Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › I/L– Sustainable Ag

Food insecurity causes extinction

John Castellaw 17, Teaching Fellow at the College of Business and Global Affairs at the University of Tennessee, on the National Security Advisory Council of the U.S. Global Leadership Coalition, former Chief of Staff for the U.S. Central Command, Lieutenant General, Marine Corps (Ret.), 5/1/2017, “Opinion: Food Security Strategy Is Essential to Our National Security”, https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/9203-opinion-food-security-strategy-is-essential-to-our-national-security

The United States faces many threats to our National Security. These threats include continuing wars with extremist elements such as ISIS and potential wars with rogue state North Korea or regional nuclear power Iran. The heated economic and diplomatic competition with Russia and a surging China could spiral out of control. Concurrently, we face threats to our future security posed by growing civil strife, famine, and refugee and migration challenges which create incubators for extremist and anti-American government factions. Our response cannot be one dimensional but instead must be a nuanced and comprehensive National Security Strategy combining all elements of National Power including a Food Security Strategy. An American Food Security Strategy is an imperative factor in reducing the multiple threats impacting our National wellbeing. Recent history has shown that reliable food supplies and stable prices produce more stable and secure countries. Conversely, food insecurity, particularly in poorer countries, can lead to instability, unrest, and violence. Food insecurity drives mass migration around the world from the Middle East, to Africa, to Southeast Asia, destabilizing neighboring populations, generating conflicts, and threatening our own security by disrupting our economic, military, and diplomatic relationships. Food system shocks from extreme food-price volatility can be correlated with protests and riots. Food price related protests toppled governments in Haiti and Madagascar in 2007 and 2008. In 2010 and in 2011, food prices and grievances related to food policy were one of the major drivers of the Arab Spring uprisings. Repeatedly, history has taught us that a strong agricultural sector is an unquestionable requirement for inclusive and sustainable growth, broad-based development progress, and long-term stability. The impact can be remarkable and far reaching. Rising income, in addition to reducing the opportunities for an upsurge in extremism, leads to changes in diet, producing demand for more diverse and nutritious foods provided, in many cases, from American farmers and ranchers. Emerging markets currently purchase 20 percent of U.S. agriculture exports and that figure is expected to grow as populations boom. Moving early to ensure stability in strategically significant regions requires long term planning and a disciplined, thoughtful strategy. To combat current threats and work to prevent future ones, our national leadership must employ the entire spectrum of our power including diplomatic, economic, and cultural elements. The best means to prevent future chaos and the resulting instability is positive engagement addressing the causes of instability before it occurs. This is not rocket science. We know where the instability is most likely to occur. The world population will grow by 2.5 billion people by 2050. Unfortunately, this massive population boom is projected to occur primarily in the most fragile and food insecure countries. This alarming math is not just about total numbers. Projections show that the greatest increase is in the age groups most vulnerable to extremism. There are currently 200 million people in Africa between the ages of 15 and 24, with that number expected to double in the next 30 years. Already, 60% of the unemployed in Africa are young people. Too often these situations deteriorate into shooting wars requiring the deployment of our military forces. We should be continually mindful that the price we pay for committing military forces is measured in our most precious national resource, the blood of those who serve. For those who live in rural America, this has a disproportionate impact. Fully 40% of those who serve in our military come from the farms, ranches, and non-urban communities that make up only 16% of our population. Actions taken now to increase agricultural sector jobs can provide economic opportunity and stability for those unemployed youths while helping to feed people. A recent report by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs identifies agriculture development as the core essential for providing greater food security, economic growth, and population well-being. Our active support for food security, including agriculture development, has helped stabilize key regions over the past 60 years. A robust food security strategy, as a part of our overall security strategy, can mitigate the growth of terrorism, build important relationships, and support continued American economic and agricultural prosperity while materially contributing to our Nation’s and the world’s security.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › I/L– Sustainable Ag

A need for massive expansion of ag is coming --- by 2050 we will run out of food if we don’t find new strategies for sustainable farming

Elferink et al ‘16

(Maarten Elferink is the founder and Managing Director of Vosbor, an Amsterdam based commodity service and solutions provider dedicated to sustainability, originating soft commodities and derivative products selectively in Eastern Europe and the FSU for distribution in the Asia-Pacific region, Florian Schierhorn is a post-doctoral researcher at the Leibniz Institute of Agricultural Development in Transition Economies in Halle, Germany and was selected for participation in the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting on Economic Sciences in 2014. His overall research relates to the question of how to meet global food security without increasing pressure on land, “Global Demand for Food Is Rising. Can We Meet It?,” pg online @ //um-ef)

Over the last century, the global population has quadrupled. In 1915, there were 1.8 billion people in the world. Today, according to the most recent estimate by the UN, there are 7.3 billion people — and we may reach 9.7 billion by 2050. This growth, along with rising incomes in developing countries (which cause dietary changes such as eating more protein and meat) are driving up global food demand. Food demand is expected to increase anywhere between 59% to 98% by 2050. This will shape agricultural markets in ways we have not seen before. Farmers worldwide will need to increase crop production, either by increasing the amount of agricultural land to grow crops or by enhancing productivity on existing agricultural lands through fertilizer and irrigation and adopting new methods like precision farming. However, the ecological and social trade-offs of clearing more land for agriculture are often high, particularly in the tropics. And right now, crop yields — the amount of crops harvested per unit of land cultivated — are growing too slowly to meet the forecasted demand for food. Many other factors, from climate change to urbanization to a lack of investment, will also make it challenging to produce enough food. There is strong academic consensus that climate change–driven water scarcity, rising global temperatures, and extreme weather will have severe long-term effects on crop yields. These are expected to impact many major agricultural regions, especially those close to the Equator. For example, the Brazilian state of Mato Grosso, one of the most important agricultural regions worldwide, may face an 18% to 23% reduction in soy and corn output by 2050, due to climate change. The Midwestern U.S. and Eastern Australia — two other globally important regions — may also see a substantial decline in agricultural output due to extreme heat. Yet some places are expected to (initially) benefit from climate change. Countries stretching over northern latitudes — mainly China, Canada, and Russia — are forecasted to experience longer and warmer growing seasons in certain areas. Russia, which is already a major grain exporter, has huge untapped production potential because of large crop yield gaps (the difference between current and potential yields under current conditions) and widespread abandoned farmland (more than 40 million hectares, an area larger than Germany) following the dissolution of the Soviet Union, in 1991. The country arguably has the most agricultural opportunity in the world, but institutional reform and significant investments in agriculture and rural infrastructure will be needed to realize it. Advanced logistics, transportation, storage, and processing are also crucial for making sure that food goes from where it grows in abundance to where it doesn’t. This is where soft commodity trading companies, such as Cargill, Louis Dreyfus, or COFCO, come in. While Big Food companies such as General Mills or Unilever have tremendous global influence on what people eat, trading companies have a much greater impact on food security, because they source and distribute our staple foods and the ingredients used by Big Food, from rice, wheat, corn, and sugar to soybean and oil palm. They also store periodically produced grains and oilseeds so that they can be consumed all year, and they process soft commodities so that they can be used further down the value chain. For example, wheat needs to be milled into flour to produce bread or noodles, and soybeans must be crushed to produce oil or feed for livestock. Nonetheless, even if some regions increase their output and traders reduce the mismatch between supply and demand, doubling food production by 2050 will undeniably be a major challenge. Businesses and governments will have to work together to increase productivity, encourage innovation, and improve integration in supply chains toward a sustainable global food balance. First and foremost, farmers, trading companies, and other processing groups (Big Food in particular) need to commit to deforestation-free supply chains. Deforestation causes rapid and irreversible losses of biodiversity, is the second largest source of carbon dioxide emissions after fossil fuels, and has contributed greatly to global warming—adding to the negative pressure on agriculture production for which these forests were cleared in the first place. Farmers must also grow more on the land they currently operate through what is called “sustainable intensification.” This means using precision farming tools, such as GPS fertilizer dispersion, advanced irrigation systems, and environmentally optimized crop rotations. These methods can help produce more crops, especially in parts of Africa, Latin America, and Eastern Europe with large yield gaps. They can also reduce the negative environmental impacts from over-stressing resources–preventing groundwater depletion and the destruction of fertile lands through over-use of fertilizer. The agricultural sector also needs significant long-term private investment and public spending. Many large institutional investors, including pension funds and sovereign wealth funds, have already made major commitments to support global agricultural production and trading in recent years—not least because agricultural (land) investments have historically delivered strong returns, increased diversification, and outpaced inflation. Still, investment in agriculture in most developing countries has declined over the last 30 years and much less is spent on R&D compared to developed countries—resulting in low productivity and stagnant production. And because banking sectors in developing countries give fewer loans to farmers (compared to the share of agriculture in GDP), investments by both farmers and large corporations are still limited. To attract more financing and investment in agriculture, the risks need to be reduced by governments. Regulators need to overhaul policies that limit inclusion of small, rural farmers into the financial system— for example, soft loans (i.e., lending that is more generous than market lending) and interest rate caps discourage bank lending. More supportive policies, laws, and public spending on infrastructure would help create a favorable investment climate for agriculture.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › I/L– Sustainable Ag

Biotech can create more sustainable, efficient, and productive agriculture

Chatterjee 21 (Jayanta Chatterjee, “Developing More Sustainable Global Food Systems Through Agroecology and Biotechnology”, US Department of State, September 30th 2021, , WC-NAS

Agroecological systems are meant to be highly diverse and biotechnology can help keep them diverse.  All breeding techniques depend on diversity, embracing the range of traits found in plants and beyond to develop robust, tasty crops needed to feed our families.  Sometimes these traits already exist in the same or related species and need just a little selective breeding to have the new trait(s) incorporated in that crop, as has been done for , since we invented agriculture.  In other cases, traits need to be shared between two unrelated (sexually incompatible) species, which is accomplished by genetic modification, both naturally or through engineering.  In fact, all plant species naturally have  to survive and thrive on dry land.  Modern biotechnology is helping diversify our diets and adapt to changing conditions.  Purple tomatoes that contain more antioxidants than blueberries, more nutritious and less pungent , a mustard variety with  with great health benefits and  are just a few examples worth noting. 

Agroecology depends on context-specific knowledge.  Co-creation and sharing of knowledge have been essential to our understanding of the biology of living organisms and their interactions at the molecular level.  Research in molecular biology and its application in the form of biotechnology can help to scientifically validate and improve upon immensely powerful traditional and indigenous knowledge while protecting vulnerable ecosystems and promoting biodiversity.  Unfortunately, ideological arguments and unfounded fears often jeopardize scientists’ ability to verify the efficacy, ensure the safety, and demonstrate the benefits of biotechnology.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › I/L– Carbon neutrality and sustainability

Biotechnology is critical to long-term carbon neutrality and short-term sustainability measures

USDA 22 (U.S Department of Agriculture, “Biotechnology and Climate Change”, February 22nd 2022, , WC-NAS

Agricultural biotechnology can be an important tool for addressing the causes and consequences of  and for achieving important societal goals such as reduced poverty, improved global food security, and reduced environmental impacts from agriculture. That’s why agricultural biotechnology is part of USDA’s toolkit for a healthy planet and sustainable future.

Causes and impacts of climate change

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Global warming causes extinction

Krosofsky 21 (Andrew Krosofsky, “How Global Warming May Eventually Lead to Global Extinction”, Green Matters, March 11th 2021, https://www.greenmatters.com/p/will-global-warming-cause-extinction , WC-NAS)

Life on this planet has gone through many extinction-level events over time. Most of these phenomena were caused by natural, cataclysmic forces beyond the control of any of the lifeforms existing at that time. The current cataclysmic forces anything but natural and they are well within our control. The question is not, "?"— it’s, "how can we prevent that inevitability from happening?"

Will global warming cause extinction?

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

A cohesive framework that recognizes the agricultural and environmental benefits of biotech is key to overcome status quo regulations

Zilberman and Wessler 22 (David Zilberman and Justus Wessler, David Zilberman is an agricultrual economist and Robinson Chair at the University of California Berkeley, Justus Wessler is a professor and head of Agricultural Economics at Wageningen University, “The Role of Policy in Supporting a Globally Diverse Bio-economy That Mitigates Climate Change and Food Insecurity”, American Enterprise Institute, January 3rd 2022, , WC-NAS)

Perhaps the most significant cost of the extensive regulation of agricultural biotechnology is that it has prevented researchers from taking advantage of new biotechnology tools. As a result, the development of auspicious traits of crops and livestock hasn’t materialized. For example, researchers have identified mechanisms to improve the shelf life of crops and enhance animal feed’s digestibility to reduce methane emissions, but they have not yet been adopted. In addition, scientists have identified means for nitrogen fixation and accelerating photosynthesis, further increasing yields and reducing costs and GHG emissions. Unfortunately, there has been underinvestment in developing faster-growing trees or other organisms that sequester carbon because of the low likelihood of application due to regulation. Other examples include developing biopolymers to substitute fossil fuel–based solutions and using genetically modified microorganisms for producing enzymes that more efficiently convert a wide range of biological resources to food, feed, and bio-based materials.8

One avenue to increase the contribution of agriculture to address the challenges ahead is to streamline and harmonize biotechnology regulation to allow researchers and innovators to take advantage of its potential increasing scale and scope of solutions. Studies have shown that harmonization of approval processes can substantially reduce approval costs for new technologies and increase the incentives for investment in biological control agents.9 The National Academy of Sciences has shown that modern biotechnologies are not posing additional environmental health risks compared to traditional agricultural foods.10 On the contrary, they can increase crop yields; reduce land, inorganic fertilizer, and pesticide use; and reduce GHG emissions. With enabling regulation, we expect that both the public and private sectors will expand investment in developing these technologies and, most importantly, using them.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Enhanced diplomatic credibility solves every transnational risk

Burns 20, Goodman Family professor of the practice of diplomacy and international relations, is chair of the Harvard Kennedy School’s Program on Transatlantic Relations, director of the Future of Diplomacy Project, and a co-leader of the American Secretaries of State Project (Nicholas, “The Indispensable Power,” Harvard Magazine, https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2020/07/features-forum-indispensable-power)//BB

DIPLOMACY has never been so important as now, when we are confronting the most serious crises since the Second World War: the global pandemic and economic collapse. When we emerge finally from the grip of the coronavirus, Americans will need to account for a public-health disaster that has killed well over 100,000 people to date and shuttered nearly every institution in our society (including Harvard) for much of the spring and into the summer. But we’ll also need to look beyond our borders to assess what went wrong globally. Why did the World Health Organization—its long and continuing record of expertise in matters of global health notwithstanding—not press China more aggressively to tell the truth about the virus in early January? How should nations be better prepared for a possible second wave? Can they agree to share a vaccine equitably among the world’s 7.7 billion people? Will the major economies collaborate to prevent the current recession from turning into another Great Depression? The answer to these questions will depend in large measure on our ability to work diplomatically across the world in this multi-front struggle. As a former career Foreign Service officer, I have spent four decades of my professional life representing the United States overseas and teaching about America’s role as the indispensable power in the international arena. For much of that time, the nation leaned heavily on its unmatched military might—during the Cold War, after 9/11, and in the Afghan and Iraq wars. Now, with the spread of the coronavirus to every inhabited continent, diplomacy’s time has come in the reconstruction of a more stable and better world. Unfortunately, restoring the role of U.S. diplomacy won’t be easy. One early casualty of the pandemic is our plummeting credibility as the unmatched global power. For the first time since World War II, America has chosen not to lead in confronting a quintessentially global threat. With American energy and confidence in short supply, President Donald Trump is a spectral figure on the world stage as nations struggle to contain the virus. Instead of leading the G-20 major economies against the contagion, the world has watched an American president castigate China for birthing the “Wuhan Virus,” pin the blame for the failed response on the World Health Organization, and—as one of my European students lamented—fail even to offer a simple word of sympathy in all those endless news conferences to those dying in Italy and Spain and other bedrock allies. Former Secretary of State Colin Powell has long maintained that America should place its diplomats out in front (“on point” in the military vernacular), with the armed forces in reserve, to be used only when diplomacy fails. Powell’s dictum is an important reminder of how the United States should seek to lead in this time of pandemic, for the coronavirus is only one of many among a new type of threat that requires us to lead as much through the power of diplomacy as through that of the military. Many of the students I teach point to transnational threats that affect every nation and person on earth as our greatest challenges: climate change, food and water shortages, narcotics and crime cartels, the lack of cyber security, and pandemics top the list. We cannot succeed in containing them without forming diplomatic alliances among governments, universities, foundations, businesses, and citizens. This new brand of diplomacy is not an alternative to the military but its logical partner in the twenty-first century American arsenal. The military remains essential to fight terrorists, and to counter rivals Russia and China and outlaw governments in North Korea and Iran, but even in these cases we have to have robust diplomacy to achieve our aims. Even if we deployed the full might of the U.S. military to eliminate the North Korean and Iranian nuclear programs, and the regimes that support them, does anyone believe that would, by itself, “solve” the problem? Even in those cases, deft, multilateral diplomacy will have to play a lead role—as recent experience has shown. We can no longer default to force alone, as we have done so often since 9/11. A Foreign Service for 2030 AMERICA’S DIPLOMATIC EFFECTIVENESS rests, in large part, on the women and men of the U.S. Foreign Service—more than 11,000 career officials in more than 280 embassies and consulates and at the State Department in Washington, D.C. They are our primary interface with foreign governments, businesses, and citizens. They adjudicate immigrant and non-immigrant visas and refugee admissions to the United States. They help American businesses overcome barriers to foreign trade and investment. They manage difficult war and peace challenges in every corner of the world—from daily challenges to the most intricate, strategic matters vital to our national security and prosperity. Diplomatic collaboration also underpins our ability to advance the more positive scientific, technological, and societal trends that can sustain the historic alleviation of poverty worldwide, promote women’s rights, and realize the promise of a carbon-free economy. Just when we need to turn to diplomacy, however, the Foreign Service is experiencing one of the greatest crises in its long history. Some of the damage has been caused by prior Democratic as well as Republican administrations. The United States is the only major country that fills a third or more of its ambassadorial assignments with political appointees, often poorly qualified, from outside the career ranks—often depriving the country of the advantages it could secure with expert, professional, nonpartisan diplomatic representation around the world. That mistake has only accelerated, with the current administration appointing the lowest percentage of career ambassadors in more than half a century. Former generals and admirals have been appointed to ambassadorships that would otherwise be filled—as they should be—by civilian officers. The politicization and militarization of our foreign policy by both parties is a genuine problem. More broadly, the Foreign Service has been substantially weakened and is in need of major repair. Even as the Trump administration’s budget requests for the Department of Defense rose from $686 billion to as high as $718 billion during its first two years, it sought to slash the State Department’s budget by up to a third. The administration fired several of America’s most senior and experienced diplomats early in 2017 and sidelined countless others, triggering an exodus of officers of every rank. The president himself has castigated career diplomats as the “Deep State.” Unsurprisingly, morale has crashed and young Americans’ applications for the Foreign Service have fallen to just under 10,000 from a high of 31,000 in 2003—a worrisome indicator that our nation’s ability to attract superb diplomatic talent is being eroded. Re-Imagining American Diplomacy THE KENNEDY SCHOOL launched an ambitious, nonpartisan initiative this winter—A New American Diplomacy for the 21st Century—to address these concerns and spark a national conversation about the future of the Foreign Service. I am working with former Foreign Service colleagues, Ambassadors Nancy McEldowney, Marc Grossman, and Marcie Ries, to issue a major public report after the November presidential election. We have organized online meetings with hundreds of current and former officials, business and nonprofit leaders, and everyday citizens to discuss ways to strengthen the career service. American diplomacy needs a major generational update. Since 9/11, Congress and three administrations have reformed the U.S. military and intelligence services and created the Department of Homeland Security. But collectively, they did little to re-imagine diplomacy’s role in the American arsenal. During the last century, there have been just three efforts to modernize the U.S. diplomatic corps: in 1924, 1946, and 1980 (when Congress passed the last major State Department Authorization Act). In our vastly altered geo-strategic environment, 40 years later, it is time to renew the mission of the Foreign Service. Barack Obama, Benjamin Netanyahu, and Mahmoud Abbas, September 22, 2009, at the Waldorf Astoria, New York City Photograph by John Angelillo-Pool/Getty Images We can mine America’s long diplomatic history for inspiration. Drawing on my own experience, I recall, as a young intern at the U.S. embassy in Mauritania, seeing first-hand the respect and influence President Jimmy Carter earned as the first U.S. leader to make Africa a priority. A decade later, when I served at the National Security Council with responsibility for the Soviet Union, I witnessed President George H.W. Bush negotiate the peaceful end of the Cold War and Bill Clinton consolidate the triumph of democracy over communism. President George W. Bush launched the bipartisan PEPFAR initiative to help in the fight against HIV/AIDs, polio, malaria, and other deadly diseases in Africa, the Caribbean, and elsewhere (a useful precedent when thinking about what it will really take to combat the coronavirus, not only in the developed nations, but in those with far fewer economic and healthcare resources). It was on 9/11, however, as U.S. ambassador to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, that I learned one of the most powerful lessons about diplomacy. Just a few hours after Al Qaida terrorists attacked the World Trade Center and Pentagon, my phone started to ring at NATO headquarters outside Brussels. My Canadian colleague, David Wright, called first—followed by the ambassadors of the United Kingdom, France, Poland, Germany, Italy, and many others. Each asked, “What can we do to help?” Those were very welcome words on the single darkest day in recent American history. By the next morning, invoking Article 5 of the 1949 NATO Treaty for the first time in history, all of the NATO-allied countries came to the rescue of the United States—lending mighty political and diplomatic support to the military response that would come later. Our allies considered Osama Bin Laden’s attacks on New York and Washington as an attack on them as well. Their militaries all went into Afghanistan with us (the majority remain 19 years later—and they and other partner nations have suffered more than 1,000 combat deaths; we owe them a lot). Contrary to such evidence, the current president believes the United States is strongest when it acts alone—unburdened of allies and partners whom he views as relics of our Cold War past. I lived the history of 9/11 and draw a very different lesson about the value of allies to the United States. Why would we want to live alone in a troubled and dangerous world, without the benefit of friends and allies by our side? Our NATO allies, as well as Japan, South Korea, and Australia, act as multipliers of American power in the world. They provide a lifeline of military, economic, and political support when we often need it most. They represent the great power differential between the United States and our rivals Russia and China, who can count on no such allies when the chips are down. As we recover from two decades of war and COVID-19’s assault on our society and economy, we will need to look at our global role in a new way. The era when America could run the world by fiat has vanished. We are still the strongest economic, military, and technological power—but China, India, and others are gaining on us. We can no longer overpower our adversaries in every crisis. And although we will need to call on the military to defend us in the future, we will more often than not need to outwit and outmaneuver adversaries through the strength of our diplomats and our alliances—not to mention mustering support for those broader, nonmilitary crises we now face, from pandemics to climate change.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Only opening communication on biotech increase’s NATO’s soft power which increases its global diplomatic ability

Cansu Gulec, 2021 “NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century.” MEF University Of Political Science And International Relations, Faculty Member and Underwriter at Anadolu Sigorta, Perceptions (Ankara, Turkey), vol. 26, no. 1, Balgat: Center for Strategic Research, pp. 100–20//AL

The term “public diplomacy” contains the word “diplomacy.” As an instrument of statecraft, diplomacy has long been used as a tool by states in their relations with other states. Although it does not have a commonly agreed-upon definition, diplomacy is generally considered to be the conduct and management of relations, through peaceful means, by and among international actors. The major international actors are states, and diplomacy mainly involves relations among states or between states, international organizations and other international actors. Today, diplomacy continues to be conducted mainly by states, but also includes international and regional organizations, multinational corporations, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and even individuals. Since the number and types of actors involved in international affairs have expanded, and the interaction among these actors has increased, the agenda and conduct of diplomacy has evolved in line with these developments. The expansion of intergovernmental and regional organizations does not mean the weakening of diplomacy, but rather a shift from traditional state diplomacy to new forms. Especially in today’s world, international and regional organizations generally compete for better visibility, and they consider their image, identity and brand important. As a collective defense and security organization, NATO has defined itself as the security branch of an institution of liberal-democratic norms and values, and has embraced the main principles of the Western world since its foundation in April 1949. Nonetheless, after the end of the Cold War and the disappearance of the Soviet threat, there emerged deep disagreements about the future role of the Alliance. In today’s global information environment, it is apparent that NATO needs to strengthen its communication tools and approaches, consider public audiences and develop its agenda setting according to the current communication challenges and opportunities. Accordingly, the main purpose of this paper is to understand and interpret the evolution of NATO’s public diplomacy efforts, taking into account the opportunities and limitations of today’s globalized environment. Public diplomacy is based on the ability of states and non-state actors to better explain their values to the world. It concentrates particularly on “soft power” tools such as science, art, culture, sports and media that enable interaction between societies. As an organization widely associated with security and defense issues, it is important to understand how NATO responds to the developments of today’s diplomatic As an organization widely associated with security and defense issues, it is important to understand how NATO responds to the developments of today’s diplomatic trends with its public diplomacy and communication activities. Cansu GÜLEÇ 102 trends with its public diplomacy and communication activities. Since technology has changed and evolved, NATO’s communication strategies must adjust to new types of networks and platforms. Having recently celebrated its 70th anniversary, and now in its 72nd year of existence, the Alliance is seeking to develop a contemporary communication policy and to implement it by means of new mechanisms. In this framework, this paper will first present a working definition of the concept of public diplomacy; next, the historical evolution of NATO’s public diplomacy agenda will be evaluated. Then, NATO’s coordination activities, its values, its practical means of communication and their expected impact will be discussed. The aim of this study is to explore the effects of the opportunities and challenges of the contemporary international environment on NATO’s public diplomacy efforts. Definition and Evolution of Public Diplomacy Diplomacy is derived from a Greek word diploma that means an official document or state paper. The Oxford dictionary defines diplomacy as “management of a country’s affairs by its agents abroad and the activity of managing relations between different countries.”1 As a key process of communication and negotiation in world politics and an important policy device used by international actors, the term diplomacy has been given a number of definitions in International Relations discipline. While some definitions associate diplomacy with the activity of engaging in foreign policy, others use the term to refer to a tool or technique of foreign policy. Accordingly, the term is therefore described as “a foreign policy instrument for establishing and developing peaceful relations between the governments of the various states through the use of intermediaries mutually recognized by the respective parties.” 2 As one of the oldest instruments of world politics, diplomacy is seen as an art, specifically the art of managing relations among sovereign actors. Originally, diplomacy was considered an instrument used by states in order to deal with other states. After the establishment of international and regional organizations, these entities too became involved in diplomatic practices. It can be stated that communication is the focus of diplomacy in managing relations among different international actors. In order to create effective communication mechanisms among different players, diplomacy is supported by an established body of rules and practices.3 Since diplomacy is based on the conduct of relationships using peaceful means, these rules and practices should be implemented by governments and other international actors alike. In practice, diplomacy aims to create a favorable image of the global actor. Modern communication, in that sense, functions to shape views and perceptions around the world. NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century 103 In contemporary global environment, although states and governments remain the main actors within the international system, the number and variety of actors, from governments to regional and intergovernmental organizations, multinational corporations and NGOs, have been rapidly expanding. In tandem, the domain and scope of the diplomacy have expanded to involve different sectors that expand beyond traditional high foreign policy issues. Globalization with its the complex web of interdependence has increased the range of negotiations, especially in multilateral meetings.4 Under these circumstances, diplomatic activities require the use of diplomatic tools to directly influence the people of nations as well. In that respect, public diplomacy can be regarded as one of the efficient means of diplomacy in use today. Thanks to this tool, relations between states and global actors progress more peacefully, with inclusion of public opinion alongside that of official representatives. The term ‘public diplomacy’ was first coined in 1965 by Edmund Gullion. According to Gullion, public diplomacy is concerned with the influence of social viewpoints have on the formulation and implementation of foreign policy.5 Indeed, the rise of the concept of public diplomacy is best understood in terms of its relationship with soft power. As mentioned above, with the increase in numbers and types of actors, with the expansion of the subject matter or content of diplomacy, and with the change in the modes, types, and techniques of diplomacy, a new terminology of Public Diplomacy as the language of prestige and international image has brought the concepts like soft power and branding to the nation states’ agenda.6 In IR discipline, power is generally defined as the ability to affect others to obtain desired outcomes. According to Joseph Nye, others’ behavior can be affected in three main ways: threats of coercion; inducements and payments; and attraction that makes others want what you want.7 While discussing the concept, Nye puts a distinction between hard power and soft power.8 The former is achieved through military threat or use, and by economic menace or reward. However, in the 21st century, under the influence of technological developments and globalization, international politics is also changing, and a state cannot address its problems or achieve all of its goals by acting alone. In this environment, it is important to set the agenda and attract others in world politics, as it is not always feasible or desirable to force them to change by means of threats or the use of military or economic weapons. In that sense, ‘soft power’ co-opts people rather than coerces them. Nye coined the ‘soft power’ as “the ability of affect others to obtain the outcomes one wants through attraction rather than coercion or payment.”9 While military force remains the fundamental form of power in international system, abilities like communication, organizational and institutional skills, have also become important instruments in today’s global environment of growing interdependence.10 Diplomacy is a crucial instrument enabling allies to cooperate, and adversaries to resolve conflicts without Cansu GÜLEÇ 104 using force. International actors communicate, influence one another, bargain and adapt their differences through diplomacy. As a key process of communication and negotiation, diplomacy is used as a significant policy instrument by global actors. Today, diplomacy takes place between actors with a wide range of authority, power, tools and impact. A country’s soft power capacity has a crucial role in the success of an actor’s public diplomacy as much as efficacy of its policies; indeed, a country’s political values, culture and foreign policies are important indicators of its soft power.11 Credibility is the significant source of soft power. Since reputation has become one of the main objectives of today’s global actors, they make efforts to increase their credibility around the world. States compete with other states, and also with other actors including media, NGOs, international organizations and other networks in the quest to gain and maintain credibility.12 Public diplomacy is about relationship building. It is about understanding the requirements of other countries, cultures and people; communicating one’s perspectives; correcting misperceptions; and searching areas of common ground.13 Nye defines public diplomacy as an instrument that governments use to mobilize these resources to communicate with and attract the public of other countries, rather than only their governments. Public diplomacy seeks to attract by bringing attention to potential areas of commonality, interest and attraction through broadcasting, supporting cultural initiatives and organizing exchanges.14 The main distinction between traditional and public diplomacy is that the latter involves a much broader group of people on both sides, and a wider set of interests that go beyond those of the government of the day.15 Listening, advocacy, cultural diplomacy, exchange, and international broadcasting are five components of public diplomacy.16 Understanding, planning and engagement are also very important concepts for the establishment of powerful relationships. In the 20th century, public diplomacy was considered a state-based tool used by foreign ministries and other governmental entities to engage and persuade foreign publics with the aim of influencing their governments. Today, public diplomacy has become an instrument used by states, associations of states, and some sub-state and non-state actors to understand cultures, attitudes and behavior; to build and manage relationships; and to influence thoughts and mobilize actions to advance their interests and values.17 A country’s soft power capacity has a crucial role in the success of an actor’s public diplomacy as much as efficacy of its policies; indeed, a country’s political values, culture and foreign policies are important indicators of its soft power. NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century 105 Public diplomacy is a process of creating an overall international image that strengthens a country’s ability in order to achieve diplomatic success. This is also important for “propaganda.” Propaganda is an attempt to influence another country through emotional techniques rather than minds by creating fear, doubt, sympathy, anger or other feelings. In order to change or influence other actors’ opinions, actions or policies, propaganda also operates by means of symbols, such as words, gestures, banners, monuments, music, clothing, etc. Propaganda acquired negative connotations in the 20th century, although it was an effective tool of foreign policy during the First and Second World Wars, as well as the Cold War. During these times, propaganda was associated with manipulating populations at home and abroad.18 Unlike public diplomacy, propaganda is generally not interested in dialogue or any meaningful form of relationship-building.19 The main objective of the propaganda is to influence opinion and behavior of its targeted audience. Although both public diplomacy and propaganda intend to convince people to create a favorable image, the distinction between propaganda and public diplomacy lies in the pattern of communication. In that respect, public diplomacy goes beyond propaganda. It is comprised of what is actually said and done by political figures, as well as practices of promotion and other forms of public relations that are utilized by the business sector.20 In other words, public diplomacy, like propaganda, is about creating influence. However, unlike propaganda, that influence is not a one-way street from the speakers to their target audience. Public diplomacy is perceived as a two-way street with a process of mutual influence, in which the foreign public is seen as an active participant.21 In that sense, the objective of public diplomacy is not propaganda, but building a strategic language of communication based on objective facts and truth. Nye asserts that if public diplomacy degenerates into propaganda, it not only fails to convince, but can undercut soft power. Since soft power depends upon an understanding of the minds of others, an efficient public diplomacy is regarded as a two-way street.22 After the end of the Second World War in 1945, a new type of conflict emerged between the U.S. and the Soviet Union, known as the Cold War. The Cold War was based on a contest of ideologies that divided the world into a bipolar competition characterized by a war of words and the threatened use of nuclear weapons, rather than their actual use. In that era, the idea of nuclear war was ever-present in the minds of the international public. U.S.-Soviet relations became the main global, political agenda, and the erection of the Berlin Wall in 1961 became the symbol of a world separated by the “Iron Curtain.”23 Moreover, in both the U.S. and the Soviet Union, and in their alliance blocs of NATO and the Warsaw Pact, the objective was to convince people that fear of the enemy was genuine, legitimate and justified. This, in turn, would legitimate and justify the need to sustain a Cansu GÜLEÇ 106 nuclear arsenal that would have to be at least equal to that of the other side, although there might never be a use for it. This climate of fear was also played out in the media. Propaganda exploited these fears, and the ‘other side’ had always to be portrayed as aggressive, militaristic and repressive.24 In other words, during the Cold War period, propaganda had a special importance in the foreign policy objectives of the U.S. and the USSR. Both used an organized form of propaganda activities with one-sided, deformed messages, mainly based on their respective ideologies; while the U.S. underlined the material prosperity of the Western world and the desirability of individual freedoms, the USSR emphasized the adverse sides of capitalism. This kind of propaganda sought to stress the admirable side of one’s own country, while denigrating the other side by focusing on specific issues.25 In order to shape public attitudes all over the world toward their respective ideologies, the main tools used by the two superpowers were international broadcasting and radio stations, such as the Voice of America (VOA), Radio Liberty and Radio Free Europe on the American side, and Radio Moscow on the Soviet side.26 The U.S. government developed a number of propaganda channels through the work of the United States Information Agency (USIA), and promoted the universal attractiveness of such American brands as Coca-Cola, Levi jeans and McDonalds, as well as American music and Hollywood films. With the end of the bipolar world, the international environment faced new problems with the rapid expansion in the number and scope of interactions. Contemporary challenges emerged in a new, global communication that had different features from that of the Cold War period. Under these circumstances, it can be claimed that the end of the Cold War made public diplomacy much more important. The spread of democracy, media proliferation and the expansion of global NGOs changed the nature of power and now exert much more influence on the freedom of action of national governments than ever before.27 With these developments, public diplomacy has been used in non-traditional forms with new participants, such as non-state actors; with new sorts of relations between state and non-state actors; and with new goals, such as gaining the support of foreign actors to maintain profound relations rather than using propaganda to influence them. The mechanisms used by these actors to communicate with the world public are supported by new, real-time, global technologies, especially by the Internet. These new technologies have blurred the formerly rigid lines between the domestic and international news spheres. A new emphasis has emerged on people-to-people contact for mutual enlightenment, with international actors playing the role of facilitator. Consequently, instead of top-down messaging, “relationship-building” has become the chief task of the new public diplomacy.28 NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century 107 Although public diplomacy is accepted as a two-way relationship, there is no agreement on how to measure its impact and success, as there is no clear variable that shows the political outcome of public diplomacy initiatives. However, the establishment of daily communications with the target audience to explain foreign policy decisions and the enhancement of lasting relationships with target groups, including individuals, may help to build relationships and to foster understanding. Since public diplomacy begins with listening, one of the pathways of understanding the success of its activities is to measure “public opinion” to see the largest impact of the attraction. In that sense, successful public diplomacy projects increase favorable public opinion toward the practitioner actor. Another pathway for understanding an initiative’s success is “agenda setting,” which determines the issues covered in the media or discussed in the target population. “Framing” is yet another pathway that changes the media coverage of the practitioner actor’s foreign policy in the host country.29 In sum, public diplomacy increases people’s familiarity with one’s country or international institution by making them think about it, update their image of it and change negative opinions. It also increases people’s appreciation of one’s country or international institution by creating positive perceptions, getting others to see issues of global importance from the same perspective. Moreover, it also helps strengthen ties by getting people to understand and subscribe to common values. More importantly, it influences people and/ or politicians by making them favored partners.30

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Slow growth deteriorates the international order and prevents cooperation on major existential threats

Haass 17 [Richard Haass, President of the Council on Foreign Relations, previously served as Director of Policy Planning for the US State Department (2001-2003), and was President George W. Bush's special envoy to Northern Ireland and Coordinator for the Future of Afghanistan.] “A World in Disarray: American Foreign Policy and the Crisis of the Old Order”

A large portion of the burden of creating and maintaining order at the regional or global level will fall on the United States. This is inevitable for several reasons, only one of which is that the United States is and will likely remain the most powerful country in the world for decades to come. The corollary to this point is that no other country or group of countries has either the capacity or the mind-set to build a global order. Nor can order ever be expected to emerge automatically; there is no invisible hand in the geopolitical marketplace. Again, a large part of the burden (or, more positively, opportunity) falls on the principal power of the day. There is more than a little self-interest at stake. The United States cannot remain aloof, much less unaffected by a world in disarray. Globalization is more reality than choice. At the regional level, the United States actually faces the opposite problem, namely, that certain actors do have the mind-set and means to shape an order. The problem is that their views of order are in part or in whole incompatible with U.S. interests. Examples would include Iran and ISIS in the Middle East, China in Asia, and Russia in Europe. It will not be an easy time for the United States. The sheer number and range of challenges is daunting. There are a large number of actors and forces to contend with. Alliances, normally created in opposition to some country or countries, may not be as useful a vehicle in a world in which not all foes are always foes and not all friends are always friendly. Diplomacy will count for a great deal; there will be a premium on dexterity. Consultations that aim to affect the actions of other governments and their leaders are likely to matter more than negotiations that aim to solve problems. Another reality is that the United States for all its power cannot impose order. Partially this reflects what might be called structural realities, namely, that no country can contend with global challenges on its own given the very nature of these challenges. The United States could reduce its carbon footprint dramatically, but the effect on global climate would be modest if India and China failed to follow suit. Similarly, on its own the United States cannot maintain a world trading system or successfully combat terrorism or disease. Adding to these realities are resource limits. The United States cannot provide all the troops or dollars to maintain order in the Middle East and Europe and Asia and South Asia. There is simply too much capability in too many hands. Unilateralism is rarely a serious foreign policy option. Partners are essential. That is one of the reasons why sovereign obligation is a desirable compass for U.S. foreign policy. Earlier I made the case that it represents realism for an era of globalization. It also is a natural successor to containment, the doctrine that guided the United States for the four decades of the Cold War. There are basic differences, however. Containment was about holding back more than bringing in and was designed for an era when rivals were almost always adversaries and in which the challenges were mostly related to classical geopolitical competition.1 Sovereign obligation, by contrast, is designed for a world in which sometime rivals are sometime partners and in which collective efforts are required to meet common challenges. Up to this point, we have focused on what the United States needs to do in the world to promote order. That is what one would expect from a book about international relations and American foreign policy. But a focus on foreign policy is not enough. National security is a coin with two sides, and what the United States does at home, what is normally thought of as belonging to the domestic realm, is every bit as much a part of national security as foreign policy. It is best to understand the issue as guns and butter rather than guns versus butter. When it comes to the domestic side, the argument is straightforward. In order to lead and compete and act effectively in the world, the United States needs to put its house in order. I have written on what this entails in a book titled Foreign Policy Begins at Home.2 This was sometimes interpreted as suggesting a turn away from foreign policy. It was nothing of the sort. Foreign policy begins at home, but it ends there only at the country’s peril.3 Earlier I mentioned that the United States has few unilateral options, that there are few if any things it can do better alone than with others. The counterpart to this claim is that the world cannot come up with the elements of a working order absent the United States. The United States is not sufficient, but it is necessary. It is also true that the United States cannot lead or act effectively in the world if it does not have a strong domestic foundation. National security inevitably requires significant amounts of human, physical, and financial resources to draw on. The better the United States is doing economically, the more it will have available in the way of resources to devote to what it wants and needs to do abroad without igniting a divisive and distracting domestic debate as to priorities. An additional benefit is that respect for the United States and for the American political, social, and economic model (along with a desire to emulate it) will increase only if it is seen as successful. The most basic test of the success of the model will be economic growth. U.S. growth levels may appear all right when compared with what a good many other countries are experiencing, but they are below what is needed and fall short of what is possible. There is no reason why the United States is not growing in the range of 3 percent or even higher other than what it is doing and, more important, not doing.4

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Creating room for growth in the biotech sector is key to key to economic resilience---it creates a virtuous cycle of post-COVID growth

Rob Carlson 21 - PhD, managing director at Bioeconomy Capital & affiliate professor in the Paul G Allen School of Computer Science & Engineering at the University of Washington "Beyond Biological Defense: Maintaining the U.S. Biotechnology Advantage," War on the Rocks, https://warontherocks.com/2021/09/beyond//AL

Biotech is now a major contributor to the US economy. When considered as an industry in itself, biotech and its economic impact rivals mining, utilities, chemicals and computing and electronics. Internationally, at least 20 countries have articulated strategies that explicitly identify biotech as critical to their future economic and employment growth (1). Given this focus on economic development, it is crucial to better define the current systemic role of biotech. Moreover, ongoing discussions of funding and investment, benefit and risk, and opportunity and threat all would benefit from a more detailed understanding of where biotech is and where it is headed. In this article, I use data collected from a variety of public and private sources to assemble an initial economic assessment of biotech in the United States as a test case for an analysis at the global level. What emerges is a picture of a sector already making a remarkable and accelerating transformation of the US economy. By my estimate, total domestic US revenues generated by biotech in 2012 reached at least $324 billion--the equivalent of >2% of gross domestic product (GDP; for comparison, see Supplementary Table 1 for a list of selected industries and their contributions to US GDP). The estimate is intended to be conservative; the actual total could be 10-20% higher. Total revenues comprise three biotech subsectors: biologics (drugs), at $91 billion; crops (and seeds), at $128 billion; and industrial products (biofuels, enzymes, biomaterials and biochemicals), at >$105 billion. Over the past decade, aggregate revenues have grown on average at annual rates >10%, much faster than the economy as a whole. Remarkably, biotech revenue growth was the equivalent of >5% of annual US GDP growth every year between 2007 and 2012. It is difficult to project exactly how large the biotech sector might ultimately become, but the trends indicate that biological technologies are likely to generate an increasing share of both GDP and annual GDP growth. Economic and security policy implications towards implementation using other successful models outlined in this article.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Disease causes extinction

Dimandis 21 (Eleftherios P. Diamandis, “The Mother of All Battles: Viruses vs. Humans. Can Humans Avoid Extinction in 50-100 Years?”, PrePrints 2021040397, April 13th 2021, , wcNS)

The recent SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, which is causing COVID 19 disease, has taught us unexpected lessons about the dangers of human extinction through highly contagious and lethal diseases. As the COVID 19 pandemic is now being controlled by various isolation measures, therapeutics and vaccines, it became clear that our current lifestyle and societal functions may not be sustainable in the long term. We now have to start thinking and planning on how to face the next dangerous pandemic, not just overcoming the one that is upon us now. Is there any evidence that even worse pandemics could strike us in the near future and threaten the existence of the human race? The answer is unequivocally yes. It is not necessary to get infected by viruses of bats, pangolins and other exotic animals that live in remote forests in order to be in danger. Creditable scientific evidence indicates that the human gut microbiota harbor billions of viruses which are capable of affecting the function of vital human organs such as the immune system, lung, brain, liver, kidney, heart etc. It is possible that the development of pathogenic variants in the gut can lead to contagious viruses which can cause pandemics, leading to destruction of vital organs, causing death or various debilitating diseases such as blindness, respiratory, liver, heart and kidney failures. These diseases could result n the complete shutdown of our civilization and probably the extinction of human race. In this essay, I will first provide a few independent pieces of scientific facts and then combine this information to come up with some (but certainly not all) hypothetical scenarios that could cause human race misery, even extinction. I hope that these scary scenarios will trigger preventative measures that could reverse or delay the projected adverse outcomes. Introduction Le Chatelier’s Principle: Named after the French chemist, Le Chatelier’s principle posits that “When an external stress (change in pressure, temperature or concentration) is applied to a system in chemical equilibrium, the equilibrium will change in such a way as to reduce the effect of the stress”. In other words, a change in a system will evoke a counter-change, which will bring the equilibrium to a new point. This principle operates with almost every human or other activity. For example, it is known that when fruit production in the Serengeti ecosystem is reduced, the number of elephants, who feed on these fruits, is reduced proportionally. In the context of this essay, I hypothesize that human-made changes in climate, the atmosphere, waters, soil and all other planet-living organisms, will likely evoke counter-changes that may be highly consequential to human life. Due to the complexity of our ecosystem, humans do not know exactly how these dramatic changes will affect them in the long run. Consequently, they choose to disregard them because adjustments cost money and convenience or loss of well-established pleasures. The earth is changing rapidly What is changing on earth that could induce a potentially catastrophic counter-change? The answer is everything is changing*, from the living inhabitants (humans, other species and plants), to the atmosphere, water, soil, climate, etc.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Rapidly adapting innovation is the only thing that can solve for the inevitable increased risk of disease outbreak

Jeff, Tollefson, 20. "Why deforestation and extinctions make pandemics more likely." Nature, vol. 584, no. 7820, 13 Aug. 2020, pp. 175+. Gale Academic OneFile, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A632281042/AONE?u=umuser&sid=googleScholar&xid=1b0801f0. Accessed 24 June 2022//AL

As humans diminish biodiversity by cutting down forests and building more infrastructure, they're increasing the risk of disease pandemics such as COVID-19. Many ecologists have long suspected this, but a new study helps to reveal why: while some species are going extinct, those that tend to survive and thrive -- rats and bats, for instance -- are more likely to host potentially dangerous pathogens that can make the jump to humans. The analysis of around 6,800 ecological communities on 6 continents adds to a growing body of evidence that connects trends in human development and biodiversity loss to disease outbreaks -- but stops short of projecting where new disease outbreaks might occur. "We've been warning about this for decades," says Kate Jones, an ecological modeller at University College London and an author on the study, published on 5 August in Nature 1 . "Nobody paid any attention." Jones is one of a cadre of researchers that has long been delving into relationships among biodiversity, land use and emerging infectious diseases. Their work has mostly flown below the radar, but now, as the world reels from the COVID-19 pandemic, efforts to map risks in communities across the globe and to project where diseases are most likely to emerge are taking centre stage. Last week, the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) hosted an online workshop on the nexus between biodiversity loss and emerging diseases. The organization's goal now is to produce an expert assessment of the science underlying that connection ahead of a United Nations summit in New York that's planned for September, where governments are expected to make new commitments to preserve biodiversity. Others are calling for a more wide-ranging course of action. On 24 July, an interdisciplinary group of scientists, including virologists, economists and ecologists, published an essay in Science 2 , arguing that governments can help reduce the risk of future pandemics by controlling deforestation and curbing the wildlife trade, which involves the sale and consumption of wild -- and often rare -- animals that can host dangerous pathogens. Most efforts to prevent the spread of new diseases tend to focus on vaccine development, early diagnosis and containment, but that's like treating the symptoms without addressing the underlying cause, says Peter Daszak, a zoologist at the non-governmental organization EcoHealth Alliance in New York, who chaired the IPBES workshop. He says COVID-19 has helped to clarify the need to investigate biodiversity's role in pathogen transmission. The latest work by Jones's team bolsters the case for action, Daszak says. "We're looking for ways to shift behaviour that would directly benefit biodiversity and reduce health risks." Concentrating risk Previous research has shown that outbreaks of diseases such as severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) and bird influenza that cross over from animals to humans have increased in the past few decades3 , 4 . This phenomenon is likely to be the direct result of increased contact between humans, wildlife and livestock, as people move into undeveloped areas. These interactions happen more frequently on the frontier of human expansion because of changes to the natural landscape and increased encounters with animals. A study published in April by researchers at Stanford University in California found that deforestation and habitat fragmentation in Uganda increased direct encounters between primates and people, as primates ventured out of the forest to raid crops and people ventured in to collect wood5 . But a key question over the past decade has been whether the decline in biodiversity that inevitably accompanies human expansion on the rural frontier increases the pool of pathogens that can make the jump from animals to humans. Work by Jones and others6 suggests that the answer in many cases is yes, because a loss in biodiversity usually results in a few species replacing many -- and these species tend to be the ones hosting pathogens that can spread to humans. For their latest analysis, Jones and her team compiled more than 3.2 million records from several hundred ecological studies at sites around the world, ranging from native forests to cropland to cities. They found that the populations of species known to host diseases transmissible to humans -- including 143 mammals such as bats, rodents and various primates -- increased as the landscape changed from natural to urban, and as biodiversity generally decreased. The next step for Jones's team is to examine the likelihood of disease transmission to the human population. The group has already made this type of evaluation for Ebola virus outbreaks in Africa, creating risk maps based on development trends, the presence of probable host species, and socio-economic factors that determine the pace at which a virus might spread once it enters the human population7 . The group's risk maps accurately captured where outbreaks occurred in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) in the past few years, suggesting that it is possible to understand and project risks on the basis of relationships between factors such as land use, ecology, climate and biodiversity. Some researchers urge caution when communicating that biodiversity hotspots are where outbreaks are likely to occur. "My worry, frankly, is that people are going to cut down the forests more if this is where they think the next pandemic is going to come from," says Dan Nepstad, a tropical ecologist and founder of the Earth Innovation Institute based in San Francisco, California, a non-profit organization that campaigns for sustainable development. Efforts to preserve biodiversity will only work, he says, if they address the economic and cultural factors that drive deforestation and the rural poor's dependency on hunting and trading wild animals. Ibrahima Socé Fall, an epidemiologist and head of emergency operations at the World Health Organization in Geneva, Switzerland, agrees that understanding the ecology -- as well as the social and economic trends -- of the rural frontier will be crucial to projecting the risk of future disease outbreaks. "Sustainable development is crucial," he says. "If we continue to have this level of deforestation, disorganized mining and unplanned development, we are going to have more outbreaks." Coordinating efforts One message that the IPBES's upcoming report is likely to deliver is that scientists and policymakers need to treat the rural frontier more holistically, addressing issues of public health, the environment and sustainable development in tandem. In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, many scientists and conservationists have emphasized curbing the wildlife trade -- an industry worth an estimated US$20 billion annually in China, where the first coronavirus infections appeared. China has temporarily suspended its trade. But Daszak says the industry is just one piece in a larger puzzle that involves hunting, livestock, land use and ecology. Wildlife markets like this one in Bali, Indonesia, sustain the livelihoods of many people. But they are also under scrutiny as hotspots for pathogen transmission. Credit: Amilia Roso/The Sydney Morning Herald via Getty Live animals, including local wildlife, are on sale in Bali, Indonesia "Ecologists should be working with infectious-disease researchers, public-health workers and medics to track environmental change, assess the risk of pathogens crossing over and reduce risky human activities," he says. Daszak was an author of last month's essay in Science , which argued that governments could substantially reduce the risk of future pandemics such as COVID-19 by investing in efforts to curb deforestation and the wildlife trade, as well as in efforts to monitor, prevent and control new virus outbreaks from wildlife and livestock. The team estimated that the cost of these actions would ring in at $22 billion to $33 billion annually, including $19.4 billion for ending trade in wild meat in China -- a step that not all experts think is desirable or necessary -- and up to $9.6 billion to help curb tropical deforestation. The total investment would be two orders of magnitude less than the $5.6-trillion price tag estimated for the COVID-19 pandemic, the team estimates. Fall says the key is to align efforts by government and international agencies focused on public health, animal health, the environment and sustainable development. The latest Ebola outbreak in the DRC, which began in 2018 and ended last month, had its roots not just in disease but also in deforestation, mining, political instability and the movement of people. The goal must be to focus resources on the riskiest areas and manage interactions between people and animals, both wild and domestic, Fall says. With the right collaboration between human health, animal health and environmental authorities, Fall says, "you have some mechanisms for early warnings".

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

2-- Only cooperating internationally with NATO prevents a biological arm’s race that increases the risk of disease outbreak

Steve Fyffe 15, 12-17-2015, Steve earned his Master of Journalism degree from UC Berkeley, and served in several senior communications roles at Stanford University "U.S. Needs a New Approach for Governance of Risky Research," No Publication, //AL

The United States needs to build a better governance regime for oversight of risky biological research to reduce the likelihood of a bioengineered super virus escaping from the lab or being deliberately unleashed, according to an article from three Stanford scholars published in the journal Science today. "We've got an increasing number of unusually risky experiments, and we need to be more thoughtful and deliberate in how we oversee this work," said co-author David Relman, a professor of infectious diseases and co-director of Stanford's Center for International Security and Cooperation (CISAC). Relman said that cutting-edge bioscience and technology research has yielded tremendous benefits, such as cheap and effective ways of developing new drugs, vaccines, fuels and food. But he said he was concerned about the growing number of labs that are developing novel pathogens with pandemic potential. For instance, researchers at the Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, in their quest to create a better model for studying human disease, recently deployed a gene editing technique known as CRISPR-Cas9 on a respiratory virus so that it was able to edit the mouse genome and cause cancer in infected mice. "They ended up creating, in my mind, a very dangerous virus and showed others how they too could make similar kinds of dangerous viruses," Relman said. Scientists in the United States and the Netherlands, conducting so-called "gain-of-function" experiments, have also created much more contagious versions of the deadly H5N1 bird flu in the lab. Publicly available information from published experiments like these, such as genomic sequence data, could allow scientists to reverse engineer a virus that would be difficult to contain and highly harmful were it to spread. And a recent spate of high-profile accidents at U.S. government labs – including the mishandling of anthrax, bird flu, smallpox and Ebola samples – has raised the specter of a dangerous pathogen escaping from the lab and causing an outbreak or even a global pandemic. "These kinds of accidents can have severe consequences," said Megan Palmer, CISAC senior research scholar and a co-author on the paper. "But we lack adequate processes and public information to assess the significance of the benefits and risks. Unless we address this fundamental issue, then we're going to continue to be reactive and make ourselves more vulnerable to mistakes and accidents in the long term." Centralizing leadership Leadership on risk management in biotechnology has not evolved much since the mid-1970s, when pioneering scientists gathered at the Asilomar Conference on Recombinant DNA and established guidelines that are still in use today. Palmer said that although scientific self-governance is an essential element of oversight, left unchecked, it could lead to a "culture of invincibility over time." "There's reliance on really a narrow set of technical experts to assess risks, and we need to broaden that leadership to be able to account for the new types of opportunities and challenges that emerging science and technology bring," she said. Relman described the current system as "piecemeal, ad hoc and uncoordinated," and said that a more "holistic" approach that included academia, industry and all levels of government was needed to tackle the problem. "It's time for us as a set of communities to step back and think more strategically," Relman said. The governance of "dual use" technologies, which can be used for both peaceful and offensive purposes, poses significant challenges in the life sciences, said Stanford political scientist Francis Fukuyama, who also contributed to the paper. "Unlike nuclear weapons, it doesn't take large-scale labs," Fukuyama said. "It doesn't take a lot of capacity to do dangerous research on biology." The co-authors recommend appointing a top-ranking government official, such as a special assistant to the president, and a supporting committee, to oversee safety and security in the life sciences and associated technologies. They would coordinate the management of risk, including regulatory authorities needed to ensure accountability and information sharing. "Although many agencies right now are tasked with worrying about safety, they have got conflicting interests that make them not ideal for being the single point of vigilance in this area," Fukuyama said. "The National Institutes of Health is trying to promote research but also stop dangerous research. Sometimes those two aims run at cross-purposes. "It's a big step to call for a new regulator, because in general we have too much regulation, but we felt there were a lot of dangers that were not being responded to in an appropriate way." Improving cooperation Strong cooperative international mechanisms are also needed to encourage other countries to support responsible research, Fukuyama said. "What we want to avoid is a kind of arms race phenomenon, where countries are trying to compete with each other doing risky research in this area, and not wanting to mitigate risks because of fears that other countries are going to get ahead of them," he said. The co-authors also recommended investing in research centers as a strategic way to build critical perspective and analysis of oversight challenges as biotechnology becomes increasing accessible.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

1-- Innovation can push back against the threat of mass disease spread through vaccine creation, disease detection systems, and biosecurity preparedness

Hamish De Bretton-Gordon 20, Hamish de Bretton-Gordon is a highly operationally experienced CBRN practitioner and a leading expert in chemical and biological counterterrorism and warfare. He was the commanding officer of the U.K. Chemical, Biological, Radiological and Nuclear (CBRN) Regiment and NATO’s Rapid Reaction CBRN Battalion He advises the British Ministry of Defence and the Foreign Office on CBRN and is the Distinguished Visiting Fellow at Magdalene College Cambridge 2020-21. "Biosecurity in the Wake of COVID-19: The Urgent Action Needed – Combating Terrorism Center at West Point," Combating Terrorism Center at West Point, AL

With a quarter of a million dead in the United States and more than a million globally, a massive economic toll,a and a second wave in full swing in the northern hemisphere, the United States and other countries are paying a price for years of neglecting biosecurity as a top-tier national security priority. For years, biosecurity has been the poor relation of the ‘other’ securities for one simple reason: policymakers and analysts failed to grasp just how devastating a highly transmissible new virus in a highly interconnected world could be, and viewed a devastating global pandemic or catastrophic bioterror attack as very unlikely. This article first describes how the COVID-19 pandemic has upended such assumptions, requiring policymakers to rethink both the potential impact and likelihood of the most concerning biological threats (bio threats). Based on this author’s decades of experience confronting CBRN threats,c it then makes a series of observations on the approach now needed to counter biological threats. Some have seen this crisis as a one-in-a-100-year event. But, as this article will outline, this is both naïve and risks creating complacency. Unless countries around the world develop a comprehensive biosecurity strategy and coordinate their efforts, pandemics (either natural or engineered) could devastate the planet every decade. The New Bio Threat Horizon The Need to Rethink Potential Impact Policymakers around the world did not grasp just how large the impact of a bio threat could be. Beyond the enormous human and economic impact, the current pandemic has exposed the weakness, lack of preparedness, and poor responsiveness of healthcare systems of even highly developed countries like the United States and the United Kingdom. And the virus has inflicted carnage, even though SARS-CoV-2 (the virus that causes COVID-19) is not especially virulent. The world may be confronted with other viruses in the future whose combination of virulence (the harm a pathogen does to its host), transmissibility, and other characteristics pose much greater danger. While overwhelming evidence points to SARS-CoV-2 spontaneously spreading to humans, the advances in synthetic biology and the growth in the number of Level 3 and 4 biocontainment facilities around the world storing deadly viruses1 mean there is also the very real possibility that in the future, bad actors will try to engineer or steal/obtain a highly transmissible and highly virulent virus and unleash it onto the world. Another risk is accidental releases from such biocontainment facilities. COVID-19, a highly transmissible but not very virulent pathogen, has had a devastating global impact, a fact that will not have gone unnoticed by rogue states and terror organizations. Advances in synthetic biology have created tools that could be put to malevolent use. In the last two decades, scientists synthesized the poliovirus from its genetic sequence,2 recreated the 1918 Spanish flu virus,3 and succeeded in modifying the H5N1 avian flu virus so that it resulted (in a research laboratory) in airborne transmission among mammals.4 In the future, we should think of weaponized biology as no less of an existential threat to the planet than weaponized atomic science. It should also be noted that the fear and panic that even a medium-scale bioterror attack could create could have dangerous implications that may rival or even surpass the immediate loss of life. The Need to Rethink Likelihood Given the fact that in late 2019 when, as far as is known, COVID-19 cases first started emerging in China, it had been more than a century since the previous catastrophic outbreak (the 1918-1919 “Spanish flu” pandemic),d it was unsurprising that many thought of such pandemics as a one-in-a-100-year event. Such assumptions should no longer hold. The encroachment of human settlements into areas that had previously been sanctuaries for wildlife5 and the popularity in some parts of the world of markets where people and wild animals are brought into proximity have made it more likely viruses will make the species leap to human beings.e And when they do, as the COVID-19 pandemic illustrated, the interconnectedness of a world in which millions of people fly each day6 means they can spread very rapidly. There is also growing concern about engineered viruses. Not only have advances in synthetic biology (SynBio) created growing capacity for extremely dangerous viruses to be engineered in a laboratory, but the number of people with access to potentially dangerous ‘dual use’ technology has greatly expanded and continues to expand, making malevolent use of such technology ever more likely. In the August 2020 issue of this publication, scientists at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point warned that: The wide availability of the protocols, procedures, and techniques necessary to produce and modify living organisms combined with an exponential increase in the availability of genetic data is leading to a revolution in science affecting the threat landscape that can be rivaled only by the development of the atomic bomb. As the technology improves, the level of education and skills necessary to engineer biological agents decreases. Whereas only state actors historically had the resources to develop and employ biological weapons, SynBio is changing the threat paradigm. The cost threshold of engineering viruses is also lowering, with the West Point scientists warning that synthetic biology has “placed the ability to recreate some of the deadliest infectious diseases known well within the grasp of the state-sponsored terrorist and the talented non-state actor.”7 As already noted, another source of vulnerability is that deadly viruses could be stolen from or escape from a research laboratory. There are now around 50 Biosafety Level 4f facilities around the world, where the deadliest pathogens are stored and worked on, and this figure is set to increase in the next few years.g This is a large increase over the last 30 years, creating bigger risk of a breach. Of equal, if not greater concern are the thousands of Biosafety Level 3 labs globally,8 which handle deadly pathogens like COVID-19.9 Given what has been outlined above, the risk of a future destructive biological attack or another devastating global pandemic should no longer be seen as low. From this point forward, there should no higher priority for the international community than biosecurity. Hamish de Bretton-Gordon Improving Biosecurity

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Biotech revolution has the potential to create a new wave of innovation to solve for a litany of existential threats BUT effective regulation is key

Michael Chui 20, 5-13-2020, "The Bio Revolution: Innovations transforming economies, societies, and our lives," McKinsey & Company, //AL

A confluence of advances in biological science and accelerating development of computing, automation, and artificial intelligence is fueling a new wave of innovation. This Bio Revolution could have significant impact on economies and our lives, from health and agriculture to consumer goods, and energy and materials. Some innovations come with profound risks rooted in the self-sustaining, self-replicating, and interconnected nature of biology that argue for a serious and sustained debate about how this revolution should proceed. Accidents can have major consequences—and, especially if used unethically or maliciously, manipulating biology could become a Pandora’s box that, once opened, unleashes lasting damage to the health of humans, ecosystems, or both. The risks are particularly acute because many of the materials and tools are relatively cheap and accessible. Moreover, tackling these risks is complicated by a multiplicity of jurisdictional and cultural value systems, which makes collaboration and coordination across countries difficult. Sidebar COVID-19 and bio innovations However, new biological applications are already improving our response to global challenges including climate change and pandemics. Global responses to the novel coronavirus—SARS-CoV-2—illustrated substantial advances in biological science in just the past few years. The speed with which scientists sequenced the virus’s genome—weeks rather than months—bore witness to the new world of biology described in this research. However, sequencing is just the start: biological innovations are enabling the rapid introduction of clinical trials of vaccines, the search for effective therapies, and a deep investigation of both the origins and the transmission patterns of the virus. As much as 60 percent of the physical inputs to the global economy could, in principle, be produced biologically—about one-third of these inputs are biological materials (wood or animals bred for food) and the remaining two-thirds are nonbiological (plastics or fuels) but could potentially be produced or substituted using biology. Therefore, it is possible that bio innovations could impact up to 60 percent of physical inputs, although attaining that full potential is a long way off. Even modest progress toward it could transform economies, societies, and our lives, including what we eat and wear, the medicines we take, the fuels we use, and how we construct our physical world. In human health, at least 45 percent of the current global disease burden could be addressed using science that is conceivable today. A pipeline of about 400 use cases, almost all scientifically feasible today, is already visible. These applications alone could have direct economic impact of up to $4 trillion a year over the next ten to 20 years. More than half of this direct impact could be outside human health in domains such as agriculture and food, consumer products and services, and materials and energy production. Taking into account potential knock-on effects, new applications yet to emerge, and additional scientific breakthroughs, the full potential could be far larger.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
AFF—Biotech—Updates › 1AC – Innovation that Excites

Current uncertainty in US-NATO biotech industry has the potential to collapse the industry and deck innovation

Jonathan Smith 22, 1-3-2022, "European Biotech Industry Braces as War Erupts in Ukraine," Jonathan Smith studied Neuroscience in the University of Bristol, trained mice in Eisai, Hertfordshire, for one year, received his Ph.D. at the University of Leicester,Labiotech.eu, AL

Europe has been blindsided by its biggest war in decades with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Amid a raging humanitarian crisis, the biotech industry is preparing for increasing economic uncertainty, cyber threats, and clinical trial disruptions. The invasion of Ukraine by Russian forces last week caused a widespread outcry from the European community. The geopolitical landscape has undergone a historic shift and the tragic consequences of the event are rippling out to the European biotech industry. “The conflict in Ukraine is above all an enormous and deplorable shock to all of us,” said Miguel Forte, CEO of the Belgian regenerative medicine specialist Bone Therapeutics. “Our thoughts should go for those people, both in Ukraine and Russia, directly affected by reckless and irresponsible leadership.” The crisis has many facets and the biotech industry in Europe is preparing itself for challenges on a number of fronts. The human crisis The human cost of the invasion is expected to be heavy, with deaths and injuries from the conflict currently numbering in the hundreds, and a growing number of refugees moving west. The supply of lifesaving medications to and from the region are already being disrupted; the World Health Organization recently reported an urgent shortage of oxygen for use in healthcare in Ukraine. Another factor at play is the clamping down on air travel and shipments to and from Russian companies. “The primary and immediate consequences will be affecting Ukraine, but the impact could also likely be felt in Russia and for the Russian population,” said Forte. He added that other countries could be hit indirectly by the chaos. For life science companies, the impact will be strong in countries close to the epicenter of the conflict, including the Baltic states and Eastern European nations. These countries are facing uncertainty from the neighboring crisis, and many resident companies have employees and close contacts in Ukraine. In the Lithuanian life sciences industry, there are “companies that have business units, collaborations, and clients in Ukraine, which now has stopped,” said Monika Paule, CEO of the Lithuanian gene editing specialist CasZyme. “Companies are willing to relocate their employees, move collaborations to other countries, but all hope to get back to operations in Ukraine when the conflict is over.” While countries close to the conflict face large challenges, Paule sees life science companies in these regions also playing a strong role in alleviating the situation. “The sector is ready to help Ukraine by all means during and after the conflict either with medical supplies or bringing business activities back to the country,” she said. Clinical trials caught in the middle European biotech companies now face delays to clinical trials that are being run in Ukraine and Russia. The two countries have increasingly contributed to international studies over the last 10 years thanks to easy access to patient populations; Forte told me there are currently about 500 ongoing studies in Ukraine and over three times more in Russia. The ability of the sponsors, contract research organizations, and suppliers to keep going during the invasion is limited. “We can expect centers in Ukraine to shut down immediately to protect its staff and patients,” said Antoine Papiernik, Managing Partner of the investment firm Sofinnova Partners. “For Russian centers, the integrity of data from those sites might be at stake, and trials that are reliant on those sites will likely be affected.” Overall, Forte advises that big pharma and biotech companies focus on maximizing the safety of clinical trial staff and participants in affected regions. To compensate for the trial shortfall, companies may ramp up recruitment efforts in countries away from the war zone. However, the shifts will likely mean that Ukrainian and Russian patients lose access to many experimental treatments. Even patients that are included in clinical trials in affected regions could have poorer monitoring from clinicians due to the challenging conditions. Financial consequences threaten biotech stocks In addition to the human tragedy caused by the events in Ukraine, financial aftershocks are expected. Many European nations have launched a volley of sanctions against Russia and its ally Belarus. These include bans on investments flowing to Russia-based banking and oil industries in addition to the removal of some Russian banks from SWIFT, the international financial transactions system. The current conflict and resulting sanctions on Russia could have direct and psychological repercussions on the overall business environment in Europe and scare off already risk-averse investors from the biotech scene. Forte sees less impact on early-stage private investment, but bad news for public biotech firms and life sciences companies at later stages of drug development. This blow comes as biotech stocks are already in an anemic situation due in part to inflation fears. “It was already tough in Europe since the beginning of the year, and it might worsen even more,” said Bertrand Delsuc, founder of the business intelligence firm Biotech Radar. “Cash is king, more than ever.” Nonetheless, Papiernik is confident that the biotech industry can pull through. “Biotech has, in the past, demonstrated resilience compared to many other industries,” said Papiernik. “Protecting human lives in the immediate term remains the priority, but I hope we can also preserve the infrastructure enabling us to develop drugs that will help patients in need over the long term.” Cyberthreats to life sciences grow Part of the modern military arsenal is cyberattacks, and cyber threats are growing as Europe and the US slap economic sanctions on Russia. “Several cybersecurity agencies and government bodies have warned about Russia’s ability to retaliate asymmetrically through cyber means,” said Charles Fracchia, CEO of the US firm BioBright. “This means that any sectors of the EU, NATO, and the US economy are likely to be targets, including critical sectors such as banking, healthcare, and life sciences. In life sciences, the threat is probably highest for critical operations such as vaccine manufacturing, biomanufacturing more broadly, and large clinical centers.” Life sciences companies have been caught in the crossfire in the past; the US big pharma MSD lost over €1B in 2017 when it was hit by malware known as ‘notPetya,’ designed by Russia to target Ukraine. It took until January 2022 for MSD to claw back damage payments from insurers. “The notPetya attack was ostensibly not targeted at [MSD], and yet, it had this enormous effect, thousands of miles away,” said Fracchia. “[MSD] was big enough to withstand this, but it is clear that our industry could not withstand a targeted attack, to say nothing of the smaller biotech’s ability to survive altogether.” To endure pressing threats from cyberattacks, biotech companies are advised to assess their security measures and keep them up to date. Europe’s biotech industry braces itself Despite the bleak conditions in Ukraine, there might be a silver lining in the long term. European countries are presenting an increasingly united front against Russia’s actions in Ukraine, which could strengthen links between Europe’s various life sciences hubs, and improve the supply chains of medicines to Ukraine. In addition, the EU is considering lowering its dependence on Russian fossil fuels by increasing investments in renewable energy. This move could benefit biotech companies that aim to usher in a circular bioeconomy. For now, there are numerous ways that biotech companies can weather the current geopolitical storm. Many biotech players have signed a pledge to halt business activities with Russian companies and investors. According to Paule, biotech companies can help the situation in Ukraine by focusing on how to use their contacts and resources to bring medical supplies to those in need, in addition to providing work to Ukrainians coming to the rest of Europe. And, as Forte added, biotech startups should be confident that their efforts will bear fruit in the difficult situation, “even if at this stage there seems to be little space for optimism.”

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Psychoanalysis › Aff › Psycho fails

Psycho is divided into many sections – causes disagreements and makes the future of psycho uncertain

Javier Yanes, 2019 (Yanes, author, scientific journalist, PhD in immunology and molecular biology. “Psychoanalysis, Science or Pseudoscience?” OpenMind BBVA. May 6, 2019. /// MF)

As much as the couch is a piece of furniture associated with television, the “divan” or Turkish couch is a piece of furniture associated with psychoanalysis. Starting at the end of the 19th century, the Austrian  abandoned neurological research to develop his psychotherapy, the method that acquired such notoriety that it became an ingredient of Western popular culture, elevating its originator to the position of the most famous psychiatrist —something he never was— of all time. But his status is wrapped up in a perennial polemic: Is there any scientific evidence to support psychoanalysis? Or is it merely a pseudoscience, perhaps among the most academic of them all?

In 1885, Freud (6 May 1856 – 23 September 1939) traveled to Paris to study the use of hypnosis in the treatment of psychopathology by the neurologist Jean-Martin Charcot. On his return to Vienna the following year, he began to apply this technique to the treatment of his patients, but soon dispensed with it to limit himself to an extensive dialogue that brought out the subject’s experiences and memories. Of particular importance were dreams, which for Freud were a door to the unconscious and the repressed memories from childhood, usually of a sexual content. Oedipus complex, castration and penis envy became theoretical pillars of his method, which a decade later was already being applied under the name of psychoanalysis.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Psychoanalysis › Aff › Psycho fails

Psycho has no scientific backing and is highly criticized

Javier Yanes, 2019 (Yanes, author, scientific journalist, PhD in immunology and molecular biology. “Psychoanalysis, Science or Pseudoscience?” OpenMind BBVA. May 6, 2019. /// MF)

As much as the couch is a piece of furniture associated with television, the “divan” or Turkish couch is a piece of furniture associated with psychoanalysis. Starting at the end of the 19th century, the Austrian  abandoned neurological research to develop his psychotherapy, the method that acquired such notoriety that it became an ingredient of Western popular culture, elevating its originator to the position of the most famous psychiatrist —something he never was— of all time. But his status is wrapped up in a perennial polemic: Is there any scientific evidence to support psychoanalysis? Or is it merely a pseudoscience, perhaps among the most academic of them all?

In 1885, Freud (6 May 1856 – 23 September 1939) traveled to Paris to study the use of hypnosis in the treatment of psychopathology by the neurologist Jean-Martin Charcot. On his return to Vienna the following year, he began to apply this technique to the treatment of his patients, but soon dispensed with it to limit himself to an extensive dialogue that brought out the subject’s experiences and memories. Of particular importance were dreams, which for Freud were a door to the unconscious and the repressed memories from childhood, usually of a sexual content. Oedipus complex, castration and penis envy became theoretical pillars of his method, which a decade later was already being applied under the name of psychoanalysis.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Psychoanalysis › Aff › Psycho fails

Policy is just driven by desire – it acts as a temporary fix

Ahmad & Nayah, 2019 (Mushtaq, assistant English professor at the Imperial College of Business Studies. Sidra, researcher at Riphah International University. “Psychoanalysis as a method of reading texts and practices: a descriptive study” Asian Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities. Vol. 8(1). February 2019. /// MF)

The third stage of development is the ‘Oedipus complex’: the encounter with sexual difference. Successful completion of the Oedipus complex enforces our transition from the Imaginary to the Symbolic. It also compounds our sense of ‘lack’. The impossibility of fulfillment is now experienced as a movement from signifier to signifier, unable to fix upon a signified. For Lacan (1989), desire is the hopeless pursuit of the fixed signified (the ‘other’, the ‘Real’, the moment of plenitude, the mother’s body), always forever becoming another signifier – the ‘incessant sliding of the signified under the signifier’. Desire exists in the impossibility of closing the gap between self and other– to make good that which we ‘lack’. We long for a time when we existed in ‘nature’ (inseparable from the mother’s body), where everything was simply itself, before the mediations of language and the Symbolic. As we move forward through the narrative of our lives, we are driven by a desire to overcome the condition, and as we look back, we continue to ‘believe’ (this is mostly an unconscious process) that the union with the mother (or the person playing the symbolic role of the mother) was a moment of plenitude before the fall into ‘lack’. The ‘lesson’ of the ‘Oedipus complex’ is that the child must now resign itself to the fact that it can never have any direct access to the prohibited body of the mother. After the Oedipus crisis, we will never again be able to attain this precious object, even though we will spend all our lives hunting for it. We have to make do instead with substitute objects with which we try vainly to plug the gap at the very center of our being. We move among substitutes for substitutes, metaphors for metaphors, never able to recover the pure (if fictive) self-identity and self-completion.

In Lacanian theory, it is an original lost object – the mother’s body – which drives forward the narrative of our lives, impelling us to pursue substitutes for this lost paradise in the endless metonymic movement of desire. The ideology of romantic love – in which ‘love’ is the ultimate solution to all our problems – could be cited as an example of this endless search. What I mean by this is the way that romance as a discursive practice holds that love makes us whole, it completes our being. Love in effect promises to return us to the Real: that blissful moment of plenitude, inseparable from the body of the mother. We can see this played out in the masculine romance of Paris, Texas. The film can be read as a road movie of the unconscious, a figuration of Travis Henderson’s impossible struggle to return to the moment of plenitude. The film stages three attempts at return: first, Travis goes to Mexico in search of his mother’s origins; then he goes to Paris (Texas) in search of the moment when he was conceived in his mother’s body; finally, in an act of ‘displacement’, he returns Hunter to Jane (a son to his mother), in symbolic recognition that his own quest is doomed to failure.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › DAs › 2AC---A2: Turkey Politics

Even if they don’t trust NATO, they still want to stay in.

The Economist 22 [The Economist, 06-16-2022, "Is Turkey more trouble to NATO than it is worth?", Economist, https://www.economist.com/europe/2022/06/16/is-turkey-more-trouble-to-nato-than-it-is-worth, DOA: 7-2-2022 //ArchanSen]

Turkey and the West will never see eye to eye on the issue, and Mr Erdogan’s antics, as well as his habit of suggesting that the West, and not Russia, is the biggest threat to his country, will only make matters worse. Already, 65% of Turks say they do not trust NATO, according to a recent survey, although 60% support membership of the alliance.