Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Gothicism › General

The combination of Gothicism and cyberpunk is a useful heuristic to challenge Anthropocene capitalism

Heise-von Der Lippe 20 is an assistant lecturer with the chair of Anglophone Literatures at the University of Tübingen, Germany. Her research focuses on the parallels between monstrous corporeality and monstrous textuality, as well as the intersections of the Gothic and critical post- humanism. Recent publications include her co-edited collections Posthuman Gothic (2017) and Literaturwissenschaften in der Krise (2018). She is one of the series editors of Challenges for the Human- ities for Narr, Tübingen. (Anya, “Gothicism” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 32, p264) //le

Recent cyberpunk narratives reflect scientific research into longevity and the possibility of overcoming the limitations of the human body. In consequence, they often foreground death as a liminal state to be overcome by technology, but in a climate of Anthropocene capitalism, they do so on a much larger scale, reflecting contemporary concerns with the death of whole populations. In these texts Gothic imagery of death, decay, and abjection is used to underline a critical point which goes beyond the vision of earlier cyberpunk texts like Blade Runner and Neuromancer. These cybergothic texts draw on critical posthumanist discussions of death as a global issue connecting north and south in a framework of institutionalized necropolitical exploitation of marginalized bodies at the hands of greedy global corporations. As Braidotti argues by drawing on Achille Mbembe’s concept of “necropolitics” (Mbembe 11), “the bodies of the empirical subjects who signify difference (woman/native/earth or natural others) have become the disposable bodies of the global economy” (Braidotti 111). Blade Runner 2049 reflects this by showing an orphanage

sweatshop in which a uniformly clad army of pale children with shaved heads disassemble used consumer electronics, presumably to recycle their components.5 The atmosphere of the scene is clearly Gothic—from the gloomy architecture of the vast space to the unsmiling children as uncanny doppelgangers. It is, clearly, not personhood which is at stake for this collective body of children, but rather the underlying question whether any of them will survive this environment, which considers their “wasted lives” (Bauman) as less valuable than the electronic trash they are sorting. Their absorption into the “integrated circuit” (Haraway 291) of production and recycling of high-tech consumer goods has certainly led to a kind of cyborgization and the dissolution of gendered markers (along with any other signs of individuality). The scene, however, presents a techno-capitalist dystopia, a bleak distortion of Haraway’s liberating cyborg myth in which the status of the superrich “depends on the material deprivation of others” (Frase) and automation technology benefits only the rich.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Gothicism › General

Gothicism and cyberpunk are compatible

Heise-von Der Lippe 20 is an assistant lecturer with the chair of Anglophone Literatures at the University of Tübingen, Germany. Her research focuses on the parallels between monstrous corporeality and monstrous textuality, as well as the intersections of the Gothic and critical post- humanism. Recent publications include her co-edited collections Posthuman Gothic (2017) and Literaturwissenschaften in der Krise (2018). She is one of the series editors of Challenges for the Human- ities for Narr, Tübingen. (Anya, “Gothicism” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 32, p264) //le

Gothic textuality, Fred Botting argues, is “[u]nstable, unfixed and ungrounded in any reality, truth or identity other than those that narratives provide, [and] there emerges a threat of sublime excess, of a new darkness of multiple and labyrinthine narratives” (181). Cyberpunk, as a more recent, but related narrative mode focusing on the celebration of a kind of “urban uncanny” (Schmeink 25) or techno-sublime, was aesthetically influenced by earlier forms. Its defining com- bination of “low life and high tech” (Ketterer 141) draws on a wide variety of conventions, mixing dystopian and science fiction (sf) elements with film noir and hard-boiled detective fiction, freely combining cybernetic high-tech elements and abject Gothic body horror with postmodern pop culture and futuristic architecture into a unique aesthetics. At the core of both the Gothic and cyberpunk lies a fascination with spaces—virtual or imagined—and the way these are shaped by and, in turn, influence cultural ideas. It would be tempting to read cyberpunk’s fascination with the imaginary architectural patterns of the urban ‘Sprawl’ (see Gibson) as simply a new take on the Gothic sublime; after all, the flickering lights and screens of late-capitalist advertising, which are integral components of cyberpunk, suggest a mere surface aesthetic. Cyberpunk texts, however, often revolve around a much deeper posthuman and ultimately quite Gothic integration of bodies and technologies, undermining and shaping our understanding of what it means to be human.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Posthumanism › General

Cyberpunk and posthumanism combine to challenge what it means to be human – new cognitive technologies can challenge health span, cognition and emotion capabilities

Julia Grillmayr 20 is a literature and cultural studies scholar as well as print and radio journalist, based in Vienna and Linz, Austria. Her postdoc project at the University of Art and Design in Linz (funded by the Austrian Science Fund FWF) investigates ‘scenario thinking’ in contemporary science fiction and futurology (see ). (Julia, “Posthumanism(s)” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 33, p273-274) //le

What contributes to cyberpunk’s ongoing importance is without question its capability to put the idea of an original human essence to the test; this applies to the cadre of Movement-era authors1 in the 1980s onwards. Cyberpunk shows bodies and minds that are constantly altered, enhanced, or perverted by bio- and nanotechnological prostheses, cognitive implants, and/or new orifices that interface with digital networks and cyberspatial domains. The definition of what it means to be human becomes slippery in cyberpunk as categories of identity, nature, and essence crumble: everything is interdependent, in flux, and defined rather by what it does than what it is. Closely linked to cyberpunk’s emergence comes the advent of what is loosely called the posthuman, a concept which focuses on the same central themes—the amalgamation of bodies and technology, brain-machine interfaces, and potential habitats for humans in virtual spaces and space colonies. Various writers, cultural theorists, and philosophers have been conceptualizing what posthuman bodies in an increasingly posthuman present and future could and should look like. It is therefore imperative to identify and differentiate the two major strands of understanding the posthuman that not only set different priorities but contradict each other in fundamental assumptions: trans- humanism and critical posthumanism.

First, transhumanism is all about transcendence. The prefix is short for ‘transitional human,’ an intermediate stage of human development into, at some future endpoint, the posthuman. Transhumanists put forth the freedom of the human individual to technologically alter their cor- poreal body—referred to as “morphological freedom” (More 4)—through prosthesis, but more often through speculative bio- and nanotechnology. In this respect, one of the main goals is the extreme postponement or even abolition of death. “Becoming posthuman,” argues Max More in “The Philosophy of Transhumanism,” “means exceeding the limitations that define the less desirable aspects of the ‘human condition’” (4). Posthuman beings would not only “no longer suffer from disease, aging, and inevitable death,” but would “have vastly greater physical capability and freedom of form” (More 4). Furthermore, More explains transhumanists “typically look to expand the range of possible future environments for posthuman life, including space coloniza- tion and the creation of rich virtual worlds” (4). Moreover, transhumanists extrapolate that new cognitive technologies will not only enhance human capabilities to think and remember, but also to feel. Nick Bostrom, one of the most prominent voices of the transhumanist movement, identifies health span, cognition, and emotion as the three areas where posthuman capacities, “greatly exceeding the maximum attainable by any current human being without recourse to new technological means,” should be developed (28–29). Together with intellectual capacity and “the capacity to remain fully healthy, active, and productive, both mentally and physically,” Bostrom

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Janelle Monáe (afrocyberpunk) › Communication

Music is an effective method of communication – Dirty Computer proves

Capetola 20 -- is an Andrew W. Mellon Engaged Scholar Initiative Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Texas at Austin. Her research mobilizes sound and vibration as analytics for studying identity formation and historicizing the recent past. She has an article on Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean” in Souls: A Critical Journal of Black Politics, Culture, and Society, is a mu- sic writer for Bitch Media, and blogs about contemporary pop and R&B on her website www. christinecapetola.com. (Christine, “Janelle Monáe”,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 30, p245) //le

To accompany the release of her new audio collection Dirty Computer (2018), Janelle Monáe released a concept film—what she refers to as an emotion picture— of the same name that son- ically and visually recounts how Jane 58721 (Janelle Monáe) and her android friends attempt to hold onto their feelings (of black solidarity, of feminist collectivity, of same-sex desire) in the wake of a white-washed ruling power that wants to render them all complacent—and emotionless— machines. In what we can call an example of ‘Afrocyberpunk,’1 Dirty Computer is Monáe’s fusion of cyberpunk visuals and 1980s pop sounds to inspire us to act in the present and build a different future than the dystopian one portrayed in the film. In so doing, Dirty Computer centers black- ness and the African diaspora as a pivot point for pushing back against the technological grip of a hyper-globalized society, and although they are considered ‘dirty computers,’ Jane and her friends utilize the technologies of black musical traditions to continuously display the ‘human’ desires for sex, love, and connectivity. For example, during the performance of “Django Jane,” Jane 58721 sits atop a throne dressed in a regal maroon suit, white shirt, black tie, white leather boots, and maroon kufi cap with gold embroidery; a cohort of black lady androids with black leather jackets and sunglasses layered atop similar outfits surround her, supporting her regal position. The group nods along as Jane raps, “Yeah, yeah, this is my palace/ Champagne in my chalice,” alluding to both the queens and kings of African history and the power of global collectivity rooted in shared experiences of blackness. The androids move their machinery along with the beat, connecting with the felt oscillations of sound that are the song’s vibrations. After lifting their arms in the air, they quickly pull them back down to their right in the fashion of a militaristic salute. Using the hard-hitting synthesizer and drum machine sounds as catalysts for movement, they invoke Janet Jackson’s “Rhythm Nation” (1989), the black pop star’s successful single on which she calls her fans to “Join voices in protest to social injustice/A generation full of courage, come with me.” For Monáe, “Django Jane” highlights how vibration is a source of identity-making that works both in conjunction with and in excess of sound to create points of connectivity that push on the limits of visual representation. Through being drawn into movement along with the oscil- lations of a sound’s vibrations, they channel the fluidity of identity formation into the project of history-making (Capetola 4).

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Janelle Monáe (afrocyberpunk) › Alt – Music

Pop music can break through discourse and everyday practices to build collectivity

Capetola 20 -- is an Andrew W. Mellon Engaged Scholar Initiative Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Texas at Austin. Her research mobilizes sound and vibration as analytics for studying identity formation and historicizing the recent past. She has an article on Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean” in Souls: A Critical Journal of Black Politics, Culture, and Society, is a mu- sic writer for Bitch Media, and blogs about contemporary pop and R&B on her website www. christinecapetola.com. (Christine, “Janelle Monáe”,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 30, p247-248) //le

The genius of Dirty Computer is that it uses pop music to visually and sonically situate histories of black suffering within a context of struggles for widening understandings of gender and sexu- ality beyond the purview of sterile and respectable whiteness. Through mapping the sounds and vibrations of pop music onto Afrocyberpunk aesthetics, Monáe emphasizes how racial minorities and androids who are categorized as ‘other’ can turn their being read as (or being) queer and gender non-normative into a mechanism for building collectivity. Both androgyny and queerness have always been part of the mix for Monáe, as evidenced by the shouts of “Queer!” during the chorus of her 2013 single “Q.U.E.E.N.” and her later confirmation that she identifies as pansexual. For example, using repurposed James Brown-styled dance moves to try to escape her jailers in the music video for “Tightrope” (2010),6 Monáe challenges the dominance of the guards’ white maleness and underscores femaleness and queerness as critical elements of black musical traditions and black life (Royster 188).

Given these intersectional interests, Dirty Computer is optimistic that pop music—i.e. poptimism— can work as a catalyst for change in the world. The emotion picture challenges the gender ste- reotypes that have been grafted onto musical genres, beginning with the assumption that pop is more ‘feminine’ than rock—and therefore the politically weaker of the two. In a 2014 op-ed, critic Saul Austerlitz bemoans that poptimism (versus rockism) favors “disco, not punk; pop, not rock; synthesizers, not guitars; the music video, not the live show,” adding that “[i]t is to privi- lege the deliriously artificial over the artificially genuine.” But rather than reinforcing the “de- liriously artificial,” Monáe mobilizes both pop and the technology of synthesizers to expose the behind-the-scenes workings of the memory erasers that keep white heterosexist patriarchy alive. In addition to challenging the black masculinist tendencies attributed to James Brown and other artists creating music at the intersections of rock and funk,7 Monáe utilizes pop music technol- ogies on Dirty Computer to accentuate how blackness is constructed by discourses and everyday practices while simultaneously using these same technologies to explore how gender and sexuality complicate notions of blackness which are still too much indebted to heteropatriarchal and het- erosexist tendencies. In other words, pop on Dirty Computer is a site where Monáe can reimagine race, gender, and sexuality.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Janelle Monáe (afrocyberpunk) › Alt – Music

We must recognize the dark side of technology and reject that in favor of solidarity

Capetola 20 -- is an Andrew W. Mellon Engaged Scholar Initiative Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Texas at Austin. Her research mobilizes sound and vibration as analytics for studying identity formation and historicizing the recent past. She has an article on Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean” in Souls: A Critical Journal of Black Politics, Culture, and Society, is a mu- sic writer for Bitch Media, and blogs about contemporary pop and R&B on her website www. christinecapetola.com. (Christine, “Janelle Monáe”,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 30, p249-250) //le

The potentiality of vibration and reclaiming technology remains tenuous through the end of Dirty Computer. Before the credits roll, it appears as if all has been lost: Zen, now a ‘beacon’ at the center, brings Jane through the end of the cleansing process. After she has been made into a beacon herself, Jane greets Ché, who has been strapped down to a table in the cleansing center awaiting processing. But following the credits, vibration—and love—appears to prevail. The soundtrack for this moment is “America,” the final track on Dirty Computer and the very song that Jane re- fused to forget while she was held captive. To the lines of “War is old, so is sex/Let’s play god, you go next,” we see Jane and Zen dragging Ché out of the center. In sync with the synthesizer chords, they place their feet one in front of the other as they move en route to their escape. After the line “Jim Crow Jesus rose again,” Jane smiles, remembering the multiple times in the emotion picture when she completed the lyrics to this line in protest—and was subsequently gassed with Nevermind in an attempt to make her forget her love for Zen (and Ché) and the possibility of a black, queer, and feminist collectivity. To the sounds of synthesizers making high-pitched 1980s synth sounds, Zen pushes open the door of the cleansing center and leads the group into the light.

It is therefore sound—and vibration—that ultimately brings the trio back into the light. As the audio track proclaims “Love me, baby/Love for me who I am” to the sounds of synthesizers that sound like church organs, Jane stares out into the camera before turning around and joining the others in their flight, letting the sounds guide her. She has not forgotten who she is—and the vibrations of the song have helped her to hold on to what those at the cleansing center have tried so forcefully to erase. In the tension between human and machine, love prevails, albeit one that does

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Janelle Monáe (afrocyberpunk) › Alt – Music

Embracing music to access different vibrations allows for challenging stereotype, critiquing history, and envisioning the future

Capetola 20 -- is an Andrew W. Mellon Engaged Scholar Initiative Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Texas at Austin. Her research mobilizes sound and vibration as analytics for studying identity formation and historicizing the recent past. She has an article on Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean” in Souls: A Critical Journal of Black Politics, Culture, and Society, is a mu- sic writer for Bitch Media, and blogs about contemporary pop and R&B on her website www. christinecapetola.com. (Christine, “Janelle Monáe”,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 30, p246) //le

As one of our most exciting and thought-provoking contemporary artists, Monáe creates her own black, queer, and feminist version of cyberpunk through interfacing her body and musical technology. In the words of Shana L. Redmond, Monáe “uses her body to critique and resituate history, including the identities produced from and within it” (394). By drawing on the music of 1980s black pop stars, Monáe places herself within a lineage of black artists who use sound to in- tervene in stereotypes of black, female, and/or queer people—and to call attention to the struggles of minoritarian subjects in America and the African diaspora. Even more important, Monáe con- tinues the trend of pushing back on visual stereotypes of black people as criminals, welfare queens, or (art) objects—a resistance that had begun with the work of MTV stalwarts such as Michael Jackson and Prince. Jackson and Prince were among the first black artists to go into heavy rota- tion on MTV and the first pop artists of any racial background to experiment with relatively new (at the time) digital synthesizer and drum machine technology. Such experimentation helped them re-humanize themselves and citizens of black communities as a whole in the face of dehumanizing images of black people circulated during Ronald Reagan’s presidency. Monáe has continued this foundational work in her own oeuvre and the sonic connections between Monáe’s Dirty Computer and 1980s black pop stars exemplify the resonances of ‘history’ in her present/future moment.

Dirty Computer partakes in the cyberpunk—and also Afrofuturistic—project of envisioning the future to reflect on the present.5 In this vein, Dirty Computer works as a reflection of how black—and female, queer, trans, and nonbinary—people continue to be objectified and policed in the 2010s. In the futuristic world of Dirty Computer, we encounter many of the same technological and political problems prevalent in today’s America. During the emotion picture’s opening, Jane narrates this dystopian setting: “They started calling us computers. People began vanishing. And the cleaning began. You were dirty if you looked different. You were dirty if you refused to live the way they dictated. You were dirty if you showed any form of opposition at all. And if you were dirty, it was only a matter of time.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Feminist-Cyberpunk › Political Cuteness – ALT?

Take back the Internet through political cuteness – solves

Yaszek 20 -- is a professor of Science Fiction Studies in the School of Literature, Media, and Com- munication at Georgia Tech, where she researches and teaches science fiction as a global language crossing centuries, continents, and cultures. Her books include The Self-Wired: Technology and Subjectivity in Contemporary American Narrative (2002/2014), Galactic Suburbia: Recovering Women’s Science Fiction (2008), and Sisters of Tomorrow: The First Women of Science Fiction (2016). Her ideas about science fiction as the premiere story form of modernity have been featured in The Washing- ton Post, Food and Wine Magazine, and USA Today and in the AMC miniseries James Cameron’s Story of Science Fiction. A past president of the Science Fiction Research Association, Yaszek currently serves as an editor for the Library of America and as a juror for the John W. Campbell and Eugie Foster Science Fiction Awards. (Lisa, “Feminist Cyberpunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 5, p39) //le

Women and other feminist-friendly people put these insights to work in both everyday practice and art. Kishonna L. Gray explains that women of color use digital technologies and social media (such as ‘Black Twitter’) to disrupt negative narratives of black femininity disseminated by the mainstream media and “to capture the uniqueness of marginalized women” (176). They perform this double operation by employing “diverse ways of speaking” and incorporating “music [...] poetry or spoken word [...] or other cultural art forms in their online lives” (187). Elsewhere, artists associated with the Cybertwee Collective propose that women and other marginalized people might take back the Internet by using tactics that have been historically devalued as “cute” or “femme”:

[F]ar too long we have succumbed to the bitter edge of the idea that power is lost in the sweet and tender... sentimentality, empathy, and being too soft should not be seen as weak- nesses [...] Our sucre sickly sweet is intentional and not just a lure or trap for passing flies, but a self-indulgent, intrapersonal biofeedback mechanism spelled in emojis and gentle selfies. (Emphasis added)

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Feminist-Cyberpunk › Timeframe (Solvency)

Revolution is a slow continuous process

Yaszek 20 -- is a professor of Science Fiction Studies in the School of Literature, Media, and Com- munication at Georgia Tech, where she researches and teaches science fiction as a global language crossing centuries, continents, and cultures. Her books include The Self-Wired: Technology and Subjectivity in Contemporary American Narrative (2002/2014), Galactic Suburbia: Recovering Women’s Science Fiction (2008), and Sisters of Tomorrow: The First Women of Science Fiction (2016). Her ideas about science fiction as the premiere story form of modernity have been featured in The Washing- ton Post, Food and Wine Magazine, and USA Today and in the AMC miniseries James Cameron’s Story of Science Fiction. A past president of the Science Fiction Research Association, Yaszek currently serves as an editor for the Library of America and as a juror for the John W. Campbell and Eugie Foster Science Fiction Awards. (Lisa, “Feminist Cyberpunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 5, p37) //le

Contemporary feminist cyberpunk’s focus on families that extend across time and space is closely connected to its emphasis on slow revolution. Chris Moriarty’s Spin series (Spin State, 2003; Spin Control, 2006; Ghost Spin, 2013) revolves around the adventures of a far-future aug- mented human and her pansexual AI lover as they negotiate the collapse of the human empire and the war between various species for control of the future; at the same time, Madeline Ashby’s Machine Dynasty series (vN, 2012; iD, 2013, reV, 2015) relates the multigenerational saga of a hybrid human-AI family that must contend with a very real religious Rapture that changes the balance of power between humans and machines on Earth. Nnedi Okorafor’s The Book of Phoenix (2015) does not provide much detail regarding the radical changes that occur between the main action of the book (set in a near-future much like our own present) and the frame narrative (which takes place in a far-future post-oil society), but the very lack of detail only underscores how long and complex the process of change can be. Such stories stand in sharp contrast to Cadigan’s Synners, where globe-spanning technological and economic networks are destroyed and rebuilt in a matter of weeks, and Hopkinson’s Brown Girl in the Ring, in which the Canadian government is destroyed and rebuilt in a matter of years. While earlier generations may have envisioned digital revolutions happening quickly because digital technologies were themselves new phenomenon, contemporary authors who have witnessed multiple generations and iterations of digital technologies treat revolution as a slow process that takes place over great spans of time and space.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Feminist-Cyberpunk › General

Cyberpunk reimagining is a useful heuristic for analyzing the structures unpinning society

Yaszek 20 -- is a professor of Science Fiction Studies in the School of Literature, Media, and Com- munication at Georgia Tech, where she researches and teaches science fiction as a global language crossing centuries, continents, and cultures. Her books include The Self-Wired: Technology and Subjectivity in Contemporary American Narrative (2002/2014), Galactic Suburbia: Recovering Women’s Science Fiction (2008), and Sisters of Tomorrow: The First Women of Science Fiction (2016). Her ideas about science fiction as the premiere story form of modernity have been featured in The Washing- ton Post, Food and Wine Magazine, and USA Today and in the AMC miniseries James Cameron’s Story of Science Fiction. A past president of the Science Fiction Research Association, Yaszek currently serves as an editor for the Library of America and as a juror for the John W. Campbell and Eugie Foster Science Fiction Awards. (Lisa, “Feminist Cyberpunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 5, p32-33) //le

Women’s interest in the organizing themes of cyberpunk—including technoscientifically induced alienation, corporate global domination, a rapacious media landscape, and the often-reckless use of new technologies to transform bodies and minds—is as old as science fiction (sf) itself. The fury experienced by Mary Shelley’s artificial human in Frankenstein (1818) when he learns that he is the throwaway product of bad science and bad parenting is every bit as charged as the electricity that an- imates him. As such, Shelley anticipates the dilemma of cyberpunk’s grifters, sex workers, and other outsiders who eventually realize that they, too, are the disposable products of a technoscientific cul- ture. As sf developed into a unique popular mode with its own creators, publishing venues, and rules for good writing, women began to explore the perils of capitalism in greater depth. For example, both Lilith Lorraine’s “Into the 28th Century” (1930) and Thea von Harbou’s Metropolis (published as a novel in 1925 and produced as a film by Fritz Lang in 1927) imagine futures where the mad science of technologically reorganizing human life for profit becomes standard practice in globe-spanning “Industrial Dictatorships”—and where women band together with each other and fringe communi- ties of “reformers, scientists, and radicals” to change the course of history (Lorraine 257).

In the 1960s and 1970s, women associated with the development of feminist sf explored sim- ilar concerns in relation to new media technologies, including television, early video games, and early computers. Feminists writing proto-cyberpunk in this era specifically envisioned “media

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Bio-Cyberpunk › AT: Perm Do Both

Biopunk cannot utilize the government or big corporations – gets co’opted

Schmeink 20 -- is the project lead at the “Science Fiction” subproject of “FutureWork,” a research network funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research. He was the inaugural pres- ident of the Gesellschaft für Fantastikforschung from 2010 to 2019 and has published extensively on science fiction and posthumanism. He is the author of Biopunk Dystopias: Genetic Engineering, Society, and Science Fiction (2016) and co-editor of Cyberpunk and Visual Culture (2018). (Lars, “Biopunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 10, p77-78) //le

Taking up the critique voiced by these artists and turning it into social activism is a loose group of DIYbio, biohackers, or biopunks (self-proclaimed) that came together around the turn of the 21st century and in “The Biopunk Manifesto” found a kind of philosophical treatise to express their

values. Meredith Patterson, author of the manifesto and a computer scientist, is seen as a leading figure in the biopunk movement and approaches biology through its connection with information technology—thus conceptually drawing a parallel between cyberpunk and biopunk, between the anti-authoritarian practices of hacking code and hacking DNA. Speaking for biopunk activism, she demands scientific research be open, free, and in the hands of the public, arguing for empow- erment through “scientific literacy” and the goal of “making the world a place that everyone can understand.” In her manifesto, she explicitly states that engineers and scientists (professional or hobbyist) need to become political actors and activists, involved in policy because both corpo- rations and politicians “wish to curtail individual freedom of inquiry.” As such, DIYbio is part of the movement toward open practices (i.e., open data, open publishing, open education, open source, and open access), and biohackers have joined with lawyers and social activists to fight, for example, against the patenting of human genomic information or against the restrictions of access to biological materials.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Bio-Cyberpunk › AT: Realism Good

Cyberpunk controls realism – the integration of technology means their theories are wrong

Tomberg 20 -- is a senior researcher of Contemporary Literature in University of Tartu, Estonia. His research focuses on science fiction, realism, utopia, and the philosophy of literature. His two monographs focus on the poetics of Science Fiction, and his essay “On the ‘Double Vision’ of Realism and SF Estrangement in William Gibson’s Bigend Trilogy” won the Science Fiction Research Association’s Pioneer Award in 2014. He is the editor of the Estonian Avant Garde mag- azine Vihik and, besides research, has written two plays. (Jaak, “Non-SF Cyberpunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 11, p81-82) //le

During the first years of the 21st century history—or, more precisely, technological development— finally seemed to have caught up with cyberpunk. The various technological phenomena and processes common to cyberpunk increasingly started to pop up in everyday reality, including virtual communication technologies, digital networking, and the emerging social media plat- forms; advances in genetic engineering and increasingly common prosthetic supplementations to the body; the mediated intimacy of historical events and the eventual emergence of cyber-war; and the overall onslaught of the society of the spectacle and the virtualization of finance capital.2 These all became more evident, more strongly felt in quotidian late-capitalist reality. In a way, several of cyberpunk’s central speculative elements seemed to have ‘bled’ straight from fiction into the everyday.

More important than the manifold materializations of cyberpunk’s particular thematic ele- ments, though, was the sheer speed and intensity of overall technoscientific developments that brought them about, and the corresponding over-accelerated pace of cultural change felt in ev- eryday life. All of a sudden, change seemed to have been the only constant of contemporary glo- balized existence. And this, in turn, posed some novel imaginative and representational problems to science fiction (sf) in general and cyberpunk in particular.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Bio-Cyberpunk › Biopunk > Cyberpunk

Biopunk overcomes the shortcomings of cyberpunk – able to challenge environmental issues

Schmeink 20 -- is the project lead at the “Science Fiction” subproject of “FutureWork,” a research network funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research. He was the inaugural pres- ident of the Gesellschaft für Fantastikforschung from 2010 to 2019 and has published extensively on science fiction and posthumanism. He is the author of Biopunk Dystopias: Genetic Engineering, Society, and Science Fiction (2016) and co-editor of Cyberpunk and Visual Culture (2018). (Lars, “Biopunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 10, p74-75) //le

As Thomas Foster has pointed out (and many of the entries in this collection further demon- strate), cyberpunk needs to be viewed as a cultural formation interacting with the posthuman: it acts as “an intervention in and inflection of a preexisting discourse, which cyberpunk signifi- cantly transformed and broadened, providing a new basis for the acceptance of posthuman ideas

in contemporary American popular culture” (Foster xiii).4 In spite of its posthuman potential, however, cyberpunk often retains a humanist subjectivity based on a position of human excep- tionalism and the underlying idea that “there is a distinctive entity identifiable as the ‘human,’ a human ‘self’” (Nayar 6). Cyberpunk, in many instances, depicts cybernetic technology as a means to enhance humans and overcome “any number of natural human limitations such as aging, death, suffering” (Philbeck 175). As a result, cyberpunk’s transhumanist concepts of cyborg enhance- ment, up to its extreme position of uploading one’s consciousness into fully realized machine bodies, are ways to allegedly free humanity from its biological limitations, or so the transhumanist arguments go. The humanist self, though, is untouched by these enhancements, transcending its bodily prison to consolidate its position of exceptionalism.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Bio-Cyberpunk › Link

Biopunk link: genetic modification is a pervasive technological invasion

Schmeink 20 -- is the project lead at the “Science Fiction” subproject of “FutureWork,” a research network funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research. He was the inaugural pres- ident of the Gesellschaft für Fantastikforschung from 2010 to 2019 and has published extensively on science fiction and posthumanism. He is the author of Biopunk Dystopias: Genetic Engineering, Society, and Science Fiction (2016) and co-editor of Cyberpunk and Visual Culture (2018). (Lars, “Biopunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 10, p73) //le

While it is not quite clear when and where the term ‘biopunk’ was first used, its heritage reflects two distinct traditions of literary science fiction (sf): that of cyberpunk, on the one hand, and that of biological sf, on the other.1 The latter, of course, is the far older tradition, with biology provid- ing a “thematic emphasis emerg[ing] very early in the development of science fiction” (Parker 35), including such foundational texts as Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) or H.G. Wells’s The Island of Doctor Moreau (1896). The thematic focus of biological sf most relevant to biopunk is genet- ics, whether genetic mutation or “the feasibility and desirability of planned genetic alteration” (Parker 35). Cyberpunk, the other tradition informing biopunk, plays directly into mainstream culture’s scientific interest in genetics and the issues “about the nature of life itself, about what it is to be human, about the future of the human race” (Reiss 13). Many of cyberpunk’s themes connect with biological sf. Bruce Sterling, for example, writes about the loss of control by governments and big corporations as technology is no longer a tool of those in power, but “visceral,” “pervasive, utterly intimate” (Preface xiii). Technology is for everyone to use and invades the minds and bodies of cyberpunk society. By extension a central theme in cyberpunk is that the borders of what consti- tutes the ‘human’ are being crossed, blurred, or erased. For example, in the documentary No Maps for These Territories (Neale 2000), Sterling reminisces upon cyberpunk’s earliest days: “We were able to make computers glamorous. [...] This was a supermodel among technologies. [...] They were going to be cute; they were going to be miniature; they would be designed; they would be ador- able. The boundaries of the human body would be crossed.” Brian McHale notes that biopunk, just as cyberpunk, is founded upon the “centrifugal self” but in terms of prominent themes ascribes to it the revision of “Gothic-horror motifs of bodily invasion and disruption” (257). What differen- tiates biopunk from cyberpunk, therefore, is that it deals with the hybridization of the human not with machinic elements but with other organisms: human, animal, bacterial, fungal, viral, and so on. In biopunk fiction, the invasion of the body is intimate and visceral as it takes place on the level of the cell, or smaller still, on the level of the nucleotides that form all living matter.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › General › Link

The idea of superheroes or superhumans links – gets commodified

Higgins* and Iung^, 20 -- * is the speculative fiction editor for the Los Angeles Review of Books. He is a tenured English faculty member at Inver Hills College in Minnesota, and his article “Toward a Cosmopolitan Science Fiction” won the 2012 SFRA Pioneer Award for excellence in scholarship. He has published in American Literature, Science Fiction Studies, Paradoxa, and Extrapolation, and his work has appeared in edited volumes such as The Cambridge History of Science Fiction 2019. In ad- dition, he serves as the Second Vice President for the International Association for the Fantastic in the Arts (IAFA). ^ is an English major at Concordia University in St. Paul, MN, and he serves as an editorial assistant for the Los Angeles Review of Books. His publications have appeared in Con- cordia’s newspaper The Sword as well as online in Talking Comics and DM du Jour. Matthew is an aspiring fiction writer with a lifelong love of comics, literature, and the arcane.. (David M., Matthew., “Comic Books,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 12, p94-95) //le

Some regard the 1990s as the beginning of a ‘post-cyberpunk’ era, or a moment when the initial ideas, images, and aesthetics of cyberpunk became a broadly recognized and shallowly commodified style (Booker and Thomas 117–18). Thomas Foster, in contrast, suggests that during the 1990s cyberpunk experienced a “sea-change into a more generalized cultural formation” that responds to and reflects diverse conditions of social, technological, and economic change much more broadly than the original close-knit cadre of cyberpunk authors were able to imag- ine (xiv). Both of these tendencies—the shallow commodification of cyberpunk style and the use of recognizable cyberpunk sensibilities to interrogate contemporary life—are present within

mainstream superhero comics during the early 1990s. As Mark Oehlert observes, various cyborg heroes had been appearing within mainstream comics since at least 1941, when Marvel created Captain America, one of the first genetically modified ‘cyborgian’ superheroes (112). Other cyborg figures—such as Iron Man (1963), Deathlok (1974), Rom (1979), Cyborg (1980), and Cable (1990)—had appeared with increasing frequency within mainstream comics since the 1970s, but it wasn’t until the early 1990s that mainstream comics truly started to explore the terrain of cyberpunk. As Daniel Martin argues, for example, the Marvel comic Spider-Man 2099 (1992–96) “deploys the themes and tropes of cyberpunk fiction in the service of a postmodern superhero nar- rative” (467). Spider-Man 2099 was the most popular of a wave of 2099 titles from Marvel (includ- ing The Punisher 2099 [1993–95], Doom 2099 [1993–96], and Ravage 2099 [1992–95]) that were set in a grim, dystopian, cyberpunk future: “[I]n 2099, your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man is a little less friendly. So is the neighborhood” (qtd. in Martin 470). As Martin shows, Spider-Man 2099 offers ambivalent portrayals of “genetic engineering, cybernetic enhancement, and artificial intelligence” and, like many other cyberpunk texts, reflects a variety of “Orientalist cultural anx- ieties and regressive gender codes” (466).

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › General › Continuous Evolution/Co-Opts

Snowcrash shows the evolution of Cyberpunk – interaction between language and code

Kilgore 20 -- currently serves as special programs coordinator for Teaching & Learning Innovation at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. He has published on cyberpunk, narrative theory, and graphic narrative. In his spare time, he maintains an online fantasy novel system, The Adasir Project (www.adasir.com). (Christopher D., “Literary Precursors,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 7, p48-49) //le

While critics point to a host of authors,2 Neal Stephenson quickly emerged as one of the most prolific and important figures associated with post-cyberpunk, particularly given the immense success of Snow Crash (1992), an influential novel that played a pivotal role in transforming lit- erary cyberpunk and popularizing post-cyberpunk. At its most basic level, Snow Crash delivers cyberpunk’s tropes of virtual spaces, techno-biological viruses, ambivalence about embodiment, and hacker heroes with a hefty dose of enthusiastic, playful irony. The novel embraces the flashy, stylish, surface-oriented features of cyberpunk, while simultaneously undermining them as al- ways already amenable to commodification. The novel’s protagonist, dubbed Hiro Protagonist, caricatures the elite hacker (anti)hero and yet still functions in traditional hacker-hero fashion, saving the world from L. Bob Rife, televangelist, oil baron, and the novel’s obligatory megaloma- niac. Finally, Stephenson’s portrayal of the near-future U.S. parodies cyberpunk’s urban sprawls

with the brilliant neon ‘loglo’ of the multinational ‘franchulates’ into which society has devolved, articulating a scathing anti-capitalist satire in the process—yet also deploying, in support of Hiro, the outsized corporate figureheads of Cosa Nostra Pizza’s Uncle Enzo and Mr. Lee of Mister Lee’s Greater Hong Kong. Snow Crash shares with the tradition of postmodernist parody the propensity toward simultaneously critiquing and embracing materialism and commodification.3 The paper- back jacket copy sums up Snow Crash’s post-cyberpunk approach in one blurb: “Cyberpunk isn’t dead—it has just (belatedly) developed a sense of humor.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › General › Continuous Evolution/Co-Opts

Capitalism coopts cyberpunk through creating marketable products – extension and revision key to evade

Kilgore 20 -- currently serves as special programs coordinator for Teaching & Learning Innovation at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. He has published on cyberpunk, narrative theory, and graphic narrative. In his spare time, he maintains an online fantasy novel system, The Adasir Project (www.adasir.com). (Christopher D., “Literary Precursors,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 7, p48) //le

By the end of the 1980s, cyberpunk risked becoming a pastiche of itself or, worse still, merely one more marketable product. As Andrew M. Butler argues in Cyberpunk, “the cutting-edge nature of cyberpunk ensured that it rapidly became a cliché: like many avant-gardes, it was obsolete as soon as the mainstream media took notice” (43). Butler’s assessment is reinforced by multiple claims that rapid commodification had effectively killed cyberpunk as the 1990s dawned.1 At the same time, cyberpunk tropes remain resilient in science fiction, giving rise to a new label— post-cyberpunk—whose short- and long-form fictions contribute to cyberpunk’s thematic arcs. In their collection Rewired: The Post-Cyberpunk Anthology, James Patrick Kelly and John Kessel explain that post-cyberpunk builds upon cyberpunk’s initial obsessions: “some writers extend them, some react against them, some take them for granted and move the basic attitudes into new territories” (x). For example, a “key insight of CP [cyberpunk], extended still further in PCP [post-cyberpunk], is that we are no longer changing technology; rather it has begun to change us” and “human values are not imprinted on the fabric of the universe because what it means to be human is always negotiable” (Kelly and Kessel x, xi). At the same time, the “punk in post- cyberpunk continues to make sense if it is pointing toward an attitude: an adversarial relationship to consensus reality” (Kelly and Kessel xii). Post-cyberpunk therefore represented an expansion of cyberpunk beyond the initial literary forms embodied by the fictions of William Gibson, Bruce Sterling, or Lewis Shiner; post-cyberpunk’s emergence in the 1990s was fostered by social milieus and climates that increasingly resembled the cyberpunk that had emerged a decade earlier but was now fast becoming quotidian reality. In particular, post-cyberpunk extends and revises core cyberpunk concerns in its handling of (dis)embodiment, online realities, networked subjectivities, and techno-biological viruses.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › General › Generic Impact

4 Impacts: cybercrime, cybogrized lifestyles, elimination of reality, abandoning of mortal “meat”

Lantham 20 --the author of Consuming Youth: Vampires, Cyborgs, and the Culture of Consumption (2002) and the editor of The Oxford Handbook of Science Fiction (2014) and Science Fiction Criticism: An Anthology of Essential Writings (2017). He was, for two decades, a senior editor of the journal Science Fiction Studies (Rob, “Literary Precursors,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 2, p8) //le

In fact, four key cyberpunk themes were foreshadowed in specific works of the New Wave era: (1) the emergence of an information economy, with all its complex impact on the social order, in particular the spread of cybercrime and forms of info-warfare; (2) the resultant hypercom- modification of culture and the attendant growth in cyborgized lifestyles; (3) the proliferation of synthetic realities, to the point that simulated experience has begun to supplant the real thing; and (4) the possibility of a transhumanist “uploading” of consciousness, allowing individuals to abandon the mortal “meat” in favor of a virtual existence as discorporate data. All of these themes are perceived as quintessentially cyberpunk, yet all were powerfully prefigured—indeed, basically crystallized—in important sf works of the 1960s and 1970s.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › General › Origin/AT: Other Cyberpunk

Cyberpunk and the New Wave era are intrinsically tied – need to incorporate previous arguments instead of breaking radically

Lantham 20 --the author of Consuming Youth: Vampires, Cyborgs, and the Culture of Consumption (2002) and the editor of The Oxford Handbook of Science Fiction (2014) and Science Fiction Criticism: An Anthology of Essential Writings (2017). He was, for two decades, a senior editor of the journal Science Fiction Studies (Rob, “Literary Precursors,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 2, p14) //le

In sum, and contra the claims of critics such as Pfeil and Bukatman, cyberpunk owes a significant debt to the New Wave era. As stories such as Brunner’s, Tiptree, Jr.’s, Galouye’s, and Silverberg’s clearly show, sf of the 1960s and 1970s had already begun to develop a number of the major pillars of the cyberpunk worldview, from the conviction that information technologies would radically reshape global society to the belief that capitalist forms of commodification and control would inevitably channel this process toward profitable ends. The biotech assault on centered subjec- tivity mounted by classic cyberpunk was also powerfully prefigured in New Wave treatments of proto-VR technologies, with their ability to project artificial environments and thus shatter and remold the perceiving self. A careful comparison of key New Wave and cyberpunk texts is likely to elicit as many similarities as differences: Even the 1960s obsession with “inner space” is echoed in Gibson’s famous evocation of cyberspace as a “consensual hallucination” (67), and the hard- boiled textures and tones of the 1980s were adumbrated in Tiptree, Jr.’s wise-cracking style and Silverberg’s cynicism. Seeing the two movements as radically opposed—or, as I put it in a previous essay, “focus[ing] on rupture at the expense of continuity” (45)—thus ignores the ways in which the sf mode actually grows and evolves: not by breaking radically with what has gone before but by adapting and refashioning past achievements into new and compelling forms.

2022 Michigan Negative
NEG › EU CP

The EU has collaborated on AI initiatives before, the counterplan solves---but the EU still has a long way to go

Andrés ’22 (Moisés, Lawyer of the Council of State , Professor of Digital Law at the Carlos III University of Madrid, “Towards legal regulation of artificial intelligence”, Published 3/14/2022, Accessed 7/13/2022, http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1870-21472021000200035#aff1)

The European Union has launched several initiatives aimed at developing a comprehensive AI strategy, including its regulation. The three key documents in this regard are the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the European Parliament’s Resolution of February 2017 on Civil Laws for Robotics, and the Ethics guidelines for trustworthy AI produced by the European Commission’s High-Level Expert Group on Artificial Intelligence (AI HLEG), a final version of which was presented in April 2019.

Although the GDPR was not aimed specifically at AI, its provisions nevertheless appear likely to have fairly drastic effects on the industry even beyond what its drafters might have intended. The GDPR extends the scope of EU data protection law to all foreign companies processing data of EU residents. The GDPR is intertwined with AI for several reasons, including that it requires a certain amount of explanation, which can be challenging with “black box” AI systems. Article 22 GDPR stipulates that: “In particular, the controller must allow for a human intervention and the right for individuals to express their point of view, to obtain further information about the decision that has been reached on the basis of this automated processing, and the right to contest this decision.” The European Parliament’s Resolution of February 2017 on Civil Laws for Robotics includes thought-provoking content, but it has not yet created binding law; instead it was merely a recommendation to the Commission for future action. Specifically, it is the preparatory document for the drafting of a Directive concerning civil-law rules on robotics. The results and a summary of this consultation were made available in a later report published in October 2017. Meanwhile, the European Parliament voted on the resolution in February 2017 to regulate the development of AI and robotics throughout the European Union. The Joint Declaration on the EU’s legislative priorities for 2018-2019 also named data protection, digital rights, and ethical standards in artificial intelligence and robotics as priorities. Taking up the European Parliament’s appeal to create binding legislation, the European Commission issued a call in March 2018 for a High-Level Expert Group on Artificial Intelligence (AI HLEG), which, according to the Commission, “will serve as the steering group for the European AI Alliance’s work, interact with other initiatives, help stimulate a multi-stakeholder dialogue, gather participants’ views and reflect them in its analysis and reports.” The work of the AI HLEG includes “propos[ing] to the Commission AI ethics guidelines, covering issues such as fairness, safety, transparency, the future of work, democracy and more broadly the impact on the application of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, including privacy and personal data protection, dignity, consumer protection and non-discrimination.” An initial version of the guidelines was published on 18 December 2018 and the experts presented their final version to the Commission in April 2019 after extensive consultation throughout the European AI Alliance. Based on fundamental rights and ethical principles, the document lists seven key requirements that relevant systems should meet in order to be trustworthy. Aiming to operationalise these requirements, an assessment list is presented to provide guidance on the requirements’ practical implementation. This assessment list will undergo a piloting process to which all interested stakeholders can participate. The objective is to then bring Europe’s ethical approach to the global stage. The Commission is opening up cooperation to all non-EU countries that are willing to share the same values. In April 2018, 25 EU countries signed a joint declaration of cooperation on AI, the terms of which included a commitment to “[e]xchange views on ethical and legal frameworks related to AI in order to ensure responsible AI deployment”. Subsequently, on 25 April 2018, the European Commission adopted a Communication on Artificial Intelligence for Europe laying down the European approach to take utmost advantage of the opportunities offered by AI and address the new corresponding challenges of AI. In 2019, the Commission developed and made available the Guidance on the interpretation of the Product Liability Directive to prepare its reform in 2020. Also, on 7 December 2018, the Commission submitted a Communication to the European Parliament, the European Council, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions entitled Coordinated Plan on Artificial Intelligence, accompanied by the Coordinated Plan on the Development and Use of Artificial Intelligence Made in Europe - 2018 prepared by Member States (as part of the Group on digitizing European industry and Artificial Intelligence), Norway, Switzerland, and the Commission. Next, on 19 February 2020, the European Commission published a White Paper aiming to foster a European ecosystem of excellence and trust in AI and a Report on the safety and liability aspects of AI. The White Paper proposes measures that will streamline research, foster collaboration between Member States and increase investment into AI development and deployment. It also proposes policy options for an imminent EU regulatory framework that would determine the types of legal requirements that would apply to relevant actors, with a particular focus on high-risk applications. Finally, on 20 October 2020, the European Parliament has approved three resolutions that analyze how the European Union understands that different matters affected by Artificial Intelligence (AI) can be regulated, while promoting innovation, ethical standards and confidence in this technology. These resolutions analyze (i) the intellectual property rights for the development of AI technologies (supporting an effective system to guarantee them and to safeguard the European patent standards); (ii) the civil liability regime in matters of AI (a regulatory framework is proposed to guarantee the strict liability of the operators of “high risk” AI systems in case of damages); and (iii) certain ethical aspects of AI, robotics and related technologies (having as a key guiding principle the human control and centrality). Despite these encouraging signs and laudable intentions, the EU’s regulatory agenda remains at a nascent stage.