Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Counterplan
!!!Bilat CPs!!! › Top Shelf › 2NC --- Solvency Run

The aff is slow, the cp is fast

Kilman et al., 20 (Daniel Kliman, Senior Fellow at CNAS, Ben FitzGerald, Kristine Lee, Joshua Fitt, 3-29-2020, " Forging an Alliance Innovation Base," CNAS, , LASA-CSK)

Speed: U.S. action through large-scale international groupings is generally slow and cumbersome. By contrast, working bilaterally with allies can yield rapid results, in part by leveraging existing mechanisms for alliance management designed to translate policy dialogue into concrete outcomes. Minilateral consultations, though less conducive to swift action than bilateral discussions, remain agile compared with multilateral export control regimes like Wassenaar. Disproportionate impact: Leadership in some critical technologies such as semiconductor manufacturing equipment (SME) is concentrated among a small number of U.S. allies.98 In these instances, minilateral and even bilateral consultations can have an outsized impact in denying China access to technologies that could underpin its future commercial prowess and military effectiveness.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
!!!Bilat CPs!!! › Top Shelf › 1NC --- CP Shell

The CP competes and solves the case --- Bilat agreements allow info sharing and interoperability

Adgie et al. ‘22 - Mary Kate Adgie is a research assistant at RAND, with a focus in international development and national security, sub-Saharan African affairs, and socio-economic development; Jason H. Campbell is a policy researcher at the RAND Corporation, where he focuses on issues of international security, counterinsurgency, intelligence, and measuring progress in post-conflict reconstruction; Beth Grill is a senior policy analyst at the RAND Corporation specializing in national security policy and security cooperation; Jennifer Moroney is a senior political scientist at the RAND Corporation and manages many of RAND's security cooperation–related projects for DoD clients; Angela O'Mahony is associate dean for academic affairs at Pardee RAND Graduate School and a senior political scientist at RAND; Rachel Tecott is an adjunct researcher for RAND Corporation who has helped to inform U.S. security cooperation and security force assistance efforts around the world; David Thaler is a senior researcher at the RAND Corporation (RAND, “Prioritizing Security Cooperation with Highly Capable U.S. Allies”, 2022, )//RG

The United States and its allies prioritize establishing shared standards and procedures to ensure that they have the ability to coordinate effectively in a potential conflict. Liaisons and personnel exchanges provide a way to sustain enduring relationships between U.S. and allied militaries. The United States conducts SC activities on a bilateral basis, engaging allies in liaison and military personnel exchange programs. The United Kingdom has as many as 15 liaison officers and 13 exchange officers placed in Army commands. These officers have the opportunity to share information on operational procedures, which helps build and sustain long-term interoperability between the two armies.19

Defense and military contacts, which are more short-term, also provide a means for sharing information. The contacts include army-to-army staff talks and key leader and senior leader engagements. According to G-TSCMIS, Australia and the United Kingdom have the highest number of SC engagements among highly capable partners, including planning conferences, bilateral and multilateral coordination meetings, and staff talks; the majority of these engagements are focused on interoperability.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AFF Answers › General Pressure Answers › Pressure CP---Turn

Threatening allies creates extended fears AND collapses deterrence.

Tad A. Schnaufer 21. Doctoral candidate in Security Studies at the School of Politics, Security, and International Affairs at the University of Central Florida (UCF). Additionally, he serves as a Captain in the Florida Army National Guard. “The US-NATO Relationship: The Cost of Maintaining Political Pressure on Allies.” Georgetown Journal of International Affairs. 1-15-2021. https://gjia.georgetown.edu/2021/01/15/the-us-nato-relationship-the-cost-of-maintaining-political-pressure-on-allies/ //EM

These responses from European leaders show that startling allies into thinking the United States will abandon them has influenced allies to increase defense spending in line with the 2014 Wales Pledge. However, in the long term, NATO policymaking should employ a balanced approach. If the United States brings its security guarantee of the alliance too much into question, Russia or other states may take action to test the United States’ resolve. During the Cold War, US leaders continually reaffirmed their commitment to allies, effectively deterring a Soviet invasion. Deterrence works best when allies clearly express their mutual obligations to all actors on the international stage.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AFF Answers › General Pressure Answers › Pressure CP---Fails---Spending

European countries will not increase defense commitments unliterally.

Andrea Gilli 17. Post-doctoral fellow at Stanford University’s Center for International Security and Cooperation.. “Analysis.” Washington Post. 2-3-2017. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2017/02/03/europe-may-not-be-able-to-expand-its-defenses-like-president-trump-wants/?utm_term=.82d774c6d808 //EM

President Trump’s reassurances last week to U.K. Prime Minister Theresa May that the North American Treaty Organization (NATO) was not, in fact, “obsolete” are unlikely to have Europe taking up more of the defense burden, at least in the short term.

As discussed here in the Monkey Cage, national security adviser Michael T. Flynn wants to see other NATO members pay more of the cost of defending Europe. It’s not a new pitch, but such calls neglect the budgetary, financial and political barriers to enhanced military capabilities in Europe.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AFF Answers › General Pressure Answers › Pressure CP---Fails

Non-escalatory is critical to get allies to agree

O’Hanlon ’19 [Michael; October 2019; Senior Fellow and Director of Research in Foreign Policy at the Brookings Institution, adjunct Professor at Columbia and Georgetown University, Ph.D. in Public and International Affairs from Princeton University; Foreign Affairs, “Can America Still Protect Its Allies?” ]

A sanctions-based strategy would be judicious and proportionate, but it would not be weak. Indeed, if Beijing or Moscow refused to either back down or otherwise resolve the dispute once the United States and its allies had deployed sanctions, Washington could raise the stakes. Recognizing that the aggressor state’s strategic aims had become fundamentally untrustworthy or hostile, Washington could seek to not only punish the perpetrator for its specific action but also limit its future economic growth. Over time, export controls and permanent sanctions could replace temporary punitive measures. This strategy would require support from key U.S. allies to be effective—one more reason why Washington needs to respond to these kinds of crises in a way that seems judicious, patient, and non-escalatory, so as to strengthen its coalition and not scare away key partners.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AFF Answers › General Pressure Answers › Pressure CP---Fails

Threatening to cut-off aid pushes countries closer to Russia and fails to create concessions for the US.

Jessica Trisko Darden 17. Assistant Professor of International Affairs at American University’s School of International Service and a Jeane Kirkpatrick Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. “President Trump wants to pressure allies by cutting foreign aid. That never works.” Washington Post. 8-25-2017. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/posteverything/wp/2017/08/25/president-trump-wants-to-pressure-allies-by-cutting-foreign-aid-that-never-works/ //EM

In his speech this week on his plans for the U.S. military presence in Afghanistan, President Trump said he will use the threat of withdrawing foreign aid to put pressure on Pakistan to better support the American mission. Despite proposing dramatic cuts to the State Department and U.S. Agency for International Development budgets, the Trump administration still requested $740 million in foreign aid for Pakistan, so this threat carries significant weight. Then, just one day later, news broke that the State Department is withholding $195 million in military aid for Egypt and has revoked another $95 million in foreign aid, seeming proof that we are willing to use aid as leverage.

But history shows that foreign aid is a poor way to get what we want. Threatening to cut off aid is almost certain to fail in bringing about political change in Egypt, Pakistan or any country that the United States has a strategic interest in supporting.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AFF Answers › General Pressure Answers › Pressure CP---Fails---Top Level

Pressure fails---politics and self-interests.

Andrea Gilli 17. Post-doctoral fellow at Stanford University’s Center for International Security and Cooperation. “Analysis.” Washington Post. 2-3-2017. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2017/02/03/europe-may-not-be-able-to-expand-its-defenses-like-president-trump-wants/?utm_term=.82d774c6d808 //EM

2) European countries pay more in defense overhead — All armed forces require military bases, training facilities, and administrative support. So in a continent with several small, national armed forces, overhead necessarily absorbs a higher fraction of resources than in the United States.

A solution for Europe would be to share some military assets and functions. In recent years, there have been important bilateral and multilateral initiatives in this respect — but there are strong political limits as well.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AFF Answers › Cong Threats Answers › 2AC – Solvency -- Congressional Threats Fail

Partisanship and the news cycle destroy effective threats.

Warburg 21 [Gerry Warburg is a professor of practice of public policy at the Frank Batten School of Leadership and Public Policy, January 2021, “Congressional Accountability in Shaping United States Foreign Policies 1970-2020,” Center for Effective Policymaking, https://thelawmakers.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Working-Paper-Congressional-Accountability-in-US-Foreign-Policy-1.pdf] Eric

Research on this question, supplemented by interviews with leading policymakers, offer details that reveal how profoundly the policymaking environment has been altered.(30)

First, there are ever fewer centrists elected to Congress from either major party, and those that remain find few electoral incentives for taking tough votes on international policy. Consequently, there are fewer Members prepared to place institutional prerogatives over partisan politics. In the late 1980s, there were a dozen liberal Republicans to ‘the left’ of conservative Democrats, often from southern states, and vice versa. In the last Congress, the most conservative senator in the Democratic caucus, Joe Manchin of West Virginia, was still ranked as more liberal than the most moderate Republican, Susan Collins of Maine.(31) Those who challenge party orthodoxy, or who reach across the political aisle to support a bipartisan compromise—or to defend the institutional prerogatives of Congress—are at greater risk of being defeated. As a consequence, Members of both parties have adopted a classic ‘blame avoidance’ strategy to dodge difficult votes while reserving the ability to blame the President for foreign initiatives gone awry.(32) In fact, several powerful Senate Foreign Relations Committee chairmen have lost their re-election bids. The list includes William Fulbright of Arkansas, Frank Church of Idaho and Charles Percy of Illinois. Many incumbents now fear primary election challenges more than general elections. Primary voters defeated relative moderates such as Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Richard Lugar (R-IN) in 2010, while Trump critic Bob Corker, a popular Tennessee Republican retired unexpectedly in 2019. The muchnoted ‘sorting out’ of parties has significantly increased party-line voting while dis-incentivizing would-be champions of the institution of Congress.(33) This has occurred most notably on domestic issues such as health care—not a single Republican voted for Obamacare, even after Democrats accepted scores of GOP-sponsored amendments. Stimulus spending and tax cuts also became party-line votes in the House. Yet, it also happened on issues like the Iran nuclear pact, where Republicans voted en bloc against an agreement that had been supported by U.S. and Israeli military and intelligence leaders, five United Nations Security Council partners, including key European allies, as well as Russia and China. This party-line voting on security matters and the failure to defend institutional prerogatives “makes it easier for future administrations to just ignore the will of Congress,” Senator Chris Coons (D-DE) observes, “it means there’ll be less and less bipartisanship in defending Congress.(34)

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AFF Answers › Cong Threats Answers › 2AC – Solvency -- Congressional Threats Fail

Congress is an illegitimate actor – structural problems destroy credibility.

Mann and Ornstein 12 [Thomas Mann is a 2012 FP Global Thinker and is a senior fellow at the Brookings institution and Norman Ornstein is a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, a weekly columnist at Roll Call, and co-author, with Thomas Mann of It's Even Worse Than It Looks: How the American Constitutional System Collided With the New Politics of Extremism, Norman Ornstein 12 [Thomas Mann, Norman Ornstein, 11-26-2012, Yes, Congress Is That Bad, Foreign Policy, https://foreignpolicy.com/2012/11/26/yes-congress-is-that-bad/] Eric

What has gone wrong? Two sources of dysfunction are central to the current impasse:

The first is a mismatch between the checks and balances built into the U.S. system and the extreme polarization now separating the two major political parties. By constitutional design, U.S. policymaking moves slowly; the president cannot dictate what happens in Congress, and legislators use separate procedures in the House and Senate that then must be reconciled to write law. In the past, eventual compromise was the standard outcome, at least when some legislators worked across party lines. Not anymore.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC – AT: PDB

Threats cannot be combined with material security guarantees

Blankenship 16 [ is a Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at Columbia University, studying international relations. His research interests focus on alliance politics, and his dissertation studies reassurance and burden-sharing in U.S. alliances, 8-15-2016, Can Obama Play the Trump Card with Allies?, War on the Rocks, https://warontherocks.com/2016/08/can-obama-play-the-trump-card-with-allies/] Eric

It is important to note that there are differences between Trump’s pressure and the pressure that domestic actors have often applied on U.S. policymakers in the past. Members of Congress who propose withdrawing U.S. forces from allied soil or making strong demands of allies are elected officials who can wield direct influence over U.S. spending and foreign policy. By contrast, while he may enjoy the loyalty of a significant chunk of the electorate, unless elected, Trump holds no political power — and it is far from clear that he would gain or lose votes on the basis of allied burden-sharing performance. Thus, the Obama administration may not be able to credibly threaten negative consequences — or promise positive consequences — based on allies’ compliance with U.S. burden-sharing demands. Nevertheless, even if he does not become president, what matters is not only Trump the candidate, but what he may represent — and thus, who might take up the mantle of the free-riding issue in the future.

While Trump’s candidacy raises challenges for U.S. relationships with allies, it is important to recognize that it may also create openings for favorable bargaining. These opportunities must be managed deftly, however, lest the United States undermine the bargaining chip that its security guarantees provide it.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC – AT: PDB

Combining Congressional and executive action guarantees an ineffective policy – defers to executive security cooperation.

Sideris 18 [Vicki Sideris worked as a project consultant at the Social Impact Hub and as a contract administrator at Insurance Australia Group, 10-03-2018, American Allies and Congress: A Friendly Face in the Age of Trump?, Australian Institute of International Affairs, https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/resource/american-allies-and-congress-a-friendly-face-in-the-age-of-trump/] Eric

As the current US President challenges the post-war status quo on the American alliance system, Congress is increasingly stepping up as one of its most vocal defenders. While there are limits to how far Congress would challenge the President and how much difference this would make, cultivating closer congressional ties represents a useful opportunity for allies seeking stability in America’s alliance management.

America’s traditional  and  allies have been dismayed by the President’s challenging of the alliance system. While past presidents have had disagreements with allies over defence spending, ,  and , President Trump’s questioning of the fundamental value of alliances and the national  they serve,  a significant shift from the post-war consensus in Washington. “” portrays allies as taking advantage of the US, judges the burdens of alliances to be greater than the benefits and prefers more transactional relationships. Allies are increasingly  that the President’s anti-alliance outlook may not be an aberration and that business-as-usual will not resume after his term.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC --- Solvency --- Democracy

Pressure can encourage democratic reforms

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

Help shift NATO’s narrative to highlight democratic values. NATO’s primary function as a military alliance is far better understood (and more widely agreed on) than its more nebulous secondary role as a community of democracies with shared values.107 Just as Congress can shift the narrative by emphasizing NATO’s military and consultative strengths, it can highlight NATO’s role as an alliance of values. Such signals would indicate that Congress is paying attention to the behavior of Turkey, Hungary, and Poland while avoiding an overly public callout that could create diplomatic friction or undermine other areas of cooperation. Members can use questions at hearings and briefings, media statements, and private conversations with allied counterparts to emphasize that they understand that NATO is a community of democracies in addition to a military alliance. In this way, it will lend urgency to the backsliding issue and elevate it on NATO’s agenda.108 Ø

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC --- Solvency -- NATO

Can better solves NATO cohesion – create a more realistic agenda and increases coordination

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

Participate in ongoing efforts to redefine NATO’s mission. The current Congress has a timely opportunity to engage with two internal NATO processes that will shape the alliance’s future mission and purpose. The first is the “reflection process,” a study group convened to “reinforce Alliance unity, increase political consultation and coordination between Allies, and strengthen NATO’s political role.”83 In late 2020, the group published a report that included 138 recommendations to achieve those three goals.84 A reaction from members of Congress to the report could help the alliance choose which recommendations to focus on and develop a narrower, more feasible agenda for NATO policy meetings.

Congressional engagement on the reflection process could take the form of a joint letter to the secretary general responding to the report, a request to the administration for further information about some of the recommendations, or simply a public statement endorsing certain recommendations while expressing the need for more study on others. One interviewee suggested that the Senate NATO observers’ group, an informal existing group of senators who are interested in NATO, could take the lead on this initiative. 85

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC --- Solvency --- (Constructive Pressure)

Comparatively, Congress can better mediate tensions and encourage burden-sharing.

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

Transatlantic tensions over burden-sharing: Burden-sharing is the area of NATO policy where Congress has traditionally been most active. Congressional pressure, calibrated effectively, can give the executive branch leverage with allies. The legislative branch, as the representative of the American taxpayer and the overseer of the U.S. defense budget, is well-equipped to play this role.

However, Congress should consider several caveats. First, the issue of burden-sharing is especially sensitive after the Trump presidency. With allies wary that future U.S. administrations will treat burden-sharing the way Trump did,88 congressional pressure could easily become a source of friction. Second, while Congress may find it politically valuable to crack down on “free-riding” allies, ultimately the executive branch does the negotiating.89 A heavy-handed congressional approach that isn’t coordinated with the executive could disrupt ongoing diplomatic efforts on a variety of issues.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC --- Solvency --- Allies

Through narrative shaping, hearings, and reporting requirements, they can easily influence allies.

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

Influencing the executive agenda and shaping the narrative: A third set of strengths has to do with Congress’ ability to put priorities on the executive branch’s agenda and generally shape the domestic and international narrative around particular issues.60 These strengths, which are closely related to the “calling out wrongdoing” idea, similarly stem from Congress’ status as the representative of the American people, which endows its priorities with a unique legitimacy.

Narrative-shaping through hearings and more: Congressional attention to a given foreign policy priority can significantly influence the debate over that issue at home and abroad. Interviewees who have worked in the executive branch and with NATO agreed that both actors pay close attention to what happens in Congress. As Fontaine and Schulman argue, “Congress can play a vital role in encouraging, convening, and organizing public and alternative sources of information.”61 For instance, they argue that congressional hearings can uncover new issues or new ways of thinking about old issues. 62 Nicholas Burns, former U.S. ambassador to NATO, told me that calling a hearing “shines a bright light on a big issue...It’s a convening power to ask members of the administration to appear before Congress and to engage in conversation and debate about the administration's policies.”63 As a 2018 Foreign Affairs article noted, “Hearings and investigations draw attention to neglected issues and can force administrations to rethink decisions. They can divert the executive branch from its priorities and focus the attention of the press.”64

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC --- Solvency --- Allies

Threatening allies works – Congress has significant leverage.

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

Calling out wrongdoing. First, Congress is especially well-suited to vocally and forcefully critiquing bad behavior by other actors at home or abroad. As the branch of government that represents the American public, Congress has long embraced a duty to investigate wrongdoing within the broader constitutional system of checks and balances. 44 More generally, it derives unique legitimacy from its role as the voice of the people and the body that ultimately determines whether a policy can be backed by funds. 45 As Richard Fontaine, a former foreign policy advisor to Sen. John McCain, put it, “They have institutional authority and power that doesn’t exist anywhere else in government, from the power of the purse to the confirmation process to other forms of power and leverage.”46

Lawmakers have added incentives to engage in “callouts” because fighting unethical or unlawful behavior plays well with constituents and in the media. In addition, the sheer size of Congress creates a messiness that lends itself to the calling-out function: It is much easier to get a group of lawmakers with different interests to agree on criticizing something than on, say, proposing a new initiative.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 2NC --- Solvency --- Allies

Close relationships ensure demands are followed.

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

Relationships abroad: Closely related, members of Congress and congressional staff have strong relationships with representatives of foreign governments. One staffer argued that congressional relationships with foreign dignitaries are underused and that behind-the-scenes diplomacy with members of Congress can have an important impact.75 Foreign dignitaries are often eager to engage with members of Congress, which is a source of legislative strength.76 Again, however, there’s a balance to be struck, as interviewees emphasized that the executive branch should retain the lead in diplomatic negotiations. Travel: An important part of congressional relationships with foreign counterparts is travel. Many experts argued that members of Congress can have a significant impact by traveling to a NATO-related location and meeting with stakeholders. 77 Lawmakers sometimes travel with congressional delegations (CODELs) to places like NATO headquarters in Brussels and the Munich Security Conference. CODELs offer a chance to communicate American priorities to foreign governments, including wielding threats of punitive action if a country is seen as not cooperating.78 To be sure, it’s difficult to get members on these trips, in part because traveling to seemingly glamorous places like Europe may come off to constituents as spending taxpayer dollars on a luxurious getaway.79 More generally, NATO is low on the list of places that are worth members’ limited time. Still, members should note that travel offers a way to have a big impact, particularly on foreign governments.

Congress retains significant influence on foreign policy despite today’s constrained environment and the executive branch’s general dominance of this area. Notably, most of these avenues of influence can be pursued in a highly partisan climate. Initiatives like spotlighting rights abuses abroad, critiquing the executive branch, and interacting with allies often have bipartisan support, while tactics like private conversations with foreign counterparts and statements to the media do not require reaching across the aisle at all.80

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Congress Threatens › 1NC --- Congressional Threats Shell

They can easily pressure allies AND gives the executive political cover in negotiations

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

“Bad cop” for allies. The function of critiquing undesirable actions extends to foreign nations. Congress frequently serves as a useful source of pressure on other countries, drawing attention to problematic behavior and opening the door for the executive branch to follow up with negotiations or other measures.

When it comes to NATO, Congress has played the “bad cop” most frequently in the area of burden-sharing. Members routinely put pressure on allies to increase their contributions to the alliance, which gives executive-branch negotiators political cover to make the same demand because they can claim Congress is tying their hands. NATO expert Stanley Sloan is worth quoting at length on the history of congressional involvement in burden-sharing: From the very beginning, the congressional partner regularly raised questions about the persistent burden-sharing issue. This questioning began with the initial debate in the Senate on whether it should give its advice and consent to the Treaty. The administration of President Harry Truman reassured senators that the European allies would contribute to their own defense and that the United States would not end up carrying a disproportionate share of the burden. As the European states recovered from the devastation of World War II, some senators argued that the Europeans had become capable of defending themselves. Montana’s Senator Mike Mansfield (D) famously promoted resolutions from the mid-1960s into the early 1970s that sought to force administrations to begin withdrawing US forces from Europe. While US administrations—Democratic and Republican—sought to contain the financial burdens and to get the Europeans to compensate the United States for some of NATO’s costs, the established pattern persisted into the post– Cold War years. Over all these years, Congress did most of the complaining while successive presidents of both parties urged allies to do more but largely defended the alliance and its costs as necessary for US national interests [emphasis added]. 53 Interviewees with experience in the executive branch repeatedly told me that congressional “complaining” or “needling,” sometimes seen as unproductive grandstanding, is actually a useful way to pressure allies and get issues on the agenda.54 To be sure, congressional critiques can also cause headaches for the executive branch if they create diplomatic friction. Interviewees emphasized the need for useful congressional pressure that is coordinated with the executive and stops short of disrupting fragile bilateral relationships.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Other Threat Options › Solvency---Threaten Withdrawal

The CP threads the needle---it pressures allies to create concessions for the [X]---while sustaining allied unity.

Tad A. Schnaufer 21. Doctoral candidate in Security Studies at the School of Politics, Security, and International Affairs at the University of Central Florida (UCF). Additionally, he serves as a Captain in the Florida Army National Guard. “The US-NATO Relationship: The Cost of Maintaining Political Pressure on Allies.” Georgetown Journal of International Affairs. 1-15-2021. https://gjia.georgetown.edu/2021/01/15/the-us-nato-relationship-the-cost-of-maintaining-political-pressure-on-allies/ //EM

In order to pressure allies, the United States has to send costly signals, such as withdrawing troops from Europe, to demonstrate that their security interests have diverged. This political pressure acts as a forceful method to motivate NATO allies to do more because it provides a credible threat of exclusion from the benefits of US protection. Within NATO, only the United States maintains and controls the conventional and nuclear capacity to deter and defend against existential threats to the alliance. No other ally has the expeditionary military capacity to do so. For example, Estonia is not worried about being abandoned by Romania, Portugal, or even Germany, knowing none of them could bring a sizable military force to bear in response to a Russian invasion or fait accompli. In this case, Estonia’s chief concern revolves around the United States’ guarantee of their sovereignty through NATO. Suppose the United States can make credible claims that it is willing to abandon an ally and not fulfill its treaty obligations. In that case, the ally will experience a drastic incentive to increase its military capabilities to defend itself.

It may seem that these tensions and fears will only lead to negative outcomes, but some disunity within an alliance can yield positive results. Several articles researching the implications of free-riding and burdening-sharing in alliances have supported this notion. In Olson and Zeckhauser’s seminal article on burden-sharing, they wrote, “This fact leads to the paradoxical conclusion that a decline in the amity, unity, and community of interest among allies need not necessarily reduce the effectiveness of an alliance…” and “The United States, at least, should perhaps not hope for too much unity in common ventures with other nations. It might prove extremely expensive.” Similarly, Plumper and Neumayer note in reference to the smaller allies (non-US allies), “Unless the interests of alliance members are independent, the existence of NATO allows the smaller allies to free-ride to some extent.”

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Unilat Threaten CPs › Top Shelf › Solvency---Threaten---AT: Gilli

Gilli is wrong.

John Glaser 17. Adjunct scholar with the Cato Insitute and host of Cato’s Power Problems podcast. “Encouraging NATO Burden Sharing: What Works?” Cato Institute. 02-08-2017. https://www.cato.org/blog/nato-burden-sharing //EM

President Donald Trump has repeatedly complained that the United States carries too much of the economic and military burden in NATO. He has even gone so far as to call the European alliance “obsolete” and to suggest that his administration might not fulfill the treaty’s Article 5 obligation that commits NATO countries to come to the defense of any member that is attacked (Note: administration officials have repeatedly sought to reassure NATO allies that we remain committed to the collective defense of Europe, and Trump has contradicted himself on this score).

Many think this provocative rhetoric is just a ploy to get our NATO allies, who habitually underspend on defense and free‐​ride on America’s security guarantees, to pay more of their fair share of the burden. At the Washington Post’s Monkey Cage blog, Andrea Gilli argues this approach is unlikely to jolt NATO allies into spending more on defense, though. Among other reasons, most NATO allies “face financial and political constraints to increasing military expenditure” in part because U.S. security assurances “have freed up state funds in Europe for other priorities, including a robust system of social services.” And since cutting welfare benefits is typically a political non‐​starter, we shouldn’t necessarily expect NATO countries to boost defense spending due to Trump’s abrasive rhetoric.