Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Only a combination of a historical and economic understanding allows for the creation of a critical consciousness. This allows students to not only understand these systems, but also begin to critique them.

Chandler 15 [Dr. Prentice Chandler is Dean and Professor of the Eriksson College of Education at Austin Peay State University in Clarksville (TN). “Doing Race in Social Studies: Critical Perspectives,” Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing. 2015]//ZH

Thinking about the nexus between race, racism, and economics, we cannot over-look the fact that a good portion of the U.S. market economy was based on White supremacy. Major companies such as J.P. Morgan, Brooks Brothers, and New York Life insurance, major universities such as Emory, Brown, and Yale as well as influential and rich families such as the Vanderbilts and Walkers benefited eco-nomically from the racial hierarchy and the institution of slavery. Even consumer goods are influenced by race and racism in economics. Take for instance the types of toiletries in hotels and motels around the United States; flesh-toned bandages and hosiery for women, real estate prices and housing values, and even the adop-tion policies of Black and White children are marked with heavy economic racism and White privilege. The approach to race, racism, and economics can also be applied to economic agency. Throughout history, African American communities’ economic decisions were based on and informed by their racial treatment. We see this through northern migration periods, the “do not buy” campaign against businesses with racist policies, and the creation of independent African American economic centers.

While these topics can be brought up by teachers in economics classes and re-lated to opportunity cost, supply and demand, personal finance, fiscal policy, and monetary policy, we propose that simply mentioning these topics as racial issues in economics is not sufficient. Racial economic teaching should be more active, meaning that teachers’ attention should focus on the centrality of race in economic thought and practice and provide ways to combat racism in educational spaces. When race is not approached theoretically, the topic is playing a tangential rather than central role in U.S. economic teaching. This approach may end up reproduc-ing liberal notions of racial progress rather than on inequity and agency against racial hegemony (Brown & Brown, 2010; Ladson-Billings & Tate, 1995). A CRT framework provides the lexicon and a more sophisticated literacy for exploring race and racism in economics.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Wealth tax key to reducing wealth-gap- places wealth-places wealth into the hands of those lacking wealth through a UBI.

Farooqui 21 [2021, Sana is a second-year health management MPH student and Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Fellow at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. She received a bachelor’s degree in government and politics and a Master’s in Public Policy from the University of Maryland, College Park. “The Case for Universal Basic Income as a Tool for Racial Justice”, HPHR, https://hphr.org/30-article-farooqui/] RVP

To help rectify the 300+ years of racial and socioeconomic disenfranchisement, a universal basic income program must be implemented. This intervention refers to a regular provision of cash to a specified population group within a targeted area. Some form of UBI has been promoted since the 1500s, by advocates as varied as Thomas Paine, Milton Freidman, Mark Zuckerberg, and Elon Musk. More recently, former Democratic presidential nominee contender Andrew Yang built his platform on UBI, inadvertently becoming the most famous proponent for the cause.9 Similar to Yang’s policy, my recommended proposal is a no-strings attached, monthly payment of $1000 regardless of the recipient’s income. This plan would target all residents of the United States ages 18 to 70, with state and federal governments each shouldering half the costs. The age limits are based on the assumption of full social security benefits remaining intact upon reaching age 62, with eight years of buffer in between. The federal government would provide oversight and distribution responsibility. State governments have the option to increase monthly amounts based on cost of living. The funds can be disbursed as live checks, direct deposits based on IRS information, or mailed “debit cards,” similar to those used by SNAP recipients. The latter method is to help reach the 5.4 percent of Americans who are unbanked and mainly low-income people of color.10 The no-strings attached approach would ensure there are no limitations to use and limit exclusions. UBI payments would include currently incarcerated people; if imprisoned folks still have to pay income taxes, then they should be afforded the payments indiscriminately. This would also be untaxed income for everyone, easing some of the middle-class/upper middle-class squeeze – and helping foment cross-class buy-in.

Guaranteeing a steady cash flow will help Black and brown Americans engage in wealth accumulation without the traditional barriers of property- or stock-market based methods. In a more roundabout manner, UBI could assist Americans in formally entering the financial economy, another source of wealth generation. More directly, UBI payments can prevent a descent into poverty, a sobering reality as almost 40 percent of Americans are only one paycheck away from being homeless.11 A regular source of income could prevent entrapment by predatory loans and ease debt burden; Black students in particular hold $25,000 more in student loans than white counterparts.12 Likewise, UBI implementation would have more social and psychological effects as well, including a potential reduction in crime and increased trust in U.S. social institutions. The policy may alleviate stress and anxiety, which can ease the effects of weathering in Black Americans. A guaranteed cash stream can also reduce barriers to healthcare access by promoting utilization, preventing future wealth losses in the form of medical debt.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Separating livelihood validates all human life- allows it to exist outside of a context of racial capitalism.

Anthony Knowles , 01-31-2021, "Universal Basic Income, Social Justice, and Marginality: A Critical Evaluation," No Publication, https://www.proquest.com/docview/2807107598?pq-origsite=gscholar&fromopenview=true//MMS

For advocates of UBI, its implementation would increase freedom by decoupling one's livelihood from work. This gives workers more power to refuse to work jobs with poor wages or abysmal working conditions. In this sense it generates a certain kind of market leverage for workers over any potential employer, as the ability to sustainably restrict the supply of one's labor-power gives advantage in the market to the workers. These concepts strive to grasp the freedom that becomes possible when basic needs are met for all and the work a person does becomes much more likely to be an expression of their desires, skills, and talents.

While benefits are delivered to individuals, the driving ethos of such visions of UBI is an ethos of collective social solidarity. For many of its proponents, the UBI should be understood as a way to "recognize how everyone participates equally, through every form of labor, in the construction of the commonwealth" (Negri 2014, 32). It is a recognition that, in a society of increasing abundance, it is necessary to "love each other, as ourselves-we have to be our brothers' keepers" (Livingston 2016, 102). The implementation of UBI is an expression of a kind of communal love because it provides a livable minimum standard for all as a way to ensure survival and restore social participation to the economically marginalized. It is an affirmation of a collective sense of solidarity that no one in society should be in poverty because the means to lift everyone out of poverty is available and therefore should be distributed to all. In this way, UBI validates all human life by providing the material basis for everyone to live a meaningful life.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Universality key to livelihood – it alleviates the generational racial wealth gap & destigmatizes racial stereotypes surrounding public assistance..

Lenczewska & Schwartz 20 [Olga Lenczewska works in the Philosophy Department at Stanford Universit. Avshalom M. Schwartz works in the Political Science Department at Stanford University. “Disagree to Agree: Forming Consensus Around Basic Income in Times of Political Divisiveness,” 5/27/2020, ] //ZH

In recent years, the Movement for Black Lives (2016) has endorsed UBI as part of their official manifesto. This recent endorsement of UBI follows a long history of support for guaranteed income among civil rights activists as a non-stigmatizing tool of emancipation, freedom, and eradication of poverty. Expanded welfare and guaranteed income have long been key demands in the African-American struggles for socioeconomic justice (King 1967; Nadasen 2004). Martin Luther King, for example, discusses guaranteed income in the context of the economic and social concerns of the Black communities in the USA, focusing on the ways in which the civil rights movement can identify means to ensure a respectable life for every American citizen. King suggests that targeted welfare schemes should be replaced with either unconditional guaranteed income or guaranteed employment (King 1967, 170–173). Today, racial justice activists draw on both historical and normative sources for supporting UBI and highlight UBI’s potential to reduce pervasive racist stereotypes, help close the racial wealth gap, and contribute to the reduction of crime and racist incarceration practices.

First, UBI is often put forward as a tool to break down the demonizing rhetoric of the “undeserving poor.” Since the early twentieth century, this demonizing rhetoric has been associated with the criticism of public assistance and enforcement of policies that systematically excluded African-American citizens (Neubeck and Cazenave 2001). Because of its unconditional and universal nature, UBI would make it more difficult to vilify public assistance recipients (Bidadanure 2019). For this reason, it is thought that UBI can reduce the stigma attached to public assistance and thus help undermine pervasive racist tropes associated with it.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Targeted universalism justifies UBI PLUS. Universalism provides workers with bargaining-power. The targeted portion ensures those who suffered through or as a result of slavery can begin to repair.

Dorian T. Warren, 5-3-2017, Warren is a Fellow at the Roosevelt Institute, an MSNBC Contributor, and Board Chair of the Center for Community Change, Washington, DC. "Reparations and Basic Income," Boston Review, //VDR

Second, even an equal income could disproportionately benefit black Americans. White Americans earn more overall, so a greater percentage of their basic income would be taxed back. More importantly today’s wealthiest Americans benefit either directly from African Americans’ disadvantaged position in our political economy, or indirectly as a result of the cumulative benefits to our nation from centuries of exploiting black bodies. Black Americans either helped build the co-owned wealth of our nation (our infrastructure and banking, legal, and patent systems) or were denied access to our share of it (land, sky, and other natural resources). Even if African Americans receive an income equal to whites, tapping wealth hoarded by racist means and distributing it universally effectively amounts to targeted redistribution.

Third, a basic income would be an improvement on portions of today’s current safety net. Some benefits, such as food stamps, are replete with paternalistic restrictions that rest on racist tropes about recipients and their consumption habits. Others, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), are significantly tied to work, which is problematic when structural racism continues to create so many barriers to black employment. A basic income lacks these flaws.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Reparations are simple- black people who were harmed by America in America, should be repaired by America in America.

National African American Reparations Commission (NAARC), 03-25-2022, "Who Should Receive Reparations and In What Forms?," National African American Reparations Commission (NAARC), //VDR

In the most basic terms, NAARC advances a simple expansive and inclusive definition of eligibility for reparations for African Americans/Black people: All Black people who were harmed by America in America, should be repaired by America in America!

We take this position because the focus on who can prove a direct lineage to the enslavement era contains two major false assumptions:

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Reparative-justice means acknowledging past-wrongs - only way to understand the ways they underpin and contribute to current inequalities.

Elise Klein and Elizaveta Fouksman 2021, "Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice," //VDR

We thus contend that a reparations way of thinking is needed within calls for universal distributory justice. This way of thinking also allows us to look beyond race to other ways in which certain groups of people have been exploited and expropriated by others — namely, via gender. We do not have the scope to address the question of reparations and gender in this article, but given the historical and ongoing harms of patriarchy, in particular the ongoing free-riding and expropriation of women’s unpaid care work and social reproduction (Fraser, 2016, 2018), and indeed the central role of patriarchy within capitalist production and accumulation (Bhattacharyya, 2018), a reparative way of thinking is also useful when considering what is rightful through a gendered lens (Rubio-Marin, 2009; Wells, 2014). Recognition and redress through reparations are important for acknowledging not just past wrongs, but also the ways these wrongs underpin contemporary inequalities. Such historical wrongs engender race and class (and gender) relations that still have material and affective impacts today. In the post-independence case, we examined how unequal global systems set up under colonialism continue to underpin divisions between the majority world and its former colonizers. In the settler colonial case, we showed how dispossession of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples continues through racialized punitive welfare programmes, the continued dispossession of lands and the denial of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander sovereignty. Racialized systems in the US set up under slavery still impact Black communities today, for example through mass incarceration, employment and educational outcomes and broader inequalities of both income and wealth. There are intersections between redistributory universalism and reparative redress. In many cases, the links between class and race can be reflected in statistics of poverty. However, this can also hide the way in which race has been the grammar of unequal relations and has justified expropriation and exploitation in places like the US since colonization. This is also the case in Australia, where ignoring the ways in which race and coloniality have impacted and continue to impact Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples ignores aspects of settler colonialism that are not only about economic dispossession, but also about racism, white supremacy and patriarchy. Yet (re)distribution must be as much a key part of reparatory justice as is recognition. As Nancy Fraser (2003, 2005) has pointed out, recognition without redistribution holds the danger of displacing struggles for economic justice — an issue that Fraser argues has plagued feminism in recent decades (Fraser, 2005: 298). The negotiations between Namibia and Germany around the Herero-Nama genocide are another example: while Germany is willing to recognize the genocide, and give some additional development aid as part of this recognition, it has declined to term the accompanying payment ‘reparations’, fearing to set a precedent for other or larger redistributive claims to reparative payments. Fraser has argued that both recognition and substantive redistribution are equally essential parts of social justice; one cannot be forsaken in favour of the other. Here we have built on that argument to make the case that the two are in fact intertwined in justice-based claims for shares of collective wealth. All three cases illustrate common themes. While the US is a post-slavery society, it is also a settler colonial state, and insights from the Australian case have resonance for Native Americans in the US who also have substantive claims for reparative justice. The US case gave us one possibility on how mechanisms of distributive justice can also do some measure of reparative work via universal, redistributive and individual payments framed as a rightful share. A U+BI contends with some of the issues of recognition and redress raised in this article. While it is universal in scope and rightful in framing, the addition of the plus includes recognition of specific historical ills in need of reparative justice. The Australian case also suggested avenues that could accompany reparations, showing how not just recognition but also sovereignty could include specific national truth-telling processes, returning of land rights and self-determination, along with a U+BI or other forms of reparative redistribution. These reparative packages would need to be directed by Indigenous peoples themselves. Decentralized and decolonial cosmopolitanism — such as a global UBI framed as reparations for colonialism and its after-effects — may help fulfil reparations for postindependence injustice. However, these payments need to also transcend nation state boundaries and connect with people that are stateless, or diaspora dispersed because of colonialism and slavery.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

This obligation falls on the federal government- demands action from core institution that established and maintained the system of racial injustice.

William Alexander Darity Jr., 2-25-2020, As a senior fellow at the Roosevelt Institute, William Alexander Darity Jr. focuses his research on stratification economics, reparations for Black American descendants of US slavery, equity-enhancing social policies, the Atlantic slave trade and the Industrial Revolution, and the social psychological effects of exposure to unemployment., "True Reparations Are a National Debt: Localities and Individuals Should Not Foot the Bill and Cannot Build Systemic Remedies Alone," Roosevelt Institute, ()//JChu

The reparations debate is longstanding and deep-rooted. In our forthcoming book, (University of North Carolina Press, April 2020), we advance the following general definition of reparations: “a program of acknowledgement, redress, and closure for a grievous injustice.” Acknowledgement is the admission of wrong and the declaration of responsibility for restitution by the culpable party. Redress is the act of restitution—compensation for the wrong—carried out by the culpable party. Closure is the settling of accounts between the victimized community and the culpable party—the arrival at conciliation.[1] Closure means that the debt has been paid and that the victimized community will make no further claims for restitution, barring the occurrence of new atrocities or the recurrence of old atrocities. The specific case for reparations for black American descendants of US slavery is predicated on 1) the cumulative damages of slavery; 2) nearly a century-long epoch of legal segregation (known as the Jim Crow era) and white terrorism; and 3) the ongoing harms of racialized mass incarceration, police executions of unarmed blacks, credit, housing, and employment discrimination, as well as the enormous racial wealth gap. We do not assign blame for this litany of harms to specific individuals or institutions. We must emphasize: Black reparations are not a matter of personal or singular institutional guilt; black reparations are a matter of national responsibility. In our estimation, black-white wealth inequality is the most powerful economic indicator of the full effects of racial injustice in the United States. Black Americans constitute about 13 percent of the nation’s population but own less than 3 percent of the nation’s wealth. Although there are many ways to calculate reparations, including an estimation of the present value of the time stolen from the enslaved or the present value of the 40-acre land grants promised—but denied—to the freedmen, we believe that a true reparations policy must make the black wealth share at least consistent with the black share of the American population. This will necessitate building the eligible black American level of asset holdings by $10 to $12 trillion, or approximately $250,000 for each black individual. So, who should pay the bill? In From Here to Equality, we argue that the culpable party is the United States government. Authority is constructed and contextual, and all three phases of atrocities catalogued here were products of the legal and authority framework established by the federal government. In many instances, the federal government further sanctioned racial atrocities by silence and inaction. This means, in turn, that local or piecemeal—little by little—attempts at racial atonement do not constitute reparations proper. In many instances, local initiatives that parade under the label of “reparations” are not that at all. Local government actions called “reparations”—whether at the state or municipal level—frequently constitute an admission that atrocities have been committed followed by allocations for research, or the construction of centers, rather than compensatory payments to black Americans. However, these scattered steps to stop an ongoing harm do not heal the wound produced by the harm; usually, they do not involve any compensatory payment. Even if they do afford compensatory payment, a series of local initiatives is highly unlikely to match the minimum bill for black reparations. As we noted above, it will require at least $10 trillion to eliminate the black-white wealth disparity. Taken separately or collectively, there is no evidence that local “reparations” will come close to addressing the full scope of the measured harm or achieving an appropriate level of restitution.. Making the Case for Systemic Reparations While piecemeal initiatives of the type pursued by the state of Maryland or Georgetown University are admirable in their acknowledgement of the existence of a debt—and though they may salve guilty consciences—these incremental initiatives will not lead to fundamental change in the conditions of structural racial economic inequality. This essential transformative change demands action from the core institution that established and maintained the system of racial injustice, the federal government. The nation must be held accountable, and the federal government must meet the debt. As stated above, state governments, specifically, have neither the obligation nor the capacity to execute an appropriate comprehensive plan for black reparations. Additionally, the focus on piecemeal “reparations” is customarily limited to the horrors of slavery, and far less attention is devoted to the damages of the Jim Crow regime or the consequences associated with ongoing harms. An exception that proves the rule is the peculiar fixation on using taxes from the sale of legalized marijuana to compensate over-incarcerated black people on minor drug charges. Federal laws concerning drug possession created the window for this form of over-incarceration. This strategy entirely bypasses the compensation merited by over-incarcerated black people for other reasons or not incarcerated at all but subjected to police abuse, and, again, it will do little to eradicate the black-white wealth gap. So, what should states, municipalities, churches, universities, families, and individuals do who admit their historical complicity with slavery? We contend that they should coalesce to form a consortium that aggressively petitions Congress to enact a comprehensive national program of reparations for all black American descendants of persons enslaved in the United States. This collective effort will be of much greater value to black American descendants of persons enslaved in the US than a string of individual steps to undertake reparations piece by piece.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Reparations are our duty and obligation- key to divesting from capitalist thinking about race.

Usha Iyer 1-8-2022, Iyer's research lie at the intersection of performance, and gender and sexuality studies, with a specific focus on film and performance histories, body cultures, and Global South cultural traffic along the vectors of race, gender, caste, and religion, “A Pedagogy of Reparations”, University of California Press, VDR

Reparations demand clear-eyed accountability for acts in the past and our role in them so we may be able to envision other futures. Academic reparations call for community accountability from all of us. Collaboratively conceptualizing a pedagogy of reparations fosters the possibility of a genuinely intersectional, decolonial, global imagination for film and media studies. Reparations are not about benevolence or charity. Reparations are our duty and obligation. I don’t like the word fix, it makes me uncomfortable. ...there is no once and for all fix for anything. The word I like is “ repair”: more tentative, more humble. ... The marines go in there to fix things, they don’t go in there to repair things. Repair can always be undone. —Teju Cole20 Institutions like to forget. A reparative pedagogy is committed to remembering, to witnessing, to repairing. A reparative pedagogy commits to curricula that critique hegemonic colonial, settler, cisheteropatriarchal, ethnocentrist, casteist epistemologies. A reparative pedagogy demands that we recognize and situate our own positionality. A reparative pedagogy asks, what will our classrooms look like when we move from stories of innocence to admissions of complicity? Rather than be defensive, when we start with complicity, we recognize our “proximity to the problems we are addressing.”21 A reparative pedagogy covers a wide range of histories, genres, and media traditions. A reparative pedagogy resists minor curricular reform, the hush money, the reluctant bribe of the one Black or one queer or one non-Western text in the syllabus (e.g., “the infamous “race week” in any Intro to Film/Media course”).22 A reparative pedagogy thinks through the relationship between epistemic violence and state violence. Iyer | A Pedagogy of Reparations 185 Downloaded from http://online.ucpress.edu/fmh/article-pdf/8/1/181/495522/fmh.2022.8.1.181.pdf by Dartmouth College user on 15 July 2023 A reparative pedagogy divests from binaries of form and content, theory and history, aesthetics and political economy, art and geopolitics. A reparative pedagogy recognizes “film’s rootedness in politics, imperialism, and capital” and interrogates purely formal, aesthetic appraisals of media forms.23 A reparative pedagogy divests from the dichotomous, hierarchical logics central to modern, colonial, capitalist thinking about race, gender, and sexuality.24 A reparative pedagogy invests in multidirectional visions, granular and textured histories, global media circulations, labor practices, underrepresented epistemologies.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

We must imagine a new country- reckoning with this image of America is key to the duty of repair.

06-2014, Coates is a journalist covering the intersection of politics, sociology, and the black identity for The Atlantic, “The Case for Reparations” published on The Atlantic, VDR

The early american economy was built on slave labor. The Capitol and the White House were built by slaves. President James K. Polk traded slaves from the Oval Office. The laments about “black pathology,” the criticism of black family structures by pundits and intellectuals, ring hollow in a country whose existence was predicated on the torture of black fathers, on the rape of black mothers, on the sale of black children. An honest assessment of America’s relationship to the black family reveals the country to be not its nurturer but its destroyer.

And this destruction did not end with slavery. Discriminatory laws joined the equal burden of citizenship to unequal distribution of its bounty. These laws reached their apex in the mid-20th century, when the federal government—through housing policies—engineered the wealth gap, which remains with us to this day. When we think of white supremacy, we picture colored only signs, but we should picture pirate flags.

2023 DDI Affirmative
1AC

Nations are defined by their stories. The standard story of America is one that is contingent on the Founding of America – we must replace this standard story with one that it is more accurate.

Roosevelt 22 [Kermit Roosevelt III is an American author, lawyer, and legal scholar. He is a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania. “The Nation that Never Was: Reconstructing America’s Story,” The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 6/3/2022, https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/N/bo146791172.html]

The same decision is playing out across the country, with monuments and statues (often those erected to honor the Confederacy), with buildings and schools. And something very similar plays out with American history more broadly. Repeatedly, Americans have faced the choice between maintaining and rejecting a connection with the past, between putting it in its best light as a way to move forward and burning it all down to start over. Neither answer is necessarily correct; neither will be the right choice in every circumstance. But there’s one scenario that might always be wrong: What if you burned it all down and started over . . . and then pretended that you hadn’t? What if you insisted on locating your ideals and your identity in an old order that you had already rejected—that, in fact, you had overthrown and destroyed by force? That should seem deeply odd. Yet this is what we do with the most fundamental question of American identity. We tell ourselves a story that links us to a past political regime—Founding America, the America of the Declaration of Independence and the Founders’ Constitution—to which we are not the heirs. We are more properly the heirs of the people who destroyed that regime.

Why do we do this? Stories of national identity exist to fulfill a particular set of purposes: to bring people together in the name of shared ideals. The story that tells us we are the heirs of Founding America—what I call the standard story—once seemed like a good way to do this. But it is not, and it never was. When the standard story flourished, it encouraged a complacency that prevented progress toward its stated ideal. It allowed many of us to believe things about ourselves that aren’t true. Once it came under attack, that standard story lost some of its power to unify and became a subject of profound disagreement instead. Less obviously, but more seriously, as we pushed forward a more accurate account, the standard story increasingly undermined itself. Whether people realized it or not, a story that was supposed to promote inclusive equality instead fed exclusive individualism

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Impact---No Populism

Democracy is resilient – populist leaders make mistakes and fail.

Oppenheimer 22 [Daniel M. Oppenheimer is a professor of psychology at Carnegie Mellon University in the Department of Social and Decision Sciences. Previously, he was a professor at the UCLA Anderson School of Management. From 2004 to 2012, he worked at Princeton University's Department of Psychology. He won the 2006 Ig Nobel Prize in Literature. He earned his BA at Rice University and his MA and PhD from Stanford University, “How Populism Dies: Political scientist Kurt Weyland sees a bright-ish future for liberal democracy,” 10-21-2022, https://lifeandletters.la.utexas.edu/2022/10/how-populism-dies-political-scientist-kurt-weyland-sees-a-bright-ish-future-for-liberal-democracy/, accessed 7-20-2023, HKR-SWY]

“If you look at the really big picture, what we’ve seen over time is waves of democracy,” said Weyland. “Democracy advances in bursts and then there is a recession. When these waves are underway, some countries move to democracy that aren’t quite ready for it, in terms of the strength of their institutions, and then lo and behold they backslide.”

Weyland says that we are currently in the backsliding phase of what scholar Samuel Huntington called “Democracy’s Third Wave.” This wave began in the mid-1970s, with the demise of authoritarian governments in Portugal, Greece, and Spain. It crested in the 1990s, with the fall of the Soviet Union and the democratization of countries like South Africa and Kenya in sub-saharan Africa. It then plateaued for a while, and really began receding around 2010.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Impact---No Populism

Fears of populism are overhyped – no democratic backsliding

Weyland 21 [Kurt Weyland is professor of government at the University of Texas at Austin. He has published Assault on Democracy: Communism, Fascism, and Authoritarianism During the Interwar Years (2021) and several earlier books and many articles. He has drawn on a range of theoretical and methodological approaches, including insights from cognitive psychology, and has done extensive field research in Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Costa Rica, Peru, and Venezuela. After receiving a Staatsexamen from Johannes-Gutenberg Universitat Mainz in 1984, a M.A. from UT in 1986, and a Ph.D. from Stanford University in 1991. He has received research support from the SSRC and NEH and was a fellow at the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington, DC, “How Populism Dies: Political Weaknesses of Personalistic Plebiscitarian Leadership,” Political Science Quarterly, 12-22-2021, https://doi.org/10.1002/polq.13277, accessed 7-20-2023, HKR-SWY]

But although it has important justifications, the recent fear of populism has gone too far. Certainly, personalistic leaders seek to establish their unchallenged predominance, which would smother democracy. But they are far from always succeeding. Instead, many fail. As a result, populism is not nearly as universally damaging to liberal pluralism as it looks in theory. Fortunately, recent concerns overestimate the danger posed by personalistic plebiscitarian leadership. Thorough investigations suggest a decidedly mixed picture: populism seems to destroy democracy only under specific, restrictive conditions.9 To avoid unnecessary panic—never a good guide for theoretical reflection, empirical examination, and defensive and remedial political action—it is crucial to arrive at a realistic assessment of populism that recognizes and elucidates the threat but does not overrate it either.

After all, theoretical analysis shows that populism is a high-risk political strategy. While some charismatic leaders can gain amazing preeminence and asphyxiate democracy, this dangerous quest also holds many pitfalls and carries substantial probabilities of failure. In the high-wire act of pursuing political hegemony based on unorganized mass support and in confrontation with established elites, it is easy to fall. Therefore, many populist leaders do not succeed in undermining democracy. Moreover, quite a few of them refrain from initiating a serious attack on liberal pluralism, especially after a prior effort in their country has failed.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Impact---No Populism

Populists will never go to nuclear war.

Shen 22 [Yang Shen holds a BA in sociology from the University of Leeds, “The Rise of Nationalist Populist Leaders and Nuclear Order,” The 2nd International Conference on Public Relations and Social Sciences (ICPRSS 2022), 10-31-2022, https://doi.org/10.1051/shsconf/202214802023, accessed 7-20-2023, HKR-SWY]

Although it is clear how the ‘loose talks’ from nationalist populist leaders could weaken the nuclear order, the risk of nuclear wars is unlikely to increase. Pain and Chen [12] studied Trump's Twitter views, revealing that he used Twitter to convey his feelings and communicate with his followers regularly. This indicates that Trump's rhetoric on Twitter is unlikely to represent the US's position on key political matters, such as the nuclear situation with North Korea. Trump, despite his harsh tweets and speeches about nuclear weapons, is more likely to be a sensible individual who understands the result of mutually assured destruction that may be caused by nuclear warfare. It is unlikely that Donald Trump will start a nuclear war with his distinctive nationalist discourses, as Michaels and Williams [13] point out. Trump himself admits that he has always thought about the issue of nuclear war, and he has stated that nuclear war is a "very important element" that must be considered.

4. CASE STUDY: PUTIN AND UKRAINE CRISIS

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---Alt Causes Populism

Alt causes to populism

Avram 20 [Răzvan-Samir Avram is a PhD student at the Faculty of European Studies, Babes-Bolyai, “Populism or the Broken Promises of Democracy. Concepts, Causes and Solutions.,” Studia Europaea, vol. 65, no. 2, 12-xx-2020, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A658980061/ITOF?u=harker&sid=summon&xid=73e227c4, accessed 7-20-2023, HKR-SWY]

From other point of views, populism is a phenomenon that transcends the social classes, and encourages greater resistance to modernization by illustrating the peasants' riots in the new urban dimension. He also identified the reasons for increasing support for populism, namely: the inability of urban workers to form autonomous organizations and a culture; the increase in the number of marginalized people due to rapid migration and urbanization; the expansion of cities, therefore this has created difficulties for the rural area. (13) This idea will also be supported by Andrej Walicki, who identifies some features of populism: reluctance to capitalism, confrontation between local culture (Russian) and foreign culture (Western), attracting on the side of the populist phenomenon not only of the more conservative class (farmers), but of all the discontented. (14)

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---Alt Causes Populism

Cultural changes are the leading cause of populism, not economic factors like job loss – best studies prove.

Margalit 19 [Yotam Margalit is the Brian Mulroney Chair in Government at the School of Political Science and International Affairs at Tel Aviv University and a Professor in the Department of Political Economy at King’s College London. He is also a non-resident Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Governance and Economics at the Israel Democracy Institute. He graduated with honors from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, receiving his B.A. in Economics and History. He received his PhD in 2009 from Stanford University, “Economic Insecurity and the Causes of Populism, Reconsidered on JSTOR,” The Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 33, no. 4, 2918, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26796840, accessed 7-20-2023, HKR-SWY]

The explanatory weakness of measures of personal economic circumstances is also evident in recent analyses of support for populist parties. As Gidron and Hall (2017) report in a study of vote choice in 20 developed democracies, even after throwing into the regression a wide array of economic predictors, the share of the variation explained is 0.07.3 Another study of individual-level support for populist parties in six western European countries (Oesch 2008) finds that employment characteristics and sociodemographics exhibited a similarly weak empirical relationship with the populist vote (R2 ranging from 0.019 in Switzerland to 0.078 in Norway). Some of the low explanatory power is probably due to attenuation bias resulting from measurement error. But this result is not merely an artifact of survey design. It reflects a broader point, which is that people’s understanding of issues such as immigration, trade openness, or EU market integration—frequent targets of populist ire—are shaped by more than just their economic impact on individuals. Specifically, public disaffection about those issues also reflects concerns related to their social and cultural consequences.

Indeed, an alternative explanation for widespread populist support views it as a backlash against cultural change (for a comprehensive discussion, see Inglehart and Norris 2016). On this view, long-term structural social developments— increased access to higher education, growing ethnic diversity, urbanization, more equal gender roles—have led to greater acceptance of diverse lifestyles, religions, and cultures. These changes, and the perceived displacement of traditional social values, have caused a sense of resentment among segments of the population in the West, particularly among white men, older people, conservatives, and those with less formal qualifications. Increased exposure to foreign influences that comes with globalization, and even more so the effects of waves of immigration, has exacerbated the sense of a cultural and demographic threat. As a result, formerly predominant majorities have felt their social standing erode and have become increasingly receptive to populist charges against a disconnected, cosmopolitan elite that has turned its back on them. They have also bought into the populist nostalgia for a “golden age” of cultural homogeneity, traditional values, and a strong national identity. Hard economic times undermine the perceived competence of the economic and political elites and thus help fuel the populist distrust in them. Yet by this account, adverse economic change is a contributing factor and possibly a trigger. However, is not the root cause of widespread populist support.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---AT: AI Job Replacement

AI Accelerates Job Growth – 97 Mil New Jobs by 2025

Kande 20 (Mohamed Kande, Mohamed Kande is PwC’s US & Global Advisory Leader for the Technology, Information, Communications, Entertainment and Media (TICE) industry sectors. His expertise spans the areas of operational strategy, technology development, mergers and acquisitions, organizational development, and operations management. “Don't fear AI. It will lead to long-term job growth”. World Economic Forum. October 26, 2020. . Accessed 7/18/23)//EKW

The COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated technological advances and the automation of many routine tasks – from contactless cashiers to robots delivering packages. In this environment, many are concerned that artificial intelligence (AI) will drive significant automation and destroy jobs in the coming decades. Just a few decades ago, the internet created similar concerns as it grew. Despite skepticism, the technology created millions of jobs and now comprises 10% of US GDP. Today, AI is poised to create even greater growth in the US and global economies. Sixty-three percent of CEOs believe AI will have a larger impact than the internet, according to PwC’s Annual Global CEO Survey. While Fourth Industrial Revolution technologies driven by AI will continue to fundamentally change the world and the way we work and live, AI may not lead to massive unemployment. Instead, AI technology will create more jobs than it automates. These newly created jobs will require new skills and necessitate significant investment in upskilling and reskilling young people and adults. But businesses and governments can – and must – work together to address this transition and embrace the positive societal benefits of AI. AI and job growth By 2030, AI will lead to an estimated $15.7 trillion, or 26% increase, in global GDP, based on PwC’s Global Artificial Intelligence Study. (To put this figure in context, it’s greater than both China and India’s current combined GDP.) Increased productivity will contribute to approximately 40% of this increase while consumption will drive 60% of GDP growth. While AI will automate some jobs, a PwC AI study has found that “any job losses from automation are likely to be broadly offset in the long run by new jobs created as a result of the larger and wealthier economy made possible by these new technologies.” Furthermore, PwC does not forecast large-scale technological unemployment as a result of automation. In its “Future of Jobs Report 2020,” the World Economic Forum estimates that 85 million jobs will be displaced while 97 million new jobs will be created across 26 countries by 2025. The Future of Jobs Report 2023 AI will automate many repetitive and sometimes dangerous tasks like data entry and assembly line manufacturing. The technology will also change the nature of work for many other jobs, allowing workers to focus on higher-value and higher-touch tasks that often require interpersonal interactions. These newly enhanced jobs will create benefits for both businesses and individuals who will have more time to be creative, strategic, and entrepreneurial.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---AT: AI Job Replacement

Empirics go Neg – Every prior tech paradigm shift!

Abbott 20 – Professor of Law at the University of Surrey School of Law, Assistant Professor at the University of California Los Angeles, Lecturer at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Stanford University, PhD from the University of Surrey School of Law, J.D. from the Yale University School of Law. Ryan Abbott, “The Reasonable Robot: Artificial Intelligence and the Law,” University of Surrey, 01-24-2020, , HKR-SWY

Despite these concerns, technological advances have generally resulted in overall job creation. The computer eliminated jobs but created jobs for working with information created by computers. The automobile eliminated jobs but created jobs in the motel and fast-food industries. The tractor and other agricultural advances eliminated jobs but drove job growth in other areas of the economy. Even as agricultural-based employment and agriculture’s relative contribution to the gross domestic product (GDP) decreased during the twentieth century, the productivity of farmworkers skyrocketed and agriculture’s absolute contribution to the GDP increased. Indeed, in each previous era when concerns have been expressed about automation causing mass unemployment, technology has created more jobs than it has destroyed.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---AT: AI Job Replacement

Automation’s impact is overhyped—“high risk” occupations have seen strong employment growth.

Costa & Yu ’23. [ Rui Costa is a research economist at LSE’s Centre for Economic Performance. Yuanhang Yu is a PhD Candidate in Economics at LSE’s Department of Economics.] “Automation Creates the Space For Entirely New Jobs: the UK Must Adopt, Adapt, and Improve.” February 27th, 2023.

Worries that jobs will be lost to automation are not new but have been heightened since a seminal study in 2013 warned that nearly half (47%) of jobs in the United States were at “high risk” of automation. Nearly a decade on, we look at both the current and longer-term picture of the relationship between technology, jobs and pay. We make two observations. First the period since the 2013 Carl Frey and Michael Osborne study has been one of rising rather than falling employment. In the four decades to the 2000s, the UK’s employment rate tended to peak at around 73%; on the eve of the Covid-19 pandemic, it reached 76%. Second, it’s also the case that even some of the jobs considered by Frey and Osborne to be at highest risk of automation, such as car washers and kitchen assistants, have grown fast in this period. Alongside high employment, productivity and real wages have stagnated. On the face of it, this is not a picture that fits well with concerns about the loss of jobs to technology. But of course, job destruction was only ever half of the story. Automation doesn’t just destroy jobs, it can also raise demand for other workers, and create the space for entirely new jobs. Consistent with this, we have evidence that exposure to automation has affected the cross-section of employment growth in the UK – both in the last decade but also in the longer term. This is consistent with what is now a wide body of international evidence pointing to the importance of automation for wage determination. So, automation is affecting jobs. But the fact that aggregate employment continues to grow alongside these effects suggests automation’s job-destroying impact continues to be offset by positive indirect effects. In Figure 1, we show employment growth from 2013 to 2019 for the occupations which, according to automobility probabilities produced by the Office for National Statistics and the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development based on the Frey and Osborne study, were at highest and lowest risk of automation. There is some vindication for Frey and Osborne: generally speaking, the occupations with low risk (in blue – including doctors and teachers) have seen stronger employment growth than the occupations with highest risk of automation (the occupations in red – including farm drivers or shelf fillers). But there are important exemptions to this pattern. Some “high risk” occupations have seen strong employment growth – including leisure attendants and kitchen assistants. Figure 1. Some occupations considered by Frey and Osborne to have the highest risk of automation have grown in size since their report in 2013 We also look at data spanning the last four decades, and set out how – at the level of different occupations and places – the adoption of and exposure to automation has shaped the UK labour market. A clear pattern emerges when looking at the exposure to different technologies across pay percentiles: workers in lower-paid occupations have historically been more exposed to robot advancements, those in the middle of the pay distribution have seen software innovations being able to perform part of their tasks and higher earners may start to see some of their work being automated by artificial intelligence. Higher robot exposure has been associated with worse employment and wage performance. On average over the last 40 years, the jobs most highly exposed to robotization have experienced wage growth 10 percentage points lower than jobs with low exposure, and have seen employment fall (by roughly 50% on average), while jobs with the lowest exposure have seen employment grow by a similar amount. Similar to workers exposed to robotic advancements, individuals working in occupations highly exposed to software technologies have seen slower employment growth over the last four decades. But the relation with respect to wage growth is less clear. It is too early to make an assessment of the effects of artificial intelligence on the economy and labour markets. Automation doesn’t just destroy jobs: it can also raise demand for other workers; and create the space for entirely new jobs. While increased automation does present risks, it also presents opportunities for growth and rising living standards. Industries with higher rates of robot adoption, such as the automotive sector, have seen higher productivity gains than those with lower rates, such as metal production. Between 1995 and 2019, an industry with one additional robot per thousand workers experienced 3% faster productivity growth on average. We find both negative and positive effects stemming from the adoption of new technologies, albeit unequally distributed across workers contingent on their occupation and industry. The focus for policymakers should not be to stop or prevent technological advancements that strongly contribute to create desirable increases in added value and productivity. Instead, the policy conversation should be directed at how best to prepare and retrain workers at risk of being adversely affected by automation technologies. A careful investigation of the effects of automation on workers, households and firms is required, for the formulation of efficient policies which minimise negative displacement effects of technology and ensure that gains in productivity and from reinstatement are more equally spread. Overall, while we must remain vigilant to the impact of automation, especially since it affects some people and places more than others, the most pressing problems facing the UK economy are not too much automation, but low investment and low productivity growth. We should worry more about these and less about robots taking our jobs.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---AT: AI Job Replacement

Automation won’t lead to mass unemployment—more higher paying roles with complex tasks will open up.

Orduna 21 [ Nahia Orduna is a Manager in the Solution Architecture area at Amazon Web Services. She holds a Master’s Degree in Telecommunications Engineering and a Bachelor’s of Science Degree in Business.] “Why Robots Won’t Steal Your Job.” March 19, 2021. https://hbr.org/2021/03/why-robots-wont-steal-your-job

Science-fiction films and novels usually portray robots as one of two things: destroyers of the human race or friendly helpers. The common theme is that these stories happen in an alternate universe or a fantasy version of the future. Not here, and not now — until recently. The big difference is that the robots have come not to destroy our lives, but to disrupt our work. Last year, the World Economic Forum released  estimating that by 2025, 85 million jobs may be displaced by a shift in labor division between humans and machines. For new grads entering the workforce, or young professionals looking to land their first jobs, this is news worth paying attention to. Entry-level positions that include routine tasks are precisely the ones disappearing. What exactly is happening? Thanks to advances in technology, some computers are able to conduct business processes without our margin of error. Natural Language Processing (NLP) allows chatbots to understand speech and provide technical support to customers in a variety of industries, including food and retail services. HR departments and finance companies use robotic process automation (RPA) to verify payroll systems, create email reports, and manage expenses, among other tasks typically handled by employees. And computer vision now makes it possible for machines to scan barcodes and track packages without the help of human hands. You may be thinking that it’s finally happened: The robots have won. But don’t panic just yet. The same report that predicts robots will soon steal our jobs also says that even more roles will open as a result of this shift — 97 million to be exact. These are the “jobs of the future,” and they are actually better opportunities, specifically for early-career professionals. There are two reasons why: The more computers are trained to conduct highly repetitive tasks that are often assigned to entry-level employees, the more roles focused on complex tasks with competitive salaries will arise in their place. This means that young professionals may have a wider range of interesting careers to choose from. People just entering the workforce usually struggle to land roles with higher salaries because they must compete with senior candidates. This competitive disadvantage disappears as new types of roles — roles that no one has done before — are created. Younger workers are less likely to be forced to compete with their seniors, and more likely to be pioneers. That said, if you are just entering the workforce, you may feel overwhelmed by the plethora of the new (and sometimes confusing) opportunities. To figure out which path you want to take first, you’ll need spend some time researching what areas feel right for you. Ask yourself these three questions to identify the “jobs of tomorrow” worth applying to, and future-proof your career. 1) What are the new roles in my area of interest? Innovations in technology are driving the creation of new jobs. To figure out what roles you may want to pursue, you first need to understand what is happening in your area of interest. My first piece of advice is pretty intuitive: Do a simple Google search. Include the name of your industry plus key phrases like “future of work,” or “job trends in [industry].” For example, you might search, “HR future of work,” “digital marketing trends,” or “banking in 2025.” If you need a little inspiration before you start your research, refer to the graphic, below which highlights jobs in various sectors that are expected to boom in the next few years. Once you learn what’s available in your field, and decide what roles sound most exciting to you, you can refine your search on sites like Indeed, LinkedIn, and Glassdoor. For example, did you study marketing? Your search may teach you that companies are hiring new roles, like Digital Marketing Specialist — a position tasked with making data-driven decisions to ensure campaigns are successful — that can be filled by employees at any level. Is your passion HR? Scoring the internet will show you that Information Technology Recruiter and HR Analyst are two jobs expected to pop up in the next few years. Both roles are responsible for collecting and analyzing people data to help companies make better choices. On LinkedIn, I’d recommend researching people who may already be in the roles that interest you. Follow them, react to their posts, and join the virtual events where they are presenting — but don’t just message them out of the blue. Only reach out directly when you are able to clearly share how their work or ideas have impacted you. From my experience, people are more likely to respond when you show you have put in the time to do your homework. In your message, you can explain that, as someone who is just entering the workforce, you’re curious to learn more about their journey. If you reach out to enough people, a few will respond, especially if you are authentic and approach them with a personalized note. Ask to schedule a virtual coffee and use that time to learn more about what their job entails, how they came into the position, and what skills you may need to sharpen to stand out as a candidate for a similar role. This will give you a better idea of what companies are hiring for right now, and the level of experience you need to be considered for those positions. The connections you make may even end up getting you a referral down the line. 2) Which new skills do I need to master and how? Most people graduate college with a solid foundation in the area of their degree. Decades ago, this was enough to get you hired. But today, that foundation is only a starting point. Technologies are moving so fast that to be a competitive candidate, you will need to learn the latest tools and digital trends in your industry. For example, you may have studied marketing in college, but by the time you graduate new social media channels and publishing tools will have emerged. You may have gotten your law degree, but the same year you apply to your first job, you could learn that law firms have started digitizing contracts and are now prioritizing entry-level roles to help their clients maintain data privacy or conduct internet transactions. You may have graduated with a major in economics, but were digital trading and cryptocurrency management covered in your coursework? This is where upskilling comes in. Upskilling is all about gaining knowledge to accelerate your career by closing skill gaps that can help you advance in your industry. If you’re the marketing major, it’s about mastering those new social media channels. If you’re the law student, it’s about studying data protection. And if you’re the economics wiz, it’s about educating yourself on digital trading trends. How do you start? List the skills related to the role (or roles) you are most interested in applying to. You can find these within job descriptions, or through the connections you make and research you conduct on sites like LinkedIn. What skills are required for your dream role that you don’t yet have? What trainings or certifications have other professionals in these positions acquired? For example, if you are searching for digital marketing positions, you may find that many open roles require “hands-on experience with Google Analytics” or “expertise in paid search.” Create a  ranking how useful it will be for your target jobs and how much time it would require to learn. A basic understanding of most skills won’t take more than two to three weeks. Many digital tools can be learned online for free through YouTube tutorials. Even more can be mastered if you invest in taking online courses. Platforms like Coursera, Udacity, FutureLearn, Udemy, or LinkedIn Learning are great places to start, and some tech companies,  offer free training too. Don’t forget to add your newly acquired skills to your resume. Online course certificates prove not only that you are up to date with the latest trends, but also that you are willing to keep learning and adapt yourself to the new times. 3) What else can you offer? What makes you unique? It could be that you are fluent in multiples languages, that you have exceptional creative writing skills, that you are a master networker, or even that you grew up in a different country than the one in which you are applying to, and therefore, have a deeper understanding of international markets or cultures. Throughout my career, I have seen junior colleagues given more responsibilities faster for using the qualities that set them apart to get ahead on their teams or in their industries. Ask yourself: What skills have I acquired over the years because of who I am, where I am from, or what I am passionate about? Maybe you organized several clubs throughout your college years and have exceptional organization and leadership skills. Or maybe you’ve developed an exceptional work ethic through your background as an athlete. If you are not sure about what unique qualities you have to offer (sometimes it can be hard to take a step back and analyze ourselves in this way), try sending an email to your fellow students, colleagues, friends, or family members asking what differentiates you from other people in their eyes. Many times, others see our strengths before we do. The ability to combine the new tools you learn through upskilling with what makes you unique will help you build a resume that stands out. And if you can provide specific examples of situations in which you used this combination of skills to accomplish a task or goal, it will give you a leg up during screenings and interviews. Machines may be disrupting the entry jobs market, but as a young professional, remember that technology is here to help you. Most companies worth applying to are looking for different people, with different interests and experiences, who can add new perspectives to their teams. Robots may have a smaller margin of technical error, but they lack your humanity, your quirks, and the rare and distinctive qualities that make you who you are. Blend those qualities with the technical skills required for the exciting roles coming your way, and you will be setting yourself up for success both now, and in the future.