2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 1NC---Cyberwar Good
Jon Lindsay 15, Jon R. Lindsay is an assistant research scientist at the University of California Institute on Global Conflict and Cooperation and an assistant adjunct professor at the University of California, San Diego School of International Relations and Pacific Studies., Lindsay, Jon R. “The Impact of China on Cybersecurity: Fiction and Friction.” International Security, vol. 39, no. 3, Jan. 2015, pp. 7–47.
the downside of “informatization” China’s ambition to become a world-class military power will lead the PLA to become more like the U.S. military in its dependence on networks and space assets. This modernization will undermine the asymmetry of vulnerability thought to make cyberweapons so dangerous to the United States and instead put some of the PLA’s own most sophisticated systems at risk. PLA antiaccess capabilities against U.S. power projection also include antiship ballistic missiles, cruise missile boats, antisatellite weapons, and ªfth-generation aircraft. The PLA requires traditional forces, moreover, for other missions that might require warªghting, military operations other than war, or coercive diplomacy (a role ill-suited for secret and intangible cyberweapons). China’s goal of “winning local wars under the conditions of informatization” requires the PLA to “enhance [its] warªghting capabilities based on information systems.”94 This transformation into a modern “informatized” force, inspired in no small part by American RMA ideals and force structure, entails greater reliance on C4ISR systems and computer networks. Yet China’s pursuit of the promise of the RMA will also reveal its liabilities. In imagining and planning for a potential war with the United States, the PLA has to worry about the demonstrated ability and willingness of the U.S. military to conduct cyber operations on the battleªeld (in Iraq and Afghanistan) and in covert action (e.g., the Stuxnet attack). If cyberwarfare is as effective as Chinese writers believe it is but they underestimate the costs of mastery, then the PLA is doubly disadvantaged. Chinese attacks can be expected to be less skillfully coordinated against more robust U.S. defenses, and vice versa. The United States already has, while China still struggles to develop, the institutional complements and experience required to plan and control cyber operations in synchrony with the larger battle. Meanwhile the fear of cyberwarfare has prompted considerable U.S. military investment in network protection, active cyber defense measures (e.g., counterintelligence deception and “hack back” counterattack), and exercises in cyber-degraded conditions. The vaunted asymmetry of cyberwarfare, usually posed as an advantage for the weaker power, in fact runs in the opposite direction, giving the stronger and more experienced force the advantage.95 If the military utility of cyber- warfare is actually more limited than Chinese doctrine writers seem to believe, then conventional considerations about military effectiveness (e.g., the balance of power as well as skill in combined arms warfare and joint operations) should be expected to dominate strategic calculation and operational interaction in any conºict.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 1NC---Cyberwar Good
Yoo, 17—Emanuel S. Heller Professor of Law, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law (John, “Embracing the Machines: Rationalist War and New Weapons Technologies,” 105 Calif. L. Rev. 443 (2017), dml)
New weapons technologies can help overcome the obstacles of imperfect information. Coercive measures can signal political will, the value placed on the resources at stake, or military capabilities that could influence the outcome of a broader armed conflict. The more costly the signal, the more credible the information becomes. A nation's leader can make a threat of war and send military forces near disputed territory or a potential conflict zone. Deployment eats up resources that would go to waste if the nation is bluffing and incurs "audience costs" domestically if the leader backs down."' Escalating steps of force will provide the opportunity to send more precise signals that gradually consume more resources, reveal more military capability, and edge closer to war. With more avenues to credibly signal capabilities, there are more opportunities to reveal reliable, private information, and the likelihood of bluffing is reduced. While new weapons technology may produce more opportunities for violence, it can signal nations' capabilities and therey lead to peace settlements rather than war.
Limiting the ability to deploy new weapons technologies might make war more harmful. A ban could narrow the range of targets and the means of coercion to produce more destructive signaling and ultimately more lethal conflicts. One nation may want to send a signal during a crisis that inflicts a precise cost on its opponent. With a broader set of targets and more levels of harm, the nations can send more discrete signals in the bargaining process. If nations limit their signals to conventional attacks on military targets, they will have to employ more destructive levels of force. They might develop even more devastating kinetic weapons to produce the same effects as the precision offered by cyber or robotic weapons. Limits on new weapons technology might even destabilize crises by encouraging nations to use offensive weapons early in a crisis because they might themselves be vulnerable to attack. 15 4
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 1NC---Cyberwar Good
David Lonsdale 17, School of Law and Politics, University of Hull, Cottingham Road, Lonsdale, David J. “Warfighting for Cyber Deterrence: A Strategic and Moral Imperative.” Philosophy & Technology, Feb. 2017. CrossRef, doi:10.1007/s13347-017-0252-8.
3.4 The Failure of Cyber Deterrence? The potency of cyber deterrence is difficult to judge. This is partly because there exists no consensus on what constitutes an act of sufficient cyber aggression. Therefore, it is not entirely clear what is to be deterred. Where exactly the threshold for response should be will be discussed in section three of this paper. For now, we can state that low-level nuisance attacks are a daily occurrence. For example, U.S. military networks are probed and scanned millions of times each day (Work 2015, 1). Similarly, acts of cyber espionage are reasonably common. However, what is also evident is the lack of major cyber attacks. For a while, Stuxnet, Wiper, Shamoon and Bronze Soldier appeared to signal the rise of cyber attack as a potent new instrument of policy. However, medium to large-scale attacks have essentially dried-up. Indeed, reflecting the empirical evidence, and marking a shift in tone, in his September 2015 testimony to the Senate Armed Services Committee, Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, talked down the possibility of an ‘electronic Pearl Harbor’. Instead, he focused on ongoing ‘low-to-moderate’ level threats (Clapper 2015, 2). What does this all tell us? Is deterrence working? If one considers low-to-moderate threats as deterrable, then the answer would seem to be no. From this perspective, and according to some policy makers, deterrence is already failing. In a 2015 Senate Armed Services Committee Hearing, Chairman John McCain was scathing in his assessment: ‘Our adversaries view our response ... as timid and ineffectual. Put simply, the problem is a lack of deterrence. The administration has not demonstrated to our adversaries that the consequence of continued cyber attacks against us outweigh the benefit.’ (Takala 2015) However, if we take the view that cyber deterrence should really concern itself only with large-scale attacks, the picture is more positive. Indeed, Valeriano and Maness (2015) have identified considerable levels of restraint in state cyber behaviour. This could be due to a lack of confidence in the strategic utility of cyber attack. It may also reflect the development of norms against aggressive forms of cyber behaviour and the efficacy of deterrence. Indeed, norms increasingly form part of ‘complex deterrence’, within which military and non-military elements operate together. In cyberspace, although a settled understanding of universal rules of behaviour is still lacking, norms appear to be crystalising around acceptable forms of intrusion rather than a blanket non-use position (Stevens 2012, 25). This may explain the continuance of lowlevel probes whilst large attacks have trailed off.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 1NC---Conventional Deterrence Turn
Michael J. Mazarr et al 22, senior political scientist at the RAND Corporation. "Security Cooperation in a Strategic Competition" Research Report. //pipk
Security Cooperation Efforts in Europe Emphasize Reassuring U.S. Allies European partners have consistently received approximately 26 percent of all U.S. security aid, but there has been a shift since 2014 in the type of aid these partners have received. Specifically, more attention has been devoted to developing conventional capabilities to deter Russian aggression. Eastern European states that border Russia, particularly Ukraine, received $1.1 billion from 2014 to 2019.18 Georgia, Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia also received some funding through the European Deterrence Initiative. However, of the billions of dollars designated for the initiative, only a small portion supports building partner capacity. The initiative was designed primarily to support U.S. force presence, infrastructure, and exercises; as a result, DoD does not formally categorize European Deterrence Initiative funding as security aid.19
Over our period of study, U.S. military sales have increased for both highly capable allies and newer North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) partners in Europe. Among the top weapon purchasers, the United Kingdom, Italy, and Germany are purchasing advanced aircraft, unmanned aerial systems, and missiles through the FMS and DCS programs. Poland and Romania are acquiring Patriot air-defense systems, and Slovakia is purchasing F-16 aircraft through FMS.20
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Warming Impact
Samuel Miller-McDonald 19, PhD Candidate in Geography and the Environment at the University of Oxford, “Deathly Salvation”, The Trouble, 1/4/2019, https://www.the-trouble.com/content/2019/1/4/deathly-salvation
A devastating fact of climate collapse is that there may be a silver lining to the mushroom cloud. First, it should be noted that a nuclear exchange does not inevitably result in apocalyptic loss of life. Nuclear winter—the idea that firestorms would make the earth uninhabitable—is based on shaky science. There’s no reliable model that can determine how many megatons would decimate agriculture or make humans extinct. Nations have already detonated 2,476 nuclear devices.
An exchange that shuts down the global economy but stops short of human extinction may be the only blade realistically likely to cut the carbon knot we’re trapped within. It would decimate existing infrastructures, providing an opportunity to build new energy infrastructure and intervene in the current investments and subsidies keeping fossil fuels alive.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Warming Impact
Samuel Malm 20, Master’s Degree from Uppsala University, Disciplinary Domain of Humanities and Social Sciences, Faculty of Arts, Department of Philosophy, “Does Climate Change Justify a Global Epistocracy?”, Digitala Vetenskapliga Arkivet, 8/11/2020, https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2%3A1448606&dswid=8040
Climate change’s negative impact on humans is hardly something up for questioning. The World Health Organization believes that between 2030 and 2050 the effects of climate change will be an additional of 250 000 deaths every year; due to diarrhoea, malaria, heat stress and malnutrition.1 Accordingly, we can expect millions of deaths to occur, and the increased frequency of natural disasters will push the expected death toll even further. Additionally, the rising sea levels, and other environmental consequences, will cause an unprecedented flow of climate refugees towards areas that still are unaffected by the change. If we thought the impact was huge from the people fleeing the Syrian civil war, or the present corona pandemic, we should expect the climate disaster to be countless times larger. The pressure on societies and intergovernmental organisations will become tremendous, and we would be naïve if we did not expect this pressure to create additional suffering and death. What is then the cause of climate change? It is the result of anthropogenic acts, i.e., it is our current way of living that is causing the heating of the planet. Like a greenhouse, our planet is becoming hotter by the way that carbon dioxide traps more heat in the atmosphere, and by consequent increase the global average temperature. Additionally, it sets off other reactions that add positive feedback to the warming, e.g., creation of water vapour or the reduction of ice caps.
Now, this paper does not intend to demonstrate the truth of these claims, and if the reader is still sceptical about climate change, and its anthropogenic cause, numerous sources can justify and explain these facts better, for instance, rapports from IPCC. 2 Accordingly, I will assume these facts to be true, and that climate change will cause a state of affairs that contains a great deal of suffering and death; besides the possibility of civilisational destruction or human extinction. Thus, the circumstances are dire. So, let us summarise these detrimental effects into a single claim. Here it is:
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Warming Link
Dr. Chien-Yi Lu 21, PhD and MA in Government from the University of Texas, Austin, Visiting Scholar at Harvard University, Associate Research Fellow at the Institute of European and American Studies of Academia Sinica, Surviving Democracy: Mitigating Climate Change in a Neoliberalized World, Paperback Edition, 12/13/2021, p. 2-3 [language modified]
The doubt about the ability of democracy to handle climate challenges is palpable from the intellectual Left as well. Eric Hobsbawm offered a threefold explanation for his pessimism. To begin with, many of the strategies needed to avoid climate change would be extremely unpopular and therefore difficult to implement in a democracy. As a result, even as “the impact of human action on nature and the globe has become a force of geological proportions,” “no support will be found by counting votes” for measures required for mitigating these problems. Moreover, given that nature is border-blind, even if voters of some democratic states were sensible, the political mechanisms available to human kind in the 21th century are “effectively confined within the borders of nation-states” and “dramatically ill-suited” to deal with problems lying beyond their range of operation (2007: 113). Finally, democratic national governments are not the only relevant organizational entities that can have an effect on an increasingly globalized and transnational world. “A growing part of human life now occurs beyond the influence of voters, in transnational public and private entities that have no electorates, or at least no democratic ones.” Thus, “[d]emocracy, however desirable, is not an effective device for solving global or transnational problems”(2007: 118).
This wave of academic literature that questions the compatibility of democracy with timely and effective climate mitigation resonates with works dating back to the 1970s that focused on the role of democracy in environmental conservation. In An Inquiry into the Human Prospect, Heilbroner set to answer, in a world plagued by problems such as rapid environmental degradation, “is there hope for man?” Writing in 1974, he highlighted that:
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Warming Link
Dr. Chien-Yi Lu 21, PhD and MA in Government from the University of Texas, Austin, Visiting Scholar at Harvard University, Associate Research Fellow at the Institute of European and American Studies of Academia Sinica, Surviving Democracy: Mitigating Climate Change in a Neoliberalized World, Paperback Edition, 12/13/2021, p. 3-4
This pessimism stems from the unavoidable transition of capitalism from its expanding form to a stationary one under severe scarcity of resources, as “whether we are unable to sustain growth or unable to tolerate it…,it seems beyond dispute that the present orientation of society must change” (1980: 110, original emphasis). Social tensions will inevitably rise when scarcity-propelled stationary or even slow-growing capitalism renders infeasible the usual method of appeasing the lower and middle classes by further deepening the grab into the nature to improve their economic positions, leaving the diminishing of the incomes of the upper echelons of society the only option (1980: 102). Given the widespread belief that “centralized authority will cope with crisis and unrest more ‘successfully’ than less authoritarian structures” and the historic pattern in democracies where “the pressure of political movement in times of war, civil commotion, or general anxiety pushes in the direction of authority, not away from it,” (1980: 128–9, original emphasis) Heilbroner concluded that intolerable socioeconomic strains will eventually exceed the capabilities of representative democracy, leading governments of these societies to resort to authoritarian measures (1980: 106).
Similarly, Ophuls contended that under conditions of ecological scarcity, if individuals are allowed to pursue their self-interest “unrestrained by a common authority,” the result is bound to be “common environmental ruin” (1977: 151). Accordingly:
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Nigeria Impact
Dr. Bernard B. Fyanka 20, Ph.D. in History and Strategic Studies from the University of Lagos, Akoka Lagos Nigeria, "Chemical, Biological, Radiological and Nuclear (CBRN) Terrorism: Rethinking Nigeria’s Counterterrorism Strategy", African Security Review, Volume 28, Issue 3-4, 2/17/2020, Taylor & Francis Online
The end of the Cold War might have represented the end of mutually assured destruction (MAD), but it did not necessarily dispel the dangers of the nuclear age – in fact, to some extent the globalised proliferation of non-conventional weapons has instead escalated the possibilities for a nuclear attack being carried out. During the Cold War, the belligerents of any nuclear conflict would have been easily identifiable; however, in the post-Cold-War era, non-state actors and terrorist groups like Boko Haram have emerged as potential players in a new variety of nuclear conflicts that would entirely be based on terrorist models. The ominous possibilities for this new kind of warfare are indeed terrifying, and the rise in terrorist attacks around the globe enhances the likelihood of such an occurrence. Since 9/11, the body of academic literature on the threat posed by terrorists regarding weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) and chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear (CBRN) devices has increased. In Gary Ackerman and Jeremy Tamsett’s edited volume, Jihadists and Weapons of Mass Destruction, there is disagreement as to whether this threat is overestimated or underestimated.1 In recent times, however, ample ideological incentive for the use of CBRN devices has been provided by the likes of Abu Mus‘ab al-Suri – author of the ‘Global Islamic Resistance Call’ – who has stated that ‘[t]he aim of carrying out resistance missions and individual jihad terrorism “jihad al-irhabi al-fardi” is to inflict the largest human and material casualties possible on American interests and its allied countries’.2 This echoes the previous call of Grand Ayatollah Ahmad Husayni al-Baghdadi, who maintained:
If the objective and subjective conditions materialize, and there are soldiers, weapons, and money – even if this means using biological, chemical, and bacterial weapons – we will conquer the world, so that ‘There is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is His Prophet’ will be triumphant over the domes of Moscow, Washington, and Paris.3
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Nigeria Impact
Walter Mead 13, James Clarke Chace Professor of Foreign Affairs and Humanities at Bard College, “Peace in The Congo? Why the World Should Care”, The American Interest, 12/15/2013,
The problem is that these wars spread. They may start in places that we don’t care much about (most Americans didn’t give a rat’s patootie about whether Germany controlled the Sudetenland in 1938 or Danzig in 1939) but they tend to spread to places that we do care very much about. This can be because a revisionist great power like Germany in 1938-39 needs to overturn the balance of power in Europe to achieve its goals, or it can be because instability in a very remote place triggers problems in places that we care about very much. Out of Afghanistan in 2001 came both 9/11 and the waves of insurgency and instability that threaten to rip nuclear-armed Pakistan apart or with trigger wider conflict India. Out of the mess in Syria a witches’ brew of terrorism and religious conflict looks set to complicate the security of our allies in Europe and the Middle East and even the security of the oil supply on which the world economy so profoundly depends.
Africa, and the potential for upheaval there, is of more importance to American security than many people may understand. The line between Africa and the Middle East is a soft one. The weak states that straddle the southern approaches of the Sahara are ideal petri dishes for Al Qaeda type groups to form and attract local support. There are networks of funding and religious contact that give groups in these countries potential access to funds, fighters, training and weapons from the Middle East. A war in the eastern Congo might not directly trigger these other conflicts, but it helps to create the swirling underworld of arms trading, money transfers, illegal commerce and the rise of a generation of young men who become experienced fighters—and know no other way to make a living. It destabilizes the environment for neighboring states (like Uganda and Kenya) that play much more direct role in potential crises of greater concern to us.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Nigeria Link
Dr. Moses E. Ochonu 20, Cornelius Vanderbilt Chair in History and Professor of African History at Vanderbilt University, PhD and MA in African History from the University of Michigan, BA in History from Bayero University, Graduate Certificate in Conflict Management from Liscomb University, “Liberal Democracy Has Failed in Nigeria”, Africa Is a Country, 2/7/2020, [language modified]
Liberal democracy’s capstone ritual, zero-sum elections, endow winners with all the rewards of victory—millions of dollars in licit and illicit earnings, local and international political visibility, and power. The loser, conversely, gets nothing. The result is a high-stakes version of what is called FOMO, or the fear of missing out, in American popular lingo. This fear of political exclusion in turn catalyzes desperation, which consistently and predictably produces messy, violent, and compromised elections.
In addition, since its return to civilian rule in 1999, liberal democracy has been an unacceptably costly enterprise for Nigeria. In 2019, the country spent about $670 million on a general election widely condemned as a sham. With budget financing increasingly steeped in external and internal debt, and given the fungibility of state funds, there is a depressing possibility that Nigeria is borrowing to fund elections and to finance its fledgling democratic institutions and processes. It’s a hefty price tag in a country where most people subsist on less than $2 a day. When this financial outlay is added to Nigeria’s notoriety for having some of the highest paid legislators in the world and for spending the national fortune to maintain a large army of elected and appointed civilian officials, the unsustainability of this “democratic” trajectory emerges in full relief.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Nigeria Link
Dr. Aloysius-Michaels Okolie 21, Professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Nigeria, PhD in Political Science and MSc from the University of Nigeria, et al., “Does Liberal Democracy Promote Economic Development? Interrogating Electoral Cost and Development Trade-Off in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic”, Cogent Social Sciences, Volume 7, Issue 1, 4/28/2021, Taylor & Francis Online
The hitches and abnormalities characterising Nigeria’s electoral democracy are, no doubt, intrinsically linked to the institutionalised two-tenure renewable system. This tenure system was externally supported by the purveyors of liberal democracy and domesticated by the local accomplices solely for self-interest. In Nigeria, the winner-takes-all mentality as well as the high stakes usually associated with political offices heightens electoral contestations among the competing, polarised and distrusted ethnic nationalities who perceive political power as a means of advancing their peculiar economic interests. The struggle is usually intensified when it is obvious that access to state power guarantees an unfettered gateway to huge petro-dollar revenue. Indeed, the incumbent’s penchant for re-election often reinforces the tendency for divisiveness, violence, rancour and instability. For instance, the re-election bid of the then President Goodluck Jonathan in 2015 accounted for the deaths of 106 people while the election-related conflict in 2011 led to the deaths of 800 people and the displacement of 65,000 (Birch & Muchlinski, 2018; Harwood, 2019). The two-tenure system affects governance and policy responses since incumbent officials seeking re-election often devote a substantial part of their time and energy in politicking and grandstanding for a favourable outcome. This manifested in the 2015 and 2019 re-elections of Goodluck Jonathan and Muhammadu Buhari, respectively, in Nigeria when both leaders abandoned their jobs for campaigns. Also, given the monetised and winner-takes-all approach of Nigerian politics, incumbent candidates ruthlessly divert public funds for re-election campaigns. It drains the national treasury and redirects public expenditure to campaign funding rather than to human and capital development. A classic example is the ongoing investigation into the Office of the National Security Adviser which, at the interim, has revealed that the sum of 2.1 USD billion appropriated for procurement of military equipments was diverted and used to prosecute the 2015 general elections for the Peoples Democratic Party.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Causes War---Democracy
Dr. Daina Chiba 21, Associate Professor of Political Science in the Department of Government and Public Administration at the University of Macau, Ph.D. in Political Science from Rice University, LL.M in Jurisprudence and International Relations from Hitotsubashi University, and Dr. Erik Gartzke, Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, PhD in Political Science from the University of Iowa, “Make Two Democracies and Call Me in the Morning: Endogenous Regime Type and the Democratic Peace”, 2/19/2021, https://dainachiba.github.io/research/make2dem/Make2Dem.pdf
Before we review our approach in detail, it may be useful to explain why this type of analysis has not been pursued successfully in the past and what makes our effort different from other, broadly related projects. We are not the first to apply an IV framework (more specifically) or multi-equation models (more broadly) to the democratic peace. However, previous attempts suffer from two major problems. First, previous studies have typically used a dyad (country pair) as the unit of observation in analyzing conflict, which requires some summary measure(s) of democracy for a pair of countries rather than the state-level (monadic) democracy measure. 6 Use of a dyadic aggregate to represent regime type creates a discrepancy between the first stage regression (predicting democracy at the country level) and the outcome stage regression (predicting conflict at the dyad level). 7 We avoid this problem by using the directed dyad as the unit of observation in predicting conflict, distinguishing between the potential challenger and target in a dispute. This allows us to connect the first stage equations (predicting the challenger’s and target’s regime types) and the outcome stage equation seamlessly. Doing so has several benefits: the outcome stage model could directly include country-level covariates (such as challenger’s and target’s democracy) without having to convert them to a dyadic summary. This also allows us to estimate the system of equations jointly rather than relying on the “forbidden regression.” 8
Second, a more daunting challenge in applying an IV approach to democratic peace research is the difficulty of finding a plausible instrument for regime type — a variable that is strongly correlated with regime type but is unrelated to war. This is the challenge that has plagued empirical researchers in many fields. For example, a recent study of the effect of regime type on economic growth uses a diffusion-based measure of democracy (i.e., average value of democracies in a given region) as an instrument for democracy (Acemoglu et al. 2019). However, diffusion-based instruments such as this are unlikely to be a valid instrument, due to spatial spill-over, interdependence, and, most importantly, simultaneity (Betz, Cook, and Hollenbach 2018). Recognizing problems with spatial instruments, McDonald (2015) seeks to exploit the very discrepancy between country-level and dyad-level designs as the source of identification. His discussion, however, lacks a clear explanation as to why some determinants of regime type do not influence conflict. 9
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Causes War---Democracy
Dr. Daina Chiba 21, Associate Professor of Political Science in the Department of Government and Public Administration at the University of Macau, Ph.D. in Political Science from Rice University, LL.M in Jurisprudence and International Relations from Hitotsubashi University, and Dr. Erik Gartzke, Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, PhD in Political Science from the University of Iowa, “Make Two Democracies and Call Me in the Morning: Endogenous Regime Type and the Democratic Peace”, 2/19/2021, https://dainachiba.github.io/research/make2dem/Make2Dem.pdf
We now turn to the results from the outcome stage, where militarized conflict initiation is regressed on democracy measures and other covariates. The univariate clog-log model 32 that ignores the endogeneity, shown in column (1) in Table 1, successfully replicates the standard, dyadic democratic peace finding that democracies are peaceful, though only toward other democracies. Note that, while individual democracy measures have either a positive or insignificant coefficient, joint democracy has a negative coefficient that overwhelms the positive coefficients of individual democracy measures in the univariate model. As a result, the univariate model produces a result that, while democracy may increase conflict against a non-democracy, it decreases conflict against a democracy.
To illustrate this, we calculate the average treatment effect of joint democracy for the challenger and for the target based on the univariate model. These effects are calculated by comparing the predicted probabilities of conflict initiation when changing the regime type of self (challenger or target) from non-democracy to democracy, holding constant the regime type of the other (target or challenger) as democracy. 33 Gray, hollow circles in Figure 4 show the treatment effects of challenger’s and target’s democracy. We can see that both effects are negative and statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 1NC---Democracy Bad
Dr. Stuart Parker 20, Philosopher and Former Teacher who Lectured on Philosophy and Education at London's Institute of Education, South Bank University, Author of Reflective Teaching in the Postmodern World, “The Problem With Democracy — It's You”, The Article, 10/5/2020, https://www.thearticle.com/the-problem-with-democracy-its-you
So why is our democracy so unfit for purpose? Why is it that we can elect leaders who are little more than self-serving schemers, whose contempt for the electorate renders them incapable of giving straight, honest answers to even the most straightforward, reasonable questions? It’s not as if any of these qualities have been smuggled in under our noses. They are paraded before our eyes every single day. Nobody voting for Johnson or Trump could be blind to the fact [ignore] that they are serial liars. And yet they voted all the same. Why?
***
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 1NC---Democracy Bad
Dr. Chien-Yi Lu 21, PhD and MA in Government from the University of Texas, Austin, Visiting Scholar at Harvard University, Associate Research Fellow at the Institute of European and American Studies of Academia Sinica, Surviving Democracy: Mitigating Climate Change in a Neoliberalized World, Paperback Edition, 12/13/2021, p. 1-2
The fact that the scientific knowledge on the human contribution to climate change entered human society through the most advanced democratic societies should have been a cause for celebration. Given the congruence of climate mitigation and public interests, the problem of climate change should have been considered solved decades ago. Several decades of inaction later, however, arguments are proliferating that democracy is exactly the reason for inaction.
In The Collapse of Western Civilization, historians Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway travel to the future to look back and offer a forensic analysis on the climate-induced Great Collapse of Western Civilization of 2074 (2014: 63). The future historians’ forensic report states that “[a]s the devastating effects of the Great Collapse began to appear, the nation-states with democratic governments… were at first unwilling and then unable” to deal with the crisis. These democratic governments realized that they had no “infrastructure and organizational ability to quarantine and relocate people” as “food shortages and disease outbreaks spread and sea level[s] rose.” In China, where there was centralized government, the crisis was handled much more adequately, leading to survival rates exceeding 80%, a development that “vindicated the necessity of centralized government” (2014: 51–2). The gist of The Collapse of Western Civilization is not about critiquing democracy per se but a warning against the stubborn inaction mandated by market fundamentalism that has hijacked Western democracies.1 In their previous book, Merchants of Doubt, Oreskes and Conway documented the way that climate deniers sowed the seeds of doubt about climate change and successfully staved off implementations of mitigation measures. For the authors, the anticommunist ideology that had kept actors vigilant about government encroachment in the marketplace occupied a central place in climate denial (2014: 69). Ironically, this sort of ideology-informed calculation meant that preventative action was blocked, increasing the risk that disruptive climate disasters would eventually necessitate the suspension of democracy and legitimating the sort of heavy-handed authoritarian interventions that the conservatives most abhorred (2014: 52; 69).
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 1NC---Democracy Bad
Charles A. Ray 21, Member of the Board of Trustees and Chair of the Africa Program at the Foreign Policy Research Institute, Former U.S. Ambassador to the Kingdom of Cambodia and the Republic of Zimbabwe, “Does Africa Matter to the United States?”, Foreign Policy Research Institute, 1/11/2021, https://www.fpri.org/article/2021/01/does-africa-matter-to-the-united-states/
Africa matters in terms of size, population, and rate of population growth. It is the continent currently most affected by climate change but is also a continent that can have a devastating impact on climate change globally because of the importance of the Congo Basin rainforest, which is the second-largest absorber of heat after the Amazon rainforest. The destruction of this important ecosystem could further accelerate global warming. As residents of the region come into increasing contact with the animals of the rainforest, this region could be the origin of the world’s next viral pandemic. Violent extremism and terrorism are increasing in Africa, and while now mostly localized, the danger has the potential to spread beyond the continent. Crises—natural and man-made—cause massive relocations of populations, both on the continent and abroad, which can have negative economic, social, and political impacts.
Why Africa Matters
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 1NC---Democracy Bad
Dr. Moses E. Ochonu 19, Cornelius Vanderbilt Chair in History and Professor of African History at Vanderbilt University, PhD and MA in African History from the University of Michigan, BA in History from Bayero University, Graduate Certificate in Conflict Management from Liscomb University, “Why Liberal Democracy is a Threat to Nigeria’s Stability”, Logos: A Journal of Modern Society & Culture, May 2019, http://logosjournal.com/2019/liberal-democracy-is-a-threat-to-nigerias-stability/
In 2015, Nigeria, a country of about 190 million, spent $625 million to conduct federal and local elections. By comparison, India, with a population of 1.2 billion, spent $600 million on its 2015 election, according to figures released by the Electoral Commission of India (ECI).[1]
In 2019, the election budget of Nigeria’s Independent Electoral Commission (INEC) rose to $670 million. This represents about 2.5 percent of Nigeria’s $28.8 billion budget for 2019, a portion of which is being financed through borrowing. To put the electoral spending in context, more than half of the country subsists on about a dollar a day, and the country recently acquired the dubious distinction of being named the poverty capital of the world, with more people living in extreme poverty there than in any other country.[2] Key infrastructures and services such as roads, railway, electricity, water supply, healthcare, and education are severely inadequate, requiring urgent investments and interventions.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 1NC---Democracy Bad
Dr. Daina Chiba 21, Associate Professor of Political Science in the Department of Government and Public Administration at the University of Macau, Ph.D. in Political Science from Rice University, LL.M in Jurisprudence and International Relations from Hitotsubashi University, and Dr. Erik Gartzke, Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, PhD in Political Science from the University of Iowa, “Make Two Democracies and Call Me in the Morning: Endogenous Regime Type and the Democratic Peace”, 2/19/2021, https://dainachiba.github.io/research/make2dem/Make2Dem.pdf
The democratic peace—the observation that democracies are less likely to fight each other than are other pairings of states—is one of the most widely acknowledged empirical regularities in international relations. Prominent scholars have even characterized the relationship as an empirical law (Levy 1988; Gleditsch 1992). The discovery of a special peace in liberal dyads stimulated enormous scholarly debate and led to, or reinforced, a number of policy initiatives by various governments and international organizations. Although a broad consensus has emerged among researchers regarding the empirical correlation between joint democracy and peace, disagreement remains as to its logical foundations. Numerous theories have been proposed to account for how democracy produces peace, if only dyadically (e.g., Russett 1993; Rummel 1996; Doyle 1997; Schultz 2001).
At the same time, peace appears likely to foster or maintain democracy (Thompson 1996; James, Solberg, andWolfson 1999). A vast swath of research in political science and economics proposes explanations for the origins of liberal government involving variables such as economic development (Lipset 1959; Burkhart and Lewis-Beck 1994; Przeworski et al. 2000; Acemoglu and Robinson 2006; Epstein et al. 2006) and inequality (Boix 2003), political interests (Downs 1957; Bueno de Mesquita et al. 2003), power hierarchies (Moore 1966; Lake 2009), third party inducements (Pevehouse 2005) or impositions (Peceny 1995; Meernik 1996), geography (Gleditsch 2002b), and natural resource endowments (Ross 2001), to list just a few examples. Each of these putative causes of democracy is also associated with various explanations for international conflict. Indeed, some as yet poorly defined set of canonical factors may contribute both to democracy and to peace, making it look as if the two variables are directly related, even if possibly they are not.
2022
Michigan
Negative
Neg---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Regulation Fails
Harriet Moynihan 21, Acting Director of the International Law Programme at Chatham House, MA with Honors from the Trinity Hall, University of Cambridge, and Marjorie Buchser, Executive Director of the Digital Society Initiative, MA in Comparative and International Studies from the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich (ETHZ), MA in Political and Social Sciences from the Université of Lausanne, “Can Global Technology Governance Anticipate the Future?”, Chatham House Expert Comment, 4/27/2021, https://www.chathamhouse.org/2021/04/can-global-technology-governance-anticipate-future
Technology governance is beset by the challenges of how regulation can keep pace with rapid digital transformation, how governments can regulate in a context of deep knowledge asymmetry, and how policymakers can address the transnational nature of technology.
Keeping pace with, much less understanding, the implications of digital platforms and artificial intelligence for societies is increasingly challenging as technology becomes more sophisticated and yet more ubiquitous.