2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › 2NC Links
Jason Hickel 23 {Jason Edward Hickel is an economic anthropologist whose research focuses on ecological economics, global inequality, imperialism and political economy} - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-23-2023, https://monthlyreview.org/2023/07/01/on-technology-and-degrowth/)//penelope/
Finally, green growth scenarios maintain high levels of energy use in high-income countries by constraining energy use, and therefore devel- opment, in the Global South—in some cases to levels that are below what is required for even basic needs.6 This approach is obviously immoral and unjust (the term ecofascist comes to mind), and clearly unacceptable to Global South negotiators. It is worth noting here, furthermore, that achieving and maintaining a decarbonized economy for high-income countries with their existing levels of energy use (and automobile use) would require extraordinary levels of material extraction for all the ener- gy infrastructure and batteries, most of which will be obtained from the Global South through supply chains that are already in many cases social- ly and ecologically destructive. Yes, we need renewable energy transition. But needlessly high energy use in rich countries means this transition will be slower and the social and ecological costs will be higher.
In sum, green growth scenarios play loose with science, assume in- credibly unjust arrangements, and gamble with the future of humani- ty—and all of life on Earth—simply to maintain ever-increasing levels of aggregate output in high-income countries, which, as we will see, is not even needed.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › 2NC Links
Jason Hickel 23 {Jason Edward Hickel is an economic anthropologist whose research focuses on ecological economics, global inequality, imperialism and political economy} - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-23-2023, https://monthlyreview.org/2023/07/01/on-technology-and-degrowth/)//penelope/
Finally, it is worth pointing out that our understanding of what counts as technology should not be limited to complex machinery. Sometimes simpler technologies are more effective, more efficient, and more dem- ocratic: bicycles, for instance, are an incredibly powerful technology for helping to decarbonize urban transport, and agroecological methods are vital to restoring soil fertility. Furthermore, the power of social technol- ogies should not be underestimated. To cite a classic example from fem- inist socialist literature: dishwashers and washing machines are critical to liberating people (and particularly women) from labor, but so too are public child care and community kitchens. We must take care to ensure that our visions of technology are not polluted and constrained by capi- talist assumptions and worldviews. A better technology is possible.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › 2NC Links
Lapavitsas&Aguila’20[Costas Lapavitsas is a professor at Department of Economics, SOAS University of London, London, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Nicolás Aguila is a researcher at Interdisciplinary Center for the Study of Public Policy, Buenos Aires, Argentina]Costas Lapavitsas & Nicolás Aguila, Modern monetary theory on money, sovereignty, and policy: A marxist critique with reference to the Eurozone and Greece, 09 Dec 2020, https://doi.org/10.1080/2329194X.2020.1855593/HZ
Perhaps the most important constraint on state economic policy is the international functioning of money, which is driven by commodity and capital flows and marked by exchange rate instability. The constraint operates differentially across the world market, reflecting a hierarchy among capitalist currencies and states. Neo-Chartalist authors rightly claim that mainstream economic theory ignores the anchoring of money in nation-states (Goodhart, 1998). Yet, an analogous charge could be leveled against them regarding world money. According to MMT, the hierarchy of money starts with instruments of credit created by households, followed by debts of firms, debts of banks, and finally debts of the state at the top (Bell, 2001). This sequence bears a resemblance to Marxist analyses of the forms of money and credit, starting with enterprise promises to pay, surpassed by bank credit, money market credit, and finally central bank credit.10 However, in Marxist theory, there is a still higher level, that of world money. Money in the world market loses its local functions and returns to its original commodity form as the direct social embodiment of abstract labor (Ivanova, 2013). This is broadly consistent with Marx’s analysis of money’s ontology, positing money as an inherently international economic entity that only subsequently becomes domestic. It is also consistent with the Marxist understanding of capitalism as global in content and national only in form (Starosta, 2016). Commodity value is universal and therefore the measure of value has to be global. In contrast, units of account and symbols of value can be national and regulated by national states. This is the basis on which national currencies relate to each other through exchange rates. In mature capitalism commodity money is replaced in domestic circulation by credit money, but the international arena is far more complex and reflects power relations among nation states. Gold has been the classic form of world money, retaining its key role as means of international payments and global reserve of value, even if national currencies, such as the British pound sterling and the US dollar, have also functioned internationally. Since the collapse of Bretton Woods, the US dollar has acted as inconvertible quasi-world-money subject to competition by other currencies, including the euro (Lapavitsas, 2013; Labrinidis, 2014). Countries other than the USA are forced to acquire dollars as the internationally accepted means of payment and value reserve – they have to deliver someone else’s IOUs to settle their international obligations (Itoh & Lapavitsas, 1999). The economic and political power that accrues to the state that issues quasiworld- money is enormous. It seems that MMT supporters consider this state of affairs to be a self-imposed ordinance by nation states limiting their monetary sovereignty (Tcherneva, 2016, Tymoigne, 2020). According to Wray (2019), monetary sovereignty comprises of: i) the national government choosing a unit of account; ii) the national government imposing obligations denominated in that unit of account; iii) the national government issuing currency in that unit of account and accepting it in payment; iv) the national government issuing other obligations (say, debt) denominated and payable in national currency; and v) a flexible exchange rate.11 Thus, MMT writers often adopt a critical approach toward countries that lose sovereignty by abandoning their national currency (as in the case of the euro) or by establishing a currency board (as in Argentina). For Marxist political economy, monetary sovereignty in the world market has a very different content. The fundamental insight comes again from Steuart, who considered international monetary payments to have an obligatory rather than a voluntary character, that is, nations are obliged to deliver the prevailing form of world money. This is ultimately the reason why the global monetary system is hierarchically structured, a point that is fully appreciated by development economists (Kaltenbrunner & Painceira, 2018, Prates, 2020). Lack of monetary sovereignty is the result of international structural constraints, rather than policy choices (Bonizzi et al., 2019). The constraints include exposure to flows of money capital that are not under the control of smaller countries and depend to a large extent on the global availability of credit. Critical development economists have frequently analyzed the destabilizing impact of capital flows on domestic monetary policy (Akyuz, 2014). Above all, the constraints are associated with accumulated foreign debt, which typically has to be settled in world money, or in currencies competing for the position of world money, and thus has an obligatory character. In sum, developing countries occupy a subordinate position in the international financial system (Bonizzi et al., 2020). In this connection, even mainstream literature has proposed the notion of a global liquidity cycle, or global financial cycle, marked by common fluctuations of asset prices, capital flows, and leverage, all of which ultimately reflect changes in U.S. monetary policy (Rey, 2013). The monetary sovereignty of the USA is the reason for the lack of monetary sovereignty of developing countries. Neo-Chartalist theory is distinctly troubled by the passage from the national to the international realm, where there is no supranational state choosing units of account or having the power to tax. There is a distinct paucity of analysis of money at the world level compared to the sustained output on domestic monetary arrangements, especially for the USA (Epstein, 2019, ch. 4, 5). It is notable that MMT finds it hard to analyze monetary policy in developing countries (Bonizzi et al., 2019; Vernengo & Perez Caldentey, 2019; Prates, 2020).
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › AT: Space Col
Ozimek 17 ( Adam Ozimek. an economist at Moody's Analytics “Sorry Nerds, But Colonizing Other Planets Is Not A Good Plan.” Forbes. May 16th 2017. )//PWD
. Subscribe to newsletters In November, Stephen Hawking warned that humans needed to colonize another planet within 1,000 years. Now, , he’s saying we have to do it within 100 years in order to avoid extinction. There’s a problem with this plan: under almost no circumstances is colonizing another planet the best way to adapt to a problem on earth. Shutterstock Let’s start with Mars, which is a favorite planet for colonization scenarios, including for Elon Musk who we should colonize Mars because earth will eventually face a “doomsday scenario”. The problem with this is that there is almost nothing that could happen to earth that would make it less hospitable than Mars. Whether it’s nuclear war or massive global warming, post disaster earth would be way more habitable than Mars. For example, we worry that the oceans on earth will get too polluted, or too acidified, or rise up too high. It’s true that could make life on earth very hard. But on Mars the only surface water is frozen in the polar ice caps. We would be hard pressed to ruin the water on earth so badly that it’s worse than what’s available on Mars. PROMOTED We also worry about the level of carbon dioxide we humans are creating. But there’s nothing we could do to earth’s atmosphere to make it as bad as Mars, which is both extremely thin and also . Not to mention a significantly lower level of gravity. Whatever we’d have to do on Mars to make the atmosphere habitable would be more easily done on a very very ruined earth. Even if an asteroid were to strike earth it would very likely remain more habitable than mars. For example, consider the asteroid that struck the earth 66 million years ago creating the and wiping out 75% of plant and animal species on earth, including the dinosaurs. Well that disaster still left 25% of species that survived, all of whom would die instantly on the surface of Mars. If an asteroid like this was heading for the earth here’s what we would do instead of abandoning the planet. First, we’d try to deflect it. If we didn't know how to do that, everyone who lived on the part of the planet where it was going to land would move to safer parts of the planet. If need be we'd create biodomes and move into them, maybe even at the bottom of the ocean. “Impossible!” you say? “Technology and human behavior would never allow this!” you insist? It’s true it would be extremely hard and today's technology wouldn’t allow it. And yet it would still be way, way easier than colonizing another planet. If you think getting humans to abandon a continent peacefully is hard, try getting them to abandon the planet. Forbes Daily: Get our best stories, exclusive reporting and essential analysis of the day’s news in your inbox every weekday. Sign Up By signing up, you accept and agree to our (including the class action waiver and arbitration provisions), and . Perhaps we could focus on colonizing another planet then. One with an atmosphere closer to ours than Mars. This may be possible, but the technology required to do this is a far bigger lift than the technology required to build habitable ecosystems on the bottom of the ocean, deflect asteroids, reverse global warming, or cure pandemics. The closest star system to us is Alpha Centauri, which is 4.3 light years away. At a of around 17,000 mph would take existing space shuttles 165,000 years to reach this. Even the faster New Horizon probe, the first to visit Pluto, would take 78,000 years. The technology required to travel fast enough to get to other planets makes geoengineering to reverse climate change seem quaint. It is hard to come up with a scenario where evacuating the earth makes the most sense. So why do so many smart people obsess about it? I think the issue is that nerds find space travel and colonizing other planets extremely appealing because they love science fiction and find space exploration exciting. That’s fine, and if some nerd billionaires want to colonize Mars for fun I say go for it. But unfortunately, their nerd desires are biasing their assessment of how humanity should prepare for doomsday threats. Sorry nerds, we won’t be evacuating earth. If we are underestimating the risks of doomsday threats, lets instead invest in the technologies that will help protect earth from them or recover from them. Even though I am not an expert on space, physical sciences, or basically any relevant field, I can tell that this is obviously true. Maybe just it takes an economist to see through the nerd fantasies. ADDENDUM: The goal of colonizing to preserve the human species rather than evacuate all humans doesn't make sense either. If there are habitable planets within reach, then there must be many, many habitable planets that aren't within reach. In this case the implies humans are not alone in the universe, and therefore our existence is far less special, lowering the benefit of preserving humanity. In a world of other habitable planets, saving the actual life on earth grows in importance compared to preserving the species somewhere in the universe.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › AT: Space Col
Arwen E Nicholson 23 {research fellow in physics and astronomy at the University of Exeter in the UK, } - ("We will never be able to live on another planet. Here’s why," Aeon, published 1-16-2023, accessed 7-13-2023,
Earth is the home we know and love not because it is Earth-sized and temperate. No, we call this planet our home thanks to its billion-year-old with life. Just as people are shaped not only by their genetics, but by their culture and relationships with others, planets are shaped by the living organisms that emerge and thrive on them. Over time, Earth has been dramatically transformed by life into a world where we, humans, can prosper. The relationship works both ways: while life shapes its planet, the planet shapes its life. Present-day Earth is our life-support system, and we cannot live without it.
While Earth is currently our only example of a living planet, it is now within our technological reach to potentially find on other worlds. In the coming decades, we will likely answer the age-old question: are we alone in the Universe? Finding evidence for alien life promises to shake the foundations of our understanding of our own place in the cosmos. But finding alien life does not mean finding another planet that we can move to. Just as life on Earth has evolved with our planet over billions of years, forming a deep, unique relationship that makes the world we see today, any alien life on a distant planet will have a similarly deep and unique bond with its own planet. We to be able to crash the party and find a warm welcome.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Poverty
Jason Hickel 23 {Jason Edward Hickel is an economic anthropologist whose research focuses on ecological economics, global inequality, imperialism and political economy} - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-23-2023, https://monthlyreview.org/2023/07/01/on-technology-and-degrowth/)//penelope/
Under capitalism, essential goods are either underproduced (public transit) or commodified and priced out of reach of working-class house- holds (housing, health care, higher education, and so on). This explains why even in rich countries, despite their high levels of aggregate produc- tion, many people cannot make ends meet. In the United States, a quarter of the population lives in substandard housing and nearly half cannot afford health care. In the United Kingdom, 4.3 million children live in poverty. Why? Because the productive forces are organized around the interests of capital rather than around the interests of people.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Poverty
Jason Hickel and Dylan Sullivan 23 {Jason Hickel is professor at the Institute for Environmental Science and Technology (ICTA-UAB) and the Department of Social and Cultural Anthropology at the Autonomous University of Barcelona. He is the author of The Divide: A Brief Guide to Global Inequality and Its Solutions (Penguin, 2017) and Less Is More: How Degrowth Will Save the World (Penguin, 2020). ICTA-UAB is supported by the María de Maeztu Unit of Excellence grant from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (CEX2019-000940-M). Dylan Sullivan is adjunct fellow and PhD student in the School of Social Sciences, Macquarie University, Sydney, where he teaches in politics, sociology, and anthropology. His research focuses on global inequality, colonial history, and the economics of socialist planning., } - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-23-2023,
Progress Today Should Be Measured Against Decent Living Standards
Noting that extreme poverty was not the normal condition of human- ity prior to the rise of capitalism is not to say that life was great at that time. Clearly nobody then had access to the higher welfare standards that are available today. This is where industrialization and technologi- cal development become so important. Industrialization has brought the capacity to produce new goods that did not exist in the past: electricity, modern health care, public transit, clean cooking fuel, higher education, communication technology, household durables, and so on, which make it possible to achieve high life expectancies and decent lives for all. By these standards, obviously most everyone was poor prior to industrializa- tion, as these goods did not exist or were very rare.
We have already established that extreme poverty is not a legitimate benchmark against which to measure progress at any time. But it certainly should not be used as a threshold for human welfare today. The higher-or- der goods that exist today are essential to decent living and should be available to everyone. As a share of global productive capacity, this does not require much (as with basic goods like food and shelter in the pre-in- dustrial period). Yet the scale of decent-living poverty is astonishing: 2.4 billion people lack food security; 3.2 billion cannot afford a healthy diet; 3.2 billion do not have a clean cooking stove; 3.6 billion do not have safely managed sanitation facilities; 3.8 to 5 billion people do not have access to essential health services.13
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Green Growth Fails
Matthias Schmelzer 23 - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-13-2023, https://monthlyreview.org/2023/07/01/democratic-planning-for-degrowth/)//penelope/
In fact, an increasingly robust body of scientific literature shows that green growth cannot be sustainable—but also, that a different form of organizing society is possible. To achieve sustainability, so-called developed countries need to abandon the objective of GDP growth and scale down less necessary and destructive forms of production to reduce energy and material use. We need a planned and selective contraction of economic activity aimed at increasing well-being and equality. Or, as recently argued in this journal, we need “ecosocialist degrowth.” Degrowth is founded on and justified by a solid critique of market instruments, the optimistic reliance on price mechanisms and private-sector solutions, which are central to so-called “green economy” approaches. Indeed, the lack of social-ecological planning and the reliance on socially unjust and often ineffective market instruments is precisely what has led us into this mess in the first place.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Green Growth Fails
Richard Smith 7-4 { chair of the UK Health Alliance on Climate Change (UKHACC). } - ("Perhaps only degrowth can save us," BMJ, published 7-4-2023, accessed 7-11-2023, https://www.bmj.com/content/382/bmj.p1545)//marlborough-HL
Hickel identifies the four major problems with green growth. Firstly, despite huge and admirable progress with renewable energy we can never keep up with a growing economy, meaning we will continue to depend on fossil fuels. Secondly, solar panels, wind turbines, batteries, and electric cars depend on metals and rare earths, and mining on the scale required to feed a growing economy will create massive and growing environmental damage. Nuclear power from either fission or fusion cannot develop fast enough to meet the energy requirements of economies that continue to grow. Similarly, carbon capture technologies are not maturing fast enough, and ironically depend on energy to work; plus they are a response to only one of our environmental problems. Thirdly, geoengineering projects like injecting the upper atmosphere with particles to create a veil to reflect sunlight, which the European Union is already considering, are extraordinarily risky. Fourthly, our problem is not confronted simply with rising temperatures but with a damaged planet, and if we had 100% clean energy we would “raze more forests, trawl more fish, mine more mountains, build more roads, expand industrial farming, and send more waste to landfill—all of which have ecological consequences our planet can no longer sustain.” Economists have long identified a paradox that innovations that create more efficient ways of using energy and resources briefly reduce consumption but then increase it. As Hickel explains it’s not really a paradox but what would be expected—because companies use the savings to reinvest in more production and the growth swamps the efficiency improvements.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Green Growth Fails
Naude 23 [Wim Naude is a in Technology, Innovation, Marketing and Entrepreneurship at RWTH Aachen University, Germany and at the University of Johannesburg, South Africa. He is also of the African Studies Centre at the University of Leiden, The Netherlands; at the International Security and Development Center, Berlin, Germany, and at the IZA Institute of Labor Economics, Germany., 5-2023, Institute of Labor Economics, ] VL
The fundamental criticism against green growth that emerges from the preceding discussion is that green growth has not yet, and also does not seem able in future to achieve absolute decoupling between GDP growth and material inputs (resource uses) and carbon emissions (growth impacts). It will therefore not able to prevent, or roll back, the overshooting of planetary systems. Relative decoupling is possible, can extend the availability of resources, and reduce the impact of emissions by a small magnitude, but even these efficiency gains may end up increase total energy use due to rebound (Jevons Paradox) effects. In addition to this devastating criticism, there are also other criticisms of green growth. These will be briefly introduced. One further criticism is that green growth is economically costly, and may make poverty reduction more difficult (Resnick et al., 2012; Dercon, 2014). This has raised the issue of climate justice as a ancillary to global green growth initiatives, reflecting concerns that developing countries who may suffer the worse impacts of climate change, have contributed the least to the current stocks of human emitted CO2 in the atmosphere. In exchange for subscribing to green growth, developing countries are therefore demanding substantial financial24 and know-how transfers from advanced economies - who have pledged US$ 100 billion in financial resources for developing countries to fight climate change, but has failed to live up to this commitment (Diffenbaugh and Burke, 2019; Ehresman and Okereke, 2015; Robinson and Shine, 2018; Timperley, 2021). Another criticism of green growth is that green growth places undue hope in the energy transition, i.e. the phasing out of fossil fuels, and replacing these with renewable energy sources. The first problem is that replacing fossil fuels with renewable energy is not feasible: all renewable energy technologies need fossil fuel energy to be manufactured and renewable energy systems need back-up from fossil fuel or nuclear energy (Hagens, 2020; Rees, 2021). And second problem is that promotion of renewable energy will stimulate the re-materialization of world production - due to the need for various mineral resources as inputs for renewable energy systems. Bleischwitz (2010) and Zeihan (2022) lists some of the critical mineral resources needed for renewable energies, which include copper, lithium, gallium, aluminium, tantalum, nickel, cobalt, silicon, chromium, graphite, zinc, manganese, molybdenum, gold, silver and platinum. In addition to the re-materialization of the world economy that this would stimulate, many of these minerals are found in countries with poor institutional development, meaning that the exploitation of these resources could lead to significant human rights abuses.25 Kara (2023) documents such human rights abuses, which he calls a human rights and environmental catastrophe, in cobalt26 mines in the Democratic Republic of Congo. A final and also devastating criticism of the hope that green economic growth is possible, and could moreover be sustained indefinitely, is provided by the laws of physics. This suggest that even if in a science fiction world full absolute decoupling from physical inputs could be obtained, then there would still be the waste heat, an outcome of the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics, that will eventually stop growth. For instance, If the world GDP continues to expand at its current rate of around 2% per annum, it will double every 35 years in size. By 2037 the world GDP would be US$500 trillion after which it “explodes” to $30.7 quadrillion in 2046 and to $1.9 quintillion a year later (Roodman, 2020). In just over 8,000 years it would be 3 × 1070 its current size, which would be a physical impossibility(Karnofsky, 2021c). Even if growth slowed and the world economy doubled in size only every 100 years, then after a million years (a very brief period on cosmic timescale) the economy would be 103010 times larger, which implies that if there are around 1080 atoms in the galaxy27, that “each atom would have to support an average of around 102950 people” (Hanson, 2009). One particular constraint which would limit growth long before these time scales is that even if the global economy would be able to increase energy efficiency and be able to decouple much growth from physical resources, it would still need significant amounts of energy to run its soft-and-hardware. The share of the economy that can be non-physical (and that can thus be de-materialized) is ultimately bounded. The economic growth implied in Figure 1 has been due to an annual average growth in energy consumption of around 2,3% per annum (Murphy, 2022b). If one assumes that a Cornucopian economy would eventually be able to generate economic growth which doubles the world economy every month as discussed in the section 2.2 (see also Hanson (2018)) but with such energy efficiency that energy use continues to grow at only 2,3% then energy use on the planet will grow from its current (2019) level of 18 Terawatt (TW) to 100 TW in 2100 and 1,000 TW in 2200. Murphy (2022b) calculates that at such a rate the economy would use up all the solar power that reaches the earth in 400 years and in 1700 years all of the energy of the sun. The use of so much energy would generate tremendous waste heat independent of any future smart green-energy technology. It would be so hot as to boil the surface of the Earth in about 400 years (Murphy, 2022b). The upshot is that even if the optimistic Cornucopian green economy scenarios could be realised, any acceleration in economic growth will ultimately be a transient event - if it ever happens. As Murphy (2022b, p.847) has warned, “we would be wise to plan for a post-growth world.”
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Green Growth Fails
Alevgul H. Sorman 23 {Ikerbasque Research Fellow at the Basque Centre for Climate Change (BC3). } - ("Deceitful Decoupling: Misconceptions of a Persistent Myth," SpringerLink, published 3-1-2023, accessed 7-12-2023,
In 1987, the UN World Commission on Development and the Environment presented the report Our Common Future, better known as the Brundtland report, coining the concept of ‘sustainable development‘, then launching it at the Rio Summit on Environment and Development in 1992 – Principle 12 of the Declaration. Within such a framing, the push towards growth and economic liberalization was taken further at subsequent global events relating to sustainable development, though partially concealed behind the rhetoric of environmental sustainability. Compared to the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development in Stockholm 1972, the later conferences involved reframing both the diagnosis and prognosis in relation to the ecological crisis. The focus supposedly became poverty in developing countries, instead of affuence in developed countries, along the lines of the post-materialist thesis of Inglehart. This idea that ‘you frst need to be rich, in order to be an environmentalist’ has been critiqued by Martinez-Alier with his famous concept of environmentalism of the poor (Inglehart, 1990). Economic growth was freed of stigma and redefned as a necessary step towards the solution of environmental problems. (Gómez-Baggethun & Naredo, 2015) This watering down of the initial debates of the 1970s infuenced by the Limits to Growth report (Meadows et al., 1972) constitutes the core of the ‘green economy’, a kind of Green Keynesianism with reformist new millennium proposals, such as a Green New Deal, and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. At the UN Conference for Sustainable Development in 2012, the so-called Rio + 20 Summit, the ‘green economy’ concept played a key role as the guiding framework of the multilateral discussions, although resistance from many southern nations meant it was not as central as its proponents may have wished. In preparation for the summit, The United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) published a report on ‘green economy’, defning it ‘as one that results in improved human well-being and social equity, while signifcantly reducing environmental risks and ecological scarcities’ (UNEP, 2011). In consonance with the pro-growth approach of sustainable development, the report bypassed any trade-off between economic growth and environmental conservation and conceptualized ‘nature‘as natural capital, a ‘critical economic asset’ opening the doors for commodifcation. In fact, it clearly stated that ‘the key aim for a transition to a green economy is to enable economic growth and investment while increasing environmental quality and social inclusiveness (UNEP, 2011).’ 6 Post-development: From the Critique of Development to a Pluriverse of Alternatives 64 This environmental economics approach is based on neoclassical economic theory and a belief that economic growth will de-link or decouple itself from its environmental base through dematerialization and de-pollution because of the improvement in eco-effciency, viz. increased resource productivity and decreased pollution. In this conceptual framework, market prices are considered the appropriate means for solving environmental issues and exogenous rates of technological progress are expected to counterbalance the effects of resource exhaustion. However, the confict between a growth-dominated economy and environmental protection cannot be solved with appeals to ‘sustainable development‘, ‘eco-effciency’, ‘ecological modernisation’, ‘geo-engineering’, ‘smart agricultures’ or ‘cities’, ‘circular’ or ‘green economy’. These are false solutions. The sustainable development approach remains fundamentally fawed on a number of counts. For instance, the fnal objective for a New Green Deal is the creation of ‘resilient low carbon economies, rich in jobs and based on independent sources of energy supply’ (UNEP, 2011; NEF, 2008). While on this end there might general agreement, the controversy remains on the means. Among the faws or weaknesses of the sustainable development approach as articulated thus far in various UN-sponsored documents, including the declaration Transforming our world: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, (UNEP, 2011; United Nations, 2013; SDSN, 2013; United Nations, 2015; United Nations Secretary-General’s High-level Panel on Global Sustainability, 2012) are the following (Kothari, 2013): 1. ‘Absence of an analysis of the historical and structural roots of poverty, hunger, unsustainability and inequities, which include centralization of state power and capitalist monopolies; 2. Inadequate focus on direct democratic governance (decision-making by citizens and communities in face-to-face settings), beyond the stress on accountability and transparency; 3. Inability to recognize the biophysical limits to economic growth; 4. Continued subservience to private capital, and inability or unwillingness to democratise the economy; 5. Modern science and technology held up as panacea, ignoring their limits and marginalising other forms of knowledge; 6. Culture, ethics and spirituality side-lined; 7. Unbridled consumerism not tackled head-on; 8. Global relations built on localization and self-reliance missing; and, 9. No new architecture of global governance, with a continued reliance on the centrality of nation-states, denying true democratisation’.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Green Growth Fails
Alevgul H. Sorman 23 {Ikerbasque Research Fellow at the Basque Centre for Climate Change (BC3). } - ("Deceitful Decoupling: Misconceptions of a Persistent Myth," SpringerLink, published 3-1-2023, accessed 7-12-2023,
In 1987, the UN World Commission on Development and the Environment presented the report Our Common Future, better known as the Brundtland report, coining the concept of ‘sustainable development‘, then launching it at the Rio Summit on Environment and Development in 1992 – Principle 12 of the Declaration. Within such a framing, the push towards growth and economic liberalization was taken further at subsequent global events relating to sustainable development, though partially concealed behind the rhetoric of environmental sustainability. Compared to the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development in Stockholm 1972, the later conferences involved reframing both the diagnosis and prognosis in relation to the ecological crisis. The focus supposedly became poverty in developing countries, instead of affuence in developed countries, along the lines of the post-materialist thesis of Inglehart. This idea that ‘you frst need to be rich, in order to be an environmentalist’ has been critiqued by Martinez-Alier with his famous concept of environmentalism of the poor (Inglehart, 1990). Economic growth was freed of stigma and redefned as a necessary step towards the solution of environmental problems. (Gómez-Baggethun & Naredo, 2015) This watering down of the initial debates of the 1970s infuenced by the Limits to Growth report (Meadows et al., 1972) constitutes the core of the ‘green economy’, a kind of Green Keynesianism with reformist new millennium proposals, such as a Green New Deal, and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. At the UN Conference for Sustainable Development in 2012, the so-called Rio + 20 Summit, the ‘green economy’ concept played a key role as the guiding framework of the multilateral discussions, although resistance from many southern nations meant it was not as central as its proponents may have wished. In preparation for the summit, The United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) published a report on ‘green economy’, defning it ‘as one that results in improved human well-being and social equity, while signifcantly reducing environmental risks and ecological scarcities’ (UNEP, 2011). In consonance with the pro-growth approach of sustainable development, the report bypassed any trade-off between economic growth and environmental conservation and conceptualized ‘nature‘as natural capital, a ‘critical economic asset’ opening the doors for commodifcation. In fact, it clearly stated that ‘the key aim for a transition to a green economy is to enable economic growth and investment while increasing environmental quality and social inclusiveness (UNEP, 2011).’ 6 Post-development: From the Critique of Development to a Pluriverse of Alternatives 64 This environmental economics approach is based on neoclassical economic theory and a belief that economic growth will de-link or decouple itself from its environmental base through dematerialization and de-pollution because of the improvement in eco-effciency, viz. increased resource productivity and decreased pollution. In this conceptual framework, market prices are considered the appropriate means for solving environmental issues and exogenous rates of technological progress are expected to counterbalance the effects of resource exhaustion. However, the confict between a growth-dominated economy and environmental protection cannot be solved with appeals to ‘sustainable development‘, ‘eco-effciency’, ‘ecological modernisation’, ‘geo-engineering’, ‘smart agricultures’ or ‘cities’, ‘circular’ or ‘green economy’. These are false solutions. The sustainable development approach remains fundamentally fawed on a number of counts. For instance, the fnal objective for a New Green Deal is the creation of ‘resilient low carbon economies, rich in jobs and based on independent sources of energy supply’ (UNEP, 2011; NEF, 2008). While on this end there might general agreement, the controversy remains on the means. Among the flaws or weaknesses of the sustainable development approach as articulated thus far in various UN-sponsored documents, including the declaration Transforming our world: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, (UNEP, 2011; United Nations, 2013; SDSN, 2013; United Nations, 2015; United Nations Secretary-General’s High-level Panel on Global Sustainability, 2012) are the following (Kothari, 2013): 1. ‘Absence of an analysis of the historical and structural roots of poverty, hunger, unsustainability and inequities, which include centralization of state power and capitalist monopolies; 2. Inadequate focus on direct democratic governance (decision-making by citizens and communities in face-to-face settings), beyond the stress on accountability and transparency; 3. Inability to recognize the biophysical limits to economic growth; 4. Continued subservience to private capital, and inability or unwillingness to democratise the economy; 5. Modern science and technology held up as panacea, ignoring their limits and marginalising other forms of knowledge; 6. Culture, ethics and spirituality side-lined; 7. Unbridled consumerism not tackled head-on; 8. Global relations built on localization and self-reliance missing; and, 9. No new architecture of global governance, with a continued reliance on the centrality of nation-states, denying true democratisation’.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Green Growth Fails
George Tsakraklides 23 { Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey-New Brunswick - CONSUMER, GOVERNMENT, B2B RESEARCHER (12 yrs.): Policy, sustainability, energy and climate change. Telecommunications, FMCG, food and beverage, financial and professional services, defense, gaming. } - ("The Never, Never, Neverland of Degrowth," published 5-14-2023, accessed 7-14-2023, https://tsakraklides.com/2023/05/14/the-never-never-neverland-of-degrowth/)//marlborough-HL
The entirety of humanity is against degrowth, for the simple reason that degrowth means no economic profit, despite the fact that degrowth would, for the first time in millions of years, begin to replenish the BOE’s (Bank Of Earth) balance sheet of natural resource capacity. By today’s toxic economic paradigm, degrowth is as close to a utopia as Never Never Land is to an adult human. We are lacking both the stakeholders and champions, because there is no immediate profit to be made. This means that solution number four, renewable technologies, is also not a solution, given that it is based on growth. Renewable technologies are not a degrowth solution as they have so far only catered to meeting an increasing demand for energy, rather than addressing the problem of escalating demand itself. Moreover, they are profit-motivated, and this is why they do in fact have plenty of stakeholders and champions, who belong in the list of usual suspects and criminals mentioned earlier. These stakeholders are in it for the money, and they do not represent Earth’s biome, or future humans. The renewables industry is necrocapitalism all over again, and this is why these oligarchs are trying to sell it to us, along with the promise of jobs and a life of luxury, as these are the only messages the public wants to hear. Imagine what would happen if one morning suddenly people woke up realised that the Green New Deal they had been sold was an investor fairy tale, and that Earth was in fact doomed unless we scaled down literally everything, starting with our own use of resources. It wouldn’t go down very well. But our only choice is to have this honest conversation, finally. It is clear from this that any solution that relies on profit, and on stakeholders who are only interested in profit, is not a solution. Yet at the same time, it is evident that there is no immediate money in degrowth, and it will never be implemented by an economic and political system which only puts forward ideas which exclusively aim in boosting GDP and the pockets of oligarchs. The problem therefore is profit itself, the very notion of money, and an economic system which keeps humanity hostage to its own incoming Armageddon. We are addicted to profit. At every turn, this civilization consciously opts for meaningless short-term lifestyle benefits, at the expense of existentially disastrous future consequences. These are the exact same priorities as those of a drug addict. Our system of necrocapitalism is indeed the thief, the oligarch who still operates at large, and who never got caught. It has been running a negative balance for centuries, living on credit from the BOE. Humanity aggressively took over the formerly sustainable company called Earth, ascending into CEO with the sole purpose of devouring capital, ripping off stakeholders, and liquidating what’s left. The Leadership Board, composed entirely of humans, is a criminal organization. Technologies that can help us do exist, and our problem is not their implementation, but who implements them, and how. There are many truly renewable and sustainable solutions, such as trees, including some which are human-invented technologies. They all immediately become un-sustainable and un-renewable however, when implemented with growth, profit and investment in mind, by people who have absolutely zero interest in saving this planet. At the same time there is an incredible amount of naivety in the business world regarding sustainability. Most feel it is a case of ticking a few boxes, rather than a massive sacrifice and transformation, which no growth-driven business today is prepared to sustain. Rather than emulating the sustainable ebb and flow of “profit” witnessed in the natural world, global corporate cultures are pretending to be sustainable while still delusionally fixating on the futility of growth, and unrealistically hyper-performing employees. If this civilization had any chance of continuing, it would need to stop laying foundations for a new, bigger empire, and start learning the lessons from mourning the one which is currently already collapsing. The first such lesson is that profit is toxic, and we cannot grow ourselves out of problems. As tragic and unlikely as civilizational collapse may sound, it has happened before to every single human civilization. It is the most natural, predictable and most probable outcome for an exponentially overgrown economic system simply being brought back down to size by its own physics. But scaling back our presence on the planet is an action contrarian to everything our civilization has stood for, during the entirety of our history. Unless we realize the immensity of this challenge, degrowth will become another greenwashing term adopted and weaponized by the renewable energy industrial complex to mask all the greed underneath. The huge problem with degrowth is that it is a principle, not a technology. Humans are great with technologies, not so much with principles. The latter become distorted and corrupted. However complex and sophisticated our civilisation becomes, it cannot escape the parasite of corruption dwelling in its flesh. The second lesson is that true degrowth means reducing all aspects of our presence on Earth. This includes the most important one of all, and the most carbon-heavy, which is our population. The idea of 8 billion planet-eating humanoids continuing in a world of diminishing resources is yet another ludicrous religious and economic fantasy. True environmentalists and economists should talk about the monster of overpopulation. Earth’s system did not evolve to cater for a single species at this size. Scaling back our impact on this planet goes against everything this civilization was founded upon: scaling up greed, scaling up population, scaling up natural destruction. Degrowth is only possible if we de-criminalize contraction, simplification and ecological restoration. For an ecologist, scaling down our consumption, energy use and population growth means finally living in balance with the planet and the climate. For most politicians as well as the public who vote for them, these critical steps will be labelled as a gross infringement on human rights. Those who support these steps simply won’t get the votes. Today’s politicians after all mirror today’s humans: they lack all of the qualities that our economic system has successfully exterminated: empathy, critical thinking, and above all, a conscience. How can degrowth be implemented under these circumstances? It would require everyone having to “wake up” simultaneously. Contrary to much of the activism, the world is not only being led astray by “elites”, “corporations” or a handful of “bad guys”. The world is enslaved to a system of unsustainable greed in which each of us is an essential participant, whether we benefit from it or not. What will likely never be communicated to us by politicians is that true degrowth involves no investors, job creation, green new deals or fancy EVs. It is a sacrifice, which cannot be and should not be sugar-coated to the voters. But we will never hear the truth. In the 80s the food industry lied to us, replacing fat with sugar rather than advising us to eat less overall. In the 2020s, the renewables industry lied to us, replacing fossil fuels with Tesla cars, rather than telling us to drive less overall. I laugh at economists and politicians who still think they can plan, who think they will have access to budgets in the midst of natural disasters, massive global migration, social unrest, hunger and nuclear war. They will be lucky to simply have a job, if governments still exist. They have already become peons of the renewable energy industrial complex: rather than coming clean to voters about the gravity of the situation, they are trying to sell the beautiful golden sunsets of a Green New Deal, sponsored by the same oligarchs and psychopaths that have been running the world for the last few hundred years. Meanwhile there are authors and academics so desperate to justify humanity’s parasitic existence, all they can come up with is that our purpose on Earth is to become wisdom keepers and stewards. This is a typical hallucinating narcissist trying to save face, and refusing to concede failure. But none of this should be a surprise. It should be deeply worrying that the very species responsible for the decimation of Earth has also arrogantly put itself in charge of rescuing it. If I was the planet, humans would be the last species I would trust to bring me back to health. Degrowth is not a series of boxes to untick. It requires a fundamental change in how we define happiness. It requires the burying and mourning of a lifestyle and colorful vision of our civilization that we all falsely thought was normal, and sustainable. A controlled dismantling of the most wasteful and destructive pieces of our civilization is the bare minimum we ought to do to slow down the climate crisis and ecological overshoot. The alternative is to suffer the most cataclysmic apocalypse that all four traditional solutions presented here would result in, and which would surely erase everything we hold dear. Mitigating the climate crisis is not a technology fix. There are 8 billion humans living parasitic lifestyles. We would need to bravely accept upfront an immense amount of pain, and voluntarily demolish the ecocidal system this entire civilisation is based upon. Or it crashes down on us. Will the media and politicians treat the public as adults, and tell them the truth? And upon hearing the truth, will the public react as adults? We may never find out. Human civilization is like a brilliant firework. It may take a lot of science, patience, love, technology, cooperation and hard work to set it up, but this doesn’t mean it can’t immediately go off in one, split second.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › Green Growth Fails
Richard Smith 7-4 { chair of the UK Health Alliance on Climate Change (UKHACC). } - ("Perhaps only degrowth can save us," BMJ, published 7-4-2023, accessed 7-11-2023, https://www.bmj.com/content/382/bmj.p1545)//marlborough-HL
Hickel identifies the four major problems with green growth. Firstly, despite huge and admirable progress with renewable energy we can never keep up with a growing economy, meaning we will continue to depend on fossil fuels. Secondly, solar panels, wind turbines, batteries, and electric cars depend on metals and rare earths, and mining on the scale required to feed a growing economy will create massive and growing environmental damage. Nuclear power from either fission or fusion cannot develop fast enough to meet the energy requirements of economies that continue to grow. Similarly, carbon capture technologies are not maturing fast enough, and ironically depend on energy to work; plus they are a response to only one of our environmental problems. Thirdly, geoengineering projects like injecting the upper atmosphere with particles to create a veil to reflect sunlight, which the European Union is already considering, are extraordinarily risky. Fourthly, our problem is not confronted simply with rising temperatures but with a damaged planet, and if we had 100% clean energy we would “raze more forests, trawl more fish, mine more mountains, build more roads, expand industrial farming, and send more waste to landfill—all of which have ecological consequences our planet can no longer sustain.” Economists have long identified a paradox that innovations that create more efficient ways of using energy and resources briefly reduce consumption but then increase it. As Hickel explains it’s not really a paradox but what would be expected—because companies use the savings to reinvest in more production and the growth swamps the efficiency improvements.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › AT: Tech Solves
John Bellamy Foster 23 - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-11-2023, https://monthlyreview.org/2023/07/01/planned-degrowth/)//penelope/
The world scientific consensus, as represented by the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), has established that the global average temperature needs to be kept below a 1.5°C increase over pre-industrial levels this century—or else, with a disproportionately higher level of risk, “well below” a 2°C increase—if climate destabilization is not to threaten absolute catastrophe as positive feedback mechanisms come into effect. In the IPCC’s Sixth Assessment Report (AR6, released in its various parts over 2021–23), the most optimistic scenario is one of an end-of-the-century increase in global average temperature over pre-industrial levels of below 1.5°C. This requires that the 1.5°C boundary not be crossed until 2040, rising by a tenth of a degree to 1.6°C, and then falling near the end of the century back down to a 1.4°C increase. All of this is predicated on reaching net zero (in fact, real zero) carbon emissions by 2050, which gives a fifty-fifty chance that the climate-temperature boundary will not be exceeded.
Yet, according to leading climate scientist Kevin Anderson of the Tyndall Center for Climate Change Research, this scenario is already out of date. It is now necessary, based on the IPCC’s own figures, to reach the zero-carbon dioxide emissions point by 2040, in order to have the same 50 percent chance of avoiding a 1.5°C increase. “Starting now,” Anderson wrote in March 2023, to not exceed 1.5°C of warming requires 11% year-on-year cuts in emissions, falling to nearer 5% for 2°C. However, these global average rates ignore the core concept of equity, central to all UN climate negotiations, which gives “developing country parties” a little longer to decarbonise. Include equity and most “developed” nations need to reach zero CO2 emissions between 2030 and 2035, with developing nations following suit up to a decade later. Any delay will shrink these timelines still further.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › AT: Tech Solves
Wim Carton 19 {Associate Senior Lecturer at the Lund University Centre for Sustainability Studies. Carton’s research areas include political ecology, climate change mitigation, carbon forestry, carbon sequestration, perennial agriculture, carbon dioxide removal, negative emissions, political economy, socio-ecological theory, environmental geography, and environmental justice} - ("“Fixing” Climate Change by Mortgaging the Future: Negative Emissions, Spatiotemporal Fixes, and the Political Economy of Delay," Wiley Online Library, published 3-22-2019, accessed 7-19-2023, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/anti.12532)//penelope/
This essentially means that vast amounts of fossil fuel assets risk becoming stranded on the road to climate change mitigation (Surprise 2018). This would entail a fixed capital devaluation of epic proportions and can rightly be seen as the capitalist crisis that commentators have described it as. But note that this crisis for capital does not follow directly from the biophysical conditions associated with a changing climate. It is a crisis that first and foremost exists in socially mediated form, meaning that the direct “threat” comes from increasing social demands for mitigation and the political drive towards regulation rather than from increasing temperatures or rising sea levels. This is directly reflected in the way fossil fuel companies articulate the problem. Shell, for example, one of the world’s largest oil and gas companies, in its 2017 annual report for the first time acknowledged that climate change poses a risk to its operations (Shell 2018a).Yet it nowhere mentions actual climate change as a problem; rather, it is “rising climate change concerns” that are the issue, because they “have led and could lead to additional legal and/or regulatory measures which could result in project delays or cancellations, a decrease in demand for fossil fuels, potential litigation and additional compliance obligations” (Shell 2018a:13).
As I discussed above, it is well worth taking seriously this distinction between the social articulation of climate change and its biophysical basis, given how it speaks directly to the different fixes that are, and can be pursued. Among others it suggests that one does not necessarily need to mitigate climate change at all in order to fix (i.e. displace and defer) the crisis of legitimacy that it produces. The negative emissions concept illustrates this. Negative emissions take the carbon budget concept to its inevitable conclusion, by accounting not just for carbon “expenditures” (i.e. emissions), but also a range of proposed carbon “incomes”. This idea takes its inspiration from a number of biological (e.g. photosynthesis) and chemical (e.g. weathering of rocks) processes that remove CO2 from the atmosphere, and imagines that these could be deployed at a massive scale in order to make a limited carbon budget stretch further. The aforementioned BECCS is one example of such negative emissions technology (NET), but there are many others, including afforestation, soil carbon sequestration, direct air capture, enhanced weathering of rocks, etc. Because of the scale at which these technologies would need to be implemented, and the fact that their commercial and technological viability is in many cases unknown, models assume that NETs will only be operational at scale in the second half of the century. Essentially, this means that the negative emissions concept acts as a debt mechanism: the carbon budget for the first half of the 21st century can be extended on the basis of the assumption that large amounts of carbon will be removed in the second half (Geden 2016, 2018; Parson 2017). As Geden (2018:381) puts it, integrated assessment modellers have in this way “adopted the standard approach pursued by most governments instead of disciplining them: run huge deficits, betting on payback by future generations”. The significant, negative social and environmental consequences that one could expect with the actual implementation of some NETs have already been alluded to in the introduction. The negative emissions concept—as modelled in IAMs— however has concrete implications already now (Beck and Mahony 2018). By enabling a pathway to the 2°C target in the face of a tight carbon budget, it helps preserve a sense of normality in climate policy, fostering the notion that current policy commitments are appropriate and sufficient, that ambitious climate targets are still within reach and that governments are putting in place adequate measures to achieve them (Anderson and Peters 2016; Beck and Mahony 2017; Geden 2016; Pielke 2018). As Larkin et al. (2018:692) note, “IAM outputs risk delivering overly optimistic, unrealistic and potentially flawed message about future change [in which] challenging, but incremental energy policy is sufficient to deliver on the Paris Agreement”. The negative emissions concept in this way helps in “masking political inaction” (Geden 2016:794) and serves to legitimize mainstream climate policy in the face of 30 years of institutionalised delay. It does this without any NETs actually being implemented, indeed, irrespective of whether they will ever be implemented at all, but merely on the basis of its promised future arrival by climate models (Geden 2016; see also Markusson et al. 2017). Despite their so-far immaterial form, negative emissions help to pre-empt a crisis of political legitimacy by seemingly answering calls for ambitious climate action, all the while deferring the most difficult questions to the future.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › AT: Tech Solves
Jason Hickel 23 {Jason Edward Hickel is an economic anthropologist whose research focuses on ecological economics, global inequality, imperialism and political economy} - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-23-2023, https://monthlyreview.org/2023/07/01/on-technology-and-degrowth/)//penelope/
Degrowth does not call for all forms of production to be reduced. Rather, it calls for reducing ecologically destructive and socially less necessary forms of production, like sport utility vehicles, private jets, mansions, fast fash- ion, arms, industrial beef, cruises, commercial air travel, etc., while cutting advertising, extending product lifespans (banning planned obsolescence and introducing mandatory long-term warranties and rights to repair), and dramatically reducing the purchasing power of the rich. In other words, it targets forms of production that are organized mostly around capital accu- mulation and elite consumption. In the middle of an ecological emergency, should we be producing sport utility vehicles and mansions? Should we be diverting energy to support the obscene consumption and accumulation of the ruling class? No. That is an irrationality that only capitalism can love.
At the same time, degrowth scholarship insists on strong social policy to secure human needs and well-being, with universal public services, living wages, a public job guarantee, working time reduction, economic democracy, and radically reduced inequality.8 These measures abolish un- employment and economic insecurity and ensure the material conditions for a universal decent living—again, basic socialist principles. This schol- arship calls for efficiency improvements, yes, but also a transition toward sufficiency, equity, and a democratic postcapitalist economy, where pro- duction is organized around well-being for all, as Peter Kropotkin famous- ly put it, rather than around capital accumulation.
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › AT: Perm
Jason Hickel and Dylan Sullivan 23 {Jason Hickel is professor at the Institute for Environmental Science and Technology (ICTA-UAB) and the Department of Social and Cultural Anthropology at the Autonomous University of Barcelona. He is the author of The Divide: A Brief Guide to Global Inequality and Its Solutions (Penguin, 2017) and Less Is More: How Degrowth Will Save the World (Penguin, 2020). ICTA-UAB is supported by the María de Maeztu Unit of Excellence grant from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (CEX2019-000940-M). Dylan Sullivan is adjunct fellow and PhD student in the School of Social Sciences, Macquarie University, Sydney, where he teaches in politics, sociology, and anthropology. His research focuses on global inequality, colonial history, and the economics of socialist planning., } - ("Monthly Review," Monthly Review, published 7-1-2023, accessed 7-23-2023,
Successful Development Requires Public Planning
The existing arrangement of the world economy cannot deliver mean- ingful development in the Global South. As we have seen, imperialist dy- namics and the profit-orientation of national capital and foreign invest- ment militate against this possibility. The anticolonial movements of the mid-twentieth century understood this fact. They knew that achieving development would require directly mobilizing production to increase the output of key products, develop necessary technologies, and deliver essential goods and services.
Most of these movements were inspired by socialist principles, to varying degrees, which they saw as necessary for economic sovereignty and social progress. Many were influenced by the achievements of the Russian Revolution.28 Prior to 1917, Russia had been a low-wage agrar- ian hinterland exporting cheap raw materials (grain, hemp, flax, etc.) to western Europe.29 In 1899, the Russian Finance Minister Sergei Witte noted that “The economic relations of Russia with western Europe are fully comparable to the relations of colonial countries with their me- tropolises.”30 The communist revolution, and the transition to planning
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › AT: Jobs Solve the Link
Klein’19[Founder of THE OVERSHOOT and co-author of TRADE WARS ARE CLASS WARS]Matthew C. Klein, Debating Modern Monetary Theory, June 10, 2019, https://acrobat.adobe.com/link/review?uri=urn:aaid:scds:US:a40518b4-115a-37b4-b8fc-4d72e3c73f25/HZ
For the past few decades, MMT thinkers have been focused on those “additional institutional modifications.” In their view, the most straightforward solution is to have the government offer jobs directly to anyone who wants one. Anyone who failed to get a job in the private sector would be paid by the government to plant trees, clean streets, or perform other tasks for which there are few prerequisites. By definition, unemployment would disappear. This “job guarantee” would not be as generous as it might seem because it would also be used to help keep inflation under control. Mitchell has explained the new jobs would pay only enough to guarantee a “minimum acceptable living standard” at a fixed pay rate. If prices rise, real incomes will fall. The threat of being forced to take a “low-wage and possibly stigmatized” government job is supposed to “discipline the distributional struggle” and prevent overall wages from rising too rapidly, he notes. The least appreciated—but most important— aspect of the political economy of MMT is its treatment of inflation. The standard view embraced by the world’s central banks is that prices rise when “aggregate demand” for goods and services exceeds an economy’s productive capacity. MMT economists reject this approach. They argue that most inflation is caused by “bottlenecks” in specific sectors. As Stephanie Kelton of Stony Brook University put it in a recent interview with CNBC, policy makers have to “understand what the source of the inflationary pressure is” and then craft a “policy tool that you think is going to help you get at that inflation.”
2023
DDI
Negative
Extensions › Degrowth K › K Extensions on Case
Tadzio Mueller 12 {Frieder Otto Wolf is an eco-socialist and an early member (1982) of the German Green Party. Between 1984 and 1999 he represented the party in the European Parliament; he was defeated in the 1999 election. He has also been active as a political philosopher and has concentrated on teaching philosophy and working within political networks since 2000. Further details see, Tadzio Mueller is active in Climate Justice Action (www.climate-justice-action.org) and author of several articles on green capitalism and the Green New Deal, including ‘Another Capitalism is Possible?’ (in Abramsky, K., ed., Sparking a World-wide Energy Revolution: Social Struggles in the Transition to a Post-Petrol World.). He is an editor of Turbulence., } - ("Green New Deal: Dead end or pathway beyond capitalism? : turbulence," published 2012, accessed 7-24-2023,
TM: By focussing on the question of capitalism and capitalist growth, I am not at all denying the fact that the climate crisis – and more generally the biocrisis – has its own internal dynamics that are not reducible to the dynamics of capital accumulation. Obviously, climate change is forcing the radical left to rethink the timeframe of its political practices. Humanity, however much it is exploited, oppressed and trodden upon, has an amazing capacity to (almost) always regenerate itself. Add to that a pinch of Hegelian conceptions of history, and you get a teleology where Communists knew that ultimate victory would be theirs. Once the climate system is pushed beyond its current stable state, however, returning to that state will be impossible – so waiting for some ‘victory’ in some ‘final battle’ simply won’t do. In short: yes, there is an urgency surrounding ecological crises, and this urgency requires us to rethink some things. But where we disagree is the question of what it is that needs to be rethought.
To start with, invoking urgency is essentially a politically indeterminate move. By this I mean that anyone who invokes urgency generally does so to explain why their particular programme should take precedence over others, over the ‘normal’ course of things. As a result, calls for ‘urgent’ action should not be dismissed, but treated with a healthy degree of skepticism.