2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Advantage CP › 1NC---Solvency
Heires ’23. [Gregory N Heires is a labor journalist.] “A Federal Jobs Guarantee: Ending Unemployment.” June, 2023. https://njfac.org/index.php/2021/06/04/a-federal-jobs-guarantee-ending-unemployment/
Advocates describe a Federal Jobs Guarantee as an affordable solution to the challenges of short-term and structural unemployment. If enacted, the jobs guarantee would ensure that nearly all job seekers are able to find work, and it would significantly diminish government spending on unemployment relief and the many individual, family, and societal problems caused by unemployment. “A Federal Jobs Guarantee would virtually end unemployment,” said Trudy Goldberg, chair of the Nation Jobs for All Network. “I am absolutely convinced that a jobs guarantee would ultimately save tax dollars through reducing the cost of unemployment while bringing in more revenue thanks to the new employment opportunities it would create,” said NJFAN board member Phillip Harvey, a professor of law and economics at Rutgers University. The pandemic-induced economic downturn has created a growing interest in a federal jobs guarantee. Earlier this year, Rep. Ayana Pressley (D-Mass.) unveiled a proposal for a jobs guarantee with the support dozens of groups, including the NJFAN and PolicyLink. The Right to a Job In our modern political era, the roots of the proposal go back to the New Deal. As early as 1932, Franklin D. Roosevelt, in a major campaign speech, stated that “Every man has a … a right to make a comfortable living.” It was the achievement of full employment in World War II that convinced him that it was possible for the federal government to guarantee living-wage work. The first tenet of President Roosevelt’s 1944 Economic Bill of Rights called for the “right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms of the nation.” The second tenet supported the right to “earn enough” to lead a life of dignity. Goldberg points out that FDR regarded the job guarantee as “the most fundamental, and one on which the fulfillment of the others in large degree depends.” By this he meant that the right to employment would make it easier to achieve guarantees of decent housing, health care, and education. In short, Goldberg emphasizes, the Job Guarantee is central to the achievement of essential economic rights. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights adopted in 1948—and inspired by Roosevelt’s Economic Bill of Rights–states that everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favorable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment. For decades, NJFAN has been a leading voice in the country for a federal jobs guarantee. In 1994, Goldberg and NJFAN board members Sheila D. Collins and Helen Lachs Ginsburg wrote “Jobs for All: A Plan for the Revitalization of America,” which launched the National Jobs for All Network (formerly Coalition). In the book, the authors outlined a plan for full employment that would guarantee a living-wage work “based on the philosophy that work and production, exchange and distribution should be redesigned in ways that are conducive to the full development of the innate potential of all people and to the sustainability of the ecosystem.” A Federal Job Guarantee would set a new, higher standard — not only for wages but also for hours, schedules, and benefits — that private employers would need to compete against to find workers, according to a . A proposal developed by NJFAN board member Darrick Hamilton and economists William Darity and Mark Paul envisions creating a National Investment Employment Corps. The U.S. Labor Department would run the new agency, which would allocate funds for state, county, and local governments, as well as Native American nations. It would work with other federal agencies to provide funds for training and jobs in infrastructure and care giving. The price tag for a federal jobs program would be hefty, requiring the spending of billions of dollars on new jobs and training. One estimate places the tab at $612 billion a year, which assumes that official unemployed workers and others who are seeking work but not covered by the official government unemployment statistics would be paid $20 an hour and work 40 hours a week, according to a 2020 Insider article by George Pearkes. But put that in perspective: The Bureau of Economic Analysis reports that the government spends substantially more on military consumption and investment every year: 3.94 percent as of the third quarter of 2019, versus 2.7 percent of GDP on all discretionary non-defense spending consumption and investment by the federal government, which does not include transfer programs like Medicare and Social Security. While the spending on a federal jobs guarantee would be high, its expenditures would be partially offer by spending related to job loss. With a federal jobs program in place, the need for unemployment insurance ($33 billion in fiscal year 2016) would plummet, as a study by the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities points out. Demand for Temporary Assistance to Needy Families ($16 billion) would largely disappear. Thanks to boosted wages, millions of families would not have to rely on Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program ($368 billion) and the Children’s Health Insurance Program ($14 billion). Affected workers would not need to be covered by health care coverage, so they would no longer need to rely on Medicaid ($368 billion) as they would health coverage in their new jobs. Apart from addressing the persistent problems of poverty, inequality, structural unemployment and low-wages, a federal jobs guarantee would benefit the economy overall. A federal jobs guarantee would help address the business cycle and be “smoother” than one-time traditional stimulus packages, according to Harvey. Historically, governments have responded to major economic downturns and employment crises with Keynesian-inspired policies of injecting huge sums into the economy. These expenditures, however, generally do not target specific jobs and specific areas where unemployment is high, and there is a lag of about 18 months before the stimulus works. With a permanent program in place, the government would be able to act more quickly to provide jobs to unemployed workers to help jump-start the economy. “The program would be faster, better targeted and cheaper,” Harvey said
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › States CP › 2NC---AT: Solvency Deficit---States Can’t Do VAT Tax
Mazerov 9 [Michael Mazerov is a Senior Fellow with the Center's State Fiscal Project. He served for almost nine years as Director of Policy Research for the Multistate Tax Commission and has conducted research for the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees. He holds a Masters degree in Public and Private Management from the Yale School of Management and a Bachelors degree in economics and government from Oberlin College., “Expanding Sales Taxation of Services: Options and Issues,” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 8-10-2009, https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/expanding-sales-taxation-of-services-options-and-issues, accessed 7-21-2023, HKR-SWY]
Taxing additional services can generate substantial new sales tax revenue. Table 1 (see page 5 in the body of the report) indicates that the annual, nationwide revenue yield from taxing all services purchased by households except health care, education, housing, and a few others would be on the order of $87 billion. The new revenue from taxing household services would be less than this, since most states do tax services to some extent. Table 1 suggests, however, that states that do not tax services to any significant degree at present — such as California, Illinois, Massachusetts, and Virginia — probably could increase their sales tax revenue by more than one-third if they taxed services purchased by households comprehensively.
Some states have prepared their own estimates of the revenue gained by expanding the sales taxation of services. In June 2009, Maine became the most recent state to broaden its sales tax base significantly; it expects to generate $41 million in annual revenue by levying its sales tax on entertainment admissions, auto and equipment repairs, and such other services as laundry and car washes. This $41 million represents a 4.4 percent boost in its sales tax collections. In 2006, New Jersey added roughly one dozen services to its sales tax base. The state said this would yield more than $400 million in new revenue each year, a 5 percent increase in sales tax receipts. Note that the Maine and New Jersey expansions covered some but not all potentially taxable services. Other states have estimated the revenue that could be gained by expanding the taxation of services much more extensively than did Maine or New Jersey; these estimates (a sampling of which is shown in Table 4 of this report) confirm that states are losing billions of dollars a year due to the tax-exempt status of most services.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › States CP › 2NC---AT: Solvency Deficit---States Can’t Do VAT Tax
Bean 3 [Mitchell E. Bean served as the Director of the Michigan House Fiscal Agency, a nonpartisan agency within the Michigan House of Representatives. Mitch was on the Michigan Consensus Revenue Estimating Conference and the Chief Economist for the Michigan House of Representatives. Mitch served as a statutorily-appointed Commissioner on Michigan's Legislative Commission on Government Efficiency and as the Staff Chair of the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) Budgets and Revenue Committee. He was a member of the NCSL's Deficit Reduction Task Force and served as Overall Staff Vice Chair of the NCSL Standing Committees. He received a B.A. in economics from Washington State University and an M.A. in economics from Michigan State University, “Michigan’s Single Business Tax,” 11-xx-2003, https://www.house.mi.gov/hfa/Archives/PDF/Alpha/singlebusinesstax.pdf, accessed 7-21-2023, HKR-SWY]
Michigan’s single business tax (SBT) is a value-added tax (VAT), and the only major tax of its kind in the United States. For this reason, the SBT is perhaps the least well understood of the major taxes levied in Michigan.
This publication explains the rationale for the tax and its various provisions by reviewing the tax’s history—including business taxes that preceded the SBT, the original adoption of the SBT, and the numerous changes that have been made to the SBT over time. This history is intended to provide context for future decision making regarding the SBT and business taxation in general.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › RC---Hegemony
Kritt 22[Stephanie Kritts, has a PHD of political science from california state university and former associate of social sciences "CAPITALISM AND ITS RELATIONSHIP TO WAR AND CONFLICTS",Fall, No Publication, https://scholarworks.calstate.edu/downloads/k3569c07w, 1LEE]
Capitalism is not just an economic system; its effects extend to politics and together they are a dangerous combination. Global wealth continues to be reduced to a handful of people in the world, and they hold the power to decide our laws and policies, as was seen throughout the case studies. More importantly, it is not a sustainable or successful system because it rests on the exploitation of the many to benefit a select few. It is another form of imperialism and has been weaponized by powerful states to establish their hegemony in the world order. Freedom and capitalism cannot coexist because for profits to be gained, many must submit to oppression. Friedman’s theory that free market capitalism equates to freedom was proven false throughout the demonstrations of violence observed in the case studies. Furthermore, the case studies proved that capitalism cannot exist without the support of militarism. That is why it is the leading cause for wars and conflicts throughout the continents: it requires oppressive regimes because its nature rests on exploitation.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › RC---Inequality
1AC Merola 22 [Rossana Merola, Macroeconomist at the Research Department of the International labour Organization (ILO) , former visiting scholar at the Research Department of the Deutsche Bundesbank and the National Bank of Belgium. Rossana holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the Université Catholique de Louvain-la neuve and the University of Rome Tor Vergata, 5-31-2022 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9193369/]
Inequality has increased not only across workers undertaking different tasks in the same firm, but also across firms. According to recent research conducted at the World Bank by Kelly et al. (2017), at least in Europe, the main driver of wage inequality is the wage gap across firms, which is determined by differences in the rate of adoption of digital technologies. As pointed out by Ernst (2019), in this era of AI, we are witnessing the emergence of a new business model, called “surveillance capitalism”, which is based on collecting data without barriers to access and exploited with proprietary algorithms. While the data come free—and users are often all too willing to give up their privacy—data collection is not since it is protected by intellectual property rights. While on the one side the rise of new “big data” platforms, able to collect huge information on consumer behaviors and preferences, can certainly improve the efficiency in the economy, on the other side “big data” have encouraged the emergence of “superstar” firms which are outperforming compared to the other firms in the economy. These “superstars”, mostly digital companies such as Facebook, Google, Amazon and Netflix, collect huge amounts of data which allow them to individualize prices and product offers and cumulate profits and wealth. “Superstar” firms are then able to gain market power and not surprisingly, concentrated winner-take-all markets are associated with the fall in the labor share (see Autor et al., 2017; Barkai, 2020).
These different forms of inequalities require different forms of tax interventions. We will discuss different alternative tax policies in the following sections. One of the main arguments in favor of a tax on robots is that it preserves low-skill jobs which are more likely to be automated. In this regard, a robot tax can address inequality caused by skill-biased technological change. Another option could be wage subsidies for low-skilled workers. However, inequality may also arise because the emergence of a new business model, called “surveillance capitalism”, concentrates profits and wealth in the hands of few “superstars” firms, mostly digital companies. In this case, other types of taxes would be preferable, such as digital taxation, new tax on corporations' stock shares or the creation of sovereign funds. In particular, the latter two solution are deemed to be progressive since stock ownership is highly concentrated among the richest.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › RC---Populism
Selvin 17[Seren Selvin, he co-founder and executive director of the IstanPol Institute, an İstanbul-based independent think-tank; and a doctoral researcher at Stockholm University Institute for Turkish Studies and former Fox Fellow at Yale University, "The origins of populism: bogus-democracy and capitalism ",12-21-2017, openDemocracy, https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/can-europe-make-it/origins-of-populism-bogus-democracy-and-capital/, 1LEE]
We believe that there are two main reasons for the emergence and rise of populism: bogus-democracy and capitalism. While the former creates and deepens political inequalities, the latter attains the same end in the economic realm. These two aspects are not interdependent from each other but interrelated. The rise of populism mainly stems from people's search for a new form of representation as a result of a political and economic impasse. However, populism does not offer a solution for these inequalities and insecurities: instead it deepens the existing problems. Furthermore, populist movements have prompted the suppression of basic rights. Populists in governments combine with contagions of bogus-democracy and capitalism to create countries where people are more precarious, fearful about their future, frustrated, lonely and angry.
We argue that populism is based on a very specific way of reading social conflicts to use them to disseminate and consolidate their ideas. Albert Hirschman defines two kinds of social conflicts: one is the conflict of “more or less”-“divisible”, the other is the conflict of “either-or”-“non-divisible”.[vii] It can be argued that until the 1980s, class politics still had an influence in the political arena. Class politics is based on the conflict of “more or less” and this conflict can be overcome with a politics of redistribution. To be specific, working classes demanded a more just distribution and equality in both politics and economics by using their unions and political parties as intermediaries. Although class politics has a conflict at its roots, it does not terminate the political discussion on such conflict. However, “either-or” conflict does not allow any discussion. In politics and society, this conflict can be formulated as: “you are religious or not, you are like us or not, you will participate like us or you will leave the country.” This strict division of society is the highest level of identity politics. The demise of class politics and the rise of identity politics since the 1980s has severely narrowed the political spectrum. Worse, identity politics has been turning into a politics of finger-wagging morality under the impact of populism.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Space Col Bad
Stuart et. al. ’21 [Diana Stuart, Associate Professor at Northern Arizona University, Ryan Gunderson, Assistant Professor in the Department of Sociology and Gerontology at Miami University, Brian Peterson, associate professor in Geography, Planning and Recreation at Northern Arizona University, “In search of plan(et) B: Irrational rationality, capitalist realism, and space colonization,” published in 2021, //jwc]
While space colonization is justified to avoid risks and threats on Earth, there will be new risks and threats in space – some that are even more severe. Kovic (2020) discusses some of these risks and in certain scenarios the risks of space travel and colonization greatly outweigh the risks of staying on Earth and the benefits of colonizing space. Kovic (2020): 3) explains, [i]n general, there are two ways in which space colonization-related risks might affect the long-term future of humankind. First, humankind might become more susceptible to existing (existential) risks. Second, space colonization itself might create new (existential) risks that could result in highly undesirable or even catastrophic outcomes. Kovic (2020) in the end argues that prioritizing space colonization as a survival strategy overlooks or ignores the high probability of existential threats and risks in space. The rapid creation of new technologies for space living may also create unexpected consequences and risks that could undermine or threaten space colonization. For example, on Mars, hostile conditions including dust storms, sub-freezing night time temperatures, and lack of water or carbon-dioxide to grow plants (Szocik, Wojtowicz, Rappaport, & Corbally, 2020) could result in death, starvation, cannibalism and extremely stressful survival decisions causing “astronomical amounts” of suffering (Torres, 2018: 75). In addition, the space colonies currently proposed still would not protect humans from large-scale stellular events like supernovae or an expansion of the sun. As explained by Stoner (2017) in the context of a Mars colony, the same risks as well as new risks make the colony very dangerous and protective measures would be immensely expensive in a cost-benefit analysis: [i]f the goal is species survival, and given that the Martian environment is much less survivable than even a post-strike Earth would be, then there is no remotely realistic budget point at which the marginal dollar would be more effectively spent on Mars colonization than on protecting Earth and the creatures and civilizations that evolved to live within its shelters. Stoner (2017) goes on to argue that the analysis for the operations of projects like those of SpaceX, “only appears rational because they have carefully loaded the comparison scenarios in a way that guarantees a pro-colonization conclusion.” While space colonization may be a better preservation strategy than doing nothing, there are many more options that are less risky and more likely to preserve a greater number of human lives. Another commonly overlooked aspect of space colonization as a species survival strategy is the fact that not everyone will be able to go, and many of Earth’s commoners and poor will likely be left on Earth. Only a portion of the human population would be able to live off-planet, perhaps only the economic elite. It is not unreasonable to assume that, if there are large inequalities in power and wealth, that the most wealthy will be in power and that these elites will decide to be the “lucky” few space settlers. It is not possible for Mars, for example, to provide a safe habitat for all humans on Earth. Thus, a possible scenario is economic elites leaving behind the vast majority of humans on an inhospitable Earth. As Billings (2019: 45) questions, “how many poverty-stricken Bangladeshis, how many sub-Saharan Africans, how many permanently displaced Syrian refugees, how many disabled and unemployable workers could come up with $200,000 – or $2,000,000 for that matter – to move to another planet and start a new life. What are the ethics of giving the rich yet another advantage over the poor? What are the ethics of ignoring the need to check the rapid pace of climate change on our own planet?” Under capitalism, any solution to crises on Earth focused on moving off-planet will likely exclude the masses and the poor. Are these lives not worth saving? Are there other strategies that would save more lives? Saving the most present and future human lives would require addressing the threats on Earth, including climate change, biodiversity loss, poverty, disease, and famine. As stated by Kovic (2020: 6), “[g]iven these acute problems, pursuing space colonization today could be a misguided use of limited resources.” He poses the following question: If the goal is to save as many lives and to maximize overall wellbeing, then why focus on an alternative that only benefits a very small population, while the vast majority struggle to survive or perish? Others argue that much more than human lives need to be saved to live successfully off-planet; we need a diversity of other organisms and a measurable portion of the Earth’s biodiversity (Johnson, 2019). Given the rate of existential threats like climate change, how much time is there to develop this technology and transport all people and enough other organisms off-planet? If the goal is species survival, the time (and the immense resources required) could be spent in more effective ways to benefit all people and species. However, these alternatives are unseen or considered impossible in the context of capitalist realism (see proceeding section). Lastly, the current social order dominating human-human and human-material relations (capitalism) is likely to result in negative outcomes and problems even off-planet. For example, mining and development on Mars would very likely be environmentally destructive as colonization is unlikely to have a light impact on the planet (Stoner, 2017). We would bring these relations and the associated problems with us. As Marino (2019: 15) explains, [i]n Musk’s view we need a back-up planet. But he doesn’t acknowledge that we ourselves are the cause of this dire situation. And therein lies the problem and the reason we, as a species, have no business trying to colonize another planet. Musk’s reason for wanting to colonize Mars is to save ourselves from ourselves and it is self-evident that this alone recommends we should not be going anywhere. There is no reason to assume that we have learned our lesson on Earth and will create a new civilization with better outcomes, when the same system and drivers (namely, capital accumulation) continue to dominate the social order. Billings (2019) reminds us that while one may wish to “start fresh” in a new colony, humans will take the drivers of crises and collapse with them. These drivers and forms of logic are precisely why humans find themselves discussing the possibility of moving off-planet in the first place. This fact should inspire collective reflection and deliberative discussions on the purpose of life and alternative ways of organizing social relations to achieve this purpose. However, for irrational rationality, the latter substantive questions answered through communicative action are an irrelevant waste of time - at best, “mere opinion.” In contrast, the ostensibly “practical” and “realistic” technological rationality responds by designing ever-more sophisticated technics for the irrationally rational purpose of rushing off to space to continue the instrumental crusade of blind domination. This is the elevation of means to ends, the irony of contemporary instrumental reason diagnosed by the Frankfurt School. Rather than serving a better world, technological development and production today are ends to be pursued for their own sake. That is, because we can no longer set aims through reasonable criteria, we pursue aims, such as economic growth and technological development, that are set by a semi-autonomous economic system. For the Frankfurt School, these are irrational conditions because technology and economic activity should be instruments to serve humanity, rather than humanity serving technology and economic activity. In summary, the associated risks, inequities, and costs do not support the argument that space colonization is an effective and efficient strategy to preserve the species from existential threats on Earth. The polemical point here is to highlight how the heights of instrumental rationality—hi-tech plans to colonize space to ensure species survival—are irrational because the case for space colonization: (1) fails to make a convincing instrumental case on its own grounds (i.e., space colonization is not an efficient and effective means to safeguard the species) and, (2) by elevating means (namely economic activity) to ends, exhibits the same kind of logic that caused the Earth-bound problems that space colonization is responding to. The inversion of means and ends is examined further in the context of capitalist realism.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Space Col Bad
Billings 19[Linda Billings, Ph.D., is a social scientist and consultant to NASA’s Astrobiology Program and Planetary Defense Coordination Office and has worked in the field since 1983, "Colonizing other planets is a bad idea", June 2019, Science Direct, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0016328718303136, 1LEE]
Examining the history of the U.S. space program reveals an underlying ideology of space exploration that has at its core a rationale for conquest and exploitation. This ideology is deeply rooted in a durable American cultural narrative of frontier pioneering, free enterprise, rugged individualism, and a right to life without limits.5 It is a pastiche of many ideologies, drawing on American exceptionalism, neoliberalism (and its more extremist cousin, libertarianism), the doctrine of manifest destiny, the belief in the necessity of “progress,” and even Russian cosmism.6
In the early 21st century, the trend in the U.S. space community, energized during Ronald Reagan’s administration and reinvigorated during the George W. Bush administration, has been to view the solar system as an environment to exploit, as we have done with our own planetary environment. From this “dominionist” or “manifest destiny” perspective, our home planet, and our home solar system, are seen as resources here for humans to use as they like. The Obama administration embraced this way of thinking and advanced the cause of colonization and exploitation. Though at this writing the Trump administration has not issued any official guidance on the future of human exploration, except for NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine’s repeated claim that NASA will be returning people to the Moon and landing people on Mars, it is reasonable to assume we will see no change in ideological direction.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Space Col Bad
Billings 19[Linda Billings, Ph.D., is a social scientist and consultant to NASA’s Astrobiology Program and Planetary Defense Coordination Office and has worked in the field since 1983, "Colonizing other planets is a bad idea", June 2019, Science Direct, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0016328718303136, 1LEE]
The idea of colonizing another planet likely appeals to a small fraction of humankind and suggests an inevitably elitist enterprise. Why elitist? Who could afford to leave our home planet to live on another? The most publicly visible advocates for colonizing Mars are Jeff Bezos, who at the time of this writing was the richest person in the world, with a net worth of $156 billion; Elon Musk, worth more than $22 billion at the time of this writing; Robert Zubrin, founder and head of the Mars Society; and Bas Lansdorp, founder and head of Mars One. All are Western white males. As space policy analyst Marcia Smith has observed, “Musk has made no secret of his passion to make humanity a multiplanetary species by creating a self-sustaining society on Mars as a backup plan in case Earth is destroyed in a cataclysmic event.”3 Lansdorp’s Mars One enterprise is also planning to take colonists on a one-way trip to Mars.4 Mars One is not discussing costs.
The argument that humans need to colonize Mars because our home planet may not be habitable for us at some point avoids consideration of the need to keep Earth habitable for all the billions of people who will not have the opportunity to leave the planet. Would it be ethical to enable people with enough money to buy a ticket to leave our troubled Earth behind?
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---AT: Space Col
Don’t let them say the quals are bad, the whole article is about her interviewing experts in the field
Piper 18[Kelsey Piper, is a senior writer at Future Perfect, Vox’s effective-altruism-inspired section on the world’s biggest challenges "Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk want to colonize space to save humanity",10-22-2018, Vox, https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2018/10/22/17991736/jeff-bezos-elon-musk-colonizing-mars-moon-space-blue-origin-spacex, 1LEE]
That was a recurring theme in my conversations with experts. Earth is in trouble, but space is deeply inhospitable to humans. And even the worst catastrophes are unlikely to leave this world as hostile to humanity as a planet with no life, no atmosphere, limited gravity, and little water. Nothing we find on Mars or the Moon is likely to be our salvation in a disaster. If we want to keep humanity alive, there are better places for Bezos, Musk, and anyone else afraid for the future of our species to spend their money.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---AT: Perm
Hogg ’22. [ David James Hogg works for the Liverpool Hope University in Hope Park, Liverpool.] “ The Left will find that it has bought a Trojan Horse’: The dialectics of universal basic income.” April 25, 2022. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/02610183221092151
Support from the Left It is clear why UBI is so popular on the Right and within certain sections of capital. Needless to say, the Left case for a basic income appeals to a rather different sensibility. The Left discourse stresses the inherently exploitative nature of work under capitalism, with numerous studies finding that British workers spend far too much time at their jobs - impacting both physical and mental health - while inequality continues to rise (Jones, 2019; Day and Prins, 2020; Scurrah, 2021). After decades of neoliberalism, jobs have become increasingly precarious, which only adds to the stress and anxiety that modern workers experience. Reflecting this reality, Leftist advocates emphasise the emancipatory potential of UBI, which would see workers freed from meaningless, unsatisfying jobs and cushioned from the harshest aspects of the market. For example, van Parijs claims UBI would ‘liberate […] all men and women of the compulsion to work for a capitalist’ and enable ‘people who work too much to reduce their working time or take a career break’ (2018: 2; 15). In the same volume, Schachtschneider envisages ‘[t]he partial decoupling of work and income’ and a ‘life beyond market structures’ as a result of a basic income (Ed. van Parijs, 2018: 74–75). Meanwhile, Standing (2017) attempts to wrestle the argument for individual freedom away from the libertarian Right and in favour of UBI, while the likes of Louise Haagh (2019) and Rutger Bregman (2018) hail the aspects which support classical liberal arguments concerning leisure time and personal development. It is these kinds of arguments that have made UBI so popular on the Left, and in particular those younger members of the labour force who are confronted with a future of increasingly insecure work and low pay (Sloman, 2018; Fitzgerald, 2017). Much of this discourse draws on Marx’s early ‘humanist’ writing regarding ‘alienation’ and the exploitation of labour to justify their basic income proposals. Whether this engagement constitutes a rhetorical device to gain the backing of the radical Left or a genuine interest in Marxism is uncertain, but what is clear is that a reliance on Marx’s early work at the expense of his research in political economy is bound to be 146 C r i t i c a l S o c i a l P o l i c y 43(1) limited. The French philosopher Louis Althusser went as far as to identify an ‘epistemological break’ in Marx’s writing between his early humanism and his later “scientific” work, which came after he had shed the influence of the philosophy of G.W.F Hegel and Ludwig Feuerbach (Althusser, 2005). I mention this not to say that Marx’s early works should be written-off entirely - indeed they are foundational for what emerged later - but to suggest that remaining on one side of this break while neglecting later Marxist interventions in political economy does not offer a solid foundation on which to base a justification for UBI. In his Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts, Marx explores the degree of ‘coercion’ present in the worker’s decision to work, and defines alienating labour as that which is ‘external to the worker’ (1844: n.p.). These insights, taken up elsewhere by Marx, demonstrate how the worker is forced to sell their own labour in order to survive, living on wages while the capitalist extracts further value from them. The worker thus becomes a ‘commodity’ to be exploited, rather than - as the Right sees it - a voluntary agent meeting the employer within the market of free exchange (Marx and Engels, 2015: 12). The views such as those of van Parijs expressed above therefore appeal to some Marxists, who see UBI as a way of freeing the worker of this exploitation to some degree. So too does Micheal Howard, a researcher associated with BIEN, who regards basic income as a ‘step beyond alienation because it gives more workers the option to say no’ (2002: 4). But in their preoccupation with notions of alienation and individual freedom, some UBI proponents on the Left overlook the integral role that surplus value plays in this exploitation of workers. As has been outlined earlier, it is this process of surplus value extraction that the entirety of the capitalist economy relies on, without which it would simply collapse. However, UBI does nothing to address this key driver of capitalist expansion, meaning it cannot hope to solve the problem at the heart of the inequality that capitalism inherently produces. In defending this, van der Veen and van Parijs claim that for Marx the priority was ‘the expansion of freedom’ and ‘the abolition of alienation’, and so ‘we need not be bothered by the persistence of substantial inequalities’ (1986: 651). But this represents a glaring misreading of Marx, and reveals the ‘primary reason’ why conservative and
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---AT: Perm
Dyer-Witheford 20 [Nick Dyer-Witheford is an author, and associate professor at the University of Western Ontario in the Faculty of Information and Media Studies. His area of study primarily focuses on the rise of technology and the internet, as well as their continuous impact on modern society. Interviewed by Brian Justie who is a PhD student at UCLA, and a researcher at the UCLA Labor Center, “The Rise of AI-Capitalism: An Interview with Nick Dyer-Witheford,” Los Angeles Review of Books, 3-11-2020, https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/the-rise-of-ai-capitalism-an-interview-with-nick-dyer-witheford/, accessed 7-18-2023, HKR-SWY]
I will answer at two levels. The first is simple: there’s a wide acceptance of the idea that while capitalism has a persistent logic — the commodification of everything — it also periodically changes the way that logic is worked through, in terms of the orchestration of dominant technologies, work organization, consumption practices, and so on. So, for example, mid-20th-century Fordism, organized around the assembly line, mass work, and mass consumption, had by the millennium had morphed into a post-Fordism of digital technology, so-called flexibilized labor and niche marketing. In Inhuman Power, we suggest that AI could be an important element in another of these metamorphoses, or, as David Harvey puts it “sea changes,” in how capital operates. So here our proposition is an extension and extrapolation from other periodizations of capital.
However — second level — in postulating an “AI-capitalism,” we are suggesting a transformation that may pose some very deep problems, possibly for capital itself, and if not, certainly for its human subjects, and also, as a small piece of collateral damage, for Marxist theory. This of course has to do with the status of labor in an era of machine intelligence. A few years ago there was widespread alarm about a “robopocalypse,” an abrupt, induced crisis of technological unemployment. These fears of a sudden onset “end of work” are today contradicted, at least in North America, by the post-Recession return to reasonably robust employment levels — however dubious the wages and conditions of that employment. But longer term, there are real prospects that AI adoption will in more gradual, oblique ways attenuate and hollow out the wage labor relation. We see it as a slow tsunami. Waves of sectoral technological unemployment, ratcheting in sync with business cycles and financial crises, will be a part of this, as will various intermediate phases of job replacement, in which truck drivers ride shotgun on convoys of automated vehicles, or diminishing call center staff fill the gaps in banks of algorithmic answering services.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Postwork
Kelly 22 [Lauren Kelly is a PhD candidate located within the ARC Centre of Excellence for Automated Decision-Making and Society at RMIT University, Melbourne Australia. Her research investigates automation in Australia's supermarket warehouses and considers what technological change means for workers, “Re-politicising the future of work: Automation anxieties, universal basic income, and the end of techno-optimism,” Journal of Sociology, 0(0), 10-9-2022, https://doi.org/10.1177/14407833221128999, accessed 7-19-2023, HKR-SWY]
In response to influential yet speculative automation discourse, in recent years there has been a surge in empirical research that seeks to reveal the ‘hidden labour’ of automation (Altenried, 2022; Gray & Suri, 2019; Irani, 2015; Jones, 2021; Taylor, 2018). These theorists highlight the dissonance between many firms’ claims of sophisticated automation and the lived reality for workers in these environments. This marks a significant shift in automation discourse from speculation to an analysis of automation as it really exists, embedded in a particular place and time. These studies tend to show how the capabilities of automation and artificial intelligence are often exaggerated and may serve an ideological function of reinforcing narratives of human labour obsolescence with the goal of driving down worker expectations and bargaining power.
Suchman (2007) has argued that fantasies reproduced by Silicon Valley of enchanted artifacts are made possible through the invisibilising of labour necessary to their production and functioning. For instance, the predictive algorithms central to Brynjolfsson and McAfee's predictions of a jobless future do not train and implement themselves (Irani, 2015), and the self-service machine at one's local supermarket can barely function without regular human intervention (Mateescu & Elish, 2019). Often, digital platforms merely shift the work from (paid) staff to (unpaid) customers (Srnicek, 2017). And, seemingly automatic processes that enable internet use are in fact carried out by globally dispersed ‘click workers’ on digital piece-rate arrangements (Gray & Suri, 2019). Indeed, just as automation anxieties are cyclical, so is attendant scepticism of the ‘this time it's different’ narrative. Following closely from the mid-2010s literature on automation, terms such as ‘Fauxtomation’ (Taylor, 2018), ‘Potemkin AI’ (Sadowski, 2018), and ‘Ghost Work’ (Gray & Suri, 2019) appeared almost simultaneously, signalling suspicion of popular automation discourse and declining techno-optimism for automated workplaces. Following this, several radical left proponents of full automation have ‘softened their positions and themselves arrived at a more pessimistic, less determinist and radically humanist outlook on the viability and desirability of a technologically augmented programme for social transformation’ (Dinerstein & Pitts, 2021, p. 5). This shift is perhaps in response to empirical studies of automated workplaces. Claims of sophisticated workplace automation displacing human labour are especially challenged in empirical studies of the warehouse labour process. The Amazon fulfilment centre, which is often depicted in trade press to be semi- or fully automated, is in fact deeply reliant upon manual human labour.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Capitalist AI Bad
Acemoglu and Johnson 23 [Daron Acemoglu is a Professor of Economics in the Department of Economics at MIT and affiliated with the National Bureau Economic Research, and the Center for Economic Policy Research. He is a Fellow of the National Academy of Sciences, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, the Econometric Society, the Society of Labor Economists, and more. He received a BA in economics from the University of York, an MSc in mathematical economics and econometrics from the London School of Economics, and a PhD in economics from the London School of Economics. He is the author of various books that have won several prizes and his academic work has been published in leading scholarly journals. He has received numerous awards and fellowships (Sherwin Rosen Award; the Global Economy Prize; John Bates Clark Medal; the Erwin Plein Nemmers; BBVA Frontiers of Knowledge award. Simon Johnson is a Professor of Entrepreneurship at MIT. He was chief economist at the International Monetary Fund, and he currently co-chairs the CFA Institute Systemic Risk Council. Johnson was a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, a member of the Congressional Budget Office’s Panel of Economic Advisors, and a member of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation’s Systemic Resolution Advisory Committee. Johnson was a member of the Financial Research Advisory Committee of the U.S. Treasury’s Office of Financial Research. His research papers are widely cited, “Big Tech Is Bad. Big A.I. Will Be Worse,” The New York Times, 6-9-2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/09/opinion/ai-big-tech-microsoft-google-duopoly.html, accessed 7-18-2023, HKR-SWY]
With the emergence of A.I., we are about to regress even further. Some of this has to do with the nature of the technology. Instead of assessing multiple sources, people are increasingly relying on the nascent technology to provide a singular, supposedly definitive answer. There is no easy way to access the footnotes or links that let users explore the underlying sources.
This technology is in the hands of two companies that are philosophically rooted in the notion of “machine intelligence,” which emphasizes the ability of computers to outperform humans in specific activities. Deep Mind, a company now owned by Google, is proud of developing algorithms that can beat human experts at games such as chess and Go.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Capitalist AI Bad
Klein 23 [Ezra Klein is a journalist, political analyst, NYT columnist, and cofounder of Vox. He has contributed to various well-known news sources, like The Washington Post. He holds a BA in political science from UCLA, “The Imminent Danger of A.I. Is One We’re Not Talking About,” No Publication, 2-26-2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/26/opinion/microsoft-bing-sydney-artificial-intelligence.html, accessed 7-18-2023, HKR-SWY]
“I tend to think that most fears about A.I. are best understood as fears about capitalism,” Chiang told me. “And I think that this is actually true of most fears of technology, too. Most of our fears or anxieties about technology are best understood as fears or anxiety about how capitalism will use technology against us. And technology and capitalism have been so closely intertwined that it’s hard to distinguish the two.”
Let me offer an addendum here: There is plenty to worry about when the state controls technology, too. The ends that governments could turn A.I. toward — and, in many cases, already have — make the blood run cold.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Joblessness
Toye 21 [Brent Toye is a PhD candidate in the Politics Department at York University, “Post-Capitalist Futures? Work After Automation,” Socialist Project, 2-26-2021, https://socialistproject.ca/2021/02/post-capitalist-futures-work-after-automation/, accessed 7-18-2023, HKR-SWY]
This ‘automation anxiety’, as economist David Autor has dubbed it, has resurfaced at different moments in the history of capitalism, for a variety of reasons, usually as an explanation for structural shifts in capitalist labour markets. In the early postwar period, high levels of economic growth intertwined with technical changes in the capital-intensive system of Fordist mass production created fears that rising levels of productivity might outstrip the demand for labour. Following the stagflation crisis of the 1970s and the end of the postwar economic boom, social democratic and progressive thinkers maintained that continued economic stagnation in the core capitalist countries was the result of a ‘skills mis-match’ between labour and the technical conditions of production in the emerging new information technologies.
Automation Anxiety
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Joblessness
Bruenig 12 [Matt Bruenig is an American lawyer, blogger, policy analyst, commentator. He has a BA from the University of Oklahoma and a JD from Boston University, “Unemployment is a structural problem in capitalism – Matt Bruenig Dot Com,” 2-19-2012, https://mattbruenig.com/2012/02/19/unemployment-is-a-structural-problem-in-capitalism/, accessed 7-18-2023, HKR-SWY]
Chris Dillow of Stumbling and Mumbling pulled the curtain back on the nature of unemployment under capitalism:
capitalism requires that there be not just unemployment but that the unemployed be unhappy. I say so for three reasons:
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Automation
Kelly 22 [Lauren Kelly is a PhD candidate located within the ARC Centre of Excellence for Automated Decision-Making and Society at RMIT University, Melbourne Australia. Her research investigates automation in Australia's supermarket warehouses and considers what technological change means for workers, “Re-politicising the future of work: Automation anxieties, universal basic income, and the end of techno-optimism,” Journal of Sociology, 0(0), 10-9-2022, https://doi.org/10.1177/14407833221128999, accessed 7-19-2023, HKR-SWY]
Predictions of ‘lights-out’ warehouses that run silently in the dark, populated only by sophisticated robots do not exist and are unlikely to become reality, particularly when more dexterous and often cheaper human labour remains in abundant supply. The Amazon fulfilment centre demonstrates how automation technologies do not necessarily emancipate workers from the ‘dark, dirty, and dangerous’ aspects of work (Turner, 2018). Often, automated decision-making systems are integrated with the work of management, human resources, and scheduling (Struna & Reese, 2020), resulting in chaotic and unpredictable rostering for workers (Wood, 2020). Some of the most sophisticated warehouse technologies do not eliminate physical tasks – they monitor and track workers through wearable devices and other technologies (Gutelius & Theodore, 2019). The warehouse labour process continues to rely primarily on physical human labour, often involving ‘highly repetitive movements, lifting heavy goods and boxes, or pushing heavy carts’ (Amazon workers and supporters, 2018, p. 98). Delfanti's interviews with Amazon managers in Italy confirms this, with one manager stating that ‘technology codifies, understands and manages. But the real machine is the human: everything is done manually’ (Delfanti, 2021, p. 40). Despite claims of automation, in the United States, Amazon's serious injury rate is approximately double that of the industry standard (Evans, 2020).
Rather than replace human workers with robots, the smart systems that excite automation theorists tend to outsource decision-making to management and machines. Human workers remain but with reduced capacity to make decisions over their work. This follows a longer tradition of scientific management whereby large firms seek to reduce worker agency by separating the work of planning from execution (Braverman, 1974). In this context workers are not replaced by AI and algorithms, they are increasingly managed by them (Wood, 2021) in a process sometimes referred to as ‘algorithmic management’. This term can also have the unintended effect of erasing the human labour of middle management which remains important to the labour process. Ivanova et al. (2018) show how the ‘ideal’ form of algorithmic management, in which human management is no longer needed, may be rare in practice. More often, algorithmic management involves a combination of human and automated decision-making. Delfanti and Wood have argued that outsourcing some managerial functions to algorithms changes the role of the human manager, which becomes more political, rather than organisational, taking on a form of ‘augmented despotism’ that is enhanced by the use of technology to surveil and discipline workers (Delfanti, 2021; Wood, 2020). Amazon is not exceptional in this regard as many of these practices are standard across warehousing and many low-wage industries (Guendelsberger, 2019).
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---Automation
Hattingh 17 - Research and Education Officer, Int'l Labour Research and Information Group (ILRIG) in Cape Town, South Africa. Shawn Hattingh, “The political nature of the Fourth Industrial Revolution”, https://www.pambazuka.org/human-security/political-nature-fourth-industrial-revolution
Mechanisation and automation have been called the Fourth Industrial Revolution. But these are not inevitable or neutral economic realities. They are political weapons of oppression under capitalism. It is a war against the working classes to increase profits. It is no an accident that bosses choose to mechanise and automate in the context of the massive crisis of capitalism. Recently, the accounting multinational company, Grant Thompson, conducted a study amongst 2500 multinational corporations regarding mechanisation, automation and the introduction of artificial intelligence. Of these companies, 56% said they planned to automate parts of their operations within the next year. Another study by Oxford University was even starker. It stated that 47% of jobs in the United States and possibly 50% of jobs in parts of Africa – including South Africa - could possibly be lost to artificial intelligence, mechanisation and automation in the next two decades. It is clear that if this transpires, the consequences will be dire for workers in Africa – including South Africa - and their ability to organise. Some people have said that this move to use advanced computers and automation is the ‘Fourth Industrial Revolution’; and that the evitable advance of technology must be accepted. The reality, though, is that automation is not inevitable, but a political choice of the ruling class to wage a war against the working class to increase profits and oppression. It is important to understand how and why growing automation is political, and to do so we need to look at the relations at the heart of capitalism.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Cap K › 2NC---No Solvency
Benanav 23 [Aaron Benanav is a sociologist, economic historian, and Assistant Professor of Sociology at Syracuse University. He also serves as a senior research associate at SU’s Autonomous Systems Policy Institute. Benanav first book, Automation and the Future of Work, appeared with Verso in 2020. His writing has been featured in the Nation, Guardian, New Statesman, Boston Review, New Left Review, and Dissent. Benanav was a member of the Society of Fellows at the University of Chicago. He holds a PhD and an MA in History from the University of California, Los Angeles, and a BA in History from the University of Chicago. Benanav serves on the editorial boards of New Left Review and International Labor and Working Class History. Interviewed by Daniel Finn who is the deputy editor of the New Left Review. He gained his PhD for a study of the IRA’s political history during the Troubles. He writes regularly for New Left Review, Jacobin and the London Review of Books, “Automation Isn’t the Cause of Unemployment — Capitalism Just Can’t Generate Enough Jobs,” No Publication, 2-10-2023, https://jacobin.com/2023/02/automation-unemployment-capitalism-jobs-post-scarcity-stagnation, accessed 7-18-2023, HKR-SWY]
One of the main criticisms of basic income is that it’s very much a market-based, individual solution. The problems of insecurity that people experience are only partially to do with their inability to get money as individuals. They’re often connected instead to larger infrastructural questions such as access to public transportation or clean water and sanitation. There’s a whole range of problems that people face where the solutions they need are big and collective in nature. Those problems are difficult to solve just by giving people money and telling them to figure it out themselves.
There’s a whole range of problems that people face where the solutions they need are big and collective in nature.