(Thierry Tardy, PhD in Political Science, Director of the Research Division at the NATO Defense College (Rome), taught at Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies (HEID, Geneva), the War College in Paris, the Sorbonne, the Paris School of International Affairs (Sciences Po) and the National Institute of Oriental Languages and Civilisations (INALCO, Paris). He is also Visiting Professor at the College of Europe in Bruges., “The risks of NATO’s maladaptation,” European Security Volume 30, 2021 - Issue 1, pg Taylor and Francis //um-ef)
In the debate about congruence, one logical conclusion of the above-described elements about the character of the Russian threat is that NATO has to embrace a broader agenda than the one defined by the “deterrence and defence” mantra. To remain relevant, NATO needs to go beyond a too narrow defence-focused agenda, the argument goes. It needs to engage into a securitisation process, by which issues that were not previously belonging to its portfolio of tasks, would now appear on its agenda. As a matter of fact, the shift to security is not new. Since the end of the Cold War, the Alliance has indeed broadened its agenda through activities in the fields of crisis management, implementing mandates often closer to police tasks than to genuine military undertakings. In doing this NATO demonstrated a sense of adaptability and resilience (Menon and Welsh 2011). NATO’s role in Afghanistan’s Provincial Reconstruction Teams (PRTs), or in humanitarian relief operations, provides more specific examples of NATO operating at the frontier of military core tasks to respond to broader security needs (see Gallis 2007, Jakobsen 2010, Williams 2011). Similarly, NATO’s role in counter-terrorism, energy security (Bocse 2020), security sector reform, training, or more recently in the cyber domain, also attest to a broadening of the agenda. The entire discussion about hybrid threats and warfare epitomises this evolution. NATO has also developed expertise on these issues, both within its own staff in Brussels and through its network of Centres of Excellence. To a large extent thus, the defence agenda is subsumed into a broader security agenda and the challenge is therefore to make trade-offs between different types of activities. We believe though that not only are these activities politically and operationally less prominent than what the “deterrence and defence” agenda has implied since 2014, but a key argument of this research is also that further developing these tasks carry risks of maladaptation. Maladaptation may result from issues spanning a lack of expertise and legitimacy deficit on many of the new tasks embraced, inter-institutional duplication and competition, uneven members states’ backing, to dilution of the Alliance’s core military role. Enlarging the scope: towards security and internal threats Acquiring a mandate or a capacity to tackle a broad range of threats implies that NATO moves in two directions: towards more security-type activities as opposed to defence-focused ones; and towards more internal issues. In both directions, a more assertive role for NATO implies three levels of activity: policy development, i.e. the ability to produce policy documents that frame NATO’s role in a particular domain; capability development, i.e. the ability to acquire expertise or resources that can be used for the implementation of a particular policy; and operations, i.e. the ability to act through operational activities, be they exercises, training or actual use of NATO and member states’ capabilities placed under NATO command. These three levels allow us to distinguish between domains where NATO would only act in a coordination or information-sharing role (for which capability development and operations are not necessary), and domains where NATO would be having a more central function. Applied to the current landscape, the broadening security agenda beyond what is already done would imply a more assertive role for NATO in defensive/offensive cyber activities (with the cyberspace being an operational domain and covered by Article 5), in the fight against organised crime networks, inter alia through maritime security, as well as in the broad security sector reform (SSR) agenda of partner countries, to take just a few examples. In all these tasks coercion and military effect are not absent, yet they are less central than in traditional defence activities. The second direction of the move – inward-looking – would mean that NATO plays an increased role in the defence against internal threats, by contributing to: critical infrastructure protection and resilience building; civilian protection tasks; police-type activities such as anti-terrorist operations in European capitals; operations that aim to tackle the security consequences of (massive) migrant flows; or support to police forces facing under-the-radar hybrid-type non-conventional attacks. This would imply establishing relations with a set of national actors, from law enforcement entities to municipalities, public companies (in the energy and transport sectors among others) and the private sector (Machi 2017). The role of NATO in these various activities could vary in ambition, spanning information-sharing, awareness rising, coordination, exercises, and more operational tasks. The implied risks of task expansion Although these various tasks make sense when assessed against the broad security needs of NATO member states and societies, and may be justified for political reasons, they carry a number of risks of maladaptation. First, NATO would have to further develop or acquire an expertise on issues that can be very technical, or human resources-heavy, and for which even the member states may have a deficit (as in the cyber domain, energy security, or critical infrastructure protection). The added-value of NATO’s role would be all the more challenged as its expertise is being questioned. Second, the legitimacy of NATO’s role in some areas may be challenged due to a lack of expertise or because of the possible intrusiveness of NATO’s activities; this leads to sovereignty considerations, with states – be they NATO member states or not – having issues with any attempt from NATO to interfere with their internal sphere, in the law enforcement domain for example. Third, any task expansion would require a degree of consensus within member states on the merits of the enlarged mandate, and this will prove to be difficult, as illustrated by the sensitivities of broadening NATO’s agenda towards the South, to include counter-terrorism and migration policies for example (NATO official 2019). Even an agreement on broadening NATO’s mandate on the Eastern flank to embrace security issues would be difficult. Securitisation is inherently subjective (Buzan and Waever 2003, Sperling and Webber 2016); it is the outcome of a political choice that in turn results from an intersubjective understanding of what constitutes a threat. It follows that consensus-building on newly identified threats or policies is all the more difficult. Fourth, the broad security field is already crowded with institutions that in some areas would appear in a stronger position. NATO’s positioning on the broad field of activities would potentially duplicate existing capacities, and place it in direct competition with others, often in a weaker position. From the SSR domain in Sub-Saharan Africa to police or border tasks within European states, actors like the EU, national administrations, police forces and NGOs would not necessarily welcome a NATO role. Fifth, any broadening of NATO’s mandate would be resisted as it would carry the risk of diluting NATO’s war-fighting capability. Contemporary war-fighting is arguably politically, financially and operationally demanding; any parallel effort can, therefore, be seen as a deleterious diversion (see Stapleton 2016). Cyber security provides a good example of these risks. Cyber is arguably a key dimension of NATO’s mission. It is part of “NATO’s core task of collective defence”, and its qualification as an operational domain implies that NATO “must be able to operate as effectively in cyberspace as [it does] in the air, on land, and at sea to strengthen and support the Alliance’s overall deterrence and defence posture” (NATO 2018, para. 20) At the 2014 Wales Summit, Allies have also stated that a cyber attack could lead to the invocation of Article 5 of the Washington Treaty. Furthermore, NATO has developed a fair amount of doctrinal and policy documents in that domain. Yet the extent to which NATO can play an important role in cyber security is uncertain for reasons that have to do with expertise, capabilities, the nature of the threat and of its possible targets, and therefore the nature of the response. In terms of expertise, while NATO may provide support to the states that suffer shortfalls, notably through its Cyber Rapid Reaction teams, the Alliance does not display obvious comparative advantages vis-à-vis most member states (NATO Official 2019). As for capabilities to conduct cyber attacks, NATO has so far relied exclusively on its member states, through the concept of “sovereign cyber effects, provided voluntarily by Allies”, and integrated “into Alliance operations and missions” (NATO 2018, para. 20). The fact that cyber attacks (on NATO member states) would most likely target entities that are either private actors, or in any case under the protection of domestic police forces, is also an issue. As put by a NATO official, while what can be sought is a “military outcome, it cannot be achieved solely through military means”, and “what may be a military challenge is in fact inextricably linked with both civilian government, private industry and even individuals” (Brent 2019, p. 2). These issues lead back to the question of how much NATO can deter cyber attacks, in relation to both deterrence by punishment and deterrence by denial. Those limitations apply beyond the cyber domain, to most of the current threats, for which a military response can be necessary, but very seldom sufficient nor even central.