Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › General

An increase in consumer disposable income due to a JG would stimulate economic growth

Nasrudin ’22 [Ahmad, September 13, 2022, Bachelor in Statistics Major & Economics and Development Studies, Bogor Agricultural, “How Consumption Expenditure Affects the Economy,” https://penpoin.com/how-consumption-expenditure-affects-the-economy/]

In macroeconomics, consumption expenditure affects the economy through aggregate demand. Economists include it as an item in aggregate demand in addition to business investment, government spending, and net exports. Thus, when consumption expenditure increases, aggregate demand also increases. As a result, it stimulates the economy to produce more output, leading to economic growth. Moreover, it also lowers the unemployment rate as businesses need more labor to produce more output.

Our expenses create income for companies. In other words, the money we spend becomes the revenue for them. Therefore, they will increase production to earn more profit when they believe we will spend more money (increased consumption).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › General

A jobs guarantee causes growth

David Broder, 2-4-2017, "Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee," No Publication, https://jacobin.com/2017/02/federal-job-guarantee-universal-basic-income-investment-jobs-unemployment/

This is good for the economy as a whole. Rather than expanding the  rolls during economic busts, the FJG would put folks to work and moderate the business cycle. Federal workers’ paychecks will increase demand, which will increase economic growth.  agree that today’s secular stagnation — insufficient demand — is contributing to continued “” growth after the Great Recession. Only modest upticks in growth for the foreseeable future will come if we continue the status quo.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – JG Prompts Growth › Secular Stagnation

A job guarantee ensures limitless expansion of economies culminating in ecological collapse

Wray et al. ’18 [L. Randall, Flavia Dantas, Scott Fullwiler, Pavlina R. Tcherneva, and Stephanie A. Kelton; 2018; Professor of Economics at the Bard College; State University of New York at Cortland; University of Missouri-Kansas City; PhD Economics, associate professor of economics at Bard College, research associate at the Levy Economics Institute and expert at the Institute for New Economic Thinking; Stony Brook University, and Levy Economics Institute of Bard College; Levy Institute Research Project Report, “Public Service Employment: A Path to Full Employment,” Annandale-on-Hudson, NY: Levy Economics Institute of Bard College]

Some have emphasized other structural forces at play. John Williams, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, argues that a growing percentage of (relatively) younger Americans are leaving the labor force to care for children and older family members, obtain more education, or enjoy leisure (Williams 2016). The supply-side case would tell us that more generous social safety-net benefits, combined with an increase in the number of families with two working spouses, have reduced the costs associated with labor force withdrawal. Prime-age workers are more likely to drop out rather than take jobs that require lower skill levels or pay much lower wages.

The evidence suggests that depressed LFPRs for prime-age workers are more likely the result of a combination of insufficient aggregate demand, weak job creation, and stagnant wages — all of which have been persistent problems over the past three or four decades. While short-lived economic expansions have occasionally counteracted these trends, this temporary relief has been provided by unsustainable asset-price bubbles (dot-com stocks, commodities, housing prices) and excessive private indebtedness, which increases fragility and does little for those at the bottom of the income ladder. Further, once the bubbles burst, we return to secular stagnation.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › Degrowth Solves Consumption

Degrowth Is Possible

Pratt, 11-19-2021, "How to Save the Planet: Stop Economic Growth – KENNEDY SCHOOL REVIEW," No Publication, https://ksr.hkspublications.org/2021/11/19/how-to-save-the-planet-stop-economic-growth/

Though there are currently no post-growth societies, there is real-world evidence that degrowth is plausible. United Nations data show that various countries have achieved the highest category of educational attainment and life expectancy at a GDP per capita of just $9,000.34 Adding in employment, nutrition, social support, democracy, and life satisfaction at the highest category still requires a GDP per capita below the world average: theoretically, the entire world could “degrow” immediately while drastically increasing virtually everyone’s quality of life.35 However, degrowth does not intend to degrow the entire world. Many countries still need to increase economic activity in key sectors to meet their material needs, and the vast majority of environmental harm is caused by rich countries. The more immediate question is can rich countries maintain a high quality of life while massively reducing economic activity. The data say: absolutely. Japan’s life expectancy is almost six years higher than the United States with 35 percent lower income per capita. Portugal has higher levels of human welfare than the United States with $38,000 less in GDP per capita, meaning $13 trillion of the American economy is essentially wasted every year from the perspective of improving quality of life.36 Costa Rica also has a higher life expectancy and self-reported happiness than the United States with 80 percent less income per capita and a massively lower impact on the environment.37 Countries like Costa Rica are far from optimized, so it is safe to say that massive amounts of resources can be cut from the budgets of developed countries like the United States without negative effects on well-being. Many degrowth policies have already had pilots and full-scale implementations with favorable results. Experimental UBI programs have shown improvements in mental health, happiness, sanitation, nutrition, trust in people and institutions, entrepreneurship, education outcomes, addiction rates, stress, poverty, crime, and even employment.38 Countries that invest in universal public health care (a quintessential UBS) see better health outcomes and some of the fastest increases in life expectancy.39 The popularity of recent programs to cut working hours suggests a four-day work week will be as popular as the 40-hour week once was.40 Finally, could degrowth really be implemented? The opposition of entrenched interests, particularly the fossil fuel industry, pose major obstacles.41 However, many of degrowth’s flagship proposals—like universal health care, jobs guarantees, and wealth taxation—are already wildly popular.42,43,44 Successfully implementing them can increase their popularity further. Lastly, as John F. Kennedy School of Government researcher Erica Chenoweth’s research shows, only one government has ever survived a social movement mobilizing 3.5 percent of the country’s population.45 The numbers don’t lie: demanding a degrowth future, by ballots or mass movements, can make a degrowth future not just essential, but real.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › Degrowth Solves Consumption

Degrowth Increases Personal Wellbeing. Europe Proves

Conrad, 8-28-20, "Reality has Endorsed Degrowth – Political Science at Haverford College," https://pols.sites.haverford.edu/studentvoices/reality-has-endorsed-degrowth/

Isn’t this basically advocating for a permanent recession (even if it saves billions of lives)? No. I’d argue that recessions are unplanned economic shocks that reduce people’s wellbeing – people lose their jobs (and in the US, healthcare), face eviction, loss of income, and more. Degrowth is a planned reduction in the material/energy throughput of the economy that seeks to maximize wellbeing, even as we deliberately produce and consume less. Put simply, degrowth posits that we can increase human wellbeing while reducing economic activity. We already know this is possible – Europe has about half the GDP per capita of the US, but scores much better than the US on practically every social metric – self reported happiness, education, life expectancy, the list goes on. Costa Rica has a fifth the GDP of the US and better life expectancy. The US in 1970 was statistically happier than it is today, despite the economy being more than twice as large now. So how do we do this? How can we decouple wellbeing from GDP? Degrowth’s academic arm has a lot of answers to this question. Legislate an end to planned obsolescence – if products last 4 times as long, consumption will fall 75%. Restrict advertising, so people aren’t pushed to buy stuff they don’t need. Tax luxury consumption (which has an outsized ecological impact) more heavily. Set decreasing caps on material and energy use to ensure we hit IPCC targets. End fossil fuel subsidies, place moratoriums on new fossil fuel projects, and fund massive public investments in renewables.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › Degrowth Solves Consumption

Degrowth Lowers Consumer Spending

Conrad, 8-28-20, "Reality has Endorsed Degrowth – Political Science at Haverford College," https://pols.sites.haverford.edu/studentvoices/reality-has-endorsed-degrowth/

Fortunately, the other set of IPCC scenarios doesn’t rely on humanity collectively jumping off a cliff and hoping someone will build a net (BECCS) to catch us before we hit the ground. In this set of scenarios, global use of energy and materials decreases while societies rapidly switch to zero carbon infrastructure. Because most energy use is tied up in the production of consumable products, this basically means ending over-consumption. This would occur primarily in the global north, where we consume far more energy and materials than is sustainable – the global south’s level of consumption is well below the line for sustainability, so degrowth isn’t necessary there. Which brings me to the undiscussed implication of the IPCC report: this would likely entail negative economic growth and falling GDP in the global north. Why? The reason is simple – the best empirical evidence we have shows that GDP is tightly linked to energy use. When the economy grows, energy use goes up. When it doesn’t grow (or shrinks), energy use falls. That’s why the only year in the last 20 that global CO2 emissions have fallen is 2009 (and soon, 2020). This linkage makes sense – GDP measures all the monetized final goods and services in the economy, and pretty much everything that’s sold relies on an energy foundation – manufacturing a car requires energy to power the factory, restaurants need power to operate, selling software requires energy to power computers, etc.

But wait. Why does energy use have to fall? Can’t we just switch to renewables and then keep growing energy use? Unfortunately, no. Because economic growth compounds, a 3% growth rate doubles the size of the economy every 24 years. In other words, if we continue to pursue growth, the global economy will be twice as large by 2050, and energy use will likely have doubled with it. The last few decades of economic growth have driven global energy use up astronomically, so even though renewable energy has grown, fossil fuel has grown by more, instead of declining. With economic growth we get energy addition instead of an energy transition. That’s why energy use has to fall. Even with optimistic assumptions, supply constraints on key metals (lithium, neodymium, etc) mean that we can only bring renewables online to replace about 4-7% of existing energy use per year. The math works out such that a fall in energy use is basically the only thing compatible with achieving the IPCC’s emissions reductions targets – if we keep growing, we won’t be able to replace fossil fuels fast enough. In other words, reality has endorsed degrowth. The world’s best scientists at the IPCC have warned us that if we want a shot at avoiding climate catastrophe, we need to fundamentally reorient the economy towards less material/energy use (or jump of the BECCS cliff and gamble with billions of lives).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT -- Degrowth Solves, General

Only Degrowth Can Prevent Ecological and Economic Collapse

Remblance, 3-7-2022, "Degrowth is Not Recession. Nor is it Austerity.," resilience, https://www.resilience.org/stories/2022-03-07/degrowth-is-not-recession-nor-is-it-austerity/

The term “Degrowth” does have a negative connotation for some, presumably those that are unaware of the ecological crisis, or those who are concerned about such people embracing the concept. But, for those who are aware of the urgency with which we must act if we are to avoid activating catastrophic tipping points, the concept of Degrowth can hit like a breath of fresh air: pure relief that there may be a way to avoid some of the worst outcomes of a warming planet. This is because the future doesn’t look like today. There is no path to continuing to grow the economy and the material footprint that cannot be decoupled from that economy and everything will be ok. Whichever direction we choose, “the future will be a radical departure from the present”. The best science is telling us that we either implement planned degrowth or we face a very real risk of ecological and societal collapse.If we are honest, it’s not the term “degrowth” that people don’t like, it’s what it means: we must reduce our material footprint so that we are no longer living as though we have two, three, four or five planet earths. The lifestyles of wealthy nations are not sustainable – we are transgressing seven of the nine planetary boundaries already, of which climate change and biodiversity loss are only two. We’ve been consuming ecological resources and services that, if distributed fairly, should belong to people in other nations and to future generations, including our own children. It’s a huge failure of leadership that we’ve been able to live outside of the planetary boundaries for so long – not to mention the fact that further economic growth continues to be the mission of every major government around the world. We must face into this issue and not simply pretend it isn’t happening. Changing the term won’t change what we need to do, and we cannot take our focus off what needs to be done: we are living beyond the means of the planet and it’s time to reign it in. The good news is that by actively degrowing wealthy economies we can focus on the things in life that matter, for example: family, friendships, learning, creativity, nature, physical activity and rest. The things that actually do make us happier, because more and more “stuff” does not. We will wind down polluting industries, optimize our finite resources so that they are being used to meet needs and not wants (or merely thrown away), reduce waste via the elimination of planned obsolescence, focus on “usage” rather than “ownership” and increase the resources devoted to recycling. We will begin to live in harmony with the planet, and not actively against it.Ultimately, if we are genuinely concerned about people suffering we cannot justify continuing to grow the economies of wealthy nations any longer. Billions of people are already suffering under this economic system, and climate change will only exacerbate this further. That is because there is no path to reducing fossil fuel use each year in wealthy nations to achieve the science-based climate change targets while continuing to increase our energy use. We must deploy ‘demand-side’ solutions as well as supply-side solutions if we are to achieve the seemingly impossible task ahead of us. It can be a bitter pill to swallow for those who have embraced – and likely benefited from – growth-based economics, but we must acknowledge that it’s time to change our economic system and degrow the economies of wealthy nations. The very future of human civilisation depends on it.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT -- Degrowth Solves, General

Degrowth is crucial to our society, the costs for negligence is exponential.

Morgan, 20. (Jamie Morgan; Jamie is the former coordinator of the Association for Heterodox Economists. The AHE shares with the WEA and the Institute for New Economic Thinking a commitment to the need for a renewed and more open approach to economics. Over the last decade, Jamie has published widely in the fields of economics, political economy, philosophy, sociology and international politics.; 2020; “Degrowth: Necessary, Urgent and Good for You”; https://eprints.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/id/eprint/7124/1/DegrowthNecessaryUrgentAndGoodForYouPV-MORGAN.pdf; Leeds Beckett University; Accessed 7/23/2023; JB)

No single work can possibly make the case for degrowth and The Case as a book is more by way of a preliminary “a case” but is no less important for that. Kallis et al. do however succeed in presenting an accessible argument that achieves two important things. First, as with much of the degrowth literature (and growth sceptic literature in general) it brings to the fore just how aberrational our idea of normal is. Continual growth (as we currently conceive of this) as the systemic “normal” is abnormal, our “common sense” is insane. The truth of this hides in plain sight and it is an uncomfortable truth.26 As such, The Case for Degrowth provides a useful campaigning text for groups like Extinction Rebellion or Stay Grounded.27 Second, the book is a timely reminder, as the Covid-19 pandemic diffuses around the world with likely terrible social, economic and human cost, that there is a positive case for degrowth, not just a climate and ecological imperative. As such, The Case for Degrowth (noting its pandemic focused Preface) might usefully be read in conjunction with Jason Hickel’s recent paper summarising the difference between crisis/recession and degrowth. As he suggests:

“We have different words for recession and degrowth because they are different things. Recessions happen when growth-dependent economies stop growing: it is a disaster that ruins people’s lives and exacerbates injustices. Degrowth calls for a[n] different kind of economy altogether: an economy that does not require growth in the first place, and which can deliver justice and well-being without growth” (Hickel, 2020a: 4).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT -- Degrowth Solves, General

Degrowth is crucial now, and will have to constitute a decrease in work

Foramatti et al. ’19 [September 19, 2019, Joel*, PhD candidate at ICTA-UAB, Marula Tsagkari**, PhD candidate in Energy Policy & Economics at the University of Barcelona, Christos Zografos***, Senior Research Fellow with the Johns Hopkins University, “Why degrowth is the only responsible way forward,” https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/why-degrowth-only-responsible-way-forward/]

To sustain the natural basis of our life, we must slow down. We have to reduce the amount of extraction, pollution, and waste throughout our economy. This implies less production, less consumption, and probably also less work.

The responsibility to do so must lie mainly on the rich, who currently enjoy a disproportionate share of our resources. But we should also do things differently, as much of today's economic activity is of little benefit to human wellbeing. Imagine what could be if we organized democratically to produce what we actually need, distributed those resources fairly, and shared them in common. This, in a nutshell, is the vision of degrowth: a good life for all within planetary boundaries. And while this might seem utopian, there are already concrete policy ideas to start such a transformation.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – UBI + Degrowth Solves

A UBI is key for degrowth

Johann Beckford, 1-2-19 Johann Beckford is an MA Global Political Economy student at the University of Sheffield researching economic growth, environmental sustainability and prosperity. His dissertation research was on the relationship between basic income and degrowth for environmental sustainability., "Basic Income and Degrowth: Creating an Alternative Ecological Future? — UBI Lab Network," UBI Lab Network, https://www.ubilabnetwork.org/blog/the-moral-argument-for-basic-income-yl7wn (AG)

Universal Basic Income’s history amongst intellectual circles is well documented and varied. In many ways, contemporary trials from Finland to Scotland, Canada to Kenya feel like a building crescendo. UBI’s time is coming - and soon.

The arguments we are most familiar with usually focus on poverty alleviation and material freedom. Jason Leman and Simon Duffy, elsewhere in this blog series, have discussed UBI’s relationship with an automated future, providing further food for thought. There may be, however, a need for UBI that is more pressing than any we could have imagined.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
2NC/1NR – Reverse Econ › EXT – UBI + Degrowth Solves

Successful degrowth depends on working less and abandoning the economic measure – UBI solves better by ensuring social safety nets while reducing work imperatives.

Lewis and Stronge 21(Kyle Lewis and Will Stronge; Kyle Lewis is a PhD candidate at the University of West London and a working time consultant at the think tank. Will Stronge is co-director of the think tank. He holds a PhD in politics and philosophy from the University of Brighton; 6/8/21; Making time: working less to save the planet; The Ecologist; https://theecologist.org/2021/jun/08/making-time-working-less-save-planet; DOA 7/23/2023; [Lowell-DB])

Working less is both necessary and desirable from an environmental perspective. With climate breakdown already at our doorstep, the pressing need to change course from capitalist models of growth has spawned new disciplines and approaches within the field of economics. One such approach is referred to as degrowth - a genre of research and activism that has been active for many decades, originally inspired by the political ecology of the French-Austrian philosopher André Gorz. Conviviality Those who advocate for degrowth define its approach as being- first and foremost- a critique of growth. Economic growth is unsustainable per se, because it is inseparable and cannot be ‘absolutely decoupled’ from greenhouse gas emissions and other negative environmental impacts. In contrast to accounts that stress the need for ‘green growth’ or ‘socialist growth’, degrowth advocates demand the dethroning of growth as a goal in general and in its place want a political economy focused on using fewer natural resources in order to organise life and work. Rather than advancing an economic model destined for austerity, scarcity and recession - which are the socio-economic consequences usually associated with ‘flat’ or ‘non-growing economies’, degrowth and postgrowth advocates argue in favour of economic metrics and objectives that advance alternative modes of living, based on principles of sharing, conviviality, care and the common good. Degrowth Giorgos Kallis, a leading ecological economist, and his colleagues, said in a 2010 article for the Journal of Cleaner Production: "Sustainable degrowth may be defined as an equitable downscaling of production and consumption that increases human well-being and enhances ecological conditions at the local and global level, in the short and long term. "The adjective sustainable does not mean that degrowth should be sustained indefinitely but rather that the process of transition/transformation and the end-state should be sustainable in the sense of being environmentally and socially beneficial. The paradigmatic proposal of degrowth is therefore that human progress without economic growth is possible." A transition to degrowth must involve abandoning Gross Domestic Product as a measure of success for an economy, and fundamentally recalibrating what we value. In short: we need to change the metrics. Capture Rather than viewing perpetual growth as an end in itself, a sustainable degrowth approach would implement measurements that are geared towards, and that capture, societal well-being, ecological sustainability and social equality. For advocates of degrowth, the transition to a new economy will be undergirded by a range of policy measures that actively encourage economic activity based on resource circulation rather than resource extraction. These tend to include a universal basic income - creating an income floor irrespective of an individual's earnings or employment status- a wide range of universal services - free public transport, housing, healthcare and education- and a high rate of tax and regulation on private assets -encouraging less consumerism and more environmentally sustainable uses of energy and resources. One of the key components of a degrowth programme relates to working time and its reduction. Working less not only reduces the sheer amount of resources being used as part of the labour process, but it also reduces the amount of carbon-intensive consumption that comes with what economist Juliet Schor had called the ‘work and spend’ cycle. In a study that assessed the environmental impacts of twenty seven OECD countries, Schor and her colleagues estimated that reducing our working hours by a quarter could reduce our carbon footprint by as much as thirty percent. Unsustainable For the average British worker, this would mean cutting our weekly forty-two hours of work to just over thirty-one hours – or, a four-day week. The carbon footprint held by individual items consumed by households with shorter or longer working hours was evaluated in the US a 2019 degrowth-inspired the study Work Hours and CO 2 Emissions: Evidence from US Households. In short, each item of expenditure, reported via surveys, per household was ranked according to how carbon-intensive its production was - from packaged meals to pieces of clothing and so on. Their conclusion? ‘Households with longer work hours have significantly larger carbon footprints’, demonstrating a worrying correlation between increasingly unsustainable consumption and high workload lifestyles. This study is consonant with anecdotal everyday experience, where early starts mean plastic wrapped breakfasts and late finishes bequeath takeaway meals delivered by moped or ready meals thrown into the microwave because we’re too tired to cook. Viable In the UK context, a recent study by the four day week campaign showed that a four day working week implemented nationally could shrink the UK’s carbon footprint by 127 million tonnes per year by 2025, which represents more than the entire carbon footprint of Switzerland, and is also equivalent to taking 27 million cars off the road - effectively the entire UK private car fleet. The advocates of degrowth have made valuable contributions, not least in highlighting the problematic aspects of the pursuit of economic growth. Yet, an ardent commitment to degrowth often fails to account for the ways in which certain areas of the economy will need to grow very quickly in order to cut carbon emissions at the rates required. As economist Robert Pollin has argued, the key objective for governments around the world should be to decouple consumption from fossil fuels at both the macro and micro levels - in consonance with degrowth arguments - whilst also investing massively in green energy infrastructure as its replacement - that is, growth. The net result of this could well be that economies - GDP- grow rapidly while still advancing a viable climate-stabilisation project. This adds nuance to green strategy: the problem isn’t necessarily growth per se, but specifically which areas of the economy grow, and to what extent.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
1NCs › 1NC – Degrowth Vs. GnD

Climate oriented job guarantees would only entrench the root cause of climate change, growth-oriented capitalism

Schmelzer et al. ’22 [June 28, 2022, Matthias*, economic historian, post-doctoral researcher at the Friedrich-Schiller University Jena, Andrea Vetter**, transformation researcher, activist, and journalist, Aaron Vansintjan***, writer focusing on degrowth, “Degrowth – not just Green New Deals!” https://theecologist.org/2022/jun/28/degrowth-not-just-green-new-deals]

We live in a time of many and accelerating crises. Climate breakdown is breathing down our neck. Biodiversity is collapsing in ecosystems around the world, and many natural safety nets – water cycles, soil fertility, fish stocks, microbial diversity – are unravelling.

Civil war and natural disasters have ripped whole countries apart, sending millions of people to seek safety – only to be blocked by militarised borders.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
1NCs › 1NC – Degrowth Vs. GnD

Federal Jobs, even ones designed to improve the environment, would only hamper the transition to a degrowth economy

Vansintjan ’19 [May, 2019, Aaron, PhD candidate at Birkbeck, University of London, “Degrowth VS. The Green New Deal,” Briarpatch, Volume 48, Issue 3]

The Green New Deal has gone mainstream. The idea is to combine a massive federal job creation program with bold action to rapidly shift away from fossil fuels and protect Indigenous rights. Long a buzzword in the U.S. Green Party, a Green New Deal resolution was introduced in February by insurgent Democrats like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who've solidified its scope and demands. Now, Canadian leftist organizations like Courage are presenting their own proposals for a "Green New Deal of the North." And in March, federal NDP leader Jagmeet Singh began voicing support for the Green New Deal idea.

But some are wary of proposals like the Green New Deal--they say that it only "greens" the capitalist imperative of perpetual economic growth, which is the true cause of environmental destruction. These critics--degrowthers--believe that to reduce our environmental impacts, we need to scale down energy and material use throughout the economy. This will likely lead to a downturn in gross domestic product (GDP) growth, so we need to restructure the economy so it doesn't rely on economic growth as an indicator for well-being.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
1NCs › 1NC – Degrowth Vs. GnD

Solves the advantages

Alexander 22 (Dr. Samuel Alexander 22, lecturer at the University of Melbourne, Australia, co-director of the Simplicity Institute and a research fellow with the Melbourne Sustainable Society Institute; and Brendan Gleeson, Emeritus Professor at the School of Regulation and Global Governance, The Australian National University; “Collective Sufficiency: Degrowth as a Political Project;” Chapter 5, Post-Capitalist Futures: Paradigms, Politics, and Prospects, Palgrave MacMillan, 2022, DOI 10.1007/978-981-16-6530-1)

If capitalism is coming to an end in coming years or decades as it collides with various ecological and financial limits, how can we actively design the end of this mode of political economy rather than wait for its collapse? Or even, if necessary, how can we design for the collapse of capitalism in ways that make the best of a destabilised situation? Capitalism certainly isn’t going to lie down like a lamb at the polite request of Left-leaning environmentalists. What this means is that sustainability and justice advocates with radical visions of post-capitalist futures need to think very carefully about the question of strategy and transition. More specifically, we must confront the question of where and how to invest time, energy, and resources, if we genuinely seek a fundamentally different type of economic system ‘beyond capitalism’.1

In the prehistory of the COVID-19 pandemic, we explored in our book Degrowth in the Suburbs (Alexander and Gleeson 2019) the prospects for a systemic transition away from capitalism via degrowth— planned, managed, or imposed. We argued degrowth is the most coherent paradigm for transcending the machinic economics of growth inherent to the existing capitalist system.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
1NCs › 1NC Shell – Radical Degrowth K

Successful degrowth requires a de-alienation of labor, restructuring worker relations via a shift in the control of production. Only the alt avoids JG being integrated within a socialist-growth oriented economy, but the perm maintains a parasitic “worker-identity.”

Barca 19 (Barca, Stefania, is senior researcher at the Center for Social Studies of the University of Coimbra (CES/UC). She obtained her PhD in Economic History from the University of Bari (Italy) in 1997, “The Labor(s) of Degrowth, Capitalism Nature Socialism”, 30:2, 207-216, DOI: 10.1080/10455752.2017.1373300)

Giorgios Kallis’ response to John Bellamy Foster brings the discussion on degrowth directly to the core of my main research and theoretical concern: the place of labor in the politics of socio-ecological revolution. In my contribution to this forum, I will argue that the debate on ecosocialist degrowth must engage with the centrality of work and class in the transition to a post-carbon and post-capitalist paradigm. In other words, there can be no degrowth without dealienation (Brownhill, Turner, and Kaara 2012). Kallis (2015) and Foster (2015) agree on advocating for an ecological socialism that might be able to democratically regulate the much-needed decrease in social metabolism: the central issue being how to carry out the social transformations that will lead to the desired result. While Foster emphasizes the need for a new “ecological revolution” inspired by the Communist manifesto and by a historical-materialist approach to earth-system science, Kallis asks which institutions will allow a democratic control over social metabolism to be better realized. Both authors also put forward a list “policy proposals” that they consider achievable under the present conditions and necessary to “mobilize the general public” (in Foster’s words). I believe that what is missing to move forward with this common plan is a clearer vision of what political subjects and which processes of political subjectivation can make it happen. In other words, rather than presupposing a “general public” as the recipient of any political strategy, we need to build such strategy upon a more solid analysis of the social forces involved, their mutual relations and their possible common interests. In what follows I will offer my contribution in this sense by reflecting on the place that labor movements and working-class people can and should have in degrowth politics and in the transformation of social metabolism more in general. Kallis’ main argument that growth of biophysical throughput is still possible in a non-capitalist or even socialist economy is a useful starting point. The argument touches upon an important issue, of interest to all those who connect ecological struggles to an anti-capitalist perspective (from Naomi Klein to ecosocialists). It is reinforced by the observation that, for the most part, socialist regimes have shown levels of environmental devastation fundamentally similar to those of the capitalist world. In this sense, some authors have come to argue that, rather than Capitalocene, the Anthropocene should be actually renamed as Growthocene (Chertkovskaya and Paulsson 2016). Ecological critiques notwithstanding (materialist or otherwise), and especially with the development of nuclear power and synthetic chemicals in the post-WWII era, both systems followed the imperative of economic growth, which can be seen as the leading cause of ecological unsustainability and “environmental violence” (Barca 2014a). If degrowth ultimately means eliminating the productive reinvestment of surplus value (as Kallis and his co-authors Demaria and D’Alisa argue in the epilogue to Degrowth: A Vocabulary for a New Era), the problem arises of who decides on how the surplus should be dispensed with (dépense) and how (D’Alisa, Demaria, and Kallis 2014). This is clearly a political problem, as the authors rightly point out. And, I would add, it is one shared by all growth-oriented societies, both capitalist and centrally planned, because in both systems the producers (however defined) are typically estranged from decisions over the allocation of the surplus. In this sense, the emphasis that Kallis’ commentary puts on workers as decision-makers on surplus allocation sounds misplaced. In state socialism, decisions on what to do with the surplus have been alienated from workers as much as (if not more than) in capitalism. In capitalist systems, the surplus tends to be reinvested in increased production (but also spent in conspicuous consumption, charity, control of the media, etc.). In neither case do workers have much democratic control over the allocation of the surplus produced through their labor. As Leigh Brownhill, Terisa Turner and Wahu Kaara explain in their contribution to a previous degrowth symposium hosted by Capitalism Nature 208 S. BARCA Socialism in 2012, dealienation is the process by which Marx’s four forms of estrangement – from the products of labor and the natural world, from the labor process, from species-being and from other humans – are actively reversed through collective action. In their words, “De-alienation is about action by the exploited and dispossessed, both waged and unwaged,” aimed at un-enclosing resources and establishing new commoning practices and social relations (Brownhill, Turner, and Kaara 2012). Now, what exactly this entails is highly contingent on local situations and political choices regarding the extent to which the industrial division of labor will be accepted in the future degrowth society. Gorz (1982), a widely recognized inspiration for degrowthers, famously claimed that a certain grade of alienation from the labor process was inevitable in industrial societies. Nevertheless, the point here is that degrowth should aim for a truly democratic, worker-controlled production system where this alienation is actively countered by a collective reappropriation of the products of labor and by a truly democratic decision-making process over the use of the surplus. Estrangement from the products of labor is the specific aspect of alienation that concerns me here, in so far as it relates to the separation between the producers and the allocation of surplus that characterizes both capitalist and socialist regimes. My hypothesis is that the alienation of the producers from the products of their work is what leads to the reinvestment of surplus into increased production. Consequently, the project of building a degrowth society can only start from fostering dealienation by reopening the possibility for workers control and economic democracy, from the workplace to society at large. This, I argue, is the reason why the degrowth movement must build a constructive dialogue with the alienated and exploited workers of the world. Here, in the messy reality of everyday re/productive work, complex contradictions arise that need to be addressed in fundamentally new ways. Different forms of metabolism clash with each other and produce environmental conflicts, which enter into communities’ and people’s lives, questioning identities, crushing certain life-forms and turning them into cogs of the dominant social metabolism.1 This process takes different forms in the different but interconnected spaces of the global political economy. The fundamental political problem for degrowth is to gain a clear perspective on how the alienation of workers occurs, and how it can be reversed. A good vantage point from which the contradictions in social metabolism can be analyzed is the perspective of those workers whose livelihood depends on fossil-driven economic growth, and whose voice rarely makes it to degrowthers’ ears. While I was writing this article, one of those voices reached me from a distant place through an article published on The Leap website (Rojas 2016). It was that of a Mapuche oil worker from Patagonia, 1 I am grateful to Giacomo D’Alisa for pointing me to the issue of clashing social metabolisms. CAPITALISM NATURE SOCIALISM 209 who told a sad story of dispossession and destruction of local agriculture by Argentina’s powerful oil business sector. Together with a history of racial discrimination and state repression, this left him and thousands of others no choice but to join the extractive industries. Working in the oil fields for 25 years, he came to know first-hand the devastating impact they had on his community’s land and bodies, and he lost two family members to cancer due to the widespread contamination of water in the area. Despite all this, he considers himself to be fortunate in having a job that allows him to pay his bills and medical expenses, and to buy bottled water – especially when comparing his situation to that of local farmers who are literally on the verge of starvation. This gives us a measure of how difficult it is for many workers to even consider the possibility of losing their job, no matter how dirty and dangerous, in the absence of viable alternatives. In this Mapuche man’s experience, environmental violence was inextricably linked to alienation from the labor process: once hired, workers in the oil industry are made to sign a confidentiality agreement “that gives away (their) right to speak out publically”; in addition, they are trained in what the company calls “environmental safety,” which means that whatever disaster may happen, the blame is immediately shifted on their supposed errors. The truth is, however, that disasters occur almost invariably (in this and many other cases) because management orders workers to keep production going despite reported faults or potential leaks. And, if they question choices internally, they face a variety of repercussions. This tells us that weak unions and virtually non-existent enforcement of labor regulations play a major role in determining the environmental impact of production. Nevertheless, this worker is perfectly aware of the root causes of this situation, and of the negative balance left behind by promises of prosperity based on oil extraction. His quest is one for dealienation, in the sense of gaining control over not only the labor process and product, but also the political process where decisions are made over the best route to prosperity for his country. As he claims, “We, as people, have to question and ask ourselves: what gives us more prosperity?” The answer for him is in the development of a flourishing and diversified agriculture without oil, based on the rich natural resources of the country, rather than on soy and other soil-eroding monocrop plantations. This kind of sustainable agricultural development, he explains, is what would give people the opportunity to flourish by getting back “what’s theirs” – i.e. the product of their labor. Following his vision, we might imagine, if not degrowth, at least a prosperous way out of fossil-driven economic growth, built upon a dealienated relationship of workers with the labor process and the product of their labor. The centrality of dealienation in a discussion of degrowth becomes even clearer when we analyze the concrete historical examples in which dealienated workers have been able to enact sustainable modes of production, i.e. of 210 S. BARCA working-class environmentalism. While the history of 20th-century environmentalism is ridden with conflicts between environmental activists and workers, which have compromised any possibility for political alliance in many cases, it also shows important – if less well-known – stories of labor environmentalism, some of them opening the possibility for truly emancipative ways of organizing social metabolism. Probably, the most well-known example is that of the rubber tappers’ struggles of the 1980s, which initiated the emancipative conservation experience of the Amazon “extractive reserves” (Barca 2014b). But other stories can be dug out of oblivion, and other voices from working-class and labor environmentalism can be heard. One recent example is that of the occupied factory Ri-Maflow in Italy, a former producer of auto components, which went bankrupt and laid off 320 workers in 2009. After the new owners had dismantled and taken away all machinery, a group of former workers organized a coop and occupied the space, with the idea of reappropriating it as a starting point for building new forms of production, consumption and waste disposal. Adopting the slogan “Re-use, re-cycle, reappropriate,” these workers have initiated a workshop of computer and appliance repair, a flea market, and the processing and distribution of local produce.2 They also run the place as a space for community music and arts activities and social events, and for hospitality to refugees. Their plan is to collect enough resources to be able to turn these and other activities into a stable form of income, that is, to develop dealienated forms of work and production. The matter is complicated by the fact that, even when they claim to be sensitive to climate and environmental issues, trade unions and labor parties in the capitalist world are mostly locked in the growth paradigm, rather than in an anti-capitalist perspective of dealienation. Their proposals for Green New Deal or Just Transition get trapped into the idea that a green capitalism is possible, by which they mean a set of public policies can be implemented that would reduce carbon emissions while stimulating the green economy and creating “decent” jobs. In other words, the majority of trade unions now aim for positive changes that would address the multiple current crises of ecology, economy and social inequalities without waiting for some systemic change that is difficult to envision and agree upon. I believe this perspective is not to be dismissed too easily, as it does represent the official position of large labor confederations and so-called blue–green alliances, which have the possibility to orient union policies at the national and local level, and might influence public investment choices among alternative options, e.g. between coal and solar power. The Just Transition proposal, for example, is premised upon the notion that the shift to a post-carbon economy will inevitably imply massive layoffs of workers who are dependent on the fossil economy, and thus consequent suffering in their communities. Degrowth cannot avoid considering this aspect of the transition to a non-fossil based and substantially different production system. Therefore, degrowth policy proposals must include concrete recommendations for dealing with those foreseen layoffs, sustaining the livelihoods of working-class communities in the transition process, and replacing fossil-generated wealth with different forms of income and welfare. All this compels us to engage with the discussions and positioning that are expressed by organized labor at different levels. Simply dismissing organized labor as a non-relevant actor in the transition to a post-carbon, post-capitalist or degrowth society will not do. When taking into consideration the workers’ perspective, we also need to be aware of the limited extent to which labor organizations represent the global working class, and of the differentiations and fractures that cross the non-homogeneous world of both organized and non-organized labor. One clear example is the Keystone XL pipeline controversy in the US, where five national trade unions have expressed vocal support, two have openly declared their opposition to it (both representing domestic workers, mostly women with an immigrant status), while the remaining unions have adopted a “none-of-our-business” attitude. This has caused extreme uneasiness and contrasting attitudes among the base (union locals and individual workers), for it has often posed them on the opposite side of the struggles conducted by their communities against the pipeline (Sweeney 2013). Similar examples of other configurations of positions assumed by organized labor in face of climate politics could be drawn, e.g. the One Million Climate Jobs campaign in South Africa. Here, the exacerbation of both economic and climate inequalities has led to an alliance between parts of the labor movement with environmental justice and green movements. This alliance has been able to reclaim the Just Transition strategy, filling it with radical anti-capitalist and anti-neoliberal content. From a simple claim for jobs in a green growth agenda, the campaign has moved to advocate for public disinvestment from the fossil and nuclear sectors, coupled with energy democracy and food sovereignty at the community level (Cock 2014). What these cases exemplify is the fact that there exist, at this historical conjuncture, concrete possibilities for articulating degrowth and labor politics in new ways, via grassroots mobilizations in community unionism and social movement unionism, pushing labor organizations toward a radical critique of the growth paradigm (Bayon 2014). This articulation is a crucial starting point for developing new forms of political-ecological consciousness that go beyond the current divisions between organized labor and degrowth and environmental justice movements. In fact, they would allow for the development of an emancipatory ecological class consciousness, premised upon a reconceptualization of work in the sense of dealienation and commoning, which is a necessary prerequisite for a socially just degrowth strategy. The 212 S. BARCA articulation of degrowth and labor politics toward an ecological class consciousness implies the important task of reconsidering ideas of class in general, and of working class in particular. Class is still an important reality for most of the world population, even as it intersects with multiple other social differentiations. Simply ignoring class politics will do a disservice to degrowth, e.g. it will obscure the (largely) white middle-class nature of the movement and thus its possibilities for political action. In order to reconsider class and its intersection with degrowth, a good starting point is enlarging the concept of class relations beyond the wage labor relation and toward a broader conception of work as a mediator of social metabolism. Biophysical throughput is largely the result of work done in the factory, the field, the office, the retail center and the household, but workers have very limited control over the process. In capitalist societies, wage relations and growth-oriented state politics alienate workers from both the labor process and product. As ecofeminist political economy has abundantly shown, production takes over and dominates reproduction, the surplus is accumulated or reinvested in the infinite expansion of the system. This has negative consequences for the quality and quantity of resources available for the reproduction of life and for the entire biosphere. Logically speaking, working-class people – those who are located at the bottom of the global labor hierarchy and who pay the higher price to its social costs – have a vested interest in the subversion of this system. This is what I call an emancipatory ecological class consciousness: the awareness that climate change (and environmental violence in general) is the newest form of class war – as always, articulated with gender and racial domination – and that it needs to be combated via struggles for dealienation and communing (Barca 2015). Being locked in the growth society, however, working-class people have a limited ability to make sense of and struggle against the current organization of social metabolism, as the Mapuche oil worker’s testimony makes clear. That is why contributing to the emergence of ecological class consciousness is, I argue, a crucial task for a degrowth movement that rejects authoritarian solutions to the ecological crisis and aims at building large social alliances around a truly emancipatory transition to a post-carbon economy. In embracing the challenge of raising ecological class consciousness, degrowthers can count on the fundamental support of feminist praxis. Feminist political economy, especially in its articulations with ecofeminism and feminist political ecology, has offered invaluable contributions for a rethinking of work, and intersects in new ways with the degrowth debate (D’Alisa, Demaria, and Deriu 2014). Through dialogue with postcolonial studies, this literature has produced a thorough critique of GDP and development politics as inextricably linked to undervaluation of subsistence economies and reproductive (mostly women’s) work, what Salleh (2010) has named “metaCAPITALISM NATURE SOCIALISM 213 industrial labor.” From a Marxist perspective, the work of reproduction is mostly (even if not entirely) carried out outside of wage relations, but is inextricably linked to them via the constant need for capital to appropriate this work in order to sustain production and accumulation (Fraser 2014; see also Moore 2015). Ecofeminist scholars see the ecological crisis as a global manifestation of the gendered division of labor, and thus a major cause of the crisis of social reproduction (Bauhardt 2014). What ecofeminist and feminist political economists have in common is the identification of reproduction as a crucial terrain for anti-capitalist struggle and ecological revolution (Merchant 2010; Federici 2012; Withcherich 2015). Overall, what ecofeminist political economy tells us is that combating the capital/state appropriation of the reproductive and care labor carried out by the global meta-industrial working class is a crucial step toward the dealienation of the labor process and toward taking control over the surplus in a global commoning perspective. In this sense, degrowth should listen to the voices coming from the emancipatory ecological class consciousness that is already guiding the struggles of many women-led movements on the margins of the global political economy (Harcourt and Nelson 2014). Ultimately, my argument here boils down to a single overarching question: “What is the political subject of a degrowth revolution?” I think this subject should not be confined to an ecologically minded global middle class willing to reduce consumerism and work-addiction, and/or to engage in direct action to express its disappointment with economic/environmental policies. This has historically played an important avant-garde role in raising consciousness of the degrowth perspective and in allying with a variety of other movements and ideas. But, this approach will remain politically weak unless it manages to enter into dialogue with a broadly defined global working class – including both wage labor and the myriad forms of work that support it – and its organizations. This is a very difficult endeavor in the present conditions, but it might become a concrete possibility if we accept the implications of degrowth for the meta-industrial workers of the world and if the degrowth debate takes on a clearer direction toward emancipation from both the alienation of wage labor and the capitalist (or state) appropriation of reproductive labor. This is what is needed in order to decrease social metabolism while increasing social well-being and equality.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
1NCs › 1NC -- Reverse Econ PIC

The FJG would increase economic growth by wage increases, productivity imperatives, and competition with the private market.

Paul et al 17, Mark Paul is an assistant professor of economics at New College of Florida and a fellow at the Roosevelt Institute, William Darity Jr is the Samuel DuBois Cook professor of public policy, African and African-American Studies, and economics; and the director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University, Darrick Hamilton is associate professor of economics and urban policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and the Department of Economics, New School for Social Research., 2-4-2017, "Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee," Jacobin, https://jacobin.com/2017/02/federal-job-guarantee-universal-basic-income-investment-jobs-unemployment/ (AG)

Conventional wisdom holds that people dislike work. Introductory economics classes will explain the disutility of labor, which is a direct trade-off with leisure. Granted, employment isn’t always fun, and many forms of employment are dangerous and exploitative. But the UBI misses the way in which employment structurally empowers workers at the point of production and has by its own merits positive dimensions.

This touches on a heated debate on the Left. But for now, there is no doubt that people want jobs, but they want good jobs that provide flexibility and opportunity. They want to contribute, to have a purpose, to participate in the economy and, most importantly, in society. Nevertheless, the private sector continues to leave millions without work, even during supposed “strong” economic times.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
1NCs › 1NC -- Reverse Econ PIC

A UBI maintains social health despite the negative externalities of degrowth policies.

Alisa, Giacomo D’, et al 2014. Alisa is a ecological economist and political ecologist, Kallis is a professor of ecological economics and political ecology at the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology, Autonomous University of Barcelona, and Demaria is an Associate Professor in Ecological Economics and Political Ecology at the University of Barcelona, and a senior researcher at the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology (ICTA), Autonomous University of Barcelona Degrowth a Vocabulary for a New Era. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2014. (AG)

To eliminate poverty, capitalist societies generally rely on growing the economic pie, not slicing it differently. If the pursuit of growth were given up, however, and a degrowth process of planned economic contraction were embraced, pov-erty would have to be confronted more directly. Among other things, this would require a restructuring of the property and tax systems for the purpose of redis-tributing wealth and ensuring everyone had ‘enough’ (Alexander 2011). The Basic Income and the Maximum Income are two policies that could help achieve these important egalitarian goals, without relying on growth.

Although there is considerable variety in forms of Basic Income, the core idea is relatively straightforward. In its idealised and most radical form, every person living permanently in a nation would receive from the state a periodic (e.g. fort-nightly) payment, and this payment would be sufficient for an individual to live at a minimal though dignified standard of economic security. Advocates typically argue that a Basic Income payment should be guaranteed by the state, unconditional on the performance of any labour, and universal.

2023 Michigan Kritik
AFF › 1AR Extensions › 1AR --- Semiocap Thesis/Bifo Wrong

The alt doesn’t solve + Bifo is not qualified – turns K solvency

White 22, (Will White 2022), bachelor of arts in history – UCLA, freelance writer, syndicated columnist, political theorist, (; “,” 

Bifo’s prescription to semiotic capitalism is to isolate an act of language to escape the technical automation of capitalism and produce a new form of life.[4] He suggests that poetry exceeds the established meaning of words in communicative spaces and thus expand the imaginary beyond the captures of semiotic capitalism.[5] However, this prescription saps revolutionary potential in resisting capitalism. There is a significant issue with the way Bifo perceives semiotic capitalism and its remedy. Bifo’s conception of capital negates the fundamental premise of dialectical materialism. Forwarding the theory that capital has transcended from the material to semiotics indicates that capital functions outside the superstructure of capitalist modes of production. I.e., class antagonisms are being framed as a question of symbolic exchange instead of material repression of the working class. This saps revolutionary potential among the people because it miseducates them and thus splits any focus on a single material capitalist structure in favor of pursuing abstract academic Marxism. The impact of such revisionism upholds the ideological hegemony of the imperial “left,” whose focus is not invested in the direct liberation of the people. In other words, these forms of theorizing capital do not work as revolutionary strategies and abandon the immediate material struggles of black, brown, and indigenous proletarians. After all, theory without practice that is not axiomatically rooted in material and militant resistance of the U.S. empire and vice versa are all gateways to new forms of liberalism.

2023 Michigan Kritik
AFF › 2AC Semiocapitalism Core

[15] The neg doesn’t escape hyper reality since they still operate with second order simulacra – this means simulacrums will continue to appear, gutting any chance of alt solvency – the alt gets coopted by the never-ending signs and signifiers

Baudrillard 93 [Jean Baudrillard, (like Goodin but better) "Symbolic Exchange and Death" Sage Publications Ltd, 1993, https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/symbolic-exchange-and-death/book203211, DOA:4-1-2018]

The current revolutions index themselves on the immediately prior phase of the system. They arm themselves with a nostalgic resurrection of the real in all its forms; in other words, with simulacra of the second order: dialectics, use value, the transparency and finality of production, the "liberation" of the unconscious, or of repressed meaning (of the signifier, or of the signified called desire), and so on. All of these liberations offer, as ideal content, the phantoms which the system has devoured in successive revolutions and which it subtly resuscitates as revolutionary fantasies. All these liberations are just transitions toward a generalized manipulation. The revolution itself is meaningless at the present level of random processes of control. To the industrial machine corresponds the rational, referential, functional, historical consciousness. But it is the unconscious — nonreferential, transferential, indeterminate, floating - that corresponds to the aleatory machin(ations) of the code. Yet even the unconscious has been reinserted into the game: it long ago relinqu- 122 Symbolic Exchange and Death ished its own reality principle in order to become an operational simulacrum. At the exact point where its psychic principle of reality is confused with its psychoanalytic reality principle, the unconscious becomes, like political economy, another simulation model. The entire strategy of the system lies in this hyperreality of floating values. It is the same for money and theory as for the unconscious. Value rules according to an ungraspable order: the generation of models, the indefinite chaining of simulation. Cybernetic operationality, the genetic code, the random order of mutations, the principle of uncertainty, and so on: all of these replace a determinist and objectivist science, a dialectical vision of history and consciousness. Even critical theory and the revolution belong to the second-order simulations, as do all determinate processes. The installation of third-order simulacra upsets all of this, and it is useless to resurrect the dialectic, "objective" contradictions and the like, against them; that is a hopeless political regression. You cannot beat randomness with finality; you cannot beat programmed dispersion with prises de conscience or dialectical transcendence; you cannot defend against the code with political economy or "revolution." All these old weapons (including those of the first order, the ethics and metaphysics of man and nature, use value, and other liberatory referentials) have been progressively neutralized by the general system, which is of a higher order. Everything that gets inserted into the definalized space-time of the code, or tries to interfere with it, is disconnected from its own finalities, disintegrated and absorbed — this is the well-known effect of recuperation, or manipulation: cycling and recycling at each level. "All dissent must be of a higher logical type than that to which it is opposed."1

2023 Michigan Kritik
AFF › 2AC Semiocapitalism Core

[14] No Impact. Capitalism is sustainable and self-correcting. Profits, income, savings, and productivity are all trending upwards, and public investment ensures adaptability.

O’Rourke, 21—Professor of Economics at NYU Abu Dhabi (Kevin Hjortshøj, “Capitalism: worries of the 1930s for the 2020s,” Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Volume 37, Issue 4, Winter 2021, Pages 650–663, dml) [figures omitted; TFP=total factor productivity]

The first question which the authors have been asked to address is: what has gone wrong? But that presupposes that something has gone wrong, which is far from evident. On the contrary, according to many traditional metrics capitalism is behaving exactly the way it is supposed to.

The classical economists, from Smith to Marx, as well as later theorists such as Weber, believed that what defined capitalism above all else was its ceaseless pursuit of accumulation for its own sake. High savings rates were the engine propelling capitalism forward. Readers from Britain (where the gross adjusted savings rate in 2018 was just 13.5 per cent) or the United States (where it was 18.3 per cent) will be well aware that their countries are not saving as much as they once did, but the Anglosphere is not the world, and the global savings rate has been trending upwards since the 1990s (Figure 1): there is no sign of any crisis on this score.