Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 MNDI Counterplan
AI › Norms › 2NC --- Solvency

UNESCO has already taken the lead on AI, the counter plan furthers these efforts which solves the aff

Abhishree Choudhary 12 – 21 - Connor McPartland is an assistant director with the Atlantic Council’s Transatlantic Security Initiative, part of the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security.

[“Ethics Of AI: 193 Members Of UNESCO Adopt Recommendations” https://analyticsindiamag.com/ethics-of-ai-193-members-of-unesco-adopt-recommendations/ - Acc 6-19-22 JZ]

In a historic global agreement, all 193 members of UNESCO adopt the recommendations on the ethics of AI document

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AI › Norms › 1NC --- UNESCO

We solve modelling- UNESCO creates necessary incentives for Russia and China otherwise the aff gets circumvented

Gaubert 21 [Julie Gaubert, Public Relations Author, 28/11/2021, UNESCO member countries adopt the first global agreement on the ethics of AI., EURONEWS, MA]

One pitfall of the agreement is that it does not impose anything on companies actively using artificial intelligence, particularly the US internet giants Google, Amazon, Facebook, and Apple. David Leslie, a researcher at the Alan Turing Institute for Science and AI, nevertheless saw it as "a step in the right direction". He believes believed other international institutions, such as the Council of Europe and the European Union, will soon follow UNESCO's model. "Texts like this one put a lot of pressure on the Facebooks of this world, whose "predatory behaviour is increasingly exposed," Leslie said. "Acting with as much impunity as Facebook has done is no longer possible". However, UNESCO does not directly address the subject of facial recognition. This is a central theme that the European Union has taken up. The European Commission is proposing of remote biometric identification systems in public places. Meanwhile, Russia, China, and Iran - states regularly accused of obstructing human rights - are signatories to the text, which UNESCO acknowledges is an "incentive mechanism" without the possibility of sanctions. "If this text had no power, these countries would not even have come to discuss it," Alessandra Sala, director of the artificial intelligence service of content provider Shutterstock, said. These three countries ratified the recommendation "because they realise that we are at a pivotal moment in AI and they don't want to be seen as the countries going in the wrong direction," she added. The United States and Israel, which are very active in new technologies, are not UNESCO member states. But the US is working on AI legislation and is "ahead of Europe," said Sala.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AI › Norms › 1NC --- UNESCO

UNESCO adopts cohesive AI policies

Gaubert 21 [Julie Gaubert, Public Relations Author, 28/11/2021, UNESCO member countries adopt the first global agreement on the ethics of AI., EURONEWS, MA]

Artificial intelligence (AI) is supporting the decision-making of governments, can help combat global issues such as climate change and give us personalised recommendations. But the UN agency UNESCO also warns that the technology is bringing challenges, such as gender and ethnic bias, as well as threats to privacy. It is because of this that 193 UNESCO member countries adopted the first global agreement on the ethics of artificial intelligence on Thursday.This is the "first global ethical framework for the use of artificial intelligence," said Audrey Azoulay, Director-General of UNESCO. "AI technologies can be of great service to humanity" and "all countries can benefit from them", but "they also raise fundamental ethical concerns," the 28-page recommendation states. There is a "need to ensure the transparency and intelligibility of the functioning of algorithms and the data from which they have been trained," because they can influence "human rights and fundamental freedoms, gender equality and democracy," the Paris-based international organisation stated. Since the millennium, AI has gradually made its way into our lives: it decides what news we read on our phones, which films are recommended to us on streaming services, or what routes GPS will take us on. An expert group was set up in March 2020 to develop a draft recommendation on the ethics of AI. The aim of the text is to "provide a responsible direction for AI technologies". "We see increased gender and ethnic bias, significant threats to privacy, dignity and agency, dangers of mass surveillance, and increased use of unreliable AI technologies in law enforcement, to name a few. Until now, there were no universal standards to provide an answer to these issues," UNESCO said in a statement. In recent years, Meta (formally known as Facebook) has been at the centre of several scandals. The now shut-down British political consulting firm Cambridge Analytica was accused of misusing the US giant's data to politically influence the referendum in the United Kingdom and the election of Donald Trump in the US. In light of this, the adopted text aims to guide the construction of the necessary legal infrastructure to ensure the ethical development of this technology. "The world needs rules for artificial intelligence to benefit humanity," Azoulay said. "The Recommendation on the ethics of AI is a major answer. It sets the first global normative framework while giving States the responsibility to apply it at their level. UNESCO will support its 193 Member States in its implementation and ask them to report regularly on their progress and practices".

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AI › Funding › 2NC --- NIST

NIST is the best way to set standards – they are efficient and partner with academia

NIST 22 [NIST, National Institute for Science and Technology, "Plan for Federal AI Standards Engagement," NIST, https://www.nist.gov/artificial-intelligence/plan-federal-ai-standards-engagement] Blitz

NIST has released a  per the . The plan recommends the federal government “commit to deeper, consistent, long-term engagement in AI standards development activities to help the United States to speed the pace of reliable, robust, and trustworthy AI technology development.”

It calls for federal agencies to bolster AI standards-related knowledge, leadership, and coordination among agencies that develop or use AI; promote focused research on the trustworthiness of AI systems; support and expand public-private partnerships; and engage with international parties. 

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AI › Funding › 2NC --- NATO fails

NATO slows down solvency due – only a unilateral plan avoids

Trabucco and Stanley-Lockman 21 [Lena -- Lena is a CSER Research Affiliate whose research examines the intersection of international security, international law, and emerging military technologies. and Zoe, ​Zoe Stanley-Lockman is an Associate Research Fellow in the Military Transformations Programme at the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore. Her research interests are in the areas of defence innovation, emerging technologies, defence industries, and military capability development. Previously she worked as a defence analyst at the European Union Institute for Security Studies in Paris and Brussels. She holds a Master's degree from Sciences Po Paris and a Bachelor's degree from Johns Hopkins University. Throughout her studies, her practical experience included working on dual-use export controls with the U.S. government and consulting for U.S. government systems integrators. Her participation in the Warring with Machines project will include framing machine learning in a socio-technical context that takes into account the unique aspects of defence economics, management, and operational environments, as well as applying lessons across alliances and like-minded countries. The Oxford Handbook of AI Governance, March, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance inMilitary Affairs”-9780197579329-e-69] Blitz

Externally, as AI-enabled autonomous systems enter the arsenals of more technologically advanced countries, uncoordinated ethical frameworks between Allies could pose operational risks. Without wider alignment, AI systems will have “varying technical specifications based on the legal and policy decisions made by individual governments when answering the key questions.” Further, although one motivation of autonomous systems is the increased safety of military personnel by removing them from dangerous situations, the lack of alignment could lead some Allies to perceive other capitals’ deployments of unmanned forces as a lack of commitment to put lives on the line, therein posing credibility risks for Allies to assure one another. These credibility risks can be mitigated by accountability and verification standards and procedures that NATO can implement for multinational operations, and efforts to institutionalize these procedures for AI are underway. While the NATO AI Strategy is expected to create a common foundation for the Alliance’s pursuit of AI, it is the implementation of principles for safe, ethical, legal, and interoperable AI that will reveal how coherent different national perspectives are. As of August 2021, only the United States and France have publicly issued their military AI strategies. Other allies, including Canada and the United Kingdom, have emerging views on responsible military AI, but little official information about how they implement their ethical risk assessments is publicly available.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AI › Funding › 2NC --- Solves China

US AI RnD key to respond to Chinese AI challenges.

Flournoy, Haines et al 2020 - former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy and Director of National Intelligence [Michèle and Avril, Gabrielle Cheftiz Special Assistant to the Under Secretary of Defense for Policy October, “Building Trust through Testing Adapting DOD’s Test & Evaluation, Validation & Verification (TEVV) Enterprise for Machine Learning Systems, including Deep Learning Systems” https://cset. georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/Building-Trust-Through-Testing.pdf Acc 6/23/22 JZ]

Machine learning applications can increase the speed and quality of human decision-making on the battlefield, enable human-machine teaming to maximize performance and minimize the risk to soldiers, and greatly improve the accuracy and speed of analysis that relies on very large data sets. ML can also strengthen the United States’ ability to defend its networks against cyberattacks at machine speeds and has the power to automate critical components of labor-intensive enterprise functions, such as predictive maintenance and personnel management. Advances in AI and machine learning are not the sole province of the United States, however. Indeed, U.S. global leadership in AI remains in doubt in the face of an aggressive Chinese challenge in the field. Numerous DOD and academic reports reflect on the need to invest more in AI T 2 research and development, train and recruit a skilled workforce, and promote an international environment supportive of American AI innovation—all while promoting safety, security, privacy, and ethical development and use.

However, far too little attention is placed on the issue of trust, and especially testing, evaluation, verification, and validation (TEVV) of these systems. Building a robust testing and evaluation ecosystem is a critical component of harnessing this technology responsibly, reliably, and urgently. Failure to do so will mean falling behind.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AI › Funding › 1NC --- Private

High risk/high reward investments create necessary innovation – only a public/private partnership can create this

Bipartisan Center 20 [The Bipartisan Policy Center is a Washington, DC-based think tank that actively fosters bipartisanship by combining the best ideas from both parties to promote health, security, and opportunity for all Americans. Our policy solutions are the product of informed deliberations by former elected and appointed officials, business and labor leaders, and academics and advocates who represent both sides of the political spectrum. BPC prioritizes one thing above all else: getting things done., "Cementing American Artificial Intelligence Leadership: AI Research & Development", Bipartisan Policy Center, https://bipartisanpolicy.org/download/?file=/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/BPC_RD-AI-Paper_RV5.pdf] Blitz

Lead in Research & Development Greater investments in artificial intelligence research and development are essential to maintaining American leadership in AI. Throughout the 20th century, the federal government played a critical role in fueling technological innovation by funding pivotal basic research. Government funding was essential to developing the transistor, GPS, and the internet—inventions that transformed the world economy. Yet over the past several decades, federal government spending on R&D as a percentage of GDP declined from about 1.2% in 1976 to around 0.7% in 2018.1 This is a worrisome trend as the federal government remains the main funder of basic research. Government support again could be pivotal both in fostering new AI breakthroughs and ensuring that the U.S. government has access to those breakthroughs. Beyond AI, overall R&D spending trends are troubling. Other countries are outpacing the United States with faster growth of their national R&D budgets. Total U.S. national (public and private) R&D expenditures as a share of GDP have been mostly stagnant since 1996. China quadrupled its R&D expenses as a share of GDP over the same time frame, and countries like Israel and Cementing American Artificial Intelligence Leadership: AI Research & Development AUGUST 2020 2 South Korea also significantly ramped up spending.2 As a result, the U.S. share of global R&D has declined over the past several decades, falling from 69% in 1960 to 28% in 2016. From 2000 to 2015, the United States accounted for 19% of global R&D growth, while China accounted for 31%.3 China was on track to top the United States in total R&D investments (in purchasing power parityadjusted dollars) as soon as 2019.4 R&D is a key driver of long-term economic growth. According to a report from BPC’s American Energy Innovation Council titled Energy Innovation Fueling America’s Economic Engine:5 TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION CAN IMPROVE PRODUCTIVIT Y ACROSS INDUSTRIES AND CRE ATE ENTIRELY NEW ONES. THIS IS ONE AMONG MANY RE ASONS WHY ECONOMISTS AGREE THAT INNOVATION IS A DRIVER OF LONG -TERM ECONOMIC GROW TH AND STABILIT Y—AND WHY AT LE AST 50 PERCENT OF U.S. ANNUAL GDP GROW TH CAN BE TRACED TO INCREASES IN INNOVATION. The Bipartisan Policy Center (BPC) and the Center for New American Security (CNAS), in consultation with Reps. Will Hurd (R-TX) and Robin Kelly (D-IL), have worked with government officials, industry representatives, civil society advocates, and academics to better understand the country’s major AI related R&D needs. This paper hopes to shed more clarity on these challenges and provide actionable policy recommendations, to help guide a U.S. national strategy for AI. BPC’s effort is primarily designed to complement the work done by the Obama and Trump administrations, including President Barack Obama’s 2016 National Artificial Intelligence Research and Development Strategic Plan6 and President Donald Trump’s 2019 update, Trump’s Executive Order 13859, announcing the American AI Initiative, 7 and the Office of Management and Budget’s subsequent Guidance for Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Applications. 8 The effort is also designed to further advance work done by Kelly and Hurd in their 2018 Oversight and Government Reform Committee (Information Technology Subcommittee) white paper Rise of the Machines: Artificial Intelligence and its Growing Impact on U.S. Policy9 and the CNAS report The American AI Century: A Blueprint for Action. Our goal through this effort is to provide the legislative branch with actions it can take to advance AI building on the work being done by the Obama and Trump administrations. 3 II. Key Principles 1. Overall federal AI R&D spending needs to increase significantly 2. The country needs to expand and diversify its computing capacity 3. The federal government plays a key role in incentivizing private sector R&D 4. There needs to be international cooperation to advance AI research and development 5. The federal government would benefit from opening up avenues for private talent 6. AI standards and measurement are essential to fostering AI technologies that are safe, secure, reliable, and comport with U.S. norms and values 4 III. Overview The private sector, academia, and the government have a long history of collaborating to advance technological innovation. Academia, often through support of federally funded grants, historically has conducted much of the basic research that has enabled the private sector to advance applied research and commercialize technologies. This partnership, however, is being strained by recent innovations in machine learning whose advancement relies on large datasets and compute resources that are increasingly unavailable to academic researchers. To ensure the United States is maximizing its R&D potential and to ensure the entire R&D cycle from basic research to commercialization is fully utilized, the partnership of government, academia, and the private sector must be strengthened to ensure each has adequate access to the resources they need while protecting intellectual property rights and data privacy. This includes standardizing and making current and future government datasets more readily available to the private sector and academia to facilitate training of machine learning models.10 Under the OPEN Government Data Act of 2019, federal agencies are required by statute to make available government datasets in standardized, machine-readable formats.11 Doing so will help to address data scarcity problems, especially for entities with significant resource constraints such as startups or some university researchers, by expanding the number of open-source high-quality datasets and increasing access to compute resources.12 5 IV. Key Takeaways Overall AI R&D spending needs to increase significantly The U.S. government remains the largest funder of basic research in the United States. As during the 1960s and 1970s, government support again could be pivotal today both in fostering new breakthroughs and ensuring that the U.S. government has access to them. The federal government should prioritize high-risk/high-reward basic science research—areas where private industry has little incentive to invest but that holds tremendous potential for valuable new knowledge. Breakthroughs in software, such as novel AI techniques that address the limitation of existing AI methods, and hardware, such as nextgeneration semiconductor technologies and superconducting artificial neurons, could be game changers that provide the United States with a continuing technological edge. Advances in AI can also further R&D of other fields because of its broad, interdisciplinary nature, while breakthroughs in areas like neuroscience can greatly advance AI development. Unclassified federal government spending on defense AI R&D in fiscal year 2020 will be about $4 billion, according to a Bloomberg analysis from March 2019.13 In September 2019, the White House announced an FY2020 nondefense AI R&D budget request of nearly $1 billion.14 In contrast, the level of Chinese government spending on AI R&D is not clear. Complete annualized figures for Chinese government spending are not publicly available. Instead, only announcements of planned, multi-year spending offer a window into the scale of overall government R&D spending at the national, provincial, and local levels.15 For instance, two Chinese cities alone announced the creation of RMB 100 billion (approximately $15 billion) multi-year AI development funds while Beijing unveiled plans for a $2 billion AI research park in 2018.16 The United States enjoys robust private sector R&D funding. Precise figures are hard to discern because companies typically do not divulge details for R&D expenditures in their financial statements and privately-owned firms do not have such reporting requirements. That said, looking at overall R&D expenditures by major AI-intensive companies gives a sense of the scale of private investments in AI R&D. The combined 2018 R&D expenditures by U.S. firms Alphabet, IBM, Facebook, Microsoft, and Amazon was $80.5 billion.17 China’s tech giants also report significant R&D investments, although they are considerably smaller than those of their U.S. counterparts. Leading Chinese AI firms Alibaba, Baidu, and Tencent collectively spent $9.1 billion on R&D in 2018.18 These firms are also major investors in Chinese AI startups.19 6 In April 2020, the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence (NSCAI) published its first quarter recommendations, calling for an immediate doubling of non-DOD AI R&D funding to $2 billion. NSCAI emphasized the importance of funding basic research and investing in new microelectronics technologies. This echoes the White House AI R&D budget request for FY2021-22.20 Recommendation #1: Congress and the White House should adopt the NSCAI and White House recommendations to double AI R&D spending immediately, and further commit to boosting total yearly federal AI R&D spending to $25 billion by FY2025. Spending at this level is realistic and doable: $25 billion is equal to about 19% of total federal R&D spending in the FY2020 budget. Congress should concurrently raise total federal R&D spending to 1.2% of GDP to achieve an overall boost of total public and private R&D spending to 4% of GDP. Recommendation #2: Congress should ensure R&D includes funding to address shortcomings of current AI methods with novel fundamental approaches: prevalent deep learning systems in use today typically require large amounts of training data and computing resources that are often not available to academics and startups. Research of novel AI techniques requiring smaller data sets to train and that make more efficient use of compute could lead to important breakthroughs in the field. While increased investments in AI R&D are urgently necessary, this should not come at the expense of research in other disciplines. American competitiveness in the 21st century will depend on strong capabilities in a broad range of capabilities. Importantly, R&D investments in other sectors can enable better AI systems, creating a virtuous cycle of scientific advancement.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Space › 2AC --- China

China and US won’t cooperate now – further tensions provide an opportunity for escalation

Bin Li, 5-9-2022, "Space Won’t Be Safe until the U.S. and China Can Cooperate," Scientific American, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/space-wont-be-safe-until-the-u-s-and-china-can-cooperate1/

China is undeniably one of the world’s top players in space these days, with successful missions to the moon and Mars and a solar probe due to be launched soon. Its rise has spurred competition with the U.S.; “Watch the Chinese,” NASA Administrator Bill Nelson recently warned. Given the strategic value the two nations have placed on their space programs, and the political tension that already exists between the countries, the contest over achievements in space is likely to intensify.

Despite the tension, the U.S. and China must figure out a way to cooperate on some, if not all, issues in the use of space. The most critical area is the safety of space infrastructure, where a lack of communication could be damaging and possibly even deadly. This need was highlighted by the recent saga of a near miss between two of Elon Musk’s Starlink satellites and China’s in-progress crewed space station. Although the Starlink spacecraft are privately owned, the U.S. government is internationally responsible for their space activities under the 1967 Outer Space Treaty.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Space › 2AC --- China

US SpaceX operations would anger China

Jim Pollard, 5-10-2022, "China Fears US Will Use SpaceX to Bring Calamity to World," Asia Financial,

The Starlink internet service run by Elon Musk’s SpaceX may be used by the “hegemony-obsessed US” to dominate space and bring “chaos or calamity” to the world.

That’s according to a recent commentary published by China Military Online, an official website linked to China’s Central Military Commission, which is headed by President Xi Jinping.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Norms › 2AC --- CP fails

Norms-based approach leaves no one accountable – it is ambiguous and lacks enforcement.

MaČÁK 17 [Kubo MaČÁK, Dr Kubo Mačák is a legal adviser at the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). Prior to joining the ICRC in 2019, he worked as an Associate Professor of Public International Law at the University of Exeter in the United Kingdom. "From Cyber Norms to Cyber Rules: Re-engaging States as Law-makers," Cambridge University press, https://www-cambridge-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/core/journals/leiden-journal-of-international-law/article/from-cyber-norms-to-cyber-rules-reengaging-states-as-lawmakers/63A45029B685C11BBD9512AC0459FAE5] Blitz

While the first two indicators relate to states’ reluctance to act in ways meaningful for the generation of new rules, the third concerns their actual conduct in relation to cyber governance. It would be inaccurate to claim that states have entirely given up on standard-setting. However, instead of interpreting or developing rules of international law, state representatives have generally sought refuge in the more ambiguous term ‘norms’. It is true that law and norms are ‘intimately intertwined’ concepts and that inter-state agreement on ‘norms’ may gradually influence the development of the law.Yet, a fundamental difference between the two is that a violation of a binding rule of international law gives rise to international legal responsibility. while the same cannot be said of non-legal norms regulating cyber conduct.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Hybrid War › 2AC --- Perm do both

Perm do both- Cooperating with EU and NATO against Russian Hybrid War tactics solves best.

Clark 20 [Mason Clark, the Russia Team Lead and Research Analyst on the Russia and Ukraine portfolio at the Institute for the Study of War. His work focuses on Russian military adaptation and learning in Syria. His work has been cited by Task & Purpose, Defense One, the Kyiv Post, the New York Times, BBC, and others. He has briefed multiple senior military and civilian decision makers on Russian military development and the Kremlin’s global campaigns, September 2020, Institute For The Study of War, “Russian Hybrid Warfare Military Learning And The Future of War Series”, , Pgs 9-10, JMH]

The United States should take several actions to support this revision of its strategy and approach to Russia.

• Analyze the Kremlin’s decisions within the Russian framework of hybrid war to understand and mitigate Russian lines of effort. Obfuscating the nature and purpose of Kremlin activities is a key objective of hybrid war, and US confusion about the term and the Russian approach to such conflicts hinders the development of effective counterstrategies.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › 5-G › 2AC --- CP fails

5G infighting causes economic nosedive – governmental disputes wreck solvency – only the plan solves

Grossmann 22 [J. DAVID GROSSMAN, VP OF REGULATORY AFFAIRS, CONSUMER TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION (CTA)"US 5G leadership depends on ending government infighting," Light Reading, https://www.lightreading.com/regulatorypolitics/us-5g-leadership-depends-on-ending-government-infighting/a/d-id/776413] Blitz

From Wi-Fi and smartphones to telehealth, fitness wearables and more – wireless connectivity is a critical part of our daily lives. However, recent government infighting over spectrum use threatens the technology that so many Americans depend on. As the demand for faster and more reliable wireless connectivity continues to grow, it is time to reform our nation's spectrum policy to make sure that spectrum continues to benefit Americans. (See ). Spectrum drives a large portion of consumer connectivity and technology and influences America's economy. A recent found that unlicensed spectrum generates $95.8 billion per year in incremental sales value, and there are billions more in economic benefits from licensed spectrum used by our nation's wireless providers. DOT and FCC debris Good spectrum policy can create jobs, spur innovation and grow GDP. Bad spectrum policy places US companies, federal agencies and American consumers at a disadvantage in a world where every country is competing to offer better technology and services. The US is risking the latter due to a lack of coordination between government agencies. For example, the recent auction of the C-band for 5G, which raised nearly $81 billion in revenue, was followed by objections from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). This is not the first time in recent memory that spectrum battles have erupted. There is an ongoing dispute over the repurposing of spectrum in the 5.9 GHz band between the Department of Transportation (DOT) and the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). Many more examples of bureaucratic infighting and dysfunction have littered the spectrum landscape. Sadly, these disputes are not just Beltway parlor games; they have real consequences for America's economy. American technology companies face an uncertain environment due to whether the federal government's decisions will be implemented. How can we ask companies to invest billions of dollars in a technology direction when the regulatory rug may be pulled out from under them at the last moment?

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Biotech › 2AC --- Rogue States

Rogue states will use biotech to create super-soldiers.

Malet ’11/15 [David; 11/13/15; Qualifications; "Captain America in International Relations: the Biotech Revolution in Military Affairs," , IC]

Biological weapons are typically associated with rogue states and terrorist groups; germ weapons used by weak actors against the strong. This article makes a contrary argument, that the emerging use of biotechnology by the United States, China, and other hegemonic powers is likely to afford them a new Revolution in Military Affairs (RMA), one at least as significant as the introduction of the information technology RMA that gave the United States a dominant edge over potential adversaries at the end of the Cold War. It examines recent developments and current R&D programs that call into question the rights of enemy combatants, civilian populations in target areas, and soldiers who will be physically augmented to pursue battlefield objectives. Examples include the Quikclot used to reduce fatalities in the Iraq War, which arguably prolonged public support for the war, and the Pentagon’s publicly detailed research across various programs to create super-soldiers akin to super-heroes. The real advances in biotech will likely only further retrench the major powers of the international system by conferring an asymmetric advantage far beyond the capacity of weaker actors to match.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Biotech › 2AC --- Too Expensive

Funding extremely high totaling over 40 billion

BioSpace 22 [BioSpace Editorial Staff 9/21/2020 ; The Home of the Life Sciences Industry. Find biotech, clinical research and pharmaceutical jobs from thousands of employers; “Investment in Biopharma is Reaching an Inflection Point,” https://www.biospace.com/article/investment-in-biopharma-is-reaching-an-inflection-point-/]

Emerging biopharma companies are vital to the creation of many novel therapies and health technologies, and play an important role in the future of early-stage drug development. Little wonder U.S.-based biotech companies are the darling of private equity, venture capital companies and institutional money managers.

During the past two years, fundraising and investment in biotechnology have reached record levels. These factors have translated into elevated IPO activity and an overarching positive outlook.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Biotech › 2AC --- Impact

Any solvency deficit risks a global arms race.

Almosara 10 [Joel O.; 6/?/2010 ; The senior consultant to the Pacific Air Forces Surgeon General and commanders on occupational and environmental health programs and Deputy Director of the USAF Counterproliferation Center ; “BIOTECHNOLOGY: GENETICALLY ENGINEERED PATHOGENS,” ]

The developmental trends in biological sciences indicate there is a plethora of possibilities concerning the study of microorganisms and its applicability in creating the next biological warfare agent. Both historical and recent events show the potentially devastating effect of using biological warfare agents and the terror they cause among the populace. Even more alarming is that technological advancements in the field of biological sciences will transform biological warfare agents into a new classification of genetically engineered pathogens eliciting catastrophic consequences. 2 Just as the twentieth century was the “century of chemistry and physics,” the twenty-first century will emerge as the “century of biology.” Nations, groups, and individuals that have the resources, capabilities, and knowledge to develop this technology in the year 2035 will have the global arms race advantage.

2022 MNDI Counterplan
AFF › Biotech › 2AC --- Bans Fail

Biotech in the military is inevitable.

Malet ’11/15 [David; 11/13/15; Qualifications; "Captain America in International Relations: the Biotech Revolution in Military Affairs," , IC]

The Biotech Revolution in Military Affairs There have been numerous studies of the impacts of a wide array of emergent technologies by hegemonic actors or aspirants (For a preliminary list, see Jervis 1978, Levy 1984, Posen 1984, Shimshoni 1990, Arquilla and Ronfeldt 1997, Adams 1998, Murray and Millett 1998, Tannenwald 2008, Clarke and Knake 2010, Vogel 2012, Waltz and Sagan 2012, Carpenter 2013). However, there has been little examination of what the adoption of biotechnology by the leading military powers has meant or is likely to mean. The United States Office of Technology Assessment defines biotechnology as “any technique that uses a living organism, or parts of organisms, to make or modify products, to improve plants or animals, or to develop microorganisms for specific uses.” 320 D. Malet Other definitions include material patterned after living organisms but not necessarily using them as components (biomimetics). The conventional wisdom on biotechnology has held that coming decades will see Western nations increasingly vulnerable to ever-more sophisticated biological weapons attacks by non-state actors and rogue states. As recombinant genetic technology proliferates, a greater number of actors will possess genetic engineering capabilities that will enhance the lethality and durability of their biological weapons. Proponents of this perspective note that the overwhelming technological advantage in conventional forces enjoyed by the United States creates the incentive for competitors to develop effective asymmetric responses, and that the affordability, accessibility, and relatively easy preparation of biological weapons make them a likely means of doing so. In this view, the superior conventional capabilities of the US military not only fail to deter the proliferation of biological weapons, but encourage their development. Western states will face an increasing number of biologically armed opponents, and will remain on the defensive. The priority for military biotech research is therefore the development of protective equipment and vaccines, antibiotics and antivirals (Department of Defense 1998). However, this scenario requires the presumption that military applications of biotechnology will simply be a secular progression from the bacteriological warfare that has existed throughout history. Even when analysts have factored in the vast possibilities of genetic engineering, it has usually only been to the extent that they can breed deadlier pathogens, and that the growing availability of technology means that it may be used by a broader spectrum of actors. Conventional wisdom therefore predicts an unstable future for the international system, a Hobbesian world in which the weakest have power to kill the strongest. Rather than rogue states and non-state terrorists, it is the most powerful and resource-laden actors in the international system that will enjoy the advantages of “biological warfare” in the twenty-first century as they continuously integrate emergent biotechnologies into their military and national defense infrastructures and extend their dominance. This process will closely resemble the Revolution in Military Affairs (RMA) that occurred during the last 30 years of the twentieth century as the United States adapted its forces to exploit advances in new information technologies. The RMA, first described by the Soviet military intelligence in the 1970s and then witnessed by the world during the unexpectedly uneven 1991 Gulf War, occurred because the United States employed its competitive advantage in integrated computer systems. Rather than a single transformative device, like the atomic bomb, the steady accretion of advanced technologies augmenting existing equipment came to inform doctrine and strategies. The term asymmetric warfare is meant to describe efforts by weaker participants in military confrontations to frustrate the advantages of the stronger power by guerilla tactics or other unconventional methods not envisioned in force planning (Mack 1975). However, high technology also offers asymmetric advantages to the best-equipped actors, and American military planners sought to use the advances of the RMA to field forces that no state competitor could match. Their goals included “dominant maneuver” capability on the battlefield in bringing dispersed resources to bear against targets, “precision engagement” capability delivered by smart weapons, and “full dimension force protection” against all anticipated threats (Rizwan 2000). The ultimate expression of this vision would be a fighter comparable to a “Jedi knight” from the Star Wars films: a super-empowered solider, dressed in a protective stealth cloak and commanding an Defence Studies 321 armed companion drone, able to perform solo missions and to transmit data back to headquarters (Hundley and Gritton 1994). Coincidentally or not, this is precisely how Darth Maul was depicted in 1999’s The Phantom Menace. Military planners likewise foresee similar advantages conferred by developments across the various biotech fields. In coming decades, biotechnology is forecast to bring advances such as “rugged computers” made from biological components that will provide situational awareness to individual soldiers on the battlefield, camouflaged materials and lightweight armor incorporating the properties of living organisms, and ingested biological markers to distinguish friendlies, which would be of particular use in counterinsurgency (Purdue University 2001). From the perspective of those involved in force planning, the anticipated future is not one of vulnerability but unassailability.

2022 MNDI Affirmative
TEVV AFF – MNDI HPA › Solvency › AT Security K

The Aff is not based on Realist assumptions – our call for global norms and limits on arms reject realist assumptions. We rely on Utility Theory to explain the status quo

Sosanya, 2022 - AI researcher and a policy analyst at the Day One Project [Andrew, Jan 3, Peace Review A Journal of Social Justice “Autonomous Weapons Are Here to Stay” TM]

To understand why states ban weapons, we must first examine the dynamics of conflict and cooperation. The international system composed of states is commonly viewed through two lenses: realist and constructivist. From a realist stance, states exist in an anarchic world, and their actions are solely driven by security concerns, power, and material interests. While cooperation may occur through international institutions such as the United Nations (UN), realists believe that arms control is merely a tool of statecraft that solely reflects the distribution of power among states. To a realist, states agree to ban weapons only if they have little to no military utility. On the other hand, constructivists view the world as a product of social interactions within a web of different actors that gradually builds up preferential outcomes and behaviors. A central tenet of constructivism is the idea of norms that bind standards of behaviors influencing what these actors believe they “ought” to do, rather than making the most self-serving choice. Thus, states are conditioned to take a collaborative, humanitarian approach to arms control and ban weapons that their leaders and citizens believe to be inhumane, in which there exists a stigma or moral abhorrence typically associated with the use of the weapon itself. While both constructivism and realism have their merits in explaining the dynamics of the world, they cannot individually capture why weapons get banned. Realism cannot adequately explain why states ban weapons at all, nor can constructivism explain why states still develop and deploy certain weapons that are considered to be inhumane, even amongst those who use them. To predict what path of prohibition states will take with autonomous weapons, I introduce a framework that strikes the optimal balance between the two schools of thought: utility theory. Utility theory posits that states cannot cooperate to ban a class of weapons, inhumane or not, if they are considered by states to be decisive, meaning that they are crucial to winning a war. If those weapons are seen as indecisive and inhumane, however, states can cooperate on prohibition because the weapons’ stigma outweighs their usefulness. Utility theory predicts that autonomous weapons will not be banned because key stakeholders—state decision makers—are optimistic about their tactical and strategic benefits. These stakeholders consist of military leaders, political leaders, and others in the defense industry, and they have invested heavily in the development of autonomous weapons and auxiliary technologies, showing no sign of stopping anytime soon. With autonomous weapons, states can project more power with more efficiency and speed than states without them.

2022 MNDI Affirmative
TEVV AFF – MNDI HPA › Solvency › AT Ban AI CP

Military AI is inevitable – you cannot stop it – you can only make it safer with CBMs

Horowitz and Scharre 2021 - Director of the Emerging Capabilities Policy Office in the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Policy and  Vice President and Director of Studies at CNAS [Michael, Paul, January 12 2021, “AI and International Stability: Risks and Confidence- Building Measures”, , Acc 6/18/22. M.A.]

Military use of AI poses several risks, including the ways AI could change the character of warfare, the limitations of AI technology today, and the use of AI for specific military missions such as nuclear operations. Policymakers should be cognizant of these risks as nations begin to integrate AI into their military forces, and they should seek to mitigate these risks where possible. Because AI is a general-purpose technology, it is not reasonable to expect militaries to refrain from adopting AI overall, any more than militaries would refrain from adopting computers or electricity. How militaries adopt AI matters a great deal, however, and various approaches could mitigate risks stemming from military AI competition. Confidence-building measures are one potential tool policymakers could use to help reduce the risks of military AI competition among states. Confidence-building measures are one potential tool policymakers could use to help reduce the risks of military AI competition among states. There are a variety of potential confidence-building measures that could be used, all of which have different benefits and drawbacks. As scholars and policymakers move forward to better understand the risks of military AI competition, these and other confidence-building measures should be carefully considered, alongside other approaches such as traditional arms control.

2022 MNDI Affirmative
TEVV AFF – MNDI HPA › Solvency › AT Ban AI CP

The spread of military AI is inevitable – setting standards for reliability is key to avoiding disaster.

Horowitz, 2018 – Professor of Political Science at UPenn [Michael, September “The Algorithms of August: The AI arms race won't be like previous competitions, and both the United States and China could be left in the dust,” https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/09/12/will-the-united-states-lose-the-artificial-intelligence-arms-race/ 6/18/22 MD]

GIVEN AI'S MANY POTENTIAL MILITARY USES, policymakers need to rethink the idea of an AI arms race and what it will mean for international . The fundamental dilemma facing most attempts at arms control is that the more useful a technology is at providing with an edge, the harder it is to effectively regulate. There is, after all, no arms control agreement that meaningfully restricts countries from developing tanks, submarines, or fighter jets. Effective agreements tend to restrict the use of less important weapons that don't decide --such as landmines and blinding lasers--or ones that have rarely been used, such as nuclear weapons. suggests that those applications of AI with the greatest relevance for fighting and winning wars will also be the hardest to regulate, since states will have an interest in investing in them. Countries with advanced AI companies will be able to leverage those businesses to provide them with some military capabilities, either through adapting commercial technology or by offering financial incentives for talented researchers to focus on defense applications of AI. In these areas, the competition will be fierce because many actors could develop similar algorithms. Some AI applications, such as operational planning for a complex battlefield or algorithms designed to coordinate swarms of planes or boats trying to attack an enemy target, may appeal exclusively to militaries (though even swarms have nonmilitary applications, including firefighting). But even though there are clear military applications, AI cannot be compared to nuclear or or even military mainstays such as tanks. AI is not itself a weapon. Just as there was not an arms control regime for combustion engines or electricity, it's hard to imagine an effective regime for containing the coming AI arms race. Mitigating the military risks involved should therefore focus on specific potential uses of AI, rather than the broad technology category. For example, the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, which focuses on weapons systems with the potential to cause excessive or indiscriminate injury, is convening discussions in Geneva with countries around the world about lethal autonomous weapons systems. It is critical, however, not to let the specter of killer robots obscure the broader ways AI could reshape militaries, just as the general purpose technologies of previous centuries did. Rapid technological advances that outpace the ability of governments to administer them, fear of falling behind other countries, and uncertainty about the range of what is possible magnify the challenge of effectively regulating AI. Moreover, given the potential for economic investments in AI to spill over into potential military applications, many countries beyond the United States, China, and Russia may balk at regulatory approaches that limit their ability to develop more effective defense forces. Still, governments can create norms and practices surrounding the use of AI both inside and outside of militaries. Setting standards for AI reliability is one possibility, just like international standard setting in other arenas, such as Wi-Fi. Focusing on AI safety is a promising avenue to help ensure that, whatever forms of AI a defense team chooses to adopt, those applications work as intended. Predicting how AI will impact the future of warfare is difficult; it means assessing technologies that are still mostly immature. Much could change in just a few years. If a decade from now current predictions about the military uses of AI turn out to have been more fiction than fact, one reason might be because militaries failed to design algorithms that were robust and secure enough to withstand efforts by sophisticated adversaries to deceive and distort them.

2022 MNDI Affirmative
TEVV AFF – MNDI HPA › Solvency › AT Ban LAWS CP

There are many non-lethal applications of AI for the Military.

Horowitz, 2018 – Professor of Political Science at UPenn [Michael, September “The Algorithms of August: The AI arms race won't be like previous competitions, and both the United States and China could be left in the dust,” https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/09/12/will-the-united-states-lose-the-artificial-intelligence-arms-race/ 6/18/22 MD]

Most military applications of AI will be a far cry from the killer robots depicted in Hollywood films. For example, computer-run algorithms could aid militaries in better designing recruiting campaigns, more effectively training personnel, cutting labor costs through better logistical planning and operations, and improving surveillance. Or consider image recognition algorithms, which have a range of applications--from tailoring ads in the commercial sector to monitoring disputed territory. The race to develop such applications will be crowded for several reasons. For developed countries that have plenty of capital to invest but face challenges in recruiting and retaining talented personnel for their , as well as autocracies that do not trust their populations, there will be an especially strong incentive to leverage AI for their militaries. Doing so will allow them to replace personnel with  whenever possible.