Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › JG = Targeted Jobs

A Federal Jobs Guarantee can target jobs – contextual evidence says it can be infrastructure.

Pavlina R. Tcherneva, 2023 (The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability, )

The proposal herein is to design the Job Guarantee as a “National Care Act” that would help fill many social and environmental needs gaps. With input from community groups, localities and municipalities could begin to develop public service employment opportunities in the following three areas: 1) care for the environment; 2) care for the community; and 3) care for the people. A green Job Guarantee that targets environmental and social concerns could create many different kinds of public service employment for years to come, both in large- and small-scale projects, including physical and social infrastructure. A 21st century Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) would help address acute climate-related problems in every community and would aim to prevent, mitigate, and withstand the impact of intensifying hurricanes, tornadoes, fires, and floods. The Job Guarantee would include, monitoring, rehabilitation, and public investment programs. It could tackle soil erosion and flood control, administer environmental surveys, launch species monitoring, park maintenance and renewal programs, remove invasive species, support sustainable agriculture practices, and work to eliminate food and public health deserts in the United States. It could launch mass rural and urban reforestation projects, local fisheries, community supported agriculture (CSA) farms, community and rooftop gardens, community beekeeping projects, fire and other disaster prevention measures, weatherization of homes, and composting. In addition to the environmental challenges, communities experience social and economic problems connected to urban blight and poverty. Since communities are best rebuilt from within, the Job Guarantee could employ existing best practices from the solidarity economy to address them. Projects could include vacant property cleanup, reclamation of materials, and restoration of public spaces. They could build school gardens, playgrounds, urban farms, co-working spaces, solar arrays, tool lending libraries, alongside training and credentialing programs. They can help run restoration of historical sites, community theaters, carpooling programs, recycling, reuse, and water-collection initiatives, food waste programs, oral histories projects, and more.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › JG = No Consensus

No consensus on the term

Bruenig ’18 [Matt; March 22; founder of the People’s Policy Project, a think tank specializing in income distribution, taxation, and welfare, former attorney at the National Labor Relations Board, JD from Boston Law School; People’s Policy Project, “Some Notes on Federal Job Guarantee Proposals,” https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2018/03/22/some-notes-on-federal-job-guarantee-proposals]

Discussion around the idea of a job guarantee has picked up of late (CBPP, The Nation, Sanders Institute I, II). As with any idea that attracts a sizable number of adherents, the term “job guarantee” means lots of different things to a lot of different people, which makes it a difficult thing to talk about in a comprehensive way. But with that limitation recognized, I thought it might be worthwhile to share some notes about the recent burst.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Substantial = Materially

Substantially means real, not imaginary

Wollman ’93 (Circuit Judge, US Court of Appeals – 8th Circuit, Kansas City Power & Light Company, a Missouri corporation, Appellee, v. Ford Motor Credit Company, a Delaware corporation; McDonnell Douglas Finance Corporation, a Delaware corporation; HEI Investment Corp., a Hawaii corporation, Appellants, 995 F.2d 1422; 1993 U.S. App. LEXIS 13755, L/N)

Instruction No. 10 was not given in isolation, however. The district court's instructions also contained a definition of "substantial." Instruction No. 11 defined "substantial" as meaning "true, real or likely to materialize" and as not meaning "imaginary or unlikely to materialize." This instruction properly limited the potential bases for the jury's decision, which is the essential function of jury instructions. When combined with the contract and the verdict-directing instructions, [*1432] which tracked the operative language of the contract, Instruction No. 11 required the jury to find that KCPL had determined a real risk, not some imaginary hypothetical risk premised solely on a reduction in the DRD. Because the contract provided only one means of creating a risk of making an indemnity payment--a demand notice from an Investor--the jury's discretion was properly channelled into deciding whether KCPL had sufficiently studied and honestly considered the likelihood of receiving such a demand notice. That determination is all that the contract required.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Substantial = Large

“Substantial” means considerable or to a large degree --- this common meaning is preferable because the word is not a term of art

Arkush 2 (David, JD Candidate – Harvard University, “Preserving "Catalyst" Attorneys' Fees Under the Freedom of Information Act in the Wake of Buckhannon Board and Care Home v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources”, Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, Winter, 37 Harv. C.R.-C.L. L. Rev. 131)

Plaintiffs should argue that the term "substantially prevail" is not a term of art because if considered a term of art, resort to Black's 7th produces a definition of "prevail" that could be interpreted adversely to plaintiffs. It is commonly accepted that words that are not legal terms of art should be accorded their ordinary, not their legal, meaning, and ordinary-usage dictionaries provide FOIA fee claimants with helpful arguments. The Supreme Court has already found favorable, temporally relevant definitions of the word "substantially" in ordinary dictionaries: "Substantially" suggests "considerable" or "specified to a large degree." See Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1976) (defining "substantially" as "in a substantial manner" and "substantial" as "considerable in amount, value, or worth" and "being that specified to a large degree or in the main"); see also 17 Oxford English Dictionary 66-67 (2d ed. 1989) ("substantial": "relating to or proceeding from the essence of a thing; essential"; "of ample or considerable amount, quantity or dimensions").

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Substantially = Not All

‘Substantially’ does not mean wholly.

Zoss ’98 [Paul; November 16; Magistrate Judge on the United States District Court for the Northern District of Iowa; Lexis, “Bailey v. United States,” 39 F. Supp. 2d 1132, 1138]

To do this, the court will need a working definition of the terms "substantial" and "substantially." Courts have given these terms widely different meanings, depending on the context. See Victor v. Nebraska, 511 U.S. 1, 19, 114 S. Ct. 1239, 1250, 127 L. Ed. 2d 583 (1994) ("substantial" means either "not seeming or imaginary" or "that specified to a large degree" in the context of a reasonable doubt instruction, citing Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1981)); Kluener v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 154 F.3d 630, 637 (6th Cir. 1998) ("substantial" means something less than a preponderance, but more than a mere reasonable basis, citing 26 C.F.R. P1.6662-4(d)(3) (1997)); Id., at 639 ("substantial" means "considerable" or "ample"); Canyon Air Tour Coalition v. Federal Aviation Administration, 332 U.S. App. D.C. 133, 154 F.3d 455, 474 (D.C. Cir. 1998) ("substantial" may well be defined as meaning "more than half," "being that specified to a large degree or in the main," "not seeming or imaginary," "considerable in amount"); York Products, Inc. v. Central Tractor Farm & Family Center, 99 F.3d 1568, 1572-73 (Fed. Cir. 1996) ("substantially" means "considerable in . . . extent," citing American Heritage Dictionary Second College Edition 1213 (2d ed. 1982) or "largely but not wholly that which is specified," citing Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 1176 (9th ed. 1983)); Koch v. United States, 47 F.3d 1015, 1021 (10th Cir. 1995) ("substantially" means "justified in substance or in the main -- that is, justified to a degree that could satisfy a reasonable person." (citations omitted)); Laitram Machinery, Inc. v. Carnitech, 884 F. Supp. 1074, 1085 (E.D.La. 1995) (definition of "substantially" in a patent case is a jury question); C.E. Equipment Co., Inc. v. United States, 17 Cl. Ct. 293, 299 (1989) ("substantially" means "less than totally"); Darlington v. Studebaker-Packard Corporation, 191 F. Supp. 438, 439 (N.D. Ind 1961) ("The word 'substantially' is a relative term and should be interpreted in accordance with context of claim in which it is used."). At trial, the court will expect the parties to propose appropriate definitions for these terms for the court to use in deciding this case.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › AFF ANSWERS › Substantially = Not All

‘Substantially’ means greatly, NOT entirely.

Burke ’12 [Christopher; April 27; United States Magistrate Judge; Westlaw, “Virgin Atl. Airways Ltd. v. Delta Airlines, Inc.,” No. CIV.A. 11-61-LPS-CJB, WL 1636147]

The Court agrees, and finds that such a result would be at odds with the established law. See, e.g., Circle R, Inc. v. Trail King Indus., Inc., 21 F. App'x 894, 898 (Fed.Cir.2001) (reversing a district court decision that construed the phrase “substantially flat” to mean “entirely flat”); York Prods., Inc. v. Cent. Tractor Farm & Family Ctr., 99 F.3d 1568, 1572–73 (Fed.Cir.1996) (construing “substantially the entire height” as “nearly the entire height”). The adverb “substantially” is typically defined to mean “to a great or significant extent,” or “for the most part; essentially.”4 The adjective “flat” is typically defined to mean “smooth and even; without marked lumps to indentations” or “having a broad level surface.”5 These ordinary definitions are generally consistent with the patent specification discussed at length above, which depicts and describes seat-to-bed systems with constituent surfaces that are close to, though not entirely, flat. (See ′861 patent, col. 9–10; col. 13 (describing multiple embodiments with “substantially flat” passenger-bearing surfaces that are composed of “substantially coplanar[ ] and contiguous” surfaces)6 As such, although the patent specification and claims lead to the inescapable conclusion that the claimed “substantially flat bed” must consist of surfaces that are flat to a great extent, those surfaces need not be precisely so. (See, e.g., id., col. 33:12–17; 36:32–33; 43:7–8; 46:54–56).

Footnote 4 begins:

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – No Infrastructure

And, Jobs guarantee is distinct from an infrastructure rebuild.

PHILIP HARVEY in 2021

Professor of law and economics at Rutgers Law School.; Infrastructure Investment vs. Job Guarantee; National Jobs For All Network; https://njfac.org/index.php/2021/09/05/infrastructure-investment-vs-job-guarantee/

What is the difference between job guarantee and infrastructure investment? And to what extent would infrastructure investment and a J.G. program serve the aims of the other? The goals of a job guarantee (J.G.) and the infrastructure spending legislation like the American Jobs Plan (AJP) proposed by the Biden Administration or the bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (H.R.) currently under debate in the U.S. Congress are different. -> The purpose of J.G. legislation is to close the economy’s job gap through direct job creation and to administer the job creation program to ensure all job seekers access to proper employment providing fair and adequate wages along with safe and healthful working conditions. -> The purpose of infrastructure investment legislation is to develop and maintain society’s physical and social infrastructure, usually by contracting with private business firms, to perform the work and often stimulate economic growth and create jobs.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – JG = Wholistic

The term guarantee means it’s a right that can’t be qualified with a specific skill-set or industry – it’s an unconditional offer of a job.

L. Randall Wray 20, professor of Economics at Bard College and Senior Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, “Job Guarantee,” The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Palgrave Macmillan UK, 2020, pp. 1–9 Springer Link, doi:10.1057/978-1-349-95121-5_3080-1

‘Job Guarantee’ (JG) has become the favoured term applied to a variety of approaches that seek to ensure what can be described as true full employment. While often used as a synonym for ‘Employer of Last Resort’ (ELR), these terms evoke quite different framing. Employer of Last Resort implies that there is an entity that stands by to provide jobs to those who otherwise have failed to secure them. The term Job Guarantee implies a right to a job, although it does not indicate how that right will be secured. However, if we are to include the right to a job as similar to other recognized rights (right to life, right to free speech, right to vote, right to marriage), this would seem to imply that it is government that is to provide the guarantee. Many proponents of the JG do emphasize the human rights angle, interpreting the UN Charter on Human Rights as explicitly guaranteeing the right to access to a job (See Harvey 1989, 1993, 1999; Burgess and Mitchell 1998). Unfortunately, each term carries a negative connotation: ‘last resort’ can be seen as derogatory—the potential workers cannot find anything better; ‘guarantee’ implies that potential workers must be employed no matter what. Together, these associations fuel suspicion that work done is of low quality and otherwise without merit. There have been some efforts to rebrand the proposal as Public Service Employment (PSE) to emphasize the positive potential of such jobs (Wray 1999).

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 2NC

c. And to always be “in the main”

Words and Phrases ‘2 (Volume 40A, p. 469)

Ill.App.2 Dist. 1923 “Substantial” means in substance, in the main, essential, including material or essential parts.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 2NC

b. Requires “essential parts”

David S. Becker ‘14, Partner in the Litigation and Intellectual Property Practice Groups at Freeborn & Peters, LLP, J.D. from DePaul University College of Law, & John C. Hammerle, Associate in the Litigation Practice Group

at Freeborn & Peters, LLP, J.D. from DePaul University College of Law, “The Trouble With “Substantial Completion” in Construction Projects”, Committee News, Winter 2014, https://freeborn.com/assets/the_trouble_with_substantial_completion_in_construction_projects-aba_winter_2014_newsletter.pdf

3 See, e.g., Kinetic Builder’s, Inc. v. Peters, 226 F.3d 1307, 1315 (Fed. Cir. 2000); Ocean Winds Corp. v. Lane, 556 S.E.2d 377, 379 (S.C. 2001) (citing statutory definition of substantial completion as “that degree of completion of a project, improvement, or a specified area or portion thereof . . . upon attainment of which the owner can use the same for the purpose for which it was intended”) (internal citations and emphasis omitted); Daugherty v. Bruce Realty & Dev., Inc., 892 S.W.2d 332, 335 (Mo. Ct. App. 1995) (“a building is substantially complete . . . when it has reached the state of its construction so that it can be put to the use for which it was intended, even though comparatively minor items remain to be furnished or performed to conform to the plans and specifications of the completed building”); E.R. Stone v. City of Arcola, 181 Ill. App. 3d 513, 526 (Ill. App. Ct. 1989) (acknowledging that a project is “substantially complete” at a given date where “it could be used for the purpose for which it was intended on that date”). See also Sorenson v. Dager, 601 N.W.2d 564, 570 (Neb. Ct. App. 1999) (*fix this parenthetical); Evans & Assocs. v. Dyer, 246 Ill. App. 3d 231, 239 (Ill. App. Ct. 1993) (“Substantial performance . . . . means performance in all the essential elements necessary to the accomplishment of the purpose of the contract. ‘Substantial’ means in substance; in the main; essential, including material or essential parts.”)..

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 2NC

a. ‘Substantial’ means totality of circumstances

US First Circuit Court of Appeals ’98

In Re Richard Lamanna, Debtor.first Usa, et al., Appellees, v. Richard Lamanna, AppellantUnited States Court of Appeals, First Circuit. - 153 F.3d 1Heard July 27, 1998.Decided Aug. 25, 1998

Decision Affirmed. The court joins other circuits in adopting the "totality of the circumstances" test as the measure of substantial abuse under the Bankruptcy Code. This is a flexible standard adopted by Congress to allow bankruptcy courts to consider the factors involved in each case and to prevent abuse of Chapter 7 filings. When there is evidence that the consumer can pay their debts, there is likely to be found substantial abuse.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 1NC › 1nc – No Infrastructure

Infrastructure violates – it’s distinct from a job guarantee and wouldn’t be universal.

Pavlina R. Tcherneva in 2023

Ph.D., an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy, “The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability,” Working Paper Series Open Society University Network Economic Democracy Initiative. https://edi.bard.edu/research/notes/the-job-guarantee-mmts-proposal-for-full-employment-and-price-stability

Large-scale job creation programs are often mistaken for large-scale infrastructure projects. And while it is vital to invest in a nation’s infrastructure as a matter of national priority, such infrastructure investment should not be scheduled around fluctuations of the business cycle. Building schools should be done on as-needed basis, not as an anticyclical policy. Similarly, it would be irrational to build bridges only when the economy is in a recession or, conversely, to discontinue a high-speed rail project on the grounds that the economy is growing. In addition, infrastructure jobs are often high-skill and predominantly male, thus not always suitable for all jobseekers. Large scale infrastructure is not a particularly reliable method for addressing the spatial aspects of unemployment. Jobseekers may live in communities that do not need levees or fire prevention efforts, but may experience multiple other deprivations such as poor access to healthy food or childcare care.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 1NC › 1nc – No Spec

A ‘federal jobs guarantee’ is wholistic and includes multiple jobs.

Bhandari ’19 [Ryan Bhandari; March 25, 2019; Senior Policy Advisor at Thirdway’s Economic Program; Thirdway, “What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?” https://www.thirdway.org/memo/what-is-the-federal-jobs-guarantee-and-what-are-people-saying-about-it]

What is the federal jobs guarantee? A federal jobs guarantee is as simple as it sounds on the surface: everyone in the country will be guaranteed a job by the US government should they desire one. There are two versions right now gaining attention. One plan is written by academics Mark Paul, Sandy Darity, and Darrick Hamilton. The other was written by Pavlina Tcherneva. In general, these plans promise:

Guaranteed jobs in infrastructure repair, ecological restoration, caregiving, and community development projects.

2023 CNDI Topicality
Topicality – CNDI 23 › 1NC › 1nc – No Spec

‘Substantial’ means all and without qualification.

Lorne Slotnick 15, Chair of the Arbitration Board, Labour Arbitration Awards has issued the following decision: IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BETWEEN: St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton -and- Canadian Union of Public Employees Local 786, Labour Arbitration Awards: St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton v Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 786, 2015 CanLII 18978 (ON LA), 2015

The union points to the definition of “similar” in the online Oxford English Dictionary as “having a marked resemblance or likeness; of a like nature or kind,” and in Black’s Law Dictionary as “nearly corresponding; resembling in many respects; somewhat like; having a general likeness, although allowing for some degree of difference.” In addition, “substantially” is defined in the Oxford English Dictionary as “in all essential characters or features; in essentials, to all intents and purposes, in the main,” and in Black’s [Law Dictionary] as “essentially; without material qualification; in the main; in substance; materially; in a substantial manner.” The fact that the collective agreement uses both words together must mean that the two shift rotations have to be essentially corresponding or resembling each other in all essential respects for the conditions to be met, the union argues.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Aff Answers › UBI Good

UBI is built on working class needs – It separates income from work, contesting the structures of capital

Feltrin and Sachetto 21 (Lorenzo Feltrin is Leverhulme Early Career Research Fellow at the Department of Political Science and International Studies (POLSIS) of the University of Birmingham, Devi Sacchetto is a full Professor of Sociology of work at the Department of Philosophy, Sociology, Education and Applied Psychology, “The work-technology nexus and working-class environmentalism: Workerism versus capitalist noxiousness in Italy’s Long 1968,” Theory and Society, 3/5/2021, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-021-09441-5#Sec2) - MP

Under the supervision of former fascist officials, the “production inferno” of the post-WWII decades featured appalling toxicities and hazards, where exposure to heat, smokes, and powders and the lack of health and safety measures resulted in widespread accidents and occupational diseases such as cancers, silicosis, asbestosis, hepatic and dermatological pathologies, etc. (see Zazzara 2009). Montedison’s Petrolchimico began producing polyvinyl chloride (PVC) using Monsanto patents that involved high levels of toxicity. The Montedison worker and then environmental activist Gabriele Bortolozzo wrote: “The chloralkali units were sadly disastrous for the workers, due not only to chlorine but also to mercury vapour. […] To calm things down, all the company did […] was distributing abundant doses of cow milk”Footnote4 (Bortolozzo 1998, 33). Up to the 1950s, Porto Marghera’s class composition was centred on the figure of the “peasant-factory worker”, employed in factories but living in the countryside and immersed in a rural lifestyle (Piva and Tattara 1983). Some of them, the so-called “metalmezzadri” (literally “metal-sharecroppers”) had access to small plots of land. Strong ties to the land would remain a characteristic of Veneto’s working-class culture even after their material severance. This was a time of labour weakness and relative social peace, as Veneto was a scarcely industrialised, conservative region, where the Left had limited influence. However, the situation began to change rapidly in the 1960s, when a new cohort of young workers showed their determination not to accept the hard fate endured by their parents, with the first major strike at Edison taking place in July 1963. Ties to the land proved not to necessarily be a factor of quiescence: “The Petrolchimico workers were peasants until the day before, and after taking off their blue overalls [some] went home to work their plot. […] The strike days were very expensive for the urban workers, and less for the others”.Footnote5 The Porto Marghera group originated in the early 1960s through the encounter between intellectuals and studentsFootnote6 – mostly based in Padua and Venice – led by Antonio Negri and militant workers disaffected with the line of the Italian Communist Party (PCI) and its associated union Italian General Confederation of Labour (CGIL) (Sacchetto and Sbrogiò 2009). By 1967, they had become an extra-parliamentary local organisation known as Potere Operaio, with an office in Marghera and a journal titled Il potere operaio: Giornale politico degli operai di Porto Marghera, leafletting regularly outside the factory gates. Over the 1960s, the Porto Marghera group developed its own perspective centred on the mastering of the productive cycle and radically egalitarian demands as an instrument for class recomposition: equal wage increases (in absolute value) for everyone or inversely proportional wage hikes, a guaranteed minimum wage for all workers, the reduction of the working week, and an abolition of differences in statutory conditions (holidays, social contributions, etc.) among the different categories of employees. The guaranteed wage was rapidly expanded to become a “guaranteed income” as a demand to unify all workers, waged and unwaged. This strategy built on immediate working-class needs to expand them quantitatively to the breaking point of incompatibility with capitalism. As the division of the working class through differential wages and conditions was a political instrument of class dominance, “egalitarianism was not merely making do in the warmth of equals”Footnote7 but a political platform to “make the wage an independent variable”, independent from productivity gains in line with Keynesian planning. This platform proved to be largely successful when the discontent of Petrolchimico’s workers exploded in the summer of 1968 (see Bortolozzo 1998; Chinello 1996; Sacchetto and Sbrogiò 2009; Sbrogiò 2016; Trevisan 2017; Zazzara 2009). By then, Potere Operaio’s influence had reached five out of seven members of the CGIL workplace executive committee (commissione interna) at Petrolchimico. This mobilisation was thus characterised by a “dual leadership” in which Potere Operaio conducted a hard rank-and-file campaign of wildcat strikes, active pickets, mass marches, and roadblocks – culminating in the occupation of the Venice-Mestre train station on 1 August 1968 – while the unions were pressured to endorse the egalitarian demands of the base and negotiate for them at the institutional level. Class conflict would remain extremely high throughout 1969, when it expanded countrywide with the “Hot Autumn” strike wave for the renewal of the national-sectorial collective agreements (see Wright 2002). In June 1969, however, CGIL expelled a number of prominent Potere Operaio shop stewards and activists. The already acrimonious relationship between Potere Operaio – which became a national organisation in that yearFootnote8 – and the unions deteriorated further as the Porto Marghera group adopted a line of frontal opposition against the traditional labour movement. The unions, meanwhile, developed a more base-oriented approach that would allow them to recover much of the credibility lost in the first stages of the strike wave (Trevisan 2017), “riding the tiger” of workers’ spontaneity. The Porto Marghera group’s theorising over noxiousness was spearheaded by the Petrolchimico technician Augusto Finzi, with the assistance of external intellectuals such as high school chemistry professor Lino Bassani, academic physicians Libero Battiston and Loriano Bonora, University of Padua’s occupational health professor Bruno Saia, and Claudio Sossai, a mathematician for Italy’s National Research Council. Born in 1941 from a well-off Jewish familyFootnote9 based in insular Venice, Finzi spent part of his early childhood in a refugee camp in Switzerland to escape the Shoah.Footnote10 In 1960, he received a high school diploma in chemistry from Mestre’s Istituto Pacinotti – “where the beginning and end of the classes were signalled by the sound of a [factory-like] siren”Footnote11 – and immediately began working in a Petrolchimico VCM-PVC unit, where he joined the Porto Marghera workerist group around 1965–66. In many ways, Finzi’s “factory intellectual” profile was the counterpart to Italo Sbrogiò’s practical and charismatic approach. The Porto Marghera group’s most prominent leader, Italo SbrogiòFootnote12 was a Petrolchimico maintenance worker hailing from a poor and numerous rural family.Footnote13 Having started working before finishing elementary school, he reached Porto Marghera aged sixteen as a precarious construction labourer and joined Potere Operaio through, and in spite of, his activism in PCI and CGIL, from which he was expelled in 1969. He remembered his early factory years in these terms: “Chemical technology crashed on us like an avalanche, so much so that many labourers and technicians paid for this experience with their lives” (Sbrogiò 2016, 13–14). Up to the 1960s, the routine policy regarding noxiousness was its “monetisation”: unions and management would agree a compensation for the health damage and risks that workers suffered. The first notable struggle over noxiousness in which the Porto Marghera group was involved took place in 1967, precisely when Montedison decided to withdraw the noxiousness allowances from some factory units. In a way, this was merely a reactive struggle to restore what could be called the “moral economy of noxiousness” that had held sway up to that point. Yet, it marked the beginnings of the Porto Marghera group’s reflections and actions around noxiousness (Potere operaio, 20 June 1967).

2023 CNDI Kritik
Aff Answers › UBI Good

UBI/State reform is key– Perm Card?

Srnicek and Williams ’15 (Nick Srinicek and Alex Williams, Nick Srnicek is a Lecturer in Digital Economy at King's College London and Alex Williams is a political theorist and lecturer in digital media and society, “Inventing the Future: Post capitalism and a World Without Work,” Verso Books, )

These first two proposals equate to the reduction of labour demand through full automation, and the reduction of labour supply through the shortening of the working week.89 The combined outcome of these measures would be the liberation of a significant amount of free time without a reduction in economic output or a significant increase in unemployment. Yet this free time will be of little value if people continue struggling to make ends meet. As Paul Mattick puts it, ‘the leisure of the starving, or the needy, is no leisure at all but a relentless activity aimed at staying alive or improving their situation’.90 The underemployed, for instance, have plenty of free time but lack the means to enjoy it. Underemployed, it turns out, is really just a euphemism for under-waged. This is why an essential demand in a post-work society is for a universal basic income (UBI), giving every citizen a liveable amount of money without any means-testing.91 It is an idea that has periodically popped up throughout history.92 In the early 1940s, a version of it was advanced as an alternative to the Beveridge Report that eventually shaped the UK welfare state.93 In a now largely forgotten period during the 1960s and 1970s, the basic income was central to proposals for US welfare reform. Economists, NGOs and policymakers explored the idea in detail,94 and a number of small-scale experiments were set up in Canada and the United States.95 Such was the influence of UBI that over 1,300 economists signed a petition pushing the US Congress to enact a ‘national system of income guarantees’.96 Three separate administrations gave serious consideration to the proposal, and two presidents – Nixon and Carter – attempted to pass legislation to achieve it.97 In other words, UBI very nearly became a reality in the 1970s.98 While Alaska eventually implemented a basic income funded by its oil wealth, the idea largely disappeared from debate in the wake of neoliberal hegemony.99 But recent years have seen the idea undergo a resurgence in popularity. In both mainstream and critical media, it has gained traction, being taken up by Paul Krugman, Martin Wolf, the New York Times, the Financial Times and the Economist.100 The Swiss are holding a referendum on UBI in 2016, the proposal has been recommended by parliamentary committees in other countries, various political parties have adopted it in their manifestos, and there have been new experiments with it in Namibia and India.101 The idea has global scope, having been promoted forcefully by groups in Brazil, South Africa, Italy and Germany, and by an international network involving over twenty 69 countries.102 The movement for a UBI is thus once again resurgent in the wake of the 2008 crisis and the austerity regimes put in place after it. The demand for a UBI, however, is subject to competing hegemonic forces. It is just as open to being mobilised for a libertarian dystopia as for a post-work society – an ambiguity that has led many to mistakenly conflate the two poles. In demanding a UBI, therefore, three key factors must be articulated in order to make it meaningful: it must provide a sufficient amount of income to live on; it must be universal, provided to everyone unconditionally; and it must be a supplement to the welfare state rather than a replacement of it. The first point is obvious enough: a UBI must provide a materially adequate income. The exact amount will vary between countries and regions, but it can be relatively easily arrived at with existing data. The risk is that, if set too low, UBI becomes just a government subsidy to businesses. In addition, UBI must be universal and given to everyone unconditionally. As there would be no means- testing or other measures required to receive the UBI, it would break free of the disciplinary nature of welfare capitalism.103 Moreover, a universal grant avoids the stigmatisation of welfare, since everyone receives it. As we argued in Chapter 4, the invocation of ‘universalism’ also obliges the continual subversion of any restricted application of a basic income (in terms of individuals’ status as citizens, immigrants or prisoners). The demand for universality provides the basis for a continued struggle to expand the scope and scale of the basic income. Lastly, the UBI must be a supplement to the welfare state. The conservative argument for a basic income – which must be avoided at all costs – is that it should simply replace the welfare state by providing a lump sum of money to every individual. In this scenario, the UBI would just become a vector of increased marketisation, transforming social services into private markets. Rather than being some aberration of neoliberalism, it would simply extend its essential gesture by creating new markets. By contrast, the demand made here is for UBI as a supplement to a revived welfare state.104 Drawing upon moral arguments and empirical research, there are a vast number of reasons to support a UBI: reduced poverty, better public health and reduced health costs, fewer high school dropouts, reductions in petty crime, more time with family and friends, and less state bureaucracy.105 Depending on how UBI is presented, it is capable of generating support from across the political spectrum – from libertarians, conservatives, anarchists, Marxists and feminists, among others. The potency of the demand lies partly in this ambiguity, making it capable of mobilising broad popular support.106 However, for our purposes the significance of UBI as a demand lies in four key interrelated factors. The first point to emphasise is that the demand for UBI is a demand for a political transformation, not just an economic one. It is often thought that UBI is simply a form of redistribution from the rich to the poor, or that it is just a measure to maintain economic growth by stimulating consumer demand. From this perspective, UBI would have impeccable reformist credentials and be little more than a glorified progressive tax system. Yet the real significance of UBI lies in the way it overturns the asymmetry of power that currently exists between labour and capital. As we saw in the discussion of surplus populations, the proletariat is defined by its separation from the means of production and subsistence. The proletariat is thereby forced to sell itself in the job market in order to gain the income necessary to survive. The most fortunate among us have the leisure to choose which job to take, but few of us have the capacity to choose no job. A basic income changes this condition, by giving the proletariat a means of subsistence without dependency on a job.107 Workers, in other words, have the option to choose whether to take a job or not (in many ways, taking neoclassical economics at its word, and making work truly voluntary). A UBI therefore unbinds the coercive aspects of wage labour, partially decommodifies labour, and thus transforms the political relationship between labour and capital. 70 This transformation – making work voluntary rather than coerced – has a number of significant consequences. In the first place, it increases class power by reducing slack in the labour market. Surplus populations show what happens when there are large amounts of slack in the labour market: wages fall, and employers are free to debase workers.108 By contrast, when the labour market is tight, labour gains the political edge. The economist MichaÅ‚ Kalecki recognised this long ago when he argued that it explained why full employment would be resisted at every step.109 If every worker were employed, the threat of being fired would lose its disciplinary character – there would be more than enough jobs waiting just outside. Workers would gain the upper hand, and capital would lose its political power. The same dynamic holds for a basic income: by eliminating the reliance on wage labour, workers gain control over how much labour to supply, giving them significant power in the labour market. Class power is also increased in a variety of other ways. Strikes are easier to mobilise, since workers no longer have to worry about pay being docked or dwindling strike funds. The amount of time spent working for a wage can be modified to one’s own desire, with free time spent building communities and engaging with politics. One can slow down and reflect, safely protected from the constant pressures of neoliberalism. The anxieties that surround work and unemployment are reduced with the safety net of a UBI.110 Moreover, the demand for UBI combines the needs of the employed, the unemployed, the underemployed, migrant labour, temporary workers, students and the disabled.111 It articulates a common interest between these groups and provides a populist orientation for them to mobilise towards. The second related feature of UBI is that it transforms precarity and unemployment from a state of insecurity to a state of voluntary flexibility. It is often forgotten that the initial push for flexible labour came from workers, as a way of demolishing the constraining permanency of traditional Fordist labour.112 The repetitiveness of a nine-to-five job, combined with the tediousness of most work, is hardly an appealing prospect for a life-long career. The demands of care labour often require a flexible approach as well, further undermining the appeal of traditional jobs. Marx himself invokes the liberating aspects of flexible labour in his famous claim that communism ‘makes it possible for me to do one thing today and another tomorrow, to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticise after dinner, just as I have a mind, without ever becoming hunter, fisherman, herdsman or critic’.113 In the face of these desires for flexibility, capital adapted and co-opted them into a new form of exploitation. Today, flexible labour simply presents itself as precarity and insecurity, rather than freedom. The UBI responds to this generalisation of precarity and transforms it from a state to be feared back into a state of liberation. Third, a basic income would necessitate a rethinking of the values attributed to different types of work. Given that workers would no longer be forced to take a job, they could instead simply reject jobs that paid too little, required too much work, offered too few benefits, or were demeaning and undignified. Low-waged work is often crass and disempowering, and under a programme of UBI it is unlikely that many would want to undertake it. The result would be that hazardous, boring and unattractive work would have to be better paid, while more rewarding, invigorating and attractive work would be less well paid. In other words, the nature of work would become a measure of its value, not merely its profitability.114 The outcome of this revaluation would also mean that, as wages for the worst jobs rose, there would be new incentives to automate them. UBI therefore forms a positive-feedback loop with the demand for full automation. On the other hand, a basic income would not only transform the value of the worst jobs, but also go some way towards recognising the unpaid labour of most care work. In the same way that the demand for wages for housework recognised and politicised the domestic labour of women, so too does UBI recognise and politicise the generalised way in which we are all responsible for reproducing society: from 71 informal to formal work, from domestic to public work, from individual to collective work. What is central is not productive labour, defined in either traditional Marxist or neoclassical terms, but rather the more general category of reproductive labour.115 Given that we all contribute to the production and reproduction of capitalism, our activity deserves to be remunerated as well.116 In recognising this, the UBI indicates a shift from remuneration based upon ability to remuneration based upon basic need.117 All the genetic, historical and social variations that make effort a poor measure of a person’s worth are rejected here, and instead people are valued simply for being people.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Aff Answers › Perm – UBI

Workism reflect policy decisions and the aff can reverse it – UBI solves and sets conditions for a larger movement.

Thompson ’19 (Derek, staff writer at The Atlantic and the author of multiple books and the Work in Progress newsletter, “Workism Is Making Americans Miserable,” FEBRUARY 24, 2019, https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/02/religion-workism-making-americans-miserable/583441/)

Some workists, moreover, seem deeply fulfilled. These happy few tend to be intrinsically motivated; they don’t need to share daily evidence of their accomplishments. But maintaining the purity of internal motivations is harder in a world where social media and mass media are so adamant about externalizing all markers of success. There’s Forbes’ list of this, and Fortune’s list of that; and every Twitter and Facebook and LinkedIn profile is conspicuously marked with the metrics of accomplishment—followers, friends, viewers, retweets—that inject all communication with the features of competition. It may be getting harder each year for purely motivated and sincerely happy workers to opt out of the tournament of labor swirling around them.

Workism offers a perilous trade-off. On the one hand, Americans’ high regard for hard work may be responsible for its special place in world history and its reputation as the global capital of start-up success. A culture that worships the pursuit of extreme success will likely produce some of it. But extreme success is a falsifiable god, which rejects the vast majority of its worshippers. Our jobs were never meant to shoulder the burdens of a faith, and they are buckling under the weight. A staggering 87 percent of employees are not engaged at their job, according to Gallup. That number is rising by the year.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Aff Answers › Perm – Doubling?

The alternative is to explore the positionality and subjective experiences of workers and understand our collective alienation

Carmichael ’19 (Patrick Carmichael, Managing Director of Camtree: The Cambridge Teacher Research Exchange. Camtree is creating a global platform for educators who wish to reflect on their practice and conduct research to improve learning in their classrooms and institution, “Refusal of Work, Liberation of Time and the Convivial University”, Education and Technological Unemployment, 30 April 2019, )

The intention was not to be drawn into a minute re-examination of original texts, but rather to explore the realities of everyday working life, particularly in new industries in which precarity and fragmentation were the norm, and in contexts where automation was changing workers’ lives both within and beyond their workplaces. This in turn informed new self-organized social formations, and forms of activism more militant than those organized through established employer–worker committees. Operaist analyses characterized the latter as part of ‘neo-capitalism’ which involved close coordination of capital, industry and trades unions in cycles of mass production and mass consumption (Tronti 2010: 186). A key figure in Quaderni Rossi was Raniero Panzieri, for whom reinvigoration of Marxist theory would accompany the political renovation of the labour movement in ways that were specific to the Italian context. Central to this was a notion of workers’ inquiry (l’inchiesta operaia), that began not in social or political theory or methodology, but was instead ‘hot inquiry’ (inchiesta a caldo) stemming from the situated, subjective experiences of workers who found themselves facing, for example, worsening working conditions; personal precarity caused by automation; or the intrusions of work into other aspects of their social lives (Panzieri 1994: 126). Workers’ inquiry typically involved detailed empirical investigations into the division of labour within workplaces; mapping of the ways in which time was spent both in and out of work; critical reading of organizational documents and data; and autobiographical accounts and diaries. Some later forms of workers’ inquiry involved highly innovative approaches, the ‘interview to the double’ being an example that used the premise of going undercover into a participant’s workplace (as their ‘double’) in order to explore tacit knowledge, workplace micropolitics and subjective experience (Nicolini 2009). Perhaps the most influential of such inquiries were instances of co-research (conricerca) carried out by Romano Alquati, who focused on workplaces such as the factories of Fiat and Olivetti as they underwent cycles of automation (Alquati 1975). For Alquati, co-research was not merely a form of social inquiry undertaken to understand these changes: it represented instead a critically important form of activism which developed workers’ abilities to understand the mechanisms of their alienation, challenge these, and ultimately to extricate themselves from the constraints of capitalist labour (Alquati 1993). This involved supporting workers in reframing their concerns beyond working conditions to explore more expansive political and social questions, Alquati writing: There develops and clarifies for them a correspondence between conditions of labour and the social system… when the demand of today: “fundamentally, what does FIAT give me?” transforms… into another: “What different things can I hope for in a society dominated by businesses like FIAT? (Alquati 1975: 38)

2023 CNDI Kritik
Aff Answers › Perm – Pragmatism

The perm solves best – the workplace is vital as a breeding ground for collective organization – shared subjectivities and social cooperation create the most effective resistance.

Deranty 21

Jean-Philippe Deranty is an associate professor of philosophy at Macquarie University; April 27, 2021; Post-work society as an oxymoron: Why we cannot, and should not, wish work away; ; //[TMS—GK]

Work collectives One of the most original conclusions of Dejours’ inquiries has been the importance of cohesive work collectives from a psychological point of view. Work collectives bring together individuals through the technical division of labour: people working in the same space or involved in delivering a complex output that requires a coordination of their individual contributions. Even though work today can be performed in all kinds of arrangements, including isolated care situations, gig-, project- and ‘distributed work’, many people continue to work alongside others. From a technical point of view, the gap noted earlier for an individual worker between the prescriptions surrounding the task and how they deliver the output, such a gap is repeated at a higher level when several workers are involved. In that case, the gap lies between the formal organisation of the work process and the actual coordination of working activities among the individual workers. Just as each worker needs to find their own way of implementing work prescriptions, the working team needs to coordinate itself, across the individuals involved, to achieve true cooperation and be able to deliver a complex output. Following Dejours’ analyses, there are specific goods attached to stable, well-functioning work collectives. These goods would be difficult to find in other associations, precisely because of the specific constraints of work. Individuals belonging to a work collective, say a team of nurses in a hospital ward, share the same ‘niche’ within the world that their activity has opened up for them. They rely on and must abide by the same technical tools and organisational processes and collectively experience the latter’s potentialities, limitations and constraints. They develop modes of perception, attention and action along similar lines and mobilise their subjective capacities in parallel ways. For all these reasons, work collectives are social spaces in which individual experiences overlap significantly. Furthermore, the rigid frame imposed by work makes the sharing of experience highly specific. Workers share experiences because they face the same challenge of having to bridge the gap between prescription and the actual completion of tasks. Even if they do not get on, they have to coordinate their actions to bridge the gap between formal organisation and effective cooperation. This forces them to confront their own ways of doing things, to find reasons to defend their own perspective and potentially change their views. When a work collective functions well, the recognition it enables is highly specific, since only those who have faced the same challenge can truly judge what it took, in terms of personal resources and professional skills, to achieve a task. In this case, the person knows they are recognised authentically, for something they have truly achieved, based on standards only experts know about. This is the place where ‘a job well done’ can find its true recognition (Dejours, 2012, p. 257), which provides a special vindication of individual achievements. Solidarities built in work collectives have proven throughout history that they can be particularly strong. Many national worker movements had their roots in local workplaces, for instance, labour revolts in France and Italy in the late 1960s, with particular factories as their epicentres. A strategic dimension of the ongoing struggle between capital and labour has been the extent to which organisation on the shop floor is possible or not, as it is the soil where the roots of collective organisation can grow, not just to apply industry-level demands but even to formulate such demands (Burawoy, 1985 on the changing history of these antagonistic relations). Indeed, one aspect of class struggle is that it is often a struggle between collectives, between the collectives of workers and the collectives of managers (Bidet & Duménil, 2007). Theorists of democracy identify workplaces as a locus where democratic capacities are developed and practiced (Pateman, 1970). Dejours (1998) also demonstrates the political significance of work collectives in negative fashion when he shows the deleterious effects of aggressive forms of management on the general social ethos beyond workplaces. Post-work theorists might not deny the existence of workplace solidarity, or its psychological or political significance. Yet the call to de-emphasise work must mean that they think these goods are worth overlooking for the sake of non-work activities and relationships. Yet it is difficult to imagine other social relations that would have the specificity and the psychological depth delivering the goods just mentioned. Working cultures A second type of social relation implied in the work of social reproduction is occupational culture. This is the body of theoretical and practical knowledges and the typical skills a group of working people share as they face similar difficulties, within similar constraints, because of the occupation they have in common. These groups and the cultures they build are more or less formally structured. Arguably, homemakers whose work is not captured in the labour market make up such an occupational group on the basis of the similar tasks they share. More formal occupational cultures are organised in professions and trades whose working cultures are part of their public institutional existence. As Hegel showed, the place that an occupational group takes in the general work of social production in fact grounds more than a repertoire of knowledges and know-hows. It becomes the social anchor point for a whole lifeworld, what he called the ‘corporation’, with its specific ethos, belief system and vision of the world. These working cultures can be observed throughout human history, fleshed out in all kinds of institutional settings, framed by the most diverse cultural representations. In these historical examples, and not just in modern, capitalistic society, two remarkable features can be consistently observed. The first is that working cultures often are social spaces where the solidarity experienced at ground level in a work collective is organised and institutionalised. This was true already in the collegia of the ancient Roman world (Tran, 2019) and medieval corporations (Rosser, 2015). As the modern welfare state began to emerge towards the end of the nineteenth century, and economic and social rights became institutionalised on the basis of social-professional membership, Hegel’s early vision of the occupational roots of welfare and educational provisions (1991, p. 271) became remarkably prescient. Arguably, it is precisely the sharing of a specific kind of occupational necessity and the sharing of the technical knowledge and cultural resources that are developed to respond to it, which provides the ground for such institutionalised practices of solidarity. A second, persistent feature of work cultures is their significance for personal identity. Contrary to assumptions widely shared among social and political theorists, we find in non-Western and premodern societies many examples where the social status of the individual was influenced, more or less directly, depending more or less on the whims of a master or sheer luck, by personal achievements in an occupation. Social fate was not exclusively determined by general social markers, being a free citizen or born of unfree parents, of a noble or plebeian family, being identified as a man or a woman and so on. A Roman slave could hope to achieve freedom and some form of social recognition after manumission through hard and diligent work (Joshel, 1992). An Achuar man of the Amazonian forest owes his social standing to a large extent to his prowess as a hunter and an Achuar woman to her skills as a gardener (Descola, 1994). Even though cultural frames vary enormously across history, it is difficult to imagine that the significant social benefit an individual accrues from doing well in their occupation does not have an effect on their self-representations, even if it is impossible for outsiders to know exactly how this plays out. Given that society needs to be reproduced, all types of work need to be performed. The sharing of working knowledges and practices founds work cultures that can become the framework in which the identity of their members is constructed, as well institutional networks protecting their interests and their welfare. Advocating a post-work society ignores this important layer of social life. We might bemoan the place work has taken in societies dominated by the modern work ethic and think that there could be other ways to socialise than through work. Even if that is a valid concern, it does not have to lead to the conclusion that we should ignore work cultures. Instead, we should advocate social and economic systems that leave room for vibrant work cultures in which equality and solidarity can thrive and promote the flourishing of their members. The cooperative scheme as foundation of the social contract The occupational backbone of society also ensures that the social contract has solid foundations, namely the reciprocal contributions the individuals exchange among each other, which reproduce their lives and the life of the community. If reciprocity in fact exists and working conditions are not alienating or deleterious, this work of social reproduction provides a particularly firm basis for the polis. Work contributions matter deeply to the individuals involved as they mobilise their subjective capacities, impact on their identities and by definition serve social needs. Individuals engage in those activities not just on their own but also through work collectives and occupational groups. And by working, they interact with proximate others (co-workers, real or anonymous addressees of work) as well as the whole of society. A political community based on the exchange of reproductive activities is thus nourished by the life and blood of its members, as it were, and their many, proximate and more distant interactions underneath civic relations. This view of the political community as grounded in the division of labour is a classical one in social and political theory, articulated in different ways by Hegel, Dewey and Rawls, to name just three most eminent representatives. Focusing on the technical, ‘poietic’ aspects of the division of labour, on work as a kind of activity, provides extra conceptual ballast to this view. By contrast, let us imagine a ‘post-work society’. Even if some work still needs to be done, and some might even enjoy it, it no longer has central value. Against the background of the arguments put forward in this section, what does such a society look like? If ‘work’ in ‘post-work society’ just means capitalistic work, abstract labour, many more details need to be provided, to know exactly what the new economic and political organisation would look like. If we use Gorz’s last writings (2018) as paradigm example, it might in fact be a society in which work still matters a lot, to promote autonomy for individuals and indeed at the heart of community organisation, just not in its capitalistic form. Let us assume that more is meant by ‘work’ than just abstract labour. ‘Post-work society’ now means a society in which the exchange of reproductive contributions itself is no longer central. From what has just been said, the question immediately arises of what grounds the social contract. Post-work theorists assure us that moving beyond work is the best way to experience, and experiment with, new ways of being in the world, including new ways of being with others, notably to establish more inclusive forms of citizenship. But what would the bond with anonymous others consist of then? What would bind everyone to other individuals and give them a sense that are not just a collection of isolated atoms, each pursuing their own self-interest? Exactly what would give weight to ‘citizenship’? A realist view of human history, the consideration for example of the political shifts in regions that have undergone rapid deindustrialisation, makes us fear that, absent the exchange of working activities, what unites human beings beyond small communities of kinship or specialised interest, are factors by which they resemble each other, or think they do: the same religion, the same ‘race’, the same ‘culture’, the same imagined national narrative. The question then for ‘post-work’ society is whether it remains a society through a shared factor that is in fact more exclusionary than work is accused of being. It is only by stipulation that post-work theorists can be sure that when the exchange of work outputs is no longer the backbone of society, the outcome will be a freer and fairer social organisation. By contrast, there are many reasons to think that the implicit social contract binding a collective together is all the stronger if it relies on the cooperative scheme. Indeed, if the main consideration for participation in the collective is just the actual contributions individuals make to it, then this de facto undercuts discriminations. Undeniably, race and gender discriminations have intersected and continue to do so, with social representations of occupations and activities. But this is not to be attributed to the logic of work but rather to social logics of hierarchy and discriminatory cultural representations. Cooperation by contrast entails that only the actual contribution, what it took to deliver an output and how useful that output is to individual and collective life, matters. From this technical, ‘poietic’ point of view, neither race, nor gender, nor age, nor any other factor, should matter. Arguably therefore, a social bond that is solely based on effective cooperation has greater chances of undercutting discriminations and ideologically based inequalities. Conclusion The ills of contemporary work that post-work theorists highlight only prove that the current organisation of work should be changed, not that we should ‘abolish work’ (Ford, 2016). Indeed, correcting the injustices and pathologies linked to the contemporary organisation of work and employment can be formulated precisely in reference to the goods work can deliver. Against inequality, all contributors to the cooperative scheme should receive adequate reward for their contributions. That demand is compatible with arguments in favour of a universal basic income. If contribution to cooperation is to be a central aspect of individual and social life, then proper institutional and legal mechanisms need to be in place so that individuals are protected from the precarious features of contemporary working conditions. Indeed, insisting on the goods of work is even compatible with a demand that work take less place in our lives. Post-work theorists might raise a final objection. It is all well and good, they might say, to ask that work be organised differently. But what would that new organisation look like, and how would we get there? How likely is such a social organisation in the current circumstances? The answer to this objection can be very modest: these are tricky questions indeed, but it is not as if post-work models themselves are able to show how we would achieve a post-work society. Post-work theorists claim that, if only everyone else realised it, we could easily move to such a society, that we are already in it in a sense. The problem with this claim is that many people still seem to believe that there is tight link between justice, welfare and work. Rather than telling everyone they are wrong, it might be a better strategy to try and understand why there might indeed be a link between fair work, flourishing and a just society and to set to work to make this link effective.