Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › 1NCs---Need Impacts › Horsetrading 1NC---Social Security

The plan gets horse-traded for privatizing Social Security

James G. Chappel 2-13 (James G. Chappel is Gilhuly Family Associate Professor of History at Duke University; “The Frozen Politics of Social Security”; Boston Review; https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/the-frozen-politics-of-social-security/)//TMS-Isir

Despite this dire situation, there has not been a congressional vote, even in committee, on major reforms to Social Security since 1983. This has not been for lack of trying, at least among Democrats. In both the House and the Senate, there are serious bills, with significant support, to salvage the program. The most well-developed, known as Social Security 2100, has more than 200 cosponsors in the House. It’s an audacious bill, planning to expand Social Security benefits for the first time since the 1970s, focusing especially on the caregiving workforce. And in the Senate, Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren have put forth an even more ambitious plan, which would raise taxes and benefits while expanding the program’s solvency for decades. Still, the odds of anything happening with these bills are low, at least for now. In addition to the expected Republican intransigence, Democrats themselves are not united. The relevant division is between a politics of incrementalism and a politics of bold reform and expansion. Social Security 2100 is on the less ambitious end of the spectrum, especially as it has recently been rewritten to keep Biden’s promise of not raising taxes on people making less than $400,000 per year. As such, the bill does little to address the solvency issue. The Social Security Expansion Act in the Senate is bolder and does more to address both equity and solvency—but few Democratic senators have cosponsored the bill, leaving it oceans away from the required votes. For all their differences, these bills in the aggregate show that Social Security is perfectly capable of providing a vehicle for progressive welfare reform: any of them would do wonders, most obviously for seniors and disabled workers. But all of us, too, would benefit from knowing that something like a livable income was headed our way at the tail end of a serpentine labor market that has almost completely stopped providing traditional pensions. Despite all this, the enormous energy in recent years around expanding Medicare and Medicaid has not been matched by attention to Social Security: the politics around it have languished. Why? One major reason is that Social Security has a marketing problem. It seems like a boring, wonky program, and one that is in any case unlikely to survive much longer. (A 2015 Gallup poll showed that more than half of Americans did not expect to receive benefits when they retired.) This situation has left the door open for conservatives, who have been baying to privatize Social Security, or at least cut benefits, since the 1970s. However impractical and unpopular this idea is, it is at least an ethos. And it has kept liberals on the defensive: again and again, they rest content by (rightly) showing that privatization would be a disaster and then insisting that Social Security can be “saved,” perhaps with some tinkering to keep it solvent.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › 1NCs---Need Impacts › Horsetrading 1NC---Jobs Guarantee

Passing a jobs guarantee requires welfare trade-offs---tanks healthcare, Social Security, and higher ed

Palley 18 — [Thomas Palley is an independent economist living in Washington DC. He founded Economics for Democratic & Open Societies. The goal of the project is to stimulate public discussion about what kinds of economic arrangements and conditions are needed to promote democracy and open society, “Job Guarantee Programs: Careful What You Wish For,” Social Europe, 09-14-2018, https://www.socialeurope.eu/job-guarantee-programs-careful-what-you-wish-for, accessed 7-11-2023] - PG

Some progressive economists are now arguing for the idea of a Job Guarantee Program (JGP), and their advocacy has begun to gain political traction. For instance, in the US, Bernie Sanders and some other leading Democrats have recently signaled a willingness to embrace the idea. In recent research paper I have examined the macroeconomics of such a program. Whereas a JGP would deliver real macroeconomic benefits, it also raises some significant troubling economic and political economy concerns. Those concerns should be fully digested before a JGP is politically embraced. The starting point for discussion should be recognition that a JGP delivers multiple benefits. First, it ensures full employment by making available a job to all who want one on the terms specified by the program. Second, it substitutes wages for welfare benefits to workers who accept such jobs and would otherwise be on welfare. Third, it may deliver supply-side benefits to the extent that it helps unemployed workers retain job skills and avoid becoming detached from the labor force during periods of unemployment. Fourth, society benefits from the services produced by workers holding guaranteed employment jobs. Fifth, it has significant desirable counter-cyclical stabilisation properties. That said, a JGP generates some policy conflicts and it also has some drawbacks. Those conflicts and drawbacks concern macroeconomics, microeconomics, and political economy. A first macroeconomic concern is the putative cost of a JGP. This is a complex multifaceted concern. The immediate cost of a JGP will depend on the state of the economy and the state of the aggregate demand (AD) generation process. An economy with a deteriorated AD generation process, marked by a reduced wage share and increased inequality, will be prone to higher unemployment that raises the program’s cost. That speaks to the need to pair a JGP with other conventional structural Keynesian policies that remedy the causes of AD weakness. A second macroeconomic issue concerns financing and policy trade-offs. If government is financially constrained, policy must operate in a realm of trade-offs. Consequently, adopting a JGP may require giving up other desirable policy proposals such as increased public infrastructure investment, expanded subsidized healthcare, covering the shortfall in Social Security via general revenues, free tertiary education at public universities, elimination of student debt, or a universal basic income (UBI). This effect of financial constraints on government explains why discussion of a JGP tends to quickly spill over into a broader discussion about the macroeconomics of public finance. JGP proponents tend to believe government is financially unconstrained and can pay for everything by printing money. After the fact, government can then readily withdraw the money it has printed by raising taxes. All of this can be done without causing financial, economic, or political disruptions or distortions. That view is identified with modern money theory (MMT), which dismisses financial constraints on policy and argues the only constraint is availability of real resources (i.e. unemployed workers or under-utilised capital). In contrast, more conventional public finance macroeconomics argues that history, economic situation, markets, and political process impose financial, economic, and political constraints on governments that are difficult to thread. Though government has the technical ability to pay for everything owing to its power to issue money, doing so in excessive fashion will provoke disruptive and distorting financial, economic, and political reactions. The possibility of such reactions renders government’s technical ability to pay for everything an economic will-o-the-wisp. A government with a short time horizon can use its printing power to finance all its policy desires, but subsequent market reactions to budget excess will impose costs and may make the policies unsustainable. Alternatively, a government with a longer time horizon takes such future reactions into account when setting current policy, making it de facto financially constrained despite the appearance of being unconstrained. A third macroeconomic concern is inflation. The JGP wage is a real wage, which means the JGP nominal wage must be tied to inflation. Private sector nominal wages may then likely be tied to the JGP nominal wage to maintain an appropriate wage differential. Consequently, the JGP nominal wage could start to act as a form of economy-wide nominal wage indexation. Such indexation could potentially generate an unstable wage – price spiral, particularly if the existence of a JGP aggravates distributional conflict by increasing private sector wage demands. Raising the private sector wage share may be a desirable feature, but it points to the need for additional macroeconomic stabilisation policy tools. That requirement is either ignored or denied by JGP proponents. As regards microeconomics, there is concern related to the minimum wage aspect of a JGP. A necessary condition for the program to work is workers be willing to move from guaranteed jobs to private sector jobs when the latter become available. That requires the utility derived from a private sector job to exceed that of a guaranteed employment job. The utility depends on the job package consisting of wage, benefits, and work conditions. In effect, a JGP would set a floor for employment conditions in the private sector, akin to a minimum wage, only broader. If the guaranteed employment job package is more attractive than the private sector job package, that will attract workers out of the private sector, lowering private sector output and employment. In that case, private sector employers may respond by improving their job package, which could have effects akin to a high minimum wage that prices low productivity workers out of employment. Lastly, there are significant political economy concerns. A first such concern is the impact of a JGP on public sector unions. The distinction between government sector employment and guaranteed employment is artefactual, and both contribute to national income at cost. Consequently, there would likely be considerable pressure to lower public sector wages and benefits to the level of the guaranteed job on grounds that the work is similar. In effect, there is a high risk that a JGP could be used to open a new front for undermining public sector unions and public sector remuneration. A second political economy concern is workfare. Not only may the JGP be used to undermine the character of public sector employment, it can also be used to undermine the right to welfare. Thus, the right to welfare can be made conditional on accepting a guaranteed employment job. In this fashion, a JGP can become a double-edged sword, cutting upward against the public sector and downward against the welfare system. That is not an outlandish speculation in the context of US political economy, where the large prison population is already being exploited to work for near-free for the benefit of politically connected labor-intensive private industry. A third political economy concern is the productivity of guaranteed employment jobs. A JGP will be sold politically to the public on grounds that JGP workers are productive. However, delivering productivity requires organisational and managerial capacity that the public sector may not have. In that case, there is a risk that such jobs become perceived as “make work”. That would play into the political economy of animus to government, and it could boomerang back in the form of politics opposed to government provision of public goods and services and opposed to macroeconomic stabilisation policy. Careful what you wish for In sum, the debate over JGPs is fraught. Even those who support the aims of a JGP, and are favourably inclined to activist public policy, may still be wary of a JGP for economic and political economy reasons. Implementing a JGP will require political capital and the right political conditions. It might be better to use that favorable moment to introduce new policies (e.g. a UBI) and upgrade a collection of existing different policy modalities that together deliver the same or more benefits without the political economy risks.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › 1NCs---Need Impacts › Horsetrading 1NC---UBI

The only way to enact universal UBI is to horse-trade it for destroying the rest of the welfare state---specifically Social Security, Pell Grants, and Medicaid

Robert Greenstein 19, founder and President Emeritus of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, considered an expert on the federal budget and a range of domestic policy issues, including anti-poverty programs and various aspects of tax and health care policy, was awarded a MacArthur Fellowship for making ‘the Center a model for a non-partisan research and policy organization,’ “Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It,” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 6/13/19, https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-opportunity/commentary-universal-basic-income-may-sound-attractive-but-if-it

At first blush, universal basic income (UBI) seems a very attractive idea, especially to a progressive. Yet it suffers from two serious problems. First, the odds are very high that an effort to secure UBI would prove quixotic. Second, and more disconcerting, any possibility of overcoming the formidable obstacles to UBI will almost certainly require a left-right coalition that has significant conservative support — and conservative support for UBI rests on an approach that would increase poverty, rather than reduce it.

The key issues related to UBI include what it would cost, how it would be paid for, and the risks it poses. Let’s take these one at a time.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Extras › Horse Trading UBI Links › UBI Link---Ext

The core of conservative support for the UBI comes from the idea that it can be used to gut the welfare state.

Emma Dawson 16, executive director at Per Capita, “Why the progressive left should oppose a universal basic income,” Financial Review, 5/6/20, https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/why-the-progressive-left-should-oppose-a-universal-basic-income-20200506-p54q6r

Thirdly, there’s a reason that the UBI has been championed by heroes of conservative and neoliberal politics such as Charles Murray and Milton Friedman: it’s an effective tool by which to reduce the size of government and increase people’s reliance on the market.

Handing out unconditional cash from taxpayer funds gives great grist to the argument that government should stop delivering essential services and expect people to buy them from private providers.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Extras › Horse Trading UBI Links › UBI Link---2NC

UBI is used as a fig leaf to defund the government.

Adam Booth 17, editor of Socialist.net, “Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?,” In Defense of Marxism, 2/10/17, https://www.marxist.com/universal-basic-income-utopian-dream-or-libertarian-nightmare.htm

Despite being raised on the basis of fundamentally false premises, the call for a UBI has nevertheless found an echo in this epoch of eye-watering inequality. Already, social and economic experiments involving UBIs are underway in a variety of countries, including Canada, Finland, and Holland. In Switzerland, a proposal for a SFr30,000 per annum (around £24,000 per year) UBI was rejected by 77% to 23% in a referendum on 5th June 2016. In Britain, meanwhile, the demand for a UBI has been raised by the leaderships of both the Labour Party and the Green Party.

For those on the Left, the UBI is proposed as a progressive demand: a reinforced safety net, beyond the sticking plaster of the current welfare state, funded through increased taxation on big business and the rich. Raised in such a manner, it is clearly a demand – like any genuine reform – that should be supported and fought for.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Extras › Horse Trading UBI Links › UBI Link---2NC

UBI would be horse-traded for the dissolution of the welfare state

Alyssa Battistoni 17, Assistant Professor of Political Science, Barnard College, Columbia University, “The False Promise of Universal Basic Income,” Dissent, Spring 2017, https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/false-promise-universal-basic-income-andy-stern-ruger-bregman/

Five years ago, dropping the abbreviation UBI in conversation would be more likely to earn you a puzzled glance than a knowing nod. But these days, universal basic income—a policy often glossed as “paying people for being alive”—is gaining popularity both in the United States and abroad. UBI, where everyone gets a regular check from the government regardless of what else they’re doing or how they spend it, is an old idea. But it has seen renewed interest since the 2008 financial crash: as millions of people lost their jobs and wondered whether they’d find new ones, some also began to wonder whether they needed to work at all.

UBI was recently endorsed by the Movement for Black Lives as part of a reparations program, while Canada’s Leap Manifesto calls for consideration of UBI on the grounds of environmental sustainability. Jeremy Corbyn said last September that the Labour Party would investigate the prospects for basic income in the UK, and experiments are on the agenda in Scotland, backed by the left-wing SNP. In France, Benoît Hamon recently won the Socialist Party presidential nomination on a platform that included a basic income.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Extras › Horse Trading UBI Links › UBI Link---2NC

Conservatives cut welfare—they exploit a vague UBI in the absence of detailed policy

Juliana Uhuru Bidadanure 19, Department of Philosophy, Stanford University, “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income,” Annual Review of Political Science, vol. 22, no. 1, 2019, pp. 481–501 //MRK

A number of features importantly vary from one UBI proposal to the next, in particular the funding source, the level of the payment, and the policy package that comes with it.

Most UBI proposals are funded by appeal to a variety of taxes—an income tax, a wealth tax, a consumption tax, financial transaction taxes, carbon taxes, or a combination of those (Widerquist et al. 2005, Widerquist 2017). The Alaskan Dividend fund epitomizes the alternative of a sovereign wealth fund. Under such a model, every resident becomes a shareholder who receives a yearly grant in cash. Like UBI, the dividend is individual, unconditional, universal, and regular, but it differs from most proposals in that it is funded through a non-redistributive mechanism.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Social Security › Circumvention---Underfunding

Plan can’t fix SSA—chronic underfunding to other departments has shuttered staff and froze hiring

Kathleen Romig 22, "Social Security Administration Cuts Hurt Every State", Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 5-26-2022, https://www.cbpp.org/research/social-security/social-security-administration-cuts-hurt-every-state, Wooster FG

With the baby boom generation now squarely in its peak years for retirement and disability, the demands on the Social Security Administration (SSA) are extraordinarily high. Yet Congress has cut SSA’s core operating budget by 17 percent since 2010, after adjusting for inflation.[1] These cuts hurt SSA’s service to the public in every state. The agency has been forced to shutter field offices and shrink its staff, leading to longer waits for service and growing backlogs. While the overall effect is a decline in service nationwide, the effects of the cuts vary considerably by state.

The agency has been forced to shutter field offices and shrink its staff, leading to longer waits for service and growing backlogs.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Social Security › Circumvention---1NC

Customer service cuts wreck benefits—lack of staffing stops benefits from getting to the consumer.

Sharon Jayson, 23, "Social Security Says Customer-Service Woes to Continue", 2-22-2023, https://www.aarp.org/retirement/social-security/info-2023/customer-service-upgrade.html, Wooster FG

Customer service at the Social Security Administration is going to get worse before it gets better.

That’s the takeaway from the fiscal year 2023 operating plan the agency submitted to Congress Feb. 10, which details how Social Security will use its $14.1 billion budget allocation for the year and acknowledges a “temporary degradation” of some services, particularly for people waiting for decisions on disability benefits or calling the SSA’s national 800 number for help.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---ICE

The jobs created could be building the wall

Ryan Bourne 18, R. Evan Scharf Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics and Author of Economics In One Virus, 4-24-2018, "A Jobs Guaranteed Economic Disaster," Cato Institute, https://www.cato.org/blog/jobs-guaranteed-economic-disaster //MRK

As if all these consequences were not bad enough, such a program will be ripe for corruption and political interference at the government, provider and individual level. Senator Sanders’ plan would be administered by the Department for Labor, with local and state governments submitting projects to regional offices for consideration. There’s a huge question mark on whether projects will be considered on economic grounds, when there might be an incentive for make‐​work schemes to aid particular politicians or indeed to put resources towards “public good” causes or NGOs more in line with the ethos of the governing party. For Democrats this might be for environmental issues. For Republicans it might be, say, for a wall on the southern border.

NGOs and local public bodies themselves will have incentives to apply for federal funds for projects that would otherwise have occurred anyway, and to maximize the number of applications. Pork barrel projects would proliferate. What is more, at the individual level, the guarantee coupled with the purported unwillingness to judge worker performance on a commercial basis will incentivize low levels of work effort on the margin.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---ICE

Circumvention’s offense—administration failures mean the surplus will be absorbed by ICE.

Samuel Hammond 18, resident senior fellow at the Niskanen Center, “Why Not A Job Guarantee?,” 3/27/18, https://www.niskanencenter.org/not-job-guarantee/

The U.S. government could commit to full employment by offering any willing and able person a job in public service. But should it? Known as a job guarantee, the once heterodox idea went mainstream last year with the endorsement of the Center for American Progress. While the specifics of any particular plan vary, CAP proposes “a large-scale, permanent program of public employment and infrastructure investment—similar to the Works Progress Administration during the Great Depression but modernized for the 21st century.”

Proponents argue that involuntary unemployment is a major source of social instability, and that public service employment, in particular, would help bring the country together. Nevertheless, here are three quick reasons why I don’t think a job guarantee is the way to go.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Funding

A job guarantee would be very expensive—federal benefits steal workers from private jobs, ballooning costs

Jonathan Chait 18, New York Intelligencer political columnist, “Democrats Are Rushing Into a Job Guarantee. It Could Be a Huge Mistake.,” Intelligencer, 4/25/18, https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/04/democrats-are-rushing-a-jobs-guarantee-its-a-huge-mistake.html //MRK

Unfortunately, Democrats do not yet have a proposal that can bring these aspirations to life. One problem to work through is the traditional Democratic question of how to finance their new program. (Republican policy ideas never have this issue —they just put everything on the credit card and stick the next president with the bill.) It’s quite a large expenditure, perhaps half a trillion dollars a year, depending on the exact contours. Progressives have circulated polling showing support for a job guarantee financed by a 5 percent income tax hike on earnings over $200,000 a year, but Josh Bivens at the liberal Economic Policy Institute notes that that would cover less than a fifth of the cost.

And even that figure optimistically assumes the federal job guarantee would attract only people who are currently unemployed or underemployed. Since the most popular job guarantee plans would offer relatively solid wages and benefits ($15 an hour plus benefits), they would probably draw applicants who currently have jobs with stingier compensation. If that happened, as you’d expect, the cost of the program might balloon up to several times over. Once you start financing the program with taxes on the middle class — which would probably be necessary given the scale of its cost — then the popularity would drop off precipitously.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Funding

Congress treats itself as fiscally constrained. It will defund the program out of concerns for fiscal sustainability.

Thomas Palley 18, independent economist living in Washington DC. He founded Economics for Democratic & Open Societies, “Job Guarantee Programs: Careful What You Wish For,” Social Europe, 9/14/18, https://www.socialeurope.eu/job-guarantee-programs-careful-what-you-wish-for

A second macroeconomic issue concerns financing and policy trade-offs. If government is financially constrained, policy must operate in a realm of trade-offs. Consequently, adopting a JGP may require giving up other desirable policy proposals such as increased public infrastructure investment, expanded subsidized healthcare, covering the shortfall in Social Security via general revenues, free tertiary education at public universities, elimination of student debt, or a universal basic income (UBI).

This effect of financial constraints on government explains why discussion of a JGP tends to quickly spill over into a broader discussion about the macroeconomics of public finance. JGP proponents tend to believe government is financially unconstrained and can pay for everything by printing money. After the fact, government can then readily withdraw the money it has printed by raising taxes. All of this can be done without causing financial, economic, or political disruptions or distortions. That view is identified with modern money theory (MMT), which dismisses financial constraints on policy and argues the only constraint is availability of real resources (i.e. unemployed workers or under-utilised capital).

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Fed

The Fed won’t let employment go up

Josh Bivens 18, chief economist at the Economic Policy Institute, 4-12-2018, "How do our job creation recommendations stack up against a job guarantee?," Economic Policy Institute, https://www.epi.org/blog/how-do-our-job-creation-recommendations-stack-up-against-a-job-guarantee/ //MRK

In regards to providing benefits by undertaking public investments, particularly in infrastructure and early childcare, I’d absolutely agree that much larger public investments—particularly in these two areas—are great ideas. They’re part of our recommendations for job creation and we’ve spent most of the past decade at EPI arguing strongly for both.

Even within this overlap, there are obviously differences in emphasis. To put this perhaps too politically, if progressives don’t even have the political muscle and intellectual influence to keep the Federal Reserve from prematurely hitting the economy’s brake and intentionally keeping us from reaching full employment, then I don’t think we’re going to pass something as ambitious as the Darity and Hamilton job guarantee plans. And we certainly need to fight the good job creation fight in the meantime—until we actually do put in place some automatic fiscal mechanisms (like a job guarantee, or anything else) that ensures aggregate demand is always strong enough to keep us at macroeconomic full employment, we need to monitor monetary and exchange rate policy to ensure that they’re not throwing up barriers to reaching this full employment.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Conditionality

Congress will impose limits on eligibility---turns the case.

Matt Bruenig 20, American lawyer, blogger, policy analyst, commentator, and founder of the left-leaning think tank People's Policy Project, “Matt Bruenig Debates Job Guarantee with Mark Paul,” People’s Policy Project, 11/2/20, https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/11/02/matt-bruenig-debates-job-guarantee-with-mark-paul/

The job guarantee favored by Paul is a basic unemployment benefit that has very strict work requirements, also known as “workfare.” In opposing this kind of program, I offer the alternative of an unemployment benefit with generous income replacement and a decent minimum benefit that has very few conditions attached to it.

The problem with attaching strict conditions to benefit receipt is that many people will fail to meet those conditions and thereby lose their benefits, causing poverty, hunger, and homelessness. Even those who manage to jump through the hoops and perform their required hours of community service have to suffer through hassle and time wastes to do so. Our experience with workfare in the US, most famously with the NYC Work Experience Program, has also been very negative.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Backlash

History proves---underspecified programs will be watered down due to intransigent political commitments.

Lynn D. Lu 20, Associate Professor of Law and Co-Director, Economic Justice Project, CUNY School of Law., “From Stigma to Dignity? Transforming Workfare with Universal Basic Income and a Federal Job Guarantee,” South Carolina Law Review, vol. 72, no. 3, 2021/2020, pp. 703–734

V. NEITHER MAGIC BULLET NOR BLANK SLATE: PROCEEDING WITH CAUTION

UBI and a JG are not magic-bullet solutions for the wide range of ills they seek to address, but neither are they emerging onto a blank slate. Prior experiences reveal the ideological disagreements that hinder the creative reform of existing programs. Previous attempts to enact UBI or a JG through social safety net programs have resulted in political compromises by guaranteeing economic security only for those deemed deserving through work effort.148 Under these programs, those fortunate enough to achieve prosperity are viewed as deserving of all the credit, and those who fail are viewed simply as lacking the will to succeed and are consigned to the meanest work or circumstances. To the contrary, a minimum guarantee of social support free of work requirements, even if not constitutionally required, recognizes that individuals should not be indebted to private employers, breadwinners, or society at large for the basic necessities of life.149

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Admin

d. Jobs would be impossible to find

Max Gulker 18, Senior Research Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research, 10-01-2018, " The Job Guarantee: A Critical Analysis," American Institute for Economic Research, https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee_0.pdf //MRK

An employer normally pays an employee because the latter is doing something of value. Under a federal job guarantee, that logic is reversed: the government must find something for ten million or more workers to do because they are being paid. The difference is of great importance.

The work handed out under a job guarantee is subject to complex criteria. In the view of the Levy report, these jobs must

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Admin

Administration and management make plan impossible

Josh Bivens 18, chief economist at the Economic Policy Institute, 4-12-2018, "How do our job creation recommendations stack up against a job guarantee?," Economic Policy Institute, https://www.epi.org/blog/how-do-our-job-creation-recommendations-stack-up-against-a-job-guarantee/ //MRK

First, I’m quite worried about the ability of jobs that provide needed public investment to ebb and swell depending on the state of private sector aggregate demand. Darity and Hamilton have recently written very convincingly about the need to professionalize the care sector. We couldn’t agree more. But we think it’s precisely this need to make these professionalized, career-building jobs that make them an uneasy fit for a job guarantee. We certainly don’t want child care workers leaving these jobs as soon as demand in the private sector ramps up hiring and offers higher wages. And during times when the private sector contracts, I don’t think we can easily absorb people from a range of professional backgrounds seamlessly into early child care and education jobs. We certainly don’t think we can slide people easily into becoming K-12 teachers during downturns, and professionalizing early childhood care and education means treating this workforce much more like K-12 teachers than they are today. One could argue this is less true for, say, jobs related to physical infrastructure investment, but, I’m not sure I believe it. Most civil construction jobs these days are skilled enough (or dangerous enough or incur enough legal liability) that it’s not obvious to me that lots of people from varying professional backgrounds could just be slotted into them seamlessly during private sector contractions.

I think a larger public sector that provides needed public goods and employs a lot more people can be a useful part of job creation strategies along many dimensions, and will certainly lead to an economy more resistant to implosions following private sector demand retrenchment, and I really want the valuable investments such jobs can produce. But, I don’t think that jobs in the public sector that produce valuable investments should ebb and swell in the way that would be necessary for them to be part of a “job guarantee.” Instead, for public investments that we value, we should create a lot more permanent and sustainable jobs.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Admin

Training and cost difficulties deck implementation

Max Gulker 18, Senior Research Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research, 10-01-2018, " The Job Guarantee: A Critical Analysis," American Institute for Economic Research, https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee_0.pdf //MRK

Both reports neglect the cost of human capital. Even if most of the labor used in the proposed programs is unskilled, someone presumably needs to know how to do the work. This need is likely especially pronounced for work such as infrastructure and environmental cleanup. Other proposed work such as teachers’ aides and elder care would also require significant training. Beyond hoping that experts in these fields will become unemployed and willing to accept relatively low-wage work, some industry professionals would have to be hired at competitive salaries, further increasing the cost of both plans.

Administrative Costs

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Admin

Vague program parameters cause corruption and misdirection of resources

Peter C. Earle 18, Research Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research in Great Barrington, Mass, “‘Federal Jobs Guarantee’ Idea Is Costly, Misguided, And Increasingly Popular With Democrats,” Investor’s Business Daily, 11/19/18, https://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/federal-jobs-guarantee-democrats/

With the midterm victories in the House of Representatives, Congressional Democrats are likely to begin a full-court press on their most recent policy initiative: a federal jobs guarantee program. Senators Corey Booker, D-N.J., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., have advanced their own, and with the arrival in Congress of affirmed Democratic Socialists like Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Rashida Tlaib of Michigan additional support seems likely.

Several think tanks — including the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), Levy Economics Institute (LEI), PolicyLink, and the Center for American Progress — have proposed job guarantee plans. While there are minor differences between them, each essentially contemplates a massive, government-run program to provide work (at a predetermined wage) and benefits to enrollees on demand.