Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
On-Case › Defense › Coates Indicts

Coates is wrong – Lack of precision in the reparations programs, amount of money given, regressive policies, social barriers – Means alt causes and no solvency.

Epstein 14 (“The Case Against Reparations for Slavery”, Richard A. Epstein, May 27th 2014, Richard A. Epstein, the Peter and Kirsten Bedford Senior Fellow (adjunct) at the Hoover Institution, is the Laurence A. Tisch Professor of Law, New York University Law School, and a senior lecturer at the University of Chicago, https://www.hoover.org/research/case-against-reparations-slavery) HSLA: RP

Coates is most evasive when discussing a proposed system of reparations. He notes quite properly that “broach the topic of reparations today and a barrage of questions inevitably follows: Who will be paid? How much will they be paid? Who will pay?” These are indeed fair questions, and yet at no point does he attempt to answer them. He endorses John Conyers proposal to form a Congressional committee to seek out “appropriate remedies” for the lingering effects of slavery and segregation, but offers few clues about its mission.

Nor are there easy analogies at hand. One possibility is to try to design some system based on the model of reparations for the internment program of 110,000 Japanese-Americans during the Second World War. But there, the payments were made to specific persons who were direct victims of wrong by the government. No program that seeks to remedy the wrongs of the past 350 years could hope to duplicate that level of precision.

2023 DDI Negative
On-Case › Defense › Alt Causes/Solvency Take Outs

Their rhetoric is strong BUT can’t solve.

Sunkara 19 (“To fight racism, we need to think beyond reparations, Bhaskar Sunkara, March 28th 2019, Bhaskar Sunkara is the president of The Nation, the founding editor Jacobin, and the author of The Socialist Manifesto: The Case for Radical Politics in An Era of Extreme Inequalities, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/mar/28/racism-reparations-democratic-candidates) HSLA: RP

The moral case for reparations is undeniable. The United States is a country built in large part off the labor of black slaves. Their coerced labor was turned into capital. That capital was appropriated by planters, filled the coffers of merchants, and fueled industrialists. Meanwhile, the descendants of slaves were stuck of the lowest rung of an incredibly violent and exploitative society.

Even after the tremendous gains of the Civil Rights movement and the election of a generation of black leaders, black Americans have to settle for the worst schools, the worst health care, the worst jobs, and the worst end of the worst justice system in the democratic world. Yet at the same time, they’re told by politicians – white and black, Democrat and Republican – that their woes are the product of a “culture of poverty”, that they need to just “pull up their pants” and try a little harder.

2023 DDI Negative
On-Case › Defense › Alt Causes/Solvency Take Outs

Reparations aren’t built on a concrete Scheme, there needs to be concrete policy action to creates the social change the aff strives for. No concrete policy leads to the circumvention of the program.

Frum 14. David Frum Worked as President George W. Bush’s Speech Writer, Now Staff Writer for the Atlantic on topics such as Politics, Policy, Art, Literature, and History. “The Impossibility of Reparations.” The Atlantic, Atlantic Media Company, 3 June 2014, www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/06/the-impossibility-of-reparations/372041/. Accessed 17 July 2023. ID.ELC

4) The program will work severe inequities. Affirmative action’s quirks and injustices are notorious. But they will be nothing compared to the strange consequences of a reparations program. Not all black people are poor. Not all non-black people are rich. Does Oprah have a housecleaner? Who changes the diapers of Beyonce’s baby? Who files Herman J. Russell’s taxes? Will their wages be taxed and the proceeds redirected to their employers? Within the target population, will all receive the same? Same per person, or same per family? Or will there be adjustment for need? How will need be measured? Will convicted criminals be eligible? If not, . If yes, the program would potentially tax victims of rape and families of the murdered for the benefit of their assailants. And if reparations were somehow delivered communally and collectively, disparities of wealth and power and political influence within black America will become even more urgent. Simply put, when government spends money on complex programs, the people who provide the service usually end up with much more sway over the spending than the spending’s intended beneficiaries. The poorer the beneficiaries, the more powerfully this rule holds—and it has held strongest of all in programs intended to aid the black poor. The District of Columbia public schools have excelled at delivering stable jobs to their unionized employees. They have failed their students.

2023 DDI Negative
On-Case › Defense › Alt Causes/Solvency Take Outs

Social economic change K2 moving the needle of the Racial Wealth Gap – Reparations alone is not enough.

William, and Mullen 20. “Why We Need Reparations for Black Americans.” Brookings, 15 June 2020, www.brookings.edu/articles/why-we-need-reparations-for-black-americans/. Accessed 18 July 2023. ID.ELC

This reparations package for Black Americans is about restoring the wealth that has been extracted from Black people and communities. Still, reparations are all for naught without enforcement of anti-discrimination policies that remove barriers to economic mobility and wealth building. The architecture of the economy must change in order to create an equitable society. The racial wealth gap was created by racist policies. Federal intervention is needed to remove the racism that undergirds those polices. In some respects, the question of who should receive reparations is more controversial than what or how much people should be awarded.

2023 DDI Negative
On-Case › Defense › Alt Causes/Solvency Take Outs

UBI as a reparations project cannot address inequity.

Jellicoe 19 (“I don’t think that reparations is a good idea”, Evan Jellicoe, September 14th 2019, https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2019/9/14/1885483/-I-don-t-think-that-reparations-is-a-good-idea#comments)

The subject of reparations is beginning to appear on Democratic radar again, but I don’t think this is a good thing.

I favor a universal basic income. I do not favor direct cash reparations for descendants of slaves. The reason is that UBI is a direct and workable response to present economic inequality, while reparations is one of those things that sound easy, but turn out to be frightfully complicated in carrying out.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Presidential Commission CP › Net-Benefit

Biden must independently enact a commission – Reinvigorates his presidential legitimacy and is necessary to address historic harms.

HRW 21 (“Repair Can’t Wait. Create Reparations Commission Now”, Human Rights Watch, May 13th 2021, Human Rights Watch (HRW) is a nonprofit, nongovernmental human rights organization made up of over 250 staff members located around the globe. HRW consists of journalists, lawyers, academics, and country experts of many nationalities and diverse backgrounds., https://www.hrw.org/ReparationsNow) HSLA: RP

History is within reach. Tell President Biden to establish a federal Reparations Commission Now.

The time for the United States to account for its legacy of enslavement is long overdue.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Presidential Commission CP › Solvency

Reparations Advocates agree a Presidential Commission is key to acknowledge historic anti-blackness.

Peterson 22 (“Advocates call on Biden to act on reparations study by Juneteenth”, Beatrice Peterson, June 17th 2022, Beatrice Peterson is a political reporter and producer for ABC News, https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/advocates-call-biden-act-reparations-study-juneteenth/story?id=85418510) HSLA: RP

Nkechi Taifa is director of the Reparation Education Project, and has been calling for reparations for more than 50 years. In 1987, she was one of the founders of the National Coalition of Blacks for Reparations in America (N'COBRA), an organization that worked closely with Democratic Rep. John Conyers to draft the introduction of H.R. 40 in 1989. She says now is the time for Biden to sign an executive order so the commission can be up and running before the end of Biden's presidency.

Taifa says she hopes the display at the ellipse sends a message that reparations advocates need to be paid attention to, and Black people should not be taken for granted.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Presidential Commission CP › 1NC

Extinction

Carrington 22 (“Climate endgame: risk of human extinction ‘dangerously underexplored’”, Domian Carrington, August 1st 2022, Damian Carrington is an environment editor at the Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/aug/01/climate-endgame-risk-human-extinction-scientists-global-heating-catastrophe) HSLA: RP

The risk of global societal collapse or human extinction has been “dangerously underexplored”, climate scientists have warned in an analysis.

They call such a catastrophe the “climate endgame”. Though it had a small chance of occurring, given the uncertainties in future emissions and the climate system, cataclysmic scenarios could not be ruled out, they said.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Presidential Commission CP › 1NC

Republican 2024 win makes catastrophic climate change inevitable.

Astor and Friedman 6/8 (“Where Republican Presidential Candidates Stand on Climate Change”, Maggie Astor and Lisa Friedman, June 8th 2028, Maggie Astor is a reporter covering live news and U.S. politics. She has also reported on climate, the coronavirus and disinformation, and was part of the New York Times teams that covered the 2018 and 2020 elections, Lisa Friedman is a reporter on the climate desk, focusing on climate and environmental policy in Washington. She has covered eight international climate talks and chased climate-related stories from the bottom of a Chinese coal mine to the top of snow-capped Himalaya Mountains, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/08/us/politics/wildfires-republicans-climate-change.html) HSLA: RP

As wildfires in Canada have sent masses of smoke over the United States this week, engulfing much of the Northeast in a yellow haze of hazardous air pollution, scientists are clear that we are seeing the effects of climate change. But the Republicans campaigning for the presidency have largely downplayed the issue and rejected policies that would slow rising temperatures.

On Wednesday, even as the country experienced one of its worst days on record for air quality, with New York City especially hard-hit, former Vice President Mike Pence said in a town-hall event on CNN that “radical environmentalists” were exaggerating the threat of climate change.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Presidential Commission CP › 1NC

Only independent Biden action on a reparations commission solves – Backing and cooperation with the legislative isn’t enough – Otherwise, he loses the 2024 Black vote which is key to reelection.

Kliegman 7/24 (“Biden blowing off Black voters, reparations activist say: the president ‘needs to act’”, Aaron Kliegman, July 24th 2023, Aaron Kliegman is a politics reporter for Fox News Digital, https://www.foxnews.com/politics/president-biden-blowing-off-black-voters-reparations-activists-say) HSLA: RP

President Biden is taking Black voters for granted and losing their support by remaining silent on – and not backing – reparations for Black Americans as a way to make amends for slavery and racism, according to pro-reparations activists who spoke to Fox News Digital.

"I believe the Biden administration's stance is emblematic of the Democratic Party's benign neglect of Black voters – ADOS [American descendants of slavery] voters more specifically," said Yvette Carnell, president of the ADOS Advocacy Foundation. "Black voters are whipped into a frenzy around election time, and Republicans are made into boogeymen who, as Biden himself said back in 2012, want to 'put y'all back in chains.' It's fear-mongering, rather than offering a reparations framework or a transformative Black agenda that we can actually get excited about."

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Presidential Commission CP › 1NC

That solves the aff – Leads to non-political legislative follow on and creates a better analysis of the state’s relationship to anti-black history.

Johnson 19 (“Reparations Won’t Start With Congress. A President Needs to Do That.”, Theodore R. Johnson, June 21st 2019, Theodore R. Johnson is a senior fellow at the Brennan Center and an adjunct professor at Georgetown University’s McCourt School of Public Policy, https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2019/06/21/reparations-hearing-2020-candidates-congress-227194/) HSLA: RP

For all the attention the congressional hearing got this week, Congress is the wrong venue if America is really going to move forward with a reparations study. It’s highly unlikely such a contentious measure would ever make it through the House or the Senate, assuming either would even put it to a vote. Instead, the push is going to have to come from the White House.

Though it won’t happen in the Trump administration, this idea is no longer as outlandish as it once might have seemed. The United States is now heading into its first presidential campaign where several candidates have expressed their support for studying reparations for the descendants of enslaved black Americans. The White House has unique power to focus national attention, and a presidential commission—far more than the congressional commission discussed this week—would have the prestige and traction to pull in national leaders and shape public opinion.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › Alternative

Reparations was never meant to be a monetary project – Only the alt alone solves.

Ray and Perry 7/27 (Rashawn, is a senior fellow in Governance Studies at the Brookings Institution, renowned for his expertise in understanding and addressing racial and social inequality. Andre is a Senior Fellow at Brookings Metro, a scholar-in-residence at American University, and a professor of practice of economics at Washington University. Why we need reparations for Black Americans. Brookings. April 15, 2020. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/why-we-need-reparations-for-black-americans/. DOA 7/27/23)//NPR

Reparations for slavery and anti-Black policies We know the monetary value that was placed on enslaved Blacks and the productivity of their labor, as well as the amount of the racial wealth gap. We’ve seen other groups receive restitutions while the federal government pulled back reparations for Black Americans. Accordingly, if we want to close the racial wealth gap and live up to our moral creed to protect “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness,” a federal reparations package for Black Americans is in order. This package should include individual and collective public benefits that simultaneously builds wealth and eliminates debt among Black citizens. We assert that it should be similar to the Harriet Tubman Community Investment Act, which was recently heard before the Maryland General Assembly where Ray testified on its behalf. The Harriet Tubman Community Investment Act aims to atone for slavery and its legacy by addressing education, homeownership, and business ownership barriers. Individual payments for descendants of enslaved Black Americans The U.S. government owes lost wages as well as damages to the people it helped enslave. In addition to the lost wages, the accumulative amount of restitution for individuals should eliminate the racial wealth gap that currently exists. According to the Federal Reserve’s most recent numbers in 2016, based on the Survey of Consumer Finances, white families had the highest median family wealth at $171,000, compared to Black and Hispanic families, which had $17,600 and $20,700, respectively. College tuition to 4-year or 2-year colleges and universities for descendants of enslaved Black Americans People should be able to use the tuition remission to obtain a bachelor’s degree or an associate’s/vocational or technical degree. Tuition should be available for public or private universities. Considering the racial gap in the ability to obtain degrees at private schools, this part of the package will further help to reduce racial disparities by affording more social network access and opportunity structures. Student loan forgiveness for descendants of enslaved Black Americans Student loan debt continues to be a significant barrier to wealth creation for Black college graduates. Among 25-55 year olds, about 40 percent of Blacks compared to 30 percent of whites have student loan debt. Blacks also have nearly $45,000 of student loan debt compared to about $30,000 for whites. Recent research finds that Blacks are more likely to be allocated unsubsidized loans. Furthermore, graduates of Historically Black Colleges and Universities, compared to Predominately White Institutions, are more likely to receive subprime loans with higher interest rates. Universities including Georgetown and Princeton Theological Seminary, which is the second-oldest seminary in the country, are aiming to atone for the fact that the sale of slaves helped to fortify their university endowments and establish them as elite institutions of higher education on a global scale. Descendants of the slaves sold by Georgetown and Princeton Theological Seminary are now entitled to full rights and benefits bestowed by those universities to obtain degrees across the higher education pipeline. The Virginia state legislature voted for some of its state universities to atone for slavery with reparations. Other universities, along with state legislatures and the federal government, should follow suit. Down payment grants and housing revitalization grants for descendants of enslaved Black Americans Down payment grants will provide Black Americans with some initial equity in their homes relative to mortgage insurance loans. Housing revitalization grants will help Black Americans to refurbish existing homes in neighborhoods that have been neglected due to a lack of government and corporate investments in predominately Black communities. Given recent settlements for predatory lending, low and fixed interest rates as well as property tax caps in areas in which housing prices are significantly devalued should be part of the package. After accounting for factors such as housing quality, neighborhood quality, education, and crime, owner-occupied homes in Black neighborhoods are undervalued by $48,000 per home on average, amounting to a whopping $156 billion that homeowners would have received if their homes were priced at market rates, according to Brookings research. As gentrification occurs, Blacks are typically priced out of neighborhoods they helped to maintain, while the historical and current remnants of redlining and restrictive covenants inhibited investments. Some Black Americans are being forced from their family home of decades because of tax increases as neighborhoods are gentrified. This is an important point because some 2020 Democratic presidential candidates aimed to redress the racial wealth gap by focusing on historically redlined districts. Perry’s research shows that these policies fall short of capturing a large segment of Black Americans. Business grants for business starting up, business expansion to hire more employees, or purchasing property for descendants of enslaved Black Americans Black-owned businesses are more likely to be located in predominately Black neighborhoods that need the infrastructure and businesses. However, Black business owners are still less likely to obtain capital from banks to make their businesses successful. This reparations package for Black Americans is about restoring the wealth that has been extracted from Black people and communities. Still, reparations are all for naught without enforcement of anti-discrimination policies that remove barriers to economic mobility and wealth building. The architecture of the economy must change in order to create an equitable society. The racial wealth gap was created by racist policies. Federal intervention is needed to remove the racism that undergirds those polices. In some respects, the question of who should receive reparations is more controversial than what or how much people should be awarded.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › Reparations Links

The 1AC failed the moment it viewed reparations as a responsibility and obligation the state must do rather than a liability – Monetary UBI reparations is a responsibility from the state to its citizens that pushes black fungibility to the edges of white futurity that refuses to make racialized connections – Only framing reparations as a liability creates the necessary discrimination and linkage to disrupt the global racial empire.

Táíwò’22 [“Reconsidering Reparations.”, February 2022, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles, https://academic.oup.com/book/38812/chapter/337658637] CC and RP

So far, we’ve set one target for a good view of reparations: it should be rooted in, or at least expressible in terms of liability and not just in terms of responsibility. We’ve also discussed major challenges for each view on its own. But none of the views came out unblemished and each has benefits and drawbacks. To judge between the different ways of thinking about reparations, it will help to be direct and explicit about what a view about reparations ought to accomplish. Putting the standards in order of priority will also matter here, since it will help us decide between views that do well on some standards but not as well on others. I propose these three standards, in this order: 1. Reparations for global racial empire should make tangible differences in the material conditions of people’s lives. 2. Reparations for global racial empire should address the core moral wrongs of trans-Atlantic slavery and colonialism, to the extent possible. 3. Reparations for global racial empire should discriminate: should distribute benefits and burdens based on the different relationships of persons and institutions to the core moral wrongs. The remainder of this chapter will focus on unpacking these standards and exploring how well different approaches to reparations address them. Standard 1 The first standard is the most important, and also the most complicated. By putting this criterion first, I want to resist treating arguments for reparations on purely intellectual grounds, untethered from the history of activism and political struggle that put the issue on the table in the first place. It’s not simply the fact that the moral atrocities happened; it is also the connection of those atrocities to presentday misery, incarceration, poverty, and desperation that explains reparation’s importance. This standard is about what we want reparations to do. It says that reparations for global racial empire should make tangible differences in the material conditions of people’s lives—the conditions of their living, working, and relating to each other. It’s hard to do better in explaining this priority than Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. did in his book Why We Can’t Wait: The Negro today is not struggling for some abstract, vague rights, but for concrete and prompt improvement in his way of life. What will it profit him to be able to send his children to an integrated school if the family income is insufficient to buy them school clothes? What will he gain by being permitted to move to an integrated neighborhood if he cannot afford to do so because he is unemployed or has a low-paying job with no future? During the lunch-counter sit-ins in Greensboro, North Carolina, a nightclub comic observed that, had the demonstrators been served, some of them could not have paid for the meal . . . The struggle for rights is, at bottom, a struggle for opportunities.95 In placing material welfare first, I don’t presume that cultural or spiritual needs are unimportant. We need recognition, we need acknowledgement, we need good relationships with the people around us. But I do presume that we need to eat and protect ourselves from premature death and suffering, more than we need vindication—whether in cultural narratives, textbooks, or fancy academic journals. I presume that protection against mass displacement is a more fundamental need than the need for reconciliation with our neighbors. While such reconciliation might complement or strengthen such protection, the reverse is not true: without housing security, neighborly reconciliation becomes trivial to meaningless. So if we prioritize improving the material conditions of people’s lives, what approach to reparations best fits the bill? Relationship repair arguments, particularly the communicative versions, don’t seem up to the job. For these views, changing the living conditions of the potential recipients of reparations is more of a potential outcome of the main action than a target—to the extent that it is considered at all. The focus is on inter-group relations: the possibility of genuine moral community between those who inherit the claim right to reparations and those who inherit a moral liability to pay reparations. Proponents of this view agree that some sort of material and not merely symbolic reparations are called for, but this is because of the communicative consequences of making serious material concessions – making the attendant apologetic gestures credible as sincere and genuine.96 The living conditions of the people with the moral claim to reparations thus fades into the background, playing at best an instrumental role in explaining both how we would justify reparations projects and what they would be designed to accomplish. The harm repair view and the debt repayment version of the relationship repair view seem initially like they are better positioned to meet this first, most important standard. Both share a legalistic reference point that focuses on a concept of welfare. A clear virtue of the harm repair strategy is its preoccupation with the material and political lives of oppressed people. For the harm repair theorists, reparations ought to make a difference in the lives of the descendants of the enslaved and colonized, in concrete terms that make up for the harms they face as a result of their membership in those identity categories. But harm repair arguments may risk understanding even material welfare too narrowly. The danger is something like a resourcist view of racism: that what racial disadvantage comes down to is having less stuff, broadly speaking, than racially advantaged people. After all, those who make harm repair arguments often appeal to the amount of wealth that the racially advantaged. And a close inspection of the debt repayment family of arguments finds that they do not assign direct primary importance to the living conditions of the people who are currently owed reparations. The primary harms and injuries considered in this argument are those that befell the ancestors of the people who today are owed reparations. To the extent that harms to people living and breathing today shows up in the argument, it is as whatever particular harm can be contrived into a shape that will attach to non-payment of reparations, rather than in terms of the current living conditions and life chances of these people. These arguments for reparations, if successful, could at best tell us that reparations are owed to today’s Black people. These arguments couldn’t tell us what current rates of poverty, physical and mental health, or low levels of community institutional power and self-determination have to do with reparations as a project. The social and political conditions that make reparations important fade into the background, playing at best a rhetorical role in the justification and design of reparations projects designed on this basis. Proponents of the harm repair view could respond by expanding what they mean by harm, expanding it until the targets for correction include not only income disparities but also the psychological, social institutional, interpersonal and informal consequences of racism or colonialism. But I’ve argued that, if they study this carefully, they will find that fewer of the determinants of these aspects of social structure lie in any particular country, church, university, or state government’s jurisdiction than they bargained for. If they arrive at a set of reforms that will comprehensively change the social structures that in fact undergird the forms of domination that live on in the current political conditions of their people, they will have arrived at the constructive view: they will be describing a worldmaking project. Standard 2 Applying the second and third standards is more straightforward and makes use of the observations we’ve already made in applying the first standard. The second standard holds that reparations for global racial empire should respond to the core moral wrongs that these involved. A structural understanding of slavery, colonialism, and their legacy invites us to view the core wrongs of both the events (atrocities of slavery and the slave trade, colonial conquest, genocides) and also the social structure built out of these. The communicative repair view targets our attitudes and normative expectations of ourselves and each other. Some version of this might be required to make meaningful progress in achieving social justice, since our institutions are partly constructed by our attitudes and expectations. But this is an overly narrow view, for the historical processes that we seek to replace set up vastly different schedules of accumulation of social advantages and disadvantages – not just mistrust and lack of camaraderie. The debt repayment view targets our relationship of obligation, and our ability to inherit moral debts and liabilities. It is certainly true that past generations’ nonpayment of individual or collective reparations is a wrong. But it hardly seems a compelling construal of the core moral wrong: enslaving and colonizing people are wrong in and of themselves, not just because the slavers and colonizers avoided compensating those they wronged afterward. The constructive view responds directly to both aspects of the core moral wrongs of global moral empire. It addresses the events with its distributive principle: requiring those who inherited the moral liabilities of the atrocities of the past to take on more of the burdens of building the just world than those who inherit the moral claim rights. It addresses the structural aspect of the core moral wrong by setting a just world order as its practical target. Standard 3 That brings us to the third standard: that a good reparations view should discriminate, selecting beneficiaries and burdened parties based on their historical relationships to the core moral wrongs under consideration. The constructive view does this, building it in as a distributive principle in a larger social project. The debt repayment and harm repair views also lend themselves to discrimination, but they are only built to handle a simple binary. This starkness may seem more morally stringent, but it is no advantage. As noted in this chapter’s discussion of liability and also of the major challenge for the harm repair view, the relationship of all of us to past oppression is more complicated than such binary accounting allows. The world order determines all of our political circumstances, and all of us are advantaged and disadvantaged by it in various respects. What separates us, largely, is the extent to which we are benefitted and the extent to which we are harmed. In “If the Shoe Fits” Vincene Verdun discusses her past: she discloses that she is descended both from enslaved people of African descent and slave-owning planters of French descent. Similarly, in the present, as an African-American she is someone who is owed reparations, but as a US citizen she is someone who pays taxes and thus would contribute to any scheme of reparations financed by the United States federal government. Rather than explaining this away, she uses it constructively to argue that it fits squarely into reparation as she envisions it: something that addresses her simultaneously as someone to whom something is owed and someone from whom something is owed. Accepting this complication allows us to decisively reject the specious right-wing objections to reparations projects that suggest that rich Black folk like Oprah and Jay-Z are insurmountable complications. Just as the differences in our relationship to history lie in the extent to which we are advantaged and disadvantaged by the world order of global racial empire, our relationship to reparations projects should be determined by the extent to which we have inherited moral liabilities versus the extent to which we have inherited claim rights. We don’t need a rigid binary between one sort of inheritance and the other.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › Reparations Links

Monetary UBI approach frames anti-blackness in accounting terms which only goes insofar to frame black success as become closer to white being – That makes it impossible to address systematic violence and creates the worse forms of anti-black violence.

Táíwò’22 [“Reconsidering Reparations.” February 2022, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles, https://academic.oup.com/book/38812/chapter/337658637] CC and RP

Harm repair arguments give reparations the role of fixing present harms causally connected to or constituted by past harms. These arguments tend to use a conception of harm (or wrongdoing) that considers the aggrieved party to have harmed the victim by lowering their standard of welfare from some baseline that they would have enjoyed but for the offense. Reparations ‘repair’ this damage by distributing benefits to the victim that closes the gap between their current state of welfare and this baseline, perhaps with some interest for their trouble. These arguments are popular in the legal community since they make use of legal ways of conceptualizing harm and injury. This view also seems like it is the best representation of the rationale given by N’COBRA (National Council of Blacks for Reparations in America) for why African Americans are owed reparations, which the organization positions as a response to the “many forms of injury caused by chattel slavery and its continuing vestiges.” N’COBRA also emphasizes that reparation is a principle of international human rights law. This view has a wide uptake beyond organizational politics, in part because of the strong rhetorical appeal and strategic utility of the ready-made legal framework of harm redress that these arguments tend to make intelligent use of. For example, Joel Morse, a professor of finance, and Jetaime Ross, a community organizer, “propose a very preliminary conceptual model that may be useful in addressing the reparations issue” which “relies on a standard forensic economics framework used in US courts. In a typical personal injury litigation situation, an injury (known as a tort) is brought for analysis and possible recompense or ‘making the victim whole.’ Typically, the first step is to estimate what income would be ‘but for’ the wrongdoing and subtract it from actual post-injury income.” More recently, William Darity and A. Kirsten Mullen’s from Here to Equality advocates for a “restitution”-based approach to reparations, which would aim to move the descendants of American slavery toward a “more equitable position commensurate with the status they would have attained in the absence of the injustice(s).” I agree that the harm repair view serves a useful role in some domains of political and legal philosophy—it makes sense as a way to think about justice when someone is injured in a workplace, for example. A major advantage of applying this view to the less discrete case of reparations is that it leads us to focus on “making whole” the descendants of those enslaved. It gets something very important right; in that it focuses on the present-day ramifications of past injustices for people’s lives and welfare. Nevertheless, I’ll argue that this strategy is missing something. It runs into serious difficulties in dealing with reparations claims like the ones advanced for trans-Atlantic slavery and colonialism. It invites us to view Black suffering in accounting terms—which political theorist Lawrie Balfour notes is a point of view well suited to process aspects of systematic injustice like the labor stolen from Black peoples under slavery but isn’t obviously up to the task of redressing other systematic aspects of suffering such as systematic sexual violence. Another, conceptionally related perspective is what Adolph Reed and Merlin Chowkwanyun call the “disparitarian perspective”: viewing the differences and disparities between racial groups as the primary or even sole method of diagnosing and responding to racial injustice. Disparities between the disadvantaged and advantaged group come to be how harm is understood, and the elimination of disparity dominates our imagination about solutions. But this involves a dangerously reductive view about racism and injustice, and a counterproductive one. As Reed puts it, the policy recommendations that issue from this perspective tend to “represent détente with rather than commitment to changing capitalist class relations, including those that contribute to intra- and inter-racial disparities in the first place.” Focusing on disparities is an effective rhetorical strategy but a blunt conceptual instrument. We could, after all, resolve racial disparities in criminal justice by judging white defendants more harshly and policing their communities in a more draconian fashion. We could mitigate the environmental racism dramatized in Flint by polluting white neighborhoods’ air and poisoning their wells as well. This would mitigate disparities, and perhaps even the stigma and dishonor of being connected to a racially or colonially disadvantaged group (since it would no longer correlate with lower standards of living) but it would not accomplish racial justice. Harm repair views often run afoul of this point; for example, recall that Darity and Mullen’s view of reparation treats eliminating “racial disparities” in things like wealth, income, and incarceration as a specification of how reparations would move descendants toward a “more equitable position commensurate with the status they would have attained in the absence of the injustice(s).” This shows the danger of the politics of incessant comparison, and of an anti-politics that is overfocused on the easy questions about what we are against. But justice is about what we’re for: we don’t simply want our children to get as good an education as white children, we want them to get a good education, which involves having a view of what a good education is and how it should be made accessible and distributed to people.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › Reparations Links

Monetary reparations cannot address truth telling – It must break out of its anti-black conceptions of wealth and expand, radically, to distributive justice.

Klien and Fouksman 21 (Elise, a Lecturer of Development Studies at the School of Social and Political Sciences, University of Melbourne in Australia. Elizaveta is a Lecturer in Social Justice at the Centre for Public Policy Research in the School of Education. Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice. International Institute of Social Studies, The Hague. November 21, 2021. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/dech.12695. DOA 7/27/23)//NPR

Another set of distributional claims, known as reparations, do seek to directly address the ongoing legacy of racial violence, slavery, genocide and colonialism. There are examples of reparations being made for such acts. For instance, in 2003 the British government made a payment of over £ 20 million in reparations to more than 5,000 survivors of the Mau Mau rebellion (Balint, 2016). After World War II, Germany was ordered to pay reparations for the Holocaust to Polish and Jewish survivors (Kelley, 2002). In 1989, the US was ordered to pay over US$ 1.2 billion to Japanese-American survivors of internment by the US government during World War II (Campbell, 2009). More recently, the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal issued a decision that the Canadian federal government pay CA$ 40,000 per child impacted by the country’s residential schools, totalling over CA$ 2 billion (Cultural Survival, n.d.).4 And in 2021, Germany offered Namibia € 1.1 billion in development aid as a gesture of reconciliation for the Herero-Nama genocide (Oltermann, 2021). While in practice reparations have been largely administered in relation to concrete collective claims for monetary redress recognized by the state and judiciary (as in the examples above), reparations can also be integrated into larger redistributive systems in order to change unjust social and economic structures while providing an avenue for recognition and truth telling. (Rubio-Marin, 2009). This is particularly vital because structures put in place during colonialism and slavery continue to pattern local and global societies and economies. For instance, racism which evolved during British colonization, the trans-Atlantic slave trade, slavery and Jim Crow laws, has shaped and continues to shape racist norms, laws and policies underpinning the US economy and society (Darity and Mullen, 2020). In her ethnography of Jamaica, Deborah Thomas (2011) sees reparations as more than monetary or procedural, and calls for a structural framing of distributional claims. This shifts reparations away from purely economic justice, and towards variegated forms of redistribution plus recognition, in line with what Thomas calls a ‘reparations framework for thinking’. Such a reparations framework for thinking compels a refocusing on how ‘the current structural inequalities have emerged and persist as a result of real and codified institutional discrimination rather than because of cultural “deviation” and “dysfunctions”’ (Thomas, 2011: 6). Thomas explores the links between contemporary economic inequality in Jamaica and slavery, for instance in the way provisioning practices by slave owners are linked to contemporary politics, or the way slavery’s effects on family structures underpin culturalist views of poverty or violence. The key to a reparations way of thinking is the recognition of the continuity of historical and contemporary structures of oppression. A reparations way of thinking can thus enable demands for both recognition and monetary redistribution alongside structural reform. This article places calls for redistributory and reparatory justice in dialogue, tracing points of overlap and friction. In particular, we juxtapose justice-based claims for the universal distribution of wealth generated by previous generations or via collective resources with claims for redress for the ways in which such wealth creation dispossessed and oppressed certain groups. Placing proposals for a universal rightful share based on claims of distributory justice within a reparations framework leads us to consider whether (re)distribution can be both universal and reparative of specific historical wrongs. In so doing, we also explore whether distributory justice can be rightful without being reparative of specific historical wrongs, asking if historical and ongoing racialized violence can be adequately addressed by focusing purely on class-based economic redistribution, which is often the main concern of distributional claims.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › Black Cosmo Links

They’ve chosen their history…one full of carefully chosen plots to hide the way anti-blackness has been implanted into world systems through historic colonialism and oppressions.

Klien and Fouksman 21 (Elise, a Lecturer of Development Studies at the School of Social and Political Sciences, University of Melbourne in Australia. Elizaveta, is a Lecturer in Social Justice at the Centre for Public Policy Research in the School of Education. Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice. International Institute of Social Studies, The Hague. November 21, 2021. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/dech.12695. DOA 7/27/23)//NPR

Calls for universal distributive justice shift the framing of policies like universal basic income away from the realm of poverty alleviation or welfare and into the realm of rights and claim making. Framing redistribution as aid, welfare or charity forecloses a recognition of the economic contribution made by past unacknowledged workers as well as those expropriated in the generation of capital, or simply the collective nature of the wealth generated by previous generations. A similar point can be made about international development, which is typically framed in charitable rather than reparative terms by the West. Yet shifting redistributory demands from welfare or charity to a universal ‘rightful share’ (Ferguson, 2015) or a social right to economic security (Fraser and Gordon, 1993; Marshall, 1963) still lacks the recognition of specific historical wrongs such as slavery and colonialism. It is this recognition that has been an enduring demand from postindependence nation states, from Black communities in the US around the ongoing ramifications of slavery, and from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples asking for the telling of truth regarding the settler foundations of Australia. We thus contend that a reparations way of thinking is needed within calls for universal distributory justice. This way of thinking also allows us to look beyond race to other ways in which certain groups of people have been exploited and expropriated by others — namely, via gender. We do not have the scope to address the question of reparations and gender in this article, but given the historical and ongoing harms of patriarchy, in particular the ongoing free-riding and expropriation of women’s unpaid care work and social reproduction (Fraser, 2016, 2018), and indeed the central role of patriarchy within capitalist production and accumulation (Bhattacharyya, 2018), a reparative way of thinking is also useful when considering what is rightful through a gendered lens (Rubio-Marin, 2009; Wells, 2014). Recognition and redress through reparations are important for acknowledging not just past wrongs, but also the ways these wrongs underpin contemporary inequalities. Such historical wrongs engender race and class (and gender) relations that still have material and affective impacts today. In the post-independence case, we examined how unequal global systems set up under colonialism continue to underpin divisions between the majority world and its former colonizers. In the settler colonial case, we showed how dispossession of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples continues through racialized punitive welfare programmes, the continued dispossession of lands and the denial of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander sovereignty. Racialized systems in the US set up under slavery still impact Black communities today, for example through mass incarceration, employment and educational outcomes and broader inequalities of both income and wealth. There are intersections between redistributory universalism and reparative redress. In many cases, the links between class and race can be reflected in statistics of poverty. However, this can also hide the way in which race has been the grammar of unequal relations and has justified expropriation and exploitation in places like the US since colonization. This is also the case in Australia, where ignoring the ways in which race and coloniality have impacted and continue to impact Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples ignores aspects of settler colonialism that are not only about economic dispossession, but also about racism, white supremacy and patriarchy. Yet (re)distribution must be as much a key part of reparatory justice as is recognition. As Nancy Fraser (2003, 2005) has pointed out, recognition without redistribution holds the danger of displacing struggles for economic justice — an issue that Fraser argues has plagued feminism in recent decades (Fraser, 2005: 298). The negotiations between Namibia and Germany around the Herero-Nama genocide are another example: while Germany is willing to recognize the genocide, and give some additional development aid as part of this recognition, it has declined to term the accompanying payment ‘reparations’, fearing to set a precedent for other or larger redistributive claims to reparative payments. Fraser has argued that both recognition and substantive redistribution are equally essential parts of social justice; one cannot be forsaken in favour of the other. Here we have built on that argument to make the case that the two are in fact intertwined in justice-based claims for shares of collective wealth. All three cases illustrate common themes. While the US is a post-slavery society, it is also a settler colonial state, and insights from the Australian case have resonance for Native Americans in the US who also have substantive claims for reparative justice. The US case gave us one possibility on how mechanisms of distributive justice can also do some measure of reparative work via universal, redistributive and individual payments framed as a rightful share. A U+BI contends with some of the issues of recognition and redress raised in this article. While it is universal in scope and rightful in framing, the addition of the plus includes recognition of specific historical ills in need of reparative justice. The Australian case also suggested avenues that could accompany reparations, showing how not just recognition but also sovereignty could include specific national truth-telling processes, returning of land rights and self-determination, along with a U+BI or other forms of reparative redistribution. These reparative packages would need to be directed by Indigenous peoples themselves. Decentralized and decolonial cosmopolitanism — such as a global UBI framed as reparations for colonialism and its after-effects — may help fulfil reparations for postindependence injustice. However, these payments need to also transcend nation state boundaries and connect with people that are stateless, or diaspora dispersed because of colonialism and slavery. We have made the case that reparative justice must become a key part of conceptualizing claims for distributional justice or claims to a share of collective wealth. This is both for instrumental and intrinsic reasons. Universal forms of distributive justice that do not consider claims to redress can do damage, for instance if, in settler colonial states and post-independent states, a universal basic income is used to mute claims to more radical forms of redistribution as well as sovereignty or self-governance. At the same time, we contend that if claims to distribution are based on a historical case around the communal creation of wealth by past generations, then this view must also encompass the ways this wealth creation has been intertwined with a global history of racist expropriation. Thus, in conceptualizing claims to distributive justice, we must take into account claims for reparative justice, particularly as they highlight the limits of nation state boundaries and the importance of recognition and redress for past and contemporary harms. Only then can what is rightful also encompass the right to atonement and redress.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › Black Cosmo Links

The Racial Contract builds global socioeconomic privilege that implicates national level anti-blackness – The Political imaginary of reparations must be bigger than national level wealth.

Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.24-26, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations 9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

In his landmark 1994 book The Racial Contract, philosopher Charles Mills borrows the “social contract” language of liberal political thought to make this same claim about the basic organization of the world’s social structures. He argues that we live in a world “built by the Racial Contract”; that is, “global white supremacy” is itself a political system, the one resulting from the fact that the world has been “foundationally shaped for the past five hundred years by the . . . gradual consolidation of global white supremacy.”28 Mills characterizes that political system in comprehensive, distributive terms, describing it as “a particular power structure of formal or informal rule, socioeconomic privilege, and norms for the differential distribution of material wealth and opportunities, benefits and burdens, rights and duties.”29 This book contends that he is correct.

As this chapter moves forward to explain the structure of today’s world in terms of the historical motions it embodies, it will be helpful to pause first to highlight a key pair of concepts that we will return to throughout the book—cumulative advantage and cumulative disadvantage.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › 1NC

The Alternative is to reject the 1ACs reductive imaginary of racial history and reparations in favor of a Black Cosmo-Constructive reading of the Reparations Project - Key to addressing the global racial empire.

Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg. 84-85, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

An organizing principle of Rawls’s thought is the idea that distributive justice concerns arrangements of people or associations. Justice is bound up with the idea of fairness, and fairness is bound up with the idea of being co-members of some kind of scheme of cooperation—for Rawls, the society. Rawls then develops a view of distributive justice that focuses on idealized closed societies because he believes this is the form of association between people that could explain duties to redistribute. In my view, among the mistakes Rawls and other authors made in ignoring the history of global racial empire is a mischaracterization of what states actually are, and in what sense they are separate from each other.23

Cosmopolitan approaches to distributive justice advocated by other thinkers aim to remedy the curious generalizations of a Rawlsian view. Some cosmopolitans advocate for global redistribution and intervention on grounds that ignore institutional separations of people altogether, preferring universal moral commitments to equality or dignity as the explanation for why the well-off should change things for the benefit of the worse off.24 But this book argues for a different kind of cosmopolitan view: one that looks at specific global superstructures— institutions, associations, chains of production, and norms—to ground a distributive justice analysis for specific historical reasons.25 The constructive view of reparations is cosmopolitan in this sense.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › 1NC

Their nationalist wealth approach to understanding historic and present anti-blackness fails to account for the world economic order – A post-colonial project that makes any one nation attempt at reparations to addressing anti-blackness simply shift the scope of economic white supremacy in new ways globally – The Impact is endless shifts in anti-black violence.

Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg. 19-21, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

We live in a “world economic order.” As Martin Luther King, Jr. told us sixty years ago, you can’t go through a basic action in your day without participating in a global interaction. Odds are good that you ordered this book on a device with materials mined in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, assembled in China, and shipped to yet a third continent for sale. This global economic system that we have distributes rewards and even basic economic functions to different parts of the world through networks of trade, exchange, and movement. Some countries specialize in the manufacture of particular physical goods: perhaps petroleum, like Nigeria or Saudi Arabia; coffee and cocoa, like the Ivory Coast. Other countries specialize in being tax havens for the wealth of the world’s elite, like Switzerland and Monaco. A range of “internal” political activity organizes and optimizes this activity within the borders of nation states, through means such as taxation, subsidization, and regulation to zoning, housing, and education.

To some extent, then, these sovereign nations control how things go within their borders. But their economic activity relies on what’s going on in the rest of the world, often more acutely than on what’s going on inside. Apparently “internal” Nigerian or Saudi decisions about producing petroleum actually succeed or fail based on which cars are on the road in China or the United States; how much cocoa to produce in the Ivory Coast depends on how much chocolate is being eaten in Belgium or France; the likelihood of which financial incentives will attract foreign licit and illicit capital to Monaco or Atlantic City depends on what the other tax havens are offering.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Reparations › Anti-Blackness Kritik › 1NC

The 1ACs tracing of history and genealogy cannot rationalize the Atlantic Order – A system that globally constructs anti-blackness that makes any one country approach or analysis to historical anti-black colonialism fail to understand the true political imaginary necessary to challenge racialized structures.

Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg.23-24, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

The story of the construction of our world is the story by which the ‘Atlantic Order,’ what historian Joseph Inikori terms the large but not yet global system of slavery and colonialism, came to encompass the whole globe.26 Racism and colonialism were the basic structure of the Atlantic Order, and they accompanied and catalyzed the expansion of the Atlantic Order into a fully global economic structure. And the outcome, the global economy, is today managed and directed by global capitalism: so if global racial empire is the what, then capitalism is the how.

In the beginning, the connection between racism, colonialism, and capitalism was obvious. The latter was built with political and juridical structures that explicitly mentioned race and empire and overtly managed the affairs of business in the context of both. As Karl Marx succinctly explains in The Poverty of Philosophy: “Direct slavery is just as much the pivot of bourgeois industry as machinery, credits, etc. Without slavery you have no cotton; without cotton you have no modern industry. It is slavery that gave the colonies their value; it is the colonies that created world trade, and it is world trade that is the precondition of large-scale industry. Thus slavery is an economic category of the greatest importance.”