2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › They Say: “Pakistan DA”
Spencer-Churchill 21 — Julian Spencer-Churchill, Associate Professor of International Relations and Director of the Canadian Centre for Strategic Studies at Concordia University (Canada), 2021 (“Embrace the Arms Race in Asia,” War on the Rocks, December 10th, Available Online at https://warontherocks.com/2021/12/embrace-the-arms-race-in-asia/, Accessed 07-18-2022)
There is a lot of concern that the rapid build-up in Asia of Chinese and American military power will make war more likely, and that such a war between nuclear-armed powers will be hugely destructive. In this view, arms races are wasteful tragedies that unfold when adversaries fail to negotiate security at a cheaper level of expenditures. Warnings about arms races are also used by concerned anti-war groups, and by China as part of its public diplomacy campaign. For example, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesmen Zhao Lijian warned that “the US, the UK and Australia’s cooperation in nuclear submarines severely damages regional peace and stability, intensifies the arms race.”
But arms races do not cause war. Every case of war that followed an arms build-up was the consequence of the weakness of the attacked party. Any caution by the United States and its allies in equipping for war will reduce deterrence, and will set the circumstances for whether there is a decision to go to war in Beijing. It will tempt Beijing with the prospect of a successful fait accompli attack against Taiwan and its outlying islands of Kinmen, Wuqiu, Matsu, Pratas, Itu Aba, and Penghu.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › They Say: “Pakistan DA”
Arad 18 — Shimon Arad, Ph.D. Candidate at the School of Political Science at the University of Haifa (Israel), former Colonel in the Israeli Defense Forces, 2018 (“How Israel and Pakistan Can Avoid a Nuclear Showdown,” The National Interest, February 19th, Available Online at https://nationalinterest.org/feature/how-israel-pakistan-can-avoid-nuclear-showdown-24554, Accessed 07-18-2022)
The advancement of Pakistan’s nuclear-missile capabilities and Israel’s growing military ties with India are increasing their respective military relevance for each other. In the absence of formal diplomatic relations and against the backdrop of a prevailing antagonistic public dialogue, the need for an effective and discreet channel of communication between Islamabad and Jerusalem to mitigate misunderstandings and misperceptions about each other’s intentions is growing.
An Antagonistic Dialogue
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › They Say: “India and/or Israel ‘Say No’”
Patil 21 — Sameer Patil, Fellow at the International Security Studies Program at Gateway House—an Indian foreign policy think tank, former Assistant Director of the Joint Intelligence Committee at India's National Security Council Secretariat, holds a Ph.D. in International Politics from Jawaharlal Nehru University (India), 2021 (“Inserting India Into U.S.-Israel Defence Technology Cooperation,” Gateway House Paper Number 30, March, Available Online at https://www.gatewayhouse.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/DefTech_Doc-04.pdf, Accessed 07-14-2022, p. 9-13)
2. Imperative for a Trilateral Defence Technology Partnership
Despite its flourishing technological-industrial innovation base, the U.S. is now confronted with the reality that it no longer enjoys the absolute lead in many emerging technologies, especially in the defence sector such as drones, robotics, artificial intelligence (AI), and quantum computing. Its principal adversaries, China and Russia, have pursued the same set of technologies to reduce their capability gap with the U.S. and attain competitive advantage. In 2017, Russian President Vladimir Putin had declared that the country which takes the lead in AI will rule the world.3 China has identified these technologies as strategic technologies and anchored its flagship national policies such as “Made in China 2025” industrial strategy on them.4 In the Chinese Communist Party’s conception, these technologies are multi-use, which blurs the distinction between civil and military, thereby allowing the Party to utilise these technologies not just for national governance and industry, but for defence and security as well. Beijing has also joined hands with Moscow to collaborate and innovate on these technologies.5
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › They Say: “India and/or Israel ‘Say No’”
Patil 22 — Sameer Patil, Senior Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation—an independent global think tank based in India, former Fellow at the International Security Studies Program at Gateway House—an Indian foreign policy think tank, former Assistant Director of the Joint Intelligence Committee at India's National Security Council Secretariat, holds a Ph.D. in International Politics from Jawaharlal Nehru University (India), 2022 (“The deepening of India–Israel defence ties,” Observer Research Foundation, June 7th, Available Online at https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/the-deepening-of-india-israel-defence-ties/, Accessed 07-14-2022)
The Israeli Defence Minister, Benjamin Gantz, recently concluded a long-pending visit to India. Both countries decided to expand their defence cooperation during his visit, focusing on the emerging technologies. Gantz and his Indian counterpart, Rajnath Singh, signed the ‘India–Israel Vision on Defence Cooperation’ to put together a comprehensive 10-year roadmap to identify new areas of collaboration. The two ministers also exchanged a ‘Letter of Intent’ to enhance cooperation on futuristic defence technologies.
This focus on technological cooperation precedes the robust ties in the defence and security sector, spanning arms sales, military exchanges, and counterterrorism engagement. This article gives a broad overview of the bilateral defence relationship and suggests a way forward for defence technology cooperation.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › They Say: “NATO Deficit/NATO Good”
Patil 21 — Sameer Patil, Fellow at the International Security Studies Program at Gateway House—an Indian foreign policy think tank, former Assistant Director of the Joint Intelligence Committee at India's National Security Council Secretariat, holds a Ph.D. in International Politics from Jawaharlal Nehru University (India), 2021 (“Inserting India Into U.S.-Israel Defence Technology Cooperation,” Gateway House Paper Number 30, March, Available Online at https://www.gatewayhouse.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/DefTech_Doc-04.pdf, Accessed 07-14-2022, p. 25)
3. Develop a Silicon Valley-Tel Aviv-Bengaluru start-up corridor
A critical aspect of this trilateral collaboration will be a start-up corridor involving Silicon Valley, Tel Aviv and Bengaluru, which can bring together the innovation communities located in these geographies to contribute to this partnership. To enable these partnerships, a seed fund can be created by the three countries to offer initial funding to the start-ups’ ideas, even before they reach technology demonstration/prototype stage. The seed fund may take the form of a multi-year commitment from the three countries. As in the case of Israel, the military establishments can encourage the start-ups by incubating their ideas and technologies and also provide an avenue for commercialisation by being their first customers. A positive step has already been taken to lubricate the possibility: Air India has begun direct Bengaluru-San Francisco flights;88 a partnership will create the demand for Bengaluru- Tel Aviv flights as well. Academic collaborations between institutions from the three countries can be explored. Potential partners can be the Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad (India), Weizmann Institute of Science (Israel) and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (United States).89
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › They Say: “NATO Deficit/NATO Good”
Patil 21 — Sameer Patil, Fellow at the International Security Studies Program at Gateway House—an Indian foreign policy think tank, former Assistant Director of the Joint Intelligence Committee at India's National Security Council Secretariat, holds a Ph.D. in International Politics from Jawaharlal Nehru University (India), 2021 (“Shaping the Israel-India-US defense technology partnership,” The Times of Israel, June 14th, Available Online at https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/shaping-the-israel-india-us-defense-technology-partnership/, Accessed 07-14-2022)
Israel-India defense ties have flourished since establishing formal diplomatic relations in 1992. In July 2017, Narendra Modi became the first-ever Indian Prime Minister to visit Israel, signaling a full normalization of the relationship. During Modi’s visit, the bilateral ties were upgraded to a strategic partnership. A core element of this relationship is robust defense cooperation.
There is an opportunity to take this bilateral cooperation forward and expand it to a trilateral one by shaping a start-up collaboration between India, Israel and the US. Such a potential collaboration can focus on emerging technologies like robotics, artificial intelligence (AI), and quantum computing. This collaboration will build on the national technological priorities of these three like-minded, tech-savvy democracies.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › They Say: “NATO Deficit/NATO Good”
Patil 21 — Sameer Patil, Fellow at the International Security Studies Program at Gateway House—an Indian foreign policy think tank, former Assistant Director of the Joint Intelligence Committee at India's National Security Council Secretariat, holds a Ph.D. in International Politics from Jawaharlal Nehru University (India), 2021 (“Inserting India Into U.S.-Israel Defence Technology Cooperation,” Gateway House Paper Number 30, March, Available Online at https://www.gatewayhouse.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/DefTech_Doc-04.pdf, Accessed 07-14-2022, p. 15-23)
3. Capitalising on Defence Innovation and a Start-Up Ecosystem
Collaborating and building on defence innovation capabilities is key to achieving a long-term advantage in defence research and development. Therefore, to develop an India-Israel-U.S. defence technology partnership, the necessary starting point must be the existing defence innovation bases or start-up ecosystems in Israel and the U.S. These have provided the required technological capabilities to their respective militaries for years. India too has begun to harness the potential of the start-up ecosystem as part of its broader efforts to achieve self-reliance in defence.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP › 1NC — Trilateral Israel-India-U.S. CP
Patil 21 — Sameer Patil, Fellow at the International Security Studies Program at Gateway House—an Indian foreign policy think tank, former Assistant Director of the Joint Intelligence Committee at India's National Security Council Secretariat, holds a Ph.D. in International Politics from Jawaharlal Nehru University (India), 2021 (“India, United States, Israel Should Pursue a Defense Innovation Triad,” National Defense Magazine, December 10th, Available Online at https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2021/12/10/india-united-states-israel-should-pursue-a-defense-innovation-triad, Accessed 07-14-2022)
The United States and India on Sept. 3 signed an agreement to co-develop air-launched unmanned aerial vehicles as part of the Defense Technology and Trade Initiative, a bilateral cooperation mechanism for defense trade and joint technology development. Under the agreement, the U.S. Air Force Research Laboratory will collaborate with India’s Defence Research and Development Organisation and air force for “design, development, demonstration, testing and evaluation of systems” to co-develop the UAV prototype.
Capitalizing on this agreement on air-launched UAVs, the United States and India can advance their shared defense technology goals by involving a close military partner, Israel. If these three like-minded and tech-savvy democracies join hands to bring together their defense innovation communities in Silicon Valley, Tel Aviv and Bengaluru, it will be a crucial step in materializing a new kind of trilateral defense partnership.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › They Say: “CP Doesn’t Solve Quad Credibility”
Goldberg, 22
[Jeff, director of regulatory policy at NDIA, June 24, 2022, “Quad Needs U.S. Tech to Secure Indo-Pacific”, National Defense, , accessed 7-13-2022, BB]
This list of ambitious objectives, while not exhaustive, has clear implications for U.S. industry. Not only will U.S. industrial forces be called upon to cooperate with key allies, but they are doing so with a purpose.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › They Say: “NATO Deficit/NATO Good”
Trivedi, 21
[Atman, nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s South Asia Center and has over twenty years of foreign policy and trade experience with expertise in India and the broader Asia region, “A reinvigorated Quad is becoming a key element of the new US administration’s Asia policy—just not in the way you expected.”, Atlantic Council, , accessed 7-14-2022, BB]
A reinvigorated Quad is becoming a key element of the new US administration’s Asia policy. Its members—Australia, India, Japan, and the US—convened virtually in March at the leader level. Amid multiple global crises, they wisely opted to focus on concrete ways to deliver for their people and the region. The grouping sought to prove that democracy still works, as President Biden likes to say. The Quad Leaders’ communique set the bar high: cooperation on “the defining challenges of our time.”
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › They Say: “NATO Deficit/NATO Good”
Goldberg, 22
[Jeff, director of regulatory policy at NDIA, June 24, 2022, “Quad Needs U.S. Tech to Secure Indo-Pacific”, National Defense, , accessed 7-13-2022, BB]
Despite the protests from China, the momentum behind the Quad is accelerating. Cooperation has increased, and there are talks surrounding the expansion of this arrangement to include other regional powers. What does such cooperation mean for the United States and its defense industrial base?
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › They Say: “NATO Deficit/NATO Good”
Oak, 21
[Niranjan Chandrashekhar, Research Analyst at Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, October 26, 2021, “Evolving Idea of the Quad: Emerging Technology”, Manohar Parrikar Institute For Defence Studies and Analyses, , accessed 7-13-2022, BB]
The joint statement following the Quad leaders’ virtual summit in March 2021 mentioned “critical technologies” three times. The leaders resolved that the Quad “will begin cooperation on the critical technologies of the future to ensure that innovation is consistent with a free, open, inclusive, and resilient Indo-Pacific”.11 The minilateral group also launched “a critical- and emerging-technology working group to facilitate cooperation on international standards and innovative technologies of the future”.12 Building on the spirit of technological cooperation, the Quad took a holistic view of the emerging technologies and associated issues. In the realm of 5G mobile networks, the Quad, during the first-ever in-person summit in September 2021, decided to deploy “secure, open, and transparent 5G and beyond-5G networks” from trustworthy vendors. The statement exuded confidence about coming up with the “open, standards-based 5G technology”. Individually, the Quad countries devised formal and informal policies to deny entry to untrustworthy telecom vendors.13 The leaders also announced sector-specific contact groups to develop technical standards for emerging technologies. They launched the Quad Principles on Technology Design, Development, Governance, and Use with the purpose of “guiding not only the region but the world towards responsible, open, high-standards innovation”.14
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › Quad Key To Laundry List
Oak, 21
[Niranjan Chandrashekhar, Research Analyst at Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, October 26, 2021, “Evolving Idea of the Quad: Emerging Technology”, Manohar Parrikar Institute For Defence Studies and Analyses, , accessed 7-13-2022, BB]
Over the years, the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (Quad) has expanded its agenda to adapt itself to face the gen-next threats in the Indo-Pacific, most notably the emerging technology. The Quad was created as an ad hoc group to help the Indo-Pacific littoral states in the aftermath of the Tsunami in 2004. Although the first iteration of the Quad in 2007 was short-lived, the latest iteration promises that Quad is here to stay for decades to come. This inference can be reached based on the expansive agenda that the Quad has drawn for itself, which looks beyond narrow security calculations in the region. The first in-person summit of the Quad leaders delved upon not only the security situation in the Indo-Pacific but also multiple areas, including the supply of COVID-19 vaccines, climate crisis, terrorism and emerging technology. By making the emerging technology one of the cornerstones of the grouping, the Quad has shown its resilience to stay relevant in the fast-changing strategic environment of the Indo-Pacific. Therefore, it is pertinent to look at the evolution of the second iteration of the Quad and how the minilateral is seamlessly synergising technology with its original agenda of security.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › Quad Key To Vaccines
Lakshmi Supriya, PhD ’21, April 19, Author of the book under review: Eleftherios Phedias Diamandis, is a Greek Cypriot-Canadian biochemist who specializes in clinical chemistry. He is Professor & Head of Clinical Biochemistry in the Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology at the University of Toronto in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. He is also Division Head of Clinical Biochemistry at Mount Sinai Hospital and Biochemist-in-Chief at the University Health Network, located in Toronto, “Humans versus viruses - Can we avoid extinction in near future?” NEWS MEDICAL LIFE SCIENCES, https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210419/Humans-versus-viruses-Can-we-avoid-extinction-in-near-future.aspx
Although we are made up of human cells, we have almost ten times that of bacteria just in our guts and more on our skin. These microbes not only affect locally but also affect the entire body. There is a balance between the good and bad bacteria, and any change in the environment may cause this balance to shift, especially on the skin, the consequences of which are unknown.
Although most bacteria on and inside of us are harmless, gut bacteria can also have viruses. If viruses don’t kill the bacteria immediately, they can incorporate into the bacterial genome and stay latent for a long time until reactivation by environmental factors, when they can become pathogenic. They can also escape from the gut and enter other organs or the bloodstream. Bacteria can then use these viruses to kill other bacteria or help them evolve to more virulent strains.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › Quad Key To Vaccines
Timothy Huzar, 21. [Timothy J. Huzar is an interdisciplinary scholar whose work explores philosophical issues around politics, violence, narration, and care. "Scientists call for ‘pan-virus vaccines’ to prevent next pandemic," Medical news Today, https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/scientists-call-for-pan-virus-vaccines-to-prevent-next-pandemic]//PJ
Pandemics have been increasing over the past 20 years. The swift development of SARS-CoV-2 vaccines was in part due to the structure of the virus. Future viruses that could cause pandemics may be more “evasion-strong.” Investing in the development of vaccines that can respond to a wide variety of virus mutations is key to preparedness, scientists argue. Scientists from the Scripps Research Institute in San Diego, CA, have published a commentary arguing that governments should invest in new vaccine technology to help in the fight against future pandemics. In the article, which appears in the journal Nature, the experts suggest that vaccines that make use of “broadly neutralizing antibodies” could target numerous strains of a virus family, such as coronaviruses or influenza. This could offer comprehensive protection against particularly dangerous viral strains that may emerge in the future. Future pandemics The current COVID-19 pandemic is a recent example of the dangers that easily transmissible and potentially deadly viruses pose to humans. Scientists note that pandemics have been increasing over the last 20 years. Researchers suggest this is driven in part by land-use change such as deforestation and intensive farming practices. These can bring wild animals into closer proximity with humans and livestock, increasing the risk of zoonotic viruses crossing between species. And until the world’s governments respond to these underlying factors, pandemics will pose a significant risk. ‘Evasion-strong’ viruses However, in their new commentary, Dr. Dennis R. Burton and Dr. Eric J. Topol argue that one way of dealing with this threat is investing in vaccine technologies that can respond to a wide variety of virus types. They claim this is particularly urgent because the rapid development of SARS-CoV-2 vaccines was in part possible due to the structure of the virus. Future viruses may not be so amenable to rapid vaccine development using conventional technologies. SARS-CoV-2 has a large attachment site, through which it replicates itself within the host organism’s cells. This structural quality means it is relatively easy to develop vaccines that can stick to the virus’s attachment site, stopping it from working. SARS-CoV-2 is in this sense “evasion-lite,” meaning it does not rely on evading a person’s antibodies to proliferate but by quickly triggering the infection in a person before they have built up an immunological response. However, some viruses are more “evasion-strong.” Dr. Burton and Dr. Topol highlight HIV, which can stay hidden from a person’s immune system for years and generate a vast number of strains within the body. If a respiratory virus with these properties emerges, it will take far longer to develop an effective vaccine, while the potential effects of the virus could be far worse if allowed to develop into a pandemic. New vaccine technology To account for this, Dr. Burton and Dr. Topol argue there should be investment in research around “broadly neutralizing antibodies.” These antibodies are able to effectively respond to a variety of strains of the same virus, not just one particular strain. This means they could be valuable in responding to new mutations of a dominant virus — such as SARS-CoV-2 — as well as potentially offering protection against novel strains of particular virus families, such as coronaviruses.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › Quad Key To Vaccines
Laskar, 22
[Rezaul H., Foreign Affairs Editor at Hindustan Times, “Quad announces measures to boost vaccine partnership”, Hindustan Times, , accessed 7-15-2022, BB]
The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue or Quad on Friday announced measures to boost its vaccine partnership, including the delivery of the first batch of Quad-supported jabs in the first half of 2022 and a Covid-19 Global Action Plan to enhance coordination in recovery efforts.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › Quad Key To Disaster Response
Bose, 22
[Sohini, Junior Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation in Kolkata and a Nonresident Fellow at the National Bureau of Asian Research, July 2, 2022, “Quad Cooperation on Disaster Management Prospects for Revitalizing the Partnership”, NBR, , accessed 7-14-2022, BB]
At its meeting in May, the Quad highlighted several previous focal points of policies and explored new initiatives, including frameworks of disaster management. This raises questions about whether the political will exists for such intergovernmental cooperation. Arsalan Ahmed spoke with Sohini Bose, a junior fellow at the Observer Research Foundation in Kolkata and a nonresident fellow at NBR, about her work on natural disaster management. She discusses how multilateral cooperation through the Quad to mitigate the threat from natural disasters can be helpful for member countries as well as the broader Indo-Pacific.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › 1NC — Quad CP
Brattberg, 13
[Erik, fellow at the School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS) at Johns Hopkins University, November 21, 2013, “The case for US military response during international disasters”, The Hill, , accessed 7-15-2022, BB]
The scale of the U.S. military’s response to the disastrous Haiyan Typhoon in the Philippines has been impressive. The deployment of USS George Washington along with other smaller vessels has allowed for the delivery of over 600 tons of relief supplies. Moreover, U.S. military transport has already moved thousands of humanitarian workers into the disaster-stricken Tacloban and airlifted almost 5,000 survivors into safety.
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › 1NC — Quad CP
Bose, 22
[Sohini, Junior Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation in Kolkata and a Nonresident Fellow at the National Bureau of Asian Research, July 2, 2022, “Quad Cooperation on Disaster Management Prospects for Revitalizing the Partnership”, NBR, , accessed 7-14-2022, BB]
Do disaster management agencies in Quad member states communicate and share information to improve each other’s disaster preparedness, and how effective has this been in reducing damage?
2022
SDI
Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Quad CP › 1NC — Quad CP
Ranhotra, 22
[Sanbeer Singh, political researcher for TFIGlobal, April 3, 2022, “NATO attempts to undermine India and Quad in the Indo-Pacific”, TFIGlobal, , accessed 7-13-2022, BB]
NATO is a shady organization. First, it expanded eastward in Europe – breaking all promises made to the former Soviet Union that it will never do so, and now, it is looking to make an entry into the Indo Pacific. Mind you, NATO would have been welcomed with wide arms to the region had it not been playing its dirty games against select countries. However, at the behest of the Biden administration, NATO is looking to undercut the influence of India in this crucial region. New Delhi will not tolerate this.