Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Job Loss Coming- AI

Advancements in tech have added millions of job to the economy – this trajectory will continue

Thierer 23 (Adam Thierer - senior research fellow in technology and innovation at the R Street Institute. “Artificial intelligence is not going to take all our jobs.” The Hill. 3/22/23. https://thehill.com/opinion/congress-blog/3913530-artificial-intelligence-is-not-going-to-take-all-our-jobs/)

Why isn’t everyone already unemployed? After all, experts have been predicting for decades that technological automation might soon take most of our jobs. With the rise of even more powerful artificial intelligence (AI) and robotic technologies, these same fears are leading to a fresh round of worse-case forecasts about the displacement of skills and sectors. A new study forecasts that “up to 49 percent of workers could have half or more of their tasks exposed” to AI-powered large language models like OpenAI’s GPT-4. A decade ago, researchers at the University of Oxford published a widely cited study that similarly predicted 47 percent of U.S. jobs were at high risk of automation. The good news is that the sky is not falling due to AI. Largely the opposite of what the Oxford scholars predicted about AI job losses came true. Since 2013, the U.S. economy has added 16 million jobs and the unemployment rate fell steadily despite continued automation and increasing robotization of many workplaces. The profession that the Oxford report said faced the highest risk of technological disruption—insurance underwriters—saw employment grow 16.4 percent. Meanwhile, the biggest employment problem the economy faces today is that many business sectors are struggling to find workers to fill open positions. The White House even announced a set of new initiatives to lure more Americans back into the workforce. There are other reasons to be skeptical about grim forecasts regarding AI and employment. First, many past predictions about technologically induced unemployment were wrong because, as noted in a new R Street Institute report on the history of automation fears, we often lack the imagination to describe future jobs or worker skills. A review of old government labor market forecasts or economic papers finds no mention of today’s hottest jobs or skills. Glassdoor’s 2022 best jobs list includes job titles such as: full stack engineer, enterprise architect and machine learning engineer. These jobs would not have been comprehensible to analysts or economists in past decades. Second, pundits often fail to appreciate how humans adapt rapidly in the face of technological change. Where experts see ominous threats because of new technologies, many others see an opportunity to create new businesses and jobs. A new book, “Working with AI: Real Stories of Human-Machine Collaboration,” offers dozens of case studies of firms integrating algorithmic technologies in the workplace today and shows how organizations are “practicing augmentation, not large-scale automation.” We are using our machines to create entirely new skills and professions. We’ve seen this story before. Until the 1960s, human “calculators” did hard math on paper and chalkboards until mainframe computers came along and took over those jobs. But that automation freed up those workers to build even better computing machines. The result was the digital revolution, with entrepreneurs and workers seizing new opportunities. Finally, many technological trends get over-hyped but often fail to materialize. The past decade has seen a lot of hype about autonomous vehicles, leading to much speculation about the potential for job loss for professional drivers. But it turns out that robotic driving is much harder than anticipated and there continues to be a massive shortage of human drivers. Market forecasts also tend to overlook how social norms and cultural resistance affect technological adoption. A robot could potentially cut your hair or even be your therapist, but in both cases most people will want an actual human doing that job. Many tasks on airplanes today are handled by autopilot technology, which has dramatically improved aviation safety, but we still want human pilots in the cockpit.

2023 CNDI Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Job Loss Coming- AI

AI creates millions of new jobs

Ascott 21 (Emma Ascott – contributing writer. “AI Will Create 97 Million Jobs, But Workers Don’t Have The Skills Required (Yet).” Allwork. 11/19/21. https://allwork.space/2021/11/ai-will-create-97-million-jobs-but-workers-dont-have-the-skills-required-yet/)

Artificial intelligence technologies have reduced repetitive work and enhanced work efficiency, and as a result, almost every industry in the world is planning to leverage AI or has already implemented it in their business. Despite the misconception that automation and AI decreases job opportunities, it may actually prompt a huge spike in new positions. According to the World Economic Forum Future of Jobs Report, 85 million jobs will be replaced by machines with AI by the year 2025. While that statistic might make you uneasy, the same report states that 97 million new jobs will be created by 2025 due to AI. The question is no longer whether AI will change the workplace; it’s how companies can successfully use it in ways that enable – not replace – the human workforce. AI will help to make humans faster, more efficient, and more productive. What jobs will AI actually replace? It’s true that AI will threaten some unskilled jobs through automation, but it will also potentially create different kinds of jobs that require new skill sets that will be developed through training. AI can be used in manufacturing to make processes more efficient while also keeping human workers out of harm’s way. Opportunities to leverage AI and machine learning in manufacturing include product development, logistics optimization, predictive maintenance, and robotics. In all likelihood, AI will take over jobs that require copying, pasting, transcribing, and typing. In areas such as medical diagnosis, speech translation, and accounting, AI has outperformed humans in every way. But AI will not be able to replace human judgment. AI is just the most recent manifestation of ongoing workplace evolution. Finding the things that are worth teaching to the AI will still always be a job in the hands of humans. While this might not be true forever, AI isn’t capable of developing complex strategies or thinking critically through complicated scenarios. There is a certain element of human intuition that’s critical, and many people will turn to AI to assist them in thinking through problems – but ultimately, humans will make the decision. What jobs will AI create? AI has accelerated demand for positions like machine learning engineers, robotics engineers, and data scientists over the last five years. A number of positions are already developing around AI, such as AI trainers, individuals to support data science, and capabilities related to modeling, computational intelligence, machine learning, mathematics, psychology, linguistics, and neuroscience. PwC estimated that the healthcare industry will benefit the most from the use of AI, where job opportunities could increase by nearly 1 million. In the near future, the requirement for AI-assisted healthcare technician jobs will see an upward surge. AI is already playing a major role in the automated transportation sector. Companies like Uber and Google are investing millions of dollars into AI-driven self-driving cars and trucks. As this mode of transportation picks up in the future, it will create plenty of vacancies for AI and machine learning engineers. As AI gets implemented in every industry, the demand for an AI maintenance workforce is going to skyrocket. Companies would need large amounts of AI developers and engineers to maintain their systems. AI will help companies scale up. If AI and machine learning algorithms can competently use large amounts of big data, it will help companies perform better. It will also increase the employee retention rate and help in new customer acquisition, which will create new job opportunities as companies begin to scale up and grow. Humans will need to up-skill According to Mohit Josh at Bengaluru, India-based Infosys, there aren’t enough qualified workers available to fill all of the AI-related roles. “Currently there is a widespread shortage of talent that possesses the knowledge and capabilities to properly build, fuel, and maintain these technologies within their organizations. The lack of well-trained professionals who can build and direct a company’s AI and digital transformation journeys noticeably hinders progress and continues to be a major hurdle for businesses,” he said. Businesses should enforce on-the-job training and re-skilling. With the proper staff powering AI, employees are able to focus on other critical activities and boost productivity.

2023 CNDI Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Job Loss Coming- AI

No job loss now – AI increases employment opportunities

Gross 23 (Raushan Gross - Associate Professor of Business Management at Pfeiffer University. “The Fear of Mass Unemployment Due to Artificial Intelligence and Robotics Is Unfounded.” Mises Institute. 3/16/23. https://mises.org/wire/fear-mass-unemployment-due-artificial-intelligence-and-robotics-unfounded#:~:text=While%20AI%20and%20robotics%20have,Carnegie%20Endowment%20for%20International%20Peace.)

Although robotics can turn materials into economic goods in a fraction of the time it would take a human, in some cases using minimal human energy, some claim that AI and robotics will actually bring about increasing human employment. According to a 2020 Forbes projection, AI and robotics will be a strong creator of jobs and work for people across the globe in the near future. However, also in 2020, Daron Acemoglu and Pascual Restrepo published a study that projected negative job growth when AI and robotics replace human jobs, predicting significant job loss each time a robot replaces a human in the workplace. But two years later, an article in The Economist showed that many economists have backtracked on their projection of a high unemployment rate due to AI and robotics in the workplace. According to the 2022 Economist article, “Fears of a prolonged period of high unemployment did not come to pass. . . . The gloomy narrative, which says that an invasion of job-killing robots is just around the corner, has for decades had an extraordinary hold on the popular imagination.” So which scenario is correct? Contrary to popular belief, no industrialized nation has ever completely replaced human energy with technology in the workplace. For instance, the steam shovel never put construction workers out of work; whether people want to work in construction is a different question. And bicycles did not become obsolete because of vehicle manufacturing: “Consumer spending on bicycles and accessories peaked at $8.3 billion in 2021,” according to an article from the World Economic Forum. Do people generally think AI and robotics can run an economy without human involvement, energy, ingenuity, and cooperation? While AI and robotics have boosted economies, they cannot plan or run an economy or create technological unemployment worldwide. “Some countries are in better shape to join the AI competition than others,” according to the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Although an accurate statement, it misses the fact that productive economies adapt to technological changes better than nonproductive economies. Put another way, productive people are even more effective when they use technology. Firms using AI and robotics can lower production costs, lower prices, and stimulate demand; hence, employment grows if demand and therefore production increase. In the unlikely event that AI or robotic productive technology does not lower a firm’s prices and production costs, employment opportunities will decline in that industry, but employment will shift elsewhere, potentially expanding another industry’s capacity. This industry may then increase its use of AI and robotics, creating more employment opportunities there. In the not-so-distant past, office administrators did not know how to use computers, but when the computer entered the workplace, it did not eliminate administrative employment as was initially predicted. Now here we are, walking around with minicomputers in our pants pockets. The introduction of the desktop computer did not eliminate human administrative workers—on the contrary, the computer has provided more employment since its introduction in the workplace. Employees and business owners, sometimes separated by time and space, use all sorts of technological devices, communicate with one another across vast networks, and can be increasingly productive. I remember attending a retirement party held by a company where I worked decades ago. The retiring employee told us all a story about when the company brought in its first computer back in the late ’60s. The retiree recalled, “The boss said we were going to use computers instead of typewriters and paper to handle administrative tasks. The next day, her department went from a staff of thirty to a staff of five.” The day after the department installed computers, twenty-five people left the company to seek jobs elsewhere so they would not “have to learn and deal with them darn computers.” People often become afraid of losing their jobs when firms introduce new technology, particularly technology that is able to replicate human tasks. However, mass unemployment due to technological innovation has never happened in any industrialized nation. The notion that AI will disemploy humans in the marketplace is unfounded. Mike Thomas noted in his article “Robots and AI Taking Over Jobs: What to Know about the Future of Jobs” that “artificial intelligence is poised to eliminate millions of current jobs—and create millions of new ones.” The social angst about the future of AI and robotics is reminiscent of the early nineteenth-century Luddites of England and their fear of replacement technology. Luddites, heavily employed in the textile industry, feared the weaving machine would take their jobs. They traveled throughout England breaking and vandalizing machines and new manufacturing technology because of their fear of technological unemployment. However, as the textile industry there became capitalized, employment in that industry actually grew. History tells us that technology drives the increase of work and jobs for humans, not the opposite. We should look forward to unskilled and semiskilled workers’ upgrading from monotonous work because of AI and robotics. Of course, AI and robotics will have varying effects on different sectors; but as a whole, they are enablers and amplifiers of human work. As noted, the steam shovel did not disemploy construction workers. The taxi industry was not eliminated because of Uber’s technology; if anything, Uber’s new AI technology lowered the barriers of entry to the taxi industry. Musicians were not eliminated when music was digitized; instead, this innovation gave musicians larger platforms and audiences, allowing them to reach millions of people with the swipe of a screen. And dating apps running on AI have helped millions of people fall in love and live happily ever after.

2023 CNDI Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Job Loss Coming- AI

New tech won’t replace jobs- it complements work instead of replacing it and increases the value of non-automated work

Lincicome 2023

Scott Lincicome is the director of general economics and . He writes on international and domestic economic issues, including international trade; subsidies and industrial policy; manufacturing and global supply chains; and economic dynamism.; AI Is coming for Our Jobs (and That’s Okay); Februrary 8,2023; CATO; https://www.cato.org/commentary/ai-coming-our-jobs-thats-okay

Instead, humans—and markets—adjust in two ways .First, we learn to use whatever new technology comes along, so that it complements our work instead of consuming it. One of the more famous and commonly cited examples of this phenomenon is ATMs, which many predicted would make bank tellers obsolete. Yet, as Boston University’s James Bessen showed in a great , the rapid deployment of ATMs in the 1980s and 90s actually coincided with a small increase in U.S. bank teller employment over the same period: He cites two reasons for this surprising result, each of which shows how humans and markets react to new technologies in unexpected ways: First, ATMs increased the demand for tellers because they reduced the cost of operating a bank branch. Thanks to the ATM, the number of tellers required to operate a branch office in the average urban market fell from 20 to 13 between 1988 and 2004. But banks responded by opening more branches to compete for greater market share. Bank branches in urban areas increased 43 percent. Fewer tellers were required for each branch, but more branches meant that teller jobs did not disappear .Second, while ATMs automated some tasks, the remaining tasks that were not automated became more valuable. As banks pushed to increase their market shares, tellers became an important part of the “relationship banking team.” Many bank customers’ needs cannot be handled by machines—particularly small business customers’. Tellers who form a personal relationship with these customers can help sell them on high‐​margin financial services and products. The skills of the teller changed: cash handling became less important and human interaction more important.In a subsequent , Bessen looked at the proliferation of computers since the 1980s and found similar effects. In fact, employment in occupations that used computers grew faster, not slower, than ones “protected” from this supposedly job‐​killing technology. Even highly routine and middle‐​wage occupations—jobs more likely to be destroyed—increased in these industries. It was only the lowest‐​skill jobs that shrunk.

2023 CNDI Negative
Federal Jobs Guarantee NEG › AT: Inequality Adv › AT: Job Loss Coming- AI

AI won’t cause massive job loss- Humans can adapt and we have long history of disruptive technologies

Lincicome 2023

Scott Lincicome is the director of general economics and . He writes on international and domestic economic issues, including international trade; subsidies and industrial policy; manufacturing and global supply chains; and economic dynamism.; AI Is coming for Our Jobs (and That’s Okay); Februrary 8,2023; CATO; https://www.cato.org/commentary/ai-coming-our-jobs-thats-okay

The lump of labor fallacy is the assumption that there is a fixed amount of work to be done. If this were true, new jobs could not be generated, just redistributed. Those who believe the fallacy have often felt threatened by new technology or the entrance of new people into the labor force. These fears are rooted in a mistaken zero‐​sum view of the economy, which holds that when someone gains in a transaction, someone else loses. It’s a tempting idea to some because it seems to be true. For example, jobs can be lost to automation and immigration. However, that is not the full story. In reality, the demand for labor is not fixed. Changes in one industry can be offset, or overshadowed, by growth in another. And as the labor force grows, total employment increases too. This includes radical changes in technology that at the time raised widespread fears of mass unemployment. Such fears, of course, date back centuries,  than the famous  weavers destroying the early 19th century textile machines (and whole factories) that threatened their jobs and lifestyles. Yet research consistently shows that, while technology can and does displace some types of jobs, as well as some tasks at the jobs that aren’t destroyed entirely, fears of jobless hordes simply haven’t materialized.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: T – Social Security › 2AC --- Definitions

“Social Security” is a social insurance program that provides old-age and survivors assistance.

Marriam-Webster 08 [Merriam-Webster.com Dictionary, s.v. “social security,” 1908, .] AW

Social security noun 1: the principle or practice or a program of public provision (as through social insurance or assistance) for the economic security and social welfare of the individual and his or her family especially, Social Security : a U.S. government program established in 1935 to include old-age and survivors insurance, contributions to state unemployment insurance, and old-age assistance 2: money paid out through a social security program

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: T – Social Security › 2AC --- Definitions

Social Security includes Medicare

SSA No Date [Social Security Administration, “Welcome to Social Security”, SSA.gov, No date, https://www.ssa.gov/about-ssa] AW 


Welcome to Social Security Social Security provides financial protection for our nation’s people, supporting Americans throughout all of life’s journeys. We administer retirement, disability, survivor, and family benefits, and enroll individuals in Medicare. We also provide Social Security Numbers, which are unique identifiers needed to work, handle financial transactions, and determine eligibility for certain government services. Explore our mission and structure Looking towards retirement Social Security provides retirement income for almost every American worker. We also administer Supplemental Security Income (SSI) to some individuals 65 and older who have limited income and resources.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: T – Social Security › 2AC --- Definitions

Medicare is part of Social Security

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services 12 [U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, When should I sign up for Medicare?, HHS.gov, 2-9-12, https://www.hhs.gov/answers/medicare-and-medicaid/when-should-i-sign-up-for-medicare/index.html] AW 


Generally, we advise people to sign up for Medicare when they’re first eligible to avoid a gap in coverage and/or late enrollment penalties. For most people, Medicare eligibility starts three months before turning 65 and ends three months after turning 65. If you’re already getting Social Security benefits, you’ll be automatically enrolled in Medicare Part A and Part B (you don’t need to apply). However, because you must pay a premium for Part B coverage, you have the option of turning it down. You’ll get your Medicare card about three months before you turn 65. (Note: Residents of Puerto Rico or foreign countries won’t get Part B automatically. They must sign up for this benefit.) If you don’t get Medicare automatically, here are some ways to sign up*: Online (at Social Security) – You’ll need to create your secure my Social Security account to sign up for Medicare or apply for benefits. Call Social Security at 1-800-772-1213. TTY users can call 1-800-325-0778. Contact your local Social Security office. If you or your spouse worked for a railroad, call the Railroad Retirement Board at 1-877-772-5772. *When you sign up for Medicare, you can also apply for Social Security benefits at the same time if you want.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Cap K › 2AC --- Nationalism = Colonialism

Nationalism Encourages Imperialism and Colonialism

Anna Presnail 20—Writer at the University of Alabama at Birmingham “The Rising Trend of Nationalism and Its Implications on Human Rights” UAB Institute for Human Rights Blog, October 21,2020, -AZ

Nationalism is the strong support of a country, akin to patriotism. Self-determining nationalism refers to a desire for a state rooted in a self-identity. This is the basis of white nationalism, the desire for a white state. Some people may believe that nationalism is rooted in the American story and that without it the Constitution might not even exist. However, realistically, racism and racists in general feel represented and validated by Donald Trump’s form of nationalism. The campaign of “America First” and “Make America Great Again” are set in a very distinctively nationalist direction. The primary issue with this stance is that Donald Trump’s definition of “American” excludes quite a few groups of people who live in the United States. This is called ethnonationalism. A few examples of the ethnonationalist tactics employed by Donald Trump and his party include the creation and fascination with the border wall between the United States and Mexico, the Muslim ban, and the active separation of families along the Mexican border, among many others. Similarly, a rise in white nationalism has occurred, encouraged by the Donald Trump base. Nationalism Throughout History During the Industrial Revolution, it became apparent that aspects of a shared identity, such as shared literacy in a single language, would be important to a nation’s success. Thus, the assimilation of groups outside of the collective norm of the country became perceived as a top priority. This assimilation happened through civic institutions but also through ethnic cleansing, war, and other violent methods in order to completely wipe out any cultures or traditions considered to be “different” from the nation’s own. In the 1900s, there was a separation created between the ideas of ‘liberal capitalism’ and ‘nationalist democracy.’ This history lesson is to depict the ebbs and flows of nationalism throughout history. It is not uncommon to witness a resurgence of nationalism; however it is important to understand the negative consequences in order to navigate the resurgence in the most effective way for all groups. Benefits and Dangers of Nationalism can be utilized for development. Throughout history, nationalism can be attributed to a rise in the buying and selling of domestic products, recruitment in the military, and general patriotism. The idea of a shared identity connected to a country is a motivator among citizens. In Korea and Taiwan officials were able to implement the Japanese inspired top-down nationalist model that greatly encouraged growth. However, nationalism can also encourage exclusion and competition. In Europe, imperialism and colonization were often justified by nationalism. These were two techniques employed by western countries to overtake and completely control countries in Africa and in the Asia, the extremely negative consequences of which are still being seen today. During World War II, Adolf Hitler employed nationalist techniques in order to secure his base and rationalize his tactics as in the best interest for Germany. Nationalist sentiment, seen as establishing one group to be the rightful citizens of a country, is dangerous in an increasingly globalized world Pro Vox sign. Nationalism Across the Globe After 2016, there was a large rise in nationalist sentiment across the world. Perhaps the most popular stage for this phenomenon was the United States with the election of Donald Trump, who ran on a nationalist platform with the slogan, “America First.” In Germany, the nationalist AfD party has become a major opposition party, and in Spain right-wing Vox has become prominent within the Spanish Parliament. Similarly, nationalist leaders have ascended onto the political stage in China, the Philippines, and Turkey. Nations are no longer made up of a single ethnic, religious, or language group. This increase in exclusionary nationalism that we are seeing could prove to be potentially very dangerous for the groups considered to be “outsiders.” It is important to understand the many different facets of nationalism in order to protect against the negative consequences it brings as these political leaders rise in popularity.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Cap K › 2AC --- Link Turn

Single-payer healthcare is the first step away from capitalism.

Waitzkin 18 [Howard Waitzkin is part of an international network of health workers, activists, and thinkers dedicated to helping provide a "good life" for those requiring health care services and social conditions that determine good health, “HEALTH CARE under the KNIFE Moving Beyond Capitalism for Our Health,” Monthly Review Press, 2018, ] WC

In the United States, the road ahead will involve intensified organizing to achieve the single-payer model of a national health program, a model that aims to provide universal access to care and to control costs by drastically reducing or eliminating administrative waste, profiteering, and corporate control. Adam Gaffney, David Himmelstein, and Steffie Woolhander in the next chapter present the most recent revision of the single-payer proposal developed by Physicians for a National Health Program during the late 1980s and most recently published during May 2016 in the American Journal of Public Health. Versions of this proposal have been introduced into the Senate by Bernie Sanders and the House of Representatives by John Conyers, with more than a hundred congressional co-sponsors. Adam, David, and Steffie, lead authors of the revised PNHP proposal, first analyze the three main ways that the interests of capital have encroached on U.S. health care during the decades since the original PNHP proposal: 1) the rise of for-profit managed care organizations (MCOs), 2) the emergence of high-deductible (“consumer-directed”) health insurance, and 3) the entrenchment of corporate ownership. They offer a critique of Obamacare, explaining and demystifying such innovations as Accountable Care Organizations, the consolidation and integration of health systems, and increasing share of costs for patients. The authors then summarize the key elements of the revised single-payer proposal, including its provisions about coverage, financing, and transition from the current corporatized and financialized arrangements, and comment on shifts in needed strategy during the era of Trump. Improved medical care for physical illnesses remains an incomplete goal if it does not encompass a holistic vision of health that includes improved mental health as well. But what are the prospects for mental health during this waning phase of the world capitalist system? Updating and refining a perspective previously developed by Erich Fromm, Carl Ratner, a cultural psychologist and activist who has written widely on mental health under capitalism, mental health innovations in other countries, and cooperatives as an incompletely realized model for progressive organizational change, argues that mental health under capitalism entails “pathological normalcy.” Seen through this lens, the day- to-day economic insecurities, violence, and lack of social solidarity experienced in capitalist society generate a kind of false consciousness, in which disordered mental processes become a necessary facet of survival, and emotional health becomes a deviant and marginalized condition. Carl dissects the well-known crises of our age in terms of the pathologies that have become seen as normal conditions of life: a normally polluted natural environment, a normally corrupt political system, a normally unequal hierarchy of social stratification, a normally unjust criminal justice system, normally violent living conditions due to the marketing of guns, normally dangerous working conditions, and so forth. Thus “pathologically normal economic practices—the daily manipulation, cheating, speculation, de- skilling, outsourcing, tax code revisions, and exploitation—are more destructive than the criminal thief.” Reckoning the implications for the road ahead, Carl argues that the struggle for improved mental health conditions cannot limit itself to reforms in the delivery of services but must entail a struggle to change the economic, political, and social underpinnings of pathological normalcy. Despite our own and others’ efforts to improve access to health and mental health services, we recognize that such services are not the main determinants of health and mental health outcomes. As Carles Muntaner and evolutionary biologist Rob Wallace, who has done extensive research focusing on the impact of capitalist agriculture on infections, especially epidemics such as influenza, Ebola, and Zika, show in their chapter, social and environmental conditions have become more important determinants of health than access to care, and such broader conditions explain the greatest part of the variation in health outcomes. Concerning social determinants, Carles in prior work has focused on social class and has considered differing conceptualizations of class. He has shown the advantage of a theoretical and empirical definition of social class rooted in relations of economic production, as opposed to the more commonly used demographic indicators of inequality such as income, education, and prestige. The latter indicators impede clarity of understanding about the conditions that separate the 1 percent from the 99 percent; they also mystify needed directions of political change through the notion that adjusting “disparities” in income can produce more favorable health and mental health outcomes. The authors emphasize struggles that directly confront social determinants through changes in broad societal policies. They also analyze some of the key environmental determinants of health, including unsafe water (citing the egregious example of Flint, Michigan), capitalist agribusiness practices, and deforestation in addition to climate change. They refer especially to the impact of these environmental determinants on emergent and re-emergent infectious diseases like Ebola, Zika, and yellow fever. To conclude the book, Adam Gaffney and I try to tackle the inevitable question of “what is to be done.” First, let me express my delight to collaborate with Adam. While I and several other authors of this book are closer to the end of our work lives than the beginning, Adam is much closer to the beginning. As a physician, historian, and activist (among other things), Adam is one of an emerging cadre of young people who will carry forth this struggle in future years, and their brilliance and audacity in doing so give us much hope. In our conclusion, we recognize at the outset that we hold no corner on strategic truth, given the complexities and challenges of current realities. Still, we see four main priorities for action in the United States and in other countries still affected by the neoliberal, corporatized, and commodified model of health care during the era of Trump: 1) a sustained, broad-based movement for a single-payer national health program that assures universal access to care and drastically reduces the role of corporations and private profit; 2) an activated labor movement that this time includes a well-organized sub-movement of health professionals such as physicians, whose deteriorated social-class position and proletarianized conditions of medical practice have made them ripe for activism and change; 3) more emphasis on local and regional organizing at the level of communal organizations as envisioned by István Mészáros and attempted in multiple countries as a central component in the revolutionary process of moving “beyond capital”;7 and 4) carefully confronting the role of political parties while recognizing the importance of labor or otherwise leftist parties in every country that has constructed a national health program, and understanding that the importance of party building goes far beyond electoral campaigns to more fundamental social transformation. All these priorities emphasize the urgency of creating bridges that link health activism with social movements that focus on social-class oppression, including poverty and inequality, racism, sexism, environmental degradation, militarism and imperialism, and the dominant ideologies that lead women and men to accept pathological social conditions as normal. With these contributions by leading scholars and activists based in several countries, our book tries to answer key and previously unresolved questions and to offer some guidance on strategy and political action in the years ahead. Through this work, we aim to inform future struggles for the transformation of capitalist societies, as well as the progressive reconstruction of health services and public health systems in the post- capitalist world. At roughly the same stage in my work life as Adam’s now, I asked (with a colleague), “Is a humane health care system possible in a capitalist society?” My focus then, as it remains today, involved “the exploitation of illness in capitalist society” and the “forms of social organization which foster this exploitation.”8 As the contradictions and weaknesses of global capitalism grow more profound and as the need for revolutionary transformation becomes clearer and more urgent, a non-exploitative health care system has entered the realm of the imaginable and the possible. The road leading to that place, for all its challenges, must become the road that travels “beyond capital” and beyond capitalism.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: States CP › 2AC --- States Lack the Funds

States are unable to fund single payer healthcare, states don’t have the budget.

Yi ’22 Jean Yi is a former politics intern at FiveThirtyEight. “More States Are Proposing Single-Payer Health Care. Why Aren’t They Succeeding?” FiveThirtyEight, March 9th, 2022. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/more-states-are-proposing-single-payer-health-care-why-arent-they-succeeding/

One big reason single-payer proposals haven’t caught on at the state level is because finding a reliable way to pay for such a program is challenging. Single-payer advocates originally envisioned a federal proposal that would cover all Americans under a more generous version of a preexisting program — that is, Medicare, but now for all. Doing this state-by-state would require each state to apply for waivers to divert federal funds used for Medicare, Medicaid and Affordable Care Act exchanges to be used for their own single-payer plans. And that’s tricky because the Department of Health and Human Services has wide discretion to approve or deny states’ requests, which makes any proposal highly dependent on the national political climate. Recent Stories from FiveThirtyEight This isn’t just a theoretical debate either: Trump’s administrator for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Seema Verma said in 2018 that she would deny waivers from states to create single-payer systems, while Biden’s Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra has expressed more favorable sentiments. Almost all single-payer proposals depend on these waivers and states don’t often have fallback plans for if this federal funding gets denied. Employer-sponsored health insurance plans, which cover 54 percent of Americans, are another hurdle for states trying to pass single-payer health care. Federal law largely prevents states from regulating employer-provided health insurance, so states can’t just stop employers from offering their own health care benefits. The exact scope of this law has been litigated for decades, but suffice it to say that it’s successfully put the kibosh on many statewide health care reforms. Single-payer health insurance is particularly tricky as there’s no way to get everyone onto the plan without first changing how private insurance works. States have tried to address this through measures like increasing payroll taxes or restricting providers’ ability to accept reimbursement from private insurance plans. But the more elaborate these mechanisms get, the more complicated it becomes to implement — and the more people that could slip through the cracks. Finally, another big financial barrier is that state governments have far less leeway than the federal government to increase budgetary spending. That means tax increases, which come with their own political challenges, are often necessary for states to secure the funding they need. Take California’s single-payer proposal, which failed in late January. It would have required two-thirds of voters to pass a separate constitutional amendment to implement the necessary tax increases to pay for it. Concerns over tax increases also contributed to the demise of single-payer proposals in Colorado and Vermont. It’s true that a recent analysis of New York’s single-payer health care plan found that it would lower overall health care spending by 3 percent by 2031, but it would also require additional state tax revenue of $139 billion in 2022 — over 150 percent of the current state budget. Politicians facing the next election cycle may be leery of proposing short-term tax increases, even if the end result is long-term savings.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Politics › 2AC --- Plan is Popular

Single Payer popular—increasing number of Americans favor each year.

Jones 20 (Bradley Jones, Former Senior Researcher, Pew Research Center, “Increasing Share of Americans Favor a Single Government Program to Provide Health Care Coverage” September 29 2020, AZ

A majority of Americans continue to say the federal government has a responsibility to make sure all Americans have health care coverage. And since last year, there has been an increase – especially among Democrats – in the share saying health insurance should be provided by a single national program run by the government. How we did this Among the public overall, 63% of U.S. adults say the government has the responsibility to provide health care coverage for all, up slightly from 59% last year. Roughly a third (37%) say this is not the responsibility of the federal government, according to a Pew Research Center survey conducted July 27 to Aug. 2 among 11,001 adults. When asked how the government should provide health insurance coverage, 36% of Americans say it should be provided through a single national government program, while 26% say it should continue to be provided through a mix of private insurance companies and government programs. This is a change from about a year ago, when nearly equal shares supported a “single payer” health insurance program (30%) and a mix of government programs and private insurers (28%). Most of the increase has come among Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents. A 54% majority of Democrats and Democratic leaners now favor a single national government program to provide health insurance, up from 44% last year. Support for single payer health coverage has increased among most groups of Democrats, including those who describe their political views as very liberal (up from 66% to 77%), liberal (50% to 61%) and conservative or moderate (35% to 43%). Among Republicans and Republican leaners, a 66% majority says the government does not have the responsibility to make sure all Americans have health care coverage. Among the one-third of Republicans who say the government does have this responsibility, opinion is divided over whether or not it should be provided through a single government program or a mix of private and government programs. Although most Republicans say it is not the government’s responsibility to ensure health coverage for all, a 54% majority says the government “should continue to provide programs like Medicare and Medicaid for seniors and the very poor.” Only 11% of Republicans say the government should not be involved at all in providing health insurance. While divisions remain within the Democratic Party about the best way to provide health insurance, increasing shares across most demographic and ideological groups support a single national government program. Very liberal Democrats, constituted 15% of Democratic registered voters, are far more likely than liberal Democrats (32% of Democrats) and moderates and conservatives (51%) to say that health insurance should be provided by a single government program. White Democrats remain more likely than those of other races and ethnicities to support a single national program, but White, Black and Hispanic Democrats have each increased their support for a single national program by about 10 percentage points since last year. A similar pattern emerges with age: Younger Democrats are still more supportive than older Democrats, but Democrats of all ages have increased their support over the past year.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Spending Turn › 2AC --- Helps the Middle Class

The US middle class will thrive on cheaper healthcare with single-pay healthcare.

Francis 21’ [(Lizzy Francis- News Editor at Fatherly, where she edits news and reports on the public policy that affects the day-to-day lives of working parents.) “Medicare For All Would Benefit the American Middle Class and American Businesses” Updated( 10-12-2021) 09-06-2019]

Today, individually insured middle class families spend about 15.5 percent of their income on health care — not counting what their employees cover in premiums before their pay even hits their paycheck. Meanwhile, the wealthiest Americans actually receive such great tax exemptions for their health care spending that they receive a surplus of .1 percent to .9 percent on top of their income. “Overall health expenditures throughout the whole economy will go down, due to the efficiencies of a single payer system,” says Matt Bruenig, lawyer, policy analyst, and founder of the People’s Policy Project, a think tank that studies single-payer healthcare. “And the distribution of those expenditures and who pays for those expenditures will be shifted up the income ladder. Middle class families can expect at least thousands of dollars of savings a year from not having to pay premiums or co-pays,” he says. Today, families that make about $60,000 a year spend about $10,000 of their pay on health care. Under universal health care, they would pay less than $1,000 in taxes and no longer have to pay deductibles, deal with surprise billing, or contend with the fact that a major medical event could bankrupt them. Aside from costs, there are more reasons our current healthcare system is failing families. For example, even someone on employer-sponsored health insurance who might like their health insurance has a one in four chance of getting kicked off of it over the course of any given year. And given that today the average worker has about 11 jobs from age 18 to 50, per Bruenig, health insurance turnover is all but inevitable for the modern worker. The numbers on insurance turnover are alarming, starting with the fact that about 28 million Americans have no insurance at all. All of these people likely got kicked off of their insurance: the 3.7 million people who turned 65 in 2017, the 22 million people who were fired in 2018, the 40.1 million people who quit their jobs in 2018, and the employees who work at 15 percent of companies with employer-sponsored health insurance that switched carriers, the latter of which changes the providers that employees can see and causes a lot of paperwork. Then one must consider the 1.5 million people who got divorced in 2015 and 7.4 million people who moved states and the 35 percent of people on Medicaid had their income increase to the point where they were too well off for Medicaid but not well off enough to afford other insurance plans. Beyond that, insurers are constantly changing what providers they work with, which means the doctor that someone sees in April might not be on their plan three months later. Employees and families often feel stuck to their jobs that may have a bad work-life balance, pay poorly, or otherwise not be a good fit because the costs of trying to get on another health care plan or the risks of leaving a job due to the health care plan it offers are far too high when kids are in the mix. “Having consistency is key, even for people who have jobs,” says Bruenig. “That job will only last so long before they’re off to another one. They could get fired, the company could close down. Being in the labor force and having the security that [your insurance will] follow you no matter which job you go to is useful,” says Bruenig. It’s especially useful for parents, who have more than their own health to worry about. And even people who have health insurance through their private plan or employer go bankrupt with alarming frequency. Out of pocket spending for people with employer-provided health insurance has increased by more than 50 percent in the last 10 years; half of all insurance policy holders have a deductible of at least $1,000; and most deductibles for families near $3,000. When more than 40 percent of Americans say they cannot afford an emergency expense of $400 or more, it’s a wonder to think how they could ever meet that deductible before their health insurance coverage kicks in. About one in four Americans in a 2015 poll said they could not afford medical bills, and another poll showed that half of those polled had received a medical bill that they could not afford to pay. Medical debt affects 79 million Americans, or about half of working-age people.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Spending Turn › 2AC --- AT: Single Payer Expensive

A single-payer healthcare system would decrease costs, benefitting the low-income – 19 out of 22 studies show a net increase in just a year.

Mastroianni 20 [Brian Mastroianni, a New York-based journalist who has covered everything from health and science to the arts and politics, “How a Single-Payer Healthcare System Could Save Money in a Year,” Healthline, 1-24-2020, ] [ST]

A new study published in the journal PLOS Medicine found that a single-payer healthcare system would save more money on U.S. healthcare costs over time than competing systems. Researchers looked at 22 economic analyses of national and state-level single-payer proposals made over the past 30 years. They found 19 of the 22 reviews predicted this kind of system would result in net healthcare cost savings in as soon as the first year of existence. The researchers also found that all of the examined single-payer proposals would save money by year 10. Healthcare reform — and how best to approach it — has consistently been at the center of political discourse in the United States for the past half century. From fights over scrapping, preserving, or building on the Affordable Care Act, or “Obamacare,” to discussions over instituting what is known as a “Medicare for All” single-payer system, every side of the political spectrum has been weighing in on how to tackle America’s healthcare system. This is especially so now that we find ourselves in the midst of another contentious presidential election year. A new study published in the journal PLOS Medicine looks at one approach, single-payer. The study finds that, if implemented, this system would save considerably more money on U.S. healthcare costs over time than competing systems. In the paper, researchers looked at 22 economic analyses of national and state-level single-payer proposals made over the past 30 years. The results? They found 19 of the 22 reviews predicted this kind of system would result in net healthcare cost savings in as soon as the first year of existence, coming to an average of 3.5 percent of total healthcare spending. Beyond the short-term benefits, the researchers took a look at cost projections that were made in 10 of the proposals that looked as far ahead as 11 years in the future. They found cost savings would continue to grow as time went on, given that short-term increases in healthcare use would level off and global budgets for these single-payer systems would clamp down on costs. The researchers also found that all of the examined single-payer proposals would save money by year 10. How a single-payer system would save money One of the study authors, Dr. James G. Kahn, MPH, a professor at the Institute for Health Policy Studies at University of California, San Francisco, said the research team was surprised by the similarity of total cost savings shared by all the different plans that were studied. “We knew some of the analyses, but not the relatively large number and consistency,” Kahn told Healthline. “We were also surprised that who did or supported the studies made little difference.” Lead author Christopher Cai, a third-year medical student at UCSF, agreed that this across-the-board consensus between the different proposals was most surprising about the findings. He told Healthline that his team’s research echoed other recent studies. For instance, Cai cited a report published this month in the Annals of Internal MedicineTrusted Source that revealed the U.S. could potentially save $600 billion in administrative savings if it switched over to a single-payer model. What does this mean for the average person? For many, the regularly divisive, negative political debates about healthcare reform can leave a headache. Disinformation on social media, for instance, can cloud perceptions of what is even being discussed in the first place. Even without all of these distractions, it can be confusing given the wide diversity of plans and proposals that exist. The appeal of ‘universal healthcare’ Generally, a single-payer system refers to an alternate healthcare model to the current one in the United States. Taxes would cover health expenses for the whole population, according to an overview from the Journal of General Internal MedicineTrusted Source. The goal would be for a sole public health system, like that in Canada. How would a single-payer system improve people’s day-to-day lives? Kahn said the current system is ultimately unsustainable. “Currently, people contribute to premiums, and then pay deductibles and copays. Plus, wage growth has stagnated in part because employers have had to pay more for health insurance,” he said. “With single-payer, premiums, deductibles, and most or all copays go away. Wealthier families will see their taxes rise. But for almost all lower and middle income families, the net effect will be to lower costs,” Kahn explained. He added that the families that would benefit the most from this kind of system would be those in low to middle income brackets. This would especially be beneficial for people with family members who need regular treatment for a chronic condition like diabetes. “As a country, we will pay less under single-payer, and the way this will be passed on to patients depends on the specifics of the bill. In general, Dr. Kahn is absolutely correct. Working class families are likely to see the largest benefit,” Cai said. The need to achieve essential universal healthcare for all people has been a global goal. The World Health OrganizationTrusted Source reports that at least half of the world’s population does not have “full coverage of essential health services.” Additionally, 100 million people are thrown into extreme poverty — which comes out to $1.90 or less per day — as a result of having to redirect resources to cover their health costs. More than 930 million people, or about 12 percent of the globe’s population, spends 10 percent or more of their household budgets on healthcare. As part of its Sustainable Development Goals, United Nations has issued a goal of achieving universal health coverage around the world in just 10 years, by 2030. With all of this in mind, the current reality of healthcare in the United States looks comparatively bleak. The Commonwealth Fund reports the United States ranks last “on measures of quality, efficiency, access to care, equity, and the ability to lead long, healthy, and productive lives” compared to six other industrialized nations — Australia, Canada, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. This is despite the fact that the United States has the most expensive healthcare system. A single-payer system would likely improve healthcare in America Dr. Stephanie Woolhandler, MPH, a practicing primary care physician and professor of public health and health policy at Hunter College, said that it is “very clear” based on “mountains of evidence” that people who live in countries with some form of universal single-payer health system live longer, healthier lives. “Canadians live two-and-a-half years longer than Americans,” Woolhandler told Healthline. “This wasn’t true before they implemented a single-payer system. They are now way ahead of the United States. They are spending a lot less of their GDP (gross domestic product) on healthcare.” Woolhandler is also a co-founder and board member of Physicians for a National Health Program, an organization of more than 20,000 member physicians who are advocating for a single-payer health program in the United States. She stressed that, while the largely political obstacles blocking a single-payer system are great, there have been shifting headwinds nationally. In fact, the American College of Physicians, the nation’s largest medical specialty society, recently issued their endorsement for a single-payer Medicare for All health plan. The endorsement was significant in that it’s the second-largest physicians group in the country, behind only the American Medical Association (AMA). “It really shows a sea change from when the medical profession would fairly uniformly stand in opposition to a Medicare for All-type reform,” Woolhandler added. “It’s a major change to openness to Medicare for All and an important boost to the possibilities to this kind of reform.” John McDonough, DrPH, MPA, a professor of public health practice in the Department of Health Policy & Management at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and director of executive and continuing professional education, said that if a single-payer system was created, society would certainly “see major reductions in overall health system spending by drastically lowering the administrative and other overhead costs that add little or no value.” McDonough, who previously worked on the development and passage of the Affordable Care Act as a senior advisor on National Health Reform to the U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions, said the exact cost savings from a single-payer system would depend on a range of factors, “such as the agreed-upon rate of payment for medical care providers, especially hospitals, physicians, and nurses.” He added that it also depends on whether a new system would require consumer payments. “In terms of individuals, again, details matter greatly. Many consumers and patients would see gains in coverage and affordability, and others with generous coverage pre-single-payer could perceive themselves to be losers,” McDonough told Healthline. A contentious climate Having been a part of the inception of “Obamacare,” McDonough said a new healthcare system would most likely come about in a climate where “many would perceive themselves as losers, correctly or incorrectly.” He added, “Those who would believe they would lose, rightly or wrongly, usually would have the loudest voices among the public. We saw this all the way through the creation of the Affordable Care Act, which was far more incremental than a single-payer plan would be.” McDonough explained that, in his view, it might be easier to establish a “public option,” a public plan that citizens would choose to buy into, but that would “not eliminate private health insurance” though “it could erode private insurance over time, which is why the insurance industry and many healthcare providers would fight it bitterly.” Woolhandler said past squeamishness over enacting a single-payer system has led to damaging healthcare inequities and challenges that are framed as insurmountable, but that are actually achievable. She said a lot of this framing certainly rests with the private health insurance and pharmaceutical industries and their political allies. According to Woolhandler, the “massive industries” that “profit off a market-rate health system,” such as the private health insurance industry, generate animus toward anything close to single-payer reform. “Other developed nations pay half as much on prescription drugs as the U.S. does,” she added. “The pharmaceutical industry in the U.S. has long been opposed to single-payer and knows that there’ll be some constraints on their prices in a single-payer system.” Given the roadblocks put in place by these companies, is single-payer achievable? Woolhandler and McDonough said it goes back to politics and the role of the voter. “I can’t see far into the future. In fact, I can’t see beyond next November at this point. If in the elections, Democrats hold the House of Representatives and retake control of the White House and the Senate, they will gain the Senate by a narrow margin. 60 votes would be necessary to win a Medicare for All model in the Senate, and no Republican will vote for such a plan,” McDonough said. “So the likelihood of this happening in 2021 is close to zero,” he added. “One thing about which you can be sure — no such plan would ever pass with Republicans in charge of the White House, the Senate, or the House of Reps. When we will again see unitary Democratic control, then there’s a fighting chance, though not unless Dems hold at least 60 Senate seats.” Woolhandler strikes a more optimistic tone. She said the only way for single-payer to be a reality would be for a “political movement through the electoral process.” “It all comes down to, ‘Do we have a democracy in this country?’ which I’m still hopeful in,” Woolhandler said. “Surveys show 70-plus percent of people want a Medicare for All system. It’s possible. Regardless, it will be a major issue in the upcoming presidential election. It’s certainly a key issue in the Democratic primary right now.”

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Spending Turn › 2AC --- AT: Single Payer Expensive

A single-payer approach is substantially lower than the current healthcare system – it lessens administrative costs and eliminates competitive advertising from private insurers.

Frank 17 [Robert H. Frank, an economics professor at the Johnson Graduate School of Management at Cornell University, “Why Single-Payer Health Care Saves Money,” The New York Times, 7-7-2017, ] [ST]

Lingering uncertainty about the fate of the Affordable Care Act has spurred the California legislature to consider adoption of a statewide single-payer health care system. Sometimes described as Medicare for all, single-payer is a system in which a public agency handles health care financing while the delivery of care remains largely in private hands. Discussions of the California measure have stalled, however, in the wake of preliminary estimates pegging the cost of the program as greater than the entire state government budget. Similar cost concerns derailed single-payer proposals in Colorado and Vermont. Voters need to understand that this cost objection is specious. That’s because, as experience in many countries has demonstrated, the total cost of providing health coverage under the single-payer approach is actually substantially lower than under the current system in the United States. It is a bedrock economic principle that if we can find a way to do something more efficiently, it’s possible for everyone to come out ahead. By analogy, suppose that your state’s government took over road maintenance from the county governments within it, in the process reducing total maintenance costs by 30 percent. Your state taxes would obviously have to go up under this arrangement. Health Care in the United States Profiting From Risky Procedures: Medical device makers have bankrolled a cottage industry of doctors and clinics that perform artery-clearing procedures that can lead to amputations. Private Equity’s Takeover: A new study has found that private equity firms have been gobbling up physician practices to form powerful medical groups across the country. Drug Shortages: The nation’s monthslong shortage of highly potent cancer drugs is grinding on, forcing patients and their doctors to confront gut-wrenching situations and delays in treatment. Medicare Advantage: People enrolled in these private plans may not be getting the mental health services they need because they cannot find a psychiatrist within their network, according to a new study. But if roads would be as well maintained as before, would that be a reason to oppose the move? Clearly not, since the resulting cost savings would reduce your county taxes by more than your state taxes went up. Likewise, it makes no sense to oppose single-payer on the grounds that it would require additional tax revenue. In each case, the resulting gains in efficiency would leave you with greater effective purchasing power than before. Total costs are lower under single-payer systems for several reasons. One is that administrative costs average only about 2 percent of total expenses under a single-payer program like Medicare, less than one-sixth the corresponding percentage for many private insurers. Single-payer systems also spend virtually nothing on competitive advertising, which can account for more than 15 percent of total expenses for private insurers. The most important source of cost savings under single-payer is that large government entities are able to negotiate much more favorable terms with service providers. In 2012, for example, the average cost of coronary bypass surgery was more than $73,000 in the United States but less than $23,000 in France. Despite this evidence, respected commentators continue to cite costs as a reason to doubt that single-payer can succeed in the United States. A recent Washington Post editorial, for example, ominously predicted that budget realities would dampen enthusiasm for single-payer, noting that the per capita expenditures under existing single-payer programs in the United States were much higher than those in other countries. But this comparison is misleading. In most other countries, single-payer covers the whole population, most of which has only minimal health needs. In contrast, single-payer components of the United States system disproportionately cover population subgroups with the heaviest medical needs: older people (Medicare), the poor and disabled (Medicaid) and returned service personnel (Department of Veterans Affairs). In short, the evidence is clear that single-payer delivers quality care at significantly lower cost than the current American hybrid system. It thus makes no sense to reject single-payer on the grounds that it would require higher tax revenues. That’s true, of course, but it’s an irrelevant objection. In addition to being far cheaper, single-payer would also defuse the powerful political objections to the Affordable Care Act’s participation mandate. Polls consistently show that large majorities want people with pre-existing conditions to be able to obtain health coverage at affordable rates. But that goal cannot be achieved unless healthy people are required to join the insured pool. Officials in the Obama administration tried, largely in vain, to explain why the program’s insurance exchanges would collapse in the absence of the participation mandate. But the logic of the underlying argument is actually very simple. Most people seem able to grasp it if you ask them what would happen if the government required companies to sell fire insurance at affordable rates to people whose houses had already burned down. No home insurer could remain in business if each policy it sold required it to replace a house costing several hundred thousand dollars. Similarly, no health insurer could remain in business if each of its policy holders generated many thousands of dollars in health care reimbursements each month. That’s why the lack of a mandate in the alternative plans under consideration means that millions of people with pre-existing conditions will become uninsurable if repeal efforts are successful. An underappreciated advantage of the single-payer approach is that it sidesteps the mandate objection by paying to cover everyone out of tax revenue. Of course, having to pay taxes is itself a mandate of a sort, but it’s one the electorate has largely come to terms with. Apart from fringe groups that denounce all taxation as theft, most people understand that our entire system would collapse if tax payments were purely voluntary. The Affordable Care Act is an inefficient system that was adopted only because its architects believed, plausibly, that the more efficient single-payer approach would not be politically achievable in 2009. But single-payer now enjoys significantly higher support than it did then, and is actually strongly favored by voters in some states. Solid majorities nationwide now favor expansion of the existing single-payer elements of our current system, such as Medicare and Medicaid. Medicaid cuts proposed in Congress have been roundly criticized. Perhaps it’s time to go further: Individual states and, eventually, the entire country, can save money and improve services by embracing single-payer health care.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Spending Turn › 2AC --- AT: Single Payer Expensive

A single-payer system is inexpensive – it yields net savings by cutting administrative costs, saving prescription drugs, and creating a uniform records system.

Archer 20 [Diane Archer, an attorney and health care authority, president of Just Care USA, an independent digital hub covering health and financial issues facing boomers and their families, “22 studies agree: ‘Medicare for All’ saves money,” The Hill, 2-24-20, ] [ST]

The evidence abounds: A “Medicare for All” single-payer system would guarantee comprehensive coverage to everyone in America and save money. Christopher Cai and colleagues at three University of California campuses examined 22 studies on the projected cost impact for single-payer health insurance in the United States and reported their findings in a recent paper in PLOS Medicine. Every single study predicted that it would yield net savings over several years. In fact, it’s the only way to rein in health care spending significantly in the U.S. All of the studies, regardless of ideological orientation, showed that long-term cost savings were likely. Even the Mercatus Center, a right-wing think tank, recently found about $2 trillion in net savings over 10 years from a single-payer Medicare for All system. Most importantly, everyone in America would have high-quality health care coverage. Medicare for All is far less costly than our current system largely because it reduces administrative costs. With one public plan negotiating rates with health care providers, billing becomes quite simple. We do away with three-quarters of the estimated $812 billion the U.S. now spends on health care administration. Administrative costs are so high because thousands of insurance companies individually negotiate benefit rules and rates with thousands of hospitals and doctors. On top of that, they rely on different billing procedures — and this puts a costly burden on providers. Administrative savings from Medicare for All would be about $600 billion a year. Savings on prescription drugs would be between $200 billion and $300 billion a year, if we paid about the same price as other wealthy countries pay for their drugs. A Medicare for All system would save still more with implementation of global health care spending budgets. Even more savings are possible in a Medicare for All system because, like every other wealthy country, we would have a uniform electronic health records system. Such a system generates additional savings because system problems would be easier to detect and correct. A uniform claims data system helps reduce health care spending for fraudulent services. In 2018, total U.S. health care costs were $3.6 trillion, representing 17.7 percent of GDP. Savings are in part a function of the benefits Medicare for All covers. The Mercatus report and others projected savings, even with the elimination of deductibles and out-of-pocket costs. Under both Sen. Bernie Sanders’s (I-Vt.) Medicare for All bill and Rep. Pramila Jayapal’s (D-Wash.) Medicare for All bill, patients would not pay deductibles or coinsurance when they receive medical care. Their bills also provide for vision, hearing and dental care, as well as long-term services and supports, such as home care and nursing home care. No matter how you design a single-payer public health insurance system, it would have lower overall health care costs, so long as for-profit private health insurers no longer exist to drive up health care costs. Yes, it’s true that some other wealthy countries rely on “private insurers” to provide benefits and spend far less than we do on care. But, these insurers do not operate in any way like health insurers in the U.S. Other wealthy countries dictate virtually every element of the health insurance people receive, including what’s covered, what’s paid, and people’s out-of-pocket costs — all identical for everyone. The insurers operate like claims processors or bill payers. They follow the coverage and payment rules set by the government, nothing like the private health insurers in the U.S. which revel in product diversity (read: complexity and confusion). And, if you’re thinking that having the federal government guarantee coverage to all Americans is a big deal, it’s actually not. The government already pays for about two-thirds of health care costs. Among other things, it pays for Medicare, Medicaid, VA, TriCare and a wide range of state and local health care programs, along with private insurance for government employees and tax subsidies for private insurance. Whether you call it single-payer or Medicare for All, it isn’t some socialist pipe dream. It’s a sensible, efficient, and effective way to guarantee excellent health insurance to everyone.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Spending Turn › 2AC --- AT: Single Payer Expensive

A single-payer healthcare would save the US trillions – it lessens family spending on healthcare and reduces administrative cost waste.

Public Citizen 20 [Public Citizen, a non-profit and progressive consumer rights advocacy group, “FACT CHECK: Medicare for All Would Save the U.S. Trillions; Public Option Would Leave Millions Uninsured, Not Garner Savings,” Public Citizen, 2-21-20, ] [ST]

Medicare for All opponents repeatedly claim that Medicare for All is “too expensive” by presenting misleading numbers without the proper context of our unsustainable health care spending. Here are the facts: We can’t afford NOT to implement Medicare for All. Our health care spending is estimated to continue rising and will reach nearly $6 trillion a year by 2027. That means according to the federal government, we will spend around $42.9 trillion on health care over the next decade if we maintain the status quo. Medicare for All will cost LESS than our current system. A recent study by Yale epidemiologists found that Medicare for All would save around 68,000 lives a year while reducing U.S. health care spending by around 13%, or $450 billion a year. Medicare for All spending would be approximately $37.8 trillion between 2017 and 2026, according to a study by the Political Economy Research Institute (PERI) at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. That amounts to about $5 trillion in savings over that time. These savings would come from reducing administrative costs and allowing the government to negotiate prescription drug prices. Other studies by think tanks and government agencies have analyzed single-payer proposals at the state and federal levels. Most found Medicare for All would reduce our total health care spending. Even a study by the Koch-funded Mercatus Center found that Medicare for All would save around $2 trillion over a 10-year period. With Medicare for All, most families would spend less on health care than they do now on premiums, copays and deductibles. ​​​​​​​Some additional taxes would be needed to pay for Medicare for All, but most Americans would spend less on health care than they do right now. Overall, working families that make around $60,000 a year would pay up to 14% lesson their annual health care costs. As the debate grows on how to overhaul the health care system, Medicare for All is being pitted against a public option. It’s important to highlight the differences between the policies. A public option would: Cost even more than the wasteful status quo, around $175 billion more per year. And because it wouldn’t have comparable savings from efficiencies and negotiating power, it would cost $600 billion a year more than Medicare for All without providing as generous coverage; Leave millions uninsured or underinsured and subject to unnecessary out-of-pocket costs, including copays and deductibles; Leave more than 100 million Americans at the whim of private for-profit insurance, so they would be under constant fear of disruption when their employer changes plans or they lose or change jobs; Force employers to continue to struggle with whether they can afford to provide insurance to their employees; and Enable for-profit insurers to cherry-pick healthier Americans, threatening the financial solvency of the public programs. However, Medicare for All would: Provide guaranteed health care to everyone; Provide access to home and community-based care for all who need it; Guarantee coverage for dental, vision and hearing services; End medical debt and medical bankruptcies; Reduce administrative waste by $500 billion per year; End price gouging by pharmaceutical companies; and Put an end to corporations profiting off the sick.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Spending Turn › 2AC --- AT: Single Payer Expensive

A single-payer healthcare system would save $438 billion, eliminating insurance premiums and fraud and reducing administrative overhead.

Blair 22 [Jenny Blair, Northeast magazine columnist at Yale, “Study: More Than 335,000 Lives Could Have Been Saved During Pandemic if U.S. Had Universal Health Care,” Yale School of Public Health, 6-20-2022, ] [ST]

In the United States, death rates from COVID-19 are higher than in any other high-income country—and our fragmented and inefficient health system may be largely to blame, Yale researchers say in a new study. If the U.S. had had a single-payer universal health care system in 2020, nearly 212,000 American lives would have been saved that year, according to a new study. In addition, the country would have saved $105 billion in COVID-19 hospitalization expenses alone. The research team further calculated that in a non-pandemic year, some $438 billion would be saved by single-payer universal health care, like Medicare for All. The results make a powerful case for health care reform, according to lead author Alison Galvani, Ph.D. “Americans are needlessly losing lives and money,” said Galvani, director of Yale’s Center for Infectious Disease Modeling and Analysis and an endowed chair in the Department of Epidemiology (Microbial Diseases) at the Yale School of Public Health. “Medicare for All would be both an economic stimulus and life-saving transformation of our health care system.” Methods The researchers compared people with and without health insurance, examining death rates from COVID-19 and overall. Building on earlier research, they calculated that 131,438 COVID deaths in 2020 could have been avoided with universal single-payer health care. Overall, including both COVID and non-COVID patients, 211,897 lives would have been saved in 2020 with universal care. From the start of the pandemic in the U.S. to March 2022, those preventable deaths mount to 338,594. Far from financially burdening the nation, universal single-payer health care would not only have saved lives, it would have also avoided hundreds of billions of dollars in costs. Medicare for All would reduce costs by improving access to preventive care, reducing administrative overhead, and empowering Medicare to negotiate prices, the researchers said. Single-payer health care would also eliminate pricy insurance premiums and reduce fraud. “A single-payer health care system would be much more economically efficient than our current fragmented structure and would save over $450 billion per year,” Galvani said. A better alternative The United States currently spends more on health care than any other nation—both per person and overall. Despite such heavy spending, the piecemeal nature of the U.S. medical insurance system worsened COVID-19’s effects, the researchers argue in the study. Many people without access to adequate health care delayed necessary medical treatment, postponed isolation, and kept working when they felt sick. These factors can fuel infections and deaths. Most working-age Americans rely on employer-sponsored plans, with each enrollment typically covering more than one person. That system still left 41 million Americans uninsured before the pandemic. Universal single-payer health care is both economically responsible and morally imperative. Alison Galvani Then, during the pandemic, over 9 million workers became unemployed. As a result, many people became uninsured including, in some cases, entire families. Medicare for All would save lives in a number of ways, according to the researchers: It would make it easier to access primary care, which helps people prevent or stay on top of chronic conditions like diabetes or high blood pressure. Such conditions can raise the risk of death, including from COVID. It would lower financial hurdles to seeking care for illness. It would support rural health care facilities and ease pressures on hospitals that are forced to reduce care for other conditions, such as cancer, when COVID infections surge. “Universal single-payer health care is both economically responsible and morally imperative,” Galvani said. Meagan C. Fitzpatrick, formerly of the Yale School of Public Health and now with the University of Maryland, is last author on the study. Other co-authors are Alyssa S. Parpia, Abhishek Pandey, Pratha Sah and Kenneth Colón, all of the Yale School of Public Health; Gerald Friedman and Travis Campbell of the University of Massachusetts, Amherst; James G. Kahn of the University of California, San Francisco; and Burton H. Singer of the Emerging Pathogens Institute. Mr. Colón is also affiliated with Syracuse University. The study appears online in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. The research was funded by the National Institutes of Health, the Notsew Orm Sands Foundation, and the National Science Foundation.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Spending Turn › 2AC --- AT: Single Payer = Joblessness

No unemployment risk – The increased demand for healthcare jobs would substantially offset the displacement of workers from Medicare for All.

Bivens 20 [Josh Bivens, Chief Economist at EPI, Fundamental health reform like ‘Medicare for All’ would help the labor market: Job loss claims are misleading, and substantial boosts to job quality are often overlooked, Economic Policy Institute, 3-5-2020, https://www.epi.org/publication/medicare-for-all-would-help-the-labor-market/] AW


Employment effects of fundamental health reform: gains in health care, losses in insurance and billing—with likely economywide net job gains from rising economic demand Like all positive productivity gains, Medicare for All would be more likely to increase the total number of jobs in the U.S. economy, even as health reform leads to the redeployment of workers from some sectors and into others. Despite the many labor market benefits of fundamental health reform like M4A, many critics have claimed that such reform would lead to a loss of jobs. This claim is misleading. One small grain of truth to it is that the universal provision of health insurance would allow people who would strongly prefer not to work (or not to work full time), but who have remained in their current jobs in order to retain health insurance, to be free to quit. This type of voluntary reduction in labor supply following a health reform would be strongly welfare-improving. For example, the ACA was clearly associated with a large increase in parents with young children transitioning to part-time work (see Jørgensen and Baker 2014). To the degree this occurred because these parents no longer needed to work full time to obtain ESI, and they preferred spending more time with their children for reasons of work–life balance, it should be seen as a clear win for the policy. Generally, people expressing concern about job loss stemming from a policy are concerned about involuntary job loss that leads to a higher level of unemployment in the economy. Unemployment is almost entirely a function of the level of aggregate demand: spending by households, businesses, and governments.12 The effect of fundamental health reform on the level of aggregate demand depends in turn on the balance of increased public spending and the means of financing this spending. All else equal, more public spending will boost aggregate demand and create jobs, while higher taxes will reduce aggregate demand and restrain job growth. Further, the progressivity of taxes used to finance fundamental health reform will also condition its effect on aggregate demand. The more progressive the taxes that finance health reform, the less they will drag on job growth. Increased public spending combined with progressive tax increases would almost certainly boost the level of aggregate demand and lead to lower unemployment, all else equal. While the overall number of jobs and the level of unemployment in the economy is largely a macroeconomic issue determined by aggregate demand, claims that fundamental health reform like M4A will lead to job loss sometimes sound plausible because it is easy to envision the specific jobs that might be displaced: jobs in the health insurance and billing administration sectors. But these job displacements would be balanced by likely job gains in other sectors—most particularly in health care delivery. The health insurance coverage expansions of M4A will boost demand for health care goods and services, and workers will need to be hired to meet this demand. Job losses in the health insurance and billing administration sectors A recent analysis of the economic effects of M4A (Pollin et al. 2018) includes the projection that up to 1.8 million jobs in the health insurance and billing administration sector (the divisions of hospitals and doctors’ offices dedicated to administrative processing of bills and payments) could be made redundant. These potential 1.8 million lost jobs are frequently presented as if they constitute the net employment effect of M4A.13 This is a deeply flawed misrepresentation of Pollin and his colleagues’ work. In fact, their estimates are a gross (not net) measure of job displacement or “churn”—the regular process of workers starting and leaving jobs during the course of their work lives. Relative to the scale of other gross measures of job churn, the churn associated with M4A is not large. It is true that one source of cost savings from the introduction of M4A is the reduced demand for insurance and billing administration. In turn, this reduced demand would shift employment out of these sectors. This could certainly cause challenges and economic distress for the workers within these sectors who are directly affected. But for some perspective, it is worth noting that 21.5 million workers were laid off in 2018 (BLS 2020b). If the 1.8 million workers that Pollin et al. (2018) identify as potentially being displaced by M4A were forced to transition over the four-year phase-in commonly identified with M4A plans, this would increase the national rate of layoffs by about 2%. It is also worth noting that even within just the finance and insurance sectors, there have been 1.7 million layoffs in the past four years (BLS 2020b). And yet it’s safe to say that very few people even in the business press have made any note of this. This is not a shock: Our economy generates a huge amount of job churn every year. This churn is the hallmark of growth in productivity—getting more economic output with fewer inputs. While productivity growth can indeed put downward pressure on jobs in the sector experiencing it directly, Autor and Salomons (2018) demonstrate that productivity gains within a given sector strongly boost job growth in other sectors, as the savings to households and businesses stemming from enhanced productivity increase purchasing power that supports demand for these other sectors’ outputs. If workers in the insurance or billing administration sectors were particularly hard-pressed for reemployment prospects because of geographic isolation or low average levels of educational credentials, their displacement might pose particular concern to policymakers. But employment in the health insurance and billing administration sectors is not particularly geographically concentrated,14 and Pollin et al. (2018) show that 56.5% of workers in these sectors have a four-year college degree or more education, a far greater share than the overall labor force (in 2018, 37.6% of workers had a four-year degree or more education, according to EPI 2020b). Substantial likely job gains in the health care sector While it may seem counterintuitive, fundamental health reform like M4A is almost guaranteed to substantially expand employment in the health care sector overall, even taking reduced billing administration employment into account. Often people hear that fundamental reform is aimed at cost containment and then imagine that part of this cost containment will take the form of fewer jobs providing health care, but this is not necessarily the case. As noted before, the U.S. is an outlier in terms of how much it spends on health care, but its health care workforce as a share of the total workforce is not out of line with shares in other countries. For example, in 2017 the health care workforce in the U.S. was equal to 13.4% of the overall workforce, while the share averaged 12.9% in the 20 other richest OECD countries.15 Additionally, seven of these other countries had health care workforce shares equal to or higher than the U.S.’s 13.4%.16 Pollin et al. (2018) estimate that expanded access to health care could increase demand for health services by up to $300 billion annually. Given the current level of health spending and employment, this would translate into increased demand for 2.3 million full-time-equivalent workers in providing healthcare.17 Obviously all of the workers displaced from the health insurance and billing administration sectors could not necessarily transition into these jobs seamlessly, but well over 10% of workers in the health insurance sector, for example, are actually in health care occupations (e.g., they are doctors or nurses).18 Further, several M4A plans have provisions to pay for long-term care services. Reinhard et al. (2019) have estimated that in 2018, Americans provided roughly 34 billion hours in unpaid long-term care. If this care was divided up among full-time paid workers, it would require 17 million new positions. Of course, not all of this currently unpaid care would be converted into paid positions in the job market. But if even 10% of unpaid care translated into new jobs, it would create enough new demand for workers to essentially offset the displacement of workers in the health insurance and billing administration sectors.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Inflation DA › 2AC --- AT: Redistribution Solves Recession

Fiscal stimulus is needed to fight recession.

Stone 20 [Chad Stone, chief economist at Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, “Fiscal Stimulus Needed to Fight Recessions Lessons From the Great Recession” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, April 16, 2020,

The economy was in the longest expansion on record before the COVID-19 pandemic, but a sharp decline in economic activity is now inevitable, with unemployment insurance claims skyrocketing and many forecasters saying that the economy has already entered a recession. The last recession — the Great Recession — was a stark reminder of the need to lessen the human hardship and economic dislocation associated with a recession. It left key lessons for policymakers, who should now use a wide array of available policy tools to keep this and future downturns as short and shallow as possible.

Economists’ thinking about anti-recessionary policies has evolved in the last decade, informed in part by the limits of conventional monetary policy that fighting the Great Recession revealed. This experience generated renewed attention among policy economists to the importance of fiscal stimulus (temporary increases in government spending and reductions in government revenues) in supporting overall spending and employment when the economy weakens and preventing serious and long-lasting damage when recessions do occur.