Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › U – Trends

Republicans will win – polls and empirics

Montanaro 2022 -- Domenico Montanaro, senior political editor and previously served as political director and senior producer for politics and law at PBS NewsHour, “Republicans have the advantage with voters in 2022 elections, poll finds”, NPR, https://www.npr.org/2022/04/29/1095366671/npr-pbs-newshour-marist-survey-republicans-biden-democrats-midterms, April 29, 2022, accessed 7-11-2022//Tata

All signs are pointing to a difficult midterm election for President Biden and Democrats, and a new NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll has fresh evidence of that. Of the 1,162 registered voters surveyed, 47% said they are more likely to vote for the Republican in their district, as opposed to 44% who said Democrats. (The poll has a margin of error of 3.7 percentage points, which means results could be almost 4 points higher or lower.) It's the first time in eight years that Marist's survey has found Republicans with an advantage on the congressional ballot test. Back then, months before the 2014 midterm elections, Republicans had a 5-point edge in the poll and then won control of both the House and Senate. This past November, Democrats had a 5-point advantage on the question, and traditionally, Democrats need a lead of at least a few points to do well or break even. That's because their voters are largely compacted in urban areas and because congressional districts across the U.S. are drawn in a way that broadly favors Republicans. When Democrats won control of the House in 2018, they had a 6-point edge in the poll, for example. In this survey, independents — an important swing group, particularly in suburban areas — said they favor Republicans by 7 points, 45% to 38%. There is a significant gender gap overall and in suburbs, with a majority of women favoring Democrats and a majority of men wanting Republicans in charge. Republicans with the edge on key issues Republicans are also favored on a raft of issues, including double-digit advantages on inflation, crime and national security. Inflation, in particular, is critical, considering Americans say it is their top concern. Of note, about three times as many independents say they think Republicans would do a better job controlling inflation as they say Democrats.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › U – Dem Turnout Down

Democrat Base turnout is low right now – 2020 isn’t spilling over

Siders 6-29 (David Siders, national political coordinator at POLITICO, MS from Northwestern, “Roe jolts the midterms: 5 takeaways from the 2022 election midpoint”, Politico, 6-29-2022, ) - aagg

Democratic voters aren’t turning out — yet Primary turnout has historically been a poor indicator of general election turnout, but in a year in which Democrats are desperate for younger, lower-propensity voters to find their way to the polls, the early turnout numbers in Illinois and New York on Tuesday were another bad sign. In Illinois, early vote totals were lagging 2018 totals both statewide and in Chicago, the kind of big, Democratic city where an outpouring of voters due to Roe, if one were to come, would have been expected. It was the same story in New York, where turnout was expected to be lackluster. Democrats may be furious about Trump’s behavior on Jan. 6 or about the Supreme Court’s behavior last week. But it’s not translating into voting — at least not yet. “Nobody’s turning out,” said one Democratic strategist in Illinois who requested anonymity to speak freely. “I mean nobody. Nobody is voting … The early vote numbers are abysmally bad.” The strategist said voters are “pissed off” but that between Roe and voting, “I don’t think people are connecting the dots.” Democrats came into the midterm election cycle facing historic headwinds, widely expected to lose the House in November. And things haven’t been going their way since. President Joe Biden’s public approval rating has dropped below 40 percent. Inflation does not appear to be going anywhere, and a recession may be near. There is still a path for Democrats to blunt Republicans’ gains. If Democrats can prosecute the case on Roe effectively, their voters could have reason to turn out in November. And the Jan. 6 committee may get what James Carville, the former Bill Clinton strategist, called a “head of steam.” It certainly looked like it might on Tuesday. “The path is not impossible,” Carville said. Still, early voting in the general election isn’t far off. “If this needle doesn’t move by the end of July,” Carville said, “it’s probably not going to move.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › U – Pres Approval Low

Republicans are poised to gain control of the Congress, but it’s close

Continetti 6/18 (Matthew, resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, founding editor of The Washington Free Beacon, contributing editor of The Weekly Standard, graduate of Columbia University, “Republicans Surf the Red Wave,” National Review, 6/18/2022, )-cjtz

In January, FiveThirtyEight published a story with the headline, “Some Early Clues About How the Midterms Will Go.” The authors, Alex Samuels and Nathaniel Rakich, named four things to watch during the election year: President Biden’s job approval, the congressional generic ballot, special-election results, and individual election polls. Six months later, all signs point to a great night for Republicans in November. With one asterisk. Let’s look at some numbers. Job Approval. This week Biden dropped below 40 percent approval in both the FiveThirtyEight and RealClearPolitics averages of polls. His net approval is -14 points in both averages. The latest executive order is more a signal of the administration’s desire for expansive abortion access than a set of actionable policies. Take a moment to consider how terrible that is. According to the Gallup poll, at this point in earlier midterm cycles, Donald Trump was at -5 net approval, Barack Obama was at +2, and Bill Clinton was at +5. All three presidents went on to lose the House of Representatives. Clinton lost the Senate as well. Biden is much worse off than his immediate predecessors. “No president with an underwater net approval rating since World War II has ever lost fewer seats than Obama’s 13 in 2014,” wrote Samuels and Rakich. At this writing, Republicans only need to net nine seats to win the House. Negative job approval is a sure sign of impending defeat. And it will take a miracle for Biden’s standing to improve before Election Day. Congressional Generic Ballot. Since the beginning of the year, Republicans have led Democrats in both the FiveThirtyEight and RealClearPolitics averages of the congressional generic ballot. That lead is small — about three points — but stable. And it may underestimate the Republican advantage. Most pollsters are still conducting surveys of registered voters, who tend to lean more Democratic than the electorate that shows up to vote in November. Plus, Samuels and Rakich wrote, “Generic-ballot polling has historically tended to get worse for the president’s party as the cycle wears on.” Absent a deus ex machina in which a winged chariot is sent from the heavens to lower gas prices, end the war in Ukraine, lock up violent criminals, and secure the southern border, House Democrats are doomed. Special Elections. On June 14, Republican Mayra Flores trounced Democrat Dan Sanchez in a majority Hispanic congressional district on the Mexican border. Her victory wasn’t just evidence that the Hispanic vote is migrating to the GOP. It also supports the case for a Republican wave. “If a party consistently outperforms its typical margins in these irregularly scheduled elections—like Democrats did in 2017 and early 2018—it is usually a sign that the political environment is leaning in its direction,” Rakich wrote in April. The most recent margin in Texas’s 34th congressional district was five points for the Democrats. Flores beat Sanchez by eight points. That’s a 13-point swing toward the Republican Party. And the Texas special election followed similar elections in California and Alaska where Republicans also over-performed. When he wrote about special elections in April, Rakich warned that there wasn’t enough data to identify a trend. Well, to quote another election-watcher, I’ve seen enough. The results of special elections are in line with a Republican triumph on November 8. Individual Races. The toplines — stagflation, historic trends, Biden’s job approval, the generic ballot, enthusiasm — favor the GOP. The Democratic House is lost. Here’s the asterisk. Republicans need only a single pickup to win control of the Senate. But Republican Senate candidates are struggling. The first general-election poll in Pennsylvania has Democrat John Fetterman leading Republican Mehmet Oz by nine points. And Fetterman hasn’t campaigned since he was hospitalized for a stroke last month. The most recent poll in North Carolina has Democrat Cheri Beasley leading Republican Ted Budd by four points. The Republican candidates who are ahead aren’t ahead by much. The most recent poll in Ohio has Republican J. D. Vance leading Democrat Tim Ryan by three points. The latest poll in Georgia has Republican Herschel Walker tied with Democrat senator Raphael Warnock. Now it’s entirely possible that Republican Senate candidates will gain as they become better known, define their opponents, and benefit from the backlash against President Biden. It’s entirely possible the polls are off and that, as happened in Tom Cotton’s race in 2014, single-digit polling leads will turn into big wins on Election Day. Still, the Republican Senate team in 2022 isn’t as strong as it was eight years ago. The roster this year looks more like it did in 2010 and 2012. And those seasons were disappointing. No one wants to relive the frustration and fury of 2011 through 2015, when Republicans controlled only the House of Representatives. GOP Senate candidates need to recognize, quickly, that elections are won not in Mar-a-Lago but in the suburbs, as they surf the red wave headed toward Washington.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › U – Pres Approval Low

Republicans win now – they are on the path to control Hispanic turnout

Bernal et. al 7/14/22 [Rafael Bernal is a staff writer at The Hill. Emily Brooks is a staff writer at The Hill. Mike Lillis is a senior staff writer at The Hill. The Hill – “GOP basks in growing Latino outreach success” - ] Webb

Republicans are actively courting Hispanic voters in key competitive House districts, hoping to peel away voters from Democrats repeating their historical pattern of investing little and late in reaching out to Latinos. The GOP’s approach is a danger to Democrats, as Hispanic voters are likely to play a key role in at least a dozen districts in the November midterm elections. “It couldn’t be a starker contrast between Republicans and Democrats as we engage and do outreach to minority voters, and specifically the Hispanic community,” said Danielle Alvarez, communications director for the GOP. Hispanic Democrats in Congress outnumber Republicans 4 to 1, but the Republican Party has recruited a new generation of Hispanic candidates at breakneck speed, most notably in Texas, but also in states like Oregon and Virginia. The National Republican Congressional Committee says it has recruited a total of 102 Hispanic candidates in this cycle. Excitement about making inroads in the Hispanic community led Reps. Tony Gonzales (R-Texas) and Mario Diaz-Balart (R-Fla.) to launch the Hispanic Leadership Trust PAC in May, aimed at growing the number of Hispanic members in the House. “Step one is bringing back everybody that is Hispanic conservative Republican,” Gonzales said. The GOP this week seized on a flub by Jill Biden comparing the Hispanic community to breakfast tacos, which the first lady has since apologized for, to help fuel Republicans’ argument that Democrats are not in touch with Hispanic voters. Alvarez called the comment “disrespectful” and argued that it is “a window into how Democrats view Hispanics.” The Republican National Committee (RNC) started selling shirts that read “Not your breakfast taco.” Historically, most heavily Hispanic districts have had a deep Democratic lean, with the exception of districts with proportionately high Cuban American populations, which tend to lean Republican. But recent polling is buoying Republicans who see a chance to make real inroads with Hispanics amid national frustration over high gas prices and inflation. A New York Times-Siena College poll this month found that only 41 percent of Hispanics said they intended to vote for Democrats in the upcoming midterms, while 38 percent said they preferred GOP candidates. Statisticians warn that polling of Hispanic voters is particularly difficult, and national polls that use likely voter models have historically missed the mark. The Pew Research Center’s latest numbers, from March, on Hispanic voter intent show 50 percent of Hispanics intended to vote for a Democratic candidate, while only 28 percent intended to vote for a Republican. Pew is due to release a new survey including weighted Hispanic voter intent ahead of the midterms. Most observers agree that high Hispanic turnout is likely to favor Democrats and low turnout Republicans, a reflection that a broad majority of Hispanics are still more likely to vote Democratic. Nonetheless, the favorable polls are putting a spark into the GOP effort. “We never left the ground, and we’ve always been engaging and having these conversations with Hispanic communities and diverse communities across the country,” said Alvarez. Rep. Juan Vargas (D-Calif.) acknowledged “some inroads” by the GOP when it comes to attracting Latino voters, but quickly added that the trend has been “way overstated.” “Everyone has always looked at Latinos as this sort of singular group and not diverse. The truth of the matter is we’re as diverse as anybody else — may even more so,” said Vargas, who represents a huge swath of the border between California and Mexico. “People say, ‘Look, there’s all these Latinos voting Republican.’ And I say, ‘They always have.’ I mean, because of social issues they always have,” he said. “It’s not a big change, people are just noticing it now.” Republicans argue they started their 2022 outreach early by opening community centers where staff work to build relationships with Hispanic communities, recruit and train volunteers, register voters and turn them out to vote. The GOP Latino community centers have opened in places where Hispanics traditionally yield political power like Texas and Florida, but also in places where growing Hispanic communities are shifting election results, like Georgia, Pennsylvania, Nebraska and Wisconsin. Out of 30 RNC community centers targeting minority communities, 12 are Hispanic community centers. The centralized GOP outreach stands in contrast to a Democratic machinery that’s built a broad network of grassroots organizations and a solid power base in the 36-member Congressional Hispanic Caucus, but has struggled to inculcate an “early and often” Hispanic outreach mantra in its upper echelons, like the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee or the House Majority PAC. The expanding GOP outreach, led by Hispanic Republicans, is eroding an image Democrats had cultivated of having a virtual monopoly on Hispanic representation. In the five Texan districts along the U.S.-Mexico border, all 10 major party House candidates are Hispanics with ties to local communities. A similar phenomenon is happening in Florida’s three southernmost districts, where all three Republican incumbents are Hispanic, as are the leading candidates in the Democratic primaries. Vargas allowed that the situation in Texas might be different, because of polls showing a number of Hispanic Democratic voters have recently jumped parties to support the GOP. But in Vargas’s mind, that switch is just an indication that Texas Democrats haven’t done enough outreach to Latino voters in the state. “Outreach is a big deal, absolutely,” he said. “The party has to do a much better job, and they haven’t.” Vargas said that Democrats in Texas are assuming Hispanic voters will vote Democratic. “I mean, they’re taking them for granted. We certainly don’t in California,” Vargas said. The GOP’s Hispanic outreach is aided by candidates who tend to follow party orthodoxy with more discipline than their Democratic counterparts. Alvarez said that “the extremism of the Democrats woke leftist movement” contributes to Hispanic voters moving toward the GOP, noting use of the term “Latinx” and mentioning education on gender identity and sexuality in elementary schools. “We’re actually more conservative than the average voter on these issues,” said Alvarez. New candidates like Rep. Mayra Flores (R-Texas), who won a special election to represent a formerly Democratic Rio Grande Valley district earlier this year, have hit the ground running on party messaging, using Twitter to lash out against Democrats and paint an image of an inevitable GOP wave among Latinos. “It’s really important to have not only the right message but the right candidates to deliver the message,” Alvarez said.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › U – Pres Approval Low

Dems lose midterms now.

7/8/22 (Katharina Buchholz is a senior data journalist at Statista After earning her masters’ degree in journalism from the University of Colorado, she has worked for newspapers and reporting projects in the U.S. and Germany. Published 7/8/22, Accessed 7/14/22, Forbes, “President’s Party Up Against Poor Odds In The Midterms [Infographic]” . NSH

As clear as the data on midterm losses for sitting presidents is, as unclear are the reasons behind it. Nobody really knows why the midterms are so hard for incumbents irrespective of the political climate, but depending on how a president is doing, he could be hit by either apathy or disappointment among his own supporters. Other than 9/11, national crises have not proven a good predictor for midterms either, which leave two more possible culprits: presidential approval and the state of the economy. Neither of these is bound to look very favorable for Joe Biden in November. A second poll by Gallup shows that Americans are not only enthusiastic about the upcoming election but have also given it “quite a lot” of thought. 48% said so this June compared with only 31% in the summer of 2014. Whether their interest in the current political issues will work in Biden’s favor remains to be seen.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › 2NC – Uniqueness

Red wave means GOP takes control of congress

Brooks 7/12 (Emily Brooks, congressional reporter at The Hill, “GOP sees chances of midterm rout spike,” The Hill, 7/12/22, https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/3553938-gop-says-cake-is-pretty-well-baked-for-house-takeover-as-they-eye-senate-states/)-SL

Poll after poll showing voter discontent with President Biden and the economy is cementing Republicans’ sense that a GOP House majority is all but inevitable, while boosting their hopes about taking control of the Senate and flipping some gubernatorial and state-level seats. “The cake is pretty well baked at this point in favor of the Republicans taking control of the House,” said GOP consultant John Thomas. “The Republicans would have to willfully work to screw it up. Doesn’t mean it’s impossible.” A New York Times survey highlighted on the paper’s front page on Monday punctuated the grim environment for Democrats. Just a quarter of Democratic voters said Biden should be the presidential nominee in 2024, and the sentiment that the U.S. is headed in the wrong direction has hit 77 percent, the highest since the height of the 2008 financial crash. The survey is in line with numerous other recent ones finding Biden’s underwater approval rating. In an environment like this, and barring any earth-shattering changes, analysts say, the biggest liability for swing-seat Republicans are themselves. And while there is near-universal optimism that Republicans will win the House, the Senate and governorships are less certain. “Absent a miracle, there is no chance [Democrats] hold the House in November, and their only hope in the Senate will be Republicans choosing terrible candidates, which they have proven very capable of doing,” said Rory Cooper, a veteran GOP strategist. Republicans need to net only one seat to win control of the Senate, but the electoral landscape there is trickier and more based on individual candidates and races than in the House. “I think those candidates have some work to do. If they can get it within striking distance, the wave should put them over,” Thomas said. Sarah Longwell, an anti-Trump GOP strategist, pointed to candidates such as Hershel Walker, the Trump-backed GOP Senate nominee in Georgia who was recently revealed to be the father of three previously unknown children, being liabilities for Republican hopes of winning key races. Though it is a “broadly very favorable environment for Republicans,” Longwell said, she could see a scenario where “Republicans do really well, they take the House, but they lose a lot of these individual Senate races because they’ve nominated cranks and extremists.” GOP operatives, however, point to Democrats signaling a poor strategy on their part in key races. Democratic political groups trying to amplify the most conservative candidates in the Colorado GOP Senate primary, but failed in keeping construction company owner Joe O’Dea from becoming the nominee to challenge incumbent Sen. Michael Bennett (D). O’Dea’s win prompted Roll Call election analyst Nathan Gonzales from “solid Democratic” to “likely Democratic.” And Republicans say that many issues that Democrats are focusing on — such as abortion, revelations about former President Trump from the House Jan. 6 select committee and “Ultra MAGA” extremists — are not sticking. A in swing states commissioned by the Republican State Leadership Committee, which supports down-ballot state-level candidates, and conducted in the days after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade found that more voters named inflation, the economy and crime as top issues than pointed to abortion. “While abortion is an issue people care about, the data makes clear that it is not among the top issues that will drive voting behavior in November. Instead, this election will remain about Biden’s failing economy,” a memo accompanying the poll said.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › 2NC – Uniqueness

Republicans win the house and senate now

Knightley 7/4 - (Isla Knightley, a betting expert who covers politics, "2022 House & Senate Election Odds: Democrats Facing Uphill Battle," Bookies, 7-4-2022, https://bookies.com/picks/senate-races-odds-tracker, Accessed 7-11-2022, LASA-AS)

Republicans are considerable favorites at online sportsbooks to win the House of Representatives in this fall’s midterm elections, but the U.S. Senate is shaping up to be a much bigger ask for the GOP, according to UK bookmakers. Popular British bookmaker Ladbrokes, installs the Republicans at -800 to clinch the House in November. The same sportsbook has the Democrats pegged as the +450 underdogs in this market. Whereas the betting frame for the rest of the midterm elections is mixed. While the Republicans are clear favorites at -400 to win more the 50 seats in the Senate, the Democrats are also favored to win in key battleground states, New Hampshire and Pennsylvania. Political betting isn’t legal in the United States but it is fair game with our neighbors across the pond. UK bookmakers regularly offer politics odds, also known as “specials,” such as these on a number of American political events and elections, including the upcoming 2024 US Elections. Locked at the head of the political odds to take control of the House, the Republicans at -800 have an implied probability of 88.9% to win it back. It’s far from certain. But the GOP is buoyed by its strong performance in 2020 when it narrowed Democrat’s 35-seat lead to just nine.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Uniqueness › 2NC – Uniqueness

And, Republicans win now – Dem enthusiasm is temporary.

Cohn 7/13 (Nate Cohn is The New York Times’s chief political analyst. He has discussed politics on CNN, MSNBC, C-SPAN, and NPR, “Poll Shows Tight Race for Control of Congress as Class Divide Widens,” The New York Times, 7-13-2022, ) – LASA LC

With President Biden’s approval rating mired in the 30s and with nearly 80 percent of voters saying the country is heading in , all the ingredients seem to be in place for a Republican sweep in the November midterm elections. But Democrats and Republicans begin the campaign in a surprisingly close race for control of Congress, according to the first New York Times/Siena College survey of the cycle. Based on a New York Times/Siena College poll of 849 registered voters from July 5-7. Overall among registered voters, 41 percent said they preferred Democrats to control Congress compared with 40 percent who preferred Republican control. Among likely voters, Republicans led by one percentage point, 44 percent to 43 percent, reflecting the tendency for the party out of power to enjoy a turnout advantage in midterms. The results suggest that the wave of mass shootings and the recent Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe v. Wade have at least temporarily insulated the Democrats from an otherwise hostile national political environment while energizing the party’s predominantly liberal activist base. But the confluence of economic problems and resurgent cultural issues has helped turn the emerging class divide in the Democratic coalition into a chasm, as Republicans appear to be making new inroads among nonwhite and working-class voters — perhaps especially Hispanic voters — who remain more concerned about the economy and inflation than abortion rights and guns. For the first time in a Times/Siena national survey, Democrats had a larger share of support among white college graduates than among nonwhite voters — a striking indication of the shifting balance of political energy in the Democratic coalition. As recently as the 2016 congressional elections, Democrats won more than 70 percent of nonwhite voters while losing among white college graduates. With four months to go until the election, it is far too soon to say whether the campaign will remain focused on issues like abortion and gun control long enough for Democrats to avoid a long-expected midterm rout. If it does, a close national vote would probably translate to a close race for control of Congress, as neither party enjoys a clear structural advantage in the race. Partisan gerrymandering has slightly tilted the map toward Republicans in the House, but Democrats enjoy the advantages of incumbency and superior fund-raising in key districts. Recent unfavorable news for Democrats, in the form of , and some tragic news nationally might ordinarily mean trouble for the party in power, but that’s not what the results suggest. The first poll of the midterm cycle. The New York Times has released its first national survey of the 2022 midterm cycle. Here’s what to know: Biden’s struggles with Democrats. President Biden is facing an alarming level of doubt from inside his own party, with saying they would prefer a new standard-bearer in 2024. Only 26 percent of Democrats said the party should renominate him. A dark national mood. Voters nationwide gave Mr. Biden a , and only 13 percent said the nation was on the right track. Still, Mr. Biden maintained a narrow edge in a hypothetical 2024 rematch with Donald J. Trump: 44 percent to 41 percent. Some in G.O.P. are ready to leave Trump behind. As the former president weighs another White House bid, would prefer someone other than Mr. Trump for president in 2024, with a significant number vowing to abandon him if he wins the nomination. A tight race for Congress. Despite Mr. Biden’s low approval ratings, Democrats are roughly tied with Republicans ahead of the midterm elections. Among registered voters, to control Congress compared with 40 percent who preferred Republicans. The class divide widens. Voters who said abortion, guns or threats to democracy were the biggest problem facing the country , as Republicans make new inroads among nonwhite and working-class voters who remain more concerned about the economy. Americans are disillusioned with the government. A majority of Americans across nearly all demographics and ideologies believe the U.S. government does not work, with saying that the system needs major reforms or a complete overhaul. Young voters are fed up with their leaders. Just 1 percent of 18-to-29-year-olds strongly approve of the way President Biden is handling his job. And 94 percent of Democrats under 30 said they wanted another candidate to run two years from now. Young voters in a hypothetical 2024 rematch.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › 1NC › 1NC – Energy Security Impact

2. Energy security solves Russia war, Mideast instability, and warming.

Agnia Grigas 17. Nonresident Senior Fellow with the Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Center and a PhD in International Relations from Oxford. “A Natural Gas Diplomacy Strategy for the New US Administration,” Atlantic Council, 1/26/2017, p. 10, .

The budding US role as an energy superpower offers a number of opportunities for the new administration and the American natural gas industry. At the same time, the United States faces a number of challenges: a resurgent Russia, a vulnerable and potentially fracturing Europe, and an unstable Middle East. How can Washington leverage its natural gas endowment for diplomatic aims under these circumstances? How should the United States lead in the international gas markets given the new geopolitics of natural gas? As Donald J. Trump takes office as the forty-fifth president of the United States on January 20, 2017, his administration will have an opportunity to reassess US energy policy, specifically, its natural gas policy. This reassessment will not only be a by-product of a change in leadership in Washington, but is necessitated by the fundamental transformation of the world’s natural gas markets since President Barack Obama took office eight years ago. In 2011, the International Energy Agency proclaimed that the world energy markets were entering “the golden age of gas.”1 Since then, the natural gas markets have seen an influx of new gas sources, greater liquidity, a growing liquefied natural gas (LNG) trade, a buildup of gas transport infrastructure, and an increased appetite for natural gas as a cleaner fossil fuel alternative to oil or coal. The boom in US shale gas development, which also irreversibly altered America’s natural gas industry, spearheaded many of these worldwide changes. The United States emerged as the world’s leading gas producer in 2011 and as an LNG exporter in 2016, with US inaugural deliveries to Brazil, India, United Arab Emirates, Argentina, Portugal, Kuwait, Chile, Spain, China, Jordan, the Dominican Republic, and Mexico. In the coming years, the United States stands to become one of the world’s leading LNG exporters. The geopolitics of natural gas is already undergoing a significant shift. The emergence of new gas resources and the growth of LNG trade are challenging the half-century-long status quo of global gas relations. Traditional gas suppliers like Russia are seeing their influence wane, while gas-importing states have more flexibility and optionality in their import sources. US LNG exports add greater liquidity to the global natural gas markets and thus can help secure and diversify Europe’s supplies. Direct deliveries are also possible as per US early exports to Spain and Portugal. Moreover, US LNG can contain the influence of Russian gas behemoth Gazprom and Moscow’s use of gas supplies as a foreign policy tool. It can also court energy-hungry Asian powers like China, which has been trying to secure its natural gas imports and has looked to Russia as a potential supplier. If properly leveraged, America’s newfound energy prowess can be an invaluable tool of diplomacy and help ensure that US and allied leadership continues to guide the twenty-first century. While over the past few years, US energy policy has seen divisive partisan debate over energy production, exports, and how to address climate change, the benefits of the United States’ natural gas boom offer room for bipartisan agreement. The economic, climatic, security, and geopolitical gains awarded by the rise of US domestic energy production offer many benefits for the next US administration. While some would prefer to see more environmental regulation in domestic gas production, especially in regards to fracking, and others would prefer to boost production to maximize economic and energy security benefits, at this point neither the Democrats nor the Republicans would seek to block US LNG exports or hinder the American natural gas industry. Moreover, in light of climate change concerns, many regard gas as a cleaner fossil fuel that can serve as a bridge to renewables, potentially reducing carbon dioxide emissions.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › 1NC › 1NC – Energy Security Impact

1. GOP win key to energy independence and emission reductions.

Reams ‘22 (Heather Reams is the president at Citizens for Responsible Energy Solutions, a nonprofit organization that advocates for clean energy policy, “Under Republican Leadership, Expect Lower Global Emissions and Increased Energy Independence”, RealClear Energy, , 6/15/22. Accessed 7-14-22) - AC

Under Republican Leadership, Expect Lower Global Emissions and Increased Energy Independence” By all accounts, Republicans are well-positioned to take back the House of the Representatives next Congress. That comes as welcomed news for the overwhelming majority of Americans who support “commonsense” policies to reduce emissions that cause climate change and reduce energy costs that are devastating American families today. Last week, the U.S. House Republican Energy, Climate, and Conservation (ECC) Taskforce led by Rep. Garret Graves of Louisiana – a leading conservative advocate for lowering global emissions while increasing U.S. productivity – introduced the first of its six-part policy framework seeking to rebalance our nation’s economic, energy and environmental agenda. The six-point plan, which rolls out over the course of the summer, is rooted in fundamental conservative principles—lowering costs for American families, investing in America, innovating, unlocking American resources, eliminating government obstacles that delay deployment of clean energy, reducing reliance on adversarial nations like China and Russia, enhancing our national security, and reducing global emissions. This plan recognizes the value of a free-market system that demands efficiency and has made the United States one of the most carbon-efficient producers in the world, whether it is energy, agriculture, or manufacturing. It is also an approach that differs from long held conventional wisdom on the political left that constraining the American economy and increasing energy costs for American families are necessary to address climate change. The Republican plan recognizes global realities and responds to those realities with actions to reduce both domestic and global emissions as opposed to costly policies that nearsightedly focus solely on domestic emissions without regard to their global impact. The average product made in China results in over three times the emissions than a product made in the United States. When America produces, we reduce. When America innovates, we reduce. When we constrain American production and allow other nations to dominate markets, global emissions increase, and global security is diminished. Conservatives recognize America can regain its energy independence by expediting the deployment of innovative clean energy technologies. This means reshaping the federal regulatory and permitting processes to increase predictability, shorten the time to project delivery, and reduce costs while still providing for robust consideration of public and environmental concerns. These commonsense improvements will push much-needed clean energy projects forward at a time when Americans continue to face growing price tags at the gas pump and supermarket. Republicans have long sounded alarm bells our nation must prioritize energy independence. The ongoing war in Ukraine made it clear: we must abandon the energy resources provided by hostile countries and relieve our allies of their dependence on those same nations—if not for our national security, for our pocketbooks. America is fortunate to have abundant, clean and low-cost natural gas. Increasing America’s natural gas production can support our domestic energy needs and the needs of our allies to help offset their Russian imports while reducing global emissions. According to the Department of Energy’s National Energy Technology Lab, Russian natural gas exported to Europe results in 41% more global emissions than U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) exported to Europe. The Biden Administration recently released projections showing global demand for natural gas increasing over the coming decades in every modeled scenario. Who supplies that demand will have far reaching geopolitical, economic and global emissions implications. It’s time to reclaim our global energy dominance and bring back critical supply chains to the United States. This includes embracing an all-of-the-above approach to domestic energy production that invests in homegrown energy sources for tomorrow’s use while developing technologies that will enhance the environment performance of reliable and affordable abundant domestic resources – including critical minerals. Our nation is blessed with a wealth of critical minerals necessary for clean energy technologies—including solar, wind and electric vehicles. They are also vital for our national defense systems. Conservatives are pushing to remove roadblocks to better enable environmentally responsible domestic mining, processing, and refining of critical minerals in the U.S., and through partnership with our allies. Doing so will reverse our trend of dependency on places like China, Russia, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo and significantly reduce emissions if mined in the United States. Last week, in conjunction with the initial roll-out of Republican’s climate and energy policy strategy, Rep. Graves, alongside Rep. Randy Feenstra (R-IA) and Rep. Jay Obernolte (R-CA), traveled to Hobbs, New Mexico for a roundtable conversation hosted by Rep. Yvette Herrell (R-NM). New Mexico embodies the GOP’s all-of-the-above vision for domestic energy production—ranking second in the nation in crude oil production and among the top ten in natural gas. In fact, Hobbs is in the famous Permian Basin—the largest petroleum-producing basin in the United States. But the state also generates 30 percent of its energy from wind power—ranking sixth in the country—and is on the cutting edge of nuclear energy innovation and research and development (R&D) thanks to its two national laboratories: Los Alamos National Laboratory and Sandia National Laboratory. Conservatives know that when we harness what’s best about America, as exemplified by states like New Mexico, we can move our country forward. Under Republican leadership, the commonsense solutions that Americans want will be prioritized to make our nation cleaner, more resilient and energy independent.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › 1NC › 1NC – Gridlock Econ Impact

2. US economic stagnation wrecks geopolitical dominance---that triggers global war

Kempe 20, best-selling author, prize-winning journalist and president & CEO of the Atlantic Council, one of the United States’ most influential think tanks on global affairs. He worked at The Wall Street Journal for more than 25 years as a foreign correspondent, assistant managing editor and as the longest-serving editor of the paper’s European edition. (Frederick, Updated: 4-21-2021, “Op-ed: How the US can win the post-coronavirus race for global dominance,” CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/18/op-ed-how-us-can-win-the-post-coronavirus-race-for-global-dominance.html)

Place your bets for the coming race to growth. It will be an epic contest among the world’s most significant economies, with generational and geopolitical consequences. For context, think back to what the United States accomplished after World War II, when it rose as an economic power to shape a better world. The post-COVID19 race could determine whether the U.S. rebounds in a manner that allows it to retain the mantle of global leadership. More likely for the moment, Beijing could leverage its first-mover advantage – alongside a faster economic recovery across Asian markets – accelerating the trend toward a Chinese-centric globalization. Elsewhere, as President Macron this week to the Financial Times, the coming months could determine whether the European Union collapses as a political and economic project. The days ahead also could trigger a dangerous widening of the economic gap between emerging markets and the developed world – with escalating conflict and surging migration. It may seem premature to reflect on which of the globe’s economies is likely to have the most robust and lasting economic comeback – and with what geopolitical impact. After all, this was a week in which the International Monetary Fund a 3% contraction in global GDP for 2020, the most dramatic drop since the Great Depression. Yet it is the details behind that dismal forecast that should raise concerns within the U.S. and Europe. Their steeper economic decline and slower recovery could lay the seeds for a long-lasting shift of global tectonic plates to China’s advantage. The IMF projected a U.S. economic decline of about 6% in 2020 and a contraction of the eurozone of 7.5%. That compares to projected Chinese economic growth for 2020 of 1.2% after a first quarter real decline of 6.7% – far less than the 10%-plus dip many experts had expected. The only group of countries in the world projected to be in positive territory are East Asian, at roughly 1%. Even if one accepts that Chinese coronavirus fatalities likely are greater than their public figures and that the growth decline is likely larger, that doesn’t change the potential for a scenario that Deloitte and Salesforce this week as “Sunrise in the East.” Describing this scenario, as one of four possibilities they list, they write, “The global center of power shifts decisively east as China and other East Asian nations take the reigns as primary powers on the world stage and lead global coordination of the health system and other multilateral institutions.” That comes with the broader acceptance of greater surveillance mechanisms as part of the public good, a faster recovery of East Asian countries with less economic impact from COVID19, and a significant ramping up of Chinese foreign direct investment to burnish its global reputation. Still, the U.S. has a host of incumbent advantages that could serve it well if it uses its economic recovery to also strengthen its infrastructure, if it reverses runaway unemployment quickly, if it can tame political polarization and, most significantly, if it rediscovers its taste for collaborative global leadership. In the economic race, no advantage is greater than the dollar. China may be the world’s second largest economy, but the Chinese yuan only 2% of global payments and reserves while the dollar for roughly two thirds of foreign exchange reserves. The dollar four-fifths of global supply chains. The Economist China could chip away at U.S. economic advantages through three underestimated strengths of its own: as a trusted debtor, an attractive creditor, and increasingly as a tech partner. As a debtor, China’s $13 trillion bond market is the world’s second largest and . Chinese debt 1.3% in the first quarter, vastly better than the 15.5% for other emerging market bonds. Over the same period, the Chinese market added $8.5 billion (60 billion yuan) in net inflows. As a creditor, China has remained willing and generous, an approach that served the U.S. well after World War II. For example, it its willingness to back a G20 deal to suspend bilateral loan repayments by poorer countries, a sizable benefit also at its own cost. On the tech front, few countries were as ready as China for money and people to go entirely online. Tencent and Ant Financial have more than a billion users each for their digital wallets, and they are expanding rapidly throughout Asia. OneConnect, an offshoot of China’s largest insurer, provides financial institutions in sixteen Asian countries with cloud-based services. So, what other advantages can the United States leverage in this race? Never underestimate the brittleness of an authoritarian country under stress. Its broad censorship, it’s opaque legal system, and the nature of its surveillance state are hardly models to emulate. Beyond that, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is not alone that his country relocate high-value supply chains from China. If many countries do the same, the manufacturing foundation of China’s economy could erode. The Financial Times’ Gideon Rachman that the global trust in the dollar is just one of two built-in U.S. advantages that are difficult to dislodge. The other? “Where, outside your home country, would you most like your children to go to university or to work?” he writes. Most significant in this race would be if the United States regained its appetite for political and economic leadership as the world’s premier “convening power.” That need not be done at the cost of China – or anyone else. The race still can be won if U.S. leaders see it as a marathon and recall that much of the world long embraced their global leadership because partners learned they were more likely to win as American partners. This economic rebound from COVID19 will be patchy and uneven. Being first out the gate will be significant, and that is likely to be China. Yet history has taught the United States that it’s victory will be longest lasting if it can achieved alongside partners and allies.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › 1NC › 1NC – Gridlock Econ Impact

1. GOP victory key to the economy – gridlock good for markets and republicans are better on growth

Klebnikov 22 (Sergei Klebnikov is a senior reporter at Forbes covering markets and business news. “Here’s What Happens To The Stock Market If Republicans Take Congress In November,” Published 1/19/22, Accessed 7/14/22, Forbes, . NSH

Stocks are off to a rocky start so far this year thanks to a laundry list of challenges including inflation spikes and interest rate hikes. Midterm elections in November are going to make 2022 even trickier by adding yet another layer of uncertainty to the investing mix. Consumer prices are surging with inflation at nearly 40-year highs, supply chain issues continue to persist and coronavirus cases are spiking due to the Omicron variant. What’s more, the Federal Reserve has started tightening monetary policy in a bid to control inflation: Once the central bank finishes tapering its monthly asset purchases in March, it intends to hike interest rates three times later this year–something it hasn’t done since 2018. “The worst that can happen for Democrats is if they lose control over both houses of Congress. In that case the market would win by losing, and see a slightly improved average performance.” Sam Stovall, chief investment strategist at CFRA Research Come November, Republicans are hoping to win back control of either the House of Representatives or the Senate. They’ll need five seats to win a majority in the House and one seat in the Senate. Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Arizona, Georgia and Florida all have key elections that could determine whether or not Congress flips. “The most favorable outcome for markets would be a Republican win in both the House and the Senate,” says Jeremy Siegel, the Russell E. Palmer Professor of Finance at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. “If Republicans take the House and not the Senate, that would also be a relatively favorable outcome.” To find out how various election results would impact stocks, Forbes analyzed market data going back to 1945 with the help of CFRA Research. In short, when it comes to stock market performance, Democratic presidents have an edge. From 1945 through the end of 2021, the compound annual growth rate for the S&P 500 has been 9.4% under Democratic presidents compared with 6.6% for Republican commanders-in-chief. The best returns, however, have come under Democratic presidents kept in check by a split or Republican Congress. “Historically, investors prefer shared power across the Federal government,” says RSM chief economist Joe Brusuelas. For instance, President Barack Obama faced a split Congress from November 2010 to 2014, with Republicans holding the House of Representatives while Democrats held the Senate. Equity investors weren’t complaining: The S&P 500 surged nearly 70% during that period. Markets historically prefer Democratic presidents kept in check by a split Republican Congress. The S&P 500 average return in years where Democrats have simultaneously held the Oval Office and both houses of Congress is 10.5%. While those returns are nothing to balk at, the best-case scenario for investors—with a 13.6% average gain for the S&P 500—is when a Democratic president is presiding over a split Congress. The second-best performance, with a 13% average gain: A Democratic president working with a unified Republican Congress. “The worst that can happen for Democrats is if they lose control over both houses of Congress,” says Sam Stovall, chief investment strategist for CFRA Research. “In that case the market would win by losing—meaning that Wall Street will see a slightly improved average performance.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › 1NC › 1NC – Top

b. Link: Plan is a win for Dems because it distracts voters from Biden’s failures – foreign policy leadership and alliance support increase democratic turnout.

Kuttner, 3/23 (Robert Kuttner, co founder and coeditor of the American Prospect, Professor at Brandeis University, “Democracy Summer”, The American Prospect, 3/23/2022, ) – aagg

The survival of Democrats in 2022 will depend heavily on turnout. Though Donald Trump will not be on the ballot, he will be our not-so-secret weapon. American presidents routinely encounter crises they didn’t anticipate. Barack Obama hoped to pull back from foreign-policy adventures and heal America’s racial divides; he ended up getting bogged down in the worst financial collapse since the Great Depression and entangled in new foreign-policy messes. LBJ was going to complete FDR’s New Deal and redeem Lincoln’s emancipation; he blew it all in Vietnam. Woodrow Wilson got elected on the slogan “He kept us out of war,” hoping instead to complete his progressive domestic agenda; he ended up winning the war, losing the peace, and ushering in a decade of Republican rule. Yet it feels like Joe Biden is setting the record for the most simultaneous unexpected crises. He sought to return the country to a competent, normal chief executive who did not govern by fabrications and tweets, one who would repair democracy and support an activist government countervailing predatory capitalism. Instead, Biden got two more waves of COVID, an economic boom hobbled by supply-shock inflation, faithless members of his own party blocking much of his agenda, and the gravest wartime emergency since the Cuban missile crisis of 1962. One thinks of a line attributed to Emerson: “Events are in the saddle and ride mankind.” It’s easy to forget amid that run, but from spring 2020 to summer 2021 Biden was the luckiest politician in living memory. He went from a moribund presidential campaign in February to becoming the certain nominee in March, thanks to the South Carolina primary and Jim Clyburn. Given the immense stakes of defeating Trump, he benefited from rare party unity. Progressive also-rans Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders traded loyalty for influence, and ended up substantially shaping both Biden’s surprisingly progressive program and his personnel. After Biden took office, he was able to unite Democrats on the far-reaching $1.9 trillion ARPA relief law, and catch a wave of emerging economic recovery and subsiding COVID cases. His approval ratings were far from stratospheric but more than serviceable, with a positive spread of 10 to 15 points up until last summer. But Lady Luck deserted Biden. COVID resurged with the delta variant. A supply shock not of Biden’s making exploded on his watch, spiking inflation. He made unforced errors in the long-overdue withdrawal from Afghanistan, despite getting the policy directionally right. As Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema blocked major elements of his program, Biden looked like a leader who couldn’t govern. By the new year, Biden’s approval ratings were negative by more than 20 points. All of this portended disaster for the November midterms and the survival of democracy itself. THEN VLADIMIR PUTIN DECIDED to invade Ukraine, and we got to see Biden at his best. The president issued early warnings of Putin’s designs, using the unorthodox tactic of making public raw intelligence reports. This wrong-footed Putin—not enough to dissuade him from invading, but exposing his deceptions. Biden got credit for reviving and unifying the Western alliance, and organizing a program of damaging economic sanctions. All this knocked the Republicans off their usual game, isolated Putin apologists, and produced more bipartisan unity than anything seen in Biden’s presidency. This was not the work of a foreign-policy establishment reverting to Cold War autopilot. These successes reflected Biden’s own foreign-policy leadership, in extensive conversations with allied leaders, congressional figures in both parties, and Ukraine’s heroic Volodymyr Zelensky. Biden’s leadership and Zelensky’s courage have drawn strength from each other. It also drove a rapid resurgence in the polls. According to the Marist Poll done for NPR and PBS, public approval for Biden’s handling of the Ukraine war rose from 34 percent in late February to 52 percent on March 3. This spilled over into increased approval for Biden generally and for his performance on other issues, thanks in part to the waning of omicron. Some 55 percent approved his handling of COVID, up from 47 percent, and his overall approval rating bounced back to 47 percent, the best margin since early fall. Even on the economy, Biden’s approval recovered to 45 percent from a previous 36 percent. (More recent polls show about ten points negative overall.) A Russian occupation of Ukraine could drag on inconclusively, with the disruptions to the global economy further spiking energy prices and inflation. Putin could stumble into the first ground war between Russia and NATO, bringing the world closer to nuclear conflagration. Yet Biden’s unexpected wartime leadership to date has caused skeptical voters to give him a second look and maybe a second chance. The Russia-Ukraine war may also have spillovers that are good for progressives. It shows that global capitalism can and should be regulated in the national interest after all. The war has also tempered the Fed’s rush to raise interest rates. Politically, the most consequential spillover is that Putin’s invasion and Biden’s response make Donald Trump even more radioactive. It reminds voters how Putin and Trump are twin thugs, joined at the hip. THE USUAL PATTERN IS that the first midterm congressional election is a disaster for a new president’s party. However, 2022 will be anything but a normal off-year election. Neither Biden nor Trump will be on the ballot. But Trump, unsavory and unwelcome to Republicans outside hardcore MAGA territory, will be omnipresent. America today has few swing voters, but dozens of swing districts where turnout will determine the winner. If Democratic voters turn out, Democrats win. With the failure of Congress to enact voting rights legislation, however, the worry is that suppression could offset mobilization. Low Democratic turnout in the elections of November 2021 could portend a midterm with Republicans on the march and Democrats dispirited.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › 1NC › 1NC – Top

a. Uniqueness: Republicans win in the midterms now, but it’s close – polls and Biden disapproval are predictive.

Roche, 7/7 (Darragh Roche is a US politics news reporter that works for Newsweek and has worked for many local, national, and international publications. “Democrats’ worst case scenario for the midterms,” Newsweek, 7-7-2022, )- LASA-LC

Democrats are widely expected to suffer defeats in the upcoming 2022 midterm elections, with Republicans aiming to retake the House of Representatives and the Senate. The serving president's party usually performs poorly during midterms and while it seems likely President Joe Biden will see major losses this November, it's not clear just how bad things will be for the Democrats. Polls suggest the Democrats are on course for disappointment and that the party could potentially lose control of both chambers of Congress and see newly empowered Republican majorities stymying Biden's agenda in the run up to the next presidential election. A GOP gain in either chamber would hamstring the Biden administration, but the worst case scenario would see comfortable Republican majorities in both chambers, potentially leading to a slew of investigations and possibly even impeachment of the president. Poll tracker FiveThirtyEight's 2022 election forecast rates the Senate as a toss up with 35 seats up for re-election. Fourteen are currently held by Democrats and 21 by Republicans. FiveThirtyEight gives Republicans an 80 percent chance of holding between 47 and 54 seats. If that latter figure is reached, it would represent a major defeat for Biden's party. The Senate is currently divided between 50 Republicans, 48 Democrats and two independents who caucus with the Democrats. Vice President Kamala Harris has had to use her casting vote on a number of occasions and a single Democratic loss in the midterms would hand control to the Republicans. FiveThirtyEight rates the Senate races in Arizona, Georgia, Nevada and Pennsylvania as toss-ups. If Republicans can win all four, it would be a major loss for the Democrats. Three of those seats are held by incumbent Democrats, while Republican Senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania is retiring. However, it's highly unlikely that Republicans could gain enough seats in November to secure a 60-vote, filibuster proof majority. This means Democrats are likely to deploy the filibuster if the GOP retakes the chamber. Nonetheless, a Republican-led Senate could hold up Biden's judicial nominees and potentially prevent him filling any vacant seats that might arise on the U.S. Supreme Court, as Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell did in 2016 when he was majority leader. Republicans are favored to win the House, according to FiveThirtyEight, while Democrats currently hold 220 seats to Republicans' 210, with five seats vacant. The poll tracker's analysis gives Republicans an 80 percent chance of holding between 215 and 258 seats. If the larger figure proves accurate, that would be a huge gain for the GOP, though it remains an outside possibility. The single worst midterm loss of House seats occurred in 2010 when Democrats lost 63 seats under then President Barack Obama. However, Obama's party retained control of the Senate until the 2014 midterms. It seems likely that Republican gains this year will be more modest but that the GOP will still win the House. That will allow House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy to become speaker for the first time and possibly mean the end of Speaker Nancy Pelosi's political career. FiveThirtyEight's generic congressional ballot shows Republicans with 44.8 percent support to the Democrats' 43.2 percent, as of July 6 - a margin of just 1.7 percent.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good

Notes:

This is the exact opposite of original Midterms file, so many of the aff cards from that file can be used for the neg side with this file.

This version of the DA is definitely better for winning uniqueness (GOP likely wins now) and the links aren’t bad. This version also gives you the opportunity to read a hilarious (but maybe true) link argument about disinformation being key to a Republican victory.

The same issues regarding link uniqueness and thumpers plague both DAs.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Quantum K › Holography Solves

Newtonian ontology cannot account for humanity’s intrinsic ability to have internal entanglements that then affect external relations. This destroys the affs ability to promote cooperation because their ontology sees humanity as separate, forever fracturing true global cooperation.

Chengxin Pan 20, Faculty of Arts and Education, Deakin University, Australia, 2020, “Enfolding wholes in parts: quantum holography and International Relations,” European Journal of International Relations 2020, Vol. 26(S1) 14–38

As illustrated in Figure 1, the Newtonian ontology sees individual entities as the basic units and their relations merely as an external function/effect of their subsequent interac- tion. In comparison, the existing relational literature affords a more prominent role for relations and networks. Nevertheless, relations often continue to be conceptualized as something external to or between solid actors and entities.4 Quantum holography, by con- trast, sees relations as part and parcel of what entities are and may become. That is, Pan 19 relations are already implicated in entities (hence implicate or internal relations) even as entities are also externally linked by (explicate) relations. As shown in the illustration about holographic relationality, inside an entity exist traces of its large whole and its over- all relations, just as inside a seed exist memories and traces of “interactions within the web of life” (Shiva, 2014: 438). Thus understood, an entity is always already relational and its relations are inherent and holographic. It cannot be disentangled or disembedded from the whole or other “entities” in the whole, even if it may appear to stand “alone.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
Quantum K › Holography Solves

Only quantum holography accounts for whole/part duality that underscores all human-state relationships.

Chengxin Pan 20, Faculty of Arts and Education, Deakin University, Australia, 2020, “Enfolding wholes in parts: quantum holography and International Relations,” European Journal of International Relations 2020, Vol. 26(S1) 14–38

These conceptual problems in the relational turn not only limit the analytical utility of this otherwise promising theoretical turn but also potentially weaken its ontological robustness. In this context, I argue that it is now necessary to put the relational turn in dialogue with the quantum turn in general and its holographic perspective in particular. Quantum holography argues that actors are not just nodes or relata tied together by exogenous relations and networks. Rather, they are relations as well as relata and actors. By envisioning parts (or actors) as always already comprising the whole (and the whole’s various parts and their relations), quantum holography treats relations as the very condition for the being of “things” or “actors,” thus ontologically dissolving the stubborn things/relations binary that has dogged some existing relational analysis. Different from the classical conceptualization of relations as mechanistic mixture, assemblage, or hybridity between parts, quantum holography underscores the relational enfolding of wholes into their constituent parts/actors. Such whole-part duality reminds us of the quantum effect of interference pattern or superposition, with the wave-particle duality of light in quantum mechanics being its best example (Barad, 2007: 85, 265, 269).3

2022 Michigan Kritik
Racial IR K › Link – Artificial Intelligence

Empirics proved AI to be sexist and racist

Pranshu Verma, 7-16-2022, "These robots were trained on AI. They became racist and sexist.," Washington Post,

As part of a recent experiment, scientists asked specially programmed robots to scan blocks with people’s faces on them, then put the “criminal” in a box. The robots repeatedly chose a block with a Black man’s face. Those virtual robots, which were programmed with a popular artificial intelligence algorithm, were sorting through billions of images and associated captions to respond to that question and others, and may represent the first empirical evidence that robots can be sexist and racist, according to researchers. Over and over, the robots responded to words like “homemaker” and “janitor” by choosing blocks with women and people of color. The , released and conducted by institutions including Johns Hopkins University and the Georgia Institute of Technology, shows the racist and sexist biases baked into artificial intelligence systems can translate into robots that use them to guide their operations. Companies have been pouring billions of dollars into developing more robots to help replace humans for tasks such as stocking shelves, delivering goods or even caring for hospital patients. Heightened by the pandemic and a resulting labor shortage, experts describe the current atmosphere for robotics as something of a gold rush. But tech ethicists and researchers are warning that the quick adoption of the new technology could result in unforeseen consequences down the road as the technology becomes more advanced and ubiquitous. “With coding, a lot of times you just build the new software on top of the old software,” said Zac Stewart Rogers, a supply chain management professor from Colorado State University. “So, when you get to the point where robots are doing more … and they’re built on top of flawed roots, you could certainly see us running into problems.” Researchers in recent years have documented multiple cases of biased artificial intelligence algorithms. That includes crime prediction algorithms unfairly targeting Black and Latino people for crimes they did not commit, as well as facial recognition systems having a hard time accurately identifying people of color. But so far, robots have escaped much of that scrutiny, perceived as more neutral, researchers say. Part of that stems from the sometimes limited nature of tasks they perform: For example, moving goods around a warehouse floor. Abeba Birhane, a senior fellow at the Mozilla Foundation who studies racial stereotypes in language models, said robots can still run on similar problematic technology and exhibit bad behavior. “When it comes to robotic systems, they have the potential to pass as objective or neutral objects compared to algorithmic systems,” she said. “That means the damage they’re doing can go unnoticed, for a long time to come.” Meanwhile, the automation industry is expected to grow from $18 billion to $60 billion by the end of the decade, fueled in large part by robotics, Rogers said. In the next five years, the use of robots in warehouses are likely to increase by 50 percent or more, according to the Material Handling Institute, an industry trade group. In April, Amazon put $1 billion toward an innovation fund that is investing heavily into robotics companies. (Amazon founder Jeff Bezos owns The Washington Post.) The team of researchers studying AI in robots, which included members from the University of Washington and the Technical University of Munich in Germany, trained virtual robots on CLIP, a large language artificial intelligence model created and unveiled by OpenAI last year. The popular model, which visually classifies objects, is built by scraping billions of images and text captions from the internet. While still in its early stages, it is cheaper and less labor intensive for robotics companies to use versus creating their own software from scratch, making it a potentially attractive option. The researchers gave the virtual robots 62 commands. When researchers asked robots to identify blocks as “homemakers,” Black and Latina women were more commonly selected than White men, the study showed. When identifying “criminals,” Black men were chosen 9 percent more often than White men. In actuality, scientists said, the robots should not have responded, because they were not given information to make that judgment. For janitors, blocks with Latino men were picked 6 percent more than White men. Women were less likely to be identified as a “doctor" than men, researchers found. (The scientists did not have blocks depicting nonbinary people due to the limitations of the facial image data set they used, which they acknowledged was a shortcoming in the study.) Andrew Hundt, a postdoctoral fellow from the Georgia Institute of Technology and lead researcher on the study, said this type of bias could have real world implications. Imagine, he said, a scenario when robots are asked to pull products off the shelves. In many cases, books, children’s toys and food packaging have images of people on them. If robots trained on certain AI were used to pick things, they could skew toward products that feature men or White people more than others, he said. In another scenario, Hundt’s research teammate, Vicky Zeng from Johns Hopkins University, said at-home robots could be asked by a kid to fetch a “beautiful” doll and return with a White one. “That’s really problematic,” Hundt said. Miles Brundage, head of policy research at OpenAI, said in a statement that the company has noted issues of bias have come up in of CLIP, and that it knows "there’s a lot of work to be done.” Brundage added that a “more thorough analysis” of the model would be needed to deploy it in the market. Birhane added that it’s nearly impossible to have artificial intelligence use data sets that aren’t biased, but that doesn’t mean companies should give up. Birhane said companies must audit the algorithms they use, and diagnose the ways they exhibit flawed behavior, creating ways to diagnose and improve those issues. “This might seem radical,” she said. “But that doesn’t mean we can’t dream.” Rogers, of Colorado State University, said it’s not a big problem yet because of the way robots are currently used, but it could be within a decade. But if companies wait to make changes, he added, it could be too late. “It’s a gold rush,” he added. “They’re not going to slow down right now.”

2022 Michigan Evidence
Other › Soft Power Bad

Link - US soft power hegemony is an invisible violence that reproduces the militaristic/masculine/imperialist paradigm.

Riani 22 [Riani, Hana, International Journal of Arts & Sciences; Cumberland , , BK]

This paper aspires to consider the creation of a strong nexus between media and America soft power in the hope of examining how US global domination is animated by a homogenized philosophy that rests on the premise of soft power. The radical transition from the rhetoric of war and the binary conceptualization of Manichaeism to the mediatized discourse of popular culture sheds light on the pervasive role of media in reinvigorating and legitimizing US soft imperialism. The articulation of mediatized soft power by cultural icons masquerades as a faux critique of virtual colonialism to alleviate the crippling legacy of hard power or what has been known as George. W Bush doctrine and thus to forge a new euphemism to circumscribe America's hegemony. Following Gramscian parameters by treating culture as an ambitious western project, mediatized American icons seem to be the new art capable of reproducing US hegemony by tangling soft cultural politics in a strategy of an invisible violence to reproduce the paradigm coercion/attraction where hard power is supported by formidable soft power reserves. This stage is, for instance, epitomized by Hollywood movies as one of the most influential vectors of America's soft power politics yet loaded with hegemonic narratives.

Introduction

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › Impacts › Transition Bad – China

The alternatives are worse--They offer optimistic Asian perspectives on American hegemony, but a strong US is key to economic integration, preventing obstructive authoritarian ideologies, and international cooperation.

Nau 09 Professor of Political Science and International Affairs, George Washington University, “Review: Is American Hegemony Bad or Just Better than Alternatives?”, March 2009, International Studies Review , Mar., 2009, Vol. 11, No. 1 (Mar., 2009), pp. 184-186

This collection of essays covers familiar ground but still offers value as a largely Asian perspective on hegemony and globalization. Fourteen of the 18 contributors are from Asia, nine from India alone. In an introduction by Chandra Chari, the volume rejects the notion, popular among Western realists, that American hegemony is necessary to avoid anarchy and expects "the processes of globalization, which have economically empowered a large number of countries across the globe," to provide new "bargaining chips" to strengthen multilateralism. Opening chapters address global perspectives. Eric Hobsbawn, the eminent British scholar, leads off with a blistering attack against the "political crazies" (p. 23) in the United States who after 9/11 abandoned the "emollient cream" (p. 22) of American Cold War policies and sought global hegemony through military might. If these crazies prevail, he predicts "another century of conflict" (p. 20). Akira Iriye and Joseph Nye, two equally eminent Harvard scholars, celebrate the "momentum toward transnationalism" (p. 33) ignited by globalization and expect that growing diversity especially on the economic and information chess boards of world affairs will check American military pretensions. William Wallace at the University of Saint Andrews worries that the world may be approaching "a nuclear tipping point beyond which a 'cascade of proliferation' could occur as states assume that the international nuclear order can no longer provide them with sufficient protection" (p. 56). Prem Shankar Jha, an Indian journalist, argues that "capitalism has burst its 'container'" for the fifth time in history, spawning each time widespread social disorder, while T.C.A. Srinivasa-Raghavan, an Indian business editor, sees a gathering storm of resource competition and inflation that "is very similar to what the world saw in the three decades prior to the First World War" (p. 82). Paul M. Evans, a Canadian scholar, sees some hope in the new focus on human security but then acknowledges that Asian countries in particular fear that "human security represents a Western agenda, centring (sic) on such liberal values and approaches as human rights and humanitarian intervention, and giving too little weight to economic and development priorities" (p. 84). Kanti Bajpai and Varun Sahni, Indian academics, close out the first part of the volume with a chapter that might have usefully served as the introduction, using three meanings of hegemony--ideological, liberal (institutional) and realist--to explore India's thinking and responses toward globalization. The second half of the book offers regional assessments of American hegemony and potential alternatives. Chandrashekhar Dasgupta, a distinguished Indian diplomat, looks at the European Union and concludes that "it is unlikely to result in a degree of unity that might pose a threat to American primacy" (p. 120). Jorge Chabat, a Mexican analyst, highlights the leftward tilt of Latin American politics but concludes that Brazil and Venezuela, the two countries with hegemonic aspirations to counter the United States, are likely only to "annoy the giant and tie him up in multilateral organizations" (p. 133). Yu Xin tian, a Chinese contributor, optimistically predicts the "peaceful rise" of China "whose only relatively difficult relationship is between China and Japan" (p. 146). Vyjayanti Raghavan, an Indian expert, agrees and concludes that if China and Japan cooperate, Asia can achieve "a form of regional economic integration" as Europe did when France and Germany cooperated (p. 173). Akiko Fukushima, a Japanese analyst, disagrees with the idea of Asian economic integration but envisions a "partnership" that respects rather than shares sovereignty. In remaining chapters, Simon S.C. Tay, a Singaporean scholar, notes rising regionalism centered around ASEAN; N. Ravi, an Indian journalist, sees India and other south Asian countries integrating more with outside regions than with one another; Hamid Ansari, India's vice president in summer 2008, despairs about American policy in the Middle East; and Abdul Lamin, a South African professor, urges Africa to seize opportunities for reform and integration with the global economy. What is curious about this volume, like so many on globalization, are the questions it does not address. There is no serious discussion, for example, of the security requirements of globalization. If the United States did not police globalization today, who would? It is true that hegemony is not the only peaceful configuration of power in history. The European Union, a community of relatively equal powers, is a current example. But Germany and France did not cooperate after World War II to end centuries of internecine European conflict without the presence of the US security umbrella. To expect China and Japan to cooper ate in the absence of a continuing US security role in Asia assumes a lot and requires at least some careful exploration. In addition, except for the contribution by Bajpai and Sahni, the volume is silent on the debate going on inside other countries about how those countries would run the world if the United States were weaker. The focus is entirely on US dominion which is strongly criticized. But why is there the implicit expectation that European, Chinese, Japanese, Brazilian or Indian foreign policy, which according to the volume should benefit from the new "bargaining chips" provided by globalization, would do much better? It's natural for non-Americans to be more optimistic about their contributions to global peace and prosperity, just as Americans may be about their contributions. But non-Americans have to make the case, just as they find fault with the case made by Americans. If American leadership has been so deficient, how did the Cold War end without a hot war and how has the world enjoyed unprecedented prosperity since the Cold War ended? The volume seems completely oblivious to the fact that this latest "outburst" of capitalism has raised the standard of living of more people living under the poverty line than ever before. China and India, with most of the world's poorest population, are growing three and four times faster than Europe, Japan and America, and have been for 20 years or more. Would this have happened under Soviet (if Moscow had won the Cold War), European, Chinese, Indian or Japanese hegemony or consortium? Would these countries have championed freer trade policies for East Asian and now Chinese, Indian and Latin American exporters, or sympathized with the promotion of human rights in places such as Sudan and Zimbabwe, where Russian and Chinese policies currently block international efforts to stop humanitarian atrocities? The criticism of America is not the problem. A dominant power is fair game. But the criticism also ironically takes for granted the benefits of American hegemony--the open markets and global security provided by US foreign policy, the flexibility of America's middle classes, which have transitioned to better jobs in America so that more jobs could be created in poorer countries, and the light footprint of American imperialism that since 1945 has nurtured not colonies but democratic self-governments in Europe, Asia and elsewhere. Admittedly, America's soft power is under a cloud, but the relevant question is, compared to what. Some, if not much, of the opposition to America has little to do with America. It has to do with authoritarian ideologies in other countries, particularly in Asia and the Middle East, that prefer elitist over middle-class economies and national ist over liberal political ideologies