Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 SDI Disadvantage
Defense Innovation DA › 1NC › LAWS 1NC

The defense industry is growing and stable now – future purchases enable increased innovation of the defense market

Mordor Intelligence, 2022 Mordor Intelligence is a fully revenue-funded organization, since our founding in 2014. To date, we have partnered with 4000+ enterprises across 20+ industries, to deliver precise data and actionable insights in over 6000 projects. Our domain-specific teams of research experts continuously track markets, providing our clients the competitive edge through high-quality market intelligence.(not that Mordor from LOTR)“US Aerospace and Defense Market - Growth, Trends, COVID-19 Impact, and Forecasts (2022 - 2027).” Mordorintelligence.com, 2022, www.mordorintelligence.com/industry-reports/us-aerospace-and-defense-market.

The US aerospace and defense market is projected to grow from USD 416.63 billion in 2020 to USD 550.78 billion, registering a CAGR of around 2.37% during the forecast period (2021-2030). The US aerospace and defense sector is undergoing an unprecedented disruption due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Although the sector is projected to recover in 2021, the recovery is expected to be uneven across the two constituent sectors. For instance, the commercial aerospace sector has been significantly affected by the pandemic, resulting in a drastic reduction in passenger traffic, which, in turn, has negatively affected aircraft demand. As a result, the commercial aerospace sector is expected to recover slowly, as travel demand is projected to normalize to pre-COVID levels by 2023. However, the defense sector is expected to remain stable and even grow as the United States has not reduced its defense budget and remains committed to sustaining its military capabilities. Nevertheless, due to the widespread disruption in the supply chain, some defense programs may face minor cost escalations and delays in the short term. The US aerospace and defense sector is one of the largest, globally, in terms of infrastructure and manufacturing activities. In 2019, the total industry sales revenue left a significant footprint on the American economy, contributing to a combined economic value of USD 396 billion, representing 1.8% of the nation’s GDP. The market is primarily driven by investments in the A&D sector and is supported by the rising demand for the products of the A&D sector by both commercial and military end-users. The market is also bolstered by the presence of leading industry incumbents in the US, whose manufacturing and R&D capabilities support the growth of the industry. Scope of the Report The study provides an in-depth analysis of the aerospace and defense industry in the United States. The scope of the study encompasses the commercial and military applications of all aerial assets. Besides, the study also accounts for the developments in the industry pertaining to critical systems and components of aircraft, UAVs, and satellites. For each segment, the market sizing and forecasts have been done based on value (USD billion). Key Market Trends Enhanced Defense Spending Promoting R&D and Manufacturing The United States is ranked as the world’s leading defense manufacturer and exporter. According to SIPRI, the US defense expenditure grew by 5.3% to amount to USD 732 billion in 2019, which is around 38% of the global defense expenditure. The US Foreign Military Sales (FMS) increased by USD 15 billion to reach USD 83.5 billion during FY2020. Besides, the US is one of the world’s largest FDI investors and the leading beneficiary of FDIs. In 2018, FDIs in the US aerospace industry totaled nearly USD 22 billion. This resulted in a significant upgrade of the manufacturing capabilities of key industry incumbents in the US. For instance, in January 2019, Airbus initiated the construction of its A220 Manufacturing Facility in Alabama. Similarly, in September 2018, Planet Labs Inc. invested around USD 183 million to open a 27,000-square-foot new satellite manufacturing and testing facility in San Francisco. In 2020, Lockheed Martin completed the construction of its USD 350 million satellite manufacturing facility, located at the company's Waterton Canyon campus near Denver. As the US envisions to retain its technological superiority over rival forces in terms of deployed platforms and weaponry in the aerial domain, a significant inflow of monetary resources is anticipated to occur during the upcoming period, thereby driving the US aerospace and defense market.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › A2: AI Timeframe too slow

Russia autonomous weapons are hype – too many technical difficulties

Gregory C. Allen, 22, (Gregory C. Allen, Gregory C. Allen is the director of the Artificial Intelligence (AI) Governance Project and a senior fellow in the Strategic Technologies Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C. Director, AI Governance Project and Senior Fellow, Strategic Technologies Program, 5-26-2022, No Publication, Russia Probably Has Not Used AI-Enabled Weapons in Ukraine, but That Could Change, https://www.csis.org/analysis/russia-probably-has-not-used-ai-enabled-weapons-ukraine-could-change, 6-27-2022) SCade

In March, WIRED ran a story with the headline “Russia's Killer Drone in Ukraine Raises Fears About AI in Warfare,” with the subtitle, “The maker of the lethal drone claims that it can identify targets using artificial intelligence.” The story focused on the KUB-BLA, a small kamikaze drone aircraft that smashes itself into enemy targets and detonates an onboard explosive. The KUB-BLA is made by ZALA Aero, a subsidiary of the Russian weapons manufacturer Kalashnikov (best known as the maker of the AK-47), which itself is partly owned by Rostec, a part of Russia’s government-owned defense-industrial complex. The WIRED story understandably attracted a lot of attention, but those who only read the sensational headline missed the article’s critical caveat: “It is unclear if the drone may have been operated in this [an AI-enabled autonomous] way in Ukraine.” Other outlets re-reported the WIRED story, but irresponsibly did so without the caveat. WIRED’s assessment that Kalashnikov claims the KUB-BLA “boasts the ability to identify targets using artificial intelligence” is based on two main pieces of evidence: a Kalashnikov press release about ZALA Aero’s “Artificial Intelligence Visual Identification (AIVI)” capabilities for its unmanned aircraft, and the original Kalashnikov press release announcing the KUB-BLA in 2019. However, these two pieces of evidence are less than they seem. The Russian-language AIVI press release never mentions the KUB-BLA or military applications. Instead, it describes a ZALA Aero machine-learning AI drone product line that is marketed to industrial and agricultural sectors. Incorporating modern machine-learning AI into military applications is significantly more difficult than in industrial or agricultural applications. Modern machine-learning AI using deep neural networks offers the opportunity for incredible gains in performance, but that performance depends on having lots of training data during development. Moreover, that training data needs to closely resemble operational conditions. In general, it is much easier to get such training data from commercial customers than from an enemy military, especially if friendly weapons systems and sensors do not often come within range of enemy ones. The most mature military AI applications are ones like satellite reconnaissance: even in peacetime, satellites get to take a lot of pictures of Russian and Chinese military forces, and those pictures can be digitally labeled by human experts to turn them into training data. Training data is what machine learning AI systems learn from. The combination of a learning algorithm and training data is how AI systems learn to recognize what is in the image. But training data is generally application-specific. Satellite image recognition training data only helps build satellite image recognition AI. One cannot magically use labeled satellite image data to train an AI for a robotic drone’s targeting computer (at least not with today’s technology). Getting enough of the right sort of training data to incorporate modern AI into, say, a robotic tank’s targeting computer, is a much tougher technical challenge. It is not impossible in principle, but in practice, there are far fewer opportunities to collect the right sort of training data.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › A2: NATO fails at AI

Standardization and new rules solves for any of NATO shortcomings – gets NATO back to innovating

Ben Wodecki, 22, (Ben Wodecki, 5-4-2022, AI Business, NATO at risk of losing AI innovation race to Russia, China, https://aibusiness.com/document.asp?doc_id=777260, 6-24-2022) SCade

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) should standardize and regulate AI to keep up with rivals, according to findings published by the U.S. think tank, Center for European Policy Analysis (CEPA). CEPA’s comments came as it published a series of AI-related recommendations for NATO amid growing geopolitical tensions with the likes of Russia, China and North Korea. Its recommendations include AI standardization, encouraging and improving AI literacy and spurring private sector innovation. Such undertakings would allow NATO allies to better scale and deploy AI – and keep pace with rivals. “These new capabilities will revolutionize NATO’s military and strategic affairs, thus strengthening NATO’s ability to fulfill its essential core tasks of collective defense, crisis management and cooperative security,” CEPA’s Nicholas Nelson and Nico Luzum wrote. The pair cited AI projects being undertaken by adversaries, including China’s attempts to develop purported mind-controllable drones and AI assistants for fighter pilots. But NATO allies have their own capabilities – including U.S.-developed autonomous tanks and British-made systems that provide ground troops with information on the surrounding terrain. The think tank’s study suggests that at present, NATO is leading the AI race – but risks losing its competitive advantage to peer competitors “competitors if allies fail to leverage the private sector, coordinate implementation and engage with the public.” CEPA suggests that NATO allies should accelerate AI adoption and actively encourage private sector innovation. “Ultimately, we hope that these recommendations enable NATO allies to better innovate, scale, deploy, and integrate AI and autonomy-based technologies to form agile, system-wide solutions.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › A2: NATO fails at AI

NATO initiatives prove they are successful at AI management

Colin Demarest, 22, (Colin Demarest, Colin Demarest is a reporter at C4ISRNET, where he covers military networks, cyber and IT. Colin previously covered the Department of Energy and its NNSA — namely Cold War cleanup and nuclear weapons development — for a daily newspaper in South Carolina. Colin is also an award-winning photographer!, 5-18-2022, Defense News, NATO launches AI initiative to ensure tech advantage, https://www.defensenews.com/artificial-intelligence/2022/05/18/nato-launches-ai-initiative-to-ensure-tech-advantage/, 6-24-2022) SCade

WASHINGTON — Two NATO agencies recently kicked off an artificial intelligence initiative to better understand the technology and its potential warfare applications. More than 80 AI experts, researchers and academics from the U.S. and other member countries are involved with the venture, known as a strategic “horizon scanning,” put together by the NATO Science and Technology Organization and the NATO Communications and Information Agency. An inaugural meeting and workshop was held this month in The Hague, Netherlands, where the NCI Agency’s data science and AI facilities are located. “AI is one of the key emerging and disruptive technologies identified by NATO as vital for the maintenance of its technological edge,” NATO Chief Scientist Bryan Wells said in a statement. “By working together, the STO and the NCI Agency are able to bring together global experts to ensure the very best scientific expertise is available to advise NATO and its allies and partners on the latest scientific trends in this area.” The NATO guarantee of a collective defense and the advantage of numbers, both on the battlefield and in the lab, has been much discussed amid Russia’s latest invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent membership applications made by Finland and Sweden. NATO ministers in October adopted the alliance’s first-ever AI strategy, which describes the capability as “changing the global defense and security environment” and offering “an unprecedented opportunity to strengthen our technological edge but will also escalate the speed of the threats we face.” The strategy emphasizes responsible use of AI for defense across six tenets: lawfulness; responsibility and accountability; explainability and traceability; reliability; governability; and bias mitigation. AI frameworks and other guidance drafted by the U.S. and its defense community take a similar approach. NATO allies in 2019 agreed to focus on seven emerging and disruptive technologies, data, computing and AI among them. Making sure there are shared standards, and that systems will work with systems, will be critical to success, officials said. “One of the big challenges when we go into this new phase of disruptive technologies is how do you keep all allies on the same hymn sheet when it comes down to communicating with each other, using the same technology, being interoperable,” David van Weel, NATO assistant secretary general for emerging security challenges, told Defense News in March 2021. “So that’s a big part [of the strategy] and a big role for NATO to play.”

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › 2AC---US Failing at AI

The US is no longer demolishing China in the race – need full NATO cooperation to outpace China

Graham Allison and Eric Schmidt, 20, (Graham Allison Eric Schmidt, 8-1-2020, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Is China Beating the U.S. to AI Supremacy?, https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/china-beating-us-ai-supremacy, 6-27-2022) SCade

The US-China Race for Artificial Intelligence Combining decades of experience advancing frontier technologies, on the one hand, and analyzing national security decisionmaking, on the other, we have been collaborating over the past year in an effort to understand the national security implications of China’s great leap forward in artificial intelligence (AI). Our purpose in this essay is to sound an alarm over China’s rapid progress and the current prospect of it overtaking the United States in applying AI in the decade ahead; to explain why AI is for the autocracy led by the Chinese Communist Party (hereafter, the “Party”) an existential priority; to identify key unanswered questions about the dangers of an unconstrained AI arms race between the two digital superpowers; and to point to the reasons why we believe that this is a race the United States can and must win. We begin with four key points. First, most Americans believe that U.S. leadership in advanced technologies is so entrenched that it is unassailable. Likewise, many in the American national security community insist that in the AI arena China can never be more than a “near-peer competitor.” Both are wrong. In fact, China stands today as a full-spectrum peer competitor of the United States in commercial and national security applications of AI. Beijing is not just trying to master AI—it is succeeding. Because AI will have as transformative an impact on commerce and national security over the next two decades as semiconductors, computers and the web have had over the past quarter century, this should be recognized as a matter of grave national concern.1,2,3 Second, China’s zeal to master AI goes far beyond its recognition that this suite of technologies promises to be the biggest driver of economic advances in the next quarter century. For the Party, AI is mission critical. The command of 1.4 billion citizens by a Party-controlled authoritarian government is a herculean challenge. Since the fall of the Soviet Union, Americans have been confident that authoritarian governments are doomed to fail—eventually. But AI offers a realistic possibility of upending this proposition. AI could give the Party not just an escape hatch from the “end of history,”4 but a claim to advance a model of governance—a national operating system—superior to today’s dysfunctional democracies. As one former Democratic presidential candidate put it: “China is using technology to perfect dictatorship.”5 It’s a value proposition that resonates with many leaders around the world. As former Google ceo Eric Schmidt has argued: “if the Soviet Union had been able to leverage the kind of sophisticated data observation, collection and analytics employed by the leaders of Amazon today, it might well have won the Cold War.” Third, while we share the general enthusiasm about AI’s potential to make huge improvements in human wellbeing, the development of machines with intelligence vastly superior to humans will pose special, perhaps even unique risks. In 1946, Albert Einstein warned, “the unleashed power of the atom has changed everything save our modes of thinking, and thus we drift towards unparalleled catastrophe.” We believe the same could be said of AI. Henry Kissinger has identified these risks in what we call “Kissinger’s Specter.” In his words, AI threatens an unpredictable revolution in our consciousness and our thinking, and an “inevitable evolution in our understanding of truth and reality.”6 In response to Einstein’s insight, the technologists and strategists who had built and used the bomb to end World War II joined forces to find ways to prevent a nuclear World War III. Meeting the challenges posed by AI will require nothing less. Fourth, China’s advantages in size, data collection and national determination have allowed it over the past decade to close the gap with American leaders of this industry. It is currently on a trajectory to overtake the United States in the decade ahead. Nonetheless, if the United States will awake to the challenge and mobilize a national effort, we believe that it can develop and execute a winning strategy.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › 2AC---NATO Action Key – Montenegro

Other NATO states – like Montenegro – require US cyber help – the CP leaves NATO members defenseless

Pierluigi Paganini, 20, (Pierluigi Paganini, Pierluigi Paganini is member of the ENISA (European Union Agency for Network and Information Security) Threat Landscape Stakeholder Group and Cyber G7 Group, he is also a Security Evangelist, Security Analyst and Freelance Writer. Editor-in-Chief at "Cyber Defense Magazine", Pierluigi is a cyber security expert with over 20 years experience in the field, he is Certified Ethical Hacker at EC Council in London. The passion for writing and a strong belief that security is founded on sharing and awareness led Pierluigi to find the security blog "Security Affairs" recently named a Top National Security Resource for US. Pierluigi is a member of the "The Hacker News" team and he is a writer for some major publications in the field such as Cyber War Zone, ICTTF, Infosec Island, Infosec Institute, The Hacker News Magazine and for many other Security magazines. Author of the Books "The Deep Dark Web" and “Digital Virtual Currency and Bitcoin”., 1-20-2020, Security Affairs, Nato has sent an anti-hybrid war team to Montenegro, https://securityaffairs.co/wordpress/96627/cyber-warfare-2/montenegro-nato-hybrid-attacks.html, 6-27-2022) SCade

The Chairman of the NATO Military Committee announced that the alliance has sent a counter-hybrid team to Montenegro to face Russian hybrid attacks. Last week in Brussels, the Chairman of the NATO Military Committee (MC), Marshal Sir Stuart Peach, announced the effort of the Alliance in facing Russian hybrid attacks. The term “Hybrid warfare” refers to a military strategy which employs political warfare and blends conventional warfare, irregular warfare and cyberwarfare with other influencing methods, such as fake news, diplomacy, lawfare and foreign electoral intervention. Peach said that the NATO alliance had set up the first NATO counter-hybrid team in Montenegro. “The first NATO counter-hybrid team has been deployed to our ally state, Montenegro, with the aim of helping to strengthen Montenegro’s capacities and deterring hybrid challenges”, Peach said. Several countries, especially Russia, continue their aggressive operations against foreign states, and cyber warfare is becoming the main concern for almost any government. The official explained that since 2014 the defence spending to face hybrid threats has continued to increase, it has been estimated that by 2024 that amount will reach $ 400 billion. “NATO data shows a 4,6% increase in 2019. That is the fifth consecutive year of growth. By the end of this year, allies will have invested over $130 billion”, added Marshal Peach United States Army General Mark Milley, the highest military officer and military adviser to the President, Minister of Defence and U.S. National Security Council, accused the Russian Government of attempting to destabilize the members of the alliance and divide it. “it is evident that Russia has been trying to divide NATO and make it weaker”. General Milley said. “It would be their benefit. It would be detrimental to Europe and the US if NATO just collapsed and disintegrated.” Representatives of Montenegro’s Defence Ministry confirmed that NATO counter-hybrid team visited Montenegro in November. Experts fear that Russia could attempt to influence the forthcoming parliamentary elections that will take place in October 2020. “This visit was the first such engagement in one of the allies, and it was an important experience for Montenegro. Montenegro wants to enhance its capacities and the focus of NATO’s team was on strengthening legislative framework in this domain and its implementation”, said Ivica Ivanović, director general for defence policy. On June 5, 2017 Montenegro officially joined NATO alliance despite the strong opposition from the Russian Government that threatened to retaliate. Cybersecurity experts believe that a new wave of attacks from the cyberspace will hit the state. In February 2017, for the second time in a few months, Montenegro suffered massive and prolonged cyberattacks against government and media websites. Researchers at security firm FireEye who analyzed the attacks observed malware and exploits associated with the notorious Russia-linked APT group known as APT28 (aka Fancy Bear, Pawn Storm, Strontium, Sofacy, Sednit, and Tsar Team). Another massive attack hit the country’s institutions during October 2016 elections, amid speculation that the Russian Government was involved. Hackers targeted Montenegro with spear-phishing attacks, the malicious messages used weaponized documents pertaining to a NATO secretary meeting and a visit by a European army unit to Montenegro. At the time, the cyberspies delivered the GAMEFISH backdoor (aka Sednit, Seduploader, JHUHUGIT, and Sofacy), a malware that was used only by the APT28 group in past attacks.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › 2AC---US Vaccine Leadership Fails

The United States has had a widespread failure in expediting COVID vaccines – CP doesn’t even do enough

Highlighted parts are how the US has failed, underlined but not highlighted are examples of things the US could do but the CP probably doesn’t do

Editorial Board of NYT, 21, (Editorial Board, The editorial board is a group of opinion journalists whose views are informed by expertise, research, debate and certain longstanding values, 5-14-2021, NYT Opinion, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/14/opinion/biden-covid-vaccines-world-india.html, 6-27-2022) SCade

The United States is well on its way to protecting Americans from the coronavirus. It’s time to help the rest of the world. By marshaling this nation’s vast resources to produce and distribute enough vaccines to meet global demand, the United States would act in keeping with the nation’s best traditions and highest aspirations while advancing its geopolitical and economic interests. It is a moment of both obligation and opportunity. Unfortunately, instead of a bold, comprehensive strategy to vaccinate the world as quickly as possible, the Biden administration has thus far made a string of tactical decisions: donating millions of doses to countries in need, signaling its support for patent waivers that might expedite vaccine production efforts and nudging two companies — Merck and Johnson & Johnson — to collaborate on increasing supply. These are good steps, but they are not nearly sufficient to meet the moment. The United States and the rest of the world’s wealthiest nations are facing a great moral challenge. Covax, the World Health Organization’s initiative to pool vaccine resources, remains profoundly underfunded and has failed to meet even its modest target of vaccinating one-fifth of the population in the Global South. Without a major course correction, the rest of the world will have to wait until 2023 or later for large-scale vaccination initiatives like the one underway in the United States. The consequences of this disparity are expected to be severe. Hundreds of thousands more people will get sick and die from a disease that is now preventable with a vaccine. The global economy will contract by trillions of dollars, according to the International Chamber of Commerce, and tens of millions of people will plummet into extreme poverty as the virus continues to fester and evolve in the world’s more vulnerable reaches. As global hunger rises and global life expectancy falls, instability will prevail. Already, Colombia is mired in deadly protests over the pandemic’s economic fallout. India is facing its gravest humanitarian catastrophe in a generation. As the United Nations has warned, a similar crisis in Syria would be catastrophic. President Biden can start by announcing that the United States intends to help and by appointing a vaccine czar to oversee the expansion of vaccine production. The federal government has ample legal power to compel the participation of the pharmaceutical companies, including the sharing of critical information and technologies. Congress has appropriated $16 billion to scale up production, most of which remains unspent. Increasing manufacturing capacity has proved tricky. The global demand for vaccines may be high now, but once the coronavirus pandemic recedes, it will plummet back to normal levels. Increased public ownership, for its part, would ensure that vaccine-production capacity is ready for future pandemics, which are inevitable — potentially including new coronavirus variants for which routine boosters may be required.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › 2AC---US-NATO Cyber Good

US-NATO can improve cyber awareness, defense, and sharing---leadership is key

Lieutenant Colonel Charles L. Matallana 17, (Lieutenant Colonel Charles L. Matallana 17, United States Army War College Class of 2017. “Maintaining NATO’s Relevance in the 21st Century”. , https://publications.armywarcollege.edu/pubs/3465.pdf, 6-26-2022) SCade

The NATO alliance has taken positive steps in addressing the dilemma faced from cyber-attack. Recently, a December 2016 Joint Declaration signed by the President of the European Council, the President of the European Commission, and the Secretary General of NATO highlights progress towards finding collaborative ways to improve cyber awareness and defense capabilities. The European Union and NATO will exchange concepts on the integration of cyber defense and conduct respective missions and operations to foster interoperability in cyber defense requirements and standards. 54 These declarations will help mature the ability to defend the networks and provide a cohesive response to further attacks. The challenge will be to provide the commitment of resources to realize these goals. The U.S. must continue to take the lead in expanding cooperation within the cyber domain. The advancements made within its own capacity and capability through the development of U.S. Cyber Command have allowed the U.S. to be a lead proponent of cyber defense. As a recent Heritage Foundation study noted, more can be done “through sharing experience, expanding contingency planning, increasing training and exercises.” 55 This is especially urgent with regards to the U.S. and Baltic countries cooperation given the adverse focus Russia puts on these nations as a cyber battleground with NATO.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › 2AC---NATO Good – Cyber/AI

Alliance wide integration is key to stop Russia and China’s AI and cyber operations

Helen Warrell, 21, (Helen Warrell, 6-7-2021, Financial Times, Nato allies need to speed up AI defence co-operation, https://www.ft.com/content/61c1945c-d153-4d58-b9c5-dffd99a6919e, 6-27-2022) SCade

As Russia intensifies cyber hostilities and China weaponises artificial intelligence, joining forces in the field of high-tech warfare will feature high on the list of topics discussed by Nato allies at a summit next week. But the transatlantic alliance’s 30 members will need to move fast if they aim to make up lost ground. Nato is proposing a new tech innovation centre bringing together military personnel with industry to foster digital defence start-ups. Some of these might be financed by a separate initiative, also set to be debated: a venture capital fund for innovation which member states could choose to opt in to. The efforts are belated, as Nato secretary-general Jens Stoltenberg himself acknowledged. “For decades, Nato allies have been leading when it comes to technology, but that’s not obvious any more,” he told the Financial Times in an interview last week. “We see China especially investing heavily in new, disruptive technologies like artificial intelligence, autonomous systems, big data, and they implement them into new advanced weapon systems, drones, submarines, aircraft and so on.” He is not the first to sound the alarm. Eric Schmidt, the former Google chief executive who now chairs the US’s National Security Commission on AI, warned earlier this year that Beijing was planning to undermine conventional military forces by “leapfrogging” to new technologies. The commission’s report, published in March, raised concerns that China would use AI for “reconnaissance, electromagnetic countermeasures and co-ordinated firepower strikes”. Part of the problem is that western defence institutions have been slow to recognise the potential of innovation beyond their own industry. “For decades, a lot of technological development would happen within the defence sector — the internet, nuclear, GPS, all of that was developed by the defence industry and then shared with the civilian sector,” Stoltenberg said. “Now, it goes the other way around. It’s a civilian sector which is leading in the development of artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and many of the new disruptive technologies.” Some Nato members are ahead of others. The US and France have published military AI strategies, while the UK announced this year that it is to establish a centre for defence AI. For the first time, Britain’s intelligence agency, MI6, is recruiting from the private sector for a new head of its “Q” branch — the technical lab made famous in the James Bond films. Establishing a new Nato hub — known as an “accelerator” — in which tech companies and members of the armed forces can experiment with new ideas has advantages, according to Professor Fiona Murray, co-director of MIT’s innovation initiative. Start-ups and investors do not always have the time to tackle defence challenges when solutions are “hard to test, markets are fragmented and procurement is slow”, Murray said. Working together would create a wider market for new products and enhance collective security, she noted. It was “not enough” for countries to be handling this individually, she said. The US has started marshalling allies on the policy implications of using new technology. The Pentagon’s “AI Partnership for Defense”, comprising 13 countries (including Nato members Canada, Denmark, Estonia, the UK, France and Norway) met virtually for the first time last year to agree joint military standards on AI. Schmidt’s commission has called on the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing alliance (the US, UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand) to work more closely on developing AI systems. Ulrike Franke, an expert in military technology at the European Council on Foreign Relations, argues that Nato’s tech centre will be most effective if it prioritises systems designed to facilitate joint military operations. The alliance should look at areas such as AI-enabled command and control, she said, which could give members a unified picture of the battlefield across multiple regions, using intelligent data analysis to sift information. Franke said that in the vast arena spanning drones to quantum computing, there was a temptation to cover too much. “It makes massive sense for Nato to look more at this [technology]”, she said. “The question is, what exactly are they focusing on? There’s a danger of Nato spreading itself too thin.”

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Russia DA Links

Putin is paranoid and worried about something – plan could be what sets him off – he’s unpredictable

John Haltiwanger and Mattathias Schwartz 05-29-2022 [Haltiwanger is a senior politics reporter at Business Insider. He reports on all things politics with a particular focus on national security and foreign policy; has a BA in History from St. Mary's College of Maryland and an MSc in International Relations from the University of Glasgow; Schwartz is a senior correspondent at Insider. He is a former staff writer at the New Yorker and a current contributing writer at the New York Times Magazine.], “Putin is increasingly angry in public but top US intel and military experts warn there's no 'credible' evidence that he's ill,” https://news.yahoo.com/putin-increasingly-angry-public-top-103000113.html Cut By: m.jam

Ex-spies and Ukrainian officials have fueled speculation that Russian leader Vladimir Putin is in poor health.

But US intel and military experts say there's no clear or credible evidence that Putin is unwell.

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Russia DA Links

The plan makes Russia out to be a war criminal – and Putin opposes that

David E Sanger 03-17-2022 [a White House and national security correspondent, and a senior writer. In a 38-year reporting career for The New York Times, he has been on three teams that have won Pulitzer Prizes, most recently in 2017 for international reporting],“By Labeling Putin a ‘War Criminal,’ Biden Personalizes the Conflict,” https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/17/us/politics/biden-putin-war-criminal.html Cut By: m.jam

Mr. Biden and Mr. Putin have not talked since Feb. 12, when the American president made one last attempt to warn the Russian leader that an attack would lead to crushing sanctions, more arms to the Ukrainians and a major buildup of troops and arms on NATO’s eastern front. That buildup was exactly the result Mr. Putin was trying to forestall.

It is almost unimaginable that the two men will be dealing with each other directly anytime soon. Hours after Mr. Biden’s “war criminal” comments, the Kremlin spokesman, Dmitri S. Peskov, called the characterization “unacceptable and unforgivable rhetoric.”

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Russia DA Links

Russia has, is, and will keep using autonomous weapons

Sebastien Roblin 06-30-2022 [Journalist focused international security and military history with more than 500 published articles at The National Interest, NBC and War is Boring; committed to uncovering both human and technical dimensions ofsubjects; MA in Conflict Resolution from Georgetown University, and served as university instructor for the Peace Corps in the beautiful deserts of Gansu, China; organized and led large-scale training programs; worked in education and communications in France, El Salvador, Northern Ireland and the U.S. capital]. “Russia’s war in Ukraine,” Cut by: m.jam

In some respects a slower-moving species of cruise missile, loitering munitions are endowed with greater endurance usable for reconnaissance and target acquisition, ability to maneuver and even abort an attack, and potential for recovery if no target is found. 

Ukraine and Russia have both developed indigenous short-range loitering munitions. The use of Russia’s Zala KUB-BLA kamikaze is confirmed due to the half-dozen that have crashed without exploding or have been shot down. One recording released by Russia shows a KUB missing in an attempted attack on a U.S.-delivered M777 howitzer, its small warhead inflicting little if any damage to the high-end artillery piece. Russia’s larger Lancet-3 munition has yet to be seen in Ukraine despite prior combat tests in Syria.

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Russia DA Links

Russia is using LAWs in Ukraine

Zachary Kallenborn 03-12-2022 [Research affiliate with the Unconventional Weapons and Technology Division of the National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START);a policy fellow at the Schar School of Policy and Government; a US Army Training and Doctrine Command “Mad Scientist,” and national security consultant], “Russia may have used a killer robot in Ukraine. Now what,” https://thebulletin.org/biography/zachary-kallenborn/ Cut By: m.jam

Using pictures out of Ukraine showing a crumpled metallic airframe, open-source  of the conflict there say they have identified  of a new sort of , one that the  says can select and strike targets through inputted coordinates or autonomously. When soldiers give the Kalashnikov ZALA Aero KUB-BLA loitering munition an uploaded image, the system is capable of “real-time recognition and classification of detected objects” using artificial intelligence (AI), according to the Netherlands-based organization  (citing Jane’s International Defence Review). In other words, analysts appear to have spotted a killer robot on the battlefield.

The images of the weapon, apparently taken in the Podil neighborhood of Kyiv and uploaded to  on March 12, do not indicate whether the KUB-BLA, manufactured by Kalashnikov Group of AK-47 fame, was used in its autonomous mode. The drone appears intact enough that digital forensics might be possible, but the  of verifying autonomous weapons use mean we may never know whether it was operating entirely autonomously. Likewise, whether this is Russia’s first use of AI-based autonomous weapons in conflict is also unclear:  published analyses suggests the remains of a mystery drone found in 2019 Syria was from a KUB-BLA (though, again, the drone may not have used the autonomous function).

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Security Link

Fear of others capabilities drives development of LAWS. The alternative solves the root cause of LAWS proliferation

Michael T. Klare (professor emeritus of peace and world security studies at Hampshire College and senior visiting fellow at the Arms Control Association) “Autonomous Weapons Systems and the Laws of War” March 2019 https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2019-03/features/autonomous-weapons-systems-laws-war

In developing and deploying these weapons systems, the United States and other countries appear to be motivated largely by the aspirations of their own military forces, which see various compelling reasons for acquiring robotic weapons. For the U.S. Navy, it is evident that cost and vulnerability calculations are leading the drive to acquire UUVs and unmanned surface vessels. Naval analysts believe that it might be possible to acquire hundreds of robotic vessels for the price of just one modern destroyer, and large capital ships are bound to be prime targets for enemy forces in any future military clash; while a swarm of robot ships would be more difficult to target and losing even a dozen of them would have a lesser effect on the outcome of combat.7 The Army appears to be thinking along similar lines, seeking to substitute robots for dismounted soldiers and crewed vehicles in highly exposed front-line engagements. These institutional considerations, however, are not the only drivers for developing autonomous weapons systems. Military planners around the world are fully aware of the robotic ambitions of their competitors and are determined to prevail in what might be called an “autonomy race.” For example, the U.S. Army’s 2017 Robotic and Autonomous Systems Strategy states, “Because enemies will attempt to avoid our strengths, disrupt advanced capabilities, emulate technological advantages, and expand efforts beyond physical battlegrounds…the Army must continuously assess RAS efforts and adapt.” Likewise, senior Russian officials, including President Vladimir Putin, have emphasized the importance of achieving pre-eminence in AI and autonomous weapons systems.

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Military Readiness

The US has invested heavily in AI – key to economy

Adam Satariano et al. “Killer Robots Aren’t Science Fiction. A Push to Ban Them Is Growing.” December 17, 2021 https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/17/world/robot-drone-ban.html

Some, like Russia, insist that any decisions on limits must be unanimous — in effect giving opponents a veto. The United States argues that existing international laws are sufficient and that banning autonomous weapons technology would be premature. The chief U.S. delegate to the conference, Joshua Dorosin, proposed a nonbinding “code of conduct” for use of killer robots — an idea that disarmament advocates dismissed as a delaying tactic. The American military has invested heavily in artificial intelligence, working with the biggest defense contractors, including Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Raytheon and Northrop Grumman. The work has included projects to develop long-range missiles that detect moving targets based on radio frequency, swarm drones that can identify and attack a target, and automated missile-defense systems, according to research by opponents of the weapons systems.

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Business Confidence/Economy Disadvantage

Plan hurts the economy – LAWS are infinitely cheaper than any other form of military deployment

Coley Felt (International Policy Institute Cybersecurity Fellow) “Autonomous Weaponry: Are Killer Robots in Our Future?” February 14, 2020 https://jsis.washington.edu/news/autonomous-weaponry-are-killer-robots-in-our-future/

Outlining the Debate. The main arguments in support of the development of autonomous weaponry are the military advantages and cost reduction. Autonomous weapons systems would create military advantage because fewer warfighters would be needed, the battlefield could be expanded into previously inaccessible areas, and less casualties could occur by removing humans from dangerous missions (Etzioni, 2017). Furthermore, robots do not have the mental or physiological constraints that humans possess. Thus, their judgements would not be clouded by emotions and more sensory information would be processed without the distorting of preconceived notions (Etzioni, 2017). Numbers from the US Department of Defense show that it costs the Pentagon about $850,000 per year for each soldier in Afghanistan. Contrarily, a small rover equipped with weapons costs roughly $230,000 (Etzioni, 2017).

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › ***Off-Case*** › Business Confidence/Economy Disadvantage

LAWS key to military readiness

MAJOR ANNEMARIE VAZQUEZ (Judge Advocate, United States Army. Associate Professor, Contract and Fiscal Law Department, U.S. ArmyJudge Advocate General's Legal Center and School. B.S., Minnesota State University, 2002; J.D., Mitchell HamlineUniversity School of Law, 2008; Judge Advocate Officer Basic Course, 2010; LL.M., Military Law with NationalSecurity Law Concentration) “Laws and Lawyers: Lethal Autonomus Weapons Bring Loac Issues to the Design Table, Judge advocates Need to be There” June 28, 2022

Strategy and Communications at the Department of Defense's (DoD) Joint Artificial Intelligence Center (JAIC)reported, "Despite expressing concern on AI arms races, most of China's leadership sees increased military usage of AI[*90]as inevitable and is aggressively pursuing it. China already exports armed autonomous platforms and surveillance AI."3That same year, Defense Secretary Mark Esper announced on November 5, 2019, that China had exported lethal autonomous drones to the Middle East: "Chinese manufacturers are selling drones advertised as capable of full autonomy, including the ability to conduct lethal targeted strikes."4 In countering Russian and Chinese pursuit, possession, and export of lethal autonomy the 2018 DoD Artificial Intelligence Strategyemphasized: Our adversaries and competitors are aggressively working to define the future of these powerful technologies according to their interests, values, and societal models. Their investments threaten to erode U.S. military advantage, destabilize the free and open international order, and challenge our values and traditions with respect to human rights and individual liberties.5 The "powerful technologies" referred to in DoD's AI Strategy and the comments made by Esper, Allen, and Putinrefer to lethal autonomous weapons(LAWs),6a subset of machines that employ AI. Although there is no internationally agreed-upon definition of LAWs,7the DoD defines them as weapons that "can select and engage targets without further intervention by a human operator."8These are the "killer robots" referred[*91]to in the media and by organizations dedicated to banning them.9Though technology for some LAWs

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › NATO Cohesion Advantage › Democracy

Democracy is resilient and allows for the development of opposition groups which strengthen democratic norms

Drezner 2020. Daniel W. Drezner is a professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University. “The resiliency of American democracy” WaPo. February 4, 2020. <https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/02/04/resiliency-american-democracy/> Accessed 6/29/20. ARJH

So is that it for American democracy? Nah. I do not want to minimize the illiberal nature of the Trump administration. When Secretary of State Mike Pompeo pitches a fit because an NPR reporter acts like a reporter and then tries to claim his behavior is perfectly consistent with press freedom, he is, you know, lying. That is not good for America. Neither is the reported effort by Trump to punish former national security adviser John Bolton for writing a memoir confirming everything the House managers said about Trump. These petty acts of revenge, while troubling, are not the end of the republic. And even if elected officials seem to be behaving in as self-interested a manner as political scientists would predict, American politics is about more than just those officials. The American public also matters, and they have not taken too kindly to this sort of swamplike behavior. Erica Chenoweth, Jeremy Pressman and others have detailed the rise in organized political protests since the start of the Trump presidency. This kind of civil society activism mattered in the 2018 midterms and will matter for the 2020 election and beyond. Lara Putnam and Gabriel Perez Putnam made a similar point last summer in the Washington Monthly: “Something different has been happening in Trump-era America. The local grassroots groups that arose after the 2016 election have developed a strikingly effective infrastructural mix — including new local groups, reanimated Democratic Party structures, and passionate campaigns for previously ignored local and legislative offices — to create a dense, overlapping system with multiple on-ramps to electoral action.” Contrary to the fears of some, it would appear that Americans opposed to Trump’s brand of illiberalism are doing something about it. And regardless of what one hears about divisions among Democrats, the latest Voter Study Group findings by John Sides and Robert Griffin reveal that “Democratic primary voters are fairly unified in their favorable views of the leading candidates [and] they are even more unified in their opposition to President Donald Trump.” Similarly, for all the talk of democracy vanishing in the United States, neither experts nor the public actually believes this. A group of political scientists founded Bright Line Watch to examine whether both political scientists and the public perceives the erosion of American democracy. Their latest wave of surveys, from the end of last year, found that “perceptions of the overall performance of American democracy remain stable among both experts and the public since we began surveying each group.”

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › NATO Cohesion Advantage › Democracy

Democratic Peace fail: Authoritarianism is on the rise and the tenets of DPT are fundamentally disproven

Mearsheimer 2018. John Joseph Mearsheimer is an American political scientist and international relations scholar and R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor at the University of Chicago. “Chapter 7: Liberal Theories of Peace” Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities. 2018 Yale University Press. <https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv5cgb1w> Accessed 6/30/20. ARJH

Democratic peace theory was remarkably popular in the two decades after the Cold War ended. Michael Doyle introduced it to the academic and policy worlds in a pair of seminal articles published in 1983.9 When the superpower rivalry ended in 1989, it was widely believed that liberal democracy would steadily sweep across the globe, spreading peace everywhere. This perspective, of course, is the central theme in Fukuyama’s “The End of History?” But time has not been kind to Fukuyama’s argument. Authoritarianism has become a viable alternative, and there are few signs that liberal democracy will conquer the globe anytime soon. Freedom House maintains that the world’s share of democracies actually declined between 2006 and 2016, which naturally reduces the scope of the theory.10 Even if liberal democracy were on the march, however, it would not enhance the prospects for peace, because the theory is seriously flawed. Consider its central finding. Some of its proponents argue that there has never been a war between two democracies. But this is wrong: there are at least four cases in the modern era where democracies waged war against each other. Contrary to what democratic peace theorists say, Germany was a liberal democracy during World War I (1914–18), and it fought against four other liberal democracies: Britain, France, Italy, and the United States.11 In the Boer War (1899–1902) Britain fought against the South African Republic and the Orange Free State, both of which were democracies.12 The Spanish-­American War (1898) and the 1999 Kargil War between India and Pakistan are also cases of democracies fighting each other.13 Other cases come close to qualifying as wars between democracies.14 The American Civil War is usually not counted because it is considered a civil war rather than an interstate war. One might argue, however, that the distinction is not meaningful here. The Confederacy was established on February 4, 1861, but the war did not begin until April, by which time the Confederacy was effectively a sovereign state. It is also worth noting that there have been a host of militarized disputes between democracies, including some cases where fighting broke out and people died, but that fell short of actual war.15 There are also many cases of democracies, especially the United States, overthrowing democratically elected leaders in other countries, a behavior that seems at odds with the claim that democracies behave peacefully toward one another. But let us get back to my four cases of actual wars between democracies. One might concede that I am right yet still argue that this tiny number of wars does not substantially challenge the theory. This conclusion would be wrong, however, for reasons clearly laid out by the democratic peace theorist James L. Ray: “Since wars between states are so rare statistically . . . the existence of even a few wars between democratic states would wipe out entirely the statistical and therefore arguably the substantive significance of the difference in the historical rates of warfare between pairs of democratic states, on the one hand, and pairs of states in general, on the other.”16 Those four wars between democracies, in other words, undermine the central claim of democratic peace theorists.

2022 SDI Negative
Lethal Autonomous Weapons System – Negative › NATO Cohesion Advantage › Democracy

Democratic peace only works with globalized democracy, absent that it fails and states default to realism and conflict

Mearsheimer 2018. John Joseph Mearsheimer is an American political scientist and international relations scholar and R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor at the University of Chicago. “Chapter 7: Liberal Theories of Peace” Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities. 2018 Yale University Press. <https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv5cgb1w> Accessed 6/30/20. ARJH

Consider, for instance, that none of the liberal theories was relevant to the superpower competition during the Cold War. The Soviet Union was not a democracy, the two sides had little economic intercourse, and few international institutions had both sides as members. Or think about how most liberals talk about the prospects of China’s rising peacefully. China is not a democracy today and shows little prospect of becoming one. One rarely hears the argument that democratic peace theory can provide the basis for peace in Asia. But one frequently hears that economic interdependence theory can explain why China’s rise will be peaceful. China’s economy is tied to the economies of its rivals, and this linkage means not only that China and its trading partners depend on each other to keep prospering, but also that prosperity depends on their peaceful relations. A war involving China would be tantamount to mutual assured destruction at the economic level. Hence, economic interdependence will keep the peace in Asia as China rises. It is possible to hypothesize a world in which one or more of the liberal theories apply universally, and one where none of them applies at all. But those are not our world. In our world, those theories are likely to cover certain situations but not others. Consider, for example, how democratic peace theory would apply to a scenario in which the United States removes its military forces from Europe and NATO disappears. There would then be three major powers on the Continent: France, Germany, and Russia. According to the theory, France and Germany would not fight each other, because they are both liberal democracies and thus would not compete with each other for power. But they would have a fundamentally different relationship with non-­democratic Russia: they would be guided by realist logic, with its emphasis on the survival motive. In that situation, all three countries would end up trying to maximize their positions in the global balance of power. Let us assume that Russia becomes a democracy. Democratic peace theory would then apply to relations among all three major powers. Yet democratic Russia would have to fear a rising China, which is not a democracy, on its southern border, and so would have to act according to balance-­of-­power logic in its dealings with China. France and Germany do not share a border with China, but they would still have to worry about a possible threat if China became a superpower. As long as there is one powerful non-­democracy in the system, no democracy can escape from acting according to realist logic. As Alexander Wendt notes, “One predator will best a hundred pacifists because anarchy provides no guarantees. This argument is powerful in part because it is so weak: rather than making the strong assumption that all states are inherently power-­seeking . . . it assumes that just one is power-seeking and that the others have to follow suit because anarchy permits the one to exploit them.”6 This logic applies even though the democracies in the system would still behave peacefully toward each other, at least according to the theory.