Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Disease defense

200,000 years of existence disproves the impact

Halstead 20 – John, a Research Fellow at the Global Priorities Project, a collaboration between the Centre for Effective Altruism and the Future of Humanity Institute, where he specialised in global catastrophic risk. Before that, he was an academic philosopher, obtaining his D.Phil in Political Philosophy from the University of Oxford and working at Oxford's Blavatnik School of Government. “Safeguarding the Future Cause Area Report”, Founders Pledge, , 12-xx-2020

However, there are some reasons to think that naturally occurring pathogens are unlikely to cause human extinction. Firstly, Homo sapiens have been around for 200,000 years and the Homo genus for around six million years without being exterminated by an infectious disease, which is evidence that the base rate of extinction-risk natural pathogens is low.82 Indeed, past disease outbreaks have not come close to rendering humans extinct. Although bodies were piled high in the streets across Europe during the Black Death,83 human extinction was never a serious possibility, and some economists even argue that it was a boon for the European economy.84 Secondly, infectious disease has only contributed to the extinction of a small minority of animal species.85 The only confirmed case of a mammalian species extinction being caused by an infectious disease is a type of rat native only to Christmas Island. Having said that, the context may be importantly different for modern day humans, so it is unclear whether the risk is increasing or decreasing. On the one hand, due to globalisation, the world is more interconnected making it easier for pathogens to spread. On the other hand, interconnectedness could also increase immunity by increasing exposure to lower virulence strains between subpopulations.87 Moreover, advancements in medicine and sanitation limit the potential damage an outbreak might do.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Disease defense

Disease can’t cause extinction

Ord 20 – Dr. Toby, Senior Research Fellow in Philosophy at Oxford University, DPhil in Philosophy from the University of Oxford. “The Precipice: Existential Risk and the Future of Humanity,”, Hachette Books, pg. 124-126, 03-03-2020

Are we safe now from events like this? Or are we more vulnerable? Could a pandemic threaten humanity’s future?10

The Black Death was not the only biological disaster to scar human history. It was not even the only great bubonic plague. In 541 CE the Plague of Justinian struck the Byzantine Empire. Over three years it took the lives of roughly 3 percent of the world’s people.11

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Plan hurts doctors

The hassles involved in Medicare for All will exacerbate the doctor shortage and reduce care access.

MARC SIEGEL July 24, 2019 6:30 AM Why Your Doctor Doesn’t Like Medicare for All https://www.nationalreview.com/2019/07/why-your-doctor-doesnt-like-medicare-for-all/

There is already a growing doctor shortage in the U.S., and it is only going to get worse. The Association of American Medical Colleges predicts that under the current system we may be . And this shortage is especially a problem when it comes to public health insurance, so imagine what it would mean if we expanded Medicare to cover all. In the U.S. currently, with less than 40 percent of the health-care system in public hands, nearly , and Medicare patients frequently have . Public health insurance is more cumbersome and difficult for both doctors and hospitals, and it pays us much less. Most of us try to limit how many Medicare and Medicaid patients we see.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Plan hurts doctors

Medicare for All will drive thousands of doctors and hospitals out of business

Justin Haskins March 23, 2019 8:00am 2020 Democrats' 'Medicare-for-all' plan would cause a massive doctor shortage https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/democrats-medicare-for-all-plan-would-cause-a-massive-doctor-shortage

The Mercatus Center study, like Sen. Sanders and House Democrats, assumes that under a Medicare-for-all scheme, doctors and hospitals will accept Medicare reimbursement rates for all of their patients, even though those rates are significantly lower than the reimbursements provided by private health insurers. Data from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (CMS) Medicare actuary shows the rate paid to hospitals for Medicare patients in 2022 will be about than what hospitals will receive from a private health insurance provider. Payments to physicians will be about 30 percent lower. Over time, the gap is expected to grow. Under the House Democrats’ bill, hospitals and doctors would effectively be forced to accept these much lower rates – or something close to them – and there would be no way for hospitals or physicians to make up the difference elsewhere. The House bill would ban all doctors who agree to receive payment for services from the government from accepting private payment for services covered under the "Medicare-for-all" scheme. This doesn’t simply mean that providers would have to accept less money for their services; it would likely drive thousands of doctors and hospitals out of business.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Plan hurts doctors

Plan will exacerbate a doctor shortage, reducing salaries and collapsing quality of care.

MARC SIEGEL July 24, 2019 6:30 AM Why Your Doctor Doesn’t Like Medicare for All https://www.nationalreview.com/2019/07/why-your-doctor-doesnt-like-medicare-for-all/

In the meantime, we lack the primary-care doctors to administer the current government-run health-coverage programs, without asking us to take less money for dealing with the delays and care rationing under a system of Medicare for All. An average primary-care doctor in the U.S. in 2018 made $223,000, which isn’t a lot when you consider the many years of training and the growing time demands of an electronic record-keeping system. In Canada, which has a single-payer system, the average primary-care doctor makes $200,000. Consider how much more difficult it is for a primary-care doctor like me to practice medicine when there are long waits, and specialists aren’t readily available. for everything from MRIs to CT scans to dermatology appointments to hip replacements to cardiac stents. Imagine how much pressure that puts on the referring general doctor as well as the patient, who struggles to receive care and often risks adverse outcomes and suffers discomfort while waiting. General practitioners end up being forced to diagnose and treat conditions they would prefer to leave to specialists. A Medicare for All system here in the U.S. would place the same kind of burden on doctors and hospitals. The shortage of doctors and nurses would grow, especially without an associated plan to greatly expand medical education and make it easier to obtain. Even former vice president Biden, who doesn’t support Medicare for All, instead proposes expanding Obamacare subsidies, creating a large public option, and putting a cap on premiums — all of which would create an additional burden on the health-care system without considering the essential shortage of care available. No matter what your plan, you simply can’t pay doctors and hospitals less to do more while rationing essential services. That would be a poison pill for the health-care crisis, not a solution.

Medicare for All will cause a massive health care provider shortage and collapse access to care

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Plan causes rationing

Results in serious shortages of quality doctors and delays in medical care/supplies

Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy Care Program Is Cratering. That Should Be Wake-Up Call for U.S. Liberals. Jan 25, 2023 6 min read https://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/commentary/british-single-payer-health-care-program-cratering-should-be-wake

Big in the pay of medical professionals, as authorized in the congressional single-payer legislation, can indeed reduce health care spending. But there is a big price: You pay less, and you get less. Britain has the of doctors per 1,000 patients in all of Western Europe, while British nurses rank (ahead of only Italy and Spain) in their availability to patients. Compared to their American counterparts, British doctors and nurses have relatively low pay. There’s nothing shocking about Britain’s single-payer system being periodically hit by labor strikes, as well as serious shortages of vital supplies and equipment. As in the United States and among countries with advanced economies, Britain’s COVID-19 lockdowns have imposed a heavy price on personal health in delays and denials of medical care, particularly from pauses in medical treatment, including chemotherapy, as well as in preventive care, such as mammograms.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Plan causes rationing

Medicare for All will lead to longer wait times, decreased quality care, and higher costs.

Sally C. Pipes I cover health policy as President of the Pacific Research Institute Opinion: Single-Payer ‘Medicare for All’ Would Inflate Americans’ Healthcare Bills June 7, 2022 https://timesofsandiego.com/opinion/2022/06/07/single-payer-medicare-for-all-would-inflate-americans-healthcare-bills/

Our higher spending levels correlate with better health outcomes. Cancer prevalence has been rising globally, but survival rates in the United States have been increasing. Meanwhile, Americans typically do not have to endure the long waits common in the United Kingdom and Canada. In April, more than 24,000 people in England waited more than 12 hours in emergency departments before a decision was made about whether to admit them. In a newly released book, former UK Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt said that he was “shocked to his core” by failures in care, including hundreds of avoidable deaths. In Canada in 2019, 4.6 million people over the age of 12 lacked a family doctor, according to the country’s national statistics agency. Last year, the median wait to receive treatment from a specialist in Canada following referral by a general practitioner was 25.6 weeks — roughly six months. Patients pay dearly for their low-quality government-sponsored health care. There are the high taxes, of course. A typical family of four in Canada pays more than $15,000 in taxes just for health care. In the United Kingdom, the National Health Service costs each English household around 5,785 pounds — a little over $7,100 — each year. That per-household cost has increased more than 75% since 2000. Increasingly, people abroad are paying for a lot of their own care out of pocket — despite having government-sponsored health insurance. In the United Kingdom, out-of-pocket healthcare expenses rose about 5.3% between 2020 and 2021. By 2019, 17% of the costs of medical care in the United Kingdom were coming directly out of people’s wallets.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Plan causes rationing

Plan would increase wait times – especially for emergency care – hundreds die each week in countries with single payer systems now.

Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy Care Program Is Cratering. That Should Be Wake-Up Call for U.S. Liberals. Jan 25, 2023 6 min read https://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/commentary/british-single-payer-health-care-program-cratering-should-be-wake

According to the BBC, there are British citizens awaiting medical care, or almost 11% of the entire British population. And Sky News reports that more than in England have been awaiting hospital treatment for more than a year. Right now, the most salient problem is emergency care. According to The Telegraph, December data show that people suffering a heart attack face an average wait of for an ambulance, with some waiting up to two and a half hours. For emergency care, The Telegraph further reports, were forced to wait on hospital gurneys for “at least” 12 hours following emergency department decisions to admit them. Of course, patients suffering from a stroke or a heart attack are always in a race against time, as medical delays can result in permanent disability or death. Surveying the carnage, Dr. Adrian Boyle, president of the Royal College of Emergency Medicine, that between 300 and 500 people are dying each week because of delays and related problems in the delivery of emergency medical care.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › Plan causes rationing

Medicare for All would drastically increase health care demand and utilization

Charles Blahous J. Fish and Lillian F. Smith 2018 The Costs of a National Single-Payer Healthcare System MERCATUS WORKING PAPER George Mason University. https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/costs-national-single-payer-healthcare-system

M4A would increase healthcare demand and utilization in at least three important ways. First, the plan would provide health insurance coverage to all Americans who are currently uninsured, greatly increasing their utilization of healthcare services.11 Coverage of the currently uninsured is estimated to increase their health service costs by roughly 89 percent. 12 Second, the plan would expand the range of services covered by existing insurance, explicitly covering dental, vision, and hearing care for all participants.13 This, too, would increase utilization of such services in addition to shifting their financing from private to public spending, especially for those now reliant on traditional Medicare. Currently, only 12 percent of all personal healthcare expenses in the United States are paid out of pocket, while 22 percent are paid by Medicare. By contrast, 40 percent of national dental care expenses are paid out of pocket, while the national share financed by traditional Medicare rounds to 0 percent. 14 This indicates that the addition of dental, vision, and hearing benefits will substantially increase total projected health service utilization and costs.15 Finally, the plan’s requirement that “no cost-sharing, including deductibles, coinsurance, copayments, or similar charges, be imposed on an individual” would also significantly increase healthcare utilization. 16 As a general rule, the greater the percentage of an individual’s healthcare that is paid by insurance (i.e., the insurance’s actuarial value, or AV), the more healthcare services an individual tends to buy. There is an extensive literature devoted to estimating how much individuals increase their use of healthcare as the AV of their insurance increases—which, in the case of M4A, would be to an AV of essentially 100 percent. 17 Providing this first-dollar coverage is estimated to induce 11 percent additional demand for those currently covered by private insurance and 16 percent for those now in traditional Medicare without supplemental coverage.1

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › A2 Access to Care

Decreases quality of care and increases wait times – Canada and Great Britain prove

Sally Pipes Jan 30 2023 I cover health policy as President of the Pacific Research Institute Canadian Leaders Finally Waking Up To The Horrors Of Single-Payer Health Care https://www.forbes.com/sites/sallypipes/2023/01/30/canadian-leaders-finally-waking-up-to-the-horrors-of-single-payer-health-care/?sh=4b69e6be5d1a

But that system already exists in Canada. Canadians routinely leave the country to seek medical care that their public system can't or won't provide in a timely fashion. Canadians spent on health care in other countries in 2017 alone, a recent study found. Many of those people are rich, famous, and powerful people who have the means to escape. In 2010, former Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams to the United States for heart surgery. "This was my heart, my choice and my health," Williams said. "I did not sign away my right to get the best possible health care for myself when I entered politics." Canadian singer Michael Bublé decamped from Vancouver to Los Angeles in 2016 when his young son was diagnosed with liver cancer. His son , including chemotherapy, at the Children's Hospital of Los Angeles. Bublé credits doctors at the hospital with saving his son's life. Thankfully, his son's cancer remains in remission today. Millions of Canadians don't have the resources to flee to the United States for top-notch care. The story is similar in Great Britain's government-dominated system. Just this year, British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak after revealing that he had received private care while publicly singing the praises of the United Kingdom's socialized National Health Service. Fortunately, to , it seems that all eyes are opened, or opening, to the false promise of single-payer health care. Hopefully Americans will look at the human tragedies unfolding in Canada and Great Britain—and make clear to progressive lawmakers that they have no interest in Medicare for All here.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › A2 Access to Care

Difference between coverage and access

Michael D. Tanner April 5, 2017. Cato Institute senior fellow, Michael Tanner heads research into a variety of domestic policies with a particular emphasis on poverty and social welfare policy, health care reform, and Social Security. “Hard Truths about Health Care”

Republicans have vowed to go back to the drawing board to draft a new Obamacare repeal-and-replacement bill. Meanwhile President Trump is threatening to work with Democrats to come up with a health-care plan — or maybe to simply let Obamacare crash and burn. But whoever eventually comes up with a replacement for the Affordable Care Act should keep a few hard truths in mind. 1. Health care is neither a right nor a privilege; it’s a commodity. Worse, it’s a finite commodity. There are only so many doctors, so many hospitals, and so much money, and there are limits to how much these things can be expanded. That’s why no health-care system, outside Bernie Sanders’s fantasies, provides unlimited care to everyone. Every health-care system in the world rations care in some way, either through bureaucratic fiat (Scandinavia, the U.K.), waiting lists (Canada), or price (that’s us). One can argue about which of these rationing mechanisms is fairest or most efficient, but let’s not pretend that it won’t occur. Republicans would be well advised to stop trying to win a popularity contest and simply do what’s right. 2. Coverage is not access. Democrats like to pretend that giving everyone a piece of paper called insurance guarantees them access to the care they need. It’s sort of like magic. Say the right words, and poof, medical care appears. But in the real world it doesn’t work that way. For example, take Medicaid, which is responsible for more than half the increase in coverage under Obamacare. Nearly a third of primary-care physicians won’t accept Medicaid patients. And when doctors do see Medicaid patients, they tend to be slower in granting appointments. Moreover, for the working poor, seeing doctors during normal office hours can be problematic. Perhaps that’s why Medicaid patients continue to use emergency rooms for routine care at a disproportionate rate. Numerous studies show that health outcomes for Medicaid patients are little better than those for the uninsured. In fact, some studies show patients faring worse under Medicaid than if they had no insurance at all. Similarly, if Obamacare forced your insurance carrier to cut back its provider network, your shiny new coverage may no longer include the physician of your choice. And the incentive structure of Obamacare, notably its pre-existing-condition rules, encourage insurers to drop coverage for top doctors and hospital centers of excellence.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › A2 Access to Care

Medicare for all disrupts the entire health care sector on a domestic and international level – crushing quality of care

Jonathan Yates, 7-28-2018, Jonathan Yates, a former University of Iowa adjunct professor, was general counsel for a publicly traded health care firm, and Assistant Washington Counsel for the Health Insurance Association (HIAA). "A single-payer system will cause the health care sector to implode", Des Moines Register, https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/opinion/columnists/iowa-view/2018/07/27/single-payer-system-cause-health-care-sector-implode/849329002/, 6-26-2023, //ms

In the early days of the American automobile industry, consumers could buy a Model T in any color they wanted, so long as it was black. Such will be the "service and selection" to be expected in the United States if a single-payer system, where the government pays for all medical treatment, is implemented for health care. A single-payer system will cause the health care sector to implode, with profound implications for Iowa, the United States and the world's economy. Health care is the largest component of the American economy, about one-sixth of gross domestic product. Forcing the health care system in the United States, the best in the history of the world, to be socialized will have profound implications. The government will immediately be put in a position of having higher expenses and less revenues. With health insurance companies gone, so will the tens of billions in tax dollars paid to local, state, and federal government from these entities. This will most certainly not be compensated for by reduced government spending. Rarely in history has a government program reduced spending, especially in health care. In addition to wrecking the government budget, a single-payer system would destroy the stock, bond and commercial real estate markets. Insurance firms are major investors in the financial markets. Taking away the insurance companies would eviscerate the financial markets. The same would happen with salaries for health care professionals such as doctors and nurses. Doctors in Canada, England and France make a fraction of those in America.. Opportunities in health care would be reduced, starting with the educational system. The United States has the finest system of higher education in the world. More than half of the top 100 universities in the world are in the United States. It is the same American dominance for medical device and other health care patents. International universities can't even begin to compete with the best in the United States in a holistic approach that encompasses undergraduate education, graduate schools, research facilities and athletics.. Foreign and business leaders from abroad come to the United States for medical care. Americans go overseas for cheap health care. Those who can afford it come to the USA for the best health care treatment. Which is preferable in medical services: the cheapest or the best? A lesson learned very quickly in life is that generally the best works out to be the least expensive, over the long term. It is because of the superiority of the American health care system that single-payer systems still exist around the world. Without the United States outperforming the rest of the world in research and development, their medical systems would collapse. Single-payer systems around the world can survive only because they benefit from what the health care industry in the USA produces. There is also no need for a single-payer system as the purported 40 million uninsured in the USA has never held up to research. About 11 million of those are illegal immigrants. Another quarter qualify but can't be bothered to fill out the paperwork. Then there are those who make easily enough to buy health insurance, but prefer to go without it and pay for their medical costs as they arise. Survey after survey reports that at any one time about 80-90% of Americans are insured, with the same amount being satisfied with their health care. Over the last decade, health care and social assistance employment in Iowa has soared from around 145,000 to about 185,000, according to the 11th edition of Iowa's Workforce and the Economy. Insurance and health care are also growing segments of the state's economy. This will be truncated with a single-payer system. A single-payer system in the United States will reduce the quality of health care for Americans and the quantity of opportunities available for all around the world.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › A2 Access to Care

The plan causes immediate panic regardless of implementation details—health providers would panic and close

Daniel Summers 16, pediatrician in the greater Boston area., 2-19-2016, "I’m a Doctor. Here’s Why I Oppose the Single-Payer Revolution.," New Republic, https://newrepublic.com/article/130145/im-doctor-heres-oppose-single-payer-revolution

Compared to the lustrous ideals that inform the pursuit of a single-payer system, talking about profitability seems downright grungy. But businesses need to stay profitable in order to stay afloat, and medical practices are no different. Even not-for-profits need sufficient revenue to keep the doors open. Talking about substantially reducing payment to medical providers in one fell swoop, as though doctors and hospitals will say, “Alrighty then,” and carry on providing the exact same services without any appreciable change to patients strains credulity. For my practice, it would immediately put pressure on us to eliminate services we provide that do not generate any revenue. As it stands, every patient of ours who gets admitted to the hospital is seen by one of our providers, even if they’re not admitted to our service. We visit our patients in the hospital every day because we believe strongly that doing so keeps us informed about and involved in the management of our patients’ care, even if we’re not ultimately in charge of that care at any given time. It generates no income for the practice when we do this, and it’s hard to see how we could keep paying providers for this service when they could be in the office seeing patients instead. Further, every well-child exam at our practice is scheduled for a full 30 minutes, and for medically complex patients we dedicate an entire hour. Giving ample time to discuss each patient’s care thoroughly, answer all the parents’ questions, and offer guidance about important health and safety issues is a value we hold strongly. But the pressure to maximize patient volume could put that value in jeopardy. And despite pressure to see as many patients as possible, it’s still very likely that we would need to reduce payroll costs to stay in the black. Even if you factor in a reduction in our already-thin billing personnel (a prospect I don’t greet with any joy, as these are employees I care about), and even with the substantial haircut my partners and I would doubtless take to support our staff as much as possible, we’d have to pay our providers less. This may be a matter of blithe unconcern to advocates of Sanders’s plan, but it would almost certainly mean we’d have to make compromises in what we ask our providers to do. We’re currently open seven days a week. Even on major holidays, we make a provider available for urgent sick visits to the office. If you call our number outside regular office hours, at any time of the day, it’s one of our physicians or nurse practitioners who gets the page. It’s hard to see us maintaining that level of availability while simultaneously cutting the pay of people who show up on Sundays and take those two o’clock in the morning phone calls. Could we make all the changes necessary to make it worthwhile to stay in business? I hope so. It would be a grimmer place to work, to be sure, but we’d try to make it happen. However, I have no doubt many offices would see the writing on the wall. Some may try to sell to hospitals, which certainly won’t keep them open at a loss, and others will close outright. Who will assume care for the thousands of patients these closures would displace is not a question I see answered in Sanders’s plans. The government can provide insurance, but providing care directly is an even more ambitious change than Sanders is already proposing.

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › A2 Access to Care

Significant double bind – either reimbursement rates would have to go up – or access to care would plummet or maintaining reimbursement rates will massively increase the cost of the program.

Charles Blahous J. Fish and Lillian F. Smith 2018 The Costs of a National Single-Payer Healthcare System MERCATUS WORKING PAPER George Mason University. https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/costs-national-single-payer-healthcare-system

Furthermore, it is not precisely predictable how hospitals, physicians, and other healthcare providers would respond to a dramatic reduction in their reimbursements under M4A, well below their costs of care for all categories of patients combined. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) Office of the Actuary has projected that even upholding current-law reimbursement rates for treating Medicare beneficiaries alone would cause nearly half of all hospitals to have negative total facility margins by 2040.25 The same study found that by 2019, over 80 percent of hospitals will lose money treating Medicare patients—a situation M4A would extend, to a first approximation, to all US patients. Perhaps some facilities and physicians would be able to generate heretofore unachieved cost savings that would enable their continued functioning without significant disruptions. However, at least some undoubtedly would not, thereby reducing the supply of healthcare services at the same time M4A sharply increases healthcare demand. It is impossible to say precisely how much the confluence of these factors would reduce individuals’ timely access to healthcare services, but some such access problems almost certainly must arise. Anticipating these difficulties, some other studies have assumed that M4A payment rates must exceed current-law Medicare payment rates to avoid sending facilities into deficit on average or to avoid triggering unacceptable reductions in the provision and quality of healthcare services.26 These alternative payment rate assumptions substantially increase the total projected costs of M4A. Specifically, they would mean payment rates being set higher than they are under current Medicare law and lower than those now paid by private insurance. Even with a higher payment rate assumption, the UI team determined that “not all increased demand could be met because provider capacity would be insufficient.” This constraint is reflected in their final cost estimates.27

2023 SDI Negative
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All › A2 Health Advantage › A2 Access to Care

Medicare for All will reduce reimbursement rates for providers – calling into question the ability to continue to provide care.

Charles Blahous J. Fish and Lillian F. Smith 2018 The Costs of a National Single-Payer Healthcare System MERCATUS WORKING PAPER George Mason University. https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/costs-national-single-payer-healthcare-system

To offset the substantial cost increases created by stimulating additional consumer demand for and utilization of healthcare, the M4A bill would constrain expenditures by subjecting healthcare providers—including hospitals, physicians, and others—to Medicare payment rates.19 Under current law, Medicare reimburses healthcare providers at much lower rates than private health insurance does. In 2014, Medicare hospital payment rates were 62 percent of private insurance payment rates and are currently projected to decline to below 60 percent by the time M4A would be implemented, and to decline further afterward. Medicare physician payment rates were 75 percent of private insurance rates in 2016 and, per the terms of the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 (MACRA), are projected to decline sharply in relative terms in future years, also falling below 60 percent within the first full decade of M4A.20 The M4A Act as introduced specifies that provider payment amounts are to be consistent with those paid under current Medicare law.21 The adoption of Medicare payment rates would represent a substantial reduction in provider reimbursements for care provided to everyone now covered by private insurance (though it would also be a temporary increase in physician payments for those now covered by Medicaid, which currently pays physicians at lower rates than does Medicare).22 For example, in 2014, hospitals were reimbursed just 89 percent of their costs of treating Medicare patients and 90 percent of their costs of treating Medicaid patients— losses that were offset by hospitals collecting private insurance reimbursement rates equaling 144 percent of their costs.

2023 SDI Negative
2NC --- Case Neg vs. UBI Aff › 2NC --- Economy Advantage › 2NC --- Econ Defense

--They’re exogenous

Caldara and Lacoviello 18 – Dario, Federal Reserve Board of Governors. Matteo, Federal Reserve Board of Governors. “Measuring Geopolitical Risk”, International Finance Discussions Papers, , 02-xx-2018

We identify the structural shocks by using a Cholesky decomposition of the covariance matrix of the VAR reduced-form residuals, ordering the GPR index first. The ordering implies that the GPR index reacts contemporaneously only to its own shock. Hence, any contemporaneous correlation between the macro variables and the GPR index reflects the effect of the GPR index on the macro variables. The characteristics of the GPR index discussed in Section 2—as well as the comparison to the EPU index in Section 3—lend support to this assumption. For instance, Jackson and Morelli (2011) list religion, revenge, ethnic cleansing, and bargaining failure over resources as the main reasons for armed conflicts. Although recessions, lower commodity prices, or dismal economic performance might in some cases have exacerbated existing geopolitical tensions, it seems reasonable to assume that movements in economic variables within a month have little bearing on geopolitical risks. Nonetheless, in Section A.4 in the Appendix we explore robustness to an alternative Cholesky ordering, as well as to alternative specifications of the baseline VAR model.

The solid lines in Figure 9 show the median impulse responses to an exogenous increase in the GPR index of 167 points, while the light- and dark-shaded areas represent the corresponding 68 percent and 90 percent pointwise credible bands, respectively. The size of the shock equals the average change in the index following the nine episodes of largest increases in the GPR index.29 The rise in the GPR index induces a small and short-lived increase in the EPU index and a decline in consumer sentiment. Intuitively, geopolitical risk can induce some economic policy uncertainty on items such as national security and the fiscal budget and negatively weigh on consumer sentiment. On the real side, IP declines quickly, bottoming out at negative 0.9 percent after about 6 months, before reverting back to trend. The deterioration in labor market conditions is substantial but more gradual, with payroll employment reaching a trough of negative 0.4 percent a year after the shock. Gross trade also drops, with U.S. imports and exports falling nearly 2 percent relative to the baseline. Figure A.7 in the Appendix plots the response of private investment to a GPR shock, based on an extension of the baseline model estimated on quarterly data. The economically significant decline in investment following a GPR shock, together with the decline in employment, is consistent with models of investment under uncertainty a la Dixit and Pindyck (1994).30

2023 SDI Negative
2NC --- Case Neg vs. UBI Aff › 2NC --- Economy Advantage › 2NC --- Econ Defense

--Downturns don’t cause wars

Liao 19’ – Jianan, Shenzhen Nanshan Foreign Language School, China. “Business Cycle and War: A Literature Review and Evaluation”, Advances in Economics, Business and Management Research, Vol. 68, , 02-xx-2019

First, war can occur at any stage of expansion, crisis, recession, recovery, so it is unrealistic to assume that wars occur at any particular stage of the business cycle. On the one hand, although the domestic economic problems in the crisis/recession/depression period break out and become prominent in a short time, in fact, such challenge exists at all stages of the business cycle. When countries cannot manage to solve these problems through conventional approaches, including fiscal and monetary policies, they may resort to military expansion to achieve their goals, a theory known as Lateral Pressure. [13] Under such circumstances, even countries in the period of economic expansion are facing downward pressure on the economy and may try to solve the problem through expansion. On the other hand, although the resources required for foreign wars are huge for countries in economic depression, the decision to wage wars depends largely on the consideration of the gain and loss of wars. Even during depression, governments can raise funding for war by issuing bonds. Argentina, for example, was mired in economic stagflation before the war on the Malvinas islands (also known as the Falkland islands in the UK). In fact, many governments would dramatically increase their expenditure to stimulate the economy during the recession, and economically war is the same as these policies, so the claim that a depressed economy cannot support a war is unfounded. In addition, during the crisis period of the business cycle, which is the early stage of the economic downturn, despite the economic crisis and potential depression, the country still retains the ability to start wars based on its economic and military power. Based on the above understanding, war has the conditions and reasons for its outbreak in all stages of the business cycle.

Second, the economic origin for the outbreak of war is downward pressure on the economy rather than optimism or competition for monopoly capital, which may exist during economic recession or economic prosperity. This is due to a fact that during economic prosperity, people are also worried about a potential economic recession. Blainey pointed out that wars often occur in the economic upturn, which is caused by the optimism in people's mind [14], that is, the confidence to prevail. This interpretation linking optimism and war ignores the strength contrast between the warring parties. Not all wars are equally comprehensive, and there have always been wars of unequal strength. In such a war, one of the parties tends to have an absolute advantage, so the expectation of the outcome of the war is not directly related to the economic situation of the country. Optimism is not a major factor leading to war, but may somewhat serve as stimulation. In addition, Lenin attributed the war to competition between monopoly capital. This theory may seem plausible, but its scope of application is obviously too narrow. Lenin's theory of imperialism is only applicable to developed capitalist countries in the late stage of the development capitalism, but in reality, many wars take place among developing countries whose economies are still at their beginning stages. Therefore, the theory centered on competition among monopoly capital cannot explain most foreign wars. Moreover, even wars that occur during periods of economic expansion are likely to result from the potential expectation of economic recession, the "limits of growth" [15] faced during prosperity — a potential deficiency of market demand. So the downward pressure on the economy is the cause of war.

2023 SDI Negative
2NC --- Case Neg vs. UBI Aff › 2NC --- Economy Advantage › 2NC --- Not Good for Econ

More reasons why it doesn’t work.

Najma Dayib 4-10-2021. (Graduate of the University of Pennsylvania with a Bachelor of Arts in Philosophy, Politics, and Economics . "Universal Basic Income: A Fundamentally Flawed Concept." Penn Political Review. Web. accessed 6-18-2023 < https://pennpoliticalreview.org/2021/04/universal-basic-income-a-fundamentally-flawed-concept/ >.)MSUCB

Universal Basic Income is a “guaranteed cash benefit that the government provides to all citizens.” In short, it is a baseline, non-withdrawable guaranteed income floor. As of 2020, no country has this form of UBI written into law. It is important to note that Switzerland, in 2016, rejected the first and only unconditional UBI proposal in the world. Although there is widespread public support for UBI, there seems to be a specific obstacle to implementation for governments all over the world. A typical economic case for UBI comes from concern about the advancement of technology in our increasingly modern society. In the book Give People Money, journalist Annie Lowrey suggests that it is not a matter of whether or not “self-driving cars and other automated technology would start putting people out of work;” it is rather a question of when. Universal Basic Income would provide those who lose their jobs with a much-needed safety net. Alternatives to Universal Basic Income Any form of UBI that is not universal is not truly UBI, but an alternative. A weaker proposal of UBI was introduced in 1960 when economist Milton Friedman proposed a Negative Income Tax. The Negative Income Tax (NIT) is similar to UBI in that it guarantees a certain amount of income to each household. Still, unlike UBI, this policy would mean that one’s cash transfer would gradually be taxed away as their income increased. The scholar Charles Murray, a strong proponent of UBI, argues for a more efficient system that would cut programs such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and other social services and provide $13,000 per year to each citizen of the United States. Additionally, similar to NIT, those who earn more would receive less so that the least well-off in society could achieve a more equitable economic position. According to Murray, the current system we have in the United States is ineffective as there are many qualifications one must meet to receive government assistance. Murray argues that it would be more efficient to cut all assistance programs and institute a form of UBI that would genuinely benefit those in need. There are many other options available, as Table 1, provided by Kearney and Mogstad, shows. These include, but are not limited to, an annual transfer and conditional Basic Income: As the alternatives and table above showcase, a conditional — not universal — form of basic income would be preferable in almost all cases. The failure of UBI is the treatment of human capital as a secondary thought. In any credible and useful form, the basic income or annual transfer would allow the top 0.1% not to receive anything and the lowest 20% to receive the most. This is not a part of any true form of UBI. It is also important to note that there is significant disapproval for UBI from fiscal conservatives who would prefer that funds for social programs be diverted to other government programs. The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), through their audit, found severe government fiscal mismanagement. This mismanagement has led to a lack of financial support for all citizens and far too much support for the military and older adults who receive social security benefits. A new proposal supported by young Americans petitions that funds from the U.S. military budget be diverted to the home front and billions of tax dollars be returned to Americans through social programs. As of 2020, this has yet to be accomplished, as our current government is overwhelmingly composed of fiscally and socially conservative politicians vehemently opposed to this proposal. Given this reality, it is difficult to assess if UBI will ever be enacted. Projecting the Outcomes Before March of 2020, it was difficult to imagine what an implementation of UBI would look like. Then, over 22 million Americans filed for unemployment in the month of April alone. It’s important to note that the United States’ single $1200 conditional cash transfer to Americans during the COVID-19 pandemic cannot be considered a form of UBI. Though the United States failed to implement a long-lasting relief check for most of the country’s population, stimulus checks still garnered wide public approval. A recent poll conducted by OnePoll also demonstrated that, after receiving their first stimulus checks, 80 percent of those sampled believed that the economic impact payments should continue until the end of the pandemic. On the other hand, the Canadian COVID-19 Economic Response Plan, similar to plans in the majority of other countries facing economic crisis due to the pandemic, guaranteed checks for a larger portion of citizens than the U.S., with a plan to continue payments through the rest of the pandemic. Additionally, only six million Canadians filed for unemployment within April compared to the United States’ 22 million. Through the Canada Recovery Benefit (CRB), citizens who lost their jobs, faced income reduction, or were forced to stop working received $500 per week for up to 26 weeks. This recovery procedure is much closer to UBI than the United States’ response. Aside from the partisan divide between those within the Liberal Party who enacted the policy, and the Conservatives who argued that it lacked a commitment to fiscal restraint and failed to address the needs of “everyday Canadians,” most Canadian citizens were quite content with the package compared to the overwhelming disapproval in the United States. As the last few months have proven, UBI is not as disruptive to our normative system of government as one might assume. However, it is not enough. A consistent cash transfer alone will not remedy wealth and income inequality, the lack of access to adequate healthcare, and, overall, the government’s failure to redistribute tax dollars and provide a financial safety net. Our current system offers an overly complicated tax process, yet insufficient social benefits to account for many Americans’ difficulties. In the long term, UBI is similar to a form of symbolic redistribution. A genuinely universal UBI program would not be ideal for the economy as a whole, as it presents a short-term solution to more long-term problems. Furthermore, without a wealth tax or a modernized form of NIT, UBI could hurt the economy and the working class more than it would help. An alternative would accurately target the least well-off . Conclusion In conclusion, UBI has hardly progressed in concept since American revolutionary Thomas Paine originally proposed the idea in Agrarian Justice in 1797. The lack of implementation of UBI and the increasing complexity of the world’s economic systems tell us this: UBI is perceived as an idealistic, symbolic solution to income inequality that fails to address underlying issues. New policy proposals come mostly from former Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (NY-14), who both identify as Democratic-Socialists. These progressive policies cover many aspects of social welfare: climate justice, Medicare, housing, and college for all, and eliminating student and medical debt. Thus, these policies provide a basic social safety net for Americans, while also offering a clear path for funding. All in all, UBI does not meet the same level of planning and support, rendering it a largely unrealistic approach. UBI would be an expensive and virtually useless program for the most vulnerable in our society—the poor, disabled, elderly, and youth.

2023 SDI Negative
2NC --- Case Neg vs. UBI Aff › 2NC --- Economy Advantage › 2NC --- Not Good for Econ

Three reasons why it’s bad.

Melissa Kearney and Magne Mogstad 11-23-2019. (Melissa Kearney is a professor in the department of economics at the University of Maryland and the director of the Aspen Economic Strategy Group. Magne Mogstad is the Gary Becker Professor in Economics at the University of Chicago and a member of the Aspen Economic Strategy group., . "The math is clear: Universal basic income is a terrible idea." Business Insider. Web. accessed 6-18-2023 < https://www.businessinsider.com/yang-warren-universal-basic-income-idea-bad-2019-11 >.)MSUCB

But despite the growing popularity, UBI is a flawed idea that would do little to fix the issues some supporters claim it addresses. UBI's renewed popularity UBI has a fairly high level of approval among the electorate, which explains the attention it's receiving from candidates. A recent Gallup poll suggests that while less popular here than in the UK and Canada, 43% of Americans support the idea of UBI to subsidize jobs lost to artificial intelligence. The premise of UBI is to provide individuals with an unconditional income guarantee from the government regardless of personal circumstances or family income. For instance, a version of UBI popularized by labor leader Andy Stern, journalist Annie Lowrey, Yang, and others would distribute a $1,000 check once a month to every adult in the US. Advocates suggest that UBI would address rising income equality, insulate households from the effects of globalization and technological innovation, and be more efficient than the complicated set of existing transfer programs targeting different populations or types of need. While elements of UBI may be appealing in the abstract, in practice it's an inefficient, extremely expensive, and potentially harmful policy that would solve none of those three challenges. UBI directs resources inefficiently Let's start with concerns about the income gap in the US. If the goal is to design a progressive policy that better redistributes income, UBI is a terrible tool. Unlike programs crafted to specifically help people with low income and those with disabilities, a UBI program would, by design, spread payments across the widest possible base. This means that while the economically vulnerable would receive support, so too would middle- to upper-income families. Why give some money to everyone, rather than offer dedicated assistance to those who need it? Even if UBI payments were phased out and then capped for earners above a certain income, the program would still end up giving able-bodied working-age adults subsidies alongside families with low incomes, regardless of relative need. UBI by design fails to account for the elements of life that make families more or less in need of government support — such as having a child with a serious illness or a work-limiting disability oneself — and as such would result in a highly inefficient allocation of resources. UBI is staggeringly expensive Further, the likely fiscal costs of a UBI are staggering. Enacting a UBI that pays $10,000 to every US adult would distribute about $2.5 trillion in benefits each year. That's roughly 75% of the federal government's 2018 revenues. To fund a UBI program of this size, Congress would need to pass massive tax increases or spending cuts. Some proponents of UBI would fund the program, at least in part, by disbanding existing safety-net programs. This would be a disaster. Cutting a wide array of existing programs — such as the earned income tax credit (EITC), child tax credit (CTC), temporary assistance to needy families (TANF), supplemental nutrition assistance program (SNAP), and disability insurance — would cover only one-fifth of the cost of such a UBI and result in a massive loss of existing transfers to people with disabilities and families with children. This approach would exacerbate the needs of the most vulnerable members of society. UBI doesn't address the automation problem Next, consider concerns about displaced workers and the threat of robots taking jobs. If the goal is to get people back to work, then UBI, again, is a terrible policy. Giving people unconditional cash payments does nothing to address the root causes of declining employment and wages among less educated people. Whereas a targeted wage subsidy would encourage work and increase take home pay, UBI discourages labor supply. Instead, we should spend money helping people invest in their own human capital and making it easier for them to get to work. We should spend money on promising career and technical education programs and help low-income workers pay for child care and transportation. All told, UBI is a sub-optimal and probably harmful policy response to all three of the challenges it purports to address.

2023 SDI Negative
2NC --- Case Neg vs. UBI Aff › 2NC --- Economy Advantage › 2NC --- Not Good for Econ

Arguments based on tech are rubbish. Encouraging people to pursue projects of passions will feed shortages.

Marco Annunziata 7-27-2018. (Senior Contributor Economics & innovation, TED speaker, . "Universal Basic Income: A Universally Bad Idea." Forbes. Web. accessed 6-18-2023 < https://www.forbes.com/sites/marcoannunziata/2018/07/27/universal-basic-income-a-universally-bad-idea/?sh=5dc5ad0b3269 >.)MSUCB

If you ask, “why do we need UBI?”, most proponents respond “because the robots will soon take all the jobs”. That is why UBI is so popular in Silicon Valley, from Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg to countless start-up wizards. “And UBI is already being tested in many places” they will add. You think about this, and then ask, “why are we testing it?” “To make sure people will use it to learn new skills and look for a job, or set up their own business.” In other words, we run pilot projects to make sure UBI will not stop people from looking for a job. But… …you just told me there will be no jobs… The technological argument for UBI is rubbish. When unsupervised robots can produce the entire U.S. GDP, by all means, let’s divide the fruits of their labor equally across the entire population. That’s easy, no need to run pilot programs. (How people will find fulfillment in that utopian world is a more troubling question.) The reason people run UBI experiments, of course, is they do not believe for a second that the machines will do all the work. Which means that to finance UBI, enough people will have to work, produce, earn and be taxed. Hence the concern on how UBI would impact work incentives. (By the way, these experiments consist in giving a small monthly payment to a tiny minority among the poor and unemployed, for a limited period; thus, being neither universal nor permanent they teach us nothing about how UBI would work.) More thoughtful proponents will tell you: “we need UBI so everyone can pursue their passion. If you are guaranteed enough to live with dignity, you can take a risk, become an entrepreneur or an artist.” This sounds almost reasonable, but it clashes with two unpleasant truths: First: since we need human work to improve our lot, the priority is to make sure everyone contributes to the best of their abilities; Second: these abilities are very unequally distributed. Not everyone has a passion, and not everyone is equally talented. This is a simple fact of life. Not everyone can be an entrepreneur or an artist. Our economies need construction workers, welders, plumbers, electricians, nurses, firemen, policemen, janitors, waiters. Some people go into some of these jobs with passion, others because it pays the bills—and these jobs need to be done. We already have a shortage of skills in a number of industries. In oil and gas, mining, shipping and a host of other sectors sizable cohorts of experienced workers are about to retire with no pipeline of younger workers to take their place. This is hardly the time to send young people the message that they should follow their (as yet unidentified) passion and not worry about job prospects. UBI would send exactly that wrong-headed message, reducing people’s incentive to work. And it would get worse. Our concept of a dignified life is relative. Getting by on my guaranteed basic income, I will look at my richer, working peers and feel that my lifestyle is not quite dignified. So I will lobby politicians for an increase in UBI. As UBI rises, even fewer people will work; those who still work will have to be taxed more, and so even fewer people will work, and… If you doubt these arguments, consider that advanced economies are already littered with young people with college degrees no employer considers useful—while ancient Greek literature may be a passion, it does not guarantee a job and a living wage. The countries toying with the idea of UBI—all advanced economies—are deep in debt, with pitifully low productivity growth and a massive looming rise in pension and health care expenditures (think of Italy, where the populist Five Stars movement secured one-third of the vote in the last elections by promising UBI). They desperately need to generate more income and spend it wisely—it makes no sense to waste money on those who do not need it.