi does not. Mr. Young was candid about the trade provisions of the bill, a major sticking point. During Senate deliberations, he said, some Republican senators insisted on new trade language, and the ensuing disagreement was successfully resolved in negotiations between Senate Finance Committee Chairman Ron Wyden and Mike Crapo, the committee’s ranking Republican. This bipartisan agreement wasn’t acceptable to House Democrats, and the matter is being relitigated between Mr. Crapo and House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard Neal. Describing their positions as “principled disagreement,” Mr. Young is “concerned” that their differences might prove difficult to resolve soon. Consumer groups and app developers believe that the Wyden-Crapo trade provisions will undermine the Europe Union’s regulatory framework for digital trade. Mrs. Pelosi also appears to believe this. Mr. Wyden defends his language as a serious effort to fight authoritarian forces engaged in “digital censorship,” although he is open to refinements distinguishing between censorship and regulations addressing data privacy, antitrust enforcement, and antiharassment regulations. Mr. Young says the conferees should focus on resolving disagreements that can be successfully negotiated while setting aside intractable disputes for another day. He expressed optimism that provisions concerning the National Science Foundation, national-security innovation, domestic chip production, regional technology hubs, and workforce development for advanced production fall into the “resolvable” category. He believes the government’s credibility is on the line. “We have an opportunity to show that regular order can produce a broad bipartisan bill,” he says, but this is unlikely to happen, he added, unless President Biden pushes it across the goal line. In remarks on the America Competes Act last month, a frustrated president exclaimed, “Pass the damn bill and send it to me.” Unless he gets directly involved, this probably won’t happen, and America’s best chance in decades to boost domestic innovation and manufacturing could die in committee.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › U › Will Pass – TOA

Biden is pushing -- classified briefings are boosting momentum

Andrews 7/10

Natalie Andrews and Richard Rubin, Wall Street Journal, “Congress Juggles China Bill, Democrats’ Climate and Drug-Pricing Ambitions” July 10, 2022 https://www.wsj.com/articles/congress-juggles-china-bill-democrats-climate-and-drug-pricing-ambitions-11657458301

In recent weeks, several chip manufacturers have announced they would reconsider plans to build in the U.S. if Congress didn’t act soon. An all-senators classified briefing by Biden administration officials is planned for Wednesday to emphasize the national security implications, said several aides. Efforts are under way to put together a similar briefing for the House, said a person familiar with the matter. “Fundamentally we will not have the ability to protect ourselves as a nation if this bill is not passed,” Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo said in an interview, pointing to the U.S. dependency on Taiwan for semiconductors and overall supply-chain disruptions. Ms. Raimondo acknowledged Mr. McConnell has slowed down the process.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › U › Will Pass – TOA

It will pass it’s Biden’s top priority – McConnell’s threat is meaningless – staffers are continuing work on a compromise that will pass both houses

Wasson and Dennis 7/1 [Erik Wasson is a Correspondent for Congress in the Bloomberg News with 58 videos in the C-SPAN Video Library; the first appearance was a 2011 Roundtable as a Staff Writer for the Hill, The. The year with the highest average number of views per program was 2022 with an average of 489 views per program. Most appearances with Bill Scanlan (12), Steve Scully (8), Greta Brawner (7). Most common tags: Federal Budget, Coronavirus Disease 2019, U.S. Economy. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-01/semiconductor-funding-bill-likely-to-survive-mcconnell-threat]//LP

A $52 billion package of incentives and subsidies to bolster US semiconductor manufacturing is far from dead, despite Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell’s threat to scuttle the legislation containing it in order to stall passage of President Joe Biden’s economic plan. Democrats have multiple paths to get the chips money, which has broad bipartisan support, through Congress. McConnell stunned Democrats on Thursday by tweeting he would stand in the way of the wider China competition legislation of which the semiconductor provision is a part so long as Democrats plan to use the partisan budget process to ram through a separate package of tax increases on the wealthy and corporations, incentives for green energy, and prescription drug price limits. While the ploy is aimed at stopping the budget package, it comes as Republicans have also been pushing Democrats to abandon plans to add big-ticket spending items to the China bill, which has been the subject of closed door talks for months. Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo, in an interview with the Washington Post, called McConnell’s threat a mere “bump in the road” designed to increase his leverage in negotiations. “The only entity in the world that benefits from this bill not passing is China,” she said in the interview. Enactment of the semiconductor incentives is a top priority for the Biden administration as well as manufacturers such as Intel Corp. and companies that are heavy users of chips. While the global semiconductor shortage has eased somewhat, there is still limited production for certain chips used in cars and home appliances. The wrangling over the bill comes as semiconductor stocks took a beating, driven by concerns arose about demand cooling for chips as the US economy faces recession fears. McConnell made his threat as Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer and Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia, a key Democratic vote, were nearing a deal on the specifics of a $1 trillion budget and tax package. Republicans have largely rallied behind their Senate leader, including those who supported the competition and chips bill. The McConnell move is not without political and procedural risks. Democrats, including House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s spokesman Henry Connelly, attempted to frame the effort as being soft on China while standing in the way of prescription drug cuts. That message could blunt efforts of Republicans to present themselves in the midterms as both tough on Beijing and fighting to lower spiraling costs. Democrats could ignore McConnell’s threats, pass their economic package with a simple majority in August and then hold a potentially painful vote on a completed China bill just before the elections to hammer the issue home. At that point, with no chance to stall the economic plan, some Senate Republicans could peel off and vote for the bill. Eighteen Republicans, including McConnell, voted for the legislation when it passed the Senate in March. In a second scenario, if Schumer and Manchin’s talks fall apart as Build Back Better talks did in December, then all sides simply let the China bill move forward. Given this real possibility, Republican and Democratic staff are continuing to work on the details of the House and Senate China bills to try to make progress on a unified bill that could pass both chambers. The biggest differences remaining on the competition bill revolve around trade policy, according to people familiar with the situation. Democrats are trying to add payments to workers displaced by trade deals under a program called Trade Adjustment Assistance. There is also controversy over restrictions on investments by Americans and American companies in China, and a research and development tax provision. Democrats are widely seen walking away from an attempt to add immigration visa expansion and climate provisions to the bill after earlier dropping a marijuana banking provision. In a third scenario, Democrats can under Senate rules add the $52 billion chips bill to the budget bill if Schumer and Manchin agree to do so. Other aspects of the China legislation can be tweaked from so-called authorizations to appropriations to make them comply with Senate budget rules. Provisions related to Taiwan policy, outward-bound US investment, research security and federal procurement may not be allowed in the budget package, however. Finally, Democrats have a Senate-passed version of the China bill sitting in the House. They could simply pass it and send it to Biden without adding more spending. McConnell Tactics McConnell’s gambit of holding a bipartisan China competition package hostage while Democrats try and jam through a scaled-back economic plan isn’t the first time he’s used the lure of a bipartisan deal as leverage to try and slow or kill Biden’s larger agenda. A year ago, McConnell insisted that Democrats separate the bipartisan infrastructure plan from the larger Democratic “Build Back Better” effort. That increased tensions and confusion in the Democratic caucus. House liberals eventually caved on their insistence of simultaneously passing the infrastructure package alongside a massive Democratic plan, while negotiations with Manchin dragged on. Ultimately Democratic divisions, rather than any McConnell ploy, led to the collapse of the $2.2 trillion Build Back Better plan, but McConnell exacerbated Democratic infighting.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › 1nc

US tech leadership solves nuclear war

Kroenig & Gopalaswamy 18, *Associate Professor of Government and Foreign Service at Georgetown University and Deputy Director for Strategy in the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council **Associate Professor of Government and Foreign Service at Georgetown University and Deputy Director for Strategy in the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council (*Matthew Kroenig **Bharath Gopalaswamy, 11-12-2018, "Will disruptive technology cause nuclear war?," Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, )

Recently, analysts have argued that emerging technologies with military applications may undermine nuclear stability (see here, here, and here), but the logic of these arguments is debatable and overlooks a more straightforward reason why new technology might cause nuclear conflict: by upending the existing balance of power among nuclear-armed states. This latter concern is more probable and dangerous and demands an immediate policy response. For more than 70 years, the world has avoided major power conflict, and many attribute this era of peace to nuclear weapons. In situations of mutually assured destruction (MAD), neither side has an incentive to start a conflict because doing so will only result in its own annihilation. The key to this model of deterrence is the maintenance of secure second-strike capabilities—the ability to absorb an enemy nuclear attack and respond with a devastating counterattack. Recently analysts have begun to worry, however, that new strategic military technologies may make it possible for a state to conduct a successful first strike on an enemy. For example, Chinese colleagues have complained to me in Track II dialogues that the United States may decide to launch a sophisticated cyberattack against Chinese nuclear command and control, essentially turning off China’s nuclear forces. Then, Washington will follow up with a massive strike with conventional cruise and hypersonic missiles to destroy China’s nuclear weapons. Finally, if any Chinese forces happen to survive, the United States can simply mop up China’s ragged retaliatory strike with advanced missile defenses. China will be disarmed and US nuclear weapons will still be sitting on the shelf, untouched. If the United States, or any other state acquires such a first-strike capability, then the logic of MAD would be undermined. Washington may be tempted to launch a nuclear first strike. Or China may choose instead to use its nuclear weapons early in a conflict before they can be wiped out—the so-called “use ‘em or lose ‘em” problem. According to this logic, therefore, the appropriate policy response would be to ban outright or control any new weapon systems that might threaten second-strike capabilities. This way of thinking about new technology and stability, however, is open to question. Would any US president truly decide to launch a massive, bolt-out-of-the-blue nuclear attack because he or she thought s/he could get away with it? And why does it make sense for the country in the inferior position, in this case China, to intentionally start a nuclear war that it will almost certainly lose? More important, this conceptualization of how new technology affects stability is too narrow, focused exclusively on how new military technologies might be used against nuclear forces directly. Rather, we should think more broadly about how new technology might affect global politics, and, for this, it is helpful to turn to scholarly international relations theory. The dominant theory of the causes of war in the academy is the “bargaining model of war.” This theory identifies rapid shifts in the balance of power as a primary cause of conflict. International politics often presents states with conflicts that they can settle through peaceful bargaining, but when bargaining breaks down, war results. Shifts in the balance of power are problematic because they undermine effective bargaining. After all, why agree to a deal today if your bargaining position will be stronger tomorrow? And, a clear understanding of the military balance of power can contribute to peace. (Why start a war you are likely to lose?) But shifts in the balance of power muddy understandings of which states have the advantage. You may see where this is going. New technologies threaten to create potentially destabilizing shifts in the balance of power. For decades, stability in Europe and Asia has been supported by US military power. In recent years, however, the balance of power in Asia has begun to shift, as China has increased its military capabilities. Already, Beijing has become more assertive in the region, claiming contested territory in the South China Sea. And the results of Russia’s military modernization have been on full display in its ongoing intervention in Ukraine. Moreover, China may have the lead over the United States in emerging technologies that could be decisive for the future of military acquisitions and warfare, including 3D printing, hypersonic missiles, quantum computing, 5G wireless connectivity, and artificial intelligence (AI). And Russian President Vladimir Putin is building new unmanned vehicles while ominously declaring, “Whoever leads in AI will rule the world.” If China or Russia are able to incorporate new technologies into their militaries before the United States, then this could lead to the kind of rapid shift in the balance of power that often causes war. If Beijing believes emerging technologies provide it with a newfound, local military advantage over the United States, for example, it may be more willing than previously to initiate conflict over Taiwan. And if Putin thinks new tech has strengthened his hand, he may be more tempted to launch a Ukraine-style invasion of a NATO member. Either scenario could bring these nuclear powers into direct conflict with the United States, and once nuclear armed states are at war, there is an inherent risk of nuclear conflict through limited nuclear war strategies, nuclear brinkmanship, or simple accident or inadvertent escalation. This framing of the problem leads to a different set of policy implications. The concern is not simply technologies that threaten to undermine nuclear second-strike capabilities directly, but, rather, any technologies that can result in a meaningful shift in the broader balance of power. And the solution is not to preserve second-strike capabilities, but to preserve prevailing power balances more broadly. When it comes to new technology, this means that the United States should seek to maintain an innovation edge. Washington should also work with other states, including its nuclear-armed rivals, to develop a new set of arms control and nonproliferation agreements and export controls to deny these newer and potentially destabilizing technologies to potentially hostile states. These are no easy tasks, but the consequences of Washington losing the race for technological superiority to its autocratic challengers just might mean nuclear Armageddon.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › 1nc

Successful reconciliation quickly revitalizes competitiveness versus China

Augustine 3-1-2022, retired chairman & CEO of Lockheed Martin and former undersecretary of the Army (Norman, “America's competitive edge is shrinking — Congress can reverse the trend,” The Hill, )

Science and technology matter. Several studies, two of which led to Nobel prizes, have indicated that up to 85 percent of the growth in America’s GDP can be attributed to advancements in just two fields, science and technology. The United States cannot hope to compete with China, industrially or militarily, on a person-to-person basis given the latter’s four-times greater population. America’s competitiveness will depend on such assets as freedom, free enterprise, allies, innovativeness and prowess in science and technology. But in all-important basic research, America ranks 29th among nations in the fraction of R&D that is federally funded. In 2007, it was my privilege to lead a study of America’s competitiveness that was requested by Congress and overseen by the National Academies. Twenty individuals, university presidents, corporate CEOs, former and future presidential appointees and several Nobel Laureates performed the study. The 565-page document that was produced, known as the “Gathering Storm” report, concluded that America had moved onto a path that would lose the scientific leadership it had been building since the 1940s, and that this was largely due to the lack of investment in research and the failure of our nation’s primary and secondary public schools to produce a sufficient number of graduates qualified to pursue careers in science, engineering and mathematics. The most recent well-regarded international test of academic achievement of 15-year-olds placed the U.S. in 17th place in science and 37th in mathematics. China ranks number one in each, but only tests students in a few major cities. The qualifications and interest of America’s youth in pursuing careers in science and technology is suggested by the fraction of college students receiving their undergraduate degrees in, for example, engineering, wherein America ranks 76th worldwide — just behind Mozambique. Congress acted on the Gathering Storm report, enacting the America COMPETES Act of 2007. Subsequently, it legislated several bold plans to sustain U.S. leadership in science and technology, but it has, unfortunately, consistently failed to provide the funds needed to implement those plans. Ironically, China seems to have adopted many key parts of the plans and funded them. According to a new analysis by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, current annual federal expenditures on research (even with funding growth set merely at the rate of inflation in the years beyond those specifically addressed in the reports) are now $6.7 billion below where they would have been under the COMPETES Act of 2007 and $4.9 billion below where they would have been had the COMPETES Act of 2010 been funded. Had federal funding kept pace with China’s overall R&D growth rate during the period, the shortfall is $47 billion. It is, of course, not China that stipulates how much America invests in basic research (currently 0.2% of GDP — about what our citizenry spends on beer) or the quality of our public schools. As Pogo the Possum was prone to pronounce, “It is us.” Congress’s passage of the competitiveness legislation before it, along with the research investments it calls for, is essential if America is not to awaken one day in the not too distant future to find itself a formerly competitive nation.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › 1nc

It’s a heavy lift and requires pc – investing pc secures GOP support

Trubowitz 2021

Peter, LSE US Centre Director Professor, “Biden’s foreign policy will likely focus on rebuilding bridges with allies, pressing China, and ensuring international relationships benefit Americans again,” January 20, 2021

There are no magic bullets here, but there is much Biden can do. His campaign commitment to adopt federal “Buy American” policies to favor domestic producers is sensible and a political no-brainer. Investing in domestic priorities like infrastructure, education, and energy to create non-tradeable jobs and boost US competitiveness over the longer term is a heavier lift, politically. Still, some Republicans on Capitol Hill will find it in their political interests try to work with Biden on these efforts, especially if they are connected to recovering from the pandemic and making America more competitive vis a vis China. The more Biden invests intelligently here, the more it will ease anti-globalist pressures at home and strengthen US credibility as a reliable partner abroad. This is political capital well spent.